Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E002: Energy-Backed Money with Max Webster
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35Custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:11having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are halving all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. It all comes down to computers
- 1:27communicating. The information superhighway can
- 1:31be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 1:34Bitcoin is worthless artificial gold.
- 1:39Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 1:42We need to get into. The world of OK.
- 1:44This is actually foundational technology.
- 1:47What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 1:51which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 1:59The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 2:04the role of gun The one thing that's missing but that will
- 2:07soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 2:15We're live. Welcome everyone to the second
- 2:19episode of Final Settlement, a Bitcoin focus podcast brought to
- 2:24you by On RAMP where we take a look at Bitcoin really from more
- 2:27of a technological perspective. Bitcoin is is much more than
- 2:31just an asset. It's more than a financial
- 2:34instrument that sits in your portfolio.
- 2:36This is an open source piece of software and a distributed
- 2:40protocol that people are building on top of in in new and
- 2:44innovative ways and and really enabling different forms of
- 2:46utility by leveraging the underlying technology.
- 2:50I'm Brian Cabellos. I'm joined by Michael Tanguma
- 2:53and our guest today, Max Webster, A fascinating guy,
- 2:57really excited to have him on. He is the founder of Hive Mind
- 3:01Ventures, a Bitcoin focused venture capital firm doing all
- 3:05sorts of interesting things in in the Bitcoin related space.
- 3:09So really excited to have him on.
- 3:10How you doing Max? Good.
- 3:13Excited to be here. You know, I really enjoyed doing
- 3:15the first pod with you Michael and some of the other guys and
- 3:19excited to talk more about protocols and very nice to meet
- 3:21you, Brian. Yeah, great to meet you as well.
- 3:23It's funny, you know, when you came on our other podcast Last
- 3:27Trade earlier last year, it struck Michael, Michael and I
- 3:32that, you know, it was a very different conversation than a
- 3:34lot of the other last trade podcasts.
- 3:36And that kind of sparked honestly the idea and the
- 3:39impetus for this podcast, which is really, you know, let's take
- 3:42this a step further, let's look beyond just the macro context
- 3:45and this thing is a financial asset and really dig into the
- 3:49protocol layer and what this thing is enabling in the real
- 3:52world. And I think that was what that
- 3:54was one of our most viewed podcasts as well.
- 3:57So we knew we had to get you back on and really excited to
- 4:00chat. Most mute and most head
- 4:03exploding emojis like when you. Yeah, that's.
- 4:06It on we even have now a new mutual friend that he you know
- 4:10what listens and consumes content and he'll appreciate the
- 4:13shout out. Without naming him that was
- 4:15referencing loving the Balaji pod I think from Tim Ferriss in
- 4:18just the different mind bending ways.
- 4:20And he referenced that he was in his car with his wife and just
- 4:23said hey I got to turn this off and like re listen to it with
- 4:26like in my own you know den and and with a you know a nice glass
- 4:29of whiskey or whatever he participates in.
- 4:32So yeah, I was super excited to get you back on and there's so
- 4:34many concepts that aren't really discussed in the market for for
- 4:37those that didn't listen, Max had a previous life in Silicon
- 4:41Valley and also investing across other markets I think even like
- 4:44ultra like cryptocurrencies outside of Bitcoin.
- 4:47And I think that really provides him with one of the best lenses.
- 4:50And I think he he really is in the ecosystem.
- 4:52The best venture capitalist on the Bitcoin side because he's
- 4:54built in the existing market and he knows kind of like how people
- 4:58are thinking about it, how to back into what are the the
- 5:01stories that are told. Historically, somebody tells a
- 5:03story to VC, they've never really built anything So that
- 5:06you kind of like take it for face value versus knowing how to
- 5:09back into the 2nd and 3rd order effects of like what are you
- 5:12telling me, what's the story? And does that make sense in map
- 5:14to like user adoption, which historically has been a hard
- 5:17thing when you think about Bitcoin because we're building
- 5:19on new technology, so super pumped to have you Max.
- 5:22Sweet male. I appreciate all the kind words.
- 5:24I really loved our last pod and no pressure now with the head
- 5:26exploding. Emojis, you know?
- 5:28Yeah, exactly. Well, well, an area that I
- 5:32wanted to start is sort of I think foundational to a lot of
- 5:35the other things that we'll talk about, but also sort of
- 5:38foundational to everything that you've been doing recently in
- 5:40the space Max in terms of your investments and and the
- 5:44businesses that you're helping build.
- 5:46But really going back to, you know, this thesis or this
- 5:49concept around Bitcoin being energy backed money.
- 5:52And I think that's, you know, a phrase that gets thrown around
- 5:54and and you know most people probably don't even think you
- 5:58know what are the implications of this or or really understand
- 6:00what that even means. But I think it's worth diving
- 6:03into really you know what you mean by that when when you say
- 6:06Bitcoin is energy backed money and then another way that you've
- 6:09I've heard you describe it is you know Bitcoin is a calorie
- 6:11Ledger which I which I love. But just you know thinking
- 6:15through not only you know what does that mean, but what are the
- 6:18implications of that if we've, you know we have this thing that
- 6:22people like to refer to as digital gold.
- 6:24It's it's scarce asset but really it's you know it's
- 6:27dematerialized sound money that we can now use to build new
- 6:31primitives on the Internet and do all these different things
- 6:33with this you know native currency of the Internet.
- 6:36So just curious on on sort of that leg of your thesis and and
- 6:40really it would also be interesting to hear you know
- 6:43what led you to that because I know you had a lot of experience
- 6:45in sort of the energy world prior to really leaning into
- 6:49Bitcoin. And and, you know, just thinking
- 6:50through, you know what, what in your previous experience allowed
- 6:54you to see Bitcoin through that lens in the first place?
- 6:57Totally. Well, I mean for one, for
- 6:58starters, as you mentioned my quote UN quote prior career was
- 7:02in energy first and foremost. And so you know, I first heard
- 7:05about Bitcoin 2011 when I was a student at university and
- 7:08thought it was super cool. Never thought I'd be allowed to
- 7:10work around that same time. I was getting pretty obsessed
- 7:13with energy. And so, you know, for whatever
- 7:16reason, I love finding kind of like hidden truths or curves,
- 7:23new's curves in the world that people haven't seen yet.
- 7:25And obviously, if you can bet on the S curve before everyone
- 7:28realizes it's an S curve, that's where the alpha is, right?
- 7:30And so for whatever reason, that's just my personality.
- 7:32I love trying to find those. I've always been fascinated with
- 7:36sort of open technology. It was, you know, a kid that
- 7:38grew up with the Internet, loved watching a lot of those trends.
- 7:41I remember as an 8 year old, you know, using all kinds of
- 7:44interesting peer-to-peer networks that inspired Bitcoin
- 7:47and wishing I could have been part of it and a little too
- 7:49young. So I was stoked.
- 7:51You know, I am stoked to now get a second chance at Bitcoin, but
- 7:54you know around 20/11/2012 I start getting really obsessed
- 7:56with energy as well. And so you know, particularly I
- 8:00got very interested in solar and I think something that very few
- 8:03people understand is how quickly the cost of solar has fallen off
- 8:08of a Cliff. And so back then, you know, I
- 8:09started doing this research and you know, solar was quite
- 8:13expensive. It wasn't competitive in any
- 8:15markets with traditional fossil fuels, but it was on what's
- 8:19called a learning curve or an exponential cost decline.
- 8:22And so, you know, I started listening to some people and
- 8:24reading some posts that sounded pretty crazy, like, literally
- 8:26crazy at the time, where they said, you know, solar is going
- 8:28to be the cheapest source of energy in the world by 2020.
- 8:31And my professors in college, everyone laughed, you know, said
- 8:33that's impossible. I don't remember the exact cost,
- 8:35but let's say, you know, it was, let's say, you know, sort of Nat
- 8:38gas or coal, you know, cost like six to seven, maybe eight cents
- 8:41a kWh back then, solar was 30 plus, right.
- 8:44So it's super expensive or like in the high 20s.
- 8:47And so to say that this was going to be the cheapest source
- 8:50in the world, electricity source in the world by 2020 sounded
- 8:52like a madman. But you know, if there's one
- 8:55thing I had learned from watching things like Moore's Law
- 8:57and watching what I came to later called Wright's Law, and
- 9:01this has been written by a few people.
- 9:03You know, the idea is that they're pretty predictable,
- 9:05almost gravity like laws in the universe.
- 9:06And one of them seems to be that, you know, when you have
- 9:09sort of like these modular production systems where you can
- 9:12build a whole lot of them and you can build them fast as you
- 9:14get better and better building those, there's generally some
- 9:17sort of a constant rate that the cost of that decline.
- 9:20And so you know, I looked at solar and back then I thought
- 9:23the learning curve was something like 20%, which means for every
- 9:25doubling of cumulative capacity, the amount installed around the
- 9:27world. Then the levelized cost of
- 9:29energy, which is how we sort of measured the cost of electricity
- 9:32energy markets was falling by I thought like 20%.
- 9:35And if you just chart that curve that meant would go from
- 9:37whatever it was $0.30 to three cents or something like that by
- 9:402020 in some of your parts. And so out of college I joined
- 9:43energy startup. It was first hired company
- 9:44called Bright, which is like Sunrunner Solar City from
- 9:46Mexico. We were back by YC first round,
- 9:49Felices, Patrick Halls and all the sort of big Silicon Valley
- 9:51people moved out in Mexico, lived there for many years
- 9:53working on this 'cause I really had this strong thesis that
- 9:56particularly in sunny regions of the world, emerging markets like
- 9:59Mexico, like South Africa, solar was just going to dominate.
- 10:02And lo and behold, by 2020, you know, you started seeing
- 10:05auctions in some of the sunnier parts of the world.
- 10:07You know, for three, two, even sometimes sub two cents a kWh in
- 10:10places like Abu Dhabi and, you know, areas of the Middle East.
- 10:13Obviously, there's a whole lot more to that whole energy story
- 10:16around storage and that that's a big issue, right?
- 10:19Because solar's intermittent. The sun doesn't always shine.
- 10:21And I could talk, I could wax poetic about this, but this is 1
- 10:23area where I actually, I I still am extremely bullish that
- 10:26solar's going to keep getting cheaper, storage is going to
- 10:28keep getting cheaper and people are going to be shocked by 20-30
- 10:31to see how cheap it all is. So that was kind of my first big
- 10:34obsession. And I was, you know, constantly,
- 10:36you know, there's kind of three analysts.
- 10:37I think I've gotten this right over the years.
- 10:39This guy Tony Saba, Ramez Nom. Ramez Nom, who's investor,
- 10:42right. And sort of LinkedIn with Ray
- 10:44Kurzweil, Singularity Institute. He was literally just taking
- 10:46sort of a technologist cost curve approach this an Arkan
- 10:49vest. Kathy Wood, who's I think is
- 10:51sort of a Bitcoin champion now. You know, she and her team
- 10:53called this since about 2014. So I've been watching a very,
- 10:56very few people saw this thing happening and I always kind of
- 10:58kept that in the back of my head.
- 11:00And then so I would say I kind of had a prepared mind for
- 11:03thinking of you know what was having the energy markets like
- 11:07kind of understanding that from the 20,000 foot view.
- 11:10Then I, you know while living in Mexico got reinterested in
- 11:13Bitcoin. I started seeing it as a money
- 11:15that was going to be much more useful in emerging markets for
- 11:17obvious reasons. You know, much easier to have a
- 11:19store value. When I saw the the peso to
- 11:21dollar conversion rate go you know fall from like I think it
- 11:24was 12 paces the dollar to like 20 paces the dollar in the
- 11:26couple of years that I was living there, much worse
- 11:28inflation in other parts of the world, the US exports inflation
- 11:30with the dollar, all of that stopping right now too or
- 11:33starting to reverse that trend. And so I was starting to get
- 11:35interested in Bitcoin, but I still didn't really understand
- 11:37it is energy Back to money 2018. I left Bright and I took kind of
- 11:41like a two year sabbatical and I was very lucky.
- 11:43I had the ability to do this. Partially because as a gringo I
- 11:46was able to take advantage of my dollars in Mexico and take some
- 11:48time off. And that time I I started
- 11:50realizing how big of a deal Bitcoin was and I started going
- 11:52down the quote UN quote crypto rabbit hole and play with
- 11:54Ethereum did all of the you know, shit coins or whatever.
- 11:57But I kept coming back to Bitcoin and you know I actually
- 12:00took Justin Moons middle boot camp where we built Bitcoin from
- 12:02scratch and Python. That's why I understood mining
- 12:04and the difficulty adjustment, all this stuff.
- 12:05And I was like oh man, I think this is kind of like an Einstein
- 12:08Newton level breakthrough. I have to get super involved.
- 12:102019, I was actually kind of on an around the world trip
- 12:15vagabonding, something I very much miss doing.
- 12:18And I was reading one of my favorite authors and heroes.
- 12:20And in fact I didn't plan this, but I have one of, I actually
- 12:23have two of my Heroes books right here and Buckminster
- 12:27Fuller. And so this one is operating
- 12:30Manual for Spaceship Earth, which is kind of a provocative
- 12:32and very cool name. I think the one that I was
- 12:34reading at that time, there's two the Grunch of Giants and
- 12:37Critical Path. And Critical Path was the one
- 12:39that mentioned it. And Bucky, for those of you who
- 12:41don't know, is sort of a design scientist, philosopher, I don't
- 12:46know eccentric futurist, Gadfly, whatever you want to call him.
- 12:49And he basically, he talked about his whole thesis was that,
- 12:53you know, we should build systems that are the most energy
- 12:55efficient systems possible. And so for him, he was
- 12:57particularly interested in architecture, but you could
- 12:59apply that to human systems, computer systems basically
- 13:01whatever maximizes the flow of energy.
- 13:03And he called for in that book, he said basically, look, you
- 13:07know, I forget the exact words he used, but like essentially if
- 13:12we want a fair economy, then we have to have a fair money.
- 13:15OK, that makes sense. Kind of sounds like Bitcoin.
- 13:17And the only fair money that we can ever have is the one
- 13:20currency of the universe, energy and energy backed money.
- 13:23And you know I started thinking about that and then I started,
- 13:25you know in 2020-2021 going down the rabbit hole, couple other
- 13:29people started playing with this idea.
- 13:31Charles Edwards DiCaprio, I think he was the first person to
- 13:34publish basically trading Bitcoin just on its essentially
- 13:38production cost, which has been shockingly a good way to trade
- 13:41Bitcoin. Satoshi himself in 2010
- 13:43basically is like it's going to, you know, the cost of Bitcoin
- 13:45will just turn down towards cost production.
- 13:47Therefore hash rate is basically what matters.
- 13:49And so when you start understanding all these things
- 13:51you start saying, wait a second, like what if Bitcoin is just
- 13:54trading and what if it is just energy backed money?
- 13:56And then you start thinking about you're like, well, that
- 13:58makes so much sense because you know, at least in the known
- 14:03universe there is only one currency, full stop, No matter
- 14:05where you choose to demarcate the universe, it's energy, it's
- 14:07calories, it's kilowatt hours. You know, at the molecular
- 14:10level, you have energy out, you know, energy and energy out the
- 14:12cellular level, the biosphere level.
- 14:15And so when I started to understand that, I was like, oh
- 14:17shit, I think this might be what Bucky was talking about.
- 14:21And if you realize, you know, gold, all these other
- 14:22currencies, they were proxies on energy, right.
- 14:24The reason gold was proxy in energy, it takes energy to to
- 14:26dig it up, you know. Then around 2020-2021, shout out
- 14:30Andrew Myers at Satoshi Energy. I met this guy and I was like,
- 14:33oh fuck, this guy really understands where things are
- 14:35going. And he started explaining to me,
- 14:38you know, and I read some of his stuff about commodity money.
- 14:40Commodity money of course is another proxy in energy money
- 14:42because the commodity requires energy to grow it.
- 14:45And he, you know, kind of led me down the rabbit hole of Edison
- 14:47talking about this, for talking about this, Tesla talking about
- 14:50this. And so the deeper I went them
- 14:52where I was like, OK, cool, there there is going to be
- 14:55energy backed money for humanity and increasingly for artificial
- 14:58intelligences as well. The greatest minds in human
- 15:02history have all seen this coming.
- 15:03They didn't know how it was going to happen.
- 15:04They tried different ways because they didn't have the
- 15:06Internet back then. They didn't have, you know, the
- 15:07the tools that we have. And when I started understanding
- 15:10if that's what Bitcoin was, then my conviction went from like
- 15:15high to like all it. Because I I started seeing this
- 15:18as the prophecy. The other thing that I'll
- 15:20mention there is shout out Dhruv Bansal.
- 15:23Dhruv has also just seen things coming before everyone else.
- 15:26He has a talk from 2019, I believe 2018-2019 called
- 15:29Blockchain Minecandy which is like one of the highest alpha
- 15:32talks online. So thank you Dhruv.
- 15:34It's got like 2000 views now and probably 10% of them.
- 15:37And he basically predicted all of this like this is not, it's
- 15:42not, you know, earth shattering once you see it happening.
- 15:45And he came up with something that I, I strongly believe,
- 15:47which is the, the Nakamoto point.
- 15:50He calls it a conjecture, I guess can't prove it yet, but
- 15:53I'm, I'm pretty sure he's right. And basically what the
- 15:56conjecture is, is that the energy markets and the Bitcoin
- 16:00markets are going to be used. They're going to become more,
- 16:02they're going to become the same.
- 16:03And what that means is that the marginal cost of selling an
- 16:08electron to the electricity grid is eventually going to equal
- 16:13more or less with some, you know, minor fluctuations.
- 16:15The marginal cost of selling an electron to the Bitcoin network.
- 16:19And right now you know if the average cost of selling to the
- 16:24grid you get, I don't know what it is, $0.08 a kWh and with an
- 16:27SI don't know what they even right now the the latest miners
- 16:30are doing 19, maybe you're getting $0.15 a kWh.
- 16:32They're still essentially arbitrage opportunity from
- 16:34selling cheap energy to the electricity to to the Bitcoin
- 16:37network. But eventually that's going to
- 16:39sort of even out and I have some crazy theories on where all
- 16:41that's going to go. I think a solar keeps getting
- 16:43radically, radically cheaper, solar plus storage and wind, but
- 16:46particularly solar. You're going to see some wild
- 16:48things happen. But high level Bitcoin is energy
- 16:52backed money. There will come a point where
- 16:54the marginal cost of selling to the network equals selling to
- 16:56the other network, the grid. And that's more or less where
- 16:59we'll stabilize I think. And another interesting point
- 17:02around that is, you know there have been, I forgot where I read
- 17:05this, but some like gold standard guys that were trying
- 17:07to figure out what is the percentage of the, you know,
- 17:10global GDP, which is another way of saying global energy supply,
- 17:13if it's mapped correctly that is needed to secure the energy
- 17:16supply. And people have sort of had
- 17:19conjectures about that. Well, I think in our lifetime we
- 17:21will no longer have to make conjectures.
- 17:23We will have empirical proof that there is a rough percentage
- 17:27of global energy that is needed to secure the energy supply, and
- 17:30that's where we reached the Nakamoto point.
- 17:33Right. Yeah.
- 17:34No, that's that's a fascinating overview of of that sort of
- 17:36concept and thesis. And I think it's, you know, it's
- 17:39it's it's lost on most people who just think you know Bitcoin
- 17:44is this asset right In, in reality it's this innovative
- 17:48tool for really converting energy into a digitally native
- 17:53unit that can be used for whatever that person needs to,
- 17:55to use it for, right. And I think you know you you
- 17:58mentioned in that explanation that commodity money or gold are
- 18:04sort of proxies for for an energy deck money.
- 18:07Maybe dig a little bit deeper on why those are proxies and why
- 18:10the fact that Bitcoin is truly digital native, it creates this
- 18:13like seamless sort of seamless sort of way to make this make
- 18:18that transition happen, right. And and then the sort of 2nd
- 18:21order implications of that, basically anything that you're
- 18:24doing in the digital realm, you can now have this ubiquitous
- 18:29unit that is used to basically attach you know real energetic
- 18:33cost to any activity that is going on in the digital realm.
- 18:37Yeah. Well, I'll answer in a couple
- 18:40ways. I mean, the proxy piece, I mean
- 18:42it's pretty simple, right? Like if you want to so gold is
- 18:44scarce and if you want to mine gold, you have to expend energy
- 18:46to mine it, right. And so that is essentially
- 18:50whatever the miners are spending to mine the gold is the, the
- 18:53proxy cost, the energy proxy cost.
- 18:56Similarly with a commodity money, let's say as an example
- 18:59you're using corn or whatever it is a crop.
- 19:02And by the way, I think it was Edison that had a really
- 19:04interesting idea about doing basically crop back to money
- 19:08where I guess it was during the Depression whenever he was like
- 19:11suggesting that you know farmers basically who are going through
- 19:16a lot of volatility could like sell their crops to the US
- 19:19government. the US government would give them some kind of
- 19:21instrument as like a one year flexible loan that allow them to
- 19:23buy it back. But basically the, the and that
- 19:25instrument that they were giving was, you know to be used as
- 19:28currency as well. So it was backed literally by
- 19:30like crops And those crops are also an energy proxy, right,
- 19:34like you have to, you know, obviously have the the sunlight
- 19:36to grow them. So you know this is a much purer
- 19:41much easily much easier to chart you know way of of of
- 19:46categorizing how much energy went in.
- 19:48But but all of those required energy.
- 19:50The other thing also I just want to mention on the energy stuff
- 19:52because I know there's something a lot of like you know the
- 19:54Bitcoin community is you know always kind of up in hands
- 19:56around what's going to happen with sort of renewables and all
- 20:00this stuff. I think what's what's really
- 20:02interesting. So I actually, you guys may have
- 20:04read this. I was the lead author on a paper
- 20:06in 2021 for Square or Block and Arc Invest where we basically we
- 20:12laid all this stuff out back then saying Bitcoin is is key to
- 20:14a clean energy future and everyone called that absolutely
- 20:17crazy at the time. But a big part of that thesis is
- 20:20that, you know as the cost, particularly solar keeps coming
- 20:23down and down and down, like what we need are free markets
- 20:25for electricity and everything else is going to, it's going to
- 20:28play its course. And I don't know exactly how
- 20:30that's going to play out. But I think, I think, I think a
- 20:32lot of, you know, sort of Bitcoin energy people miss is
- 20:36that when you have extremely cheap solar, let's say you know,
- 20:39it's $0.03 a kWh in some parts of the world and it gets to less
- 20:41than once in a kWh. You know what you're also going
- 20:44to end up having there is, you know, for some of this like
- 20:47energy density stuff you hear about is you're going to have
- 20:49the production of green hydrogen.
- 20:50You're going to have like other kinds of weird electrolysis done
- 20:53to create steel as an example. And you know, green hydrogens
- 20:57created from electrolysis of water, desalina tion of water.
- 21:01Basically when you have energy that is almost free or
- 21:04extremely, extremely cheap, it makes it feasible to do all
- 21:07kinds of new and weird things. And So what I think is going to
- 21:10happen there is when you have truly free like electricity
- 21:12markets, you know, eventually we'll have AI that basically
- 21:15says in real time, I have an electron, do I sell it to the
- 21:17grid? Do I sell it to the
- 21:18electrolysis? You know, whatever green
- 21:20hydrogen producer do I sell it to, You know, my whatever AI
- 21:25inference network, do I sell it to the Bitcoin network.
- 21:27And you have all of these networks that are competing in
- 21:29real time and there's no way to plan it because, you know, free
- 21:31markets are going to do their thing.
- 21:32And so Bitcoin will always kind of be that buyer of last resort.
- 21:36And I think something that like like if there is a quote, UN
- 21:39quote productive use that Nets more than putting into Bitcoin,
- 21:42well then that'll win you know in in real time.
- 21:45But I think something that a lot of other people are are going to
- 21:47be surprised by is this essentially if we over build
- 21:50right, there's a lot of issues with like the grids as they
- 21:54stand. We need much more like high
- 21:55voltage DC connection lines, all the stuff.
- 21:57But you're starting to see more and more people build off grid
- 22:01solar farms, not even connected to the grid, but connected to,
- 22:05you know, green hydrogen manufacturing facilities.
- 22:08And eventually what I think is going to be really cool is you
- 22:10might see some of those that are basically turned into micro
- 22:12grids. Like maybe first you bootstrap a
- 22:14new completely overbuilt sword solar farm with a Bitcoin miner.
- 22:20And then over time you're able to bring in new buyers into that
- 22:23market like green hydrogen producers.
- 22:26And then maybe you create other micro grids.
- 22:27Maybe you have communities that pop up around and then maybe
- 22:30eventually you're able to connect it to the bigger grid,
- 22:32which sadly, that's harder to predict because it requires, you
- 22:37know, permitting and like government policy stuff, though
- 22:40we don't have much control over. So anyway, so I just wanted to
- 22:42add that that's a big part of my vision is really, really, really
- 22:45cheap electricity is going to blow everyone's mind.
- 22:47Yeah, yeah. Sorry.
- 22:48I'll pause there. I know, I know.
- 22:49I know what's going on about that.
- 22:51No, I think it's always important like what you're
- 22:54describing makes so much sense. But I think also anchoring it to
- 22:58on the other side of like what's like a what's happening in
- 23:02practice when I think about like misallocation of capital, right.
- 23:05We've all been in different places like Uber is the poster
- 23:08trial but maybe it's we work because of poster trial as a
- 23:10misallocation capital burning money.
- 23:12And you think about it's the most inefficient way to build
- 23:15right, the unit economics the growth, the the amount of
- 23:18calories from an individual going to the work and and you
- 23:20know building. You think about real estate as a
- 23:22good example too. When you have low interest rates
- 23:25and the things associated and it goes back to that marginal cost
- 23:27to produce a dollars effectively nothing.
- 23:29It's 0. And that idea that there's a
- 23:32cost, whether it was gold or it's Bitcoin, that anchors the
- 23:36world back to, you know, this practical sense of, like you
- 23:40have to produce something to get your Bitcoin or my Bitcoin, you
- 23:42have to produce something in the world or from the network or you
- 23:45just don't get it. And that reality, and this is on
- 23:48the other side of it, but they all tie together as if, you know
- 23:50Larry Leopard, you know, our gold, he's a he's a boomer great
- 23:55guy. He's known as the he was a gold
- 23:57guy for very long, very big in the gold communities found
- 24:00Bitcoin And we had him on a pod in the last trade and we got to
- 24:03the end and we're, you know, we tend to sometimes get a little,
- 24:06you know, cosmic and talk about what we want to see and all
- 24:08that. And one of the things was like,
- 24:09I just want to see on the other side of this accountability,
- 24:12Accountability and accountability is the same
- 24:14thing. It's in the real world.
- 24:15But similar to what you're describing of you want to see
- 24:18the reality of what it costs from somebody to like get the
- 24:21goods delivered to them and they deserve or they get that right.
- 24:24Now. When you go to the market or you
- 24:25go somewhere and you wonder why the service doesn't make sense,
- 24:28there's a reason why. And it's because people you
- 24:29think about like a startup or all the things associated
- 24:32between the rank of how do you produce that unit of currency to
- 24:35pay them and then how they got hired.
- 24:36There's all of this like, inefficiency baked in and that
- 24:41accountability on that person getting it.
- 24:42They know they're going to get the paycheck.
- 24:44They know they're able to pick up the phone and deliver
- 24:45whatever the service is. Or you're going to get like your
- 24:48Amex or your Amazon thing thrown through the car, the truck, and
- 24:52you're going to get it broken. And he's still going to work his
- 24:54job. Like in real world when the
- 24:55marginal cost actually is something to produce it, now you
- 24:58have to fight and crawl up, call for that unit to deserve in your
- 25:02job and then you start to anchor back to efficiency in the world
- 25:05of like what you're doing, why you show up how you get paid and
- 25:09it's on the other end of the spectrum in like the meat space.
- 25:11But it's a very similar concept of you don't get the goods
- 25:14unless you're actually delivering them, which is
- 25:15basically non existent in this world, Frank like from a large
- 25:18part. And I think another way of of
- 25:20saying that is like we're just anchoring back to reality.
- 25:23Like things have just become untethered from reality and the
- 25:25reality, You know what I always think about Bitcoin is it's like
- 25:28an interdimensional portal in a sense, right?
- 25:30It connects the reality of the mind with the reality of the
- 25:34physical universe. And you know, as far as we know,
- 25:37there are laws like thermodynamics in this, in this
- 25:40dimension, in this known universe.
- 25:42And when we become untethered from those, of course our
- 25:44systems break because they're not tethered in reality.
- 25:47And so yeah, I think Bitcoin is a great anchor into
- 25:49thermodynamics. Yeah.
- 25:51And that that tethered to reality, the tether to you know,
- 25:55thinking about opportunity costs, right of of you know what
- 25:58you can do with the marginal dollar.
- 26:01It it has sort of implications for what I want to talk about
- 26:04next which is like you know these layers being built on top
- 26:07of Bitcoin which is something that you've spent a lot of time
- 26:09on whether it's lightning network or or NOSA or other
- 26:12other layers on top of the base protocol.
- 26:15But basically you know having that rationality at the base
- 26:19layer, rationality of this Internet based money allows you
- 26:24to build all these other things that again are still rooted in
- 26:26rationality. So it allows you to build you
- 26:29know whether it's a marketplace or a communications platform,
- 26:31things that are more rooted in reality and rooted in what
- 26:35people, people actually value. And something that you've
- 26:37written about Max, this concept around sort of market based
- 26:41ranking systems or value rank. It's something I think is so
- 26:44fascinating because it it it directly sort of it requires
- 26:48something like Bitcoin, right. For for these things to work.
- 26:50Where you have ubiquitous monetary unit that can be tied
- 26:54to information that is digital and it allows you to build these
- 26:57systems that are actually that the the outcome is that we have
- 27:01better information about whether it's a good or service or a
- 27:05piece of content or a tweet from someone you have better
- 27:08information about. You know the value of something
- 27:10because you can more accurately ascribe value to things in real
- 27:15time. So maybe talk a little bit about
- 27:17your, your, your thesis around those, those concepts.
- 27:20Well, the first thing I'll say is another shout out to Drew,
- 27:23who again, I think is is definitely one of the greatest
- 27:26thinkers in in this space. You know, and he said many
- 27:29times, and I very much agree with him, that the innovation of
- 27:33Bitcoin is just markets. It's just like markets work and
- 27:37we should probably have markets for most things.
- 27:39I mean maybe not everything, but like most things it turns out
- 27:42markets are probably the best way to allocate scarce
- 27:44resources. And you know what Bitcoin is, is
- 27:49it's a market for energy as we just talked about.
- 27:53And you know that's extremely that's like a very helpful way
- 27:57of thinking about sort of this base layer market.
- 27:59But when you think about you know, so if you guys go back or
- 28:02if anyone listening this listens to my last show that I record
- 28:05with Michael, we talked a lot about what I do at Hive Mind And
- 28:08so even though I'm really interested in this energy stuff,
- 28:10I don't invest a ton in that then a couple, but the vast
- 28:12majority what I'm interested in Hive Mind Fund one was focused
- 28:15on lighting network infrastructure.
- 28:17Now I'm interested in like network applications and Noster
- 28:20infrastructure applications in the intersection there.
- 28:22And the reason for that is, you know, if you think about the way
- 28:24the Internet scaled right, it's sort of the OSI model.
- 28:27You have TCP, IP, you know and then on top of that HTTP for the
- 28:30web and then SMTP for e-mail and stuff like that.
- 28:32You know, I think basically this is all going to scale the exact
- 28:34same way. Bitcoin is sort of the base
- 28:36layer TCP IP, the Lightning network is something like an
- 28:39HTTP or SMTP depending on how you look at it.
- 28:42And that's that's extremely interesting to me because you
- 28:44know once you can send very tiny units of Bitcoin around the
- 28:49world instantly for almost free, what that enables is the ability
- 28:54to create new kinds of markets. And so you know one way I'm sure
- 28:58we'll talk about the AI stuff in a little bit as well.
- 29:00But one way I've been increasingly thinking about this
- 29:02is if Bitcoin is like is is energy backed money, it's it's
- 29:07critically and I want to be clear on this, it's not energy,
- 29:08it's not the Michael Segal or Bitcoin is energy that's that's
- 29:11false. It is energy backed money.
- 29:13It is something that was sold in a market for energy.
- 29:16Then on top of that, what kinds of of new things can you do with
- 29:22little units of energy backed money that you can send around
- 29:24the world? Well, in a way you can kind of
- 29:26almost think about it like ATP, you know in a cell and you can
- 29:31start to build what I call metabolic pathways, which is
- 29:34what I think the lighting network is and the metabolic
- 29:36pathways are where you're sending these little units of
- 29:39energy backed money around. Almost sounds like we're
- 29:41building a super Organism or a hive mind of course, which is
- 29:45where my my fund name came. So in that world then you start
- 29:47thinking about well where does micro payments with real energy
- 29:50backed money, what kinds of new problems or new markets could
- 29:52emerge that could solve new problems?
- 29:54Well, one problem that you're talking about that became really
- 29:58kind of, I guess, top of mind for me in 2021 when I published
- 30:01this piece on my blog called How to Disrupt Google, is that, you
- 30:05know, information quality is a real, real problem.
- 30:10And you know, over the last decade, I think there's a lot of
- 30:12reasons. It seems like a lot of society,
- 30:14at least in the US, probably much of the world, is kind of,
- 30:17you know, in chaos and in decay. I certainly think, you know,
- 30:20debasing the monetary supply, that's obviously having a big
- 30:23impact. But I don't think it's all of
- 30:24it. I think a lot of it is just
- 30:25everyone's connected online all the time.
- 30:27That's new. You know, we have no idea what
- 30:30we're doing with the long term implications of being constantly
- 30:32connected to our phones are we're like 10 years, 15 years
- 30:34into this experiment, all these social networks.
- 30:36We have no idea the long term implications of any of this
- 30:38stuff. And of course it's very
- 30:40dangerous because it's all tied not to, you know, anything real
- 30:43with real markets, but to like kind of like fake traps where
- 30:46you, you know, think you get in for free, you become the
- 30:48product, you're the frog gets boiled over time, then all of a
- 30:50sudden you're starting to believe all kinds of crazy
- 30:52misinformation fighting with your neighbors.
- 30:54I think that's playing a big a big role.
- 30:56But we have today and one thing that I concretely noticed in
- 30:592021 is that, you know, Google search just kind of like sucks.
- 31:04And, you know, some people have debated how bad this actually
- 31:06is. I think it's pretty bad in 2021,
- 31:10You know, I came across this piece by a guy, I think his name
- 31:13is DKB or something like that. And, you know, I thought it was
- 31:17extremely hit the nail on the head to show how much it hit the
- 31:21hill, hit the nail on the head, not just with me but with Hacker
- 31:23News. Let's call it the Elite Nerd
- 31:25Vanguard. It was the 11th most upvoted
- 31:28post of all time on Hacker News. Pretty interesting.
- 31:31And the basic thesis was Google page rank no longer works
- 31:35because it's so gained, The algorithms are so gained.
- 31:37Like if you type anything in, you know, unless it's like a
- 31:40direct piece of factual information, what you're getting
- 31:43is like, you know, listicles, like 10 things to do, this thing
- 31:48that like don't answer your question at all.
- 31:50Or if they do, it's essentially, you know, an advert.
- 31:53And so that system got game. For those of you who don't know,
- 31:56I mean the way, you know, sort of Google got really big.
- 31:58There were a whole bunch of search engines in the late 90s.
- 32:01Google One, because of page rank.
- 32:02Page Rank was this algorithm developed by Sergei and Larry at
- 32:05Stanford. The thesis was trying to create
- 32:07trust, proxies of trust, and the way they did that was like
- 32:11originally going back to stanford.edu and then out from
- 32:14there they basically built this network of trust.
- 32:16OK, well now that that's pretty gained what I noticed is any
- 32:20time I was searching for real information, I was appending
- 32:24Reddit to the end of my search and turns out all the online
- 32:27nerd vanguard were doing the same.
- 32:31Or stacker, you know, Stack Overflow or whatever, like some
- 32:34good quality forum with real human answers.
- 32:37That's what the real search engine was.
- 32:39Well, that's pretty interesting. But then the problem that he
- 32:42then raised is he's like cool. So you have these like little
- 32:44mini knowledge marketplaces, some of which are pretty good.
- 32:47Some got bad over time. Like core used to be pretty
- 32:49good. Then it got like ad driven and
- 32:51became crap. Reddit was good for a very long
- 32:53time. It's increasingly lowering its
- 32:54quality over time. I think they've made huge
- 32:56missteps there. That should be a monster
- 32:57company, but it's not. And so anyway, so Long story
- 33:00short, he basically spends this whole post being like lamenting
- 33:03the Google's crap, lamenting that you know, all these little
- 33:07good knowledge marketplaces would be much better if there
- 33:09was some way to like standardize a market rank of the information
- 33:14between them. And he brought up this idea of
- 33:15market rank and it stuck with but then he spent the rest of
- 33:18the post was like genius insight.
- 33:19Then he spent the rest of the post trying to like say like how
- 33:21do we solve for inflation and how do we solve for like
- 33:24currency denomination between all these marketplaces?
- 33:26Like, all right. And and this is kind of the
- 33:28beauty, by the way, of like, being somebody's soul sold on
- 33:30Bitcoin. It's like you start to see all
- 33:32these genius insights, but they're just missing this one
- 33:34piece. Right?
- 33:35And so then I was like, all right, cool.
- 33:36I think I know what that missing piece is.
- 33:38And so in my paper, I basically say, cool.
- 33:41I think one way to solve this misinformation problem, which is
- 33:44going to get a lot worse with LLMS creating more and more and
- 33:46more information, is to use one of the two scarce things that we
- 33:49have in the universe that we know.
- 33:50One is attention. That's what we've used so far.
- 33:52That's like killed society, #2 is Bitcoin and tiny units of
- 33:57Satoshi's. And so at the time, you know,
- 33:59this was 2021, I I was like, well, there's different ways you
- 34:02could create this kind of like, you know, what I call a Satoshi
- 34:05depth layer for the web, which if you think about it in
- 34:07dimensions, right, like, this is the information.
- 34:09And then you basically drop Satoshi's on top.
- 34:11That's the depth layer. That's how you kind of like,
- 34:13figure out what's viable. It's not, you know, one way to
- 34:15do it would be to create a brand new knowledge marketplace.
- 34:18I am a major two time investor in Stacker News.
- 34:21I am extremely bullish on that company.
- 34:23Oh my God. I think by the way, Kian's like
- 34:25one of the best folders I've ever seen.
- 34:26I think they're going to absolutely destroy Reddit.
- 34:28We can talk more about them, but they just recently released user
- 34:31owned Subs. Where the users own the Subs can
- 34:33set their own economic policies. Holy shit, that's going to be
- 34:36big and that's one way to do it. Another way to do it would be to
- 34:40basically take the rest of the web and drop Satoshi's on top.
- 34:44So another one of my companies that I'm a major investor in,
- 34:47ALBIE, which stars an open source project now company as
- 34:49well. I was like, well, you could just
- 34:51kind of like tip random things on the web from with a browser
- 34:54extension and that's one way to start getting some of this
- 34:56information signal. By the way, one of the key
- 34:58insights here is you don't need everyone to do this, right?
- 35:00Like the whole like, oh, people never do value for value.
- 35:02Like it's probably true, but if 1% of people do and they will
- 35:06something like that, then that's probably enough to generate the
- 35:08signal. So that that was my first kind
- 35:10of insight. Then Fast forward I'm sure we'll
- 35:13talk more about Noster comes along.
- 35:14I'm like OK, I think this is where it's going to happen
- 35:17natively. I still think the other stuff is
- 35:19interesting. Stacker News as an example is
- 35:20backwards compatible becoming a Noster client where you can log
- 35:23in with a Noster, you can cross post an Oster Relays.
- 35:27Similarly Albie is like the major way to log into most
- 35:29Noster websites that create an Oster wallet connect as well.
- 35:32So, so I think a lot of people are starting to realize this,
- 35:34but I think what's interesting with Noster is in addition to
- 35:37having an easy way to ZAP, you know, notes or information, you
- 35:40also have identity around the web.
- 35:43And that's super important because, you know, if I post a
- 35:46piece of information that says smoking is good for you and like
- 35:48all of a sudden it gets like whatever, like a billion sats
- 35:51like, hmm, maybe that's Marlboro.
- 35:52Maybe I should take that with a giant grain of salt.
- 35:54But if you can start to basically attach reputation and
- 35:57this whole concept, there's this whole thinking that Keon and
- 36:00Artur and Ostrata Band thought a lot about, which is like Web of
- 36:03Trust. You can basically start to like
- 36:06high level, like have the different nodes be like
- 36:08different public keys, non star identities that are creating
- 36:12different nodes and then like the weights between whose apps,
- 36:15what information, you know, that's one way to like figure
- 36:18out the value of that. So Jack Dorsey's app something
- 36:20much more interesting than a random anyway.
- 36:23So long start, Long story short, I think there's a lot to figure
- 36:28out there, but I'm pretty sure that some version of value rank
- 36:31or market rank is going to be foundational to the next Google.
- 36:36And that's kind of one of my main focus areas.
- 36:38Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 36:40exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 36:43about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 36:46allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 36:51We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 36:54I think it's like. Obvious at this point, like the
- 36:56Internet is kind of broken in the sense of like just trying to
- 36:59use a Google or social media platform and you know again the
- 37:02centralization and the ability from, you know, ads and the
- 37:05censorship, we saw all that happen and then maybe it is like
- 37:08reversed a little bit that there's something there.
- 37:11But when you're. I can't help but think about
- 37:14this sounds kind of like it's almost kind of dumb, but it's
- 37:17like Bitcoin couldn't exist without the Internet.
- 37:19Totally. But I think it couldn't exist
- 37:21without the Internet. Not from like ATCPIP and like
- 37:23transfer of like information and packets, from the virality of
- 37:28how fast it's like aggregated and caught steam because you
- 37:31needed the social virality of it.
- 37:32But then it's if you take that, then it's like Internet was,
- 37:36Bitcoin is the thing. What was created with the
- 37:38Internet or the Internet needed to exist.
- 37:40It's actually the thing that's going to keep the Internet alive
- 37:42in the sense of like the Internet will fundamentally be
- 37:44broken because of all the AI and all the things that we're
- 37:46talking about where you can have infinite amount of information
- 37:49that's transferred over it. So then it makes it unusable.
- 37:52So now you ascribe this value like to what we're talking about
- 37:56to like signal on the Internet. So now you know how to use it
- 37:58again. And if you take that even
- 38:00further, so now we if extrapolating that to the next
- 38:03step, it's like, well, we have AI that's existed but if you go
- 38:05back to the energy, it's the thing that keeps it from like
- 38:07not turning on us and it requires energy to go and it's
- 38:10just symbiosis that bitcoins going to play till like we March
- 38:14towards wherever. We're going to keep everything
- 38:16in check. I see an odd it's all that was
- 38:19enough to tease it. But it's just something I've
- 38:21been thinking about for a while And it was before the AI and all
- 38:23this it was just naturally the Internet.
- 38:25When I think about how fast Bitcoin has caught the viral and
- 38:28people don't generally talk about like means and all the
- 38:31things that were needed to catch the scene, there was a having
- 38:34that's obvious, right, for the reflectivity of the market and
- 38:36market awareness. But there's also like the the
- 38:38stories and the the podcast and the articles that were really
- 38:42needed that you can imagine. If that didn't exist, how much
- 38:44longer would have taken to disseminate all this
- 38:46information. Yeah.
- 38:48And I I think sort of the next step is going to be even Wilder.
- 38:51Now this is harder to predict. I mean as as an investor, I'm
- 38:54much more interested in like, well, what's going to be big in
- 38:55the next couple of years. And so I think, I think Value
- 38:58Rank and some of the AI stuff will be and I think Noster is
- 39:00going to be very big. But if you start thinking many
- 39:03years maybe a decade plus out, this is another idea that was
- 39:06inspired by that Drew talk in 2019.
- 39:10I actually. So I I kind of repackage this a
- 39:12little bit and the way I think about this, this is a bit more
- 39:14sci-fi. But you mentioned you don't mind
- 39:16going cosmic. So here we go.
- 39:19I think of the next Internet, the truly next Internet.
- 39:22What I mean by that is like the physical infrastructure behind
- 39:25it. That's what I'm going to call
- 39:26the Bitcoin orboris. And you guys know the Orboris is
- 39:29like the snake that eats its own tail.
- 39:31I think this is just like a fascinating sort of like paradox
- 39:37that we run into over and over again.
- 39:40We run into it in mathematics. There's like viral
- 39:44incompleteness theorem. We run into it and sort of like
- 39:46the zin Co ONS, we run into it in like certain statements like
- 39:51you say, well it was. You can go like there's all
- 39:54sorts of like interesting linguistics that you can like
- 39:56basically create, create these things that just explode your
- 40:01mind because it can't be true or not true.
- 40:03And I think that that's because that's kind of what
- 40:05consciousness is like. There's a thing within, there's
- 40:08like a member of the set that can't see everything because it
- 40:11can't see itself. And So what I think is going to
- 40:14happen here is that, you know, we, as you said, we needed this
- 40:18first wave of the Internet. And the Internet obviously is
- 40:20still built on one, the energy systems, you know, energy
- 40:23infrastructure powering the servers and then it's built on
- 40:26the actual cables transmitting the information.
- 40:29And so which by the way, that could become a major choke point
- 40:32in the next decade. I hope it doesn't, but it very
- 40:34well might. But we have a solution for that.
- 40:37And I think you know what's going to happen is you have this
- 40:40Internet that pops up, Bitcoin gets released to obviously fix
- 40:46the monetary problem. Then on top of it, we build the
- 40:49Lightning network, which are these metabolic pathways which
- 40:52allow us to start, you know, creating new mini markets for
- 40:55things. We get something like NOSTER and
- 40:57I think there's a debate. I'm obviously very bullish on
- 41:00Noster. So I'm spending a lot of my time
- 41:01today. I think if basically Bitcoin is
- 41:02a centralized network from value lightning to centralized network
- 41:05for payments, Noster centralized network for data, some people
- 41:08think that's going to come directly on top of the Lightning
- 41:10network, like it's a literal layer 3 where this is sort of
- 41:12like a bit of a diagonal layer three.
- 41:14We'll see. NOSTER is anchoring to lighting
- 41:16networks. It's probably good enough.
- 41:18But basically once you have an information network that's
- 41:20that's anchored into lightning Network, eventually what that's
- 41:24going to sort of translate out to is probably every pack that
- 41:26you send needs some kind of payment with it, right?
- 41:28Because again, tethering everything back into reality,
- 41:31there's some cost, energetic cost.
- 41:34And I think what's going to eventually happen is you're
- 41:37going to then once you can basically meter, you know,
- 41:41selling electrons for Satoshi's, selling bandwidth for Satoshi's,
- 41:44selling storage for Satoshi's, you're going to rebuild the
- 41:48infrastructure, the actual Internet infrastructure in a way
- 41:51that we can basically sell bandwidth.
- 41:53And you can create potentially like a mesh network where you
- 41:56know, you're incentivizing lots of people to sell their
- 41:59bandwidth and create a truly peer-to-peer Internet.
- 42:01That sounds crazy. That's probably many, many years
- 42:03in the future. But what's beautiful is if we
- 42:05can build that and now we have the incentives to do it.
- 42:08And if you want to, you know, learn more about this watch
- 42:10again that blockchain Mind candy talk drew goes into like very,
- 42:13very interesting detail about it.
- 42:15You know, you basically solve a lot of these centralization
- 42:17problems where to build a new telecom, whatever, you need huge
- 42:19amounts of capital and build out this big infrastructure project.
- 42:22Now potentially could be done in a more peer-to-peer way.
- 42:24Well, then eventually if we get that new net, then you start
- 42:27hosting Bitcoin back on top of it.
- 42:29So you literally, you had a world, you created the Bitcoin
- 42:31in the world, you build a new Internet infrastructure on top
- 42:34and rehost the Bitcoin on top of that.
- 42:36It's literally something from within the system building a new
- 42:39system which it is itself running inside of in the new
- 42:42version. That's where I think we're
- 42:43headed and I think that's going to take some time to get there.
- 42:46But one thing that does kind of bring me to as an investor is
- 42:49you know I I made a joke about this on Twitter, but I actually
- 42:51mean it. One of my theses at Hive Mind is
- 42:53to like look at all of the like shit coin projects that have
- 42:55gotten any kind of interest, right.
- 42:56So basically like look at like the multi coin portfolio, find
- 43:01the ones that are interesting and then just build them with
- 43:04Bitcoin lightning in Oscar, right.
- 43:05So you know, I invested recently in Open Agents, which also runs
- 43:09GP Utopia, Open Network for compute for AI.
- 43:13And now I'm interested in like rebuilding Helium, which is like
- 43:16the sort of like a bandwidth market with Satoshi's that I'm
- 43:18interested in building. File, Coin and all those other
- 43:21crap storage projects that went nowhere with Bitcoin, Lightning
- 43:25and probably Noster for at least the the lookups of the files.
- 43:29So I know that's a little bit out there, but I think it does
- 43:31tie down to like very concrete things that I want to invest in,
- 43:33which is marketplaces, digital marketplaces for physical
- 43:36resources metered with lightning.
- 43:38It makes complete sense. To two quick points in a Brian,
- 43:41Brian runs a tight ship on this one.
- 43:43So we got, we got topics we're going to go through, but.
- 43:46Just just to to anchor. Where that it makes complete
- 43:48sense from just a pure efficiency perspective.
- 43:50It's like we went and pulled all the data from a central
- 43:52perspective and have to shoot it back out versus what you're
- 43:54talking about is the data and information goes out to the
- 43:57edges, which is just a more robust and resilient network.
- 44:00And then when you reference reference to the altcoin
- 44:02projects and then there's validity, yeah, 100%.
- 44:05The one that always thinks comes to mind is stepping like this
- 44:08idea to have like step in was a it was something like app where
- 44:11if you ran you got tokens and obviously they traded it and
- 44:14turned it into. But you can imagine there's
- 44:16some, like social aspects to like having a unit tied to
- 44:19reward and social proof around group activities that you
- 44:23haven't seen. But once you coalesce around
- 44:25that, and it was an altcoin project where I know people
- 44:28working, I know there's going to be something out there, probably
- 44:31multiple versions of it, because it's just all interoperable and
- 44:34it makes sense because it's money and you like to get paid
- 44:36for doing physical activity and we need, you know, So yeah, no.
- 44:40And I'm. Really.
- 44:41I'm really glad you brought up that that thought Max on on sort
- 44:44of looking at looking at the crypto landscape and saying, you
- 44:48know, these aren't all bad ideas.
- 44:50It's just that they've got it twisted and that they think they
- 44:53need their own token. And part of that is probably
- 44:56greed and grift, but it's also just a lack of recognition that,
- 44:59yeah, you should be building this on Bitcoin.
- 45:01You should be building on the most robust and resilient
- 45:03foundation. But yeah, there's good ideas out
- 45:06there. I mean, it's funny like a, you
- 45:09know, one of the hot sort of crypto narratives is this what
- 45:12they call D PIN, which is exactly what you're describing,
- 45:14which is like decentralized physical infrastructure
- 45:16networks. It's like, yes, we can do these
- 45:18things, but we can do it with Bitcoin.
- 45:21And you really don't need your own token.
- 45:23That'll probably just end up being dumped on retail.
- 45:27But one one question I do want to go back to just in terms of,
- 45:32you know, something like Stacker News or or any of the sort of
- 45:36things being built on Noster in your mind, like how does this
- 45:40manifest over time? From which end does sort of like
- 45:44much larger map, you know, close to mass adoption occur?
- 45:46Does it come from people that first see Bitcoin and then say,
- 45:51like, Oh yeah, obviously I'm going to use these applications
- 45:53that leverage this network. Or does it come from just like
- 45:56better applications and better market ranking systems which
- 46:00give people better insights into whatever kind of market they're
- 46:03looking at? And then they realize, Oh yeah,
- 46:05this is using Bitcoin on the back end.
- 46:07Yeah, I think, you know, it's somewhat of a virtuous cycle,
- 46:10right? Where you know, to, to be clear,
- 46:14I'm not as excited on like the Twitter social media stuff with
- 46:17Nostrum, but you know that stuff is still going with you know 10s
- 46:21of thousands of users at least probably hundreds of thousands
- 46:24to three because the Bitcoiners have have a home there.
- 46:28So that's great and like because of that, you know the more
- 46:31people that use those protocols and the various clients like you
- 46:36get more developers that if those developers are then going
- 46:38to build more interesting new apps.
- 46:40But I do tend to learn more towards the the latter case
- 46:43which you're saying which is just brand new applications
- 46:44where you know Bitcoin or lightning are just used there.
- 46:47And so for me with Noster, you know, I, you know, I've made
- 46:51several investments here. You know, obviously I'm proud
- 46:54investor in companies like Primal, which I really like what
- 46:56they're doing and I think it's fantastic and like there can be
- 46:58a great social experience there. But I think that what's going to
- 47:03happen is it's super network effects.
- 47:05So like you're going to see some new use case that's not Twitter.
- 47:08I think probably part of the problem with Twitter by the way
- 47:10is that the like the network effect on X is so strong and if
- 47:14you really want Bitcoin lightning payments and you're
- 47:16like a Bitcoin obsessive or like a super Uber nerd, great.
- 47:19We got those people. The good news is they're
- 47:20technical for the most part, or many of them are.
- 47:22So they're going to build new stuff, but I think the next big
- 47:25wave in my guess is going to come from something else and I
- 47:29don't know what it's going to be.
- 47:30I'm very interested in marketplaces here.
- 47:32I'm also investor in Helen Betts.
- 47:34They were the first one to release open source software
- 47:37that you can use to run a Nostrom market for anything.
- 47:39I think that, you know, I expect to see someone's going to build
- 47:41local Bitcoins on Oster and then lots of other people are going
- 47:43to plug in that shared order book.
- 47:44I expect to see, you know, GPU Toby and other people doing this
- 47:46for GPUs and what he's working on now, open agents like AI
- 47:50agents where you have one order book for, you know, agents where
- 47:53you paid out in SAT's that can do all kinds of weird stuff and
- 47:55probably stuff that I haven't even thought of yet that I'm
- 47:57going to be surprised about. But what's beautiful is whatever
- 48:00that next marketplace is, the Pops or the next app with Noster
- 48:05is the POPS. Everything else that's
- 48:07integrated, NOSTER identity and NOSTER Login gets those users or
- 48:10gets the potential for those users.
- 48:12So let's say it's, you know, a couple 100,000 people have
- 48:14played with the Twitter clients, you know, and 1020% of them
- 48:17stuck around. Cool.
- 48:20The next big thing that pops anyone that's ever downloaded
- 48:22and gotten a public private key pair.
- 48:23Now they can down they can log into whatever that new
- 48:25marketplace is going to be and any of those new marketplace
- 48:28users can now log into the Twitter clients.
- 48:30OK interesting. That starts to have you know a
- 48:33super network effect. Other you know apps which I've
- 48:37also invested in things like Fountain and Wavelink.
- 48:41You know Fountain is a podcasting app.
- 48:43Oscar's also a lot about value Inc wavely for music.
- 48:46They're also doing some of the value rank, but because they've
- 48:48already integrated an Oscar, you know, whatever that next thing
- 48:51that pops is, they get those users too.
- 48:52And any new users that they bring on, even if it's linear
- 48:54growth or whatever, they're still now Noster users.
- 48:57And they can use the Twitter clones and they can also use
- 48:59Stacker News and then they can also use whatever the
- 49:01marketplace pops. So, you know, if I had to take a
- 49:03step back, one of the reasons I'm so bullish on Noster, I
- 49:07think, and there's a lot that I don't understand about what's
- 49:09going to happen this next wave. But I think that humanity is
- 49:12going through like a phase shift.
- 49:16We're going through a transition becoming.
- 49:18We don't know exactly what this new super Organism is going to
- 49:20look like or even what the economics are going to look
- 49:22like. We know it's going to be
- 49:22tethered. In reality there should be some
- 49:23economic costs. But I think the economics are
- 49:25going to look very different than what, you know, the sort of
- 49:28industrial era like you know, we have this sort of agricultural
- 49:30or hunter gatherer era, agricultural era, industrial
- 49:33era. We're just coming into the post
- 49:35industrial Information Society and I think it's going to
- 49:38surprise a lot of people. One example, I think Kevin
- 49:41Kelly, who's another one of my, you know, major heroes, he.
- 49:46You know. Predicted a lot of this very
- 49:47well in 1997, like the late 90s. Sort of the logic of networks
- 49:51and network economies is very different.
- 49:54And you know, in a network economy, you want to bet on open
- 49:58standards that are really simple, right?
- 50:00Like the easier it is for someone to grow and join and
- 50:04create value for your network, the better off you're all going
- 50:06to be. And what got me so sold on
- 50:08Noster? Well, for one thing I love that
- 50:10it already came out of the bitcoiners and ethos I agreed
- 50:13with, was tied to lightning payments, blah blah.
- 50:14But it's just so simple. Like your identity, there is no
- 50:18accounts, there is no passwords, It's a public key.
- 50:20Interestingly enough, it's a Bitcoin public key, which has
- 50:23some interesting 2nd order effects.
- 50:25But because it's just so simple and like then you share a Jason
- 50:27BLOB with just a couple of fields and like it couldn't be
- 50:29more simple. And so I think it's going to be
- 50:31hard for anything else to beat that on adoption because I think
- 50:34ultimately lowering the friction joining us matters.
- 50:38So yeah, that's why I'm bullish, Something about economics.
- 50:41Do you ever? Think about like some of these
- 50:42companies you invested in fun and they may look a little
- 50:45different than traditional you know quote UN quote Web 2.0 and
- 50:49like you know the unicorns. And something I think about in a
- 50:52in a world where it's tethered in reality and you have a unit
- 50:55that increases in purchasing power, you get, it's less of the
- 50:57app for golden handcuffs, right. Because you have this ability to
- 51:00actually learn and then go produce versus be tied to that
- 51:04kind of, you know, salary. And you see the centralization
- 51:06of like Google's a great example, right.
- 51:07It's like they have 200,000 employees and they pay them just
- 51:10to hang and hang around and not compete with them and I think we
- 51:12end up with a more flat structure.
- 51:14Does that impact any of it or do you think it's still too early
- 51:17from your like investment thesis on like how big these companies
- 51:19get and like the the top, the upside of their like potential,
- 51:23So that's. A really.
- 51:24Yeah. I mean fascinating question I
- 51:26don't know the answer to. I I think the good news is we
- 51:28can win in a lot of different ways.
- 51:29And so I I love placing bets where as long as I'm kind of
- 51:32directionally right, you know, we either win or we really win.
- 51:36And so I think that, you know, it's very possible that we never
- 51:42see a company as big as like a Facebook or Google again in
- 51:45terms of like percentage of GDP. And that's probably good thing
- 51:49for the world, right. Like I don't think and you know
- 51:51even though obviously I want to make money for me and my LP's, I
- 51:53don't think any of us have interest in like, you know,
- 51:56conquering and converting everyone to serfs, you know, and
- 51:58I I don't think that's that that's the Bitcoin ethos at all.
- 52:03Having said that, I wouldn't sleep on how big these companies
- 52:06can get, right. And the reason is open networks.
- 52:10So one way that I tell tell people about thinking about just
- 52:13just take payments companies, right is you know in the
- 52:16lighting network maybe your take rate for payments goes down a
- 52:20lot. Maybe in the traditional credit
- 52:21card networks it's 3% + a flat fee and maybe that gets
- 52:26compressed to .3%. So you have much smaller take
- 52:29rate. But when you have an economy
- 52:32that's open to 8 billion people, the vast majority of the world
- 52:35today is like not really able to plug in the online economy.
- 52:38You have trillions of AI intelligences, You have all
- 52:41kinds of weird new business models that no one's thought of,
- 52:43including stuff like Stacker News, Right.
- 52:45Which by the way, is just the most interesting case study and
- 52:47what a new online economy can look like, where you, you
- 52:51upvote, you get paid for finding things early, you get paid for
- 52:53posting early. And so then you start saying,
- 52:57well, yeah, maybe I only get .3%, but what if global GDP 1000
- 53:01XS or 10,000 XS? Because there's so many more
- 53:05people and so many more business models and so much more
- 53:08energetic flow. This, by the way, is another
- 53:10reason that I really emboldish on lightning and like, I like
- 53:13the Bitcoin digital gold thesis. But I just think it's very, I
- 53:15mean, look, the good news is, let's say everything you know
- 53:19that I'm saying is right, but you don't believe me.
- 53:23Like if it's just digital gold, you're going to win.
- 53:26And if I'm right about 10% of what I'm saying, you're going to
- 53:28win even more because it all accrues back to Bitcoin as well.
- 53:30And if I'm actually right, like then you're, you know, even
- 53:33happier. So that's the good news is you
- 53:35can be kind of directionally correct.
- 53:36But I I think that, you know, as much as I like Bitcoin as a
- 53:41storage vehicle, I think that's it's a very kind of like boomer
- 53:47last economy way of looking at the world.
- 53:50My increasing thinking is that what the Lightning Network is,
- 53:55is it's a flow network, right? Like your Bitcoin is only useful
- 54:01and it's interesting. It's like energy, right?
- 54:04It's which energy is never stagnant.
- 54:06This is by the way, one of the reasons I'm so, you know,
- 54:09bullish on Bitcoin mining with renewables.
- 54:10And by the way, if you look at interconnection queues in Texas,
- 54:12wherever, it's like literally 8090% solar, wind storage, all
- 54:15the stuff I'm talking about and it will sound crazy to live your
- 54:18of your listeners. Just like go to like the ERCOT
- 54:19air connection grid. It's all fat.
- 54:22But like what's interesting about all that is that if I over
- 54:25produce during sunny or windy times, I have all the surplus of
- 54:28electricity production. I can't just get rid of it,
- 54:32right? Like I have to do something with
- 54:34that electricity and you know I so literally that's when you get
- 54:38negative power prices because the way tax credits work in West
- 54:40TX when the winds blowing really heavily, you know you can't just
- 54:42make energy vanish right? That that's another one of the
- 54:45laws of their dynamics. So in my mind, energy and the
- 54:49digital representations of it are much more valuable when
- 54:54they're networked and constantly in flow, which is when you see
- 54:58in the long run I think what's going to happen in light
- 55:00network, you get a rate of return and you get a rate of
- 55:02return that is directly proportional to how good you are
- 55:05at pointing your flow, IE at taking the stats that you have
- 55:09in a channel and figuring out the right place to allocate
- 55:11them, which is you know, information to allocate flow.
- 55:16And so all that said, I think that your your margins may be
- 55:21lower but the overall size of the economic pie can be much,
- 55:23much, much, much much larger and people that figure out how to
- 55:28point their Bitcoin in new and productive ways are going to be
- 55:31really big winners. Yeah, no, that's that's a
- 55:35fascinating. Way to look at it.
- 55:36I think you know you you mentioned lightning as as a way
- 55:41to you know really expand basically the utility of of
- 55:45Bitcoin, right. Like it.
- 55:46It allows it to scale to more people.
- 55:48I think you know, it's funny because I love hearing your
- 55:51bullishness on Lightning, because I think it gets a lot of
- 55:54criticism, some of it warranted, some unwarranted, honestly.
- 55:58I mean, it's a six year old, roughly protocol, much younger
- 56:02than even Bitcoin, which is a very young, open protocol.
- 56:06But I'm curious how you think about, you know more from, more
- 56:10from the development side of things Like what, what are some
- 56:13of the realities of Lightning today in terms of its
- 56:16scalability and actually being able to service 8 billion
- 56:18people? What sort of things might need
- 56:21to be augmented or changed in the future?
- 56:23And and then sort of stepping back from that higher level, you
- 56:27know from an investment perspective as as someone
- 56:29investing in the space, how do you balance basically you know,
- 56:35potential protocol changes that could make all of these things
- 56:38more useful and more scalable versus hey, let's just build on
- 56:43what we have today and it'll sort of work itself out?
- 56:47I think that, you know, you're absolutely right.
- 56:49Lightning is still a very young protocol.
- 56:51And I think I think one thing that I would just caution
- 56:54everyone, you know when when you're looking at all this stuff
- 56:56is like it's one thing to be very bullish, which obviously
- 56:58all of us are and sometimes I fall into the strap or get a
- 57:01little too bullish too fast, I know that.
- 57:04But like yeah zoom out just like a little bit like to your point
- 57:07Lightning network you know we're six years in or whatever it is
- 57:10Bitcoin 15 ish years in. I mean these the internet's not
- 57:13even that old right. Like at least the web as we know
- 57:15it. And so we're we're still pretty
- 57:18early if you take kind of like the civilizational vantage point
- 57:23for all of this stuff. And so I think that while we
- 57:27would like a lot of these things to happen tomorrow like the
- 57:28Bitcoin or Burst if I was talking about, it's not, it's
- 57:30just not like there are you still have to like take
- 57:33realities of physics and human nature and like it just takes
- 57:36time to build you like of course.
- 57:38And so I think that, you know on the long term view, I think
- 57:43we're actually moving pretty quickly.
- 57:45In the short term view. You know, I think that from
- 57:50business perspective, I mean I'll tell you start out like a
- 57:52lot of my companies have done some wild or more sci-fi bets
- 57:55that'll take some more time. I think the companies that are
- 57:57just like making it rain right now are these like regional
- 58:00exchanges and lightning nodes that are doing payments.
- 58:02So like, if you want to look at like Bitcoin companies today,
- 58:06there's like, as far as I can tell, there's probably a few.
- 58:09More, but there's. Only a few things really.
- 58:10A product market fit exchange. Exchange always works.
- 58:14Exchange between Fiat currencies and Bitcoin?
- 58:16Great. Still a great business.
- 58:17There's gonna be a lot of like call the mini rivers that emerge
- 58:21in these different emerging economies.
- 58:23They're not going the next Google, but you know for fund my
- 58:25size fund almost $21 million, I think we can return the fund
- 58:28many times on our investments in those amazing investors are
- 58:30going to be super stoked and they also do payments and they
- 58:33have lightning nodes that are going to probably become very
- 58:34important to regional routers, IE the Grand Central for their
- 58:37reaches. Those businesses are going to do
- 58:39fantastic and in those cases frankly like they're custodial
- 58:42and that's fine for now. I'm not saying like obviously
- 58:46there's geopolitical things that could shift that, but custodial
- 58:48lightning, it works. It's great.
- 58:50Yes, it has a lot of problems. There's a lot of regulatory
- 58:51issues. It pisses me off that like
- 58:53companies have to worry about getting licenses and all this
- 58:55stuff. But like it is what it is and
- 58:57that's if you want to you know win in this phase, that's where
- 59:00we're at with where the technology is.
- 59:01OK, great. The other two things that you so
- 59:04you've got basically exchange payments and probably like loans
- 59:07like Unchained style stuff, those things all have product
- 59:09market fit to some degree. Everything else is a bit more
- 59:11speculative in my mind. What comes next?
- 59:14Well, you know, if we really it, it depends, right, Like if, if
- 59:17there's like major government crackdowns and certain things,
- 59:19which doesn't appear to be happening.
- 59:21If anything, it appears it's gone the other way.
- 59:22We just got ETFs approved like. But if that were to happen, then
- 59:25yes, there would have to be some kind of like, you know, faster
- 59:29building on the Noxtodial front. But even on that front, we're
- 59:31moving pretty quickly, right? So, you know, I've also invested
- 59:35in companies, you know, like Mutiny, those guys and Breeze.
- 59:38Both of those companies have done a lot of thinking about
- 59:40this. You know Breeze is using green
- 59:43light with their SDK today. Mutiny was building on LDK, you
- 59:46know and Block has put a lot of spiral, a lot of resources
- 59:49behind non CEO Lightning. There's still a lot to be done
- 59:51where you can basically separate the signer on a device from the
- 59:55node which is running in the cloud.
- 59:56That's great. I think all that stuff is
- 59:58awesome. Mutiny recently has gotten a lot
- 1:00:00of attention. I've also invested in Fetty as
- 1:00:03well for for using Fetaments. So both those companies are
- 1:00:05playing there. Kelly and some of the Ellen bits
- 1:00:08guys have done a lot with cashew and these mints.
- 1:00:13I think, yeah, the E cash stuff is interesting.
- 1:00:15I don't think it's the long term solution.
- 1:00:16I think it's a great tool in the toolbox and like if you want
- 1:00:18quote UN quote non custodial, it's not non custodial because
- 1:00:21you know you have to give up custody of your Bitcoin to get
- 1:00:22it. But it's a different trust model
- 1:00:24and that's that's probably a good option for some people.
- 1:00:29I also think people are sleeping unlike other stuff that's like,
- 1:00:31you know, if you're OK with that level of centralization and
- 1:00:34risk, like again, everything's a spectrum, right?
- 1:00:37Frankly, I feel more comfortable.
- 1:00:39Yes, there's certain risks, but having my like Lightning wallet
- 1:00:41with cash out, why Block is a, you know, public company that
- 1:00:44gets audited and like a edge. I don't think Jack Dorsey is
- 1:00:47going to try and rug us. And if he does, you know,
- 1:00:49there's the SEC there. And like, I know they're not
- 1:00:50perfect, but like whatever, there's like certain protections
- 1:00:53we get there. If things go really South, then
- 1:00:56there's other jurisdictions that will pop up, ABL Salvador and
- 1:00:59companies like Galoy operating there blink.
- 1:01:02Maybe they'll be the one that you can trust more because
- 1:01:04they're kind of regulated. So that's kind of on the more
- 1:01:06centralized version. You do have different risk
- 1:01:09models but probably you're gonna be okay there And on the other
- 1:01:13end of the spectrum if you really need private you know
- 1:01:15because you're living in a part of the world where that's
- 1:01:17necessary maybe the mints are your best option and maybe a
- 1:01:20mint with you know three of five or five of seven multi sig.
- 1:01:23You know I personally am less bullish on like randos custom
- 1:01:26your Bitcoin. That sounds terrifying to me.
- 1:01:27But like like what you guys are doing sounds a lot makes a lot
- 1:01:30of sense multi custodian, you know, and I I told Michael I
- 1:01:33would love to be able to have some Bitcoin store with, you
- 1:01:36know, a key in with one company in Singapore, another in
- 1:01:38Switzerland, another in the United States, another in El
- 1:01:40Salvador. That makes a lot of sense to me.
- 1:01:42But I do think in the long say medium term, even the next
- 1:01:46couple of years, I think a lot of people are sleeping on stuff
- 1:01:48like channel factories, hosted channels where you know maybe
- 1:01:52you have to trust, you know Lightning Labs and whoever opens
- 1:01:55those channels with them on your behalf.
- 1:01:57But like you know both of them have direct you.
- 1:02:00And then eventually I do think we'll get the fully non
- 1:02:02custodial stuff working out. But I think that'll just take
- 1:02:04time and we need patience. And yeah, I would just encourage
- 1:02:07anyone that's like down and lightning to zoom out.
- 1:02:09It's like working pretty damn well.
- 1:02:12Yeah, I think that's. That's certainly the right
- 1:02:16nuance take on on all of that and just putting my, so I I
- 1:02:22spent several years in the traditional finance world and I
- 1:02:24I did a lot of diligence on investment funds.
- 1:02:28So I'm curious from your perspective as a as a portfolio
- 1:02:31manager, you know you referenced those sort of different buckets
- 1:02:34of of almost risk profile of an opportunity right.
- 1:02:37And part of that is you know potential for monetization and
- 1:02:41and really more so like the time frame on which that could occur.
- 1:02:45How do you sort of structure your fund generally in terms of
- 1:02:48the exposures of those different types of investments?
- 1:02:51I'm just curious. Well, I mean, so for one thing I
- 1:02:55am you know, an early stage investor and it's kind of all
- 1:02:58that I'm interested in. I'm not really interested in
- 1:02:59becoming a growth stage investor.
- 1:03:00So I like, I like being the absolute first money, yet I will
- 1:03:03make exceptions to that like I invested in companies like
- 1:03:06Lightning Labs, River Light, Spark a little bit later and I
- 1:03:10think those are going to be great companies.
- 1:03:11But like typically I like to be the absolute first money yet.
- 1:03:14And the reason for that is it allows me to frankly cast a much
- 1:03:17wider net and to play a much riskier game.
- 1:03:20If you look at the best performing venture fund the last
- 1:03:22decade, I'm pretty sure it's why I see by like a large margin.
- 1:03:25And you know why is that? Well, because they get in at the
- 1:03:28very beginning and it's the beauty of power laws.
- 1:03:31If you get something and you know it's your question Michael,
- 1:03:33like how big can some of these companies get?
- 1:03:34I still think they could be really fucking big.
- 1:03:36And if I can catch, you know, maybe it's not the next Google
- 1:03:40in terms of percentage of GDP, but a Google sized company,
- 1:03:43right, like trillion dollar company, you know, even in a
- 1:03:46much bigger economy, like that's still super, super valuable.
- 1:03:49And so anything, I mean like back of the envelope math,
- 1:03:51right. My first one was $21 million
- 1:03:53fund back of the envelope with a few maybe strategic exceptions,
- 1:03:56let's say 90% of the deals I'm doing.
- 1:03:58I want to see a clear path. I want to see in my mind if this
- 1:04:02thing works. And I always think you know what
- 1:04:04could go right, what business models could emerge.
- 1:04:06But if it goes right, can I at least return the fund that's
- 1:04:09like the absolute bare minimum, right.
- 1:04:11And so I'm writing checks, typically between 250K and a
- 1:04:13mill. So I need to believe that this
- 1:04:15is my 250 or 500K or 750K stake, whatever it is, is going to be
- 1:04:19worth at least $1,000,000 in the worst case scenario.
- 1:04:22Then I start thinking, could I 10X?
- 1:04:24Could I get $200 million off of this one investment?
- 1:04:27That's where I get excited when I see stuff like that.
- 1:04:29So in general, you know, I invested in a lot of companies
- 1:04:33At some point I need to. In fact, I'm working on it.
- 1:04:34I don't know when we're getting out but updating my website, but
- 1:04:36we've invested in and fun one like 38 companies across 42
- 1:04:40rounds like I'm spread and I think typically his first money
- 1:04:44in. And so if any of those companies
- 1:04:48work at all, I think we return the funnel on one of those.
- 1:04:51If it really works, maybe we text the funnel on that one.
- 1:04:53If a bunch of them start working, could we get into some
- 1:04:55soccer returns maybe that's what I'm shooting for.
- 1:04:58And so that that's kind of the way I think about this is from a
- 1:05:00risk profile in terms of the different investments
- 1:05:02themselves. I mean, I actually didn't think
- 1:05:04about it as much at the time. But now that I'm kind of, you
- 1:05:07know, talking my LP's about this, it's kind of nice that I
- 1:05:10had a bunch of my crazy sci-fi bets, some of the infrastructure
- 1:05:13and early lightning application bets.
- 1:05:15But like I I did invest in like 6 of these kind of like regional
- 1:05:19exchange and like lightning, regional lightning nodes.
- 1:05:23That gives me like a lot of like confidence that worst case
- 1:05:25scenario even when all my sci-fi blows up like we have like
- 1:05:29exchanges and payments and that works and typically it's very,
- 1:05:33very early not first money. So I think I was kind of just
- 1:05:36getting a little bit lucky in the way that I I cast it out.
- 1:05:39But yeah, my my big thing is I want to know anything that I can
- 1:05:43return. I really want to see a way I can
- 1:05:4410X the whole fund off of 1 check.
- 1:05:46Yeah, and you. Did a lot of smart things there
- 1:05:48knowingly and and maybe unknowingly and like you've
- 1:05:51you've you've put constraints on yourself right with going at
- 1:05:55first money in where you don't need that much capital.
- 1:05:57And I think the multiples it's obviously improved looking at
- 1:06:00funds from a lower low amount raise from the multiple
- 1:06:03perspective and returning capital.
- 1:06:05But then you're you're basically playing into a tailwind that we
- 1:06:07think a lot about in the sense of the the just cost to actually
- 1:06:11start a business has just completely gone down every year
- 1:06:15and into the latest past couple of years.
- 1:06:17And I really think complete venture in general is just like
- 1:06:19almost like in the sense of the the you know zero or nothing or
- 1:06:23like 100 or nothing and all the things that are associated these
- 1:06:26large funds are really fundamentally going to get
- 1:06:28shifted especially with like what we see just with what's
- 1:06:32happening. And so it ties into like you've
- 1:06:34put this constraint on the 250 to 1,000,000 and the reality is
- 1:06:37you should be able to learn really quickly in this new age
- 1:06:39unless you're doing something insane from a regulatory or like
- 1:06:42meeting that kind of requirement to get product market a bit.
- 1:06:45And then your thesis on the regional exchanges is like spot
- 1:06:49on in the sense we just had to deal with coin MENA and they're
- 1:06:52licensed by the central bank and by Iran.
- 1:06:54They have a direct, you know window to the the the bank there
- 1:06:57and then they're also just got the Vara license in Dubai and
- 1:07:00the guy's thesis was effectively like finance had a lot of the
- 1:07:03flow there. But the reality is like in a
- 1:07:05local market when when it's financial markets and and and
- 1:07:09it's based, it's built on relationships and trust.
- 1:07:11And so like you don't want to send your money to you know X
- 1:07:14place you want to deal with people in your backyard.
- 1:07:16And so we see that globally and also ties to your point on the
- 1:07:19Fed events, we have some very strong thoughts on that.
- 1:07:21I'll share for another deal. But it's like it looks like it,
- 1:07:24but it looks different in the sense like we're not really
- 1:07:27going to, in my opinion, we're not some of this stuff, some of
- 1:07:30this stuff is going to get cosmic and look different, but
- 1:07:32we're actually, and they get conflated.
- 1:07:33We're not going to recreate the wheel.
- 1:07:35We're just repurposing it based on primitives that are unique to
- 1:07:38the protocol. And this idea of using trusted
- 1:07:41institutions and financial and media is to your point of square
- 1:07:43is like this like existed for thousands of years.
- 1:07:45So why would we just like throw it all away, you know.
- 1:07:48And so I think like Vetiments exist.
- 1:07:50They just look with like some regulatory constraints tied to
- 1:07:52who's holding it and that's what people want because they want
- 1:07:55governance in like regulatory clarity and Slas and things like
- 1:08:00that. And this goes back to just like,
- 1:08:03you know, looking and allocating.
- 1:08:04It's like if you've kind of seen that from the market and what
- 1:08:06they adopt, then you have a better understanding.
- 1:08:09And I think it ties into like, you know, a farmer in an
- 1:08:13emerging market all the way to a guy that's a billionaire because
- 1:08:16at the end of the day, the dollar to him and a billion
- 1:08:18dollars to the other person, still the same thought of like,
- 1:08:20it's your energy that's been produced and you have to
- 1:08:22understand how it works. You're just not going to park it
- 1:08:24there because everybody's trying to get your dollar or your bill
- 1:08:26in. And so they're the same concept
- 1:08:28of user adoption. They're just on different
- 1:08:29scales. Totally, I mean.
- 1:08:32A couple of reactions that one, you know on the the banks and
- 1:08:35the Fed and I'm also an investor like in Galois and you know they
- 1:08:37have a slightly different approach on regional banking and
- 1:08:39all this stuff as well. Like there's so many different
- 1:08:41ways this all could play out. But IA 100% agree with you.
- 1:08:44What I love about Bitcoin and Lightning and Nostrick, what I
- 1:08:48love about permissionless protocol, it's permissionless.
- 1:08:50You can do whatever the fuck you want.
- 1:08:53And 90% of people should not be self gusting.
- 1:08:57Like dude, the chance you're going to lose your own keys.
- 1:08:58Like let's get real. Like it's way greater than block
- 1:09:03losing your stuff. It just is.
- 1:09:04I'm not saying. And on the other hand, I'm not
- 1:09:06saying that that's the perfect solution for everyone either.
- 1:09:08And there are people for whatever reason the early
- 1:09:10cypherpunks like they don't want to participate in that system.
- 1:09:13Beautiful. Do it yourself.
- 1:09:14And you should always have that right of exit.
- 1:09:16You should always have the ability to interact with these
- 1:09:18protocols however the hell you want.
- 1:09:19But human trust is never going to die, and for most people,
- 1:09:24that's going to be very, very important.
- 1:09:25For those that you know want to go and build a crazy future and
- 1:09:28live on the edge, more power to them.
- 1:09:30That's the beauty of permissionless.
- 1:09:32Do what you want. Yep, Beauty of Open.
- 1:09:35Systems and also just having options, right?
- 1:09:37Having different options I think is key.
- 1:09:39The diversity of custodial options is very important,
- 1:09:43something we've heard from a lot of clients and prospects that
- 1:09:45we've talked to. You know, considering a multi
- 1:09:47institution custody setup doesn't necessarily have to be
- 1:09:49100% of your allocation, but just think about the different
- 1:09:52options because there's trade-offs associated with all
- 1:09:54of it and to your point like building on an open system
- 1:09:57allows you to have the diversity of those options totally.
- 1:10:01And one more point because Michael, I know you're you're
- 1:10:03somewhat and Brian you may be as well, but a student of the VC
- 1:10:07game as well. And just just to riff on that a
- 1:10:09little bit because I, I do have to say like obviously I love all
- 1:10:11this stuff and like you know, and I really truly am in this
- 1:10:14because I want to see a decentralized hive mind build.
- 1:10:17I believe in human freedom. I think it's incredibly
- 1:10:19important. Yeah.
- 1:10:20But I also love the game of investing, right.
- 1:10:21Like I find this extremely fun And the reality is, you know the
- 1:10:26bigger the fun size, the harder it is to get good returns, full
- 1:10:30stop. And you know I look at big funds
- 1:10:32and I'm not saying there's not a role for obviously it's great
- 1:10:34like if you want to be a growth investor like more power to you.
- 1:10:37But that's a whole different world.
- 1:10:39First of all. It requires like a lot more
- 1:10:40modeling and diligence and all the stuff, which is just like
- 1:10:43that's a different personality set.
- 1:10:44Now you're more of like a Wall Street guy, which is great.
- 1:10:46And I'm, you know, there are people for him.
- 1:10:47That's really fun. But what I love is cap,
- 1:10:51downside, uncapped upside man. That is such an incredible thing
- 1:10:55in the universe, right? And you know, I see a lot of
- 1:10:59funds. They start getting super huge,
- 1:11:01right? You get a billion dollars under
- 1:11:02management or $2 billion like I, you know, you can't convince me
- 1:11:05these guys aren't just like collecting fees at that point to
- 1:11:07me. I'm not interested in that,
- 1:11:09right. Like I love because if you get
- 1:11:11to kind of be a bit more of a cowboy, right, and just go out
- 1:11:13there and play the YC type game a little bit more, you can have
- 1:11:16uncapped rewards. Frankly.
- 1:11:17It's just more interesting. Yeah.
- 1:11:18To spend time with a lot more kind of like out there visionary
- 1:11:22thinkers, many of whom are not going to work.
- 1:11:24But that's OK because some will and and you know, one approach
- 1:11:27I've taken, sorry, I guess and as you guys can hear that the,
- 1:11:30the, the beauties of life in the city is, you know, I've taken
- 1:11:33the approach which is also very different in my own funds, which
- 1:11:35is, you know, I've recommitted half of my management fees
- 1:11:38always back into my funds. So I'm always, you know, one of
- 1:11:40my largest LP's. And to me part of that is one, I
- 1:11:44think the stuff's going to work. So I want the upside.
- 1:11:46But two, I I never want to get in that game of just like doing
- 1:11:52a job, to do a job and collect fees.
- 1:11:54Like, I find that extremely, like, just not interesting.
- 1:11:57I think that, you know, just like anything like your point
- 1:12:00about being tethered to reality, if you're good at this, you
- 1:12:02should really, really see the upside.
- 1:12:04And if you're not, probably should be something else.
- 1:12:06Yeah, there's two. Huge themes that you you relate
- 1:12:09on and I've always appreciated our conversations about this
- 1:12:11stuff is caps downside and unlimited upside in the sense
- 1:12:15of, you know there's this reality of I was joking around
- 1:12:18like the only thing scarcer than Bitcoin is Bitcoin talent OR
- 1:12:20people building. And so you kind of like limit
- 1:12:22the downside from acquisition or Aqua higher in the builders of
- 1:12:25this. So it has a different return
- 1:12:27profile or 0 profile than traditional like tech where
- 1:12:29everybody's building on if it goes, it's zero.
- 1:12:31Yeah. But then also I come from like
- 1:12:35well, I love like allocating and looking at things from an
- 1:12:37opportunistic perspective. I love being in like the like
- 1:12:39building with like your hands and seeing the market and the
- 1:12:42feedbacks. And it's just seen the reality.
- 1:12:45I've been on so many firms across the ecosystem whether
- 1:12:47it's, you know, we work again being that pinnacle all the way
- 1:12:49into the Bitcoin landscape where too much money literally just
- 1:12:52kills. And I fundamentally believe in
- 1:12:55it's part of the ethos that we've lived here at on ramp.
- 1:12:57It's like constrains breed creativity.
- 1:12:59And so if you inherently bring those in, then you start to
- 1:13:01really be very resourceful and how you think about your time.
- 1:13:05And we let's start to look at it like what better use of our time
- 1:13:07is it to go spend a bunch of money on marketing or have
- 1:13:09podcasts like this and we have all this kind of like learn
- 1:13:12information to be able to you know provide and bring people
- 1:13:15like yourself on that are experts in their own rights to
- 1:13:17give to the market. And that helps build confidence
- 1:13:19and trust in what we're doing. And effectively long term our
- 1:13:22vision is that if we educate the market then we'll long term you
- 1:13:25know provide services because where else would you get the
- 1:13:26service security learning from those individuals.
- 1:13:29And so just seeing that when you think about large funds and the
- 1:13:33allocation when you go and give somebody a bunch of capital and
- 1:13:36now you just like inherently it's almost like a, it's almost
- 1:13:39like a a rope and you're kind of like here you know just like it
- 1:13:42just starts getting, you get it's real dangerous on how you
- 1:13:45can hang yourself because you're effectively out.
- 1:13:47And it's almost that false signal with that amount of
- 1:13:49capital to what you're doing. And it gives you like it just it
- 1:13:54basically untightens the fidelity of like what you're
- 1:13:59doing and is it returning. And because the money has always
- 1:14:02been that benchmark when you put it on the scoreboard, so you
- 1:14:04just continue to do the thing versus actually going back to
- 1:14:07producing the value. And so I think there's just
- 1:14:10really something like really profound in the constraints and
- 1:14:12doing it. And then I think coupled with
- 1:14:14all the tools that we're having, it's just the reality is you
- 1:14:16don't need that amount of capital.
- 1:14:17So to be able to like allocate in that respect and then see
- 1:14:20that return profile with the downside is I think it's like
- 1:14:22the future of how capital allocation would be.
- 1:14:25I I I couldn't agree more and to be clear, like I'm not saying
- 1:14:28there there isn't a place for you know for big money and late
- 1:14:31stage investing purely for like deep tech and stuff like that.
- 1:14:33But I agree with I, I, dude, like, if you can't get an MVP
- 1:14:36out the door, you know, before we even chat, like, they're
- 1:14:40probably not the right builder. Because I see people that ship
- 1:14:41super fast or constantly experimenting now, especially
- 1:14:44with, you know, Copilot and Revel and all these tools.
- 1:14:46It's like, you know, come on dude, like and so a little bit
- 1:14:50of capital can allow people to quit their jobs, hire a few
- 1:14:52folks, maybe spend a little bit on, you know, some experiments
- 1:14:55and whatnot. And that's cool.
- 1:14:56But, like, I I definitely believe that there's also going
- 1:14:59to be, you know, I think there's many, like I said, I love
- 1:15:02casting bats. There's many ways we can win.
- 1:15:03I hope we get some of these like, you know, crazy you know,
- 1:15:06companies that 10X or 100X to fund.
- 1:15:08But to your point, there's also in addition to the aquire point,
- 1:15:11which is good one and that's absolutely true.
- 1:15:12The talent is scarce. That will be huge in anyway.
- 1:15:15But you know a lot of these companies maybe they only raise
- 1:15:18one round, maybe 2 rounds of financing ever and maybe you
- 1:15:22know they go a long time, maybe it's 10 years.
- 1:15:24And at some point obviously if the liquidity for the LP's and
- 1:15:26there might be some creative things around that.
- 1:15:27By the way, I'm also interested in, you know, maybe one day we
- 1:15:29have more of a Bitcoin native stock market, maybe comes up in
- 1:15:31El Salvador or somewhere else, you know, that could be
- 1:15:35interesting as well. But I do think that or maybe
- 1:15:38there's like you know, kind of like exit to the investors, the
- 1:15:41community or maybe you eventually get a dividend.
- 1:15:42Like there's a lot of different ways these things could go.
- 1:15:44But if as an example, you invest in another company I've invest
- 1:15:49in, it's kind of this is sort of an out there 1 Lightning network
- 1:15:52plus. It's just like a dude in a
- 1:15:53website, right. He's got a small team with him
- 1:15:55now, but you know, because he was early and got a great
- 1:16:00network effect, like I mean they own the vast majority of market
- 1:16:05share for all Lightning channels opened and you know, basically
- 1:16:11like they have two different products.
- 1:16:12One is like a pool, but basically channels open that
- 1:16:14that's the the metric that matters.
- 1:16:16And they've opened like I don't know 10X more than anyone else
- 1:16:19in the market. And it's just like a dude and
- 1:16:21like you know, I look at him and you know he's a really smart
- 1:16:24builder and you could use a little bit more capital, a
- 1:16:26little bit more team. He's moving kind of slowly, but
- 1:16:28like he's starting General Ave. and he's got the network effect
- 1:16:33and he doesn't need that much money.
- 1:16:36And I look about this and I'm like maybe this one takes 8910
- 1:16:39years, but like could that be, you know, $100 million company
- 1:16:42for sure? Could that be a Unicorn?
- 1:16:44Sure could. And you know, you get in, you
- 1:16:47know, whatever 4 mil post or something very small and all of
- 1:16:50a sudden, you know some of these like deals that don't go
- 1:16:53gangbusters but they're very capital efficient.
- 1:16:57You know, those could be really good outcomes for the funds as
- 1:16:59well. The other thing that's very
- 1:17:00interesting that I think I was just chatting with some of my
- 1:17:03LP's about or sharing with them in an update is I think
- 1:17:06something a lot of other people will talk about is most of these
- 1:17:08Bitcoin companies, certainly most of My Portfolio, keeps a
- 1:17:11decent chunk of their treasury in BTC.
- 1:17:14Additionally, a lot of the revenues are in BTC and SAT's,
- 1:17:17right? And so if you keep that in there
- 1:17:19and everything happens as we think it's going to happen
- 1:17:21directionally, Bitcoin goes up over time.
- 1:17:24You know, some of these companies may have infinite
- 1:17:25runway. Like, they just may not need to
- 1:17:27raise again, right? Like if you keep your your money
- 1:17:29in Bitcoin or a decent chunk of it, Bitcoin goes up.
- 1:17:32Like maybe you raise one round and then Bitcoin price
- 1:17:35appreciation is enough that you can keep growing as if you had
- 1:17:37raised further growth rounds. All that to say, there's, I'm
- 1:17:40not saying there's not a reason you know there.
- 1:17:42There's certainly cases where it will help to raise more money.
- 1:17:44But I think people are going to be surprised at some of these
- 1:17:47like raise one, precede maybe a seed round and like ten years
- 1:17:50later exit for a billion dollars and it's just a better.
- 1:17:53Tether into reality with the cap table, right, when you think
- 1:17:55from an equity perspective, it's how you get in trouble.
- 1:17:57When it's messed up in the misaligned incentives versus
- 1:17:59owning more of the company. You are able to like actually
- 1:18:02think from a long term perspective versus like how do I
- 1:18:05get out of this position because I kind of screwed up early on
- 1:18:08totally. Yep, Bitcoin helps align.
- 1:18:11Incentives. And it brings rationality back
- 1:18:14to markets. It's a bit, it's a beautiful
- 1:18:15thing, boys. I'm into it.
- 1:18:18Well. I think, I think this is a good
- 1:18:20spot to wrap. Max, thank you so much for
- 1:18:23coming on again. It was a fascinating
- 1:18:24conversation as always and hope to do it again soon.
- 1:18:27Yeah, hopefully we can make this a.
- 1:18:28Regular occurrence, we had a tight, tight rip with some other
- 1:18:31things coming up. But yeah, Max, we always enjoy
- 1:18:34you coming on and it's always a great conversation.
- 1:18:36I think we'll see the feedback from some of some of the folks
- 1:18:38and how many emojis we get. But yeah, thanks for coming on
- 1:18:41taking time likewise. Guys, well, it's super fun.
- 1:18:44Appreciate you having me on. And yeah, let's do it again.
- 1:18:47All right. See you.
- 1:18:48Guys, a couple weeks.