Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Adlerian Psychology, Part 2
Transcript
- 0:00okay, palsy We have our second conversation about adlerian
- 0:05psychology and larian philosophy, which is basically
- 0:11philosophy and psychology that is inspired by the historical
- 0:14figure of Alfred Adler, who for about a decade, belonged to the
- 0:19Inner Circle of the discussion group around Sigmund, Freud.
- 0:25So he was exposed to early and earliest psychoanalysis and
- 0:31Vienna and then did his One thing which is sometimes
- 0:34summarized as positive psychology or individual
- 0:38psychology. So last week, we discussed some
- 0:42topics and some topics are necessarily left to be discussed
- 0:47and today we catch up on some of the things that you continue to
- 0:53have in mind and were discussed by the two.
- 0:56Authors that wrote the two books, can you tell them again
- 1:02the Idols. Sure.
- 1:03It's called the courage to be disliked and then the courage to
- 1:08be happy and they're both written by cash machines on and
- 1:14another one I can never remember them.
- 1:16Yeah. So to Japan more kind of a
- 1:20journalist on the other one, a veritable adlerian, theorist and
- 1:26philosopher. Yeah, perfect.
- 1:29So, so dark, I wanted. You know, exactly like you
- 1:34mentioned, go deeper into the at Larry and psychology and before
- 1:41we even go into, you know, the topics actually wanted to talk
- 1:47about the reason I even picked the book, which was the
- 1:49subtitle, right? Like the title, which is the
- 1:53courage to be disliked, and I wanted to discuss that, and the
- 2:00premise of the book, you know, obviously, He comes down to
- 2:03that, which is for you to be happy, you have to be
- 2:06comfortable to be disliked or have the courage to be disliked
- 2:14and logically, you know, all of us know, we shouldn't care about
- 2:19what people think of us or that, and that everyone is busy
- 2:26thinking about themselves. And no one thinks about, you
- 2:29know, about me, I am the only one who thinks Thing about me
- 2:34yet. When I do something, the opinion
- 2:39of others doesn't matter, and the way I was thinking was if if
- 2:46I'm an actor, if other people say I'm a bad actor then then it
- 2:54their opinion does matter. So, you know, I cannot just be
- 2:58like, oh, I have the courage to be disliked and I'm going to
- 3:01just continue being whatever actor.
- 3:04I am becoming Or if someone tells me tells you you're a bad
- 3:10Frank, right? Like it impacts not just your
- 3:16mental ass attitude. It also impacts like, you know,
- 3:20it impacts the paycheck and impacts, you know, your
- 3:23Authority in the world and all of that and how what is your
- 3:29take on? You know, should people just be
- 3:32comfortable being disliked or and or should people just be
- 3:37comfortable? You know, that they do whatever
- 3:42they want to do, and it's okay if nobody likes them or
- 3:45understands them at Sacre and in theory, they're like so many
- 3:50slogans around it as well, right?
- 3:54But hands as if nobody's watching for exactly.
- 3:57Yeah. Those I was trying to think.
- 3:59Yeah. Those ones, right.
- 4:01But in reality it, you can't operate, right?
- 4:06Or can you can you operate like that, right?
- 4:10Okay. This is already a complex
- 4:13starting point. This is why we dedicate some
- 4:15time to it. Let us first of all, ask, who
- 4:20are we talking about? Just like by whom And obviously
- 4:24there are differences. Do I care?
- 4:27If get, if I get a message from central Africa and somebody
- 4:32says, I saw your picture on your internet.
- 4:36I didn't care reading the text that you wrote, I just want to
- 4:39tell you that I dislike you for, for you, the color of your
- 4:44beard, whatever, right? So this would be a completely
- 4:48arbitrary and random dislike. Do I have to be courageous to
- 4:53not? Care about this kind of dislike,
- 4:56probably not. It doesn't affect me so much
- 5:00because it doesn't touch so much things that are important to me.
- 5:06Nor does it expose that this person has access to other
- 5:09people who would have structural power over me.
- 5:14Mhm. So it would be very different if
- 5:16the same person from a place that I don't know, connections
- 5:20with be, you know, Mongolia or Central Africa, or Idaho sent me
- 5:27a message. So, Look, I don't care.
- 5:29You're the color of your beard and I have access to most of the
- 5:34people that, you know, and I will try to influence their
- 5:39opinion on you. So that they also dislike you,
- 5:42that is my mission. Now very different situation.
- 5:46So I don't care about the person as such, but they have revealed
- 5:50that they have an access to something that is powerful over
- 5:54me. Right.
- 5:56So these are just kind of two situations that show that it
- 6:03really matters who I imagined when I say that, I should have
- 6:10the courage to be disliked by someone, the statement implies
- 6:16the statement of courage to be disliked each, that means that
- 6:19there should be something at stake.
- 6:21So per definition. Almost the random person is
- 6:25probably We're not meant, it is meant to address people who
- 6:29dislike me, who indeed have some structural power over me.
- 6:33Be it in money, connections, career, or emotions.
- 6:39So for example, family members, right?
- 6:42Like me, siblings, parents, extended family, and so on.
- 6:47And here, it's important again to differentiate So basically we
- 6:54can differentiate the between contexts from which I can
- 6:58divorce myself, from an existential context where I can
- 7:02watch. If we talk about just work and I
- 7:07have the choice to, you know, choose contacts.
- 7:11I have the choice to go to a different company to be
- 7:14self-employed or whatever. Then this is a, you know, so to
- 7:19speak a divorce ssible, Context, I can go away from the country
- 7:24from those people from this company, from this career mode
- 7:28with family. It's a very different matter.
- 7:30I might physically divorced from them, I could create physical
- 7:35separation, but that does not mean that my mental state, or my
- 7:38unconscious is as ready to let it go.
- 7:43So, actually, I think I would, I, I have examples for almost
- 7:49all three scenarios to First. Do you see that those contacts
- 7:53are different or do? I see those contexts as
- 7:56different? But again, I think it's still
- 8:01very theoretical to me and let's talk by the three topics that
- 8:05you said write. Like one is society, some random
- 8:08person in the world, another is my, you know, the At my work or
- 8:13put my professional relationships and the third
- 8:16being the friends and family and we love those together.
- 8:19Yes. But just a short note before.
- 8:21I let you continue. I think that because those
- 8:24contacts are different. I need different kinds of
- 8:25Courage. I think I'd need a different
- 8:27kind of courage to risk money and Korea.
- 8:31Then to risk existential relationships.
- 8:33I think they are on two different axes in two different
- 8:36dimensions. So, okay, so actually, let me
- 8:40give you an example about the society one.
- 8:43And then you tell me whether whether that like I've had
- 8:51problems, just for the society example itself, like, obviously,
- 8:55you know, problem in the professional and the friends
- 8:59where I have a problem being disliked like, not having Not
- 9:04Having the courage to be disliked, right?
- 9:07Ascend, Example, I'll give you is one of my friends.
- 9:12He was driving and us and the cars in front of him had had an
- 9:20accident. So he also pulls to the side,
- 9:24the lady in one of the cars she was pregnant about like six
- 9:28seven, eight like visibly pregnant and she was really
- 9:34shaken even though she Was physically and mentally.
- 9:39She was fine. It was just a car that was
- 9:41damaged. So my friend pulls to the side
- 9:44called 911. And then he and the lady asked
- 9:50him that, hey, can you stay with me until the cops come on, till
- 9:54the ambulance come? And he's like, no, I because he
- 10:00had a pizza and he was going home.
- 10:02His pizza was getting cold. He's like, oh, you know what?
- 10:05Actually, no, you're fine. I'm going to go.
- 10:08Because in his mind, you know, the pizza was getting called and
- 10:11he wanted to go home. Now, according to Adler, he is
- 10:16doing the right thing and because he really is, you know,
- 10:23he did his job which was to call 911 ensure the woman is
- 10:27perfectly fine, more than that. He had the courage to say, you
- 10:32know what? If I stay here, I'm going to
- 10:34continue thinking about my pizza, and my food is getting
- 10:37cold. And I'm hungry.
- 10:38And my kids are getting hungry. Someone I just like go and leave
- 10:44to me. I like when we all heard the
- 10:48story, my partner was like, well this is exactly what Adler
- 10:53means, right? He had the courage to be
- 10:55disliked, he knew what his priority were was, so he left
- 11:00and it is, okay, and Annie, and this woman was just a random
- 11:05woman on the road. It's not like he was going to
- 11:07run. Dora game.
- 11:08But to me, I won't have the courage to be disliked by even
- 11:14her. I would have stayed.
- 11:16And is that and I obviously think that like my friend did
- 11:23our friend did a wrong thing, right?
- 11:26Like he should have stayed is this and And even though in my
- 11:32head, I would be just getting upset because I have to, you
- 11:37know, I'm getting hungry. I know my kids are getting
- 11:39hungry, I would have still stayed because I didn't want to
- 11:42be the person you know. Yeah.
- 11:44Who who walks away. And this is again a very extreme
- 11:48example but we do have other examples and life right?
- 11:52Where you do something for somebody and in your head your
- 11:55voice is saying oh this is so annoying that I have to do this
- 12:00and you only Because you don't want the other person to be like
- 12:04to dislike you, right? Yes.
- 12:06Okay, let's look at this example because there are some
- 12:08interesting components. Their first of all, I would
- 12:10separate the ethical from the psychological.
- 12:12So even though I ethically disagree with what he did, I
- 12:17will put that to the side because I'm not interested in
- 12:20that in this example. Let's look at it just
- 12:23psychologically. So where does it come from this
- 12:25idea of? I try to kind of put myself into
- 12:29Outlets shoes. and, and kind of impose this, this, this What is
- 12:39it called psychology? Forceful.
- 12:43I forgot the term. This is Rule basically, yeah,
- 12:48off the ability to but it's like to the situation.
- 12:54Where is it for odd ler coming from artless?
- 12:57Main, one of his main ideas was that all of us.
- 13:01Most of us walk around with an idea of an attitude of
- 13:06insufficiency. Mmm-hmm.
- 13:08Yeah, insufficiency and an inferiority.
- 13:12I'd had a very specific idea that it is not really actual
- 13:16anymore. He basically said everyone has
- 13:18some physical organic factual insufficiency when they come to
- 13:24the to the world when they're born.
- 13:27So somehow have a week live week hard, skin, rash or something.
- 13:32And that that basically manifests mentally, as a sense
- 13:37of insufficiency or inferiority in comparison to other people
- 13:41who don't have Have that. This is how it is perceived by
- 13:45children. Let's forget about that.
- 13:48The physiological aspect and let's leave the aspect that
- 13:51Alfred Adler said that basically, we all have some sort
- 13:55of inferiority complex Right, so the question is now how do we
- 14:00deal with that? And here, it becomes a kind of
- 14:04more structured. When we look at the example, you
- 14:06gave because there is a sane way to deal with that.
- 14:10And there is the more normal neurotic way to deal with that.
- 14:12The more normal neurotic way is to try to overcompensate, which
- 14:18toddler basically observed on particularly men who are too
- 14:23short and comparison to society standard and then try to
- 14:28overcompensate and try to be extra bully.
- 14:30Extra-strong extra confident In order to make up for what?
- 14:36Otherwise, crush them. With a sense of just being
- 14:39inferior in comparison to other men.
- 14:41So, in Napoleon and Mussolini and take, whatever small guys,
- 14:44you want to have in world history, would be kind of
- 14:48classic cases of overcompensating for something
- 14:51physiological. In this case again for the
- 14:53shortness, right? So this would be a normal
- 14:57neurotic / bad way to deal with that.
- 15:01Or mature way to deal with that, a more mature way to deal with
- 15:07it is to forget that I have a certain perceived disadvantage
- 15:15right beat the inferiority. That I come from a poor family,
- 15:18or an undue uneducated family, or that my nose is too big or
- 15:23that. I'm too small or whatever it is,
- 15:25right, all this at some point? Yes, I grew up with it.
- 15:29That is the normal thing. According to Allah, And at some
- 15:32point, I become so mature and gain such an understanding and
- 15:36to life in general that I understand I cannot care about
- 15:41this anymore. I stopped caring about it.
- 15:44I perceive myself as a human being that I am and I make the
- 15:48best of it and I don't care about the old perceived
- 15:51insufficient insufficiency or inferiority.
- 15:56So this would be one aspect of I don't let the Just matter
- 16:02anymore, something that we discussed last time more, right?
- 16:06So this would be one aspect that is according to Adler, where it
- 16:09makes sense from an Italian perspective to say, the past
- 16:12doesn't matter. I don't want to be ruled by my
- 16:16past perceived insufficiency. I grew out of it.
- 16:21I am different than others and I don't care.
- 16:24I live my life. I make the best out of it so I
- 16:26don't overcompensate and hence, what I do the way I speak, the
- 16:31way I act to others appears adequate and doesn't appear
- 16:35somehow neurotic. And the sense that, you know, I
- 16:38would be a short guy and I would have a kind demonstrative way to
- 16:42try to out bully taller guys, because I hate this idea of
- 16:47being inferior. So the Now the example that he
- 16:50gave was the person with a pizza overcompensating for something
- 16:55that he grew up with an idea of a certain insufficiency, or is a
- 17:01statement of Independence. This is something that we can
- 17:04only speculate about this is something that we can only look
- 17:08from the outside. So ultimately would need a
- 17:10deeper discussion with a person involved from what you tell
- 17:14because it's such an absurd example, that he left a person
- 17:18who Was visibly shaken and has a medical reason to be more
- 17:25sensitive than others because of her pregnancy and to favor the
- 17:30hot pizza, right? So this is the Absurd part of
- 17:33this element there, which is kind of very inadequate, not
- 17:36just from an ethical perspective but seems to be an adequate on a
- 17:40more fundamental way of caring about people in general, which
- 17:43speaks for me for some sort of not obvious overcompensation.
- 17:49For some neurotic thing, right? I wouldn't it doesn't scream
- 17:54like overcompensating for inferiority and insufficiency or
- 17:59not. So, this is not kind of Simply
- 18:02adlerian to be understood in a DeLorean way, but it seems
- 18:07inadequate nonetheless. And this is why for me, this
- 18:14would not be kind of an example. For an admirer.
- 18:18Herbal application of the Clarion dictum.
- 18:23The delivering rule of big be courageous enough, not to be
- 18:30liked by others. How do you see that?
- 18:36Is exactly right. Like to me that, you know, that
- 18:40friend of ours, I didn't think he, you know, besides even if
- 18:45you leave ethics to do a side I didn't I did not.
- 18:52I agree with you. But my partner's point of view
- 18:56was he did his job and his job was pull over.
- 19:00Call the cops number two. Check the woman if she's okay.
- 19:05And according to Adler this whole, you know, just that is
- 19:10what his duty was and he fulfilled his duty anything more
- 19:14than a mature. I'm not sure he did this but I
- 19:17would argue. Yeah.
- 19:18Because other would come from a psychological perspective of
- 19:21basically caring. Is that an overcompensation or
- 19:23not? Yeah, it's not clear to me from
- 19:27the example that it is, you know, that this is regardless of
- 19:32an overcompensation. I can still imagine that there
- 19:35would be an overcompensation here of some sort.
- 19:37That is not very obvious, right? And again, let's take, maybe I
- 19:43did give a very extreme example, but let's take another example,
- 19:47right? I have a, I have a friend who
- 19:53wants me to do it certain errand for her because you know, she
- 19:57is, she is up to Upstate New York and I'm right by New York
- 20:02City, she won't To me to go pick up another friend of mine of
- 20:06hers from the airport and then because I'm already driving over
- 20:11to meet her, I should pick her up and then go.
- 20:14Except for me, that means that I have to sit in the traffic for
- 20:17additional 2 hours. Now, neither, can I, and again
- 20:23here, I'm moving a little bit more from the society to the
- 20:26friends and family point of view.
- 20:28But neither do I. Neither, do I care about this
- 20:34new person who's coming, I don't know them at all, but because of
- 20:38them. Now I have to because of my
- 20:40friend. I am now suffering through two
- 20:42to three hours, extra of traffic, which will get me,
- 20:45tired, exhausted. And a lot of time is now.
- 20:50Like, I'm literally if my commute went from two hours to
- 20:55three or four hours now, and I am neither, do I have the
- 21:00courage to say no to my Friend that.
- 21:02No, I'm not going to pick them up because very rarely do.
- 21:06They ask me some a favor like that?
- 21:09Nor do I have the Lord to speak of Courage that you don't have
- 21:16the courage again? Exactly.
- 21:18Right. Like you don't have the card, is
- 21:21it really a lack of Courage? It's not the lack of Courage,
- 21:24right? Because I cannot say to my
- 21:26friend that dude, it's going to increase my commute by for three
- 21:31more hours. Hours.
- 21:32And it's going to be extremely tiring for me and it's a Time
- 21:38suck. It is exhausting and all of that
- 21:43because I feel the sense of obligation that she's my friend.
- 21:47She has never asked me before. And then again, she's not going
- 21:50to like me because the first time that she's ever asked me
- 21:53something. I'm saying no.
- 21:55Even though, you know, Like generally, she's the one who's
- 22:00always nicer will go out of our way and to towards me.
- 22:04So let's now I don't have the courage to me that's like okay
- 22:07look like I know. Let's look at these
- 22:09consequences. I think this is quite
- 22:11interesting. So there are two possibilities
- 22:14to two groups of possibilities of consequences.
- 22:16One, which is your estimate. That you would not like it.
- 22:22The other one, it's possible that you misunderstand her and
- 22:25she wouldn't, she wouldn't Don't make such a big deal out of it.
- 22:33I can call someone else. You're right.
- 22:34Someone who lives close by, I don't know like this.
- 22:37Yeah. No.
- 22:38I know. She would mind.
- 22:40She went to Harvard good. Okay.
- 22:42So let's let's take this example.
- 22:44So there's something actually it's take and what is its take
- 22:46as sympathy and kind of interpersonal Bond.
- 22:50So it might to counteract kind of, to her wish might lead to a
- 22:57diminishment of the Friendship at this is basically what is at
- 23:01stake? What would it take for someone
- 23:04to not? Take that into consideration to
- 23:08see it, as you did that, it might lead to that.
- 23:12And to say, I still prioritize, am I saving of time?
- 23:18Under which circumstances would someone or you do that?
- 23:25Because basically, then you're saying my time is more important
- 23:28to me than this friendship. I accept it's my time my energy
- 23:35like I have to now like make sure I have food in my car
- 23:39because it's going to be rather than a two-hour Journey I'm
- 23:43tacking on another two. So it's like a four-hour
- 23:46Journey. So I need to like you know,
- 23:48multiple aspects of my day are now thrown out the window so the
- 23:52inconvenience is huge, right? A huge inconvenience.
- 23:55It's versus keeping a friendship.
- 24:00I would like to keep the friendship so I'll do it but
- 24:02I'll be so irritated. Like I ended up picking this
- 24:07their family up from the airport but like the entire route I was
- 24:11pissed off. I did not, I wasn't even being
- 24:14nice to the guests who I had to pick up from the airport.
- 24:18And and then I felt like you feel like shit because, you
- 24:23know, you are not even doing it from that mindset of Being
- 24:29welcoming or being nice or like I was so lonely doing it because
- 24:34I wanted to keep that relationship and I was also
- 24:37irritated that they even asked me to do this.
- 24:40Favorite of them, the insensitivity of not knowing
- 24:43what. Yeah, Brendan tales for you.
- 24:46Okay, now imagine that the situation would have been
- 24:48different. I don't know how your friend
- 24:49asked you part of our text or call.
- 24:52Was it a telephone call? I think it was.
- 24:54Yeah, it was a call and it was okay, you know, we like there's
- 24:58no one else. Else who can do it, can you do
- 25:00it? They're coming.
- 25:03We have nobody else. Blah, blah, blah, right.
- 25:05Like okay. And since you're already coming,
- 25:08can you just pick them up? Right?
- 25:10And I did mention, oh, they're going to be like about two hours
- 25:14away. It's going to be more time and
- 25:17they're like, yeah, and Italian to up to here.
- 25:19Let's imagine you reacted very differently at that moment, when
- 25:22she kind of raised to this, this favor you would have been very
- 25:28much in tune. What you actually feel and how
- 25:30you see it. And you would right away.
- 25:33Would have said, in a polite way that I'm sorry, this is a
- 25:37terrible inconvenience for me. I will not be able to do that.
- 25:45I think what happens in reality is like most of us will at that
- 25:50time not be able to are not in touch with our feelings.
- 25:54Or let's assume you would have if I would have I think if I
- 25:59would have said this is a terrible inconvenient for me,
- 26:04they would have said well can you do it?
- 26:05This one time for me? And then I would have to again
- 26:09say yes. No, no you and this example
- 26:12you're a different person. Yeah, it was not just caving
- 26:15because of, you know, a way of discussion or some things like
- 26:20sorry, I'm not able to do this. It has to be a very different
- 26:25person, right? Like you can you just like Adler
- 26:28says you just have to choose to be comfortable with doing that.
- 26:33I don't think most would be comfortable with the
- 26:35consequences. This is my question, would I be
- 26:39comfortable with the consequences?
- 26:41So she would have been irritated like she would have found you
- 26:44rude and impolite she would have whether either told you or
- 26:49thought well. Now what?
- 26:51Because now it's for me, it's a terrible inconvenience.
- 26:53I never asked Or anything. This is the first time you could
- 26:56have helped me out and demonstrate your friendship.
- 26:58You didn't blah, blah, blah. So it would have been in her
- 27:02court and she would have decided as we assume that example to
- 27:06distance herself from you. Mmm-hmm this is the consequence,
- 27:09let's just assume, right. Yeah, you would have known that
- 27:12because you would have been in touch with the situation at that
- 27:14moment and you would have chosen your kind of your own avoidance
- 27:20of great discomfort versus the friendship.
- 27:23Hm. What else is different than how
- 27:28do you so you hang up? You know what happened?
- 27:30She knowed what was happening? What happened?
- 27:32How do you continue to deal with that?
- 27:35I think I would be, I would be upset about like, you know, I
- 27:41knew I know that would impact our friendship solving going to
- 27:44be upset about it. And again, here I didn't have
- 27:50the courage to be this light, right?
- 27:51Like I am now terrible inconvenience to with all of
- 27:55this, but I still don't have the, you know, either which way
- 27:59I'm doomed, right? So the Friendship is like, okay,
- 28:02let's it's a good example, I think Based on this example, I
- 28:08would translate this rule of the courage to be disliked to the
- 28:13rule, the courage to be alone. Because ultimately for me to be
- 28:21disliked is just the beginning of people distancing themselves
- 28:24from me, right? Because of the consequences of
- 28:28what I say or do. Right?
- 28:30So they after Maybe not immediately but why they leave
- 28:33me. Yeah.
- 28:34And I'm becoming a polarizing figure, so people keep distance.
- 28:40I have no filters of speaking, my mind and prioritizing myself.
- 28:44So people don't don't kind of form new friendships.
- 28:48With me. This is the negative scenarios.
- 28:50Well, who knows it's happens. But the possibility is there, if
- 28:53I become, if I'm standing up for myself, rigorously I have to
- 28:59take into account the possibility that basically no
- 29:01one will like that. Hence, I will be disliked and if
- 29:06nobody likes that, maybe they will want to continue to work
- 29:09with me, but I will be disliked as a colleague, and I will not
- 29:13have friendships. Absolutely, and I think, I think
- 29:17which I like that. You said, you know, the courage
- 29:21to be alone, right? So I do this to this one, really
- 29:26nice friend, they start going away and then like I do it to
- 29:30other people and the end like I am left with just myself, right?
- 29:36Like because like that and I don't think anyone can deal with
- 29:40that. Come there.
- 29:43That is not an answer to my question.
- 29:44Maybe my friends, the one who left the pizza, right.
- 29:47Right. He can do.
- 29:48That or let me ask differently under, which circumstances could
- 29:52you deal with that? I think you have to the only
- 29:58circumstance in which you can deal with that.
- 30:02Is you have, you know, you are one of those people who really
- 30:08don't care about anybody else. You're just You know, you're a
- 30:13selfish, self-centered person and self-sufficient.
- 30:19And so sufficient enough for me to be with myself, but no one in
- 30:25the world is self-sufficient, right?
- 30:27Like you do you get cancer and you even if you have all the
- 30:32doctors and all the money, you still need somebody with your
- 30:36mental health, someone else or something else, right?
- 30:39Like you cannot just be you. How can you just be that
- 30:46self-sufficient? Well, let's put a different.
- 30:48Obviously, there are many people who are alone, there's even in
- 30:52the UK, there's something like a Ministry for loneliness because
- 30:56it's become such a huge problem in modern society, that people
- 31:01because people are very selfish these days.
- 31:04And that is like, that is, that is how we use on.
- 31:09But it's, there's something a matter of fact that in modern,
- 31:13modern societies, there's a high degree of loneliness.
- 31:16So this is a fact, the question is, can I be alone?
- 31:19And happy or satisfied. This is what you seem to to to
- 31:26refuse I think in the in the short term I can be alone and
- 31:30self-satisfied but in general over my life.
- 31:35If I keep doing this to everybody right where anybody,
- 31:39somebody asked me if it's even if it's inconvenient for me and
- 31:45all I no one's going to want to hang out with me, right?
- 31:51And then it Is. It just becomes a tougher life,
- 31:57right? Nobody want, like, I say, no to
- 32:00this friend, another friend ass or some other favor.
- 32:05Again, it's out of my way, out of content, like something I
- 32:09didn't want to do or even at work.
- 32:12People in my company, you know, I basically say, oh, this is my
- 32:18work and I am not going to, you know, help for this.
- 32:24Particular project that like the entire company needs to pull and
- 32:28together I say you know what, I'm comfortable.
- 32:32There's like professional consequences there.
- 32:34Yes so there I don't think and even I may not like my team.
- 32:39Yes, I can switch my jobs but none of them really, just Solve
- 32:47the problem which is, you know, I cannot operate.
- 32:51Nobody in this world can operate as an individual by themselves
- 32:55alone, right? Let me let me rephrase the kind
- 32:59of the rule, the courage to be alone.
- 33:00Let me give you two variants of it and let's see where that
- 33:05goes. The one variant would be that I
- 33:07tell you because of your insecurities.
- 33:13And your inability to judge in which situations you should
- 33:18stand up for yourself and not and because of that you are
- 33:23freaking out by the sheer idea that you will be left.
- 33:26You are a bad advocate for yourself.
- 33:29I promise you when you develop the courage to be disliked that
- 33:35you will find true friends. So this would be one kind of
- 33:40variation of this rule so not the courage to be disliked with
- 33:45the idea that you should be so self-sufficient that you
- 33:48wouldn't need anyone. But basically because you're
- 33:51freaking out with the idea that people will leave you, you're
- 33:54doing things that that lead to maybe shallow friendships that
- 33:59are not fulfilling or were dissatisfied for them other
- 34:03reasons. So what I preach and I put
- 34:05myself into a possible outliers. Shoes.
- 34:09What I preach. As I tell you, you have to
- 34:11develop the courage to be disliked in order to to form,
- 34:15great friendships. That are truly satisfying and
- 34:19what people truly like new and not just for those half-assed
- 34:23kind of favors that you do. The other variation would be
- 34:26more strict, which is to say no. I mean it literally when you
- 34:31develop the courage to be disliked, you should be able to
- 34:36live with the possibility that Literally everyone, abandons you
- 34:40and facing this existential, if you can face this existential
- 34:44loneliness, your character will grow so much that you indeed
- 34:48will be completely self-sufficient and you will not
- 34:51be in your erotically dependent on someone else.
- 34:55Do you have a made clear? Those two variations?
- 34:59Yes, so to reiterate you said like sort of it becomes two
- 35:04different things. One is you have the courage
- 35:08enough to be alone and disliked enough to let go of those
- 35:14friendships that are fairly, you know, this and that.
- 35:18And you you say no to that. And once you become that fully
- 35:23rounded person, you do then You know, make friends, who are at
- 35:29that similar bandwidth as you, right?
- 35:31So you just sort of our Slick Rick no?
- 35:35Yeah it's basically sort of you know, saying okay I'm going to
- 35:39be uncomfortable in the present in the hopes that my future.
- 35:43I will now the so that's one and the other is other thinking is
- 35:50I'm going to be alone and self sufficient enough that it
- 35:54doesn't even matter to me. Me that, you know, yes and
- 35:57whether I would I then form friendships or not, really
- 36:01doesn't really matter. I don't think there's like Too
- 36:06much. Well there is a the first has
- 36:11like more hope great and then the whenever there's hope
- 36:14there's fear, right? That's what if I like I would
- 36:20for for scenario number one where I'm expecting that, okay,
- 36:25I will make other friends immediately I'll be in the mood.
- 36:29Okay I said no to this. Now I need to find other friends
- 36:32who will be okay. I I kind of would like to be in
- 36:37that number two scenario. Even though I would like to be
- 36:42say, you know what, I am enough, even if I end up being entirely
- 36:46alone to me, that is like, somehow that's more, feels more
- 36:57independent and feels more. Satisfying, even though.
- 37:04Yeah, yeah, yes. But they're more independent
- 37:07alone, right? Like do obviously, those people
- 37:12alone and there is kind of there's Beauty in the Simplicity
- 37:16of it, right? It would be quite radical but I
- 37:20would agree with what you said a couple of minutes ago that I
- 37:23think this is unrealistic. Yeah.
- 37:25Because it goes counter of who we are as people where the
- 37:32intimate Ships with others. The feeling to be understood to
- 37:37feel close to friends or to a partner as such an integral part
- 37:42of the fabric of who I think we are in comparison to the few
- 37:47exceptions that do exist out there and where people are
- 37:52Hermits somewhere in Canada or India as a different matter.
- 37:57Even though your hermit you're still part of communities,
- 37:59you'll still have exchange with people and so on.
- 38:01So it's not a full I never See anyone kind of her midlife.
- 38:07But there are some people who seem to be really
- 38:12self-sufficient and kind of awkward in that he had with
- 38:16that. This is not a choice.
- 38:18I would say, I think this is preserved for very, very, very
- 38:23few cases who are kind of comfortable with this, for
- 38:27whatever reason be to genetic predisposition or there be an
- 38:31Asperger's Syndrome, you know, in the Or something.
- 38:34That's from most other people in my experience.
- 38:38It would not be okay regardless of how selfish and they are to
- 38:42be completely alone without friendship or partnership.
- 38:46So coming from that, my strong impression is that the first
- 38:52variation of the rule is, what Adela actually meant that.
- 38:57It's a promise that he says trust me.
- 39:00When you are willing to get rid of most of those superficial
- 39:03Texts you have because of your Social and securities.
- 39:07You will be able and ready to find true friendships.
- 39:13And then you will be this will compensate for this will make
- 39:17you mature. You will be mature in yourself
- 39:20and more self-sufficient and you will attract the right people
- 39:24who are truly interested in you. So I promise you it will be a
- 39:28double win. I think that this is the more
- 39:30correct variation of what this Rule of courage to be disliked
- 39:36means, I don't know if the Japanese authors agree with
- 39:39that. I, yeah, I don't think they're
- 39:43talked about, like, there's going to be a promise, but they
- 39:45did talk about exactly that, which is only when you are
- 39:51comfortable being yourself. Do you have any growth and life?
- 39:58And again like, you know, like I said, like I said there, They're
- 40:04like you also said, there is, you know, you have to have to be
- 40:10able to overcome those insecurities.
- 40:13How do you come overcome? These kind of insecurity, when
- 40:16life, right? Yes, extremely difficult
- 40:19question, it's good. That we move on to that.
- 40:22It's extremely difficult. I tell you first, I think what
- 40:24the normal variation of this is obviously, we'll live in a
- 40:27western culture, Western influence culture, where people
- 40:31were to become, kind of a Facebook or Dating app
- 40:37commonplace the attitude. Now, that is a exclusive with
- 40:42many people have the attitude of Take Me As I Am or fuck you.
- 40:46And yes, I was allowed to say, thank you bend for your needs
- 40:50off. You stupid man or your stupid
- 40:51Twitter which is what coming from India, right?
- 40:54Like the reason why I always believe there's such a high
- 40:57divorce rate or so many of people I know and so many
- 41:01friends and our single is because They would be like, oh,
- 41:05this person did this hands. I'm not going to be yes.
- 41:09Like, in relationship with them, it's in, those are minor
- 41:12infractions and they never really adjust yet on the other
- 41:16hand, or given yet. On the other hand, when I have
- 41:20to do this for a friend, I was like so irritated.
- 41:25And it's that one is again a little bit more of a bigger
- 41:28example. I can even give a small example
- 41:32than that I have. Our good friend, he's literally
- 41:37two blocks away from me. He's single.
- 41:41And we end up like every time I hang out with you or not, just
- 41:45record and I'm not, and I'm not, but both me and my partner are
- 41:50very good friends with him. And we'll, every time we hang
- 41:53out with and we really enjoy ourselves, right.
- 41:55He's mentally is very amazing. You can have deeper
- 41:59conversations with him. We'll hang out.
- 42:02We'll enjoy With him, whether we are going for sushi or just
- 42:06taking a walk yet. On the other hand, I have this
- 42:11mental thing that I should hang out with him every every week
- 42:16and I'm a bad friend. If I if I don't or if you ask
- 42:20me, hey can you just draw? He has this thing where he wants
- 42:23people to pick him up or drop him from the airport and it's
- 42:27only it's $25, right? Right.
- 42:30It's not a big expensive, right? Except that every time Ask me
- 42:34that I love him but I'm like dude it's going to take its
- 42:38gonna waste at least an hour and a half of mine because I have to
- 42:42get ready, pick you up, drop, you come back.
- 42:46So it's a 25-minute 25, 25 minute twenty five dollar,
- 42:50right? I have, why are you trying to
- 42:52save those stupid? 25 bucks.
- 42:54And I know he doesn't care about the 25 bucks.
- 42:56Yeah. Because he wastes money all the
- 42:58time. He has this mental thing, and I
- 43:02given at times, And I don't given at times, but I always
- 43:06again, feel that guilty. So you're saying I have to even
- 43:10to him, who I absolutely enjoy hanging out with.
- 43:15I should just feel like, no, sorry, I'm okay if you want to
- 43:19break my friendship over it, I know he will not break our
- 43:22friendship over it, but I do feel that guilt that, you know,
- 43:27he asked me and he probably thinks of it as a way to like I
- 43:32understand as I think he to him that is just a way of feeling he
- 43:38loved by another person. It's a gesture, it's a gesture
- 43:43that counts. Not really, you know, it's not
- 43:45it's not the money obviously for him or and how do I say no to
- 43:52him? When I know that it's just a
- 43:53gesture that will really satisfy him makes him feel loved yet.
- 43:58On the other hand, it's a hate wasting an hour and a half.
- 44:03Ah point. I'm just picking and dropping
- 44:06anyone though the 25 minutes. I'll go while dropping him.
- 44:09I will actually enjoy right. Like our conversations would be,
- 44:12very fun. There is, there is still a
- 44:15little bit of benefit or fun for me at least for half of that.
- 44:20Right. But you're saying that even in
- 44:23these scenarios you just end up saying I'm okay to be alone, but
- 44:28I should because it irritates me to do this gesture for you.
- 44:33I'm going to do well, not so fast.
- 44:35Obviously, this is not my position and I don't think that
- 44:38this is a corrected layering position as well.
- 44:41So, in this context, let me rephrase again, the The Credo of
- 44:49the courage to be disliked into something else, which would be
- 44:52the courage to express my needs. With the potential risk that me
- 44:59and my needs are rejected. Which is something else than is
- 45:04disliked. I still want to be liked, it's a
- 45:07friend. I don't want to lose them.
- 45:09I don't. I do care if they like me or not
- 45:13but I put in an intermediary step between just disappearing
- 45:18in their need and rejecting their need completely, right?
- 45:22This would be the two extremes and I emerge in this dialectic
- 45:28and this in this relationship or in this contact, I emerge and
- 45:33Look, this is my position. Do you still in this insist on
- 45:38me? Picking you up?
- 45:40Or does it change something for you?
- 45:43For example, my position is I love to spend time with you not
- 45:49today, and I would like it to do it on the other circumstances
- 45:53where I don't waste so much time.
- 45:57This is where I'm coming from. Do you still want me to pick you
- 46:00up? It is tough to get it.
- 46:07I think they're that is where the courage part happens, right?
- 46:10You'd I don't have the courage to say that to us, even say that
- 46:15to him. And how do you build that is
- 46:20like, how do you in those scenarios?
- 46:23It is easier to maybe it is so much easier to like what you're
- 46:30saying to me so much easier and Perry than the minute.
- 46:35I imagine saying that to him, I don't think I would feel even to
- 46:39him. Well I would put a differently
- 46:45and say when you don't say This to him and whatever form.
- 46:49So if you choose to disappear and to subordinate yourself
- 46:54under his need and his need to receive a gesture of friendship
- 46:58and connection, right? If you choose that then I would
- 47:02say that you're not in connection with him.
- 47:05I'm exaggerating at all. Yeah.
- 47:08It's not you who picks him up. It's the projection of his need
- 47:14to feel connected that picks him up and you are giving in to
- 47:18that. So you choose, I would put it,
- 47:21who are you? Then when you do this, you're
- 47:23obviously not you. Yeah, because you are harboring
- 47:29kind of this resentment against the style of gesture that you
- 47:34understand but don't really support, or you would like to
- 47:38have a differently. This is the more complete you
- 47:42right? Where you are kind of conflicted
- 47:43about it, but you pretend to be not so much conflicted about it,
- 47:47maybe you do some eye-rolling, maybe you give a hint or
- 47:51something, but you don't really fully.
- 47:56Represent yourself with him, right?
- 47:59So here you are an absence more that you are presence.
- 48:07So I should have, I agree. So I shall basically say to him,
- 48:14hey, I understand that like, you know, I would love the way I've
- 48:19been dealing with it so far as I laugh, I'll basically tell him,
- 48:26hey, I can't do it this time. I'll do it next time and like,
- 48:30you know, sort of like half times back out half x given, but
- 48:34even when I'm giving in its It's only because I'm satisfying his
- 48:39need rather than like, my own. Yes.
- 48:42And even when you're rejecting this way, you're not fool
- 48:44yourself. Because you make an excuse,
- 48:46you're not using your need exactly or a bigger picture,
- 48:52maybe Beyond just the needs. You don't, you don't invest so
- 48:56much in the gesture. That would be important here for
- 49:00you, which is let me explain myself to you.
- 49:04And then I would hope from a gesture from you.
- 49:07A gesture of understanding, okay?
- 49:11So having that courage to sort of say that it's the courage to
- 49:18be present in the contact with the people that you care about
- 49:24mmm-hmm and the courage to express my name's.
- 49:27Yes. So how do you build that?
- 49:29Because the question is if you don't do that, what is that?
- 49:35What are you and who are you? If you don't do that, not so
- 49:38much. I would not focus so much on how
- 49:40much courage you already have do or how you do it.
- 49:43And so on, what kind of Life do you lead?
- 49:47When we're not explicitly, we explicitly not talking about
- 49:50job. This kind of outside life were
- 49:54fakeness is an integral part of how we operate.
- 49:57So we're talking about friendships, we talking about
- 50:00Connections that really matter to you as yeah, as a full of
- 50:04person. Not just a single yourself.
- 50:07So when we talk about that, if you don't even introduce
- 50:10yourself, Holy and relationships that matter to you.
- 50:17And what are you and to which small spaces, do you confine the
- 50:22big picture of yourself? When do you appear as a person,
- 50:28if not in those relationships that actually matter to you.
- 50:36That is a sad thought because you that basically means I'm not
- 50:40even being myself with some of my closest and like, you know, I
- 50:46don't like to use the word best friends but like some of the
- 50:48closest relationships in my life.
- 50:50I'm not even expressing. Exactly.
- 50:53Dad. And that means that I am only
- 50:56myself and I am by myself or just maybe with my partner but
- 51:02even enough. I'm not obviously 100%.
- 51:05So yes. This is a caricature.
- 51:08So obviously there are some when you have deep conversation from
- 51:11really do connect and obviously sure more of yourself so it's a
- 51:15caricature, but in order for the sake of Simplicity, let's assume
- 51:19let's take the caricature that you're just fully yourself when
- 51:23you're just alone, right? Exactly.
- 51:27So so then, The letter, I thought you want to lead.
- 51:34Well, that's the life that they asked you to lead in India,
- 51:38right? They say just like the love.
- 51:42You want to lead? Absolutely not.
- 51:44Okay, yet. On the other hand, you don't
- 51:47like you. Most of most of everyone's life,
- 51:51right? You are taught to do the
- 51:53give-and-take to do the, you know, okay, he let me be at
- 51:59Larry in and say, I don't care. I don't care what people have.
- 52:03Missed you or ask you to do in the past right here?
- 52:07Right now, I ask you what kind of life you want to lead?
- 52:10I don't care about your past. I would not like to live that
- 52:15kind of life. I would like to lead a life
- 52:17where I am with help with this friend of mine.
- 52:20I'm 80% myself I think if I'm 100% myself with more and more
- 52:26people I think it'll lead to happier better relationships.
- 52:31I okay. And here I mean I'm assuming
- 52:35what I understand is the Adler in position and not fully
- 52:37talking as myself right now. But here, I think you can see
- 52:41how this logic comes About what some of those are Larry and
- 52:44slogans because now I would be in the place to say me isn't it
- 52:48larian say Okay hence so I don't care about your past, we discuss
- 52:53the topic. It's clear to you.
- 52:56It's clear to me that you want to be a fuller person with the
- 52:59close people around you. And now as a consequence, I'm
- 53:05saying since this is so clear. Don't ask me how just do it.
- 53:11That's what Adler say exactly that to me is if it's not so
- 53:15clear. As we have kind of peeled the
- 53:18layers of this and the previous conversation if this is so
- 53:22clear. It's irrelevant of how to do it.
- 53:25You have to do it. This is this is the Clarion
- 53:29dictum. What?
- 53:30Exactly. He's like you just have to do it
- 53:33because there's no other option. Everything else will be
- 53:35chickening out would be finding excuses.
- 53:38Would be basically retreating again.
- 53:41Andrew position where you want to tell me that?
- 53:43It's easier, not to be yourself and be yourself and this has not
- 53:47become acceptable anymore because of the conversation that
- 53:50we had. Because you said I don't want to
- 53:52have this kind of life, I want to be more myself with a people
- 53:56around me, so which brings me as an agrarian kind of
- 54:00psychologists and do the position to say, okay, if this
- 54:03is so that I don't accept it, then I don't accept any excuses
- 54:07anymore. There is no excuses left.
- 54:10Yeah, except you want to bring in the past because I was raised
- 54:14in an Indian way, because I was told in such a way to live my
- 54:17life but we agreed, it doesn't matter.
- 54:21We can endlessly discuss about, you know, if you want to
- 54:25prioritize the past, we can endlessly go around and say,
- 54:28yes, poor you, I still like you and the therapeutic relationship
- 54:32slowly building your confidence and so on, it's all a waste of
- 54:36time. Once the problem is Yeah, once
- 54:39it's clear to me what I want and that that contrasting
- 54:43information from the past are not relevant to me anymore.
- 54:47The only position that I'm left with is okay, then I have to do
- 54:51the right thing, do it. I don't think most people aren't
- 54:56able to do it. I'm talking to you now.
- 54:59So yeah, I think I finally understand what he means that by
- 55:03the courage to be disliked and sort of the benefits that you'll
- 55:08get out of it, right? Which is you?
- 55:11Will you learn to express your needs better?
- 55:15You say, I would much rather be Hundred percent myself and be
- 55:23alone and or have with the hope that I will have deeper
- 55:29relationships. But yourself.
- 55:34Yeah as myself but I would rather than just you know,
- 55:41rather than not being this light right now.
- 55:46That is like I finally understand the concept.
- 55:49So that's helpful. But I still don't, I don't know.
- 55:55Or like, what tips would you give to that?
- 55:58Like okay, I understand the concept.
- 56:00I totally understand the need to do it either.
- 56:02Sales just do it, which is impossible for me.
- 56:07What would you say? What?
- 56:08How would you tell someone like me and the scenario with my
- 56:12friend who's very close to me, who I really like, right?
- 56:16Like, you know, I have, how do you build that courage to
- 56:21actually express your needs? Yes.
- 56:23And here we go. Back to an older point and I
- 56:26would not like that for me, the, the question of Courage is
- 56:29already done. Yeah.
- 56:31So this point of The conversation you either.
- 56:34Either ignore what we talked about on the last 20 minutes.
- 56:37Yeah. Right, or courage is not a
- 56:39question anymore because there is no other option and where
- 56:42there's no other option. You know.
- 56:44I don't really need courage, kind of to breathe.
- 56:47I don't need courage to go to the supermarket to get food.
- 56:51It's just, I have to do it too. Nobody cares.
- 56:54If I have coverage for this or not, I basically just have to do
- 56:57it now. We have to wrap it up but See
- 57:03some validity even in the alerian framework when you say,
- 57:06okay, I'm still interested in different options on how to do
- 57:09things and so on for me the huge difference is as who are you
- 57:13speaking? If you are speaking as the one,
- 57:16who is fully accepted that regardless of what happens, you
- 57:20will somehow implement this new position of your fullest self
- 57:25and this relationship with your friend.
- 57:27Then it's an exchange of ideas and you just settling in with
- 57:32the concept and it's just a friendly reflection with someone
- 57:36who has basically already decided versus.
- 57:40So this would be the correct kind of way of to go about it
- 57:44versus someone says, well, I'm still having doubts.
- 57:47I still not sure that I can pull it off.
- 57:49I can only pull it off. If you give me really good
- 57:52tools. Yeah, and I think most people
- 57:56will fall in that second category.
- 57:59Yes, they have not fully understood the position that
- 58:02they're in and I mean, I agree with you, but now I'm talking
- 58:05more specifically to you, you have to know from which position
- 58:10you come from. If you Retreat to a point of
- 58:13insecurity, I'm not sure if I should do this.
- 58:16After all, then we have to go to three steps back and kind of
- 58:21look again and the in at the end of the tube.
- 58:23Bility of this position of, by basically working out.
- 58:28What else is your alternative? The alternative is to be kind of
- 58:35a divided person to not to have full relationships and so on.
- 58:38So it would be back to this square, right?
- 58:42Or again, the other option is that, you know, I fully
- 58:45internalized it, if in our conversation, I don't get great
- 58:49tools, I will do it. Nonetheless.
- 58:52Like it's not a question anymore.
- 58:53I will just be clumsy about it and so on but yeah I get it, I
- 58:57will still talk to my friend. So the purpose of the continuing
- 59:00conversation is just to get fluidity Elegance or you know,
- 59:05kind of some embellishment around us which would be more in
- 59:10the alerian framework. But since this is clear, so it's
- 59:14basically back or it becomes kind of an informative chat.
- 59:19Maybe, at this point we can end the conversation.
- 59:21Ation. Why?
- 59:23I think it's a good exit point for me.
- 59:25It was very interesting because I achieved my goal, I wanted to
- 59:28go deep kind of into one question.
- 59:30And my impression is that you've got some more clarity about that
- 59:35which I hoped. Yeah, I think so.
- 59:37I think this was really good. So we ended up going just deeper
- 59:40into the fun topic. So absolutely thanks again to
- 59:44pallavi for the second conversation about adlerian
- 59:47psychology and there will be a third part probably in about
- 59:51Weeks where we will try to sum up our conversation, and find
- 59:57some conclusion about what Larry and psychology and philosophy.
- 1:00:02Please find in the descriptions, the details to the books, which
- 1:00:05have been the basis for our discussions.
- 1:00:08And I hope that you tune in next time.