Latest / Rewire To Rise– Beyond The Mindset / AI & The Human Future | Episode 5: AI & BEAUTY (Live Panel)
Transcript
- 0:00I'm the host of Rewired to Rise. Today we are here to for another
- 0:04edition of AI and the Human Future, this time exploring AI
- 0:09and beauty. What I'm interested to tackle in
- 0:13the what happens to us today is what happens to us when
- 0:17technology starts participating in how we define beauty, how we
- 0:22see ourselves and what we compare ourselves to, and
- 0:27ultimately what we still recognize, recognize as human.
- 0:33And that's why I brought together 3 very different
- 0:36perspectives today. But before we meet our guests,
- 0:40just a couple of quick logistics.
- 0:43I would like you to if you would like to receive the slides,
- 0:47articles, tools and additional resources shared by today's
- 0:51speakers, make sure you register today at Mirella buccanet dot
- 0:57Mailer page dot IO. You can find it also the link in
- 1:03the comments section. This is important because if you
- 1:08don't register, you won't receive the goodie bag after the
- 1:12live. The registrations also give you
- 1:15access to the wider Rewire to Rise ecosystem where the
- 1:20conversation doesn't have to end when today's life ends.
- 1:24Meaning you will be able to explore the interactive Tech
- 1:28guide Master class Co created by Mark Sinclair, Fleeton and I and
- 1:34me. Where you can practice things
- 1:37like prompt engineering as a strategic leadership discipline.
- 1:41Learn how to reduce cognitive depth and AI hallucinations and
- 1:47use practical tools such as the Hallucination Checklist,
- 1:52Accountability Stack, and the Challenge the Bot.
- 1:55You can also join the community in the Interactive Temp Guide
- 2:00connected by connecting with the other experts, leaders and
- 2:05entrepreneurs and explore our deeper research based
- 2:10perspective articles at Interactive dot AI Dash Portal
- 2:15and dot DK. Again, you can find the link
- 2:18also in the comments section. So if some something you hear
- 2:23today makes you curious, there is somewhere to connect
- 2:28exploring it. Now let's meet the three persons
- 2:31who are going to help us look at beauty from three very different
- 2:37angles today. So let's welcome to Torsten to
- 2:44use. Sorry, hello used.
- 2:49Hello Umarella and. The floor is yours.
- 2:52I'm going to lead you to your presentation.
- 2:55Thank you so much and thank you for choosing a beautiful subject
- 3:00for today. So to to kick off today's
- 3:07session, I'd like to ask the question if beauty can be
- 3:12computed. So we could also ask this
- 3:15question as if AI could rate 10,000 faces, what would it
- 3:20learn? Yeah.
- 3:22And before I answer that question, I'd like sort of to
- 3:28introduce myself a little bit on this topic because because I'm
- 3:32not a beautician. I'm a professor at the
- 3:36Copenhagen Academy of Business where I teach e-commerce.
- 3:40So when I talk about beauty, this is in the context of
- 3:45design. I teach my students how to make
- 3:49beautiful websites. And when I'm looking at beauty
- 3:54is therefore mostly at the point of view from design where we
- 3:59say, you know, that that something should be functional.
- 4:01You know, it should also be aesthetically pleasing.
- 4:04And if it it fulfils those two criterias, then we we typically
- 4:07tend to say it's good design. Yet what I've found consistently
- 4:11over the past decades is that when I asked my students at the
- 4:17two bachelor's degrees of ecommerce style teach to
- 4:20evaluate whether a home page is beautiful, I always find them
- 4:24falling back to functionality. So they ended up evaluating the
- 4:31other aspect, the functional, the logical aspect, rather than
- 4:34the emotional, the aesthetic aspect that is beauty.
- 4:40And I wonder why that is. And my short answer, the answer
- 4:46that I sort of come up with in my dialogue with them in my
- 4:49teachings over the past 310 years is simply because they,
- 4:53they lack a checklist for it. They're afraid that beauty is a
- 5:00question that is difficult to answer, that it's something that
- 5:04is subjective. Yet fortunately now in the year
- 5:082026, we have the power of AI with us and maybe, maybe we can
- 5:15put something on a formula that will find out what a beautiful
- 5:20face is. Let's see, I tried to change the
- 5:26slides there. So but, you know, but the
- 5:29question is basically here is that there is a point of view
- 5:33about beauty, that beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
- 5:37And that means that, you know, my definition of beauty is a
- 5:43unique one for me and basically what I constitute as beautiful.
- 5:47But basically that is a reflection of who I am.
- 5:51Yeah. And maybe not as much of any
- 5:55objective standards of beauty. And for years, for decades, for
- 6:00centuries, there has been writers, there's been
- 6:02philosophers, we'll come to those later in my presentation
- 6:05that are trying to say, can we make a universal law for what
- 6:08beauty is? 1 formula that works for
- 6:12everything. And, and the short answer from,
- 6:15you know, the the past endeavours is that we can't, we
- 6:21can't find a universal law and yet we can find shared patterns.
- 6:27So beauty is not a question of sort of just personal taste
- 6:31where sort of I have a view of what's beautiful, Marella has a
- 6:34view of what is beautiful, Core has a view of what's beautiful.
- 6:38And, you know, all three of our views are, are correct.
- 6:42There is something more than that.
- 6:44There are some shared patterns that exist within groups that
- 6:48exist across from groups. So basically, so you might say
- 6:52the beholder has a type. Yeah.
- 6:56And so does the crowd. And when we try to measure sort
- 7:02of what are some of these shared patterns, we come to things like
- 7:08proportions, symmetry, average Ness.
- 7:13There's one of sort of the the interesting findings.
- 7:15The more we look like other people, apparently the more
- 7:18attractive we, we seem, or rather sort of the more we lack
- 7:23unique and distinguishing features.
- 7:26Some studies tend to show that this is rated as more
- 7:29attractive. But then again, then again, we
- 7:34still come back to this thing that if you ask the question
- 7:37sort of on a, on a, on a, on a, on a scale from one to 10, you
- 7:41know, how would you, how would you rate this?
- 7:44Any answer that we get is basically, again, a person sort
- 7:48of trying to compute that scale and his or her individual
- 7:53understanding of beauty into something that's more
- 7:56operational. That could be some of the three
- 7:59things that the research supports.
- 8:03It could also be something entirely different.
- 8:08One of the things that has a great PR team, but not that much
- 8:14of sort of hard evidence supporting it is the golden
- 8:18ratio. There's been claims that when we
- 8:23have something, an image, a face that shows the, the scale of 1
- 8:29to 1.618, then that is viewed as beautiful.
- 8:35And yet sort of, you know, the evidence that supports this,
- 8:38this is a ratio. You can find it in the number,
- 8:40number of sort of very, very famous paintings and you can
- 8:47find it in, in, in famous photographies.
- 8:51And yet sort of when we look at sort of the hard evidence of of
- 8:55this scale, it's, it's not really there.
- 8:57So some of these things by saying, you know, we have, we
- 9:01have sort of strict rules about how we can compute beauty.
- 9:06They don't seem to to hold up. Sorry.
- 9:09A great example of that is the golden spiral.
- 9:12And this is a idea that is based on the golden ratio that says
- 9:17sort of if you if you put it into different sort of paintings
- 9:24like the Great wave painting from from Japan or the creation
- 9:30of Adam from the Renaissance period in Italy, well, you know,
- 9:35then then we can find the golden ratio there.
- 9:39But then again, the questions pops up, is this just because
- 9:42sort of we're trying to add it later that we find it here?
- 9:45Or is it because it's something that we as humans perceive as
- 9:50beautiful? And I mean, yet I could easily
- 9:53go to an art college here in Europe and I could find art
- 9:56students. They're being taught that, you
- 9:57know, if you paint according to the golden ratio, you create
- 10:00something that's beautiful. There's very weak evidence that
- 10:04is actually true. And yet sort of it's one of the
- 10:07things that in lack of of better seem to be taught.
- 10:13What we, however, do find is that the average face gets an
- 10:20above average rating. Yeah.
- 10:23And by average here, what we mean is a lack of sort of odd or
- 10:29strange features. So the more sort of we have a
- 10:34face that, you know, doesn't stick out from the crowd, well,
- 10:39the higher the rating is. And Mona Lisa is actually maybe
- 10:43an example of that, that this is sort of every woman in the sense
- 10:48that she looks kind of, you know, just like everybody else.
- 10:53There's nothing really distinguishing.
- 10:54Is it a smile? Is it not really a smile?
- 10:56Who knows? And for that reason, sort of it
- 10:59carries a greater appeal. So that's something that there
- 11:03seems to be evidence supporting that we like things that look
- 11:07like the rest of it. Symmetry is also a factor.
- 11:12So the basic idea sort of a beautiful face is 1, where the
- 11:16left side will match the right side.
- 11:20But it's just one factor out of many and it doesn't seem, it
- 11:26doesn't seem to really sort of be the be all and end all.
- 11:29You can have symmetrity, but if you don't have some other things
- 11:32that sort of stick out, then symmetrity doesn't really
- 11:35matter. If I have odd ears, well, you
- 11:38know, my ears look odd and doesn't matter.
- 11:40They don't become beautiful by being odd in exactly the same
- 11:42way, so to speak. And then sort of, you know, we
- 11:48can talk about sort of, you know, what what is, is shared
- 11:53across cultures and what doesn't seem to be shared across
- 11:57cultures. The the idea of the average face
- 12:00that seems to be shared across cultures.
- 12:04Some sex typical features seem to be shared across cultures,
- 12:11specifically for women. Actually, a feminine round face
- 12:15seems to be attractive in all cultures.
- 12:17And yet sort of different cultures have different views on
- 12:20whether it's sort of a strong jawbone in a man is beautiful or
- 12:24not. You can get different studies
- 12:26pointing in different directions.
- 12:29Perceived health, however, sort of somebody that looks healthy,
- 12:33that is a shared tendency. We, we do tend to, you know,
- 12:37view being healthy as being being beautiful.
- 12:40But you know, across cultures, you know, what's the ideal age
- 12:46that seems to be very different, what skin tone you should have.
- 12:49That is also a question of what group you're addressing.
- 12:54And a lot of sort of symbols like a beard, you know, that
- 12:58carries widely different interpretations in different
- 13:01groups. So there are some things that
- 13:05seem to be common across all cultures, a very few things.
- 13:11And then when I go into a, a book describing, you know, good
- 13:16design, which again, is where I typically look to find aesthetic
- 13:20ideals, I always have to sort of check how much of this is, is
- 13:24cultural bias, because that is also a lot.
- 13:31And you know, as typically I'm in these, in these sort of
- 13:34Sunday afternoons that we, we share together, those of you
- 13:38that have heard me fall know that I like to blame a German
- 13:41philosopher every time. And this time I'll blame Guter.
- 13:44Guter had the idea that we could get sort of fixed ideas and
- 13:51association out of colours, as if sort of he, there should be
- 13:56universal laws for that. And his approach was basically
- 13:59to say, you know, I'll, I'll write them.
- 14:01And now that I've written them, then people can learn them.
- 14:03And then we can all agree that that's that.
- 14:05And yet what we find is that colour, even within a language,
- 14:12the meaning that a colour carries can vary widely and
- 14:16across national cultures varies greatly.
- 14:20I mean, white has one meaning in, in, in Europe, another in
- 14:26Asia and a third in the United States.
- 14:29And something like, you know, what colour is traditionally
- 14:34associated with with men and women.
- 14:36I mean, let's ask the Germans where they say that pink is the
- 14:39most masculine colour that there ever was, which I believe is, is
- 14:44some of the parts that give rise to the, the joke about the gay
- 14:47Germans. But that's, you know, not how
- 14:49they see it. They see that nothing is as
- 14:51feminine as a blue colour and nothing is as masculine as a
- 14:57pink colour. So this is also something, the
- 15:02colour association that changes over time.
- 15:04It's, it's not stable. The association of, of, of pink
- 15:08and blue in, in Germanic societies seem to be sort of
- 15:13fairly recent as in the last 300 years.
- 15:17And right now sort of we're undergoing an unprecedented
- 15:22degree of global globalization. So maybe that will change in
- 15:25Germany, maybe if we talk about beauty.
- 15:30Then there's also the subject of an ideal that I'd like to talk
- 15:35about sort of this thing that we can make ideal body types.
- 15:39And we have to remember sort of, you know, that we've, we've
- 15:45always sort of, you know, had this thing with, with putting up
- 15:52high expectations for the most beautiful or most attractive.
- 15:57And then taking it to the extreme.
- 15:59I mean, you can find that even sort of in ancient figures from
- 16:04some of the early civilizations in, in, in Europe and in Asia,
- 16:08where sort of they have gendered figures that are
- 16:12disproportionately large in, in certain aspects.
- 16:17And I think, you know, today we have the example of Barbie where
- 16:22you can easily find an article online saying that that Barbie
- 16:26has created totally unrealistic standards for female beauty.
- 16:30And, you know, this is part of the patriarchy and so on and so
- 16:34forth, which I always like to say, well, you know, have you
- 16:37thought of female? So Barbie was was not, was not
- 16:40alone. So I mean, in terms of sort of
- 16:43toys that children play with, there is some, let's say,
- 16:51idealised, maybe even unrealistic standards that are
- 16:53being set there. But what's interesting is how
- 16:56did we get to the He Man action figure or the Barbie doll?
- 17:00Well, we got there because these were the figures that sold the
- 17:05best. Yeah.
- 17:08So much like, you know, that my fine colleagues A kilometre
- 17:14north of me at Nordic, they say that we have a diabetes epidemic
- 17:19in, in the world because we have too much access to too much
- 17:23great food and then too much sugar and therefore we can't
- 17:26help ourselves. Well, you know, there seems to
- 17:27be, psychologically speaking, a tendency for us humans to, to
- 17:31seek out these, these figures. And, and there's been studies,
- 17:36there's been studies that where you, you give children sort of a
- 17:40choice between sort of regular action figures or will regular
- 17:43in the sense, you know, that the, the bodies are not that
- 17:46disproportionate. You know, the muscles are not
- 17:49that great for the male Latin figures.
- 17:51The, the waist is not that thin for the, for the female doll.
- 17:56Then they prefer the idealist version.
- 17:59They prefer the extreme version. And they see that this extreme,
- 18:02you ask children, you know, playing with these dolls or
- 18:05these action figures, you know, isn't this something that's, you
- 18:09know, out of the norm? And they say, yes, yes, of
- 18:12course it is. And yet sort of, you know, they
- 18:16know this and they still choose them.
- 18:18And when you then ask them afterwards how they feel about
- 18:21their own body, you can also see a difference there.
- 18:25They're less satisfied. So we have this thing about
- 18:28seeking the ideals. Yeah.
- 18:31And the the whole thing of idealisation, that is, that is
- 18:36older than AI. Yeah.
- 18:39But I think sort of, you know, we've always, we've always faked
- 18:42perfection. Yeah, but The thing is that in
- 18:45the age of AI, well, you know, we automated production because
- 18:50we used to have sort of this thing with art, you know, that
- 18:53we had a few artists and it took time to to create it.
- 18:58Then we got into the mass media age, but there were still
- 19:00professional gatekeepers there. And now we've generative AI.
- 19:04Anybody, anybody can can make a idealised picture.
- 19:11And I mean, if you're, if you're watching this, most likely you
- 19:15saw an idolised picture of me in one of the ads that Mirela was
- 19:21so kind to make, because it's, it's fairly easy and it's fairly
- 19:24quick to do so. Yeah.
- 19:27And we've gone very quickly from sort of admiring others to
- 19:32editing ourselves. So we, we come sort of to this
- 19:38position that we used to, to, to chase the ideal, but now we can
- 19:42wear it. If I want a better profile
- 19:44picture of myself on, on a LinkedIn page or on the company
- 19:47website, it's just a prompt away.
- 19:52If some people, you know, even in their, their phone apps or in
- 19:56the camera app, they, they have a little button where they can
- 19:59press and say, tune up this picture.
- 20:02Or I think, you know, another fairpoint would be on on on
- 20:06podcasts like this, you know? There are also filters there to
- 20:10make sure that eyes aren't too flaky or, you know, that
- 20:13background noise is suppressed. And, and how far away are we
- 20:16then from sort of getting the voice of tune up or removing the
- 20:19earths And that that's disrupt. We're watching an
- 20:23industrialisation of, of idealisation, if you ask me.
- 20:27And we have to ask the question sort of at what point does our
- 20:33synthetic stuff then begin to feel like, you know, the, the
- 20:37real one? We used to have sort of this
- 20:39situation when, you know, we are physical selves.
- 20:42We, we, you know, had our, our little group and, and that was,
- 20:46you know, within the group. That was who we are.
- 20:48And, and then we became sort of a public self on, on, on
- 20:51Facebook, you know, we can shout out to the whole world and we
- 20:53can get enormous amounts of validation if we so desire.
- 20:58Yeah. And now we can shout out to an
- 21:01AI that can come back and create the best looking version of
- 21:09myself that never existed. Yeah.
- 21:13And I think the interesting part here is what does the filter
- 21:17then think is beautiful? Obviously, sort of, you know,
- 21:20it's a programme. It doesn't have independent
- 21:23font. So, you know, but what from its
- 21:25training sort of survived into that.
- 21:28And there are some studies that show these filters, what they
- 21:31typically do is they make you look younger, they give you
- 21:34fuller lips, they give you larger eyes and more narrow
- 21:38face, smoother skin. And that's sort of, you know,
- 21:45one of the interesting things that we have to think about that
- 21:48we're basically, we're, we're very sort of rapidly approaching
- 21:52a phase where AI is computing beauty and it is computing out
- 21:58of sort of, you know, the pictures that are the most liked
- 22:01and, and, and so on and and so forth.
- 22:05But you know, we always, I think we find ourselves in a situation
- 22:14where when, when a filter comes out with, with, with, with
- 22:16something, or you ask, you know, if an AI to tune a picture,
- 22:20Well, what changes were you specifically asking for and, and
- 22:24what was sort of automated for you?
- 22:27And I think the important aspect here is the control aspects.
- 22:31So, you know, we also see, and I touched upon this point the more
- 22:38or less every time we've had this Sunday podcast that we see
- 22:46a, a globalisation in hyperdrive right now with AI, because AI
- 22:51is, is, is very quickly coming in and sort of being used in a
- 23:02lot of sort of advertisement and a lot of filters.
- 23:05And the AI is trained on what data typically American, though,
- 23:10you know, there are a significant number of Chinese
- 23:13bots there. So what is the filter that we're
- 23:21basically sort of being being pushed on and how would that fit
- 23:24to say a Danish ideal of, of beauty or an Italian ideal of
- 23:28beauty or a French ideal of beauty?
- 23:31Does that just become sort of error in the modern
- 23:36globalization? And when we don't have sort of,
- 23:42you know, this ideal that's looking back at us, is that then
- 23:48sort of where we were then sort of getting into a situation
- 23:52where we're learning beauty from the filter that we applied to
- 23:58ourselves. One sort of fascinating term
- 24:04that I've I've I've I've picked on up on is, is the idea of
- 24:11that. I thought, well, the concept
- 24:13rate really that some plastic surgeons in London, they
- 24:17reported that, you know, they used to have people who would
- 24:19come to them and say, you know, make me look more like a famous
- 24:23person, make me look more like Susan Sarandon or Mel Gibson or
- 24:28something like that. They don't do that anymore.
- 24:32Now they come with a picture that their Instagram filter has
- 24:37produced and say, make me look more like that.
- 24:42Of course, sort of, you know, this, it's something that's only
- 24:45happened a couple of times, but still, I think it's, it's
- 24:48something that is that might be a sign of things to come and to
- 24:54take that further and explore that.
- 24:55I think this is where I hand the torch on to our core and then to
- 25:00Torsten. Isn't that right, Marella?
- 25:07Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
- 25:10I appreciate it. So let's go further with the
- 25:16next speaker, which is Kerr. Hello, Kerr, and welcome.
- 25:20So nice to have you here again. Hello Melilla, always a pleasure
- 25:25and and I mean used has already given a good perspective and I
- 25:32will I will continue and and and on top with with mine.
- 25:37Definitely, I'm sure of it. The floor is yours.
- 25:40Thank you. Just a second.
- 25:53So is my presentation on. It should be, it seems so I will
- 26:07start out from the perspective that started out with digital
- 26:14possibilities of using filters to well improve appearance or
- 26:22however we we put it and and nowadays we can actually use a
- 26:27generator to compute it all from well from scratch without even
- 26:34without even baseline starting out, we started out in the way
- 26:46that the camera would take a picture.
- 26:50We might have possibility with better lighting or with makeup
- 26:56or with other effects to, well, improve the appearance, so to
- 27:01speak. And little by little we got to
- 27:05the point where it was possible to edit digital photos using
- 27:10Photoshop or similar software. Little by little it became
- 27:16easier to do using filters on social media and and little by
- 27:23little it's harder and harder to really trust the the picture.
- 27:30It starts out from something, but it can end up going quite
- 27:34far from that something. And in this age of AI, we have
- 27:40come quite far. And when we go down that path,
- 27:52we start to really invent pixels that were never there.
- 27:58We start to step away from the photo that was the starting
- 28:02point. And, and that means that
- 28:09nowadays if I want to make a different profile picture on on
- 28:16on social media, just to take that example, I can create it
- 28:21all from scratch. It doesn't even need a, a photo
- 28:25of of me. I might be better off using a
- 28:28photo of me because if people meet me face to face afterwards,
- 28:32well, I think they should recognize that person.
- 28:36But it is possible to to make it totally computer generated and
- 28:43and of course these services are trained on what is there already
- 28:49in abundance and photos of beautiful people or pleasing
- 28:55characteristics, whatever you call it, are there in abundance.
- 28:59There will often be much more photos of young and beautiful
- 29:03people then of people who are not that young and not that
- 29:08beautiful, whatever definition we we use on on the beauty.
- 29:16So really, nowadays we can create this.
- 29:26The machine already knows pictures, it already recognizes
- 29:30pictures, it already knows what it has more most most pictures
- 29:37of already. It knows what is best perceived.
- 29:41There might be differences from one country to another, from one
- 29:46culture to another, but it little by little also starts to
- 29:50get to know the user, gets to know the the user's preference.
- 29:55So I mean, we are far away from the original biology.
- 30:01There is really no before this point.
- 30:05So it is created all from scratch.
- 30:08It is created well. Some would say that it's an
- 30:13average of a lot of images, some would say that it's the
- 30:17preferred image. Some would put it in other ways.
- 30:21But at least it need not have anything to do with what the
- 30:26person using these machines actually looks like.
- 30:33And much of it has to do with the median or the average use
- 30:41was also down this path. And I mean, some of it is
- 30:45really, really comes down to a very basic human behaviour.
- 30:53I mean, if the, the purpose of a human is to reproduce, get
- 30:59children, you would choose a life partner who has a good
- 31:04genes to pass on. And, and if there are illnesses,
- 31:09you would try to avoid those. If there are other features that
- 31:14wouldn't be beneficial for, for the child, you would try to stay
- 31:18away from that. And, and we're kind of of, of
- 31:23biologically programmed to go for in this case, the face that
- 31:30has a symmetry, the face that is close to, to, to, to the median.
- 31:37And of course the, the, the machines can reproduce
- 31:42appearances down that path. So we're quite far away from,
- 31:51well, the starting point, so to speak, which brings me to this
- 31:56shifting baseline. Because if we see too many
- 32:03artificially generated images that are, well, median, some
- 32:11would call them beautiful. They would have very little
- 32:19biological friction, little asymmetry, little texture,
- 32:23little other defects or whatever use word we use for it, then it
- 32:32it can calculate that, but it will really end up bypassing
- 32:38that knowledge about what humans generally do look like, what is
- 32:45a a much more likely appearance of a person.
- 32:50And I think the more we are aware of this, the more we can
- 32:54navigate in a world where we cannot any longer trust images
- 33:01that that are artificially generated.
- 33:07And that also means that the better we understand this loop
- 33:13that I have sketched out in the right hand side, the better we
- 33:17understand what is actually happening here.
- 33:20Because if AI generates these synthetic images and those are
- 33:25part of the training data sets, which will mean that new models
- 33:30will train on those synthetic data, which means that they will
- 33:36output images that way, then we really, but just get back to,
- 33:40to, to that loop. So it's important that we feed
- 33:44in new data in order to still be true about what humans actually
- 33:50do look like and what each of us looks like with the, with all
- 33:54the variety and and and and so on, in order to still well
- 34:01recognize an actual human, appreciate the looks of an, an,
- 34:05an actual human, which is not a computer generated.
- 34:12From my point of view, there is a lot of value to the friction.
- 34:16It doesn't only go with appearance, but it definitely
- 34:19also does go with appearance. It's much easier to remember
- 34:23face with, with features. It's much easier to remember
- 34:29body or an appearance with the with with feature.
- 34:32Of course it's also about personality.
- 34:34Of course, it's also about a lot of things.
- 34:37I mean, the way we walk in there and and and so on.
- 34:40So the more we succeed in introducing that friction, the
- 34:47more interesting it really becomes.
- 34:53There can be good reasons for having wrinkles.
- 34:55I mean, it has also a sign of a of a lived life and, and, and,
- 34:59and hopefully experience picked up along the way.
- 35:03There can be good reasons for scars in our skin gotten by by
- 35:11well, the lived life and and and whatever we we experienced down
- 35:15the lake the the way. And that means that I would
- 35:23suggest that we do our very best to preserve this human
- 35:30fingerprint. We should not just accept that
- 35:34this bottle that I was showing earlier with the the artificial
- 35:38data going back into the system and really just enhancing that.
- 35:43The more we can add new data, the more we can actually still
- 35:47understand what humans look like, the more we can expose
- 35:51these hidden pipes, the more we can actually design systems that
- 35:56still have diversity. It is still about people being
- 36:01tall, or not so tall or thin, or not so thin, or have different
- 36:07colours of the skin or have different features.
- 36:10I really enjoy that variety and I really hope that we can
- 36:14preserve that variety also in what we are presented with from
- 36:19these artificial systems. And it is possible, I'm
- 36:23perfectly sure I, I'm, I'm quite sure that there is also a market
- 36:27for it, that there is really also demand for it when we are
- 36:32clear about asking for for that from the system providers.
- 36:39And this brings me to this pivotal question.
- 36:46I think that the scientific beauty created by the machines
- 36:52is really cheap is it is infinite and it is
- 36:56indistinguishable from the the the real world how how humans
- 37:02actually does look. So it is about stepping away
- 37:06from the pixels. It is about stepping out in the
- 37:09real world, meeting actual people, taking actual photos
- 37:13without enhancing and retouching and everything.
- 37:17And I hope this builds on top of what Yust was already
- 37:22presenting. And I hope it delivers a good
- 37:25bridge to the very interesting things that I'm sure we will
- 37:29hear from from Torsten in just a few minutes.
- 37:35So thank you for your time and thank you for for the
- 37:39opportunity to to present. Thank you so much, Paul.
- 37:41Thank. You OK?
- 37:47So now let's go to our last guest.
- 37:53Hello and welcome. Well, hello Mirella, and thank
- 37:57you again to let me in the studio here and to talk a little
- 38:03bit in my beautiful English with my grammar.
- 38:07You're going to do fine, I'm sure, like.
- 38:10Always. Yeah, I hope so.
- 38:11Always learn so. Like.
- 38:13It as an exercise, you know that.
- 38:17Exactly. Well then so I will all the
- 38:20space that you need. So please, I don't think so.
- 38:25I will start to my presentation here.
- 38:44Yes. OK, now.
- 38:54Yes, 0220. Well, hello everybody.
- 39:01Yeah, well, I want to talk about beauty from a slightly different
- 39:07angle from the two hours. I hope so.
- 39:12Well, not about beauty as perfection, not beauty as
- 39:21symmetry. I think so, yes.
- 39:24And not only beauty as something we see.
- 39:32Yes. See, now I want to talk about
- 39:37beauty as something we we actually recognise something
- 39:43that carries a piece of us. And for me, the, the, the
- 39:53interesting question is not only can make can AI make something
- 39:58beautiful? Of course I can.
- 40:00You already hear that from Houston Carhair, and we all can
- 40:06see it. Clear that can the more well,
- 40:17the more it's the interesting question for me here is what
- 40:24happens to the human being inside the beauty we create?
- 40:32What does what what what happens?
- 40:36Yes. So I now need the slide too.
- 40:40I just I just thought that's my that's that's me.
- 40:45Well, then I should start. Well, a few a few weeks ago I
- 40:54was in my workshop and I opened some old boxes and sites.
- 41:07There were films I had made, made for many years ago, stuff
- 41:12and and and and and stuff like this, small handmade objects or
- 41:21pictures, pieces of my own history.
- 41:28And then I looked at them and something happened.
- 41:36Well, I did not only see the objects, I remembered where I
- 41:42was when I made them. I remembered people, places and
- 41:51situations. Well then, yes And yeah, here is
- 41:58this. I want to well, let me show you
- 42:03something. I hope you all can see this.
- 42:09Yes, I made this many years ago with a tattoo artist from
- 42:16Flintsburg called Turdipete. Well, he also also taught me to
- 42:24to, to, to tattoo. Yes.
- 42:29And we, we built this one, we bet this, this one ourselves.
- 42:38Well, and in a strange way could well, it could, I could call
- 42:48this our human image generator. So well, it could not create
- 42:58anything by itself, but it needed a human hand, a human eye
- 43:09practice, and another human being who wanted something
- 43:17individual on their own body. Well, the machine I just hooked
- 43:25up, it's, it's not beautiful. It's a shame to say this, but
- 43:33but what came through it could become beautiful for one
- 43:40particular person. When I found it again, I did not
- 43:55only see this strange little machine, I see a piece of my own
- 44:02life and sometimes in lives a human well.
- 44:17Well, sometimes in life the the the human history around it.
- 44:24If it gave sense. I hope so.
- 44:29Well, then I must go far for you.
- 44:33Yes. Oh, yes.
- 44:35Yes, yes, yes. Well, then I just talked about
- 44:40this one. No.
- 44:46Yes, sorry. Where we are now?
- 44:55The Tesla machine? Yes.
- 45:11Well, and this made me, well, this made me think about AI and
- 45:22beauty because today AI can create almost anything.
- 45:33Well, a perfect face and perfect photograph, perfect voice,
- 45:43perfect song and even more perfect version of ourselves and
- 45:57becoming very good at making things polished.
- 46:00We Polish everything so it looks good.
- 46:04This make us feel better. But again, this little machine,
- 46:13well, it reminds me of an important, important difference.
- 46:21The tool gave us the capacity and well, you mean the human.
- 46:30I gave it direction and the individual person who gets a
- 46:40tattoo give it meaning. So if everything I can do now or
- 46:52if everything now can make more beautiful, I think we should ask
- 46:59what what happens to the things were beautiful that were
- 47:06beautiful because they were our own.
- 47:13And sometimes beauty comes from the relationship.
- 47:25We, we, we. So we have with those things.
- 47:30It's made the beautiful in it, the beauty in it all.
- 47:47Well, then, yeah, I think our well, I work a lot with AI and I
- 48:01also wake, make, make music with it, with the AI.
- 48:08Well, I'm not a great singer. Well, actually that would be a
- 48:16very polite way to saying it. I should probably not sing in
- 48:22public, but I have stories, I have feelings and I have
- 48:31experience and sometimes I know I want to express something, but
- 48:42but I do not have the technical skill to create all the music by
- 48:47myself. And and AI gives me the access
- 48:53for for for this kind of form. I can put something into the
- 48:58system and sometimes when I hear the result, I think is that was
- 49:08that was what what I was trying to say exactly.
- 49:13For me, that was that that one, that was one thing is the
- 49:19beautiful possibilities of the AI.
- 49:24If you can give the people ways to express something, they would
- 49:32they well, it gave it will give people the way to express
- 49:38themselves in ways they couldn't do before.
- 49:43Yeah. So so that's a that's a very
- 49:46good thing. Well then yes, but there's also
- 49:55a different. We should notice the difference
- 49:59between help me make this or help me make that and make
- 50:05something beautiful. Because if it where where,
- 50:16because it because if I give too much away from me, the the
- 50:26result may be too impressive because it would take all this
- 50:32and and and make one beautiful polished surface of it.
- 50:38Very beautiful, very, very, very blacking.
- 50:43But but not me, Yes. Well, human beings, they are not
- 51:00average. No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
- 51:04We all look different. But but like like like Carl just
- 51:10said, the average in the middle and also you've talked about it.
- 51:19The middle is this that what we like?
- 51:21It's average, but it's still not the person we are our history.
- 51:31Why remove? I got a sky in my, in my, in my,
- 51:34in my forehead. And every time I take the sky
- 51:40away, why is it something wrong with me, something not right in
- 51:47my face? This is what I look like.
- 51:52And I look every time in my mirror every morning and then
- 51:55tell myself I'm a beautiful man. And then I go to the AI and make
- 52:01a picture of me and then it's gone.
- 52:03That's not me now I'm not beautiful anymore.
- 52:06I'm polished, yes, you know where.
- 52:16Where's the bottom years? Well then?
- 52:30Well, I did. That is why I think human
- 52:34judgment becomes very important if we look at us as a more
- 52:43polished version, beautiful kind of ourselves, Not because we
- 52:53always write with the with our perspectives.
- 53:01Maybe another one look at it and and it tells another story for
- 53:06them or maybe something it's better for for me, but not for
- 53:11them of other people, in fact, and so on.
- 53:18So, so this is a small human check you can use for well, just
- 53:30to say what happened, what happened to me before explaining
- 53:34it and what must not be lost on your Yeah, what might AI be over
- 53:43interpreting what this what that this is not the the right
- 53:53version of me, but or a better version of me.
- 53:58Well, you can use this as an instrument, not an Oracle.
- 54:01It's never Oracle in that fact, but but it's a help on the way.
- 54:08Well, and this last one now concludes my journey for now,
- 54:16that's more and the goodie bag you you can read about.
- 54:19It's very, very, very interesting.
- 54:22But for me, the question is not, again, can AAI make beauty?
- 54:28Of course it can. Of course it can.
- 54:31Well, my question is more again, AIAI help us create beauty
- 54:37without slowing it, slowly teaching us that beauty must
- 54:43look the same. And I can tell technology also
- 54:50support our expression without replacing our judgement.
- 54:55It's yeah, man, but but we can also.
- 55:01We can also. Oh, I lost it.
- 55:14Well, well, but, but for me it, it matters.
- 55:26Did did, Did the AI choose from me?
- 55:30Did I choose for myself? Did I change something I deeply
- 55:37want to change by myself but but not as I not as I am as a as a
- 55:45human but also create the the beauty for me but also for the
- 55:55other humans around me. But I don't think what are we
- 56:03making to who are we making this beautiful thing is for us or is
- 56:14it for whom? Well, I think this must be be be
- 56:22good for now and I just I just want to want to what to tell
- 56:40you. Thank you for now and Marella.
- 56:44Now you're. Welcome.
- 56:47So let's get all the speakers on the floor.
- 56:50Hopefully someone is here used and the hotel OK.
- 56:54It's here, thank God. Yes, it's like I never left
- 56:58Marella. That's such an honor, my dear
- 57:01guest. Well, guys, that we have lost
- 57:06for a while the car just for you to know, but hopefully he will
- 57:10be able to get in again. Just wanted to let you know.
- 57:15Yeah, but we can definitely go further with Q&A's.
- 57:20I actually have an interesting, very simple, but very
- 57:24interesting and powerful question from LinkedIn.
- 57:27Someone is asking, and this is for all of you guys, If you
- 57:31could protect one thing about human beauty in the age of AI,
- 57:35what would it be? Reality.
- 57:45What do you mean? Can you explore?
- 57:46Can you elaborate a tiny bit please from your perspective?
- 57:50Obviously. Well, well, to protect beauty
- 57:55from beauty, we, we, we, we, we, we may, we must, may just make
- 58:04it more real, more reality, not fake, but the reality like like,
- 58:10like I talked about more, more ourself, our history, our
- 58:17context too. So, well, like I'm, I'm a I'm a,
- 58:22I'm a soldier. And every time my my, my history
- 58:26confirmed as a, as a, as a content or not contact context,
- 58:33my scar up here, it's going to be very boreal.
- 58:37Like why? It's not me, it's just
- 58:42beautification, I call it. So we need a kind of reality
- 58:47filter. What?
- 58:51About you use. Yeah.
- 58:54Well, I mean, I think you know that as you know, Marilla, I
- 59:01think we live in an age where where the the old saying goes
- 59:05mirror, mirror on the wall, who has the highest rating of them?
- 59:10All right. And I think sort of, you know,
- 59:15that this, so I think that this question of, of beauty, what we
- 59:29have need to protect is, is basically that when we, when we
- 59:33do things like ratings or we, we have, we've had this chasing of,
- 59:37of beauty. You know, I think it's, it's
- 59:39deeply endeavoured in, embedded in, in what it means to be
- 59:41human, that we always chase ideals and, and ideas and
- 59:46extremes. And, and we've done so long
- 59:49before the age of AI. So what I think I wanted to to
- 59:55protect in the age of AI is, is not forgetting that this is a
- 1:00:00chase. Yeah.
- 1:00:02And that when you ask somebody to rate something on a scale,
- 1:00:06you know, of of 1 to 10 of what is beautiful.
- 1:00:08Well, the important part is asking the follow up question.
- 1:00:11How did you get to that rating? I mean, what do you base that on
- 1:00:14when you say this is A10 or A7 or not?
- 1:00:17Well, what is it that you're focusing on?
- 1:00:19And then? Sort of understand that as being
- 1:00:23that person's, you know, impromptu definition of beauty.
- 1:00:28And I think that's something that that's always been
- 1:00:29interesting to talk about. But I think in, in an age of,
- 1:00:33of, of, of AI where we get to the fast superficial answers
- 1:00:39really easily, I think, you know, as, as I, as core has
- 1:00:44pointed out many times, it's, it's important to remember to
- 1:00:47keep the friction there and ask the deeper questions.
- 1:00:51And, and that's what I'd like to protect.
- 1:00:53That's a great question, by the way.
- 1:00:55Yeah, I think so too. Again, as I mentioned just the
- 1:00:59the couple of minutes ago, very simple, but simple doesn't mean
- 1:01:02less important or in that sense actually when things are simple
- 1:01:08or even difficult to even answer or understand etcetera,
- 1:01:12etcetera. So thank you for this question.
- 1:01:16Well, at this point since Kerr is missing, I'm gonna answer if
- 1:01:20you don't mind guys. Well, for me in this case, it's
- 1:01:24my voice, my, my in every way, more precisely my
- 1:01:32distinctiveness, what distinguished me right as a
- 1:01:35person, as an individual. And what I mean by this because
- 1:01:41I mean, human beauty has never really been about perfection.
- 1:01:45Me guys and you, we have talked just before we get live, went
- 1:01:50live about this. So it's not about perfection.
- 1:01:54It's in the things that makes us reconnect, recognizable now as
- 1:01:59us, you know, as person again, as individual.
- 1:02:03So meaning our expressions, our imperfections, our even our
- 1:02:07background of history, even the way we change with time.
- 1:02:12That's too so AI can optimize almost everything nowadays
- 1:02:19aesthetically, right? But I don't want us to reach a
- 1:02:24point where in trying to become more beautiful, we slowly start
- 1:02:29looking, sounding or expressing ourselves more like everyone
- 1:02:34else. So we'll become like each one of
- 1:02:37us. We don't have that
- 1:02:39distinctiveness that I have mentioned all year on.
- 1:02:42You know, that's my point. So if I could protect one thing,
- 1:02:47I would be it will be our right to remain humans.
- 1:02:55You know, this thing like in that sense, you know,
- 1:02:59individuals without feeling that we constantly need to optimize
- 1:03:05ourselves because of this standard that society nowadays
- 1:03:09implies or ask or expect from us, you know, to be become to
- 1:03:14prevent ourselves or whatsoever. So this is kind of my answer to
- 1:03:19this question. Oh, here we go.
- 1:03:23Hello. Hello, I'm sorry for for
- 1:03:26leaving. I have been following along on
- 1:03:31YouTube so I'm fairly updated but there was technical issues.
- 1:03:35No problem. So we were just answering to a
- 1:03:39question from LinkedIn. I'm gonna say it out loud again
- 1:03:44so you can hear it. And if you want to, you can
- 1:03:46reply to it because we're already have done that.
- 1:03:51Someone says ask if you could protect one thing about human
- 1:03:54beauty in the age of AI, what would it be?
- 1:04:00The variety in short, I, I am so fascinated that people can have
- 1:04:07a variety of skin colours or a variety of different features.
- 1:04:11And I, I really think that is what makes the, the, the, the
- 1:04:15world so fascinating and so beautiful.
- 1:04:20And I've, I've, I appreciate a lot that that can be different
- 1:04:25ideals from, from one region to, to another.
- 1:04:29So, so the variety would, would be my preferred one.
- 1:04:34I could also talk about fiction. I already did that in the
- 1:04:37presentation. And of course there's a lot more
- 1:04:39to it, but I mean, AI has a tendency to to, to make us more
- 1:04:45equal. And I enjoy having the the
- 1:04:49variety. There is another question from
- 1:04:53LinkedIn. Someone says and ask AI can
- 1:04:57generate generate endless versions of beauty.
- 1:05:01But the deeper question is how that changes the way we define
- 1:05:06our authenticity, individuality, and what feels generally human.
- 1:05:16Yeah. And to, to, to take a lead on
- 1:05:19that one, then I think that's a, that's a great question, which,
- 1:05:22which may not be sort of totally boxed in to the concept of
- 1:05:30beauty, because I think it's a general question of, of
- 1:05:32artificial intelligence. And, and, and one of the things
- 1:05:36I actually as a professor or a lecturer that I like about this
- 1:05:40whole sort of to debate about AAI and artificial intelligence
- 1:05:45is that it forces us back to question what human intelligence
- 1:05:50is or should be. If an AI is basically sort of,
- 1:05:55you know, a bot sort of coming up with the statistical likely
- 1:05:59answers back and forth based on a calculation.
- 1:06:04And we say that mimics sort of, you know, the way that that we
- 1:06:07humans talk, you know, is that all that there really was or was
- 1:06:11there something more? And I think this is this is
- 1:06:14again with with beauty. I think this is this is the
- 1:06:19question that's also being presented to us here.
- 1:06:22What is human beauty then, really, I mean, Core touched a
- 1:06:27little bit upon it in in his statement with again, sort of,
- 1:06:31you know, and I know the some old philosophers that say, you
- 1:06:35know, that that when we what we think is desirable is is a
- 1:06:38question of of basically biologically choosing a suitable
- 1:06:42mate that will, you know, balance ourselves out and lead
- 1:06:46us more into the group that we seek to belong to.
- 1:06:48And maybe maybe that is our biological imperative.
- 1:06:52And yet sort of, I think in throughout human history, you
- 1:06:56can find many instances where that effect has not been that
- 1:07:00strong, where different things have occurred, right?
- 1:07:03Maybe for the better. And I think sort of an important
- 1:07:07part in this age is, is simply to remember to have that
- 1:07:09conversation and be informed by it.
- 1:07:12But. What are?
- 1:07:13I'm just curious to use from your perspective and point of
- 1:07:16view. What do you think?
- 1:07:18Maybe for the better things have changed in that sense.
- 1:07:22What do you mean by that? Can you elaborate a tiny bit?
- 1:07:27Bye. Well, I mean.
- 1:07:35Relationship and so forth. Yeah.
- 1:07:39Cool you go. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:07:41It seemed that I have some some connection problems.
- 1:07:46And I also think, I mean, if we meet another person for the
- 1:07:51first time, there will be a first impression.
- 1:07:53But if we establish some sort of relationship, there will be so
- 1:08:00much more true to that relationship.
- 1:08:02It is about appearance, it is about a common understanding, it
- 1:08:08is about respect. It is about so many other
- 1:08:10things. It is also about how people
- 1:08:15supplement each other. So, so I think that AI can
- 1:08:22create first impressions, but that sort of relationship over
- 1:08:26time has a different dynamic and, and there's a lot of beauty
- 1:08:31to, to, to having that sort of relationship over time.
- 1:08:37Well, at least if it's a good one.
- 1:08:40What about you, my dear? Yeah, well, here are some dogs
- 1:08:44barking, so I just hear the half of it, Yes.
- 1:08:49That one was was asking AI can generate endless version of
- 1:08:55beauty, but the deeper question is how that changes the way we
- 1:08:59define our authenticity, individuality and what feels
- 1:09:03generally human. As I experienced it the way when
- 1:09:13I when I see a picture or something made not even a
- 1:09:18picture but something else I made some most beautiful, It
- 1:09:22could be be essay, it could be something else.
- 1:09:29First it goes in into me and does something.
- 1:09:37Maybe I see the beauty in it, or maybe I just going to be blind
- 1:09:42beauty blind. I call this from from everything
- 1:09:47that's good. But what some kind of good
- 1:09:52polished. I need the, the rough, the raw,
- 1:09:57the raw beauty behind it So, so it can be more real for me to to
- 1:10:05to, to dive into it. So but it can make millions of
- 1:10:11yeah, entirely, all the time. Beautiful here, beautiful there.
- 1:10:19And we're going to be beauty, beauty blind.
- 1:10:22I see it so. Yeah, thank you.
- 1:10:25So I have another one, but it's more like a comment from
- 1:10:29LinkedIn. Still someone says I would be
- 1:10:32comfortable using AI to support decisions but not to make high
- 1:10:37impact decisions without humor review.
- 1:10:39The more a decision effects someone's opportunities,
- 1:10:42finances or well-being, the more important context of
- 1:10:46accountability and human judgment.
- 1:10:48Judgment. Jasmine, Jasmine become sorry
- 1:10:52about that. Yeah.
- 1:10:54Can you please tell me what do you think about this comment
- 1:10:58guys system LinkedIn? But at least from, from my point
- 1:11:04of view, I, I, I do understand the perspective, but I think
- 1:11:08that humans can also make awfully bad decisions.
- 1:11:13And humans can make decisions for reasons that are not
- 1:11:19balanced really. So I think there are actually
- 1:11:24situations where machines can make better decisions.
- 1:11:28Now there's an overall topic, but there are situations down
- 1:11:32that line, at least from where I see it.
- 1:11:35But this person also kind of says from my from my
- 1:11:39understanding, and I'm going to ask to you at this point, please
- 1:11:44do you still review what an AI replies to you, for example,
- 1:11:48just an example or you do not? I, I surely do.
- 1:11:52I mean yes, of of of course I do.
- 1:11:56And I, and I also search for different perspectives.
- 1:11:59So I, I, I enjoyed the, the, the human machine interaction.
- 1:12:03I, I benefit a lot from using the machine, but it's all based
- 1:12:08in collaboration with the, with the person.
- 1:12:11I think that there are situations where people will be
- 1:12:14limited in ways where machines can help us out.
- 1:12:17But of course there are also situations where machines might
- 1:12:21go down a wrong path. So I think it's a lot in the
- 1:12:27interaction really. I have a question produced from
- 1:12:34Facebook. Do you think AI could actually
- 1:12:37change what we find beautiful over time?
- 1:12:42I think it's, it's, it's already doing that.
- 1:12:47And I mean, I, I think Mark Sinclair, he also in the
- 1:12:52comments there asked the question of how we can prevent
- 1:12:54it. And, and I yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:12:59And I love that question. But but I think the the train
- 1:13:01has left the station on that one.
- 1:13:05So, so sorry about that. Just but, but where was I?
- 1:13:15Yeah. So I think it's a great
- 1:13:17question. And I think the train has left
- 1:13:19the station on that one, unfortunately.
- 1:13:20And and I see a parallel here to the homogisation within nations
- 1:13:26that have happened over the past century.
- 1:13:28I mean, even if you take a little country like Denmark, if
- 1:13:32we go 200 years back, there was no common way to spell Danish.
- 1:13:37That is a fairly recent invention.
- 1:13:39Everybody just wrote the way that, you know, they wanted to.
- 1:13:42Then we got a public school system.
- 1:13:44Then there was official standards for how to write
- 1:13:47different words down, and that then became the standard for
- 1:13:51writing Danish. There was still large regional
- 1:13:54variations in how it was spoken. Then in the 1950s, we got mass
- 1:13:59media and all of a sudden the regional dialects came under
- 1:14:03pressure. Now, Torsten, he can still speak
- 1:14:06Southern Atlantic in a very great way, but what about the
- 1:14:11next generation growing up there that is retrieving all of those
- 1:14:19media inputs to a much higher degree than ever before?
- 1:14:23And, and I think what we're seeing now is that the, the, the
- 1:14:27emphasis is no longer on cultural homogalisation, or
- 1:14:30maybe it still is because right now we have AI and to a small
- 1:14:36extent Chinese dominated AI and social media that is pressing
- 1:14:40their standards down on top of ours.
- 1:14:43So back to the old Rammstein song about that.
- 1:14:46We all live in America that and that's not a love song as as
- 1:14:51they sing, right? But I think there is a choice
- 1:14:55here. And I think the choice is, is
- 1:14:58unfortunately between whether we get into a situation of there
- 1:15:02being national AIS. There's been the recent Danish
- 1:15:05experiment with creating Mimna, which is an AI created
- 1:15:09exclusively on Danish language material.
- 1:15:12Now the researchers behind that, they find evidence that it
- 1:15:15actually performs as good at the top line models that have been
- 1:15:19trained in English and then subsequently learnt Danish when
- 1:15:22it comes to Danish language tests.
- 1:15:24Now what I mean by that is we seem to have a choice between
- 1:15:28global AI and national language based AIS.
- 1:15:34Both of them will increase homogisation.
- 1:15:36I think that's a given. But we may have a choice of
- 1:15:38whether we get the global homogisation or the national
- 1:15:42homogisation. And that's sort of the
- 1:15:44pessimistic answer that I'll leave you with there.
- 1:15:48I have a question from core. Yeah, it says core.
- 1:15:53Are you starting to compare? Are we starting to compare
- 1:15:57ourselves to something that was never human in the first place?
- 1:16:04That's a very good question. And I think in, in some aspects
- 1:16:11we and I think it's really not a new thing.
- 1:16:16I mean, in earlier days when, when, when, when we did not have
- 1:16:24cars compared to now where cars allow us to, to, to transport
- 1:16:29ourselves much more easily. Well, that is also a behavior
- 1:16:34that would not be possible for humans in, in earlier days.
- 1:16:39And I think that nowadays we are depending on on a lot of tools
- 1:16:44being IT computers, being IT, mobile phones, being IT, AI.
- 1:16:49And nowadays, and I cannot say that it's really good or bad it,
- 1:16:58it just seems to be a tendency. I think that awareness is very
- 1:17:03important in that aspect. I can say these for my own part,
- 1:17:07I use technology a lot. But this morning when I went
- 1:17:10singing in the church, that was not digital at all.
- 1:17:13And I enjoyed it so much. If I go out in nature or if I do
- 1:17:18other things that that really that I do because I am a human,
- 1:17:23I I try to balance out the the things, but but there are
- 1:17:27situations where we are dependent on technology, not
- 1:17:31only AII. Have a question for Touston?
- 1:17:37Ask Touston. If AI can make everything look
- 1:17:41perfect, could imperfection actually become more valuable?
- 1:17:46Oh, that's a huge one. That's powerful.
- 1:17:50So you toasting. Well, I say I'm, yeah, I just
- 1:17:55can say yes, imperfection. It is.
- 1:18:01It is a reality. It's not, it's not a lie.
- 1:18:07I'm imperfect. You and perfect.
- 1:18:09We all imperfect, but we also beautiful inside, outside for
- 1:18:17somebody. So at this point I would ask if
- 1:18:23I would be someone that doesn't really know you such but how a
- 1:18:29person can actually look inside and be more aware of the inner
- 1:18:34beauty rather rather than just paying so much more attention
- 1:18:39from the external point of view that means the aesthetic beauty
- 1:18:43how they can do so? Well, and if I if I look on the
- 1:18:49the pictures you have made for me, I look like when I eating
- 1:18:54small children at mornings and then nobody won't go to therapy
- 1:18:59or something like this. No, yes, again, we we all look
- 1:19:09like we do and we can also set a market or name on that or a
- 1:19:18professional or something who can lift it up what people see
- 1:19:23and but but to to make it more punished.
- 1:19:27I don't think so. No imperfection the way you
- 1:19:31still. Have another.
- 1:19:35Question for you before you ask that question, Mirela, just a
- 1:19:39comment to to Torsten. I mean the the concept of the
- 1:19:44perfect imperfection is designed meme that's been active there
- 1:19:49for the last decade now. So you know, whenever you go
- 1:19:53into Trustpilot, a 5.0 score there is really bad.
- 1:19:58It looks fake 4.94.7, something like that.
- 1:20:02If you want to fake that, that's where you should fake it.
- 1:20:05You should always leave. Small imperfections in there to
- 1:20:09make it seem more real, even though technology easily allows
- 1:20:14us to do something that would be a perfect tool.
- 1:20:18So, you know, just as a shout out, Torsten, I mean, within the
- 1:20:21sign theory, within webshop aesthetics.
- 1:20:27And I know we can probably debate whether webshops can
- 1:20:29truly be beautiful. I believe they can, but that's
- 1:20:32my that's my bias there speaking.
- 1:20:36The perfect imperfection is really a thing.
- 1:20:39But Marilla, your question? Yes, thank you.
- 1:20:43So it says use. If AI learns beauty from what
- 1:20:48already exists, does it risk making our idea of beauty narrow
- 1:20:54rather than broader? Definitely, definitely.
- 1:21:00I mean, and, and, and it, it risks making it narrow in two
- 1:21:04ways. One was, as I touched upon in,
- 1:21:07in, in sort of my last long winded answer, in a terms of, of
- 1:21:11globalization, where we get sort of one global unified idea of
- 1:21:16beauty, which will most likely be a combination of the American
- 1:21:19and Chinese beauty ideals, you know, because they are the
- 1:21:22majorities of the users on the Internet.
- 1:21:24So there we go. Or we get into a situation where
- 1:21:30the beauty ideals, they coalesce around national standards.
- 1:21:37But in both cases we end getting narrower choices and and the
- 1:21:42range becomes smaller. And maybe, as Torsten says, you
- 1:21:45know, this leads to a counter reaction where, you know,
- 1:21:51striking out in, in, in, in certain ways becomes even more
- 1:21:55popular. And I see, we see, we see
- 1:21:57elements of that new culture already today where, you know,
- 1:22:03there is a just a different level of, of diversity in the
- 1:22:07looks that young people are adopting then I would argue at
- 1:22:11any time before this in, in, in world history.
- 1:22:17Someone else wants to add something.
- 1:22:22So what is the risk? Making our ideal beauty narrow
- 1:22:25rather than broader? OK, I actually had the question
- 1:22:36for him, but I'm going to wait because do you hear me, Carl?
- 1:22:40Yes, I, I do, but I don't really know what to say.
- 1:22:44It's it's, it's a very interesting dialogue, but I'm
- 1:22:47going to. Can I ask you the question that
- 1:22:50it's actually for you? It asks, how do we protect our
- 1:22:56sense of what's real when synthetic beauty becomes almost
- 1:23:01impossible to recognize? I I think that it's really about
- 1:23:17making sure that we have the non digital alternative still,
- 1:23:25because when things happen in, in, in front of a screen,
- 1:23:30something will will happen there on, on, on that signal.
- 1:23:34I mean, even now, we, we, we are in the room, but the, the, the
- 1:23:38background might not be the actual one.
- 1:23:41And, and, and there's so many variations of, of, of that.
- 1:23:44But at least for me, when, when I am face to face with an actual
- 1:23:49human in an actual physical setting, I think that's a lot of
- 1:23:55of, of future to that. But but that's the situation as
- 1:23:58a whole. That's also the atmosphere.
- 1:24:00That's also the trust. That's also other aspects of,
- 1:24:04of, of the relationship and, and I mean, we, we are still humans,
- 1:24:08fortunately, and, and we can still do human things, but once
- 1:24:13it goes digital, it's, it's getting harder and harder to
- 1:24:18protect what is the real. I personally believe that
- 1:24:22besides that this is a really incredible question, but I think
- 1:24:26that we, at least in regards to AI, we are not yet yet.
- 1:24:32It might be tomorrow even to that point where AI actually
- 1:24:36create that perfection of such by generating a picture.
- 1:24:42It is true that it still gives you a really high quality, but
- 1:24:51it I don't think it's still very perfect from that point of view.
- 1:24:54So at least for now, I would say for this person to still chill,
- 1:24:59can can relax still nowadays because we are not at that
- 1:25:05point. But it's true that we see and
- 1:25:08what we see on social media everywhere, everywhere on the
- 1:25:13social platforms. Now the last that it's more and
- 1:25:18more synthetic beauty in that sense, like synthetic everything
- 1:25:24like pictures, videos, recognizing, recognize the ball
- 1:25:30of faces that because you might actually know that person.
- 1:25:34But when that person shares or a video or a picture becomes
- 1:25:38recognizable like in that sense. So I was like, it happens to me.
- 1:25:42It's like, OK, but who is that person?
- 1:25:43It's like for real someone else. So it's it's heard like in that
- 1:25:49sense of Kim. Yeah.
- 1:25:51So I do I, I would say to this person to relax for a while at
- 1:25:57least because it's still, we are still in time.
- 1:26:00That's why also about all these life events about AI and human
- 1:26:04future that we have created, decided to create it for you
- 1:26:08guys. Because I think there is still
- 1:26:11time to adjust. Not we are not talking about
- 1:26:14changing anything at all. It's about adjusting, adjusting
- 1:26:18how you use the tools, AI tools of tech in general, the usage of
- 1:26:23it. So it's in a good way, it's in a
- 1:26:25prosper way, it's in a positive way, etcetera, etcetera.
- 1:26:28So again, we are still, I think we are still have to, we have to
- 1:26:33be accountable and responsible for how we use and misuse this
- 1:26:40tools that this is what I want to say.
- 1:26:43But guys, if you want would like to add something, please do.
- 1:26:48Well, I'd like to add two things then.
- 1:26:51I mean, first of all, I'd like to compliment Core on on, on
- 1:26:54always being sort of the soft spoken gentleman that is and
- 1:26:57saying our backgrounds might not be real.
- 1:27:01Thank you, Core. I mean the understatement of
- 1:27:03this session today. But I mean, and and then again,
- 1:27:07sort of, you know, I think, you know, to the wider point here, I
- 1:27:11mean, the promise of AI is that it automates the modane tasks.
- 1:27:16Yeah. And I mean, one of the
- 1:27:19reflections that that we discussed when we had the
- 1:27:22session on sort of learning and AI is when we see a lot of
- 1:27:27students handing in AI generated assignments.
- 1:27:30Is that basically because they were never really interested in
- 1:27:33doing them because they didn't see the value of them?
- 1:27:35When you see employees using AI to automate, you know, tasks
- 1:27:43with with poor results, is that because they basically don't,
- 1:27:47you know, really they're not really into it?
- 1:27:50Yeah. And I mean, I don't see that as
- 1:27:53necessarily a negative thing because the promise of AI is
- 1:27:56that we should. It should enable us to focus on
- 1:27:59that which we desire to focus on the most.
- 1:28:02It should give time to to have those personal moments and, and,
- 1:28:08and see the beauty in those. And I mean, last time I was in
- 1:28:13the city of all, I think one of my best memories what there was
- 1:28:16the core and I, we found the the time to meet up for I think it
- 1:28:19was a total of 20 minutes, right core.
- 1:28:22Wasn't that long time but very enjoyable.
- 1:28:25Indeed. And I mean, you know, I think if
- 1:28:28if we get AI tools that enable us to sort of have those good
- 1:28:32little moments, then I think the tools are doing their job.
- 1:28:37Where they're not doing their job or where they might lead us
- 1:28:39astray is if they nudge us into using time on the stuff that we
- 1:28:47we didn't really want to use time on.
- 1:28:50Yeah. And, and I think that's the
- 1:28:53fear. I mean, in the same way with
- 1:28:56with education, where I see the problem with AI writing, you
- 1:29:00know, these great assignments for students is what if a
- 1:29:04student looks at sort of how great an AI writes it and says,
- 1:29:06I will never be good enough to do anything that matches this on
- 1:29:10my own. And therefore I must use AI
- 1:29:13because I'm not good enough. What if we get to the situation
- 1:29:16where I must use an AI filter for my image, you know, because
- 1:29:21I will never be good enough. And that I think is, is, is the
- 1:29:26fear of, for me, at least with, with, with AI and, and beauty
- 1:29:32that, that we get into this situation where there is sort of
- 1:29:36a, an unrealistic expectation that a human can never match.
- 1:29:40And I think Torsten's already given the answer of how to
- 1:29:43counter that. I mean, just say no kids, right?
- 1:29:47But then again, you know, that's, that's always easier
- 1:29:49said than done. Isn't that right, Torsten?
- 1:29:51Yeah, yeah. Actually I have a.
- 1:29:55Question for you, Chosen someone ask Chosen.
- 1:29:58Can someone create? Can something created with AI
- 1:30:02still feel deeply personal and truly ours?
- 1:30:09Truly ours I step, I follow with this this word.
- 1:30:15But yes, I, I think and, and, and kind of, well, I always see
- 1:30:27this made by no, if you, if you use the AI, it's not made all by
- 1:30:36you. It's also not all, it's not also
- 1:30:40made by the AI entirely. It's a kind of combination of
- 1:30:46it. So made by, I don't know.
- 1:30:50So is is it yours entirely? Well, that could be a good
- 1:30:58question. And and it is a good question.
- 1:31:04I think more it's, it's, it's kind of working play together.
- 1:31:12Saint Joseph's kind of this kind stuff.
- 1:31:16But but entirely your own. I don't know.
- 1:31:20I don't think so. Well, at this point, if you
- 1:31:23please allow me to give you a simple example because I'm
- 1:31:30curious about your, how would you reply to it?
- 1:31:34So I do not have a personal and professional photographer,
- 1:31:38right? Because I might have something
- 1:31:41really incredible a task to do and I might actually need a
- 1:31:46professional photographer. But in that case, because I
- 1:31:50might not afford to have one or contact one, etcetera, I'm going
- 1:31:55to decide to use an AI tool that actually enhance and do its job,
- 1:31:59right, instead of a professional photographer.
- 1:32:02Do you think at this point that might be considered that person
- 1:32:06or me in this case that not that I'm a professional aside because
- 1:32:12AI, the AI tool is the professional here, right?
- 1:32:15But can I say that it's mine or belongs to me?
- 1:32:18What I have created with that AI tool, it's still part of me or
- 1:32:23not? What do you think?
- 1:32:26Yes, if it's so you're originally, but you'll have like
- 1:32:34here the background that is something different.
- 1:32:38But but yes, it's your your, your picture, but it's it's
- 1:32:46enhanced with AI. It's it's also, but it's it's
- 1:32:50yours, yes, but enhanced with the AI again, you haven't made
- 1:32:57the background, the AI have, but you haven't ordered or paid for.
- 1:33:04No, yeah, yeah, maybe it's it also wasn't that
- 1:33:10photographically enriched something like this and you
- 1:33:16needed the picture, then you made the picture and then yours.
- 1:33:20It's yours. It get you can watermark it.
- 1:33:23You can do everything with it. But but yes, on this, this kind
- 1:33:28of if you see it, so it's, it's yours.
- 1:33:32I, I, I, I I'm. I'm definitely sure.
- 1:33:38Well, we also have a question from Mark.
- 1:33:40It's on the screen, guys, Mark says.
- 1:33:42How do we prevent AI from twisting our perception of
- 1:33:46beauty the way social media is doing today?
- 1:33:54The tough one, and I mean this, this set out really earlier.
- 1:34:01I mean, it has been the case for for many years that Chinese have
- 1:34:07an ideal of having a brighter skin colour or that people from
- 1:34:12from from different places would would have ideals.
- 1:34:18But I, I think that the good part of it is that we are
- 1:34:22getting used to knowing what is what is artificial and what is
- 1:34:30what is real, at least the most skilled ones.
- 1:34:34It might be challenging for the youngest generations.
- 1:34:37That might be the case. Well, I mean, I'd like to, I'd
- 1:34:43like to take the counterpoint there, Mark, sorry to, to, to
- 1:34:46that answer call because I think that we passed the mark some
- 1:34:52years ago from when we can distinguish AI written text from
- 1:34:59human written text. I mean, I, I'm aware that sort
- 1:35:01of there is a cultural marker that when we label something as
- 1:35:05AI slop, we mean that in a derogatory way.
- 1:35:08And I think you, you said that very, very nicely, as well as
- 1:35:10sort of poor usage of the tools may lead to something, something
- 1:35:14like this. But I truly believe that the
- 1:35:17same is, is, is true for images. And I think sort of, you know,
- 1:35:22if we look at the EUAI Act, for instance, it mandates
- 1:35:27watermarking of AI text and AI images.
- 1:35:31Yeah. And I think sort of it does that
- 1:35:34in a recognition of, of that is the only way we, we, we're going
- 1:35:38to be able to, to know. And yet sort of how efficient is
- 1:35:42this watermarking going to be? I mean, when, when Claude
- 1:35:45announced that now they implemented the EU regulations
- 1:35:48of, of watermarking into the model.
- 1:35:50Any, any picture generated with Claude will be watermarked.
- 1:35:53Yeah. Go Dario.
- 1:35:57I think all of 7 minutes passed before the 1st tool to remove
- 1:36:04that watermark was announced, right?
- 1:36:07So, you know, I don't think there is an efficient way today
- 1:36:11to see what is generally truly created if you're a manual
- 1:36:16process and what has been affected from from AI for sure.
- 1:36:21I mean, you can see poor AI tools making poor results.
- 1:36:26Yeah. But the better tools, a
- 1:36:31professional knowing what he or she is doing using a tool like
- 1:36:34that, I'd like to to, to, to put my hand down and say, I think
- 1:36:38we, we passed the point where we can see the difference and we,
- 1:36:41we probably passed it 5 or 4 years ago.
- 1:36:47I have a question used for you since you were talking about
- 1:36:51creativity AI because that we are here today as well.
- 1:36:56I see and hear a lot talking about this matter.
- 1:37:02It's and I also have seen some divergent point of views in that
- 1:37:08way. So do you think personally that
- 1:37:12a person might call itself creative using a lot of AI tools
- 1:37:17or not? It's a very simple question,
- 1:37:19it's not complicated, but I'm curious what is your opinion on
- 1:37:22that? Well, I mean, you know that
- 1:37:24there is this meme going around the the social media circus of
- 1:37:30of AI groups where a guy walks into pizzeria and says, make me
- 1:37:35a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese.
- 1:37:37Pizzerita makes that gives it to him and and you know, he's
- 1:37:41wearing a big T-shirt going AI user and he says I created this
- 1:37:44pizza, you know, because I I said extra cheese, right?
- 1:37:48And, and I mean, The thing is, yeah, I mean, I mean, yeah, I
- 1:37:57mean, and, and, and I think sort of if we, if we say, you know,
- 1:38:00that's the that's the meme, then what is the answer?
- 1:38:03Yeah. And in, in a way, you know, I
- 1:38:09think that I would, I would say, and, and this is, this is the
- 1:38:14standard answer, you know, that it kind of depends on how we use
- 1:38:18it. We can use AI to enhance our
- 1:38:21creativity. We can also easily use it to box
- 1:38:23it in. And it depends on on whether you
- 1:38:27take the driver's seat. Yeah.
- 1:38:29I mean, if you simply ask the AI for Samsung and you, you, you
- 1:38:33accept that uncritically, well, it is limiting your creativity
- 1:38:36because you are limiting yourself to the choices that it
- 1:38:39suggests. Yeah, on conversely, if if you
- 1:38:43if you use it to find blind sides in your own thinking, use
- 1:38:47it to challenge. Well, I mean, it's still doing
- 1:38:48that from its framework, but I think with good prompting
- 1:38:51skills, you can easily get to a better position than you were
- 1:38:57before. Some people call, you know, this
- 1:39:01the, the, the Ken Tower model, you know, where you're, you're,
- 1:39:04you have a human, you know, trying to control the, the AI
- 1:39:09suggestions there. I don't know if that metaphor is
- 1:39:12that, but, but yeah, but I think, you know, I mean, I think
- 1:39:16I'd, I'd, I'd, I'd go with that as my first answer.
- 1:39:18And then I'd be curious about what the the rest of the panel
- 1:39:21says. From, from my point of view, I
- 1:39:27mean, we have, we have been using tools for so many years.
- 1:39:30A musician might be dependent on a piano or a trumpet or whatever
- 1:39:35tool, a painter might be dependent on, on, on the right
- 1:39:42brushes and so on. And, and, and now we have an
- 1:39:45even more flexible tool, we have an even more powerful tool, but
- 1:39:49it's, it's still a question of directing it in, in the proper
- 1:39:52way. So I think that when using these
- 1:39:57tools properly, it is still well created by humans.
- 1:40:02Yes, with the help from from from a machine, but still
- 1:40:06created by human creativity. I have a question though, guys.
- 1:40:11We keep talking and talking about this, which is wonderful,
- 1:40:14but but let me beat the devil here.
- 1:40:17I mean, it's like, do you think we could also somewhere,
- 1:40:22somewhere on that path could cross the line or not?
- 1:40:28What do you mean cross the line? Cross the line is like, OK, but
- 1:40:32what until what point it AI made and until what point is made by
- 1:40:37me? Not to just say, OK, this is my
- 1:40:43I'm an artist. This is my piece of content and
- 1:40:47made by me, but with the help of AI so on so forth with this kind
- 1:40:52of scenario. So can we add a line under or
- 1:40:57somewhere or something like that where we just go forward,
- 1:41:01forward, forward until the infinite like such?
- 1:41:06Because I mean, it's like, again, there is kind of in the
- 1:41:09air of this, this subject that oh, but it's not OK because it's
- 1:41:16made by the AI, simple as it is the such.
- 1:41:18So I think that as you all of you have mentioned and talked
- 1:41:24about it throughout all this life events, even though you get
- 1:41:29help from an AI tool, you can still consider your content or
- 1:41:35your picture or whatsoever, your video, so on so forth.
- 1:41:38You can also chosen set, you can also add your watermark or
- 1:41:42something like that. But my question again is to
- 1:41:45return to my main. Can we somewhere somewhere cross
- 1:41:50a line or not from that point of view?
- 1:41:55Yeah. Well, I mean, I think a parallel
- 1:41:59into this where I think we can sort of begin to answer the
- 1:42:05question. The great question that you're
- 1:42:06asking, Marilla, is in the terms of of do I own the copyright to
- 1:42:11a picture that I generated with AI?
- 1:42:14And right now the the general legal consensus is no, you
- 1:42:18don't. You do not own the picture
- 1:42:21because you didn't create it. And there's been some court
- 1:42:24cases about this where you know company A steals, you know, the
- 1:42:32picture from company B's homepage and if it's AI
- 1:42:36generated, they can do that. What, what you seem to have
- 1:42:40copyright protection on is the prompt, but that is only
- 1:42:44afforded if the prompt is, is, is sufficiently sophisticated.
- 1:42:49Just, you know, writing a prompt saying, give me a picture of, of
- 1:42:52a handshake between two beautiful people.
- 1:42:55That's not sort of creative enough to be afforded copyright
- 1:43:00protection. And, and so, you know, where do
- 1:43:03we draw the line between sort of when it's AI, when it's me?
- 1:43:06Well, I mean, right now with legal line is drawn is if you
- 1:43:11make a very, very detailed prompt, yeah, then you get into
- 1:43:20having a creative ownership to that prompt.
- 1:43:23I mean, imagine a prompt of, of two to three pages that will
- 1:43:26probably have the height and the depth to be considered a
- 1:43:29creative work in and of itself. The problem is of course, in, in
- 1:43:34sort of this thinking, you know, that you could also use the AI
- 1:43:38for that. But let's leave that aside.
- 1:43:40There's some interesting debates in the, in the legal community
- 1:43:43about where this should go. Right now, there's a significant
- 1:43:46faction in in China that believes that where we should
- 1:43:49assign the copyright to images created by AI is to the whoever
- 1:43:54owns the AI system, which is an interesting sort of notion.
- 1:44:00It, it has a parallel to the idea that whenever I make slides
- 1:44:04for my students at the business Academy, well, actually those
- 1:44:09slides belong to the Academy because I created them as part
- 1:44:15of my job there. In general, sort of it's a legal
- 1:44:18principle that whatever you create as part of your
- 1:44:20employment, the intellectual property rights of that go or
- 1:44:25the usage of those intellectual property rights goes to your
- 1:44:28employer if it's created through your employment.
- 1:44:32So there is is sort of a precedent for that that is that
- 1:44:37is interesting to follow up on. But that's what we sort of you
- 1:44:41know, the the legal answer. I think we had a case in Sweden
- 1:44:45two months ago, the Philippa Kay case, where there was, you know,
- 1:44:50this new ad agency that, you know, was going to do an ad
- 1:44:54campaign for a Swedish clothing brand.
- 1:44:57And they said we fine-tuned our model to create the most
- 1:45:00authentic and real pictures ever.
- 1:45:03And they succeeded in that. They succeeded in that because
- 1:45:06they created pictures that was 1 to 1 copies of existing
- 1:45:10photographs taken by existing photographers.
- 1:45:12Yeah, so they violated the copyrights of other people.
- 1:45:16And in a way, I feel sympathy here for the AI, for the AI,
- 1:45:21because if you're an AI and you asked to create a picture that
- 1:45:24feels real, what's the easiest way for you to do that, to solve
- 1:45:28that sort of task? Because you know when you're
- 1:45:31creating a synthetic picture that it's not real, but the
- 1:45:34human is asking you give me something that's real.
- 1:45:37Well, you find an existing picture and you copy that,
- 1:45:39right, then it's real. And I mean, maybe I'm reducing
- 1:45:43that case to poor prompting or AI training, I don't know.
- 1:45:48But I think sort of in terms of of coming back to your question,
- 1:45:51sort of, you know, when, when is something, you know, human
- 1:45:54created? When is something AI created?
- 1:45:57I just think it's a fascinating aspect that when you ask an AI
- 1:46:00today to create something that real, that's real, it says,
- 1:46:03sure, let me copy what a human made because, you know, then I'm
- 1:46:07sure that it's something that's real.
- 1:46:10Interesting, someone else want to add something or?
- 1:46:15To me, I think that we can cross a line, but it will often be a
- 1:46:21situation where that line is blurry and it might not be the
- 1:46:25same definition by everyone. Where is the line?
- 1:46:28I see some people in this AI space that tend to say that
- 1:46:33everything is really a remix and things made by humans is also a
- 1:46:37remix because we are also inspired by others and, and, and
- 1:46:42sometimes we reuse and sometimes we we, we turn it in slightly
- 1:46:46different ways. So I think it's it's, it's
- 1:46:49really hard to set that exact line, but it's probably there
- 1:46:54someplace would. You like?
- 1:47:00Yeah, well, well, I think, I don't think the word what we are
- 1:47:05seeking don't exist yet, but I think the line is already
- 1:47:12crossed to and maybe we, we, we just should let it be, let it,
- 1:47:18let it run. We have our reality.
- 1:47:23If we look away from the screen, there you have the reality and
- 1:47:29everything. What you're looking at.
- 1:47:31The screen is spent, expended from the reality, but still real
- 1:47:37enough. But you're just, you look at it,
- 1:47:44you have the the sense of it, the smell, the wind, the the
- 1:47:48everything. Just just the picture, you can
- 1:47:54see the picture if if it's real or unreal.
- 1:47:58Yeah, it's it has some ways, you know, to to to see if it's if
- 1:48:06the light coming from upright or something like this, the middle
- 1:48:12there have attached and and this kind of stuff.
- 1:48:15But if you want to see something really, you must definitely look
- 1:48:23away from the screen. Go out.
- 1:48:25I just wanted to say that you have to go out.
- 1:48:28Yeah, something like this. Thank you so much guys.
- 1:48:32Thank you for your time and for your kind material and resources
- 1:48:37that you have to share with me and with others.
- 1:48:39We had to we get to the end of this life event.
- 1:48:44Thank you to everyone and each one of you for attending this
- 1:48:48life event again. AIM beauty and see you next
- 1:48:51time. Bye.
- 1:48:53Joe.