Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / We Take the Big Five Personality Test (2021 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So Burto. Today's episode is just going to be for patrons of the podcast,
- 0:03but I thought we would do an introduction. The reason why I want
- 0:07this to be for patrons only is because you and I are going to be
- 0:10taking a personality test that is pretty involved, and we'll be talking about our
- 0:15own personalities and our own voibles. Yeah, and I would rather not have
- 0:21that go to literally everyone on the planet. I usually try to limit that
- 0:25to just the patrons. So what do you say we find out what is
- 0:30wrong with the two of us? Berto? What do you say? Let's
- 0:33do it all right? Today is the episode of a podcast called Psychology and
- 0:38Seattle, and I am a co host called doctor Kirk Kanda. I'm a
- 0:42therapist and a professor. Who are you Berto? My name is Umberto,
- 0:46and I make deciduous Christmas trees. So this is a personality test that we're
- 0:53going to be taking. But Berto, what is personality? Yeah? It's
- 0:57funny you should ask. When I was about twelve or eleven, my cousin
- 1:02older cousin, she wasn't really my cousin. She was They called her my
- 1:04cousin, but she we weren't actually related. Good story. Yeah, But
- 1:08anyways, She was two years older than me, and she always dated these
- 1:12older guys, but I had a major crush on her, okay, And
- 1:17one day I remember she told me, well, the problem is you have
- 1:19no personality, right, You've said that, And I was like so puzzled
- 1:23by this. I'm like, person I have? How does one acquire personality?
- 1:27What do I have to do to have a personality? And it always
- 1:32haunted me to the rest for the rest of my days. How does one
- 1:36acquire personality? I think that the way we're meaning it is, you know,
- 1:41sort of like what is our behavior with others, you know, with
- 1:44ourselves in social situations and things like that. But there's apparently some magic out
- 1:49there that if you have the right personality, you'll get the right girl.
- 1:53Okay, So that's a part of personality. But in site and certainly in
- 1:57colloquial language, people say that person has personality, that person doesn't have personality.
- 2:01That is not the way we use it in psychology. Personality in a
- 2:06nutshell is, and this is my definition, the relatively consistent patterns of thinking,
- 2:14behaving, and feeling. So, in other words, Burdo, you
- 2:20consistently when you enter a party, are talkative, so that is a consistent
- 2:25pattern of behavior that we would say is a description of your personality. It
- 2:31makes us when you add up all the qualities of our personality, the big
- 2:36ones and the small ones, it distinguishes us from other people. So another
- 2:43way of thinking about this is that it's our interpretations. The way we interpret
- 2:49the world is based on our personality. Our emotional experiences and our emotional expressions
- 2:53are based on our personality. You know, if someone is very expressive,
- 2:59then that's a person, whereas another person doesn't show their heart and their sleeve
- 3:04there, that's another that's a part. It seems consistent over time, and
- 3:07when you have friends, you can describe them like that person is very warm,
- 3:12that person is very cold, that person is very ambitious, that person
- 3:16is very into children, that person is really into saving the planet, that
- 3:23person is very into their job or whatever. And our motivations and behaviors are
- 3:29based our personality. Research shows that, as with many things, it's a
- 3:34combination of biology and our experience. And there are various different models and theories
- 3:39regarding personality. I could talk about this forever and ever, but you know,
- 3:44commonly known models and theories are psychoanalytic, behaviorism, humanistic attachment, that
- 3:52kind of thing. But in terms of personality tests, Burdo, what are
- 3:55some popular personality tests out there? Breaks right? What else you've actually taken
- 4:01a few. Yeah, there's the I don't know what it's called, but
- 4:05there's the one where it gives you the like colors. Huh, what was
- 4:11it? What's that one? Well, we did anywhere like wed orange and
- 4:15okay, I don't know that one, but we did anyagram anagrams. Yeah,
- 4:18and astrology is another personality typology based on when you're born. Also you
- 4:25will see on Facebook, you know, which Harry Potter character are you?
- 4:30Right? Like like comparisonse to fiction? Right? And what makes all of
- 4:35these unscientific and not very useful, Burdo? Because they are. I mean,
- 4:42you know, so if we had enough samples, and you know,
- 4:46you had like aggregated it for a million people, and then you randomized all
- 4:51those million people, and then you actually tracked their behaviors in real life,
- 4:56and then you compared it to their answers, and then you could probably form
- 4:59something. But normally all these online tests they have nothing of that. It's
- 5:02just kind of for fun, you know. They r some high level generalizations
- 5:08and then okay, what yeah, right. I think what you're saying is
- 5:12that a good, valid, reliable personality test predicts behavior. It predicts our
- 5:17interpretations. For example, if the Meyers Briggs gives you a typology and it
- 5:25says you are this kind of person, it should be able to predict what
- 5:30a group. You know, if you take one hundred people with that typology
- 5:33with you know, E, NFJ or whatever, and you present them with
- 5:36a situation in a lab like you have to help someone but they're a jerkface,
- 5:45then we would see a signal there. There would be some kind of
- 5:47grouping based on the sixteen types. But what we find is that that's not
- 5:54true. What's another aspect of personality testing? Or you're saying that in order
- 6:00to make it like a scientific and helpful thing. Sorry, but you're saying
- 6:04that that's not true even of like Myers Briggs. Right, Oh, it's
- 6:08not true of anyagram. It's not true of astrology. It's not true that
- 6:11youre t Yeah, I thought you were talking about more of like the Facebook
- 6:13and the astrology ones. No, no, all of them. Facebook is
- 6:17just as unreliable as Myers Briggs and astrology and Anyagram, And it makes sense
- 6:23because Myers Briggs, Astrology, and Anyagraham we're all established by people pre science
- 6:28essentially, or Myers Briggs was during science, but it was developed unscientifically.
- 6:32It was developed based on an interpretation of young and it was just anecdotal.
- 6:39It's not based on it's not based on research, it's not based on observation.
- 6:42But and I'm not saying Myers Briggs is useless. I'm not saying Anyagraham
- 6:46is useless or astrology is useless. I'm just saying that we don't use it
- 6:49in psychology because it's not scientific interesting. So nowadays you could if you could
- 6:57get around the privacy aspects. But if you ask people enough questions and then
- 7:01had simply statistical correlation to all their actual decisions, then you could end up
- 7:09with a generated model of something that would would be predictive. And we do
- 7:14have We've approximated that, I mean, not every data point. If Facebook
- 7:17has that, that's what Cambridge Analytica was exploited. And curious as to what
- 7:23sort of type apologies they have. I mean, it's basically just based on
- 7:27capitalism. But but anyway, so why else are Myers Brigs astrology and integram
- 7:32and Facebook not considered useful to psychologists. Why else, Yeah, they're probably
- 7:40biased. What do you mean, They were probably developed with you know,
- 7:45certain cultural biases and geopolitical biases. Well, really, all personality tests have
- 7:50baked in bias because they're all developed by people with bias. So it also
- 7:56could be because of self reporting, right, So that's another issue. So
- 8:01let me just sort of calm through which I think you're zering on a little
- 8:03bit. But another thing is that your type changes too quickly and too often.
- 8:09So with Myers Briggs we found that because one of the things about a
- 8:15personality type is that it's presumably a consistent, relatively consistent part of your personality.
- 8:22Your personality can change over time, for sure, and we'll get into
- 8:26that later. But generally speaking, if you're talking about a type, we're
- 8:30talking about something that can, you know, sort of stay consistent at the
- 8:33very least month to month or day to day. Whereas with Myers Briggs,
- 8:39Astrology, Enneagram, and Facebook, you don't find that. You find that
- 8:43people when you test groups of people, they don't stay in the same category
- 8:48from day to day, which indicates that it isn't really measuring personality. It's
- 8:52measuring something else, like your mood that day or something, which is fine,
- 8:56but you can't call it a personality test. The other aspect of these
- 9:03tests is that the types aren't actually different, you know, like some typologies
- 9:07just highlight positive traits and common flaws, like you might hear someone say,
- 9:13for astrology, for example, you know, because you were born in this
- 9:16month, you are hardworking, responsible, pessimistic, and stubborn. Well,
- 9:22most people consider themselves to be hard working and responsible. I mean I'm guessing
- 9:28there's a minority of people who are just like, no, I'm a lazy
- 9:31sob. I mean everyone tries, you know, and stubborn. You know,
- 9:35I would say that, how do you quantify stubbornness? I mean everyone
- 9:41has a stubborn streak, right, and everyone has pessimistic pessimistic streaks, you
- 9:48know, that kind of thing. So when you have these typically astrology is
- 9:52like this about other enneagram is kind of like this as well, that when
- 9:56you tell people, you know, you take the tests, and you tell
- 10:00tell people what type they are, you can actually mix it all up and
- 10:05just say a random one back to someone and they're like, oh my god,
- 10:09that's so me, and that's one of the ways that you test these
- 10:11things. Now, I know there's people out there that love Myers Briggs,
- 10:16they love Enneagram, and that's fine. It can be useful. If it
- 10:20resonates with you, then great. But science has really tried to establish these
- 10:26tests because they're so widely used and they've been studied thousands upon thousands of times,
- 10:31and they've really tried to say, Okay, can this be useful as
- 10:35a personality construct and they've not been able to Now they've not been able to
- 10:39do that. Again, if it's useful, just like if going to if
- 10:43you're a Catholic, and that's useful to you, but science hasn't proven that
- 10:46God exists. I found, for example, I found that Myers Briggs useful
- 10:50at work because the people we did it as a team, and then it
- 10:56was it opened up a conversation about different work styles and being accepting of other
- 11:01work styles. Right, So if it facilitates a conversation and that enhances productivity
- 11:07and profit, then it was it did its intention? Did it actually test
- 11:13personality or a sess personality? Probably not? And then we had to write
- 11:16and read letters, our letters in our forehead and as we walk, people
- 11:20pointed and laughed. Yeah. The other thing that I can think of as
- 11:24to why some of these tests aren't very respected is that the types basically just
- 11:31summarize your responses, like if you said you know, because it's self report,
- 11:35and so one of the things too or false, I like sex,
- 11:39and you say true, and then there was so they ask like fifty questions
- 11:43and at the end they say you're the type of person who likes sex.
- 11:46And then the person's like, oh my god, gosh, this is true.
- 11:50Yeah. A lot of tests are actually like that, Like a lot
- 11:54of the enneagram and Facebook tests they're all kind of like that, and it's
- 12:00like, yeah, well you just asked a bunch of questions and then summarize
- 12:03the answers in a paragraph and it doesn't that doesn't mean anything. So well,
- 12:09it's like have you seen the ones about what's your spirit animal? Yeah,
- 12:13it's the same idea because it asks you things like would you rather fly
- 12:16right or swim? And then in the end it's like I am a fish.
- 12:20That's crazy. I know. So the tests that are actually used by
- 12:26psychologists and have you know, decades of testing to establish its validity and reliability,
- 12:35meaning that it the test seems to be consistent over time when it's administered
- 12:39to the same person overtime, and the typology that it generates tends to be
- 12:46predictive of other things. Are and you've taken the MMPI and the mcm I.
- 12:52I forgot those yes years ago, this would have been twelve years are
- 12:56long? They are, Yeah, four hundred questions. Yeah, I think
- 13:00the m mp I takes like two hours hours is boring to leading? Yeah,
- 13:05many the p A I, and then the Big five inventory is the
- 13:11BS So that's what we're going to talk about today is Big five. And
- 13:16some of these other tests actually get at the Big five. I think I'm
- 13:18pretty sure that p AI gets at it. But the Big five personality traits
- 13:24are in psychology the seemingly most scientific and most reliable in that when you test
- 13:33on the Big five. So Big five meaning there are five personality spectra that
- 13:39everyone sort of tests on, and that's what we're going to take, BURTLE,
- 13:43And it's like conscientiousness, right, openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion,
- 13:48agreeableness, and stable emotionally. Neuroticism is sort of the negative side.
- 13:56And so when we administer you tests and we give them a you know,
- 14:03we rate you on these five different spectra. We find that over time you
- 14:07tend to test similarly. They do change over time, potentially, but relatively
- 14:15stable over time, and it absolutely predicts behavior. There's so many studies showing
- 14:20that people who are more open react to this situation in this consistent in this
- 14:24consistent way. People who are high on neuroticism have more physical ailments. You
- 14:31know, there's all sorts of associations that seem to be born out from from
- 14:37this typology. And you know, for people out there, it might be
- 14:41a little surprising because you would think that personality would be pretty easy to categorize.
- 14:48You know, this person is an extrovert. Yeah, this person well
- 14:52introvert extroverts and actually is a is one of the things. But this person's
- 14:56sides. But even in that one, for example, as we've discussed before,
- 15:00a lot of us have aspects of both, right, you know,
- 15:03yeah, right, but the other dimensions, like, you know, this
- 15:07person is type A. You know, they're really ambitious, you know that
- 15:11kind of thing. And what we find is like it's really context dependent,
- 15:15right, Some people who are labeled as ambitious are just that way because of
- 15:22the constraints that the context provides for them. You know. An example of
- 15:26that for me is at Antioch when I first started as a full time professor,
- 15:31I was, you know, one of the youngest, if not the
- 15:33youngest professor on staff, and everyone was on average twenty years older than me.
- 15:39I was very intimidated and I was quiet. I didn't talk much at
- 15:43all. I kind of went into a mode of just survival. Half the
- 15:48time. I didn't know what anyone was even talking about, because at university,
- 15:52administrative talk is like a whole or the language, you know, and
- 15:56based on premises. I didn't really understand it at the beginning. And so
- 16:00in the beginning people called me reserved. But berto among my friends, no
- 16:04one would call me. I mean, I'm the you and I are the
- 16:08loud mouths. And so I know one more in our friendship group that's like
- 16:14that, Am I reserved or am I a loud mouth? Well, it's
- 16:18you know, it's it's context dependent and and we'll get into that. But
- 16:22so I want to we're going to take this test. It's going to take
- 16:25some time, so I don't know, forty questions. We're going to kind
- 16:27of discuss our answers, and it's going to be for patrons only, So
- 16:33if you want to hear the rest of this episode, become a patron of
- 16:36the podcast, and then you'll be able to hear this episode along with hundreds
- 16:41of other episodes that are really our best episodes, our patriot only episodes.
- 16:45Do it now, Berto right, do it now.