Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Where Metta practice and Attachment Repair meet
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:20love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is Thursday, October 23rd, 2025 at six, 7:36 PM Pacific
- 0:28Daylight Time and I thought that I would talk about something
- 0:34that comes up quite a bit, which is meta practice and attachment
- 0:40repair. And why do we practice meta the
- 0:43way that we practice here? And when you look at the what
- 0:51that really means, if we start with what kind of meta practice
- 0:56we offer here, it's metagana practice.
- 1:01So high concentration practice, using loving kindness as the
- 1:09object of meditation is one way to translate it into English.
- 1:17The main reason that we that I like to teach it in this way is
- 1:22because you use the mind state of loving kindness is the object
- 1:30of meditation, which means you have to be able to identify what
- 1:33a mind state is. You have to be able to generate
- 1:36the mind state you want. You have to be able to sustain
- 1:39it to use it as an object of meditation and in insecure and
- 1:45disorganized attachment. One of the things that's missing
- 1:49in the consolation of skills that you would need in order to
- 1:53maintain security is recognizing mind States and having some
- 1:58agency in dealing with them. And the reason that insecure and
- 2:04disorganized people don't have that capacity well developed is
- 2:09because in childhood it wasn't one of the the skill sets that
- 2:13was offered to them to learn by their caregivers.
- 2:17In secure family systems, the caregivers are interested in the
- 2:24mind states of the children as they're growing, and they
- 2:27inquire about the mind states. And in that constant inquiry
- 2:32about the mind state of the child, the child has to learn to
- 2:36recognize the mind States and also has to learn to communicate
- 2:40about them. And very often in insecure and
- 2:45disorganized attached family systems, that inquiry doesn't
- 2:50happen. So what would that sound like?
- 2:53Your caregiver would be going. What's going on with you?
- 2:55Use your words. I can't figure out what's going
- 2:58on with you. What?
- 2:59You seem excited. Are you excited?
- 3:01You seem sad. Are you sad?
- 3:03What's actually going on with you?
- 3:06And then the child would have to be able to investigate and
- 3:08understand what that was. And then they would have to be
- 3:11able to communicate it. I'm not sad, I'm angry or
- 3:17whatever it is that's happening with the child.
- 3:22The statistic which Mary Ainsworth came up with when she
- 3:28was doing the in home studies in London, when they were
- 3:33formulating the collaboration with John Bolby, the
- 3:38understanding of these three basic attachment strategies.
- 3:43When they began, of course it was focused on children and so
- 3:47secure, securely attached children anxiously avoided
- 3:51detached children and anxiously ambivalent attached children
- 4:00have lost by train of thought. What they noticed is that these
- 4:16kinds of questions came up in the securely attached families.
- 4:21But also, the statistic that was so haunting to me was that the
- 4:30kids that grew up to be secure were in households where their
- 4:34needs were met 30% of the time or more.
- 4:40And as I like to say, the last time you took took a quiz and
- 4:47got 30% correct, what grade did they give you?
- 4:52So it is a low, an astonishingly low bar the level of care that's
- 4:58required in order to earn security, which also means that
- 5:02kids who didn't grow up in an environment where their needs
- 5:05were met 30% of the time or more were pretty harsh.
- 5:11Kids who grow up in disorganized with a disorganized attachment
- 5:16strategy, it's so highly correlated with trauma that you
- 5:20might say that the environments that they grew up in were, were
- 5:24dangerous. And so when we begin to
- 5:30understand and create our database, our perceptual
- 5:34database of meaning, if you grow up in these environments which
- 5:39are so adverse, you tend to begin to develop these
- 5:44structures that are quite lopsided on the negative side of
- 5:48things. You know, we build a working
- 5:54model of ourselves and we build a working model of other people.
- 5:57And it comes from that early engagement with other people.
- 6:02In Buddhism, we call itself in world, but world means other
- 6:07people, not the physical world. If you remember your Sati
- 6:14Patanasuta in, in the chorus, it says mindfulness of inside,
- 6:20mindfulness of outside, and mindfulness of inside and
- 6:23outside. Inside is you and outside is
- 6:26other people. And then being able to track the
- 6:30interaction between you and other people is that full set of
- 6:35understanding. This is what's going on with me.
- 6:38This is what I think is going on with you.
- 6:41I'm reacting to the way that you present yourself.
- 6:44You're reacting to where that I present myself and I can
- 6:48mentalize that I can make sense of that as it goes back and
- 6:52forth. That would be a good level
- 6:54mentalizing, but but you also notice in insecure and
- 6:58disorganized attachment is that people don't mentalize well
- 7:03enough actually to be able to do that.
- 7:05It's one of the reasons why I think that the positive
- 7:10meditators score higher on the mentalizing engages the non
- 7:16deposit of meditators do because the the training that comes from
- 7:22the pasta improves mentalizing to such a great degree.
- 7:28But as you build the the working models yourself, you build it
- 7:33from the reactions of your primary caregiver.
- 7:37And really it's constructed in the first few years of life.
- 7:42You present yourself just spontaneously to the world and
- 7:47then depending on how the world reacts, you have an
- 7:52understanding of who you are. We don't have a good facility
- 7:58in, in the human condition to accurately gauge who we are.
- 8:04We, we really do experience that in relationship to the way that
- 8:10other people experience us. What that means really is that
- 8:14if you had a well resourced arrested caregiver who was able
- 8:22to control the environment enough that they could provide
- 8:27reliable care to you, then you thought of yourself as somebody
- 8:31who get their needs met. And if you grew up in an
- 8:34environment where the the caregivers were stressed that
- 8:38they they had difficulty controlling the environment that
- 8:42you grew up in, then their reaction to you was often that
- 8:49the neediness that you had was a burden.
- 8:53If you grew up and you come into the world and you think that you
- 8:57are too needy and that you're a burden to other people, this is
- 9:01really rooted in the infant expressing this need to the
- 9:06caregiver and the caregiver being overwhelmed by the need of
- 9:11the child. The child that you were had
- 9:15happened to you. If you've ever been around small
- 9:19kids, you know, it's a lot of work, it's a lot of attention,
- 9:24it's a lot of energy and they're unfiltered.
- 9:30So can be astonishingly how hurt your feelings could be by, you
- 9:37know, a 10 month old. Step back a little bit.
- 9:43You realize they're ten months old.
- 9:45I should really be able to take this less personally.
- 9:48If you bet around infants, you know, they, they, they respond
- 9:54to movement and they make that I, I think of it as a grimace,
- 9:57but it's kind of like a, a smile, an attachment request
- 10:00smile. That's generic and it, it goes
- 10:03off for everybody. And we get so attached and so
- 10:08interested in creating these pictures of particularly when
- 10:13it's, it's us taking care of the child.
- 10:15The child is responsive to us and can see us and know us.
- 10:19Actually, that isn't what's happening.
- 10:26However, be that as it may, we are receiving the information
- 10:33back from the caregiver in the way that they are able to pay
- 10:36attention to us and we're understanding our requests for
- 10:41care in relationship to their response to them.
- 10:45If, if our caregivers are reliable, they're predictable.
- 10:50If we can learn a language of communication that's that's in
- 10:56feeling in the body and gesturally.
- 10:59And they are able to empathetically attune to us and
- 11:03pay attention enough to notice how we're expressing ourselves
- 11:08and to identify from those expressions what we need and
- 11:12then provide that need for us. We really develop a sense of
- 11:17confidence that we can manage the world and that our knees,
- 11:22even if we don't, even if we can't articulate what they are
- 11:26because we can't or we know what they are, which we don't, we
- 11:30still develop a sense of confidence that we can navigate
- 11:35the world. And if you don't have that
- 11:40experience as a child, you develop a a sense of yourself
- 11:45which is different than that. The defining characteristic of
- 11:50children who grow up to be avoidant is neglect.
- 11:54Profound neglect in child. Often left to our own devices to
- 12:02figure things out, we can't figure it out.
- 12:05But we don't know that either. And it's a terrible sadness that
- 12:16overtakes us when there's nothing we can do.
- 12:19And we try everything we can think of to get a response from
- 12:26our caregivers. We try everything and nothing
- 12:29really works, and so we abandoned ourselves and
- 12:34undertake learning what we have to do in order to get the
- 12:40attention that we want. And it's an unbearable sadness.
- 12:45And so we learn to suppress that.
- 12:48And in suppressing sadness, we suppress all emotion and we
- 12:56learn to suppress our attachment system because we can't bear
- 12:59the, the, the, the failure of connection.
- 13:06And then we create a kind of idealizing defense, which is
- 13:14what's required in those family systems for us.
- 13:19At the core of that is the terrible sadness and the
- 13:23recognition that there's nothing that we can do to actually get
- 13:26people to take care of us. And that moves us away from
- 13:34forming collaborative relationships.
- 13:36We we never really learn how to collaborate with people.
- 13:41What we learn is to transact, to trade for care.
- 13:48We learn to idealize, which is the mechanism of commerce in
- 13:52those kinds of family systems. I idealize you and you give me
- 13:57what I want. That's the transaction.
- 14:01And the better I am at figuring out how to idealize you, the
- 14:05bigger the reward. So I want to get really good at
- 14:09it in kids who grow up to be ambivalent, anxious, ambivalent
- 14:16or preoccupied. Avoidant kids are dismissing
- 14:20when they grow up. It's chaotic and you can't
- 14:25predict how to communicate you. You think that you don't
- 14:30understand the world, that you don't know what's going on
- 14:34because you can't get a consistent response out of your
- 14:38caregiver. You could do the same thing
- 14:40three times to get 3 different responses from them.
- 14:43And so don't rely on any of that.
- 14:46You just demand, demand, demand, demand.
- 14:50And every now and then you get what you want, which is
- 14:53confusing because you might think, oh, this time I did it
- 15:00right. But if you did that same thing
- 15:01again, you'd get a different response from it.
- 15:03So how do you manage that? You begin to think of yourself
- 15:07as fundamentally broken, unable to do that.
- 15:11That's the working model that we're beginning to talk about in
- 15:16that, in that, that avoidant child, there's just all of this
- 15:22suppression and this idealization, which is the way
- 15:25of coping in, in the ambivalent child.
- 15:30It's just chaos. And so it really is this demand,
- 15:33this demand, this demand over and over again to try and and
- 15:38figure out what it is that will get you what you need.
- 15:46That creates in the avoiding child, of course, a totally self
- 15:49involved experience. Whereas in the ambivalent child
- 15:54that develops an external focus and an enmeshing in the mind
- 16:00state of the caregiver so that you can try and figure out what
- 16:05the the caregiver needs in the moment, who you have to be in
- 16:10the moment so that you can get them to respond to you.
- 16:15That's the working model. These are largely negative
- 16:20experiences. When the sense of self arises
- 16:25for the child that's avoided or ambivalent, the experience is
- 16:37partly negative. It's held differently and
- 16:41avoided children. They they in a defense idealized
- 16:48their self concept. They're the greatest thing that
- 16:53ever happened. But that's this very flimsy
- 16:57facade that's covering at the center of it is this terrible
- 17:01sadness that there's nothing that they can do, that they're
- 17:05not worth anything, that somebody would be responsive to
- 17:09them. The preoccupied, sorry, the
- 17:13ambivalent child who grows up to be the preoccupied adult loses
- 17:17track of themselves in their involvement in the mind state of
- 17:21the other person. And so that their self concept
- 17:24is somebody who's completely helpless and that and dependent
- 17:30on the care that they would receive from someone else.
- 17:36When the, when you're, when you grow up on the other side of the
- 17:39trauma line, where the caregiver is actually the source of
- 17:41fearfulness or someone in the family system is the source of
- 17:46fearfulness that activates the attachment system.
- 17:50When you are compelled by the attachment system to seek
- 17:53proximity to the the caregiver, the fight or flight mechanism
- 17:59goes off to prevent you from seeking proximity to somebody
- 18:04who might harm you. And in that case, really, you
- 18:08think of yourself as damaged goods and you think of the other
- 18:14person as dangerous or harmful. So the kind of double negative
- 18:21that happens, why am I talking about this if I'm talking about
- 18:28loving kindness? Because we have a lot of work to
- 18:37do to change the self concept, the working model of self, and
- 18:43also some work to do to change the working model of other
- 18:46people. And we do this really by
- 18:51intentionally developing our capacity for positivity.
- 18:58I think remarkably in a way, the the further out you are from
- 19:04secure functioning, the the higher your tolerance to
- 19:07negative states is. And and this is actually also
- 19:11negative. Disorganized people don't tend
- 19:19to react to difficult circumstances or problematic
- 19:23behavior in relationships until way beyond everybody else's
- 19:27protesting because their tolerance for pain is so high,
- 19:32their tolerance for distressing behavior and relationships is so
- 19:35high. And what we really need to do is
- 19:39bring that down to really lower it.
- 19:41If you could lower it to the to the reaction that secure people
- 19:45have to that kind of behavior, you wouldn't engage in it at
- 19:49all. Secure people don't.
- 19:51They won't do it. And you know, you're 10 miles
- 19:55down the road is a disorganized people with that kind of
- 20:00distressing behavior. Most of us who are grew up
- 20:08insecure, disorganized have underdeveloped positivity
- 20:18systems. We're used to a lot of negative
- 20:22States, and we're not so used to positive states.
- 20:26And so part of the repair for this is to begin to develop our
- 20:33capacity for positive states, usually in the way that it goes
- 20:40when you don't have the full spectrum of skills already
- 20:46developed, you have an absence of some skills, but you've over
- 20:51developed the other skills to compensate for the absence of
- 20:54the other skills. So this is a, it's a 2 pronged
- 20:59approach here. We have to bring down the
- 21:02overdevelopment of our capacity to hold negative States and we
- 21:07have to bring up our capacity to hold positive states.
- 21:12Mudit hey. George.
- 21:16Hi. The the concept of positive
- 21:22emotions. Yeah.
- 21:25Sometimes I feel it's not conscious.
- 21:30How do you mean? Consciously developing positive
- 21:34emotions versus indirect positivity, which comes from
- 21:38meditation is it's it's. It's hard for to tell somebody
- 21:45to be consciously positive because their inner system feels
- 21:50not positive. Right.
- 21:56I think that we're talking about two things that are distinct,
- 22:02not one thing. You do practice meditation for a
- 22:08while and you you make various breakthroughs.
- 22:12You see, for instance, that the self is not the author, the
- 22:16controller, the doer, the creator of anything.
- 22:19It's actually the audience. And then you, you, you begin to
- 22:23track and understand how a conditioned responses to things,
- 22:27if they're not examined, create these conceptual realities, some
- 22:32of which can be quite afflictive.
- 22:36And so you stop reacting from a particularly conditioned way and
- 22:44move into the natural state, which is quite positive.
- 22:50I think that that happens over time.
- 22:53Emotions, of course, in the Buddhist frame are neutral and
- 22:57it's the relationship to the emotions that provide a positive
- 23:02or negative valence to that, which I actually agree.
- 23:08But it is also a part of our colloquial conditioning, our
- 23:14colloquial understanding that we've designated some emotions
- 23:18as negative and some as positive.
- 23:19So I'm really talking about it in that colloquial sense.
- 23:26If you look at the seven base emotions that, well, there's a,
- 23:34depending on what group you're looking at 4:00 or up to seven
- 23:39base emotions. But I like the Ekman anger for
- 23:42sadness, discuss contempt, surprise and happiness are the
- 23:46seven. What do you notice about our
- 23:49valencing of that? There's five negative ones and
- 23:54two positive ones in in in western thought right?
- 24:00And I, I'm, so I think that that's part of it.
- 24:07In Buddhist thought, it's the relationship to the emotional
- 24:10experience that matters. Is it a, an afflictive or
- 24:14beneficial relationship to it? For instance, sadness is often
- 24:19one of the, the negative emotions, but it is also an
- 24:23astonishing amount of energy. And when you harness it, it is
- 24:28the thing that motivates you to replace relationships when
- 24:32they're lost, right? And it's built into our nervous
- 24:38system. Part of each moment of creation
- 24:42of reality is who do I share this with?
- 24:45And when you know people for a long time, they get connected to
- 24:51a lot of stuff that you just naturally think of them to share
- 24:54your experience with. And when you lose them, when you
- 24:58get to that part, there's a pop of sadness that happens with
- 25:02each of those occasions when you think of them to share something
- 25:07and they're no longer available, which is to alert you to move
- 25:10that attachment to someone else. And when you've known somebody
- 25:15for a long time, that that that little pop of sadness can be so
- 25:20many that it's an ocean of sadness that overtakes you.
- 25:23And so then we have the capacity to create a buffer that holds
- 25:28all of that loss. I like to call it the if only,
- 25:31if only that didn't happen. If only I did something
- 25:34different. If, if only they would come back
- 25:38or whatever it is that holds that as you gradually move it to
- 25:43other people in a negative sense.
- 25:49If we're going to parse it the way Buddhist thought does,
- 25:52that's a very positive experience of sadness.
- 25:55It moves you into connecting where the connection has been
- 26:01lost and in a negative sense, that sadness.
- 26:05When you fail to grieve, that is when you fail to move the
- 26:09attention to someone else. You get caught up in these
- 26:14cycles of remembrance of someone you know.
- 26:21I have a close friend. We we shared a a close friend
- 26:25who died and after about 30 years, she said to me, I think
- 26:37it's time I'd let him go. That would be just a terrible
- 26:45confounding of sadness. No way in Christianity or you
- 26:54have a a mourning period. We don't have that in Buddhism.
- 26:57We move on fast. Is that making sense?
- 27:05And if I answered enough of your question or is there still more
- 27:11we did? Yeah, just good guy.
- 27:14I mean I just feel like even when we do meta there is a
- 27:17conscious move of the mind towards positive emotion.
- 27:23Right positivity. Even though the body might feel
- 27:28negative emotions. So then we're talking about the
- 27:34view and the feelings, the emotions in the body, which are
- 27:38also different things. So you have the capacity to send
- 27:46something. The object can be sensed when
- 27:47there's contact between the two. You have a consciousness of a
- 27:50sensing experience arising. This is pre self.
- 27:53So you don't know about this is unconscious, but we have
- 27:57consciousness of the sensing experience.
- 27:59The body really tells us, is it urgent?
- 28:03Does it not matter? Is there time for something
- 28:05pleasant? And then it hits up into the
- 28:08brain stem, which is then the thing that distributes it.
- 28:15There's and there's a bottleneck in the brain.
- 28:18Really it's these discrete mind moments, one after the other,
- 28:21that are being defined, creating meaning, which create moment by
- 28:27moment the perception of conceptual reality.
- 28:34The mind if that undifferentiated, unfixated
- 28:38sensing experience has a match in the perceptual database, that
- 28:42whole thread of memory attaches to it and it rolls into
- 28:46conceptual reality. That tableau that we experience
- 28:50in between ultimate reality and the defining of it and the
- 28:54conceptual reality we experience is where the view goes, and the
- 28:58view has a distorting quality on the way that we translate
- 29:03ultimate experience into conceptual reality.
- 29:07Is that making sense? And so when we begin to explore
- 29:14what views are, we're looking at what that filtering mechanism
- 29:18is. And then we would see through
- 29:21that filtering mechanism, the emotional experience that's in
- 29:24the body. So that you could have a loving
- 29:27kindness view and you could experience all sorts of
- 29:31emotional states in the body and they would be distorted in your
- 29:34perception of them, but they might still be recognizable in
- 29:40response. Christian.
- 29:44George, would you think of the meta view or maybe another view
- 29:48as being like a container where any emotion that you feel in
- 29:54that is not ultimately emotionally dysregulating and
- 29:58that's kind of the the effect of it?
- 30:02It's often like that, but I don't think of it so much as a
- 30:07container as a as a filter. Would you think of it if it's a?
- 30:17Filter. I think of awareness as the
- 30:19container. OK, if if it's a filter, I think
- 30:24filter and I think something's not getting through.
- 30:27So do you? No, no, it's, it's clearly
- 30:29distorted, right? It the perception.
- 30:35Do you ever sorry, do you, do you ever think that like we're
- 30:38we're losing important information in some way that
- 30:41like through this conscious distortion?
- 30:45Well then, this is the question. Is it a beneficial distortion or
- 30:48is it an afflictive distortion? I also think it.
- 30:55As a good eater, what? I also thought it as the
- 30:59practice of dry and metal was also container for me.
- 31:02Oh, can you say more about that? That you know, there will be
- 31:08fear in my belly or there will be just unpleasant feeling.
- 31:15Well, I cannot change that feeling.
- 31:16But it's almost like, what if I imagine outside my body?
- 31:21The air itself is loving, friendly.
- 31:31So you're you're seeing the the the self body in a larger
- 31:36container. Because the the the the body is
- 31:41full of unpleasant. Like not the whole body.
- 31:45But yeah, let's say I am feeling unhappy or discontent.
- 31:50Right, the self is experiencing. I cannot change that in the next
- 31:5410 minutes, so I have to be the container only.
- 31:57That's my only option. And what about awareness?
- 32:06That is aware of. The container of awareness.
- 32:12Yeah, this is similar, same, same wish, except the container
- 32:16awareness and awareness, it's more neutral.
- 32:19But in this case, I make the awareness slightly inclined.
- 32:24I'm more AIDS, I don't want to say sympathetic, but yeah,
- 32:26there's a undertone of sympathy towards negative emotion in my
- 32:31body. Right, I think that we're
- 32:37getting lost in some semantical discussion.
- 32:42Gotcha. I would it also sounds a little
- 32:50self self centric when the self actually is not a separate
- 32:56thing. It's just all part of the same
- 32:58thing. So that I would say that the
- 33:01container is the is is awareness.
- 33:04And what we're really looking at here is distortions of
- 33:08perception or lack of distortion of perception sometimes.
- 33:20But I just, I remember the first year that we went to to Miranmar
- 33:25and we're up in this monastery in two hours outside of Mandalay
- 33:32in a small place called Pin with Wynn.
- 33:39And it seemed OK. It seemed nice enough when when
- 33:45we first got there. And then it became drearier and
- 33:50drearier and rundown and shabby and mean and awful and all of
- 33:57those things as we were descending into the frustration
- 34:00of not being able to find the mind state of loving kindness.
- 34:08And then you'd notice boom, somebody blew up and they're
- 34:11just completely blissed out, crazily blissed out.
- 34:16And when I mentioned to the to the sado, he said, yeah, we call
- 34:20that the meta bomb. It blows people up.
- 34:24And and over a course of that period, a few days, it happened
- 34:30more and more. And when it happened to me, that
- 34:34dreary, rundown place that I couldn't wait to leave became so
- 34:40beautiful. And all of the miserable people
- 34:43up for sitting in the retreat where it became so beautiful,
- 34:48even the Say It Out became so beautiful.
- 34:51I don't know if you've ever sat with the Say it out before, but
- 34:53they're totally inscrutable. And it was the same place.
- 35:00It was the same 4:00 in the morning, bell going off right,
- 35:05the same bright walk to the to the meditation hall.
- 35:15That's what we're really, I think, talking about, Paul.
- 35:25Thanks, George. It might be a twin question kind
- 35:30of stemming from the conversation, but on the one
- 35:32hand to make a sense I guess of what is some of the value of of
- 35:37the meta John of practice in our context with attachment.
- 35:41Yeah. So I've heard all right, what
- 35:43I'm practicing with you. Part of it is just to be aware
- 35:46that there's a mind state in play.
- 35:48Yeah. Developing some agency to choose
- 35:50the mind state that's in play. And then from the one hand, from
- 35:55the conversation that's going on, just trying to make sense
- 35:59of, you know, in classical Buddhism, it's really Theravatum
- 36:02trying to be wary around being too captured by craving for
- 36:06since since input basically right.
- 36:10And so hence the the near, sorry, the far enemy would be
- 36:12sentimentality. No far enemy is anger, the near
- 36:17enemy is. The two enemies are both some
- 36:22kind of engagement and getting taken in by by by since craving,
- 36:26right? Either it's the heat of anger or
- 36:29it's the heat of sentimentality or, and I guess I'm just, I'm
- 36:38just hearing, you know, in a practical sense, like even this,
- 36:42this meta bomb situation with this, the meta meta temple or
- 36:47the meta monastery, that'd be the sort of thing to watch out
- 36:52for with the meta bomb where you just get so enraptured with
- 36:56everything is just nice to feel and nice to think about and nice
- 36:59to see. But isn't that the moment we
- 37:01should say, well, that is a different mind state.
- 37:04That's the mind state of sentimentality.
- 37:06Would that be the sort of, if you will, level of we're hoping
- 37:10to cultivate with awareness to to watch that happening?
- 37:14And the in. That in in meta.
- 37:18So metamind is in the present moment, in the full unfolding of
- 37:27what's happening and the experience of it.
- 37:30And sentimentality is a thought process where you withdraw from
- 37:34the experience of the present moment into a thought process.
- 37:38Yeah, thanks. That's.
- 37:39Probably that's the difference. But yes, you can easily get
- 37:43attached to the the bliss States and Shinzen used to call it the
- 37:49most pernicious trap in all of meditation getting attached to
- 37:53that. But it it is also not fruitful
- 38:01to do that. But also, you know, I like to
- 38:05say when you have the first bite of the first piece of cake, it
- 38:10is awesome. By the time you've eaten the
- 38:14whole cake, you're daushes. So you pay you pay attention to
- 38:25that and there there's nothing in the in what we're doing here.
- 38:28That's suggesting that we should be going for these split states,
- 38:32but what we should be doing is being able to recognize when
- 38:36we're in anger mind or when we're in low self esteem mind or
- 38:39when we're in rejection mind and then having the agency to swap
- 38:45them out. And while it may be difficult to
- 38:50get into equanimity, it will be less difficult to switch out a
- 38:55mind state if you have set up and practice being able to
- 38:58switch out a mind state. So.
- 39:02Yeah. So that's maybe a perfect segue
- 39:05to the where the question I really started with was, I just,
- 39:09you know, Sue Asponte have been doing some of my practice is
- 39:12just is to be switching, trying to switch mind states.
- 39:15Right. Here's the meta one.
- 39:16Here's the, I don't know, an undistorted one.
- 39:19Here's a here's the joy and bliss one or something.
- 39:22Is that do you think, do you think that's a fruitful practice
- 39:24to be doing? As well I do because you
- 39:28actually are in charge of monitoring your sense gates and
- 39:31monitoring what, what, how you make the experience of what's
- 39:36happening. It's not to say that we want to
- 39:39just engineer these, these bliss states or these positive States
- 39:44and cope over what's happening or exclude from the perception
- 39:49of things negative states or negative happenings in the
- 39:55world. We don't want that.
- 39:58We want you to see what's happening.
- 40:01So probably the deeper under all of this and hope this is useful
- 40:06for the everyone else. I do try to watch the ones that
- 40:10are not. It's not paper over my most
- 40:14common, like I'm not like actively monitoring.
- 40:17I think my most common experience is what I've been
- 40:20thinking of is like the confusion mind state.
- 40:22But I wonder if it's, you know, to put it in Western terms, it
- 40:25feels like the psychological defense is not to get numbed
- 40:28out, but to be confused about what's going on.
- 40:30And now sometimes I find that comes up when I'm meditating
- 40:33formally as well. It's like I get confused.
- 40:36There's this. It's like almost like walking a
- 40:38tightrope on this side could fall off into just getting lost
- 40:40in thought on this side I could fall off into I don't know what
- 40:43can because I'm confused and I can't tell what mindset I'm in
- 40:45because I'm confused if that makes sense as I'm experiencing.
- 40:54You might say Zen is a whole path of confusion.
- 41:03Except that in booted nature, there's no distinction between
- 41:05confusion and non confusion, right?
- 41:09So what I would say is it is a great mind state for learning.
- 41:15It's one of the best. OK.
- 41:20Thanks, Mudit. That sounds right.
- 41:22Yeah, so if you want to learn something completely new, you
- 41:27need to be able to tolerate the confused mind state for long
- 41:31periods of time or you'll make decisions about it based on
- 41:35other things that you know already.
- 41:37You won't, you won't get a good basis for learning something
- 41:41new. It'll all be shifted into what
- 41:44you already know and and and the hierarchies of value will
- 41:50already be imposed on it before you have enough information to
- 41:53begin to make a decision about it.
- 41:56So the more that you can hold the state of confusion and not
- 42:00make any of these judgments, and this is really applicable to
- 42:04attachment learning, the more you can just hold open and not
- 42:09make a decision and fix. What do you think your
- 42:12attachment conditioning is and how simple or elaborate it might
- 42:17be, the better off you will be and be able to map it for
- 42:20yourself. OK, so thank you because I think
- 42:26you just validated or supported something I do, which is when I
- 42:30sense it, I've been treating it like a mind state and saying
- 42:33great, it's here. Can I now just watch the mind
- 42:36state of confusion and become familiar with it?
- 42:38Right, more familiar. I think for me personally, it's
- 42:42important in the attachment lens and the not formally meditating
- 42:47part of life because I've been so prone to enmeshment and
- 42:50that's my experience of enmeshment.
- 42:52Right. Sorry, the the experience of
- 42:54recognizing enmeshment is usually I'm confused.
- 42:57I don't know what I, I don't know why I'm doing this
- 42:59etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. And it's kind of huge, and it's
- 43:02often the point of recognizing that enmeshment was going on.
- 43:06Yeah. And then you bring your
- 43:09attention back into yourself as this as the center.
- 43:13Exactly. Good.
- 43:15Earlier some months ago, and thankfully because of the, you
- 43:21know, secure behavior that goes along, I've been not finding
- 43:24myself in situations where I'm as likely to get a mesh.
- 43:27So maybe less practice, but also probably a good thing to have.
- 43:30Sorry. Less free form practice in the
- 43:32world, but probably a positive thing for my life.
- 43:36Yes, good. So.
- 43:38Thank you, George. Christian.
- 43:43George, I was just going to say you, you gave me like a really
- 43:45good idea from the story about being in, in Burma.
- 43:51You know, we all know like healthcare inflation is real and
- 43:54plastic surgery is getting more and more expensive.
- 43:59I was thinking I just taught everyone to do meta practice.
- 44:03I just get hotter and hotter and I don't have to spend any money.
- 44:08Yeah. Never underestimate the value of
- 44:16a Photoshop facelift. Now they have AI it's almost
- 44:28seamless. The the, the, the mission for
- 44:40attachment repair is to see yourself clearly and to see
- 44:45other people clearly as well. And that the the the
- 44:50collaboration is to find the hotness, but not through
- 45:05distortion. So I'm going to sum up a little
- 45:18bit and then we we can do some practice.
- 45:22The reason that I think that a loving kindness practice is so
- 45:26important, and also the passion practice, the sympathetic joy
- 45:29practice, equanimity practice is so important is because most of
- 45:34us who have insecure, disorganized attachment are
- 45:37working with self systems, working models of self that are
- 45:44decidedly lopsided on negative states.
- 45:48And so we need to pull that down.
- 45:52But it isn't enough to simply pull down the overdevelopment of
- 45:57the negative side. Our capacity for holding
- 46:01positive experience is also not particularly well developed, and
- 46:06we need to then intentionally develop a sense of positivity.
- 46:15Dan used to say, which I quite liked, that the origin of self
- 46:22love or the origin of self hate is where the balance of this
- 46:27self system is. If you're largely on the
- 46:31negative side, each time the self experience arises, it's
- 46:35largely a negative experience that you have in the creation of
- 46:41your experience of self. And over time, we we begin to
- 46:46develop an aversion to the negative state arising over and
- 46:49over again each time we experience ourselves.
- 46:53And that aversion is the root cause of self hatred.
- 46:58We just can't bear that every time our sense of self arises,
- 47:02we're overwhelmed with negative states or afflictive states.
- 47:09Conversely, the origin of self love is that if you lop side the
- 47:14working model of self with positivity, then each time the
- 47:18sense of self arises, it's a pleasant experience which you
- 47:22enjoy having. And it doesn't matter what the
- 47:25circumstance is. It could be a difficult
- 47:27circumstance. And still when the sense of self
- 47:30is is lopsided, on the positive side, you enjoy the experience
- 47:35of yourself responding to a difficult experience and that is
- 47:40the root cause of self love. Now we've built both of these
- 47:46models over the course of our lives, so there's no reason why
- 47:50we can't affect it. And this is depending on how
- 47:57difficult your life has been and how lopsided the working model
- 48:02of self is, months of practice or maybe longer than that to
- 48:09change that. But you know, the sense of self
- 48:13arises in response to stimulus in the environment.
- 48:17And there's not much you can do about the reactivity of the self
- 48:21experience arising, but there's a lot that you can do about what
- 48:27arises. Is that makes sense.
- 48:29We did. I'm sorry real quick.
- 48:32So it's about the it's even in any situation feeling about the
- 48:37self is positive. It it's, it's not tied to
- 48:45anything or people. It's how you so the self
- 48:52experience is a lot of these little memory gists that are in
- 48:55a pattern and they they activate and you recognize the pattern as
- 49:00you. It it's slightly towards this, I
- 49:05don't want this sympathy, but it's there's a slight sympathy
- 49:07towards itself even in difficult situations.
- 49:10Is that right? Depends on your conditioning.
- 49:15No, the positive conditioning reconditioning.
- 49:19Oh, it can be all the way to delight.
- 49:24Even in hard situations. Yeah, totally delight.
- 49:27Delight because it's a it's a unplaced.
- 49:30Because you've you've just banged all of his gists onto the
- 49:35the working model of self so that in order to recognize
- 49:38yourself, you recognize it with all of this delight in who you
- 49:42are. You combine that with a, a deep
- 49:47meditation practice where just in that still state, everything
- 49:50is. I don't know how far you are,
- 49:52but you'll get to a place where everything has a subtly positive
- 49:59quality to it. Everything is slightly
- 50:01beautiful, everything is easy. And so you add to that the the
- 50:09the trumpets of delight when the self experience activates
- 50:14because you know you can wander around without so much self
- 50:16experience. It's not a part, it's more on a
- 50:20neutral side. But yes, everything is easy.
- 50:23Yeah, so. Yeah.
- 50:32And then, you know, it also depends how, how do you, when
- 50:35you're walking around, how do you know what's what's going on?
- 50:39And if you're a sighted person, most of us are relying on the
- 50:43visual field. But if, you know, you can get to
- 50:45a place where the visual field is not that solid, then it's
- 50:49forming stuff all over the place that isn't that isn't there.
- 50:53I really, I mean, and that also becomes quite enjoyable the way
- 50:59you make up the world when you really have a, an easy sense of
- 51:04how much of it you're making up, which is pretty much all of it.
- 51:13You can make it up one way or another.
- 51:15Why not make it up in a way that that that's delightful.
- 51:22It also makes you more resilient and we have a lot of resistance
- 51:26we're going to have to be putting out into the world, so
- 51:30the more resilient you are, the better.
- 51:33One thing I've noticed is this, when you talk about this, there
- 51:36is an aspect of independent regardless of the sense data.
- 51:42Regardless of the sense data, there is delight.
- 51:44Regardless of the the life situations, there is still
- 51:49delight, but there's still positive emotions.
- 51:51It's almost like there's an independent feeling, very less
- 51:54of what's happening on the outside.
- 51:56And and part of that is focus, you know, the we're biased
- 52:01toward urgency. I like to call it so.
- 52:06And the brain science on this is pretty good brain time. 3/8 of a
- 52:11second urgent material is already forming a response in
- 52:14the bottom pleasant, pleasant experience.
- 52:18It's a half a second and the the urgent stuff always supersedes
- 52:25the pleasant stuff. So it's very easy for us to get
- 52:28oriented toward negative stuff or difficult stuff.
- 52:33And because there's that, that preference in the queue have no
- 52:38experience of positive stuff, which is also happening most of
- 52:43the time. And so then we, when you're not
- 52:49seduced by that and you can, you know, intentionally make sure
- 52:56that you're getting a whole picture, we do not take a
- 53:01uniform survey of what's in front of us.
- 53:04We take a survey of things that we prefer.
- 53:08And part of that survey is to leave out the things that we
- 53:11don't want. That's why it's so easy to to
- 53:14create these very skewed perceptions of what's happening.
- 53:20And it's very easy to get fixated on the, the particular
- 53:24view you're mentalizing collapses and you think that the
- 53:28thing that you're perceiving is what's actually happening
- 53:31because you've lost track of the fact that you're highly
- 53:34selective in what you're allowing in your mind.
- 53:40And so it's opening up that that Taja Panati, which I like to
- 53:44talk about a lot, you're, you're this is what I made, this is the
- 53:49data, this is what I made. This is the data, this is what I
- 53:52made. This is the data, this is what I
- 53:55made, this is the data. So you're constantly actively
- 53:58engaged in making sure that the representations that you are,
- 54:03you know, creating your karma on are actually representative of
- 54:08what's happening. And you're not completely
- 54:10distorted, completely lost in some mental construction that
- 54:16you then use as the basis for the actions that you take as a
- 54:21prelude to reaping the consequences of your behavior.
- 54:32So there's. Not like one emotion, but
- 54:33there's a range of emotions at the same time.
- 54:35Even though you're saying there's delight the self, it's
- 54:38delight along alongside other. OK, I misunderstood.
- 54:42OK. Yeah, you're not, you're not.
- 54:46It's not the by the, the spiritual bypass of excluding
- 54:50negativity. We would call that idealization
- 54:53and it, it tends to be the avoidant people who are doing
- 54:58that, right. So if we pull it down into
- 55:00attachment conditioning, that's what's happening.
- 55:11How do you get to that place where everyone, everyone is
- 55:15deserving of love? How do you get to the place
- 55:17where you can do that? Actually, that's where we're
- 55:22we're headed. That place.
- 55:26Even when the unforgivable has been acted out.
- 55:36How do you come to that place? It's not so easy.
- 55:47Would you like to do some concentration and inside
- 55:50practice? Would you like to do some meta
- 55:52practice? Would you like to do a round of
- 55:57ideal parent figure? Well, I'm going to vote meta
- 56:01because we've been talking meta. All right, So go ahead and
- 56:09settle in. OK, let go of the meditation.
- 56:15How's that? So what's coming up is
- 56:19Kaleidoscope tomorrow at 11:00 to 12:30.
- 56:27And then we did our our new lunchtime thing last Tuesday,
- 56:37but the electricity went out in my neighborhood.
- 56:40And so we're repeating it on this Tuesday, the 28th at 1:00.
- 56:49Then let's see what else is happening.
- 56:57We're going to start. We started a new Level 2 class,
- 57:01which is really a good crowd. If you want to join us, you can.
- 57:08The next time it's meeting is on November 4th and we'll close the
- 57:12enrollment after that. What time of day is that from
- 57:15George? It's at it's at 4:30 in the
- 57:18afternoon, which I think is a good time for you, 4:30 to 6:30
- 57:25on the 1st and 3rd Tuesdays. So George, I, I am potentially
- 57:32interested, but I haven't done level 1.
- 57:34I don't know if that's prerequisite, but I don't know
- 57:36if it's separate to the other that we've already talked about
- 57:39as well. So yeah, I just thought I would
- 57:41ask, but maybe we can talk about that when?
- 57:44Yeah, we can. It is separate.
- 57:48And I always ask the question, are you comfortable jumping into
- 57:54the deep end or do you need to inch your way into the shallow
- 57:57end? I've seen those prompts.
- 58:02Actually on your. Website So yeah, then you could
- 58:05jump into level 2. Not a problem, we'll chat, OK?
- 58:11Great. Thanks.
- 58:13What else? I'm doing my annual, what I like
- 58:19to call Family Archaeology half Day on Saturday, the 15th, which
- 58:25is because what we used to call the threefold disease of
- 58:31Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's is coming up and how to
- 58:36go home and have a good time and explore your attachment
- 58:40conditioning. I think that we're almost at the
- 58:47end of the year at this point. I am going to do a virtual
- 58:51retreat the week between Christmas and New Year's.
- 58:55Well, it's it, it covers New Year's, so on the 29th of
- 58:58December through the 2nd of January, we're going to do a
- 59:04retreat from 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM. Not so good for Australian time.
- 59:13And then that brings us into the New year.
- 59:16We have a level 1 starting on January 10th.
- 59:22Thanks for your practice. It's really good to sit with
- 59:25you, I really appreciate you so much and Ioffer the teaching
- 59:31freely, but if your resource and can make a donation, that's
- 59:35appreciated. There's a link on the website.
- 59:38I hope to see you soon somewhere along the path.
- 59:42Bye. Thanks everybody.