Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #4 - What are the Red, Blue, and Purple States?
Transcript
- 0:00Who's ready for some politics?
- 0:02I know I am.
- 0:04Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about red, blue, and purple states.
- 0:13After all, election time is just around the corner, and there's a lot made about these red
- 0:19and blue and purple states.
- 0:21What exactly they are, and are they though typically in the context of presidential
- 0:26elections, but How exactly do you tell when a state is red or blue purple?
- 0:33Well, that's what we're gonna dive in today.
- 0:35So let's begin.
- 0:38We had bet best to start off with how blue and red even originated.
- 0:44It's been around for, at least you could say, about 100 40 years or, give
- 0:52or take.
- 0:53Although, not at all, like, what we think of it as today.
- 0:57It wasn't always red and blue.
- 1:00Every once in a while, sometimes other colors would be used.
- 1:03But when it was red and blue, it actually used to be more so that blue was used for
- 1:10Republicans or, for states or counties that voted Republican, and red was democratic.
- 1:17Reason being that blue was the color of the union in the civil war, and conservative
- 1:24parties in Europe and other countries and in in centuries elsewhere, they were also blue.
- 1:34So for some time, Blue was considered the color of the Republican party.
- 1:39Republicans being generally more conservative.
- 1:43Democrats generally being more liberal.
- 1:46But even as far back as 18 83 from a book called Scribner's Statistical Atlas of the
- 1:53United States, used blue for counties that had voted Republican and red for counties that had
- 1:59voted democrat.
- 2:01First use on TV seems to be the 19 seventies when Color TV became a lot more commonplace was
- 2:07a lot more common than black and white TVs.
- 2:11Couple of, sources I was, researching seemed to seem to have a little bit of conflicting,
- 2:18information as to which year exactly was the first, but, NPR seems to note that n p NBC in
- 2:271976 used blue for work Gerald Ford, the incumbent then, who went into office after
- 2:34Richard Nixon resigned following the Watergate scandal and then his vice president, Spiro
- 2:38Agnew, before he had a chance to become president.
- 2:41He also resigned for, offenses, including, I believe, ex invasion.
- 2:47So Gerald Ford became president.
- 2:50And then RED was used for Jimmy Carter who would defeat Gerald Ford in the election.
- 2:55And an electoral vote map.com says CBS News in 1972 used blue for Nixon and red for George
- 3:04McGovern, who was his, was his general election opponent.
- 3:09But there wasn't necessarily uniformity in which card which party had which color across
- 3:16outlets.
- 3:16There was actually a time I I was reading.
- 3:19I forget where exactly, but that even Republican had been yellow.
- 3:24But it became more consistent for the parties at about 2000 election or so.
- 3:30Tim Russard, former, the late correspondent he passed away back in I think it was 0809.
- 3:38But he, was noted even though he was not the first one to use it, and he would not say he
- 3:46was the first one to use it.
- 3:48The red blue state dichotomy is sometimes associated with him.
- 3:52So around 2000 is when it became more consistent, and now we today know it as red is
- 3:58Republican, blue
- 3:59is Democrat.
- 4:01So what exactly makes a state, red, or blue,
- 4:05or purple?
- 4:06Red?
- 4:07Meaning, again, re re republican lean, blue meaning a democratic lean, and when we have
- 4:13purple, it's a mix of blue and red, so we say that a state is a little bit more back and
- 4:19forth between the parties if they are purple.
- 4:23But calling a state red or blue or purple is not always very explanatory.
- 4:28Yes.
- 4:29It's not it's not saying that this is how the entire state votes on everything, but when you
- 4:35teach people that a state is red, or blue or purple, they kind of get that impression than
- 4:40that is across the board because
- 4:42a lot of people aren't necessarily diving into this stuff themselves.
- 4:46So it's it it is something that's a little
- 4:51Could be a little less vague, but it doesn't account for differences in offices within a
- 4:55state having a different voting tendency.
- 4:58A state might tend to vote one way for republic or one way for presidents versus a different
- 5:03way for governor, or they might vote a different way for US Senate or districted
- 5:09offices like state legislatures or the US house might have a majority of a different party
- 5:14depending on how the districts are divided, and it doesn't necessarily need to be
- 5:17gerrymandering.
- 5:18It doesn't even if it's not gerrymandering, Sometimes it could be different colors, but
- 5:23does the media hit the color of these states correct?
- 5:26Generally, yeah, they're not necessarily wrong.
- 5:28But, again, it's not always very in-depth.
- 5:33And just because the state is considered red or blue does not mean that that applies to every
- 5:38geographical area of the state.
- 5:39So we gotta be careful not to assume if we see a city or a county in the state, we can't
- 5:44necessarily say, oh, so They must vote Republican because the state typically is
- 5:48Republican, or they're typically democrat because the state typically leans democratic.
- 5:53Not necessarily.
- 5:54So a couple of examples.
- 5:56In Alabama, even as Alabama has become increasingly democrat, The lone democrat in the
- 6:02US house is Terry Sewell.
- 6:04She's been there since she won in the 2010 election.
- 6:08Similarly, South Carolina Bim Plieburn has been the Democrat has been a Democratic member of
- 6:16the house for South Carolina since 1992, even as the state has become increasingly
- 6:21Republican, and now he's the only house democrat for South Carolina.
- 6:26And then in Maryland, we have, Republican Andy Harris, who is the only Republican in congress.
- 6:31He's been the only Republican in congress for Maryland since 2012, but he's been in office
- 6:36since 2010.
- 6:37He had another, Republican from the state alongside him in that chamber.
- 6:43So when can you say a state is definitively red or blue
- 6:48or purple?
- 6:50How long do you
- 6:50have to wait to declare such a thing?
- 6:53There's no real clear criteria for it.
- 6:55There's no Okay.
- 6:57If they vote Republican, 3 times straight in this office, or they vote Democrat, 3 times
- 7:02straight in this office, or four times, whatever.
- 7:05It's it doesn't necessarily work like that, but there are some states where you can generally
- 7:10say, okay.
- 7:10Yeah.
- 7:10That's a red state or a blue state.
- 7:13But in any case, you def you should wait at least a few elections before you declare a
- 7:18trend.
- 7:19And a perfect example of that is I'll use my state, Florida.
- 7:24It's been declared a red state for president now, but
- 7:28is it, I mean, in 2020, for, Donald Trump won by 3 points.
- 7:373 percentage points, against, Joe Biden.
- 7:41Now ultimately, he lost the election, and, that snaps the streak of Florida voting for the
- 7:47winning presidential candidate since 19 96.
- 7:51They were the only state from 1996 to 2016 to pick the winning presidential candidate, and
- 7:56then that got snapped in, 2020 in 2020.
- 8:01But we we probably need several presidential, like, to definitively say whether it's red now.
- 8:07The state level, Florida has definitely been a red state.
- 8:11But or president, we need to get at least another election or 2 before we can
- 8:16definitively say that.
- 8:17Yes.
- 8:18Ron DeSantis, the governor of Florida in 2022, he won a landslide against, Democrat Charlie
- 8:24Chris, who himself was actually a Republican governor of Florida, back in the late 2000s.
- 8:32But that doesn't mean automatically mean Trump will do it again in 2024, even if he has a lot
- 8:38of art and supporters in the state does not necessarily mean that it's going to happen for
- 8:44him.
- 8:45In 2024.
- 8:49So there's not really an objective way to say, okay.
- 8:52Or not a totally object objective way to say.
- 8:55This is a red state, the the blue state, but there are some states that are Pretty safe to
- 8:59say that they are clearly red or blue, on on most accounts.
- 9:05So de definitively, red states, you can say Alabama, Idaho, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah,
- 9:12Wyoming, Those are pretty red.
- 9:15It's not like they don't ever vote for Democrats, but it's very uncommon and they're
- 9:20usually for the districted offices like state legislatures and the US house.
- 9:27But some exceptions, Kansas is a pretty red state, but twice now, they voted for Democrat
- 9:32Laura Kelly for governor, even though the state legislature is very Republican state votes
- 9:39Republican a lot for US Senate.
- 9:41In fact, it hasn't voted a democrat for US Senate since.
- 9:45I believe it's 1932.
- 9:50But other but, and but, otherwise, it's it's pretty It's a pretty Republican state.
- 9:56And then for it's inevitably blue states.
- 9:59That's those are ones like California, Hawaii, Maryland, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, So
- 10:07especially Hawaii.
- 10:08Hawaii is in fact the number of Republicans in the state legislature there.
- 10:14You can count on one hand.
- 10:16They're they're there's very few of those, and they have there's only been 2 There's only been
- 10:22one person who was 1 one Republican who was 1 US house in, Hawaii since Hawaii's been a state
- 10:31since 1959, and that was Patricia Sakai.
- 10:35I think I think that's how you say her name, Sakai, and she won, two times back in the
- 10:40eighties.
- 10:42But other than that, you are very hard pressed to find a Republican in Hawaii.
- 10:47Some exceptions, Maryland.
- 10:49So, again, pretty blue state, but they recently had a Republican governor and Larry Hogan.
- 10:55Now he could he couldn't run again in 2022, and it's Democrat again.
- 11:00I believe it's West Moore is the current governor of Maryland but otherwise, Democrats
- 11:07dominate the state.
- 11:09Now how do you tell if a state is purple?
- 11:13So a couple of several ways that you can generally say something is or a state is purple
- 11:18is There is back and forth competitions for offices like president and governor.
- 11:23Even if not every co election is competitive, so Florida for a while was pretty well, you
- 11:30could still arguably say is a pretty purple state at least for resident.
- 11:36But, in the in the case of Wisconsin, there's been the last 2 elections have been won by,
- 11:43Democrat Tony Evers, the 2 before that were Republican Scott Walker, I think.
- 11:48And then there was 2 by a Democrat, before then.
- 11:54And I believe I believe they also did that for president, as well.
- 11:59Another way you can say is one color for at one office and another color for
- 12:04a different office.
- 12:05Which you're
- 12:06gen you generally see less of these days.
- 12:08We call that ticket splitting where in the in a given year, somebody votes Republican for one
- 12:14party, and they vote democrat for another party.
- 12:17Now you see a lot more straight ticket voting, which is just a dispute Republican across the
- 12:23board or a Democrat across the board.
- 12:26But one example one notable example here is in Vermont, Phil Scott has won the last for
- 12:33elections as a Republican, and it's otherwise a pretty, democratic, pretty left leaning state.
- 12:41You would other you would say it's a blue state,
- 12:45in most respects.
- 12:47So, you
- 12:48know, would you say it's a lighter shade of blue or whether it's purple?
- 12:52I mean, that that's where it gets to be
- 12:55a little bit murkier, but The, Republicans have also one governor in that state from 2002 to
- 13:012008 in Vermont and New Hampshire are
- 13:01the 2 states that have who your terms for their
- 13:08governor.
- 13:09And then another big way you can tell if a state is purple
- 13:13or you can argue a state is purple is if there's a generally a split in partisan
- 13:18competition across offices.
- 13:20Michigan is a good example of this.
- 13:22Been back and forth for governor last two times, Gretchen Whitmer.
- 13:26The two times before that, his name escapes me, but it was a republican, and then two times
- 13:30before that was a Democrat.
- 13:33It votes regularly democrat for, US Senate, but the Argent of Victory have gotten smaller over
- 13:40time.
- 13:41And then there and then there's an almost even split between the parties for state legislature
- 13:46and the US house.
- 13:47In fact, the state house just flipped back in 2022, I believe, from Republican to to
- 13:55Democrat.
- 13:56And then their Senate is up.
- 13:58All of their Senate seats are up every 4 years.
- 14:01And I believe it's a a small Republican majority in there right now.
- 14:07So purple states, it gets a little bit you know, is it a purple state, or is it a lighter
- 14:12shade of blue or a lighter shade of red?
- 14:15You know, you could argue one way or
- 14:17the other, but some states Some states where you can argue, are there a lighter shade of red
- 14:24or blue?
- 14:26It's either Republicans or Democrats have won an office consistently, but there have been
- 14:30several close contests in recent memory, Democrats or Republicans consistently win most
- 14:37offices, but with some exceptions, or they often or one party will win statewide elections
- 14:43much more often, but distributed elections are much closer.
- 14:47One example of a blue state that you can say is maybe a lighter shade of blue, but you probably
- 14:52wouldn't say is purple is Oregon.
- 14:55It's regularly democrat for president, US Senate, US house, governor, but the divided in
- 15:00the state legislature is somewhat close, and believe their last governor election was was
- 15:06pretty close too.
- 15:07So it it's still a pretty blue state, but you can argue it's a little bit of a lighter shade
- 15:11than, say, a California or New York.
- 15:15Red states are a little bit less red.
- 15:17You could argue Ohio is predominantly republican, but US Senator, Sharad Brown, for
- 15:24the Democrats.
- 15:25He's won election for his seat.
- 15:27Since 2006, and he's up for reelection this year.
- 15:30So we'll see if he's able to keep up the streak.
- 15:32And then it's been back and forth between the parties for president.
- 15:36That's two times, it was for No.
- 15:42No.
- 15:42It was it it it flipped from Donald Trump back to, Donald Trump won it in 2016 and then Joe
- 15:50Biden won it in 2020.
- 15:51And before Donald Trump had won in 2016, it was Democrat in 2012.
- 15:59And, of course, states have some of these states have changed their color over time.
- 16:05You you you look at 50, 100 years ago, some states looked completely unrecognizable in
- 16:13terms of partisanship.
- 16:16No.
- 16:16The big example being south used to be a democratic wall.
- 16:20It was if you are a Republican, you couldn't win you you almost couldn't win anything for a
- 16:27very long time, not even, say legislature, you would be hard pressed to get at least one or
- 16:34two seats.
- 16:36And there were some states that went decades
- 16:40where they were completely dominated by the Democratic Party and Republicans didn't even
- 16:46win a single seat in the state legislature, and they certainly didn't win for offices like
- 16:51Governor or US Senate.
- 16:53Florida, again, is a great example of that.
- 16:56Only for a long time, it was as blue as they came, but since the 19 nineties, the mid 19
- 17:03nineties, State legislature has been majority Republican.
- 17:07Republicans have won the governorship since 1998, each election since 1998.
- 17:12And they've won most of the other
- 17:12state executive offices since then too.
- 17:12State executive offices being
- 17:17paying like attorney general or well, secretary of state is is not a, it's not an elected
- 17:26office in Florida anymore.
- 17:27They they changed that back in, I believe, 2002.
- 17:31There was 2002 Amendment, or maybe it was 1998.
- 17:35But secretary of state used to be an elected office, but it's not anymore.
- 17:38We have a chief financial officer, which has some similarity similarities to, treasurers and
- 17:45auditors in other states and the commissioner of agriculture and consumer services.
- 17:52Nikki Freed, who's a democrat and she's the head of the Florida's democratic party now.
- 17:57She won the election for that
- 17:59office in 2018, but then she ran an unsuccessful bid for governor in 2022, and it
- 18:05became Republican.
- 18:06Again, it's Wilton Simpson, who is actually, state, my state senator confirmed as in I live
- 18:13in his state senate district.
- 18:16So
- 18:17that's a it's been a pretty red state in the state government for a while, but for a long
- 18:22time, it was democratic across the board.
- 18:25It was very blue.
- 18:27Massachusetts also used to
- 18:28be a very solidly Republican state.
- 18:32Really a
- 18:32noticeable trend that started in the 19 fifties, especially for federal seats as
- 18:36Democrats won.
- 18:38Elections increasingly author.
- 18:39Now you're they all
- 18:40of the US house seats there
- 18:44are democratic right now.
- 18:46And US
- 18:49Senate, Republican, hasn't won in at least 20 years.
- 18:54I can't remember the last time exactly, but it's it's now a very blue, very democratic
- 19:00state, but for way back when back in yesterday,
- 19:03they were a very Republican state.
- 19:03So other long term red and blue streaks, I am actually in the midst of a series of medium
- 19:16posts about this about the longest Republican and democratic street streaks or in another
- 19:23perspective, longest routes for various types of offices.
- 19:27So just a just a some examples for president, governor, and US Senate.
- 19:34So for president, Democrats have not won The following states since 1964.
- 19:41There's Naga, them.
- 19:42It's Alaska, Idaho, Kansas, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Utah, and
- 19:49Wyoming.
- 19:51Both Dakotas are very Republican, and Wyoming may be the most Republican state in the
- 19:58country.
- 19:58That's it's arguably the case.
- 19:58For the last Republican victory, in, states
- 20:08Minnesota is the longest time since a Republican has won it,
- 20:131972 for Minnesota.
- 20:15And then there's 6 states that have not been won by Republican presidential candidates since
- 20:211984.
- 20:22That'd be Hawaii, Massachusetts, New
- 20:24York, Oregon, Rhode Island, and Washington.
- 20:24For the US Senate, we have States that have not been won by a Democrat in the longest time.
- 20:37Kansas, again, 1932 is the last time a Democrat won it for US Senate.
- 20:44Utah and Wyoming Democrats haven't won for US Senate.
- 20:49Since 1970, Idaho in 1974, and then Mississippi in 1982.
- 20:55And then for Republican droughts, Republicans haven't won a US senate seat in Hawaii since
- 21:011970, New Jersey since 1972, Maryland since 1980, Connecticut, 1982, and then
- 21:06California at 1988.
- 21:07And then for governors, South Dakota, or, excuse me, longest democratic droughts going
- 21:17on.
- 21:18So Democrats have not won the governorship in South Dakota since 1974, Utah since 1980, North
- 21:26Dakota since 1988, Idaho since 1990 and Texas since 1990.
- 21:31And then longest Republican droughts for governor, Washington is the longest, drought
- 21:38they've had.
- 21:38They haven't won Republicans haven't won the Washington governorships since 1980.
- 21:42In Oregon, it's been 1982, Delaware 1980 8, Colorado 2002, and then New York in 2002.
- 21:51So some pretty long standing,
- 21:55Creeks going on, for for those states.
- 22:01And there's some states that that, like, I
- 22:04kinda try to keep it at the the top 5, unless there were some states that were tied for the
- 22:09top 5.
- 22:11So some of those states, Republicans haven't won a given office or Democrats haven't wanna
- 22:16give an office since for 40, 50 years, or in the case of of Kansas's US Senate seats,
- 22:25Democrats have have won that in over 90 years now.
- 22:30But some major watershed events in US politics where you've seen changes in states' colors,
- 22:34and some sometimes it was temporary.
- 22:34Sometimes
- 22:38it's It's been, longer standing or even current going on.
- 22:44And these are just a
- 22:45couple of examples, but when Franklin Roosevelt became president in 1932 in the midst of the
- 22:50great depression, Democrats
- 22:53had a lot of success all over the the US.
- 22:58A lot of states shifted blue, even if temporarily.
- 23:01Other times, there was a longer term change.
- 23:05But
- 23:05and most of his elections started tapered off towards the end when FDR won his 4th
- 23:13presidential election, then he would pass soon into that, but
- 23:17Early on, he won the vast majority
- 23:19of states.
- 23:19But a one of the more recent, instances of major watershed events work, states change
- 23:32their color is, in 2010 state legislative elections, a lot of state chambers were picked
- 23:39up by Republicans.
- 23:41And Republicans became the majority and a majority of they legislative chambers.
- 23:46They picked up 20 of them in 2010, 7 state tenants, and 13 state houses.
- 23:52They also started picking them up in, 2011 2012, but since 2010 or since 2010 elections,
- 24:01Republicans have held a majority of state legislative chambers since then.
- 24:06And there's been some ebbs and flows where Democrats have made some gains, and then they'd
- 24:11lose some, then they make some gains.
- 24:12But since 2010, Republicans have had a majority of state legislative chambers, and they've
- 24:18enjoyed a pretty comfortable lead in that regard since then.
- 24:22And some of these states were once dem dominated by Democrats historically, but
- 24:27they've been slowly shifting red over time.
- 24:31Alabama, being one example.
- 24:34Both chambers flipped to Republican in 2010, and as the state became
- 24:40redder and redder.
- 24:40But even, again, even when states didn't flip
- 24:41in 2010, some of them flipped
- 24:47in 2012 or 2011 because there's
- 24:51a few states that have state legislative elections or other elections in odd numbered
- 24:55years, Mississippi being one of them where the 1 or both chambers of
- 24:58the state legislature.
- 24:58I can't remember for certain
- 25:04became Republican.
- 25:08And speaking of which you
- 25:08see, there are more states that are becoming deeper shades of
- 25:08red and blue over time.
- 25:08You particularly see a trend of more state government protect us, which is where the same
- 25:22party for both chambers of a state legislature and give or this the same party wins a majority
- 25:29of both state legislative chambers as well as the governorship.
- 25:33And for, as a as ballopedia notes, as of August 2024, there's 23 Republican trifectas, 17
- 25:41democratic trifectas, and then 10 divided governments in that context.
- 25:47And at when we look at it from population standpoint, as of January 2024, 41.7% of the
- 25:55country's population lived in a state with a democratic trifecta, 41% lived in a state with
- 26:00a Republican trifecta and 17.4% lived in a state with divided government.
- 26:07A little bit of rounding errors
- 26:07that you gotta enforce.
- 26:08But it does
- 26:13Now, obviously, I'm not going to ever argue that one, you know, that this party should win
- 26:20this this election, and these candidates should win this this election.
- 26:24That's not what I do.
- 26:25That's for you to decide, but I do have a strong belief in the need for political
- 26:32competitiveness because less competition generally means a less responsive government if
- 26:36they don't have to worry about losing their jobs, they're probably not going to be as
- 26:42responsive And everybody's constituent, you're not just a your constituents are not
- 26:48just one party.
- 26:48They're all across the political spectrum, and then less competition is shown also less
- 26:48voter participation as well.
- 26:57So there are a lot of issues we have for political competitiveness that need to be
- 26:58addressed, but in any case, that covers red and blue and purple states, hopefully, to shed some
- 27:12light on exactly how these are, demarcated, how we exactly say a state is red or blue or
- 27:21purple.
- 27:21A lot of times, it's not.
- 27:23Very in-depth or very descriptive.
- 27:26And, usually, it's just in the context of president.
- 27:28It's not totally again.
- 27:29It's not totally objective, but there's some states or a lot of states you can say.
- 27:34Okay.
- 27:34That's a red state.
- 27:35Okay.
- 27:35That's a blue state.
- 27:37And so with that, we're going to do our random question
- 27:42of the day, which doesn't necessarily have to do with politics.
- 27:44Sometimes it will.
- 27:45Sometimes it won't.
- 27:47Sometimes there's a correct answer.
- 27:50Sometimes there's not.
- 27:51Sometimes it looks like an opinion, but, like, come on now.
- 27:54We know what the answer is.
- 27:56That's this one's not one of those, though.
- 27:58So a random question of
- 27:59the day is, What's the coolest planet in our solar system?
- 28:04And he can't say earth to you right now.
- 28:05That's that's just it's cheating.
- 28:08So
- 28:09and I'll and if if you want, I'll allow Pluto to be used even though it's technically non
- 28:13Planet anymore.
- 28:13Now as I when I was a a little kid.
- 28:16I was a big astronomy nerd.
- 28:18I still enjoy astronomy, but, obviously, I can't devote a whole bunch of time to learning
- 28:23about it, but astronomy is still one of my is my first love.
- 28:28It it I still I still love astronomy.
- 28:30So For me, it's Venus because
- 28:32it's a a planet
- 28:32we have so little, documentation of the surface of because whenever you send probes down there,
- 28:45the pressure of the atmosphere just crushes everything.
- 28:49We do have a few, pictures of it.
- 28:52Yeah.
- 28:52Funny enough.
- 28:52We used to when, science fiction novels, back in, like, the sixties and seventies before we
- 28:59actually got a look at what the surface of Venus looked like.
- 29:03People imagined lush jungles and and basically almost like a paradise.
- 29:08And, boy, Venus is not like that at all.
- 29:11Also, it rotates the opposite direction on its axis compared to all the other, other presence,
- 29:17other planets.
- 29:19And it's, its day is longer than its year because a day is how long a planet takes to
- 29:25rotate on its axis, and a year is how long it takes to revolve
- 29:30around the sun, and it takes longer to rotate on the axis than to revolve around the sun,
- 29:35hence a longer day than year.
- 29:38So I think it's the most fascinating planet.
- 29:42But with that being said, let me know what you think
- 29:47what what's your answer is in the comments on this video or on social media when I post this.
- 29:52And thank you so much for listening.
- 29:54Again, you can follow me on Facebook, Paul Raider, author and speaker.
- 30:00You can also follow me on linkedin and my website, paulrader.org.
- 30:06That being said, I will talk to you later.
- 30:09And until then, take care.