Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Kentucky's Economy, Jobs and Taxes
Transcript
- 0:02BAILEY
- 0:03[♪♪]
- 0:06[♪♪]
- 0:09GOOD EVENING.
- 0:11WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:12I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:13THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: KENTUCKY’S
- 0:17ECONOMY, JOBS, AND TAXES.
- 0:22SO, HOW ARE WE DOING, OVERALL?
- 0:23THERE’S GOOD NEWS AND BAD NEWS.
- 0:24THE STATE HAS A BUDGET SURPLUS
- 0:26OF ABOUT THREE-POINT-SEVEN
- 0:27BILLION DOLLARS.
- 0:29THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS CUT THE
- 0:31INCOME TAX TWICE, BUT THE STATE
- 0:32DIDN’T MEET CERTAIN FINANCIAL
- 0:35CONDITIONS THAT WOULD HAVE
- 0:36ALLOWED FOR A THIRD CUT IN
- 0:3820-25.
- 0:39IT’S BECOME A TALKING POINT IN
- 0:41THE GOVERNOR’S RACE. AND WHILE
- 0:42UNEMPLOYMENT IS AT FOUR PERCENT,
- 0:44KENTUCKY’S WORKFORCE
- 0:45PARTICIPATION RATE IS WELL BELOW
- 0:47THE NATIONAL AVERAGE.
- 0:49TO DISCUSS ALL THIS, AND MORE,
- 0:51WE’RE JOINED, IN OUR LEXINGTON
- 0:53STUDIO, BY: STATE SENATOR
- 0:55CHRISTIAN MCDANIEL, A RYLAND
- 0:56HEIGHTS REPUBLICAN AND CHAIR OF
- 0:58THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS AND
- 0:59REVENUE COMMITTEE; STATE SENATOR
- 1:01ROBIN WEBB, A GRAYSON DEMOCRAT
- 1:03AND MEMBER OF THE SENATE
- 1:04APPROPRIATIONS AND REVENUE
- 1:06COMMITTEE; CHARLES AULL,
- 1:08EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
- 1:09KENTUCKY CHAMBER CENTER FOR
- 1:11POLICY AND RESEARCH; AND JASON
- 1:12BAILEY, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
- 1:14THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR ECONOMIC
- 1:15POLICY.
- 1:20SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:21COMMENTS BY TWITTER AT K-Y
- 1:23TONIGHT K-E-T.
- 1:27SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 1:28K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 1:29OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 1:32O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 1:34OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:37WELCOME TO ALL OF OUR GUESTS.
- 1:43GOOD TO HAVE YOU BACK ON THIS
- 1:45FULL WEEK AFTER FALL HAS
- 1:47ARRIVED.
- 1:48LET'S TALK ABOUT WHERE WE ARE
- 1:50FISCALLY.
- 1:50AND I WANT TO DO AN OVERALL
- 1:53QUESTION ABOUT HOW YOU ASSESS
- 1:56KENTUCKY'S ECONOMY RIGHT NOW,
- 1:57HOW STRONG IS IT?
- 1:58>> WE'RE SEEING SIGNS OF GROWTH.
- 2:01WE LOOK AT A COUPLE DIFFERENT
- 2:04GOVERNMENT SURVEY METRICS THAT
- 2:05COME OUT AND GIVE US A GOOD
- 2:08SENSE WHERE KENTUCKY'S ECONOMY
- 2:09STANDS COMPARED TO THE NATIONAL
- 2:10ECONOMY.
- 2:11IN TERMS OF GROWTH WE'RE SEEING
- 2:14GOOD PROGRESS IN THAT AREA.
- 2:15THAT IS A GOOD SIGN THAT
- 2:17EMPLOYERS ARE STILL INVESTING
- 2:19AND CREATING JOBS.
- 2:20UNEMPLOYMENT IS STILL LOW.
- 2:234% COMPARATIVELY IS STILL A VERY
- 2:26LOW UNEMPLOYMENT RATE FOR
- 2:28KENTUCKY.
- 2:29ONE METRIC WE'RE WATCHING
- 2:30CLOSELY IS THE NUMBER OF OPEN
- 2:32JOBS.
- 2:32THAT IS A METRIC THAT HAS BEEN
- 2:35RUNNING VERY HIGH THROUGHOUT THE
- 2:36COURSE OF THE PANDEMIC AT TIMES
- 2:38SEEING TWO OPEN JOBS FOR EVERY
- 2:42UNEMPLOYED WORKER.
- 2:43THAT'S BEEN SLOWLY NARROWING
- 2:44OVER TIME AND THAT IS SOMETHING
- 2:46WE HAVE EBEEN EXPECTING TO SEE.
- 2:47IF WE GO BACK SEVERAL MONTHS AGO
- 2:50YOU WOULD SEE 2 TO 1.9 OPEN
- 2:53JOBS.
- 2:54MOST RECENT DATA THAT IS COMING
- 2:56CLOSER TO 1.4.
- 2:57THE WAY I LIKE TO DESCRIBE
- 2:59KENTUCKY'S ECONOMY IS
- 3:01ESSENTIALLY IT'S SHOWING SIGNS
- 3:03OF NORMALIZATION.
- 3:04WHAT WE'VE SEEN OVER THE PAST
- 3:05COUPLE OF YEARS THAT IS NOT A
- 3:08TYPICAL WAY FOR AN ECONOMY TO
- 3:10BEHAVE THAT MUCH GROWTH IS
- 3:11DIFFICULT TO SUSTAIN.
- 3:12THE ECONOMY IS STARTING TO LOOK
- 3:14MORE SIMILAR TO WHAT WE SAW IN
- 3:162019.
- 3:17WITH THAT BEING SAID THERE'S
- 3:18STILL A LOT OF VOLATILITY.
- 3:20THERE'S STILL A LOT OF
- 3:23IRREGULARITIES.
- 3:24INFLATION WOULD BE THE MOST
- 3:26PRIME EXAMPLE OF THAT.
- 3:27WE'RE DEALING WITH QUITE A BIT
- 3:28OF INFLATION.
- 3:29SO I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS WE
- 3:31ARE GOING TO BE WATCHING FOR
- 3:33OVER THE NEXT SEVERAL MONTHS
- 3:35DOES THE FEDERAL RESERVE
- 3:37CONTINUE TO INCREASE INTEREST
- 3:38RATES AND MIGHT WE SEE THAT HAVE
- 3:40AN IMPACT ON KENTUCKY'S
- 3:42UNEMPLOYMENT RATE.
- 3:44MIGHT THAT RANCH UP A LITTLE
- 3:46BIT.
- 3:46>> THAT IS WHAT THE FEDS WANT?
- 3:50>> WHAT THE FED IS TRYING TO
- 3:52ACCOMPLISH MAINTAIN LOW
- 3:54UNEMPLOYMENT AND AT THE SAME
- 3:55TIME REDUCING INFLATION.
- 3:57WHAT TYPICALLY HAPPENS, HOWEVER
- 3:58IS THAT AS YOU INCREASE INTEREST
- 4:00RATES IN THE EFFORT TO FIGHT
- 4:02INFLATION THAT TRENDS TO TRIGGER
- 4:03HIGHER RATES OF URN EMPLOYMENT.
- 4:05IT'S ENTIRELY POSSIBLE WE CAN
- 4:08GET TO A POINT TO ACHIEVE THE
- 4:10SOFT LANDING AT JEROME POWELL IS
- 4:13TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH THERE ARE
- 4:14GOOD SIGNS WE ARE ON THE PATH TO
- 4:16DO THAT.
- 4:17IN KENTUCKY WE HAVE A STRONG
- 4:19ECONOMY AND UNFILLED JOBS AND
- 4:21STILL SEEING PAYROLL GROWTH.
- 4:24THOSE ARE GOOD INDICATORS WE
- 4:25COULD BE ON THE PATH TO THAT
- 4:27TYPE OF SOFT LANDING AND
- 4:30ACCOMPLISHING OUR GOAL OF
- 4:31LOWERING INFLATION.
- 4:33>> Renee: Mr. BAILEY, WHO IS
- 4:35THE ECONOMY WORKING BEST FOR AND
- 4:36WHO IS BEING LEFT BEHIND?
- 4:38>> WELL, I THINK THAT ONE THING
- 4:40ABOUT THE ECONOMY WHERE WE ARE
- 4:41NOW IS ALL THE PANDEMIC STIMULUS
- 4:43THAT PASSED THAT SORT OF PULLED
- 4:45US OUT WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN A
- 4:47DEPRESSION DID WORK TO STIMULATE
- 4:51FAST ECONOMIC GROWTH AND DRIVE
- 4:52THE UNEMPLOYMENT DOWN AND GIVE
- 4:56WORKERS BARGAINING POWER THEY
- 4:57HAVE NOT HAD IN DECADES.
- 4:58AND WE'RE SEEING THAT IN WAGE
- 5:02GROWTH AND INFLATION CAUSED BY
- 5:03THE SUPPLY CHAIN ISSUES DURING
- 5:04THE PANDEMIC.
- 5:05THAT OFFSET.
- 5:07BUT INFLATION IS COMING DOWN AS
- 5:09THOSE ISSUES WORK THEMSELVES OUT
- 5:11AND WORKERS HAVE FEELING MORE
- 5:13CONFIDENT THE FULL EMPLOYMENT
- 5:14ECONOMY THAT WE WANT TO SEE IS
- 5:17COMING TO FRUITION TO SOME
- 5:19DEGREE AND YOU ARE SEEING THAT
- 5:20IN THE TWO LARGEST EMPLOYERS IN
- 5:23KENTUCKY.
- 5:23U.P.S. AND FORD.
- 5:24THE WORKERS IN BOTH CASES THE
- 5:26UNIONS HAVE BARGAINED HARD IN
- 5:27THE CASE OF THE TEAMSTERS AND
- 5:30U.P.S. THEY GOT A GOOD CONTRACT.
- 5:32AND WE'LL SEE TRUCK DRIVERS FOR
- 5:34U.P.S. AND PACKAGE HANDLERS GET
- 5:36A SIGNIFICANT WAGE INCREASE AND
- 5:38THE AUTO WORKERS ARE ON STRIKE
- 5:40RIGHT NOW AND SEEM TO HAVE 75%
- 5:41OF AMERICANS SUPPORTING THEM IN
- 5:43THEIR BID FOR HIGHER WAGES
- 5:45BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE ARE IN
- 5:47THAT SAME SITUATION.
- 5:48THEY'VE SEEN THAT HAPPEN IN
- 5:50THEIR JOBS OVER THE PAST FEW
- 5:52DECADES WHERE WAGES HAVE NOT
- 5:53KEPT UP WITH GROWTH.
- 5:54IN THE ECONOMY.
- 5:55THEY HAVE NOT KEPT UP WITH
- 5:56INFLATION.
- 5:58THEY SEEING THEIR PENSION
- 6:00BENEFITS AND HEALTH BENEFITS
- 6:02ERODE.
- 6:02AND THEY ARE FRUSTRATED YOU ARE
- 6:04SEEING A TURN IN PUBLIC OPINION.
- 6:05WE HAVE A GOOD START SO IN TERMS
- 6:08OF THAT BUT WE HAVE A LOT OF
- 6:10GROUND TO MAKEUP AND THE CONCERN
- 6:10IS THAT THE FEDERAL RESERVE WILL
- 6:13ACT TOO QUICKLY IN RAISING
- 6:14INTEREST RATES AND WILL
- 6:16INCREASING THE COST OF BORROWING
- 6:17AND POTENTIALLY PUSH US INTO
- 6:20SLOWER GROWTH AND GET OFF THAT
- 6:23FULL EMPLOYMENT PATH THAT WOULD
- 6:24BE A BAD TRACK WHEN WE ARE JUST
- 6:26NOW STARTING TO SEE THE
- 6:28BENEFITS.
- 6:29>> Renee: LET ME ASK THE
- 6:31LAWMAKERS, CHAIRMAN McDANIEL
- 6:32HOW DO YOU SIZE UP KENTUCKY'S
- 6:35ECONOMY AND JOB GROWTH AND WE
- 6:37HAVE PRIVATE INVESTMENT AND GOOD
- 6:39THINGS ARE HAPPENING ARE YOU
- 6:41SATISFIED WHERE WE ARE
- 6:42ECONOMICALLY?
- 6:43>> I DO NOT THINK YOU CAN BE
- 6:48SATISFIED WITH WHERE WE ARE AND
- 6:50I HAVE TO DISAGREE WITH JASON
- 6:53THE PRIMARY DRIVER OF INFLATION
- 6:55WAS TOO MUCH FEDERAL STIMULUS
- 6:56WAS PUMPED IN AND IF YOU LOOK AT
- 6:59THE NATION'S DEBT IT'S EXPLODED
- 7:01OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS.
- 7:02AND OVER THE COURSE OF THIS
- 7:05CENTURY, AS A WHOLE AND
- 7:06SOMETHING WE HAVE TO LOOK AT.
- 7:07YOU CANNOT CONTINUE TO CREATE
- 7:09NEW MONEY WITHOUT AN ABILITY TO
- 7:10PAY FOR THE DEBT WITHOUT LEAVING
- 7:13YOURSELF LONG-TERM PROBLEMS.
- 7:14HERE IN KENTUCKY CERTAINLY THERE
- 7:16ARE DEFINITELY GOOD SIGNS THAT
- 7:19WE HAVE BEGUN TO LIKE.
- 7:20BUT WE HAVE A TALE OF TWO
- 7:22ECONOMIES IN THIS COMMONWEALTH.
- 7:24WE STILL CONTINUE TO SEE VERY
- 7:27TROUBLING DIFFICULTIES OVER IN
- 7:29APPALACHIA THEY ARE NOT ENJOYING
- 7:30A LOT OF THE SAME BENEFITS THE
- 7:32BALANCE OF KENTUCKY HAS SEEN.
- 7:34AND I THINK THAT IS WHY YOU SAW
- 7:37FOCUS AND WILL CONTINUE TO SEE
- 7:38FOCUS IN TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
- 7:40WHAT IT IS THAT WE CAN DO
- 7:42REGIONALLY TO HELP THOSE FOLKS
- 7:43OVER THERE ENJOY THE SAME LEVEL
- 7:45OF PROSPERITY AND THE SAME RISE
- 7:47THAT THE BALANCE OF KENTUCKY HAS
- 7:48SEEN.
- 7:49>> Renee: YOU KNOW THAT AREA
- 7:50VERY WELL.
- 7:51AND THEY ARE NOT EXPERIENCING
- 7:53THE SAME TYPE OF GROWTH THAT THE
- 7:56GOLDEN TRIANGLE IS.
- 7:57WHAT DO YOU THINK?
- 7:58>> NO WE'RE NOT.
- 8:00I WAS IN PIKEVILLE SATURDAY AND
- 8:02TO THE NORTHEAST WHERE I
- 8:05REPRESENT THE WHOLE INDUSTRY
- 8:06AMONG OTHER THINGS AND ALL THE
- 8:09INCIDENTALS THAT COME WITH THAT
- 8:11WITH THE SUPPLY CHAIN ISSUES AND
- 8:13SOME WORKFORCE ISSUES THAT WE
- 8:17HAVE INHERENTLY.
- 8:20ADDICTION AND OTHER WORKFORCE
- 8:21ISSUES WE HAVE.
- 8:22THERE ARE POCKETS THAT ARE
- 8:24SUFFERING WITH ALL THE GOOD
- 8:25THINGS THAT ARE GOING ON.
- 8:28SO AND I APPRECIATE MY
- 8:32COLLEAGUES STEPPING UP DURING
- 8:32THE FLOOD AND LOOKING FOR
- 8:34ALTERNATIVES FOR TRANSITIONING
- 8:36OUT OF INDUSTRIES.
- 8:38THAT ARE NO LONGER WITH US OR ON
- 8:40LIFE SUPPORT.
- 8:42SO WE HOSTED THE APPALACHIAN
- 8:44REGIONAL COMMISSION IN ASHLAND
- 8:46LAST WEEK AND WE HAD 13 STATES
- 8:48THERE, FEDERAL OFFICIALS, STATE
- 8:50OFFICIALS AND THE COMMUNITY
- 8:52THERE'S A LOT OF HOPE IN OUR
- 8:55COMMUNITIES AND THEY HAVE
- 8:56STEPPED UP AND THEY ARE MAKING
- 8:58DOING THE BEST THEY CAN DO.
- 9:00WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TOURISM,
- 9:01TALKED ABOUT TRAILS, TALKED
- 9:03ABOUT THINGS THAT WE DO HAVE.
- 9:05AND WE'VE GOT THINGS HAPPENING
- 9:07THERE.
- 9:07WE'RE GETTING QUARTERHORSE TRACK
- 9:10IN ASHLAND.
- 9:11THE PEOPLE ARE HUNGRY FOR
- 9:13GROWTH.
- 9:15AND GET THEIR SHARE OF THE PIE
- 9:17BACK AND WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE
- 9:19TO TRY TO DO THAT.
- 9:21AND LOOK WE ARE INNOVATIVE
- 9:22SOLUTIONS THE POWER BILLS ARE A
- 9:24BIG THING FOR US.
- 9:25AND TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT
- 9:26PEOPLE CAN AFFORD TO KEEP THEIR
- 9:28LIGHTS AND HEAT ON.
- 9:30THAT'S WHERE MY PEOPLE ARE RIGHT
- 9:31NOW.
- 9:32>> Renee: WELL, LET'S TALK ABOUT
- 9:33AN ITEM IN THE NEWS AND THAT IS
- 9:35THE INCOME TAX BECAUSE WE DID
- 9:37LEARN THIS MONTH WE DID NOT MEET
- 9:39ONE OF THE CONDITIONS TO IGNITE
- 9:41THAT TRIGGER IF YOU WILL FOR THE
- 9:43INCOME TAX TO BE LOWERED ANOTHER
- 9:46HALF PERCENT IN 2025.
- 9:48THE BIG QUESTION IS: WILL YOU
- 9:50SUSPEND YOUR OWN RULES TO ALLOW
- 9:53FOR THAT TAX CUT TO HAPPEN
- 9:56ANYWAY DESPITE THE FACT THAT
- 9:57BOTH CONDITIONS THE GENERAL
- 9:59ASSEMBLY SET FORTH WERE NOT MET?
- 10:01>> I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO
- 10:03NOTE, RENEE, BY THE END OF 2024
- 10:08THIS TAX THESE TAX CHANGES WE'VE
- 10:09PUT INTO PLACE WILL SAVE WORKING
- 10:12KENTUCKY FAMILIES $1.8 BILLION.
- 10:14DOLLARS GOING DIRECTLY INTO
- 10:17KENTUCKIANS POCKETS THAT THEY
- 10:18CAN CHOOSE TO SPEND HOW THEY SEE
- 10:20FIT.
- 10:20THE MEASURES WE PUT INTO PLACE
- 10:22TO BE ABLE TO EFFECTUATE THIS
- 10:25POLICY, THE BALANCE IN THE RAINY
- 10:27DAY FUND, THE REQUIREMENT OF TWO
- 10:29TIMES THE AMOUNT OF ACCESS
- 10:32VERSUS THE AMOUNT OF THE CUT.
- 10:34THOSE WERE PUT IN THERE TO AVOID
- 10:36SOME OF THE DISASTROUS RESULTS
- 10:38THAT WE SAW IN KANSAS AND THIS
- 10:41PROVED THAT WHEN THE
- 10:42COMMONWEALTH HAD TO TAKE
- 10:43PARTICULAR ACTIONS I MEAN AS
- 10:45SENATOR WEBB REFERENCED, THE
- 10:47FLOODS THE TORNADOES, THE
- 10:49HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
- 10:50WE NEEDED TO PUMP IN THERE THOSE
- 10:52DO THINGS TO GOVERNMENT SPENDING
- 10:53THAT CAUSE REACTIONS.
- 10:55IN THIS CASE THEY DID.
- 10:56AND THE MECHANISM FUNCTION AS IT
- 10:59WAS DESIGNED TO DO TO PUMP THE
- 11:01BRAKES ON THIS AND MAKE SURE
- 11:02WE'RE IN THE APPROPRIATE PLACE.
- 11:04I THINK THAT IT REALLY HAS BEEN
- 11:07TELLING THAT LIKE I SAY IT DID
- 11:09WORK AS INTENDED AND I CERTAINLY
- 11:11DON'T THINK I WOULD SEE US GOING
- 11:13BACK ON THE MEASURES THAT WE PUT
- 11:15INTO PLACE WHEN WE BEGAN THIS
- 11:16PROCESS.
- 11:17>> Renee: YOU ARE GOING TO STICK
- 11:18TO THAT STATUTORY LANGUAGE THAT
- 11:20REQUIRES THOSE CONDITIONS TO BE
- 11:21MET AND NOT JUST PROCEED FORWARD
- 11:24AND MAYBE INSTITUTE OTHER CUTS
- 11:26ELSEWHERE TO MAKEUP FOR THAT?
- 11:27>> THAT IS WHAT I ANTICIPATE.
- 11:31>> Renee: SENATOR WEBB?
- 11:31>> THAT WORKS FOR ME.
- 11:33I THINK THOSE MECHANISMS ARE THE
- 11:35SAFETY NET THAT'S IMPORTANT.
- 11:36I'VE GOT A LITTLE BIT I LIKE A
- 11:39MORE DIVERSE TAX PORTFOLIO.
- 11:41THE SITES THAT HAVE DONE AWAY
- 11:43WITH THE INCOME TAX RELY ON
- 11:46NATURAL RESOURCES AND SALES AND
- 11:47PROPERTY TAX.
- 11:48IF YOU ARE NOT PAYING ONE YOU'RE
- 11:50PAYING THE OTHER AND SOMETIMES
- 11:52THE LOWER 30% OF THE POPULATION
- 11:56DOESN'T FARE WELL BECAUSE SALES
- 11:57TAXES ARE REGRESSIVE AND IT'S
- 11:59HARDER ON THOSE FOLKS.
- 12:02I SPEND A LOT OF TIME IN
- 12:03TENNESSEE I'VE GOT HORSES THERE
- 12:04AND WITH THE GROWTH THEY ARE
- 12:07EXPERIENCING, THAT DEMOGRAPHIC
- 12:08IS STRUGGLING.
- 12:09THAT'S MY FEAR IN TOTAL
- 12:13ELIMINATION OUR TAX SYSTEM A
- 12:16LITTLE BIT ARCHAIC AND NEEDS
- 12:18WORK BUT YOU HAVE TO ADAPT.
- 12:20SO I'M GLAD TO HEAR THAT.
- 12:21I THINK IT WILL BODE WELL FOR
- 12:24THE COMMONWEALTH AS WE MOVE
- 12:26FORWARD ON TAX POLICY.
- 12:27>> I WANT TO ASK YOU ABOUT THAT
- 12:29BECAUSE THE KENTUCKY CHAMBER
- 12:31CHAMPIONED THE HOUSE BILL 8 THAT
- 12:34BECAME HOUSE BILL 1 AND THIS IS
- 12:35SOMETHING YOU ALL HAVE BEEN
- 12:38CHAMPIONING TO ELIMINATE THE
- 12:41INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX AND THE
- 12:43CHAMBER IS AFOR ABIDING BY THE
- 12:45CONDITIONS SET FORTH AND HAVING
- 12:46IT TAKE A PAUSE?
- 12:47>> I THINK CHAIRMAN McDANIEL'S
- 12:50STATEMENT WAS WELL PUT.
- 12:51THIS IS HOW THE SYSTEM IS
- 12:53SUPPOSED TO WORK.
- 12:54IT WAS DESIGNED SPECIFICALLY TO
- 12:55DO THIS.
- 12:56I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT ANYBODY
- 12:58WATCHING THIS, UNDERSTANDS THAT
- 12:59WHAT THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY IS
- 13:01TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH IS VERY
- 13:03DIFFICULT.
- 13:03VERY, VERY DIFFICULT ECONOMIC
- 13:05PUBLIC POLICY THEY'VE SET OUT TO
- 13:07DO.
- 13:07WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT STATES THAT
- 13:09HAVE ELIMINATED INDIVIDUAL
- 13:12INCOME TAXES ONE STATE HAS DONE
- 13:13THAT WHICH IS ALASKA.
- 13:15AND ALASKA WAS ABLE TO DO IT DUE
- 13:17TO THE GOOD FORTUNE OF
- 13:19DISCOVERING A TON OF OIL.
- 13:21OTHER STATES THAT DON'T HAVE THE
- 13:23INCOME TAXES THEY NEVER HAD ONE
- 13:26IN THE FIRST PLACE LIKE
- 13:28TENNESSEE, TEXAS AND FLORIDA
- 13:29THEY DID NOT DO THAT.
- 13:30WE ARE GOING DOWN A PATH THAT IS
- 13:32DIFFICULT AND I APPLAUD CHAIRMAN
- 13:36McDANIELS AND COLLEAGUES IN
- 13:38THE HOUSE THEY ARE TRYING TO DO
- 13:40SOMETHING THAT IS HARD BUT IT'S
- 13:41THE RIGHT THING TO DO IT IS A
- 13:43GOOD THING FOR OUR STATE TO
- 13:45GRADUALLY REDUCE OUR RELIANCE ON
- 13:47INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAXES.
- 13:48AND THERE ARE REASONS FOR THAT.
- 13:50OVERALL BUSINESS INVESTMENT WILL
- 13:52FOLLOW THOSE TYPES OF STATES
- 13:54THAT ARE PURSUING REDUCTIONS TO
- 13:56INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAXES.
- 13:57>> Renee: AND WE'VE SEEN THAT
- 13:58BEAR OUT EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE THAT
- 14:01SUGGESTS THAT?
- 14:02>> THERE'S STRONG RESEARCH TO
- 14:04ILLUSTRATE THAT BUSINESS
- 14:07INVESTMENT WILL FOLLOW TAX
- 14:09ENVIRONMENTS I THINK IT IS NOT A
- 14:11SURPRISE WE'RE SEEING INVESTMENT
- 14:13IN TENNESSEE AND TEXAS AND
- 14:15FLORIDA.
- 14:15THERE IS A WHOLE NUMBER OF
- 14:17DIFFERENT REASONS AS TO WHY
- 14:19THAT'S HAPPENING INCLUDING
- 14:20ISSUES WITH FEDERAL TAX POLICY
- 14:22LIKE THE CAP ON THE STATE AND
- 14:24LOCAL TAX DEDUCTION THAT HAS
- 14:27BEEN AN INCENTIVE FOR BUSINESSES
- 14:28AND INDIVIDUALS TO LEAVE THE
- 14:30HIGHER TAX ENVIRONMENTS.
- 14:31THE KEY THING, THOUGH AS WE HEAD
- 14:33DOWN THIS PATH IS THAT WE DO
- 14:35THIS RESPONSIBLY AND CAREFULLY.
- 14:36AND THAT IS AT THE HEART OF
- 14:38HOUSE BILL 8.
- 14:39THERE'S OFTENTIMES COMPARISONS
- 14:42BETWEEN WHAT KENTUCKY IS DOING
- 14:43AND KANSAS, NOTHING COULD BE
- 14:45FURTHER FROM THE TRUTH.
- 14:46WHAT KANSAS DID IS A RIP-OFF A
- 14:49BAND-AID AND KEB KEN IS DOING
- 14:51THE OPPOSITE OF THAT.
- 14:52WE ARE DOING THIS CAREFULLY,
- 14:54DILIGENTLY AND IN A WAY THAT
- 14:56WILL INSURE THAT WE ARE ABLE TO
- 14:57CONTINUE INVESTING IN KEY
- 14:59SERVICES WHILE SLOWING REDUCING
- 15:01THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX RATE.
- 15:04>> Renee: I DO WANT TO ASK YOU
- 15:05BECAUSE YOU SAID ON KENTUCKY
- 15:08EDITION THAT IT WAS ALWAYS
- 15:10ANTICIPATED THIS TYPE OF PLAN
- 15:11COULD TAKE 10, 20 YEARS.
- 15:13WOULD YOU SHARE YOUR ANALYSIS
- 15:15ABOUT THAT?
- 15:15>> YEAH.
- 15:16THE WAY THAT HOUSE BILL 8 IS
- 15:18SETUP, IS THAT IT IS SETUP TO
- 15:22REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN HALF
- 15:25PERCENTAGE POINT INCREMENTS.
- 15:26WE STARTED AT 5%.
- 15:29PRESUMABLY WE HIT THE METRICS
- 15:32EVERY TIME, BEST CASE SCENARIO
- 15:33WE WILL END UP IN 10 YEARS WE'LL
- 15:36SEE THAT PHASE DOWN.
- 15:37THE REALITY IS THERE'S GOING TO
- 15:38BE TIMES WHERE WE MISS THE
- 15:40TRIGGERS.
- 15:40AND WHAT THAT MEANS IS AS A
- 15:42STATE WE NEED TO CONTINUE
- 15:43WORKING HARD TO MAKE SURE WE ARE
- 15:45ACHIEVING THE GROWTH WE ARE
- 15:46WANTING TO ACHIEVE.
- 15:47AND SPENDING IN WAYS THAT ARE
- 15:51VERY STRATEGIC AND WITH THE
- 15:54INTENT OF OBTAINING A STRONG ROI
- 15:56AND THAT IS THE WAY WE CAN
- 15:58CONTINUE MOVING FORWARD AND
- 15:59HITTING THE BENCHMARKS.
- 16:01BUT THIS IS SOMETHING FOLKS HAVE
- 16:02TO ACCEPT WILL TAKE TIME AND IT
- 16:04WILL REQUIRE PATIENCE.
- 16:05IN THE MEANTIME ILY WE'LL SEE
- 16:08THE BENEFITS OF THE PATH.
- 16:11>> Renee: Mr. BAILEY YOU'VE
- 16:12WRITTEN THIS IS 41% OF STATE
- 16:15REVENUES THAT WE COULD BE LOSING
- 16:16HERE?
- 16:17>> RIGHT.
- 16:18THE MAIN DIFFERENCE BETWEEN US
- 16:19AND KANSAS, KANSAS DID IT WHEN
- 16:22THE ECONOMY WAS NOT GOOD.
- 16:23IN 2013 WE WERE RECOVERING FROM
- 16:24THE GREAT RECESSION.
- 16:26UNEMPLOYMENT WAS STILL HIGH.
- 16:27NOW WE'RE IN THIS REALLY UNIQUE
- 16:29PERIOD WHERE WE HAVE HAD THIS
- 16:32STIMULUS FUNDS CREATING A LOW
- 16:34UNEMPLOYMENT RATE.
- 16:35STUDENTS HAVE NOT BEEN MAKING
- 16:38LOAN PAYMENTS.
- 16:40THESE THINGS PUSHED UPSTATE
- 16:42REVENUES AND RESULTED IN A
- 16:44SURPLUSES THAT ARE USED TO MAKE
- 16:46PERMANENT TAX CUTS THERE'S NO
- 16:48SACRIFICE NO BUDGET CUTS HAVING
- 16:50TO BE MADE BUT RECESSIONS COME.
- 16:53GOOD TIMES DON'T LAST FOREVER.
- 16:55AND WE WILL BE IN THAT RECESSION
- 16:57WITH OUR LARGEST REVENUE SOURCE
- 16:5941% OF OUR REVENUE COLLECTED
- 17:03DIMINISHED.
- 17:03AND THERE'S JUST NO WAY TO
- 17:05OFFSET.
- 17:06THE FOLKS WHO WANT TO MOVE DOWN
- 17:07THE PATH OF A ZERO INCOME TAX
- 17:11PRESENTED NO OPTION TO REPLACE
- 17:13HALF OF OUR STATE BUDGET AND
- 17:15ONLY ONE STATE HAS DONE THAT.
- 17:16ONE STATE HAS DONE THIS, ALASKA
- 17:19AND THEY ONLY DID IT WHEN THEY
- 17:20STRUCK OIL.
- 17:21IT'S A DANGEROUS PATH TO GO ON.
- 17:23WE WILL SEE THE HARMS OF IT WHEN
- 17:25THE ECONOMY TURNS AROUND.
- 17:26AND THE RESULT IS ONE OF TWO
- 17:29THINGS: WE HAVE A MUCH HIGHER
- 17:30SALES TAX.
- 17:31WE'D HAVE TO HAVE A SALES TAX OF
- 17:33THIRTEEN% TO REPLACE OUR INCOME
- 17:35TAX.
- 17:36THE HIGHEST SALES TAX IN THE
- 17:38COUNTRY IS SEVEN AND A QUARTER.
- 17:40WE ARE NOT GOING TO DO THAT.
- 17:42WE HAVE TO APPLY SALES TAX TO
- 17:45GROCERIES AND PRESCRIPTION DRUGS
- 17:47THAT WILL HURT FAMILIES VERY
- 17:48HARD AND THE WEALTHY ARE THE
- 17:50ONES THAT BENEFIT.
- 17:52THE MILLIONAIRES WILL GET A
- 17:55$55,000 ANNUAL TAX CUT IF YOU
- 17:57ELIMINATE THE INCOME TAX OF TAX.
- 17:59TWO-THIRDS OF THE MONEY GOES TO
- 18:00THE TOP 20% OF PEOPLE.
- 18:03THERE WOULD BE A SHIFT IN TERMS
- 18:04OF WHO PAYS AND THOSE WHO
- 18:06STRUGGLE THE MOST WOULD BE THE
- 18:08ONES THAT WOULD BE HARDEST HIT.
- 18:11EITHER WE'VE HAVE TO HAVE THE
- 18:12HUGE TAX INCREASES OR GIVE UP
- 18:15MAJOR FUNCTIONS OF GOVERNMENT
- 18:16LIKE PUBLIC SCHOOLS, HIGHER
- 18:18EDUCATION, THE MEDICAID PROGRAM
- 18:19AND THAT IS WHAT KEEPS OPEN OUR
- 18:21HOSPITALS AND OUR DOCTOR'S
- 18:24OFFICES THAT EVERY COMMUNITY
- 18:25RELIES ON.
- 18:26PARTICULARLY IN THE RURAL AREAS,
- 18:28THOSE THINGS WILL BE VERY HARD
- 18:29TO LOSE AS WE ALREADY TALKED
- 18:32ABOUT ARE ALREADY STRUGGLING
- 18:33FROM SO MUCH JOB LOSS.
- 18:35>> .
- 18:37>> Renee: ARE THERE
- 18:38CONVERSATIONS ABOUT SPREADING
- 18:39THE SALES TAX TO INCLUDE MORE
- 18:41SERVICES.
- 18:41IN THE ORIGINAL HOUSE BILL 2022,
- 18:45THE SALES TAX WAS EXTENDED IT
- 18:47MORE THAN 30 SOMETHING SERVICES,
- 18:506% SALES TAX.
- 18:51IS THAT A DIRECTION THAT THE
- 18:53GENERAL ASSEMBLY COULD EMBRACE
- 18:56IN THIS UP COMING SESSION?
- 18:58>> WELL, I THINK FIRST OF ALL I
- 18:59NEEDED TO COMMENT ON WHAT JASON
- 19:02SAID.
- 19:02BECAUSE HE PRESENTS FIGURES AS
- 19:04IF THIS WERE A REVENUE SOURCE
- 19:06THAT WOULD GO AWAY OVERNIGHT
- 19:07THERE WOULDN'T BE ECONOMIC
- 19:09GROWTH AND WOULDN'T BE MORE
- 19:11BUSINESSES AND POPULATION AND
- 19:13SALARY INCREASES ALL THE THINGS
- 19:15THAT WE BELIEVE WITH THE
- 19:16CONSERVATIVE TAX POLICY WOULD
- 19:17HAPPEN AND IT IS NOT JUST A
- 19:19CONSERVATIVE TAX POLICY IT WAS
- 19:21RECOMMENDED AS THE EUROPEAN
- 19:23UNION CAME OUT OF THE RECESSION
- 19:25FROM THE ECONOMIC COMMISSION WAS
- 19:26TO GO TO MORE OF A CONSUMPTION
- 19:30BASED TAXATION SYSTEM AND SHIFT
- 19:32AWAY FROM A PRODUCTION BASED
- 19:34SYSTEM WHICH IS WHAT THIS IS
- 19:36DESIGNED TO DO.
- 19:36YOU HAVE TO RECOGNIZE THERE ARE
- 19:38OTHER ACTIONS THAT HAPPEN AS A
- 19:39RESULT OF THESE TYPES OF TAX
- 19:41POLICIES AND THEY THIS IN NO WAY
- 19:44SHAPE OR FORM EVER WAS DESIGNED
- 19:46OR WILL HAPPEN OVERNIGHT.
- 19:47NOW, YOU DO MENTION THE IDEA OF
- 19:51TAXATION ON SERVICES.
- 19:53AND CERTAINLY, THAT ALWAYS COMES
- 19:54UP.
- 19:56AND EVERYONE'S ALWAYS FOR THE
- 19:57IDEA OF MORE TAXATION ON
- 19:59SERVICES UNLESS IT'S THEIR
- 20:01SERVICE IN WHICH CASE IT IS NOT
- 20:03SUCH A POPULAR IDEA ANYMORE.
- 20:04SO YOU KNOW, I CERTAINLY
- 20:07ANTICIPATE THOSE CONVERSATIONS
- 20:08WILL CONTINUE TO OCCUR.
- 20:10BUT I DON'T THINK THAT THEY WILL
- 20:12NECESSARILY OCCUR IN ERNEST IN
- 20:15ANYTIME SOON.
- 20:16>> Renee: FOOD AND MEDICINE
- 20:18SACRED COWS?
- 20:18>> I THINK SO, ABSOLUTELY.
- 20:20>> SENATOR WEBB?
- 20:21>> SENATOR ARMSTRONG WE
- 20:24PRESENTED A BILL LAST WEEK ON
- 20:26DIAPERS AND THE IMPACTS OF THAT
- 20:29PHYSICAL IMPACT ON THE STATE
- 20:32BOTTOM LINE BUT THE IMPACT ON
- 20:33THE FAMILIES MADE A COMPELLING
- 20:37CASE.
- 20:38>> Renee: TAX EXEMPT ON TYPERS.
- 20:39>> AND THAT CUTS A WIDE SWATH
- 20:42SOCIOECONOMIC SWATH.
- 20:43AND I AM INCLINED TO SUPPORT
- 20:47THAT.
- 20:47BUT, AGAIN, I JUST THINK THAT
- 20:50DIVERSIFICATION HAS CARRIED US
- 20:52THROUGH RECESSION AND ECONOMIC
- 20:56DOWNTURNS.
- 20:56AND EVEN THOUGH I'M FOR CUTTING
- 20:58TAXES AND THE PLAN THE
- 21:00INCREMENTAL PLAN MIGHT WORK, I
- 21:03STILL FEAR TOTAL ELIMINATION FOR
- 21:06THAT VERY REASON BECAUSE THE
- 21:07REVENUE IS GOING TO COME FROM
- 21:10SOMEWHERE IF WE'RE GOING TO
- 21:11MAINTAIN THE STATE AND ALLOW THE
- 21:13INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THAT GROWTH.
- 21:14WE HAVE TO FUND THE
- 21:17INFRASTRUCTURE.
- 21:18FOR THE POTENTIAL GROWTH THAT WE
- 21:19HOPE WE HAVE.
- 21:20BUT NOBODY'S GOT A CRYSTAL BALL
- 21:22HERE.
- 21:23I LIKE HOPING FOR THE BEST AND
- 21:24PLANNING FOR THE WORST.
- 21:27I LIKE TO DIVERSIFICATION OF OUR
- 21:30SYSTEM AS IMPERFECT AS IT IS,
- 21:32I'D LIKE TO SEE IT MAINTAINED IN
- 21:35SOME FORM.
- 21:36>> Renee: BECAUSE THE GROWTH
- 21:37DOES NOT HAVE A DATE CERTAIN?
- 21:39TENNESSEE, I THINK, THEY'VE
- 21:41NEVER HAD A PERSONAL INCOME TAX
- 21:43AN INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX AND FOR
- 21:45A PERIOD OF 40 YEARS THEY
- 21:47STARTED OUTPACING KENTUCKY IN
- 21:48TERMS OF POPULATION GROWTH,
- 21:51EXPONENTIALLY YOU COULD SAY BUT
- 21:53HOW LONG WILL IT TAKE FOR
- 21:54KENTUCKY TO MEET WHERE TENNESSEE
- 21:57IS?
- 21:57AND THERE ARE MORE CONDITIONS
- 21:58THAT JUST THE ECONOMIC
- 22:00CONDITIONS AND TAXES THAT MAKE
- 22:02TENNESSEE MAYBE MORE ATTRACTIVE
- 22:04FOR MORE PEOPLE AND MORE
- 22:05INDUSTRY.
- 22:05>> SURE.
- 22:07TAX IS GOING TO BE ONE OF A
- 22:10MULTIPLE VARIABLES THAT WILL
- 22:11FACTOR INTO THE ECONOMIC GROWTH
- 22:12AND POPULATION GROWTH OF
- 22:13KENTUCKY BUT IT IS AN IMPORTANT
- 22:15ONE.
- 22:15THE OTHER THING WE'RE LEAVING
- 22:17OUT OF THIS CONVERSATION, TOO,
- 22:20WHAT KENTUCKY IS TRYING TO DO WE
- 22:22ARE NOT THE STATE AIMING TOWARDS
- 22:24THIS GOAL WE ARE SURROUNDED BY
- 22:25STATES THAT ARE DOING THE SAME
- 22:27THING.
- 22:28GOOD EXAMPLE IS WHILE WE HAVE
- 22:29TENNESSEE TO OUR SOUTH, THAT HAS
- 22:32ZERO INCOME TAX RATE, INDIANA IS
- 22:35ABOUT 3.15.
- 22:36INDIANA HAS RECENTLY FORMED ITS
- 22:38OWN COMMISSION FOCUSED
- 22:40SPECIFICALLY ON HOW THEY CAN
- 22:41MOVE MORE QUICKLY TO REDUCE
- 22:43THEIR INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX
- 22:45RATE.
- 22:46OHIO REDUCED ITS.
- 22:49MISSOURI REDUCED ITS.
- 22:51ARKANSAS, WEST VIRGINIA,
- 22:53VIRGINIA EVERY STATE AROUND US
- 22:54IS HEADING DOWN THIS PATH.
- 22:55I THINK WHAT WE'RE SEE SOMETHING
- 22:57LIKE IN THE EARLY 20TH CENTURY
- 22:59WHEN A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT
- 23:00STATES WERE ADOPTING INCOME
- 23:02TAXES I THINK WE'RE HEADING DOWN
- 23:04A PATH THAT FEWER STATE ALSO
- 23:06HAVE THAT AS PART OF THE REVENUE
- 23:08PORTFOLIO BECAUSE THEY RECOGNIZE
- 23:10THE ECONOMIC BENEFITS OF HAVING
- 23:12A LOW TO NO INDIVIDUAL INCOME
- 23:13TAX.
- 23:14WHAT WE WANT TO AVOID IS A
- 23:17SITUATION WHERE KENTUCKY HAS
- 23:20MAYBE A 4% INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX
- 23:21WHILE WE ARE SURROUNDED BY OTHER
- 23:23STATES RANGING FROM 0-2%.
- 23:25IF YOU ARE A BUSINESS, IF YOU
- 23:27ARE AN INDIVIDUAL AN
- 23:29ENTREPRENEUR AND THINKING ABOUT
- 23:31STARTING A BUSINESS IN THE STATE
- 23:32YOU ARE GOING TO TAKE THOSE
- 23:34THINGS INTO CONSIDERATION ALONG
- 23:36WITH OTHER FACTORS SUCH AS
- 23:39WORKFORCE AVAILABILITY,
- 23:40INFRASTRUCTURE AND WEATHER.
- 23:41IT'S GOING TO BE AN INPUT IN
- 23:42THAT DECISION MAKING PROCESS IN
- 23:43WHAT WE'RE DOING IS POSITIONING
- 23:45KENTUCKY TO BE A STATE WHERE WE
- 23:48CAN ADDRESS THAT MAJOR CONCERN
- 23:49AND IT IS A MAJOR CONCERN.
- 23:51PARTICULARLY AMONGST A LOT OF
- 23:52DIFFERENT EMPLOYERS AS WELL AS
- 23:54INDIVIDUALS WITH HIGH SKILLS
- 23:55THAT MIGHT WANT TO DOME HERE AND
- 23:57WORK.
- 23:57>> THERE'S TWO TRAINS GOING ON
- 23:59IN THE STATES.
- 24:00STATES THAT ARE TAKING ADVANTAGE
- 24:01OF THIS ONE TIME REVENUE BUMP
- 24:03FROM THE STIMULUS TO MAKE
- 24:05PERMANENT INCOME TAX CUTS AND
- 24:07ANOTHER GROUP OF STATES THAT ARE
- 24:08GOING IN THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION
- 24:10THEY ARE RAISING TAXES ON
- 24:13MILLIONAIRES AND GENERATING
- 24:15PROGRESSIVE TAX REVENUE SO THEY
- 24:17CAN BETTER FUND SCHOOLS,
- 24:18INFRASTRUCTURE AND HEALTHCARE.
- 24:19AND OVER THE PAST 10 YEARS, THE
- 24:22NINE STATES THAT HAD THE HIGHEST
- 24:23TOP INCOME TAX RATE ON THE
- 24:26WEALTHY ARE DOING BETTER THAN
- 24:28THE NINE STATES WITH NO INCOME
- 24:31TAX AT ALL.
- 24:31THE NARRATIVE IS LOW TAXES IS
- 24:33WHAT IS DRIVING ECONOMIC
- 24:34INVESTMENT HAS TO EXPLAIN HOW
- 24:36STATES LIKE TENNESSEE AND
- 24:39KENTUCKY HAVE A LIFE EXPECTANCY
- 24:44SIX YEARS SHORTER THAN THE
- 24:45WEALTHY STATES DO.
- 24:47TENNESSEE IS CLOSE TO US IN LOTS
- 24:49OF WAYS IN TERMS OF IT BEING A
- 24:52HIGH POVERTY SOUTHERN STATE AS
- 24:53OTHER STATES NEAR US THAT HAVE A
- 24:55LOT OF TROUBLE AND A LOT OF
- 24:58PROBLEMS THAT NEED TO BE FIXED.
- 25:00IT'S THE CASE THAT THE STATES
- 25:02NEVER CREATED AN INCOME TAX HAVE
- 25:05ONE OR TWO TYPES OF ECONOMIES,
- 25:09TOURISM, FLORIDA, TENNESSEE AND
- 25:10NEVADA OR NATURAL RESOURCES LIKE
- 25:12TEXAS, WYOMING AND ALASKA.
- 25:14AND WE'RE NOT IN THOSE CAMPS
- 25:16ANYMORE.
- 25:17WE HAVE TO HAVE THIS DIVERSIFIED
- 25:19TAX SYSTEM INCLUDING AN INCOME
- 25:21TAX IF WE INVEST IN THE THINGS
- 25:24THAT DO CREATE A THRIVING
- 25:27ECONOMY LIKE INFRASTRUCTURE AND
- 25:27QUALITY OF LIFE.
- 25:29THERE WERE THINGS PUT IN THE
- 25:30LAST BUDGET WHICH I DIDN'T THINK
- 25:32THE BUDGET WAS GOOD ENOUGH BUT A
- 25:35LOT OF THINGS WE WOULD BE ABLE
- 25:36TO FUND IF WE GIVE AWAY OUR BEST
- 25:39SOURCE OF REVENUE.
- 25:40AND THAT IS CONCERNING WHEN YOU
- 25:41ALSO LOOK AT SOME WAYS IN WHICH
- 25:43WE HAVEN'T RECOVERED FROM THE
- 25:45GREAT RECESSION.
- 25:47WE'RE LOOKING AT YOU KNOW,
- 25:48SCHOOL FUNDING AT THIS POINT
- 25:50THAT IS IF YOU LOOK AT THE
- 25:52DISPARITY BETWEEN THE WEALTHY
- 25:53AND THE POOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS
- 25:54WE'RE BACK TO WHERE WE WERE WHEN
- 25:57THE SUPREME COURT SAID IT WAS
- 25:58UNCONSTITUTIONAL OUR FUNDING
- 25:59LEVEL THERE'S LONG-TERM TRENDS
- 26:01THAT WE NEED TO TURN THE OTHER
- 26:02WAY.
- 26:03AND I WORRY IF WE CONTINUE TO
- 26:05DIMINISH OUR LARGEST REVENUE
- 26:07SOURCE WE ARE NOT GOING TO BE
- 26:08ABLE TO DO THAT.
- 26:09>> Renee: AND TO THAT POINT WE
- 26:11HEAR REPUBLICANS SAY THERE'S
- 26:13RECORD LEVELS OF SEEK INVESTMENT
- 26:16TO THE BASE FUNDING IN K-12
- 26:19EDUCATION AND YET WE HEAR Mr.
- 26:21BAILEY SAY FOR SOME DISTRICTS
- 26:23THERE IS AN EQUITY DISPARITY
- 26:24WHERE THE POORER DISTRICTS ARE
- 26:26NOT GETTING WHAT THEY NEED AND
- 26:27BACK TO THE UNCONSTITUTIONAL
- 26:31LEVELS BEFORE THE KENTUCKY
- 26:32EDUCATION REFORM ACT.
- 26:33WHAT IS THE ACTUAL STORY HERE?
- 26:35>> SO I THINK FIRST OF ALL WE
- 26:37HAVE TO REALIZE THAT THE STATES
- 26:38DECIDED TO IMPOSE TAX ON THEIR
- 26:41HIGHEST INCOME EARNERS HAVE SEEN
- 26:43A FLIGHT OF THOSE HIGH INCOME
- 26:45EARNERS FROM THE STATES.
- 26:46CALIFORNIA IS ATTEMPTING TO
- 26:49POTENTIALLY RETROACTIVELY TAX
- 26:50PEOPLE WHO MOVE OUT WHO ARE
- 26:52FACING NEGATIVE TAX
- 26:53CONSEQUENCES.
- 26:54WE SAW NEW JERSEY AND RHODE
- 26:55ISLAND HAD A SINGLE INDIVIDUAL
- 26:57MOVE OUT AND PUT $150 MILLION
- 26:59HOLE IN THE BUDGET BECAUSE THEY
- 27:01TRIED THIS STUNT.
- 27:02WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT RAISING THE
- 27:03TAXES THEY SOUND GOOD UNTIL YOU
- 27:05REALIZE THOSE ARE THE PEOPLE WHO
- 27:07BY AND LARGE YOUR ENTREPRENEURS
- 27:08WHO ARE RUNNING YOUR BUSINESSES
- 27:10AND CREATING THE JOBS THAT WE
- 27:12COUNT ON AS THE MIDDLE CLASS TO
- 27:14BE ABLE TO PROSPER INSIDE OF AN
- 27:16ECONOMY.
- 27:17WHEN YOU RUN THOSE PEOPLE OUT OF
- 27:19YOUR STATE, WHEN YOU SAY YOUR
- 27:21SUCCESS IS UNWARRANTED AND WE
- 27:22WANT A LARGER SHARE OF IT, YOU
- 27:25DRIVE THEM SOMEWHERE ELSE.
- 27:26SO YOU HAVE TO BE VERY, VERY
- 27:28CAREFUL WHEN YOU LOOK AT THOSE
- 27:30STATES THAT HAVE DONE THAT.
- 27:31BECAUSE YOU'VE SEEN A MASS
- 27:33EXODUS OF HIGH PRODUCERS FROM
- 27:35THE STATES.
- 27:36TO YOUR POINT, OBVIOUSLY, SEEK
- 27:38IS A TOUCHY ISSUE LIKE THE TAX
- 27:40CODE.
- 27:41I KEEP ON MY DESK A COPY OF A
- 27:45TAX REFORM COMMISSION FROM 1903.
- 27:48ABOUT EIGHT YEARS AFTER THE
- 27:50ADOPTION OF THE CONSTITUTION
- 27:51TALKING ABOUT THE TAX CODE IS
- 27:52UNFAIR WE TAX THE WRONG THINGS
- 27:54IT'S HITTING THE WRONG PEOPLE ON
- 27:55AND ON.
- 27:56IT IS A PERPETUAL DEBATE AS IS
- 27:59SCHOOL FUNDING.
- 27:59AND I WILL TELL YOU I REPRESENT
- 28:02ONE-THIRD OF KEN TON COUNTY AND
- 28:04I HAVE FIVE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ALL
- 28:05OF THEM WOULD AGREE THAT SEEK IS
- 28:09AN UNFAIR DISTRIBUTION OF THE
- 28:13COLLARS BUT FOR DIFFERENT
- 28:14REASONS.
- 28:16I HARKEN BACK TO THE IDEA PEOPLE
- 28:18MIGHT NOT LIKE THE SEEK FORMULA
- 28:20IT WAS DEVELOPED AFTER A LOT OF
- 28:23LITIGATION, IT IS FOLLOWED AS
- 28:24CLOSELY AS IS HUMANLY POSSIBLE.
- 28:26AND I ALWAYS CAUTION PEOPLE
- 28:28WE'RE WALKING WHAT A SUPREME
- 28:30COURT FROM THE 1990s SETUP IS
- 28:32A CONSTITUTIONAL TIGHT ROPE AND
- 28:33WE HAVE TO BE VERY CAREFUL TO
- 28:36INSURE THAT WE WALK IT
- 28:38APPROPRIATELY SO THAT WE DON'T
- 28:39END UP IN A SITUATION WHERE
- 28:41WE'RE YOU KNOW, POTENTIALLY
- 28:42THROWING THE BABY OUT WITH THE
- 28:44BATH WATER.
- 28:45>> Renee: IT SEEMS LIKE YOU'VE
- 28:47FALLEN OFF THE TIGHT ROPE IF YOU
- 28:50GO WHAT THE REPORT SET OUT THE
- 28:52POORER DISTRICTS THERE IS AN
- 28:53EQUITY GAP IN TERMS OF FUNDING.
- 28:56HASN'T THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 28:58ALREADY FALLEN OFF THE TIGHT
- 28:59ROPE?
- 28:59>> NOT IN THE LEAST.
- 29:01IT IS AN APPROACH HOW SEEK IS
- 29:03ALLOCATED BASED ON ASSESSED
- 29:05PROPERTY VALUES AND AS THE
- 29:07ASSESSMENTS GO DOWN THE SEEK
- 29:09CONTRIBUTION GOES UP.
- 29:13SUBSEQUENTLY, YOU'RE WEALTHIER
- 29:14DISTRICTS ARGUE IT'S UNFAIR ON
- 29:16THE OTHER SIDE THEY ARE HAVING
- 29:18TO SEND TOO MANY TAX DOLLARS.
- 29:19IT IS A FORMULA THE GENERAL
- 29:23ASSEMBLY FOLLOWED WITH GREAT
- 29:25PRECISION OVER THE LAST 30
- 29:26YEARS.
- 29:26AND I KNOW THERE IS A WORKING
- 29:28GROUP HAVING THESE CONVERSATIONS
- 29:29RIGHT NOW ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT
- 29:31IT IS HITTING APPROPRIATELY
- 29:34MEETING THE CONSTITUTIONAL
- 29:35MEASURE.
- 29:35BUT YOU KNOW, FOR RIGHT NOW, I
- 29:38THINK IT'S DOING WHAT IT WAS
- 29:39INTENDED TO DO.
- 29:40>> Renee: ANY OTHER COMMENT ON
- 29:41THAT?
- 29:41WITH THE JEFFERSON COUNTY BUSING
- 29:44SITUATION THAT THEY WERE OWED
- 29:46ESSENTIALLY $25 MILLION OVER THE
- 29:48PAST FOUR YEARS, AND THAT COULD
- 29:50HAVE MADE A SIGNIFICANT
- 29:51DIFFERENCE HOW THEY ROLLED OUT
- 29:54THEIR NEW SCHOOL TRANSPORTATION
- 29:56PLAN THIS YEAR.
- 29:57>> THAT IS FUNDAMENTALLY NOT AN
- 29:59ACCURATE ARGUMENT.
- 30:01JEFFERSON COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 30:02WAS GIVEN $10 MILLION OF NEW
- 30:04FUNDING FOR TRANSPORTATION THAT
- 30:05THEY NEVER SEEN BEFORE.
- 30:08JEFFERSON COUNTY IN THE LAST
- 30:09FOUR YEARS HAS SEEN $ONE00
- 30:13MILLION IN STATE CONTRIBUTION.
- 30:14IN THE LAST THREE YEARS THEY
- 30:16RECEIVED HALF OF A BILLION
- 30:17DOLLARS IN FEDERAL PANDEMIC
- 30:19FUNDS.
- 30:20JEFFERSON COUNTY HAD THE MONEY.
- 30:22THERE'S PEOPLE LOOKING FOR
- 30:23SCAPEGOATS AND THERE'S ONE AND
- 30:24THAT IS THE JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 30:27PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM.
- 30:28>> WE HAVE A BUS DRIVER SHORTAGE
- 30:30ACROSS THE STATE AND IT'S BEEN
- 30:33BUBBLING FOR ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
- 30:34BUT STATES ARE THE ONES THAT
- 30:35HAVE TO RESPOND TO THAT AND MANY
- 30:37OF THEM ARE.
- 30:38BUT IN KENTUCKY WE HAVE A LAW
- 30:40THAT UNDER THE SEEK FORMULA THE
- 30:41LEGISLATURE WILL FUND 100% OF
- 30:43THE COST GETTING KIDS TO AND
- 30:45FROM SCHOOL AND WE HAVE NOT DONE
- 30:47THAT SINCE 2005.
- 30:48THIS IS ONE OF THE WAYS IN WHICH
- 30:50WE'VE THE SEEK FORMULA WORKS IF
- 30:52YOU FUND IT.
- 30:52BUT IF YOU DON'T FUND IT THEN
- 30:55THE INEQUITIES FORM.
- 30:58SINCE 2005 EVERY TIME THE
- 30:59LEGISLATURE SUSPENDS THAT LAW
- 31:00AND PUTS IN A LOWER AMOUNT.
- 31:02IT'S 124 MILLION LESS TO THE
- 31:05STATE TO THE DISTRICTS FOR
- 31:07SCHOOLS IN THE CURRENT YEAR.
- 31:08AND BUS DRIVERS ARE MAKING
- 31:12$15,000 A YEAR ON AVERAGE IN
- 31:14KENTUCKY.
- 31:14I MEAN WITH THE COMMERCIAL
- 31:16DRIVER'S LICENSE THERE ARE
- 31:17BETTER OPTIONS.
- 31:18IF WE CAN'T GET KIDS TO AND FROM
- 31:20SCHOOL WE ARE NOT GOING TO HAVE
- 31:21SCHOOL.
- 31:22IT IS AN EXAMPLE OF HOW THERE
- 31:24ARE NEEDS UNMET IN THE CURRENT
- 31:26BUDGET THAT I THINK WE HAVE TO
- 31:27LOOK AT REALLY HARD WHEN WE'RE
- 31:29THINKING ABOUT POTENTIAL VERY
- 31:31LARGE TAX CUTS.
- 31:32HALF A POINT CUT IN THE INCOME
- 31:33TAX IS $600 MILLION THIS FUNDING
- 31:36GAP IN TRANSPORTATION IS ONLY
- 31:39124 MILLION.
- 31:40WE CAN DO A LOT IF WE FOREGO
- 31:43THESE LARGE TAX CUTS AND WE CAN
- 31:45MAKE PROGRESS ON THESE THINGS.
- 31:47>> WE HAVE TO RESTORE EFFECTIVE
- 31:51LEVELS FOR EVERYONE THROUGHOUT
- 31:52THE STATE.
- 31:52THE PARITY ISSUES ARE IMPORTANT
- 31:55AND A KID IN A POORER AREA IT IS
- 31:59THE GREAT EQUALIZER AND THE
- 32:01COURT REALIZED THAT.
- 32:02AND I THINK THE COURT WOULD
- 32:03REALIZE IT AGAIN.
- 32:05WE'VE GOT TO BE DILIGENT HOW WE
- 32:07ARE LOOKING AT THAT.
- 32:08AND WE HAVE THE WORKFORCE ISSUE,
- 32:11COMMUNICATING WITH ONE OF MY
- 32:12SUPERINTENDENTS RIGHT NOW WE'RE
- 32:13TRYING TO WORK WITH AGENCIES TO
- 32:16INCENT BUS DRIVERS.
- 32:17EVEN PEOPLE THAT ARE WORKING IN
- 32:18THE SYSTEM AND HOW BEST TO DO
- 32:20THAT AND SEE WHAT WE CAN DO
- 32:23WITHOUT STATUTORY RELIEF.
- 32:24THAT IS HOW DESPERATE IT IS IN
- 32:26THESE DISTRICTS.
- 32:27AND THERE'S MANY DIFFERENT
- 32:31THINGS THAT GO INTO THIS.
- 32:32I LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING WHAT
- 32:34THE TASK FORCE SAYS BUT I UNDER
- 32:36PRESENT CONDITION I ANTIES
- 32:39PARTICIPATE ANOTHER COURT
- 32:40CHALLENGE.
- 32:40>> Renee: THAT WAS GOING TO BE
- 32:42MY NEXT QUESTION AND THE REPORT
- 32:43IS DUE BY DECEMBER?
- 32:45>> I THOUGHT IT WAS DECEMBER THE
- 32:48FIRST.
- 32:49BUT DON'T HOLD ME TO THAT
- 32:51ANSWER.
- 32:52>> Renee: THEY TEND TO BE AROUND
- 32:54DECEMBER 1, WHICH IS SESSION
- 32:55RIGHT AFTER THE NEW YEAR.
- 32:56THIS QUESTION WILL GET TO SOME
- 32:58THAT COME IN FROM OUR VIEWERS.
- 33:00DREW FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY FOR
- 33:02SENATOR McDANIEL WITH THE
- 33:03STATE IN A $3 BILLION SURPLUS
- 33:05WHEN WILL KENTUCKY PENSION
- 33:10RETIREES RECEIVE COLA?
- 33:11>> I WILL SAY AND I WANT TO BACK
- 33:13UP FOR A SECOND BECAUSE I AGREE
- 33:15WITH JAY SOB NOW.
- 33:16THERE IS A STATE-WIDE BUS DRIVER
- 33:19ISSUE AND IT'S NOT JUST UNIQUE
- 33:21TO KENTUCKY NOT UNIQUE TO BUS
- 33:23DRIVERS BUT IT IS ACUTELY FELT
- 33:26IN THOSE DISTRICTS THAT HAVE
- 33:28TRANSPORTATION.
- 33:28YOU HAVE TO REMEMBER NOT EVERY
- 33:30DISTRICT HAS TRANSPORTATION.
- 33:31WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT THE FUNDING
- 33:33DISPARITIES, ONCE AGAIN, THE
- 33:35DISTRICTS THAT DON'T HAVE IT
- 33:36THEY DON'T GET MONEY FOR
- 33:38TRANSPORTATION.
- 33:38TO THE QUESTION FROM YOUR CALLER
- 33:40ABSOLUTELY.
- 33:41SO THE STATE PENSION SYSTEM WHEN
- 33:43I SHOWED UP 10 YEARS AGO IT WAS
- 33:45AN ABSOLUTE MESS.
- 33:46THE STATE HAD NO RAINY DAY FUND
- 33:48LEFT.
- 33:49THE PENSION SYSTEM WAS A MESS
- 33:50AND WE'VE WORKED IN A
- 33:52DISCIPLINED MANNER TO REALLY
- 33:54WRANGLE THAT BACK IN FOR THE
- 33:57FIRST TIME SINCE I'VE BEEN IN
- 33:58THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, THE
- 33:59KENTUCKY RETIREMENT SYSTEM
- 34:01RECOMMENDED A REDUCTION IN
- 34:03CONTRIBUTION BECAUSE THE FUNDING
- 34:04IS GOING IN THE APPROPRIATE
- 34:06DIRECTION.
- 34:07NOW, I WILL PUSH US THAT
- 34:09ALTHOUGH THE RECOMMENDATION IS
- 34:11SLIGHTLY LOWER WHICH THE IS
- 34:13APPROPRIATE ACT AERIAL
- 34:15RECOMMENDATION.
- 34:16>> Renee: IS THERE A NUMBER?
- 34:17>> A DROP BY A COUPLE OF
- 34:19PERCENTAGE POINTS IN THE
- 34:20CONTRIBUTION BUT I WILL PUSH US
- 34:21NOT TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT WE'RE
- 34:23CONTRIBUTING.
- 34:24THAT CONTINUES WHILE IT IS A
- 34:26PROBLEM THAT IS IMPROVING IT
- 34:27REMAINS A PROBLEM AND WE NEED TO
- 34:29CONTINUE TO REMAIN VERY FOCUSED
- 34:31ON THE STATE OF THE
- 34:32COMMONWEALTH'S PENSION SYSTEMS.
- 34:34TO HIS POINT, ABSOLUTELY.
- 34:35THERE IS A LOT OF CONVERSATION
- 34:37GOING ON REGARDING THAT.
- 34:39THE CONVERSATION VARIES.
- 34:42BUT BECAUSE RETIREES VARY.
- 34:44FOLKS THAT RETIRED A YEAR OR TWO
- 34:46AGO ARE IN A DIFFERENT SITUATION
- 34:48THAN THOSE WHO RETIRED IN 2010.
- 34:51BOTH OFF OF THE SALARY THE
- 34:53PENSION WAS CALCULATED ON AND
- 34:55THEIR AGE AND ABILITY TO
- 34:58POSITIVELY INFLUENCE THEMSELVES.
- 35:00THERE'S PRETTY WIDESPREAD HOPE
- 35:03FOR ACTION THIS TIME AROUND.
- 35:05>> Renee: TO GIVE THEM A COLA
- 35:07INCREASE?
- 35:07>> SOMETHING.
- 35:09>> Renee: SOMETHING.
- 35:09WHAT ELSE WOULD THERE WE?
- 35:11>> THERE'S CONVERSATIONS ABOUT
- 35:13COLAS AND CONVERSATIONS ABOUT
- 35:15ONE TIME LUMP SUM PAYMENTS, AND
- 35:17CONVERSATIONS ABOUT A MEANS
- 35:19TESTING OR AN AGE BRACKETING OR
- 35:21A RETIREMENT DATE BRACKETING
- 35:23THERE'S DIFFERENT TYPES OF
- 35:25OPTIONS ON THE TABLE.
- 35:26PEOPLE TEND TO THINK IN THIS BY
- 35:29THEORY COLA OR NO COLA.
- 35:30>> Renee: BECAUSE THEY DON'T
- 35:32KNOW THE OTHER OPTIONS PERHAPS.
- 35:33>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 35:34THOSE ARE ALL BEING RUN THROUGH
- 35:36THE PROCESS.
- 35:40>> LONG OVERDUE IN MY OPINION.
- 35:45RETIREMENT SYSTEMS REPORT WAS
- 35:47GREAT TO SIT IN THERE AND HEAR
- 35:48THAT NEWS.
- 35:49IT WAS GOOD NEWS.
- 35:51AND ON TRACK.
- 35:52SO I THINK NOW THAT SITUATION'S
- 35:55HANDLED WE KEEP FUNDING IT ACT
- 35:57USE AIRLY AND WE PUT OUR
- 36:00CONCENTRATION ON THE RETIREES
- 36:01WHO SERVED THIS STATE MOSTLY
- 36:04UNDERPAID AND OVERWORKED.
- 36:06AND IT'S TIME TO RECOGNIZE THEIR
- 36:07SERVICE.
- 36:09>> AND I GIVE CREDIT SENATOR
- 36:13MCCANNLE IS A LEADER IN MAKING
- 36:15SURE AND STARTING TO FUND THE
- 36:17DETERMINED CONTRIBUTION AGAIN
- 36:18AND THAT IS THE REASON WE ARE IN
- 36:19THAT POSITION.
- 36:20BUT IT'S REALLY GOOD TO HEAR
- 36:22THAT THAT MAYBE ON THE TABLE.
- 36:24BECAUSE IT IS AN ISSUE WITH
- 36:26HIRING TOO IF FOLKS THING THEY
- 36:27WILL NEVER GET A COLA FOR THE
- 36:29PENSION BECAUSE THERE HASN'T
- 36:31BEEN ONE SINCE 2011 IT
- 36:34DISCOURAGES PEOPLE FROM COMING
- 36:35INTO PUBLIC SERVICE.
- 36:36TO HEAR THAT THAT MAY BE
- 36:38POSSIBLE THIS TIME AND MAYBE WE
- 36:39CAN GET BACK ON TRACK TO DO THAT
- 36:41IN A REGULAR BASIS I THINK WOULD
- 36:43BE A REALLY IMPORTANT THING FOR
- 36:45RETENTION.
- 36:46>> Renee: NEXT QUESTION STATE
- 36:47WORKERS YOU ENVISION A RAISE FOR
- 36:50THEM THIS TIME AROUND?
- 36:51>> IN FACT WE APPROPRIATED FOR
- 36:53AN 8% RAISE AND THERE IS A 12.5%
- 36:59CONTINGENT ON A SALARY SURVEY WE
- 37:01WILL BE GETTING AFTER THAT AS
- 37:03WELL.
- 37:04CERTAINLY, I ANTICIPATE THAT
- 37:05SECOND ROUND COMING OUT.
- 37:06I KNOW WE'RE HAVING THOSE
- 37:08CONVERSATIONS ABOUT WHAT THAT
- 37:09LOOKS LIKE EXACTLY.
- 37:10WE DO HAVE TO CONTINUE TO BE
- 37:13DILIGENT IN ADDRESSING THE
- 37:15COMPETITIVENESS ISSUE.
- 37:16BECAUSE FOR SOME AREAS OF STATE
- 37:17GOVERNMENT, I THINK THE SALARY
- 37:19IS GOING TO SHOW US WE ARE ON
- 37:21PAR AND A LITTLE BIT BETTER.
- 37:22BUT OTHER AREAS WHERE WE'RE
- 37:26WOEFULLY INADEQUATE.
- 37:27RATHER THAN SAYING ACROSS THE
- 37:29BOARD WE HAVE TO BE SMART WHAT
- 37:30WE ARE DOING SO WE ARE
- 37:32COMPETITIVE.
- 37:32THE IT MARKETPLACE IS NOWHERE
- 37:34CLOSE TO WHAT IT WAS 20 YEARS
- 37:36AGO.
- 37:37AND CERTAINLY ONLY WILL CONTINUE
- 37:39TO ACCELERATE IN THIS PARTICULAR
- 37:40ECONOMY.
- 37:41THE SERVI SECTOR HAS PICKED UP E
- 37:46MIGHT HAVE TO HAVE THE
- 37:49CONVERSATIONS ABOUT THE FOLKS
- 37:50WHO WORK IN THE STATE PARKS WE
- 37:52WILL RELY ON THE SURVEY TO
- 37:54INFORM OUR DECISIONS.
- 37:54AND WE HAVE TO RECOGNIZE THERE
- 37:56ARE AREAS WHERE THE COST OF
- 37:58LIVING IS HIGHER THAN OTHER
- 37:59AREAS AND WE HAVE TO RECOGNIZE
- 38:00THAT BECAUSE IT DOESN'T MATTER
- 38:02IF A KID LIVES IN JEFFERSON
- 38:06COUNTY THEY STILL MAY NEED
- 38:07ACCESS TO A SOCIAL WORKER AND
- 38:09THE COST OF EMPLOYING THAT
- 38:12EMPLOYEE IN JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 38:14MIGHT BE HIGHER.
- 38:15WE HAVE TO RECOGNIZE THOSE
- 38:17THINGS TO PROVIDE THOSE SERVICES
- 38:19WHEN PEOPLE NEED THEM.
- 38:21>> THE LAST BUDGET MADE GREAT
- 38:24ACCOMMODATIONS BUT WE HAVE MORE
- 38:25TO DO.
- 38:26YOU TRY TO HIRE A MEDICAL
- 38:28EXAMINER OR A STATE
- 38:30VETERINARIAN, WE'RE GETTING
- 38:32KICKED BY OTHER STATES.
- 38:33OUR JUDGES ARE REALLY
- 38:36UNDERFUNDED WHEN YOU LOOK AT
- 38:38NEIGHBORING STATES.
- 38:39A LOT ABOUT NEIGHBORING STATES
- 38:42FOR OUR JUDGES AND OTHER WORKERS
- 38:44THAT ARE JUST NECESSARY,
- 38:46NECESSARY EMPLOYEES.
- 38:48WE'VE GOT TO BE MORE COMPETITIVE
- 38:50BECAUSE THESE WORKFORCE ISSUES
- 38:52IT'S NOT JUST BUS DRIVERS IT
- 38:54GOES ALL THE WAY TO THE TOP.
- 38:56>> Renee: THE PERSONNEL CABINET
- 38:57WAS SUPPOSED TO SUBMIT THIS
- 38:59COMPENSATION STUDY WAS THAT DUE
- 39:01JULY?
- 39:03>> ONCE AGAIN, I THOUGHT IT WAS
- 39:05A SEPTEMBER DUE DATE ON THAT ONE
- 39:08BUT I BELIEVE IT'S FINISHED AND
- 39:10WE ANTICIPATE IT ROLLING OUT
- 39:11SOON.
- 39:12>> Renee: AND THAT WILL BE
- 39:14INFORMATIVE ON WHAT THE
- 39:16DIRECTION THE ASSEMBLY TAKES.
- 39:17>> IF I COULD ADD A COUPLE
- 39:19THINGS.
- 39:19I THINK A LOT OF THE CHALLENGES
- 39:21WE'RE SEEING WITH STATE
- 39:22EMPLOYEES AND A LOT OF PUBLIC
- 39:25SECTOR EMPLOYEES SOME IS A SIDE
- 39:26EFFECT THE EXTENT TO WHICH THE
- 39:28PRIVATE SECTOR INCREASED
- 39:29COMPENSATION.
- 39:30SO THAT HAS PUT A SQUEEZE ON OUR
- 39:33PUBLIC SECTOR EMPLOYEES.
- 39:34THE COMPENSATION ANALYSIS IS
- 39:36BEING DONE IS PRUDENT AND AN
- 39:38EXCELLENT WAY TO DO THAT AND
- 39:39THIS IS SOMETHING THAT IS GOING
- 39:40TO HAVE TO HAPPEN.
- 39:41HOWEVER EVEN IF YOU GET THE
- 39:43WAGES HIGHER, AND EVEN FOR
- 39:45SOCIAL WORKERS, BUS DRIVERS
- 39:47WHOEVER IT MIGHT BE, IT'S STILL
- 39:48GOING TO BE INCREDIBLY DIFFICULT
- 39:50TO HIRE WHEN YOU HAVE A
- 39:52WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION RATE IN
- 39:53THE RANGE OF 57.6% AND ONE OF
- 39:57THE TOP 10 LOWEST IN THE NATION.
- 39:59I THINK ALL THESE STEPS HAVE
- 40:01VERY, VERY IMPORTANT BUT THEY
- 40:03STILL NEED TO BE PAIRED WITH
- 40:04BROADER EFFORTS TO BRING MORE
- 40:06PEOPLE INTO KENTUCKY'S LABOR
- 40:08MARKET.
- 40:09UNTIL WE SOLVE THE LARGER
- 40:11SYSTEMIC ISSUES AND SOME OF
- 40:12WHICH AREN'T NECESSARILY THINGS
- 40:13THAT CAN BE SOLVED SUCH AS THE
- 40:15DEMOGRAPHIC CHANGE AND
- 40:16RETIREMENTS WE'RE SEEING THOSE
- 40:18ARE DIFFICULT FACTORS TO
- 40:19OVERCOME.
- 40:20BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY, FOR
- 40:21THE SAKE OF OUR PUBLIC SECTOR
- 40:23WORKFORCE AND OUR PRIVATE SECTOR
- 40:26WORKFORCE INCREASING WORKERS
- 40:27PARTICIPATION IS GOING TO BE KEY
- 40:28TO ADDRESSING BOTH CHALLENGES.
- 40:31>> Renee: LAST YEAR WE TALKED
- 40:32ABOUT THAT AND THE POINT WAS
- 40:34MADE FOR THOSE 25-54, THE
- 40:36PARTICIPATION RATE IS 79%.
- 40:39TRUE OR FALSE?
- 40:39>> TRUE.
- 40:41HOWEVER THAT IS SIGNIFICANTLY
- 40:42LOWER THAN THE NATIONAL PRIME
- 40:45AGE LABOR FORCE PARTICIPATION
- 40:46RATE CLOSER TO 82% AND IN
- 40:48ADDITION TO THAT IT'S STILL IN
- 40:50ONE OF THE BOTTOM 10 AMONGST
- 40:52STATES ACROSS THE NATION.
- 40:54YOU CAN CUT THAT APPLE HOWEVER
- 40:56YOU WANT.
- 40:56WE HAVE REMARKABLY LOW RATES OF
- 40:59WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION.
- 41:00AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT THAT PRIME
- 41:02AGE WORK GROUP THAT GROUP IS NOT
- 41:05GROWING.
- 41:05THE PARTICIPATION RATE IS STABLE
- 41:06BUT IT'S NOT GROWING.
- 41:08SO THAT IS A REALLY SERIOUS
- 41:10LONG-TERM PROBLEM BECAUSE WHAT'S
- 41:11HAPPENING IS OUR OVERALL
- 41:13WORKFORCE IS GETTING OLDER AND
- 41:15OLDER, AND THERE'S
- 41:1725-54-YEAR-OLDS THEY ARE
- 41:18BECOMING MORE FEW AND FAR
- 41:20BETWEEN.
- 41:21SO WHETHER YOU ARE LOOKING AT
- 41:22THE BROADER WORKFORCE
- 41:23PARTICIPATION RATE OR PRIME AGE
- 41:27WORKFORCE RATE YOU COME TO THE
- 41:30SAME PROBLEM WE SIMPLY HAVE A
- 41:32SMALLER SHARE OF OUR ADULT
- 41:34POPULATION THAT IS PARTICIPATING
- 41:35IN THE WORKFORCE AS THE NATION
- 41:37AS A WHOLE AND OTHER STATES.
- 41:39>> SO 80% OF THE PEOPLE IN THE
- 41:43PRIME WORKING AGE ARE WORKING IN
- 41:44KENTUCKY.
- 41:4679%.
- 41:46SO 21% ARE NOT.
- 41:48ALMOST EVERYBODY WHO IS NOT IN
- 41:50THAT CATEGORY IS EITHER A
- 41:51CAREGIVER IF WE WANT THOSE FOLKS
- 41:53TO HAVE A PAID JOB WE HAVE TO
- 41:55LOOK AT CHILDCARE AND ELDERCARE.
- 41:57THEY ARE A STUDENT WHICH I THINK
- 41:58ALL OF US WOULD SUPPORT PEOPLE
- 42:00BEING IN SCHOOL.
- 42:01OR THEY HAVE A DISABILITY.
- 42:04THEY ARE CURRENTLY UNEMPLOYED
- 42:05AND THEN THERE IS A SMALL NUMBER
- 42:07THAT WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY
- 42:09ARE.
- 42:10AND WHY THEY ARE NOT IN THE
- 42:11WORKFORCE.
- 42:12THIS ISSUE IS OVERSTATED AND
- 42:14WHEN NOBODY SHOULD SAY THAT 57%
- 42:18OF PEOPLE ARE IN THE WORKFORCE
- 42:19THAT IS TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE IN
- 42:21THEIR 80s AND 90s.
- 42:23IT'S ALSO THE CASE, THOUGH, THAT
- 42:25WHEN YOU BREAK KENTUCKY'S
- 42:27NUMBERS DOWN, AND THE KENTUCKY
- 42:30CENTER FOR STATISTICS DID A
- 42:31REPORT ON THIS THIS YEAR IF YOU
- 42:33LOOK AT KENTUCKY'S WORKFORCE
- 42:36PARTICIPATION RATE IN THE ENTIRE
- 42:38STATE IS RIGHT ON PAR WITH THE
- 42:39NATIONAL AVERAGE EXCEPT IN ONE
- 42:41PART OF THE STATE IN EASTERN
- 42:42KENTUCKY WHERE THERE ARE NOT
- 42:44JOBS.
- 42:44WHERE WE HAVE SEEING THIS
- 42:46TREMENDOUS LOSS OF COAL JOBS AND
- 42:48OTHER JOBS WHERE THE
- 42:49UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IS HIGH.
- 42:51IT'S NOT LOW.
- 42:52IT'S VERY HIGH.
- 42:54AND WHERE THE PEOPLE JUST LACK
- 42:56OPPORTUNITIES.
- 42:57SO IF WE WANT TO DO SOMETHING
- 42:58ABOUT IT IT'S NOT THERE ARE ALL
- 43:01THESE JOB OPENINGS THERE ARE NOT
- 43:03JOB OPENS IN THAT PART OF THE
- 43:04STATE.
- 43:05WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT JOB
- 43:07CREATION AND GET US BACK TO WHAT
- 43:08WE WERE TALKING ABOUT EARLIER,
- 43:09ABOUT THE NEED TO LET'S TAKE ALL
- 43:13THE FEDERAL MONEY FOR
- 43:14INFRASTRUCTURE AND MAKE SURE
- 43:15THAT THE MATCHING FUNDS ARE
- 43:16AVAILABLE IN THE EASTERN
- 43:18KENTUCKY COUNTIES SO THEY CAN
- 43:20CREATE SOME JOBS IN THE PUBLIC
- 43:23SECTOR.
- 43:24BUT IT'S IF YOU LOOK AT URBAN
- 43:26KENTUCKY, AND SUBURBAN KENTUCKY
- 43:27AND THE REST OF RURAL KENTUCKY
- 43:29IT IS NOT UNUSUAL.
- 43:30PEOPLE ARE WORKING.
- 43:31THEY HAVE TO WORK TO GET BY IN
- 43:33THIS ECONOMY AND THE BIGGER
- 43:37ISSUE IS THE QUALITY OF THE JOBS
- 43:39THAT ARE AVAILABLE.
- 43:41>> Renee: GO AHEAD.
- 43:42>> QUALITY OF JOBS.
- 43:44LET'S TAKE THE COAL INDUSTRY,
- 43:45THE RAILROAD, THE STEEL
- 43:47INDUSTRY, THE HOSPITALS THAT ARE
- 43:49CLOSING.
- 43:49THOSE ARE GOOD JOBS.
- 43:51GOOD QUALITY JOBS.
- 43:53AND SHOULD MY PEOPLE HAVE TO
- 43:55MOVE SHOULD EAST KENTUCKIANS
- 43:57HAVE TO MOVE?
- 43:59I WANT TO SEE EMPHASIS AND FOCUS
- 44:02ON BRINGING HIGH PAYING JOBS IN.
- 44:07WE SERVICE JOBS ARE NOT GOING TO
- 44:09DO THAT.
- 44:09SO WE'VE GOT TO CONCENTRATE ON
- 44:13JOBS TO REPLACE THAT.
- 44:15OR RETRAIN OUR WORKERS AND FOCUS
- 44:18BROADBAND INFRASTRUCTURE WE'VE
- 44:20GOT TO HAVE BROADBAND IF WE ARE
- 44:21GOING TO HAVE PEOPLE WORKING
- 44:22FROM HOME.
- 44:23IN A REMOTE ECONOMY.
- 44:26AND THOSE THINGS ARE SLOW TO GET
- 44:28THERE.
- 44:28BUT WE'RE GETTING THERE.
- 44:31BUT LIKE JASON SAID, WE'VE GOT
- 44:35AN AMOUNT OF DISABLED FOLKS
- 44:39BECAUSE THE ECONOMY THAT RELIED
- 44:41ON HAS BEEN HARD ON PEOPLE.
- 44:43WE HAVE HIGH RATES OF CANCER IN
- 44:45EAST KENTUCKY NOT JUST
- 44:49LIFESTYLE.
- 44:51SOME ENVIRONMENTALLY AT FAULT.
- 44:53I MEAN WE'VE GOT TO FOCUS ON
- 44:56GOOD FOR EVERYBODY.
- 44:58WE'VE LOST ENOUGH PEOPLE NOW.
- 45:00WE'VE TOOK HARD HITS IN EAST
- 45:02KENTUCKY AND I REPRESENT THE
- 45:04NORTHEAST BUT I'VE LIVED IN THE
- 45:06SOUTHEAST AND I'M THERE OFTEN.
- 45:11AND IT'S URGENT AND ALL THE
- 45:12MONEY WE PUT IN WE'RE GOING TO
- 45:13HAVE NEEDS THERE.
- 45:14SOME OF THE COMMUNITIES AREN'T
- 45:16COMING BACK.
- 45:17AND THE STEEL INDUSTRY MAY NOT
- 45:18COME BACK.
- 45:20IN THE COAL INDUSTRY CERTAINLY
- 45:22ISN'T COMING BACK.
- 45:23WE ARE TRYING TO LOOK AT WAYS IN
- 45:25THE ENERGY SECTOR TO FIND WAYS
- 45:28TO REPLACE SOME OF THOSE JOBS
- 45:29FOR PEOPLE WHO STILL WANT TO
- 45:30WORK IN THE ENERGY SECTOR.
- 45:34AND FIND RELIEF ON PEOPLE'S
- 45:36POWER BILLS I'M ON THE NUCLEAR
- 45:39ENERGY TASK FORCE I NEVER
- 45:40THOUGHT THE COAL MINER WOULD BE
- 45:43ON THE NUCLEAR ENERGY TASK
- 45:47FORCE.
- 45:47>> Renee: SENATOR CAROL IS
- 45:48PERVASIVE?
- 45:49>> I'M PROUD TO DO IT AND I
- 45:50THINK IT WILL BRING
- 45:52OPPORTUNITIES AS WE MOVE
- 45:53FORWARD.
- 45:53>> THIS IS A PIVOT FROM OUR
- 45:55DISCUSSION.
- 45:56BUT JEFF SIMS FROM CALDWELL
- 45:58COUNTY ASKS HOW IS KENTUCKY
- 45:59GOVERNMENT AND THE LEGISLATIVE
- 46:01EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR,
- 46:02DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION WORKING
- 46:03TOGETHER TO FIND KENTUCKY'S WAY
- 46:05FORWARD IN THE FACE OF AI AND
- 46:08THE RADICAL AUTOMATION OF JOBS
- 46:11THAT KENTUCKIANS DO NOT WANT TO
- 46:13FILL.
- 46:14THAT IS A DEEP QUESTION.
- 46:15>> THAT IS A DEEP QUESTION AND
- 46:17SOME OF THE BEST MINDS IN ALL OF
- 46:19GOVERNMENT AND INDUSTRY ARE
- 46:19TRYING TO UNDERSTAND THAT.
- 46:20AND IT IS A FEAR ACROSS
- 46:22INDUSTRIES WE DON'T THINK ABOUT
- 46:23THE HOLLYWOOD WRITERS STRIKE ONE
- 46:25OF THE CENTRAL ISSUES WAS THE
- 46:28INVOLVE THE.
- 46:29AI IN THE PRODUCTION OF NEW
- 46:31SHOWS AND WRITING.
- 46:33AND SO IT IS AN ABSOLUTELY
- 46:35TRANSFORMATIVE TECHNOLOGY.
- 46:36IT IS BEING HARNESSED INSIDE OF
- 46:39THE BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH INDUSTRY
- 46:41TO BRING US DRUGS QUICKER, USE
- 46:43DATA SETS IN NOVEL WAYS AND
- 46:45SLICE THINGS, THINGS THAT
- 46:46PREVIOUSLY WERE TAKING
- 46:48SCIENTISTS WEEKS TO RUN A
- 46:49PARTICULAR DATA SET ARE TAKING
- 46:5115 MINUTES.
- 46:52THEY ARE ABLE.
- 46:52IT WILL REVOLUTIONIZE OUR
- 46:54SOCIETY IN MANY, MANY GOOD WAYS
- 46:56AS AI BECOMES MORE ACCEPTED.
- 46:59BUT THERE ARE TREMENDOUS
- 47:01CHALLENGES THAT IT WILL PRESENT
- 47:03AND I THINK MOST OF US DON'T
- 47:04EVEN CAN'T BEGIN TO UNDERSTAND
- 47:06IT BECAUSE THE TECHNOLOGY ITSELF
- 47:08IS SO NEW AND SO NOVEL BUT IT
- 47:11WILL ABSOLUTELY IT WILL BE A
- 47:14DOMINATING CONVERSATION FOR THE
- 47:15NEXT FIVE TO 10 YEARS.
- 47:16AS WE REALLY BEGIN TO UNDERSTAND
- 47:18HOW THIS NEW POWER IS HARNESSED.
- 47:20>> .
- 47:21>> I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT WHEN
- 47:22WE THINK ABOUT ARTIFICIAL
- 47:24INTELLIGENCE OR AUTOMATION WE
- 47:26NOT NECESSARILY THINK ABOUT THEM
- 47:27AS JOB DISPLACERS OR THINGS THAT
- 47:30WILL TAKE JOBS AND FILL JOBS WE
- 47:32CAN'T FILL.
- 47:33OFTENTIMES THE TECHNOLOGY ALSO
- 47:34SERVE MORE TO AUGMENT JOBS.
- 47:36THEY CAN IMPROVE SAFETY, THEY
- 47:37CAN MAKE US MUCH MORE EFFICIENT.
- 47:40NOW THERE ARE JOBS THAT MAYBE
- 47:41CAN BE INCREDIBLY DIFFICULT TO
- 47:44FILL.
- 47:44MAYBE IN THE HEALTHCARE SECTOR
- 47:45SOME OF THE CLERICAL WORK THAT
- 47:47NEEDS TO HAPPEN.
- 47:49ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IS
- 47:50STEPPING IN AND HELPING
- 47:51STREAMLINE THOSE PROCESSES.
- 47:52THERE IS A LOT OF POSITIVE
- 47:54THINGS THAT CAN HAPPEN BOTH FOR
- 47:56BUSINESSES AND WORKERS THROUGH
- 47:58THE ARRIVAL AND UTILIZATION OF
- 48:00AI AND AUTOMATION.
- 48:01I DO THINK IT DOES MEAN WE NEED
- 48:03TO START THINKING HARDER ABOUT
- 48:06EDUCATION AND JOB TRAINING.
- 48:08BECAUSE AS THOSE FEATURES BECOME
- 48:10MORE PREVALENT IN THE WORKFORCE,
- 48:11I CAN TELL YOU I'M NOT WELL
- 48:14EQUIPPED TO UTILIZE ARTIFICIAL
- 48:17INSURANCE TELL JEANS IN MY JOB
- 48:18AND I HAVE A PH.D.
- 48:20FOLKS ARE GOING TO NEED TO
- 48:21EMBRACE THAT TYPE OF TRAINING
- 48:24AND BECOME MORE COMMON LIKE
- 48:26EASTERN KENTUCKY THOSE ARE THE
- 48:28THINGS WE NEED TO MAKE SURE
- 48:29THOSE ARE HAPPENING IN THOSE
- 48:31AREAS SO WE ARE MORE PREPARED
- 48:33FOR THIS ECONOMIC TRANSITION IN
- 48:35COMPARISON TO SAY PREVIOUS
- 48:38TRANSMISSIONS WE'VE MADE.
- 48:39IT WILL BE A KEY COMPONENT WITH
- 48:41WORKFORCE TRAINING.
- 48:42>> Renee: THIS QUESTION POSED TO
- 48:44SENATOR WEBB FROM CARTER COUNTY.
- 48:47WHAT WILL SENIOR CITIZENS DO IF
- 48:49THERE IS THIS IS A FEDERAL
- 48:50GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN AND THEY
- 48:51CAN'T RECEIVE THEIR SOCIAL
- 48:54SECURITY CHECKS WHAT KIND OF AID
- 48:56WILL KENTUCKY PROVIDE?
- 48:58>> WELL, I'D LIKE TO THINK WE'D
- 49:00STEP UP TO THE PLATE IN A
- 49:03COMPLETE FEDERAL FAILURE.
- 49:04WE GO THROUGH THIS QUITE A BIT
- 49:07LATELY BEING ON THE BRINK OF A
- 49:09SHUTDOWN.
- 49:09AND IT'S JUST REALLY NOT PRUDENT
- 49:12OR GOOD POLICY FOR THE FEDS TO
- 49:13DO THAT TO US.
- 49:15AND I'M SURE WE WOULD ACT
- 49:20QUICKLY.
- 49:21>> Renee: CAN YOU ACT QUICKLY?
- 49:21>> WE CAN MAYBE DO A STOPGAP
- 49:25MEASURES JUST TO CERTAIN
- 49:27POPULATIONS AND SOME FORM.
- 49:28BUT I DON'T THINK THAT'S GOING
- 49:30TO HAPPEN.
- 49:33BASED ON HISTORICAL CONTEXT.
- 49:35BUT YOU KNOW WE WOULD CERTAINLY
- 49:39HAVE HAVING AVAILABLE HAVE ALL
- 49:41HANDS ON DECK IF SOMETHING LIKE
- 49:42THAT WOULD HAPPEN.
- 49:44>> Renee: THE GOVERNOR WOULD
- 49:45HAVE TO CALL YOU INTO SPECIAL
- 49:47SESSION.
- 49:47>> HE PROBABLY WOULD FOR SURE
- 49:49AND SOME OF THAT STUFF COULD BE
- 49:52DEEMED NG NECESSARY GOVERNMENT
- 49:54EXPENSE.
- 49:56BUT IT WOULD DEPEND ON THE
- 49:57GRAVITY OF THE SITUATION.
- 49:59>> Renee: CHAIR DO YOU HAVE
- 49:59ANYTHING TO ADD TO THAT?
- 50:01>> VERY LITTLE.
- 50:02SPECULATING WHERE THE FEDERAL
- 50:03GOVERNMENT WILL GO IN THE BUDGET
- 50:06NEGOTIATIONS IS PERILOUS AT
- 50:08BEST.
- 50:09I REMAIN WORRIED ABOUT THE
- 50:11SPENDING AND THE DEFICITSES WE
- 50:13CONTINUE TO RUN.
- 50:14AND CERTAINLY, HOPE THAT OUR
- 50:16LEADERS CAN COME TOGETHER TO
- 50:17GIVE US A GOOD SOLUTION TO IT.
- 50:19BUT ANY PARTICULAR BETS ON WHERE
- 50:23THEY WILL WOULD BE A LITTLE BIT
- 50:25DANGEROUS.
- 50:28>> Renee: STICK TO FAN DUAL.
- 50:29AS WE ENTER THE BUDGET SESSION,
- 50:34THE GOVERNOR WHOEVER HE IS WILL,
- 50:35OF COURSE, PRESENT THEIR
- 50:37PRIORITIES AND WE'VE HEARD FROM
- 50:38THE CANDIDATES ABOUT WHAT THE
- 50:39BUDGET PRIORITIES ARE.
- 50:42SENATOR AND CHAIRMAN McDANIEL
- 50:44HAVE YOU TALKED ABOUT WHAT ARE
- 50:46THE ABSOLUTES THAT SHOULD BE
- 50:49CONTINUED IN THIS UP COMING
- 50:50BUDGET CYCLE?
- 50:51>> I THINK THE BIGGEST ABSOLUTE
- 50:53FOR ME WOULD BE THAT THE
- 50:54COMMONWEALTH'S PENSION PLANS.
- 50:56WE'VE GOT TO CONTINUE TO ADDRESS
- 50:57THEM.
- 50:58WE CANNOT LEAVE FOR THE NEXT
- 50:59GENERATION OF LEADERS OF THIS
- 51:01COMMONWEALTH THE PROBLEMS THAT
- 51:02WERE LEFT FOR US.
- 51:03AND I THINK YOU WILL CONTINUE TO
- 51:05SEE US REMAIN INTENSELY FOCUSED
- 51:07ON THAT ISSUE.
- 51:08I THINK YOU WILL CONTINUE TO SEE
- 51:10US WORKING ON ECONOMIC
- 51:12DEVELOPMENT.
- 51:13SENATOR WEBB AND SEVERAL
- 51:14COLLEAGUES FROM THE EAST AND I
- 51:16WORKED THROUGH MANY MACHINATIONS
- 51:19OF TRYING TO DO THINGS.
- 51:20THE ECONOMIC PROBLEMS IN EASTERN
- 51:21KENTUCKY ARE NOT AN EASTERN
- 51:24KENTUCKY PROBLEM THOSE ARE A
- 51:26NORTHERN KENTUCKY PROBLEM AND
- 51:28WESTERN KENTUCKY PROBLEM BECAUSE
- 51:31ULTIMATELY THE SUCCESS OR
- 51:32FAILURE OF ANY REGION OR THE
- 51:34RICE RISE AND DECLINE IMPACTS
- 51:36THE BALANCE OF THE COMMONWEALTH.
- 51:37WE HAVE TO CONTINUE TO STAY
- 51:38FOCUSED ON THOSE TYPES OF ITEMS
- 51:41AS WELL.
- 51:42YOU'LL SEE US CONTINUE TO FOCUS
- 51:44ON TRYING TO BRING THE INCOME
- 51:45TAX RATE DOWN AND CRAFTING
- 51:47RESPONSIBLE SPENDING PLAN THAT
- 51:50LEAVES ENOUGH AT THE END THAT WE
- 51:52CAN PUT MORE MONEY BACK IN THE
- 51:53POCKETS OF EVERYDAY KENTUCKIANS.
- 51:56>> Renee: SOME PEOPLE HEAR THAT
- 51:57AND THEY SAY THAT MEANS CUTS?
- 51:59>> THERE WILL NOT BE NECESSARY
- 52:01CUTS IN ORDER TO EFFECTUATE THAT
- 52:03POLICY.
- 52:03>> Renee: OK.
- 52:04THIS QUESTION QUICKLY FROM
- 52:06FAYETTE COUNTY.
- 52:07WITH ALL THE TALK ABOUT
- 52:08SURROUNDING STATES WHY NOT LOOK
- 52:10AT TAKING AN AVERAGE OF STATE
- 52:13INCOME TAX OF THE SEVEN
- 52:15SURROUNDING STATES?
- 52:15>> I WOULD LIKE TO TAKE THAT ONE
- 52:18ON.
- 52:18BECAUSE I THINK THAT CHARLES
- 52:20MADE AN EXCELLENT POINT WHICH IS
- 52:22THE OVERALL ECONOMIC SUCCESS
- 52:25WHILE TAX POLICY IT IS
- 52:28UNPARALLELED AND UNQUESTIONED
- 52:29THAT STATE WITH THE LOWER INCOME
- 52:33TAX RATE DO BETTER THAN OTHER
- 52:35STATES IN ATTRACTING BUSINESSES.
- 52:37BUT THERE ARE OTHER THINGS THAT
- 52:39GO INTO WHY BUSINESSES AND
- 52:41INDIVIDUALS LOCATE.
- 52:42WHY YOU HAVE A LARGE POPULATION
- 52:43OF PEOPLE OVER 65 THAT WANT TO
- 52:45BE IN FLORIDA INSTEAD OF MAINE.
- 52:48AND IT'S NOT THEIR AFFINITY FOR
- 52:51MAPLE SYRUP.
- 52:52SO YOU KNOW, YOU'VE GOT TO HAVE
- 52:54A GOOD COMPREHENSIVE LOOK AT
- 52:57WHAT MAKES YOUR STATE
- 52:58COMPETITIVE WITH NEIGHBORING
- 52:59STATES WHEN YOU LOOK AT
- 53:02TENNESSEE, TO JASON'S POINT YOU
- 53:03HAVE TO REALIZE THEY TAX
- 53:06GROCERIES AND POSSIBLY
- 53:07PHARMACEUTICALS AS WELL DOWN
- 53:08THERE.
- 53:09THERE ARE TRADE OFFS IN THESE
- 53:11POLICIES THAT YOU HAVE TO BE
- 53:12AWARE OF.
- 53:14AND SO JUST WHILE THE INCOME TAX
- 53:16LOOK IS IMPORTANT AND I CAN
- 53:18ASSURE YOU AT LEAST SEVERAL
- 53:20TIMES A YEAR WE RECEIVE AN
- 53:22UPDATE ON WHAT EACH STATE IS
- 53:23DOING WITH THAT TAX POLICY.
- 53:25IT DOESN'T GET TO EXIST IN A
- 53:28VACUUM WHEN WE GO TO CRAFT OUR
- 53:30PLANS.
- 53:30>> I THINK IT'S ONE THING THAT
- 53:32IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND ABOUT
- 53:35MIGRATION IS PEOPLE DON'T MOVE
- 53:36AS MUCH AS THEY USED TO BETWEEN
- 53:38STATES AT ALL.
- 53:39THE SHARE OF PEOPLE WHO MOVE
- 53:40BECAUSE OF TAXES IS EVEN LOWER.
- 53:43PEOPLE MOVE TO FLORIDA BECAUSE
- 53:44THEY HAVE BEACHES IN FLORIDA.
- 53:46EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT.
- 53:48CLIMATE IS A BIG DRIVER.
- 53:51FOR EXAMPLE, WHEN FOLKS TALK
- 53:52ABOUT PEOPLE MOVING BECAUSE OF
- 53:53TAXES AND SAYING THEY MOVED TO
- 53:55FLORIDA THEY DON'T MENTION SOUTH
- 53:57CAROLINA WHICH IS ONE OF THE TOP
- 53:59STATES TO WHICH PEOPLE MOVE AND
- 54:00THEY HAVE AN INCOME TAX THEY
- 54:02HAVE A 6% OR 7% TOP INCOME TAX
- 54:05IN SOUTH CAROLINA BUT THAT GETS
- 54:06LEFT OUT BECAUSE IT DOESN'T FIT
- 54:08THE NARRATIVE PEOPLE ARE TRYING
- 54:10TO RIGHT.
- 54:12PEOPLE MOVE TO OTHER STATES THAT
- 54:14HAVE INCOME TAXES.
- 54:15IT HAPPENS TO BE THE STATES THAT
- 54:18DON'T HAVE THEM ARE IN THE SOUTH
- 54:20WHERE PEOPLE MOVED TO BE IN A
- 54:21DIFFERENT CLIMATE.
- 54:25TAXES ARE VERY SMALL IN TERMS OF
- 54:27THEIR IMPACT ON HOW PEOPLE MAKE
- 54:30DECISIONS ABOUT WHERE TO BE
- 54:32WHERE BUSINESSES MAKE DECISIONS
- 54:33ABOUT WHERE TO BE AND KENTUCKY
- 54:35HAS THINGS THAT IT SHOULD TAKE
- 54:37ADVANTAGE OF THAT HAVE NOTHING
- 54:38TO DO WITH TAXES OUR CENTRAL
- 54:40LOCATION IN THE EASTERN HALF OF
- 54:42THE UNITED STATES THAT IS WHY WE
- 54:44HAVE A LOGISTICS INDUSTRY AND
- 54:45AUTO INDUSTRY.
- 54:47BUT TO CONTINUE TO GROW THAT WE
- 54:49NEED TO HAVE AN INFRASTRUCTURE,
- 54:51WE NEED TO HAVE BROADBAND WE
- 54:53NEED TO HAVE ALL THE THINGS AN
- 54:55EDUCATED WORKFORCE ALL THE
- 54:56THINGS THAT DO REQUIRE TAX
- 54:58REVENUE AND TO HAVE THAT REVENUE
- 55:00YOU HAVE TO HAVE A BALANCED TAX
- 55:02SYSTEM THAT HAS LOTS OF SOURCES
- 55:03AND NO ONE HAS PROPOSED AN
- 55:06OPTION THAT CAN REPLACE THE
- 55:07INCOME TAX.
- 55:07>> AND KENTUCKY'S A GOOD
- 55:10ECONOMIC INVESTMENT WE'VE GOTTEN
- 55:12QUITE A BIT COMING OUT OF THE
- 55:15PANDEMIC.
- 55:15I'D LIKE TO HAVE MORE IT IN IN
- 55:17EAST KENTUCKY BUT WE'VE BEEN
- 55:19GETTING IT IN THOSE UNEMPLOYMENT
- 55:21RATES IN CERTAIN AREAS ARE
- 55:24ALMOST NOTHING AND YOU LOOK AT
- 55:26DRIVE BY THE BATTERY PLANT AND
- 55:28SEE WHAT IS GOING ON THERE.
- 55:30WE'VE GOTTEN INVESTMENT WITH OUR
- 55:33PRESENT STRUCTURE.
- 55:34BUT AS FAR AS PRIORITIES GO,
- 55:36PENSION IS CERTAINLY AT THE TOP
- 55:39ALONG WITH BROADBAND AND OTHER
- 55:40INFRASTRUCTURE THAT IS GOING TO
- 55:41TAKE TO ACCOMPLISH THAT GROWTH
- 55:43AND IF WE'RE GOING TO GO ON A
- 55:45TREND OF CUTTING INCOME TAX WE
- 55:46HAVE TO INVEST IN OUR TOURISM.
- 55:49WE HAVE TO INVEST IN OUR PARKS.
- 55:51GOVERNOR BESHEAR HAS BEEN DOING
- 55:53THAT.
- 55:53BUT WOEFULLY NOT MAINTAINED FOR
- 55:55THE PAST FEW YEARS.
- 55:56IF WE'RE GOING TO RELY ON OTHER
- 55:59FORMS WE'VE GOT TO INVEST IN
- 56:00THOSE SECTORS THAT PRODUCE THAT
- 56:02THAT WILL FILL IN THE GAP.
- 56:04WE GOT TO FOCUS ON MAINTAINING A
- 56:07RAINY DAY FUND.
- 56:08AND THOSE ARE IMPORTANT THINGS.
- 56:11>> Renee: AND WE'LL GET IDEAS
- 56:11FROM THE GUBERNATORIAL
- 56:13CANDIDATES TOO ABOUT HOW TO
- 56:15MAYBE INVEST SOME OF THAT AS
- 56:16WELL.
- 56:17AND WE THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING
- 56:18HERE IT'S BEEN A GOOD
- 56:20DISCUSSION.
- 56:25BE SURE TO JOIN US EACH
- 56:26WEEKNIGHT AT 6:30 EASTERN, 5:30
- 56:27CENTRAL FOR ‘KENTUCKY EDITION.’
- 56:28AND JOIN BILL BRYANT AND A TEAM
- 56:29OF WORKING JOURNALISTS TO
- 56:29DISCUSS THE NEWS OF THE WEEK ON
- 56:30‘COMMENT ON KENTUCKY,’ FRIDAY AT
- 56:31VE A GOOD WEEK.SEVEN CENTRAL.