Latest / Newcomer Pod / Why Software Is Eating The Banks | Mercury CEO Immad Akhund, Then Lead Bank CEO Jackie Reses
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. Welcome to the Newcomer podcast.
- 0:03We've got two conversations from our Banking Summit.
- 0:07First up is my chat with Amada Kun, the CEO of Mercury,
- 0:12followed by Jackie Reese's former Top Square executive and
- 0:15now the CEO of Lead Bank. Both companies are competing
- 0:20aggressively where the banking business Mercury is a little bit
- 0:24more in the direct customer facing.
- 0:26It is not itself a bank. It is working with partner
- 0:30banks. Meanwhile, Jackie's lead bank is
- 0:35a Chartered Bank and is often sort of behind many of the
- 0:38financial technology product that you're familiar with.
- 0:41Give it a listen. Can you just start off why did
- 0:44why did you start Mercury? Actually, what is the founding
- 0:47story? Yeah, hi everyone.
- 0:49I've been doing startups since 2006 and then how many years has
- 0:54I have lost CAN 1617? And I was just always really
- 0:57frustrated with kind of the banking experience that I had.
- 1:00You know, in 2006 as an entrepreneur, everything sucked.
- 1:03Like, I remember like there's no slack, there was no Stripe.
- 1:07Like I did the thing that you did before Stripe existed, which
- 1:10is impossible. And then I had this idea for
- 1:12Mercury in 2013 and basically everything had improved apart
- 1:16from banking. And banking was the same kind
- 1:19of, you know not to be harsh to them, 100 year old institutions
- 1:22that like have the same product and you know, maybe they have a
- 1:25mobile app, but they're not like kind of this product led.
- 1:28And you know, frankly, the expectations I had for like
- 1:31software and services were just way higher and I didn't think
- 1:35the banks were going to build it.
- 1:37How long did it take to have something that people could use
- 1:40from the start of the business? Yeah.
- 1:42So I had this idea in 2013 and then I sold my previous company
- 1:46in 2016 and at the start of 2017 I was like OK, you know, I think
- 1:51I know what to do on the product and you know how to get
- 1:54customers, but I had no idea how to kind of launch a bank
- 1:58account. So basically 2017 I kind of
- 2:00started and you know at the same time I was having a kid and all
- 2:03this. So it wasn't like full time and
- 2:05then you know, figured out how to do it and we decided to go
- 2:09kind of the route where we partner with existing banks and
- 2:12it took us about a year and a half kind of from like starting
- 2:15building it to kind of doing bank partnership and getting
- 2:18everything live and launching in April 2019.
- 2:22And how transformative or not was the SVB crisis for Mercury
- 2:26like on the On the one hand, I imagine it's like, oh, we need a
- 2:29new bank account, you're easy to open.
- 2:31On the other hand, you know, if people are running to JP Morgan,
- 2:35are they, you know, going to a start up for their banking or
- 2:38how? How did that play out?
- 2:39For you, I thought it might be fun to do a little show of
- 2:42hands. I don't know how many
- 2:43entrepreneurs are there, but how many people use Mercury?
- 2:47All right. How many people from that used
- 2:50it because of March 2023 versus just before.
- 2:55So yeah, everyone there already used Mercury.
- 2:58So I think like you know, we've been doing this since 2019 and
- 3:03we've been growing, you know, fairly consistently and fairly
- 3:05fast. We, you know went from basically
- 3:08a nine person kind of seed stage company to raise the Series A
- 3:12and then the Series B in 2021 and you know 2023, especially
- 3:17March, it was definitely significant for us at the time.
- 3:20There was a you know, big blip. We got about 8700 kind of
- 3:24customers in a short. 8700, you say what percent increase that
- 3:30was or anything like? That, so we've said it before,
- 3:32we have about 100,000 kind of customers, more than 100,000
- 3:35customers live something like that.
- 3:38So you know you can get the rough idea.
- 3:40So we already, yeah, fairly big at the time, but it was
- 3:43definitely like a significant bump and obviously these
- 3:45customers were on the bigger side.
- 3:47In general, what it has done for us is it's really kind of kind
- 3:51of been an inflection point in terms of how fast we've been
- 3:54growing. So even since then you know
- 3:56we've been growing basically twice as fast as we were pre
- 3:58SVB. So like January and February
- 4:01this year was were our biggest, excluding that one month in
- 4:05March were by far biggest months we've ever had.
- 4:08And I think it's really when when I think about product, I
- 4:11think about like amazing user experience and all these things
- 4:15when you know when banks think about product they mean like
- 4:19what kind of loan they can sell you, right.
- 4:20So it's like a very different mindset and I think tech enabled
- 4:24companies and entrepreneurs like you know they're looking for a a
- 4:28banking service that that matches the rest of the
- 4:31expectations of the software they use all.
- 4:33Right. We've got a banking service or
- 4:35like you go to your website, you know, banking I think is the
- 4:37first word. But then you have this like we
- 4:39are not a bank, You know, we work with Choice Financial Group
- 4:42or whatever. I think people here are savvy
- 4:44enough to understand that probably, but the decision not
- 4:47to be a bank is a pretty core one.
- 4:50Why did you decide to be the software platform, work with
- 4:53banks and not be a bank yourself?
- 4:56I think in general, you know, people want to feel like their
- 4:59money's safe and people want a great product and they don't
- 5:02care too much if like mercury is a bank or not.
- 5:05And actually I think we can provide a much safer product by
- 5:09not being a bank. So by default, anyone that signs
- 5:11up to Mercury gets a sweep account, and we sweep it too,
- 5:14kind of 20, 20 banks underneath the hood.
- 5:17So it's. Like some of the traditional
- 5:18banks like will have sweep, but it's not default, is that sort
- 5:21of the 10? Yeah.
- 5:21I mean, yes, you have to jump through a lot of hoops to get
- 5:25these kinds of things at banks. Yes, it's possible, like they
- 5:28call it ICS, but it's not easy. And then, you know, we also have
- 5:31kind of U.S. government T bill product called Mercury Treasury
- 5:34that makes it very easy to put your money together.
- 5:36And that's something we launched over the weekend when this SVB
- 5:40crisis happened. We launched something called
- 5:42Mercury Vault, which helps you understand where your money is
- 5:45and we also extended FDIC insurance from 1,000,000 to kind
- 5:48of three and then 5 S overall. I think it matters a lot more to
- 5:54be kind of a Chartered Bank if you are doing lending.
- 5:58I think, you know, there's not that many fintechs that pulled
- 6:00on like at scale lending without being a bank, but in terms of
- 6:05providing depository services, payments, kind of all the
- 6:08software that you need to run your business, you I don't think
- 6:11you need to be a bank. Are you going to re evaluate the
- 6:13decision? I mean, we look at it every
- 6:15year. Yeah, in the UK actually most of
- 6:19the new banks became banks because the UK has like some
- 6:23kind of fintech friendly charters.
- 6:25So does Germany and Brazil. So yeah, the US hasn't done
- 6:29that. Are you in the UK?
- 6:31No. So that's your way of saying,
- 6:33oh, if we wanted to go to the UK, we would have to become a
- 6:35bank. No, I mean there's also other
- 6:38ways and you can partner there as well.
- 6:39I'm just from the UK. So I was thinking, I always
- 6:42think about the UK and and like that was actually part of
- 6:45Mercury's inspiration. Like there's a lot more, you
- 6:48know, now actually the US has got up to some extent, but in
- 6:512017 there was a ton more innovation in kind of new
- 6:55banking in in Europe. What are the main ways right now
- 6:58that Mercury generates revenue? Yeah.
- 7:01So we have 5:00 or so revenue streams.
- 7:03We have a lot of deposits and we have a very deposit rich kind of
- 7:06customer base. So we make money both on on our
- 7:09treasury but we have kind of fees on it.
- 7:12And the Treasury is like, you run that, Yeah.
- 7:15And the deposits? The bank runs it and pays you
- 7:17some money. Yes, exactly.
- 7:18So those are two. And then we have both credit
- 7:20cards and debit cards and we get interchange on those and we also
- 7:23have FX and we also have a venture debt lending book we
- 7:26make, We get fees, but we work with the bank on that and we get
- 7:29fees from that as well. You're just like a funnel to
- 7:31them, basically. Well, we do all the servicing
- 7:33origination, but they do the balance sheet part.
- 7:36And would you want to do lending yourself?
- 7:38Well, we'll probably, we're not a bank, so we can't, we can't do
- 7:41it using our deposit. So we always have like some
- 7:43balance sheet provider for it. But yeah we're we're going the
- 7:46lending book as well. Venture debt is our current
- 7:49current kind of product there, but we're kind of experiment
- 7:51experimenting with others. I mean a big theme of the day
- 7:54has been what's the state of relationship banking, right?
- 7:58I mean we've got like several banks whether are basically
- 8:01Stifle or citizens or whatever that are premised on, you know,
- 8:05you liked us at this bank, you'll love us at this bank, you
- 8:09know, so that's a belief in relationship banking.
- 8:12I think Matt's presentation was very sort of skeptical of that
- 8:16model. If people are able to use like
- 8:18generative AMI models to price shop and sort of that inertia
- 8:23goes away and people are much more conscious of getting the
- 8:25best deal, you know you're you're sort of focused on
- 8:28product. What do you think of
- 8:29relationships when it comes to banking?
- 8:32Yeah, I mean, my experience, experience with relationship
- 8:36banking was I need to send a wire and I literally cannot
- 8:40figure out how to do it. Please help me.
- 8:42Which like to me never felt like a relationship.
- 8:46It felt very transactional and like painful and with Mercury
- 8:49you don't have to do that. I think there is an element of
- 8:52like, OK things are getting complicated.
- 8:54I'm considering loan options and and things like that and I think
- 8:57for those relationships matter a little bit more.
- 9:00I would say ideally the there is a a product that can answer your
- 9:04questions right. Like as I mean if you take
- 9:06lending ideally it's like hey we already have your banking data
- 9:10and like has a generated loan that you just click on to
- 9:13accept, right. Like I think that would be the
- 9:14better customer experience. But you know we, we have
- 9:17relationship managers now and we do that as well.
- 9:19But yeah, I don't think that's the future.
- 9:21I think the future is a product based approach to to banking and
- 9:26I think frankly that that's kind of one people want.
- 9:28There's definitely elements where you know you want to make
- 9:31sure there's someone there and sometimes like that human can
- 9:35really help you. But you know, maybe the AI can
- 9:37answer all your questions. Yeah.
- 9:38OK, so I was going to ask about AI, like generative AI.
- 9:40Yeah, I'm sure you're experimenting with it.
- 9:44Where? Where do you think it might be
- 9:45useful to your business? Yeah, I mean I think the first
- 9:48part of maths presentation on the Gen.
- 9:51AI thing is like, hey, increases efficiency.
- 9:54I think there's definitely elements of that and we already
- 9:56experimenting, you know, when it comes to fraud and things like
- 9:59that, there's always been machine learning anyway.
- 10:00And yeah, there's other I I don't know if Jenny AI pays a
- 10:04big piece there, but customer service understanding, you know,
- 10:07even something like receipts, like it's way better to like OCR
- 10:10them using kind of these modern techniques.
- 10:13So there's lots of like this kind of efficiency things to be
- 10:15had and that's where our focus has been.
- 10:18On on the regulatory front, I mean, there's clearly been some
- 10:23push for fintech companies have a tighter relationship with the
- 10:28underlying banks. Or how would you characterize
- 10:31sort of the pressure and feedback that you're getting in
- 10:35terms of your banking partners and how how much they want them
- 10:38to be involved with your business?
- 10:40On a high level, 2021 saw a ton of innovation, like a lot of
- 10:45fintechs launched, but actually a lot of new partner banks came
- 10:49along that like previously were not partnering with fintechs
- 10:52that started partnering with it. So, and then, yeah, when there
- 10:56was a crypto crisis of 2022, there's a lot of companies that
- 11:00kind of had issues. And then obviously the SVB
- 11:02thing, the regulator. Saying those were red flags.
- 11:04It's like crypto. Yes, the Fintech from a
- 11:09regulatory. Perspective.
- 11:10It's like, hey, we need to check out what's happening in Silicon
- 11:13Valley, right? And that's fair.
- 11:15We've always kind of operated on like, you know, we do business
- 11:18banking like we're not doing any weird crypto thing, right?
- 11:22Like. I mean, I like crypto, but.
- 11:24No crypto for Mercury. Well, we're not doing any crypto
- 11:27products, but yeah, we've always done like fairly vanilla
- 11:30products but just in from a regulatory perspective, but but
- 11:34you know obviously packaged in a really nice way and we've always
- 11:36felt that compliance and risk is like a very important thing for
- 11:39us to get right and we've always invested heavily in it.
- 11:42So I think the current regulatory scrutiny and both
- 11:47fintechs and these banks having to kind of look at what they're
- 11:51doing and go, hey, you know are we are we doing this in like a
- 11:54fully compliant way. I think it's healthy and we're
- 11:56going to come out of this with there'll probably be less
- 11:59fintechs and there'll probably be less kind of banks that work
- 12:02with fintechs. But the ones that come out on
- 12:04the other side will be in a kind of much healthier position and
- 12:07with like you know, products that hopefully are in a position
- 12:11where they can scale. How does it translate on just
- 12:13cost or you know, are you just having to do more work telling
- 12:17your banking partners about customers or is it having.
- 12:21Yeah. Does it, does it change for the
- 12:22cost structure of your? Business, I don't think it
- 12:24changes the unit economics and costs significantly.
- 12:27I think it's you know you can still and like you know
- 12:32businesses like Mercury will always have like a lot more kind
- 12:35of automation and and even when we have people we can give them
- 12:38a lot of leverage with the tools we build.
- 12:40So we have our own risk product team and we build, yeah, we
- 12:43still use third parties, but a lot of our tools are built
- 12:45internally. So we can like do things really
- 12:47fast and with a lot of information.
- 12:49So overall, I don't think it changes the risk like it doesn't
- 12:54change the, you know, economics. What we've tried to really be
- 12:56careful about is, you know, how does it change the user
- 12:59experience. And actually, you know, one of
- 13:03the things to think about is like a lot of the time when
- 13:05people complain about their banking or financial services
- 13:08experience, but they're really complaining about is like my
- 13:11account froze. I couldn't get this thing done
- 13:13or it was slow to do this. And those are all like actually
- 13:15like compliance and risk friction.
- 13:18So how do we do that in a way that actually like is some of
- 13:22the friction is necessary, but but I don't think it's all
- 13:25necessary, right? Like if you've already collected
- 13:27the document on the user, like let's make sure that we don't
- 13:29have to ask them again, right? Or like preemptively if we know
- 13:33something's going to come up, let's try to be ahead of it.
- 13:35So that's the kind of thing we think about.
- 13:36It all you basically you work with two banks right now, right?
- 13:40Well, it's complicated, but yeah, we have two main partner
- 13:42banks, but we also have kind of two providers on the
- 13:44international payment side, yeah, and we also with Mercury
- 13:47Treasury will work with Apex as our custodian.
- 13:50Is that a good equilibrium or is there sort of an ideal, you
- 13:55know, one banks, mini banks or how do you think about why have
- 13:59two or I? Think 2:00 is a good number,
- 14:02maybe three is slightly better, but I don't think.
- 14:05I think one is bad because you need redundancy and I think it's
- 14:08as a fintech is responsible to have like multiple partners that
- 14:11you can work with. I think if you have more than
- 14:14three, it's just going to be a lot of work to follow all the
- 14:17all the rules and make sure everyone is like fully abreast
- 14:20on things. So I I think 2:00 is a good
- 14:22number for us. It's yeah, we have a really
- 14:24strong and deep relationship with both the partner bank.
- 14:27So you know we talk directly with them both in terms of the
- 14:30technology side and the kind of compliance counterparts and
- 14:33things like that. So yeah, And it's important for
- 14:36us to go really deep there. You know, we heard I I think on
- 14:38the rippling panel, this idea, OK, where you really need to dig
- 14:41deep with partner banks, especially if you're like a big
- 14:44company. You know, I've been hitting on
- 14:47this team, but like you know, Mercury is the brand, but then
- 14:52it sort of leads your customer not to do or think about the
- 14:56underlying banks or how much, I guess when you're dealing with
- 14:58bigger customers, are you spending more time educating
- 15:01them on the banks behind Mercury?
- 15:04So I think Matt Harris said this and I completely agree that I
- 15:08don't think our customers should be checking the balance sheet
- 15:11of. I mean also like did you see his
- 15:13graphs like who's going to who is who here even.
- 15:17And we're banking experts as like you know qualified to look
- 15:20at all this data to make an assessment on their on their
- 15:23bank. And like you know were people
- 15:24looking at SVB data and going like oh this might have a bank,
- 15:27bank run. So I don't think that's
- 15:29realistic. I mean, I think it's much better
- 15:31to go like, hey, we have 5 million FDIC insurance and
- 15:35anything above that you can put into U.S. government T-bills.
- 15:38Like you know that is something where we can help our customers
- 15:42understand how that works. And we have a lot of information
- 15:44and we have this product called Vault where we explain it.
- 15:47But I feel like that's the answer.
- 15:49I think I don't think the answer is everyone's going to become
- 15:51bank experts. I'm going to open it up to
- 15:53questions soon. How?
- 15:55How is it been living through the Fintech hype cycle or where
- 15:59where are we right now? You know what?
- 16:01What's your read on the mood in terms of venture capital and and
- 16:05fintech companies like your own? Yeah, I mean, you know, 2021,
- 16:09serious hype cycle. I've been in the Valley since
- 16:112007, so I'm like a little, little immune to these things.
- 16:15But you know, I much prefer building a company outside a
- 16:18hype cycle. It's easier to hire people and
- 16:22you know, you get less competition like there was a
- 16:24while where everyone was like every single product is going to
- 16:27have a bank account attached to it.
- 16:28I was, I was skeptical. But you know obviously as a
- 16:32startup I'm like well maybe the whole every single company is
- 16:34going to compete against us or something.
- 16:36But I think it's it's healthier. And yeah overall like I just
- 16:42looked this up because I, I I was, I was like what percentage
- 16:45of GDP is financial services, So it's 8.3% according to the quick
- 16:49Google I did earlier. So that's huge, right.
- 16:52And I I think the the trends that are underlying it, yeah,
- 16:57everyone's interacting with things on their phone as
- 17:00generative AI trend that Matt talked about.
- 17:02Like it's inevitable that most people will relate to financial
- 17:06services via tech products. Some of that's going to be from
- 17:10existing banks, but I think a lot of it is going to be from
- 17:14fintechs. So.
- 17:15So I think these trends are going to go on for a long time.
- 17:18You know, I'm happier to do it outside of Hype Cycle, though.
- 17:21Any questions? The question was where does Bass
- 17:24two point O go? I think, you know, there's this
- 17:27movement. There was a moment in time where
- 17:31a lot of banks wanted to work with fintechs, but they couldn't
- 17:34do it easily. And you know Bass kind of sprang
- 17:37up as like the middleman in the space.
- 17:39I think the next set of things is banks either themselves or
- 17:44working with technology providers to have Bass
- 17:47internally and that's basically what we're saying.
- 17:49So you know, column and lead are these two kind of bass banks
- 17:54where you know we have Silicon Valley people go buy a bank and
- 17:57then apply technology to it. The two banks we work with,
- 17:59Choice and Evolve, have built all of the tech internally to
- 18:04you know, to work with us and to work with other fintechs.
- 18:07I really think that's the future and not just from a regulatory
- 18:11perspective. It's also just like, you know,
- 18:13if you can remove the middleman and there's one less person
- 18:15taking margins, like it's just kind of an inevitability.
- 18:19So that's where I see it going. And I think that's like if you
- 18:22go three years from now, I would think most banks will be working
- 18:25directly with fintechs, especially at scale.
- 18:28I think the the bit that the middle men do really help with
- 18:31is when you're first starting out, when Mercury launched,
- 18:34there was only nine of us at Mercury and that would have been
- 18:36quite hard to get like a direct bank partnership done and be
- 18:40able to service that fully. Leads next, like, have you
- 18:43thought about working with them or lead or call them or, yeah.
- 18:47We don't work with them currently, but I'm a huge fan of
- 18:50Jackie. Where is she?
- 18:53Hi, Jackie and and William over columns.
- 18:57So I'm sure we will at some point.
- 18:59Yeah, I guess depends why you're looking for diversification.
- 19:01I think the way the sweep network works and you know
- 19:04Mercury treasury like at least in terms of like putting your
- 19:07money somewhere safe, I think that we've got that covered and
- 19:11Mercury's been profitable for the last six, I guess almost
- 19:14seven quarters. So you know, we feel like we're
- 19:16in a very stable place and we think about the long term.
- 19:19So I would say you should. You'll be happy with Mercury.
- 19:23So just one bank. Sure.
- 19:24I mean, we're not one bank. We're flat.
- 19:28We're not a bank at all, actually.
- 19:30If if you were to start a fintech company today, besides
- 19:34your own, is there an area you're excited about or where
- 19:38would you? You know, honestly, I'm pretty
- 19:39excited about these Gen. AI agents.
- 19:41Someone's going to have to make those actually invested in a
- 19:43company building like fintech Gen.
- 19:45AI agents. I think those are really cool.
- 19:47What do they do? Well, they're not live, so I
- 19:50won't say exactly what they do, but it's this exact thing.
- 19:52It's like, hey, if you want to buy car insurance or mortgage,
- 19:57like who wants to click those buttons?
- 19:59Like have it automated, find me the best one, swap it out
- 20:02whenever something cheaper comes.
- 20:03You know, it's like that kind of thing.
- 20:05My, my final question, you know, it's sort of this, this same
- 20:08take stock question I've been asking like as a founder, you
- 20:12know, watching like an institution like Silicon Valley
- 20:15Bank unravel, like did you do anything differently afterwards
- 20:19or how did it change your perspective as a CEO?
- 20:23I mean for us it was a is a weird moment, right?
- 20:26Because they were the 800 LB gorilla competitor for us,
- 20:30right? Like when we when we launched,
- 20:32yeah. People would say like Oh yeah,
- 20:34why would I not use SVB instead of Mercury?
- 20:36Like it was always a always a thing.
- 20:39And then you know, post March, like, I don't know if we've been
- 20:44fully reversed, but it feels like a very different world,
- 20:47right? Like now when I talk to
- 20:49customers, it's, yeah, I'm sorry, Mark from SPB.
- 20:52But when I talk to customers, it's mostly like should I use
- 20:55JPMC or should I use Mercury? Like those are the conversations
- 20:58now. So like the paradigm has shifted
- 21:00quite a bit. And yeah, I was really sad about
- 21:03it. Like I used SPB in my previous
- 21:05company and you know, I think even though we were competing
- 21:09against them, like I never thought badly of them.
- 21:10I think they're like great people.
- 21:12The yeah, it was a sad moment. It also gave us this opportunity
- 21:15to grow Foster. Great.
- 21:17I'm on. Thank you very much.
- 21:18Yeah. Thanks for having me.
- 21:20Jackie Rhesus, lead bank. Thank you for joining me.
- 21:23Of course I'm happy too. So yeah, you are a bank and a
- 21:27fintech all in one. Yes, I've built one and I've
- 21:31bought 1. How did you become a bank?
- 21:33Tell us that story. I went and bought one, having
- 21:35built one as a de Novo charter at Square.
- 21:38It was one of the most painful experiences of my life.
- 21:41One of my Co founders is here, her mom.
- 21:44It was probably the most painful experience of his life as well
- 21:48because he spent years working with the FCIC teaching and
- 21:52working on algorithmic lending for example, and going through
- 21:56how machine learning works. But in that process, you realize
- 22:00when you write the first lines of code and you write the first
- 22:03set of policies and procedures that you get to think about
- 22:08banking in a first principles mindset of like what should this
- 22:12be and how would I build it? And so it really changes the
- 22:15framework for how you would think like, huh, I have just
- 22:19started from zero. I'm going to build the ultimate
- 22:22bank. Now in that context, we were
- 22:25able to think of that, but we are only serving one customer.
- 22:29And so it became that's a square, but it made it more
- 22:34obvious that no one had built the bank we wanted to be.
- 22:39And we had worked across the industry with many of what I
- 22:43would describe as the best banking partners even still out
- 22:47there while we were at Square. And we saw many challenges as a
- 22:50customer. And so given that we decided
- 22:55that there was a better way to do this and there are four of us
- 23:00who left Square, Erica Khalili and Ronak Vias.
- 23:02So that my other two Co founders.
- 23:05And we searched across the country for a certain profile of
- 23:12charter that we were looking for that we thought would maximize
- 23:17the opportunity of banking as a service.
- 23:21And we went and found the best high quality company we could
- 23:26and that's lead bank. And lead bank was owned by a
- 23:30very old school family in Kansas City that we're very well known.
- 23:36You know the mom who is the chairman of the bank is the
- 23:39chairman of the Symphony. Very philanthropic city.
- 23:42The banks are absolutely gorgeous.
- 23:44If you walk in, you'd be amazed. Are you still operating?
- 23:48The absolutely. We're a part of the community
- 23:50and. Are the owners involved anymore?
- 23:53We are now the owners, so they're gone.
- 23:55We bought it 100%, but we thought very methodically about
- 24:02what charter we wanted, what company we wanted, what kind of
- 24:05employees we wanted, in what kind of location and in what
- 24:08state. And so we ended up with an A+
- 24:13opportunity because even if everything wasn't perfect at
- 24:17lead before we owned it, and there are examples where you're
- 24:20like, oh, that's kind of, you know, not perfect in their
- 24:24history. It had the infrastructure and
- 24:28mindset of the team that we could use to go build and
- 24:34continue to grow banking as a service.
- 24:37How big was the acquisition? About $52 million.
- 24:42And what was the first product that you want to provide or what
- 24:47would it be when you bought it and you're like, OK, now we are
- 24:49a Fintech bank, like what was the beginning?
- 24:52The best part of lead was that they already were a Fintech bank
- 24:55and they had wonderful clients. And so we were able to take what
- 24:59was already there and supplement with some of the world's
- 25:03greatest engineers. And so our engineering team is
- 25:06amazing. We knew almost everybody that we
- 25:10hired right out of the gate. They all came from Square, from
- 25:13Stripe, from Yahoo. They'd built some of the largest
- 25:15payment systems in the world. They built some of the largest
- 25:18banking systems in the world and several of them have accounting
- 25:23degrees and Cfas. And so they have been through
- 25:27the ringer with us in prior circumstances around building
- 25:30out AP is for banking products. And so we took what was already
- 25:35a strong banking as a service partner bank and then added us,
- 25:41added the engineering and product team, added a much
- 25:46deeper compliance and legal team.
- 25:48And with that came extreme product market fit and I will
- 25:53say extreme product market fit. And so we don't have sales, we
- 25:57don't have marketing. We have inbounds of people who
- 26:02know us, who have been credentialized through people we
- 26:05know, through compliance teams we know, and we have an extreme
- 26:10level of inbound interest in working with us.
- 26:12Your partners like what are they getting like?
- 26:14What is? What services are you providing?
- 26:17So 4 main product areas. So lending, all kinds of
- 26:21lending. AP is around any kind of card
- 26:24product, any kind of loan product by now, pay later
- 26:27accounts, so either virtual accounts or actual Ddas that you
- 26:32might need payment rails. So all kinds of money movement,
- 26:36things like that. And then issuing.
- 26:39And so card issuing been sponsorship, things like that.
- 26:42The only thing we don't do and don't have on our road map right
- 26:45now is acquiring and it's just frankly because of our size,
- 26:50we're about a billion won in assets right now.
- 26:53And when we're bigger in size, I think we'd look at doing
- 26:57acquiring in the future. It's just not anywhere on our.
- 27:00We have so much to build with such strong inbound demand.
- 27:04Do you want a customer facing brand at all or you want to be
- 27:07facilitating other companies to build those brands?
- 27:09So in Kansas City, our home market, we take a really active
- 27:14presence and we have amazing customers.
- 27:17We have 3000 customers in. Is that a regulatory strategy?
- 27:21Or it's a strategy to stay active in the market because the
- 27:26purpose of community banks in a local market is to serve the
- 27:30community. And we are blessed with a great
- 27:33group of clients, some of whom I've become really good friends
- 27:36with. And there's someone here from
- 27:39Kansas City. Where is he?
- 27:40Where'd you go? There he is.
- 27:41And he knows where we're at in Kansas City and likes how we
- 27:45show up. Thank you very much.
- 27:46And you know, there's no reason to stop it.
- 27:48We have an amazing customer. Base but you were saying that is
- 27:51the public facing part. It's the.
- 27:53Public facing part. We have a app.
- 27:55It's built by Fiserv. It's awful.
- 27:57If Frank were here, I'd ask that he update the design of that app
- 28:02on behalf of community banks across the United States.
- 28:05But that is a customer facing community bank app.
- 28:08And so most of the business locally is real estate
- 28:12developers. They're not in office, they're
- 28:14in mixed-use kinds of activities.
- 28:17We don't have any issues with regard to liquidity deposits,
- 28:23bad loans. The bank actually operated
- 28:27pretty clean from a lending point of view and we diligence
- 28:30that pretty actively. And then the, the other part of
- 28:33the business which is the growth is banking as a service.
- 28:38But interestingly even some of our local clients want to use
- 28:41like ACH rails because they're a real estate developer and they
- 28:44want to work with clients to do ACH.
- 28:47And while their volume might be smaller because they're local,
- 28:50they love the fact that we could bring technology feedback to
- 28:53them to support their own banking needs.
- 28:56That's not everybody out of the 3000.
- 28:58Maybe that's 20, but it feels good to be able to change the
- 29:03nature of what we do in a local community and bring technology
- 29:06expertise to Kansas. Who are some of your bigger
- 29:08customers that you can talk about or?
- 29:11There are only a few that are public and one of our strategies
- 29:16is to not really talk about our customers, let them talk about
- 29:19us if they want to. And so we show up on a few
- 29:22websites like RAMP and a firm, a few other fintechs like Flex and
- 29:27Credit Key. But otherwise I don't know that
- 29:30anyone's put us on their website, so I won't comment.
- 29:33Our clients are some of the biggest e-commerce, fintech big
- 29:37and Scaling also fintech e-commerce consumer companies.
- 29:41We have many public companies on our rails.
- 29:44We have many up and comers of people that came through our
- 29:48network that we know that we want to help support that we
- 29:50feel like have really good strong teams.
- 29:52We know who they are. We know who their compliance
- 29:54teams are and so we vet all the inbounds.
- 29:59But thankfully we're part of the tech community, so we usually
- 30:03know these folks and through someone in our network we have
- 30:08pretty good insight into what kind of operator they are and
- 30:11what the perspective is on the likely growth of their business.
- 30:14And so we do have several small small clients on our rails and
- 30:21then we also have some crypto companies on our rails.
- 30:24And we're one of the only banks in the US that's been through a
- 30:27full three-year exam with crypto that has been included in our
- 30:33bank and I. And I think that when when we
- 30:37went through those exams, I think it's because the depth of
- 30:39understanding of the team and the type of enhanced due
- 30:42diligence we did with those clients in order to take Fiat
- 30:46only currency. I think they believed through
- 30:50our behavior, through the understanding of the products
- 30:54that we were able to understand how to do enhanced due diligence
- 30:57and what's to look for with red flags.
- 30:59Outside of the community bank, do you hold a lot of customer
- 31:01deposits on behalf of these companies or it's mostly money
- 31:04passing through? So part of the strategy with
- 31:08fintechs is that in some cases for some of the products there
- 31:12is more liquidity that stays on your balance sheet.
- 31:15In some cases, it's very short duration and other cases it's,
- 31:19you know, holding customer funds on behalf of a Fintech because
- 31:23we work with fintechs to try to be a good partner to them and
- 31:27rate is 1 component of being a good partner to them.
- 31:30Rate is not our strategy though. And by any stretch of the
- 31:33imagination, what we build and how we execute from a technology
- 31:36point of view is the strategy. And so I'd say they come to us
- 31:40first for the way we build products and the way we operate
- 31:44from a compliance point of view and the way we are
- 31:47foundationally strong financially, how we operate
- 31:51across the balance sheet is just one component.
- 31:53How do you substantially substantiate that you're
- 31:56financially strong or what? What are the key?
- 31:58Signals. Oh, so then this was something
- 32:00that came up in the last discussion is people have to do
- 32:03due diligence on us. And thankfully we report numbers
- 32:07to the FDIC every quarter. And so everyone can pull up our
- 32:10call report and we advise fintechs before they choose a
- 32:14bank to go do reverse diligence. What are the key numbers?
- 32:17Give us some of the What will we find?
- 32:20We did about 140 million in sales last year, 55 million of
- 32:25what I described as gross profit and 16.4 million in net income
- 32:30and so we're billion want in assets.
- 32:33Those numbers are publicly available.
- 32:35There's nothing secretive about them.
- 32:37You're. Supposed to position this as a
- 32:39big route now. The big reveal?
- 32:40No, but you know, it's interesting as a size point of
- 32:43view because we're actually a pretty big partner bank size.
- 32:48You know most people want to partner with someone below the
- 32:50Durban size, which is $10 billion.
- 32:53So that they can make money on interchange.
- 32:55Well, you can make money either way.
- 32:56It's just a matter of the how the fees are calculated.
- 33:00But it's it's more that there aren't that many that are
- 33:03actually that big in scale. There's a handful and then when
- 33:07you look by product, there are only handful that are good at
- 33:10different kinds of products. And so we've already
- 33:13distinguished ourselves. You know, we bought this bank
- 33:15about two years ago. We've already distinguished
- 33:17ourselves in size pretty substantially and kind of
- 33:21separated ourselves from a, you know, a pack of of smaller
- 33:25players. And so when people do due
- 33:28diligence on us, first of all like our CF OS bio is
- 33:32extraordinary then you talk to her and you're like this woman
- 33:36knows what she is doing. She was the ex CFO of post
- 33:40bankruptcy Lehman Brothers. And so she managed the entire
- 33:43dissolution of their $132 billion balance sheet and has
- 33:48been had been working there for 10 years.
- 33:50And before that ran FP and A at Willis.
- 33:52And so she has an extreme level of detailed understanding of
- 33:58complexity of balance sheet at scale, and she has a detailed
- 34:04understanding of how to build unusual balance sheet structures
- 34:09in order to support the financing needs of clients.
- 34:13Then I'd make one more point. She doesn't come from tech.
- 34:18So she can look at us and call bullshit and say like, yeah, I
- 34:23get that, yeah, we're not going to do that and let's figure out
- 34:26why and what makes sense and why you're going to do something.
- 34:29And it helped makes the conversation better.
- 34:34When you're not all coming from a closed ecosystem of
- 34:37understanding, you want to have divergent perspectives in order
- 34:41to make the conversation smarter.
- 34:43And so she's a very can do person, I think she's incredible
- 34:46approach. But when a client goes and, you
- 34:49know, asks her questions about how we manage risk, how we
- 34:53manage introjay, money flows. Because I do think that's going
- 34:56to be the challenge of banks for the next few years because of
- 35:01the complexity of money moving soon 24/7 365, there's not
- 35:05enough volume yet, but it's coming and all the flows amongst
- 35:09all the counterparties are still not aligned yet.
- 35:12And so you know, I wanted someone who was going to
- 35:16understand that complexity, so. You're saying just the speed of
- 35:19money movement is going to become the core issue or I just
- 35:22want? To speed of money movement,
- 35:23velocity of what flows intraday, because most of the metrics that
- 35:28are looked at are measured at ends of periods.
- 35:34Ends of are not a distinctive moment for liquidity challenges.
- 35:39And in some cases there's mismatches of windows that
- 35:43operate between all different kinds of counterparties.
- 35:46That might be fine where you have closed Fed windows, and I
- 35:49think Matt touched on this a little bit.
- 35:51But when you are in a world with Fed now and 24/7 money movement,
- 35:57you have to make sure that every counterparty can pull to the
- 35:59same moment in time. And today that's not the case.
- 36:05Big question, but what is your, yeah, broad read on regulatory
- 36:09friendliness to fintechs right now or how much has sort of
- 36:13regulatory scrutiny changed how you operate?
- 36:17Where you operate within the guidelines and confines of the
- 36:19regulation, I haven't seen issues full stop where you're
- 36:24able to actually answer questions and substantively step
- 36:27back with a framework of understanding around how your
- 36:30clients operate. KYCKYB red flags, I haven't seen
- 36:35any issues full stop. Now, that doesn't mean that
- 36:40regulators are necessarily forward-looking to take
- 36:43proactive views of, you know, how the market's moving and
- 36:47they're not on their forefront or their their their forward
- 36:51foot trying to change the way banking operates to experiment.
- 36:56But last I checked, when the American taxpayer is insuring
- 37:00banks, I don't know that that we all as taxpayers want banking
- 37:06regulators to be flippant about risks that banks are taking.
- 37:10And so you know, you hope that where there's innovation and
- 37:16features of what people are doing around the edges that
- 37:19regulators were operate and understand them.
- 37:22But I think they need to see data 1st and you know I'm pretty
- 37:26thankful that they're pretty detailed in their analysis.
- 37:31And so where you have very high profile, high class, very strong
- 37:36compliant customers, I think they operate you know quite
- 37:42safely within the context of banks that they work with.
- 37:45Do you have to say no to your clients a lot or it's more just
- 37:48building the product in a way that?
- 37:50They can. It's definitely not a no.
- 37:51It's. Most of our clients are super
- 37:54high quality. They want to scale and they want
- 37:57to scale safely. Having a mistake from a banking
- 37:59point of view is existential. No one wants to do something
- 38:02stupid. And so the situation I'm am more
- 38:07likely to see is not understanding something.
- 38:11And when you explain it with a strong rationale, I rarely see
- 38:17instances of debate. But if you're taking a position
- 38:23on something, I'll give you an example.
- 38:25Used to drive me crazy that a bank I worked with in Utah would
- 38:29not let us do CBD loans and used to drive me crazy because I
- 38:35would say like, OK, but now, so when I go into Whole Foods,
- 38:38let's see, I mapped it out on Google and I think they're 1/2
- 38:41mile from you. When I go into Whole Foods and I
- 38:43buy CBD bubble bath and I put it on my Visa card and then that
- 38:49runs through Stripe. You're telling me that those
- 38:54products aren't banked. You know, in in However, like,
- 38:58yeah, I know, I know, I know. And you'd get like an answer of
- 39:02like, yeah, that seems kind of ridiculous, but let me just
- 39:06shrug my shoulders and say like, yeah, I don't get it, but we're
- 39:08not changing. Those answers are illogical And
- 39:12if in fact you and the way we try to respond to clients,
- 39:17respond with a better answer, better advice, a can do approach
- 39:21to solving their problems, we usually get pretty thankful
- 39:24people who are happy we've got their back.
- 39:28Open, Open to questions while people think about it.
- 39:32Well, when you started lead or now managing it, what was the
- 39:36main sort of leadership lesson you learned from your time at
- 39:39Square? What?
- 39:40What did you take from Square or what did you reject when you
- 39:43started at? So when I was at Square, I
- 39:46oversaw hundreds of licenses. So I ran a very heavy, heavily
- 39:51regulated part of Square. I was not just a tech executive
- 39:55or, you know, an engineer or product manager.
- 39:58I sat on top of lending and banking.
- 40:00And I started a bank first principles.
- 40:03And the thing I saw at Square, which I consider to be a very
- 40:07strong innovative fintech, was that owning a bank and operating
- 40:13a bank is a 10X delta in understanding compliance to
- 40:18working in a tech company. And the language you use and the
- 40:23mode of operation and the way that you run a company is night
- 40:27and day different. And even if you think because
- 40:30you sit on licenses like Mt LS, which is often what I hear, oh,
- 40:34we have Mt LS. We know what we're doing.
- 40:36Oh, this is a different world. And and so my learning I got to
- 40:42learn thankfully in the context of Square and living it every
- 40:46day was to appreciate the complexity of what it takes to
- 40:51do this. So that we could learn how to
- 40:54serve our clients better and help them scale, but make sure
- 40:59we never put ourselves in a position to risk the
- 41:03relationship that we have operating with our regulators.
- 41:08Question. One of the questions I had was
- 41:11around this trend towards like real time payments kind of money
- 41:15being moved instantly, I'm 24/7 and kind of gearing up towards
- 41:20you know a world where we do have instant money movement.
- 41:22Like what are the things that you're thinking about for a lead
- 41:25bank that you need to have to be prepared to be able to
- 41:29facilitate, you know, this huge volume to make sure that there's
- 41:33you know you're covered in terms of like anti fraud.
- 41:37Just curious, high level like how are you thinking about that
- 41:39transition? Yeah, for us around real time
- 41:42payments, I don't think there's anything from a technology point
- 41:47of view that we need to do today to be prepared for that.
- 41:50We actually haven't connected to Fed now yet, even though Mark
- 41:55Gold who runs it, I know very well from the Fed I have the
- 41:58world's most like unbelievable respect for him.
- 42:02We worked at the San Francisco Fed together.
- 42:04I would was an advisor to them for nine years and he's amazing
- 42:09and he's methodically going through the road map.
- 42:12But we didn't have client demand for it and so we just decided
- 42:15not to hook it up until we're ready.
- 42:18But our AP is and the way that we operate as a platform, as
- 42:25soon as we're ready, we're going to connect to Fed now.
- 42:28And I don't think there's anything we need to change.
- 42:30We're kind of we are ready and I think that's because of the
- 42:34sophistication of the systems we built thus far.
- 42:37And so whether it be any of the core money movement AP is or
- 42:41even our anomaly detection system, I think we're prepared
- 42:44for it from a fraud point of view.
- 42:47I do think they need more volume going through the system.
- 42:51And you know, up to now they've only had a few hundred banks
- 42:55involved. And at some point they have
- 42:59enough functionality. They open up the dollar value of
- 43:03each transaction you're allowed to send and the functionality
- 43:07grows enough that it actually can be an unbelievable platform.
- 43:12And that's when I think you're going to see unbelievable
- 43:16growth. Do you think that lead bank is a
- 43:18model for community banking in general, given there are lots of
- 43:22questions about the future of community banking?
- 43:24You know, I don't in a sense. One of the things that I think
- 43:27is problematic about many of the banks that have operated in
- 43:31banking as a service is that they've done it
- 43:34opportunistically. They've fallen into a client
- 43:37because of a lawyer, an accountant and an advisor.
- 43:40Or it came through their local area by fluke.
- 43:44But they're working with people who I don't think truly
- 43:46understand the products. And that's when I think banks
- 43:49get into trouble. If they're not able to explain
- 43:52the products to regulators, all of a sudden you get a very
- 43:56squishy feeling that it's unclear that they've done the
- 44:00appropriate amount of compliance KYBKYC checks that they need to
- 44:03be doing, or even red flags, SARS, you name it.
- 44:06And so I do. I'm very weary of banks trying
- 44:10to be opportunistic of doing that.
- 44:13Having said that, I do think there are models for banks to
- 44:17deploy technology in a better way than they do.
- 44:21And I think that would help community banking if their apps
- 44:25were better, if they were able to use applications that other
- 44:30fintechs who serve banks sell into that Channel.
- 44:35And so I do think there's a market for them to deploy third
- 44:39party technology in order to offer different kinds of
- 44:42services. I see a need for community
- 44:46banking. I see what we do at a local
- 44:48level. Even though I'm the biggest
- 44:50advocate for lending in context of where transactions happen, I
- 44:55think there's an AND not an OR and the AND is being part of a
- 45:00local community and lending to people that a fintech might not
- 45:04reach or supporting part of the community at the most local
- 45:09level with entrepreneurs who come in, you know and hang out
- 45:13in your office on a Tuesday and you know learn different
- 45:16financial skills. I just there's so many things
- 45:19that happen in order to make the texture of a community better.
- 45:23And so I don't know that we need 4000 banks, but we certainly
- 45:27need community banking across the United States to thrive.
- 45:30And so I do hope technology more integrates into the banks as
- 45:35opposed to banks deciding that they can necessarily go build
- 45:40for, you know, the most sophisticated technology
- 45:43companies in the world. Just just you get the last word
- 45:46like a zoom out sort of question.
- 45:48You know, it feels like sort of coming out of the wilderness or
- 45:51hopefully if there aren't more bank crises, you know, it's like
- 45:55Silicon Valley went through this SVB crisis, FRB, there were the
- 46:00crypto banks and then fintech overall is retrenched.
- 46:04You know, would you tell somebody to start a fintech
- 46:07company today? Or what message would you give
- 46:09people about what they should do going forward reacting to sort
- 46:13of all these, I don't know, traumas?
- 46:15Yeah, absolutely. I think you heard in our last
- 46:18presentation, it's, you know, a huge part of the economy, $25
- 46:24trillion of assets sit in the banking system.
- 46:27And the one thing I think is amazing about Fintech is that it
- 46:33provides real functionality that everybody uses every day.
- 46:37And so I do think they're such an incredible market
- 46:40opportunity. You know, it's really just open
- 46:43to creativity. Now, I think it's actually
- 46:46harder to build fintechs than it is many other kinds of companies
- 46:52because precision and regulation are two components of the
- 46:57ecosystem and value chain that have to be built where in some
- 47:01cases you don't need precision. And so I think there's
- 47:06incredible utility that fintechs provide.
- 47:08And because it's such an important part of the US
- 47:10economy, and because banking is such an old industry where more
- 47:14than 50% of the market cap is over 50 years old, there's an
- 47:18incredible room for invention everywhere along financial
- 47:23services, including in consumer companies.
- 47:27And this idea of having banking and financial transactions
- 47:31happen in context of where you are.
- 47:33It doesn't have to look like a bank app in order to be banking.
- 47:37Great. Jackie, thank you so much.
- 47:39Thanks everybody for coming. That's our episode.
- 47:42I'm Eric Newcomer. Thanks so much for listening.
- 47:45Shout out to G Co and Bain Capital Ventures for sponsoring
- 47:48the Newcomer Banking Summit. You can follow along with more
- 47:51coverage of the summit at newcomer.co and check out our
- 47:55YouTube channel, where we'll be posting conversations from the
- 47:58summit. Thanks so much.