Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP187: The Crimes of Robert Durst
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Talia. Welcome back everybody
- 0:36to this week's episode of Crimes and Consequences. We are going to do a
- 0:41very popular one today that I know very little about, or I knew very
- 0:47little about and was always very curious. This is about Robert Allen Durst.
- 0:54Yes, that that is definitely there was a bit HBO watch it. Yes,
- 1:00I should have a little background. He was born in April twelve,
- 1:04nineteen forty three, in Scarsdale, New York, to Seymour and Bernice.
- 1:11He was the oldest of four. He had two younger brothers, Douglas and
- 1:15Thomas, and one of little sister, Wendy. Robert and his siblings were
- 1:19born into a very powerful and wealthy family, one whose name carried weight along
- 1:26with it New York City. Robert's grandfather, Joseph Durst, he built a
- 1:32prominent billion dollar real estate company, d a lot of money which was turned
- 1:38into an empire. All of his wealth started with his very first building purchase,
- 1:45which was back in nineteen twelve. Then the Durst family's name became notorious.
- 1:49Today, the company is one of the city's largest family run real estate
- 1:53organizations, and it's Robert's brother, Douglas. He's the one that is at
- 1:59the of it. One night, when Robert was seven years old, his
- 2:04mother either walked off or fell off the side of the roof of the mansion,
- 2:12killing herself. Oh Man. Robert claimed that his father had brought him
- 2:17to the window and that he witnessed her death, which is kind of strange,
- 2:21yea. But his brother Douglas is like na that didn't happen. That
- 2:24didn't happen. At the time of her death, when it occurred, the
- 2:29newspapers had said Bernice had fallen off the roof after overdosing an asthma medication.
- 2:36How Her, some family members, including Robert, claimed it was suicide.
- 2:40I don't know exactly why she was on the roof. I am not usually
- 2:45on my roof. You've ever been on the roof of your house me either?
- 2:47Regardless of which one is actually true, her death really affected Robert.
- 2:54I mean he struggled with mental health afterwards. When he was ten years old,
- 3:00he was assessed by a psychiatrist who claimed he couldn't be treated because he
- 3:05had personality decomposition and possibly schizophrenia. Oh no, he couldn't be treated.
- 3:13No, not really. I guess you don't treat those disorders. What's metal
- 3:15decomposition? I don't know. It doesn't sound that's something I want. No,
- 3:19maybe I have it. I don't even know now. Maybe he attended
- 3:23Scarsdale High School, so he's still functional. You know, he's still going
- 3:27to school, and he was described as a loaner. He then went on
- 3:30to Pennsylvania's Lehigh University, So I don't know how bad he could be if
- 3:37he's in college. He ended up graduating nineteen sixty five with a bachelor's degree
- 3:43in economics. Oh that's hard staff. Well, then he enrolled in a
- 3:46doctoral program. Yeah, you see, all right, I mean that's some
- 3:51difficult subjects, especially if you have personality decomposition. Yeah, SCHIPA. That
- 3:59is where he met and became very close friends with an aspiring writer and the
- 4:04daughter of a mobster, Susan Berman. The two were thick as thieves.
- 4:10But I'll get back to that Later in nineteen sixty nine, he withdrew from
- 4:15the doctoral program and he moved back to New York City, but he was
- 4:17only there for a little bit. At some point in the early nineteen seventies,
- 4:23he ended up moving to Vermont and opening a health food store called All
- 4:29Good Things. I have a sense that he traveled a lot back and forth
- 4:34between the two states. In the fall of nineteen seventy one, he met
- 4:39eighteen year old Kathleen. She went by Kathy McCormick. She was a donal
- 4:45hygienist who lived in one of the buildings owned by the Durst family or organization,
- 4:49if you want to call it. They met when Robert stopped by to
- 4:54pick up a run. Oh Hey, nice to meet you. Katy had
- 4:59just moved to New York City from a Long Island. She was bright,
- 5:01charming, It's just the kind of person everybody liked, and the two immediately
- 5:06hit it off. Kathy didn't seem to mind his cool affection. As a
- 5:13matter of fact, she thought of him more as a sweet, sensitive guy.
- 5:18The two were smitten with each other just after two dates, and that's
- 5:21when Robert asked Kathy to move into his Vermont home near his health food store.
- 5:27It wasn't until January nineteen seventy two that she took him up on the
- 5:30offer and moved in with them. They were undoubtedly in love, but they
- 5:36had some issues. He's got a couple yeah issues. For one thing,
- 5:42he was ten years older than her. Secondly, they came from two completely
- 5:47different worlds. He came from a life of wealth and power, and Kathy
- 5:53came from a modest, Irish Catholic household. It was easy for her to
- 5:57quickly become swept up in the lifestyle that came along with being a Durst,
- 6:02but they still had their differences. After being pressured from his father to move
- 6:08back to New York City and work for the Durst organization, Robert eventually gave
- 6:13in. Just one year after the couple had moved in together, Robert ended
- 6:16up closing his health food store and moving back to the city. Both of
- 6:20them did. Actually, on Robert's thirtieth birthday, Robert and Kathy got married.
- 6:28While la Marins had started out as a loving one, things suddenly changed
- 6:31after moving from Vermont to New York City. It was a big change,
- 6:36and it was not a good change. Kathy had said that Robert's father,
- 6:42Seymour, brought out the worst and Robert, and that he turned him into
- 6:46a completely different person from the man she fell in love with and Vermont.
- 6:51At first, Robert loved nothing more than showed Kathy off because she's I mean,
- 6:56she's just beautiful, and he would take her to the best and biggest
- 7:00events in New York. He loved showing her this world that he knew and
- 7:05grew up in. Even Seymour approved of his new daughter in law. However,
- 7:11his time went on. Robert, who wasn't really as I said,
- 7:15that warm before he had a cool affection, he got even colder. For
- 7:19a long time. Kathy kept how miserable she was a secret. However,
- 7:26there were hints drop that alluded to Robert having anger problems. What it first
- 7:30started out as yelling turned into pretending to hit her. What yea, what
- 7:35the fuck is that is that? And then much worse As time went on,
- 7:42it went downhill. Kathy's brother Jim said he first witnessed Robert abusing Kathy
- 7:48at a family Christmas party when he grabbed her by the hair. Oh my
- 7:54god, does it at a family Christmas party? Right? Fuckjeez? He
- 7:59don't give one shit who sees right. Kathy had kept numerous diaries filled with
- 8:05details about how she'd been suffering in the marriage. For one, Believe it
- 8:09or not, Robert was a cheapskate. Ah geez. He was one of
- 8:13those guys, A ton of money but cheap as how, even though she
- 8:18was married to a millionaire, she was still she was going to medical school.
- 8:22She wanted to have a career and have her own money to do with
- 8:24as she pleased. He's probably up her ass all the time, right about
- 8:28her spending. Then one day Robert dropped this bomb on her. He told
- 8:33her I hidden money children and that was upsetting for her. So she just
- 8:37tried to focus on school, but saying that really fractured their relationship and after
- 8:43that it never got repaired. Robert would tell her that he might be open
- 8:48to considering adapting, which gave Kathy just like a little bit of hope,
- 8:54but he squashed that every time she set up any appointment with any agency,
- 8:58he wouldn't go to make up excuses. In nineteen seventy six, Kathy ended
- 9:03up getting pregnant and Robert was pissed. He accuses her of doing it on
- 9:09purpose. And he for started get an abortion, and he told her that
- 9:15he would divorce her if she didn't. She was really reluctant to do that
- 9:18because she really wanted to have a baby, but she went through it and
- 9:24then she ended up suffering from depression as a result. To make matters worse,
- 9:30it was also around the same time when she first found out that Robert
- 9:33was a fucking knew it. I knew it having an affair, fucker,
- 9:39you know how she found out how she found polaroid pictures and their medicine cabinets.
- 9:46The medicine cabinet right like, like though you're not even hiding it,
- 9:50right like at least tied the ship beat a great man. How insulting.
- 9:58She asked him about the photos, and Robert revealed that he'd had a woman
- 10:01in their home. Oh man, and that's when shit would go nuclear at
- 10:05my house. Right, Not only did he have a woman in their home,
- 10:11but he had moved things around their home to make it look like he
- 10:13was a single man living there, Like, get rid of those photos of
- 10:18anything of hers. He just outright told her this, And it's just weird.
- 10:24No, this was something that no relationship can really survive. There was
- 10:30no love left between the two of them and Kathy, she was just basically
- 10:35suffering. In early nineteen eighty two, she was only twenty nine, Kathy
- 10:41was treated for facial bruises at the Bronx Hospital. She told a friend that
- 10:46Robert had beaten her up when she confronted him about another affair. She knew
- 10:50he'd taken up with a woman named Prudence Farrell. And that is the same
- 10:56Prudence that the Beatles sing about in their song to Your Prudence. It was
- 11:00the same woman and happens to be Mia, Mia Pharaoh's sister. Yeah.
- 11:07So medical school alone stressful. It was her final year and it was pretty
- 11:11difficult. Yeah, and then she's daily being abused and emotionally abused. It
- 11:18was too much for twenty nine year old Kathy. As a result, she
- 11:22began drinking successfully and using drugs to cope with the abuse. She barely slept
- 11:26or eight. Her friends couldn't help but notice this one's probably bright person,
- 11:33which is like a shelf of her former self. She was detached, constantly
- 11:37frayed, and nervous. Kathy wanted a divorce and began telling friends that she's
- 11:43going to leave Robert. As soon as she finished medical school, she was
- 11:46going to file. Robert caught wind of this, and he reacted by canceling
- 11:52all of her credit cards and removing her from the joint bank account, and
- 11:58he wouldn't pay for her semester of medical school. What a fuck had Yeah,
- 12:03that's when she just demanded a divorce, and she was only asking for
- 12:07a two hundred and fifty thousand dollars settlement, which considering he's an error to
- 12:11a billion eira, I mean. Kathy told her friends they were probably married
- 12:16almost like ten years at this point too. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 12:20you're running two or fifty grandsn't that much. Kathy told friends that she had
- 12:24proof that Robert been embezzling money from his father made and had made fraudulent claims
- 12:31on his tax returns as well as her own, and she had let Robert
- 12:35know that she knew that shit girl. One time when she was at her
- 12:41New York City apartment with two friends, Phil Stevenson and George Karns. Those
- 12:45were the friends. Phil said that Robert showed up at the door, threw
- 12:48a lot of cash at Kathy's face and said, quote, this isn't happening.
- 12:54He was referring to the divorce that's not gonna happen. Kathy then told
- 12:58Robert that she was just done and she was going to move to Delaware.
- 13:01George, who was there witnessing this interaction, said that there was a lot
- 13:07of yelling and screaming and that Robert seemed really out of control and was out
- 13:13of his mind. Angry, no, how fucking awkward. Ten days later,
- 13:18Kathy disappeared oh fuck yeah, yeah, yeah yeah. She was last
- 13:24seen alive January thirty first, nineteen eighty two, when she went to a
- 13:28dinner party without Robert at her friend Gilbert I don't know his last name in
- 13:33Connecticut. Kathy had shown up unexpectedly, and according to Gilbert, she wasn't
- 13:39acting like herself. She was typically wore high quality clothes. She showed up
- 13:46in red sweatpants and seemed visibly upset when she got there. During the party,
- 13:52Robert called that house multiple times wanting to speak to Kathy, and people
- 13:56could hear him screaming through the phone for her to come home. God,
- 14:01what a psycho, I mean she didn't want to. She eventually left the
- 14:05party to return to the house in New York. In an interview, Gilberte
- 14:11talked about the last conversation with Kathy. She said it was a very powerful
- 14:16conversation. Quote. As she was leaving my house, she turned to me
- 14:20and said, Gilberte promised me, if something happens to me, you'll check
- 14:26it out. I'm afraid of what Bobby might do. End quote. I
- 14:31guess Robert went by Bobby. That's less time anyone saw Kathy aside from Robert.
- 14:37According to Robert, he and Kathy argued that night. He said Kathy
- 14:41wanted to go to their apartment in the city instead of saying the house,
- 14:46because they were actually at a house they had in South Salam hamlet of Westchester
- 14:52County, New York. Okay, okay, and she wanted to go to
- 14:56the apartment in New York City, so she dropped her off at the train
- 15:01station so she could catch the nine fifteen train to Manhattan. Afterwards, he
- 15:07told the New York City Police Department that he went for a walk. You
- 15:11know, I don't have an alibi. I'm just screaming my fucking head off
- 15:15at her when she's at a party. He had a drink in a neighbor's
- 15:18house, spoke with Kathy on a pay phone when she returned to Manhattan apartment,
- 15:22and then he went to bed at the other house, so she called
- 15:26him on a payphone, or he called her on the most called her when
- 15:31he thought she returned. Sure the neighbors Robert had allegedly seen that night that
- 15:37was Bill and Ruth. Mayor later testified that Robert this is gonna be surprised
- 15:43live to police and he actually never visited him that night the night she disappeared
- 15:48surprise. Moreover, Ruth also testified that Kathy had told her in private that
- 15:54Robert was abusing her, and Ruth encouraged her to report it, but Kathy
- 16:00said she just was too afraid. Before her disappearance, Kathy had made plans
- 16:03to meet Gilberte at a pub in Manhattan. I don't know exactly what day
- 16:08it was, but Kathy never showed. Gilberte was worried, and that's when
- 16:14the police got called several times over the next few days after Gilberte didn't hear
- 16:19from her or see her. On February fourth, Kathy's college, someone from
- 16:25the college administration called Robert and said that Kathy had called in sick on February
- 16:30first and had missed a full week of classes. So on February fifth,
- 16:36I mean basically, like we're really concerned, Robert reported his wife missing.
- 16:41Detectives wondered why Robert had waited so long to report his wife missing, and
- 16:48he was very calm when he explained that they just spent lots of days apart.
- 16:53She was always working and studying and at the hospital, and he was
- 16:57too busy with his girlfriend, and yeah, he had your prudence. Yeah.
- 17:02Police described Robert as completely calm and unmoved, as if he was on
- 17:07phase that his wife had been missing for several days. Something else that was
- 17:12weird was when he reached out to the press soon afterwards, and he offered
- 17:18a thousand dollars reward for information leading to her safe return. However, he
- 17:22then reduced the amount, stating that the original article had made a mistake.
- 17:30What a cheap fucker what right? Wait? Wait wait wait wait wait in
- 17:34a wrong amount? What a thousand? Fuck? Is that it's only five
- 17:37hundred? Yeah, forget that one hundred thousand. And it's obvious his wife
- 17:42didn't mean much to him if he was willing to reduce the reward, right,
- 17:48and he never reached out to her family, oh man, Instead,
- 17:52Cathy's family, who had no idea who she was missing, found out about
- 17:56her disappearance in the newspaper. That's terrible. Due to his high profile status,
- 18:02Kathy's disappearance and Robert himself game a lot of media attention. Yeah,
- 18:07Luckily for him, his longtime friend Susan Burman stepped in as basically an unofficial
- 18:14spokeswoman and made statements and answered questions on his behalf. Because he's Koku.
- 18:19I mean, he would have said something stupid like that. Rewards reduced even
- 18:23more. Oh yeah, he's so stupid. Yeah yeah. After the article
- 18:30was mistake, yeah, oh yeah, it gets better. Oh yeah,
- 18:33you know the story better than I can do. Three weeks after Robert reported
- 18:40Kathy missing, who was already trying to basically eraser in their Manhattan apartment,
- 18:45he threw out almost all her belongings into the garbage shoot because that's not suspicious
- 18:51that and it led to the buildings incinerator and the building manager had to ask
- 18:56him to stop because he was clogging it off. Oh my god. He
- 18:59was throwing so much stuff throughout her clothes, medical school books, jewelry,
- 19:03pretty much everything that belonged to her. Oh yeah, She's not with us
- 19:06anymore, for sure, and he knows it exactly. Kathy's friends they ended
- 19:11up taking her disappearance into their own hands, and they broke into Kathy and
- 19:15Robert's South Salem home and the hopes they might find maybe her or find clues
- 19:22to her whereabouts. When they arrived, they found that the house had been
- 19:26turned upside down, Kathy's mail had been ripped open, her belongings were stuffed
- 19:33into garbage bags, and interestingly enough, they found an itinerary of everything Robert
- 19:40had done on the night of Kathy's disappearance, as well as the day's prior.
- 19:45When they turned it into the police, they said, this isn't normal
- 19:49behavior for an innocent man, but rather for someone that was guilty of something
- 19:55who wanted to keep track of his lies. Oh yes, shady, shady.
- 20:00While the New York Police explored leads in questioned Robert, it didn't go
- 20:04unnoticed that higher ups were not really pushing to solve this case. The investigation
- 20:11only been going on for a few weeks when it already began winding down.
- 20:15Which this is a whole high profile case, and you would think somebody from
- 20:19the Dirt's family being missing would be continue to be a priority, but it
- 20:26seemed like the Dirt's family didn't really care about it, and the police didn't
- 20:32either. The Dirt's family wasn't cooperating with the police either. By the way,
- 20:37Robert refused interviews, polygraph tests, and even answering like the most basic
- 20:42questions. But he did give several interviews to reporters. Yeah, but don't
- 20:48talk to the police. To the press. No, he claimed that Kathy
- 20:52just ran off with another man, took nothing with her, No, nothing,
- 20:59not a dollar and yeah, he's so dramatical. School didn't decide to
- 21:03finish yet didn't finish it, just just laughed. Since there was really no
- 21:07evidence about Kathy's disappearance, there wasn't any leads. The police actually did speak
- 21:15to some psychics, oh okay, and they did have suspicions that Robert might
- 21:21be involved. I mean he lured up right away, which is what you
- 21:23do. That's what you do. Look guilty, No, protect yourself.
- 21:30Got the best criminal attorneys in New York. But eventually this case, when
- 21:33cold solely Cathy's disappearance turned into nothing more than a cold case file. After
- 21:41a period of morning, Robert returned to work in the family business. The
- 21:47following year lazy ass, this time in New York City, He took a
- 21:53big stop from the social scene he once dominated. He ended up only keeping
- 21:59very close circle of friends, including Susan Burman. In the next ten years
- 22:03to follow it, or roughly around that amount of time, he tried to
- 22:08reinvent himself and he got a new girlfriend. Her name was Deborah Lee Sheraton.
- 22:14She was an ambitious New York City real estate broker. He sold at
- 22:18South Salem home that he and Cathy shared an unbeknownst to Kathy's family, he
- 22:23filed for divorce from his still missing wife, claiming spousal abandonment. Wow,
- 22:33but before I tell you more about this story and the murders to come,
- 22:38We're going to take a quick break. Robert allegedly started behaving oddly at work.
- 22:48No, okay, this includes urinating and trash cans. That's fucking odd.
- 22:53Like you and I are in this office and you piss in a trash
- 22:56can. I'm going to be upset. I'm going to be concerned. Learned
- 23:00about you. Come on now, Really, he was next in line to
- 23:03take over the family's company. I mean I had to go bad. I
- 23:07know, but I've never seen you do that yet. No, not yet,
- 23:10and I never will. Okay good. Robert was supposed to be next
- 23:12in line to take over his family's company, but his father ended up appointing
- 23:17his younger brother, Douglas in that position. In nineteen ninety four, Robert
- 23:21accused his brother of stealing the company from him, which caused a big riff
- 23:25between Robert and the rest of his family. He would then spend the next
- 23:29decade traveling as a vaga behind He's like, fuck it, fuck it.
- 23:33I'm sure he still had access to money. In nineteen ninety nine, after
- 23:38the New York Police Department received a bogus tip about the location of Cathy's body,
- 23:44police in Westchester reopened Kathy Durst case. This time they were looking at
- 23:48as a homicide. Police search the Durst's home in South Salem. It was
- 23:56nearby a lake, but I mean they didn't find anything. I mean,
- 24:00twenty years later or something. In two thousand, the investigation became public.
- 24:04People knew about it. A month later, Robert married Debrah, his longtime
- 24:10girlfriend. It was kind of a quick ceremony, officiated by a single rabbi
- 24:15picked out of the phone book. It's reported that they never lived together over
- 24:18the course of their marriage, and that they've went years without speaking, which
- 24:23might sound weird. I mean, why I get married to begin with,
- 24:26right? According to Robert, Susan Burman called him in December of two thousand
- 24:30to tell him the police wanted to interview her about Kathy's disappearance. At that
- 24:36time, Susan was living alone at her home in Benedict Canyon, Los Angeles,
- 24:41and she was working as a journalist and an author. A sop called
- 24:45Mafia Princess. Susan wrote about her family's ties to gangsters, specifically her father,
- 24:52David Davey Burman. I guess he was some Las Vegas mob boss.
- 24:57Okay, I'm gonna give you a little background on Susan and Robert. They
- 25:00became friends after meeting as students at UCLA. They bonded over their trauma.
- 25:07When Susan was twelve, her father died on the operating table. Oh damn,
- 25:11and her mother died of a drug overdose a year later. Oh that's
- 25:15terrible. Robert talked about how he believed his mom committed suicide, and Susan
- 25:21McCall Robert, her little brother the little brother she never had. She was
- 25:25really protective of him. When she got married in nineteen eighty four, it
- 25:30was Robert who walked her down the aisle. Oh that's cute. No,
- 25:33it's not cute. Okay. The two had been nearly inseparable for decades when
- 25:40Kathy disappeared. However, she and Robert ended up drifting apart. After Kathy's
- 25:44disappearance, Susan ended up leaving New York and settled in California, where she
- 25:49wrote two books. And I told you about her life is a mob boss's
- 25:55daughter. She acted like she had a really glamorous life and led people to
- 26:00believe that, but that really wasn't accurate. In August of two thousand,
- 26:04Susan was really short on money and facing in fiction. In a desperate attempt,
- 26:08that's when she reached out to Robert asking for money. She didn't know
- 26:14how to get a hold of him, so she left a voicemail on a
- 26:17phone he kept in New York without even speaking together. He gifted her fifty
- 26:22thousand, and she used that to pay her debts and get herself back on
- 26:26track. Wow, that was nice. Oh, I would have called him
- 26:29a long time ago. Yeah, no shit, Robert chucking in this obviously
- 26:34helped Susan a lot. Yeah. The two eventually talked on the phone,
- 26:37and Susan started her life started getting better. She got hired to do a
- 26:41couple of new projects, and now Robert was back in her life. Everything
- 26:47was good until she got contacted by the Westchester DA, who informed her Cathy's
- 26:51case was being reopened as a homicide and they wanted to talk to her.
- 26:56After all, she had never been interviewed in the initial investigation. She never
- 27:00been interviewed, so the interview had been arranged to take place sometime early in
- 27:06the new year, And of course this interaction between the DA and Susan made
- 27:11front page in the news because you've got the Durst family. On December nineteenth,
- 27:17Susan spoke with her friend. This was an actress named Kim Langford,
- 27:21telling her that she had the story of a lifetime and had information that was
- 27:26going to blow the top off of things. Oh, Kim just assumed that
- 27:33this information one was related to I don't know, another mob story something like
- 27:37that in Vegas. Susan also told Kim she had recently spoken to a psychic
- 27:42who told her that she was destined to die a violent death. Oh my
- 27:48god, what a horrible thing to find out. What excuse me? Usually
- 27:55psychics only tell you good things, like why would you tell me that I
- 27:57know here to die of very violent? Deftly? Okay, well shit,
- 28:04I'm just gonna go figure out a way to go peacefully if that's my future,
- 28:11And the psychic said it would involve a gun. On Christmas even two
- 28:15thousand, police were called to Susan's home after neighbors reported that her dogs were
- 28:19running loose on the street and barking wildly. Police arrived at Susan's home and
- 28:26they found the back door was a little bit open. In the doorway of
- 28:30one of her bedrooms was fifty five year old Susan. She'd been shot execution
- 28:37style with one bullet to the back of the head. There's no signs in
- 28:41fourth century, and nothing was stolen. Police determined she'd been dead a day
- 28:48or two before the body was discovered, so maybe the dogs eventually just ran
- 28:52out. Some people speculated was a mob hit in retaliation for all that information.
- 28:57She was writing in books of people on her upcoming project. But when
- 29:03police learned she was supposed to talk with the dam that seems suspicion seems awfully
- 29:08suspicious. It didn't help matters that Robert flew out from New York City to
- 29:14San Francisco, California, on December nineteenth, which is near where she lived,
- 29:18and then flew back to New York City from San Francisco on the twenty
- 29:23third, the day before Susan's body was found. After Susan's body was found,
- 29:30the LAPD received an anonymous letter postmarked December twenty third. The letter was
- 29:37addressed to the Beverly Hills Police with Beverly misspelled. Inside. The letter had
- 29:44Susan's address with one word cadaver. What's crazy? What is this? It
- 29:53was obviously a letter letting the police know there was a body there. Yeah,
- 29:59what the fire? I didn't know this, Yeah, this is crazy.
- 30:02As it turns out, Susan did have some information to share about Kathy.
- 30:07According to her friend Linda Opps, Susan had told her that she was
- 30:12the one that called Kathy's college on February first, and allegedly said she was
- 30:19sick. She pretended to be Kathy. According to the prosecuting attorney, Robert
- 30:26asked Susan to cover for him. When Kathy had first disappeared by posing as
- 30:30Kathy and then calling in sick Oh. They theorized that Robert had killed Susan
- 30:37after discovering because it's in the paper. Yeah, she's going to meet with
- 30:40the DA and he was really afraid that she turned them in. A woman
- 30:45named Miriam Barnes that's one of Susan's close friends, ended up testifying later that
- 30:51Susan called her and told her that she'd done a favorite for Robert, but
- 30:55was nervous about sharing it. She told Miriam that anything happened to her,
- 31:00Robert did it. Robert was questioned about her murder, but he was never
- 31:04charged. Robert didn't even end up attending the funeral, and this is supposedly
- 31:11his close, oldest, dearest friend. In April of two thousand, Robert
- 31:17escaped the city to avoid police inquiries, and he started renting a three hundred
- 31:22dollars a month apartment in Galston, Texas, where no one knew where he
- 31:26was. This isn't like a billionaire's son and three hundred dollars a month because
- 31:33he's trying to just escape, you know, they had to be a shithole,
- 31:37right, Yes, I mean three hundred dollars a month. Well,
- 31:42yes, okay, I mean he had to be right. While living in
- 31:45Galveston, he pretended to be a mute woman named Dorothy's Signer, a name
- 31:52he took from a high school friend. Likely Yeah, okay, mute,
- 31:59what is this shit? Yeah? I can't with people. Sometimes. He
- 32:04was spotted wearing women's wigs around town, visiting the library to look up articles
- 32:09on himself. God, I would a narcissist. He posed as a mute
- 32:15woman because he had a really distinctive voice, and he thought that it would
- 32:19be very easily identifiable by someone which is mute. He's not gonna say anything.
- 32:25That'd be hard. It would be hard. On September thirtieth, two
- 32:30thousand and one, a man fishing with his son in Galveston Bay discovered a
- 32:35human torso floating in the water. They called the police and searched the area,
- 32:38and they found some garbage bags. Each bag had a total of twelve
- 32:44dismembered body parts in the bags. They also found an outer packaging for a
- 32:50bow saw, a receipt for garbage bags, cloths, and a newspaper that
- 32:54contained a handwritten note with an address two two one three Avenue UK, Gross
- 33:00Yeah at the address. Officers searched the garbage cans around the area and they
- 33:06found more black garbage bag similar to the ones that they were covered inside some
- 33:10dumpsters and they found an empty trash bag box, a four inch pairing knife,
- 33:17and a twenty two caliber shellcasing and of in fiction notice addressed to of
- 33:22someone named Morris Black. Morris was one of the tenants in the shared home
- 33:27on Avenue K. He'd been a veteran with a kind of a murky past.
- 33:34He was a strange from his family and his ex wife. He lived
- 33:37a nomadic life and he occasionally reached out to someone, but he was just
- 33:45pretty what's the word I'm thinking of? He kept to himself. Ended up
- 33:50landing in Texas sometime in the mid nineties and he was arrested nine eight for
- 33:53threatening to blow up a utility company. Oh wow. Because he was upset
- 33:58about his lifestyle. Made up really hard for them to track the timeline of
- 34:06him and what he'd done in the past. There was just decades without any
- 34:10documentation. Those in Galveston who had met Morris described with miss a grumpy old
- 34:16man who was suspicious of everyone, paranoid you know, I'm prone to screaming
- 34:21outburst. He used to live in New York City but seemed to have gone
- 34:24off the grid. In eighty two, it was discovered that this Morris guy
- 34:29had one hundred and thirty thousand dollars in an out of state bank account,
- 34:32despite not having a job at least on record for decades. He'd been living
- 34:38on this money and all his friends and he didn't have many had no idea
- 34:43he had any money. And now he was missing. Oh, he's gone,
- 34:49he's gone, He's gone. Police were able to execute a search warrant
- 34:52for Morris's home based on the fact the address was found yes with a torso.
- 34:58Once inside, they discovered blood everywhere in the bathroom, sink, the
- 35:04kitchen, and the drains. When they sprayed lumin all throughout the apartment,
- 35:08it lit up like Christmas walls, floors, drag marks man that led from
- 35:14Morris's apartment to the apartment across the hall, whoops, across the law and
- 35:20that's where well, we don't know the mute woman lives. How did you
- 35:22know that belonged to Dorothy Signer, a mute old woman whose neighbors didn't know
- 35:30very much about this woman, except she probably looked like an ugly man.
- 35:34She looked like an old man. She was rarely seen, had been known
- 35:38to travel frequently, always kept her shades drawn, and always kept to herself.
- 35:45Investigators got a court order to enter, and then they found blood everywhere
- 35:47or there too, shit in Dorothy's kitchen. There had been several cuts in
- 35:52the linoleum floor, and when officers pulled the linoleum bag, they discovered pools
- 35:58or dry blood. I don't mean, what, what a fucking mess?
- 36:01What is this? Yeah? Like Morris Guy's got one hundred and thirty thousand
- 36:06dollars, But you know I was living in a probably three hundred dollars a
- 36:09month apartment. I got a mute woman and blood going between the apartments everywhere
- 36:16everywhere. They've so crazy. This apartment hadn't been cleaned as thoroughly as Morris's.
- 36:24There was dry blood splatter all over the place. There was a pairing
- 36:28knife, a cleaver, a handsaw, oh geez god, a pistol.
- 36:35What are the bigs they recovered from the water. It was empty and it
- 36:38had this large rip in it. Officers concluded that that was the one that
- 36:45contained missing Morris's head man because the body was headless was Morris's and headless and
- 36:54that was the only part not recovered geez, and to them that likely contained
- 37:00the key evidence in this case because they believed that Morris was probably shot and
- 37:05had based on the rest of the body parts. They compared the fingerprints from
- 37:12Morris's time in the military to those body and that's how they ended up identifying
- 37:16them. A medical examiner determined that the body parts were covered were from seventy
- 37:22one year old Morris Black. The medical examiner would later testify that the person
- 37:25who cut his body up knew what kind of instrument to use on what bone
- 37:30and what muscle and what part of the body, and it was a work
- 37:34of someone that had done this before. Oh shit, Oh man, it's
- 37:38fucking disgusting. Dorothy's signer was now missing too, and police turned their attention
- 37:45to finding Dorothy. They had been able to determine that Morris was likely killed
- 37:50in his apartment, but then dismembered in Dorothy's. But why, why is
- 37:55this happening? It all started to make sense when they to receipt in the
- 38:00buildings trash. It was from a local optometrist and it had Robert's name on
- 38:07it. Well, now that's weird. Yeah, without information, they thought,
- 38:12okay, perhaps this mute woman, mute, older woman might be Robert
- 38:19Durst. Yeah, how strange, very weird. Look what the hell?
- 38:22I would just be like, what the fuck is this? Yeah? Fuck
- 38:25is this? Neighbors couldn't recall seeing Dorothy around the time that Morris disappeared,
- 38:30although they did recall seeing a man floating garbage bags into a Honda CRV he
- 38:37left his way at home. It's like what They hadn't recognized him, but
- 38:43noticed that he did make several trips in and out of Dorothy's apartment. Police
- 38:46took down a description the vehicle and they put a bulow out. They also
- 38:50looked in the national database to try to get any information they could about miss
- 38:54Signer. Thankfully, they found Miss Signer alive and well. But she said,
- 39:00I don't live in Galveston, Texas, and I'm not mute. When
- 39:05they asked if she knew Robert Durst, she replied that she she did.
- 39:09They attended high school together back in the fifties, and she was very confused.
- 39:15I mean, she hadn't spoken to him in decades and had no idea
- 39:17why there was an apartment runned using her name in social security number? Wow,
- 39:22her kid? Yet the hell is this? And by the way,
- 39:28there's a body in the apartment you've been running, or there's a blood in
- 39:30the apartment you've been running? What what I know? I'd be like,
- 39:35somebody needs to sit me down, and I'm very confused. Seven days later,
- 39:39a vehicle that was matching the description for the Bolo was found and they
- 39:45pulled up the driver and they searched the car. Inside they saw a bosaw
- 39:50and blood in the trunk of the vehicle, and that's when they arrested fifty
- 39:53eight year old driver Robert Durst October ninth, two thousand and one, and
- 40:00they charged him with the murder of Morris Black. He paid three thousand dollars
- 40:04bail and then he left Texas and went on the run. He failed to
- 40:08appear to his court date and he was declared fugitive. He ended up renting
- 40:14a car in Mobile, Alabama under the name Morris Black. What what this
- 40:22guy is? Too much? Too much? Then, in another really strange
- 40:25twist, he was found and arrested in a Wagman's grocery store in Bath,
- 40:30Pennsylvania, he was accused of shoplifting a six dollar chicken sandwich. Really dude,
- 40:37some bandages in a newspaper, even though he had thirty eight thousand dollars
- 40:42in cash on him on hill on him. What the hell? He had
- 40:46two loaded guns, a Medicaid card, and a driver's license belonging to Morris
- 40:52Black. But this time he cheaved off all his hair and his eyebrows because
- 40:58that's not his all. I mean, at first they didn't really recognize him.
- 41:05It was only after he was arrested and they ran a social Security number
- 41:07when he's arrested for the chicken sandwich that they realized who they had arrested.
- 41:13In January of two thousand and two, he returned to Texas to see on
- 41:17trial for Morris Black's murder. According to Robert's testimony, he came home on
- 41:22September twenty eight, two thousand and one, to find Morris in his apartment,
- 41:27angry because Morris had a key to his apartment, Robert hadn't been expecting
- 41:31him. He said he immediately suspected Morris of taking a gun that he'd stored
- 41:37in his oven. That's a fantastic place for a gun. What is this
- 41:45shit. When Robert asked him, where's my gun, Morris reportedly stood and
- 41:52pointed it at Robert. Robert clean that he grabbed the gun and the two
- 41:55men fell to the ground, and that's when the gun went off. He
- 41:58said. He never even touched the trigger, and that's when Morris got shot
- 42:01in the hut. So what do you do? I mean, you dismember
- 42:05him? And he tried to help his neighbor, okay by going to another
- 42:09neighbor's apartment, but no one answered, so he went back to his apartment.
- 42:14I mean, and then you kind of just like, what do you
- 42:15do? You gotta take matters into your own hands. So he grabbed a
- 42:20bottle of Jack Daniels and, you know, dismembered Morris's body because that's what
- 42:23I would do before dumping in in the Galveston Bay. I mean, you
- 42:28wouldn't do the tried. He knocked on the neighbor's door. No one answered
- 42:30answer. He's like, well, fun, what am I gonna have to
- 42:34cut the body? I guess somebody have to dispose of it, like mean,
- 42:37it was an accident, but no one's gonna believe me. Well,
- 42:39he said, because of you know, the suspicions of the past. Yeah,
- 42:44no one would believe him. And the other bodies I cut up private
- 42:47investigator, ended up Pie's and together a connection between Robert and Morris that went
- 42:52way back, because remember Morris had all that money that's right on his account,
- 42:59but had no job. That's right. Morris Black had a brother named
- 43:02Harry, and the two of them owned a construction business in New York back
- 43:07in the eighties. According to family members, it had been funded by the
- 43:12Durst organization, specifically Roberts. There you go. Harry had passed in two
- 43:19thousand and three, but his wife had said that when he learned that Morris
- 43:22had been murdered, he was really concerned he would be next. You can
- 43:28see why because you got this freak on the run too. When that's why
- 43:30his wife said, well, he had dark secrets. I'm wondering, like,
- 43:35if he's got a construction company, what about her way to dispose of
- 43:37a body? Right? Why? And then yeah, why didn't Morris have
- 43:45all that cash exactly? I mean, I don't know, I don't know.
- 43:47I'm I'm not saying anything. He got bribed to do something with the
- 43:53body. But anyway, his wife told the private investor that she believed the
- 43:57brothers knew something about Cathy's disappearance. Prosecutors believe that Robert murdered Morris when he
- 44:02found out his true identity, and he killed him out of fear let he'd
- 44:07be charged with Cathy's murder. They believed that Robert had specifically chosen Galveston and
- 44:14he arrived concealing his identity as an old mute woman in a lowcome area next
- 44:21to the man that he used to fund work for him. Like it was
- 44:24intentional that he did. Yeah, it was intentional for Robert. Why,
- 44:29I know, it's so weird, Like why would you give an apartment across
- 44:32the hall from someone you possibly allegedly bribe because he's nuts. Yeah. In
- 44:37his trial, because he did have a trial, Robert hired the best criminal
- 44:40defense attorneys the money could buy. Lasted two months, and despite amount of
- 44:45evidence, he was acquitted. I love the American justice system sometimes sometimes you
- 44:52know, sometimes it works, sometimes it sometimes it doesn't. Needless to say,
- 44:57him being acquitted was pretty shocked. I don't know if I told you.
- 45:00After his original bail jumping, he was put on a three billion dollars
- 45:07bail, but that was found to be unconstitutional. It was a little excessive,
- 45:10I guess. He did get found guilty of tampering with evidence and bail
- 45:15jumping, and he got sixty months for it's a felony. In October of
- 45:20two thousand and four, just as he was about to be paroled, Pennsylvania
- 45:23authorities charged Robert with weapon possession stemming from his time when he was on the
- 45:29run. In July of two thousand and five, he was released from federal
- 45:32prison and sent to Texas to serve parole. I don't really even know.
- 45:37I can't even keep track evolve all this shit, but Robert couldn't stay in
- 45:42one place. In December of two thousand and five, he was arrested for
- 45:45a parole violation for making unauthorized trips to Galveston. He got caught after visiting
- 45:52a Texas mall where he happened to run into the judge who was presiding over
- 45:55the murder Trialous, what are the odds of? What are the odds?
- 46:00I've never run into a judge in my right, And yeah, that's crazy.
- 46:06In February two thousand and six, he was released from prison and his
- 46:09paroles supervision ended. Nine months later, and he was a freeman. Four
- 46:14years later, Robert's infamous deeds were made into a movie. It was called
- 46:19All Good Things. It was kind of loosely about his life. After the
- 46:23movie was released, he contacted the director praising him about the movie, and
- 46:29they kept in contact for two years. They did they were baby kame friends.
- 46:32Eventually, Robert agreed to be interviewed for an HBO documentary series about his
- 46:38life, even though his lawyer was like, don't do that. It was
- 46:43called The Jinks, which I didn't see, The Life and Deaths of Robert
- 46:47Durst. It was good. I recommend it. I recommended for anybody who
- 46:52hasn't seen it. He denied all responsibility for Susan and Cathy's deaths, disappearances.
- 46:59They do know during the interview, the interviewer, I think the interviewer's
- 47:04name was Jarecki or something like that, has to take a break. Yes,
- 47:07this is at the very end, and he's just what mumbling underneath this
- 47:10breath, the assholes still Mike. I think he goes to the bathroom.
- 47:15You can barely hear him. But that didn't mean no one hurt him because
- 47:20he had a hot Mike and as lawyer promptly walked out to him and told
- 47:25him, you're you know, they just started everything you said, and Robert
- 47:30starts to say something like what he said was harmless, and he said,
- 47:36did not tell the whole truth. Nobody tells the whole truth. And that
- 47:38same interview, Robert was asked the following do you have anything to do with
- 47:42the death of your wife? He said, I don't know that she's dead,
- 47:45Okay, yeah, and then he was asked, do you think that
- 47:49it's possible she's alive now? And he said it's possible, but not likely.
- 47:52With the help of Susan's stepson, Jarecki, was able to produce a
- 47:58letter written by Robert had the exact same misspelling of Beverly like the Beverly Hills
- 48:05letter from like the cadaver letter. Not to mention the handwriting was uncanny ly
- 48:13similar to that tip. So Direcki said, Hey, do you want to
- 48:17have another interview Robert? And He's like, yes, absolutely, of course
- 48:21I would, because I'm a narcissist. So Direci brought out both the letters
- 48:25and confronted Robert with the similarities. Robert had a hard time himself, started
- 48:31having some problems start burping uncontrollably as he answers answers the question. Once it's
- 48:37evident that he had no excuse for the similarities in the letter. They took
- 48:43an break. During the break, Robert then goes to the bathroom and he's
- 48:46got a hot mike once again. Yes, stuff, he's an idiot,
- 48:51and he says the following. There it is, you're caught. You're right,
- 48:54of course, but you can't imagine arrest him. I don't know it's
- 49:00in the house. Oh I want this. What a disaster. He was
- 49:02right, I was wrong. And the burping. I'm having difficulty with a
- 49:07question. What the hell did I do? Killed them all? Of course?
- 49:12What the fuck is that, Tanya? He killed them all of course.
- 49:15In the interview, he admits he's lied to the police about the night
- 49:19Kathy went missing. He said that he told the police he dropped her off
- 49:22the train station and you know, went to the neighbors. But you know
- 49:25that wasn't true. That was all. It was all bullshit. The day
- 49:29before the final documentary episode aired March fourteenth, twenty fifteen, Robert was arrested
- 49:34on a warrant charging him with the first degree murder of Susan Berman. He
- 49:38was charged in Louisiana with phony weapon possession and he was denied bail because he's
- 49:44a flight risk. He accepted a plea deal on the charges and was sentenced
- 49:47to seven years in prison. Then in November of twenty sixteen, he got
- 49:52transferred to Los Angeles County Dale to await trial for the murder of Susan.
- 49:55During questioning, he tells the prosecutor he was high on math when he was
- 50:00a host and agreed to the interview for the James Really the next year,
- 50:07Cathy was declared legally dead at the request for a family. The trial for
- 50:10Susan's murder began on March for twenty twenty, but, as we know,
- 50:15because of COVID, it got halted for fourteen months in May of twenty twenty
- 50:19one. The case resumed on September seventeenth. It took the jury three days
- 50:24and they found him guilty the first degree murder of Susan, as well as
- 50:28lying in wait and killing a witness. Less than a month later, the
- 50:31Los Angeles judge sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parl That
- 50:37same month, the Westchester County, New York DA's office announced that a grand
- 50:43jury would be impaneled to hear witness testimony and evidence in Cathy's disappearance. In
- 50:49late October, Robert Tessapasit for COVID name his hospitalized. They didn't think he'd
- 50:53lived through the indictment, so the state investigator, believing Robert may not live
- 50:59enough to be indicted long enough to be indicted, fouled a criminal complaint charging
- 51:02him with Kathy's death. On November first, twenty twenty one, Robert was
- 51:07indicted. He was by the Westchester County Grand jury on second green murder charges
- 51:14of Kathy, and he was a waiting trial, that is until he went
- 51:19into cardiac rest in California, San Joaquin General Hospital and died on January tenth.
- 51:24That's a shame. Twenty twenty two. Wow, this story is.
- 51:28It's so crazy. That's why everybody tells it because it's fucking nuts. It's
- 51:34nuts. He was nuts, clearly, clearly. Well, thanks to Leah,
- 51:37thanks Tanya, and thanks Tara for helping us with this one. And
- 51:42if you'd like to take over, Tan, you go ahead. If you
- 51:45would like to see more and I see our sources, you can go to
- 51:49our website Crimes and Consequences dot com. You can find that information there about
- 51:52becoming a Patreon member. And becoming a Patreon member you get our weekly episodes,
- 51:58add free and early release. You can go to patreon dot com slash
- 52:01t nt crimes also to sign up, and if you listen to us on
- 52:06your Apple podcast app, you can sign up there as well. They're the
- 52:09same episodes, and what you get by becoming a patren member or an Apple
- 52:14subscriber is you get another weekly episode besides the ones week release and the weekly
- 52:20one. Like I said, ad free an early release. Yeah. You
- 52:22can find us on social media at Hardcore True Crime on Instagram and Facebook.
- 52:28And I think that's it all right until our next episode. Don't kill each
- 52:31other and do please don't do this weird shit. Yeah, thank you,
- 52:36you're welcome. Bye,