Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: On Topic - Sorta traditional Zoom-enabled classroom type room
Transcript
- 0:03av super friends on topic is an
- 0:05independent production wholly owned and
- 0:07operated by av super friends llc for the
- 0:09highest quality recording of all of our
- 0:11shows visit avsuperfriends.com this is av
- 0:17super friends on topic a thirty minute
- 0:19monthly round table focused on a single
- 0:21topic this discussion will be opinionated
- 0:23to the point and saturated with our
- 0:25well-known blend of painfully one
- 0:26expertise and deeply ingrained immaturity
- 0:36for september twenty twenty six yes you
- 0:38heard me september it's the best sounding
- 0:40and most awkward different type of
- 0:42microphone whatever related podcast and
- 0:44higher ed this is the av super friends
- 0:45on topic episode number seventy seven yes
- 0:49that's correct didn't seem confident about
- 0:51that sir
- 0:52I'm making up as I go along because
- 0:53I forgot to write that.
- 0:54Broadcasting live across three time zones
- 0:56and yet spanning the same amount of
- 0:57geographic space.
- 0:58From cornfields to coastlines,
- 1:00dodging potholes, dead zones,
- 1:01and suspiciously low clearance signs,
- 1:03I'm your navigator with no map, no plan,
- 1:05and absolutely no business holding this
- 1:07clipboard.
- 1:08I'm Chris Dechter,
- 1:08and you're tuned in for another Friday
- 1:09afternoon podcast adventure with the AV
- 1:11Super Friends.
- 1:12And let's say hello to that panel who,
- 1:14for those of you who haven't looked at
- 1:16it, everyone got a promotion.
- 1:17Ooh, I did see that.
- 1:20I was excited.
- 1:20I can't find the notes because the notes
- 1:22are the wrong date,
- 1:23but I think I found them.
- 1:25Well,
- 1:25it's episode seventy-seven if you want to
- 1:26find the notes.
- 1:27Our first panelist coordinates AV, IT,
- 1:30facilities, networking,
- 1:31and support teams to ensure that after
- 1:33fourteen meetings,
- 1:33everyone agrees that button should say on.
- 1:37He's a vice president of cross-functional
- 1:39button alignment from Kansas City, Salem,
- 1:40Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:42I'm so excited to be vice president.
- 1:44I forgot about my title.
- 1:47Well,
- 1:47our next panelist ensures that every
- 1:49learning space is fully operational before
- 1:51classes begin,
- 1:52except for the rooms that nobody mentioned
- 1:53until Thursday afternoon.
- 1:55He's a vice president of classroom
- 1:57technology expectation management from
- 1:59Corvallis, Oregon, say a little Mr.
- 2:00Mark Kolowczynski.
- 2:03Let's just lower that expectation level a
- 2:06little bit,
- 2:06and that will increase our success
- 2:08metrics.
- 2:09Perfect.
- 2:09That's how you do it.
- 2:10It actually does work.
- 2:11I know.
- 2:12It's a valid strategy, sir.
- 2:13That's all day two stuff.
- 2:14Yeah, don't worry about that.
- 2:15Don't worry about that right now.
- 2:17Our next panelist leads long-term refresh
- 2:19planning by identifying equipment that
- 2:20should have been replaced three fiscal
- 2:22years ago and is confidently just moving
- 2:24it into next year's budget.
- 2:25He's a vice president of deferred
- 2:27replacement strategy from Greensboro,
- 2:28North Carolina.
- 2:29Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:31If it made it for three extra years,
- 2:33it'll make it for four.
- 2:36That is a real strategy, sir.
- 2:38That's legit.
- 2:40That's legit, sir.
- 2:42And our final panelist maintains the
- 2:43university's carefully documented AV
- 2:45standards and approves the completely
- 2:47unique exception required for every single
- 2:49project.
- 2:50He's a vice president of technology
- 2:52standards, governance,
- 2:53and reasonable variance from Bowling
- 2:54Green, Kentucky.
- 2:55Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:56I think that reasonable variance is ninety
- 2:59percent of my job.
- 3:02Everything's a standard except for these
- 3:04things.
- 3:05Everything's a standard.
- 3:06Within reason.
- 3:07Let's not get carried away.
- 3:09Someone's reasonable expectations,
- 3:12I guess.
- 3:14Lower those expectations, sir.
- 3:16You'll be fine.
- 3:17In a recent conversation I had, well,
- 3:19is this part of our standard?
- 3:20We don't really have those.
- 3:21And then about a half an hour later,
- 3:22that's not on our standard.
- 3:25Show me the standards document we keep
- 3:26talking about.
- 3:27Where are these standards wrote down?
- 3:29You know what?
- 3:30AVSF is going to make one giant standards
- 3:32document,
- 3:32and we'll just keep posting it on our
- 3:34website.
- 3:34Justin,
- 3:34I'm going to send you all the standards.
- 3:36Everything's going to be longer than the
- 3:37Bible, man.
- 3:38Like we can will be the word.
- 3:45Evolution of starting with bad jokes.
- 3:49All right.
- 3:49So on today's show, whoops,
- 3:50I just scrolled right past it.
- 3:52On today's show,
- 3:53we're gonna discuss the only way you
- 3:55should be deploying BYOM systems.
- 3:58This is the only way to do it.
- 4:00It's the word.
- 4:01The one true, correct way to do it.
- 4:03Are we still doing the show we planned?
- 4:06We are, Justin.
- 4:06I just said that.
- 4:08That's what we're doing.
- 4:09I was confused, but okay.
- 4:10I'm just verifying.
- 4:12You're confused because I said exactly
- 4:13what we talked about?
- 4:15Well,
- 4:15I wasn't entirely sure how you phrased
- 4:18that, but let's move on.
- 4:19Anyway,
- 4:20so but first we have to do our
- 4:21little bit of housekeeping here.
- 4:22So if you're listening to this as recorded
- 4:23MP three,
- 4:24we do stream live on Fridays at about
- 4:25three fifteen Eastern twelve fifteen
- 4:26Pacific or whenever Mark finally shows up
- 4:28from whatever the heck he was doing right
- 4:29before the show.
- 4:30Mark, you can.
- 4:32No, he was not.
- 4:33That was late.
- 4:35You can join us for that live on
- 4:36Twitter, LinkedIn or YouTube.
- 4:37And if you can't join us live,
- 4:38we still want you to connect with us
- 4:39on the socials.
- 4:39You can follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 4:41Blue Sky and YouTube to keep up with
- 4:42our latest updates and news.
- 4:44Please don't forget to spread the word.
- 4:45Share this podcast with your friends,
- 4:46colleagues, enemies, perfect strangers,
- 4:48anyone who might enjoy it.
- 4:49Find that person on campus who still knows
- 4:51where there's a VGA distribution amplifier
- 4:53mounted above the ceiling and make them
- 4:55listen because they have the knowledge we
- 4:57all need.
- 4:57It's where that extension cord goes to.
- 4:59It's over on the weird... Yeah,
- 5:00we just tuck that above the ceiling.
- 5:01It's fine.
- 5:02Don't pay attention to that.
- 5:04It may run through a wall as well.
- 5:05If you want to support the show,
- 5:06please consider donating your
- 5:07contributions to help us to keep bringing
- 5:08you the honest content that you love or
- 5:10love to hate.
- 5:11And you can find the donation link for
- 5:12that in the show notes or right at
- 5:13the top of our website.
- 5:14Every little bit helps us continue our
- 5:15important work of questioning decades of
- 5:17higher-ed AV decisions and asking things
- 5:18like, why is this here?
- 5:20Who installed this?
- 5:21And most importantly,
- 5:22is this still plugged in?
- 5:24And remember,
- 5:24before removing any piece of mysterious
- 5:26equipment from a university AV system,
- 5:27take a picture, label the cables,
- 5:29and wait at least ten minutes to see
- 5:30who comes running after you unplug that.
- 5:33And finally,
- 5:33while you're listening to this on YouTube,
- 5:34Spotify, Apple Podcasts,
- 5:36whatever other platform you're on,
- 5:37please rate and review.
- 5:39Your feedback helps us to grow and reach
- 5:40more listeners,
- 5:40whether they like it or not.
- 5:42So thanks again for your support.
- 5:43We couldn't do this without your help.
- 5:45It's working.
- 5:46What's so funny, Mark?
- 5:48Whether you like it or not, Justin,
- 5:50we've grown in our popularity due to some
- 5:54podcast polls.
- 5:55Yes.
- 5:56We saw metrics around us a couple weeks
- 5:57ago.
- 5:57Metrics that we're now in front of other
- 6:00people who seem to have larger podcasts.
- 6:03We are outliving the competition.
- 6:05That's right.
- 6:06I think that's what it is.
- 6:08Well,
- 6:08there is something to be said for
- 6:09consistency.
- 6:10It doesn't matter.
- 6:11We're taking our vitamins.
- 6:11Just take it.
- 6:12We're still here.
- 6:15So on today's show, Justin,
- 6:18you brought this to us.
- 6:18You said,
- 6:19I've got something I want to discuss.
- 6:21I've got this project coming up,
- 6:22and this is kind of what we have
- 6:23to do.
- 6:23How do we want to do this?
- 6:24And so we're going to determine the one
- 6:27true way this must be done forever and
- 6:30ever again.
- 6:31Amen.
- 6:31You know, we have to agree here.
- 6:34I'm going to pick a winner and go
- 6:37with it based upon this.
- 6:38That was directly for you, Joe.
- 6:41There's no winner.
- 6:42It's
- 6:44It's the one way.
- 6:45It's the one way.
- 6:46We're all going to agree.
- 6:47We never agree.
- 6:49Why would we do that?
- 6:50Well, that's what Chris just said.
- 6:51It's the only way.
- 6:52It's the best way.
- 6:53It's the only way.
- 6:54I would say the best way.
- 6:56It's the only way.
- 6:56Setting the background here, I've got...
- 7:00We've got a new CRNA program that's
- 7:02putting in a – All right, back up.
- 7:04Those are a lot of letters.
- 7:05Certified – what does that mean?
- 7:07I actually don't know.
- 7:08Why do we – It's something to do
- 7:09with nurses,
- 7:09but they're in high demand right now.
- 7:11Certified registered nursing –
- 7:12Certification for nursing –
- 7:16I don't know.
- 7:17Certified residential nursing assistant?
- 7:19I'm just making that up.
- 7:20That sounds good.
- 7:21Close enough.
- 7:24I have a feeling it has nothing to
- 7:25do with the actual topic,
- 7:26so let's continue on.
- 7:31I'm setting the background here.
- 7:35Leave a tapestry for me here.
- 7:37Can you take one step back and start
- 7:38with, so there I was.
- 7:41There I was.
- 7:41Waiting for that next project to hit,
- 7:42and it hit me.
- 7:46And so we meet with the client.
- 7:47They have a room going into Owensboro,
- 7:49Kentucky, which is about an hour away.
- 7:51They wanted to replicate the room that
- 7:54we're putting over at the medical center,
- 7:55which is down the road from us,
- 7:57which is part of our building.
- 7:58That's a different conversation.
- 8:00Anyways,
- 8:02the idea here is to do a sort
- 8:05of traditional Zoom-enabled type thing.
- 8:10classroom with online learning-ish kind of
- 8:13whatever.
- 8:14So here's the deal.
- 8:16That doesn't matter.
- 8:17What matters is we got a camera in
- 8:18the back that's going to track the
- 8:20instructor up in the front.
- 8:21We have a camera in the front that's
- 8:23going to sit still and do a wide
- 8:24shot of the audience.
- 8:26Here's the trick.
- 8:27And there's five different ways to do
- 8:29this.
- 8:31There's way more than five.
- 8:34Let's get to the...
- 8:34I've identified at least four.
- 8:37What's the needs analysis here, man?
- 8:38Just give us the details.
- 8:41If this was a successful endeavor,
- 8:43what would happen in here?
- 8:44Zoom's not the answer.
- 8:45Go on.
- 8:45no it doesn't matter if it's zoom or
- 8:46teams it is just bear with me because
- 8:50one of them sucks the whole thing is
- 8:54the instructors would like to bring in
- 8:57their laptops plug in usbc and get the
- 9:01same experience as if you were using the
- 9:04room pc
- 9:06So we're talking audio from the ceiling.
- 9:10Did you interpret that news analysis?
- 9:12Was that verbatim?
- 9:13I want to bring in my laptop and
- 9:14plug in this USB-C cable.
- 9:17Is that verbatim?
- 9:18That is the action they must have.
- 9:19That's where we got to.
- 9:21Instead of the perfectly good computer
- 9:23that's sitting there.
- 9:23We talked about...
- 9:27We discussed the operation of starting the
- 9:30room PC,
- 9:31joining the laptop with that same Zoomer
- 9:33Teams meeting.
- 9:34That's no-go.
- 9:36That's not happening.
- 9:38It's either or.
- 9:40And I need to kind of figure out
- 9:43what the best way to do this is.
- 9:44And there's the ecosystem way.
- 9:47We're not going to do that because you
- 9:48can go out and spend a crap ton
- 9:51of money on a single ecosystem and get
- 9:53to where we need to go.
- 9:55What we're looking for is standards-based
- 10:01common protocols.
- 10:03I don't care if that's NDI, SDI,
- 10:06how the control works.
- 10:07Why are you bringing the network in there?
- 10:11It doesn't matter to me.
- 10:13Ideally, you would have.
- 10:16Hold on.
- 10:17The goal is to get the same experience
- 10:18on the laptop as the PC.
- 10:20And some of the other questions are,
- 10:24How are the cameras switching?
- 10:26Is it manual?
- 10:27Is it through the web interface?
- 10:29Is it through the touch panel slash button
- 10:31panel?
- 10:31Is it automatic?
- 10:33And how does that exactly work?
- 10:35And we could talk specific product here.
- 10:38I don't know if the cameras matter a
- 10:39whole lot,
- 10:40but otherwise we're looking at standards
- 10:43based protocols, Larry.
- 10:46Did they give you a budget?
- 10:47Because that determines which one of the
- 10:50notable ways we go.
- 10:52By the way,
- 10:52on the budget thing real quick,
- 10:54one of the last projects I had before
- 10:55I left UW was, oh, no, no,
- 10:56don't worry about the budget.
- 10:57We have plenty.
- 10:58And then they didn't have plenty.
- 10:59They don't have plenty.
- 11:00Plenty is not a number.
- 11:01A thousand dollars would make this work.
- 11:03A thousand dollars is plenty.
- 11:04There's a number,
- 11:05and I went through all the scenarios
- 11:06except for the ecosystem scenario.
- 11:09Let's stay away from that.
- 11:10That is one option.
- 11:12I understand that.
- 11:13Well,
- 11:13just spec this one manufacturer for
- 11:15everything.
- 11:16We can get into that in a different
- 11:17way.
- 11:17Oh, you're a consultant.
- 11:19Exactly.
- 11:21So round robin here.
- 11:23I know there might be other questions.
- 11:24We don't want to get into the weeds
- 11:26on design and all this stuff.
- 11:29They've got a confidence monitor for the
- 11:31instructor,
- 11:32main single display for the students.
- 11:36And what I'm battling in my head is
- 11:37that same experience laptop computer in
- 11:42the room.
- 11:45In essence, it's not hard.
- 11:47These two things should be able to
- 11:48simultaneously call each other and
- 11:50simultaneously use the same equipment.
- 11:52No, no, no.
- 11:56You want the PC and the laptop
- 11:58simultaneously.
- 11:59to use all the same equipment,
- 12:00but it's almost simultaneous.
- 12:02There's not a switcher in there.
- 12:03I didn't say the same equipment.
- 12:04There can be.
- 12:05Why not?
- 12:05Why is there not a switcher in there?
- 12:07This is the topic.
- 12:09This is why we're doing this.
- 12:10Here we are.
- 12:11We've gotten to the problem space.
- 12:13Simultaneous.
- 12:14Why do you want that to happen?
- 12:17That's a singularity.
- 12:19One person at a time.
- 12:20You're going to end the universe there,
- 12:22Jamie.
- 12:22Let's merge this bastard and go.
- 12:24You map it out in your head, Jamie.
- 12:26There's no reason to do that.
- 12:28I've been doing this for years,
- 12:29so this is easy.
- 12:32So where is your concept of diving into
- 12:35this?
- 12:35What tools are you using to design this?
- 12:38Which way would you go?
- 12:40I wouldn't even be in design.
- 12:41I'm still parsing through the ask here.
- 12:44Don't worry about the ask, Mark.
- 12:48You've defined,
- 12:49I have this room that has a computer,
- 12:51but overwhelmingly all people want to come
- 12:53in and use their laptop.
- 12:55Both of those are not two realities that
- 12:57are the same thing.
- 12:58It's split fifty-fifty.
- 12:59Half the teachers want to use the
- 13:00computer,
- 13:00half the teachers have their laptop.
- 13:03It's a problem!
- 13:04I haven't identified an emerging use case
- 13:11that defines either one of those things as
- 13:13needing to be the hosting mechanism.
- 13:15Like,
- 13:16you haven't defined enough that wanting to
- 13:18use my laptop and inject this cable into
- 13:20it because I'm more comfortable with my
- 13:22thing is not a use case that says
- 13:24you must design around this.
- 13:25We're past that.
- 13:26Are you?
- 13:27I try.
- 13:27Should you be?
- 13:30That's not the conversation.
- 13:33So you're just going to accommodate shit
- 13:34you shouldn't accommodate?
- 13:34The task is what the task is right
- 13:36now.
- 13:37Which is?
- 13:40We went over this a few times.
- 13:42So, Justin,
- 13:43let me see if I can translate for
- 13:44you.
- 13:45What you're asking is fundamentally,
- 13:46regardless of who's teaching or what
- 13:48they're doing in the space,
- 13:49they want the same experience,
- 13:51same conferencing experience,
- 13:52whether they log into the installed
- 13:54computer or they bring their own device,
- 13:57bring their own meeting.
- 13:59Nearly the same exact setup process,
- 14:03which takes out what I wanted to do.
- 14:06start the meeting on the room PC,
- 14:08have any laptop join, blah, blah, blah.
- 14:11That's out.
- 14:11We're not doing that.
- 14:12I understand.
- 14:14Okay.
- 14:15Right.
- 14:15I get it.
- 14:17So this is why it's a challenge.
- 14:18We're trying to,
- 14:20we're trying to figure out one way to
- 14:22do this in both rooms.
- 14:24Teachers are going to be moving between
- 14:26cities teaching.
- 14:28So it needs to be while they're driving.
- 14:32No, they're going to be in the room.
- 14:35Take the system with them.
- 14:36Kentucky,
- 14:36I'm not sure what's happening over there.
- 14:39Focus on what we're trying to solve for.
- 14:41So going back to Jamie's comment,
- 14:42map out in your head how we're doing
- 14:45this.
- 14:45So if you're holding a gun to my
- 14:47head and saying, we have to do this,
- 14:48what you're telling me,
- 14:49we have to accommodate.
- 14:50This is the show.
- 14:51And we must accommodate full BYOM at the
- 14:55laptop level.
- 14:57And USB-C,
- 14:58just so we're all on the same page
- 15:00with.
- 15:00I just want to say.
- 15:02It needs to charge.
- 15:04Yeah.
- 15:04Okay.
- 15:05Yeah.
- 15:06It needs to have Ethernet.
- 15:07Yeah.
- 15:08Okay.
- 15:08It needs to do the camera ingest.
- 15:12Time.
- 15:12And it needs to do the microphone ingest.
- 15:14You can't call time.
- 15:17I'll stop the clock.
- 15:18Hold on.
- 15:19Larry, we're past the line.
- 15:21I know.
- 15:21I wonder why it has to have Ethernet.
- 15:23Don't you have wireless for the laptop?
- 15:26Fine.
- 15:26Forget Ethernet.
- 15:27Okay, great.
- 15:28Now I'm back on board.
- 15:29We can do this.
- 15:32Well, the Ethernet thing, actually,
- 15:33that struck me too.
- 15:33I don't know if the solution I was
- 15:34thinking of actually does that,
- 15:35so I'm checking.
- 15:37Mine doesn't.
- 15:38The one solution in my head was the
- 15:40docking station,
- 15:40which makes Ethernet easy.
- 15:41That's one solution.
- 15:44Okay, I get it.
- 15:46We'll shovel that over here.
- 15:47What's next?
- 15:50What is, Jamie,
- 15:51going back to what you were originally
- 15:53saying until you were rudely interrupted.
- 15:54Yeah, I've been doing this for years.
- 15:58Several different versions of it, right?
- 16:00This exact thing.
- 16:02And so usually it's like,
- 16:04so there's a DSP there, right?
- 16:06It has the USB to the local computer.
- 16:08Then I use NDI for all the cameras.
- 16:10So it has a little NDI to USB
- 16:12widget factory that switches.
- 16:15So where are you doing your switching at?
- 16:18Where would the user be doing the camera
- 16:20switch?
- 16:22Well, there's either a touch panel.
- 16:24Okay, so you're not doing it through Zoom.
- 16:27You're doing it through a touch panel,
- 16:28so it's switching the cameras over some
- 16:31API through NDI widget.
- 16:34Right,
- 16:34because we're not using Zoom Rooms in most
- 16:37of those places.
- 16:37It's just regular old, plain old Zoom.
- 16:40This was one of the options that was
- 16:41on my plate to try.
- 16:43So you're saying you don't ever offer
- 16:45application-level switching of cameras in
- 16:47your scenario, Jamie?
- 16:49Most of the time, no.
- 16:52Because normally when we get in this
- 16:55situation,
- 16:58there's some struggle bus about going,
- 17:00and especially with NDI,
- 17:02there's some struggle bus about going down
- 17:03to the camera icon and switching the
- 17:06camera,
- 17:07where if they just touch the touch panel,
- 17:08it says, see me, see them.
- 17:10They're just, it's just easier for,
- 17:12I also have physical buttons.
- 17:13Remember I put arcade buttons on my thing
- 17:15and they just hit there.
- 17:16Yeah.
- 17:16Where are you bringing in your Dante audio
- 17:19for microphones?
- 17:20What are you doing for that?
- 17:21Into the DSP.
- 17:23That's connected to the PC.
- 17:26With over USB, right?
- 17:27Where's the laptop?
- 17:30The laptop connection,
- 17:31there is a dock for the laptop.
- 17:33And it has another, it can either take,
- 17:37if I use like,
- 17:38I've done several different ways.
- 17:39I have another NDI widget that's pulling,
- 17:41because you can plug analog audio right
- 17:44into that thing.
- 17:45You do an analog from DSP into the
- 17:51NDI USB.
- 17:54I've also used the Biamp product,
- 17:56and I like to put in the UBTs
- 17:57because you can name them.
- 18:00So I would take the computer,
- 18:02the USB out of the bi-amp directly to
- 18:05the room PC because I control that.
- 18:08Take the UBT that I can name and
- 18:10make it available to the laptop and then
- 18:13get the video.
- 18:15to go that way.
- 18:16Jamie explain is like my option for right
- 18:19now.
- 18:20I wouldn't do any of that.
- 18:21I'd buy two of those.
- 18:22I, you know, genie, you know, genies,
- 18:24which is something I want to be done.
- 18:27What do you mean be done?
- 18:28Explain it.
- 18:28What do you mean?
- 18:29One goes to the PC cause it rips
- 18:31the Dante audio off the processor.
- 18:33It rips the NDI off the network.
- 18:35And then the other one can go into
- 18:37a doc or something,
- 18:39some kind of little connector deal to,
- 18:41The power is what makes the dock.
- 18:44Are you still running your USB from the
- 18:47DSP directly to the computer?
- 18:50No, at that point,
- 18:51I would do two InnoGenies.
- 18:53That's twelve hundred bucks.
- 18:54How much power does it provide?
- 19:00The power is the problem, right?
- 19:02So with the power,
- 19:03you almost have to have a dock.
- 19:04You've got to have an injector.
- 19:05I have the power figured out.
- 19:06You have to have the power.
- 19:08Injector.
- 19:09For me,
- 19:10and I've used this product in a very
- 19:12similar scenario,
- 19:13the DTP cross point four two.
- 19:15Oh fuck.
- 19:17I'm saying it works.
- 19:19It allows me to provide the laptop with
- 19:21a hundred Watts and all the devices over
- 19:24USB.
- 19:25And then I can't do them both at
- 19:26the same time,
- 19:27but I can switch it and it works.
- 19:29A four by two?
- 19:31It is a four by two that does
- 19:33switch USB reliably.
- 19:35Larry, what are you,
- 19:36what are you using for switching cameras?
- 19:38For the cameras,
- 19:39I would probably do the Energini or the
- 19:41Magewell.
- 19:42You still have to have the widget.
- 19:47Right,
- 19:47but someone still has to go to Zoomer
- 19:48Teams and switch the camera, right?
- 19:50No, you can control those,
- 19:53or you can do the Energini.
- 19:54Okay,
- 19:54you're driving through the control system
- 19:56then.
- 19:57Yeah.
- 19:57I usually try to control that through the
- 19:58control system,
- 19:59because then if I want to use
- 20:01sound-triggered controls, I can.
- 20:04If I want to use... It's just...
- 20:06again we have this thing where people
- 20:08don't like to go down to the zoom
- 20:09camera thing and switch cameras they would
- 20:11rather just touch the interesting again
- 20:14we've been building them like this for
- 20:15years so they're more accustomed to
- 20:17reaching up and going look at me look
- 20:19at them and that's literally what it says
- 20:21look at me look at them no i
- 20:23like i like front camera rear camera they
- 20:24have to think wait is that the camera
- 20:26right yeah you have no idea then they
- 20:27have to think so i say see me
- 20:29see them mark
- 20:32mark don't i hate i hate all of
- 20:34you into this bucket i want to just
- 20:36go on the record and say no off
- 20:38the bat no pick one together but you
- 20:40were forced i would dabble down the road
- 20:43of probably doing um something along the
- 20:46line of like the new visionary stuff
- 20:48one dedicated to the PC,
- 20:49one dedicated for laptop,
- 20:50my USB-C for both of those things,
- 20:52bring those pieces in, ingest them,
- 20:54and switch them to Ravion VIP.
- 20:55That way would probably be the way I
- 20:57would set down.
- 20:58I don't know if it's a hundred percent
- 20:59accurate and going to get me there,
- 21:01but I would keep everything in the USB
- 21:02two point O domain,
- 21:03which it rules out all three point O
- 21:04cameras.
- 21:05I'm not going to be any three point
- 21:06O cameras.
- 21:07And so I'm going to drive some of
- 21:08that that way.
- 21:09But I would elegantly try to solve it
- 21:12with those types of tools that allows me
- 21:14to virtually switch those pieces to bring
- 21:17them into each one of those encode
- 21:18decodes.
- 21:19Similar to Larry,
- 21:20you're not going to get both, right?
- 21:21You're going to have one or the other
- 21:22into that domain.
- 21:24I'm not asking for both to work at
- 21:25the same time.
- 21:25Programmatically,
- 21:26that's going to be in my common room
- 21:27controls.
- 21:27When I select that mode,
- 21:29if I'm an installed PC or laptop,
- 21:31that whole infrastructure is going to
- 21:33swing and only be available with that
- 21:34thing at that moment.
- 21:36So what's your camera transport?
- 21:38And don't say USB extension.
- 21:39No.
- 21:42No one does that.
- 21:43No,
- 21:43I could probably stomach using typical SDI
- 21:48still.
- 21:49I'm coming back to us.
- 21:49You're still on SDI and then you're going.
- 21:52I would dabble in NDI world.
- 21:55Mark, in the same visionary ecosystem,
- 21:56you could drop it into an encoder or
- 21:58a decoder.
- 21:59Yes, you could ingest it right there,
- 22:01but you'd have to make sure you're
- 22:02ingesting the two point O and not letting
- 22:04the camera get into.
- 22:04No, it's only two.
- 22:05Are you saying put a AV over a
- 22:07P endpoint at each camera?
- 22:09Potentially, if you want.
- 22:10Potentially.
- 22:10You don't have to.
- 22:11You don't have to.
- 22:11You just got to get that USB into
- 22:13wherever your decode may be.
- 22:14You said you already have a confidence
- 22:15monitor.
- 22:15So I'm going to say that's at the
- 22:17back camera location.
- 22:19I could just piggyback off that one.
- 22:20It's there.
- 22:21And so it's back there.
- 22:22That's how it works.
- 22:23Yes.
- 22:24No, you hang it mid-room, Chris.
- 22:25No, no.
- 22:27I mean, that's where the computer is.
- 22:29Visionary was option two to handle that
- 22:31backbone and do it all over.
- 22:33I like what I'm seeing.
- 22:34Like, I can pull enough out of that,
- 22:35like,
- 22:36kit there to build that out um in
- 22:39like on paper it's penciling out for me
- 22:41correct i mean we have to make sure
- 22:43all the legos are the right format here
- 22:46but it's that's where i'm leaning towards
- 22:48this and using that mechanism if i had
- 22:50to do this which i don't
- 22:52But if I had to... And wouldn't.
- 22:54Yes.
- 22:55This is why we're talking about it.
- 22:57But this is why it sucks that we
- 22:58can't get some of these softwares into an
- 23:03enterprise-ready computer environment.
- 23:06Because if you can have the NDI or
- 23:09pick-your-flavor
- 23:11virtual driver,
- 23:12and you can have the Dante virtual driver
- 23:14right there on all the computers.
- 23:15We're not talking about any of this crap.
- 23:17It's just booked in.
- 23:18I would probably opt, honestly,
- 23:20to be in a room scenario where I
- 23:21would probably want this to land if I
- 23:23had to pick one.
- 23:25I know.
- 23:26I'll put an installed computer in that
- 23:27room scenario.
- 23:28I don't care.
- 23:29If you really want to have an installed
- 23:30computer, you could still do that.
- 23:32Another thought that I haven't gone down
- 23:34is the research of does it make sense
- 23:37to do Dante audio and video here?
- 23:41still you're on a private island no i
- 23:43i didn't even do that no i i
- 23:45think like the turtle av products you
- 23:47could do to do that dante av all
- 23:49the way around i think you're in yeah
- 23:51you're still in that i can do all
- 23:52that through that was another option i had
- 23:55to do this we're on five options already
- 23:57you can also because you could run it
- 23:59right off the dante av enabled cameras
- 24:01already
- 24:02And that's still when you're in
- 24:03e-connection if I can send Dante audio and
- 24:06video.
- 24:07Correct.
- 24:08I just haven't done it yet.
- 24:11I don't have enough familiarity with Dante
- 24:13AV to know.
- 24:14So, Justin,
- 24:15you can always take whatever camera you're
- 24:16using and inject audio at the camera,
- 24:17and then you have a single stream with
- 24:18audio and video on it.
- 24:19So that's an option, too.
- 24:20Yeah.
- 24:21I like to expose everything as one-stop
- 24:22shop the best I can.
- 24:24I don't want people, oh, well,
- 24:24you've got to choose this for your in
- 24:26and this for your out, and blah, blah,
- 24:27blah.
- 24:28Agreed.
- 24:28One device.
- 24:29Yeah, it's got to be one identity.
- 24:31I want it named.
- 24:32I want it to look at the thing
- 24:33and go, oh, it says room twelve audio,
- 24:37room twelve video.
- 24:38I'm in.
- 24:39Let's go.
- 24:41That's why I don't switch at Zoom.
- 24:43Justin,
- 24:43question for you on a bit of
- 24:45clarification.
- 24:48Was there one display in this room or
- 24:49you had two displays?
- 24:50Two.
- 24:51One for confidence, one for primary.
- 24:54No, but it's a single output.
- 24:57Oh, you're not dual display.
- 24:59You have one at the back of the
- 25:00room, one at the front of the room.
- 25:01Correct.
- 25:03Those images will be identical always.
- 25:05Right.
- 25:05Because that's what changed some of the
- 25:07structure forming.
- 25:08Now, unless the user decides to extend,
- 25:11then that's on them.
- 25:13Should they be identical?
- 25:16It can work because you have...
- 25:17I like people on one and content on
- 25:19the other, but that's just me.
- 25:20You can extend it and do that,
- 25:21and that's part of the training.
- 25:23So you can have your laptop as...
- 25:25But not all laptop input devices will do
- 25:29that.
- 25:30Correct.
- 25:31It starts to get brittle when you start
- 25:32getting... Correct.
- 25:32Anyway...
- 25:34So that does add a bit of a
- 25:35wrinkle,
- 25:35but I'm pretty sure I can still do
- 25:38this one hundred percent off the network,
- 25:40not with network.
- 25:41I'm going to do it all baseband HD
- 25:43based because fight me.
- 25:45You're going to do base.
- 25:46Oh, I haven't.
- 25:47I was too.
- 25:48All right.
- 25:49Larry was close,
- 25:50but I'm going to go wrong.
- 25:52I'm going to go one step below that.
- 25:54Oh, this is where we like it.
- 25:56One step below.
- 25:58I'm going,
- 25:59and I'm going to do this for nine
- 26:00hundred bucks.
- 26:02Okay.
- 26:02Okay.
- 26:02Survey says?
- 26:04Liberty, Hunk, Liberty, Huck,
- 26:08Huck forty-two.
- 26:10I can see it.
- 26:11Okay.
- 26:11This is a,
- 26:12if you've not looked at this,
- 26:13and for anyone out there listening,
- 26:14get a hold of two of these.
- 26:15They're,
- 26:15they're four hundred fifty bucks a piece,
- 26:16transmitter, receiver.
- 26:17It's a pair.
- 26:18It is USB, or it's a, um, uh,
- 26:20HDBase between them.
- 26:21One box at your table, one box,
- 26:23it's designed for conference rooms,
- 26:24one box at the display.
- 26:25The PC is at the front of the
- 26:27room display, wherever it is,
- 26:29where God intended it to be.
- 26:30There's dual inputs.
- 26:31You can run dual outputs if you'd like
- 26:32to.
- 26:33Now,
- 26:33if you're going to extend a second loop,
- 26:36and I've done this,
- 26:37you put a cheap EHD-based T-extender on
- 26:39the second display and fire that to the
- 26:40other end of the room.
- 26:41Everybody's happy.
- 26:43It has USB ingest for any device.
- 26:46device you want.
- 26:47Whatever cameras you're using,
- 26:48whatever mics you're using,
- 26:49I'm just going to say, I don't care.
- 26:50You pick.
- 26:51Get it to USB,
- 26:52because it has to end up in the
- 26:53computer anyway.
- 26:54So regardless of what you're doing,
- 26:55you're doing that,
- 26:55because like Jamie said,
- 26:56you can't run the application level things
- 26:57for these.
- 26:58So at some point,
- 26:59you're converting those devices back to
- 27:01USB.
- 27:01Plug that into the HUC-Forty-Two set.
- 27:04It now exposes that to the laptop on
- 27:07the other end, and the laptop,
- 27:08you get a bonus on this one for
- 27:09you.
- 27:10USB-C for the laptop with sixty watt
- 27:12charging.
- 27:12Not ideal, but it gets the job done.
- 27:15plus HDMI and USB for old-school laptops,
- 27:18and it auto-switches,
- 27:20no control system needed.
- 27:22It auto-switches reliably between the
- 27:24computer and both laptops,
- 27:26so you get three device inputs on this,
- 27:28two laptops, one computer,
- 27:31and it switches all those USB devices
- 27:33super clean.
- 27:35That was one of the options that was,
- 27:37I don't know, remember what number,
- 27:38but I just didn't classify that as
- 27:40HD-based T, even though it is.
- 27:41That's what it is.
- 27:42Liberty widgetry kind of option.
- 27:46So at a former institution,
- 27:47and they will soon to be appearing here,
- 27:49I've deployed probably twenty of those.
- 27:51And you're switching cameras with it.
- 27:55It's kind of that HD-based T mixed with
- 27:59a dock.
- 27:59So here's the camera switching thing.
- 28:01I can do it two ways.
- 28:02There are three ways I can switch.
- 28:05One is four ways, three ways, four,
- 28:08whatever, multiple ways.
- 28:09One,
- 28:09I do Jamie's favorite method of tell them
- 28:11to go down and click the button in
- 28:12the application.
- 28:13That's free,
- 28:14and most people understand that,
- 28:15except apparently if you live in Missouri,
- 28:17which pointed anathema to them.
- 28:18Anyway, if you're not good with that,
- 28:20okay.
- 28:20It's mouse hunting.
- 28:21Nobody wants to mouse hunt.
- 28:22Eh, that's up to them.
- 28:23It's their device.
- 28:24Hey, they're bringing their device.
- 28:25They can use their freaking mouse, so...
- 28:28If they're not comfortable with that and
- 28:29they want some sort of physical input,
- 28:31the HUC-A-D has the ability to have a
- 28:33local touch panel running on it,
- 28:35and it's basically a TCP IP socket,
- 28:37so you can run it on almost anything.
- 28:39So it's kind of an interesting way to
- 28:40play it there.
- 28:41It does have IP and two-thirty-two control
- 28:44of the switchers.
- 28:45If you wanted to do that to actually
- 28:46switch.
- 28:46I was going to say I can control
- 28:47that with Crestron or Q-SYS.
- 28:48Correct.
- 28:49Yes.
- 28:49Correct.
- 28:50Or you use one of those outboard devices
- 28:53to do some automatic switching.
- 28:54So depending on, say,
- 28:55the microphone you're using,
- 28:56if it can get positional activity or
- 28:57presets or whatever.
- 28:58So maybe like one of those Nureva bars
- 29:00or something like that with a little Ino
- 29:01Genie magic switcher sort of dealie.
- 29:03So if you want to add some widgetry
- 29:05on top of that,
- 29:05then you could have an auto switch based
- 29:07on that.
- 29:08Nureva, Nureva, Nureva.
- 29:09You know what all this sounds like,
- 29:10Justin?
- 29:11It's out of the budget of your... Yeah,
- 29:14what is your budget?
- 29:14This all feels like it's out of the
- 29:15domain of possibility.
- 29:16Because mine was nine hundred bucks.
- 29:17Not this one.
- 29:19This one has a budget.
- 29:20I don't know what it is,
- 29:22but it was adequate.
- 29:23It was adequate for all four or five
- 29:25options.
- 29:25Of these philosophical approaches we've
- 29:28given you,
- 29:29Which one would fit your current support
- 29:32structure?
- 29:33Well, so that's a good question.
- 29:36I like the visionary option,
- 29:38but we don't use visionary currently.
- 29:41We do now.
- 29:41That's not a huge deal.
- 29:44I don't know.
- 29:45Maybe it is.
- 29:48I also like the Inogeny method with NDI.
- 29:52That's the one I would want to have
- 29:55the toys to play with.
- 29:56Mark,
- 29:57you're saying you want that one to be
- 29:58used.
- 29:58I want that one,
- 29:59but I feel like I'm leaning towards the...
- 30:02I mentioned it.
- 30:04Yes, because I'm in the same.
- 30:05I mentioned it because in my brain,
- 30:07it's the way it works.
- 30:08But I haven't done it yet.
- 30:11And COVID does have that really good power
- 30:12injector.
- 30:13So in theory, you could hook that up
- 30:15to the power injector and still get power.
- 30:17That's a good point.
- 30:18That's how I would do it.
- 30:19I would pass that right through and just
- 30:21inject it right there.
- 30:23This is why we have these shows, Larry.
- 30:26Is it why we have these shows?
- 30:27I'm not sure.
- 30:29All's we've really told everybody is none
- 30:31of us agree on any of this.
- 30:32There's a hundred ways to do it.
- 30:33This is the standard.
- 30:34We're not winning here until we're done.
- 30:37Justin said he was going to pick a
- 30:39winner.
- 30:40Less money, less boxes.
- 30:42Figure it out.
- 30:43that's the problem I got.
- 30:47So I'm designing a different room right
- 30:50now for a couple other campuses.
- 30:52And this is going to start
- 30:54My design process is going to start in
- 30:56a couple of weeks.
- 30:57So I still have time to think about
- 30:59my approach before I start sketching crap
- 31:02out on paper.
- 31:03I think what really it's like if mine
- 31:05is my solution is a bolt on to
- 31:08what an already complete system is anyway.
- 31:11Right.
- 31:11So it makes a little bit easier.
- 31:12But if you weren't going to do a
- 31:13full size DSP,
- 31:13if you're not going to do a full
- 31:15video switching rig.
- 31:16We're probably going to do a.
- 31:17right probably going to do it like eight
- 31:19in each room yeah and then it makes
- 31:21more sense to do it some other way
- 31:23right because mine is like well this is
- 31:24my standard kit and this is a twelve
- 31:26hundred dollar bolt-on and i've done it
- 31:29i've i've created i've solved your problem
- 31:31but it was twenty four thousand dollars of
- 31:32the rest that you have to have in
- 31:33place kansas city money i told you
- 31:37Well, Jamie, you're not wrong.
- 31:38You could very quickly stay.
- 31:40I'm going to stay within my comfort zone
- 31:42ecosystem.
- 31:43Right.
- 31:43And suddenly end up with a fifty thousand
- 31:45dollar conference room.
- 31:46Let me tell you what the budget is.
- 31:47Yeah.
- 31:47And that's why, again,
- 31:49my nine hundred bucks is going to say
- 31:52as least as possible.
- 31:54I'm like three times.
- 31:57No, this is one of those new programs.
- 31:58They're wanting to do things right.
- 32:00You know, nine hundred bucks.
- 32:02But all of this,
- 32:04it's just that one piece, though, sir.
- 32:06It is irritating as shit.
- 32:08You still have to buy the display and
- 32:09cameras regardless.
- 32:10Correct.
- 32:10I think we're going to carry all those
- 32:12costs together no matter what solution
- 32:13we're going to have.
- 32:15Just use the software, damn it.
- 32:18All you software people, figure it out.
- 32:21Just set all the PCs to run admin
- 32:23all the time in the DMZ and so
- 32:26many problems are solved.
- 32:27Why is this so difficult to find?
- 32:28Why is this a problem?
- 32:29The
- 32:32Jamie,
- 32:33keep in mind that the software solution
- 32:36raises a wrinkle here for the BYOD or
- 32:38BYOM scenario.
- 32:40Because step one for all these users is,
- 32:42oh, go install NDI Director.
- 32:44I have about.
- 32:46I know.
- 32:46It's not.
- 32:47Sixty-six to seventy thousand dollars for
- 32:50both rooms.
- 32:51Nine.
- 32:52Oh.
- 32:52Not a problem.
- 32:53You're good.
- 32:54You're golden.
- 32:55Pick one.
- 32:55Told you.
- 32:56I mean, like,
- 32:56the budget's not the problem.
- 32:58I mean,
- 32:58Larry's throwing top dollar at you.
- 33:00I'm not throwing top dollar.
- 33:02I don't want to make it complex.
- 33:03It needs to be easily supportable.
- 33:05It needs to have standards-based
- 33:07transport.
- 33:08There is nothing about this that's not
- 33:09complex.
- 33:11When you're in this domain,
- 33:12you're doing the best of all these
- 33:14scenarios.
- 33:15It's not complex to the end user.
- 33:16It's going to be what it is.
- 33:20The end user and the teachers,
- 33:21it just needs to fucking work.
- 33:24Can I interest you in USB extenders?
- 33:26No.
- 33:28The magic ones.
- 33:31Justin,
- 33:31what's the rest of the room look like?
- 33:32Is it a... The rooms are different shapes.
- 33:35It's not a conference...
- 33:36I was going to say,
- 33:37is it a conference room?
- 33:38The room in Owensboro was set up like
- 33:40the traditional two monitors in the back,
- 33:43two monitors in the front, you know,
- 33:44the room-to-room conferencing.
- 33:46Is it traditional?
- 33:47Two in the back, two in the front?
- 33:49Yeah, the H-三二三 people post content crap.
- 33:50Yeah, and all the tech's been stripped,
- 33:52all the rough ends and electrical's still
- 33:54there, so that's, like,
- 33:56perfect to do whatever I need to.
- 33:58The other room at our medical center
- 34:00complex is not great for this.
- 34:05I'll trust that.
- 34:05Cobble it.
- 34:07But it's a long bowling alley.
- 34:09Lean into the mic, Cam.
- 34:10Lean into the mic.
- 34:11Cam, get up on that mic.
- 34:13That is going to be turned into like
- 34:14a classroom style with new furniture.
- 34:16So that's more of an overall.
- 34:17But you said it's a long bowling alley.
- 34:19How are they going to do a classroom?
- 34:21One row of long walls.
- 34:23One row of desks all the way back.
- 34:24Well,
- 34:24I'm going to have to use one of
- 34:25the long walls and turn it sideways.
- 34:28And so the students are going to be
- 34:31really wide.
- 34:31But they're really wide.
- 34:33you know, wide seating, but gross or,
- 34:37or rose deep, maybe.
- 34:38So that's kind of what it is.
- 34:40I don't know.
- 34:43So that sounds terrible.
- 34:44Don't teach in that room.
- 34:46We've got to the bottom of it.
- 34:47I mean, nothing else.
- 34:48We all agreed.
- 34:49So you guys,
- 34:50so we're always two monitors everywhere.
- 34:53Us?
- 34:54Two monitors all over the place.
- 34:55No, we don't.
- 34:57Every way you look.
- 34:57Displays in the room or monitors on the
- 34:59desktop?
- 34:59What are we talking about?
- 35:00All the above.
- 35:02Like your confidence monitors,
- 35:03you only do one?
- 35:04You don't do two?
- 35:05Yeah,
- 35:05because you're only getting one feed out
- 35:07anyway.
- 35:08Yeah.
- 35:08Are you doing dual connection from your
- 35:09computer all the time?
- 35:10No, no, no.
- 35:11I mean, I get what Jamie's saying.
- 35:13I get dual all the time.
- 35:14If you have two displays in the front
- 35:15of your room,
- 35:16I always have two displays on the right.
- 35:17That barbecue dollar's again hard at work.
- 35:19So even if it's a single projector up
- 35:21front...
- 35:23I always have the dual displays at the
- 35:25desk.
- 35:25So there's dual displays as a confidence.
- 35:27I thought you meant one display in front
- 35:28of the room and two at the back.
- 35:30That is just crazy town Missouri Jamie
- 35:32stuff.
- 35:32I would agree with Justin completely on
- 35:34this.
- 35:35This way you can have the gallery on
- 35:36one.
- 35:37You can power play that with one monitor
- 35:39on extended, Jamie.
- 35:41PowerPoint loves to take over your full
- 35:44screen.
- 35:44It doesn't like to run in a window.
- 35:46So when you share it,
- 35:46it takes over the whole screen.
- 35:48So now to go change anything with Zoom
- 35:50or see the gallery,
- 35:50you've got to switch views.
- 35:53Are you asking just because?
- 35:56Are your local monitors direct connected
- 35:58or tell me they're hooked to a decoder?
- 36:02No, they're not hooked to the decoder.
- 36:03Why would you do that?
- 36:05I thought you were into some elaborate
- 36:07matrixing going on for that.
- 36:08No, no, no.
- 36:09Matrixing still... It's left-right.
- 36:10Wherever you look, it's left-right.
- 36:12He only has one encoder at the lectern,
- 36:13but in front of it is a sixty-four
- 36:15by sixty-four matrix.
- 36:17What's your video card in these computers?
- 36:20Whatever comes with it.
- 36:21You only need two outputs.
- 36:23What else do you need?
- 36:24You only need one output.
- 36:25No, no, no.
- 36:27You just conflicted.
- 36:29Based on what you said, Larry, thank you.
- 36:31You need four outputs.
- 36:34Larry does math.
- 36:36If you have a four-by-four switcher in
- 36:38there or you have...
- 36:39What the hell's going on now?
- 36:41If you have the visionaries where you get
- 36:43three in, two out, now you're done.
- 36:46That's only one stream on the outside,
- 36:48though.
- 36:49Okay.
- 36:50So you have two of them.
- 36:53It's still cheaper than Larry's.
- 36:55It's still cheaper than Larry's.
- 36:56Oh, it is.
- 36:57How much is that thing?
- 37:00How much is that thing?
- 37:02I get it for about thirty five.
- 37:03Great.
- 37:04I just spent twenty six hundred dollars
- 37:07and I got all of it.
- 37:09With a lot more complexity.
- 37:11No way.
- 37:11It's network cable.
- 37:12You plug in a PoE network cable.
- 37:14From an instructional standpoint,
- 37:16what happens if I don't want my students
- 37:18to see my notes on the back screen?
- 37:22What?
- 37:22Those are secrets.
- 37:24What are you hiding?
- 37:26I'm not hiding anything.
- 37:28I'm just saying my solution gives the
- 37:30instructor the choice.
- 37:31Yours doesn't.
- 37:32Yeah, it does.
- 37:33It says show left, show right.
- 37:35A minute ago, it was show me,
- 37:37show them.
- 37:39That's the camera.
- 37:40But on the back,
- 37:41so you can show left, show right.
- 37:43What do you mean show buttons you got
- 37:45on your touch panels?
- 37:46What's going on here?
- 37:47Oh,
- 37:47you should see the one that says show
- 37:48this.
- 37:51I'll show you.
- 37:53Please tell me you have a way to
- 37:56do this with two arcade buttons,
- 37:57depending on how quickly they click.
- 37:59Actually, you can.
- 38:01Left, left, right, right, left, left, up,
- 38:03right, left, right, up, damn it.
- 38:05Do I?
- 38:06Yeah, can you do the up, up, down,
- 38:07down, left, right, left, right, B, A,
- 38:08select, start?
- 38:09You know, if you walk through Jamie's...
- 38:12If it's drawn out,
- 38:13you guys will look at it and go,
- 38:14oh, that makes sense.
- 38:15It probably sounds like an arcade and
- 38:18everybody's playing Pac-Man.
- 38:20I've been inspired by my trip to Vegas
- 38:23over the summer and then all of the
- 38:25ads on the streaming services now for
- 38:27those games.
- 38:28So from now on out,
- 38:30it's going to have fast-moving graphics
- 38:33with loud chimes and dings and rings,
- 38:35and it's going to just randomly say,
- 38:37you won!
- 38:38Mm-hmm.
- 38:40Apparently that's what people want.
- 38:41So I'm in.
- 38:42You want to be winners.
- 38:42You're not wrong.
- 38:44I'm in.
- 38:45Whack-a-mole's done.
- 38:47We're not doing whack-a-mole anymore.
- 38:48We're doing casino level room.
- 38:50Tall screens with buttons.
- 38:53Right.
- 38:53Mortal Kombat.
- 38:54And it's just got a flash pictures.
- 38:56You don't know what they mean.
- 38:58It just tells you if you lose or
- 38:59win.
- 38:59Oh, sorry.
- 39:00You lose.
- 39:02Digital signage things.
- 39:03You can have those throughout.
- 39:05No, I want that personally.
- 39:06I don't need that in the classroom.
- 39:07I want to get back to real conversation.
- 39:09Yeah, who's the winner?
- 39:10Yeah, we're going to get here.
- 39:14I think it's a tie.
- 39:15I think it's a tie.
- 39:16I think it's soccer.
- 39:19Justin,
- 39:19you said you had sixty thousand dollars
- 39:20for this?
- 39:21For two rooms.
- 39:22For two rooms.
- 39:23Thirty grand each?
- 39:24He's good.
- 39:25Thirty-thirty, thirty-thirty-five each.
- 39:29That's just AD.
- 39:30He'll have no displays to show.
- 39:31Doesn't matter, right?
- 39:33You could buy that many of your solutions,
- 39:35Chris, and in two years,
- 39:37you'd have to replace them all.
- 39:38I'm leaning towards either visionary or
- 39:42InnoGenie methods with some NDI mixed in.
- 39:47You just made up your own thing.
- 39:50InnoGenie, it's NDI.
- 39:52Yeah, it's NDI.
- 39:52I don't know if I want to try
- 39:53the Dante video audio thing yet.
- 39:56Oh, I'm really intrigued.
- 39:58Maybe you think I should try it and
- 40:00just see what happens?
- 40:01You should.
- 40:01Yes.
- 40:01At the wiener?
- 40:03You try it.
- 40:05I'm really intrigued.
- 40:06Really?
- 40:07I am.
- 40:08Okay.
- 40:10Well, maybe.
- 40:11Okay.
- 40:11Here's what I'm going to do.
- 40:12Do both.
- 40:13So this is going to.
- 40:14Couple it for the win.
- 40:16No, couple it's not going to win.
- 40:17So I think I might.
- 40:20Damn it.
- 40:21I think I might try to design this
- 40:22with.
- 40:24You put it together,
- 40:25and next week I want you to come
- 40:26back and give me the side-by-side dollar
- 40:27comparison.
- 40:28I'm not doing it next week.
- 40:29You're going to do the homework right now.
- 40:32Actually, the next on topic is two weeks.
- 40:35You've got two weeks.
- 40:37The rough commit.
- 40:39Just has to be a ROM, Justin, yeah.
- 40:42Just a wag.
- 40:45Okay,
- 40:46I might be able to squeeze that in.
- 40:47That was sooner than expected.
- 40:48Then we can do a follow-up on this
- 40:50and see what happens.
- 40:52You could paper draw this out and know
- 40:53what the pricing is.
- 40:55I'm more interested in when you get the
- 40:56test kit because you've got to know it
- 40:59works.
- 41:00You can't take my word for it.
- 41:02I do some wacky shit.
- 41:04Put that on a network island.
- 41:05Guarantee it works because it doesn't
- 41:06matter.
- 41:08Okay.
- 41:08If the specs say what they say,
- 41:11I'd roll with it, man.
- 41:12It's fine.
- 41:13I am thinking like a consultant.
- 41:15Yeah.
- 41:15I have made that mistake.
- 41:16We're going to cowboy this stuff.
- 41:17Okay.
- 41:18Specs say it does it.
- 41:19Yeah, it should be fine.
- 41:21Put eighty of them in your new nursing
- 41:23building.
- 41:23I called them and asked them,
- 41:24does this do this?
- 41:25They said yes, so I bought a hundred.
- 41:26No, that's different.
- 41:27No, you specced a hundred.
- 41:29That's different.
- 41:30You don't call salespeople and they'll
- 41:32always say yes.
- 41:32That's the problem.
- 41:35You're a money in my account, sir.
- 41:37It sure does.
- 41:38All right.
- 41:38So are we,
- 41:39are we at a point where you're,
- 41:40you're comfortable moving forward with
- 41:41some solution that was,
- 41:42I'm going to try to experiment with a
- 41:45Dante.
- 41:45I don't know.
- 41:46I don't know if I like it yet
- 41:47or not, but it'll probably end up being,
- 41:50if I were to guess based upon the
- 41:53homework and exercises I'm going to do,
- 41:55I'm,
- 41:56No,
- 41:57you move forward based on what you learned
- 41:58here today, sir.
- 41:59What your homework is irrelevant to this
- 42:01conversation.
- 42:01You got to make a choice after right
- 42:02now.
- 42:03You all were supposed to sell me on
- 42:04this shit.
- 42:04You did a terrible job.
- 42:05Nine hundred dollars.
- 42:07They all work.
- 42:08It's just whichever one you want to do.
- 42:11Exactly.
- 42:12What are you going to have to live
- 42:13with?
- 42:14Mine's not on the network.
- 42:16Guaranteed reliability.
- 42:19Is it?
- 42:20Mine works all the time.
- 42:21That USB option is not on the network
- 42:23either.
- 42:24I wouldn't go as far as guaranteed
- 42:25reliability.
- 42:26I work on network islands here,
- 42:28so anything on the network is on our
- 42:30network.
- 42:30All right, let me rephrase.
- 42:32Mine doesn't involve networking.
- 42:34In that case, visionary all day,
- 42:36multicast the shit out of it.
- 42:39Visionary versus the NDI energy?
- 42:41Well, if it's on the regular network,
- 42:43let's get after it.
- 42:46What do you mean regular network?
- 42:48Enterprise.
- 42:50The big network.
- 42:51Not your router.
- 42:52The big network.
- 42:53The one where you said it's not isolated.
- 42:55It just goes everywhere.
- 42:56And watch everybody go,
- 42:57why does my email go really slow right
- 43:00now?
- 43:01Must be these new cameras.
- 43:04But hey, you might want that camera.
- 43:06Seventeen buildings over.
- 43:11Yeah, but we don't.
- 43:11Overflow.
- 43:12That's effectively what this is.
- 43:14So I had that conversation with somebody
- 43:15the other day about the reason people like
- 43:17this concept of all devices on the
- 43:21enterprise is because of overflow.
- 43:22And Justin, you're exactly right.
- 43:23Someone said they got their request.
- 43:24I'm like, that's what Zoom is for.
- 43:26And they were like, mind blown.
- 43:28Yeah.
- 43:30I have purposely set up some of these
- 43:33to take Zoom out of the question and
- 43:34just beam right from one to the other.
- 43:37I'm not running that over Dark Five.
- 43:38I'm not.
- 43:40Come on, man.
- 43:41Grow a pair.
- 43:42Get it.
- 43:42Grow a pair.
- 43:43Prove it.
- 43:43Live dangerously.
- 43:44Prove it.
- 43:46We leased that from city to city for
- 43:49our campuses.
- 43:49I'm not doing that.
- 43:51No.
- 43:52They don't need that real-time
- 43:54information.
- 43:56It's not real-time.
- 43:57That was four seconds ago.
- 43:59There's just barely a little bit of
- 44:01latency on full bandwidth.
- 44:03You're good.
- 44:06Twenty-one ten that crap.
- 44:07No problem.
- 44:07Good after.
- 44:08If they can't see each other,
- 44:09two seconds of latency doesn't matter.
- 44:16It's just ten G. Don't worry about it.
- 44:18Go for it.
- 44:20I set everything to be the Grandmaster.
- 44:21It's great.
- 44:22It's great.
- 44:24How many Master Clocks do you want?
- 44:26I think the energy allows us to possibly
- 44:30do a docking station with charging and
- 44:33wired ethernet.
- 44:33Keep going back to that.
- 44:35Take that docking station and yeet that
- 44:37into the nearest waterway.
- 44:39Ah, they work fine.
- 44:40Why don't you like docking stations?
- 44:42Because docking stations,
- 44:43despite being a quote unquote standard for
- 44:46PCs, they, they, um, uh,
- 44:48don't always work the exact same way on
- 44:51all devices.
- 44:53I mean,
- 44:53just wildly throwing that wired network
- 44:55out through that USB to somebody who may
- 44:57or may not be affiliated with your
- 44:59network, that is wildly risky.
- 45:00Doesn't matter.
- 45:02Give it to them.
- 45:05Take a plug into the wall.
- 45:07What's the difference?
- 45:09The docking station allows that land to
- 45:11just, like, anyways.
- 45:12Just exposes it.
- 45:14It's good to go.
- 45:15All right.
- 45:16Are we kind of at a consensus-ish point
- 45:19here that we're going to roll out and
- 45:20see what Justin comes up with?
- 45:21I think that's where we're at.
- 45:24PC.
- 45:24We're going to wait for everybody to yell
- 45:25at us.
- 45:25It should be a Zoom room.
- 45:26You all know that should be,
- 45:27and let's move on from there.
- 45:29I think you all demotivated me.
- 45:30Now I'm going to have more analysis
- 45:33paralysis on this.
- 45:35Yeah,
- 45:35but you know what your heart wants in
- 45:37this, Justin.
- 45:37Just go there.
- 45:38I don't know what my heart wants.
- 45:39I'm like you, Mark.
- 45:42I'm in this dirty bucket of filth,
- 45:43and I've got to work my way out
- 45:44of it.
- 45:46Wow.
- 45:46Just like you, Mark.
- 45:49Just like you.
- 45:49Why are you building team's rooms?
- 45:52No, we're not building that.
- 45:53We're going to do this in a team's
- 45:54room.
- 45:55I don't get that luxury.
- 45:56Hey, just lean into it, brother.
- 45:57You said you're trying to get out of
- 45:58dirty buckets of filth,
- 45:59and you're talking about team's rooms.
- 46:01well like the easy way is to do
- 46:03a team zoom room or it is definitely
- 46:05not just keep it easy and have the
- 46:08laptop just join the same call but like
- 46:12whatever by the way larry i was expecting
- 46:16to bring it up and you didn't um
- 46:17yeah i will roll out here in like
- 46:18three seconds uh where's our uh click
- 46:20share oh why would i bring that up
- 46:26is lair the click share guy
- 46:29Yeah,
- 46:29somebody's screaming the running gag.
- 46:30These wireless appliances do USB?
- 46:32Oh, yeah.
- 46:38Thanks for putting up with yet another
- 46:39episode of AV Super Friends On Topic.
- 46:42You can contact us with questions,
- 46:43topic ideas,
- 46:44or general complaints at
- 46:45avsuperfriends.com.
- 46:46Nice work, everyone.
- 46:56Sharp broadcast.
- 46:57Really good.
- 46:58Everyone on the floor as well.
- 47:00Really a lot of hustle.
- 47:00I liked it.
- 47:02The opinions expressed by the AV
- 47:03Superfriends are solely those of the
- 47:04individuals and do not represent their
- 47:06respective institutions, organizations,
- 47:08companies, or clients.