Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Precision in Practice: Mastering Discovery in Catastrophic Trucking Litigation
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Precision in Practice, Mastering Discovery
- 0:06in Catastrophic Trucking Litigation. I'm Belinda
- 0:09McCauley. I am the CEO and Executive Director
- 0:13of the BHBA, and I am delighted to be here this
- 0:16morning to introduce our speakers. Bobby Reagan
- 0:19is an attorney in the L .A. Office of Panachea
- 0:22Raviputi LLP, specializing in catastrophic personal
- 0:26injury and wrongful death. He joined the firm
- 0:28after nine years in practice litigating catastrophic
- 0:31injury cases. He is admitted to practice in California,
- 0:35Washington and the U .S. District Court for the
- 0:37Central District of California and has argued
- 0:39in courts of appeal. He has recovered tens of
- 0:42millions of dollars from insurance companies
- 0:43on behalf of his clients. Dustin Thorterson is
- 0:47an attorney also at Panacea, a Ravaputi LLP,
- 0:51where he represents individuals in complex personal
- 0:53injury, wrongful death, and product defect cases.
- 0:56Since 2021, he's secured more than $100 million
- 0:59in settlements and verdicts for his clients.
- 1:01Throughout his career, he has focused exclusively
- 1:04on catastrophic PI and wrongful death cases,
- 1:07handling matters involving burns, amputations,
- 1:10spinal cord injuries, orthopedic injuries of
- 1:12many kinds. and brain injuries. So now let's
- 1:15get started and learn a lot from these two experts.
- 1:20Thank you, Belinda. Good morning, everybody.
- 1:24I'm going to start by sharing our PowerPoint.
- 1:27Welcome to Beverly Hills Bar Association. As
- 1:30you heard, my name is Bobby Reagan. I'm here
- 1:33with Dustin Thorderson. We're here today to discuss
- 1:38some strategies for litigating trucking cases.
- 1:46So here's our contact information. Please reach
- 1:49out to either of us or both of us with any questions
- 1:52or if you'd like copies of things that we've
- 1:56discussed or samples. And so. Right. Real quick.
- 2:04I just want to say thank you to the Beverly Hills
- 2:07Bar Association for inviting us to come and speak
- 2:10on this issue. And Bobby has largely done most
- 2:16of this PowerPoint presentation. So I got to
- 2:19give him props, and we're going to dive right
- 2:21in. OK, guys? Yeah. So we wrote an article together,
- 2:29Dustin and I, about discovery in trucking cases
- 2:32and how it's a completely different animal from
- 2:38other auto cases. This presentation sort of builds
- 2:44on that. We're going to talk about some basic
- 2:46aspects of truck cases, discovery regulations.
- 2:50For a lot of you, it's probably just a refresher
- 2:52course, but hopefully for some beginners, it's
- 2:56a good starting off point. So the first thing
- 3:01that I think is really essential in any catastrophic
- 3:05trucking case is the Federal Motor Carrier Safety
- 3:08Administration's website. They maintain the electronic
- 3:15record system that's a website with all sorts
- 3:18of important details that you need in these trucking
- 3:20cases. And so all sorts of companies are listed
- 3:26here in the safer system. If it's a motor carrier
- 3:30or a company with a U .S. Department of Transportation
- 3:35number, then it's going to be tracked in the
- 3:39safer system. And so in California, Caltrans
- 3:43requires commercial carriers to obtain a USDOT
- 3:46number. And so all of those carriers will be
- 3:51listed in this safer system that anybody can
- 3:53access. And so as you see in the slide, there's
- 3:59a lot of really great information that you can
- 4:02access just through this publicly available website,
- 4:07carrier identification. So this is not only the
- 4:10legal name of the motor carrier, but it's also
- 4:13the DBAs. There's crash data which shows, I think
- 4:20it's updated weekly lately, the number of fatal
- 4:25crashes, the number of injury crashes, even tow
- 4:28away crashes. All that crash data is included.
- 4:34safety ratings. So these are audits that the
- 4:39FMCSA performs on and off site. And so you get
- 4:44to see is the carrier unrated, which tends to
- 4:50be a lot of carriers. If the FMCSA hasn't actually
- 4:53performed an audit, it'll just say unrated. Sometimes
- 4:56it's hopefully. a conditional or satisfactory,
- 5:01satisfactory being the highest rating, conditional
- 5:04or unsatisfactory are the various ratings within
- 5:10these safety ratings that the FMCSA includes
- 5:15on the safer website. And just real quick, this
- 5:20is so critical when you first get retained on
- 5:26a case. because all of this information is free,
- 5:30right? And what do we care about when we're looking
- 5:33into whether we wanna take a case on or get involved
- 5:37in a case, right? If there is a motor carrier
- 5:40involved, depending on the size of the motor
- 5:43carrier, depending on the insurance coverage,
- 5:45and depending on the goods that are being hauled,
- 5:47you might have several very viable defendants,
- 5:51but the first one that you're gonna really get
- 5:54a grip on is typically the motor carrier if it's
- 5:57a motor vehicle collision. So you can look up
- 6:00authority history, which is what Bobby referenced
- 6:03earlier. This is the authority granted by the
- 6:05United States government to this motor carrier
- 6:09to do business and engage in interstate commerce.
- 6:13And so as a result of that, you literally just
- 6:16put in the DOT number and there is all this information
- 6:19that you can then use in the course of developing
- 6:22your discovery plan. in terms of what you're
- 6:25going to do and what you find out so that you
- 6:27know already how bad are they? Are they a good
- 6:30motor carrier? Are they getting in a lot of accidents?
- 6:33Are they getting put out of service all the time?
- 6:35Those are the things that matter because if you
- 6:37see those, those are red flags for a carrier
- 6:40that's really not very safety conscious or they're
- 6:45trying to cut corners on maintenance costs and
- 6:47that's why they're getting out of service all
- 6:49the time. So it's a very, very helpful informal
- 6:53discovery tool that costs zero dollars that will
- 6:57give you a ton of information to inform you before
- 7:01you file suit. Yeah, I think that's a really
- 7:04good point to send just the fact that you can
- 7:07do all of this stuff without hiring an expert
- 7:10or spending much money on the case. So the safer
- 7:18system is a great place to start. But there's
- 7:22all sorts of other things that the federal rules
- 7:25require motor carriers to hold on to, to create
- 7:31records and maintain records for statutory periods
- 7:36of time. And so we have a list of some of them
- 7:40here. So driver qualification files. These are
- 7:47required to be kept by the federal rules. They've
- 7:50been adopted in California. So even intrastate
- 7:55carriers in California have to comply with a
- 7:58lot of these federal rules. And so carriers have
- 8:03to hold onto these records for the entire time
- 8:06that a driver is employed by the carrier plus
- 8:09three years after at a minimum. And so, you know,
- 8:14we have here like medical certifications. I know
- 8:21Dustin and I have talked about this a lot recently.
- 8:23Department of Transportation physicals can be
- 8:26a really interesting source of information in
- 8:28a case. If a DOT physical form has a driver saying
- 8:36that he drinks three to four drinks per day,
- 8:40three to four days per week, That information
- 8:43can be cross referenced against his hours of
- 8:46service to show that he was almost certainly
- 8:48drinking on the job. There's also some disqualifying
- 8:55medical reasons that drivers shouldn't be employed
- 8:59or that make them more susceptible to fatigue
- 9:04or causing crashes. I know Dustin had an issue
- 9:09with medical certification from a DOT physical
- 9:12recently. Yeah, so this is a good part for me
- 9:17to segue because Bobby is brilliant and I like
- 9:23to talk about the things that I do every day.
- 9:25And so a recent memory for this really the driver
- 9:32qualification file in its entirety, but in any
- 9:36trucking case, if you do not receive in a production
- 9:40of documents these basic, basic things like the
- 9:45driver's history, I think it's a five or a seven
- 9:49year window that they're required to provide
- 9:51when they get hired by the motor carrier, that
- 9:54will show any moving violations on the commercial
- 9:58CDL, the commercial driver's license. Also, it
- 10:02will show whether they disclose the existence
- 10:06of any speeding violations, moving violations,
- 10:10and what due diligence did the motor care exercise
- 10:13when they hire them, because what are we all
- 10:17trying to do? We're always trying to establish
- 10:21concurrent negligence of multiple torque visas,
- 10:24because that's how we can essentially maximize
- 10:28or do our job. to try and maximize our clients
- 10:32recovery. So when you can demonstrate that, for
- 10:36example, in a case that I had where the driver
- 10:42was hired, he handed the motor vehicle record
- 10:45to the human resources representative, and she
- 10:50just didn't even review the fact that he had
- 10:53two speeding violations on his motor vehicle
- 10:57record. Now, he also was on metformin, gabapentin,
- 11:03several other different medications that he did
- 11:06not disclose to the examiner that certified his
- 11:12fitness to operate a commercial motor vehicle.
- 11:15And so I then established all of these things
- 11:20when I cross -examined the person most knowledgeable
- 11:23at that position. And you show that they actually
- 11:29received what's called poll notices. And poll
- 11:33notices are essentially any action on a CDL in
- 11:39your motor carrier's fleet, you will immediately
- 11:43receive an electronic notification typically
- 11:46by email from the Department of Motor Vehicles
- 11:48informing you of whatever the speeding violation
- 11:52or collision or fatality is. And so, you have
- 11:57to understand that if you don't get that information
- 12:01outright it's a beautiful thing and it's a gift
- 12:04because then you get to go take a PMK and presumably
- 12:10they're going to dump all of this information
- 12:12on you about the night before or the morning
- 12:15of and the defense lawyers that do that are giving
- 12:19you a gift because it's almost a guaranteed certainty
- 12:23that there are documents that they have not produced.
- 12:27And so you give yourself an opportunity to get
- 12:30two bites at the apple and you go through every
- 12:33single document that's produced and you identify
- 12:37based on your knowledge of the FMCSA rules and
- 12:42regulations with respect to what they're supposed
- 12:45to do, the records they're supposed to maintain,
- 12:48where they're supposed to maintain them. and
- 12:51where they are currently and why they didn't
- 12:53produce any of those documents or they produced
- 12:56incomplete sets of those documents because they
- 12:59thought that you didn't know that they existed.
- 13:07Yeah, I mean, it's a goldmine, these driver qualification
- 13:10files. You know, we have listed here the job
- 13:13applications. Something as simple as what the
- 13:17driver wrote down in his application can be such
- 13:21a gold mine and such a simple way to get to know
- 13:24a driver. What did he write down in his job application?
- 13:26What did the driver omit for one reason or another?
- 13:31Again, this just goes to the very large paper
- 13:33trail that's required to be created and maintained
- 13:37for commercial drivers, road test certificates.
- 13:43Motor vehicle reports, as Dustin mentioned, includes
- 13:47the driver's history. And under the federal rules,
- 13:56the motor carrier is required to investigate
- 13:58a driver's MVR in each of the states where the
- 14:03driver has held a commercial driver's license
- 14:05in the past three years. Safety performance histories
- 14:11also required under the federal rules. Accident
- 14:16history, drug and alcohol violations, all of
- 14:19this stuff has to be created and maintained in
- 14:24the carrier's files and held onto for these statutory
- 14:29periods of time. As Dustin said, it's a huge
- 14:33red flag if the carrier hasn't held on to some
- 14:36of these really routine, basic documents. Because
- 14:39like, for instance, for drug and alcohol tests
- 14:42and the result of those tests, if the driver
- 14:47has worked at a FMCSA carrier, then there's going
- 14:54to be the clearinghouse these days where the
- 14:58carrier can just reach out to the FMCSA clearinghouse
- 15:01and check for the records of drug and alcohol
- 15:05violations for the driver. But crucially, the
- 15:10carrier still has to reach out to all of the
- 15:13driver's past employers for the prior three years.
- 15:18And all of these records and the qualification
- 15:22file, each of them gives you an opportunity to
- 15:26explore something that might have been overlooked
- 15:29by the carrier in the hiring process or might
- 15:33reflect something that's a theme in your own
- 15:37case. And so, you know, annual reviews, for instance,
- 15:41we list here, every driver has to submit their
- 15:44own list of violations. That includes parking
- 15:47tickets in the last 12 months, every year. or
- 15:52certified that they've had none. The carriers
- 15:57also have to annually request these MVRs for
- 16:01every state where the drivers listed are licensed.
- 16:06These are obviously very important records. I
- 16:12think a good practical application of it, Dustin,
- 16:18you have a deposition clip of uh PMQ talking
- 16:22about how they couldn't find these really basic
- 16:27driver records right yeah so let me i have a
- 16:30cue to uh oh so One of the things that you got
- 16:48to make sure when you are taking a PMQ is You
- 16:54have to probe how evasive they are being at the
- 16:57beginning. Okay, and part of that includes a
- 17:03review of what was produced to determine whether
- 17:05they're being forthcoming and providing what
- 17:08you know, they're legally required to maintain
- 17:11in their place of business or if they're trying
- 17:14to be evasive So in this case, this was a fatality
- 17:19and this individual was, let's just say, being
- 17:25a little bit evasive. And so I just wanted to
- 17:28play around and see what he did or did not know
- 17:32or would say he knew. So you are familiar with
- 17:35DOT standards that apply to your tractors and
- 17:41the materials that you are hauling with respect
- 17:44to hazardous materials. Is that correct? Yes,
- 17:46of course. Okay. Did you have to place a phone
- 17:52call to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration
- 17:56within the first 48 hours, notifying them of
- 18:00the fact that this fatality occurred? Yes. And
- 18:04did you do that? Yes, of course. Did you prepare
- 18:08a written report within 30 days of the fatality
- 18:11occurring? Yes, we have a timeline. as well as
- 18:16an insurance report. And those are documents
- 18:20that exist, true? True. So tell me about the
- 18:30report that you made to the DOT. The report to
- 18:35the DOT was made as it was a phone call given
- 18:38to them stating to them as there was a fatality.
- 18:43that occurred on this date. They don't really
- 18:48ask a ton of questions. They just, you just call
- 18:52to report it. That's about it. Do you have an
- 18:56understanding as to whether that conversation
- 18:58was recorded? I would estimate it is by the DOT,
- 19:04but I don't fully know if they do because it
- 19:10doesn't say this conversation is being recorded
- 19:11when you speak to them. so my estimate would
- 19:16be no. Were you the one that called the DOT?
- 19:20Yes. As far as the training that you have on
- 19:30the DOT requirements relating to your company
- 19:37operating, Okay, so here you see this guy was
- 19:5220 years old and he was running a motor carrier
- 19:57company that had 51 tractors and 54 power units.
- 20:04This is a perfect example of identifying a situation
- 20:09in which there's clearly medical records and
- 20:12items that were in their possession. that he
- 20:16just felt he wasn't legally obligated to produce.
- 20:22So after a round of court orders, compelling
- 20:26the deposition of this gentleman and the driver
- 20:30of the tractor and responses to discovery, there
- 20:34remained numerous things that had not been produced.
- 20:39And the way that you have to approach it is you
- 20:44have to confront the witness with the actual
- 20:48knowledge of the industry requirements because
- 20:52once you start talking about the Federal Motor
- 20:55Carrier Safety Administration regulations they
- 20:57know that they are in trouble if they did not
- 21:02comply and that's when they start to at least
- 21:05kind of crack and start to tell the truth and
- 21:09you can really see how bad the operation is.
- 21:13And I'll go back to this a little later on, but
- 21:17as part of this case, there were requests for
- 21:20admissions that were served, incorporating the
- 21:24safer information. And I'll leave that horror
- 21:29story for a little later. Well. So moving on
- 21:37to other records that. we should all be looking
- 21:40for in these trucking cases, hours of service
- 21:43records. Dustin and I have both been in practice
- 21:48long enough to recall when hours of service records
- 21:52were in paper format, believe it or not. So I
- 21:58think it's a true statement that even though
- 22:01there are these electronic logging devices for
- 22:04hours of service records these days, that has
- 22:07not done away with the problem of hours of service
- 22:12violations. The way that the hours of service
- 22:18are cheated or sort of finessed around the edges
- 22:22is just more sophisticated now than it used to
- 22:25be. Just zooming out, the purpose of requiring
- 22:31records about a driver's hours of service is
- 22:34because driver fatigue is a huge problem in the
- 22:37industry, and it causes a ton of crashes. And
- 22:40so these records document the driver's duty status.
- 22:45So that's both the driver's hours actually driving,
- 22:51but also off duty hours. There's on duty, but
- 22:58not driving hours. And for the most part these
- 23:04days, these hours are tracked in a FMCSA approved
- 23:09electronic logging device. And the records have
- 23:15to show a driver's duty status for every 24 hour
- 23:19period. And so not only duty status, but location.
- 23:26total miles driven that day. There has to be
- 23:31supporting documentation. It's not like the driver
- 23:34can just say, I drove X number of miles and was
- 23:39on and off duty during these hours. The federal
- 23:43rules required supporting documentation. So bills
- 23:48of lading, dispatch records, all of this stuff
- 23:52has to be created and maintained. And so you
- 23:55see on the slide, it must be kept for six months.
- 24:01And so the driver also has to certify the accuracy
- 24:04of these records and submit them within 13 days
- 24:08to the carrier. The carrier is also charged with
- 24:11verifying the accuracy. As you can imagine, there's
- 24:16lots of occasions throughout this vetting process
- 24:20of the hours of service where somebody might
- 24:23have slipped up and that gives you an opportunity
- 24:26to explore the potential liability. Any discrepancy
- 24:31or unexplained period of time in these hours
- 24:35of service records should be considered an immediate
- 24:37red flag. If the driver tells you in deposition
- 24:41that a discrepancy was just a mistake, You'll
- 24:46be able to check that statement against the supporting
- 24:49documents, the location information to just sort
- 24:54of determine if it really was a violation or
- 24:57just a mistake. And so, Dustin, you recently
- 25:05asked about a driver's discipline for an hours
- 25:11of service violation, I believe, right? Yeah,
- 25:14um and and I had initially planned on talking
- 25:16about that but the bill of lading is something
- 25:19that I want to bring up first because for those
- 25:22of The members of the audience who don't know
- 25:26much if anything about trucking I I want to make
- 25:31sure you understand a bill of lading is a very
- 25:35important document in the transaction of a motor
- 25:40care moving goods from one point to another.
- 25:44It identifies who the motor carrier is, it identifies
- 25:48who the seller of the goods are, and it identifies
- 25:53who the buyer of the goods are, and potentially
- 25:56if there is a broker involved, it would also
- 25:59identify the broker involved in the transaction.
- 26:03Now, that's a lot of words, but what does that
- 26:06actually mean, right? So when you're trying to
- 26:09hold someone legally liable, for something that
- 26:13happens in transit, whether it's a driver that
- 26:16was unfit to be behind the wheel, whether it's
- 26:19a motor carrier that's operating a chameleon
- 26:24carrier type of a business, whether it's, you
- 26:29have to keep all of that in the front of your
- 26:33mind because that is one of the single most important
- 26:36documents to determine every player in the transaction
- 26:42from an overhead view. And ostensibly, before
- 26:48you bring those parties into the case, you obviously
- 26:55would want to have a good fit basis to bring
- 26:57those parties into the case. So the way that
- 27:01I've seen this happen and play out when you're
- 27:05actually litigating a case is you take the PMQ
- 27:10and the driver's depot of the motor carrier as
- 27:13soon as you can in the case. I'm very aggressive
- 27:16with that because it does, by doing so, it prevents
- 27:20the defense from really being able to get all
- 27:24of the records and to really get their head around
- 27:27what's going on and how good or bad of an operation
- 27:31the motor carrier is running. And then you also
- 27:34have a situation where if it is like most transactions,
- 27:39the motor carriers have little to no bargaining
- 27:43power with the people that hire them to haul
- 27:46goods. And when that is the case, and you want
- 27:50to prove a joint venture between those entities,
- 27:55and obviously with everything going on with the
- 27:57preemption, it's kind of a tricky issue with
- 27:59broker liability, and Bobby will get into that
- 28:01more later. but these are things that you have
- 28:05to keep in mind because these are viable potential
- 28:08defendants that you need to get the information
- 28:12to assess whether there is a valid claim to pursue
- 28:18against that person involved in the transaction
- 28:20and figuring out whether someone is a de facto
- 28:25motor carrier in essence if there are other parties
- 28:30involved or if there is, I mean, it's too, there
- 28:35are too many scenarios to try and predict what
- 28:40it's going to be because each case is different.
- 28:42But the bottom line is, right, electronic control
- 28:46module data and satellite tracking. Like Bobby
- 28:49said, there's GPS data and speed data that is
- 28:54in every tractor now. And if they're not affirmatively
- 28:59giving you that information, then that's a problem,
- 29:03right? And in the same case, I showed you a clip
- 29:06from, same thing happened. They had the data
- 29:11in the tractor and this tractor was traveling
- 29:1358 miles an hour before this collision happened.
- 29:18And then here's the thing, instead of preserving
- 29:22the actual telematics data, that they were a
- 29:27subscriber to, they decided that they would discontinue
- 29:31their account with that telematics provider when
- 29:35I served them with the lawsuit. Two and a half
- 29:38months after I served them with foliation of
- 29:40evidence letters. And so at deposition, I was
- 29:45able to establish that they just kept all of
- 29:50this satellite tracking data. did not affirmatively
- 29:55keep it and instead elected to record their computer
- 30:00screen depicting some of the data from the crash
- 30:07where the 18 -wheeler hauling 8 ,000 gallons
- 30:11of aviation fuel on the 110 freeway flipped over
- 30:14and spilled a few thousand gallons and almost
- 30:16essentially created a bomb that shut down the
- 30:19entire freeway. When you put that together, you
- 30:26can really get to the bottom of what happened
- 30:31in a case before even the traffic crash report
- 30:36has been finalized, which sometimes takes up
- 30:39to a year in a fatality. So you got to use these
- 30:43things to your advantage and you got to understand
- 30:46what they are. And I will just sit there and
- 30:51I will go onto Google or AI and I will say, what
- 30:58are the satellite tracking devices that are most
- 31:02popular for motor carriers? And the more you
- 31:05handle these cases, the more familiar you become
- 31:08with the technology that's out there and that's
- 31:10available. And there are now AI assistants within
- 31:14cab videos that will watch the driver. And if
- 31:19you look like you're getting drowsy, if you're
- 31:21doing something that's distracted, that will
- 31:23actually give you a verbal correction if the
- 31:26motor carrier has it configured to do so. And
- 31:29that's data that's kept and reflected in a safety
- 31:32rating. And that's stuff that you should be asking
- 31:34for in your discovery. And if you're not asking
- 31:36for it, now you will. And if you're asking for
- 31:39it and you're not getting it, you need to file
- 31:42motions because that will give you a comprehensive
- 31:45history. of the safety rating of that driver
- 31:48ostensibly for the entire time that that program
- 31:51was in existence in that tracker. Yeah, great
- 31:59points, Dustin. I don't want to just hue only
- 32:03to the PowerPoint, but I want to make sure I'm
- 32:06staying on track myself. So I'll talk next about
- 32:10this vehicle inspection and maintenance records.
- 32:14So the exact wording from the federal rules is
- 32:17every carrier shall systematically inspect, repair,
- 32:20and maintain all commercial motor vehicles under
- 32:22its control. I didn't want to just list a bunch
- 32:26of the federal rules, but as Dustin said, showing
- 32:31that you know what's required can often help
- 32:35avoid... motion practice because the carrier
- 32:37realizes that you know everything that they're
- 32:41required to maintain and that they have to give
- 32:44it to you. And so these records include preventative
- 32:49maintenance records. So are all the parts in
- 32:54the truck in proper condition? It'll also contain
- 33:02these vehicle inspection and maintenance records.
- 33:04We'll also include VIN numbers, the make, the
- 33:09model, all that basic information. Crucially,
- 33:14in a couple of cases, I've seen it helps that
- 33:18the identity of the owner is listed. for under
- 33:23the vehicle identification information in these
- 33:27vehicle inspection and maintenance records. So
- 33:29even where the unit is being leased, you'll be
- 33:34able to identify the actual owner. Then there's
- 33:38driver vehicle inspection reports. Drivers are
- 33:41required to complete post -trip vehicle inspections
- 33:45after every trip. They have to list efficiencies.
- 33:50I guess it's worth mentioning that these days,
- 33:53these maintenance records are typically automatically
- 33:56generated by software and they include schedules
- 34:01like, for instance, for preventative maintenance.
- 34:06But, you know, I think an area in deposition
- 34:09that's ripe for discussion is these DVIRs where
- 34:14a driver is using an app, you know, or on his
- 34:18device or a phone. And it allows them to complete
- 34:22these vehicle inspection reports in a number
- 34:27of seconds. So I think it's worth asking questions
- 34:31to the driver. How long does it take you to complete
- 34:33these post -trip vehicle inspection reports?
- 34:37Maybe it's mere seconds. I think it's also worth
- 34:43checking with a subject matter expert to see
- 34:45if pressing a couple of buttons on a device really
- 34:49complies with the spirit of the federal rules.
- 34:54Is this, in other words, just the floor of what's
- 34:57required, or is it the best practice? And so
- 35:02these are required to be kept for three months
- 35:05by the carrier. And obviously, there can be some
- 35:10really big red flags if you're seeing poorly
- 35:15created schedules of maintenance for preventative
- 35:18maintenance or obviously if there's something
- 35:22flagged by the driver following a trip and that's
- 35:26not followed up on by the carrier, that can be
- 35:30a big deal. Fuel tax agreement records, I'll
- 35:37just briefly mention this. I've only been able
- 35:40to use it once or twice. They're tax records,
- 35:45really granular data on mileage. In theory, you
- 35:51can use these records to cross -reference hours
- 35:56of service, compliance, and a driver's activity.
- 36:06As Dustin mentioned, the electronic logging device
- 36:09records are huge. One of the things that's not
- 36:14listed here are devices like Dustin mentioned,
- 36:18like Lytics. It's a company that has a device
- 36:21that monitors driver behavior, like lane changes,
- 36:26speed. Really, really helpful to get data from
- 36:31companies that have these devices that monitor
- 36:35driver behavior. I will say for me personally,
- 36:40it's sometimes really difficult to parse the
- 36:43data that I receive on some of these devices.
- 36:48And so if we don't have an expert yet on the
- 36:51case, a PMQ deposition or a 30B6 always helps
- 36:56me understand. uh, what a particular auto generated
- 37:00report really means, how exactly it was created.
- 37:05Um, and, um, Dustin, you, you had, um, I think
- 37:11some comments on the, the electronic data. I
- 37:14mean, we've, we've already sort of discussed
- 37:16all the various ways. Yeah. I want to tie it
- 37:19all together now because What you have to do
- 37:23is it's a multi -pronged approach, right? There's
- 37:26written discovery which we talked about there's
- 37:29deposition which we talked about and there's
- 37:35Essentially getting to the finish line whether
- 37:38that's trying the case or getting it ready and
- 37:41then the carrier putting a good number on it
- 37:43to get it resolved and What can you do? to help
- 37:49yourself out Number one, if you don't send this
- 37:53foliation of evidence letter at the beginning
- 37:55of every single case, please, please, please
- 37:59do yourself a favor and start doing that. You
- 38:03send it to the address that you find on the safer
- 38:08system for any parties involved. and that way
- 38:13you know that you are relying on the information
- 38:16that's up to date as of a couple days beforehand,
- 38:20okay? Number two, you then take the deposition
- 38:25of the PMQ or the 30B6 like Bobby said, and you
- 38:30identify what in the universe of information
- 38:35that we know is out there, are they hiding? because
- 38:40customarily there's going to be something and
- 38:43you just have to be thorough in terms of how
- 38:47you approach each deposition to cover each category
- 38:51of information that they're required to maintain
- 38:54in order for you to then delve into whether there
- 38:58is a spoliation issue. And so when that happens,
- 39:03you already know that you have to have filed
- 39:08motions to compel PMQs to compel the production
- 39:13of the documents and things that you're seeking.
- 39:18Once you do that, and you get a court order granting
- 39:21that, if the defendant does not comply with the
- 39:26court's order, you then have to get aggressive.
- 39:30And the way you do that is you bring a motion
- 39:33for issue, evidence, or terminating sanctions.
- 39:38Typically, terminating sanctions are obviously
- 39:40a very, very, very drastic remedy. However, when
- 39:45you can establish that there has been affirmative
- 39:48spoliation of evidence in the face of being served
- 39:54with a preservation of evidence letter, putting
- 39:57them on notice of the fact that they're required
- 39:59to basically put any evidence into a litigation
- 40:03hold, when they ignore you, and don't do that,
- 40:09you then get to bring a motion for sanctions.
- 40:14And what you do with that is you put the court
- 40:18on notice again of how competent you are, that
- 40:22you are being so diligent, representing your
- 40:25client zealously, that you're not going to let
- 40:27this motor carrier hold onto things that are
- 40:32clearly discoverable and are just going to further
- 40:36help you prove your case as to the concurrent
- 40:39negligence of the driver who most likely made
- 40:43some type of mistake when operating the tractor,
- 40:46as well as the employer for failing to either
- 40:51adequately or reasonably supervise, train, or
- 40:56retain someone. And so that's how you figure
- 41:00this out is the way to get to the corporate tortfeasor.
- 41:05is analyzing each one of the avenues in the electronic
- 41:12logging and the ELDRs. When you then bring a
- 41:19motion, you then put all of the documents that
- 41:24weren't produced, all of the testimony about
- 41:28how they have all those documents, the court
- 41:32orders, compelling those documents, and then
- 41:38you wait and see what happens. Because when you
- 41:43are dealing with a defendant that's just not
- 41:45going to listen, you put yourself in a beautiful
- 41:48position to either affirmatively strike their
- 41:53answer because of this foliation issue and the
- 41:57continued defiance of numerous court orders,
- 42:01but You also are working up an incredible case
- 42:06against the owner of the goods identified on
- 42:10the bill of lading because they have specific
- 42:15legal obligations in terms of what they're required
- 42:18to do to vet a motor carrier before they hire
- 42:22them to transport goods for them and going back
- 42:27to the safer system, I'm going to, Bobby, if
- 42:30you don't mind, I want to share a couple requests
- 42:32for admission that I propounded just to show,
- 42:36you know, we want to take every issue off the
- 42:42table that we can to the extent that we can,
- 42:46right? And so that means we want to definitively
- 42:53nullify and remove an issue. And so here, let
- 42:59me pull this up. Apologies. There we go. Okay.
- 43:09So I happen to be driving on my way to the airport
- 43:16for a family vacation and I happened to drive
- 43:23by the defendant in this case and at this time
- 43:29the defendant motor carrier had not, we had not
- 43:33had access to the tractor or the trailer or our
- 43:37client's vehicle because they were still in CHP
- 43:41custody and We did not know what was going on,
- 43:46but I had suspicions that they were operating
- 43:50at what's called a chameleon carrier. And on
- 43:54the side, you see what we discussed earlier,
- 43:58that DOT number and the motor carrier number.
- 44:03And then there will be information that is legally
- 44:09required to be posted on the side of the tractor.
- 44:13Then you look at the actual logo on the tractor
- 44:19and you see the name of a motor carrier. And
- 44:23this is why it's so important to be familiar
- 44:26with SAFER because in this case, the registered
- 44:35owner of the tractor that was involved in this
- 44:39fatality is an entity by the name of Maverick
- 44:44Tank Lines was, I should say, and its operating
- 44:49authority was revoked on May 31st of 2024. Now
- 44:56that happened roughly six months before the fatality
- 45:04in this case. And so what you do is you can't
- 45:11you can't not admit the information on this is
- 45:16true and accurate because it's coming from the
- 45:20defendant that's responding to the discovery
- 45:22and here you get the actual content and their
- 45:28responses, right? And so this admission is functionally
- 45:36an admission that this motor carrier is operating
- 45:39a motor carrier with suspended operating authority
- 45:47from the Department of Transportation and it's
- 45:50putting the logo for the California licensed
- 45:58motor carrier on the side of the tractor. That's
- 46:02a felony and I have admissions as to each of
- 46:10these items, admitting that the DOT number is
- 46:15registered to the defendant that is the suspended
- 46:19entity. And this is all just RFAs that I put
- 46:23together from what was on the safer website and
- 46:27a picture that I took because I was lucky enough
- 46:29to drive by that tractor on the way to the airport.
- 46:33But when you put all this together, what a judge
- 46:36will do is this case It is now going to be an
- 46:44admitted liability case. And in all likelihood,
- 46:49those defendants are going to be criminally prosecuted.
- 46:54The federal government is aware of it. The state
- 46:57of California is aware of it. And you just have
- 47:01to do your due diligence to make sure that you
- 47:04inform yourself of every aspect of each entity
- 47:08that is involved in a transaction because if
- 47:11you do and you pay attention, you're going to
- 47:14find the bread crumb that unravels. You're going
- 47:18to unravel the entire operation. And when you're
- 47:23representing someone that's catastrophically
- 47:25injured or someone who's lost their kid and you
- 47:30have an immense responsibility to do right by
- 47:33them. And if you treat your trucking cases like
- 47:39this, and you methodically approach and make
- 47:43sure that you are provided with everything that
- 47:47you know exists. That is what you will be able
- 47:50to do right by your client with to get the best
- 47:54outcome for them. Yeah, that's a great point,
- 47:59Dustin. So in addition, I think what he's saying
- 48:03in addition to the publicly available information
- 48:06on the safer website, you should try to be extremely
- 48:09lucky and see the actual motor carrier on the
- 48:13freeway. That's an incredible, incredible story.
- 48:17But just to wrap up the electronic logging device
- 48:22discovery, Dustin said it best when he said that
- 48:27modern trucks are basically computers on wheels.
- 48:31Every Carrier has a telematic system that records
- 48:34everything from the speed, the location, the
- 48:37braking. And oftentimes the carrier will want
- 48:43to produce a summary report of these telematics.
- 48:48And Dustin mentioned earlier, you want to get
- 48:50the raw data. of these electronic logging devices
- 48:55and have it parsed by an expert because sometimes
- 49:00those summary reports will gloss over conveniently
- 49:04some pretty important points. So this part of
- 49:13the presentation comes with a big caveat. So
- 49:16we should start by noting there's a split in
- 49:18authority in broker liability cases. Jesse Creed,
- 49:24a partner here at Panache Ravaputi, recently
- 49:28pointed out a recent case that could significantly
- 49:32limit broker liability. Nonetheless, there are
- 49:39some theories. And the most obvious being negligent
- 49:45selection of a carrier. So the broker has a duty
- 49:48to competently select a competent motor carrier
- 49:52on behalf of the shipper. And if they didn't
- 49:56do so, or they didn't do their due diligence
- 49:59in looking at the carrier safety statistics,
- 50:03then arguably you have something to hang your
- 50:07hat on in terms of liability. There's cases where
- 50:11you can argue an agency relationship exists But
- 50:16here, you know, we have a slide that talks about
- 50:18contracts and agreements contracts and agreements
- 50:21between a broker and a motor carrier is going
- 50:25to define that relationship and It'll show these
- 50:32load specific documents. This will show how much
- 50:35control in some situations the broker is exerting
- 50:39over the carrier And and so that can sort of
- 50:43help prove this agency relationship Those communications
- 50:48often Communications between the broker and the
- 50:52carrier can also show how much control is being
- 50:54exerted by the broker And so these are all ways
- 51:01to expand your thinking about liability in a
- 51:07trucking cases by bringing in the broker. And
- 51:11so like with everything that we've discussed,
- 51:15vetting a motor carrier creates a paper trail.
- 51:19And so... the broker is going to have all sorts
- 51:22of documentation about everything that they did
- 51:24to ascertain the competency of the carrier. And
- 51:30they're also going to have to produce, the broker
- 51:33is going to have to produce their policies and
- 51:36procedures for vetting carriers. And if those
- 51:42aren't up to snuff, that's another ripe area.
- 51:48And so everything listed here, I don't want to
- 51:51go through every single thing, but these are
- 51:53all really important areas of discovery for brokers
- 51:57in these cases. Again, there is a split of authority.
- 52:02Another attorney here at the firm, the famous
- 52:04Andrew Owen, pointed out that the Supreme Court
- 52:08is going to be... hearing a case that might resolve
- 52:12the conflicting decisions. So we might have some
- 52:18more clarity on the issue soon. So this is what
- 52:26I mentioned earlier, the load -specific documents.
- 52:30This helps identify who was involved. The dispatch
- 52:34records show control. I'll just move through
- 52:40here. We've had a couple of cases where a broker
- 52:44has some really interesting marketing materials
- 52:47where they seemingly hold themselves out as akin
- 52:53to a motor carrier or handling everything from
- 52:58start to finish. And these kinds of things help
- 53:01show more control than just a neutral middleman
- 53:07connecting a shipper and a carrier. And so this
- 53:13is the case that Jesse Creed pointed out. recently,
- 53:17and I don't want to go too much into FAAA preemption.
- 53:22It's not outside the scope of our discovery talk,
- 53:25but it's certainly something to keep an eye on
- 53:29right now. The Supreme Court is going to weigh
- 53:31in on the Montgomery case. But going back to
- 53:37really the thrust of the presentation is the
- 53:40types of discovery in these trucking cases that
- 53:42are so crucial. We really like to review jury
- 53:47instructions at the outset of the case before
- 53:49propounding discovery because it really shows
- 53:52you the answers to the test before you take the
- 53:55test and so we use those to craft our active
- 53:59discovery and and then you know the Staying updated
- 54:06and in the trucking cases is really important
- 54:09as you can see with the broker liability shifting
- 54:13theories. Sometimes the regulations will change.
- 54:19So it's important to not just sort of cut and
- 54:22paste old discovery and reuse it because sometimes
- 54:26things will change enough that it needs to be
- 54:31meaningfully altered. Dashcam, 911 calls, these
- 54:37are other areas that should obviously be explored
- 54:40in discovery. Dustin, you mentioned on the point
- 54:46of just discovery in general that this isn't
- 54:51your typical case. It comes with a really awesome
- 54:54responsibility because there's infrequently a
- 54:58situation where somebody's involved in a trucking
- 55:00case and it's a small injury. So really there's
- 55:04a huge duty to look at all the publicly available
- 55:07resources at the outset. and then sort of dig
- 55:13a little deeper based on everything that's required
- 55:16by the federal rules. Yeah, just to echo what
- 55:21Bobby said, I am always perpetually blown away
- 55:27by how much information I can get through a public
- 55:31records request or a FOA. Granted, the FOA request
- 55:36have been very slow recently, but still, at least
- 55:40with my PRAs in the state of California, I have
- 55:45gotten almost immediate responses. Obviously,
- 55:49they're obligated to respond within 10 days.
- 55:52And if you're not representing the party, then
- 55:55you're going to get less or redacted information
- 55:57or redacted materials or partially redacted.
- 56:01But that said, I try and tell people this, there
- 56:06are cameras on a lot of the highways that are
- 56:11controlled by Caltrans that I think record up
- 56:17to 72 hours after, at which point they disappear
- 56:21forever. So if you are retained on a case after
- 56:28it happens immediately, do yourself a favor and
- 56:33do a public records request act to Caltrans on
- 56:37the highways for any of the cameras in the vicinity
- 56:40where it happened. Also CHP asking for MBAR footage,
- 56:49the body -worn camera footage, all 911 logs.
- 56:54That will help you identify all the parties that
- 56:58were involved in terms of the first responders
- 57:00because we always know that there's some type
- 57:02of hearsay issue with a really important statement
- 57:05that was made and if you don't know who it was
- 57:08that was involved in responding it's going to
- 57:11make it really hard for you later down the line
- 57:13and people don't remember things so when you
- 57:16get that stuff informally for free basically
- 57:21within 10 days you already have your liability
- 57:25roadmap most of the time and then it becomes
- 57:30a game of are they going to tell me the truth
- 57:34as to what happened based on my reviewing everything
- 57:38that was recorded at this crash? Because any
- 57:43time law enforcement goes code three and they
- 57:47have lights and sirens on, the M bar camera inside
- 57:50the cruisers automatically records. So that's
- 57:54something that if you have a case involving catastrophic
- 57:57injuries or death, you are certainly going to
- 58:02have a plethora of information because of department
- 58:07policies mandating use of bodywork cameras out
- 58:11in the field now. So again the more you prepare
- 58:17and you know I'm a Wisconsin Badger fan if you
- 58:20cannot see my clock behind me but you know the
- 58:23great John Wooden said failing to prepare is
- 58:25preparing to fail and my mentors I have always,
- 58:32always stressed upon me the importance of being
- 58:36prepared. And if you do this stuff, you are going
- 58:39to be able to take on anyone regardless of the
- 58:42size of the firm, regardless of the tactics that
- 58:44they employ, and you're going to do right by
- 58:46your clients. Well said. Dustin mentioned the
- 58:53Public Records Act. This is a hobby horse of
- 58:55mine. I'd be remiss if I didn't at least add
- 58:58that we've had a couple of cases they're not
- 59:01necessarily tractor trailer cases but sort of
- 59:04adjacent to trucking tow trucks and medical waste
- 59:08trucking where the defendant entities have contracts
- 59:13with public entities. And so we've been able
- 59:17to craft Public Records Act requests to obtain
- 59:21contracts and certificates of insurance from
- 59:25like, for instance, in one case, a public university
- 59:27and another case from California Highway Patrol
- 59:31that showed a minimum level of insurance that
- 59:35was required by the public entity to be kept
- 59:38by the defendant carrier. And we got that information
- 59:44for free. And it contradicted in one case, what
- 59:50defendants form an interrogatory 4 .1 response
- 59:53set. So Public Records Act is, I think, just
- 59:57an amazing use of time and discovery. And it
- 1:00:03doesn't cost anything, as Dustin said. Dustin
- 1:00:09mentioned earlier the idea of preserving evidence.
- 1:00:15If you get involved in a case early, or even
- 1:00:18if you're coming in late, it's still worth sending.
- 1:00:22a preservation of evidence letter that's ideally
- 1:00:25very specific about emails, trip receipts, engine
- 1:00:31control module data, telematics, GPS, all of
- 1:00:35that. So it's really important to send that out
- 1:00:40early as soon as you get in the case. And we've
- 1:00:47talked about this, Dustin. played a deposition
- 1:00:50clip already. We like taking multiple PMQ or
- 1:00:5630b6 depositions just to verify information that
- 1:01:00we've received from the defendants and get their
- 1:01:04own take on their compliance with the federal
- 1:01:07rules. And so I guess our final takeaways, you
- 1:01:15know, Dustin mentioned that preparation is a
- 1:01:19huge part of it. I couldn't agree more with that.
- 1:01:23I think at the outside of the case, using the
- 1:01:25jury instructions and using publicly available
- 1:01:29information really helps you get off on the right
- 1:01:34foot in the discovery process. And a lot of people
- 1:01:38say that that's where the case is truly won is
- 1:01:41in the discovery process or in deposition. And
- 1:01:46with that, thank you very much for attending.
- 1:01:52This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:01:55so much, Bobby and Dustin, for your time and
- 1:01:57thank you so much to our audience. Have a great
- 1:01:59day, everybody.