Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Do Collective Efforts At Ohio State Have The SEC Running Scared?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Oh, Tony?
- 0:13On the Morning Show for Tuesday, you and I talked about this crazy
- 0:17month of news in Ohio State football and players coming back and transfer portal editions
- 0:24and all that kind of stuff. Today, Tony, I regret to inform
- 0:28you we're going to be talking about the dark side of college football. It
- 0:32turns out, Tony, that nil is a thing that is happening. It
- 0:37could be happening in your neighborhood, Tony, in the area where our listeners'
- 0:42children go to school. Tony, Nil is it coming for your children next?
- 0:49I don't know. We're going to try and explore that space in the
- 0:51next twenty six to seventy two minutes or so. How it sounds like you're
- 0:58saying the Ohio State collectives are putting nil in tail and all around the nation
- 1:03and just leaving them on shelves. Tony, I'm going to If you're just
- 1:07listening as a podcast, you can't see this. But I have a frying
- 1:11pan here and I have egg I have some eggs, and I'm going to
- 1:15create the eggs represent your children in college football as we know it, and
- 1:22the frying pan represents nil, Tony. This is your sport on nil well,
- 1:30and fittingly, Ohio State learned it from watching you, all right,
- 1:34they learned it from watching you. You know, Tony. It's interesting that
- 1:38that's the punchline because a lot of the concern about Ohio State's recent nil fora's
- 1:46have been coming from the southeastern part of the country, which is curious,
- 1:49Tony, because that is how can I put this diplomatically? It is an
- 1:57area in which comps for amateur athletes is not the newest concept. So it's
- 2:04fascinating to see the level of concern that is coming out of the Southeastern Conference
- 2:08footprint over some recent developments in the sport. Yeah, and it was also
- 2:14fascinating that to one of those people who seem to be most concerned, maybe
- 2:19depending on how you want to take this is Lane Kiffin, Ole miss head
- 2:22coach, who tweeted out an article from a click farm site citing a person
- 2:29on Twitter saying that Ohio State has spent thirteen or Ohio State collectives have spent
- 2:32thirteen million dollars on building their team to this point. And that precludes that
- 2:38was before Caleb Downs came aboard. So it's interesting that Lane Kiffin, the
- 2:45guy who has championed the transfer portal and come to the SIP and but he
- 2:52just tweeted it out there, you know, tweets the article out there.
- 2:53You can take that as he's trying to bring attention to a negative thing,
- 3:00like I can't believe this is going on, or is like, hey,
- 3:04everybody's doing it. I with Lane, he's just you know, sticking a
- 3:08knife in and just trying to tweak anybody he can. But he's not the
- 3:13only one you have there. There's a Saturday down south compared to Ohio State
- 3:16to live golf in terms of like yeah, they spend a lot of money,
- 3:20but they're not really winning anything. I have I have talked to other
- 3:23people who in the in the NFL when they talk to sources or departments that
- 3:32there are concerns at Ohio State is getting involved this way, the collectives are
- 3:38bouncing back this way. But I did find it interesting that on three after
- 3:43that thirteen million dollar report comes out, they say, well, Ohio State's
- 3:46you know, not there yet. That the top programs are within are around
- 3:52like ten to fifteen million dollars right now. And so Tim, it's not
- 3:57that Ohio State is spending a bunch more than anybody else else the collectives.
- 4:00It's just that now they are what is going on is reportedly comparable to what
- 4:05else is going on. And remember these numbers are all if you consider like
- 4:11a recipe for a cake and you don't have quite all of the ingredients,
- 4:15and the recipe calls for butter, but you've get like, well, I've
- 4:16got some miracle up, I'll just use that. It calls for garlic powder.
- 4:18It looks like, well, I've got some seasoned salt, like it
- 4:21might end up looking somewhat like a cake. Like the numbers are somewhat accurate,
- 4:25but there's no way they're entirely accurate. But basically, people are getting
- 4:30upset around the country. It is specifically in the Southeast that Ohio State is
- 4:34now apparently getting into their realm of talent procurement, talent retainment and just all
- 4:45good old college football. Can we go back to the part where you're making
- 4:48a cake where the recipe calls for garlic powder, we can we expect that
- 4:53space for a minute savory cake that sounds like quite a savory cake. I'm
- 4:59sure these the play of re salt will do just fine. Just a little
- 5:01shit, it's shaken bake. He can subsake, shake and bake for anything.
- 5:05Write that down. That's good advice. Yeah. I just was scrolling
- 5:09through as you're talking, scrolling through Lane Kiffin's timeline, and I had to
- 5:13go all the way back, Tony. Eight days January fifteenth, lane Kiffen
- 5:16tweets hashtag transfer to the SIP, three exclamation points, we just getting started,
- 5:21shark emoji at ole Miss football, and then a screenshot of the transfer
- 5:27portal rankings for this cycle. Tony, I'm not sure that any concerns that
- 5:36lane Kiffin may have about transfer, you know, the transfer portal impact,
- 5:41transfer culture, what have you, might be the most intellectually well founded,
- 5:46shall we say. I would say there's probably also some relationship to While Lane
- 5:49Kiffin has brought in a bunch of transfer portal players and has benefited greatly from
- 5:53that, he's also lost Davis nig Nossen ANTIWM alone and now quin Shawn Judkins
- 5:58to Ohio State. So I do think that's part of the concern as well.
- 6:00But you know, the thirteen million dollar number. I saw that was
- 6:03thrown out at one point, and then they got picked up by the click
- 6:09farm site, and then Lane Kiffin ttweeted it out, and then the person
- 6:12who initially reported it said, look confirmation. It's like, no, that's
- 6:16just someone saying that thing that you said, and it's like everyone said,
- 6:19this number is ridiculous, and then now look it's been confirmed by Lane Kiff,
- 6:24and it's like, that's not how any of this works. And even
- 6:27if we do, like you said, even if we do assume all of
- 6:30these numbers are exactly right, they're all stipulate, well just for the moment,
- 6:32stipulate everything is exactly right. This is not you know, I don't
- 6:39think Texas A and M was ever actually spending thirty million dollars on a recruiting
- 6:43class, like the numbers were a lot of the numbers in the space are
- 6:45just absolute garbage. But this is not the first team to put money out
- 6:51there, and they're not, you know, according to all of the publicly
- 6:55available numbers right now, for whatever those are worth, the numbers out there
- 6:58on Ohio State, for whatever those are earth, are very much in line,
- 7:01as you said, with what a lot of other programs are doing,
- 7:03and so exactly I'm gonna need to see sort of what's the problem here,
- 7:10because it's not like Ohio State has brought in fifteen players of the transfer portal.
- 7:15Ohio State's brought in I believe, six players in the transfer port which
- 7:19is very much in line with what pretty much everyone else is doing. And
- 7:26you're not going to be able to I don't. I don't think you're going
- 7:28to be able to bring in forty players in the transfer portal like Colorado did
- 7:33and see things actually work out. Like you need to have a certain semblance
- 7:38of culture. You need to have guys who've played together for a while,
- 7:41and then it's like a garnish, it's just okay, well, oh hey,
- 7:45we've got the cake made. It's gonna taste just like garlic. It's
- 7:47gonna be delicious. Okay, now we just need to put the frosting on
- 7:50it. The frosting, Tony, what are you putting in your frosting on
- 7:54this cake? Is it like Frank's Red Hot or no, it's more of
- 7:58a you know, like the the meatloaf ketchup topping. Okay, yeah,
- 8:03okay, so so yeah, so like our garlic cake. With a ketchup
- 8:09frosting, a little meat loaf sprinkled on top, meat loaf sprinkles off the
- 8:13top. You're not going to make the whole cake out of the meat loaf,
- 8:18because then you don't have a cake. You don't have a cake,
- 8:18you have a meat loaf. So that's a totally different thing, right,
- 8:20But you can't have you can't build your whole roster at the transfer portal.
- 8:24You're supplementing out of the transfer portal. And what's amazing to me about this
- 8:28is all the programs that are complaining about this right now, or the programs
- 8:33the national programs that are complaining loudest about this right now, whether it's coaches
- 8:37or fan bases or websites, whatever, are all the ones that have been
- 8:43doing this for the last few years, just like Ohio State has been this
- 8:46is this is not like a brand new thing for Ohio State. They're just
- 8:50doing it a little better now than they were before. Yeah, and the
- 8:54thirteen million is the exact number of the Ryan Day said a year ago that
- 8:58Ohio State would need to keep everybody, and a year ago more than a
- 9:03year ago in terms of operating and keeping everybody, and then keeping up with
- 9:09everybody. So this is Ohio State's attempt to keep up with everybody. And
- 9:15you get the sense that that idea, that decision is concerning to a lot
- 9:20of programs around the nation because it's a lot easier to operate when Ohio State
- 9:26is kind of sitting back and no, we're going to do it our way.
- 9:28Well, we're not gonna it's it's one toe in. It's like the
- 9:31pool is clear because Ohio State's just sitting by the side with their legs in
- 9:35there and they're not getting in. And now that they've jumped in, they
- 9:37splash a lot. They're very loud and obnoxious. And now Ohio State is
- 9:46doing what they can and being involved more so, and they've kept their players,
- 9:50kept most of their players. They've they've gone to the portal, not
- 9:54more than the not more than they have in the past, honestly. And
- 10:00and now you just see this level of concern because that's what it looks like
- 10:03to me. It's not Ohio State isn't doing anything that anybody else is.
- 10:09It's just that it's Ohio State now because you look around the country and everybody
- 10:13is poaching from everybody. Everybody's signing players from everybody because of the the Nick
- 10:18statement has kind of started all of this once he retired and just through the
- 10:20entire college football world essentially wide open. But the fact that Ohio State is
- 10:26securing their own players, landing a couple of the nation's top transfer portal people
- 10:33that has honestly rankled a bunch of people. And I think it is a
- 10:37big concern. Now it's I don't want to say awoke in some sort of
- 10:43a giant, but the nation, the Southeastern Conference, the people in the
- 10:48Southeast, people, you know, the other college football powers liked it a
- 10:52lot better when Ohio State wasn't disinvested in being invested for sure. I mean,
- 10:58I think it has to be a huge concern for a program like Alabama
- 11:01when a program like Ohio State, large historically national power can go into the
- 11:09South and pull a running back out of a Southern school and just steal him
- 11:15away after that school has developed him for a couple of years. And that
- 11:18running backs name is Jamiir Gibbs, and he went from Georgia Tech to Alabama,
- 11:22and boy, for a program like Alabama to be able to take a
- 11:26position a prominent offensive posit player away from another program right at their level and
- 11:31be able to just plug him into their lineup and boy, just no repercussions
- 11:35at all. And that player's name is Jamison Williams and he went from Alabama,
- 11:39from Ohio State to Alabama, and oh boy, it is going to
- 11:43be devastating for the future of the sport of football. And you know,
- 11:48it feels like this is a you know, you know, the old me
- 11:54reaping, me sewing tweet where it's just you know, oh, you know,
- 11:58me reaping, ha, you know, or me sewing haha, me
- 12:01reaping. Oh, this is terrible. This is okay, this is how
- 12:07it is. The transfer portal. The transfer portal is not a one way
- 12:11door. This is this is a door that it's like one of those kitchen
- 12:13doors you know in the restaurant. It swings kind of both directions, like,
- 12:16well, sometimes you've got guys come in, sometimes you've got guys going
- 12:20out. Sometimes you have the legendary coach who is a big draw for everyone,
- 12:22and sometimes that guy leaves, and then there's a lot of questions about
- 12:28the future of your program and if the head coach was the one who was
- 12:31sort of holding it all together and We've talked on previous shows about, Hey,
- 12:35the history of Alabama football is not one of continuous and uninterrupted excellence.
- 12:41It is Bear Bryant and then some stuff happened, and then Nick Saban and
- 12:46the some stuff happened was not consistently excellent. And I don't know if Alabama
- 12:50is going to be able to maintain the Nick Saban level in perpetuity. So
- 12:56this is this is what college football is right now. I don't think this
- 12:58is what college football is going to be for the foreseeable future. I think
- 13:01you're going to see more rule changes that are going to change it. But
- 13:05if you are a program like Georgia, Alabama, Michigan, I mean,
- 13:09any of the many, of the many or all of the prominent national programs
- 13:13Texas who have been taking advantage of these roles in previous years, you don't
- 13:18really get to complain now that it's like, oh well, I don't like
- 13:20it when they do it, like in Texas. Texas right now is kind
- 13:24of in the Ohio State camp where they have had Texas has been kind of
- 13:28picking at the carcass of Alabama football the last few last few weeks as well.
- 13:31So this is you know, this is what it is, and it
- 13:35also is kind of an interesting, an interesting look at what might happen anytime
- 13:41a coach coaching change happens and there's not sort of an immediate replacement, And
- 13:43even if there is an immediate replacement, if there's questions about the immediate replacement,
- 13:48what that might open teams up to. So this is this is not
- 13:52how college football is going to be forever, but it's how college football is
- 13:54for everyone right now. Well, the Nick Saban thing has changed a lot
- 14:01because so many players went to Alabama for Nick Saban and you're seeing once he's
- 14:07gone, well, the reason I went there is no longer there, So
- 14:11I'm going to go to, you know, a second option or where I
- 14:13wanted to be, and that there's a place that I wouldn't mind being that
- 14:18you know, is still available. And Nick Saban obviously one of the great
- 14:22recruiters, if not the greatest recruiter of all time. So when he leaves,
- 14:26that recruiting leaves and the tie leaves, and so you're going to have
- 14:30this just huge deluge of players leaving. So it's I don't expect that for
- 14:37Alabama every year, and they'll be there'll be a fought okay, but Calen
- 14:43Borr has his work cut out for him bringing people back to Alabama because it's
- 14:46never hasn't been a hotbed for a while until Nick Saban got there. So
- 14:52the transfer portal rankings, Tom, there's a an article I think it's from
- 14:58twenty four to seven talking about the headline is Ohio State surges into top ten
- 15:01with Julian Sayan in the transfer portal rankings. Ohio State very big on the
- 15:07headlines and the transfer portal right now, Ohio State in twenty four seven's transfer
- 15:11portal rankings is nine in the top ten and first is Old miss with fifteen
- 15:18transfers, So that's a you know, that's a lot. Texas A and
- 15:22M second with twenty three transfers. Florida State fourteen. Five of those fourteen
- 15:28players former Alabama Crimson Tide players. Louisville at number four with twenty six players,
- 15:33Oregon number five with ten players. They've got some quality, not just
- 15:39quantity. And speaking of quantity, Colorado number six with twenty three and then
- 15:43seven Texas has seven transfers. So far, they've taken in seven transfers.
- 15:46South Carolina at eight with twenty transfers, and there you go, Ohio State
- 15:50number nine, having brought in six transfers. Washington rounds out the top ten
- 15:56with eleven transfers. So Ohio State in there with their there's six transfers outraging
- 16:03everybody. Ole Miss with the fifteen and Lane Kiffin trying to instigate some stuff
- 16:11is hilarious. But five state the fewest number of transfers in there, they're
- 16:15getting all of the the angst. And those two things are certainly related because
- 16:22if it's Ohio State doing it, then more people are going to take notice,
- 16:25and more people are going to be concerned about it, more programs are
- 16:26gonna be concerned about it, as we talked about. But when you look
- 16:29at this top ten, clearly there's some quality for Ohio State. And however
- 16:33they do their rankings, but it's just funny to see that Ohio State gets
- 16:37the look at how much they're spending, look at what they're doing, and
- 16:41they have six transfers compared to Texas A and M with twenty three, Ole
- 16:44Miss with fifteen. You know, even Oregon at ten with what they've done.
- 16:48Everybody else is flying under the radar because Ohio State landed three transfers who
- 16:52everybody else wanted. Well, I think there's a couple interesting things about this
- 16:57list. One is sure Ohio State showing up at nine at ninth with just
- 17:03six transfers, just behind a school that has twenty transfers. The other thing
- 17:07that's interesting is the quality of program and the number of transfers taken in seem
- 17:14to be inversely related. Here. Where Ohio State, one of the best
- 17:18programs of the country, has taken in six, Texas, just played in
- 17:21the College Football Playoff, has taken in seven. Oregon college Football Playoff adjacent,
- 17:26certainly in recent years, has taken in ten. The other teams at
- 17:29the top of this list that ones who are have taken in the most Louisville,
- 17:33Colorado, South Carolina, Texas, A, and M. Those are
- 17:37all schools where I mean Louisville played in the AEC Championship, but if you
- 17:40watch the ACEC Championship, you know Louisville not exactly college football Playoff adjacent right
- 17:45now. None of the other schools are really college football Playoff adjacent right now.
- 17:48This is sort of the two worlds of how teams use the transfer portal.
- 17:53One is we're going to just basically do a line change. Like hockey,
- 17:56We're going to bring in a whole new set of guys and we're going
- 18:00to help fill out the roster. Colorado's roster is like desperately short of guys,
- 18:03but a lot of other schools it's just like, well, we're just
- 18:06going to bring in a whole bunch of new guys, and the schools the
- 18:10Texas, the Ohio States are just kind of like finding guys to fill specific
- 18:14spots rather than just give me, you know, one of these, two
- 18:15of these, like Al Cervik in the pro Shop in Caddyshack. It's just
- 18:22it is two different ways to build a team, and you know, everyone
- 18:27is using the portal in some way. I think even Clemson has probably taken
- 18:30some transfers at this point. You know, everyone is sort of kind of
- 18:33having to sort of grow up and deal with the realities of modern college football
- 18:37where you're going to have to bring in transfers because you're going to lose people
- 18:40to the portal. So there's just kind of two different ways to do it.
- 18:44And I find it very difficult to believe that the school bringing in six
- 18:48transfers is the one that's going to ruin college football, and this is this
- 18:51is going to set college football back for decades and oh, this is the
- 18:53worst thing ever, and it's going to completely upset the balance of power in
- 18:56the sport. Which how many of the team's complaining have brought in at least
- 19:00six transfers in previous cycles. I'm going to guess virtually all. Yes,
- 19:07Tom, if there are any complainers who have brought in fewer, then let
- 19:11them stand in front of everybody and tell us how all to do it,
- 19:14and to do it properly and with gentlemen's handshakes and gentlemen's agreements like back in
- 19:18the days of yore, of the nineties and early two thousands. Something we
- 19:25have said from the outset of NIL, and we've had shows on it titled
- 19:27shows about this. NIL is not going to buy you a championship. You
- 19:33can't buy a championship with NIL because it takes more talked about. You need
- 19:37culture. And in this case in Landing Caleb Downs and Julian saying, those
- 19:44are prior relationships with the Ohio State coaches that led to them coming to Ohio
- 19:49State and to being an option to come to Ohio State. None of those
- 19:56guys are at Ohio State right now if Nick Saban doesn't retire. So this
- 20:00isn't Ohio State going out and just Willie Nilly. These are prior relationships that
- 20:04came in and the Ohio State recruited Julian saying even when he was recruited,
- 20:10when he was committed to Alabama, he stuck with Alabama. So they went
- 20:11and moved on to Aaron Noland. Caleb Downs was a Signing Day thing.
- 20:15We talked about it on the live show Signing Day Live Show last year and
- 20:18we did like eight hours and I think four of those hours were talking about
- 20:22Caleb Downs. Possibly you know what's going to happen if if I remember correctly,
- 20:27But when we've done these shows in the past, now I even remember
- 20:30tweeting one out and I think the question the title of the show is like
- 20:36can you buy a championship? With nil? And Brian Hartline either quote tweeted
- 20:41it or replied with no. And so this is this is how Ohio State
- 20:45views about it. But as you said, Tom, what you can do
- 20:48is supplement, and that's what Ohio State did with Justin Fields. That's what
- 20:53going and getting Trey Sermon the I think the outlier may be John Jenkins,
- 21:00like that was a surprise because where was the prior relationship. But through all
- 21:07of this, when I want to reiterate Tom something we also talked about,
- 21:11there are no batters for winning the off season. Whenever I'm tweeting or your
- 21:15tweeting, or we're talking or reporting about what Ohio State is doing, you'll
- 21:18have people underneath combating like good job on your off season championship. There's no
- 21:22such thing. This is just talking about what's going on, and things are
- 21:26good for Ohio State right now, but obviously what happens in the fall would
- 21:32determine how things go. But I want people to realize Ohio State had five
- 21:37transfers at this point last year. They've got six now. The reason they
- 21:40have six is because they had to replace their quarterback, so they had to
- 21:41go get a quarterback. So Ohio State's not doing anything that they haven't done
- 21:48in the past in terms of looking it's just I think the targets have been
- 21:52there been more targets out there. There have been guys that they've wanted more,
- 21:56and then obviously the the influx of capital to like, Okay, we're
- 22:02going to go do this, but I think these are just circumstances that Ohio
- 22:07State is taking advantage of. But it's also again, you're not going to
- 22:10buy a championship, Tom, but what they have done to supplement that,
- 22:12and when I say buy a championship, it helps to keep your players.
- 22:17That's I think the most significant thing here is they're not starting from ground zero.
- 22:22Well, and I think we're going to get to that a little later
- 22:25on in the show, that there is a model they are following here,
- 22:26Tony in terms of bringing that using nil to help you know, if guys
- 22:30are sort of on the fence belt whether to leave for the NFL or not
- 22:33to get them to come back for one more year. And a year ago
- 22:36that was viewed as an inspirational model, and now that's going to be the
- 22:38death of college football. But you know, again that maybe have to do
- 22:41with which of what the shoe is on. In those particular cases, there
- 22:47is no banner for a January national championship. January national championships are even less
- 22:51meaningful than September Heisman's and we see, you know, we spend a lot
- 22:53of time making fun of whoever the quarterback of the month is in the in
- 22:57September, where it's like, oh man, and this guy has come Kenny
- 23:00Hill, Tony the Heisman winner. Any minute now, it's gonna any minute
- 23:06now, he's gonna win that Heisman Trophy. At least in September, you're
- 23:10playing actual games. You're not you're not winning anything. You're not accomplishing you
- 23:14know you're not. You can't win a championship in January. I think you
- 23:18maybe can lose a championship in January. Maybe this is a little bit of
- 23:21an update on the old you can't win a national title in the spring or
- 23:26during summer camp, but you can lose one if you're not focused, if
- 23:29you're not getting done the stuff you need to get done, if you are
- 23:33losing a bunch of your big pieces in January. I think Alabama has probably
- 23:36lost the national championship in January this year. If you know, Ohio State
- 23:41probably can't win it, but Alabama could lose it if they keep losing guys
- 23:45the way they have. So that's I think a little bit of perspective there.
- 23:48As you said, there are no banners for January, there are no
- 23:52banners for the offseason. But you're put you know you're putting yourself in a
- 23:55position for that. And you know, Ohio State, as you said,
- 24:00lost its quarterback. Will Howard is not at Ohio State. Probably if Kyle
- 24:03McCord is still at Ohio State, you're probably maybe maybe he is, maybe
- 24:08they decide they need to go out and supplement the quarterback room. But the
- 24:12fact that Ohio State lost its quarterback was one of the driving factors certainly in
- 24:18bringing in a new quarterback. And I think also one of the things that
- 24:23makes Ohio State maybe a little more attractive to a Quinn Shawn Judkins where there
- 24:27might not have been an existing relationship is all those underclassmen coming back. So
- 24:33you're not coming to Ohio State and playing with a bunch of unknowns or a
- 24:37bunch of question marks. You know, this is a team that was one
- 24:41drive away from beating the beating the eventual national champions in each of the last
- 24:47two seasons. So it's not like Ohio State is a million miles away from
- 24:49winning a national championship. And you see the sort of flood tide of these
- 24:53underclassmen all coming back. That's not a hard you know, that's not a
- 24:57hard sell to get someone jump on board with that so and and using NIL.
- 25:04I don't know exact numbers on every single player, but I think it's
- 25:08probably safe to say Ohio State has spent more in terms of bringing guys back
- 25:15than anything else. And whatever, you know, this year's nil UH portal
- 25:21or this year's portal additions might bring in ultimately an NIL. The bulk of
- 25:26the attention, the bulk of the focus, and the bulk of the numbers
- 25:27is guys coming back and having JG. Twomloow and Jack Sawyer and Lathan Ransom
- 25:33and Jordan Hancock and Denzel Work and all those other guys come back for another
- 25:37year. That that's I think where a lot of that focus has been.
- 25:40And you know that that's you're supposed to be keeping your core development and not
- 25:44purchasing championships, Tony, Right, is that is that the thing that's that's
- 25:47supposed to be the thing you're supposed to do, right, That is the
- 25:49thing you are supposed to do. But don't bring so many guys back.
- 25:56I want to the the six guys at Ohio State has in from the portal
- 26:00to this point, Let's just remember what happened when Ohio State brought them in.
- 26:06When will Howard came in. You had Ohio State fans and national fans
- 26:11being like that, really you're gonna, you're gonna this is the guy you're
- 26:14gonna go with. And so there are some dismissive things there, some uh
- 26:19you're and we you and I me at least questioned if you're not necessarily good
- 26:26enough to you stay at to stay in in compute at Kansas State, like
- 26:29Wyo Ohio State. So there obviously this is not an instance of a oh
- 26:33gosh, Ohio State went out and paid two and a half million dollars for
- 26:37a quarterback. You know, that's cam Ward was out there. Dylan Gabriel
- 26:41pretty quickly went to Oregon. But there were a lot of names out there,
- 26:45and Ohio State ends up with Will Howard, and a lot of people
- 26:48viewed it as oh so you get like the sixth guy that was available.
- 26:51Oh well, I think that's pretty funny haha. And then the next guy
- 26:55is Will chas Merrick tied end from Ohio under the radar. Nobody cared like
- 26:59this is not a I can't believe they went and landed the top tight end
- 27:03in the nation. Then it was Seth McLoughlin. The center from Alabama who
- 27:07had just come off of a pretty bad game of snapping the ball. So
- 27:10again people had their fun with that one. And then quinnch Own Jenkins transfers
- 27:15and people like, whoa, that's that's interesting. And then you get a
- 27:19weekend with Caleb Downs and Julian saying transferring to Ohio State, and then people
- 27:26that's that's what got people mad. So they bring in six guys. Three
- 27:30of them were scoffed at, laughed at, or completely completely ignored. Didn't
- 27:33the last three have worried people, got people upset, to concerned, whatever
- 27:40you want to put it, because I think Tom the easy assumption with these
- 27:44three guys is that they would have just spread out and gone somewhere else.
- 27:47But when they all go to one spot, then it's like uh oh.
- 27:51Because right now, as we said, like five guys have gone to Florida
- 27:53State from Alabama, three guys have gone to Texas from Alabama. Three guys
- 27:56have gone to Texas to Ohio State from Alabama's well, but you add in
- 28:00the quinch On Jutkins and like three of the top guys from Alabama from the
- 28:07transfer portal pool, and not just Alabama but end up at Ohio State.
- 28:11And then this is what is making things unfair, because for one, they're
- 28:17supposed to stay closer to home and it be spread out. You can't all
- 28:22when you start focusing on one school, then it becomes an issue, especially
- 28:26when an issue is Ohio State. But you're absolutely right, the draw of
- 28:30Ohio State in a lot of ways is Ohio State. I think you put
- 28:33the logo on your chest and let you into any school. The amount of
- 28:37talent coming back, as you said, this is a decent place to play.
- 28:41Quinch On Judkins with a thousand carries in his first two years, wouldn't
- 28:45mind probably sharing some carries at this point. So a lot of this makes
- 28:48sense, and there's some logic behind it, and I think people are ignoring
- 28:52the logic and just looking at the fact that Ohio States collectives are spending almost
- 28:59as much money as other collectives. Well yeah, yeah, and you know
- 29:03this is this is now a problem and college football players receiving compensation for their
- 29:08money. I think there has been a common misperception over the previous few years
- 29:14that the secs it just means more campaign the it there it's a little vague,
- 29:19but I think the strong implication for years has been football. Actually,
- 29:23Tony. Not many people know this, but the it's is actually compliance.
- 29:26That is what the SEC finds, the passion in strict interpretations of rules,
- 29:33not just letter of the wall, but spirit of the law. And really,
- 29:36Tony is supposed to be able to amateurism and oh boy, and respecting
- 29:40each other and not taking people from each other's teams. And that's not what
- 29:42college football is all about. Never mind the each mir Gibbs behind this door,
- 29:48the Jamison Williams, That's not what this is about. This is about
- 29:52respect and seeing it through and earning it as a degree from a fine Southern
- 29:56institution like the University of Alabama. That's this is all about. So and
- 30:00just just so in case anyone was concerned about you know what, what does
- 30:03the it in? It just means more, That's what it's. It's about
- 30:07compliance historically too, that's always been a real passion of the folks down south.
- 30:11This is a this is a very specifically kind of it's weird how specifically
- 30:21like this is a problem right now. It has not been a problem in
- 30:23this specifically is a problem. And like I said, it's it's honestly a
- 30:27little weird to me that Florida State has not been looked at as well.
- 30:32They got five guys from Alabama, So why is that, you know,
- 30:33why is that not a problem, because it's not like Florida State was,
- 30:37until Jordan Travis broke his leg, a very legitimate national championship contender this year.
- 30:42And you know, I'm not going to relitigate the should jew Florida State
- 30:47have gotten into the playoff or not conversation, But it's not like Florida State
- 30:51was a million you know, was a million miles away from getting into the
- 30:55UH getting into the playoff and adding talent like that in the league that they're
- 31:00in, they could you know, they're very likely, I'm going to say,
- 31:03be in the playoff next year. So it is a little weird that
- 31:06this is so specifically focused on Ohio State. But Ohio State has sort of
- 31:10been for the last couple of years or the last couple of decades, sort
- 31:14of the exception to the rule that you know, all of the national championships
- 31:18come from. You've seen the map where it's like the sort of red oval
- 31:22circle between Clemson, South Carolina and like Baton Rouge, Louisiana and It's like
- 31:29all of the National Championship champions except for one have come in this circle in
- 31:32the last twenty years. And you know, now it's Michigan has won one.
- 31:36Now Ohio State's won two since two thousand and well, I guess USC
- 31:41over that year, so I don't remember what this it was fifteen years or
- 31:45whatever this period was, but it's like Ohio State and Michigan are now the
- 31:48two that have won one outside of that small region. And it's like,
- 31:51no, no, no, no, no, you can't do that.
- 31:52We're the ones who get to win the championship every year. You don't get
- 31:55to have that. And you know, I think there's all a little bit
- 32:00of you're seeing some fan bases, I think having some existential crises right now.
- 32:05Where Georgia had two years in Moore where they were the National Championships and
- 32:08then champions and then they missed the playoffs and then oh boy, you know,
- 32:13as soon as you don't win one, the roof is you know,
- 32:15the sky is falling. George is going to be just fine. Georgia is
- 32:16going to be one of the favorites for the National Championship this coming year.
- 32:21Alabama and Michigan I think are in a little bit more of an existential crisis
- 32:24mode right now. Where Alabama, I think the fan you know, the
- 32:28fan base can certainly see the handwriting on the wall that hey, the post
- 32:32Nick saban era might not look like the Nick saban Era in a lot of
- 32:36ways, and that might be happening right now around us, and there's nothing
- 32:38we can really do about it. And I think you're seeing Michigan as well,
- 32:43where Michigan won the national championship what two weeks ago, fifteen days ago?
- 32:47And uh has I mean, like really has they had their parade?
- 32:52But I don't know how much they've really gotten to enjoy it because their head
- 32:54coaches, you know, jetting around the country flirting with every NFL team and
- 33:00imaginable and if he leaves, are you going to see then, you know,
- 33:04post Nick sabin type rating of the roster. And while all of Ohio
- 33:07States underclassmen came back, pretty much all of Michigan's underclassmen left. So I
- 33:13think you're seeing some programs, maybe in transition, having some sort of a
- 33:16little bit of an existential crisis, and that's sort of playing out in some
- 33:21of the more overly hysterical reactions to this. Well, let's continue with these
- 33:27overly hysterical reactions and move on to Michigan's reaction to this. The Michigan fans
- 33:35and the sphere of the Wolverine base talk about the the irony of their being
- 33:45upset about Ohio State's success in the off season right now when last year Michigan
- 33:52had their one more year fund to keep players from leaving for the NFL.
- 33:58Not that they were able to like this, this is what Trevor Keagan,
- 34:00Zach Zentter, Blake korm. They weren't. These were not top draft picks,
- 34:05but they were able to get them to stay through their anisal fund,
- 34:07and fans bragged about it, and the fund bragged about it, and so
- 34:12this year they've got those who stay fund to quoting the tweet from the fund
- 34:17itself, stop our rivals from stealing our players and Tom That immediately reminded me
- 34:24of the scene in mad Men when somebody tells Don Draper, I feel bad
- 34:29for you, and Draper's like, I don't think about you at all.
- 34:31I don't know how many school I don't know how many rivals are coming in
- 34:36to steal Michigan's players at this point, but the idea that it's okay for
- 34:43Michigan to brag about it and have success with it. Ohio State keeps their
- 34:49players and it's like, well, this is this is overboard. You shouldn't
- 34:51be able to keep so many good players. This is only meant to keep
- 34:53a few fifth rounders. You shouldn't be able to keep first and second rounders.
- 34:58That's not what this is about. Well, this is Ohio State following
- 35:02the Michigan model in a lot of ways where and I think I think Michigan
- 35:07and we said this last year. I think Michigan did NIL very intelligently last
- 35:13year. Where you're trying to bring back the guys who are in your system,
- 35:15the guys who you know, the guys who know know the system,
- 35:19the guys who know coaches, the guys who know the playbook, all that
- 35:21kind of stuff. You bring back all those veteran guys and they had I
- 35:24mean, what was it over forty something seniors and fifty year guys and whatever
- 35:29it was on last year's team. That's the intelligent way to use NIL and
- 35:32that's what Ohio State's doing. Brian Large right now, and you know,
- 35:37oh Tony, you can't you can't bring in prominent national players to supplement your
- 35:45largely returning corps. That's not what it's about. You can't bring in a
- 35:49high profile center. That's not what Tony. Do you remember Ola Matemi who
- 35:53was a Remington Ward finalist at the University of Virginia and then graduated and transferred
- 36:00to I forget where he went anyway, doesn't matter. He went somewhere and
- 36:04then won the Remington Ward, and I believe the Outland Trophy as well.
- 36:08I don't remember where that was. So it's, I guess, not a
- 36:10great example to bring up in a context in Michigan. But it doesn't matter.
- 36:15That's fine, it it is. This is, I think exactly the
- 36:20way that you're seeing smart programs start to use, and smart programs really having
- 36:24been using the transfer portal is you bring back as many of your your core
- 36:30guys as you can, and then again you supplement. You crumble to meet
- 36:35loaf on top of your cake. That's what that's what the transfer portal is.
- 36:37You bring in Ola Olawa Temy from Virginia, You bring in Jonah Jackson
- 36:44like Ohios Date did from Rutgers to Okay. You need one plug and playoffensive
- 36:46Lineman. Boom, there you go. You Alabama does this Georgia, believe
- 36:52it or not, Tony has brought in transfers over the years. It is
- 36:54a thing that has happened. As crazy as it is to say it's that's
- 36:59also a thing has happened. So I think my biggest question with all of
- 37:05this is what exactly is the problem? What exactly is the new thing here
- 37:14that hasn't been done before that that like the people complaining that, like your
- 37:17specific team has not done before this. This all feels like exactly what's happened,
- 37:24And it's just it's a problem in this case. And I don't I
- 37:30don't quite understand other than the you know, other than the existential crisis thing
- 37:34and the Georgia fan base being mad that they didn't they don't get just to
- 37:37win the National championship perpetuity. Like I don't, I don't understand what the
- 37:42actual problem is here. Yeah, Georgia right now also has brought in six
- 37:46players how many what'd you say? How many? Six? Which is zeroes?
- 37:53They bringing again? Six? Yeah? Yeah. The at this point
- 38:00last year, Michigan had brought in seven transfers. So is that more or
- 38:06less than six. Well, let me get the do some back of the
- 38:09napkin math as you say, Yeah, it's more tom than what Ohio State
- 38:13has brought in this year. And the thing is wherever Caleb downs had gone
- 38:16other than Ohio State, like, because it looked like he was going to
- 38:20Georgia and nobody's gonna be like, oh, I can't believe you know,
- 38:23this is how how unfair for the nation that Georgia and how this is wrong?
- 38:28This is wrong, and it was just gonna be like, yep,
- 38:30that makes sense, you know. I this is not a surprise to see
- 38:35him go to Georgia, but in Ohio State. If he ends up at
- 38:37Ohio State, then it's like, wow, this has come on. What
- 38:39are we what are we doing here? Will somebody think about the kids?
- 38:44By the way, time right now, Michigan is only brought in two transfers.
- 38:47I'm not sure what's going on there. Is it is it a culture
- 38:52issue? And is it concerned about the NCAA. Probably any number of reasons.
- 38:57Is the fact that your head coach isn't isn't available to meet with you
- 39:01on a visit. Who is to say why they only have two transfers at
- 39:07this point Tom as we wind out, let's you if you want anything further
- 39:12on Michigan. I know it is one of our favorite topics. I have
- 39:15anything else before I bring in a couple of other wind down pieces here.
- 39:20No, I think, frankly, I think there's probably a whole separate show
- 39:22to do on Jim Harbaugh and the Michigan coaching staff and the future of the
- 39:27Michigan program. And that's it feels like that's a separate a conversation. We
- 39:30should just wait because he's had set, you know, second interviews now with
- 39:34a couple of different NFL teams, So you know that's going to go one
- 39:38of two directions, and either he strikes out on the NFL for the third
- 39:43straight year, or he leaves, and either one of those, it has
- 39:46left them in this spot where you're in January and the rest of the college
- 39:52football world is out improving its roster and your coach is out, you know,
- 39:57batting his eyes at NFL teams. And so that's fine if you do
- 40:02what Michigan did last year and bring all these guys back. Once those guys
- 40:06are gone, that's going to create a problem and you're going to be kind
- 40:08of trying to play catch up this year, and that gets into this existential
- 40:13crisis thing we talked about. I do want to caution people the analogy of
- 40:21Ohio State, the football program, and the NIL and you're seeing people talking
- 40:24about fully weaponized NIL fund referring to the Death Star from Star Wars. Tom
- 40:34I will remind people the death Star got blown up. It's sure it destroyed
- 40:38a planet, but it did get blown up. And I'm wondering at this
- 40:44point, like if I put out a tweet saying, hey, if Ohio
- 40:46State is the death Star right now, like what part of the program,
- 40:50what position is the small thermal exhaust port that can lead to everything blowing up?
- 40:57And I don't know what it is. But just before you go crazy
- 41:00with the analogy, yeah, fully wep and fully operational, just know,
- 41:06yeah, blown up by some moisture farmer. Okay, that it was just
- 41:12in his little X wing. Okay, So anything can happen, and now's
- 41:15up thinking about it. Does that describe Dylan Gabriel more than anybody, well,
- 41:22a moisture farmer, I mean, got you being being in Oklahoma.
- 41:25It is the home of the dust bowl, so I guess. But he's
- 41:29moved to see it. He's moved. He's moved to Oregon. Now has
- 41:31moved. Yes, oh yeah he has. Yeah, yeah, I uh.
- 41:36I love the fact that you felt compelled to explain like the one Star
- 41:38Wars thing that I know. I was like, I was like, oh,
- 41:40I'm gonna jump in. I'm gonna explain the debt because of the exhaust
- 41:43port thing, right, yeah, And and you jumped on it. The
- 41:46moment is gone. I will not forget to explain a Star Wars thing here
- 41:49again. That's okay, Uh yeah, it's and know all you have to
- 41:53do, Tony, what is the exhaust port? Look at the mentions,
- 41:55looking at the replies on any post about oh they're brooding. They've brought in
- 42:00Julian saying does he play offensive line? No? No, at reply,
- 42:06guys sixty nine four to twenty, would like you to know that the exhaust
- 42:07port is the offensive line. And maybe that's a possibility. I mean,
- 42:12the offensive line this year was not great by any means, and then they
- 42:16still were driving to potentially win in ann Arbor. So you know, the
- 42:21offensive line and the defense is going to presumably be better next year, and
- 42:24the offense is going to be you know, certainly similar, if not better.
- 42:30Is you know, similar as I think the floor for the offense this
- 42:31next year and could be substantially better depending on how things go. So,
- 42:37yeah, the offensive line, and you know they've missed some field goals over
- 42:40the years. That was always Nick Sabans exhaust port was the kicking game.
- 42:45And you know, so Ohio State is going to have new special teams leadership,
- 42:50and you know, we'll see how that We'll see how that all goes.
- 42:52But this is not, as Tony said earlier, you cannot win a
- 42:57national championship in January. You can You're not a banger banner for anything in
- 43:01January. This is a This has been a very very exciting month and an
- 43:07encouraging month and an optimistic month for a high date football fans, especially coming
- 43:10off of the Cotton Bowl where the offensive line was not good. You know,
- 43:15you can't play the offense, you can't play on offensive line. Legohiftated
- 43:20in the Cotton Bowl, but that's not that was not the starting Ohigersted offensive
- 43:22line and it won't be the starting o Hoisted offensive line moving forward either.
- 43:25So it just it feels like this is a time of year when Ohigsted fans
- 43:30should be encouraged, excited, optimistic. Oh absolutely, you know, you
- 43:37know, no one is saying you get to hang a banner. And I
- 43:40think I think a lot of people are looking at that as a you know,
- 43:45a way to sort of like clap back tony as the kids say,
- 43:50at people who are getting excited. It's like no one, you know,
- 43:52no one, no one has built as I haven't been in the trophy lobby
- 43:54of the Woody Hayes in at least the last three weeks or so, I
- 44:00have not seen anyone building a trophy case for the twenty twenty four season National
- 44:05Championship trophy just yet. I suspect they won't get too far ahead of themselves
- 44:07on that. But you're allowed to be excited. That is that is okay,
- 44:13that's college football is allowed to be. You're allowed to be you know,
- 44:16excited and look forward to college football. It's actually supposed to be something
- 44:19you enjoy and not something you just sort of sort of like perpetually miserable.
- 44:22While and my last point, Tom is when you consider what the donations have
- 44:30brought in and what the donors have done for these collectives to keep Ohio States
- 44:34veterans. What happens next year when they are accustomed to giving this much but
- 44:42they don't have to spend it all on keeping the veterans. What do they
- 44:45do with all of that money? Tom, in free eight don't I didn't
- 44:51want to say free agency, but there's a situation where if y State does
- 44:55very well, and even if they don't, there are times where you just
- 45:00get accustomed to giving a certain amount of money. So if the donors that
- 45:04have given however much this year are just doing that again next year and you
- 45:08don't there there isn't the junior class to hold out Ohio State. There's going
- 45:15to be quite the nil fund available for players in the transfer portal. But
- 45:20again, as Ryan, they will tell you they have to be the right
- 45:22players. It's just something to think about, perhaps, Tom as we look
- 45:27forward to the next twelve months. Yeah, and I think there's an underlying
- 45:32point there, which is the good last three weeks does not mean that Ohio
- 45:37State is forever going to be the number one team in the country. No
- 45:40one is ever going to forever be the number one team in the country for
- 45:44the foreseeable future. That just, especially in the twelve team playoff era,
- 45:47there's just you got to win too many games. You're not. That's just
- 45:50you're asked to do more and more and more, and you've got to not
- 45:53have the one bad week or the one bad game. So, you know,
- 45:57I'm not expecting a four time repeating national champion in the next decade or
- 46:00something, whether that's Ohio State or Georgia or anyone else. I think,
- 46:05you know, Ohio State is the twenty twenty five Ohio State season. I
- 46:08think it's reasonable to wonder is that going to look something like Michigan where you
- 46:15know, not necessarily the head coaching drama, not necessarily, the NCAA drama,
- 46:19not necessarily some of the other extenuitting factors there. But could you know,
- 46:22you're losing all the guys were coming back this year are out of eligibility
- 46:25next year, So then you're losing a bunch of those guys next year.
- 46:29So you know, what is twenty twenty five O look like for Ohio State?
- 46:31That's sort of an open question. And then the other piece of that
- 46:35tony is what are the NIL rules look like twelve months from now? What
- 46:37is it? You know, what is is that all going to be brought
- 46:40in house? In twelve months, in eighteen months and twenty four months,
- 46:44there's there are changes coming again in nil Ohio State. Seems like they have
- 46:47done a good job of capitalizing on the current set of rules. What are
- 46:52those rules going to look like? How is that can impact things in twelve,
- 46:54eighteen, twenty four to thirty six months. We don't know. It's
- 46:58all sort of up in the air. So you know this is this is
- 47:01you know, Ohio State capitalizing on a lot of the same things that a
- 47:05lot of the other programs that we've been talking about on this show have been
- 47:07capitalizing on for the last few years. And then the game's going to change
- 47:13once again in the next year or two, and then you're gonna have to
- 47:15figure out what's the best way do we capitalize on that moving forward? And
- 47:20when we do have our Michigan show, we will talk about the lack of
- 47:22ability to capitalize on a national championship which has been we'll see the dividends that
- 47:30it doesn't pay down the road for them. My last suggestion you're talking about
- 47:34this, I'm wondering, once it all comes in house, and that's what
- 47:37I expect within the next year, it all comes in house. And you
- 47:42know how like the power Ball will say, you know, it's eight hundred
- 47:45and forty million dollars this this week. You know, there's advertisements. What
- 47:50if Whio State just advertises like we've got seventeen million dollars in the fund,
- 47:54and like after somebody signs, it's like, well we've got sixteen point four
- 47:58two million dollars in the fund. It's like they're not enticing anybody. They're
- 48:01just telling people how much money is available. Is that that there's nothing wrong
- 48:07with that? Right? There's no I'm sure based on previous history involving state
- 48:16universities and transparency on such matters, I'm going to assume Tony that's a HIPPA
- 48:22or a one are the other academic SHRPA, I don't know, you know,
- 48:29yeah, yeah, I don't know. Dave Berba, it can be
- 48:32a Dave Berba violation, I'm sure. Short. So, yeah, it's
- 48:37some sort of some sort of student privacy something, something academic, something moistrails
- 48:43off something. H Yeah, I don't I'm not expecting that level of transparency.
- 48:46And you know, with it going away potentially from the nonprofit model,
- 48:52which I think a lot of people are following nonprofits have to file what's called
- 48:55the nine to ninety every year, which is like a report on how much
- 48:59money they actually brought in and where the money went and all that kind of
- 49:00stuff. So you're going to have a certain level of transparency on that for
- 49:06a short period of time, but I as soon as it goes away from
- 49:09the nine to ninety model. You know, athletic departments are required to put
- 49:13out certain stuff. If they have to put out you know that you have
- 49:16to put MAK. They have to put out salaries, so you can look
- 49:19up public employee salaries, like if you want to find out what your kid's
- 49:22third grade teacher is making in the state of Ohio, there is a database
- 49:24where you can look that up. But there is you know, I don't
- 49:29know exactly what the rules on that are going to look like because the rules
- 49:32haven't been written on that yet. And you know, are they going to
- 49:35is are they to be considered public employee employees? Are their contracts going to
- 49:38be subject to FOYA like the Ohio State assistant coach contracts or subject subject to
- 49:43FOYA. We don't know, like this is this is all kind of unexplored,
- 49:47undecided territory we're looking at right now. So a lot of a lot
- 49:52of questions still up in the air. But I mean, the one thing
- 49:55I can say, what's with a great degree of certainty, Tony, It's
- 49:59going to be interesting. It definitely is going to be interesting, and that
- 50:02will do it for us today. Remind you please go ahead and hit the
- 50:07thumbs up on this video if you haven't, should have told you that a
- 50:08long time ago. I apologize for that now. Of course, you can
- 50:12find us at YouTube dot com, slash bucket Hudle. If you're listening to
- 50:15this and you want to watch it instead, why wouldn't you, You can
- 50:17always find us at Buckeye huddle dot com becoming a member. It is there
- 50:22is still plenty going on. This is go listen to Buckeyes tomorrow morning if
- 50:25you have not yet. As time and I go over to last the first
- 50:30three weeks of January, it's been ridiculous and even if it slows down a
- 50:34little, it's still going to be pretty ridiculous because there is no off season
- 50:37during the off season, So find us at Buckey Hudle dot com. Become
- 50:40a member. We would appreciate you seeing you there. On the message board,
- 50:44we are there constantly, so thank you all for tuning in and we
- 50:47will talk to you guys later