Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Conservatorship: When NCUA Removes the Board & What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Hey everyone.
- 0:35This is mark Treichel with another episode of, with flying colors.
- 0:39This is part of a recording I did with Steve Farr and Todd Miller of my
- 0:44team, Steve Todd and I worked on the biggest and baddest conservatorships.
- 0:49And CYA history and have a lot of knowledge on this topic.
- 0:52Uh, if you don't know what the term conservatorship means in the
- 0:56context of credit unions, that's when NCUA removes the board.
- 1:00And steps in and represents both the insurance fund.
- 1:04And the members for a particular credit union.
- 1:06So without further ado, Uh, here is myself, Steve and
- 1:10Todd on conservatorships.
- 1:13Treichel: All right.
- 1:14Conservatorships.
- 1:15They're an adrenaline adrenaline ride as a former special actions person,
- 1:20as you two were you learn a lot.
- 1:22You, they're, they can be a challenge.
- 1:25They can be fun.
- 1:26They can be scary.
- 1:28And they can be very effective when they're appropriate.
- 1:30So let's talk a little bit about NCUA's conservatorship approach and powers.
- 1:37Miller: So conservatorships are quite.
- 1:41Interesting, and I think one reason NCOA doesn't go down the path of cease
- 1:46and desist very often is usually by the time you get to that place where
- 1:52you have legal grounds to issue a cease and desist, you almost have the legal
- 1:56grounds to conserve a credit to and by then problems are pretty severe.
- 2:01They're usually related to the people in place of being unable
- 2:05or unwilling to correct problems.
- 2:07Going through a cease and desist isn't going to change that if they don't
- 2:10have the competency to fix the problem.
- 2:13Giving them a cease and desist isn't going to magically resolve that problem.
- 2:17There are almost always people problems at this point.
- 2:20You're almost always getting close to involving potential losses to
- 2:24the insurance fund at this point.
- 2:26So from a legal perspective, quite often, it's just as easy for a regional
- 2:31director to pursue a conservatorship than it is a cease and desist.
- 2:36And then once NCUA is in control, they can make a better assessment of
- 2:40what are our potential losses here.
- 2:43Can this credit union be saved?
- 2:45Sometimes we've conserved credit unions just because, We've tried to get them
- 2:49a merger partner and people wanted 40 million in assistance and you can serve
- 2:54them and you clean up the books and you clean up some of the bad loans and that
- 2:57cost of the insurance fund drops to 20 million the next time you bid it out
- 3:01after NCOAs had a period of time hiring some competent people to clean things up.
- 3:07In other times, it was, You can clean things up and end up with a stable credit
- 3:12and you can return it to the members.
- 3:14You just give it to a different set of board of directors that we
- 3:17recruit and the CEO that we recruit.
- 3:21I always thought as a, PCO and as a DSA that NCOA should do more conservative
- 3:28shifts because you said you learn a lot.
- 3:30And here's what happens.
- 3:31We go through a recession and we do a lot of them.
- 3:34I think in like 2011, 2012 in our region, we may have done six or eight of them.
- 3:39I know at one point I had four at one time, but you learn a lot.
- 3:43And then the economy gets better and all those people move on
- 3:47and get promoted and retired.
- 3:49And then eight years later, when you're doing it again, you've lost
- 3:51that skill set and you have to relearn all the same lessons over again.
- 3:55So I thought you should do more just to keep people in practice because
- 3:58there's, there are a lot of work and like you said, they're fun.
- 4:02The year when I was managing four of them.
- 4:05Okay.
- 4:05I didn't take a day off those weeks.
- 4:06I worked on Saturdays and Sundays too.
- 4:09When you brought me into Westcore, so I spent a whole year there under
- 4:13your supervision mark at westcore.
- 4:16Similar things.
- 4:17There's a lot of days that are fun.
- 4:19You learn a lot, and there's other days that are not very pleasant when
- 4:23you're running a conservatorship.
- 4:25But ultimately, NCUA, when they do conserve a credit union.
- 4:30I try and make a decision early on.
- 4:31Is this salvageable or are we just trying to put lipstick on this
- 4:36ugly beast and try and reduce our losses to the best of our ability?
- 4:41Said Steve.
- 4:43Farrar: Yeah, I had a unique opportunity.
- 4:46It was pretty great.
- 4:46I got to as working for NCOA, I was involved in.
- 4:51Direct supervision of a number of conservatorships and assisted
- 4:55people, with other ongoing ones.
- 4:58And then post retirement, they had the opportunity where I went
- 5:02in and was part of the management team that NCLA brought in.
- 5:06To run a conservatorship, and so it was nice to see both sides.
- 5:10It was it was very interesting when I was on the side of the conservatorship
- 5:15management team that we had issues of course dealing with our regulator.
- 5:21It was in conservatorship, and so I even I would get frustrated with the regulator
- 5:26and then, I wanted, to stay focused on the issues that needed to be resolved.
- 5:31And so it, it, the, it still is, NC way, the conservatorship team is still,
- 5:37working with the regulator on that.
- 5:38And it can create problems.
- 5:41The other thing that we had is usually, as Ty pointed out, we're, you can serve them
- 5:45because you just can't deal with mainly the people or the board of directors that
- 5:49are there anymore, just aren't taking care of it and putting the fund at risk.
- 5:52The 1st thing you clean all of that out, and then, when you come in and
- 5:55conservatorship, the 1st thing we would, we did an action was actually
- 5:59on there was we reviewed the abilities of all of the senior managers.
- 6:05To make sure that they were the people we needed to resolve everything.
- 6:09And there's usually a large number of terminations that would take place
- 6:12because we need to gain efficiency.
- 6:14Also, I think,
- 6:16Treichel: yeah, I think even back in the day, they'd say those were part of
- 6:20the those who were part of the problem will not be part of the solution.
- 6:22So it comes in the board is removed.
- 6:25The regional director represents the.
- 6:29Members serves as the board and then also as the regulators.
- 6:35If if there was someone who was in a loan program that went haywire and should
- 6:41have known better, those folks will go find their happiness elsewhere under
- 6:45the conservatorship and then oftentimes NCWA will bring in a team like you
- 6:49mentioned and I believe that I know the one you worked on, it was one of
- 6:53those success stories where the region was able to turn it back to the members
- 6:56and It's out there thriving right now.
- 6:58And another one of yours, Steve, I think they, they named
- 7:00a boardroom after you, right?
- 7:02The Steve Farr boardroom.
- 7:04Farrar: Yeah, because we're going to build a cheap building.
- 7:08You need a new building.
- 7:09It's going to be we're going to do it.
- 7:11Yeah, those are nice when you can go back and Todd and I have that thing is,
- 7:16you go back and you go back and look at those conservatorships and check their
- 7:20numbers every now and then and say.
- 7:21Okay.
- 7:21It would be really neat to go visit them again someday, but
- 7:24We probably don't, but yeah.
- 7:26The conservatorship I is is, we always refer to this kinda the most extreme
- 7:30option NCA takes 'cause it, has to be approved by the NCA board and then
- 7:34you gotta go back to the NA board when you have the success and you're
- 7:38returning it to the credit union.
- 7:40And NCA board would also be involved if they turn into a liquidation and
- 7:45stuff because the regional director.
- 7:48Is appointed by the board nso, a board is in charge of it, and then they appoint
- 7:52regional director that is basically, but the conservator, I'm trying to remember
- 7:55exactly what that document agent for.
- 7:57The conservator, the agent for the conservator.
- 7:59And then letters are written to, everybody who's working in that case.
- 8:03That's, you're subagent of the conservator.
- 8:05So it's it, lots of legal paperwork is completed.
- 8:09Treichel: Lots of legal paperwork.
- 8:11And as you're talking through that I'm getting a smile on my
- 8:13face cause I'm thinking about, that, so there is no board, right.
- 8:16And then you could have an advisory board, which might be some, which will be
- 8:20some NCA staff and that there was this.
- 8:23There was this pendulum that swung towards we need to have more robust documents
- 8:29of what the conservator is doing and there'd be formal board meetings and
- 8:33then there were lawsuits and then the pendulum swung as we don't need as robust
- 8:37board documents for conservatorships.
- 8:40And then I contrast that this is a total non sequitur kind of sorta, but then I
- 8:45contrast that with where NCOA is going on corporate governance right now, as
- 8:49far as you must document everything.
- 8:52Or that's how some examiners are interpreting it.
- 8:55And and as we've told our clients, there's some things you
- 8:58want to put in board minutes.
- 8:59There's some things you don't.
- 9:00NCWA wants to understand that, that you're involved and that the board is doing what
- 9:04it needs to do, but there's a balance.
- 9:06And you, as a conservator, You would be running the credit union and you
- 9:11would start to understand some of those balance issues more than you would have
- 9:14just being a government NCOA worker, which goes back to Utah and saying
- 9:19it'd be great if they did more so people could learn from the process.
- 9:23Miller: I always thought that balance was one of the hardest things to
- 9:26strike because most of the time when you're Involved in a conservatorship,
- 9:32the credit is not going to survive.
- 9:33There, there are ones that do survive and we've all mentioned that those
- 9:37are high points in our career when we get to return a credit to the members.
- 9:41Most of the time they don't, but the agent for the conservators got a tough road.
- 9:46A hulk is.
- 9:47They're there as the members representatives, and sometimes doing
- 9:51things that are best for the members is not what's best for the insurance fund.
- 9:56And they're also a regional director in most cases, and they're there to do
- 9:59what's best for the insurance fund, too, and sometimes there's a conflict between
- 10:03those two things that is difficult to navigate, which is why sometimes you
- 10:08want less documentation about things.
- 10:10But for the most part, fixing troubled credit unions, whether they're
- 10:15in conservatorship or not, or the conservatorships that we have resolved,
- 10:19they almost always going back to doing what's in the best interest of the member.
- 10:23That's generally the way you fix the credit union is get it refocused on
- 10:28what is in the best interest of the members here and you go through that
- 10:32process and generally that's what you go through to actually fix a credit
- 10:37union and return it to its members.
- 10:39And I think even for credit unions that just get an unpublished LUA or
- 10:44even a door, if they keep that in mind that what's in the best interest of
- 10:47our members, it's going to lead them down to the right path, not just.
- 10:51When you're in a conservatorship, it just seems to be the heart of a lot
- 10:55of present problem resolution and pretty gains is what is really in
- 10:59the best interest of the membership.
- 11:01Treichel: And you know what?
- 11:02That's my alarm that says it's time for a client call, guys.
- 11:06Thanks so much for sharing your wisdom on this topic.
- 11:09I know it gets my blood flowing talking about conservatorships
- 11:12because it brings back good memories, bad memories, and scar tissue.
- 11:16Thanks for your time guys.
- 11:18Have a good day.
- 11:19You too.
- 11:19And those who are listening, I want to thank you for listening.
- 11:22I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 11:24This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 11:33Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 11:37your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 11:41of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 11:46If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 11:49out our services at marktreichel.
- 11:51com.