Latest / Foth and Friends: Stories from the Road / A Look@Social Media
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, I'm Dick Foth, and I'd like to welcome you to known stories to make sense of it all.
- 0:09These stories are what I call walking books, real-life people, different places, different
- 0:16ages, different cultures, and I want to have some conversations with them across disciplines
- 0:21and generations and cultures in order to encourage a kind of knowing fresh lenses through
- 0:29which to see the world. One of those lenses will be Scripture, or more specifically, Jesus
- 0:36of Nazareth, whose life I believe changed the course of the history of the world. So thanks
- 0:44for listening in. Great to have you with us.
- 0:48So today is the second part of a two-part conversation with Justin and Mackenzie Matthews. These
- 0:54are friends of mine who work with young people. They love each other, and they love young people.
- 1:01Middle schoolers up through young adults are sort of their bailiwick. Whatever that means,
- 1:07I love that word, but whatever that means, that's where they live and spend their hours and
- 1:12their days. And recently we had the chance to deal with probably the most significant central
- 1:20issue in human dynamics, certainly in the last decade, as it relates to young people.
- 1:27Here we go. A question for the day is, when I say social media, what do you think of?
- 1:36The first word that comes from a line is fascinating, followed by inspiring and dangerous.
- 1:44Okay. Do you have any words to add to that?
- 1:48I think that covered everything. I think of social media as from a middle school or
- 1:56hospital perspective, I would say it is connection as middle school and high school kids see as connection.
- 2:06Okay. All right. So in 2007, I think this date is right. In 2007, the iPhone, the smartphone was
- 2:14introduced, and it has changed the world, literally changed the world. So talk to us to
- 2:23me into our listeners about what you see as the things that are fascinating, inspiring, and
- 2:30dangerous. Just jump into that. And I'll just have a little conversation here.
- 2:34Totally. Well, I would say, I mean, I have and love all the social media as myself.
- 2:40So I enjoy them all. I think they're really fun. I connect with people near. I connect with people
- 2:45far. They're fun for me. And I think. So all the social media? I know. I should do it.
- 2:51Well, let me see if I know them all. I'm older, so I know Facebook, obviously.
- 2:58Twitter. Snapchat. Instagram. Yes. Wasn't there something called Vine?
- 3:05Yeah, but that I don't think. Yeah, I think Vine's gone now. It's gone. It's a touch and go. So
- 3:09that didn't count, but there will be others coming along. Totally. Okay. So that's all. Go ahead.
- 3:14Yes. I don't have Vine, but I have all of the other ones. Yes. And I enjoy them and use them.
- 3:19I see a lot, especially young people, you know, high school college, even young adults, peers,
- 3:25and the way they use social media, I think that's always really, really interesting.
- 3:29Within each of the social media, you know, there's some things when you think about what is
- 3:34dangerous about them. The amount of just the numbers that are associated to certain things,
- 3:41like how many followers you have or how many people are affirming or liking the things that you're
- 3:46doing. There's a thing on Snapchat called a snap streak where if I send you a photo and you send
- 3:53the photo back to me in a day, we get a number. And if however many days we do that in a row,
- 3:59it adds to our numbers of saying how long our snap streak is. So recently, I was spending time
- 4:03with this friend of mine that's a high school student and she was showing me her snapchat or she
- 4:08had her snapchat open or something. And I was looking at her homepage and she had a snap streak that
- 4:12had like 570 something days on the snap streak. And I was like, get out of town. I was so curious
- 4:21about that and asking her about that. And I was like, is this real? And she's like, oh, she gave
- 4:27her login. When she went to summer camp, she was out of service range. And she gave someone else
- 4:32her login so they could log in and like send something for her just to maintain that number.
- 4:39So the idea of that number being such a big deal. Okay, so it sounds to me that what some people
- 4:46called connection other people would see as competition. And when we chatted before,
- 4:53you said something about comparison that social media perhaps is less about connection
- 5:01behind the scenes than it is about comparison. And I think the line that was said was comparison
- 5:07is the thief of joy. So, Justin, you work with what age group? I work with middle school, high
- 5:16school, and college. Okay, so let's just look at middle school. Okay. What would the youngest
- 5:21middle schooler be? 10 years old? 11? I think it's like 11 to 14-ish. And they're on social media.
- 5:27Oh yeah. So, talk to me about, give me a couple of anecdotes about how you have seen social media
- 5:36work with your age group. Yeah, and so I think of Instagram, that's the social media I have.
- 5:43I don't have Snapchat. And I look at Twitter for almost my news to kind of get the news.
- 5:49And Instagram, you can kind of get that with Instagram, the news. But for the most part, it is.
- 5:55By news, you mean like World News? Yeah, World News, Sports News. But Instagram is your telephone.
- 6:01Yeah, more or less of this age. Yeah. And I remember a student, and when McKinsey now we're
- 6:10living in California, I remember a student would go onto her Instagram and she would follow like
- 6:17thousands and thousands of people just so they would follow her back. And then after two or
- 6:24three weeks, she would go through and then unfollow all these people. And I remember talking to her
- 6:28about this. I mean, how long does this take? And she's like, well, the last time I did it,
- 6:33it took four hours, four hours to go through her friend group, just to unfollow people. So it made
- 6:39it look like she had more followers than people she's following. And so that is very true even here
- 6:48in Colorado with middle school students. Middle school students, they, they're very, very insecure.
- 6:55And they want to have this number associated with them. And it's a very big comparison thing.
- 7:00Every single student wants to, first off, have more followers than people they follow. So they
- 7:06want that number to be bigger. And I remember someone talking about a ratio. And they call it like
- 7:10your follow ratio. And I just think of that. And I think of the amount of hours and time put into
- 7:19this for something that for I would assume a parent just seems so silly. But for a middle school kid,
- 7:26I would almost say that it's not just silly or it's it's more than just silly. It's it's
- 7:32their life. Yeah, absolutely. So at the heart of this discussion, we find comparison.
- 7:39And comparison has a twin called competition. Nothing wrong with comparison and nothing
- 7:46wrong with competition. The exception being how often, how long, how intense,
- 7:56to what end? Why are we doing it? And things that are constant, if you have constant comparison
- 8:07and constant competition, and there's no other metric by which to evaluate things,
- 8:14it can become very challenging. It sounds like disease. Not disease, but disease. Yeah. That
- 8:25that it is a it is a way of establishing my identity every day, every hour. I'm working on
- 8:35who I am. And I get that from you. I you my my network. Right. So if if you, you know, we talk about
- 8:45cyber bullying, but there is a sense in which, especially for younger folks, it sounds like
- 8:54it could be cyber intimidating or cyber jailing because I freeze you out if you will. Is that
- 9:03am I overstating that? I don't think so. I think today students are are always comparing themselves,
- 9:11no matter what it is they're doing, but it's sports. Which is human nature. Right. Which is sports.
- 9:16It could be grades. It could be who you're dating, who you're not dating, all this stuff. They're
- 9:20always comparing each other. And now it's even more dangerous because they have a number that
- 9:24associates with how they compare to someone else. So so I don't only get a grade in my math class.
- 9:30Right. I get a grade in my social class. Right. And anything that they post, they're waiting for
- 9:35that affirmation. So the second that you post something, you're looking at how many likes it's
- 9:39gotten. People were a fresh at over and over and over again. So they can see how many numbers they're
- 9:43getting, how liked that thing is. So there's almost like anxiety filled with that. I knew a high
- 9:47school girl who said, Oh, if I don't have 50 likes on a picture, I'd delete it. It's embarrassing.
- 9:51You know, there's that response that's like, Oh, if it's if I'm not, if I'm not getting that
- 9:55affirmation of I try to put something and they spend a lot of time in, I mean, I would say some
- 10:00high school kids and all high school kids are young people in general spend a lot of time thinking
- 10:03about what they're putting on their Instagram specifically. So well taken photos. They're thinking
- 10:10of captions or spending a lot of time thinking about or curating what they're choosing to put out
- 10:15there. So this is this is this is the 2000 or the or the 21st century version of putting my best
- 10:25foot forward. Yes. That phrase comes from those old colonial things where you had silver buckles
- 10:30on your shoes and you see these pictures, these guys standing with one foot in front of the other
- 10:37and it was literally putting your best foot forward that that's the beautiful that catches the
- 10:41intention. This is that. But if I'm a soccer player, let's say, it isn't just that now I'm comparing
- 10:47myself to the other soccer players in my class or in my school or in my county or in my league.
- 10:53I'm comparing myself to a kid in Mumbai or in Edinburgh. That seems to me that that that's
- 11:01overwhelming for me and I'm an old dude and for somebody just getting their identity
- 11:07seems to me that is so counterproductive in the long haul that it's just debilitating
- 11:14to a person to a person if you will. So on the one hand it's fascinating and inspirational
- 11:23because you can you can get cute videos that are you know or inspiring talks all of that.
- 11:33But but it's the intro it isn't that I just go into internet and get the inspiring talks
- 11:38or get those passed around. It's that when I'm communicating with you at some level
- 11:45you're evaluating me. Is that right? Or to what degree is that correct my statement?
- 11:53I mean I think when it's young people looking at young people there is a there is a bit of
- 11:58evaluating or comparing but I feel like sometimes that lens is just more inward thinking of how
- 12:03they're not those things. Not necessarily maybe evaluating but I think sometimes it's like
- 12:08cyberbullying sometimes that is like very much evaluating or judging the people that they
- 12:11look at but if it's someone is perceived to be a professional or someone is perceived to be
- 12:16as impressive I feel like it's like a different category. Okay so so you guys are investing your
- 12:21whole lives with young people from from middle school through young adulthood okay could you do
- 12:28what you do in terms of trying to have positive influence encourage the following of this
- 12:35Jesus of Nazareth person could you do what you do today without social media? I believe so.
- 12:44I I almost never post anything on social media. I think the biggest thing about social media the
- 12:54reason I have it is I try to stay relevant right to to middle school students I'm no longer
- 13:00a middle school student so I kind of don't really know what's going on and I think middle or I
- 13:05think social media kind of keeps me in that loop a little bit longer but to say that I could I do
- 13:12this without social media I say absolutely. And how would you do that without social media? I mean
- 13:20there's there's a lot of ways to communicate there's a lot of ways to be in each of those lives
- 13:24whenever whenever we well I on Thursday nights I meet with a with middle school kids and we normally
- 13:31go to what we call man night and we go and do we do man things on man night normally it's like
- 13:36eating wings and stuff like that and not using napkins and yeah yeah and so we do we do that and then
- 13:44I always say that whenever we get there I don't think anybody's really ever on their phone
- 13:50I would say for the most part just because they know that in our small group that we have on
- 13:55Wednesday nights that you're not allowed to be on your phone so that's a rule on Wednesday. Yeah yeah
- 14:00you're not allowed to be on your phone and I think it's they've realized that being without your
- 14:07phone or without social media while you're all together is fine like even when I took guys to camp
- 14:13I've taken my small group to camp three times from three years and every year I collect their
- 14:17cell phones when we get to camp because I don't want them to be on their cell phone the whole time
- 14:21you want to experience whatever right and I remember the first the first year it was like a
- 14:25it was a battle every kid's like why can I have my phone all this stuff and I I kept telling
- 14:30that I said hey you just gotta trust me I promise it's better I promise it's better just trust me
- 14:35and then I remember the next year it kids just kind of gave their phones willingly here does
- 14:40here's my phone don't need it for the week and then in eighth grade I remember there's about four
- 14:44or five new students like we have to give our phones up and I remember a student looking at him
- 14:48going hey it's way better without your phone and yeah and so I really believe that our time
- 14:55at least the time that I get to spend with middle school students I believe that they truly believe
- 14:59that it's better without their phone because we get to hang out with one another and so I do
- 15:05believe that I could do what I do without social media I think sometimes it does make it a little
- 15:10easier and I also think it helps me promote what we're doing much better so so it's an informational
- 15:18tool absolutely to get the word how about you we can oh yeah for the you can getting the word out
- 15:24yeah that's I mean it's huge yeah I use it for I mean I hardly ever print anything anymore
- 15:29because everything is a lot of you know trying to do advertising or building new relationships
- 15:38that's where it's like a really effective way to do that I think with relationships that we
- 15:43already have it's the ability to know things that are happening in their lives like I can see
- 15:48something and ask them about it later like I remember especially with some high school kids or
- 15:51something where a high school kid had tweeted something about like very aggressive some very
- 15:56aggressive tweet which is really angry and I was like hey what's going on like Twitter told me
- 16:00Twitter told me that you said this and it was you know it's able to see the students in different
- 16:05elements of their lives and being able to ask them and connect with them about things going on
- 16:09with them I think it's possible to do it outside of the realm of social media but I agree that it
- 16:14makes it easier because you can just know the things that they're choosing to put out there and you
- 16:18can ask them about that or you can say this is such a big part of your life I can be curious about it
- 16:22so you're doing the evaluating kind of you know because if it's a feeling I have but it isn't
- 16:30just that I'm saying it to you I'm saying it to 38 other people and learning that 38 other people
- 16:36have 38 different opinions as something it comes with maturity isn't it and I'm still learning
- 16:41bad and I you know it's been a while I heard somebody say I don't have a relationship with people
- 16:47anymore I have relationships with my devices there's there's something about the idea of addiction
- 17:00connected with I mean I think there are even camps now for people who feel addicted to their
- 17:08devices if you will are you aware of those camps or have you heard about that I have heard about
- 17:13them I'm not aware of any or I don't like know of anyone who's been there but I have heard of them
- 17:18because I was I was reading the other day about that so okay here's here's this platform for
- 17:25communication I mean back you know almost a hundred years ago now the telephone came into existence
- 17:32and that became a new thing it changed the culture the automobile a hundred years ago it came
- 17:37into existence it changed the culture the credit card came into existence it changed the birth
- 17:43control pill in the sixties came into it changed the culture and forever it will be changed it
- 17:48cannot go back so this is true of the of the telephone made personal because it's not just a
- 17:56telephone it is in fact this this a storage center for my life I'm a parent let's say of a 14
- 18:05year old or an 18 year old and I want to help the student know how to how to handle this arena and
- 18:17not have the arena handle me okay we so thoughts or any other thoughts you have you can go anywhere
- 18:26you want with this I'm I'm a very firm believer in accountability I believe that that what you
- 18:34post online and what you look at on your phone and all that stuff you need to be accountable for
- 18:41I know parents that say that their student isn't allowed to have their phone pass 9 o'clock their
- 18:46phone goes in the bedroom with mom and dad and they're allowed to look at anything they want to
- 18:50look at and I know all all all sorts of kind of things like that and you mean the parents yeah
- 18:55are able to look at their parents yeah the parents are able to look at their their their son
- 18:59under the daughter's phone that's an understanding yeah and it's understanding it's one of those
- 19:02things that like I know a friend of mine Bob with his daughter he was saying that I paid for this
- 19:08phone so I'm letting you know right now that I'm allowed to look at anything on your phone so if
- 19:13you want a phone this is the this is the kind of the contract we're in and and at first I would
- 19:18it was pretty it was pretty bad but now now Riley Bob's daughter just gives it to Bob willing he
- 19:24absolutely sure we I get it and so I always say that parents should always have some rules
- 19:30for for their phone I mean today I mean we have the world at our fingertips always in our pocket and
- 19:38yeah and and I just feel like that could be that could be super dangerous and and to be honest
- 19:44with I mean you can access anything on Instagram on Twitter on Facebook I mean you can you can
- 19:50you can see anything you want like basically and so I really believe that parents should be
- 19:56involved and invested in that and and I even had a parent this was a years ago that said well hey can
- 20:03you check in on my son's Instagram like every couple weeks and let me know what's going on
- 20:09and I remember saying no but I'll show you how to do that I'll show you to how to set up an
- 20:15accountant so I just think that the more invested you are the better I really believe that it could
- 20:21be really dangerous without any accountability so so a parent communicating with the child vice
- 20:27versa sets the stage for whatever other communications the child has or the young person has with
- 20:35folks beyond that circle so step one is let's us have communication right understand and this is
- 20:42true in a home when I was growing up we didn't have that we still had to have okay these are the
- 20:47guidelines of it so this is just guidelines for different arena right right it's just that arena
- 20:53is very active and it's pinging me it's coming after me because I'm a dollar this is all about money
- 21:01for the people who are who are setting things up that's not being cynical at the end of the day
- 21:07any program any kind of thing that's going on somebody's making money off that right that's how
- 21:13it is that's the macro picture the the micro picture is how do I help my child my young adult
- 21:22learn to manage life that comes in on that little screen or on that I in that is that fair to say
- 21:30that I was so any any other thoughts yeah whenever I talk to parents about this I always
- 21:37encourage them to be curious and try to like come to their students with curiosity saying hey tell
- 21:43me about this or things that you hear like asking about the new Snapchat update like I heard that you
- 21:49can see where people are in a map like I would love for you to show me that it's not something you see
- 21:53or asking them hey what do you think are the problems with this where do you see this in in your
- 21:57friends like I think it's always a win if you can get your kids talking about those types of things
- 22:03or having conversations about how it's dangerous trying to trying to shift their perspective and
- 22:08be curious in a way that is a is a conversation that is safe and not a conversation that is threatening
- 22:14because I know a lot of parents that are coming at this being like no you're not allowed it's over
- 22:17you know it's very like it's rule based which it has to be to a degree but if you can also create
- 22:22some trust and some safety to have conversations about issues with it issues they see in their peers
- 22:28questions just trying to be curious um and trying to monitor and at least know and understand
- 22:32the social media that the kids are on so parents creating conversations that are about life
- 22:40part of which is this it has to do with social media rather than letting social media create
- 22:46the conversation in which parents may or may not be involved that coming back to that whole
- 22:52piece you know we have single mom single dads listening to this and it's a it's a challenge as
- 23:00a single parent it's just a challenge let alone social media that's a whole other arena
- 23:06but to consider to consider the time together at one's house an entire dinner table conversation
- 23:16let's say dinner table is a metaphor for that where you can put commas in the conversation you
- 23:21know fix it all the night you don't have to solve it all or understand it all it seems to me
- 23:28that to create a conversation as a family's parents and young people to create a conversation
- 23:37that includes something about social media so that you don't have to have that big conversation
- 23:45all the time it doesn't always become the flashpoint seems to me that would be helpful yeah
- 23:50yeah I think anytime we can have a conversation about something and not just wait till they're in
- 23:56trouble is always best I always say that I get parents I get emails from parents from everywhere
- 24:03between social media I don't like what they're posting on social media too I don't like the music
- 24:07they're listening to and my advice is to always make it a conversation and not so much of just
- 24:14you got caught doing this now you're in trouble and try to get out ahead of that and make it a
- 24:18conversation before it gets there we're we're going to give you McKenzie the the closing word here
- 24:26and for those of you listening are hard to make from McKenzie's Mac
- 24:30no one has Mac during the round here yeah I would just want to look at social media and seeing
- 24:39the positives of social media I think it's really easy to be very scared it's very I teach a class
- 24:45about social media to some of our parents here at our church and every time parents get so scared
- 24:50about all the bad things that can be associated with social media but I think there is a lot of good
- 24:55things that are in all the social media as well in finding where where students are creative
- 25:00where young people are creative trying to look for the positive things and ask about the positive
- 25:04things and not always living in fear about all the things that you know are negative and are hard
- 25:10and are you know dangerous about social media so that's what I would say so
- 25:16so when I read the story of Jesus I'm reading the story of what we would call today a millennial
- 25:23and he went to the places where people gathered he went to the dinner table he went to the wells
- 25:29that's where he went I what do you think he'd be on Twitter
- 25:34I'd like to think it would be on Twitter according to Twitter he already is
- 25:40so well there you go yeah and with that my dear friends we we sign off thanks a million guys
- 25:49for letting me appreciate it so much