Latest / Podcast Network Insights: Understanding the Business of Podcast "Networks" / Protecting Small Podcasts: Networks for Indie Voices, Not Profit
Transcript
- 0:00I would be thrilled if somebody paid me $100
- 0:01for an episode or getting really tired of hearing
- 0:04rich celebrities saying, oh, I don't even make
- 0:06any money. What they pay me is a joke, right?
- 0:08Like, we're tired of hearing it because that
- 0:11seems very out of touch. But if they really feel
- 0:13that way, and I think a lot of them do, I think
- 0:15they're going to burn themselves up pretty quick
- 0:16when they realize, like, oh, yeah, there isn't
- 0:18a lot of money in this podcasting game for somebody
- 0:20who's already worth millions. It doesn't make
- 0:22a whole lot of sense unless you happen to be
- 0:24the people who get like a 300 million or 100
- 0:26million dollars from Sirius. And I think those
- 0:28paydays are going to be. are pretty much coming
- 0:30down. What exactly are equitable dues for a podcast
- 0:39network? And how do you decide who pays $5 a
- 0:42month, who pays $25 a month or who pays nothing
- 0:45at all? Is there really a network that asks applicants
- 0:48to agree to a value set before they join? Look,
- 0:52almost every podcaster has heard about network
- 0:55directories, masterminds, but this idea that
- 0:59membership pricing is based on someone's life
- 1:02circumstances, and that a network might redirect
- 1:05someone purely on misalignment with values. Those
- 1:09are a little far from standard operating procedure,
- 1:12even for industry veterans. My guest today is
- 1:15Becky Mullencamp, a journalist turned business
- 1:19coach. Becky Mullencamp has been creating and
- 1:21hosting podcasts for years, but about two and
- 1:24a half years ago, she launched the Feminist Podcast
- 1:27Collective. Instead of waiting for a major network
- 1:30to knock, Becky built the space where support,
- 1:34not ad revenue, is the operating priority. I'm
- 1:38Greg Wasserman, host of this great show, Podcast
- 1:41Network Insights. I spent 15 years of my career
- 1:44in advertising sales, and since 2021, I've been
- 1:47immersed in the podcast ecosystem. So I believe
- 1:50life is about time and relationships. You have
- 1:52no clue where one conversation may lead, and
- 1:55that's why I've built relationships. with podcasters,
- 1:58with solo creators, or like my guests here, podcast
- 2:01networks. If you've ever wondered whether joining
- 2:04a network makes sense, or how these networks
- 2:06actually run, or other networks you might want
- 2:10to explore joining, whether it's advertising
- 2:13with, partnering with, or learning from, my goal
- 2:16is to give you a real look behind the scenes
- 2:18so you can confidently navigate whether you host,
- 2:22produce, sponsor, or run a network. As you listen,
- 2:26Focus on how Becky constructed the feminist podcast
- 2:29collective operating system from application
- 2:32requirements to payment scale to member participation.
- 2:36Not just as a philosophy, it's a series of boundary
- 2:39setting mechanisms that shaped who joins and
- 2:43how they relate and what the network really delivers.
- 2:47And stay tuned after the interview as there's
- 2:49more to the conversation. And no, it's not to
- 2:52get you to subscribe to the show on your favorite
- 2:54platform and leave a review. Though let's be
- 2:57honest if you're listening to this you already
- 2:59know you should do that and I appreciate you
- 3:01for that And it's not to encourage you to sign
- 3:04up for my newsletter and discover more podcasts
- 3:06though You probably should do that as well since
- 3:09discovery is one of the most challenging parts
- 3:12of podcasting But that all said let's get into
- 3:15the conversation Becky I always love to start
- 3:19with and anyone that's listening knows shows
- 3:22called podcast network insights. So what? When
- 3:25I say podcast network, what does that mean to
- 3:27you? I think of two things. First, what I think
- 3:32is maybe the technical definition, which is a
- 3:36group that people join to sort of disperse advertising
- 3:40dollars amongst all of the members by having
- 3:43sort of this collective experience of increased
- 3:46revenue because you have increased licentorship
- 3:48by having a bunch of people in the group. And
- 3:50I think that's great. I also think, though, maybe
- 3:54in a slightly less formal way that a podcast
- 3:56network is a community. It's a community of podcasters
- 3:59with a shared mission, shared values, shared
- 4:02approach who say, let's support each other. And
- 4:04I think, yes, that's often around monetization.
- 4:07But I really think network doesn't have to be
- 4:08just about monetization. At least I hope not,
- 4:10because I think support, care, community, you
- 4:14know, education, those things matter, too. And
- 4:16I think a network can look like that. So then
- 4:18I guess that goes to anyone that's listening
- 4:20and that we don't know. that you run the feminist
- 4:23podcast collective, which has collective in it
- 4:26and it goes into your second definition as opposed
- 4:28to the network, but it actually is a network.
- 4:31So when you decided to create, what did you model
- 4:34it off of? This was a little over two years ago,
- 4:38almost two and a half years ago now. And I'm
- 4:40a big podcast listener, have been for a long
- 4:42time. I've also been a podcast creator for a
- 4:44long time. And I started to notice more and more
- 4:47a few years back that every time I was listening
- 4:49to a podcast, I would hear, hey, if you like
- 4:52this show, you might also like this show. And
- 4:55I was discovering podcasts that way. And as a
- 4:57podcast creator, I was thinking, how do I get
- 4:59people to say, if you like this show, you might
- 5:01like Becky's show? And I wasn't sure how to do
- 5:04that. you know, as much as Wondery is awesome
- 5:07or I heart radio or whatever, they weren't knocking
- 5:09down my door. They weren't asking me because
- 5:11I didn't have those kind of numbers and I can
- 5:12understand that. So sort of this moment of, well,
- 5:15could I create. something like that for myself.
- 5:18There's got to be other small independent creators
- 5:21who would like to have some collective force
- 5:23behind their show. And so it started with 15
- 5:25of us who got together and said, what might this
- 5:27look like? It was originally meant to be a bit
- 5:29more of a collective in that everyone was going
- 5:31to equally collaborate. What I've discovered
- 5:34over the years is those things typically need
- 5:37somebody who says, I'll take the reins because
- 5:40it's easy to say, sure, sure, I'll help until
- 5:42it's like, oh, there's a lot of work here. So
- 5:44eventually I sort of took over as the person
- 5:46who organizes things, but the goal was really
- 5:48just selfish. I would like to have something
- 5:51like that. Nobody's asking me into there. So
- 5:53how about I create one found 15 other shows that
- 5:55were like, yeah, I would love something like
- 5:57that. And then getting together and thinking
- 5:58what might it look like for us to model something
- 6:01like that without the advertising component,
- 6:03at least for now. So then. How did you, did you
- 6:07put everyone under the same hosting company?
- 6:09Is it just the matter of, we have a spreadsheet,
- 6:12everyone comes together and shares, here's my
- 6:14show, and then who wants to go and talk about
- 6:16each other's show? Was it a guesting swap? Like,
- 6:19how did you build, in your mind, not just the,
- 6:23you talk about my show, I talk about your show,
- 6:25but create this community then? Yeah, spreadsheet's
- 6:29pretty accurate to begin with, Greg. There was
- 6:32a lot done in a spreadsheet at the beginning.
- 6:34There's still some done in a spreadsheet, a lot
- 6:36more now on Notion where I have more databases
- 6:38and actual things that can speak to each other.
- 6:40But yeah, I really it looked like a database
- 6:42where truly we would have two calls a month back
- 6:45then. Now it's a lot more than that, where we
- 6:47would get together and just go around the room
- 6:49and say, here's my show. Here's how you could
- 6:52support me right now over these next two weeks.
- 6:54And then we would log our attendance. And we
- 6:57would have a log to where we would say, Okay,
- 6:59I've listened to this show. I've liked the show.
- 7:01I've commented on this. I've shared this on social
- 7:04media. And it really started like super piecemeal
- 7:07like that. And eventually over time began to
- 7:09grow into something a little more organized,
- 7:11hopefully, where yes, we are doing guest swapping,
- 7:14but You don't have to do guest swapping. Some
- 7:16people don't have guests on their show. It may
- 7:18look like running an ad. It may look like running
- 7:20somebody else's trailer in your feed when they
- 7:22have a new season coming out. There's a lot of
- 7:24ways that we support each other. And we do try
- 7:26to put some structure around that. But we've
- 7:28also since then added things like having guest
- 7:30speakers come in and educate our crew. You've
- 7:32done that, which was amazing. We've had all kinds
- 7:34of people come in and do things like that. Also,
- 7:37we support each other through things like little
- 7:38mini mastermind sessions where we get together
- 7:40and help one show figure out how to do whatever
- 7:43it is they're looking to do with their challenge
- 7:45at the moment. So we do a lot of different things
- 7:48inside of the community, but at the heart of
- 7:50it, it really is how do we all support each other
- 7:52so that we can try to get, use that power of
- 7:55the collective to get more ears. onto all of
- 7:57these shows that otherwise can get really lost
- 7:59in the algorithm. So am I paying into the collective
- 8:03or is it just hey, it's free to join and it's
- 8:05just a place and who is the right person to join
- 8:09the feminist podcast collective? Yeah, it did
- 8:12start free. Couldn't wasn't very sustainable
- 8:14as I found out because again, originally thinking
- 8:17the workload would be more evenly dispersed having
- 8:19to take on more of that. I recognize that this
- 8:22wasn't an arm of my business to begin with. I'm
- 8:25not like a podcasting expert by any stretch.
- 8:27And so I was like, if this is something I'm going
- 8:29to be doing, I need to at least get some sort
- 8:31of compensation for the time I'm putting in.
- 8:33So the dues are very, very friendly, I think,
- 8:37though we have equitable dues is what I call
- 8:39it. So there's various options and The do say
- 8:42sort of if your life circumstances look like
- 8:44this, if your privileges look like this, if your
- 8:47marginalizations look like this, find a place
- 8:49that you can pay no one ever questions. Nobody
- 8:51knows how much other members pay, but it's anywhere
- 8:53from five to twenty five dollars a month. And
- 8:55then we have a few people who actually don't
- 8:57pay anything because I don't want anyone to not
- 8:59be able to join who is an active wants to be
- 9:02an active member just because of money. The goal
- 9:04really isn't this is not a money making venture
- 9:06by any stretch. It's really about trying to amplify
- 9:09voices that go under. recognized. I guess I have
- 9:13to dig into that one. Why isn't it a money venture?
- 9:17You know, when you think about if we go back
- 9:18to the original answer of what is a podcast network,
- 9:22take away the monetization of just ads. But the
- 9:27ultimate thing is like this could have the financial
- 9:30backings or financial success. So you've chosen
- 9:34this collective not to be that. How come? Well,
- 9:38first of all, we have feminist in the name and
- 9:41feminist in my mind is your feminism isn't feminism
- 9:44if it's not intersectional if it doesn't identify
- 9:46and acknowledge that we all have varying overlapping
- 9:49identities that create both privileges and also
- 9:52marginalizations those can sometimes increase
- 9:55our access, but also in the case of most of our
- 9:57members restrict access in so many ways. My goal
- 10:01is not to try and do what capitalism does and
- 10:04monetize everything and see how I can get rich
- 10:06off of the backs of folks who go under recognized.
- 10:08My goal is to just try really to help people
- 10:11get more recognition that otherwise don't get
- 10:13it. And yeah, I do have to charge something because
- 10:15I did discover that my time does require some
- 10:18amount of money, especially because I pay for
- 10:21things to help support the community. But it's
- 10:24not about that. And I know it's hard for a lot
- 10:26of people to understand inside of capitalism,
- 10:28that that's not what it's about. But truly, this
- 10:30is about I want to see more voices get heard
- 10:34inside of podcasting that are not getting heard,
- 10:36especially as we move more and more to video,
- 10:38which again, really harms folks who don't have
- 10:41those kind of resources to be doing video and
- 10:44certainly not at the level of many of the celebrities
- 10:46that are able to do video, people who aren't
- 10:48celebrities, people who maybe don't have a built
- 10:50in audience for a whole lot of reasons. We know
- 10:53what the algorithm favors and doesn't favor and
- 10:55algorithms, if anyone needs to know, read algorithms
- 10:58of oppression, they are inherently biased. And
- 11:01so there are voices that are getting left out
- 11:02and not because they're not great, not because
- 11:04they don't have important things to say, but
- 11:06strictly because they aren't. No offense. white,
- 11:09heterosexual, you know, cis het men, like, and
- 11:12that's unfair. And I want to be a part of trying
- 11:15to change that. And this is one small way that
- 11:17I hope to be a part of that. And sure, I could
- 11:19probably make a lot more money, but it wouldn't
- 11:21feel good in my body to do that. So then, I guess
- 11:25what is, because this is what I love about what
- 11:28already the guests we've had on the show, whether
- 11:29we've released it or not. But I think about some
- 11:32of our other guests who have similar model where
- 11:35it's like, I'm not here. I'm here to raise voices.
- 11:38I'm here to not. I could make more money than
- 11:41I could than I'm doing. And you've gone down
- 11:45that path, but they all have another business
- 11:48side that's actually fueling. So what is what
- 11:52is Becky's other business? And this is the collective
- 11:55podcast network that is helping voices be raised.
- 12:00I don't know. But I mean, sure, I think. On the
- 12:03face of it, the podcast collective probably doesn't
- 12:05really benefit my business. My business is feminist
- 12:08business coaching. I work with people who are
- 12:11sort of going from me to we, meaning they're
- 12:13going from that solopreneur or doing most of
- 12:16the service providing in their business to needing
- 12:17to bring our consultants, move to an agency model,
- 12:19et cetera, making that leap in a way that honors
- 12:21their values. I suppose the work sort of benefits
- 12:25that and that maybe some of those people could
- 12:27be my clients. They haven't been, but perhaps
- 12:28they could be. Obviously my own podcasts exist
- 12:32inside of the collective. So I get the benefit
- 12:34of that as well. All of these things help with
- 12:37name recognition. I just wrote a book called
- 12:39liberate your business. I, you know, and this
- 12:41gives me an easy end to a whole lot of podcasts,
- 12:43which is really nice, right? I'm going on a tour
- 12:46of like 25 podcasts and a lot of those are members
- 12:49of the podcast collective. They know me. There's
- 12:51that built in trust. They like me. So in those
- 12:53ways it supports my business, but I'm again,
- 12:55I'm not in the. podcast business. I'm not a podcast,
- 12:59you know, producer or any of those things. And
- 13:01I love that there are people that do that, but
- 13:03I'm not really here to try and make money off
- 13:06of the people in the collective other that like,
- 13:08how can I support them? And it fits into my ethos
- 13:11of like, I don't even have a sign. I don't know
- 13:14if you can see it, but it says without without
- 13:16community, there is no liberation, which is Audre
- 13:18Lorde. And that's what I really believe. Like
- 13:20we need community. We need collective spaces.
- 13:22We need to move together. to be able to make
- 13:25change. And if I'm gonna say it, I feel like
- 13:27this is one place I get to walk it a little.
- 13:30I love that. I mean, look, we both know, my ethos
- 13:33is life is about time and relationships. So you're
- 13:35going community, I'm all about relationships.
- 13:37I mean, that's why we're able to have these conversations.
- 13:40And I get excited about how each person's doing
- 13:43what they're doing. But if we take the actually
- 13:46the step back and go in like, I'm not a production.
- 13:49I'm a podcaster, but I was doing this for out
- 13:53of my own needs per se. But like correct me if
- 13:56I'm wrong and let everyone else know your background's
- 13:59actually in comms, right? Like you came from
- 14:02journalism and communications background and
- 14:05then kind of fell into this podcast collective.
- 14:08But you've been doing the business coaching for
- 14:10quite a while as well, right? Yeah, journalism
- 14:13into coaching, which may seem like a leap, but
- 14:16honestly, at its core, coaching is asking questions.
- 14:19That's really what we do as coaches. And I learned
- 14:21really well how to do that as a journalist. There's
- 14:23also some storytelling that happens inside of
- 14:26coaching with both helping our clients tell stories
- 14:29and helping you stories to help clients. So there's
- 14:32actually so much overlap that I didn't even realize
- 14:34as I was going into coaching. And I'm like, Oh,
- 14:36this actually makes a lot of sense. And podcasting
- 14:39has been this really beautiful opportunity for
- 14:41me to go back to some of those journalism roots
- 14:43and feel a bit like a journalist again by hosting
- 14:46people, again, doing interviews, asking questions,
- 14:49helping to tell stories, but in a way that feels
- 14:51like I'm doing it because it's what I want, which
- 14:54is why I ultimately left journalism because I
- 14:56got really tired of telling other people stories
- 14:58to make other people rich. It didn't really feel
- 15:00that good to me. It just wasn't... Lighting my
- 15:04soul anymore. And so now I'm in a place where
- 15:06I'm getting to do use a lot of those skills in
- 15:08new ways but in ways that actually feel really
- 15:10really good for me and writing the book is just
- 15:12the latest example of that of like using those
- 15:14skills in a way that actually lights me up and
- 15:17I hope I hope Helps to make some small bit of
- 15:20difference in the world. I mean, I think that
- 15:23If just you follow your ethos, it's definitely
- 15:26doing that right creating this community and
- 15:29allowing more voices. So what is the struggle?
- 15:32I mean, you're solving the issue of discover
- 15:34ability by getting these, how many shows are
- 15:36on the network right now? We're up to about 50
- 15:38now. So we have 50 members. So actually some
- 15:41of our hosts have two, I have three shows. So
- 15:44we actually have more than 50 shows, but about
- 15:4650 members. All right. So 50 members now being
- 15:48able to swap, collaborate, partner, whatever
- 15:52it may be for now in their show, but maybe their
- 15:56businesses, which is the other side of it. What
- 16:00challenges are you running into? Where has Where
- 16:03you've taken the collective of creating? I don't
- 16:06know this cross promo and where do you want to
- 16:08take it? Right now it's about Managed growth
- 16:12is part of it trying to decide how big do we
- 16:15want to get and still be able to maintain? The
- 16:18community because as you said relationships are
- 16:20at the heart of it and it's really beautiful
- 16:22at 50. It's still amazing. We have, everyone
- 16:25really gets to know each other. They all get
- 16:27to feel, I think, I hope, heard, seen, appreciated
- 16:30by each other, not just by me. I mean, I feel
- 16:32like our community really does support each other.
- 16:36And turnover is not a problem. It's more about
- 16:38how many people do we let in to say, before we
- 16:40start to say this might be where it's now going
- 16:43beyond what feels good for us. Because I think
- 16:45everyone who's in there like you are people who
- 16:47care about relationships. That's why they're
- 16:50there. And so we want to be able to maintain
- 16:51that. For our members, I think some of the biggest
- 16:54challenges are some of what you've come in to
- 16:57help talk to them about too, which is great.
- 16:58But it's sort of how do I use this podcast to
- 17:00actually make a difference in my business? Not
- 17:03just to sort of hear my own voice or to put a
- 17:05voice out there or to get caught up in vanity
- 17:08metrics and just like trying to get as many downloads
- 17:10as I can. How does it actually support my business?
- 17:13Because almost all of our members are people
- 17:14who have businesses and the podcast is in support
- 17:17of that. Some of our people are doing podcast
- 17:19podcasting as hobbyists, which I think is also
- 17:21great. And so that's fine. It's a different set
- 17:23of concerns. But I would say for the most of
- 17:25our members, that's where sort of the biggest
- 17:28challenge for the members are. So then tech is
- 17:32that being, I guess I always have the conversation
- 17:34on tech. You said you're charging because you've
- 17:39bought some tools. What is it that you've created
- 17:42within the collective from a tech standpoint,
- 17:46tech stack? How do we... get beyond Google Sheets
- 17:51and invest besides Notion, right? So like, what
- 17:54is the tech stack for your collective look like
- 17:57that is allowing you to service the needs of
- 18:01your members and also think about how we grow?
- 18:05Yeah. Well, the first step was exiting just using
- 18:08a spreadsheet and Google Drive to share things
- 18:10that worked for a while until it didn't. So I
- 18:12moved to teachery, which is like, you know, Teachable
- 18:18and some of the other platforms high level. Yeah,
- 18:21so we're on teachery That's where I can that
- 18:23allowed me first of all to make an easy way for
- 18:25recurring payments for people to be able to pay
- 18:27for membership when we made that leap about a
- 18:29year ago, so I've only been charging dues for
- 18:31a year So that was helpful in establishing dues
- 18:34being able to make that something that was easy
- 18:36before that I was doing sort of if you want to
- 18:38throw some money at me throw me some PayPal a
- 18:40few people would now it's a little more formal
- 18:43I don't have to feel icky about like asking all
- 18:45the time, would anybody mind? So that was the
- 18:47first step. It also gave me an easy way for the
- 18:49resource library to exist for all of the resources
- 18:52because we have so many resources at this point.
- 18:55Two years in, we have dozens and dozens of outside
- 18:59educators who've come in. We have dozens of community
- 19:01discussions around topics like AI and Substack
- 19:03and, you know, audience growth and engagement,
- 19:06all these things. So that all exists in there.
- 19:08I do use notion for the admin side of things
- 19:11for me to be able to track things like When are
- 19:14our members podcast anniversaries and birthdays
- 19:16so we can celebrate those things? Things like
- 19:19how many meetings are people attending? Not because
- 19:22I'm keeping track for any reason other than I'm
- 19:24curious how engagements going. What are the kinds
- 19:27of sessions that people are attending the most
- 19:29and the least? I'm trying to gather that kind
- 19:31of data so that I can make sure that I continue
- 19:33to have this thing evolve in a way that best
- 19:35serves people and also to try and put some structure
- 19:37around things like guest swapping and or having
- 19:41we do a pitch fest. four times a year, I want
- 19:45to know, are people actually getting booked out
- 19:46of those Pitchfests? Is that worth the time for
- 19:48the people showing up, for our members? Which,
- 19:51by the way, they have been. It's amazing how
- 19:53many people at the Pitchfest get booked onto
- 19:54podcasts. And then I have added, most recently
- 19:57probably, is our newsletter, Amplify, which is
- 20:00on Substack, which is now a way that, beyond
- 20:02our website, for me to try and say... What can
- 20:06I, as FPC, do to help raise awareness for members
- 20:11beyond just each other supporting, the members
- 20:13supporting each other? And so we have a public
- 20:15-facing newsletter where I share information
- 20:17about podcasting, but also then our members'
- 20:20latest episodes so people can find new shows
- 20:22to listen to. and help to try and get some of
- 20:24the word out about some of our members as well
- 20:26as about the podcast collective itself. So that's
- 20:29the most recent thing. And then last year we
- 20:31had our first public facing event, which was
- 20:33called Drop the Mic. We'll do something again
- 20:35this fall. We're trying, we're starting to talk
- 20:37about what that might look like. Again, to try
- 20:40and raise awareness about our members shows as
- 20:42well as about the collective itself. So those
- 20:44are all things that have been adding on over
- 20:48time. So when I listened to it, I mean, like
- 20:50thought that comes to my mind is a lot of the
- 20:53podcasters who run. And it sends podcasts, coaching,
- 20:56consulting, and right. They create their masterminds,
- 20:59like pay me whatever it is for monthly. And either
- 21:01they're doing production side to it, or they're
- 21:04doing consulting on it. You're not doing any
- 21:06of that. You're like, look, pay me 25 bucks a
- 21:09month. I don't want to be in the business of
- 21:11coaching you. I'm going to bring in the coaches.
- 21:13Like I came in and have that. And so you're modeling
- 21:17this in a sense competing against those who are
- 21:21running that as a business because you're not
- 21:24running this as a business, but you're offering
- 21:26something that they usually don't do, but you've
- 21:29decided to do is create this cross promo asset
- 21:33that most of those aren't doing. And it's really
- 21:36interesting. I don't know if there's so much
- 21:38a question as much as just like a realization
- 21:40of like how you've created your network and how
- 21:43I believe others who are doing what they're what
- 21:46you're not doing could be doing what you're doing
- 21:49as well. I think, Greg, it's when you free yourself
- 21:52from capitalist restraints, the capitalism's
- 21:56restraints that say everything you do has to
- 21:59serve some purpose for scaling, for growth, for
- 22:01monetization, or it's not worthwhile. I was free
- 22:05from that completely. I didn't go into this remotely
- 22:07thinking in that way. And I think that that just
- 22:09sort of shakes off a lot of limitations that
- 22:11we often have and allows us to be creative. It
- 22:13was just truly like, what do I want and need?
- 22:17And then what would solve that? And then... building
- 22:20that thing and then slowly over time realizing,
- 22:22OK, it's not about trying to get rich here in
- 22:25any sort of way, scaling and growing. In fact,
- 22:28I foresee a future where we will cap growth.
- 22:30But it is about like saying, OK, I do need some
- 22:33amount of compensation just to be able to sustain
- 22:36this over time or I will burn myself out. But
- 22:38other than that, it's like free from so many
- 22:40of these other things that so often we're using
- 22:43to make decisions. that limit us in so many ways.
- 22:46And so I don't feel any of those limitations
- 22:48because I'm not bogged down by any of that stuff
- 22:50guiding my choices. Anyone that's listening and
- 22:54has listened to a couple episodes and the future.
- 22:56I mean, I've got some guests. You're starting
- 22:59to hear the trend of of many networks like Becky
- 23:03with the Feminist Podcast Collective that are
- 23:05following that model. It is it is for the greater
- 23:08good. But it's also why I love about podcasting
- 23:11is. You can go down the path of I need to monetize
- 23:14and how do I make all this money? You can go
- 23:17down the path of being a rep firm and look at
- 23:20it from an advertising, or you know what, whether
- 23:23you're a business or you're a hobbyist, hey,
- 23:25here's a place to come together because, like
- 23:27you said, there was nowhere for you to go to
- 23:30get the cross promos that you were looking for.
- 23:33I love that. Can I quickly say too, because I'm
- 23:36feeling like I'm coming across a bit judgmental.
- 23:38Not at all. Okay, but because I do think there
- 23:41are obviously great places for so many of these.
- 23:44Yeah, and all of those things serve a really
- 23:46great purpose and have their place. So I don't
- 23:48mean to say that one is better than another,
- 23:50but I do think it's nice to have something that
- 23:52fills a particular space for people because not
- 23:54everyone can afford a really expensive mastermind.
- 23:58Most of our members can't pay for production.
- 24:00It's all DIY, indie, we're doing it all ourselves
- 24:04and even $25 a month is a stretch, right? And
- 24:07those people deserve a home too. I think if you
- 24:09can afford to be part of some of these other
- 24:11places or if you're looking for a very narrow
- 24:14type of help, they're going to have more depth
- 24:16than we're providing here, right? We're providing
- 24:19probably a wider breadth with maybe less depth
- 24:22in each of the areas. And so I do think there
- 24:23is something to be said for all of these things.
- 24:25I just want to make sure I'm clearly saying that
- 24:27too, because I don't want people to think I'm
- 24:28saying what I'm doing is somehow better. It's
- 24:30different. But I also think it serves an audience
- 24:33that maybe isn't being served by some of the
- 24:35other places that exist. 100%. And that's what
- 24:37I love about all these conversations is how each
- 24:40network is operating, how each is found. success
- 24:43in their own way, how you define success versus
- 24:47the network that's making millions of dollars
- 24:49or just got sold for $30 million, right? It's
- 24:53a completely different business model, but it's
- 24:55also a completely different audience that they're
- 24:57trying to serve and a reason that they're serving,
- 24:59but it all fits. Everything is able to coexist,
- 25:03and that's what I love about what we've created
- 25:05here in just our space. Yeah, and I have been
- 25:09so blown away too because again, I've never felt
- 25:11like an insider in a podcasting industry. I was
- 25:14a little tiny podcaster and it's been amazing
- 25:17like how the podcast community when you start
- 25:20to actually see it as community and participate
- 25:22it participate inside of it like community. It's
- 25:25so it's been so welcoming so helpful like people
- 25:28are not I haven't felt any way people judging
- 25:31me to be like, you're not in this business, get
- 25:33out of it. Everyone's just been so amazing and
- 25:35just reaching out to say, would you come speak
- 25:37to our group? We're small, but we have a lot
- 25:39of really interested people who otherwise can't
- 25:41afford to get access to quality education around
- 25:44these issues. Like people are willing to step
- 25:45up. I've been, people introduced me to other
- 25:47people. It's been amazing. I just, I've been
- 25:49really blown away by the podcasting space. And
- 25:52this is what I love about Art as well. You mentioned
- 25:55a couple of times here, a cap that gets some
- 25:58point. 50, you'll have a cap. And the question
- 26:02I love to find out is when a person is looking
- 26:04to join a network, and we'll go with yours, because
- 26:08as we just described, each network is going to
- 26:10be different. But like, what are the red flags
- 26:12that they should be looking for? What were the
- 26:14flags that you were even thinking about when
- 26:16you created this network going like, I'm going
- 26:18to do it the way you've actually decided to do
- 26:20this? Well, I mean one of the things that we
- 26:22have is an application process. You don't just
- 26:24click buy now and join There's a form part of
- 26:27that is agreeing to our value set which not everyone's
- 26:30gonna agree with It's important to us as members
- 26:33because that is the thing that unites us all
- 26:36We are not united in any other way, not in types
- 26:38of shows, not in who we are, what our businesses
- 26:41do. The only thing that unites us is our value
- 26:43set. So that's the thing that's most important
- 26:45to me to protect. I could have a lot more members.
- 26:47I have a feeling had I just had a buy now button.
- 26:49I could probably be taking money from people
- 26:51who never show up to anything and they're just
- 26:53forget that they have an auto pay. Those things
- 26:55exist. That's not the way that I want to show
- 26:57up. Our community wants to show up. So we have
- 26:58an application form. I think that's something
- 27:01for people to think about. Do you want to be
- 27:02in a space where First of all, just what is the
- 27:05united thing? What is it that's uniting you all?
- 27:08If the thing that you live by is your values
- 27:11matter most, I would be really careful to make
- 27:13sure I'm looking for organizations that share
- 27:15my values and how are they showing me that, right?
- 27:18One way we do it is by saying we don't just welcome
- 27:19anyone. If that's not the most important thing
- 27:22to you, that's also okay, but what is and how
- 27:25is the group you're considering showing you that
- 27:28they are aligned with you on whatever that thing
- 27:30is that's most important to you? I would ask
- 27:32about engagement. If you can, if there's someone
- 27:35you can reach out to, if that's important to
- 27:37you, if what you're looking for is community
- 27:39support, are people showing up to calls? Are
- 27:41people helping each other? What does it actually
- 27:43look like? I can talk about engagement. I can
- 27:45talk about churn rate. I can tell you what our
- 27:47membership looks like if people want to ask those
- 27:50kinds of questions. We have a very high engagement
- 27:51rate. We have a very low churn rate. Most, we
- 27:54have members who've been around for two plus
- 27:56two and a half years now, right? That don't leave.
- 27:58So I think. The most important thing is what
- 28:01matters most to you. What is the reason? What's
- 28:03your why for considering joining a space? And
- 28:06then what is the evidence, not just somebody
- 28:07saying something on a website, right? But what
- 28:10can they actually show you both in words, but
- 28:12also in the way they show up that tells you they
- 28:15really do. We are aligned on these most important
- 28:18things to me. Yeah, I mean, if we go to. The
- 28:23the financial backing of the collective that
- 28:26you've put together. it's got to be tied to values
- 28:30versus another network where it's like, look,
- 28:33values. It's more of just an alignment of, am
- 28:36I going to be able to make you the most amount
- 28:37of money? Exactly. Am I the right person to sell
- 28:40your show or are the shows that are in this collective
- 28:44or network the right shows to be aligned with?
- 28:48And so you've got the values, the feminist side
- 28:53of it. And then, hey, here's your sliding scale.
- 28:56So it makes sense. Yeah, I think just knowing
- 29:00that for yourself and again, that's why our we
- 29:02have an application form because For people who
- 29:05are just interested in are you gonna meet me
- 29:07money? Well, the answer is no, we aren't gonna
- 29:08make you money, right? We don't do that and I
- 29:11don't want people are just like I'm gonna sign
- 29:12up somewhere hoping that I can like take and
- 29:15not give our part of that application is, are
- 29:17you going to show up? Are you going to give?
- 29:19Are you going to support? Cause it's not, we
- 29:21don't do things one way here, but if that's what
- 29:23you're looking for, that's also okay. Knowing
- 29:26that when you go in really reading through a
- 29:28website, maybe speaking to other members, because
- 29:30if you can't do any of those things and that's
- 29:32red flags. So I'll take the monetization side
- 29:35of it, you know, cause that's what most are saying.
- 29:37Hey, how do I, am I going to make money? And
- 29:39you're saying, no, you're not. But like, The
- 29:42real answer is you're not going to make money
- 29:43in terms of sponsors and ads unless you're growing,
- 29:47but like, I'm not here to help you do that. But
- 29:50it sounds like based on not only the value system
- 29:53that the 50 members have, but also the cross
- 29:56promo of business and partnerships like, yeah,
- 29:59you will make money if you can leverage the other
- 30:02members in this collective, not just to grow
- 30:04your show, but also to find either partnerships
- 30:07or business opportunities that will drive your
- 30:10core revenue stream. Right. And the knowledge
- 30:14base, like I can't even tell you the resource
- 30:16library that we have accumulated over these two
- 30:18and a half years is it blows me away. Like if
- 30:20you sign up. in that for that dues, you're getting
- 30:23access to like a master's degree in podcasting.
- 30:27At this point, it's amazing stuff in there. And
- 30:30so much of it. I mean, yours was one example.
- 30:31And we have several that are really focused on
- 30:34monetization and not just through ad dollars
- 30:35and sponsorships. We do have some of those sorts
- 30:37of things, but things that make sense for little
- 30:39independent smaller shows, which in your case
- 30:42was talking about how do we use how do we make
- 30:45sure that our show becomes part of our funnel,
- 30:47our lead generation system and that those guesting
- 30:50opportunity. that are the guests that we're having
- 30:52on, is there a potential for those to become
- 30:54clients, right? And we have so many things like
- 30:57that. So yeah, we're not saying I'm going to
- 30:59give you ads and you're going to suddenly be
- 31:00getting, you know, a hundred dollar paycheck
- 31:02in your inbox every month. That's not going to
- 31:05happen. We aren't doing that. And I don't want
- 31:06to get into advertising. Our shows are small.
- 31:09They're not the kinds of things that advertisers
- 31:11want, but that's... That audience needs help.
- 31:16They need to figure out what are the ways then
- 31:17that I do make sure this podcast is sustainable,
- 31:21right? And sustainable, that's really, I think
- 31:22what we're focusing on is how do you make your
- 31:24podcast sustainable? Part of that is money, right?
- 31:27Not through ad dollars, probably. Maybe through
- 31:29sponsorships, we do have things about that as
- 31:31well, but also through things like Patreons and
- 31:33memberships and then... to using it for in support
- 31:37of your business. But also, like, how do you
- 31:39make it sustainable in that if you don't have
- 31:41a community to vent to or people who can say,
- 31:43oh, yeah, I've been there, when things get really
- 31:46hard, it's easy to quit and podcasting. Right.
- 31:48If you want to have your show actually sustain,
- 31:51even when you have dips in numbers or when they
- 31:53change the algorithm and then suddenly your show
- 31:56takes this nosedive or whatever the things are,
- 31:58it's helpful to have a community people you can
- 32:00turn to to say, is it just me? Is this happening
- 32:01to everyone else? So that is part of it's not.
- 32:05Money, but I do think it's part of the riches
- 32:07that you get out of being part of a community
- 32:09And so everything I'm guessing is virtual have
- 32:12you thought about because I start thinking about
- 32:14a lot of the networks and how Especially because
- 32:17their niche have turned into a conference can
- 32:21have turned into an award So if you thought about
- 32:23all right, how do I take these 50 members and
- 32:26we all meet up or I throw an event that I'm able
- 32:30to do something that that becomes a podcast education
- 32:34or once again, that is not your purpose. That
- 32:37would be too much of an undertaking and that's
- 32:39not where you want to put your energy. Well,
- 32:42everything is virtual. Our first event last year,
- 32:44our first public facing event was also virtual,
- 32:46actually ran it through Riverside, which is what
- 32:48you're using here. It was really cool because
- 32:50I had never done like a live sort of event through
- 32:53Riverside. So that was fun. We will be doing
- 32:55that again. We do have talks inside the community
- 32:58frequently about maybe getting together at some
- 33:00point for something because we do have quite
- 33:02a good concentration of Midwestern folks, not
- 33:04everybody. We have people in other countries
- 33:06besides the U .S. as well. But we do have quite
- 33:08a few people in Chicago. I'm in St. Louis. So
- 33:10we've talked about maybe having some sort of
- 33:12get together. That's it right now. That's as
- 33:14far as we've gotten in that. That'll be a while
- 33:16because I just. It's my capacity to write. So
- 33:21I don't know. I've had people suggest things
- 33:22like awards. I'm not interested in taking that
- 33:25on right now. But yeah, at some point we may
- 33:27grow. I mean, again, I want to see us get to
- 33:29100 members. That's my current goals. Can we
- 33:31go from 50 to 100 and see how it feels there?
- 33:35Does 100 still feel great? Do we want to try
- 33:37to go to 200? Do we want to cap somewhere after
- 33:39100? And then once we kind of have that model
- 33:42going a little more figure out, are there additional
- 33:45things we want to add on? So in person, who knows?
- 33:47We'll see. There you go. We've talked about tech.
- 33:52We've talked about the different tools you're
- 33:56using. I guess what I'm curious is from an operational
- 34:01standpoint, what would you have done if you were
- 34:05to start today what you didn't do with spreadsheets,
- 34:09you know, two years ago when you started this?
- 34:11Like if you had this, what would you be doing
- 34:14today if I were to start a network? I would have
- 34:18listened to people who told me I should have
- 34:20started charging money earlier. I waited over
- 34:23a year to do that thinking, I let a lot of my
- 34:27own value set sort of get in the way. And while
- 34:29I'm not in it to make money, I do recognize that
- 34:32if I can't sustain it because I burn myself out,
- 34:36then it goes away and that's not what I want.
- 34:38And there were people telling me... much sooner
- 34:40than a year that I needed to be charging dues.
- 34:43I had members saying, we'll pay you dues and
- 34:45me sort of being getting my own way as I sometimes
- 34:47do. So I definitely would have started charging
- 34:49a lot earlier than I did. And in framing it in
- 34:53that way of understanding, it's not about getting
- 34:55rich. It's not about taking advantage of people.
- 34:56It's just about my own capacity and my own ability
- 34:59to sustain this thing. I also would have gotten
- 35:02out of spreadsheets sooner than I did. I love
- 35:05a spreadsheet, Greg. They're beautiful. I make
- 35:07them really pretty. I enjoy it. I know it. That
- 35:10said, I got bogged down in spreadsheets for a
- 35:13while. Like I had a new one every quarter. I
- 35:15was trying to carry things over. It got messy
- 35:18really quick. I would have also definitely gotten
- 35:20out of Google Drive sooner because I was having
- 35:22to give people access. My storage was going.
- 35:25bonkers trying to keep up. So I just I think
- 35:27all along the way, it would have been helpful
- 35:29if I had moved to new to more robust technology
- 35:33more quickly. And charging also allows me to
- 35:36do that. And so it's part of what held me back.
- 35:39But yeah, I think it's okay to do things before
- 35:43you're ready. And sometimes I wait until I'm
- 35:45over ready. So then what, if not Google Drive,
- 35:50what are you using? If not spreadsheets, what
- 35:52are you using? And also, what's the framework
- 35:55that, if I were to start a network today, that
- 35:57I should be even, you didn't know when you started
- 36:02this two years ago, but now that you know, what
- 36:05would you be telling a person, hey, set these
- 36:08markers in place or set these folders in place
- 36:11or whatever it may be? Yeah, well, if not spreadsheets
- 36:14now notion because it is so much more robust
- 36:17things can speak to each other much better I
- 36:19have a dashboard that I've built that I can actually
- 36:21quickly visualize data about things like engagement
- 36:23and churn rate and see What are the upcoming
- 36:26anniversaries or things that I want to celebrate
- 36:27in our internal newsletter to members? And if
- 36:31not Google Drive I'm now using teacher II with
- 36:34YouTube where the videos are there and then I
- 36:36can put them into teacher II and there's this
- 36:37wonderful resource library when new members come
- 36:40in they can see everything it's much easier for
- 36:42them to navigate than in the past. I didn't add
- 36:46a website for a year either. That's another thing
- 36:48I would have done sooner. And that has been extremely
- 36:52helpful, too, just for people to better understand,
- 36:54because I think for as far as framework and start
- 36:56from the start, get really clear about the mission,
- 37:00the vision, the values, and think beyond today.
- 37:03And I had some thoughts about that, but I definitely
- 37:06lacked any clarity. And again, not to say that
- 37:09you have to have all the answers before you start,
- 37:10because sometimes that slows me down. But I do
- 37:13think trying to think six months out or a year
- 37:15out, what would I like this to look like and
- 37:18starting to build the infrastructure that will
- 37:19help you get there instead of waiting till you're
- 37:21there and then being like, Oh, we should probably
- 37:23have a website like it would have been helpful
- 37:24to have a website earlier because I was fielding
- 37:26so many emails for questions that were really
- 37:29easy, easily answered on a website, right. And
- 37:32a website really wasn't that hard to build. It
- 37:33doesn't cost that much, especially now with AI
- 37:35tools, if people are open to using them, there's
- 37:38just really no reason not to have a website.
- 37:40So that's been really helpful. So I think just
- 37:41know like, what is the goal? What is the purpose,
- 37:44right? There are a million different ways, as
- 37:46we said, that this that something like this can
- 37:49look in picking what feels right to you and what
- 37:53you actually think you want to because you're
- 37:55gonna be with it for a while. probably. I mean,
- 37:57here I am two and a half years later and it still
- 37:59feels like I just started. And so if you're going
- 38:01to be doing this thing for a while, what does
- 38:02it need to look like? What does it need in place?
- 38:05What do you want it to be about so that you will
- 38:07stick with it? Because managing people, having
- 38:11community is not like work. And I think it gets
- 38:13undervalued. very often that people think, oh,
- 38:17it's no big deal. You just have a community of
- 38:18people. It's a lot of work. You have different
- 38:20voices with different needs, with different demands,
- 38:22with different schedules with, you know, everyone
- 38:25has a thought about where things should live.
- 38:26We use stack or slack, which I didn't mention
- 38:29for our internal sort of member communications.
- 38:31Believe me, there's people who are like, I hate
- 38:32slack. I understand, but I'm not there's no tool
- 38:35that's going to please everyone. So sometimes
- 38:36you have to be ready to. But you have to be ready
- 38:39to deal with all of these things. So if you're
- 38:41going to deal with all these things, it's got
- 38:42to be something that you actually want. be a
- 38:44part of. So build it with yourself in mind. I
- 38:47know that goes against so much of the advice
- 38:49out there to build it with the client in mind.
- 38:51There are enough people in podcasting. I'm sure
- 38:54Greg knows all the numbers. I don't know how
- 38:55many podcasters there are. There are enough podcasters
- 38:57that there are going to be enough people who
- 38:59are like you that want to show up the way you
- 39:01show up. So build it for you because you're the
- 39:03one who has to deal with it for the years ahead.
- 39:05So I think that's sort of like Go from there.
- 39:08Start there. What do I actually want? And then
- 39:09start thinking at least six months to a year
- 39:11out of where you think you're going to get and
- 39:14build a little bit ahead. Because I was always
- 39:16sort of building a little bit behind. Now, this
- 39:18is all great advice. And I think about, you know,
- 39:20episode one with Peter. and how he forces everyone
- 39:24to Slack. He's like, Slack is our onboarding.
- 39:27So your comment about, I have an application,
- 39:29part of your qualifying thing is not only my
- 39:32values, but these are the tools I use. If you
- 39:34can't get onboard with these tools, then you're
- 39:36not gonna get the value out of this. So this
- 39:39isn't gonna be an actual right match for both
- 39:41of us. Yeah, and I hope number two won't use
- 39:43Slack. And there's still members. And that's
- 39:45OK. You're missing out a piece of it. But the
- 39:47nice thing about having multiple lanes of this
- 39:50membership is we have, yes, the slack for communication
- 39:53between our community calls. But we are up to
- 39:55having about six calls a month. So there's times
- 39:58that people are like even our few members. We
- 39:59don't have that many, but we have a few people
- 40:01who are just like, I don't want you slack. OK,
- 40:02if you still feel like it's worth your investment
- 40:05with all these other things, then join. If it
- 40:07doesn't, then don't. But yes, I do think we have
- 40:09to be really clear of like you're going to have
- 40:11people say like, well, that meeting time doesn't.
- 40:13work for me or that's that tool I don't like.
- 40:16And you have to be willing to just sort of say,
- 40:18I understand that. And this is what we do. Right.
- 40:20And you may lose members. You may have people
- 40:22who don't join because of those things. So knowing
- 40:25that in advance of having your own belief in
- 40:27why you're making the choices you're making is
- 40:30really important because it can be very easy
- 40:31for people, especially people who are people
- 40:34pleasers to start to make a bunch of decisions
- 40:36and be like, well, we have a Slack community
- 40:37and a Circle community, or you can come on WhatsApp.
- 40:40No, you can't. That's not sustainable. make some
- 40:42choices. I want to go back to what you're talking.
- 40:46One thing came to mind. I want to go back to
- 40:48the. Your podcasters aren't big, right? So if
- 40:53we think about it from sponsors, they're not
- 40:56massive. They're not going to get these massive
- 40:57sponsors. But as a network, what is your focus?
- 41:01What is your what is your value prop to them
- 41:05saying I'm going to help you grow or do you even
- 41:07look at the numbers? Do you help them? The numbers
- 41:09are is part of the goal. after two years, maybe
- 41:13not right now, but the goal is to graduate from
- 41:15the Feminist Podcast Collective and go someplace
- 41:18that maybe I've now gone from, I don't know,
- 41:21a thousand downloads and now I'm at the 15 ,000
- 41:23downloads, so I'm past the Feminist Collective
- 41:26in terms of its values, even if the information's
- 41:28still there, even if people are there, but I'm
- 41:30at a different level because I'm a higher download
- 41:33number. Do you look at that? Do you think about
- 41:35that? Do you have a responsibility to that? One
- 41:40of the things I want to add at some point and
- 41:42I have because we have sponsors as well I have
- 41:45a few folks who for whatever reason. Well, I
- 41:47know the reason they love what we're doing. They
- 41:50think what we're doing is important. And so they
- 41:52pay a certain amount of money a year so that
- 41:53they get on our website. And I mentioned in the
- 41:55newsletter sometimes just as a way to say we
- 41:58support this mission of uplifting these voices
- 42:00that go under recognized. Some of those folks
- 42:03are also bigger podcasters. And I do would love
- 42:06to start some sort of mentorship program. That
- 42:08is something that's in the has been on the potential
- 42:11horizon for a while. Being able to pair some
- 42:13of our people. So those who may be graduate or
- 42:15maybe Maybe who even remain as members, but they
- 42:18move into sort of more of this mentor role inside
- 42:20the membership where they've moved to a different
- 42:23place, whether that is because of download numbers
- 42:25or also just experience because our people are
- 42:28not all people who are just like, Oh, what matters
- 42:31the most is getting to a million downloads or
- 42:32something. They also respect. You've been podcasting
- 42:35for 10 years consistently that that is worthy
- 42:38of celebration as much as I've hit a million
- 42:40downloads or I consistently make revenue out
- 42:43of my podcast because of the way that is part
- 42:46of my client funnel. Even if I'm only getting
- 42:48200 downloads an episode, I'm consistently earning
- 42:50income. That's also worthy of somebody saying
- 42:53I would love to have that person mentor me. So
- 42:55eventually I would like to do that. We're not
- 42:56doing that yet, but that is a goal. But yeah,
- 42:58we we really are servicing people who are. brand
- 43:01new. We had we had one member who's been she
- 43:04just launched her show in the fall after being
- 43:06in the collective for like a year, right, of
- 43:08just being there and learning and getting inspired
- 43:11and, you know, trying to figure out her own launch
- 43:13path. But most of our people have been podcasting
- 43:15for a little while, probably an average around
- 43:17a year to two years. And they are all in that
- 43:20like zero to fifteen hundred downloads an episode
- 43:23sort of a range. And that's who I program for.
- 43:28That's who is there to kind of support each other.
- 43:30So for now, that is probably sort of the space.
- 43:33So far, we haven't had people like really aging
- 43:35out. The only people who tend to leave are people
- 43:36who decide that they're going to take a hiatus
- 43:38from podcasting for whatever reason, usually
- 43:40life circumstances. But, you know, if people
- 43:44do decide they age out, that's also OK, or that
- 43:46they sort of move beyond what we're doing. But
- 43:48I think because the thing that unites us is value
- 43:51set more than anything. I think that's what sort
- 43:54of keeps people around because there are a lot
- 43:56of other options that are probably focused more
- 43:58on bigger numbers and those sorts of things,
- 44:00but that's just not really the primary driver
- 44:02for our members. And so I don't know, I just
- 44:05don't think that they're that concerned about
- 44:07moving to some space that's going to promise
- 44:09them more money, more numbers, whatever. Makes
- 44:12sense. I mean, know the lane you're in, know
- 44:15the audience that you serve. Either as we always
- 44:20do we evaluate reevaluate, you know where I'm
- 44:22at two years from now. It's like, okay Maybe
- 44:24this is is this still serving me or my limiting
- 44:27myself by by where I'm capped at who knows Yeah,
- 44:32and I always make it every member newsletter.
- 44:34I send a newsletter to our members every week
- 44:36That's just for them from my personal email inbox.
- 44:39It's not like something thing and Every week
- 44:42I share here's how to exit Like I want to make
- 44:44this, I don't want ever, I never want anyone
- 44:47to be in who's like, I just really like Becky,
- 44:49so I'll stick around. I don't want her to feel
- 44:50bad or whatever. Like that's not it, right? That's
- 44:53not, this is again, it's not a big moneymaker.
- 44:54I want people to know how easy it is for them
- 44:56to leave if they choose to, because I think that's
- 44:59important. I think it is important to be in spaces
- 45:00that are serving you. And I think for the most
- 45:03part, our members are feeling like it's serving
- 45:06them if for no other reason to pay. $5, $10,
- 45:09$15, $20, $25 a month to be around people who
- 45:12they feel like get it, you know, who are like,
- 45:14I understand how you show up in the world. And
- 45:17that there is a real value to that. I think sometimes
- 45:19we discount that as people creating communities
- 45:21and we shouldn't because that has real value
- 45:23for a lot of people. There's the buzzword that
- 45:25I love hearing, you know, being of service. And
- 45:28so the Feminist Podcast Collective and what Becky's
- 45:31doing is truly of service. And I think anyone
- 45:33that's listening here. Keep that in mind when
- 45:36you're evaluating a network would be just thinking
- 45:39about how networks operate. So I guess that goes
- 45:42into the question video. We've talked a little,
- 45:46we dance and I hate to always bring it up because
- 45:48it's it. It's like the AI question. We all hate
- 45:51to talk about it. But I think it's important,
- 45:54especially for who your audience is, the Feminist
- 45:56Podcast Collective, when we think about marginalized
- 45:59voices, but also how video changes that entire
- 46:02piece. how I am able to show up as a male versus
- 46:06how a woman is able to show up. It's weird to
- 46:11say that as a male and go like, I know that's
- 46:14the truth, and how trolls happen, so forth. So
- 46:16for your collective, where do you see YouTube,
- 46:20Spotify video, with Apple now doing video, and
- 46:23so RSS .com being a partner of that, those are
- 46:26completely video platforms. And then you've got,
- 46:28of course, the social posts that are heavy on
- 46:31there. So for the most part, Where do you focus
- 46:34the collective? Where do you focus the energy
- 46:36the the education because? Video could be just
- 46:40everything Well first of all Greg we need more
- 46:44men to say exactly that to not only know it,
- 46:47to be aware of the fact that there are differences
- 46:49in what video means for white folks, men, you
- 46:53know, straight men, cis men, all the different
- 46:55identities that we hold that there are differences
- 46:58in how you are received and perceived than somebody
- 47:01who holds more marginalized identities to know
- 47:04it and then to say it. There's not enough folks
- 47:06who have privilege saying that, right? Acknowledging
- 47:09that, yeah, my videos probably get more views,
- 47:11get more likes, get fewer hate comments because
- 47:13of the body that I'm in. That's really important.
- 47:15So thank Thank you. And I encourage people listening
- 47:17to think about that because so many people aren't
- 47:19saying that they don't even realize it, but then
- 47:21they are. If they do, they aren't saying it.
- 47:22We need that. That's what advocacy and allyship
- 47:24looks like. So first of all, thank you. Secondly,
- 47:27with the newsletter, I have been doing a lot
- 47:29of talking about two big areas and those are
- 47:32video and AI. Those are two things that right
- 47:34now are pervasive. on everyone's sort of minds
- 47:38showing up more, trying to figure out how to
- 47:40navigate those things, both from just the perspective
- 47:43of like tech, right, and the challenges there,
- 47:46but then also the ethical concerns around both
- 47:48of those things. And as you mentioned with video
- 47:50that it is a real challenge. First of all, in
- 47:53how we are received and perceived and how the
- 47:56algorithm treats folks who have different identities
- 47:58on whether those things get pushed out and video
- 48:01only amplifies that, but also in just Our folks
- 48:05are, like I said, DIYers. These are people who
- 48:07are trying to just do it themselves. And podcasting
- 48:11started with this promise that you just need
- 48:13a mic, right? Like, that's it. You just need
- 48:15a mic. Heck, you don't even have to have a mic
- 48:17if you don't want it. It's not going to sound
- 48:18as good, but you don't even have to have a mic.
- 48:20It was supposed to be this really low barrier
- 48:21to entry, democratizing media, giving everyone
- 48:24a space. Video adds another layer to that that
- 48:27is another expense. And certainly, if you want
- 48:30it to look good, an additional expense that most
- 48:33people don't have, it creates some accessibility
- 48:36issues. So it is a real challenge for people.
- 48:39Also, pretending that it's not real isn't helpful,
- 48:42right? So it's the same with AI, right? These
- 48:44things are real, we can't pretend that this isn't
- 48:46happening. And we can't acknowledge that those
- 48:48things do make a difference. And whether your
- 48:50podcast gets heard, seen in this case, right?
- 48:53Whether YouTube is going to push it out or not,
- 48:55you can still put up an audio podcast, but are
- 48:57you really going to get the same results? So
- 48:59we try to walk that line of educating people
- 49:01like through the next the newsletter, I'm doing
- 49:05a lot of education around just the why these
- 49:07issues are issues, trying to help people better
- 49:09understand and think about these issues so that
- 49:12they're not just taking it for granted that everyone
- 49:15has the same experience around these tools and
- 49:17technologies. But then we're also providing education
- 49:20on these things, you know, acknowledging this
- 49:22is real. For some of our members, they've taken
- 49:24a harder stance on AI, not going to use it. OK.
- 49:27And I respect that as well from an ethical standpoint.
- 49:30And for now, the community is still saying some
- 49:34of us are using it for the reason that it does
- 49:36actually increase accessibility for some of us.
- 49:38It does make more possible for indie producers,
- 49:42indie creators. So I do provide education around
- 49:44both AI and video. It's a tightrope. It's a difficult
- 49:48thing, right? Do I think on the whole that it's
- 49:50helpful? No, I don't think video is all that
- 49:52helpful. Honestly, I think it was lovely when
- 49:55video was video and podcasting was podcasting.
- 49:58I prefer that world. And here we are. And it's
- 50:01clear that everyone has, you know, the big players
- 50:04have made a decision. The video is where things
- 50:06are going. And that is clearly what they're supporting.
- 50:09And so we can't pretend that that's not happening.
- 50:11We can, but the ostrich with its head in the
- 50:13sand. Doesn't you know, he doesn't realize it's
- 50:16about to be attacked about to be eaten and I
- 50:18don't want that to happen to our members I want
- 50:20them as best they can to continue to show up
- 50:22in that way if it works for them But the other
- 50:25piece that we always bring into that conversation
- 50:27is you don't have to do anything You don't want
- 50:29to do you know, you're you don't have to We will
- 50:33acknowledge the reality that it may come at some
- 50:36detriment Right. I can't pretend that's not true.
- 50:38But also I'm never going to tell people like
- 50:40if you don't do video, you can't be here. Or
- 50:42if you don't do video, you're doing it wrong
- 50:44and you're bad. Make the choices that allow you
- 50:46again to be sustainable, because I guess at the
- 50:48core of what we're really trying to do with the
- 50:49collective is make podcasting sustainable for
- 50:52marginalized voices. So those voices don't flame
- 50:55out and leave right away. We want them to stick
- 50:57around. And if that means no video, then that
- 50:59means no video. And that's OK. So I'll take that
- 51:02and I'll run with this because there was a lot
- 51:05in there. that you could look at is like, so
- 51:10I'll end with this one. It's like, what are you
- 51:12optimistic about podcasting as we move forward,
- 51:15right? I asked the question on video. What are
- 51:17we optimistic about podcasting moving forward?
- 51:20Well, I don't think it's going away. I think
- 51:22it's only going to get stronger. I do actually
- 51:25think. I don't know, maybe I'll get in trouble
- 51:28for this. I think a lot of these celebrities
- 51:29who have sort of jumped on board are gonna get
- 51:31real tired of it. I think they're gonna, you
- 51:33know, first of all, I think a lot of us who are
- 51:35like, I would be thrilled if somebody paid me
- 51:36$100 for an episode, are getting really tired
- 51:39of hearing rich celebrities saying, oh, I don't
- 51:41even make any money or what they pay me is a
- 51:43joke, right? Like, we're tired of hearing it
- 51:45because that seems very out of touch. But if
- 51:48they really feel that way... And I think a lot
- 51:50of them do. I think they're going to burn themselves
- 51:51up pretty quick when they realize, like, oh,
- 51:53yeah, there isn't a lot of money in this podcasting
- 51:55game for somebody who's already worth millions.
- 51:57It doesn't make a whole lot of sense unless you
- 51:59happen to be the people who get like a 300 million
- 52:01or 100 million dollars from Sirius. And I think
- 52:03those paydays are going to be. are pretty much
- 52:06coming down. I think we've kind of reached a
- 52:08peak around, I hope around this like celebrity
- 52:11bubble, this highly polished produced bubble.
- 52:14And I think we're going to start to see the other
- 52:16side of that, especially with AI. Maybe I'm wrong.
- 52:20But I really think I have a new podcast coming
- 52:22out that supports my feelings around this. And
- 52:25so maybe I'm being it's wishful thinking. But
- 52:28I really think the more that we're going towards
- 52:30AI and all of this. heavily Botox, pretty, everything's
- 52:36polished, beautiful lighting that makes you look
- 52:38like you're 20 when you're 70. I think people
- 52:40are getting tired of it. I think people want
- 52:42real. I think with AI, everyone's starting to
- 52:44just say, I actually want to see you mess up.
- 52:47I want to hear the mistakes. I want to see your
- 52:49wrinkles so that I know you're human, right?
- 52:51I've seen more and more writers talking about
- 52:53putting errors into their copy so people know
- 52:56it wasn't AI created. That's a wild world we're
- 52:59living in. And so I think more that's going to
- 53:01show up with podcasting. And I think people are
- 53:03going to be curious about like, how do I just
- 53:05get back in touch with what it means to be human?
- 53:07And like, yeah, that might mean that there's
- 53:09a little crackle sometimes or the audio quality
- 53:12is not perfect or you don't have the best lighting.
- 53:14And I actually like that because it makes me
- 53:16remember that you're a human like me. That's
- 53:19my hope. And I really do believe that's the case.
- 53:21I don't know how far off we are from that, but
- 53:23I think we're starting to reach a bit of a fever
- 53:24pitch with some of the stuff. And I think we're
- 53:26going to start to see the other side, which I
- 53:27think bodes really well for our members. I love
- 53:30it. I love the future. If you think about earlier
- 53:35conversations we've had here was around. how
- 53:38each network operates differently and what fits
- 53:41for your network versus someone else's. And so
- 53:44if I think about my conversations with the ladies,
- 53:47Cleo and Nadine from Pod Nation or Asha from
- 53:52Stoke Bros, you know, they're celebrities, they're
- 53:55high profile people and what they're seeing from
- 53:57their networks, but also from the talent standpoint.
- 54:00And then the the, uh, the, the prediction projection
- 54:03prediction came and say it, uh, that you've just
- 54:06said in terms of where you think those are. So
- 54:09it'd be interesting. And once again, uh, I think
- 54:11there's a space for all of it. Hopefully there's
- 54:13a space exactly as you described for the authenticity,
- 54:16for, uh, the real human connection and not just
- 54:19celebrities. Um, so you mentioned your podcast
- 54:22and the wishful thinking about what that, so
- 54:25what is one podcast? Uh, it can't be your own,
- 54:28uh, but also someone else is like, that podcast
- 54:31discovery. I mean, this is why you started your
- 54:33network in the first place. Podcast discovery
- 54:35is incredibly difficult. So here, help me help
- 54:39others understand one podcast they should be
- 54:41listening to. Well, I'm going to reference my
- 54:44friend and a big supporter, also a supporter
- 54:47of the podcast collective, one of our sponsors,
- 54:50which is Amelia Ruby. It's with an H -H -R -U
- 54:53-B -Y Amelia Ruby and her podcast Off the Grid,
- 54:56which is talking about how to grow a business
- 54:57off social media. She has a rabid following of
- 55:01people and it's not a huge podcast. She's not
- 55:03getting millions of downloads. She gets more
- 55:04than a lot of our members, but still not. It's
- 55:07not by some big name, any standard, but she's
- 55:10the perfect example of what it looks like to
- 55:13show up authentically, to have a really quality
- 55:15show. She's a podcast producer, so her show is
- 55:19really high quality and have a small audience
- 55:22and have that actually make a meaningful difference
- 55:23in your business. Her podcast makes a meaningful
- 55:26difference in her business and she's not a celebrity
- 55:29and she doesn't get a million downloads. Love
- 55:31it. We'll have that in the show notes. And then
- 55:33the other question I like is, You know everyone
- 55:36always says that there's too many books out there.
- 55:39There's too many podcasts Sorry, we always say
- 55:41there's too many podcasts. No one ever complains
- 55:43about too many books. So what's a book that you've?
- 55:46That you'd recommend to people whether it's personal
- 55:49whether it's one that you find recently you've
- 55:51read just Something you'd give a shout out Okay.
- 55:55Listen, because I was so selfless on the last
- 55:57one and recommended somebody else's podcast,
- 55:59I'm going to be a little more selfish here and
- 56:01recommend my book, which is called liberate your
- 56:04business. It comes out April 30th. So I'm not
- 56:06sure when this runs, but the book is out. It's
- 56:08available now on my website. And it's all about
- 56:11how to build a business inside of a broken system
- 56:14for people who care about humans. So what does
- 56:16that look like to honor your own needs, your
- 56:19clients, your staff, employees, consultants,
- 56:21if you have them, and then your community, the
- 56:23broader community. How do we build businesses
- 56:25that aren't causing harm? There you go. I will
- 56:28have that in the show notes as well for me. If
- 56:32you can see it, I've got Ryan Berman's return
- 56:35on courage. So that has been one that I've been
- 56:38recommending to others. Well, let's talk for
- 56:41a bit. Anyone that's made it this far in the
- 56:44episode, is there anything that you would love
- 56:46to leave them? Anything we haven't touched on?
- 56:49I think about who's listening to this. They're
- 56:51either a podcast or they're a network operator.
- 56:53Maybe they're an advertiser, while it may not
- 56:55be relevant for you since you guys aren't doing
- 56:57so much in the monetizing and advertising, but
- 56:59like anything that we haven't covered that you'd
- 57:01want to leave being someone who's running a network.
- 57:04I guess just for everybody, be yourself. I just
- 57:09think that we need to stop trying to create what
- 57:12we think other people want, what other people
- 57:15are saying will make money. You've got to build
- 57:19for yourself. If you're not building for yourself,
- 57:21if you don't love it, it doesn't matter if other
- 57:24people want to buy it. It isn't going to be sustainable.
- 57:28So start from within and ask yourself what feels
- 57:31good to me, whether that's your show, if you're
- 57:33a podcaster, whether that's a network you're
- 57:35building. And frankly, if you're an advertiser,
- 57:38don't just look at the things everybody else
- 57:39is buying. What do you actually respond to? What
- 57:42do you like to listen to? Because there's other
- 57:44people just like you. So just start by asking
- 57:46yourself, what do I love? I like, what do I actually
- 57:49want to spend? It's like getting married when
- 57:52you're building a network or starting a podcast.
- 57:53You're going to be with this thing, hopefully
- 57:55for a long time. So you better love it. You better
- 57:58really enjoy it. So I just think we need to think
- 58:00more about that and a little bit, at least a
- 58:02little bit less about who's going to pay for
- 58:05it and how much. I love it. That is a great way
- 58:07to end this. Becky Mullencamp for Feminist Podcast
- 58:10Collective. Thank you so much for joining me
- 58:12here on Podcast Network Insights. Thanks for
- 58:15having me. Well, you've made it this far, and
- 58:18I really appreciate it. I truly do, because I
- 58:20know most of us don't make it to the end, so
- 58:22if you allow me, as I said at the beginning of
- 58:25the show, a few extra minutes to share my thoughts
- 58:27on this conversation, I'd appreciate it. At the
- 58:30start, I got into this idea of equitable dues,
- 58:34that sliding scale at the core of the feminist
- 58:36podcast collective. Most networks set a rate,
- 58:40set expectations, and move on. This idea... of
- 58:44members paying anywhere from $5 to $25 or nothing
- 58:48if they need to, bakes flexibility into the very
- 58:51structure. It's not just about making it affordable.
- 58:55It's a mechanism that allows different lived
- 58:57experiences to exist side by side without putting
- 59:01anyone in a box. But zooming out, there were
- 59:04a few other pieces that I can't ignore. First,
- 59:07what stood out to me was the way Becky resisted
- 59:09turning the network into an engine for personal
- 59:12profit. Most network leaders would look for ways
- 59:15to monetize, add services, or at least spin up
- 59:18a coaching arc. Instead, she drew a clear line.
- 59:22The network isn't a pipeline for more business,
- 59:24coaching, or production gigs. That's not how
- 59:27most networks operate, and it changes how you
- 59:30look at what a network actually is providing.
- 59:33Support, visibility, not just revenue share.
- 59:37Second, the fact that growth of the network being
- 59:40capped, not for scarcity, but to protect what
- 59:43works. So members actually know each other and
- 59:46engagement doesn't drop off. It's a network that
- 59:49wants to stay small enough for relationships
- 59:52to matter. Most creators wouldn't expect that,
- 59:55but it's actually strategic choice you have to
- 59:57make at some point. Do you want the biggest group
- 1:00:00possible? Or do you want a network that can actually
- 1:00:03deliver on what it promises? The third thing
- 1:00:07I'd highlight is the approach to sustainability
- 1:00:09goes beyond just money. It's not how many downloads
- 1:00:13or how fast you can monetize. Instead, it's how
- 1:00:16do we make this something members actually want
- 1:00:18to be part of, month after month, including those
- 1:00:21who aren't aiming for six -figure ad deals or
- 1:00:23industry awards. It makes you reconsider what
- 1:00:27you'd want out of a network when the goal isn't
- 1:00:29simply to grow, maybe it's to last. There's so
- 1:00:33much more that I enjoyed and learned from my
- 1:00:35conversation with Becky. These are just some
- 1:00:37of the few things that I thought were worth sharing.
- 1:00:40Once again, Thank you for tuning in to the two
- 1:00:43people who gave me a five star review on Apple.
- 1:00:46Thank you. I've received DMS that you're enjoying
- 1:00:49the podcast, but go ahead and leave a review
- 1:00:51and let others know the show wouldn't have been
- 1:00:54made possible without some of these amazing companies
- 1:00:57that I must say thank you. The show is produced
- 1:01:00by stories and strategies. If you don't know
- 1:01:02them, I suggest you do reach out. I'm using rss
- 1:01:06.com for my podcast hosting because let's be
- 1:01:09honest. Podcast hosting is more than just storage.
- 1:01:12They provide me so many features to ensure a
- 1:01:14great podcast experience. It's easy to use, maximum
- 1:01:18distribution. They have a community to learn
- 1:01:20from, monetization solutions, and so much more.
- 1:01:24Systems and processes are key for the consistency
- 1:01:27needed in podcasting, which is why I use Northflow,
- 1:01:30a dedicated podcast project management platform
- 1:01:33built by podcasters for podcasters. And then
- 1:01:38turning these conversations and recordings into
- 1:01:40hundreds of pieces of content is why I use Cast
- 1:01:43Magic for content repurposing, guest assets,
- 1:01:46and more. As I say, life is about time relationships.
- 1:01:51You have no clue where one conversation is going
- 1:01:53to take you. This is why I'm able to have these
- 1:01:55conversations and provide you these great insights.
- 1:01:58This is why I love networking. And you have no
- 1:02:01clue where listening to these conversations may
- 1:02:03take you in the future. But your future self
- 1:02:06we'll actually thank you for tuning in. I live
- 1:02:09on LinkedIn. Reach out. Let's talk. To those
- 1:02:13who've already done so, I appreciate you. That
- 1:02:16alone means this podcast has value and is creating
- 1:02:19more conversations. I have a newsletter, as I've
- 1:02:22mentioned. This discovery is really difficult
- 1:02:25for podcasts. It's on LinkedIn. You can't miss
- 1:02:29it. Subscribe where you listen. New episodes
- 1:02:32come out every Thursday. Until next time. I appreciate
- 1:02:36you.