Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No55.🎙️ Public Inquiry - Week 4 in Review 9th May 2026
Transcript
- 0:04Right? So this is the end of week review from the pack
- 0:08inquiry. And honestly, I think if you missed the daily
- 0:11episodes, this was probably the one to listen to, because over
- 0:17these three days, a few themes really started settle in and
- 0:21become impossible to ignore. I came away from this week with
- 0:27more questions than answers. One of the biggest issues hanging
- 0:31over this week was the continuing absence of key
- 0:34information. We kept hearing about, the missing feasibility
- 0:37study, the missing economic model, the spreadsheet, nobody
- 0:41outside the applicant seemed to have access to, at one point, it
- 0:47was described almost like a mystery box that updates
- 0:50whenever the facts change. And I think for ordinary people
- 0:55listening to this process, that matters, because if the numbers
- 0:59are changing, if the assumptions are changing, if major financial
- 1:04arrangements are only emerging now under questioning, then how
- 1:08exactly was this application assessed before it ever reached
- 1:12this stage? That concern came up repeatedly this week, savers
- 1:20Burns said very plainly that they do not believe this
- 1:24application is fit for robust public scrutiny in its current
- 1:28form. Fermana and OMA District Council's legal team raised
- 1:34concerns about whether enough information even exists for the
- 1:38commission to make an informed judgement
- 1:40in moment,
- 1:43and what struck me was that DFI never really seemed willing to
- 1:47meet that concern head on. There were moments this week where DFI
- 1:53appeared oddly detached from the detail of the application they
- 1:57are meant to be overseeing. Questions were raised around
- 2:03financial structures, royalties, liabilities, public cost
- 2:08exposure, even mine closure bonds and too often, the answers
- 2:13coming back from the department felt vague or incomplete. One
- 2:21exchange that really stayed with me was around the gold
- 2:23laundering concerns. Detailed references were made to warnings
- 2:28issued by the National Crime Agency, the OECD, the FATF, and
- 2:34others, about vulnerabilities within the global gold
- 2:39concentrate trade. Questions were asked about whether any
- 2:43arrangements exist here to monitor or prevent those risks.
- 2:48The response from DFI was basically that this level of
- 2:51scrutiny is not usual. And sitting listening to that, I
- 2:55honestly thought, but this isn't usual. This is a massive
- 3:01proposed gold mine in an area of outstanding natural beauty
- 3:05involving international finance, concentrate, exports,
- 3:11explosives, long term waste management and potentially
- 3:16generations of environmental Monitoring. I don't think people
- 3:21expect this to be treated like a routine planning application.
- 3:27The financial side of things became even murkier as the week
- 3:31went on. A huge amount of time was spent trying to untangle
- 3:36relationships between dalradian, Wheaton, Minko, Orion and
- 3:41various corporate entities connected to Canada, Delaware
- 3:46and the Cayman Islands. And to be honest, even the
- 3:49commissioners, at times, appeared to struggle to get
- 3:52clear answers about who exactly controlled what and where money
- 3:57would actually end up. We heard again about Wheaton being repaid
- 4:03in gold at heavily discounted rates. Questions were raised
- 4:08about royalties, about whether taxes would be paid on
- 4:11concentrates rather than refined gold, about how much profit
- 4:17would actually remain here, and whether the public had ever been
- 4:21given a full picture of these arrangements. At one point,
- 4:28Commissioner McCary directly asked why certain payments had
- 4:33never been mentioned before. And I think a lot of people
- 4:37following this inquiry, that sums up the feeling right now,
- 4:42things keep emerging deep into the process that feels
- 4:46significant enough that it should have been openly examined
- 4:50much earlier. There was a lot of discussion this week, also
- 4:56around the promised economic benefits. Two the jobs claims
- 5:01came under serious scrutiny. The headline wage figure turned out
- 5:07not to reflect what most workers would actually earn. We heard
- 5:13that many specialist jobs would likely come from outside the
- 5:17area, at least initially, we heard concerns that some of the
- 5:24employment projections were based on outdated figures from
- 5:28years ago before major changes to the proposal itself. And one
- 5:35thing that kept coming up from economists and people with
- 5:40experience of mining elsewhere, was how temporary and uncertain
- 5:45a lot of these jobs actually are. There was a moment where a
- 5:52representative for dalradian described a five or six year
- 5:56rule as long term employment. Another acknowledged that jobs
- 6:02would tail away later in the mine life. People listening to
- 6:09this inquiry are trying to work out what exactly communities are
- 6:14being asked to carry in exchange for that, that question became
- 6:20sharper again when discussion turned to public costs. Policing
- 6:28costs had apparently not been considered by dfi. To date,
- 6:33there were discussions around explosives, escorts, protests,
- 6:38licencing requirements and the previous unpaid policing Bill
- 6:42linked to exploration activity. And the scale here is enormous.
- 6:49The figure mentioned this week was a conservative estimate.
- 6:53According to Mr. Beatty, 44,000 tonnes of explosives over the
- 6:59life of the mine. To put that in perspective, Hiroshima, little
- 7:05boy, bomb was 15,000 tonnes. And Nagasaki, fat man, 21,000 tonnes
- 7:12of explosives. Nobody seemed able to clearly explain what the
- 7:22total public cost exposure could look like if this project
- 7:27proceeds. The PS and I and Department of Justice were not
- 7:32even present to answer questions around that side of things. Then
- 7:39after lunch on day nine, the conversation moved into mines
- 7:42closure, and honestly, I think this was one of the heaviest
- 7:46parts of the week. People with lived experiences near other
- 7:53mines spoke about acid mine drainage and contamination
- 7:58continuing decades after closure, questions were asked
- 8:04about what happens 15 years from now, if pollution emerges after
- 8:09the company has long gone. The discussion around the closure
- 8:16Bond was uncomfortable at times. There were moments where
- 8:20department representatives appeared uncertain about how
- 8:24these guarantees even operate, and meanwhile, campaigners and
- 8:30community representatives were pointing to abandoned mines
- 8:34across Ireland that still require public money and long
- 8:38term management years after companies disappeared, one
- 8:44figure mentioned was around 100 million euro already spent
- 8:49dealing with legacy mining issues in the south of Ireland.
- 8:54That stayed with me because this week kept circling back to the
- 8:58same unresolved concern. Who carries the risk once the
- 9:02company leaves, not during the profitable years afterwards. And
- 9:09I think maybe the line that summed the week up best came
- 9:13from one of the local speakers who said, We are lay people with
- 9:17a conscience that landed because many of the people raising these
- 9:23issues are ordinary local residents who have spent years
- 9:26trying to understand incredibly technical material simply
- 9:30because they feel they have no choice by the end of the week, I
- 9:35honestly got the sense that many people in that room felt they
- 9:39were doing the scrutiny they expected government departments
- 9:44to have already done. So that's where things stand heading into
- 9:50next week, still no full clarity around economics, still major
- 9:56questions around public benefits, still major questions.
- 10:00Around long term liability and still uncertainty around who
- 10:05ultimately profits and who ultimately pays, and the inquiry
- 10:10rolls on. See you all next week,
- 10:12you.