Latest / The Vegan Report / The Most Effective Animal Charity in the World!? With Dan Shannon | Ep. 99
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:03and today I want to ask you, which do you think
- 0:06is the most effective animal charity out there?
- 0:10The one that has moved the animal rights movement
- 0:13forward the most? Well, for the last 12 consecutive
- 0:18years, there is one animal charity that has been
- 0:23evaluated and recommended again and again and
- 0:27again by animal charity evaluators and its name
- 0:31is the Humane League. Have you heard of them?
- 0:35I think of them as the smart kid of the class
- 0:38always getting an A+. That got me curious. Why
- 0:42has it been deemed such a successful charity?
- 0:45What explains their success? To get some answers,
- 0:49I have with me none other than the CEO of the
- 0:52Humane League, Dan Shannon. Dan and I discussed
- 0:56among other things who is his favorite employee,
- 1:01does he think Big Ag spies on his nonprofit,
- 1:05the secret agenda of the welfare reforms he is
- 1:09passing, and how he takes care of the mental
- 1:12health of his employees. Check the episode notes
- 1:16for a link to connect with the Humane League.
- 1:19And as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 1:23Follow or subscribe to the show and don't miss
- 1:27next week's 100th episode. Share the episode
- 1:31with the vegans you know. Let's shed light on
- 1:34the important work of the Humane League. Thank
- 1:37you. So last Wednesday, the Science of Activism
- 1:42episode was about the animal charity Evaluators.
- 1:48and they described their list of 10 recommended
- 1:52charities. And I looked the Humane League up
- 1:57and discovered that you were part of that list
- 2:00since forever, since the creation of the Animal
- 2:04Charity Evaluators initiative. And so I guess
- 2:07my first question for you is, what explains how
- 2:12efficient you are at doing progress? Yeah, we're
- 2:17delighted to be named for the 12th year in a
- 2:20row very privileged and honored to be a part
- 2:23of the list I think Our work is cost -effective
- 2:28by nature. And I think that's one of the things
- 2:30that animal charity evaluators looks for in us.
- 2:33And it's cost -effective by nature in that our
- 2:36core theory of change at the Humane League is
- 2:39changing institutional policy to eliminate the
- 2:42worst abuses of farmed animals. So particularly
- 2:45corporate policy and then public policy. And
- 2:49when we're working in that way, right, individuals
- 2:52like you or me, we can make decisions in our
- 2:54lives that might impact dozens of animals, hundreds
- 2:56of animals. I've been vegan for almost 30 years.
- 3:00Maybe I've affected a thousand animals with my
- 3:02personal choices. But companies can make decisions
- 3:05that affect millions of animals at scale. And
- 3:09so when our work is about applying public pressure,
- 3:12activist pressure, primarily to companies, to
- 3:14get them to make policy choices that eliminate
- 3:16the worst abuses of farmed animals in their supply
- 3:20chain, with relatively little effort, And I don't
- 3:24want to undervalue the very important work folks
- 3:27on my team do. It is hard work. But we can make
- 3:30changes to corporate policy that affects animals
- 3:32by the millions. And with that formula, I think
- 3:36we can be very cost effective with the number
- 3:38of animals lives that we can improve. phone calls,
- 3:44meetings, and negotiations. Of course, we will
- 3:47often have to go to a public campaign, a public
- 3:50activist pressure campaign, if companies aren't
- 3:52willing to make changes through dialogue and
- 3:55negotiation alone. But the majority of change
- 3:58that we make is actually just through dialogue
- 4:00and negotiation, which leaves us being very cost
- 4:02effective, which is, I think, one of the things
- 4:04that animal chariot evaluators has really valued
- 4:07in our work. Amazing. Yes, hard work. but also
- 4:11expert work, you know, I would not know where
- 4:14to start, you know, in order to make a corporation
- 4:18receptive to my message of compassion for animals.
- 4:23And so let's talk about this. Starting with how
- 4:28do you decide, you know, which corporation to
- 4:31target? So we have a large research team at the
- 4:34Humane League that does extensive research to
- 4:37understand where our best leverage points are
- 4:40with the industry. And that looks a couple of
- 4:42different ways. One, it looks at scale of animals
- 4:46impacted by supply chains. As you can imagine,
- 4:49most companies are not publishing, oh, we have
- 4:52six million hens living in cages in our supply
- 4:54chain right now. We have to do digging and research
- 4:58and get into industry publications and government
- 5:00reports to really be able to construct a picture
- 5:03of what corporate supply chains and industries
- 5:05look like. So a lot of research goes into understanding
- 5:08which are the companies that are abusing the
- 5:10most animals in their supply chain, what regions
- 5:12of the world. are those concentrated in, et cetera,
- 5:16so we know who are the biggest targets to go
- 5:18after. A second stream of research is around
- 5:22then sort of how feasible it is for companies
- 5:25to make the kinds of changes that we're advocating
- 5:27for. So we often advocate, we primarily advocate
- 5:31for companies to move from using cruel battery
- 5:34cages, right, where you've got four to six egg
- 5:37-laying hens living in a wire cage the size of
- 5:40a file cabinet drawer for their entire lives.
- 5:43to what we call cage -free environments. We should
- 5:46be clear that cage -free environments are also
- 5:48not great from an animal welfare perspective,
- 5:50but they do represent a meaningful improvement
- 5:52over battery cages. But then we also try to understand
- 5:57how feasibly can companies make that change as
- 5:59their existing supply in the regions of the world
- 6:02that they purchase from, where they can actually
- 6:04get access to cage -free eggs for their supply
- 6:09chain. So we look at scale, we also look at tractability,
- 6:12whether or not a company can actually do what
- 6:15we're asking them to do. And then the third thing
- 6:18that we look at is the vulnerability of companies
- 6:21to public pressure. Different companies have
- 6:24different levels of tolerance for how much consumer...
- 6:28Pushback they're willing to absorb right companies
- 6:31that have had a lot of other kind of issues or
- 6:33campaigns launched against them and they have
- 6:35been unresponsive to them maybe more likely to
- 6:39not do what we're asking, right? Whereas companies
- 6:41that have a proven track record of responding
- 6:42to activist demands are more likely, right? And
- 6:45so we try to understand how likely is a company
- 6:47to say yes to what we're asking for. So it's
- 6:50sort of the combination of those three factors
- 6:52that our team research is kind of independently
- 6:54of one another, that that informs our campaign
- 6:57strategy and who we choose to go after. And going
- 6:59back to that strategy of being cost effective.
- 7:04I guess the corporation needs to be like a big
- 7:07corporation in order to have a greater impact.
- 7:11You won't be targeting like the local butcher
- 7:15shop. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, we try to go
- 7:18after companies that both, you know, are abusing
- 7:21animals by the hundreds of thousands or the millions
- 7:23in their supply chain where we can create the
- 7:25most impact. And also where a win with one particular
- 7:30company can help create progress in industry.
- 7:33overall. To give you an example of what I mean
- 7:36by that, here in the U .S., where I'm based,
- 7:40we are currently, over the past 20 years, you
- 7:42know, THL is celebrating its 20th anniversary
- 7:45this year, and over the past 20 years, the U
- 7:48.S. egg -laying industry has gone from, you know,
- 7:51maybe one to two percent cage -free, right, in
- 7:54terms of the number of hens that are living outside
- 7:56of caged environments, to now at about 45 percent.
- 7:59just over about 20 years, which is meaningful
- 8:02progress over a relatively short period of time.
- 8:06What we're left with here in the U .S. is primarily
- 8:08the grocery industry. So most of the 55 % of
- 8:12hens that are still living in caged environments
- 8:15are part of the grocery industry supply chain
- 8:17that they're the largest retailer and seller
- 8:19of eggs as an industry in the U .S. And we have
- 8:23made very little progress, if we're being honest,
- 8:25in the grocery industry, right? So when we look
- 8:28at target selection for an industry like grocery,
- 8:30where we're trying to get in the door and really
- 8:32create is that we need to find a campaign that's
- 8:35winnable enough so that we can get a company
- 8:38to be the first to make this kind of change in
- 8:40their industry. Because often companies are very
- 8:42reluctant to be the first company in their industry
- 8:44to want to make any kind of change, whether it's
- 8:47animal welfare related or anything else. But
- 8:50once you have a proof point that you can point
- 8:52to, then a lot of the other victories become
- 8:54a lot easier, right? Because you're not asking
- 8:56them to be the first to do it. So along with
- 8:59other coalition partners and allies in the movement
- 9:01that we work with, we've identified a company
- 9:03called Ajo Del Haze, which is a grocery company
- 9:06that owns a bunch of regional grocery change
- 9:08in the US, Stop and Shop, Food Lion, a bunch
- 9:11of other ones. They're not the biggest player
- 9:15in the industry. I believe they're the seventh
- 9:17largest grocery chain. But we believe they're
- 9:21the one that would be the most susceptible to
- 9:22public pressure and the most likely to concede
- 9:27to our demands. So our strategy is if we can
- 9:30get this company to go first and go 100 % cage
- 9:34-free in their supply chain, the bigger companies
- 9:37will follow suit. Right. So campaign target selection
- 9:40is often about kind of what would the domino
- 9:42effects on the rest of the industry that these
- 9:44companies operate in as much as it is the individual
- 9:47scale that that company is operating on. I want
- 9:50to go back to talking about what kind of changes
- 9:56you're asking those corporations to implement.
- 10:00You mentioned, you know, going cage free. Now,
- 10:04is there an underlying I guess another agenda
- 10:08to, you know, asking to those corporations to
- 10:12make that change, you know, so we're not only
- 10:15doing it for, you know, the welfare of animals,
- 10:19but also with a bigger strategy, long term strategy
- 10:24of maybe making it more costly to exploit those
- 10:30animals. Yes, it's exactly what you said. I think
- 10:33there are There's several ways that I think about
- 10:36this. As I said, I think we have to be realistic
- 10:40with ourselves that even a company, even a leg
- 10:43-ling hen going from a battery cage to a cage
- 10:46-free environment, this animal is still suffering
- 10:48and is still living a life of misery. We have
- 10:51to be realistic with ourselves about that. It
- 10:53is both meaningful progress and a significant
- 10:55improvement and yet far from ideal or what I
- 10:58think any kind, decent person would think would
- 11:00be appropriate for an animal to live in. So we
- 11:02have to be clear -eyed about that. But as you
- 11:05said, I think there are two additional benefits
- 11:08to doing these kinds of corporate welfare campaigns
- 11:12that are beyond the meaningful suffering reduction.
- 11:15I think the meaningful suffering reduction is
- 11:16enough in and of itself. I want to be clear about
- 11:18that. And I think it accomplishes two long -term
- 11:21objectives. So when we talk about the worst abuses
- 11:25of factory farming, even through the lens of
- 11:27ending them, we are increasing people's awareness
- 11:29about how animals suffer on factory farms. And
- 11:33I think the more that we talk about the cruelty
- 11:35of this industry and the more that we shine a
- 11:38light on the reality that the industry spends
- 11:42millions of dollars, billions of dollars to prevent
- 11:44people from understanding, the more we build
- 11:47a shared collective understanding that factory
- 11:49farming is bad for animals. And I do think that
- 11:51that moves us closer to a world where no animals
- 11:54are being raised and killed for food, which is
- 11:56the world that... We all, well, those of us who
- 11:59are listening to this podcast, all of us would
- 12:01like to live in. So I do feel like it helps advance
- 12:04the cultural saliency of the issue of factory
- 12:07farming and does cause people to think differently
- 12:09about their relationship to animals raised for
- 12:11food. And then what you said, I think it's the
- 12:14second way that I think about it, which is that
- 12:16it just makes, it shrinks the factory farming
- 12:21industry's ability to operate. I think that every
- 12:24industry has to operate within what I call a
- 12:26box, right? A box that's kind of defined by kind
- 12:30of three things. So what is financially viable,
- 12:34right? These are companies that are trying to
- 12:36make money. What's legally permissible and what's
- 12:40socially acceptable. What customers and consumers
- 12:43will be willing to tolerate, right? And I think
- 12:46corporate welfare campaigns meaningfully reduce
- 12:50the size of the box that the factory farming
- 12:52industry has to operate in. I think it demonstrates
- 12:55to the companies directly that there is a limit
- 12:58to the amount of suffering and abuse that customers
- 13:01and consumers are willing to tolerate, including
- 13:03people who are not vegetarian or vegan, right,
- 13:05which is. obviously the overwhelming majority
- 13:07of the audience and the customer base for the
- 13:10grocery industry, for instance. And it does,
- 13:13you know, to your point, it does increase the
- 13:16cost of operation and reduces profit margin within
- 13:19the factory farming industry. It is more expensive,
- 13:21right, to raise egg -laying hens in cage -free
- 13:23environments than it is caged environments. the
- 13:26industry overplays how much more expensive it
- 13:29is. And actually most of the markup at retail
- 13:32is actually profit for the industry, right? They're
- 13:34sort of the humane tax, right? Where they mark
- 13:36up the price of the eggs. But the fact is that
- 13:39it does, I think incrementally each of these
- 13:41campaigns. shrinks the box that the factory farming
- 13:44industry can operate within. I don't think that
- 13:47corporate campaigns are going to bring us in
- 13:49and of themselves to the end of factory farming
- 13:51over any time horizon. I think more other work
- 13:53is needed. We need public policy reforms to enshrine
- 13:57into law protections for farmed animals. And
- 14:00of course, we do need behavior change at scale
- 14:02and a significant reduction of the consumption
- 14:04of animal products. At the Humane League, we
- 14:07try to be very focused in our work. And going
- 14:09back to the idea of cost effectiveness and sort
- 14:11of why I believe we've been effective as an organization,
- 14:14I think one of the reasons we're effective is
- 14:16that we try to stay in our lane. I believe many
- 14:19strategies are required to bring about the end
- 14:21of factory farming and the end of the abuse of
- 14:23animals used for food. But I think each individual
- 14:25organization is more effective if we focus on
- 14:28a strategy. Our strategy at the Humane League
- 14:30is applying public pressure to companies to eliminate
- 14:33the worst abuses. And that's what we do. And
- 14:35I think we do it very well. And other work will
- 14:38be required to get us to the outcome that we
- 14:40want in the long run. And we respect that. And
- 14:42we welcome all the other activists and organizations
- 14:45in the movement that are doing that important
- 14:46work. I think for most activists out there, the
- 14:53default You know mode of activism is to convince
- 14:58people to go vegan And so to address, you know
- 15:01the general public but there is a You know the
- 15:07issue of you know our corporations actually shaping
- 15:12those Behaviors from the public and shouldn't
- 15:16we you know target the source of? That marketing
- 15:22Have you discussed that or done something around
- 15:26that at the HumaneLink? Yeah, our focus is really
- 15:31exclusively about applying public pressure to
- 15:34companies to eliminate the worst abuses. So in
- 15:39the past, THL has gone through different iterations
- 15:42over the years. There have been times in our
- 15:44past where we've done a lot of vegan outreach
- 15:46work and vegan advocacy work. We've moved away
- 15:48from that. strategically. Again, not because
- 15:52we don't think that it's important work that
- 15:54somebody ought to be doing, but we think we can
- 15:56best play our role in the movement if we are
- 15:59focused and pick one job to do and choose to
- 16:03do it very well. So I would say it is a strategic
- 16:06decision. that we do not kind of engage in vegan
- 16:10outreach and advocacy. Again, not that we don't
- 16:12think it's important and we don't think it's
- 16:14part of the solution. There are many organizations
- 16:16who do that work very well, right? And we support
- 16:18them and celebrate them doing that work. And
- 16:20our focus is on doing the work that I think we
- 16:22do well. which is improving as we work towards
- 16:25that long -term vision of bringing about an end
- 16:28to factory farming and to the animals being abused
- 16:32for food, make meaningful progress in reducing
- 16:35their suffering in the meantime, which I do believe
- 16:37we have a moral and ethical obligation to do.
- 16:40Great. I want to ask you about, yes, you ask,
- 16:43you know, companies to adopt, you know, welfare
- 16:48practices, but if there is the option of going
- 16:53full vegan, for instance, by adopting cell based
- 16:58meat or something of the sort. Would you consider
- 17:03adopting that tactic? Certainly in the future,
- 17:07as those technologies become more readily available,
- 17:10I think that could be an option for us. I think
- 17:14at THL, we will always do what we think is going
- 17:17to be the most effective at reducing the suffering
- 17:19of farmed animals. That's our mission, right?
- 17:23At the moment, I believe and we believe as an
- 17:26organization that the best role that we can play
- 17:28in doing that is by advocating for, again, you
- 17:30know, the end of the use of battery cages and
- 17:32things of that nature. That may change over time.
- 17:35I think it will. I'll rephrase that. I believe
- 17:39that in the next five years, we're going to get
- 17:42to a point, at least in the U .S., where the
- 17:46use of battery cages is reaching a tipping point.
- 17:49We're currently at about half of the industry
- 17:51is currently cage free. Within five years, we
- 17:55think we can get to about two thirds. And you
- 17:58do get to a point with these industry wide changes
- 18:01where once you've reached a certain threshold,
- 18:04market factors more or less kind of finished
- 18:06the job from there. You know, it becomes untenable
- 18:09to be one of the very few producers in the industry
- 18:11who's relying on this outdated technology, whatever
- 18:14that technology happens to be. So as we get closer
- 18:17and closer to that point, our strategy will need
- 18:19to change, right? It's unlikely that we will
- 18:21still be doing cage -free work in 20 years because
- 18:24we probably will have won on that issue, right?
- 18:26Perhaps at that point. cell -based meat is at
- 18:29a point where corporate advocacy to encourage
- 18:31companies to use that as opposed to real animal
- 18:33protein, that could very well be the direction
- 18:36that we choose to move in. But yeah, I like to
- 18:39say that THL, we are not a particularly ideological
- 18:42organization. We are a very practical organization.
- 18:46Our ideology is that we're trying to end the
- 18:47abuse of animals used for food. And then we are
- 18:49very tactical and practical about what... choices,
- 18:53what kind of work we engage in to try to do that.
- 18:56So we're not particularly attached to any one
- 18:58approach. It's really going to be what's going
- 19:00to be the most effective at reducing the suffering
- 19:03of farm animals. I love that. I'm also a practical
- 19:06person, so it appeals to me. And yeah, cell -based
- 19:10meat, you know, that has been on my mind this
- 19:13morning because of the whole Campbell scandal.
- 19:16I don't know if it reached you. No. Anyway, let's
- 19:21not get into it. Dan, I want to ask you about
- 19:27your role as CEO. And let me start with this.
- 19:34Who is your favorite employee at the Humane League?
- 19:41I feel like I can't, I have a professional obligation
- 19:44not to give a straight answer to that question.
- 19:47But I will, so I'll say this. Just last week,
- 19:50I was out at a, we've been, I was at a series
- 19:54of protests organized by the organizing and campaign
- 19:57staff at the Humane League at Ajo Del Hay's headquarters
- 20:01in the United States, the grocery chain that
- 20:03we're targeting right now. We were very. happy
- 20:06to be joined not just by a number of THL staff
- 20:08and local volunteers, but also volunteers and
- 20:12staff from other grassroots animal advocacy organizations
- 20:16across the movement. It really felt like many
- 20:19organizations coming together and working in
- 20:21tandem to apply public pressure to this company
- 20:24to make this meaningful progress. And so I think
- 20:28about the team, like I am an organizer by training.
- 20:30That's my professional background. It's the work
- 20:32that I started out doing in my career. So I have
- 20:35a bias towards our organizing team and our organizing
- 20:38program, both because that's my skill set, but
- 20:42also because I think that's some of the hardest
- 20:43work that we do in the movement is kind of bringing
- 20:45people together and actually getting people to
- 20:47come out and take action, right? It's one thing.
- 20:51to listen to a podcast, for instance, right?
- 20:53It's another thing to make personal choices.
- 20:55These are all great things for people to do,
- 20:57but really the way that we change the world and
- 20:59we make progress towards the end goal that we
- 21:01want is by people taking advocacy actions. I
- 21:05feel very strongly about that. And so I think
- 21:08our organizing team, that's their job, is to
- 21:10try to build relationships with activists and
- 21:12supporters, connect them with opportunities in
- 21:15their community to take action in meaningful
- 21:17ways that can move the ball forward for farmed
- 21:19animals. And so I'm not going to pick a single
- 21:22favorite employee, but I will say, I think that
- 21:24work of kind of building community power and
- 21:26deploying it to create change for animals is
- 21:28the most important work that we do as an organization
- 21:30and as a movement. Yeah, it was a bit of a tongue
- 21:34in cheek question. I mean, it's important to
- 21:37humanize, you know, the the people, the the organizations.
- 21:42Often we focus too much on the brand, you know,
- 21:46but who are the people behind, you know, the
- 21:48Humane League? Okay, let me ask you about how
- 21:53to keep your employees motivated and I guess
- 21:57how to take care of their mental health. It's
- 22:04a problem in this community. I would even say
- 22:06it's a crisis among animal rights activists.
- 22:10And there are too many, you know, groups and
- 22:13communities that just don't focus on that and
- 22:18keep things, you know. Just unsupervised and
- 22:22so what kind of you know Culture do you put in
- 22:29place in the Humane League to make sure that
- 22:31everyone is happy? It's a great question and
- 22:34I agree with the premise of the question. It's
- 22:37What we really need as a movement is longevity
- 22:40we need to build a movement that people feel
- 22:43like it can be a part of their lives for their
- 22:45entire lives. You know, whether that's as a paid
- 22:47professional staff member at NGO or an activist
- 22:50or supporter, right? There's a lot of ways to
- 22:52be involved in the movement, but it does need
- 22:55to feel like a sustainable movement to be a part
- 22:58of, particularly in the professional wing of
- 23:00the movement. So a couple of things I think a
- 23:03lot about at the Humane League. I think one is
- 23:05that Because, you know, we're a big nonprofit
- 23:07organization, so we have lots of campaigners
- 23:10and corporate outreach, you know, people who
- 23:12are doing the work that we do directly. And then
- 23:15we also have accountants and HR professionals
- 23:17and operations staff, right, people who do kind
- 23:20of quote unquote normal jobs, right, at the Humane
- 23:23League. And I think it's very important as a
- 23:26mission -driven organization to help people in
- 23:28those roles understand the critical importance
- 23:32of their work to achieving our mission. It's
- 23:35obvious if you're a corporate negotiator, you
- 23:37understand that by negotiating with companies,
- 23:40you're helping us reduce the suffering of farmed
- 23:42animals. But also somebody's got to process all
- 23:45the expense reports for the travel for those
- 23:47meetings, and somebody's got to make sure they
- 23:49have a computer that works so that they can send
- 23:51the... And so I think helping people understand
- 23:53that connection between the role that they play
- 23:56at the organization and the impact that it makes.
- 23:59And regularly communicating that back to them,
- 24:02helping them understand, we won this victory
- 24:04and you made it possible with your work. And
- 24:06really drawing direct lines of connection between
- 24:09the effort that staff put in and the victories
- 24:11that we're able to achieve, especially where
- 24:13that's less obvious than it might otherwise be.
- 24:17One of the things that we talk a lot about at
- 24:19the Humane League is this idea of we are all
- 24:21campaigners. And that's sort of what that means,
- 24:24right? Some of us are literally campaigners.
- 24:26It's our job to manage and run campaigns. And
- 24:29other folks have roles with whom those campaigns
- 24:32are not possible, without whom those campaigns
- 24:34are not possible. And so even if you're an accountant,
- 24:36right, you are a campaigner because your work
- 24:39makes our campaigns possible. We encourage people
- 24:42then to also like get involved personally, right?
- 24:45Like if there's a protest taking place in your
- 24:47community, like... you can come out and join
- 24:49us there even if that's not a core part of your
- 24:51job. We had staff retreats this year. We had
- 24:54three different staff retreats and as part of
- 24:56those staff retreats we held protests against
- 24:58our campaign targets and encouraged all of our
- 25:00staff to join just so that people have a sense
- 25:03of what that work looks like and can sort of
- 25:06have an experience of being a part of it directly.
- 25:09So I think that's a big motivational factor is
- 25:12people really understanding the nature of what
- 25:14we do, how the role supports it, and having some
- 25:17opportunity to participate in it directly. And
- 25:19then in terms of mental health, as you said,
- 25:22and protecting against burnout and kind of ensuring
- 25:24that people can do this work for the long run.
- 25:27We try to be to the degree that we can as a,
- 25:29you know, budget limited nonprofit. We try to
- 25:31be generous with things like health benefits,
- 25:34mental wellness benefits, ensure that people
- 25:36have their healthcare needs met, including their
- 25:39mental health care needs met. They have access
- 25:41to mental health services when they need them.
- 25:44We try to be generous with our time off policies
- 25:46and our breaks so that people can rest and recover
- 25:48from the hard work that they do and then get
- 25:50back into action on the other side of it. A lot
- 25:53of that is just, I think, good. nonprofit management.
- 25:56I think it's just good organizational management
- 25:58in general. But this is very hard and difficult
- 26:02work. And we really it's important to me that
- 26:05people feel that the organization recognizes
- 26:09that right in the way that we compensate people
- 26:12in the way that we in the benefits that we provide
- 26:14in the celebration that we provide the staff
- 26:16for the victories that we win. nothing's worse
- 26:19than working hard and feeling invisible. And
- 26:21so we work very hard to try to help our staff
- 26:24be visible in the victories that we achieve for
- 26:26animals. What about your corporate partners?
- 26:31Do you, and it's kind of a weird question, but
- 26:34do you ever invite them to mix with the rest
- 26:39of the Humane League team? When you say corporate
- 26:43partners, you mean the companies that we're negotiating
- 26:45with yes, we're campaigning. Yes Not really is
- 26:49my answer. It's an interesting. It's an interesting
- 26:51question. Um We talk a lot at the humane league
- 26:55about what is the nature of our relationship
- 26:57with companies? Is it a or you know, do we answer
- 27:00to visit? Is it a friendly relationship or is
- 27:02that an adversarial relationship and there are
- 27:04different schools of thought about this? but
- 27:08I think there is a And I think this may be perhaps
- 27:10another tongue -in -cheek question, but I think
- 27:13there's a real risk in thinking that our job
- 27:16is to build kind of positive relationships with
- 27:18the companies that we work with. I think that's
- 27:20not quite the right way to think about it. I
- 27:23think we need to be a feared and respected adversary
- 27:27is sort of how I think about it. I feel very
- 27:31strongly and I think anybody who does campaigns
- 27:33work would agree with like companies don't do
- 27:36don't make positive forward progress on any issue,
- 27:39whether it's animals or any other issue, out
- 27:41of the goodness of their hearts. They do it because
- 27:44these are profit maximizing machines. They're
- 27:47soulless corporations. They do not have any sort
- 27:50of sense of a heart, let alone a good one. And
- 27:53so our job is to apply pressure and to force
- 27:57them to act. That pressure can simply be through
- 28:00negotiation, right? It doesn't always need to
- 28:03be through the form of a campaign, but implicit
- 28:06in all of our negotiations is the threat of a
- 28:08campaign, right? Because they can see us campaigning
- 28:11against other companies in the world. So I think
- 28:14it is very important that we sort of hold the
- 28:18line that we are not your friends and we are
- 28:21not here to make friends. We can have a productive
- 28:24and constructive relationship if we can work
- 28:27together to achieve the outcomes that we want.
- 28:29But if we can't, then it will go the other way
- 28:34in the form of a public campaign. And if they
- 28:36are unwilling to do that, then it is going to
- 28:38become an adversarial relationship. And that
- 28:40always needs to be an option. So for those corporations,
- 28:45they also have accountants and people who work
- 28:49from the office. They're not the ones. handling
- 28:54the animals or slaughtering them. But just like,
- 28:58you know, every employee at the Humane League
- 29:00is a campaigner, they do collaborate in that
- 29:06suffering. I wonder, after one of your campaign
- 29:11pressure campaign, did you hear of any employees
- 29:15from those corporations deciding to leave? you
- 29:20know after understanding after you exposed you
- 29:23know the suffering and what's happening behind
- 29:27closed doors i'm not aware of an instance where
- 29:30we've heard of an employee like leaving their
- 29:33job full stop we do pretty regularly get messages
- 29:37like anonymous messages from employees saying
- 29:39things like hey i work here and i really support
- 29:42what you're doing and keep it up so um you know,
- 29:45when I say these companies don't have any, you
- 29:47know, like individual people who work at these
- 29:49companies may very well be supportive of the
- 29:51issue. And, you know, often we do have a counterpart
- 29:55that we're negotiating with who seems to mean
- 29:58well and want to work collaboratively together
- 30:00to make progress. But I think at the end of the
- 30:03day, we have to be clear -eyed that at the end
- 30:05of the day, these are business decisions and
- 30:07we need to make a business rationale, right,
- 30:11for making that decision, which is basically
- 30:12that the cost of Not doing what we're what we
- 30:16want will be greater than the cost of doing what
- 30:19we want The cost is not necessarily, you know,
- 30:23you mentioned accountants and things like that
- 30:24like Our movement isn't really at a scale, if
- 30:27we're being honest with ourselves, that we can
- 30:29sort of boycott a company and sort of make a
- 30:31meaningful kind of impact on the bottom line.
- 30:34The impact is often more reputational. These
- 30:37companies really just don't want their name and
- 30:40animal cruelty appearing side by side in the
- 30:42same news story or tweet or video or what have
- 30:45you. But yeah, we have to incentivize them to
- 30:49make through negative incentives to make the
- 30:53changes that we want. What's the role of subsidies
- 30:58in all of that? I guess many of those corporations
- 31:01get a boost of confidence that you won't harm
- 31:06them because there are all of those subsidies
- 31:09in place. I often say that if I could change
- 31:13a single thing about the animal agriculture industry,
- 31:15it would be, at least in the US, it would be
- 31:17the heavy subsidies that are provided to the
- 31:19industry by the government. I think, honestly,
- 31:22it's a linchpin that holds the whole industry
- 31:24together, again, at least here in the United
- 31:27States. It artificially suppresses the cost rate
- 31:32of animal products significantly. I think the
- 31:35cost would be prohibitive for most. people, if
- 31:37those subsidies weren't in place, it does protect
- 31:39these companies financially and gives them, allows
- 31:43them to have allowed them over the years to scale
- 31:45and to grow and to reach the kind of market saturation
- 31:48that they have. So yes, that's subsidies, particularly
- 31:51of, you know, the animal agriculture industry,
- 31:54a huge barrier that we will eventually have to
- 31:58find a way to overcome as a movement to ultimately
- 32:00get to the end state that we want. Do you ever
- 32:05get paranoid by the power that those corporations
- 32:12hold. So for instance, there have been several
- 32:18environmental organizations, foundations that
- 32:22have released reports stating that those big
- 32:27corporations and interests have spied on animal
- 32:32rights activists or have launched, you know,
- 32:35social media campaigns against those animal rights
- 32:41organizations. Have you been the target of that?
- 32:45Do you think of it often? I don't think it's
- 32:49paranoid at all. I think it's just reality. I
- 32:52do have reason to believe that I myself personally
- 32:55in my career have been surveilled and watched
- 32:58by government agencies. Certainly companies have
- 33:02their own as you acknowledge private security
- 33:04and kind of intelligence apparatus that they
- 33:07use against activists. Absolutely. I think that
- 33:10is we have to assume that that's happening to
- 33:14us at all times. I don't think that I think it's
- 33:16practical and realistic to engage in that. And
- 33:18then also we just have to be confident. that
- 33:21we are doing the right thing. This is where,
- 33:24you know, having lawyers on staff is important
- 33:26to understand kind of, OK, we are operating within
- 33:28the boundaries of the law, whether it's things
- 33:30like, you know, whether it's about protest activity
- 33:32and what's permissible, you know, things like
- 33:35libel and slander laws. Right. It is very important
- 33:38that we are correct and defensible in all the
- 33:41messaging that we use. And so, you know, we have
- 33:44to pay attention to that. But as long as we are
- 33:46doing the right things and protecting ourselves
- 33:49in the way that we need to, I feel strongly that
- 33:51we can't let it bother us. We just have to go
- 33:53move full steam ahead and do our work and trust
- 33:56that if we are operating within the boundaries
- 33:58that we should be that that we're going to be
- 34:00OK. It doesn't mean that they may not try to
- 34:02make our lives difficult, but it's hard work
- 34:05and we have to keep doing it. Just a way to measure,
- 34:09you know, how big of a threat this is. Um, have
- 34:14you implemented measures when recruiting employees,
- 34:17you know, to see if they're generally, you know,
- 34:21um, caring for animals or, um, their spies or
- 34:27something of the sort, you know, trying to infiltrate
- 34:29the humane link. Yeah, we don't do necessarily
- 34:32a sort of full full -blown background check on
- 34:35every on every applicant But obviously we do
- 34:38our screening, you know, I think the same I think
- 34:40we do similar practices to what most mid -sized
- 34:42nonprofit organizations would have call references
- 34:45You know ensure that people are who they're representing
- 34:48themselves to be But yeah, I this is just one
- 34:53of those areas where I think we just have to
- 34:55accept a little bit of risk sometimes and And
- 34:59be confident that, and I am confident about this,
- 35:02right? That there's nothing we're doing at the
- 35:04Humane League that in terms of our communications,
- 35:07in terms of our tactics, in terms of what we
- 35:08talk about internally, that I wouldn't be comfortable
- 35:12seeing the light of day. I don't necessarily
- 35:14want every company to have insight into all of
- 35:16our different planning and our strategy and all
- 35:17that, but I'm very confident that even if somebody
- 35:20were to be inside the organization and kind of
- 35:23release a whole bunch of documents or whatever,
- 35:24we're not doing anything wrong. You know, so
- 35:27I think we have to just feel confident that we're
- 35:29doing the right thing and carry on with our work
- 35:31and not. I think we can twist ourselves up into
- 35:34knots trying to play defense. And I think that
- 35:36distracts us from our important work to play
- 35:38offense. Definitely, I agree with that. Okay,
- 35:44so earlier, you mentioned how it is important
- 35:47to make the work of your employee, make them
- 35:53feel like this is meaningful work and make them
- 35:56feel like they have a share in the victories.
- 36:01I want to ask you about the victories, but first
- 36:04the failures. I'm sure you have some failures.
- 36:10Can you name a few of those and how you dealt
- 36:13with the aftermath of those failures? I can.
- 36:20I'm relatively new to my role here. I've been
- 36:23in my role for about six months. So hopefully
- 36:26I haven't had too many big failures in six months.
- 36:29I will say that looking at the Humane League
- 36:32though, historically and before my tenure, there's
- 36:35a well -known example in the movement. Some of
- 36:38your listeners may be familiar with it. There
- 36:40was a big campaign. that a number of organizations
- 36:43led several years ago against McDonald's, trying
- 36:45to get McDonald's to make progress on broiler
- 36:48chicken welfare, welfare for chickens that are
- 36:50raised to be eaten as opposed to raised for eggs.
- 36:54A lot of time and energy was put into the campaign.
- 36:56It was, I think, a well -run and strategically
- 36:58sound campaign, but it ultimately didn't bring
- 37:01about the victory that we had hoped, and ultimately
- 37:03organizations had to make the decision to move
- 37:05on, rather than continue to kind of bang their
- 37:08heads against this wall. And we can look at that
- 37:11as a failure. I think that would be one way to
- 37:12look at that, because it was. We set out to achieve
- 37:15a goal, and we didn't achieve it. And a lot of
- 37:18time and energy was put into that, and obviously
- 37:20that's always a shame when that happens. I also
- 37:23though, another way I think about this though
- 37:25is I think we can't be afraid to fail as a movement.
- 37:29I mean obviously we want to win and we don't
- 37:31want to fail, but I feel very strongly that if
- 37:33we never fail at anything it means that we're
- 37:35not trying hard enough and we're not stepping
- 37:37outside of our comfort zone. If we only do things
- 37:40as an organization or as a movement that we know
- 37:43are going to work, then we're never going to
- 37:45try anything new. And we're never going to innovate.
- 37:48We'll never find new approaches that may be even
- 37:50more effective than what we're doing currently.
- 37:52So I'd always prefer to win a campaign than lose
- 37:55a campaign. And I'd certainly prefer not to spend
- 37:57a lot of money on a campaign that we don't ultimately
- 37:59win. But I do feel like when we have those moments,
- 38:03the important thing to do is just kind of figure
- 38:05out what we can learn from them and how that
- 38:07can inform our work to be more effective in the
- 38:10future and not sort of beat ourselves up over
- 38:12the fact that we didn't win this one. There will
- 38:16be failures. There have been and there will continue
- 38:18to be. And I think we can't be afraid of them.
- 38:20We have to be we have to embrace failure as a
- 38:22part of the path to success. I love that entrepreneurial
- 38:27spirit. Okay, let's talk about the victories.
- 38:32Which victory from the Humane League is your
- 38:35favorite one? It's a great question. I'm going
- 38:38to go with a relatively recent one just because
- 38:40I'm relatively new to my role. Earlier this year,
- 38:43we won a campaign against Subway to get them
- 38:47to go 100 % cage -free in all of their North
- 38:50American operations. And it was probably the
- 38:54biggest campaign that we've won in my tenure
- 38:57with THL, so that kind of makes it my favorite
- 38:59by default. But beyond that, it isn't necessarily
- 39:04our single biggest campaign victory. That victory
- 39:08impacted about 300 ,000. hens who will now live
- 39:11outside of battery cages as a result of the victory,
- 39:13which is not nothing, but we've also won campaigns
- 39:15where the hens are measured in the millions as
- 39:17opposed to the hundreds of thousands. But what
- 39:19I liked about the win with Subway is that it
- 39:22demonstrated a couple of things. It demonstrated
- 39:25a long -term strategy. This is a company that
- 39:28we've been working with for 10 years or more,
- 39:30not necessarily always in a public campaign mode.
- 39:33But in terms of working with them to try to get
- 39:36to this outcome, it's been a very long time coming.
- 39:39And I think it speaks to the value of sort of
- 39:41never giving up and not walking away. I also
- 39:46think that it Subway, and I'm going to nerd out
- 39:49on the campaign strategy here for just a moment,
- 39:51but Subway is a heavily franchised company, right?
- 39:55So most Subway locations are franchise owned.
- 39:58And we took a different strategy with this campaign
- 40:00than we have taken with some previous campaigns,
- 40:02which is that we really focused on applying pressure
- 40:05to the franchisees in addition to the kind of
- 40:09the corporate mothership, if you will. And that
- 40:12seemed to work very effectively. Because if you
- 40:14think about the incentive structure, Subway is
- 40:18a big multinational organization, billion dollar
- 40:20company. But a Subway franchisee, they might
- 40:24own three Subways in their community. It's almost
- 40:28like a network of small businesses that have
- 40:29a lot more to lose. If we were to decide that
- 40:32we're going to target one of their franchisees
- 40:35with a kind of pressure campaign. So what we
- 40:38found through this campaign is that actually
- 40:40applying pressure to those franchisees in addition
- 40:42to the kind of corporate mothership was very
- 40:45effective at building incentive across the corporate
- 40:49structure to adhere to the commitment that they
- 40:52had made. And I really liked that we found something
- 40:55new that we think works and we think can be applicable
- 40:58to future campaigns. Am I hearing that you gained
- 41:02an appetite for replicating that with other businesses
- 41:06with the same business model? Yeah, exactly that.
- 41:11Different companies are different, right? And
- 41:13it requires different types of tactics and strategies
- 41:16to win against different kinds of companies.
- 41:18And I do feel like, yeah, we found something
- 41:20that works with a particular kind of company
- 41:21here. And now we know that and we can have that
- 41:24in our toolbox for the future. Yes, that's amazing.
- 41:28I love how this is a whole chess game. It feels
- 41:34that way. I guess, since you're a very successful
- 41:40nonprofit, what should other animal charities
- 41:43out there, animal causes, learn from the Humane
- 41:48League? Well, I think, as I mentioned earlier,
- 41:53I think one of the secrets to our success is
- 41:55focus. And I think the movement needs a range
- 41:59of different approaches. I don't think everybody
- 42:01should be doing the same thing. But I do think
- 42:03organizations are stronger when they sort of
- 42:06pick one core theory of change, one core strategy
- 42:09for creating impact and going all in, right?
- 42:11For us, it's corporate welfare campaigns. For
- 42:14another organization, it might be vegan advocacy.
- 42:16For another, it might be public policy change.
- 42:18You know what I mean? But I do feel like, and
- 42:20I've worked at many organizations that are very
- 42:22scattered in their approach. They try to do a
- 42:24lot of things. And then by definition, they only
- 42:27do each of those things so well. So I think one
- 42:31piece of advice I would offer if folks are interested
- 42:34would be to kind of think about how to focus
- 42:36in on like a core thing that you can do really
- 42:38very well. And if we have enough of those groups
- 42:41doing enough of those core things very, very
- 42:43well, we'll have the coordinated movement wide
- 42:45strategy that we need. I think it's good advice.
- 42:49I've heard that before from successful entrepreneurs,
- 42:52you know. at least in the business world, it's
- 42:54something you hear often, you know, how important
- 42:57it is to stay focused. Do you have a timeline
- 43:03in mind on, you know, when we could see true,
- 43:08you know, substantial progress in this movement?
- 43:14Yeah, it all depends, I think, on what we mean
- 43:16by true substantial progress. One of the ways
- 43:20that I think about this question is factory farming
- 43:24is a relatively recent invention in the grand
- 43:26scheme of things. I'm sure your listeners are
- 43:29familiar with this, but you know, humans have
- 43:31been doing agriculture of various kinds for like
- 43:3310 ,000 years, quite a long time. And factory
- 43:36farming has got about 100 years of history. And
- 43:39so if you look at it as a kind of moment in time
- 43:42in the history of human agriculture, it's really
- 43:44quite a short moment. And I say that for because
- 43:48I think for many people, you know, perhaps not
- 43:51your listeners, but for most kind of normal,
- 43:53typical consumers, I think they have this idea
- 43:56that this is just the way we've always done things,
- 43:59right? When I talk to people, I don't talk to
- 44:02anybody for the most part who says, I think it's
- 44:04great that animals suffer on factory farms. I
- 44:07think most people have some amount of sympathy
- 44:09for the idea that like, yeah, that sounds pretty
- 44:11bad when you tell me about it. But I think it
- 44:14often runs up against this barrier of, but I
- 44:16don't know what else we would do. And I think
- 44:19you see this a lot. You see this at the previous
- 44:23stage of my career, I worked in the movement
- 44:25to end global poverty. And we saw there's a similar
- 44:29dynamic with the anti -poverty movement. If you
- 44:33try to convince somebody that poverty is bad,
- 44:35it doesn't really move the needle because people
- 44:37either already know that, like of course it is,
- 44:39or they don't care, in which case they're not
- 44:41going to do anything anyway. But if you can convince
- 44:43people that it's possible to end poverty, That
- 44:46message is very motivating, because it actually
- 44:48does cut through what people's real mental barrier
- 44:51is, which is that like, I know that it's bad
- 44:53that people live in poverty, but this is just
- 44:56the way that it's always been. And so I think
- 44:58about that point about factory farming being
- 45:01a relatively new invention, really just a factor
- 45:04of the past hundred years of human history, as
- 45:06a way to help people understand that we don't
- 45:08have to do it this way. Right. And it's one thing
- 45:12to even talk about obviously living in a world
- 45:13where no animals are raised or killed for food
- 45:15at all. I very much hope that we live in that
- 45:17world one day. But I don't think I'm going to
- 45:19see that world. I don't think my daughter is
- 45:21going to see that world. I don't think her children,
- 45:23if she has them, will see that world. I think
- 45:25that world is a very long time coming. Whereas
- 45:28I don't think it's crazy to think that if it
- 45:31took 100 years to build the factory farming industry,
- 45:34maybe it'll take 100 years to dismantle it. And
- 45:37I think we're actually already into that hundred
- 45:40years as we speak, right? As I mentioned, you
- 45:43know, even just using the use of the battery
- 45:46cage as a kind of proxy for the worst abuses
- 45:48of just over the past 20 years, we've gone from
- 45:52basically zero, right? To 45 % of the entire
- 45:56industry in 20 years. That's significant progress.
- 45:59I believe we could end the use of cages in the
- 46:03next 20 years. And now, you know, does that bring
- 46:06us all the way to the end of factory farming?
- 46:08Of course not, let alone all the way to a kind
- 46:09of vegan future, but that would be meaningful
- 46:12progress and a meaningful reduction in suffering
- 46:15for tens of millions of animals every single
- 46:18year. So I think that kind of progress is very
- 46:21doable on maybe a shorter time period, measured
- 46:25in decades, than people might think. And I think
- 46:28that kind of full dismantling of, of the industry
- 46:31of factory farming, right. And going back to
- 46:34something that might've looked more like the
- 46:35industry looked a hundred years ago, I think
- 46:37is very doable if not in my lifetime, but perhaps
- 46:40in my daughter's lifetime. It makes me feel optimistic.
- 46:43What you just said, I don't want you to be right,
- 46:47but still, you know, there's a positive spin
- 46:50to that reality. Um, yes, I agree with. your
- 46:56assessment, but do you think we'll see more progress
- 46:59maybe in certain countries versus others? And
- 47:04maybe even we'll see in our lifetime, the kind
- 47:07of world we wish existed, but only in a couple
- 47:12of countries. It's certainly possible. I agree
- 47:15with you that industry change is very kind of
- 47:20geography dependent, right? A big part of our
- 47:24work at the Humane League is outside of the US.
- 47:26We coordinate a coalition of organizations called
- 47:29the Open Wing Alliance, which is about 95 organizations
- 47:33operating in 75 countries around the world, all
- 47:36working to end the use of extreme confinement
- 47:38in the factory farming industry. So in a lot
- 47:41of places that they operate, like Sub -Saharan
- 47:43Africa, for instance, we actually haven't seen
- 47:46the full industrialization of the agriculture
- 47:48industry as we have in North America and in Europe,
- 47:51for instance. So in places like that, we're not
- 47:55necessarily trying to dismantle a factory farming
- 47:57industry. Rather, we're trying to prevent it
- 48:00from taking hold in the way that it has in other
- 48:02parts of the world. So actually, another thing
- 48:05I feel very optimistic about is I think there
- 48:07are parts of the world where we could maybe prevent
- 48:10the full industrialization of agriculture before
- 48:12it even happens. You know, because they're just
- 48:15further along. They're not as far along in their
- 48:17journey yet. And that's actually quite exciting
- 48:19to think about. It's sort of a counterfactual
- 48:21way of thinking about it. But, you know, we're
- 48:24never wide scale uses of battery cages in some
- 48:27parts of the world. Right. And we were to just
- 48:29head that off entirely. I think that kind of
- 48:31progress is very, very meaningful and very possible
- 48:33for sure. Open wings. I love the name. I. Wish
- 48:40to ask you about, you know, backyard chickens.
- 48:43Uh, this is something I covered on my show. Um,
- 48:46I'm against it. You know, do you think this is
- 48:50good PR for the poultry industry that people,
- 48:54you know, um, cannot differentiate backyard chickens
- 49:00to the chickens they get at, you know, grocery
- 49:04stores or at least they develop a certain insensitivity
- 49:09towards. chickens because they are turned into
- 49:13farmers or they get that farmer mindset. How
- 49:19do you have any reflection around that? Yeah,
- 49:22it's not something we have a sort of institutional
- 49:25position on at the Humane League. It's sort of
- 49:27outside of our line of work on a personal level.
- 49:30Yeah, I don't think people should raise animals
- 49:32for food. And so I don't think people should
- 49:34raise animals for food. I do think that it I
- 49:38think one of the challenges of things like backyard
- 49:40chickens or the kind of like I do think it creates
- 49:43a perception that it's possible right to sort
- 49:47of at scale right at the scale of the hundreds
- 49:50of millions of animals right. raise animals for
- 49:53food in a way that people would feel comfortable
- 49:56with. I just don't, I don't think there is any
- 49:58version of that that's possible. And as you're
- 49:59saying, right, sure, maybe you can rate maybe
- 50:02somebody with who knows what they're doing can
- 50:04raise a chicken in their backyard and they can
- 50:06live a happy life. I don't, I don't know, you
- 50:08know, maybe that's possible, but it's like, I
- 50:10think it creates an unrealistic expectation that
- 50:12there's a version of that that's kind of scalable
- 50:15to meet the kind of demand, you know, of the
- 50:18hundreds of millions of people that live in this
- 50:19country. And I think there is a real a real risk
- 50:22with that. Dan, I think I asked you everything
- 50:25I wanted to ask you. Did you want to add something
- 50:28before I stopped the recording? I think we've
- 50:32covered most of what I had hoped that we would
- 50:34talk about. I think I think the main the main
- 50:37thing I would encourage people to think about
- 50:38is that there's a role for everybody to play
- 50:45and kind of bringing out bringing about this
- 50:48Future that we've been talking about right and
- 50:50I do feel like you know again I made the choice
- 50:52to go vegan 30 years ago It's best choice ever
- 50:55made in my life and I'll never go back and I
- 50:57think it's important that we make those kinds
- 50:58of choices and also I think participating in
- 51:01the movement as an activist, you know, it is
- 51:04as Important, you know as sort of making individual
- 51:08personal behavior change choices I think partially
- 51:11because and I because I think it's important
- 51:13that these companies hear from everybody Right.
- 51:16Who feels the way that we do about farmed animals,
- 51:18even if you're never going to buy a cage free
- 51:20egg. I'm never going to buy a cage free egg.
- 51:22And here I am advocating for companies to go
- 51:24catering and their supply chain. Right. But I
- 51:26think the more vocal all of us are and the more
- 51:28visible we are with our beliefs and the more
- 51:30we translate our beliefs into pressure on the
- 51:34industry. Right. Both direct and indirect. I
- 51:36think the more progress we're going to make.
- 51:39And I want more people to be to adopt the same
- 51:43practical approach that the humane league has
- 51:47towards this issue, which is a more nuanced and
- 51:51strategic approach, one that meets people where
- 51:55they are. Yeah, I really like it. So if people
- 52:01want to, you know, support your mission, or be
- 52:05part of this effort, what are the best ways you
- 52:08know, for them to connect with you? So Folks
- 52:11who want to learn more about our work can visit
- 52:13thehumaneleague .org and learn more about our
- 52:17corporate campaigns, the victories that we've
- 52:19won. They can find ways to get involved in their
- 52:21local community. They can sign up to be a part
- 52:23of our Changemaker program, or they can connect
- 52:26with other local activists in their area to take
- 52:29action to support farmed animals. And of course,
- 52:32we always need more financial support, as every
- 52:34organization does. We recently released a cost
- 52:38effectiveness study that says that it costs us
- 52:4150 cents to free an egg laying hen from a cage
- 52:45through a programmatic work. So even a donation
- 52:47of a dollar, right, will help us get two hens
- 52:50out of cages for the rest of their lives. So
- 52:53as people are thinking about, you know, their
- 52:55personal giving, especially at the end of the
- 52:57year, we welcome all the support that we can
- 52:59get. Yes, it's giving Tuesday, actually. And
- 53:06And, you know, yeah, be part of the Humane League,
- 53:10be a hero. I kept thinking about the Justice
- 53:13League. I like that part of our name. It does
- 53:18feel like it's a team you want to be a part of.
- 53:21Exactly. Yes. So be a hero, be part of the Humane
- 53:26League. and join Dan in the good work that he's
- 53:31doing and leading. Dan, thank you so much for
- 53:34your activism. Thank you for having stopped by
- 53:36and discuss your amazing work. Truly amazing
- 53:41conversation. Thank you. Thank you for having
- 53:43me. It's been a pleasure. Thank you everyone
- 53:45for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 53:48podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 53:51more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 53:55so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday
- 53:58for a new episode.