Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court May Deliver Another Blow to Agencies
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 1: The Supreme Court will consider overturning a nearly forty year
- 0:14Speaker 1: old legal precedent called the Chevron Doctrine. It's given federal
- 0:19Speaker 1: regulators brought power to define their authority, and it's something
- 0:23Speaker 1: conservatives have been pushing to get rid of for years,
- 0:27Speaker 1: saying it's empowered the administrative state. Several conservative justices have
- 0:32Speaker 1: soured on the doctrine, and Justice Neil Gorsich is one
- 0:36Speaker 1: of them. He was even questioned about Chevron during his
- 0:39Speaker 1: Senate confirmation hearings because he'd criticized the doctrine in an opinion,
- 0:44Speaker 1: saying it allowed quote, executive bureaucracies to swallow huge amounts
- 0:49Speaker 1: of core judicial and legislative power.
- 0:52Speaker 2: And I've raised some questions that arise in a case
- 0:55Speaker 2: that I actually had to deal with, how it would
- 0:59Speaker 2: impact people, real people, if agencies can change the meaning
- 1:03Speaker 2: of the law back and forth every four years, depending
- 1:08Speaker 2: upon the outcome of an election. I thought the judges
- 1:13Speaker 2: were supposed to say what the law is. I thought
- 1:18Speaker 2: that's what Justice Marshall said, And I thought the point
- 1:22Speaker 2: of having judges decide the law is because you wanted
- 1:25Speaker 2: someone who's neutral and independent to say what the law means,
- 1:30Speaker 2: someone who doesn't have a dog in the hunt.
- 1:33Speaker 1: And next term the justices will consider a case testing
- 1:37Speaker 1: the doctrine. Joining me is an expert on the separation
- 1:40Speaker 1: of powers, Harold Krant, a professor at the Chicago Kent
- 1:44Speaker 1: College of Law. How will you explain just what the
- 1:47Speaker 1: Chevron doctrine is?
- 1:49Speaker 3: The ship on doctrine sets the tone or if you will,
- 1:53Speaker 3: between the reviewing court and the agency which is promulgated
- 1:58Speaker 3: rule or conducted into judicated to settle rights between the
- 2:02Speaker 3: government and either individuals or regulated businesses. And oftentimes agencies
- 2:08Speaker 3: engage in very complicated decision making, dealing with questions about
- 2:13Speaker 3: kinds of nuclear discharge, how to gauge it, questions about
- 2:16Speaker 3: hearing rights or disabled, what kind of drugs should be regulated,
- 2:22Speaker 3: how do we know if it's safe. There's so many
- 2:24Speaker 3: areas in which regulators have to make decisions, and Congress
- 2:28Speaker 3: can't foresee all of the details. Congress therefore gives of
- 2:32Speaker 3: why leash to agencies or leeway to the agency to
- 2:36Speaker 3: flesh out those regulations. As social conditions and indeed, as
- 2:40Speaker 3: political conditions change subject to the oversight of the President,
- 2:46Speaker 3: and that's the kind of standard. But the Court is
- 2:49Speaker 3: fighting back. The Court is thought that agencies shouldn't have
- 2:52Speaker 3: this power. It's okay if Congress cuts the details itself,
- 2:56Speaker 3: but the Court doesn't want agencies to have the ability
- 3:00Speaker 3: to reinterpret their own enacting statues, to reinterpret and refashion
- 3:04Speaker 3: rules as these conditions change. And therefore they're trying to
- 3:09Speaker 3: straight jacket administrative agency power.
- 3:12Speaker 1: And the doctrine has sort of a two step approach.
- 3:16Speaker 3: The Chevron doctrine is a two step doctrine which first
- 3:19Speaker 3: asked if Congress has clearly specified what the agency should do,
- 3:23Speaker 3: and if it does, then the Court will just either
- 3:25Speaker 3: say agency acted appropriately or not. But if there is ambiguity,
- 3:30Speaker 3: and there's almost always ambiguity, then the doctrine suggests that
- 3:34Speaker 3: the Court will agree to any kind of reasonable interpretation
- 3:38Speaker 3: of the satutory language that the agency has reached. And
- 3:41Speaker 3: so they were giving deference, in other words, to agencies
- 3:44Speaker 3: because the agencies are more expert, they have more experience
- 3:47Speaker 3: in the areas of pollution, of drug safety, of labor
- 3:51Speaker 3: management relations, and therefore they should be the ones to
- 3:55Speaker 3: decide the issue as long as they're acting reasonably. That's
- 3:58Speaker 3: this sort of ructure of Chevron. But the Court, i think,
- 4:03Speaker 3: has battled back because it thinks that it's not right
- 4:07Speaker 3: for agencies to share with the Court the power to
- 4:11Speaker 3: interpret congressional language. The Court thinks it's their own prerogative
- 4:15Speaker 3: to interpret what Congress says, and therefore to share it
- 4:19Speaker 3: with agencies. By giving this leeway to reasonable agency interpretation
- 4:24Speaker 3: of satutory language would be to limit their own power. So,
- 4:28Speaker 3: in some ways, Chevron is an ideological war that the
- 4:32Speaker 3: Court is waging in order to affirm its own superiority
- 4:38Speaker 3: in terms of satutory interpretation.
- 4:41Speaker 1: The Court has chipped away at Chevron, but is this
- 4:45Speaker 1: the first direct challenge to it?
- 4:48Speaker 3: So the Court has not upheld a case on the
- 4:51Speaker 3: basis of the Chevron doctrine for over six years. Lower courts, however,
- 4:56Speaker 3: have continuously applied Chevron. But the Court has a acasionally
- 5:00Speaker 3: asked whether the Chevron doctrine should be not just limited,
- 5:04Speaker 3: which it has done, but whether it should be overruled
- 5:07Speaker 3: in its entirety. And this case may or may not
- 5:09Speaker 3: be the right vehicle. In this case, there's a very
- 5:12Speaker 3: narrow question has to do with a herring fishing industry
- 5:16Speaker 3: about whether the industry itself has to pay for agency observers.
- 5:21Speaker 3: And agency observers are unquestionably permitted under the statutory scheme
- 5:26Speaker 3: to make sure that the fishing boats conserve resources, don't overfish,
- 5:30Speaker 3: don't take too small fish, et cetera. So the questions
- 5:33Speaker 3: that they have to pay for it. Maybe it's implicit
- 5:35Speaker 3: in the statute, but it's not explicit. And the Court
- 5:38Speaker 3: has taken two questions on the case. One is whether
- 5:41Speaker 3: the Chevron doctrine should be overruled in its entirety, and
- 5:45Speaker 3: the second is whether the fact that there is no
- 5:48Speaker 3: explicit power given by Congress to the agency to make
- 5:53Speaker 3: the private fishing industry pay for observers, whether the fact
- 5:56Speaker 3: that there's congressional silence should be a reason to deprive
- 6:00Speaker 3: the agency of the power to determine that the fishing
- 6:05Speaker 3: industry should pay for these observers. So on the second question,
- 6:09Speaker 3: the court would be just narrowing Chevron even more. The
- 6:12Speaker 3: idea would be agency can still interpret what the statute says,
- 6:17Speaker 3: but if the statute doesn't give a power explicitly, then
- 6:21Speaker 3: Chevron would not be applied, and so that would be
- 6:23Speaker 3: another way to whittle down the number of circumstances in
- 6:28Speaker 3: which agency interpretations would be deferred to.
- 6:32Speaker 1: There isn't a split in the circuits there.
- 6:34Speaker 3: This case is all about the Supreme Court. And again,
- 6:36Speaker 3: I think the challenge of Chevron, I don't think it
- 6:39Speaker 3: makes that big of a difference in terms of number
- 6:41Speaker 3: of cases the agency's win or lose. But it's a
- 6:44Speaker 3: thorn in the Court's side because the Court thinks that
- 6:47Speaker 3: they have the superiority in terms of interpreting statutes, and
- 6:52Speaker 3: to publicly announce that agencies should have a role in
- 6:56Speaker 3: interpreting language of Congress as well as they do, it's
- 7:00Speaker 3: sort of an insult to the Court. To the Court,
- 7:02Speaker 3: I think wants to wipe this insult away. But what
- 7:06Speaker 3: I think is interesting is to think about what happened
- 7:09Speaker 3: before Chevron. And that's something that often commentators aren't really
- 7:13Speaker 3: discussing because before Chevron, what courts would do would say,
- 7:17Speaker 3: you know, this is a kind of complicated agency issue.
- 7:21Speaker 3: Agencies have more expertise than we do. We'll defer to agency.
- 7:24Speaker 3: And there was this sort of patchwork of deference that
- 7:29Speaker 3: grew up in mongst courts that say, well, in this case,
- 7:32Speaker 3: we're not sure it's kind of murky. There's a lot
- 7:35Speaker 3: of expertise involved. We'll defer to the agency. And what
- 7:39Speaker 3: Chevron did was to try to take this kind of
- 7:42Speaker 3: scheme of uncertain difference and try to give it a
- 7:47Speaker 3: uniform two step package which would then unify and systematize
- 7:53Speaker 3: difference across the country. So, even if Chevron is wiped out,
- 7:58Speaker 3: I think over time, which would say, you know, I
- 8:01Speaker 3: don't really know about nuclear discharge. What the agency did
- 8:05Speaker 3: here there is technical, it seems pretty minor. Let's defer
- 8:09Speaker 3: to the agency because who knows what Congress really intended
- 8:14Speaker 3: and the agency is familiar with it. The agency is
- 8:18Speaker 3: applying the statute, It has the expertise, it knows what
- 8:21Speaker 3: Congress meant by that vague language better than we do.
- 8:24Speaker 3: So I think that over time, even if the court
- 8:27Speaker 3: scuttles Chevron, it's not going to make a dramatic difference.
- 8:31Speaker 3: And the other side of the coin, if the court
- 8:34Speaker 3: really cares about an issue, and courts, you know, do
- 8:37Speaker 3: about the vaccine mandate for instance, or about carbon discharge,
- 8:41Speaker 3: the Court's going to come up with a decision as
- 8:43Speaker 3: to what the statute means. Irrespective of whether Chevron applies
- 8:47Speaker 3: or not. And we've seen many instances of that. So
- 8:50Speaker 3: even Chevron gives a court enough leeway to step in
- 8:54Speaker 3: and say that an agency interpretation is not reasonable, or
- 8:58Speaker 3: the congressional language was clear enough to make sure that
- 9:02Speaker 3: they end up with the result that they like. So
- 9:05Speaker 3: my own view is that in cases that courts aren't
- 9:10Speaker 3: wrapped up in politically or ideologically, they'll defer to agencies,
- 9:15Speaker 3: and in cases where they do care ideologically or politically,
- 9:19Speaker 3: then they'll find some kind of way to rule for
- 9:22Speaker 3: against the agency, depending upon their own leanings and their
- 9:26Speaker 3: own political views. So if they get rid of Chevron,
- 9:29Speaker 3: it will make a little bit of a difference, but
- 9:31Speaker 3: I don't think it'll be as dramatic as some people think.
- 9:35Speaker 1: Do you think that they intend to get rid of Chevron?
- 9:37Speaker 1: Because the justices didn't have to take this case, there's
- 9:42Speaker 1: no split in the circuits. The Administration said the fishery
- 9:45Speaker 1: dispute has no practical importance now because the monitoring program
- 9:50Speaker 1: is on hold, and the court took an unusually long
- 9:54Speaker 1: time to decide how to handle the case, it scheduled
- 9:57Speaker 1: it for potential discussion at five private conferences.
- 10:00Speaker 3: This case is not that important. It has to do
- 10:02Speaker 3: with just the herring fishing industry, and it has to
- 10:05Speaker 3: do with whether the industry has to pay for monitors.
- 10:08Speaker 3: Congress Crude stead the monitors are permitted, and that the
- 10:11Speaker 3: agency has the power to impose the monitoring system to
- 10:13Speaker 3: conserve fishing resources. So that's not even a question. So
- 10:16Speaker 3: this is not like a major questions case. This is
- 10:19Speaker 3: a minor regulatory issue about who pays. And the only
- 10:23Speaker 3: reason the Court took this case is because they wanted
- 10:26Speaker 3: some kind of context in which they could decide again
- 10:29Speaker 3: whether to scuttle Chevron, to interer it completely, or whether
- 10:32Speaker 3: it to limit it even more than it has been
- 10:35Speaker 3: in the prior ten years. Indeed, the fact that Justice
- 10:38Speaker 3: Jackson has recused from the case is even more sort
- 10:41Speaker 3: of fishy, so to speak, because they could have easily
- 10:44Speaker 3: taken a case in which all nine justices could have participated.
- 10:49Speaker 1: Presidents of both parties have leaned on the Chevron doctrine,
- 10:54Speaker 1: although democratic administrations perhaps relied more heavily using it to
- 11:00Speaker 1: justify mandates on energy, the environment, and the workplace. So
- 11:05Speaker 1: I'd like you to explain why conservatives, the critics of
- 11:09Speaker 1: big government or the administrative state or executive power I
- 11:12Speaker 1: think they're all the same, almost have had their eyes
- 11:16Speaker 1: on destroying Chevron.
- 11:18Speaker 3: Well, to take a step back, Chevron grew in the
- 11:21Speaker 3: midst of the Reagan administration, and the Reagan administration was
- 11:24Speaker 3: engaging in somewhat of a radical deregulation at the time,
- 11:28Speaker 3: and the Republicans supported Chevron because they supported the regulatory
- 11:33Speaker 3: regime that the Reagan administration was forwarding. And it was
- 11:36Speaker 3: only during the Obama administration when Republicans then began to
- 11:40Speaker 3: attack Chevron because they saw that Chevron helped the Obama's
- 11:45Speaker 3: administration's effort in Obamacare, effort in reforming the welfare system,
- 11:50Speaker 3: that they thought that having stricter judicial controls on the
- 11:54Speaker 3: administration would be more beneficial to their political interests. So Chef,
- 12:00Speaker 3: I'd really neutral. It can help administrations, whether the Republican
- 12:03Speaker 3: or Democratic. It just suggests a reality of our political system,
- 12:08Speaker 3: which is Congress doesn't like to deal with details. There's
- 12:11Speaker 3: a lot of gridlock in Congress. But even aside from
- 12:14Speaker 3: the gridlock, Congress looks at some issues, but it prefers
- 12:17Speaker 3: only to look at some issues, and it doesn't want
- 12:20Speaker 3: to get into details of vaccines, the details of even
- 12:24Speaker 3: the herring industry, not to mention pollution, labor management relations,
- 12:29Speaker 3: and so much more. And so for years Congress has
- 12:32Speaker 3: decided that it's better to have agencies take the first
- 12:35Speaker 3: crack at many of those important issues, and it sits
- 12:39Speaker 3: back and only gets involved if they are convinced that
- 12:42Speaker 3: the agencies have messed up. That's been a reality of
- 12:45Speaker 3: our governance now for generations. And it is true that
- 12:49Speaker 3: back in the seventeen nineties there were very few agencies.
- 12:52Speaker 3: There were some, and so Congress did grapple with more details,
- 12:56Speaker 3: more specifically, and that was the main way we had rules.
- 13:00Speaker 3: Over time, is life has become so much more complicated
- 13:03Speaker 3: and our society has grown so much that Congress has
- 13:07Speaker 3: been more content to issue some major rules but allow
- 13:10Speaker 3: the agencies to flesh them out and to adjust and
- 13:13Speaker 3: adapt as conditions change. So I don't think Chevron itself
- 13:17Speaker 3: is ideological, but it does do is it reflects the
- 13:20Speaker 3: fact that Congress has willingly given up the reins of
- 13:23Speaker 3: its own authority to the agencies. And someone who wants
- 13:26Speaker 3: to turn back the clock to seventeen eighty nine and
- 13:29Speaker 3: to someone who doesn't believe that agencies have any kind
- 13:33Speaker 3: of special role in interpreting what Congress intended. That's an assault.
- 13:38Speaker 3: And so I think what the Court is upset about
- 13:41Speaker 3: in Chevron isn't so much the view that agencies are liberal.
- 13:45Speaker 3: It's just that they want a different kind of society.
- 13:48Speaker 3: And Chevron is a reflection of the fact that we
- 13:52Speaker 3: have a society that's changed and where agencies are both
- 13:56Speaker 3: Republican and democratic. Administrations wield a great deal of power
- 14:01Speaker 3: by necessity and also because Congress simply hasn't tackled although
- 14:05Speaker 3: those complex issues dealing with climate change, dealing with vaccines,
- 14:10Speaker 3: dealing with labor management policy, and so much more.
- 14:13Speaker 1: If they do away with Chevron, that's going to put
- 14:17Speaker 1: more bonus on Congress to directly tackle policy issues and Congress.
- 14:25Speaker 1: Congress has not been so adept in the last years
- 14:29Speaker 1: at doing that.
- 14:31Speaker 3: Absolutely correct, I think that doing way with Chevron and
- 14:34Speaker 3: limiting deference to agencies pushes the ball back in Congress's lap,
- 14:38Speaker 3: and the question is what will Congress do with it.
- 14:41Speaker 3: We have seen Congress over the years be more and
- 14:44Speaker 3: more willing to give up power to agencies because they're partisan,
- 14:49Speaker 3: because they're more involved in re election campaigns, whatever the
- 14:53Speaker 3: issue may be. And I am not convinced that doing
- 14:57Speaker 3: away with Chevron will affect actively prod Congress to be
- 15:01Speaker 3: more responsible and to actually do more in terms of legislating.
- 15:05Speaker 3: If you're optimistic, maybe that's what the Court is trying
- 15:08Speaker 3: to get Congress to do, and if so, it's a
- 15:12Speaker 3: noble effort, But I'm not sure it's a winning effort.
- 15:14Speaker 3: And the predicament that our country may phase is if
- 15:19Speaker 3: agencies have much less authority and Congress doesn't pick up
- 15:23Speaker 3: the slack and become more active, we may end up
- 15:27Speaker 3: in a worse situation than we are today. Rather have
- 15:30Speaker 3: agency action supervised by the Chief executive and reflecting the
- 15:34Speaker 3: Chief executive's policy preferences, then we'd rather have no kind
- 15:38Speaker 3: of guidance whatsoever.
- 15:40Speaker 1: If Congress doesn't step in. Does that mean the courts
- 15:44Speaker 1: will have more power without Chevron?
- 15:48Speaker 3: Well, clearly, in the short run, the move to dump
- 15:52Speaker 3: Chevron gives more power to the courts because courts will
- 15:56Speaker 3: not be sharing the authority to interpret staff with agencies.
- 16:02Speaker 3: They will do it on their own. And of course,
- 16:05Speaker 3: if Congress doesn't change the terms of these broad open
- 16:09Speaker 3: statues that they've already delegated to agencies such as the
- 16:13Speaker 3: Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Labor, and so much more.
- 16:17Speaker 3: Then it's up to courts to step in to say
- 16:20Speaker 3: whether these agencies have read these broad statues correctly or not.
- 16:25Speaker 3: So in the short one, clearly the courts would get
- 16:28Speaker 3: more power. The question is in the long run whether
- 16:31Speaker 3: Congress would take up the dialogue and legislate more and
- 16:35Speaker 3: legislate more carefully with specific language, which would then take
- 16:39Speaker 3: away power from the courts, because it would then be
- 16:42Speaker 3: Congress which would be making all of those hard decisions
- 16:45Speaker 3: about what kind of anti pollution measures are appropriate, what
- 16:50Speaker 3: kind of phishing conservation issues are appropriated, as in this
- 16:54Speaker 3: particular hearing controversy, you know what kind of insecticides can
- 16:58Speaker 3: be used in different kind of program, and what kind
- 17:01Speaker 3: of reimbursements can be used under Obamacare. Congress hasn't wanted
- 17:04Speaker 3: to insert those kind of details in legislation, and it's
- 17:08Speaker 3: hard to do that, and so Congress has chosen not to.
- 17:10Speaker 3: But perhaps if the Court decides to knock down Chevron,
- 17:16Speaker 3: there will be at least a little more incentive for
- 17:18Speaker 3: Congress to do its job and legislate more and legislate
- 17:22Speaker 3: more carefully.
- 17:23Speaker 1: Just to clarify the Court could decide this case without
- 17:27Speaker 1: knocking out Chevron.
- 17:28Speaker 3: One of the issues that the Court said that it
- 17:30Speaker 3: will consider is whether, in the face of congressional silence,
- 17:35Speaker 3: can an agency power ever be implied and as applied
- 17:40Speaker 3: to this case. Congress clearly said that the agency has
- 17:44Speaker 3: the power to install monitors on ships to protect against
- 17:49Speaker 3: over phishing, but it didn't say clearly whether the agency
- 17:53Speaker 3: had the power to require the hering industry to pay
- 17:58Speaker 3: for the observers themselves. So they could hold that you
- 18:01Speaker 3: can never imply a duty or a power from silence,
- 18:06Speaker 3: and this power would be whether or not the agency
- 18:09Speaker 3: can require the private industry to pay for the observers.
- 18:13Speaker 3: So if the Court limits its holding to that ground,
- 18:17Speaker 3: it would just be another limitation of when Chevron could
- 18:21Speaker 3: be applied. Chevron could still be applied to questions what
- 18:23Speaker 3: does a vessel mean? For instance, what does herring mean?
- 18:26Speaker 3: Those kinds of terms could still be subject to Chevron deference,
- 18:30Speaker 3: But you could never imply a power that wasn't explicitly
- 18:33Speaker 3: given in the statue, And.
- 18:35Speaker 1: We'll have to wait until next term to find out.
- 18:37Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Hal. That's Professor Harrald Krant of the Chicago,
- 18:40Speaker 1: Kent College of Law. And that's it for this edition
- 18:43Speaker 1: of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get
- 18:46Speaker 1: the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You
- 18:49Speaker 1: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www
- 18:53Speaker 1: dot bloomberg dot com slash podcast Slash Law, And remember
- 18:58Speaker 1: to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at
- 19:01Speaker 1: ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 19:04Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg