Latest / Bloomberg Law / First Trademark Trial Over NFTs
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: It's four thousand, I know, and there's a waiting list.
- 0:13Speaker 1: I assumed five years for a bag. It's not a bag,
- 0:20Speaker 1: it's a Birken The Hermes broken bag the ultimate status symbol,
- 0:26Speaker 1: instantly recognizable, hard to get with stunning prices ranging from
- 0:31Speaker 1: ten thousand to more than three hundred thousand dollars, and
- 0:35Speaker 1: of course it's been the subject of more than one
- 0:38Speaker 1: storyline on Sex in the City, Broke my Broken Sort.
- 0:45Speaker 1: So it's no surprise that French luxury brand air Mez
- 0:49Speaker 1: sued for trademark infringement when a digital artist started creating
- 0:53Speaker 1: and selling meta broken and f T s. They depict
- 0:57Speaker 1: digital images of the broken bag covered a cartoonish colorful
- 1:01Speaker 1: fur instead of leather. Is it art or a digital knockoff?
- 1:05Speaker 1: The trial is the first to focus on how trademark
- 1:08Speaker 1: rights will be applied to n f T s, and
- 1:11Speaker 1: the outcome may have broader implications for whether n f
- 1:14Speaker 1: t s are art or commercial assets. My guest is
- 1:18Speaker 1: intellectual property litigator Terence Ross, a partner caton Uchen Rosenman.
- 1:23Speaker 1: Terry set the stage for us about this trademark battle
- 1:27Speaker 1: over the meta Burken n f T s So Hermes
- 1:30Speaker 1: has put out for a decade now a type of
- 1:34Speaker 1: pope bag for lack of better word that they branded
- 1:37Speaker 1: the Birkin, and the Birken has literally become iconic in
- 1:41Speaker 1: the fashion world. The least expensive one I could find
- 1:45Speaker 1: online sold, but most of these are far more expensive
- 1:49Speaker 1: and can run over a hundred thousand dollars each. The
- 1:52Speaker 1: very high quality bag made out of only to find
- 1:56Speaker 1: its materials, including esoteric things like ostrich and rocodile. The
- 2:01Speaker 1: latches are made out of palladium or gold, you know,
- 2:04Speaker 1: very expensive metal. The craftsmanship is absolutely the best in
- 2:08Speaker 1: the world. It's a phenomenal handbag. Is to afford to
- 2:11Speaker 1: spend that much for a tote bag. All the celebrities
- 2:14Speaker 1: and brag about them. The Kardashians, Cardi b all have them.
- 2:17Speaker 1: And so in December of one along comes a gentleman
- 2:23Speaker 1: by the name of Ason Rothschild who is involved in
- 2:28Speaker 1: fashion and art and entertainment in Los Angeles, and he
- 2:32Speaker 1: puts out online what he describes as Meta Birken, and
- 2:36Speaker 1: they are an FT non fungible token in the digital
- 2:40Speaker 1: world of the metaverse. And for all practical purposes, they
- 2:44Speaker 1: are a two dimensional image of the Birken in the
- 2:47Speaker 1: form of n f T s. He embellished them in
- 2:50Speaker 1: some ways trying to sell online m He finds out
- 2:54Speaker 1: about this and the cease and desist letter accusing the
- 2:57Speaker 1: trademark in the fringement, and when he refuses to comply
- 3:00Speaker 1: with the season desist letter, Rmese files a lawsuit or
- 3:04Speaker 1: trademark infringement and and other clauses of action in the
- 3:07Speaker 1: United States District Card for the Southern District of New
- 3:10Speaker 1: York as a January and a year later here we
- 3:15Speaker 1: are beginning of February, and that lawsuit is now in
- 3:21Speaker 1: trial in New York City in front of a jury.
- 3:24Speaker 1: Or mist claims that consumers were duped into believing that
- 3:28Speaker 1: the n f T s were created or endorsed by
- 3:32Speaker 1: her mess. So this is fundamental to trademark law in
- 3:37Speaker 1: the United States. Trademark law exists to protect consumers against
- 3:42Speaker 1: being duped or tricked into buying goods or services under
- 3:47Speaker 1: the mistaken assumption that they are being offered by someone
- 3:53Speaker 1: other than the person actually offering. So in every trademark
- 3:56Speaker 1: infringement case, it is necessary for the plant of the
- 3:58Speaker 1: trademark owner. To establish what we call consumer confusion, you
- 4:03Speaker 1: don't have to establish that every consumer is confused, just
- 4:06Speaker 1: a significant portion of them, and most courts say that's
- 4:10Speaker 1: in the range of ten to the consumers, depending on
- 4:13Speaker 1: the type of good or service. And the argument here,
- 4:18Speaker 1: which there seems to be some support for, is that
- 4:22Speaker 1: people assume that Hermes had entered the metaverse and was
- 4:27Speaker 1: putting out these meta berkins. There has been testimony that
- 4:32Speaker 1: one Hermes executive was teaching a class at I think
- 4:35Speaker 1: Columbia University in New York City and students came up
- 4:38Speaker 1: to him after the class and asked about the new
- 4:43Speaker 1: Hermes line meta burkins, and I think there are obviously
- 4:46Speaker 1: the are Columbia University of smart kids, and you know,
- 4:49Speaker 1: if they're being duped, that's the guest that the broader
- 4:51Speaker 1: public probably is also being duped into thinking that somehow
- 4:54Speaker 1: Hermes is affiliated or associated with these meta berkins. Rothschild said,
- 5:00Speaker 1: as quote, my meta Berkin's project as a whole was
- 5:03Speaker 1: an artistic experiment to explore where the value in the
- 5:06Speaker 1: broken hand bag actually lies in the handcrafted physical objects
- 5:11Speaker 1: or in the image it projects. So his story has
- 5:15Speaker 1: changed over time. When he first put these out in December,
- 5:19Speaker 1: he described them as a tribute to the iconic Hermes Berken. Apparently,
- 5:24Speaker 1: after the lawsuit was filed and he got legal counsel,
- 5:27Speaker 1: he started to describe the meta Berkins as a commentary
- 5:31Speaker 1: on the fashion company's mistreatment of animals and a way
- 5:36Speaker 1: to own a berkin without actually having to kill a
- 5:40Speaker 1: crocodile and ostrich cow whatever the particular Berken is made
- 5:44Speaker 1: out of. So the story shifted over time, and the
- 5:48Speaker 1: reason for that is that the defense strategy is trying
- 5:51Speaker 1: to bring itself within the Rogers v. Grimaldi test, which
- 5:56Speaker 1: is a tricky test, and provide the First Amendment protection
- 5:59Speaker 1: against trade mark infringement. And we've talked about that test before.
- 6:03Speaker 1: There's a case before the Supreme Court that we discussed
- 6:06Speaker 1: involving Jack Daniels and their trademark bottle. We have June
- 6:11Speaker 1: talked about this before, and I think just in December
- 6:14Speaker 1: when the case you're referring to, which goes by the
- 6:17Speaker 1: title Jack Daniels Versus v. I P. Products, was first
- 6:20Speaker 1: accepted by the Supreme Court, they granted cert cr on it.
- 6:24Speaker 1: And it's one of the confusing things here clearly Jed
- 6:27Speaker 1: Draycoss is the trial judge on this case. Very smart man,
- 6:30Speaker 1: very good judge. You must know that the Supreme Court
- 6:34Speaker 1: is considering the Rogers e. Grimaldi test, and I would
- 6:37Speaker 1: have thought, indeed, if I were the judge, I would
- 6:39Speaker 1: have simply stayed this lawsuit pending Supreme Court guidance on
- 6:43Speaker 1: whether the Rogers test even exists anymore, and if it
- 6:47Speaker 1: does exist, what are the parameters for it. When I
- 6:50Speaker 1: heard about this, I thought, who would have bought these
- 6:53Speaker 1: n f T s if it was you know, these
- 6:55Speaker 1: fur lined bags not shaped like a birkin, but also
- 6:59Speaker 1: about Andy Whirlhol's silk screens of Campbell soup cans. If
- 7:03Speaker 1: this was a painting in a gallery of birken hambag,
- 7:08Speaker 1: you know, would there be any question that it was
- 7:10Speaker 1: considered art. So, June, I can't help you with the
- 7:14Speaker 1: question of who it's bocking, and it's not just the
- 7:17Speaker 1: meta Birken. I don't understand why anyone buys any n
- 7:22Speaker 1: f T s, and I understand that some of these
- 7:25Speaker 1: n f T s sold for as much as an
- 7:28Speaker 1: actual Burken So I'd rather have the handbag. I agree
- 7:32Speaker 1: with you as for the Campbell suit, the Andy Warhol
- 7:35Speaker 1: famous painting. That has been a trope that the defense
- 7:40Speaker 1: has trotted out from a very early point in the case.
- 7:44Speaker 1: They want to sell the notion that this is artwork
- 7:48Speaker 1: and therefore an expressive work within the Rogers test that's
- 7:52Speaker 1: protected by the First Amendment. That argument took a body
- 7:57Speaker 1: blow in trial when Arakoff barred the defenses expert witness
- 8:04Speaker 1: from testifying that the Meta Berkins were nothing more than
- 8:08Speaker 1: the digital equivalent of Andy Warhol's Campbell Soup painting. But that,
- 8:13Speaker 1: in terms of trial strategy, was very serious blow to
- 8:16Speaker 1: the defense and that they weren't going to be allowed
- 8:18Speaker 1: to present this key witness and probably weren't going to
- 8:21Speaker 1: be able to talk about the Campbell Soup argument. Why
- 8:24Speaker 1: did Judge Rakoff make that decision, Well, the Supreme Court
- 8:28Speaker 1: number of years ago established a very tough test for
- 8:34Speaker 1: allowing expert witnesses to testify uh and under that test,
- 8:39Speaker 1: the disrecord judge, the trial judge has to determine that
- 8:43Speaker 1: first the witness is qualified in whatever field to gran testify.
- 8:47Speaker 1: It too, that the opinion they intend to offer is
- 8:53Speaker 1: um based on solid methodology and grounded in some form
- 8:59Speaker 1: of scientific approach, and third that the results obtained by
- 9:04Speaker 1: the expert in coming to opinion are replicable by other experts,
- 9:09Speaker 1: because that's ultimately under science the way new theories are
- 9:14Speaker 1: established and accepted in scientific community. Somebody does the procedure,
- 9:19Speaker 1: reports upon it in a peer review journal. Other scientists
- 9:22Speaker 1: go out, they repeat the exact procedure, and they come
- 9:24Speaker 1: up with the same result that therefore it becomes accepted
- 9:27Speaker 1: the scientific community. And what Judge ray Cost said here
- 9:30Speaker 1: is you maybe have the qualifications and experience to offer
- 9:34Speaker 1: expert testimony, but there's nothing about how you reached your
- 9:38Speaker 1: opinion that's based through grounded in any scientific approach, let
- 9:41Speaker 1: alone replicable by other experts, And therefore it doesn't pass
- 9:46Speaker 1: the Supreme Court tests and I cannot allow it indevidence.
- 9:50Speaker 1: And I thought Judge ray Costs decision was absolutely correct
- 9:53Speaker 1: in that regard. He also said that the um as
- 9:58Speaker 1: experts explanation of n f T S was over complicated
- 10:02Speaker 1: and that the jury appeared puzzled to join the crowd.
- 10:06Speaker 1: He said it was far more confusing than helpful. So
- 10:10Speaker 1: this is the most common criticism of trial lawyers that
- 10:13Speaker 1: you get from juries and individual drawers. When you interviewed.
- 10:17Speaker 1: The map to this fact built my career on the
- 10:19Speaker 1: ability to explain very complex things in very simple ways
- 10:23Speaker 1: to lay people such as jurors or judgets. That is unusual.
- 10:27Speaker 1: The vast majority of trial lawyers in the intellectual property
- 10:30Speaker 1: space seemed to um fall into the trap of over
- 10:35Speaker 1: explaining in very unnecessary detail how things work. And n
- 10:43Speaker 1: f t s are fundamentally about digital source codes, and
- 10:46Speaker 1: the lawyers and the expert they put on explained this
- 10:49Speaker 1: when did the great detail about how would write source
- 10:52Speaker 1: code and and about digital coding and things that were
- 10:56Speaker 1: really unnecessary instead of talking about n f T s
- 10:59Speaker 1: in the way that most human beings talk about it
- 11:02Speaker 1: in in terms of analogies to real world objects. You know.
- 11:06Speaker 1: Of day one of the trial, of the of the
- 11:07Speaker 1: evidence of the trial, it seemed like both sides suffered
- 11:10Speaker 1: significant blows. The loss of the expert was a blow
- 11:13Speaker 1: the defense um this dreadful approach to testifying about explaining
- 11:18Speaker 1: fts by the planets expert was a mistake and a
- 11:22Speaker 1: blow to their case. So neither side got off to
- 11:24Speaker 1: quick starts in this trial. So I mean, what does
- 11:28Speaker 1: ers have to prove that it's confusing? In the marketplace
- 11:33Speaker 1: that it's like, you know, the rip off handbags that
- 11:36Speaker 1: we see on the street. What exactly is is its
- 11:39Speaker 1: burden of proof? Hear the law, the land of Act
- 11:43Speaker 1: is the name of the trademark law in the United States,
- 11:47Speaker 1: and it prohibits anyone from and I'm just reading here
- 11:52Speaker 1: now causing confusion or deceit as to affiliation, connection, or
- 11:58Speaker 1: association in or as to origin, sponsorship, or approval of
- 12:05Speaker 1: their goods or services with a trademark because their services.
- 12:10Speaker 1: And so you have to show that the consuming public,
- 12:15Speaker 1: which I think would be someone in the luxury goods marketplace,
- 12:21Speaker 1: that the consuming public would be thinking that somehow the
- 12:25Speaker 1: meta burkin was affiliated with, connected with, associated with, sponsored by,
- 12:31Speaker 1: or approved by Hermes. And so what we're in here
- 12:36Speaker 1: a lot of is testimony on the planet side of
- 12:40Speaker 1: instances in which consumers reported that sort of confusion to them.
- 12:46Speaker 1: And the example of this one executive going and teaching
- 12:49Speaker 1: at Colombian being approached by students about the Hermes new
- 12:54Speaker 1: meta burkin is a classic example of the sort of
- 12:58Speaker 1: consumer confusion that's required to established trademark infringement. And we'll
- 13:02Speaker 1: just have to wait for the trial to go on
- 13:04Speaker 1: to see how much more of that is and then
- 13:06Speaker 1: it will be up to the jury to decide whether
- 13:08Speaker 1: that's sufficient or not. And then there's the Rogers v.
- 13:12Speaker 1: Grimaldi test, which would be a defense even if there
- 13:15Speaker 1: was consumer confusion. So if this jury believes that these
- 13:20Speaker 1: n f T s are in fact art, then the
- 13:24Speaker 1: defense would win. So let's just remember what the Rodgers v.
- 13:28Speaker 1: Grimaldi test is all about and remind people even then.
- 13:30Speaker 1: We just did an episode in the back in December.
- 13:33Speaker 1: This was a lawsuit by Ginger Rogers, the famous dancer,
- 13:37Speaker 1: against the producers of a movie who had titled the
- 13:40Speaker 1: movie Friend and Ginger I think was the name of
- 13:43Speaker 1: Ginger referring to her. Went up on appeal of Second Circuit,
- 13:47Speaker 1: and they held that the use of a celebrity name
- 13:51Speaker 1: in an expressive work, if artistically relevant to that expressive
- 13:55Speaker 1: work and not intentionally misleading, is protected on of the
- 14:00Speaker 1: First Amendment against trademark infringement. And so it was a
- 14:03Speaker 1: relatively narrow ruling. You know, it was limited to US
- 14:06Speaker 1: celebrity names. It's been expanded beyond that to a broader
- 14:12Speaker 1: range of trademarks. But again, the requirement has always been
- 14:17Speaker 1: in connection with the use of that trademark connection with
- 14:20Speaker 1: an expressive work, if it's really artistically necessary to use
- 14:25Speaker 1: that trademark, and if it's not misleading, intentionally misleading, And
- 14:31Speaker 1: there's a lot of factual predicates there that and facts
- 14:34Speaker 1: are determined by jury, not judges or lawyers. And so
- 14:37Speaker 1: the first thing juries going to have to decide is
- 14:40Speaker 1: whether or not the Meta Birkin is an expressive work.
- 14:43Speaker 1: And that's why you see the plainiff trying to push
- 14:47Speaker 1: the notion that Mr ross Shaw was just about to
- 14:50Speaker 1: make money here, and you see on the other side,
- 14:53Speaker 1: on the defense side, the argument Mr Rothschild is an
- 14:56Speaker 1: artist and this is an artistic work. I mean, they
- 14:58Speaker 1: want to bring it within this Rodgers test and the
- 15:00Speaker 1: requirement established it was an expressive work and artistically relevant,
- 15:05Speaker 1: not intentionally misleading. And we'll just have to see how
- 15:08Speaker 1: that plays out. I mean, Judge Rakoff said on a
- 15:10Speaker 1: motion to dismiss brought by the dependants that he thought
- 15:12Speaker 1: Rogers v. Grimaldi applied here. I think there's a big
- 15:16Speaker 1: question mark about that. The case accepted by the Supreme Court,
- 15:19Speaker 1: which came out of the Ninth Circuit is the very
- 15:21Speaker 1: first case in which the Rogers test was applied to
- 15:25Speaker 1: a commercial product there it was a dog shoot toy,
- 15:28Speaker 1: and other circuit courts have consistencies. Was said that Rogers
- 15:31Speaker 1: test is not applied to commercial products. N f T
- 15:34Speaker 1: s are really a type of commercial product. And that's
- 15:37Speaker 1: why this is at the intersection of technology and art.
- 15:41Speaker 1: I mean, is the n f T work of art?
- 15:43Speaker 1: Is it? Technology is a bunch of source code? I mean,
- 15:46Speaker 1: what is it? And I think Judge Rickoff may have
- 15:49Speaker 1: sort of jumped the gun by saying that the Rodgers
- 15:52Speaker 1: test applies when I think there's a lot of factual
- 15:54Speaker 1: issues about that. And I really think it's going to
- 15:56Speaker 1: depend on what Supreme Court says in the Jack Daniels case,
- 15:59Speaker 1: because the Supreme Court good one option for them is
- 16:01Speaker 1: to say, hey, you know, there is no such thing
- 16:03Speaker 1: as Roger's test that was made up by a court
- 16:05Speaker 1: that's not in the statute. Statute already has a fair
- 16:09Speaker 1: use test that should be applied instead of this Roger's test.
- 16:11Speaker 1: I don't know what's going to happen. That's why I
- 16:13Speaker 1: think it's very curious to allow this case to go
- 16:15Speaker 1: forward when it all could become moot in June. Which
- 16:19Speaker 1: side do you think has the better argument. Which side
- 16:22Speaker 1: would you rather be representing? I always prefer repressing the
- 16:26Speaker 1: side that has the money to pay me, and I
- 16:29Speaker 1: doubt Mason rots Sound has that money is apparently using
- 16:32Speaker 1: a new law firm that I think it's sort of
- 16:34Speaker 1: a public interest type firm called Lex Lumena. But as
- 16:37Speaker 1: far as the law and the fact this is the case,
- 16:39Speaker 1: the first impression, I think it's fair to say my
- 16:41Speaker 1: gut reaction is that the Hermes side of the argument
- 16:46Speaker 1: is a bit stronger. Particularly, I don't like the way
- 16:50Speaker 1: that the defendant story kept changing over time, apparently in
- 16:53Speaker 1: a sort of post hoc attempt to fit itself within
- 16:56Speaker 1: the Rogers test. You lawyer up and you go, oh,
- 16:58Speaker 1: you know what I should have been saying all along,
- 17:00Speaker 1: that this is artistically relevant, is an expressive work. I'm
- 17:02Speaker 1: not just trying to make money less. I mean, they
- 17:04Speaker 1: seem to be trying to force fit this into the
- 17:06Speaker 1: Rogers test, and I not so sure that it fits.
- 17:11Speaker 1: Quite Frankly, who would buy this if it didn't have
- 17:17Speaker 1: the burke In name on it? If these were just
- 17:19Speaker 1: called handback, would any consumer actually buy these? I mean,
- 17:22Speaker 1: isn't it the association with the Birkin iconic handbag that
- 17:27Speaker 1: makes it purchasable and people interested in it. I don't know.
- 17:31Speaker 1: I mean, it's an interesting question. This case to be
- 17:33Speaker 1: a game change. You're right, this is a really important
- 17:36Speaker 1: case to trademark law as the metaverse expands and more
- 17:42Speaker 1: companies move into it. And we've heard a lot of
- 17:45Speaker 1: testimony already, and her Knees has plans to move into
- 17:47Speaker 1: the metaverse, and therefore this would directly impact their ability
- 17:51Speaker 1: to do that. We need to probably update the Land
- 17:54Speaker 1: of Act to really address this sort of issue. You're
- 17:57Speaker 1: absolutely right, June. It is a cutting edge haste and
- 18:00Speaker 1: just the first of many. I think we're seeing this field.
- 18:03Speaker 1: We'll keep track of what happens here, and that Jack
- 18:06Speaker 1: Daniels case is going to be heard by the Supreme
- 18:09Speaker 1: Court on March two, so maybe we'll learn more about
- 18:14Speaker 1: their take on the Rogers test at that point. Thanks
- 18:17Speaker 1: so much, Terry. That's intellectual property litigator Terence Ross, a
- 18:21Speaker 1: partner at Caton Euten Rosenman. Republican state attorneys general are
- 18:27Speaker 1: trying to kill a climate friendly retirement investment rule they
- 18:32Speaker 1: derived as WOKE. More than two dozen states are suing
- 18:35Speaker 1: to block the rule which permits private sector employers to
- 18:39Speaker 1: consider environmental, social, and corporate governance factors when choosing pension investments,
- 18:45Speaker 1: and the US Labor Department is facing litigation deja vu
- 18:50Speaker 1: because it has to defend its rule in a conservative
- 18:53Speaker 1: Texas jurisdiction known for striking down consequential employee benefit regulations.
- 18:59Speaker 1: Will his to re repeat itself? Joining me to answer
- 19:02Speaker 1: that question is Josh Lichtenstein, partner and head of the
- 19:05Speaker 1: ARISCA fiduciary practice at Ropes and Gray. So, Josh tell
- 19:10Speaker 1: us about this rule that's being challenged. The rule that
- 19:13Speaker 1: we're talking about here, it's often referred to as an
- 19:16Speaker 1: e x G investing rule, but it's really broader than that.
- 19:20Speaker 1: This is actually a rule that governs the way that
- 19:24Speaker 1: produciaries to arista plans, and that's both the traditional defined
- 19:28Speaker 1: benefit pensition plans and define contribution plans like a following
- 19:32Speaker 1: Cave plan. It's the rule that governs the way that
- 19:35Speaker 1: produciaries to those plans make all of their investment decisions.
- 19:40Speaker 1: And so the rule will cover how plan produciaries select
- 19:45Speaker 1: a particular fund that they either want to invest assets
- 19:48Speaker 1: in or want to make available to four along participants,
- 19:52Speaker 1: and it goes to how they're supposed to determine what
- 19:57Speaker 1: criteria are relevant interesting those funds, and then how they're
- 20:01Speaker 1: supposed to wait those criteria. And while people are generally
- 20:06Speaker 1: thinking about this in terms of whether a plan sponsor
- 20:10Speaker 1: can use E s G factors as part of their
- 20:13Speaker 1: investment decision or not, it's really much broader than that,
- 20:17Speaker 1: and it goes to every financial or potentially financial factor
- 20:21Speaker 1: that might be utilized by a plan producer. So Texas
- 20:27Speaker 1: and other Republican led states are suing, what are their allegations,
- 20:34Speaker 1: what's their cause of action? Basically it's very interesting, right,
- 20:38Speaker 1: you know, And I think that this is important to
- 20:39Speaker 1: sort of be clear about because there are a lot
- 20:41Speaker 1: of headlines about various of these states, including Texas, having
- 20:47Speaker 1: passed laws the government how their own retirement plans get invested.
- 20:51Speaker 1: And generally speaking, you know, these laws are limiting the
- 20:55Speaker 1: ability to use E s G considerations for ind USTs
- 20:59Speaker 1: and purposes is or are restricting the state pensions from
- 21:03Speaker 1: investing with certain asset managers based on levels of participation
- 21:08Speaker 1: in certain industries like the uscile fuels industry. But the
- 21:12Speaker 1: Department of Labor's rule does not actually impact those government
- 21:17Speaker 1: plans are making all of these headlines. The Department of
- 21:20Speaker 1: Labor's rule only impacts private pension plans. Of these are
- 21:24Speaker 1: pension plans that are either maintained by a private employer
- 21:28Speaker 1: or that are maintained by a union that covers employees
- 21:32Speaker 1: of private employers. So it's not obvious necessarily, you know,
- 21:37Speaker 1: why it would be the States that would want to
- 21:39Speaker 1: bring a lawsuit like this because doesn't directly impact their plans.
- 21:43Speaker 1: You know, what the States are claiming at heart as
- 21:46Speaker 1: the basis for why they should be able to sue
- 21:48Speaker 1: is an alleged detrimental impact on residents of the states
- 21:52Speaker 1: and on the tax receipts of the states. But there
- 21:55Speaker 1: are also some private plaintiffs, you know, that are part
- 21:57Speaker 1: of the suit, and there's ending might be somewhat more
- 22:01Speaker 1: obvious as a plan sponsor alleging that they will be
- 22:05Speaker 1: um you know, more work and more costs associated with
- 22:08Speaker 1: money their plan under the rule of plan participants and
- 22:11Speaker 1: energy company. But at heart, what all of these allegations
- 22:16Speaker 1: really are about. They're basically allegations that the rule put
- 22:21Speaker 1: forward by the Biden administration's Department of Labor will have
- 22:25Speaker 1: the effects of devoting more retirement assets towards E S G.
- 22:31Speaker 1: GOLs and away from the fossil fuels industry and certain
- 22:36Speaker 1: other sectors, and that that will have a detrimental impact
- 22:40Speaker 1: on the states that are joining this letter, and that
- 22:43Speaker 1: it would be sort of a being appropriate use of
- 22:47Speaker 1: retiring assets to pursue non retirement related goals. I know,
- 22:53Speaker 1: I started this answer by saying that the duos rules
- 22:57Speaker 1: do not govern the state plans, and that's correctly, it's
- 22:59Speaker 1: not covering them. But it's interesting the state laws that
- 23:03Speaker 1: government state pension plans are all modeled on the federal law.
- 23:07Speaker 1: They're all modeled on ARISSA, and so the Biden administration
- 23:11Speaker 1: and many of these states that are involved in this
- 23:14Speaker 1: lawsuit have actually themselves come to very different interpretations of
- 23:19Speaker 1: the same statutory language around few Sharry standards, and so,
- 23:24Speaker 1: you know, sort of separate and apart from the question
- 23:27Speaker 1: about the interests of the states have in directly bringing
- 23:31Speaker 1: this lawsuits, they're sort of a secondary question of who
- 23:36Speaker 1: really has the right interpretation of this statutory language when
- 23:42Speaker 1: you have multiple government bodies, you know, at the state
- 23:44Speaker 1: in paral level, interpreting the same language that brings up
- 23:46Speaker 1: a couple of things. The Texas Attorney General Can Paxton
- 23:50Speaker 1: said that this kind of investing what's hard working Americans
- 23:54Speaker 1: retirement savings at risk. The rule reverses restrictions on socially
- 24:00Speaker 1: conscious investing that we're adopted by the Trump administration. Can
- 24:04Speaker 1: you compare the rules for US? So, I find the
- 24:08Speaker 1: allegations in the complaints to be somewhat opposite to what
- 24:14Speaker 1: my read of the actual rule is, because the allegations
- 24:17Speaker 1: of the complaints are basically that the Department of Labor's
- 24:21Speaker 1: current rule will have the effect of making it more
- 24:26Speaker 1: difficult and more costly for planned sponsors to have to
- 24:30Speaker 1: evaluate different investment options, and that it will have the
- 24:35Speaker 1: effect of driving more assets into e s G type funds.
- 24:41Speaker 1: But I think that the reality is that the Biden
- 24:44Speaker 1: administration's rule is very neutral. I actually think it's the
- 24:48Speaker 1: most neutral version of this guidance that we have seen
- 24:50Speaker 1: from the Department of Labor, and the Department of Labor
- 24:52Speaker 1: has been putting guidance out on this topic for decades,
- 24:57Speaker 1: literally for decades. It may have the longest history of
- 24:59Speaker 1: any of you US regulator regulating the E s G
- 25:02Speaker 1: type investment decisions, and the guidance has gone back and
- 25:06Speaker 1: forth over time as administrations have changed, but you know,
- 25:10Speaker 1: there's sort of core principles that have been in the
- 25:12Speaker 1: guidance from the start. I've really been that fiduciaries are
- 25:17Speaker 1: supposed to invest solely based on what's in the best
- 25:19Speaker 1: interests of the planned participants, and that you know, they're
- 25:24Speaker 1: only supposed to consider sort of non economic collateral factors
- 25:28Speaker 1: like the positive externalities or the social good created by
- 25:33Speaker 1: E s G investing in very limited circumstances where the
- 25:38Speaker 1: fiduciary otherwise can't choose between two different investment options, and
- 25:42Speaker 1: so rather than flipping a coin to choose which of
- 25:45Speaker 1: the two they can select m the investing option actually
- 25:48Speaker 1: considering those non economic considerations like the positive externalities. And
- 25:53Speaker 1: that's what the guidance has said, with varying levels of
- 25:57Speaker 1: emphasis for years. The Trump administration rule came out a
- 26:01Speaker 1: little bit different because the Trump administration rule, both the
- 26:04Speaker 1: proposed rule and then also the final rule, and with
- 26:08Speaker 1: a viewed as being very very restrictive on the ability
- 26:11Speaker 1: to consider E s G factors as pure economic factors.
- 26:16Speaker 1: And so that was really the reason why the Trump
- 26:19Speaker 1: adminstrator rules having impact on the market, and why it
- 26:22Speaker 1: was causing plan sponsors so much angst and worried because
- 26:26Speaker 1: it made them worry that entire classes of economic data
- 26:32Speaker 1: could be prohibited, I mean, part of their decision space
- 26:36Speaker 1: because the Trump administration rule was so skeptical of the
- 26:40Speaker 1: ability for E s G factors to the economic considerations.
- 26:44Speaker 1: And that's really strange because if you look at institutional
- 26:48Speaker 1: investors behavior more broadly in the market, it's just become
- 26:53Speaker 1: very common practice, as I understand it, to incorporate E
- 26:57Speaker 1: s G data the same way that other financial data
- 27:01Speaker 1: is incorporated as just the means of assessing different types
- 27:04Speaker 1: of risks. And so, but the Trump administration rule, you know,
- 27:08Speaker 1: one of the fears that people had was that the
- 27:11Speaker 1: rule was basically going to force pension plans from being
- 27:14Speaker 1: able to invest into mainstream like not you know, E
- 27:17Speaker 1: s G impact funds, just sort of mainstream investment funds
- 27:21Speaker 1: which are incorporating E s G risk factors as part
- 27:24Speaker 1: of their economic analysis the same way that they consider
- 27:27Speaker 1: any other risk factor. So when you see the Attorney
- 27:30Speaker 1: General saying that that this is going to create extra
- 27:33Speaker 1: risk or be harmful to plan participants. To me, that
- 27:38Speaker 1: doesn't really ring true because, based on my understanding, in
- 27:44Speaker 1: almost every case you know, where a plan sponsor or
- 27:48Speaker 1: plan producer is going to be considering E s G
- 27:51Speaker 1: factors as part of their investment process, it's because they're
- 27:54Speaker 1: just behaving the same way that other similarly situated institutional
- 27:58Speaker 1: investors would behave in you know, considering the full range
- 28:02Speaker 1: of economic criteria. And the other thing that I think
- 28:05Speaker 1: is interesting is that you know, even within these states,
- 28:08Speaker 1: right like Texas State Planned have themselves, you know, adopted
- 28:13Speaker 1: E s G considerations as part of their own risk
- 28:15Speaker 1: evaluation framework. And there are questions now under state law
- 28:18Speaker 1: about whether they're allowed to really do that or not,
- 28:20Speaker 1: But it's just a very accepted part of institutional invest
- 28:25Speaker 1: things that you would consider E s G risk factors
- 28:28Speaker 1: like you consider other risk factors. We've seen the State
- 28:31Speaker 1: of Texas and other Republican led states bring all kinds
- 28:36Speaker 1: of suits against the Biden administration, everything from immigration to
- 28:42Speaker 1: healthcare issues. So what do you think the real reason
- 28:46Speaker 1: is for bringing this suit? Well, I mean, it's impossible
- 28:50Speaker 1: to get inside of people's heads you know exactly why
- 28:52Speaker 1: they're bringing it, right, But I think it's hard to
- 28:54Speaker 1: ignore the political dimension here at E s G has
- 28:57Speaker 1: obviously become a very political topic. I all so think
- 29:00Speaker 1: that part of it maybe that, as I was saying before,
- 29:04Speaker 1: you know, a lot of these states have adopted or
- 29:07Speaker 1: are adopting their own E s G restrictive views of
- 29:13Speaker 1: investing for their state retirement plans. And because the states
- 29:18Speaker 1: are operating under the same statutory language as the federal government,
- 29:23Speaker 1: is here the fact that the Biden administration's rule has
- 29:27Speaker 1: a very different interpretation of the way that produciary duties
- 29:31Speaker 1: should be discharged. We're making investments, you know, because the
- 29:35Speaker 1: Biden administrations rule is basically from its prefuducers to choose
- 29:38Speaker 1: any factor that they think is an important financial factor
- 29:42Speaker 1: in the considerations, and a lot of these state rules
- 29:44Speaker 1: are restricting consideration of the s G even there would
- 29:47Speaker 1: be a financial factor, or her skeptical the ability of
- 29:50Speaker 1: the s G to the financial factor. So I think
- 29:53Speaker 1: that there may be a motivation here from these states
- 29:56Speaker 1: that if they're either able to get the Biden rule
- 29:59Speaker 1: not own, or even if you're just able to sort
- 30:02Speaker 1: of put the argument out there into the world that
- 30:04Speaker 1: their interpretations are also sort of valid or consistent with
- 30:09Speaker 1: historical interpretations of the standards, notwithstanding that they differ so
- 30:13Speaker 1: much from the Biden administration rule. Now, we could talk
- 30:17Speaker 1: about the accuracy of the account that the complaints gives
- 30:24Speaker 1: of sort of historic interpretations of the rule, and I'm
- 30:27Speaker 1: not really sure that they get the rights to be frank,
- 30:30Speaker 1: but I think that that may be part of what
- 30:32Speaker 1: the motivation is here, that the states are trying to
- 30:34Speaker 1: protect their own somewhat radical interpretations of the statutory language
- 30:41Speaker 1: by challenging the Biden administrations more traditional interpretation of the
- 30:46Speaker 1: statutory language. This lawsuit is going to be heard by
- 30:50Speaker 1: federal Judge Matthew Kismarik, and he's a trumpet pointee who's
- 30:55Speaker 1: struck down Biden administration rules on immigration and health care
- 31:00Speaker 1: protections for LGBT people. I mean, we've seen the fact
- 31:05Speaker 1: that the Texas a g they file in a friendly venue,
- 31:09Speaker 1: just as the Democratic a g s would file on
- 31:13Speaker 1: a friendly venue under Trump. So how likely is it
- 31:17Speaker 1: that this judge will issue an injunction blocking the rule.
- 31:22Speaker 1: I can't speak to how likely they are to issue
- 31:24Speaker 1: an a junction, but I agree with you, if they've
- 31:27Speaker 1: selected a very friendly venue and I wouldn't be taking
- 31:32Speaker 1: this lawsuit as seriously as a threat to the rule
- 31:37Speaker 1: if it were in the left friendly jurisdiction, because I
- 31:40Speaker 1: really do think that the Biden administration rule is very
- 31:45Speaker 1: sort of neutral, and that's the arguments put forward in
- 31:49Speaker 1: the complaints about it driving more assets towards d s
- 31:52Speaker 1: G are incorrect. But I do think that the fact
- 31:56Speaker 1: that's in front of this judge, and the fact that
- 31:57Speaker 1: it's you know, within the Fifth Circuit, anything vision lights
- 32:00Speaker 1: up being appealed to wind up in front of the Circuit,
- 32:02Speaker 1: and that does create a greater risk of an adverse
- 32:06Speaker 1: finding for the Department of Labor than if it was
- 32:08Speaker 1: in another court. And you know, I always come back to,
- 32:12Speaker 1: you know, this division of the Department of Labor that's
- 32:15Speaker 1: responsible for retirement. It had you know, an expansive rulemaking
- 32:19Speaker 1: on the definition of a fiduciary under arrissa, and that
- 32:22Speaker 1: was struck down by the Fifth Circuit back in And
- 32:27Speaker 1: that was a pretty surprising decision to a lot of
- 32:29Speaker 1: people because irrespective of what somebody might have thought of
- 32:33Speaker 1: the merits of the rule the Department of Labor had
- 32:36Speaker 1: gone through, it seemed like a very painstaking process and
- 32:38Speaker 1: despite that very painstaking process, the rule was found to
- 32:41Speaker 1: be arbitrary and deprecias and so here again, I think
- 32:45Speaker 1: that the administration has gone through an extensive process. If anything,
- 32:49Speaker 1: people were wondering what was taking them so long to
- 32:51Speaker 1: come out with final rule, because there was a long
- 32:53Speaker 1: time that elapsed between the end of the comment period
- 32:56Speaker 1: on the proposal and when the final rule came out.
- 32:58Speaker 1: But you know, it all just goes to the rigor
- 33:01Speaker 1: of the process and consideration of the comments became in.
- 33:04Speaker 1: But you know, I think it's very very hard to
- 33:07Speaker 1: predict how how this particular court and how the Fifth Circuit,
- 33:11Speaker 1: also on an appeal, will react to these types of arguments.
- 33:15Speaker 1: I will say, though, that if the deals current rule
- 33:19Speaker 1: is struck down by a court on the basis of
- 33:22Speaker 1: the process that they went through, that I wouldn't necessarily
- 33:25Speaker 1: expect the results of that to be that we wind
- 33:28Speaker 1: up back at the Trump administration's rule, because I would
- 33:31Speaker 1: expect the Trump administration's rule, if that was then put
- 33:34Speaker 1: back into place, to be challenged itself on similar grounds.
- 33:37Speaker 1: And I would expect that any claim that the Trump
- 33:41Speaker 1: administration rule, you know, didn't go through an appropriate process
- 33:44Speaker 1: would be much stronger an arguments of the Biden administration
- 33:47Speaker 1: didn't go through an appropriate process because the Trump administration
- 33:50Speaker 1: had very short comment periods and a much faster turnaround
- 33:54Speaker 1: time between the close of the common period on the
- 33:58Speaker 1: proposed rule and when they came out with a rule,
- 34:01Speaker 1: and the Trump administration final rule was very different from
- 34:04Speaker 1: the proposed rule, and they had had to respond to
- 34:07Speaker 1: a much larger number of individual comment letters which themselves
- 34:11Speaker 1: were starkly sort of negative and disapproving of the Trump
- 34:15Speaker 1: administration rule. So I think that if the Biden administration
- 34:19Speaker 1: rule is struck down, then the ultimate outcome it might
- 34:23Speaker 1: be a reversion to the prior law. And then again
- 34:27Speaker 1: I would probably expect that we've lined up with the
- 34:29Speaker 1: rule that still remains sort of neutral, not anti E
- 34:34Speaker 1: s G consideration like the Trump administration rules. So how
- 34:38Speaker 1: much of a setback would it be for the Biden
- 34:40Speaker 1: administration if there was an adjunction issued against this rule?
- 34:44Speaker 1: Would it be a great setback? I mean, I think
- 34:47Speaker 1: it would be a pretty significant set back to my mind,
- 34:50Speaker 1: because the Department of Labor put a lot of resources
- 34:53Speaker 1: into this rule, similar to how they put a lot
- 34:55Speaker 1: of resources into the prior produciery rule which are struck down.
- 34:58Speaker 1: The agency had limited resources, r a limited number of employees,
- 35:03Speaker 1: and they have a lot of responsibilities. They have a
- 35:05Speaker 1: lot of rules they need to put out, and they
- 35:07Speaker 1: oversee something very important, right They oversee private retirements in America,
- 35:11Speaker 1: which is critically important. So you know, I think that
- 35:15Speaker 1: the loss of the time that they put into this rule,
- 35:18Speaker 1: plus the need to vote more resources, would be a
- 35:21Speaker 1: real set back. I will also say that I think
- 35:23Speaker 1: that it would be very unfortunate for pretty much every
- 35:27Speaker 1: stakeholder if the rule was struck down, because I really
- 35:32Speaker 1: do believe that the Biden administration rule gets it right
- 35:36Speaker 1: in a way that administrations both Democratic and Republicans have
- 35:40Speaker 1: failed to do so in the past. Because it's so neutral.
- 35:43Speaker 1: It makes it so abundantly clear in my mind that
- 35:47Speaker 1: plan producers are supposed to be able just to choose
- 35:49Speaker 1: what they think is appropriate in making their investment decisions.
- 35:52Speaker 1: That I think that's the right rule. I think that's
- 35:54Speaker 1: the way things are supposed to be. That the regulators
- 35:56Speaker 1: shouldn't be putting it some on the scale for or
- 35:58Speaker 1: against any particular set of economic considerations, and should let
- 36:02Speaker 1: the plant producers make their choices. See, I think it
- 36:04Speaker 1: would be a pretty big setback not just to the administration,
- 36:08Speaker 1: but to plan sponsors, retirement didaver's, asset managers, consultants, really
- 36:13Speaker 1: everybody if the rule was to be struck down. I
- 36:16Speaker 1: will also just say, you know, as another note on
- 36:19Speaker 1: that point, that while the Trump administration rule was sort
- 36:22Speaker 1: of wildly unpopular among basically every constituency, we had consumer advocates,
- 36:27Speaker 1: trade organization drifting in the active management industry, and plan
- 36:32Speaker 1: sponsors all lining up together just saying that the Trump
- 36:34Speaker 1: administration rule was a harmful rule in a lot of ways,
- 36:38Speaker 1: and it had a negative impact on the market of
- 36:40Speaker 1: chilling effects is the language that people use the Biden rule.
- 36:44Speaker 1: The only detractors I'm aware of really of this rule
- 36:47Speaker 1: elected Republican officials. I'm really not aware of any market
- 36:51Speaker 1: participants or planned sponsors who are unhappy with this rule.
- 36:56Speaker 1: I think it's noteworthy that when they were gathering private
- 36:58Speaker 1: plaintiffs for this plan, just one plan sponsor and not
- 37:02Speaker 1: like one of the most noteworthy plan sponsors in America
- 37:05Speaker 1: or anything. So I think, from my perspective, I think
- 37:08Speaker 1: that having a settled, neutral rule benefits everybody and creating
- 37:12Speaker 1: more chaos in the space only hurts retirees. Thanks for
- 37:16Speaker 1: being on the show, Josh. That's Josh Lichtenstein, a partner
- 37:19Speaker 1: in Ropes and Gray. And that's it for this edition
- 37:22Speaker 1: of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get
- 37:24Speaker 1: the latest legal news Honor Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can
- 37:28Speaker 1: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
- 37:32Speaker 1: bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law, and remember to
- 37:36Speaker 1: tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every week night at
- 37:39Speaker 1: ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 37:43Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg