Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Appeal Bail for Green Party Deputy Leader, Security Guard Guilty of Manslaughter and the Escheat Act
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, michael Mulligan, with Legally Speaking for Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: Morning Michael, how are we doing?
- 0:07Michael Mulligan: Hey, I'm doing pretty good.
- 0:07Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here not at the Saanich Peninsula Hospital with cockroaches or the norovirus, so it's always good to be here.
- 0:16Adam Stirling: Indeed, and both of those conditions hopefully hold for up to 10 days more, and on into infinity.
- 0:20Adam Stirling: We have some interesting things on the agenda this week, including an update on the overall situation that we spoke about at Ferry Creek.
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: Indeed, we do, and it's a decision on bail pending appeal that I think is worth commenting on, and it's an appeal that was filed on behalf of Ms Davidson, who is described as a deputy leader of the federal Green Party, who was convicted of seven instances of criminal contempt and was sentenced to a period of 60 days in jail, minus 12 days credit for pretrial custody, along with 18 months probation with 75 hours of community work service, and so she was taken into custody to start serving that sentence, but was recently released the date of the judgment was April 29th pending a sentence appeal, which there are several interesting elements all wrapped up in that.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: First of all, one of the things that I noted about this was I watched a news report and you can now actually see a recording of it on YouTube if you search for this person's name and sentencing, and the interesting thing about it is, in the interview she's giving to a reporter right outside the courthouse immediately before her sentencing, right outside the courthouse, immediately before her sentencing, she says I would do it again, yes, so you have somebody here who is convicted on seven occasions and who's standing outside the courthouse prior to her sentencing says in a recorded interview that she would commit the offenses again, which is an interesting thing, of course, from the perspective of bail, which is an interesting thing, of course, from the perspective of bail right.
- 2:06Michael Mulligan: And so she was successful in her bail application and the principal argument she's making is that the sentencing judge didn't give sufficient weight to glad-do factors claiming that she would have reduced moral culpability as a result of her Indigenous background, also claiming the judge should have given further weight to the strict bail conditions that she had been on for a period of time, although I must say that doesn't seem to have a whole lot of merit at least that argument, on least by read of this decision, given that she was alleged to have breached her bail during these seven prior convictions and she was granted bail.
- 2:50Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, she filed an affidavit indicating that she would abide by any and all terms the court imposes, which is an interesting thing, of course, given her recorded comments immediately outside the courthouse.
- 3:02Michael Mulligan: All of that raises some very interesting issues about things, including why is this person involved with running for office federally?
- 3:12Michael Mulligan: Because, honestly, if you're somebody who takes the position that you're just going to repeatedly breach whatever laws you don't agree with.
- 3:21Michael Mulligan: It's hard to understand why you would want to spend any time participating in the making of laws.
- 3:26Michael Mulligan: What's the point?
- 3:28Michael Mulligan: And I must say I had a similar reaction to Miss May, who is the leader of the Green Party, who is herself a lawyer, who has also been convicted of criminal contempt not on seven occasions, but I must say the entire performance was rather disappointing from somebody who has some interest in political office, because it just raises the question of why bother If the approach is that people can just do whatever they think is the right thing to do if they don't agree with the law, what's the point of having any involvement with it at all?
- 4:00Michael Mulligan: But that's this person's view.
- 4:03Michael Mulligan: So she has been released on bail pending the hearing of the appeal.
- 4:06Michael Mulligan: The rationale for that I should just refer to that.
- 4:09Michael Mulligan: One of the things that's considered on the issue of whether somebody should get appeal bail is whether the appeal has sufficient merit, which isn't to say that it has to be particularly meritorious, but simply that it's not a frivolous exercise.
- 4:23Michael Mulligan: And here one of the other significant considerations for the judge who granted bail was and I should say, the Crown agreed that she should be released on bail and there's no reference to her remarks outside the courthouse about doing it again in this decision.
- 4:41Michael Mulligan: So perhaps they weren't aware of what she had had to say.
- 4:44Michael Mulligan: But one of the other central considerations on a sentence appeal that was applicable here is that it is likely to take more than 60 days to have a sentence appeal right, and so if you say yes, you can have your sentence appeal, but you're going to serve your entire sentence beforehand, there's not much point in a sentence appeal.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: And so that was obviously a significant consideration for the Crown and the judge in terms of granting her bail.
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: She's been released on conditions, including keep the peace to be a good behavior, so that would involve don't commit more crime.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: And also, specifically, that this language, if the appellant is engaged in protest or activism, it will be lawful and not include behavior that subjectively puts the public at risk.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: And so there it is she's been released on bail pending her sentence appeal.
- 5:32Michael Mulligan: The conditions require her, unless they want to make sure that things are moving along, unless she has filed her required material for the sentence appeal prior to November 25th, she would have to turn herself back into custody and otherwise she'll have to surrender herself into custody by 9 am on the date fixed for the pronouncement of the judgment, which is a common term on a sentence appeal, where you might be going back to jail.
- 5:57Michael Mulligan: They don't want to have you out, tell you you're going back to jail and have the person run away and have to go and capture them.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: And so the idea is that before the decision is released in terms of whether there would be an appeal, whether her appeal would be successful, she'll need to turn herself in into custody.
- 6:15Michael Mulligan: So that's the case of Ms Davidson and the Green Party, and we'll wait and see whether she follows her conditions of release or whether she is true to what she said in her recorded interview immediately before sentencing, saying she would do it again.
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: And so we'll wait and see.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: That's Ms Davidson, her appeal and the Green Party.
- 6:35Adam Stirling: A university security guard and a manslaughter conviction involving a chokehold.
- 6:40Adam Stirling: What happened in this case?
- 6:42Michael Mulligan: Well, a tragedy, but a legally interesting one.
- 6:45Michael Mulligan: So fact pattern is this the fellow who is charged is a security guard.
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: He's a security guard working for Trinity Western University.
- 6:53Michael Mulligan: It's a private, religious university over on the mainland and it dates back to September of 2020, when everything was locked down, you know.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: People couldn't come in, go to the campus, things were all online, that kind of thing.
- 7:04Michael Mulligan: Everything was locked down, people couldn't come in and go to the campus, things were all online, that kind of thing.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: And there was a man observed, described as a tall man wearing black, all black wandering through student residences, rummaging through rooms, and it resulted in multiple calls to security about this person who shouldn't have been there rummaging through property.
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: It looked like he was trying to steal things, and a fellow who was a security guard this is interesting described the security guard as 51 years of age, 5 foot 4 1⁄2 inches tall and 150 pounds.
- 7:35Michael Mulligan: He's working.
- 7:36Michael Mulligan: He sees this man in all black and runs after him.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: He yells at him to stop, the man, takes off running and the security guard runs after him and tackles the man, who's described as a 30-year-old, 6'3.5" and 194 pounds.
- 7:50Michael Mulligan: Unfortunately, that man's also described as having schizophrenia and had been off his medication for five months 51-year-old security guard trying to get control of this man.
- 8:07Michael Mulligan: As the man is doing things including punching him, pulling his hair, spitting on him, trying to do all kinds of things to the security guard to get free.
- 8:12Michael Mulligan: Eventually the older, smaller security guard manages to get this man into a headlock and then he's yelling for students to call the police, to call 911 to come and get him.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: Another person, who's the resident director, comes over and sits on the person's leg.
- 8:27Michael Mulligan: So they're trying to restrain this guy who's spitting and kicking and doing various things, and the police eventually show up and at that point, unfortunately, the man isn't moving.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: They do CPR, the man's taken to hospital but eventually he passes away and so the security guard is charged with manslaughter.
- 8:47Michael Mulligan: Now the thing with manslaughter is opposed to murder.
- 8:49Michael Mulligan: Murder requires that you'd have an intention to kill somebody.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: Essentially, manslaughter does not.
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: Manslaughter requires that somebody commit an unlawful act in this case the Crown alleged an assault.
- 9:00Michael Mulligan: Then the unlawful act has to be objectively dangerous and then it must cause the person's death.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: And there's a mental requirement.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: Like for unlawful act, manslaughter, there has to be some objective foreseeability of the risk of bodily harm.
- 9:15Michael Mulligan: That's not trivial and transitory, but you don't need to be intended to kill somebody.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: And so the judge is analyzing here in her decision.
- 9:26Michael Mulligan: First, the defense was essentially self-defense or defense of others.
- 9:29Michael Mulligan: The security guard said look, this man was dangerous.
- 9:31Michael Mulligan: He was trying to spitting on me and kicking me and he's going and breaking into residences and I was trying to restrain him and protect myself and protect the students.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: And the judge found that, well, he also headbutted him and threatened to kill him, by the way, to say, the man being arrested.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that the initial force used tackling the man and holding him down and putting him in a headlock and having the other person sit on his legs and do all of that to stop him as he was doing all those things headbutting and trying to kick him and threatening him and spitting on him and doing all these things was lawful.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: But the judge found that eventually the man stopped moving and the judge found at that point the force used by the security guard was not reasonable in continuing to hold him in a headlock.
- 10:19Michael Mulligan: And so, even though the initial force was lawful and reasonable, the judge's analysis was that continuing to hold him when he stopped trying to do things like, you know, kick him or headbutt him or spit on him.
- 10:35Michael Mulligan: And when he stopped thrashing, that the security guard should have stopped the headlock and didn't.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: And so, on that basis, found that an assault had occurred and the assault could be objectively dangerous and the man died from it.
- 10:52Michael Mulligan: And so, even though there was another argument that the man made at his trial, he argued look, there are other things that could have caused his death, including the fact that a toxicology test found that he had hydromorphine in his urine.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: And so he argued look, the man might have died from effective drugs or heart attack or something else.
- 11:09Michael Mulligan: The judge didn't accept that as so.
- 11:11Michael Mulligan: She found that drugs in the urine doesn't mean they were in his blood and accepted that the headlock was the cause of his death.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: And so, at the end of it, despite that fact pattern, what this man was doing, found that, even though the security guard, the judge, said I accept you did not intend to cause this man harm.
- 11:32Michael Mulligan: However you did so and found that it was objectively not reasonable, which is an interesting thing, you know, in applying the issue of self-defense you know there is sort of a often referred to adage look, you don't need to measure self-defense with nicety.
- 11:51Michael Mulligan: But you know, here you have a circumstance where, even though the judge accepted that the security guard didn't intend to cause harm, certainly didn't intend to kill this man, found that continuing to hold him in the headlock after he stopped kicking and spitting and head-butting was not objectively reasonable.
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: And so on that basis there was a conviction, and you know, it's, I think, something we all should just think about right in terms of what we want the state of the law to be right.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: There were changes to the law with respect to self-defense a few years ago, trying to simplify what was a complicated area, and it gives judges a whole list of things to think about when trying to determine whether something was objectively reasonable.
- 12:27Michael Mulligan: But you can have this kind of a scenario where you had a person who was trying to help and was himself being assaulted and ultimately there's this decision which you said look, it's just not objectively reasonable for there to be self-defense, and so this man's been convicted of, the 51-year-old security guard's been convicted of manslaughter.
- 12:49Michael Mulligan: We don't yet know what the sentence would be.
- 12:51Michael Mulligan: Certainly you think all of those things would be factors in that, but that's the outcome and you can just see how quickly life can turn around.
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: This 51-year-old, five-foot-four security guard wasn't even supposed to be working that day.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: He apparently was filling in for somebody who was sick.
- 13:06Michael Mulligan: So what a terrible, what a terrible day to be a university security guard.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: And I must say it also caused me to reflect upon.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: We've got all these sort of encampments with people smashing windows and doing all sorts of things you know protesting over Palestine, and you've got sort of police out there're arresting people and so on, and you've just got to think how quickly something can turn from, you know trying to remove somebody or hold them for the police into some tragedy like this.
- 13:35Michael Mulligan: You know we spoke the other week about the incident at Costco that resulted in a conviction for manslaughter and this is sort of another example of that and just how quickly something can go very badly.
- 13:47Michael Mulligan: So that's the case of the security guard, the university and the manslaughter conviction.
- 13:51Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking.
- 13:54Adam Stirling: We'll continue right after this.
- 13:56Adam Stirling: All right, we're back on the air here at CFAX 1070.
- 13:59Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 14:02Adam Stirling: As we continue looking at the legal updates of the week, number three, I see here Court of Appeal, reconsideration of a moral claim to property in the context of an act that I've never heard of.
- 14:14Adam Stirling: What's happening here?
- 14:16Michael Mulligan: Yeah, this is an interesting act and interesting legal concept and it's a legal concept of the escheatment is what it's called Escheatment Escheatment and there is a British Columbian act called the Escheatment is what it's called Escheatment Escheatment and there is a British Columbian act called the Escheat Act.
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: And here's the history of that.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: So the concept of escheatment is if you have land that winds up for some reason with no lawful owner, it transfers to the crown and that concept has been around for a long time and there's a common law concept of a sheetment that still exists in British Columbia and it existed in British law for many, many years and actually the Court of Appeals case references the Magna Carta and how that used to operate.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: And you might think how is it that you could wind up with some land that no one owns?
- 15:05Michael Mulligan: And there are a couple of ways that could happen.
- 15:08Michael Mulligan: One way that could happen is if you have somebody who dies without a beneficiary, without a will, and if you die without that, we have an act in British Columbia, WESA, this act that would provide for who gets your stuff if you die without a will, and it would essentially go to your spouse, right?
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: If no spouse, then it would essentially go to your spouse, right?
- 15:27Michael Mulligan: If no spouse, then it would go equally to your kids.
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: If no kids, it could go to your parents.
- 15:30Michael Mulligan: But what if none of those people exist?
- 15:32Michael Mulligan: What if you're unmarried with no kids and your parents aren't alive?
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: Well, it goes to the province, the Crown.
- 15:37Michael Mulligan: They get it.
- 15:38Michael Mulligan: Another circumstance where that can happen is if you have a company that owns land and the corporation is dissolved.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: Now what?
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: Again, it gets transferred to the Crown.
- 15:50Michael Mulligan: The province gets it.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: But when there is a sheetment, that is, you know, the Crown's getting the property because there's no other owner for it, right?
- 15:59Michael Mulligan: Somebody died or company's gone.
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: There's then a provision in this Act that provides that the attorney general, who would act in this capacity, can transfer the property to somebody who has a legal or moral claim to it.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: There's also provision to give it as a reward to a person who discovers the achievement or forfeiture.
- 16:20Michael Mulligan: That's fascinating.
- 16:22Michael Mulligan: Reward Now the history of all this, and this existed before this Ashit Act and the common law.
- 16:29Michael Mulligan: History still exists, the long ago history of this, and part of this was the Magna Carta protecting landowners from having the Crown take their land, and the idea was that if property Ashit to the Crown.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: It couldn't happen unless then there was a hearing which involved a then jury and government officials, determining whether somebody has some moral claim to it like some other family member.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: Should somebody else get it, Does somebody have a claim to it?
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: And that concept is embedded in the Sashet Act.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: And so how does that relate to what on earth is going on in 2024?
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: What's the Court of Appeal doing?
- 17:02Michael Mulligan: Well, this relates to a piece of property that is up near Nelson Sounds like a nice piece of property, Two pieces.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: They're described as the West Lot and the East Lot, and they're both on the lake, and the origin of it was that there was a larger piece of property granted to somebody by the Crown back in 1889.
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: And then in the early 1920s there was a from the owner transferred apart the east lot to what was described as the Nelson City Land and Improvement Company, kind of a predecessor to the city, and it was being transferred for the purpose of a road, like a road to be built there, so a road allowance.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: Problem was that it didn't get transferred properly.
- 17:49Michael Mulligan: The paperwork wasn't done properly, like it wasn't properly indicated on the paper, get to draw a red line around it.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: That didn't happen and never got fixed and never got filed properly.
- 17:58Michael Mulligan: So the transfer from the person to the this nelson city improvement Company didn't happen.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: And then a few years later, in 1930, that entity, that company, the Nelson City Land and Improvement Company, dissolved itself.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: It said it thought that it didn't own anything else and wasn't needed anymore.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: It had the municipality.
- 18:20Michael Mulligan: It thought it had transferred everything it owned, and so it was dissolved.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: Trouble was it hadn't, and so that's one of the ways that the Ashit Act can exist, if the company gets dissolved and it did.
- 18:33Michael Mulligan: And so once and then the property changed hands a couple of times and it was always treated as sort of one block of land, like apparently there's, like you know, fence all around it and like there's a home on one part of it but like the storage buildings on the other.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: It looks like one property but there's a fence all around it and there's a home on one part of it but the storage building's on the other.
- 18:48Michael Mulligan: It looks like one property, but there's been legal fighting over it for years, as between the current owners of this land the property bought it back in 1992, and Nelson, the city They've been fighting over whose is this right?
- 19:02Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 19:03Michael Mulligan: And that issue went all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 19:06Michael Mulligan: Right, yeah, um, and that issue went all the way to the supreme court of canada, and one of the arguments being made by the people who live there, uh, was that this another interesting concept called adverse possession, which can result in property being transferred to somebody if they occupy it long enough.
- 19:20Michael Mulligan: Uh, but they weren't able to prove that.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: Uh, they weren't able to prove through this continuous occupation at the relevant periods because of bad records.
- 19:29Michael Mulligan: That went all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada, who found that, no, that didn't apply.
- 19:33Michael Mulligan: And so then it came back, and then the determination was the land had been sheeted back in 1930 when this company dissolved itself.
- 19:42Michael Mulligan: There then was no owner, so it went to the province, which then, once that was realized, resulted in an application for the modern version of what used to be the 12-person jury determining whether there was a moral claim to some other family member.
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: That's in this Ashit Act, but it's a responsibility of the Attorney General provincially to decide.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: Should this go to somebody?
- 20:06Michael Mulligan: Does somebody have a moral claim to it?
- 20:08Michael Mulligan: Should there be a reward to the person who discovered the achievement?
- 20:11Michael Mulligan: And so the provincial government, in the form of the then Deputy Attorney General, made a decision saying no, he didn't think that anyone had a moral or legal claim for it, certainly not the city, because the city never was used as a roadway and just kind of dismissed out of hand the concept of giving a reward to somebody who discovers the achievement which is written into the legislation.
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: And so that decision went for a judicial review and now just wound up in the Court of Appeal and that's what brings us to the Court of Appeal decision that just came out, wound up in the Court of Appeal, and that's what brings us to the Court of Appeal decision that just came out.
- 20:49Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal has this sort of interesting discussion about, you know, the history of a sheetment and how those juries used to work and the Magna Carta and the Act and how they work together.
- 20:58Michael Mulligan: It's really a bit of fascinating legal history.
- 21:00Michael Mulligan: There's not just history.
- 21:01Michael Mulligan: We still have this and so it was a judicial review determining was the Deputy Attorney General's decision reasonable here?
- 21:11Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal found it was not reasonable and they pointed out that in this Ashit Act one of the things that has to be considered is whether there should be a reward to a person who discovers that property has a sheeted.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: And nobody figured it out back in 1930, right, Nobody had yet figured out what was going on, and really only that determination was made once a trial judge determined it upheld eventually by the Supreme Court of Canada over the legal tug of war about who gets the East lot, Canada over the legal tug of war about who gets the east lot.
- 21:52Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeals found that the Attorney General has to go try again, because their previous effort failed to determine why the current owners shouldn't be given the property as a reward for quote discovering the achievement, and then, moreover, found that there should have been a broader consideration, more factors taken into account when determining whether the people who own the West lot have a moral claim to it right on the basis that they thought they owned this thing or thought they had a right to it.
- 22:26Michael Mulligan: It right on the basis that they thought they owned this thing or thought they had a right to it At one point.
- 22:29Michael Mulligan: Somebody they purported to have purchased the interest from the person who owned the West lot, but ultimately that wasn't effective because the guy owning the West lot didn't really legally own the East lot.
- 22:39Michael Mulligan: Nobody did right.
- 22:41Michael Mulligan: The paperwork didn't get filed properly, and so that's how this lot wound up in this kind of legal no-man's land with nobody owning it, how it is sheeted to the province, and now the Court of Appeal has said no, you've got to go back and determine whether the people who own the other part of this property that looks like one piece of property, whether they should receive either the reward for discovering this or whether there should be a broader consideration of whether they have a moral claim to it.
- 23:10Michael Mulligan: And so that's the Ashit Act, Ashitment and what's going on in Nelson about who owns the east side of this parcel of property, Michael.
- 23:20Adam Stirling: Mulligan, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 23:24Adam Stirling: Thanks, michael, appreciate it.
- 23:26Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 23:26Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 23:27Adam Stirling: All right, you too.