Latest / Her Journey: Women, identity, culture & modern life / Teaching My Daughter How to Throw a Punch in Anger | Her Journey
Transcript
- I watched my three-year-old daughter throw a fist into the air and scream, and for the first time in my life, I didn’t tell her to be gentle. I told her to mean it. It happened last Tuesday. We were at the park, that chaotic, sun-drenched place where mothers gather like islands in a sea of plastic slides and screaming toddlers. My daughter, Elara, was playing with a boy named Leo. They weren’t really playing together so much as existing near each other, which is how most toddler interactions go until they don’t. Leo grabbed the blue truck Elara had been holding for twenty minutes. Not asked for. Not traded. Just taken. The kind of swift, unthinking seizure of property that defines early childhood development. In the old days, in the versions of myself I used to be, I would have stepped in. I would have smoothed things over. I would have said, 'Oh, let’s share,' or 'Leo, please give it back nicely.' I would have modeled the polite, conflict-avoidant woman I thought I was supposed to be. But something stopped me. Maybe it was the look on Elara’s face. It wasn’t sadness. It wasn’t even surprise. It was pure, unadulterated rage. Her little face turned red, her chest heaved, and she swung her arm. It wasn’t a hit, not yet. It was a wind-up. A declaration of war. My first instinct, wired deep into my nervous system by every mother, every teacher, every well-meaning auntie who ever told me to use my words, was to soothe. To de-escalate. To teach her that violence is bad, that hitting is wrong, that we must always be the bigger person. And usually, that’s good advice. Usually, we want our daughters to be safe, to be liked, to navigate the world with grace. But here’s the thing about grace when you’re three years old and your boundaries are being trampled: it feels like surrender. I looked at Leo’s mom, who was scrolling on her phone, oblivious. I looked at Elara, trembling with the force of her own injustice. And I realized that if I intervened now, if I took the truck from Leo and gave it back while cooing at Elara, I was teaching her that her anger was a problem to be managed rather than a signal to be heard. I was teaching her that her voice didn’t matter unless it was soft. That’s a dangerous lesson. It’s the lesson that keeps women small, quiet, and complicit in their own erasure. So I didn’t step in. I knelt down. I got on her eye level. I held her gaze. I said, 'Elara, you are mad. You have a right to be mad. He took your truck without asking.' She nodded, fierce and nodding. Then I asked, 'What do you want to do?' This is where it gets tricky, because society has very specific scripts for how girls should express anger. We are expected to cry, to tattle, to withdraw. We are rarely allowed to fight. But Elara didn’t want to cry. She wanted to act. She wanted to reclaim her space. I took her hand. I showed her how to make a fist. Not a violent, aggressive fist, but a solid one. A grounded one. I said, 'You can tell him, 'No. That is mine.' And if he doesn’t stop, you can show him with your body. You can push his hands away. You can stand your ground.' I didn’t say 'hit him.' I didn’t encourage aggression. But I did validate her capacity for physical assertion. I taught her that her body belongs to her. That she has the right to defend it. That her anger is not a flaw; it is fuel. Where does that live in you? Right there, in the muscles of your arms, in the set of your jaw. It’s power. And power isn’t evil. It’s neutral. It’s how we protect what matters. Elara stood up. She walked over to Leo. She didn’t yell. She didn’t throw a tantrum. She placed her small, firm hand on his chest and pushed. Just once. Gentle but immovable. Leo stumbled back, surprised. He dropped the truck. He looked at his mom, who finally looked up, saw the dynamic, and sighed. She picked up Leo and pulled him away. Elara picked up the truck. She came back to me. She didn’t smile. She didn’t cheer. She just exhaled. A long, slow breath that seemed to release all the tension from her tiny frame. She looked at me, and her eyes were clear. She knew she had done the right thing. She knew she hadn’t broken any rules, because I had given her permission to break the rule of silence. That moment, standing in the dirt and dust of the playground, I felt a shift in my own soul. I realized how many times I had swallowed my own anger. How many times I had let people take my truck, my time, my energy, because I was afraid of looking 'difficult' or 'aggressive.' I had spent years apologizing for taking up space. And I never wanted that for her. I never wanted her to feel that her natural response to injustice was shame. Let’s sit with that for a second. Why is a girl throwing a punch such a radical act? Because in our culture, female rage is pathologized. If a man gets angry, he’s passionate. He’s a leader. He’s driven. If a woman gets angry, she’s hysterical. She’s emotional. She’s unstable. We are taught from birth to manage our emotions for the comfort of others. To be pleasant. To be agreeable. To be easy. But ease is often code for compliance. And compliance is often code for exploitation. When I teach Elara to throw a punch, I’m not teaching her to be violent. I’m teaching her to be whole. I’m teaching her that her feelings are valid, even the ugly ones. Even the ones that make us uncomfortable. Especially the ones that make us uncomfortable. Because those are the feelings that keep us safe. Those are the feelings that draw boundaries. Those are the feelings that say, 'I am here, and I will not be moved.' It’s complicated, isn’t it? The line between protection and aggression is thin, especially for little girls. But it’s not about the punch. It’s about the intent. It’s about the message we send ourselves when we choose to act in our own defense. I think about my own mother. She was a sweet woman. A gentle woman. She never raised her voice. She never fought. She absorbed the slights and the hurts and she carried them silently. And I love her. But I also see the toll it took. I see the resentment that built up over decades, turning into a quiet sadness that permeated our home. I didn’t want that legacy for Elara. I wanted her to know that she could fight. That she could speak up. That she could take up space. It’s not about making her a warrior in the traditional sense. It’s about making her a citizen of her own life. Someone who knows her worth. Someone who knows her rights. And yes, someone who knows how to throw a punch if she needs to. Because the world is not always kind. The world is not always fair. And if we don’t teach our daughters how to defend themselves, who will? Will we expect them to just endure? Will we expect them to just smile and walk away? No. I want her to stand her ground. I want her to be bold. I want her to be brave. And sometimes, bravery looks like a fist in the air. Sometimes, bravery looks like saying no. Sometimes, bravery looks like refusing to apologize for existing. This episode ties back to something we discussed recently, though perhaps in a different context. Remember when I talked about quitting that high-paying job that was killing me? It was about reclaiming my identity, about stepping away from a role that demanded my silence and my perfection. Teaching Elara to throw a punch is the next logical step. It’s about passing on the courage it takes to leave rooms that don’t serve you. It’s about modeling the boundary-setting that I struggled to practice for so long. When I tell her she can push back, I am also telling myself that I can push back. That I can say no to the demands that drain me. That I can protect my peace. That I can prioritize my joy. It’s a dual healing. For her, and for me. We are breaking cycles. We are rewriting the script. And it starts with the smallest acts of defiance. A fist in the air. A word spoken loudly. A boundary drawn in the sand. These are the building blocks of a life lived authentically. A life where you are not just surviving, but thriving. Where you are not just enduring, but leading. Where you are not just present, but powerful. Thank you for sitting with me today. Thank you for letting me into your heart and your mind. I hope you feel a little lighter, a little bolder, after this. Go forth and claim your truck. Claim your voice. Claim your life. I’ll see you next time. Bye for now.