Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / James Wallis
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamers Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamers guild. Find out more at grand Gamers Guilds dot com. Out of
- 0:17the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:20waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:24at you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:29of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:32that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:36still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:39shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 0:53into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 0:57take five of their games with them. Which will they choose? My guess
- 1:02this week is a legend of the British gaming industry. A game designer,
- 1:04game writer, design teacher and all around fount of knowledge. He's designed once
- 1:08upon a time and run the classic British RPG company, Hogshead Publishing, as
- 1:14well as teaching game design for a decade at London South Bank University. My
- 1:18guest this week is James Wallace. James, Welcome to the cabin. Hello,
- 1:22it's a pleasure to be here, I'd say a pleasure, but there's
- 1:23an apocalypse going on outside. Yeah, and you're stuck with and you're stuck
- 1:26with me, so it's a bit of a nightmare. But you know,
- 1:29we'll all get by. I'll take players where I can find them, frankly,
- 1:34So my first question is how difficult was it for you to pick the
- 1:37five games to take to the cabin? Oh? Hugely, hugely, as
- 1:41you can imagine. I have a fairly large collection and then a collection of
- 1:45in my head of games I've played, or want to play, or think
- 1:48I ought to have played. So yes, I stood in the room I
- 1:55laughingly called the games library and looked around an awful lot and pulled things off
- 1:59the shelf and put it back. Not doing role playing games did help a
- 2:02great deal. I have some, you know, fond role playing games,
- 2:07but this is not that conversation, I think, and you know you you
- 2:12straddle both arenas, both RPGs and board games. Yes, I guess RPGs
- 2:20take up less space right typically. I mean they used not to when they
- 2:23were all boxed sets, but they lend themselves more to supplements, so very
- 2:30quickly they can take up a lot of shelf space. But yes, in
- 2:34their basic form, it's it's a book, and quite quite soon you can
- 2:38simply assimilate the rules in your head, or at least all the rules that
- 2:43you're happy playing with will live quite cheerfully in a mental space, and you
- 2:46don't actually need the physical book, though so many books these days are so
- 2:52beautifully produced that actually the physical book is what you really want. I mean,
- 2:57I'm I'm. As I get older, I adopt the moraise of people
- 3:01who are getting older, and so I become more and more traditional, and
- 3:06I have certain things with regards to RPG's. I don't like guns in my
- 3:10fantasy. And also I am very very suspicious of this new the way D
- 3:17and D is now going, where they're trying to encourage everyone to use virtual
- 3:21tabletop. What is your view of that? Are you suspicious of it as
- 3:25me? Or are you embracing the new technology? I'm generally happy for role
- 3:30play to go in as many new directions as it wants to as it wants
- 3:34to. I find them all really exciting. That said, I don't get
- 3:39on with the virtual tabletops I have personally tried over Lockdown. I played a
- 3:46campaign of Ravenloft with a GM who I know well I've played with in the
- 3:52past, and his style I like, but the virtual tabletop reduced it to
- 3:54the sense of it being an unsatisfactory skirmish war game right because it was.
- 4:00It was a top down view of icons on a map, and there was
- 4:05no sense of theater of the mind, which is what I get out of
- 4:08role playing it. I like the pictures in my head. I like imagining
- 4:11the drama and all of that and everything. It's what differentiates them from board
- 4:14games essentially, right, I think so, yes, And it felt it
- 4:17was a board game and not a terribly satisfactory right at that. So I'm
- 4:26not in favor of that unless they can bring new tools that we haven't thought
- 4:30of or haven't seen yet that aid the role play. But my own history
- 4:34of game design is very much about that story creation space, about the narrative
- 4:41rather than about the mechanics of combat, or you know, whatever interactions it
- 4:46may be, getting away from dice, getting away from tables, getting away
- 4:49from anything that requires rules to adjudicate it. I mean, to what degree
- 4:55is writing a role playing scenario or writing a role playing system about scaffolding.
- 5:01I assume you don't want to put too much of yourself into it, because
- 5:08there needs to be room for the players to create. Yes, it depends
- 5:14very much. I have a fairly strong or furial voice. When I write
- 5:19games material. I find myself talking directly to the reader, which is a
- 5:25style you know, It's evolved over decades and I'm very happy with and other
- 5:30people seem to enjoy. Other people would prefer that the author be almost invisible,
- 5:34and it's just like, Okay, here's a very brief description of the
- 5:38room. Here's how many monsters there are in it, and here's how many
- 5:40hit points and how much gold they've got. That's really not my style of
- 5:44tying. But yes, absolutely, you're giving other people a structure for creating
- 5:48their or retelling their own narrative. And I think there is a division between
- 5:54the two. Are you giving people a pre written story that you want them
- 5:58to play through, or are you giving them essentially the toolkit to create stories
- 6:01of their own. A lot of people, a lot of role playing designers,
- 6:08particularly early in their career, are essentially they think they know the tools,
- 6:12and then they just kind of take existing things and tweak them a bit
- 6:16and don't really understand the effects. Thereafter, and as designers mature they get
- 6:21the idea that different rules create different effects, and it can be used for
- 6:26different narrative things. And just this morning I was having a discussion with someone
- 6:30who was talking about hidden world games, and I was suggesting that, actually,
- 6:34I think the way to make that work is for the GM to adopt
- 6:39two very different GMing styles. For the traditional world, the mundane world,
- 6:44which should be uninteresting details, it should be a deliberately unengaging place, and
- 6:49then the hidden world, which should be full of all these amazing details and
- 6:53things that catch the imagination and take you off down tangents and characters who engage
- 6:58you. For a GM, that's that's two completely different styles. I can't
- 7:02think of a game that's actually encouraged the GM to switch GMing styles in the
- 7:06middle of a style of play. But hidden world games are all over the
- 7:10place, from the world of Darkness to actually the world of darkness that leaps
- 7:15to mind, but unknown Armies, so many others, and you know,
- 7:20nothing, nothing is immune from the culture war, and certainly RPGs aren't.
- 7:27And if you were to read the the discourse on the internet, you would
- 7:31you would think that the role playing world is in irrepairably split. But do
- 7:36you think role playing games are more political now than they've ever been? Or
- 7:42is this just internet hysteria. It's a good question, I think. Oh
- 7:51sorry, I'm going to take a moment here, and you're going after edit
- 7:54out of pause problem. I apologize. I mean, every thing is always
- 8:01political, you know, even things that say they're not political are inherently supporting
- 8:05a status quo. I think they're more overtly political these days because I think
- 8:13they allow people of all kinds of minorities to not just tell their stories present,
- 8:18but present their stories and present, as we were saying, toolkits for
- 8:22telling their stories to people who do not share that body of experience, or
- 8:26indeed people who do. There's an amazing trans community in role playing games design
- 8:33from you know, the late Janelle cha Ka is just probably the most well
- 8:37known example, but many many others, and I'm not going to name them
- 8:41because I don't out people, but well, unless I know that they want
- 8:46to be outed, But it's that's a tangent. I've worked with many of
- 8:52them. I think they bring a really interesting and unique point of view to
- 8:58gain and to this whole idea of seeing the world from someone else's eyes.
- 9:03A role playing game is a toolkit for experimentation with different points of view,
- 9:09and if that's not an excuse to make it political or at least to try
- 9:15out different political or cultural viewpoints, then I think to an extent, you're
- 9:20just it's just escapism. Not that there is anything wrong with just escapism,
- 9:26but I've always looked for more. So let's go to the beginning then.
- 9:31So you've been reviewing games since the eighties. What got you into that?
- 9:37It was, well, fanzines. Basically. I discovered fanzines very quickly after
- 9:41I discovered role playing games. Started a fanzine, and at the time I
- 9:46was just following other people's templates of what a fanzine could be because I was
- 9:50in my mid teens and trying to strike out and do something original was not
- 9:54high on my list of priorities. I just got a huge buzz out of
- 9:58creating this kind of material and writing for publication, even if it was my
- 10:03own publication, and we were selling fifty copies, and so I was creating
- 10:07RPG material for that, but I was also reviewing new RPG stuff, so
- 10:11tiny little reviews, one paragraph, two paragraphs, very rudimentary staff. But
- 10:18I developed the art, and I developed the art, and I started doing
- 10:20proper journalism and then was approached by I'm trying to think. My first professional
- 10:30reviews, i think were for Games International Magazine, which came out at the
- 10:33end of the eighties, which was a monthly magazine about board games. Way
- 10:39I'm not going to say ahead of its time, because there'd been a very
- 10:41successful magazine in the seventies in Britain call Games and Puzzles, which had lasted
- 10:48i think most of the decade, and Games internetal was trying to kind of
- 10:52pick up that mantle and run with it, and it was reasonably, you
- 10:56know, successful as far as it went, and I started reviewing RPG material
- 11:03and board games for them, partly because I knew the assistant editor quite well
- 11:09because he was part of my role playing group, or I was part of
- 11:13his role playing group, or we were part of the same role anyway they
- 11:16needed writers. I was looking for stuff that would pay my bar bills going
- 11:20through college, so that was, you know, that was some of that.
- 11:26I think they're all up on the Internet archive now, or at least
- 11:28a lot of them were. It's kind of interesting and you read through and
- 11:31there's you know, seeing my staff, which is, you know, it's
- 11:37early works. Let's put it that way, right next to reviews of stuff
- 11:39by Alan Moon, for example, who at the time, you know,
- 11:43we knew he was a respected game designer, but he wasn't Alan Moon at
- 11:48that point. He wasn't the creator of Ticket to Ride. So it's kind
- 11:52of interesting watching people. Essentially, reviews are fascinating because they are a way
- 11:56of exploring a space. It encourages you to think about again because you're trying
- 12:01to explain what a game is and why it's good or not to somebody you
- 12:05haven't met, so you have to kind of think through all the angles on
- 12:07what they might be interested in. It's a really interesting way of exploring a
- 12:11game, and watching people and going through it myself was a really really useful
- 12:18learning experience and sort of what were some of those early games that really fired
- 12:22your imagination bag. Oh, I mean the stuff I was revealed. The
- 12:26trouble with being a reviewer is ninety percent of the stuff you get is rubbish.
- 12:30I mean, you'll never think about it again. But at the same
- 12:33time, it puts you in contact with stuff that you wouldn't necessarily have seen
- 12:37yourself. The Gazetteer series I remember for Dungeons and Dragons, not AD and
- 12:43D at the time, but actual Dungeons Dragons, which was some of the
- 12:48best world building I had seen up to that point in the kind of in
- 12:52the traditional fantasy space. The game that we were playing the role playing group
- 12:58I mentioned were we were mostly playing Empire of the Pedal Throne. Professor Barker's
- 13:03extraordinary. I mean, talking about world building, that's one of the best
- 13:09I think deep culture games ever written. This bizarre planet that's you know,
- 13:15having been high science collapses over ten thousand years into something you know, there's
- 13:22magic, there's leftover technology, there's weird races. It's really and there's ten
- 13:28thousand years of history. There are four or five chronicled different languages using non
- 13:35Latin alphabets that you can learn and I do know speak people who speak and
- 13:41write sol Yarny, extraordinary levels of depth and just understanding the scope of what
- 13:48a role playing game and a role playing world could be, you know,
- 13:52left to its own devices and in the hands of people who are passionate about
- 13:56it. Again, that kindled a fire, really understanding what could be done,
- 14:01and it was. I mean when I was the mid eighties, when
- 14:07I started at college and started my second fans ine and was freelancing for White
- 14:13Dwarf and various others, was an amazing time for role playing games. There
- 14:16were people who were just smashing the mold of what could be done. Paranoia
- 14:20Greg Castickien's masterful dark humor game of you know, an apocalyptic, nightmarish future
- 14:31really reflected in the rules though too in the mechanism Yeah, oh completely yes,
- 14:37But the idea that role playing games could be funny, could be dark,
- 14:41You didn't have to be the hero, it was okay to die.
- 14:45All of these things were completely new. Tune, I think, was roughly
- 14:48simultaneous and kind of did the same thing. But touone was slapstick cartoon humor.
- 14:54You know, it was nineteen eighty This was nineteeny four, nineteen eighty
- 14:58five. The threat of nuclear armor again still hung very in a very real
- 15:01way in the air. And then Ghostbusters, which was partly the same team,
- 15:07Greg sticking again editing that, but it was created by Greg Stafford and
- 15:11then Willis and the Knossium crew, and people dismiss it because it's a license
- 15:16off the Ghostbusters movie. But it's so good. I would put that up
- 15:20against almost any game that comes out today, and it still stands up for
- 15:24the slickness and cleverness of its mechanics and the way that it uses this stuff
- 15:30to create not just humor genuine It's not a game that tells the jokes for
- 15:35you. It is a game that gives you the toolkits to make to be
- 15:37funny on your own, and that's really smart. The great tragedy of that
- 15:43is because it's a license game, and the license is long expired, it's
- 15:48completely unavailable unless you're willing to pay stupid collector's prices. Somebody really needs to
- 15:54scrub the serial numbers off that and put it out again just so people can
- 15:58see it. And so you went from poacher to gamekeeper by designing games?
- 16:06What led you led you there? And is it just inevitable that a gamer
- 16:10will at some point try to design something. I think so. I mean,
- 16:12I've been creating games material, as I said, for the fanzines,
- 16:15and it was just it was a jump from that to creating role playing games.
- 16:22Once upon a Time. You said I designed it, I didn't.
- 16:25I co designed it. And it was Andrew Rilston and Richard Lambert who came
- 16:29up with the original idea. And I saw this incredibly scrappy prototype deck that
- 16:34they'd got. I think it was a New Year party New Year Party two
- 16:41thousand and Andrew showed me this thing, and I went, this is brilliant.
- 16:45This has got real potential. I would really like to work on this
- 16:47with you. And we worked on it for two years and then I took
- 16:51it across to America and found a publisher for it. This is Once upon
- 16:55a Time. This is Once Upon a Time the storytelling card game. And
- 17:00yeah, I mean it felt like a progression. It felt like I understood
- 17:03a bit about games. I certainly understood a bit about game narrative, though
- 17:07not in any kind of coherent way. You know, I didn't have a
- 17:11thesis at that point. And we put this thing together. People seemed to
- 17:17really enjoy it. People who weren't us seemed to really enjoy it, and
- 17:21as I say, we found a publisher in out As Games. It came
- 17:25out at gen Con ninety three, the same convention that Magic launched at,
- 17:30and you know, like Magic, it's never been out of print since,
- 17:36though our sales do not match theirs unfortunately. So your first game, then,
- 17:41is a choir. Why does a choir hold such renown? Oh,
- 17:45because it's so good, I think, I mean, it's still good for
- 17:49people who don't know about Acchoir. It came out in nineteen sixty three,
- 17:53I believe, from three M Games, when the Minnesota Mining and manufacturing company,
- 18:00better known as the people who invented post its, decided to set up
- 18:03a games division for reasons that remain unclear, and the smartest thing they did
- 18:11was higher essentially Alex Randolph and Sitzaksen to create a lot of their early releases,
- 18:18both giants in the field. They weren't necessarily giants back then, but
- 18:22partly on the reputation of the work that they did for three a M became
- 18:26these Titans and Acquire is basically it's the first eurogame created by a guy who
- 18:33was living in Brooklyn for a company in Minnesota. But it embodies so much
- 18:37of the principles of what makes a modern eurogame work. And when I say
- 18:44modern Euro I don't mean the kind of the big trading essentially multiplayer solos with
- 18:48hundreds of components. I mean, you know, the principles that the German
- 18:52game industry took in the late seventies and early eighties and grew into, largely
- 18:57speaking, the modern games industry. The idea that knocking players out halfway through
- 19:02a game is anti fun and that shouldn't and you shouldn't do that. The
- 19:07idea that everyone should be involved at all times, even when it's not your
- 19:11go. All of these kinds of things that basic principles for designers these days,
- 19:15but back then, Revolutionary and Acquire is such an elegant demonstration of how
- 19:21you do that and how you make that work, and all of its rules
- 19:26fit on one side of a four paper. The components are lovely. It's
- 19:32I mean, it's basically it's a grid with tiles, and their later editions
- 19:34have just done it with bits of cardboard, but the original one was injection
- 19:37molded plastic and it's tactile. It's random, but random in a really good
- 19:45way. The randomness is is not does not It does not favor one player
- 19:52over another. It's remarkably balanced despite the fact that it's based on random tile
- 19:56draws and you're building hotel chains. What you do, it's kind of it's
- 20:00the game that Monopoly would really like to be when Monopoly grows up. You're
- 20:03building hotel chains, but you don't own the hotel chains. You own shares
- 20:08in the hotel chains, and your aim is to either take over or be
- 20:14taken over by other chains by connecting them in this their physical representation on the
- 20:19board. When two chains touch, the larger one takes over the smaller one,
- 20:26and the shareholders of the smaller one can cash out. The shares of
- 20:30the larger in the larger chain become more valuable, but you can't sell them,
- 20:34so your liquidity, you know, is reduced. To say, it's
- 20:40beautifully balanced. It's so clever. There's so much going on in the game
- 20:44that is not explained in the rules that you have to understand. You know
- 20:48that you will understand in play. The tactics are really really it's I can't.
- 20:53I still love introducing it to people, going, here's a game that
- 20:57is you know, it's six years old, now more than sixty years old,
- 21:03and they go, come, yeah, okay, well okay, granddad,
- 21:06we'll give that one a try, and they come away just blown away
- 21:08by it. It still feels contemporary. It's proof that you know, a
- 21:12good game doesn't age. And was this pioneering in the sense that it also
- 21:19posited a theory that games could be an adult pursuit rather than you know,
- 21:25something you did with your kids. I think they've always been that division has
- 21:30been around really, I think since the seventeen hundreds, late seventeen hundreds when
- 21:37games for kids really came through it in a big way. Card games,
- 21:41gambling games, or games with that kind of element to it became the area
- 21:48that adults would play in, whether they were gambling for money or not.
- 21:51But that was what grown ups did while kids played tedious Role and Rights,
- 21:55not rolling rights, roll and moves. Sorry, but yeah, I think
- 22:00I mean kids can play it. It is not rule wise, it's not
- 22:03an overly sophisticated game, but the theme is a little bit dry. It
- 22:07doesn't have you know, big cartoon things and stuff. You wouldn't probably wouldn't
- 22:11play it with your eight year old unless you had a remarkable eight year old.
- 22:15But yes, part of the whole three AM game thing was games had
- 22:19become quite kidified, at least games that you bought off the shelf had become
- 22:25quite kidified. Particularly in the fifties. Injection molded plastics and stuff like that
- 22:30had brought brightly colored games, some really clever stuff, but there was an
- 22:37aura of them being four children or at least four families. And the three
- 22:41M games were presented, they called them bookshelf games. They were presented in
- 22:45a box that you could store on a bookshelf and it would look elegant there.
- 22:48They have a pseudo leather binding with gold blocking on it. They are
- 22:52gorgeous just and the production values are so high. The production design is really
- 22:57clever. One of the things I really love about them is on each one
- 23:02there is a photograph of the game set up, but it's always in appropriate
- 23:07surroundings. So I think it's executive decision, which is clearly in a nineteen
- 23:14sixties corporate boardroom with leather bound armchairs on this mahogany table. And then there's
- 23:21stuff like Contigo, which is a clever take on Mankala, and that's in
- 23:26this kind of I don't know how to describe it, a very Californian kind
- 23:33of hippie carved out of clay style building. It's very organic shapes with you
- 23:40know, very what the sixties or the seventies thought of a space age furniture
- 23:45around it. It's just it's it's a lovely, lovely way of presenting a
- 23:51game and saying this game is for you, this game is for grown ups.
- 23:53This game is for you know, smart, fashionable, potentially well off
- 23:59people, all people who aspire to be that, and perhaps playing the game
- 24:03will help you be that. There's far too little of that in games packaging
- 24:07these days. We have all this glorious artwork on the covers of boxes,
- 24:11and so often you flip it over and you don't actually get to see a
- 24:15picture of the game in play, and if you do it, it'll be
- 24:19on a neutral background, And I think that's such a shame. There's still
- 24:22stuff we can learn from the three M games. So I want to move
- 24:26on to your working board games. You talked about Once upon a time,
- 24:32So how long did it take for you to get stuff published? Well,
- 24:40once upon a time. As I say I joined the team, I think
- 24:44Andrew and Richard had only been working on it for a couple of months up
- 24:45to that point. We play tested it for a couple of years and refined
- 24:52it. And remember this is the early nineties. I think we had email,
- 24:57but initially we towards the end certainly we had email, but initially we
- 25:03were corresponding by post because that's what there was. And all our you know,
- 25:10our prototypes were photocopied onto card and cut out with scalpels, and it
- 25:14was, you know, sharing stuff by PDF. No, because you know,
- 25:18we didn't have Internet access. PDFs wouldn't exist for another five years,
- 25:23it was. It was an early time. So two years of prototyping and
- 25:29refining and we got it to a state that we liked. We took it
- 25:33over to Apps Games. I met John Nephew in August I think August nineteen
- 25:42ninety two, as I said, and pretty much the first thing you said
- 25:45is I love this. We're going to publish it, but it needs more
- 25:48play testing. So we tested it again, and I think we finalized the
- 25:52card list late spring, early summer nineteen ninety three, and it was,
- 25:59as I say out out in August ninety three, so a good two and
- 26:03a half year's work. Not you know, not every day obviously, but
- 26:10if one thinks of I think a good game is often like a kind of
- 26:12a fine wine. There are times where it just needs to kind of sit
- 26:15and age for a bit and then you turn the bottle or whatever it is
- 26:21and to refresh it lightly. So that was that was an unusually long one.
- 26:30I haven't actually had that many games published for the commercial market. I've
- 26:34done an awful lot of I run a consultancy these days, I do a
- 26:37lot of client work. That was probably the longest gestation. By contrast my
- 26:45Baron Munchausen game, which I created while I was at Hogshead. That actually,
- 26:52because I was writing it in kind of snatched moments here and there,
- 26:56took a fairly long time to write. But one it was written. I
- 27:02play tested that twice at mostly at a games convention in Cambridge, and it
- 27:07went so well that I just went, yeah, I'm going to publish this
- 27:10as it is. I'd see no need to change this any further. And
- 27:14that basically came out the same summer that I think started play testing it.
- 27:22So yeah, I mean, sometimes it comes together in a rush and you
- 27:23just you hit the target quite quickly. Most times your first draft will be
- 27:29rubbish and you just need to refine. And there is no way of knowing
- 27:32how long that process is going to take. That you know, play test
- 27:37and revise, and play test and revise. I run workshops on this,
- 27:41the game design masterclass in which I teach people. It's a three hour masterclass.
- 27:48I talk for an hour, and then people divide into teams. They
- 27:51create a game inside an hour from scratch, then everyone tests everyone else's games.
- 27:57Then they get half an hour revise game. Then everyone tests everyone else's
- 28:00games again. So you can iterate a prototype that quickly if you've got the
- 28:07focus, and also if you're not looking for a terribly sophisticated game, it
- 28:11can be a really fast process. It can take literally years, but it
- 28:15is always worth taking the time. I think it's I think it was me
- 28:22and Oto who created Mario Brothers and many of the great Nintendo games said a
- 28:27late game is late, but a mediocre game is mediocre forever. It's worth
- 28:33taking the time. And so can you tell us then? About Baron Munchaus
- 28:37And I'm I'm rather ashamed to say that I that I bought this and I
- 28:41read it, and I have yet to play it. And so give give
- 28:48the listeners a view of this game because it from a read, it sounds
- 28:51incredibly fun. Okay, I'm glad to say that most people do think it's
- 28:55incredibly fun. It's a to describe the game itself. It is a game
- 29:02of drunkenly retelling your adventures in the persona of an eighteenth century noble adventurer and
- 29:10raconteur at a drunken gathering of such reconteurs and adventurers. Essentially, the way
- 29:18it works is everyone has a small pile of coins in front of them and
- 29:21a drink, and the game starts with one of the players turning to the
- 29:26player on their left and challenging them to tell a story. And there's three
- 29:29hundred in the Basic the Basic book, or you can just make stuff up.
- 29:33So, as my dear count, I've heard many tales your extraordinary exploits
- 29:38around the world, but one I've always wanted to hear from your own lips
- 29:41is the time that you accidentally impregnated the pope. And this person who's been
- 29:48challenged just has to start telling a story. Just make literally making stuff up,
- 29:56doesn't matter particularly if it makes sense or not, but just launch into
- 30:00the story in the style of an eighteenth century raconteur, which is a fantastic
- 30:06time for the setting of the game, because people still believe that magic was
- 30:10real, but science was also real, and people understood that science was the
- 30:14coming thing, but at the same time they didn't really understand what science was
- 30:17or where it could go, and geography was still kind of nebulus, and
- 30:21islands were being discovered, and you know, your exploits on the island of
- 30:25Cheese, and you know travels to the moon and the Sun and all the
- 30:30rest of that. So you tell the story, but other players, by
- 30:34pushing a coin towards you, can interrupt you and suggest clarifications or corrections.
- 30:41So you say, we're in Vienna in the spring. It's well known Vienna
- 30:45closes for spring cleaning. How pray was it that you were able to gain
- 30:49admittance? And you can either accept this interruption into your story, which sounds
- 30:55terrifying, but actually they're giving you stuff that you can use or not use,
- 31:00so's they're like handholds that you can accept or reject, so you can
- 31:04build it into your story, or you can push a coin back and reject
- 31:07it and go no, you're thinking of parrots Paris famously Vienna's knee deep in
- 31:14the Filth of three hundred Years. As it's well known, you know,
- 31:19do not any resemblance to truth or historical accuracy. Is entirely accidental. So
- 31:26each story lasts about five minutes, and then you turn to the player on
- 31:30your left and you challenge them to tell a story. You go around the
- 31:32entire group, everyone tells a story, and then you use the coins that
- 31:34you have accumulated during the course of the game to vote on what you thought
- 31:38was the best story. And that's it. It plays typically in less than
- 31:42an hour. It is genuinely funny. As I said, it's a toolkit
- 31:47for allowing people to be funny. That's the way the rules are structured.
- 31:52The interruptions themselves are often funny, people's reactions are often funny. And then
- 31:59the thing that almost always starts happening, although it's not in the rules,
- 32:02is people start inserting themselves into each other's stories. So, of course,
- 32:06oh, that was me Scrawfield's beggar. No, I was in the guy.
- 32:10It's a hoot. As you probably gathered, that's not actually very many
- 32:15rules in the original letter sized version, A four size version. The rules
- 32:20were actually less than a page. You can't sell a page of rules,
- 32:22and you can these days on itch, but back in the day, back
- 32:25in nineteen ninety eight when it came out, you can't. You couldn't,
- 32:29so I dressed it up. The story goes that my ancestors John and Edward
- 32:35Wallace not direct answers, but they're in a family tree who were board game
- 32:39publishers in London at the end of the eighteenth and early nineteenth century, and
- 32:44that is completely true. The story goes that John met Baron Munchausen at Dover
- 32:50and commission him to design a game that is less true, and so it's
- 32:54the game has written by Baron Munchhausen, who is a wit and raconteur and
- 32:59so, and there's twenty four pages of material. So that's what the game
- 33:04is. Basically. The majority of the book is the Baron telling you how
- 33:07to play it, which is amusing and works as functions as an example of
- 33:12play, and then there's the actual rules. So your next game then is
- 33:16Railway Rivals. Is this the first crayon rail game? I believe it is.
- 33:23It dates from the seventies. It's another early game It's a British design
- 33:28by a geography teacher, David Watts, who created it to teach his student's
- 33:32physical geography through the medium of letting them build railroads over various maps. And
- 33:40it was one of my gateway games. I encountered it for the first time
- 33:45at my first residential games convention, which was Games Fair at Reading University in
- 33:50the early eighties, where I was actually taught to play the game by David
- 33:52himself. And it's beautiful. It's a lovely simple game once again, works
- 34:00in two phases. Phase one is you draw. You basically you create your
- 34:07railroad, your your railway network across whichever map it is, by drawing directly
- 34:12onto the map using wipe off pens, using a really clever system that at
- 34:19the start of each turn somebody rolls a die and that's how many building points
- 34:22everybody gets. But the thing is, you know, so what six six
- 34:28points everyone can draw across six hexes or builder bridges or build tunnels or whatever
- 34:32it is. But building a tunnel I think costs five. So if the
- 34:37role isn't a five or a six, you can't build a tunnel that tern.
- 34:40Nobody can build a tunnel that tern It works incredibly well, and it
- 34:45costs points to cross over people's lines or to join create intersections with other people's
- 34:49lines if they've got their first. And you're connecting up cities across the world.
- 34:52And the phase two you race trains between cities randomly determined cities. This
- 34:59is basically asked dice rolling. You're just rolling six sided dice to see whose
- 35:05train gets there first. But it's really fast and it's exhilarating. It's really
- 35:09fun. It sounds like it shouldn't be, but it is tactical, except
- 35:15the tactics came first in designing the railroad, and you're rolling the dice so
- 35:20much that it all tends to even out, and the best network will usually
- 35:24win, but not necessarily. But you can use bits of other people's railroads.
- 35:29You can pay them to use their track to shorten your route, but
- 35:32it's not a surety that you're going to win. It's huge fun. The
- 35:37great tragedy of railway Rivals is it's been out of print in English since nineteen
- 35:42eighty five. It won the Spiel des Jachez under its German name Dampfross in
- 35:45nineteen eighty four. Ah I know Dampfross. Okay, yeah, it's Damphross.
- 35:51Yes. And then the game's workfod petition went out of print in nineteen
- 35:54eighty five was not reprinted. I know the chap who owns the right,
- 36:00and he is not actively looking for for anyone to republish it, though I
- 36:04keep meaning to put a bit together because I think there's a market for it,
- 36:07because it's fun. The design feels a little dated, but it's still
- 36:12hugely entertaining to play. You read the rules and you go, oh,
- 36:14this wouldn't work, and then you play it. And I've played it with
- 36:17games design students and unanimously they say where can we get a copy? And
- 36:22I say, well, ebabe, it will cost you sixty quid and their
- 36:24face is full. But it's it's just it's a joyous game. It has
- 36:30all the again, it's it's not typically a euro game, but everyone's in
- 36:35it till the finish, everyone feels that they might win. It's not overly
- 36:38complex. Essentially, it's a it's a score race. You're trying to,
- 36:43you know, end up with the most money. But it's just it's a
- 36:46delight. It's always fun, and there's so many maps for it. As
- 36:51well as soon as you get bored of one map, there's another people have
- 36:54done. Maria they've done, and Antarctica, you know, racing trains across
- 36:59in it's huge. And why so board gaming is a very cult of the
- 37:07new sort of pursuit and games age like fine milk, Why should we go
- 37:15back to a game that is so old? I would disagree with that.
- 37:20I think a good games stick around, Chess, Go Mankala, even the
- 37:25Royal Game of Earth is still entertaining today, though I would say that one's
- 37:31probably more of historical interest. And you know, part of what I'm trying
- 37:36to do at the moment is get people to understand that it's you know,
- 37:39just because a game is new does not mean it's necessarily better. It may
- 37:43have more modern mechanics, but sometimes a simple card deal is more interesting than
- 37:49drafting. So there are a lot of really really good games out there that
- 37:54are still really good in their in their unedited form. Some of them could
- 37:59do with a little bit of a wash and brush up. Quite possibly their
- 38:01components, you know, were designed in the seventies, you know, using
- 38:07seventies style manufacturer, before the idea of not just metals but kind of bits
- 38:10of wood and you know, the whole the idea that came out of Germany
- 38:15of wooden, beautiful wooden components so that you know, they'll be cheap cardboard.
- 38:21So many, so many games I've got still, you know, just
- 38:24cardboard chits. I think it's really worth worth re evaluating. And we can
- 38:30learn from these games. We can see what mechanics stick around, what mechanics
- 38:32don't. My most recent book, Everybody Wins Token plug Here, is about
- 38:40the history of the rise of modern board games from the seventies onwards, and
- 38:45you know, for which I had to go back and play all the Shielders,
- 38:49Yachas winners, and an awful lot of the games that are kind of
- 38:52you know, got on the recommended list as well, and the vast majority
- 38:57of them are still fun. They're not necessarily quite the style of fun that
- 39:02we're familiar with today. But you can pick up such delights on eBay for
- 39:09almost nothing. I pically, just last week I picked up a bundle of
- 39:15four games for twelve pounds, including a very early black box copy of Cludo.
- 39:22Because there's nothing out there that almost nothing on the internet goes This is
- 39:25a you know, this is a nineteen fifties printing of Cludo. It ought
- 39:29to be worth It's not worth anything particularly, but it ought to be.
- 39:35But Scoop as well. I don't know if you ever came across scoop.
- 39:37Scoop I think was out of print by the seventies. It's a game of
- 39:42basically being a newspaper editor and you're putting together the front page of your paper
- 39:45by assembling stories and eats. At its heart, it's running again and all
- 39:51for so many games. Ticket to Ride is rummy, So it's this.
- 39:54You're trying to put together sets of cards in all which will allow you to
- 39:58take particular types of news story. Do you go with the big, splashy
- 40:02headline or the little thing? Or you can buy get adverts as well,
- 40:06and you're trying to create the most value. But there's this amazing cardboard telephone
- 40:12and we're talking old style rotary phone in it, in which you determine if
- 40:17your story is any good, if it's actually you know, verbal, And
- 40:22you turn this thing and it randomizes. I need to take this thing apart
- 40:25and work out how it works for the result to give you the result?
- 40:30Is it truly random? Is it? You know? Is it can you
- 40:37work out the sequence that these answers come in, but you dial a particular
- 40:40Every story has a particular number that you need to dial on it. It's
- 40:45brilliant gameplay wise, would probably you know, probably I would say a six
- 40:52point five on board game Geek. It's not exceptional. I don't know what
- 40:57it is on board Gamekeep. But the trouble is old a game get devalued
- 41:00because people pick them up and they go, oh, this doesn't look modern.
- 41:02Oh all the girl works in black and white, you know, and
- 41:06they mark it down for that. Of course it was. It was the
- 41:07nineteen fifties. Yeah, there are treasures to be discovered. Pit is still
- 41:15I will jump into a game of PIT. It's just a simple real time
- 41:19set collection game. But it's the game I've been told to stop playing most
- 41:22often at games events because it gets so raucous, so loud, and people
- 41:30aren't doing that. You won't learn very much from looking at games from the
- 41:36last five years. But if you go back fifty years and you look at
- 41:38some of the ideas that have fallen by the wayside, or that people were
- 41:42using mechanics when those mechanics were still raw and interesting, you can learn so
- 41:47much from them. Gamers Guild is excited to announce their first kickstarle of project
- 42:02of twenty twenty four, boober Kiki, from the mind of John Chaffer,
- 42:07designer of the hit holiday Hijinks. Boober Kiki uses a real world psychological concept
- 42:12to facilitate gameplay. I'm going to ask youber question, what does a boober
- 42:16look like? And now, what does a kiki look like? Ninety percent
- 42:22of people would say that a boober is a rounded shape and a kiki is
- 42:24a spiky one. And this phenomenon holds across language and culture. Boober Kiki
- 42:30takes the hive mind mechanic of Just One and the storytelling scenarios of the crew
- 42:35and mashes them into a fun, communication party game. Six mini campaigns of
- 42:39ever increasing difficulty are included. If you want to sign up for a launch
- 42:44notification, the link is in the show notes. And I'd like to thank
- 42:46Grand Gamers Guilds for sponsoring this podcast. So I want to move on now
- 42:59and talk about Hogshead, which was your RPG company. So how did you
- 43:01start the company? Ah Hogg said, came out of three things coming together
- 43:07simultaneously. Andrew Rilston the aforementioned, and I had started a journal of role
- 43:14playing and storytelling systems, a quasi academic journal called Interactive Fantasy, talking about
- 43:19how you use in how you create interactive stories, essentially, how interactive stories
- 43:24work, how you can create roles, rules systems that you know to govern
- 43:30these things, an entirely unexplored area at the time that seemed to be doing
- 43:35quite well. I had a role playing game I had been working on for
- 43:38four yea four years at that point, called Bugtown, which had just been
- 43:45dropped by its publisher, and so I was looking for a home for that,
- 43:49and I became aware that the rights to Warhamer Fantasy Roleplay were available from
- 43:52Games Workshop. They were looking for a licensee and this seemed to be a
- 43:57confluence of things that fitted with what I wanted to do and my school's my
- 44:00skill set. So I applied to Games Workshop and sent them a business plan
- 44:07and they gave us the license. So that was where it came from.
- 44:13It was also the fact that I had spent the previous five or six years
- 44:16watching people trying to make British role playing companies work, because in the late
- 44:21eighties Games Workshop had moved away from role Play and Workshop was not only the
- 44:27home of Warhammer, but it was also at the time the largest games distributor
- 44:30and retailer for hobby games in the UK. So when they moved away from
- 44:36role play, roleplay essentially withered on the vine here. So people were setting
- 44:40up companies going, oh, you know, there's a space in the market.
- 44:44Yeah, but can you get to that market? Because again, it's
- 44:47the late eighties, it's the early nineties. There is no internet worth worth
- 44:52speaking of. There were role playing magazines, but they weren't out there,
- 44:55you know, they weren't widely read. People were, as you used,
- 45:00mostly playing to hunts and dragons towards every bus. And I quickly came to
- 45:07the realization that the UK market simply wasn't large enough to support a company.
- 45:10Because I've been working for American companies. I've been going over to American trade
- 45:15shows. So Hoggshaid pretended to be an American company, or it behaved like
- 45:19an American company. We printed everything in the States, warehoused and shipped everything
- 45:22from the States. We priced everything in dollars. We kept American office hours
- 45:28so that American distributors could contact us and we would respond quickly. And it
- 45:32worked. We didn't go bust. We did get screwed over by our We'd
- 45:37signed an exclusive deal for the whole of Europe for a Fantasy roleplay with a
- 45:42British distributor now out of business, and they just they screwed us on the
- 45:46deal. They didn't pay us. It was as simple as that. We'd
- 45:50taken out a considerable overdraft to extend our print run to give them as many
- 45:53books as they had ordered, and it became clear they had no intention of
- 45:58actually paying us, and so Hogshead, you know, which was supposed to
- 46:04you know why, I'm Fantasy role Play was going to be our first release,
- 46:07and then I think called FRUP, which was kind of a throwaway D
- 46:09and D parody, and then Bugtown and instead what happened is I had to
- 46:14lay everyone off, including myself because we had no money, work without pay
- 46:20for the best part of eighteen months just to get the company back on and
- 46:22even keel financially and by that point and take a day job. So I
- 46:28was doing. I was running Hogshead evenings and weekends out of my spare bedroom.
- 46:31And you know, this may have been one of the other reasons that
- 46:36UK Games companies didn't survive. It's because most of the distributors at the time
- 46:39were sharks. And yeah, we survived. But by the time that we
- 46:47kind of got out of that pit and you know, found an office and
- 46:51I was able to hire more staff. Nineteen ninety eight, my personal appetite
- 46:55for designing a big role playing game was kind of out of the window.
- 46:59Plus was working a day job. But I had this idea for Baron Munchhausen,
- 47:02so I did that kind of as a throwaway. It was meant to
- 47:07be a vanity project. It was meant to be. I set this company
- 47:09up three or four years ago to publish games with my name on and that
- 47:14didn't happen. So damn it, I'm going to do one and I don't
- 47:15care if nobody buys it. And then they bought it, and I was
- 47:21kind of surprised. I mean, it's Fantasy Flight did the third edition.
- 47:25It's this beautiful hardback with full color art throughout. It's a stunning book.
- 47:31If you had told me back then that, you know, almost twenty years
- 47:37no more than twenty years later, it would still be around. People would
- 47:39still be talking about it, you know, and it would be heralded as
- 47:44one of the the four erunners of modern role play because it was the first
- 47:49game that broke away from the Geygax arms and paradigm of how role playing games
- 47:53are supposed to work, the idea that you know, there's a dungeon master,
- 47:57and you have character sheets, and you have die saw some randomizer or
- 48:00points systems to create your character, and you have to create a character.
- 48:05It does away with all of that. It's an after dinner role playing game.
- 48:09It does bill itself as a role playing game, and I've been taken
- 48:13to task about that by many people, including Gary guy GaX. But the
- 48:16thing is, when it came out in nineteen ninety eight, there was no
- 48:20other term for what it was, in the same way that the original edition
- 48:22of Dungeons and Dragons describes itself as a miniatures wargame on the cover or I
- 48:30forget exactly the phrase, but it doesn't use the term role play because the
- 48:32term role playing game didn't exist back then. So yeah, so I'd regard
- 48:37it as a role playing game. And yeah, one could say that things
- 48:39like the how To Host Murder games came along first, but they don't consider
- 48:44themselves role playing games. They consider the murder mystery that consider themselves murder mystery
- 48:47games. So yeah, it's it lit a fire, and I'm just still
- 48:54astonished and unbelievably pleased that people are still playing it and enjoying it. And
- 49:00so, how has role playing role playing games as an art form, but
- 49:07also sort of how they're played, how they're distributed, all of that sort
- 49:10of stuff, How has that changed since those days at Hogshead? Oh?
- 49:15Completely, The Internet has absolutely changed everything in the same way that the growth
- 49:22of board games changed in the eighties and games conventions. Because what the Internet
- 49:25did and what games conventions and stuff did is they put designers in touch with
- 49:30other designers, and in role playing terms, that meant designers from all over
- 49:32the world were in touch with each other. So and people from I mentioned,
- 49:37people from minorities or whether that's a sexual or gender minority or a racial
- 49:44minority or whatever else can get together and can create games that cater to their
- 49:51market, or if they just want to push the form, they can do
- 49:55that as well. So it did initial create kind of enclaves. There was
- 50:00the Forge famously in the early two thousands, which trying to push the state
- 50:05of the art and then you got the old School Revival or old school whatever
- 50:10youthing are stands for in OSR, and that formed, and it's arguable whether
- 50:16that would have formed in the same way without those Internet communities and those bulletin
- 50:20boards and those almost guaranteed markets. Crowdfunding has changed everything again because you can
- 50:24now essentially use Kickstarter to find out if there is a market for your game
- 50:29before you actually pay to create the game, before you pay the printers.
- 50:35And that's enormously useful, and yeah, it's wider. People decry the you
- 50:42know, the fact that D and D is everywhere, But what D and
- 50:44D is doing is it introduces people to the idea of what a role playing
- 50:47game is. I don't think we would be playing as many board games as
- 50:52we do today if Monopoly didn't exist, and Dungeons and Dragons is exactly the
- 50:55same and holds the same market position within roleplay that Monopoly does in board games.
- 51:01Widely reviled by the cognoscenti, but at the same time a really important
- 51:07thing for getting people involved. And yes, an awful lot of people get
- 51:09involved to that extent and never go any further, and that's fine, But
- 51:15for those who want to go further. There is now a viable space and
- 51:19you can find out about it drive through URPG. I was talking to one
- 51:22of their people the other day. They get almost two thousand new products listed
- 51:28every month. Wow, that's extraordinary. And yes, some of them are
- 51:32throwaways, you know, one page, two page things, but some of
- 51:36them are you know, works of colossal imagination and design that people have sweated
- 51:43over and I just hope they find an audience. So when people talk about
- 51:47representation within the hobby, both board games and RPGs, it's always delineated down
- 51:52identity lines, whether that be sexuality, whether that be religion, whether that
- 51:55be color. And yet and yet never is class mentioned. Is this because
- 52:04gaming is irretrievably bourgeois? I I am not sure. I am bourgeois.
- 52:14I went to boarding school. That was where I discovered Dungeons and Dragons,
- 52:16and it quite possibly saved my life there because I had a bloody, awful
- 52:20time. I can't imagine. Frankly it was. It was genuinely, you
- 52:23know, I was, I was a geek. I had insufficient social skills,
- 52:29I was very bullied and Dungeons and Dragons was my escape. It was
- 52:34you know, it was a safe space that though I could go to a
- 52:37place in my head, but which I shared with a small number of friends,
- 52:43and you know, gave me, gave me an escape, gave me
- 52:45an escape route. I did not think at that point that I would ever
- 52:49end up as a professional games designer. I assumed I would do what my
- 52:52contemporaries did and probably going to the law or the city or advertising or something
- 52:59like that. And you know, I trained as a journalist I have,
- 53:04you know, was on the Sunday Times for a while, I was a
- 53:06TV presenter briefly, but I've always been doing games, either you know,
- 53:10on a kind of amateur basis or professionally as evenings and weekends. You know,
- 53:15at the time I was running Hogshead most of that I was also managing
- 53:21editor on a magazine that was selling on hundred thousand coups a month and didn't
- 53:24have anything to do with gaming. I'm digressing. I think there is certainly
- 53:30to build a games collection is a bourgeois pursuit, particularly board games, because
- 53:37that requires physical space, and for an awful lot of people, particularly younger
- 53:40people these days, physical space is something they simply don't have in their living
- 53:45conditions. You know, they can't. I got this sounds bourgeois, but
- 53:52it was. I'm going to get my time skills wrong here. It's the
- 53:53late eighties and it was possible for me to buy a house while I was
- 53:59still at college because I came into some money on my twenty first birthday.
- 54:02Not a huge amount, but I was able to put a deposit down,
- 54:06and then I got friends into rent rooms in the house and they paid the
- 54:09mortgage because mortgages were not that high at that point. And that sounds like
- 54:16an impossible dream today. That doesn't sound real for someone today. And I've
- 54:21got teenage kids and the thought that they could do anything like that under no
- 54:27circumstances. You know, perhaps if you move to a different country that did
- 54:31not consider itself part of the first World, you might be able to do
- 54:36that. Well, I think so. I think it's fascinating that when people
- 54:40talk about this sort of stuff, I think it's only when it hits the
- 54:43middle classes that anyone starts to talk about it because you say this. And
- 54:45I grew up in a Council of State in the countryside in the West Midlands,
- 54:50and for my mother, a single mother working in a factory. The
- 54:57idea of home ownership the early eighties was an impossible dream too, right,
- 55:02Yes, And I guess I guess it's become current. And I guess this
- 55:07is an extension of that. Wasn't it Thatcher used one of her kind of
- 55:10tent pole things, the idea that everyone should be able to and have.
- 55:15But I guess it's become current because it affects the middle classes as with And
- 55:20that's why I guess representation is never sort of delineated on financial lines because it's
- 55:27the middle classes and they don't think about money as much as the poor.
- 55:30I guess I think you may well be right. I think we're in danger
- 55:34of digressing off into some conversation I would I would love to have. I'm
- 55:37waving, I'm waiving my my, my closureless flag here. Yes, I'm
- 55:43not sure your listeners would be terribly fascinating. Get back to board games,
- 55:46Wallace. Yeah, I think it is interesting, and I gain it comes
- 55:52down to available time. I would like to hope that everybody has the time
- 55:57to design a role playing game that you know, puts forward a point of
- 56:01view. And there are punk role playing games out there. I'm not sure
- 56:05punk is necessarily the best way to convey, you know, a lack of
- 56:09satisfaction with the status quo. I think it's quite dated and well, you
- 56:13know, was quite middle class actually when it happened, or a lot of
- 56:15it. A lot of the instigators certainly were. But one of the great
- 56:21things about roleplay these days is you can do a role playing game that is
- 56:23one page, two pages, four pages and no more, and you can
- 56:28put it up on each which costs seem nothing to set up an account and
- 56:30create essentially your online storefront. And there is a chance that you know,
- 56:36you will find sympathetic or an audience who will be interested in what you're doing
- 56:43and form a community. And I would like to think that might change people's
- 56:47minds, if not actually changed the world. I mean I would love to.
- 56:51I'd love to think that games could change the world. I think the
- 56:54time for games simply being an escape is over, and there's amazing stuff happening
- 56:59in the digital field, real you know, games for change, games in
- 57:05education. But of course digital gets the funding, Digital gets the eyeballs because
- 57:10it's unfortunately gets the sales too well, not necessarily, it's interesting. There
- 57:15was the big piece in the Guardian about the upcoming sequel to Stalker s t
- 57:22a l R. With darts based loosely on the Tarkovski movie. But it's
- 57:28a Ukrainian game, and they were going, you know, and the you
- 57:32know such and such came out in I can't remember when it came out and
- 57:36sold. I think they said close on three million copies, and I'm going
- 57:40code Names Code Names has done way more than that. Code Names sold a
- 57:45million copies in its first year. Why you know, all right, code
- 57:50Names is not coming out of Ukraine, But there are Ukrainian board games companies.
- 57:53Mysterium is a Ukrainian game and the company I Games who did that are
- 57:59still looking and still producing games and they are lovely clever games. Why are
- 58:04you know, Guardians should be doing articles on that. But you know,
- 58:07board games aren't sexy apart from three weeks coming up to Christmas. You know,
- 58:10when I get articles in the Daily Telegraph, it's it's weird, but
- 58:16I think people are slowly coming round to it. There was briefly an article,
- 58:22a short article and not actually a great one in the Guardian as well.
- 58:25Basically, if you enjoyed watching The Traitors, here are four board yes
- 58:29I did read that. Yeah, yes, and it's basically and they're all
- 58:31were wolf variants. Yes, I thought, you know, are we going
- 58:35to are going to see the resistance in there? Are we going to see
- 58:37you know, coup? No, it was just weird wolf variance. But
- 58:42you know, fair enough, it's a start. You know, it's slow
- 58:45progress, slow progress. So your next game then is TOTAN. What is
- 58:49this game? Total Totalan is Tales of the Arabian Nights. Ah okay,
- 58:54sorry then, because I was I was looking this up and I could not
- 58:59find it anywhere. Now I know it's for the Avalon Hill seventies titled Titan.
- 59:05No, it's not Tales of the Arabian Nights. Eric Goldberg and others.
- 59:10This is again came out of West End Games. The same people who
- 59:14were producing Paranoia Ghostbusters are all playing game at about the same time. It's
- 59:19I'm not going to say it's the first storytelling board game, but it's the
- 59:21first storytelling board game that matters. And you are heroes of the thousand and
- 59:25one Nights, exploring the world of Arabia and the world beyond it, having
- 59:32adventures, and the thing that people remember about it is the Book of Tales,
- 59:37which in the original version had over a thousand storylits and in the revised
- 59:42Zeman edition has over two thousand story lits. And it's a work of madness,
- 59:49madness and obsession. But it's pretty much guaranteed that whenever you know you're
- 59:53right, Oh I'm in the desert, who do I encounter? I create
- 59:58a vengeful iffrite and you will come up with an encounter that you have never
- 1:00:01had with a vengul affret before, no matter how many times you've played the
- 1:00:06game. And it's got role playing aspects to it because having encountered the ventul
- 1:00:09effret, you look it up on table. There's these matrices. It is
- 1:00:15very much a game of the eighties. You look up what you can do
- 1:00:20with eventual efriat. You you can barter with it, you can avoid it
- 1:00:23or try to you can try to enslave it. You may even be able
- 1:00:29to seduce it. And this these options will vary depending on the type of
- 1:00:34encounter, the type of thing that you have encountered. And then you roll
- 1:00:37a die and that will direct you to one of the paragraphs in the book
- 1:00:42of Tales which are stripped down. You know it's not flowery pros, and
- 1:00:49it's up to the storyteller to kind of pad these things out, and you
- 1:00:53know, you find out what happens to you, and some of these will
- 1:00:57be You get some destiny points, you get some story points, which are
- 1:01:00essentially your victory points, and you need a combo of those. But you
- 1:01:04also get skills and statuses, and you may be able to use skills and
- 1:01:06statuses within the encounter. And you know, statuses range from sex changed to
- 1:01:15beast form, which usually means you've been turned into a monkey. Imprisoned.
- 1:01:20In prisoned, you will see the same encounters over and over again, because
- 1:01:22all you ever encounter when you're in prisoned is a hunchback. And this becomes
- 1:01:28very funny, and it's a funny game. It's a game in which your
- 1:01:30characters have adventures, build narratives about their exploits. They get richer, they
- 1:01:36get less rich. You know, they can make fortunes, they can lose
- 1:01:38fortunes, they can become envious, they can become grief struck if something tragic
- 1:01:44has happened to them. I can sum up the game in one mechanic,
- 1:01:49one tiny mechanic. If you are grief struck and you also have the storytelling
- 1:01:53skill, and you are in the same space as another player, you can
- 1:01:57make them grief struck too, telling the story of your sad exploits. And
- 1:02:02I just I love that it's so evocative of the original tales, but also
- 1:02:08this wonderful world that it captures. It would probably pale eventually, but it
- 1:02:14has never pailed for me. I played the original West End copy too destrunction.
- 1:02:19I have a Zman copy that's holding up so far. It's just a
- 1:02:22delight, and the core mechanic is really I mean, it requires an awful
- 1:02:29lot of work to attempt to duplicate, because you need to create a book
- 1:02:31of tales. But people have tried to do it. I did some years
- 1:02:36ago. I pitched Zman on the idea of doing a Hitchhunk's Guide to the
- 1:02:38Galaxy version of it, because I think it would translate perfectly, and they
- 1:02:45were like, well, can you get the license? And I wrote to
- 1:02:46Douglas Adam's literary agent and never heard back. But it's still it occupies a
- 1:02:53little space in my brain of how I would do that. And if anyone
- 1:02:57has a spare large five figure some of money burning a hole in their bank
- 1:03:00account, let's talk, because my god, I would love to do that.
- 1:03:07So I want to talk now more broadly about Britain and its role in
- 1:03:12the table top world and this question. I want you to imagine, just
- 1:03:20for the purpose of this question, that games Workshop doesn't exist. Okay,
- 1:03:25but apart from games Workshop, who many people don't think of as British.
- 1:03:30I think it's interesting, Yeah, Britain is not thought of as a major
- 1:03:35player in game. You have the two sort of pillars of the gaming world,
- 1:03:38which is Germany and America and Britain. Even though there's an incredible amount
- 1:03:43of designers, even though you know the crane rail system was invented in Britain,
- 1:03:47eight and XX was invented in Britain, it is that thought of as
- 1:03:52a major player in gaming. Why is that, do you think? I
- 1:03:55think I think we've lost our luster because we were in the seventies and I
- 1:04:00talk about this in Everybody Wins, available now from All Good online book all
- 1:04:06Good bookshops, generally online and off. In the nineteen seventies, Britain was
- 1:04:12the world's gaming powerhouse. We were where the rest of the world looked at,
- 1:04:15partly because we had these magazines, we had chains of shops, there
- 1:04:19were games events. There was a chap who organized I always get the strong
- 1:04:26the way around. I believe he was world I think he organized the World
- 1:04:30Scramble championships and I think may have been the British Cludo champion as well.
- 1:04:34Giles Brandreth. Oh, yes, of course, yes was a huge you
- 1:04:38know, a personality who went on purveyor of cardis, Yes, paveyor of
- 1:04:43cardis, writer of many, many books about games and puzzles. Really really
- 1:04:47smart guy. But also we had a number of really really interesting publishing companies.
- 1:04:54Waddington set up their game, but there was I forget the name of
- 1:04:58the company that produced heron to us initially here and taught us what first.
- 1:05:01Shebil as the eye as when a British game came out in the early seventies
- 1:05:05and there were games of that kind of caliber coming out of the UK.
- 1:05:09Sid Saxon even in a Gamma Gamut of Games, one of his better books,
- 1:05:15describes coming over to Britain on a trip and basically buying every single game
- 1:05:20he sees and packing them all down, you know, throwing away anything that's
- 1:05:25not essential, So throwing away the boxes if counters. Oh, we've got
- 1:05:29counters. There's counters that're throwing at dice. We don't need to spit as
- 1:05:31many of possible into his luggage before flying home. And they go, okay,
- 1:05:36we've got three hours till we need to be at the airport. He
- 1:05:40goes out for a walk, discovers five more games, buys them too.
- 1:05:44But the Germans were doing this as well. The German. It's interesting.
- 1:05:47German had much more of a media culture around games. They were reviews in
- 1:05:51mainstream newspapers and things like that, and they would come over to Britain to
- 1:05:56buy games. But and this is where the sch bild Is kind of came
- 1:06:00from, because it was how do we kick the German games industry up into,
- 1:06:04you know, the heights where we want it to occupy. But the
- 1:06:09British industry crashed in the late seventies, partly because we hit the country hit
- 1:06:14an economic recession, and partly because an awful lot of companies were piling into
- 1:06:18the space and producing games that were not any good. Let's be honest,
- 1:06:23they were derivative and they just weren't interesting, and that clogged up the distribution
- 1:06:29channels that I mean, this is the same reason I got I sold.
- 1:06:32Hogs had publishing in the early two thousands because Dungeons of Dragons had produced the
- 1:06:38Open Gaming License, which meant anybody could use the Dungeons of Dragons and mechanics
- 1:06:43in their published game and claim that it was compatible with D and D or
- 1:06:46with the OGL. And the distribution channels just filled up with crap. Some
- 1:06:51good stuff, you know, and stuff that's still around today, but a
- 1:06:56huge amount of crap that just sat there because nobody actually wanted to buy it,
- 1:07:00but people had invested money in it, the retailers and the distributors,
- 1:07:03and I saw that this crash was coming and went, Okay, what we're
- 1:07:06trying to do with the hogsheed is we're trying to push the envelope. We're
- 1:07:10doing minority games. We are not going to survive this clut. This clut
- 1:07:14will take us down with it. Better to get out now, So I
- 1:07:17did. And that's just actually what happened in Britain in the late seventies,
- 1:07:21and our games industry has never really recovered, which is a huge shame,
- 1:07:27and it's I think the big question that a lot of people ask is what
- 1:07:30if Brian Ansell had not taken over Games Workshop. If Games Workshop had continued
- 1:07:35to grow as a retail chain creating and licensing interesting board games and role playing
- 1:07:43games, would we have, you know, regained our position as the guiding
- 1:07:49light of the global tabletop games industry instead of you know, my hat is
- 1:07:56off to Games Workshop. To create what they have created is genuinely astonishing,
- 1:08:00a multi billion pound company. There is no business like like what they do
- 1:08:06anywhere in the world, and the strength of their ip is astonishing. But
- 1:08:14I'm not sure it would have worked because you have to remember the eighties was
- 1:08:16the growth in home computers and games consoles as well, and you've talked about
- 1:08:21the cult of the new It's not just board games. People like the new
- 1:08:25shinies, and I think attraction would have gone elsewhere. I think one of
- 1:08:30the reasons that role playing game survived to an extent, it's because they were
- 1:08:33doing something that video games couldn't do and to arguably still can't do, that
- 1:08:39improvisational style of storytelling. Though you know, borders Gate three, maybe we're
- 1:08:45finally there, but the amount of time and investment required to create a borders
- 1:08:49Gate three as opposed to slapping together some my ideas, you know, running
- 1:08:54a role playing sectionion and the expenses as well. Yeah, I mean it's
- 1:09:00people talk about board games as a bourgeois pursuit, but video games, which
- 1:09:04these days you require what three hundred four hundred pounds console or a high end
- 1:09:09laptop and sixty apart and sixty quid apartment. That's the price of entry.
- 1:09:16You know. I think there's there's an argument there that that's a or could
- 1:09:21be seen as a middle class for all one that tends to favor the middle
- 1:09:29class. Yeah, it's it's a sad story and a lot of town.
- 1:09:35A lot of the British talent started designing for German companies, but Britain has
- 1:09:41not produced a Schpielders as winning game since the early eighties. Railway Rivals was
- 1:09:46the last one. Well. Well, Alan Moon was born in Southampton.
- 1:09:51So when I spoke to him the other day and I told him that I
- 1:09:57claim him for Britain, whether he agrees with it or not, it's what's
- 1:10:00his accent like these days very American? Indeed, Well, I think accent
- 1:10:04is how I judge these things. I think we have to allow that the
- 1:10:09Americans have conquered Alan Moon. Yeah, and you know, there are great
- 1:10:16designers out there. Martin Wallace of course no longer lives in Britain either,
- 1:10:21you know, and we ran a Knetsia was doing amazing design work while he
- 1:10:25lived in Britain, which he doesn't do anymore. Wolfgen Walsh was over here
- 1:10:30doing a research scientist while he was designing I Think the Mind and some of
- 1:10:34his earlier titles, David Thompson, Trevor Benjamin, Matthew Dunstan. Yeah,
- 1:10:40all of these people living in Britain and not being British, not actually being
- 1:10:44British, you know. And we do still have great designers, but the
- 1:10:50industry as a whole, as I said, we're at that awkward stage of
- 1:10:55not quite being big enough to support a big company. And I think to
- 1:11:00a greater extent and a lot of our cousins on the continent hasbro dominates our
- 1:11:04industry, you know, and they have a grip on the on the mainstream
- 1:11:10and it's been much harder for hobby and hobby style games and let's call them
- 1:11:15intelligent games, to all modern games to get a grip on that space.
- 1:11:19And it's happening now, you know, through through the bookshops, in particular
- 1:11:25most chain bookstores have a section of pretty good board games these days, and
- 1:11:30yeah, and also a selection of pretty crappy party games. But the territory,
- 1:11:36you know, we are not It is not on us to dictate what
- 1:11:40other people should play and what other people should enjoy. You know. We
- 1:11:44can pontificate and go, this is a good game and this is a bad
- 1:11:45and we can be snotty about it though. That is my right, absolutely,
- 1:11:50you know. But if somebody is having a great time with their mates
- 1:11:53playing some derivative of cards against humanity, if they're having a good time the
- 1:12:00game, they're doing it right, you know, you can't say more than
- 1:12:03that. I do not. You know, what's the internet phrase, don't
- 1:12:08yuck on someone else's young If other people have fun with Monopoly, good,
- 1:12:13I am glad of that. I think they could be having more fun with
- 1:12:15Acquire. But perhaps they have to get past Monopoly before they can get onto
- 1:12:20Acquire. I'm not sure Acquire is a starter game. And so it's amazing
- 1:12:28when if you were to say, and this is relating to the previous question,
- 1:12:31if you were to say to someone, give us a British tabletop publisher,
- 1:12:36yeah, I think most people wouldn't say, oh, Games Workshop because
- 1:12:42it seems to me the Games Workshop sort of transcends its Britishness, even though
- 1:12:47you know it continues to produce all of its stuff in Nottingham. You know,
- 1:12:51you you've been involved in the industry for years. What is GW's relation
- 1:12:59to the rest of the British game industry. Do they stand aloof or do
- 1:13:03you think they they they bolster it in some way. I think they bolso
- 1:13:09in the same way that you know, Dungeons and Dragons and Monopoly. Do
- 1:13:12people you know get into gaming through Games Workshop and just if all they take
- 1:13:16away from that is that gaming is fun and a great way to spend an
- 1:13:19afternoon with your mates. Fantastic, you know, And then they are they
- 1:13:24are primed to pick up the sort of games that we like. We are
- 1:13:29essentially and I think not so much the miniatures companies, you know, but
- 1:13:34there's an awful lot of scrabbling in their crumbs. Though It's interesting there are
- 1:13:40so few board games and role playing games and things that are essentially notably GW
- 1:13:46knockoffs. There's an awful lot of things that have drawn on Warhammer Fantasy roleplay
- 1:13:49and the Warhammer Old World in kind of Renaissance. Things you've said very early
- 1:13:54on you don't like guns in your fantasy. Wow, sorry, Warham a
- 1:13:58fantasy roleplay. There's guns in the fantasy and I think it's one of the
- 1:14:01things that gives it a distinctive flavor, and it's it's fun, it really
- 1:14:06works. But yeah, it's certainly the British role playing industry is a footnote
- 1:14:14to a footnote of the wider games industry. You know. I don't know
- 1:14:19if any shops that are primarily role playing game shops anymore. If there ever
- 1:14:25were, role playing was always you know, a few shells or you know,
- 1:14:30some sections along with the family games. The stuff that pays the bills.
- 1:14:35To be honest, if you talk to people who run game shops in
- 1:14:38the UK, what pays the bills is the stuff that people have heard of
- 1:14:42because they grew up playing it when they were kids, you know. And
- 1:14:46Magic as well, Yes, the collectible card game and Pokemon and Ugo and
- 1:14:54Lorcana as well. Lorcana seems to be settling in quite nicely. I think
- 1:14:59it's going to to be around for several years at the very least. Certainly,
- 1:15:03Ravensburger seemed very happy with it so. Yeah, but if that you
- 1:15:09know, it is not for us to begrudge the existence of such things.
- 1:15:13I've played one game of Magic in my life. I was at gen Con
- 1:15:16nineteen ninety three. I was walking past the Wizards booth, trying to understand
- 1:15:20what this other card game had that we hadn't got, and somebody grabbed me
- 1:15:26cracked a fresh deck. So all you have to play Magic, I'd be
- 1:15:28demo magic for you. She dealt out two hands of cards. We played
- 1:15:32the card sorting that. You know, the randomization on those very early decks
- 1:15:38was very poor. I got such a bad hand I could not cast a
- 1:15:42single spell for the entire game. And I walked away thinking, that's a
- 1:15:45shame about Wizards of the Coast. I heard they did some nice stuff,
- 1:15:47but this game's going to kill them on that kind of industry knowledge. I
- 1:15:53two years later I set up a games company. Yeah, it's they're not
- 1:15:58for me. I'm really, really glad the an awful lot of people get
- 1:16:00a huge amount of enjoyment out of them, not just because that provides a
- 1:16:06solid financial basis for game shops to stock the kind of minority interest stuff or
- 1:16:13the selling stuff they can take they can experiment on niche games out of Japan
- 1:16:19and stuff like that, assuming they can get them through distribution, and maybe
- 1:16:23those things will find an audience, certainly I would. What fascinates me is
- 1:16:28stuff I've never seen before, doing things in the game space I've never seen
- 1:16:32before, which we will come on to, I think later on. So
- 1:16:39your next game then is a classic and this is El grande? Why are
- 1:16:42you taking this one to the cabin? Oh? Well, this is an
- 1:16:45absolute classic, a big Wolfgangkramers, arguably his masterpiece, though I'm a huge
- 1:16:53fan of Wolfgang Cremers work. Possibly certainly the first great area control game came
- 1:17:02out in the late nineties, has been unavailable for decades in English. I
- 1:17:09have a German copy. I don't speak German, so I have the badly
- 1:17:13translated card PDFs off board game Geek to play it. And it's still absolutely
- 1:17:19great. And it's partly because it captures the flavor of the It's it's setting,
- 1:17:26which is warring knights, kind of paying court on the King of Spain,
- 1:17:30getting close to him but not too close. It's just lovely. But
- 1:17:35it's absolutely tactical as well. It has so many clever elements in it cards
- 1:17:43that change the game conditions. It's just it's immersive at a really comfortable level
- 1:17:53for me. And the example I always give of cognitive load in games optimizing
- 1:17:58cognitive load is on Katan is a masterpiece. And I you know, toyber
- 1:18:03had had won the Shielders Areas what twice three times three times before he did
- 1:18:09Katan. He knew what he was about, and clearly this went through a
- 1:18:14lot of testing. But it's not the kind of thing that you can design
- 1:18:16out the gate. The amount of cognitive loader a game will take. How
- 1:18:21much space in your brain does it feel that is comfortable? And I remember
- 1:18:29many years ago seeing somebody's I think it was their master's research in game design,
- 1:18:32and they analyzed the jump times in platform games and they said, there
- 1:18:38are basically two optimum jump times for a character to remain in the air when
- 1:18:43they're doing a jump, and they are the Mario jump time and the Sonic
- 1:18:45jump time, and every other game just defaults to one of those, whether
- 1:18:49they realize they're doing it or not. And I think cognitive load for me
- 1:18:55is quite similar. There's the Katon level of cognitive load, which is comfortable,
- 1:18:58but at the same time the game not consume your every thought. You
- 1:19:02can chat with friends, but at the same time you're thinking about your tactics
- 1:19:05and you know what you're going to do next next time. And then a
- 1:19:09step up from that is the l Grande level of cognitive load, where that
- 1:19:13you can still talk to the people around the table, but you have to
- 1:19:15think all the time. You have to watch everyone else's move because that will
- 1:19:19change the game state and should change what you're planning to do next time.
- 1:19:23And it's a comfortable level of cognitive load. It is enjoyable having that level
- 1:19:29of strain on your brain. It's just pleasing. And if a game is
- 1:19:33not pleasing in the mind as you are playing it, then for me,
- 1:19:36it's lacking something. And you know the two great examples, Katan and El
- 1:19:43Grande. And the reason I'm not taking Katan is because I will beat you.
- 1:19:46I will beat anyone. I'm not world class level, but I am
- 1:19:51sufficiently good as an amateur Qatan player that people refuse to play against me.
- 1:19:58Gel Grande, I'm not that good. A long way from mastering El Grande.
- 1:20:01I'm not sure it's possible to master El Grande. It's a challenge and
- 1:20:05it's a lovely, lovely challenge, and I would urge people to check out
- 1:20:09the new English language edition if they haven't. And so you know you're a
- 1:20:14game designer, I am sure that you can't turn off the game design aspects
- 1:20:18of your brain when you're playing games. Is there anything about El Grande you'd
- 1:20:24change or is it perfect? I? I would not dream. It's not
- 1:20:34the style of game I design. Actually, there are a couple of things
- 1:20:39I would be interested to tweak and see how it changed the game. I
- 1:20:44would not say I could improve El Grande. I would like to try and
- 1:20:46perhaps alter it that might change its flavor or turn it into a slightly different
- 1:20:51thing. Off the top of my head, I couldn't tell you what those
- 1:20:55are, but I do regard it as a masterpiece, in the same way
- 1:20:59that I would never draw a mustache on the Mona Lisa. Other people have
- 1:21:02to great acclaim, But you know I wouldn't mess with wolfken Kramer. He
- 1:21:06is for me the master great you know, toiber genius, Kramer is for
- 1:21:15me is just games personifier, German games personified. I love his work.
- 1:21:20So we're to talk now about the future. So what do you have coming
- 1:21:23out in the future that we can get hold of in the future. That's
- 1:21:27a good question. Twenty twenty three for me was the year of projects falling
- 1:21:30through. So I'm working on stuff at the moment, but it's all at
- 1:21:34an early stage and I can't talk about it. But I will say that
- 1:21:40I seem to have become a games historian by accident, on the grounds that
- 1:21:44if you write two books about something, people assume you're an expert. And
- 1:21:48this whole thing about we were talking earlier about older games and the value of
- 1:21:54those. Nostalgia is a powerful driver in games. People want to play the
- 1:22:00games that they played when they were kids. You know what people always ask,
- 1:22:03or often ask, why do people still play Monopoly? Is it because
- 1:22:05they don't know any better now? That's because they enjoyed Monopoly when they were
- 1:22:10kids and they want to spread that joy. And that's fair enough. I
- 1:22:15think there's a lot to be explored in the history of games, which is
- 1:22:19very little understood the history of play, and there's some really interesting people working
- 1:22:24in the history of play at the moment and the nature of play and why
- 1:22:27we play as human beings. Leslie Scott, who invented gnger, is doing
- 1:22:32a lot of really interesting work in that at the moment, but also the
- 1:22:39history of individual games as well. There's not enough discourse about this stuff.
- 1:22:44There's not I mean video games. There are you know, epic tomes written
- 1:22:46about Doom and stuff like that. Where are the epic toomes about Gatan?
- 1:22:49Where are the epictomes about a couple of histories of monopoly? Because the history
- 1:22:54of Monopoly is really interesting because the whole design was stolen, almost the whole
- 1:23:00design, I'll clarify that. But you know, where are these books?
- 1:23:03What if I wanted to find out the history of domin right, Dominoes is
- 1:23:08a really bad example because we literally there are academic papers going. We don't
- 1:23:12know the history of dominoes. We have no way of finding it out other
- 1:23:15than if you kind of you know, when it's arrived in Europe, how
- 1:23:17it got to the West Indies. That's about it. But you know,
- 1:23:23even fairly modern games and the inventors are dying. It's a huge you know,
- 1:23:30Toybert died last year, very you know, surprisingly young, very unexpected.
- 1:23:39There you know, there are this whole generation, their knowledge, their
- 1:23:43understanding of what what makes games works or what made games works. When they
- 1:23:46were designing is in danger of being lost, and I think we have a
- 1:23:51limited time to do something about that, and I intend to do it,
- 1:23:56or I do some of it, at least that's the plan. I'm you
- 1:23:58know, putting together business plan at the moment. And so what do you
- 1:24:01think your legacy has been to British games in general? A small one.
- 1:24:08It's no, I did some stuff. I don't think either of the main
- 1:24:14games I'm known for once upon a time more Barren mun shows and are enormously
- 1:24:18remarkable themselves in games, but it was more kind of what they did when
- 1:24:23they did it, going look, this is possible, this is fun.
- 1:24:25We can break out of what the previous perception of what games could be and
- 1:24:29kind of that's my legacy in British games as well, proving that it is
- 1:24:32possible for a feisty British role playing company to break to crack America and crack
- 1:24:39the European market as long as you know what you're doing on a business front.
- 1:24:44You know, we had a unique business plan, or it was unique
- 1:24:47at the time. I would not recommend anyone try and follow that business plan
- 1:24:50these days, because the Internet and Kickstarter have changed everything. But if someone
- 1:24:57was looking to start a games company in the UK or in a territory like
- 1:25:01it not necessarily connected geographically or commercially to other major markets, work out a
- 1:25:11new way of doing that. There are new ways, There are always avenues
- 1:25:15that are not being explored. Find out, you know, first, and
- 1:25:17research the market. I mean, do not go. Oh, I've had
- 1:25:19an idea for a game. I think I'll publish it. No, go
- 1:25:23and work with games publishers and talk to distributors. Go and find out the
- 1:25:28shape of the industry and the trends and where it's going first. But yeah,
- 1:25:34I mean various things. With Hogshead, I'm intensely proud of. Munchhausen
- 1:25:40is one publishing Nobilists, the first coffee table role playing game. Essentially with
- 1:25:45us, we wanted to do a grown up role playing game, a book
- 1:25:48that looked like it was designed for grown ups instead of adolescents. An awful
- 1:25:53lot of graphic design board in role playing games is very adolescent. They look
- 1:25:57like children's annuals. And Nobilists, you know. We set the entire thing
- 1:26:02in Adobe Caslan. We had art from Charles Ves and Brian Talbert and Raven
- 1:26:09and Mura and just amazing beautiful art the whole way for full page art as
- 1:26:14well, rather than floating text around it. And we won design awards for
- 1:26:18that. And it's written by Jenna Morn who is just so good. Her
- 1:26:26role playing design is amazing, her fiction is amazing. She's stunningly good writer.
- 1:26:31So I'm intensely proud of that. I'm you know, just bringing war
- 1:26:34have a fantasy role play back and bringing in, you know, being able
- 1:26:39to wave the banner for British role playing in the nineties because there really wasn't
- 1:26:43very much a bit out there. So yeah, it's I've never looked for
- 1:26:48a legacy, really and what I would like to do, what I would
- 1:26:54like my legacy to be is the stuff I'm hoping to bring out this year
- 1:26:57and next year, you know, slightly shifting the culture of how we understand
- 1:27:01and appreciate games rather than being about the gameplay, but about the game as
- 1:27:06a cultural artifact. Because you use the word art form about role playing games
- 1:27:11earlier on, and this is a battle I've been fighting for thirty years.
- 1:27:15Yes, yes, games are and art form. They absolutely are. There
- 1:27:18is no question they predate written language. They are one of you know,
- 1:27:24they are integral to our understanding of ourselves as the human species. Of course,
- 1:27:30they're an art form, but we don't think about board games as an
- 1:27:33art form. And until people start going, look, it's a bloody art
- 1:27:38form and doing that over in eighties worthy of cultural attention and appreciation that you
- 1:27:45know, it's not going to happen from a few posts on board game Geek.
- 1:27:48It needs people actually putting products out there that are going, look,
- 1:27:51love, we love games. You should love games like this. Magazines like
- 1:27:56Senate are doing a fantastic job. I love Senate, I love with Tail
- 1:28:00Stories, and you know Tabletop Gaming Magazine as well, which I used to
- 1:28:04write for doing an excellent job. But in magazines there's an a femorality to
- 1:28:11them. I think there's I think there's other ways. As I said,
- 1:28:15there's other ways of approaching the problem, and I think I've got it and
- 1:28:17I'm going to give it a crack. So your last game, then,
- 1:28:20is the Mind. Why does this game work? Oh? I wish I
- 1:28:26could tell you. The Mind is a work of absolute genius. You explain
- 1:28:31it to people and they just go, well, that doesn't sound longing fun,
- 1:28:33And then you put it in front of them and they go, oh
- 1:28:35my god. It's for those who don't know it. It's cards number one
- 1:28:41to one hundred, and it's a cooperative game round and what you have to
- 1:28:45do is play the cards face face up to the center of the table in
- 1:28:51the correct numerical order without speaking to each other. And round one everyone gets
- 1:28:56one card, and round two everyone gets two cards, and round three every
- 1:29:00gets three cards. So it gets progressively harder because the spaces, or the
- 1:29:03perceived spaces between the cards grow smaller and smaller. And the reason I mean
- 1:29:12it's a really clever piece of game design. Again, you can explain the
- 1:29:15rules in two minutes. There are some other rules, there are lives,
- 1:29:18there are suri ken as well. But it's an incredibly simple game to play,
- 1:29:25incredibly simple game to explain, and then you play it and it does
- 1:29:30some interesting things with the concept of the magic circle, you know, Johann
- 1:29:36Hoosinger's idea of this kind of space that forms around people playing a game,
- 1:29:41that's almost a ritual space in which what takes place is safe. But Husinger
- 1:29:46was also a ritualist, you know, he understood sacred spaces and stuff,
- 1:29:50and I think there's something about that the mind has. You start off with
- 1:29:54almost a meditate to move. You'll put your hands on the table and and
- 1:29:57then you raise your hands together and that creates in a way that most games
- 1:30:02don't actively create a magic circle. They just allow it to arise passively,
- 1:30:09you know. And we've been playing games for you know, best part of
- 1:30:14eight thousand years as a species, and it wasn't n till the nineteen thirties
- 1:30:16that someone went, you know, there's something about why is playing again?
- 1:30:19Stuff that happens in a game safe, and stuff that happens outside a game
- 1:30:23not spay. And that was husinger. We don't perceive the magic circle.
- 1:30:27We don't understand it, and this someone points it out. But the mind
- 1:30:30very consciously creates this magic circle, and what happens in it is quite special,
- 1:30:33with the silence and everything. And it's hard, it is very surprisingly
- 1:30:40hard to watch other people staring at this sixty seven in your hand and somebody
- 1:30:45has putten. The card on the table is a fifty, and nobody else
- 1:30:48is making a move, and you're going, surely sixty seven is not the
- 1:30:53next card in the sequence, and you kind of you edge it towards and
- 1:30:56somebody else is maybe they're moving their hands lightly. It's great. It's always
- 1:31:00great with strangers, with friends. It's just it's a delight when it goes
- 1:31:05well. When you get one of those runs that you know, somebody bangs
- 1:31:10down forty six and round the table people just forty foot of a bang,
- 1:31:15four or five cards in perfect sequence in you know, and you look at
- 1:31:20each other, how did were we reading each other's minds? Because it feels
- 1:31:26like it. It feels like a psychic experience. And this is the core
- 1:31:30of why it works for me. It makes me feel something that no other
- 1:31:33game has ever done. It's not simple success. It's not emotional peaks and
- 1:31:38troughs. It's not about cognitive load. It's that sense of we are utterly
- 1:31:43in tune with each other when it goes well. And then and then somebody
- 1:31:45else grew it up and you get that wonderful moment of Catharsis and it's like
- 1:31:49cold water has been poured over you. But the sensations that one gets out
- 1:31:55of the mind again, eight thousand years of games history and people are still
- 1:32:00deducing new things, not just new mechanics, but new ways of feeling within
- 1:32:05a game, and that to me is almost literally magic. It's the magic
- 1:32:11of what makes games work. We can't explain what makes a good game and
- 1:32:14a bad game. You can't read the rules and go, oh, this
- 1:32:15is going to be good. The rules of railway Rivals read really badly.
- 1:32:18You read it, you go this is not going to be fun, and
- 1:32:20then you play it and people are rolling sixes and shouting out loud it's yeah,
- 1:32:27games are magic, and you know, pull back er stuff. I
- 1:32:30can't think of a better thing to have waiting out the apocalypse than a bunch
- 1:32:34of board games. At the very least, I would understand a lot more
- 1:32:38about the other people in the cabin by the end of it than I would
- 1:32:41if I got five record albums or books or something. So I've got one
- 1:32:46last question for you. Then, So you're heading out of London the cabin.
- 1:32:50You go around a corner and the back door of the car flies open.
- 1:32:55Four of the games fly out down ravine into a river and are swept
- 1:33:00away to posterity. Which game do Your hope is sitting on the backseat of
- 1:33:02the car. Oh that's that's a tough one. Okay, I'm going to
- 1:33:10I'm going to not to I love I love all five games, Tales of
- 1:33:15the Arabian Nights and Railway Arrivals. For me, there's a lot of nostalgia
- 1:33:17in there because I you know, I've been playing these games since the eighties.
- 1:33:24So let's not say those It's it's going to be a toss up between
- 1:33:29the Mind and a Choir, because I believe those are both genuinely great games.
- 1:33:34I think those are games that will survive at least one hundred years,
- 1:33:40and if this is going to be the last outpost of humanity, I want
- 1:33:43to be one of those two games. Oh, I'm going to say The
- 1:33:47Mind. The Mind, I just I love it on a acquire I also
- 1:33:54love, but I appreciate as a piece of design. The Mind it's something
- 1:33:59for It's just it's it's for me. Has the potential to be the forerunner
- 1:34:05of a whole other school of game design, which I've not really seen come
- 1:34:11through. There is games like Medium and Wavelength are kind of getting there on
- 1:34:15that that sense of group rapport, thinking in tune with each other. I
- 1:34:20would like to see a lot more of that school of design. I'd like
- 1:34:24to see people be inspired by by these So probably the mind, and I'm
- 1:34:27aware that there'll be people out there going how good you? It has its
- 1:34:30haters, but like I said, don't yuck on someone else. He's youm
- 1:34:35So if people want to get a hold of you, they want to find
- 1:34:38out what you've got coming out, they want to buy some of your previous
- 1:34:41books or games. How can they go about doing that? I have a
- 1:34:45website. I have several websites. James Wallace dot com is my personal website.
- 1:34:49Space with threea's dot com is that's you. Spell Space with threea's dot
- 1:34:55Com is my games consultancy. I have a podcast which are on role playing
- 1:35:00games, which I do with Ross Payton and Greg Stalsey. We're about to
- 1:35:04kickstart the third season of that. That's called Loudo Narrative Dissidents not Dissonance Dissidents
- 1:35:11dot com though available wherever podcasts are casted. My book Everybody Wins, which
- 1:35:18I've plugged a couple of times, is available at all good bookshops and online.
- 1:35:24There's digital versions, audiobook versions as well. My previous book, which
- 1:35:29I don't actually get any royalties on but is still quite good. Board Games
- 1:35:31in one Hundred Moves with Ian Livingston Sirian Livingstone is still in print with Drlin
- 1:35:38Kindersley. My Barnmunchausen game is available in PDF form on the usual pdf places
- 1:35:45on the Internet, not parroted you scoundrels, drive through RPG, or if
- 1:35:51you want one of the remaining physical copies, you can buy it from Indie
- 1:35:54Press, Revolution in the States or Leisure Games in North London usually has copies,
- 1:36:01and once upon a time it's still in print and still available all good
- 1:36:04bookshop, all good game shops. That's probably about it. And I'm I'm
- 1:36:11on Blue Sky, I'm on what's the other on Masterden, I'm on I'm
- 1:36:16sort of on Facebook, but it doesn't really count. Just search for James
- 1:36:21Wallace. I tend to be an early adopted, so I tend to get
- 1:36:26the I tend to be that person. Excellent, well, James Wallace,
- 1:36:30thank you very much. Thank you. This has been an absolute pleasure.
- 1:36:34You can support the show in many ways. You can tell your friends,
- 1:36:38you can talk about it on social media. You can talk about it in
- 1:36:40your own blog, podcast or video. You can support it directly by going
- 1:36:43to patreon dot com forward slash five GFD for a rolling donation or for a
- 1:36:46one off donation hitting the papal link at the bottom of the website five Games
- 1:36:49for Doomsday dot com. It's these donations that keep the show going. Also,
- 1:36:55if you want to say something nice about the show, if you want
- 1:36:56to say something horrible about the show, you can contact me on Twitter at
- 1:36:59five Games for Doomsday or send me an email at five Games for Doomsday gmail
- 1:37:02dot com. And if I managed to leg it from the tentacled game show
- 1:37:06host and Robert Johnson's House of pancakes, I'll see you in two weeks for
- 1:37:11another five Games for Doomsday