Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D News-The Accessible Cook Book Episode
Transcript
- 0:07From the kitchen of the cabin. It's the Five Games for Doomsday News with
- 0:11Ben and Steve. It's beautiful day, Steve look at it for lovely.
- 0:21It's too bad the listeners can't see it. We sat in the middle of
- 0:25Berlin, the city that is being slowly killed by the Conservative government stave.
- 0:31So what just happened to you? Ben? So So for the listeners,
- 0:34Berlin has a unique thing in Germany. It's just only Berlin, yeah,
- 0:39apparently. So it's called a speight couff. And what it is is for
- 0:43me, like openly for the British, for the British listeners, it's an
- 0:46off license. But they're kind of more than off license. For the New
- 0:49Yorkers like me, it's a bodega. Yeah, but I assume they're more
- 0:52than that. They're kind of you can't drink it, kind of cheap pubs,
- 0:56right. So they sell sweets and they sell crisps, and they sell
- 0:59a lot of alcohol, and they are the sort of cultural center of Germany
- 1:03in many ways. And I just found out that the Conservative government had bought
- 1:10a law. So these spatis, the spake cows, they put tables outside
- 1:15and I've just discovered that the Conservative mayor has made a law that you can
- 1:22no longer drink alcohol as a Spati. Now we do have German listeners and
- 1:26they're probably gonna correct us on the finer points of Hope, I hope I'm
- 1:30wrong some fucking German, some German bloke just fucking very rudely told bollocked you.
- 1:37Is that how you say it? Bollocked you? I mean I still
- 1:40see people drinking and spetis at night, so maybe the ordnungs Armed is only
- 1:44patrolling in the daytime. Well, the thing is as well. What's fascinating
- 1:47about this is that the European Championships are coming up, and Spatis make a
- 1:51lot of money at the European Championships because they put screens up and then people
- 1:55sit there and watch. If they can't do that, if I was a
- 1:57spaty owner, I would be living. Are you Are you concerned for the
- 2:00plate of the working class spat owners or are you concerned for the availability of
- 2:07low cost beer you see everywhere in the city. You see this is your
- 2:10problem state. I'm just asking this is your problems asking questions always you always
- 2:15draw false mutual exclusivities, right, I can I can be concerned for both
- 2:21at the same time and they don't contradict each other. What are you concerned
- 2:23for? More? Let's say that you have ten concern points, okay,
- 2:28and you have to allocate them between these two concerns. Can I use decimals?
- 2:30Is it five and five based? Can I use decimals? Sure?
- 2:35Nine point nine to nine recurring. I'm more concerned about my cheap booze and
- 2:38I've got a little bit of a point zero one that's actually more than I
- 2:44expected, exactly to you, I can't do anyone just because I don't know
- 2:46enough about mass math math mass exactly. So this is our first ever emergency
- 2:53podcast episode. By the way, is it an emergency podcast episodes? Because
- 2:57they've called a general election in the US? Hell, so they have on
- 3:00on Independence Day, on the on my country's birthday. And by the way,
- 3:04I believe there's a very good chance I will be reporting live from London
- 3:08for the election results. Oh yeah, you'll be in London. That's very
- 3:12exciting. Potentially, Yes, I'll be in America, which is also exciting.
- 3:15On Independence Day. On Independence Study, we should we should do a
- 3:19London Nevada live show. We should, we should some kind. I mean,
- 3:23we won't because you don't tend to want to organize these sorts of things.
- 3:27But what a thrill would it be for the listeners if you could?
- 3:29Absolutely so live stream? Are you still doing the Wednesday live stream from the
- 3:31US? What day is July the fourth? I don't know. I very
- 3:36much died. I'll be I'll be out at the nug watching the fireworks only
- 3:38fourth. Well, I mean we can do a live stream though, Okay,
- 3:43So anyway, we're here for reasons other than current phase. This is
- 3:47the news show, but we're not. The rest is politics stafe, So
- 3:51we're here to well, you don't you don't want to talk about the Conservative
- 3:54Party's chances against the the You can do this the labor, the labor under
- 4:00cure Starmer. Hey, good stuff, Look at you. He's gonna map
- 4:03the floor with those Tories, isn't he. Well, let's hope. So
- 4:05what about the live dems? Live dems are just irrelevant now, aren't they.
- 4:08Yeah, they're crap. They shouldn't have gone into coalition with the tourists.
- 4:11Absolutely not. I agree with you there anyway. So had a bit
- 4:14of a flurry in the past two days. Steve of newbackers. We had
- 4:17three new backers in the last in the last two days. And this is
- 4:23my least favorite part of the podcast. Why because my incredible nickname conferring skills
- 4:31have been have been eschewed in favor of your populist rubbish. Well, it's
- 4:38also a difficult part of the show for me because I feel like I have
- 4:41a reputation to look up to. Now, well, I'm sort of like
- 4:43Susan Sontag and you're kind of like Dan Brown, aren't you on the nickname
- 4:46front. I don't get it because you're just populous. There's no logical there's
- 4:53nothing rationalization. There's nothing to do with nicknames that they may or mean out
- 4:57of come. No, no, no, no, no, it's just
- 4:59you know, you're like serrated blade. Well connection does that have to anything?
- 5:02Nothing? I just thought it sounded cool. I think it's people just
- 5:05go, oh it's amazing. Yeah, it's Isn't that what matters if they
- 5:09enjoy the nickname that they get. Oh yeah, no, you should.
- 5:13It should be rationally logically linked. But anyway, so are you ready?
- 5:16Yep? So first one is Aspien, LP Aspire and LP. Yeah,
- 5:28let's do uh Aspiorn, jagged Little pill LP. So just just to remind
- 5:36the people who are getting nicknames, you could join the discord. How did
- 5:40they join the discord stuf? Well, you probably just google it at this
- 5:44point or ask shat gpt how to do it, or if you feel like,
- 5:46if you're trade, if you're a trad Internet user, go to five
- 5:50G for d dot com and click the pinned post at the top of the
- 5:54page. You have to click the post. You click the invite link in
- 5:57the post. In the post, you have to click the post in the
- 6:00invite link. So first of all five D three do dot com, then
- 6:02click the post, then click the invite link to the discord, and then
- 6:06then you're in and you're gonna be with me ben Asburn, famed board game
- 6:11designer, Isaac shalev CD Hunter, and all of our other friends. Yes,
- 6:15that's aspion Jack middle Pilp. Then we have Eric sund Eric machete man
- 6:21Son. What link does that have? It's just cool Eric, It's just
- 6:26cool man. What link do you need? Like, he's obviously a machete
- 6:30man. I mean, look at him. She's saying that upstage is serrated
- 6:33Blaze, not at all they're all equivalent. All right, Then we have
- 6:36Enrich Melen, Enrik Bulletproof, Melen. I think you're jumping the shak here,
- 6:44because I think you just are great nicknames. And you said three four.
- 6:47You said there were three. Yeah, three in the last two days,
- 6:50but four over the months. Yeah, but I only came up with
- 6:53three in advance. So we have Yakov Petrovitch, Gold, Yakin, Yaka
- 7:00of smear enough, Petro Petra whatever, Gold whatever. Hey, you're very
- 7:04good at this. I think listeners. I think listeners, you should tell
- 7:08Steve that he's jumped the shark. He is like Fonsie and Happy Days.
- 7:12Anyways, So let's see how many of them put their nicknames in quotes when
- 7:15they joined the discord. How many? How do you feel about the ancillary
- 7:18board game world, Steve? The ancillary board game world? Yeah, so
- 7:21you know, you've got board games, which is part of the board game
- 7:24world. I'm part of you got the Yeah, but like there's a whole
- 7:28market of things connected to board games but not board games. Yeah, it's
- 7:30sort of like the meta board game world. How do you feel about cookbooks
- 7:34based on ticket to Ride the board game metaverse? There is not a ticket
- 7:39to Ride cook There is a ticket to ride cookbook. And not only that,
- 7:41Steve, I've spoken to the writer. Oh so I'm very excited on
- 7:48the new show to be joined by Casey Vogelman all the way from Ulysses Press
- 7:54to talk about the new revolution in culinary publishing with a Ticket to Ride cook
- 8:00Book. But first of all, you'll from Ulysses Publications, Can you give
- 8:05us a bit of background on who they are, what they do, that
- 8:07sort of stuff. Good thing. So I am the VP and publisher at
- 8:13Ulysses Press and we are a indie book publisher based out of Brooklyn, New
- 8:18York, and Berkeley, California. And we have a very interesting story in
- 8:22that we started over forty years ago as a travel book publisher and sort of
- 8:28over time, as the nature of travel and travel publishing changed, so did
- 8:33Ulysses Press. And we started publishing in all sorts of different areas, particularly
- 8:39focusing on unique, oftentimes rather niche subject areas. And that's how we kind
- 8:46of started publishing into pop culture and pretty recently what some people might describe as
- 8:50a nerd culture, and so we have been publishing kind of books all across
- 8:58nonfiction, cookbook, gift books, practical sort of lifestyle books, and that's
- 9:05kind of the Ulysses Press story. And that's why I'm so excited today to
- 9:09talk about our official pop culture cookbook that's based off of board games. An
- 9:16interesting combination, but that's exactly what Ulysses Pressed does. We're all about kind
- 9:20of finding these really unique ideas and kind of pulling them together. And so
- 9:24I hear the word banded around a lot, and I'm not entirely I'm entirely
- 9:28sure I understand quite what it means when you say you're an indie publisher.
- 9:31What does that mean exactly? Yeah, So that means that we kind of
- 9:37operate out of the Big five. So in a kind of traditional book publishing,
- 9:41there are the big five publishing companies which are pretty recognizable to most people.
- 9:50Are talking about Penguin, Random House, Hashet, Harpercollin, Simon and
- 9:54Schuster and McMillan, and those are kind of the big players in the game.
- 9:58They publish a lot of everybody's favorite books and the ones that are really
- 10:01big hits. But that's not to discount there's the huge size of indie publishing,
- 10:07and those are smaller publishers and these can be very small. We're talking
- 10:11like one or two people to you know, maybe fifty to one hundred people
- 10:16that are publishing kind of outside of those big corporations and are doing sometimes very
- 10:22specific books, sometimes literary fictions that kind of ranges, you know, spans
- 10:26the gamut of all sorts of different types of genre. But I would say
- 10:30like the best indicator of being an indie publisher is kind of being outside those
- 10:33big five publishers. And what I think about, you know, society has
- 10:39become more homogenized, the world we live has become more homogenized, and when
- 10:43I think about things like tech, you there are very there are very few,
- 10:48very big companies that take a lot of the bandwidth. And I guess
- 10:50if you have a big five in publishing, that's a similar thing. How
- 10:54do you ensure that people know who you are, know what you are doing,
- 11:00and are able to get hold of your books. That's really different from
- 11:05independent publisher to independent publisher. What we do at Ulysses Presses, and I
- 11:09think is something that probably many indie publishers do, is we really focus on
- 11:16the audience and the content of our books. So while some of the big
- 11:18five publishers certainly not all, and I won't speak to all their imprints,
- 11:22but they're looking for the widest audience possible, kind of the broadest book they
- 11:28can sell. Because they're investing so much money, they've got kind of those
- 11:33big, big advances, big big marketing budgets that indie publishers frankly just don't
- 11:37have. We're looking specifically at targeted audiences, groups of people that we think
- 11:43that we can get a more specific topic interest and kind of hone in on
- 11:48that in order to kind of the content itself really focus on what those readers
- 11:54are interested in. So some of our authors have some you know, larger
- 11:58platforms, podcast or newsletters that are oftentimes very specific speaking to their specific audiences.
- 12:05And then a lot of time our authors are just very very talented writers
- 12:09who we work with to kind of hone their idea, to find that topic
- 12:13and really speak to what people are looking for in those communities. And so
- 12:20how then, I've been I've been sort of looking through your website and it's
- 12:22it's very interesting, but how did you get the idea to do cookbooks based
- 12:28on board games? It's been a journey, certainly, it's not necessarily the
- 12:33most obvious kind of first thought when you're like, oh, what what type
- 12:37of nonfiction kind of pop cultury book could you do around a board game.
- 12:43But we've been recently seeing and publishing in the last i'd say probably five years,
- 12:50this move to do sort of pop culture infused everything, particularly really nostalgic.
- 12:58And this can comes in different ways. It's like there's like a you
- 13:03know night they have before Christmas Tarot Deck, like taking these like very very
- 13:07like popular brands and that have these big fan bases and applying them to different
- 13:13book products, And one of the big ones is cookbooks. We saw a
- 13:18lot of official and unofficial stuff happening in the market, and when I started
- 13:24talking with the teams at Ticket to Ride in Katan, the cookbook kind of
- 13:30really just came naturally out of what was happening in the market, and honestly,
- 13:35just it felt right when we started talking about these projects. We had
- 13:37so many ideas right out of that. And you can kind of see it
- 13:43once you actually take a look at the books, like why why that kind
- 13:46of works? It's a really natural extension of the brand. I mean,
- 13:50I don't know about you, but when I'm playing board games, I am
- 13:52eating quite a lot of foods. It's really a natural kind of synergy there.
- 14:00And so why was it? I mean, I guess the answer to
- 14:03this is quite obvious, but I'd like it from your perspective. You've picked
- 14:07Ticket to Ride in Katan, two massive franchises, very very established with within
- 14:13the board game world. Was it? Was it simply that brand recognition that
- 14:16made you think that these would be good titles to base a ancillary project on.
- 14:22Yeah, I mean they have huge brand name recognition. I mean that
- 14:26everything from just you know, the fonts, like if you're you know,
- 14:31if you are like us and you love board games, it's very easy to
- 14:33recognize these books, their art, their their their titles. But you know,
- 14:41while I was talking to the team as well, I mean we did
- 14:45talk about other board games because I worked with Asthmadi Entertainment, who licenses a
- 14:48lot of different board games from different creators, and these were the two that
- 14:52really just made the most sense. Not only are they kind of two major
- 14:56players in the board game space, but there are some titles that truly aren't
- 15:01going to lend themselves to food, even if you are playing them and have
- 15:05snacks nearby. They just kind of conceptually don't don't work as much. And
- 15:09you know, speaking as a huge fan myself, these are two of my
- 15:13favorite board games. So I've certainly shifted the conversation towards these two, uh
- 15:20naturally, just just based on my own love of them. And so how
- 15:24does a book like the Ticket to Ride cookbook like the Katan Cookbook come together?
- 15:28Then, once you've signed off with the partners and you've decided this is
- 15:31the project we're going to push forward with, how does how do the recipes
- 15:35happen? How does the project take off? So we work pretty closely with
- 15:41the team at Asmidi, who works closely with the studios at Ticket to Ride
- 15:46and Katan. They're very very much in tandem, and we started off really
- 15:50just outlining the concepts, you know, trying to hammer out what made sense
- 15:54for the books. And for both books, we developed a recipe list that
- 15:58and a kind of structure and outline those were. We worked with Asmindi and
- 16:03the studios to get those approved, and then after that we went out and
- 16:07we talked with recipe developers and testers and photographers and kind of brought together sort
- 16:12of like a whole team and like a vendors style team of excellent people to
- 16:19kind of pull the whole book together. We had writers, we had photographers,
- 16:23we had recipe developers, we had editors and proofreaders and production designers kind
- 16:30of all come together. So many people touch these books and sort of piece
- 16:34them together and then worked with the studios of course to make sure it all
- 16:41aligned with the brand, the mission, and the aesthetic and so what can
- 16:47we find in the Tickets to Ride cookbook and also how would that appeal to
- 16:51fans of the game. The Ticket to Ride Cookbook is really fun because we
- 16:56have designed the game sort of around the destinations and so as all players know,
- 17:02in order to complete your destination tickets, you need to complete a series
- 17:04of routes, and we've kind of used that sort of turn of the century
- 17:10charm to create dining car menus, if you will, that's sort of are
- 17:15thematic around the different cities that you pass through. And this is this is
- 17:18really all focused on the North American edition of the game. So you know,
- 17:25we've got like we have a dining car menu for like the New England
- 17:30Flyer, which goes through Boston and New York, and we have New England
- 17:33clam chowder and lobster roles and sort of things that are inspired by those regions.
- 17:40So that's and we've kind of separated them into a series of destination tickets
- 17:44different parts of the country. And it was so so fun to kind of
- 17:47do a little bit of research, look into kind of what are the different
- 17:49things that people in these areas are proud of, regional specialties or just using
- 17:56some of the ingredients that could be found in those places. And so far
- 18:00be it from me to a tea to a terrible cliche, but I'm not
- 18:04the world's greatest cook. Is there going to be something in this book for
- 18:08me that I can manage? Oh? Certainly, I mean, we have
- 18:14them all separated in all the dining car menus kind of start with like a
- 18:18appetizer, a sort of main course aside, a dessert, and a cocktail
- 18:23at the end. And so certainly, if you're afraid of cooking altogether,
- 18:27the cocktails are by far the easiest, at least in my opinion, but
- 18:32there are plenty of easy recipes that are, you know, required just a
- 18:37lot less work than say, our New York cheesecake. I'm personally a awful
- 18:41baker, so I probably would avoid that one. But there's in our first
- 18:48first dining car menu there's mac and cheese, which I'm pretty sure anybody could
- 18:52try their hand at. And I'm just looking at the page now and it
- 18:55says possum pie. I assume that's a dessert, not a a pie with
- 19:00rodents in it. It is definitely a delicious dessert and it's a true,
- 19:06true like Americana. To me, it's an it's it's a I think pretty
- 19:11popular in Arkansas in particular, although I'm sure many other places in the region.
- 19:17And it's really about the different layers I believe. I'm sure it's in
- 19:22the headnote, but I think it's about playing possum, which is like about
- 19:26how the different layers are hiding. There's many layers in this pie, so
- 19:30definitely no rodents in it, but I think a lot of crunchy nuts and
- 19:34lipped cream and chocolate. It's delicious, and so I'm gonna put you on
- 19:38the spot here. So I want a favorite recipe from the Ticket to Ride
- 19:45book and a favorite recipe from the Catan book for you for for a ticket
- 19:49to Ride. I actually recently made the half smoked Sausage bites, which are
- 19:57inspired by the half smokes that you can find in Washington, d C.
- 20:03And those are a really really excellent appetizer. I unfortunately couldn't get my hands
- 20:08on true half smokes, and I used a different smoked sausage there. So
- 20:11there are variations if you can't get quite the regional specialty. But it was
- 20:17a really really good appetizer and I served it at a party that I was
- 20:23going to, so really really, really delicious kind of wrapped in a puff
- 20:29pastry. For the Katan Cookbook, there are so many really really fun recipes
- 20:37in that one. And let me think, oh, you know I made
- 20:41recently I propped up in a book because I was looking for a pretty hearty
- 20:48comfort food dish. I'm based in New York and recently the weather has been
- 20:52kind of dreary, and so I made a sort of traditional shepherd's pie,
- 20:56which kind of gives give you that feeling of that kind of Katan tavern esque
- 21:02feel we were going for in that book. And you know a bit of
- 21:06a link to that world card that although sheep, you continually look at it
- 21:10in the books, So that one is really good as well excellent. So
- 21:14if you could give me the vital statistics, because I think the Ticket to
- 21:18Ride is on pre old currently and the Katan book is already When can we
- 21:21get them? How much do they cost? All of that good stuff.
- 21:23The Ticket to Ride book just came out, so you should be able to
- 21:27get the book, both Ticket to Ride the Official Cookbook and Katan the Official
- 21:32Cookbook pretty much anywhere books are sold. That includes you know, your independent
- 21:37bookseller. If they don't have it on the shelves, they absolutely can order
- 21:40it for you. Amazon, Barnes and Noble, depending on where you're based,
- 21:45Indigo, Waterstones, all those places will be able to stock the book
- 21:48get it to you if it's not already on the shelves. Brilliant. Well,
- 21:52Casey Vogelman, thank you very much for your time. Thank you.
- 21:56This is so fun. I appreciate it now. So I'm delighted on the
- 22:03news show to have Michael heron here, the former current blogger of meple Like
- 22:08Us and author of a new book, tabletop game Accessibility. So first of
- 22:15all, Michael, can you tell us about meeople like Us. This is
- 22:18a blog that I've seen around for a while, and it says on the
- 22:22website that it's on the hiatus at the moment, but I think it deals
- 22:26with what the book is a sort of more formalization of I guess, yeah,
- 22:33I mean that's exactly what it is. Meeple Like Us is basically for
- 22:37a long time. It's been my research annotations. Years and years ago.
- 22:44When I first started to get into board games, I saw this sort of
- 22:48gradually blooming collection of games. I sort of felt like I should be doing
- 22:52something, I should be doing something productive with it, rather than just having
- 22:57fun with it. So I decided to work to the topic of accessibility,
- 23:02which had been sort of for years my research area, and I thought,
- 23:07I look at maybe three or four of them, I'll maybe write a paper
- 23:10on it, and then I'll never think about it again. And it turned
- 23:12out that led to what was like a maybe a six seven year not so
- 23:17much research interest but research obsession. And maybe like Us was a sense where
- 23:22I was recording all the observations from the research work I was doing, and
- 23:27so, can you give us a bit of your background, sort of what
- 23:32your research focus is, what you trained in, all of that sort of
- 23:36good stuff. Sure, so my research focus is varied. Recently, I
- 23:44had I write what was called a research plan or a research outline or such,
- 23:48and what they really like you to do is put together like a neat
- 23:52narrative of what your research work has been. And essentially, the first thing
- 23:56I said and the thing I wrote was that these things an attempt to put
- 24:00an anauthentically neat narrative onto a messy life. So my research is sort of
- 24:06bounced from place to place over the years, but the thing that's probably the
- 24:10center of gravity of it is the topic of accessibility. Back in two thousand
- 24:15and eight, I did my PhD at the University of Dundee and the PhD
- 24:19was Technology to help an aging workforce, and what that eventually sort of revolved
- 24:26into was the topic of accessibility for an older workforce. And I, honestly
- 24:32at the time, had no interest at all in the topic of accessibility.
- 24:36I had been teaching in a university, but I didn't have a PhD,
- 24:40and you kind of need a PhD to teach in the kind of places I
- 24:42want to be teaching. So I thought, well, there's this PhD they're
- 24:47recruiting for somebody. I'll apply for that, and I did, and they
- 24:52were happy enough with what I was planning to do, so they offered it
- 24:55to me, but there was no sort of deep concern about the topic accessibility.
- 25:00That sort of came afterwards, And it came afterwards after my PhD supervisor
- 25:04said to me, but my sort of technical background was software engineering, and
- 25:10what he said was, if it's difficult to make an interesting program, just
- 25:12imagine how much more complicated it is to make an interesting program everybody can use.
- 25:18And that was sort of the trigger for me to really start digging into
- 25:22this as a topic. But from my PhD, which was just accessibility,
- 25:26I then sort of looked at the accessibility of video games, and then over
- 25:30time that sort of drifted into people like us, which is obviously the accessibility
- 25:33of board games. So it's mostly sort of just following the path of interest
- 25:40in some of these problem domains. So I'm one of these people who I'm
- 25:45sure all computers get together every year and they basically decide who they're going to
- 25:53target for their particular approbrium each year, and I'm one of these people who
- 25:56comes up every year. It's clear computers hey to me. But what I've
- 26:00noticed is that accessibility for someone like me, who's not a natural techie,
- 26:07has clearly been a focus over the last sort of ten to fifteen years,
- 26:11right, I remember when I first started podcasting ten over ten years ago.
- 26:18Now, the idea of being able to build your own website you had to
- 26:22be able to code, and now basically it's drag and drop, right,
- 26:26And so have you seen is the accessibility question just a product of basically wider
- 26:37distribution of it? I think that's an insightful observation because a lot of the
- 26:45things that we sort of consider to be accessibility, as in people who work
- 26:48in accessibility, we consider these to be sort of our achievements. Over time,
- 26:53they just sort of merrige into the background as just good design. Say
- 27:00as well, I wouldn't necessarily think that they're singling you out. As far
- 27:03as computers go, I think they're singling Oh no, I'm convinced. I'm
- 27:06convinced my computer is has has some sort of singular malice against me. I'm
- 27:11convinced of it. It's just, you know, I talk about this one
- 27:14messions quite a lot that you know, once upon a time we used to
- 27:17talk about user friendliness, and now we sort of mostly talk about user hostile
- 27:22design. You know, you can't go to a website these days without four
- 27:25or five things that you have to shut down. No, No, I
- 27:27don't want your notifications. I don't want to sign up to your mailing list.
- 27:30I'm fine with cookies. There's so much that you have to do in
- 27:33order. Do you know what I don't want to do? Do you know
- 27:34what I don't want to do? Michael? I feel my blood pleasure writing.
- 27:38I don't want to rate every bloody thing. I don't want to give
- 27:42every bloody thing a bloody rating. I bought something, I gave you my
- 27:47money, our transaction is over. I don't want to bloody write it,
- 27:52especially when you just downeloader thing and says, would you consider giving us five
- 27:55stars? No, I've never bloody used it. No, I wouldn't absolutely,
- 28:00Yeah, but yeah, I mean this idea is are like accessibility sort
- 28:03of blending into the background as good design is sort of one of the cores
- 28:07of the way in which a lot of us now talk about accessibility, which
- 28:11is, while people with disabilities are obviously the largest and most important beneficiaries of
- 28:18accessibility, we all massively benefit from it, and as a result we sort
- 28:23of tend to adopt these these improvements as things that sort of are just as
- 28:27I say general design. You know, once upon a time audiobooks were called
- 28:32books on tape for the blind, but we're just audiobooks. You know.
- 28:36Predictive text on your phone was originally something to help people with physical impairments be
- 28:41able to communicate, but now it's just predictive text. A plague of modern
- 28:45technology. So these kinds of things, as things become more common, as
- 28:51become more used by wider ranges of people, accessibility tends to be something that
- 28:56gets focus but you can sort of see when you were here. Sort of
- 29:02video games, accessibility and video games. Over the past ten fifteen years or
- 29:06so, that has just exploded in importance to the point that if you forget
- 29:11to put subtitles in a game these days, you can expect like a series
- 29:14of articles in you know, Rock, Paper, Shotgun, Polygon, all
- 29:17these places saying, look at these clowns they didn't put subtitles in their game,
- 29:22and then go and behold, a few weeks later, subtitles will appear.
- 29:26But I mean, I mean, the thing is, it doesn't seem
- 29:27it doesn't seem to be look at these clowns. Where where the towne that
- 29:33I tend to see on the Internet is look at these evil people who are
- 29:37maliciously targeting people with disabilities, right, yeah, I mean it sort of
- 29:44depends on where you're looking. I guess I've tended to weadle water sources out
- 29:48of my Internet diet these days because I found for a long time the Internet
- 29:52was just making me sad. Yes, and so these kind of things,
- 30:00these these kind of accessibility things have become ubiquitous. And when I when I
- 30:03look at board games, so your book, so we'll get into your book.
- 30:07Now. This is called Tabletop Game Accessibility MEPAL Center design and there's a
- 30:12table of contents and after the introduction is the first thing that I think of
- 30:18that is a this is a standard of accessibility within board games and wasn't when
- 30:22I got into board games, and that is having an option for those who
- 30:27are color blind? Is this? I mean, how did how do you
- 30:33think this came about? That it is not even thought about now? That
- 30:37is it is just a standard in tabletop game graphic design. Well, I
- 30:45mean we still even see these days games that just don't take endo account because
- 30:49there is sort of like this this historical inertia of well, what are the
- 30:53colors that we use? For a board game, and you know, if
- 30:56you have four players, then for a long time the default was red,
- 31:00green, blue, and you know, yellow usually, and so people just
- 31:04sort of like adopt that as a standard, as in, well, I'm
- 31:08not going to think about it too much. It must be. If it's
- 31:11works for everybody else, it must work for me. But I think the
- 31:14thing that's really changed over the past few years is the extent to which people
- 31:18are willing to complain about inaccessibilities in their games, because I remember sort of
- 31:25ten years ago, even with video games, when somebody would say, oh,
- 31:27I can't play this because they're color because I'm color blind, the response
- 31:33would overwhelmingly be, well, you know, sorry, but not everything is
- 31:36for everybody, and we've sort of gotten past that. I think that in
- 31:41video games, but just because color blindness is so easily solved, as in
- 31:48it it's there's only one game I've ever seen that I would say color blindness
- 31:52is a challenge to solve, and that's Cigarda That every other game it's almost
- 31:59trivia to solve the problem of color blindness. And it's not even necessarily just
- 32:05changing colors. Sometimes it's just double coding things, providing information in multiple channels
- 32:09symbols and colors. Yeah, absolutely, you know, like for example,
- 32:14Colo Etto is a great example of this because it's a game about matching colors,
- 32:19but also those colors have texture backgrounds, so you can tell the difference
- 32:22even if you can't tell the difference in color because the backgrounds are different.
- 32:28So you know, it's just redundancy in providing information to people. And so
- 32:32how did the book come about? Then? So for maybe like US has
- 32:38been going for a fair while now, and there's maybe two hundred and thirty
- 32:44ish games that have been analyzed from the perspective of accessibility. And I went
- 32:50on hiatus a while ago because I kind of felt like I wasn't adding anything
- 32:53more to the discussion, like every new game was sort of a variation of
- 32:58a game that come before, and I just felt like this is sort of
- 33:01treading the same ground over and over again. But conversations I had with people
- 33:07made it clear that one of the things I would have liked to have done
- 33:10with the site, which was raised the sort of standards of expectation that people
- 33:15have on accessibility. It's not really possible to do with a sort of game
- 33:20by game focus, which is what people like us had, you know,
- 33:23it would look at Catan and go over all the accessibility issues. It would
- 33:27look at China Town, look over the accessibility issues and such. But if
- 33:31you want a big picture, if you want a wider lens, as in
- 33:36I just wanted to make a game that is accessible for people who are blind.
- 33:38I just want to make a game it's successible for people who have cognitive
- 33:42impairments. It wasn't really possible to use the site for that, and so
- 33:49the book is essentially taking the site, the insights of the site and sort
- 33:52of turning them inside out, so that rather than being based on this is
- 33:58what individual games are, it's about this is how you address accessibility in particular
- 34:01categories. And so I'm looking at the table of contents here. It's interesting.
- 34:09So the one that stands out to me is because I guess the idea
- 34:14of accessibility is to make games available to as wide to as wide a group
- 34:21of people as possible, and yet there are always going to be there are
- 34:28always going to be challenges to that, And so can you go over what
- 34:32you talk about in the cognitive accessibility chapter, because I guess if people have
- 34:39learning issues, there are it's just inevitable that certain games of certain complexity are
- 34:45just never going to be accessible, right Well, I mean there's I think
- 34:51again this is like a very keen endsight as one of the issues are,
- 34:55and that you're never going to make something that's fully accessible for everybody. And
- 35:00one of the things that I've sort of argued in a whole range of venues
- 35:05is that you have to approach the development of accessibility and games very carefully because
- 35:09inaccessibility is where the fun comes from. You know, no game is fun
- 35:14if it doesn't have obstacles, and the key thing is sort of identifying which
- 35:19of those obstacles are core to the experience and which of those obstacles are there
- 35:24accidentally or as as a side effect of other design. So when we talk
- 35:29about, for example, cognitive accessibility, there are things like, let's look
- 35:34at Dungeons and Dragons as a very simple example. You know, you're let's
- 35:37say you're a tenth level wizard or whatever, casting a fireball out of a
- 35:42third level spell slot, which means that you're adds exomount of damage and whatever.
- 35:47Knowing that you're sort of adding you know, these kind of bonuses in
- 35:51you're adding in this kind of fire resistance versus fire immunity and all these different
- 35:57kinds of things is actually very cognitively comp likes to calculate. If you have,
- 36:01like maybe a roll where you're sort of rolling five six sided dice and
- 36:06six twelve sided dice, it's very difficult to sort of predict what the actual
- 36:10number the range of numbers are likely to be. So one of the really
- 36:15nice features in Dungeons and Dragons these days is it just lets you pick a
- 36:17number. You know, rather than doing one D eight damage, you can
- 36:22choose to do five damage. And that's an example of creating a cognitive accessibility
- 36:27in what's otherwise quite a challenging calculation. And these are the kind of things
- 36:32that when we talk about sort of making games cognitively accessible, that's what we're
- 36:37talking about. You know, instead of asking people to do complex arithmetic,
- 36:40maybe you just let them position things on a number line, instead of sort
- 36:45of having to calculate offsets, as in, you know, i've got ten
- 36:51troops, you've got eight troops. Therefore we roll a dice for each of
- 36:52them, and then we you know, we trade them off against each other.
- 36:55You do something like Chogun does which is you just throw it into a
- 36:59tube and then their number come out at the end. So you can do
- 37:02a lot of this translation of cognitively complex tasks into much simpler tasks, and
- 37:10that's the thing that raises the cognitive accessibility. But you are absolutely never going
- 37:15to get to the point that every game is going to be fully accessible for
- 37:19everybody. And so I'm by nature a sort of I'm a nature someone who
- 37:29sort of sees something and then instantly disagrees with him. It's just it's just
- 37:32the way. It's just the way I am. I'm one of those bloody
- 37:35minded sort of people. And so, while unquestionably accessibility is clearly to be
- 37:42desired, there are I sort of I like to think of opposing arguments to
- 37:49things that are established. And so is there a worry that a an over
- 37:55focus on accessibility, especially when we live in a society now where old games
- 38:00are being thought of as works of art as opposed to just leisure activities,
- 38:05that an over emphasis on accessibility might compromise the artistic endeavor within a design.
- 38:12I mean, I think an overfocus on accessibility would do exactly that, which
- 38:15is why AI like to stress that you're not every game is going to be
- 38:19accessible for everybody. And when I talk to companies about, you know,
- 38:23how do you make your games more accessible? What I often talk about is
- 38:25the idea of a dump start you get in Dungeons and Dragons. You know,
- 38:30if you're a warrior, you probably don't need a high charisma kind of
- 38:32thing, so you trade off your charisma for your strength. And I think
- 38:37in gaming, is particularly board gaming, you have to be sort of mindful
- 38:40of the strategic aspect of building an accessible game. One of my favorite examples
- 38:46is Scrabble, because scrabble without the complexity of the positioning of the tiles and
- 38:53the mathematics of scoring and be able to create multiple words from individual plays.
- 39:00I don't know what that game is, but it's not Scrabble, and it's
- 39:02not a game I particularly want to play. But that doesn't mean you can't
- 39:07make Scrabble more accessible in other categories, like larger text on the tiles,
- 39:13braille on the board, or sort of tattel markings on the board. So
- 39:17you probably don't want to try and make scrabble accessible for people with communication impairments
- 39:22because you're going to lose the heart of the game in doing that, but
- 39:27that doesn't mean again that there aren't excellent word games out there for people who
- 39:31do have communication impairments. So it's all a case of sort of respecting the
- 39:37heart of what the game is, that sort of intentional and accessibility I mentioned
- 39:42earlier, and then getting rid of the things that you think are safe to
- 39:46get rid of. And for all these things, you know, people need
- 39:50to make a judgment, as in, you might be able to make improvements,
- 39:54but they might not be improvements that you want to make because of ourtistic
- 40:00choice or financial consequences or such financial consequences in particular is something that's almost unique
- 40:06to board gaming and in sort of gaming accessibility, because let's say the solution
- 40:10to a problem is make bigger cards. Sure, but that also means bigger
- 40:15costs for printing. It means more costs for the paper. It means bigger
- 40:19boxes, which means you know, more creates to ship it in, which
- 40:22means greater shipping costs, which means fewer copies being sent. You know,
- 40:27there's a big chain of consequences to go with this, and especially in an
- 40:30industry with such a narrow margin. Yeah, it's a consideration, right,
- 40:35Yeah, So there is an extent to what you have to take into account.
- 40:38What is the sort of feasible return that comes from making accessibility improvements?
- 40:44But a lot of them are very, very cheap, and a lot of
- 40:45them have no impact on an artistic vision for how a game should be.
- 40:51But you know, everybody has to decide for themselves what accessible choices should be.
- 40:55But in order to do that, they need to know what the options
- 40:59are. And that's you know, where the book comes in. And so
- 41:02chapter six is interesting because I when I look at the type of contents,
- 41:07I see what it says, and I kind of I guess understand pretty much
- 41:14what all of them are except chapter six, which is emotional accessibility. What
- 41:19does that mean? So I take some credit or blame, It depends on
- 41:24your perspective for introducing this as an idea in accessibility. But basically, the
- 41:30way in which I communicate this to people is, have you ever played a
- 41:34game with a bad winner? Or have you ever played a game with a
- 41:37bad loser? And it's such a universal experience that almost everybody will put their
- 41:42hands up. And the fact that I embody both is every time I play
- 41:46Michael, every time, absolutely, And there are some games that are better
- 41:52designed as far as being mitigating those problems of how it feels to win in
- 42:00lose. So, for example, chess, chess has a massive cultural cache
- 42:07to it. You'll see in any number of movies, any number of TV
- 42:12shows that playing chess well is sort of a proxy for somebody being very intelligent.
- 42:16Yeah, it's a short cut to genius, right, exactly. Yeah.
- 42:20So if you do play chess like I do, which is as if
- 42:23somebody has put an iron spike through the reasoning center of your brain and you
- 42:29lose, it's hard for you to say it's hard for you to hide behind
- 42:32a loss like the dice didn't go against you, because there's no dice in
- 42:36chess. It's not the case that information was hidden from you because everything's on
- 42:42the board. There's no place really to hide when you lose, other than
- 42:45I played poorly in comparison to the other person I was playing with. But
- 42:50if you buy into this idea that playing chess, as you say, is
- 42:53a proxy for genius, then it's easy to come away from playing chess feeling
- 42:59a bit stupid. And when that happens, cognitive dissonance heads in. So
- 43:04cognitive dissonance is the idea that you can't hold contradictory ideas in your head for
- 43:09very long before you have to resolve them. So, either chess is a
- 43:15game for people who are intelligent and you therefore are not intelligent, or people
- 43:22puss too much focus on chess and therefore you know you're perfectly intelligent even though
- 43:25you can't play chess very well. That's what I plumbed for. Yeah,
- 43:29yeah, exactly, And that's the essentially that's the right answer, because look
- 43:32at Bobby Fisher, for example, it's hard to consider Bobby Fisher to be
- 43:37a paragon of sort of general intelligence. He was a very very specialized chess
- 43:43playing machine. But I wouldn't take financial advice from him social advice from him.
- 43:51So yeah, if the cognitive dissonance resolves into you know, oh,
- 43:54I'm stupid, therefore I played this game. I played the game poorly,
- 43:59Therefore I'm stupid. People tend to sort of react poorly, and that's sort
- 44:01of where you know, bad winners and bad losers sort of come from.
- 44:07And there are a whole lot of games that are designed better or worse from
- 44:09that. Can you give us an example of a game that does that well
- 44:15well? I would say, for example, there's a game Once Upon a
- 44:21Time. It's a really good example of a game that does cognitive accessibility,
- 44:23not emotional accessibility well, because it makes the mistakes you make are part of
- 44:30the comedy of playing the game as in so for those who never played Once
- 44:35upon a Time, it's basically a storytelling game where you play down cards and
- 44:38you try and sort of get to the end of a story based on an
- 44:42ending that's in your hand. And if you sort of repeat something, if
- 44:45you don't make any sense, if you say something that's in somebody else's hand
- 44:50they're hand of cards, then they can take control of the story. But
- 44:53the way it emphasizes doing this is not by saying, ah, you were
- 44:57stupid, you didn't tell the story properly. It's sort of like treat it
- 45:00like you would in a nursery school, you know, chant oh silly or
- 45:04mistake or mistake and sort of make it, make it sort of like a
- 45:07low cost funny thing to go with it. Games like a Jenger are also
- 45:14quite good in terms of how they deal with failure, because the failure is
- 45:19where the fun is. You know, poking the box out of Genger is
- 45:22not a massively interesting thing to do. The interesting thing is when it falls,
- 45:27and then you get to sort of make fun of the person that made
- 45:29it fall. But it doesn't sting because failure sort of that's you know,
- 45:35you succeed at playing the game. When you fail to actually move the tower,
- 45:39you become you become for a second, almost the hero of the game,
- 45:45because actually what people secretly want in gener is for the tower to fall
- 45:49right absolutely, and just just sort of like a counterpoint of that, there's
- 45:52a game called Meeple Circus, which is about placing meepole's on top of increasingly
- 45:55weird shapes. You know, So you have like strong menholdling up a plant
- 46:00which has a donkey on it, and on top of the donkey there's an
- 46:02upside down the elephant, that kind of thing, and it's sort of like
- 46:06the inversion of Jenga, because this is a very skill based game and you
- 46:09have to build these things and when the thing falls, it's funny, but
- 46:13it's a mistake, and so people are in sort of worst kind of group
- 46:17scenarios. People are laughing at you for having made this mistake. But Jenga,
- 46:22as you say, you're the hero when things fall down. You're the
- 46:23one who made that. You're the one who made the thing cathart. You
- 46:28know, the Catharsis is down to you. So I'm also fascinated here because
- 46:34I've been I've been banging this drum now for a while. That often people
- 46:39talk about inclusion within the gaming Honey, I'm not entirely sure that it's not
- 46:45a bit of a straw man, if I'm honest, but people often talk
- 46:50about attracting LGB players. People often talk about attracting players of color, And
- 46:57what seems to always be ignored is the fact that, more so than anything
- 47:04I can kind of currently think of, apart from maybe polo tabletop, gaming
- 47:09is a resolutely middle class pursuit. And the way people brag in gaming is
- 47:20with whole photos from conventions. You know, I've been able to have the
- 47:23disposable income to spend five hundred quid on games when I was at Essen this
- 47:28year and so and so. You have a chapter on socioeconomic accessibility. Is
- 47:35this something that gaming really needs to address? Well, I mean it's this
- 47:43there's probably going to sound an extreme viewpoint, but this is sort of my
- 47:46experience of fandoms in general, which is that all fandoms have a toxic element
- 47:52to them, and some of those toxic elements are not intentionally toxic. Sometimes
- 47:57they're sort of corrosive accidentally because people are just engaging in their enthusiasm for the
- 48:01hobby. But I do think there are sort of inaccessibilities about this hobby that
- 48:08don't relate to the games themselves. For example, gloom Haven is a tremendous
- 48:15example of a game that is socio economically inaccessible. And it's not even just
- 48:21because of the price tag. It's because how long do you need to be
- 48:25able to play through the game of gloom Haven, how much table space do
- 48:30you need, how many friends do you need, and how often do you
- 48:32need to get them to come along and play a game. So for one
- 48:37of the things that I think Corona really sort of highlighted for a lot of
- 48:42people that maybe was hidden before was that not all of us have the luxury
- 48:45of space, as in you'd be in zoom meetings with colleagues and you see,
- 48:51you know, one of them, myself for example, in like a
- 48:53nice comfortable study and it's you know, it's all fine. There's absolutely no
- 48:58problems working at home, and other people who are sort of sitting in the
- 49:00kitchen with like a kid on their lap, trying to, you know,
- 49:05make sure people stay out with the background. Not everybody has the ability to
- 49:09sort of accumulate large quantities of games or even necessarily play them. Having a
- 49:15table surface that you can weave unused for hours at a time is kind of
- 49:21a luxury for a lot of people. But when it comes to halls and
- 49:24such, you know, people are enthusiastic about it. But I think a
- 49:30lot of hobbies have sort of understood the difference between the two different sides of
- 49:34a hobby, which is the collection aspect and the participation aspect. But you
- 49:39see, for example, in like BookTube and all these different kinds of things,
- 49:43people who are just buying books but not actually reading them. That's fine,
- 49:47that's a hobby in and of itself. But the distinction between participating as
- 49:53in somebody who actually plays games, the level of requirements are relatively over there.
- 49:59But to be somebody who's sort of like recognized as having hundreds and hundreds
- 50:02of games is a different part of it. And I do think it is
- 50:05a problem. I think it puts people off, particularly when it comes to
- 50:08sort of like the sticker shock of board games, which is phenomenal. Anthomo
- 50:15is most definitely a thing, right, absolutely yeah. I mean my resentment
- 50:21at seeing all the posts from gathering of friends. Recent testament of that well,
- 50:24I mean I went to the UK Games Expo like a while ago now,
- 50:28and I found it such an overstimulating experience that it sort of killed any
- 50:32pomo I had of any convention from that point onwards. It was just so
- 50:37lolled, so busy, so few spaces places. I just found it quite
- 50:43unpleasant for a lot of the time. But sort of coming back to this
- 50:47idea of sticker shock. You know, Monopoly for all its flaws, and
- 50:52it is mostly flaws, but it is sort of like the touchstone people who
- 50:57aren't geeks have about what games are. So when you look at like Monopoly
- 51:01in a supermarket, which is I don't know, twenty five thirty euros or
- 51:06something, and then you go and look at the one I looked at most
- 51:09recently before I decided maybe it's time to stop visiting game shops was the New
- 51:15Hero Quest, which is like one hundred and fifty euros. And I remember
- 51:20that when I was a kid, and when I was a kid, it
- 51:22was what inflation adjusted the equivalent like forty euros. You know, there's a
- 51:25there is a massive sticker shop that comes with this hobby if you want to
- 51:30play anything. That's sort of part of the discourse. And so what this
- 51:36is the reaction to the book being in general? The reason I contacted you
- 51:39is because people I know who are in the industry were posting that this has
- 51:44become the new sort of indispensable thing for industry people to read when when they're
- 51:50thinking about games as products. So what does the reaction? I mean,
- 51:54it's hard to say. Like part of my whole the Internet makes me sad.
- 52:00Thing was I kind of disconnected from most of the conversation around board gaming,
- 52:06like a few years ago. So I'm not really on Reddit, I
- 52:09don't spend very much time on Twitter, and I gather in the in the
- 52:15aftermath of a certain acquisition. Twitter is no longer like the center of the
- 52:20hobby. You know, people are on Blue Sky or Masters on all these
- 52:23different kinds of places. No they're not, they not, Okay, they
- 52:27like people like to go on Twitter moaning about how terrible Twitter is. That's
- 52:30the way it works. No one's on bloody blue Sky I've been there,
- 52:35believe me. Well, that's that's fine, because that's pretty much the only
- 52:38thing I want to do When I'm on Twitter three four tweets and I think
- 52:42of myself, I wish I wasn't here. So it's difficult for me to
- 52:45sort of gauge at this point here because it's still relatively early on in the
- 52:50publication process. But I do know, like I have had some very positive
- 52:54feedback from a whole bunch of people, So I have reason to believe that
- 53:00those who are sort of designing games are finding it useful, and I would
- 53:07really realistically, the thing I hope from this is that enough people are sort
- 53:12of aware of its existence, that they know it's an option to take accessibility
- 53:15seriously, and that there are some guidance and much to do. But from
- 53:21the sounds of it, you know better about how it's being received than I
- 53:22am, because, as I say, I'm disconnected from the discourse. So
- 53:29I don't want to be grotty here, but I'm going to be inevitably.
- 53:31Is that you work at the School of Computer Science and Gotham Birds, and
- 53:36so that's your job, right. I assume writing a book like this is
- 53:43about contributing to the literature, rather than any expectation that you'll be able to
- 53:49retire from the proceeds. Right, So the publisher made a sort of snaffo
- 53:54when they sent out the free author copies, and they send me an additional
- 53:58sort of five hard part copies. And I considered that to be like an
- 54:02order of magnitude improvement in my financial compensation writing the book. You know,
- 54:08these things, they do not make money, these books through academic publishing.
- 54:14You're exactly right. You write these things as a contribution. You don't write
- 54:19them in terms of being expected to retire or even necessarily see any actual money.
- 54:27The sale numbers tend to be very very low, and mostly they tend
- 54:30to be purchased by you know, for example, academic libraries as such.
- 54:35And that's great. You know, I would massively encourage people to contact their
- 54:38libraries for a copy if they see the relatively large price tag and think I
- 54:44don't really want to spend that kind of money. You know, this being
- 54:46a resource in a library is for me exactly what's most valuable rather than lots
- 54:53of sales to people who perhaps wouldn't even necessarily read it. So online,
- 55:00then let's completely contradict everything you've just said and shift some paper. So if
- 55:04people want to get it, how can they go about doing that? So
- 55:07you can buy it from pretty much anywhere good books are sold, as I
- 55:10believe the slogan goes. You can get it from Amazon, you can get
- 55:14it directly from tailor and Francis for the publishers. If you go to my
- 55:17website, there's a couple of links in there that you can click. But
- 55:22basically, if you just type tabletop game accessibility into any sort of book site,
- 55:25you'll you'll probably find a way to get a copy. Excellent. Well,
- 55:30Michael Herron, thank you very much, No no problem at all.
- 55:34Thank you very much for having me. He's your favorite past Dave, it's
- 55:42the Q and A. I'm exhausted from listening to all those interviews. How
- 55:45do you do it? What do you find the time? You just ask
- 55:46people questions? Don't it? I feel like I'm being like crowded out though
- 55:50by the other content here you have. You have like three whole shows on
- 55:54this network. Three So I've got this is the new show. Yeah,
- 56:00this is the main feed this one. Yeah, it's on the main feature
- 56:01hashtag channel. Yeah, that's the main feed or patrons only, that's main
- 56:06feed. Okay, we do battle reports, that's right, that's patrons patrons
- 56:10only. We've got five g for the expeditions. Yeah, well that's a
- 56:14sort of exactly, that's a regular thing. Movie show, movie show.
- 56:17That's four, that's on the patroon. Yeah, that's four. You've got
- 56:20four shows. Uh, D and D and D and D five. That's
- 56:24true. What am I complaining about? Exactly? So, Marcus the Dog,
- 56:29I assume you gave him that nick name Shepherd. What games will be
- 56:36nominated for this year's Spielders Gyrus? I don't know if I pay enough attention
- 56:40to the kinds of games that tend to win the spield srs. Do you
- 56:45think Gin might be nominated? I guess Gin maybe too heavy, mate,
- 56:46that's more of a Kenner spiel, Canis spiel? Yeah, so give me
- 56:50one. I was thinking back to though, and I really enjoyed it,
- 56:52and I wish I'd bought it. Give me the dj I that's your thing
- 56:55to the Kennishpiel my nomination, I don't know if it count says this year
- 56:59though, I've been saying this since I've been saying this forever but my nomination
- 57:02for the spield is ARUs is schnitze lyaut or pray another day? Oh is
- 57:07it? Is it eligible this year? Yeah? Came out last year lesson
- 57:09Yeah. Yeah, but it's like a little card game. Yeah, spield
- 57:13as Gus has no chance? Well no, nominated not he's gonna win?
- 57:16Oh yeah it might be not okay nominated? Yeah? All right? So
- 57:20what are some other options that I could consider? I'm trying to think.
- 57:23Give me some options and then I can tell you if I think it has
- 57:25that. My memory is terrible. I don't play spield this yours weight games
- 57:29ever? Watching a flag that stone my game? No? Probably the B
- 57:34one a pury b behive incorporated a pury No too heavy for the spield of
- 57:39RS, right, kenn of Spiel? Are you too heavy for that?
- 57:43Probably? I don't know what I Maybe Cabanga might be nominated for spielders.
- 57:47You could have prepared for this, you know, I could have, or
- 57:50you could have even told me, and I would have prepared. But did
- 57:52you read the Did you read the discord just before we started recording? Nope?
- 57:54Because I wrote ah forgot to elicit questions for the news show. We're
- 58:00recording in thirty time every fucking time. And by the way, the names
- 58:07of the episodes no consistency what you mean like, no editorial oversight whatsoever on
- 58:12this fucking program. I'm the fucking I'm the talent, random punctuation, exclamation
- 58:15points sometimes and not other times on the talent. You don't label the shows
- 58:20on the talent. I'm the booker, I'm the editor, I'm the audio
- 58:23engineer, I'm the producer. I can't. I make a couple of plenty
- 58:28of mistakes from time to time. Some I folt time to time, time
- 58:30to time. So anyway, yeah, carry on later, games that deserve
- 58:37the attention, play many you know. Yeah, I don't know. You
- 58:38know, Wavelength I think would be worthy of one if it were eligible.
- 58:42Yeah, but it was like years ago. They're coming out with an expansion,
- 58:45but I guess they don't. They don't do expansions today, So you
- 58:47know, I have no idea. It would be great if someone could come
- 58:51up with a list of potential nominees and then we do it again next time.
- 58:54Yes, to get on the discode. Are we gonna even bother to
- 58:57do that? Well, certainly on a news show, we'll do a reaction
- 58:59to this, then I would have had I would have had to play them
- 59:01right like I didn't. I didn't play Door from Antique until like the day
- 59:06before the Awar exactly exactly. So there's like there's like no chance that my
- 59:08opinion has any bearing. We'll talk about it in Bretsch Bilcon, because a
- 59:12Berlin Bresch Bilcon, they'll have a Yeah, maybe we should try to play
- 59:16the you know, that's a good place to play those games exactly, because
- 59:19it's like it's a bit too busy to try and get into anything too heavy,
- 59:22so we do that new tradition. Second question from Marcus the Dog Shepherd,
- 59:28why why is the Golden Geek award the most rigged? It is obviously
- 59:35referring to five games for Doomsdays. Terrible showing at the could be a question
- 59:39for you, Ben, not for me, and I believe it's a leading
- 59:44question. So firstly, we all know my disappointment at not winning the Golden
- 59:52Geek is fucking ludicrous because I know going in what the deal with the Golden
- 59:55Geek is, Right, your disappointment is ludacrous. Yeah, I know what
- 59:59the deal is going. I just know what it is going in so I
- 1:00:02know I'm not gonna win for because for some reason, I'm not as popular
- 1:00:05as the podcasts. So so me getting disappointed is just irrational and stupid.
- 1:00:10You not being popular is different from people not voting for you. So we
- 1:00:15don't know, like the Dickheads could be. Well, I mean, I
- 1:00:17maybe they're very lazy and they don't bother to support you. I didn't.
- 1:00:21I didn't know the podcast that won, which says a lot. Maybe they're
- 1:00:23just very good at marketing themselves. But I went and looked at their Patreon
- 1:00:27afterwards, and they've got more Patreon backers than me, probably double Patreon backers
- 1:00:30than me, and they probably they probably mentioned it every episode. They're clearly
- 1:00:32make sure you vote for us in the Golden Geek. Yeah, well I
- 1:00:36I did last year and it did fuck all. So I decided to give
- 1:00:38up. But the thing is, and I've said this a lot, right,
- 1:00:42I've said this a lot. There's only one year where I thought five
- 1:00:46Games for Doomsday deserved to win the Golden Geek, and I knew I wasn't
- 1:00:52going to, but the fact that I didn't was very disappointing to me.
- 1:00:57And this is the problem with the Golden Geek. Being a popular art contest
- 1:01:00is that it doesn't reward your prize. It doesn't reward quality necessarily. You
- 1:01:05don't even the world's popularity in twenty twenty, I should have won the Golden
- 1:01:08Gig. There was no one in twenty twenty that did better work in the
- 1:01:13podcast sphere of games than I did with my voices from the Solitude series.
- 1:01:16And I'm not saying you are a board game journalist. You cover like the
- 1:01:20entire newspaper. You do news, you do interviews. I mean, you
- 1:01:23don't exactly do investigative reporting, but it's like board games. You do like
- 1:01:28entertainment pieces, reviews, I mean original content. I don't know, this
- 1:01:32could be maybe not with the mainstream board game podcast listenership wants. I'm sure
- 1:01:36I would love to win the Golden Gig, but if I didn't win that
- 1:01:38year, I'm kind of not that fucking bothered about the initial sting is there,
- 1:01:44there's no doubt, But I'm kind of not bothered if I don't win
- 1:01:45any other year, because that was the year I deserve to win, and
- 1:01:49I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of the people voting don't even listen to
- 1:01:52podcasts, they just vote, they vote for whatever. And so the point
- 1:01:55is the reason I like spield this year. I think the the Schilder's RS
- 1:02:00is important. And fundamentally the Board Game Geek Awards are fucking not is because
- 1:02:06their popularity contest, they're voting contest. The fielders jars takes experts in the
- 1:02:09field and have of them judge. That implies something. I find it inconceivable
- 1:02:15to think that I wouldn't have won something in the last few years. And
- 1:02:21again this may sound like arrogance, but I wouldn't have won something in the
- 1:02:22last few years if the Podcast Award hadn't been if the BGG Award had been
- 1:02:30a jury prize. But I can tell you why it's not going to be
- 1:02:32a jury prize. Ever. Going to be a jury prize is because if
- 1:02:37you look at Board Game Geek, I'd love Board Gang Geek, don't get
- 1:02:38me wrong, But nevertheless, this is nevertheless true. It's fucking lazy.
- 1:02:45If you look at the design of the website, it's still from the fucking
- 1:02:47nineties. If you look at the way all of the awards there are configured,
- 1:02:52they're fucking lazy. Fundamentally, the very grassroots kind of community. Everything
- 1:02:58is all the content is generated by the community members. Yes, so it
- 1:03:00kind of makes sense that the awards would be like this too. How would
- 1:03:02they even put a jury? Again, well, what's qualified to judge best
- 1:03:06parts? Well, there's loads of people who are. But the point is
- 1:03:09the point is what annoys me about the way it's voted on? And I
- 1:03:15said I didn't have sour grape, It's clear I do. What annoys me
- 1:03:17literally everything is that you have two fucking votes. What the fuck is the
- 1:03:22point of that? I think sourcing sourcing the crowd for the top ten,
- 1:03:27for the finalist is a great idea because that really reflects what people are listening
- 1:03:30to. Right then you have a jury of people who go and listen to
- 1:03:36the latest five episodes for instance, Well, the people who work at fucking
- 1:03:39board game Gik, the people who write critical articles on board game gig,
- 1:03:43the fucking the guy, the guy who works at board game Geek who is
- 1:03:46willing to fucking chuck people off fucking board game Geek who politically disagree with him
- 1:03:52and then go brag about it on fucking Twitter. Maybe he could have maybe
- 1:03:55he could have his time better, fucking spent by doing something useful judging the
- 1:04:00fucking awards. But then does he have to judge all of the awards,
- 1:04:02like he gets to pick best game, best RPG, best podcast. Why
- 1:04:08not? Maybe he doesn't want the responsibility, or maybe it's it's too much
- 1:04:10work. Well, then it's fucking pointless. I mean, this is kind
- 1:04:13of like, there's no way that one person can listen to all of the
- 1:04:16podcasts and then be able to make an objective judgment. No, well,
- 1:04:19first why you don't. Firstly, you don't make an objective judgment, And
- 1:04:23secondly, they do crowdsauce it. They crowdsource the finalists and if it's too
- 1:04:27much work, have a top five, top five, top three might work,
- 1:04:30not a top ten, and then judge from those. Okay, so
- 1:04:32you're you're you're wining thatwithstanding, should I or should I not? Next year,
- 1:04:38program a bot to vote for five games for room to day, like
- 1:04:41five times a day. Oh yeah, absolutely, okay. So Chekhov's gun
- 1:04:45jen Stehammer, Fokemon asks Hummer. Chikhov's gun is the advice for writers to
- 1:04:50never put something in their stories that won't be mentioned ever again, thus has
- 1:04:54no significance for the plot our question, God, You're a fucking asshole.
- 1:05:00Which game ignores Chekhov's gun the most? He was clarifying before we asked the
- 1:05:05question, state, So is this sort of like, is he trolling me
- 1:05:12to say Scythe because it's obviously scythe? Go on, explain. I mean,
- 1:05:15I've gone off on side so many times, and maybe I'm not interpreting
- 1:05:19correctly the spirit of the question, but for me, this is like a
- 1:05:23game that promises something that it doesn't deliver, right, And it's all about
- 1:05:27the theme in the packaging, which is essentially what still Myer game seems to
- 1:05:30be selling in all of their games, is like theme and packaging and like
- 1:05:33the glossy images, and it looks like it's gonna be this weird sort of
- 1:05:39I don't know, nineteen twenty cyberpunk futuristic combat game. Yeah, exactly,
- 1:05:45And it's not. It's just a fucking worker placement game. And you're even
- 1:05:47penalized for engaging in combat. I know people are gonna argue with me or
- 1:05:51whatever, but I felt like really let down, And I think that's a
- 1:05:55good example of a Chekhov's gun. You like, you don't kind of you
- 1:05:58don't really get what's on the tin. So I'm going to give another one.
- 1:06:01And so my version of the Chekhov's gun is that you have mechanisms within
- 1:06:05the game that don't factor into the game, and they're there, and to
- 1:06:11use them is kind of pointless. And I think the game that really highlights
- 1:06:15this the most is Maracaibo. There is that exploration track at the bottom.
- 1:06:20You shut your horror mouth. That is just pointless that you don't need to
- 1:06:25use. That is just your exploration track is pointless. That is just there
- 1:06:28because there, because the game isn't complicated enough. I released my review of
- 1:06:33Bloodstones today and basically my whole thesis, and I think my whole thesis of
- 1:06:38games is that extraneous rules are ruining game design, and I think Maracaibo is
- 1:06:43an absolute, absolute example of that. There's too much shit you just don't
- 1:06:47use in that game. And it's not about there are different paths to victory.
- 1:06:51It's just a flabby design that's eighty five percent done. May I may
- 1:06:57offer a rejoinder, yeah, you're an asshole. Ah so there are no
- 1:07:00more questions. So that that's you know, the mechanism, the way of
- 1:07:05looking at the question, like I think there are a lot of games that
- 1:07:09probably attempt to be very mechanism forward and fail in doing so. Yeah,
- 1:07:14and you're always saying quite sagely, I might add very much that a good
- 1:07:18game, in a good game, the the let's say, the mechanisms or
- 1:07:21the UI disappears right like you know, you don't you don't feel it,
- 1:07:25but you feel it and you don't feel it right. It doesn't it doesn't
- 1:07:29stick out, but it like it facilitates your enjoyment of the experience. As
- 1:07:31I said, with a lot of silver age games, and in my review
- 1:07:33I used I used one of your terms was that gaming's baroque era. I'm
- 1:07:39into this. I I believe in this term. And basically I said that
- 1:07:45there are a lot of games that you play that feel like the mountain you
- 1:07:49have to climb to learn how to play the fucking thing is the game itself.
- 1:07:54After that, it's kind of pointless because what was the sentence I used,
- 1:07:58which I think is quite good. These are games that they cover up
- 1:08:00the fact that they only go six inches below the surface. I mean,
- 1:08:04Satama reminded me of this. It's like you have a whole game that's great
- 1:08:08and then also over here. You know, if you want, you can
- 1:08:10play the Wheel of Fortune. Why why? Why? Yeah? The biggest
- 1:08:14example I think of a game that is I gotta oh Yeah, a game
- 1:08:19that implies whimsy and interest and is seemingly based upon Ghibli movies is Botoku,
- 1:08:30and Betoku is just a terribly designed game. It is different areas of a
- 1:08:34board that have no connection to each other, and you can go there and
- 1:08:39it's caused you points, and then you go there and it scores you points,
- 1:08:42and then you go there and it scores you points, and they have
- 1:08:44no link and the game doesn't feel cohesive, Whereas you have a game like
- 1:08:47Trajan, which you could say ostensibly has those different areas, but they are
- 1:08:53all They all emerge from the engine of that wonderful Rondel that you have to
- 1:08:59put. The starf owns it. The grab bag of mechanisms game, I
- 1:09:02suppose has its place. Why am I always talking about splatter games. Someone
- 1:09:08was mentioning their like thirteenth play of Horseless Carriage, Yeah only disco, and
- 1:09:12I thought, I thought that was a very compelling statement. I mean,
- 1:09:15I wish I could have played this game thirteen times. I could see how
- 1:09:17it would develop in that direction, and every single one of the mechanisms in
- 1:09:20that game is indispensable. Yeah, because you are immersed in these mechanisms.
- 1:09:26You cannot avoid them. They are the game. They are not options that
- 1:09:30you can or cannot take that you you have to somehow figure out how to
- 1:09:33incorporate. And it's not referential shine, it's not people. It's people caring
- 1:09:40about the construction of something rather than getting something published. It seems to me,
- 1:09:45Yeah, I mean, I would have to think a little bit longer
- 1:09:47about the question of a proper answer, because I'm sure there are some like
- 1:09:51games with I mean, it's to me, it's like a whole genre of
- 1:09:55games, like a gras I guess comes to mind. I don't know why
- 1:09:59that you say, like Chekhov Chekhov's Gun. You play the game and it's
- 1:10:04it's like an economic euro game with worker placement and the very like very very
- 1:10:09the thin veneer of a theme and it seems to promise a thematic sort of
- 1:10:14experience, and and then you play the game and then then it's over.
- 1:10:16Yeah, and it was just like yet another you know, generic Baroque era
- 1:10:23euro game, And you know, I think it's a whole category of games.
- 1:10:26I don't know if there's like anyone that I would say is like a
- 1:10:28greater transgressor than any other except Side. And also it's Equl Expeditions. Same
- 1:10:33story, Like you're literally moving these giant fucking minis around. They don't do
- 1:10:38anything. I think it's the point of them. I think there's a fundamental
- 1:10:41difference between Scythe and Expeditions. I think Side is fine. I think Side
- 1:10:45is is a good guy. Expeditions is cynical though. I think Expeditions is,
- 1:10:50like you like Scythe, you fucking muppets. Here you go, here's
- 1:10:55another box of toys. I've never played a lazy game in my life.
- 1:10:58The the scoring condition are the laziest. If it is a choose, if
- 1:11:02there is a Tuesday and it's four players, you score this many points.
- 1:11:05Yes, it's insulting. I agree. If you like strawberries, get ten
- 1:11:09thousand points, yeah it is. And I think what you've seen in board
- 1:11:15gaming is that lavish production is now cheap. Right. So, for instance,
- 1:11:21I think Side was one of the first games to have dual player boards,
- 1:11:26and it was a big thing at the time, and now it's the
- 1:11:29norm. Almost all games have them, and so you can cover up a
- 1:11:33whole world of sin with beautiful components and wonderful art. And there are so
- 1:11:40many good artists out there, and what you see is products that give the
- 1:11:45veneer of being professional but are actually half asked and very fucking lazy. Because
- 1:11:49and this is and this is a difference. I think now, now this
- 1:11:53is the this is the chauvinism of the modern day. I'm sure if you
- 1:11:57go back to nineteen ninety seven, a ton of shitty games, but only
- 1:12:01the really good ones have survived till today. Right, But it feels like
- 1:12:06the immediate concern back then was the construction of the game. The secondary concern
- 1:12:14was the art. You look at Richard Breeze's games, right, Whereas now
- 1:12:16the primary concern is to make the game look good and make sure you've got
- 1:12:20enough fucking twelve inch dildos in the box, and the secondary concern is actually
- 1:12:25constructing a game that's any good. Right. Do you remember the kids game
- 1:12:28Mousetrap? I do. Maybe that's like the opposite example. It's all Chekhov's
- 1:12:31gun and no game, right, And I think I think that maybe we're
- 1:12:35seeing a lot of especially driven by Kickstarter, a lot of Chekhov Gun and
- 1:12:41no game. You know, it's hard for me to answer these types of
- 1:12:44questions, which are essentially asking me to come up with games that I don't
- 1:12:47feel very positively about. And I tend to feel positively about most games,
- 1:12:53Like I like games. What's the thing. When I review games, I'm
- 1:12:57more likely to give a positive review because I like game. Yeah, you
- 1:13:00know, if you listen to us long enough, it might seem like we're
- 1:13:02very negative on a lot of games, and actually it's not the case.
- 1:13:05But the question is asking you. The question is deliberately asking you to rip
- 1:13:10on games. It's just like the ones that I don't like. I don't
- 1:13:12play that many times. I played once, right, and and then I
- 1:13:15forget them. So it's like hard for me to go back in my memory.
- 1:13:17And you know, the best example would be a game that has a
- 1:13:19lot of notoriety and yet I and yet I think it's this example I think
- 1:13:24is overrated. So I say side, like, imagine if my example were
- 1:13:27castles of Burgundy, Like what would be the Chekhov's Gun and castles of Burgundy?
- 1:13:30Like I'm not even sure. Well, I think I think the thing
- 1:13:34is the castles themselves. Well, I think this is one too much.
- 1:13:38This is why, because games are a mechanistic art form, not a narrative
- 1:13:42art form. That I think if you this, the Chekhov's Gun is an
- 1:13:45explicitly narrative proposition, but I think you need to talk about it in terms
- 1:13:49of mechanisms. That's why I chose Marikaid. I mean Seafall. I never
- 1:13:54played it, but it's a legacy game, and this would be a great
- 1:13:57example. And you said it's shit, a leg game which has got to
- 1:14:00be all Chekhov's Gun, and yet you maybe you should talk about it.
- 1:14:04It's a huge disappointment. I would think a legacy game that's a disappointment that's
- 1:14:08got to be like the Chekhov's Gun. Maybe maybe King's Dilemma. That felt
- 1:14:11a little bit repetitive to me. Yeah, King's Lemma was repetitive. The
- 1:14:14problem is c Fall. It was just mechanistically terrible. I don't it was
- 1:14:16just it was just designed horribly and every game got longer, and it was
- 1:14:21too long to begin with. I think it's just very hard to create a
- 1:14:26multi game arc in in board games like it has been done successfully, but
- 1:14:30not often so what is a game then that does it properly Betrayal Legacy.
- 1:14:39Betrayal Legacy brilliant. If you're talking of a narrative game, Betrayal Legacy is
- 1:14:44absolutely perfect. It knows its tropes, it tells a brilliant story, and
- 1:14:47it's an excellent game mechanical. I would even say, despite what you may
- 1:14:51think of season two, the Betrayal Sorry, the Pandemic Legacy series, like
- 1:14:58within each individual's season, they managed to pull this off, and they also
- 1:15:01pull it off across all three seasons. Because coming to the last of the
- 1:15:06three seasons, season zero, I mean that that is an amazing feat like
- 1:15:12unrivaled, unparalleled, and and I want to even say perhaps a bit unthung
- 1:15:16in the Niboard games. I don't think that Pandemic Legacy Season zero is my
- 1:15:19favorite. I don't think it got Maybe I'm wrong about this. I don't
- 1:15:23think it got as much attention as the earlier season. So I think if
- 1:15:26you talk if you talk about it, what a coup. Though, if
- 1:15:28you talk about it mechanistically, the game that does it perfectly is the game
- 1:15:32we played at the weekend Lajava. Because you think, what is the Chekhov's
- 1:15:36Gun in Lajava. Well, you're talking about Chekhov's gun is when it sets
- 1:15:43out mechanisms and they all get utilized perfectly. So the Harvre, you think,
- 1:15:50how useful is it for me to pick up these fucking three things off
- 1:15:54the board? But by the end it's completely vital. At the beginning it
- 1:15:59promises something you don't even understand really why it's there, and by the end
- 1:16:02it is a fully integrated and useful part of the game. This is absolute
- 1:16:08genius, and the Harvre fulfills that the most. I think, Well,
- 1:16:13Yen's d'ahama Folkemon, you really got us talking, all right. So to
- 1:16:17wrap up, Steve, how did I join the discord once more? Times?
- 1:16:21There's a lot of things that you need to do, all right,
- 1:16:25I'm even like losing track. You need to go to five g for d
- 1:16:28dot com. Click the post it's pinned yeah, at the top of the
- 1:16:31page. There you will find a link through which you can travel through the
- 1:16:34tubes of the Internet to the discord and join me and Ben and Jen's der
- 1:16:40Hamer, Folkemon and Asgerd and everyone else. We're all waiting for you there.
- 1:16:45You need to go to Patreon dot com, golash five Games for Doomsday,
- 1:16:47get a nickname, join the patron at five euros a month and get
- 1:16:53any name and listen to the battle reports, which is like the best content.
- 1:16:57To be honest on the whole thing, what should they do it?
- 1:17:00You need to go to the iTunes store or the Android play store or like
- 1:17:02your local spati and you need to give this podcast a five star review.
- 1:17:08Most of all, next year you need to give Five Games for Doomsday as
- 1:17:11many votes as possible on the Golden Geek a words anyway, So I just
- 1:17:14like and and if you go to the five Games for Doomsday merch shop,
- 1:17:18which is located out dot com cer people dot com, you can get yourself
- 1:17:23a more Steve in the feed t shirt. Can you you have like latest
- 1:17:26numbers and how many two or three left in stock? Two or three left
- 1:17:29in stock? We're not making anymore. There was one thousands originally. Yeah,
- 1:17:31we're not making anymore. This is the final run. Get you as
- 1:17:34why you can just like to say thank you all for contributing. Have a
- 1:17:40lovely month and uh yeah the news of that. Thank you for listening to
- 1:17:49the Five Games for Doomsday news To listen to past episodes, you can go
- 1:17:54to five Games Fordoomsday dot com, or to back the show, you can
- 1:17:58go to Patreon dot com Forward slash five g f D So join us again
- 1:18:02next month for some hot and spicy five Games for Doomsday New