Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #57 🎙️ | Public Inquiry -Common Wealth Mining Feasibility Guidelines Week beginning 12th May 2026 | Day 1
Transcript
- 0:04The day started with some talk about the timetables again, and
- 0:07it was a plan to switch around the dates for non water ecology
- 0:11with culture and heritage. This draft version lasted until at
- 0:15least lunchtime, but lo and behold, when we came back after
- 0:18lunch, it was changed once more. And frankly, now I'm not clear
- 0:23at all about the timetable. I imagine I'm not the only one.
- 0:27Timetable is important for us, the third parties, as we have to
- 0:31fly in our expert witnesses from abroad. We have already lost one
- 0:36set of airfares from the US due to timetable changes. And also,
- 0:41there are folk in our group who have given up all of their
- 0:43holiday leave for this year to be able to attend a public
- 0:46inquiry. They have no wiggle room left, so they do not want
- 0:50the public inquiry to continue in September, preferring that it
- 0:53continues April 2027 when their new holiday for the year opens
- 0:58up, listening to the arguments around the table, timetable
- 1:03drawn on and on. I was imagining a scenario where the commission
- 1:08and all of the departments, the applicants and all of their
- 1:11people, cross the room and physically swap shoes with the
- 1:15third parties. Imagine them sitting in our chairs in the
- 1:19auditorium. Imagine them living our lives in houses close to the
- 1:23mine. I see them in my mind's eye, them being told, this is
- 1:27your home. Now. Imagine them not being able to get into their
- 1:30cars and simply drive comfortably and carelessly away,
- 1:34but to be trapped here forever in our lives, having decisions
- 1:37made about their lives that they have little or no control over I
- 1:41want to ask them, what would they do in our circumstances?
- 1:45Would they continue to be polite about not being able to
- 1:47participate in the public inquiry as the timetable and the
- 1:50narrow narrative becomes rigged for exclusion, would they just
- 1:55sit quietly accept the monstrosity of a mine plunked
- 1:58into the centre of their world? Would they build their big,
- 2:02fancy houses that I imagine they live in in close proximity to
- 2:06the mine? Would they send their children to a school that was
- 2:09overlooked by mine tailings waste facility? Would they
- 2:14become angry and upset at the fractures created in their
- 2:17communities? What would they see? What would they experience?
- 2:21What would they feel? How would they cope with a heavy blanket
- 2:24of anxiety and desperation? What would they do? Such were my
- 2:28thoughts during the timetable discussions today. Anyways, I
- 2:32guess we better move on, as we actually struggled with many
- 2:35other questions today as well. Another topic early in the day
- 2:41was the section 76 agreements, which we were just about to
- 2:44start on when Cormac McAleer brought the attention of the
- 2:46commission to a new document published in January to 2026
- 2:51called the Commonwealth model mining feasibility study
- 2:56guidelines. What a mouthful, which he believed is relevant to
- 3:00the public inquiry and should be considered as part of the
- 3:03evidence base. Cormac explained that, to date, del radian have
- 3:08not produced a feasibility study publicly, or at least none that
- 3:12we've seen present during proceedings. If this new
- 3:17evidence is accepted, it raises important questions for the
- 3:21department for infrastructure around standards assessments,
- 3:24frameworks and the adequacy of evidence currently before the
- 3:29inquiry, if rejected, many people will inevitably ask what
- 3:35that means for public confidence In the inquiry process itself,
- 3:40particularly where potentially relevant evidence and
- 3:43international guidance are concerned. So what is the
- 3:47purposes of a feasibility study? To quote from the publication, a
- 3:52feasibility study is not simply a technical or financial
- 3:56document. It is the first and most important step in deciding
- 4:00whether a mining project should go ahead, it tests whether a
- 4:05proposed project is realistic, responsible and aligned with
- 4:09national development priorities. Without rigorous feasibility
- 4:13studies, governments risk granting approvals to projects
- 4:17that may be unsuitable fail to deliver expected benefits or
- 4:21create disproportionate social and environmental costs. The
- 4:27commission has reserved its position on whether the document
- 4:29and associated guidelines will be accepted into the inquiry
- 4:33process, saying they would let us know in the morning, at
- 4:38least. I think that's what they said, right? So back to Section
- 4:4176 what is it? The key aspects of it are, it enables councils
- 4:47to enter into a legally binding, voluntary agreement with
- 4:51landowners developers to secure obligations necessary to make a
- 4:54development acceptable. And these agreements are often used
- 4:59for information. Structure contributions and must be
- 5:02completed before planning permission is issued. This
- 5:07agreement will probably be between delraydian Crown Estate
- 5:11and dfi, and will include a bond of money to be held by
- 5:15delraydian in one of their accounts, equivalent to about 20
- 5:19million. There was a discussion around if this would be enough
- 5:23to maintain a site in perpetuity. But Mary old Mr.
- 5:28Murray, speaking for dalradian, did not accept that it was a
- 5:31perpetuity situation, or that a one in 10,000 Year catastrophe
- 5:36event was likely to occur. Dr Brian Garvey, I think concluded
- 5:42that statement by saying, Sure, that's like saying the Titanic
- 5:45was unsinkable. Around about now, the conversation kept
- 5:50drifting off towards the so called dry stack facility,
- 5:53which, of course, we all know by now is a marketing term for mine
- 5:58waste, tailings, toxic dump over the course of the morning, what
- 6:03became glaringly obvious was the more the commissioners tried to
- 6:06reduce each question down to one narrow area, in a classic
- 6:10example of reductionist thinking, the more the
- 6:13connections to other areas continued to emerge and expand.
- 6:18In many instances, it became almost impossible and at times
- 6:21ridiculous, to discuss one aspect in isolation without
- 6:25acknowledging the wider interconnected issues, simply in
- 6:29order to stay within the procedural boundaries set by the
- 6:32Commission. Finally, a third party comment on the section 76
- 6:38noted that if dalradian does sign the agreement they actually
- 6:41don't have any assets, as Wheaton owns everything, leaving
- 6:45delrayden as a mere shell company. And to find out more
- 6:49about this, listen to the podcast from last week. I'll put
- 6:53the links in the show notes. Who Moved on then to agriculture,
- 6:58and with Paul Hollywood speaking about his anxieties about the
- 7:01future of his farm and his son's livelihoods, as their farm is
- 7:05right next door to the mine, followed by Linda Sullivan
- 7:09speaking about living in South America near a gold mine and
- 7:12witnessing the distress of cows whose health had been severely
- 7:16impacted by drinking water from The mine. Dermot Devlin, another
- 7:21resident, spoke about the importance of clean air for his
- 7:24health. Explained how long it had taken him to find a
- 7:27treatment that finally allowed him to breathe easily. He
- 7:30described how significantly his health is affected whenever air
- 7:35quality deteriorates. I spoke myself about Patton null Gagan
- 7:40and the horrific experience they endured with their farm animals
- 7:44and how both their own health and well being of their family
- 7:46had been profoundly impacted. And check out their podcast in
- 7:51the link in the show notes as well. Dorina Fyffe also spoke
- 7:56about the food industry in Northern Ireland, noting that
- 7:59the Balmoral show is currently taking place, a major showcase
- 8:04for agriculture and food producers across the region. She
- 8:07raised important questions about what impact the proposed mine
- 8:11could have on agricultural produce, food quality and the
- 8:15reputation of Northern Ireland's farming and food sector. The
- 8:20afternoon started with a deposition from Tara mine ex
- 8:23employees about how wonderful Everton was down to the mine in
- 8:26navan, in stark contrast to what we've been told by the
- 8:29organisation called scent representatives, who tell quite
- 8:34a different story. Other afternoon discussions included
- 8:38terberry rights, which Mr. Beatty, the counsel for
- 8:42dalradian, went to some pains to explain what they were to the
- 8:46Welly ware and sheep farmers. Prices of houses, we are told,
- 8:52are not considered to be of material consideration by the
- 8:54applicant. I wondered, if they lived in them themselves, would
- 8:59they then consider them a material consideration we had
- 9:03mental health mansplained to us by a Mr. Baroni expert witness
- 9:08for the applicant through a series of questions, we discover
- 9:13all of his research is via a tabletop exercise. That is to
- 9:17say, no primary research done, but it's all fine and dandy
- 9:22because there are no receptors. He essentially dismissed mental
- 9:26health issues in relation to the mine. Fidel McCain, Bill
- 9:31Donnelly, Dr Chris O'Connell all answered barony's observations
- 9:35with their lived experiences, both here and across the world.
- 9:41This question came to a close with Mary brawley's observations
- 9:44that local people are receptors suffering harassment,
- 9:48intimidation, anxiety, sleepless nights, all in relation to the
- 9:53mine. And right now, I've run out of energy, so I'm bringing
- 9:57this podcast to a halt, and I'll see you all tomorrow.
- 10:00Tomorrow, you.