Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Howard Marks on the Fed and AI
Transcript
- 0:00You know when you first learn to bowl, they put those inflatable
- 0:03bumpers in the gutters. You roll the ball, it bounces
- 0:06left, it bounces right, but it like it always hits the pins.
- 0:09Yeah, it feels amazing. Right.
- 0:10You feel totally invincible, but you are actually learning how to
- 0:13bowl. You're just learning how to
- 0:14throw a heavy object without any consequences.
- 0:18And the second somebody deflates those bumpers, panic sets in.
- 0:23Suddenly, the reality of the lane actually matters.
- 0:26'Cause you haven't developed the underlying skills to navigate
- 0:30the actual physical environment. I mean, you've just developed
- 0:32this reliance on an artificial safety net that guarantees A
- 0:36somewhat positive outcome, you know, no matter how poorly you
- 0:39actually perform. Exactly.
- 0:41And that illusion of safety, that tension between relying on
- 0:44the bumpers and facing the very real unforgiving reality of the
- 0:47lane, is exactly what we are unpacking today.
- 0:50But before we reveal the realities of the actual lane, a
- 0:53quick note for those looking to do their own lane reading.
- 0:56To access more advanced researches, follow Guru's latest
- 0:59movement MAD and leverage our latest Deep Values agents.
- 1:02Welcome to download Deep Values APP from App Store to track
- 1:06stock market temperature. Welcome to download iOS app
- 1:09Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store or Bubble Watch from
- 1:12Google Play. Links to the description
- 1:14Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 1:18and maybe subject to revisions or different interpretations.
- 1:21All contents from this channel is for research and
- 1:23entertainment purposes only and does not constitute any
- 1:26investment or financial advice or service.
- 1:28Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 1:30financial decisions. OK, so with that other way,
- 1:34let's look at today's source. Yeah, it's a really fascinating
- 1:37transcript from Bloomberg Television, specifically an
- 1:41interview recorded at the Qatar Economic Forum.
- 1:43Right. And the person sitting in the
- 1:45hot seat is Howard Marks. Yeah, and for those who track
- 1:48the really smart minds in finance, he is the Co chair of
- 1:51Oak Tree Capital Management. He's just a legendary figure,
- 1:54mostly known for his incredibly thoughtful, meticulously argued,
- 2:00and often really contrarian memos.
- 2:02Yeah. And if you're listening to this,
- 2:03you're here because you are a learner.
- 2:06You know, you are constantly trying to find the actual signal
- 2:09and the absolute noise of the market.
- 2:10You want to figure out how these brilliant minds operate.
- 2:12But like, without drowning in impenetrable financial jargon.
- 2:17Which is exactly what we're going to try to do here.
- 2:19Right. So our mission for this deep
- 2:20dive is to unpack Mark's genuinely surprising views on
- 2:24how central banks should operate, why the market is
- 2:27currently entirely ruled by optimists, and how a traditional
- 2:30value investor wrestles with the massive, unquantifiable
- 2:33uncertainty of this whole AI boom.
- 2:35It really is a master class in how to process uncertainty in
- 2:38real time. And you know, the conversation
- 2:40starts with a topic that usually puts casual observers right to
- 2:43sleep. But Marx completely flips the
- 2:45conventional wisdom on its head. And we're talking about the
- 2:47communications strategy of the Federal Reserve, right?
- 2:50Exactly. The interviewer asks Marx how
- 2:53he's processing the recent remarks from Fed Chair Jerome
- 2:55Powell. Because, you know, there's been
- 2:57this whole narrative lately about the Fed giving very
- 3:00limited speeches. Right.
- 3:01Like they aren't giving the market perfectly clear signals
- 3:04about what they're going to do next.
- 3:05Yeah. And you would think a
- 3:07billionaire investor managing massive portfolios wants all the
- 3:11forward-looking information possible, like every little
- 3:14crumb of data. Obviously, yeah.
- 3:16But Mark says less communication is actually better.
- 3:20He says he does not want the Fed chair to tell him what to do or
- 3:23even tell him what the Fed is going to do.
- 3:25Wait, really? Because it seems like the entire
- 3:28market hangs on every single word Powell says.
- 3:30Right. But Marks is pointing out a
- 3:32fundamental flaw and how the modern financial system has
- 3:34evolved over the last couple of decades.
- 3:37The system has grown just deeply, deeply reliant on
- 3:41central bank signaling. Oh right, like the dot plots.
- 3:44Yes, the interviewer actually brings up the dot plots, which
- 3:47are those literal charts the Fed publishes showing where each
- 3:50official thinks interest rates are heading over the next few
- 3:52years, and marks kind of jokes that he's had to learn way too
- 3:56much about dot plots lately. His core argument, though?
- 4:00It's about the systemic health of society.
- 4:03If the central banker stops handholding the market and tells
- 4:06people less about what's coming, businesses and investors are
- 4:10forced to make their portfolios anti fragile.
- 4:12Anti fragile, meaning you build a system that can withstand
- 4:15unforeseen shocks rather than a system perfectly optimized for
- 4:19like 1 specific guaranteed output.
- 4:22Kind of like driving with AGPS that dictates every single micro
- 4:26turn, every single lane change like a mile in advance.
- 4:29If you drive like that for years, you completely lose your
- 4:33innate sense of direction. 100% you stop looking at the road
- 4:36signs entirely right? And if that GPS signal suddenly
- 4:39cuts out, or you know the map is outdated, you have absolutely no
- 4:42idea how to navigate, you just crash.
- 4:44And that's exactly what Marx is warning about.
- 4:47If every investor and business owner thinks they know exactly
- 4:50what the Fed is going to do, they all calibrate their entire
- 4:53financial structure for that exact telegraphed outcome.
- 4:57They build around the bumpers. Yes, the entire society becomes
- 5:01completely dependent on that single path.
- 5:03So if an unexpected macroeconomic shock hits.
- 5:07Like a pandemic. Or geopolitical conflict.
- 5:09Or supply chain collapse. Yeah, the system just shatters
- 5:12because no one built in a margin of safety.
- 5:14They didn't think they needed one.
- 5:15So Marx wants the Fed to just step back.
- 5:18Yeah, he advocates for a decidedly less activist central
- 5:22bank. He wants the economy to just
- 5:24function on its own unless it's in danger of going completely
- 5:27off the rails. You know, like hyperinflation or
- 5:30severe depression. But if the economy is just
- 5:32humming along, somewhere in the middle.
- 5:34His advice is to leave it alone. He points directly to this
- 5:36concept of natural interest rates.
- 5:39Right. And he defines natural interest
- 5:40rates as the rates that result purely from negotiations between
- 5:43borrowers and lenders. Yeah, like actual market
- 5:46dynamics. We're talking about the free
- 5:48market pricing the cost of money based on actual risk and reward.
- 5:53Think about it, if you are starting a highly speculative
- 5:56tech company, the free market should naturally demand a higher
- 6:00interest rate from you than from someone taking out, say, a 30
- 6:03year mortgage on a stable piece of real estate.
- 6:05Because the risk dictates the cost of the capital.
- 6:08Exactly when a central bank artificially suppresses interest
- 6:12rates and broadcasts exactly how long they're going to stay
- 6:15suppressed, they distort that natural negotiation.
- 6:19Capital flows into places it probably shouldn't simply
- 6:21because the money is artificially cheap.
- 6:24But wait, let me push back on this a little bit.
- 6:26Isn't a lack of communication from the Fed exactly what causes
- 6:30massive market panics? I mean, investors hate
- 6:33uncertainty. Oh, they despise it.
- 6:35Right. So if the Fed goes completely
- 6:36silent and stops providing forward guidance, doesn't
- 6:39everyone just panic and sell off because they don't know what the
- 6:42cost of capital will be next month?
- 6:43Investors absolutely crave certainty in the short term, but
- 6:47Marx is saying that constantly feeding that craving creates a
- 6:50long term systemic danger. Providing artificial certainty
- 6:54breeds this very specific and honestly sometimes dangerous
- 6:57type of market psychology where risk assessment is essentially
- 7:01just outsourced to the government.
- 7:04So in central bank stops hand holding the market, investors
- 7:07are suddenly forced to confront their own psychology.
- 7:09Yes, and right now, according to Marx, that psychology is
- 7:13overwhelmingly 1 sided. Yeah, I mean, the interviewer
- 7:16asks him what this current environment actually feels like
- 7:20for a value investor. And Marx makes a very distinct
- 7:23categorization of himself to answer this.
- 7:25He says he identifies as a value investor but with a small V, not
- 7:29a capital VA. Small V value investor.
- 7:31OK, So what does that actually look like in practice is when
- 7:34someone is analyzing a stock, because usually value investing
- 7:38sounds pretty rigid. Well, a Capital V's value
- 7:40investor tends to be heavily dogmatic.
- 7:42You know, they might have these rigid, unbreakable rules about
- 7:45price to earnings ratios, or they only buy companies trading
- 7:48below their book value. Right, old school Buffett stuff.
- 7:51Yeah. But those strict historical
- 7:53metrics often lock them completely out of modern asset
- 7:56like growth companies. A small value investor strips
- 8:00the discipline down to its core philosophy into what you figure
- 8:03out the intrusic value of an asset, and you try to buy it at
- 8:07a fair price relative to that value.
- 8:09Intrinsic value being the actual measurable worth of the business
- 8:13based on the future cash it's going to generate.
- 8:15Right, Basically, yeah. You calculate how much cash a
- 8:18business will produce over its lifetime, discount that back to
- 8:21today's dollars and that's your intrinsic value.
- 8:26If the stock market is offering you the company for a less than
- 8:29that number, you buy it. But doing that right now is
- 8:32incredibly difficult, isn't it? I mean, Marks points out that
- 8:35since roughly October of 2022, the markets have been entirely
- 8:38ruled by optimists. He knows the S&P 500 has more
- 8:41than doubled in that specific period.
- 8:43Yeah, and when optimists dictate the flow of capital, prices
- 8:46naturally detach from that grounded intrinsic value
- 8:49population Marx is looking for. People start paying for best
- 8:52case scenarios rather than current realities.
- 8:55Which is wild. The interviewer asks a really
- 8:57crucial question about the source of this optimism.
- 9:00Because even when diplomatic or economic deals in Washington,
- 9:04Europe or the Middle East seem completely unlikely to
- 9:07materialize, the market just responds positively to just the
- 9:11trace of a rumor. It's just wild optimism, and
- 9:14Marx lists a few core reasons driving this behavior.
- 9:18First, to be fair, the underlying truths are actually
- 9:21pretty solid. the US economy is doing well in the aggregate.
- 9:25He actually calls it the best performing developed world
- 9:27economy. OK, that's fair.
- 9:28What's the second reason? Second, there's the Tina trade.
- 9:31Tina, there is no alternative. Right.
- 9:33For years, bond yields were incredibly low.
- 9:36If you kept your money in a savings account or a safe
- 9:38government bond, you were actually losing purchasing power
- 9:42to inflation. So you had to buy stocks?
- 9:44Investors were essentially forced to put their capital into
- 9:47the stock market to get any sort of real return, and that in
- 9:50green habit is hard to break even as interest rates have
- 9:53shifted recently. OK, so that's two.
- 9:55Third is obviously the massive excitement over AI, which we
- 10:00will dig into shortly. But the fourth reason is the
- 10:03most fascinating to me from a psychological standpoint.
- 10:06Yeah, the time frame. Marks points out that we haven't
- 10:08had a truly devastating, prolonged bad time since March
- 10:12of 2009, when the stock market bottomed out during the global
- 10:16financial crisis. It's incredible to think about
- 10:19an entire generation of investors and financial
- 10:21professionals has has essentially never managed money
- 10:24through a catastrophic multi year bear market.
- 10:27They don't know what it feels like when the bumpers are gone.
- 10:29Exactly. People get used to good times,
- 10:32and human nature naturally extrapolates those good times
- 10:35into the future. Optimists, as Marx observes,
- 10:38they just Slough off bad news. They get thrilled by the rumor
- 10:41of a settlement, but they do not adjust their valuations downward
- 10:44when that deal inevitably falls through.
- 10:47But wait, if optimists are just blindly ignoring bad news,
- 10:51shrugging off failed deals, and extrapolating good times
- 10:54indefinitely, aren't they just building a massive House of
- 10:57Cards? Like buying stocks at
- 10:59historically high prices relative to their intrinsic
- 11:03value? Sounds like the exact scenario
- 11:06where a value investor should just liquidate everything and
- 11:09hold cash. You'd think so, but Mark's take
- 11:11away is remarkably pragmatic. He really avoids extreme
- 11:15reactions. He doesn't say sell everything.
- 11:17No, he doesn't advocate panic selling at all.
- 11:20He says you have to clearly acknowledge the positive bias in
- 11:23the room. You have to recognize who was
- 11:24setting the prices. When optimists are in control,
- 11:27prices are high. That doesn't mean a crash is
- 11:29imminent tomorrow. Markets can remain elevated for
- 11:32years. It's simply means your margin
- 11:34for error is smaller, so it's time for caution.
- 11:37You build in a little defense. Exactly.
- 11:39You don't leave the game entirely, but you start favoring
- 11:42companies with stronger balance sheets.
- 11:44You take a lot more care in how you allocate new capital because
- 11:47the forces driving this current wave of optimism carry risks
- 11:51that are genuinely unprecedented in modern financial history.
- 11:55And that need for caution is exactly why Marx's view on AI is
- 11:59so surprising to me. I mean, you think the ultimate
- 12:01market optimist engine, the promise of artificial general
- 12:05intelligence reshaping everything, would absolutely
- 12:08terrify A disciplined value investor?
- 12:10It does, but his concerns are focused completely outside of
- 12:13the stock market. In previous memos, Marx has
- 12:15expressed acute concern about AI wiping out jobs, particularly in
- 12:18middle America. Right, so the interviewer asked
- 12:20him. Given all the hype and all the
- 12:22recent existential dread we hear about, AI have his fears
- 12:25compounded. And this is where Mark shares a
- 12:27quote from his wife that frames his entire approach to this
- 12:30macro level anxiety. She defines worrying as bleeding
- 12:35before you're shot. Bleeding before you're shot.
- 12:38Wow, yeah. A sentient human being observing
- 12:41the landscape obviously has to think about these massive
- 12:44technological shifts, but you also have to acknowledge when
- 12:47there is absolutely nothing you can personally do to alter the
- 12:50trajectory. Right, He can't put the AI
- 12:52technology back in the box. He can't stop companies from
- 12:54adopting it, so he rolls with it.
- 12:56Yeah, he actively prevents it from becoming a daily
- 12:58preoccupation that clouds his judgment.
- 13:01But that personal Stoic acceptance doesn't mean he
- 13:04thinks society as a whole should just ignore the implications,
- 13:07right? Not at all.
- 13:08He points his finger directly at the lack of structural
- 13:11governmental action. People are endlessly debating
- 13:15philosophical existential threats like killer robots, but
- 13:19he doesn't see any concrete policy coming out of the
- 13:21government to manage the economic transition.
- 13:23Right, He argues there needs to be a dedicated government task
- 13:26force to address the coming societal effects of AI.
- 13:30Yes, and he poses A purely practical balance sheet question
- 13:33that completely bypasses the usual sci-fi debates.
- 13:36He asks if AI puts millions of people out of work, who pays the
- 13:41taxes? Oh wow.
- 13:42If a software program takes the place of a human worker, how
- 13:46does it take their place as a taxpayer?
- 13:48What happens to municipal, state and federal government revenues
- 13:51when payroll taxes just vanish? It is a devastatingly simple
- 13:55question with massive macroeconomic implications, like
- 14:00we hear constantly about universal basic income as a
- 14:02solution for displaced workers. But Marx is looking at the other
- 14:05side of the Ledger. Exactly how do you fund any
- 14:09societal safety net if the primary revenue engine human
- 14:12income tax just evaporates? It is like a corporate board
- 14:16deciding to RIP out the heavy gas engine of a delivery truck
- 14:19to save on weight and improve efficiency, completely
- 14:22forgetting that the engines alternator is what powers the
- 14:24headlights, the dashboard and the refrigeration unit in the
- 14:27back. That is a perfect.
- 14:29Analogy If citizens lose jobs on mass, the government's revenue
- 14:32engine collapses. You can optimize corporate
- 14:35efficiency all you want with AI, but if you break the underlying
- 14:38funding mechanism of the society those corporations operate
- 14:41within, the efficiency gains literally don't matter.
- 14:44Right. It's a macro level societal risk
- 14:47that is entirely unquantifiable right now.
- 14:49Nobody knows how fast job displacement will actually
- 14:52happen, or if new industries will replace the old ones
- 14:55quickly enough to maintain that tax base.
- 14:57And this sober kind of pragmatic view of the macro risks
- 15:01translates directly into how Marx is utilizing AI inside his
- 15:06own billion dollar firm right now, because the interviewer
- 15:08asks if he's out there actively using ChatGPT and if Oak Tree
- 15:12has integrated AI tools into their workflows.
- 15:15And they have. Oak Tree has absolutely
- 15:17integrated AI to Marshall massive amounts of data and
- 15:20perform early analysis. The technology is phenomenal at
- 15:23taking tedious manual tasks that used to consume days or weeks
- 15:27and compressing them into minutes.
- 15:28It is an undeniable massive time saver.
- 15:31Like, instead of a junior analyst spending three grueling
- 15:33weeks reading 400 pages of obscure corporate debt covenants
- 15:37just to find a specific legal loophole, the AI model flags
- 15:40that exact loophole in three seconds. 3 seconds.
- 15:43Yeah, that is the prep work, Yeah, But Marx is adamant that
- 15:45they absolutely do not turn actual business or investment
- 15:48decisions over to the AI. Right.
- 15:50And the reasoning gets to the absolute core of what Marx
- 15:52believes makes a great investor. He argues that exceptional
- 15:56investing doesn't come from a computer or an algorithm, simply
- 15:59having access to more information.
- 16:01OK, then what does it come from? It comes from a human being
- 16:04doing a superior job of assessing the import of that
- 16:07information. The import, like the weight, the
- 16:10subtle meaning, the broader context of the data.
- 16:13Exactly. The AI can gather the data
- 16:15perfectly. It can summarize the debt
- 16:17covenants, Florida State. But judging what that loophole
- 16:21actually means in the messy, irrational real world is a
- 16:24uniquely human skill, right? A human analyst has to decide if
- 16:28exploiting that loophole will ruin a vital long term
- 16:31relationship with a corporate partner.
- 16:33The AI doesn't understand reputation or human psychology.
- 16:36Marx explicitly states that this level of nuanced superiority is
- 16:39just not available through AI. And.
- 16:41The interviewer asks a really insightful follow up to this.
- 16:45When Oak Tree hires younger people, young analysts who grew
- 16:47up digital natives, are they seeing them outsource their
- 16:50critical thinking to these AI tools?
- 16:52Which is a huge concern, Mark says.
- 16:55Oak Tree actively discourages that reliance.
- 16:58He warns that if you stop doing the hard, slow work of critical
- 17:01thinking, you will inevitably lose the muscle.
- 17:04The analogy of a kitchen works perfectly here, I think.
- 17:07AI is like the ultimate sous chef.
- 17:09It can dice 10,000 onions perfectly and instantly, measure
- 17:12every complex spice blend to the microgram, and prep all the
- 17:16ingredients faster than any human brigade ever could.
- 17:19But wait, if the AI sous chef is that flawless?
- 17:22If it processes a million times more data and makes 0
- 17:26mathematical errors, why wouldn't we just trust it to
- 17:29cook the final meal? Because the sous chef doesn't
- 17:31know who's sitting in the dining room, The sous chef doesn't know
- 17:34that it's an unusually hot day outside, so the soup needs to be
- 17:37balanced with a little more acidity to feel refreshing to
- 17:40the guests. Context.
- 17:42Right context. You still require the human head
- 17:45chef to taste the broth, assess the broader atmosphere, context,
- 17:48and know what the dish actually needs to succeed in reality.
- 17:52And Marx believes AI will do to active investing exactly what
- 17:55index funds did decades ago. It will put average,
- 17:59unexceptional active investors out of business.
- 18:02But it won't replace the exceptional human ones.
- 18:04The true alpha, the actual edge, remains human judgement.
- 18:08But applying that human judgement to the current AI
- 18:11landscape is where things get really complicated.
- 18:14How does a human mind evaluate the pure chaos and intense hype
- 18:19of AI companies trading on the stock market today?
- 18:22Oh. This prompts the interviewer to
- 18:23ask the bubble question. The bubble question.
- 18:25Yeah, the interviewer references Alan Greenspan's incredibly
- 18:28famous phrase from 1997, Irrational exuberance.
- 18:32They ask Marx how publicious this current AI driven market
- 18:35environment actually looks to him through his small value
- 18:38lens. And Marx agrees that there is
- 18:39definitely exuberance, right? The optimism is visible in the
- 18:42evaluations everywhere, but he hesitates very specifically to
- 18:45call it irrational. Which is a striking, deeply
- 18:48analytical distinction for a traditional value investor to
- 18:51make, because usually high prices driven by overwhelming
- 18:54optimism are immediately labeled irrational by value purists.
- 18:58So why doesn't he call it irrational?
- 19:00Marx explains his logic. To definitively call a market
- 19:04behavior irrational, you have to know with certainty what the
- 19:08rational baseline is. And right now, absolutely nobody
- 19:11can spec out exactly what artificial intelligence is going
- 19:14to be doing in five years. No one knows what specific
- 19:17transformative effect it will have on global productivity, or
- 19:20how profitable these underlying models will actually be, because
- 19:24that future is completely unwritten and technologically
- 19:27unprecedented. You cannot definitively state
- 19:30that the current excitement is irrational.
- 19:32But he draws a really sharp practical contrast between
- 19:36different types of technology companies currently involved in
- 19:39this boom. He points to the hyperscalers.
- 19:41Right, massive companies like Microsoft, Amazon and Google,
- 19:44Yes, they are investing 10s of billions of dollars into AI
- 19:47infrastructure, but they also have massive, existing, highly
- 19:51robust legacy businesses. Like global retail logistics or
- 19:54enterprise cloud hosting. Things that actively support
- 19:57their current earnings estimates.
- 19:59Exactly, you can actually build a financial model around their
- 20:03existing cash flow. But then he points to pure AI
- 20:06companies. Companies whose entire existence
- 20:09and valuation are dependent solely on AI technology, many of
- 20:13which have never produced a single dollar of actual
- 20:16operating profit. So for anyone trying to
- 20:19calculate intrinsic value, a pure AI company presents an
- 20:22almost insurmountable degree of fundamental uncertainty.
- 20:26You are trying to discount future cash flows, but you can't
- 20:30even quantify what the basic revenue model looks like.
- 20:33Yeah, Marks brings up Warren Buffett's famous strategy for
- 20:36dealing with exactly this kind of scenario, putting it in the
- 20:38too hard pile. It is practically impossible for
- 20:41a small value investor to confidently slap a fair
- 20:44valuation on a pure AI company today.
- 20:46But hold on, if we have absolutely no idea what a pure
- 20:49AI company will generate in revenue in five years if we
- 20:51can't quantify the future earnings at all, isn't throwing
- 20:54billions of investment dollars out of the literal definition of
- 20:58irrational behavior? It sounds exactly like venture
- 21:00capital gambling, not discipline public market investing.
- 21:03It does sound like that, but Marx addresses this exact
- 21:07tension with a piece of counterintuitive logic that
- 21:09forms the bedrock of his risk philosophy.
- 21:12He essentially argues that just because you do not know the
- 21:15exact outcome, that does not mean the underlying premise is
- 21:18untrue or silly. OK, the fact that there is an
- 21:21unusual, historically high amount of uncertainty present
- 21:24doesn't mean you just freeze up, sell everything and do nothing.
- 21:27You don't just ignore a massive technological shift simply
- 21:31because the math is hard. The presence of immense,
- 21:34unquantifiable uncertainty. You shouldn't paralyze you.
- 21:37It should simply inform how you structure your investments.
- 21:40It informs which specific form of AI exposure you choose to
- 21:43take. Like leaning heavily toward the
- 21:45established hyperscalers that offer a downside floor instead
- 21:48of, you know, rolling the dice on the pureplay startups.
- 21:51Exactly. And more importantly, it informs
- 21:54exactly how much of your total portfolio you allocate to that
- 21:57theme. You acknowledge the heavy
- 21:59uncertainty, you size your financial bets accordingly, and
- 22:03when you actively build in that defensive posture we talked
- 22:05about earlier, you don't walk away from the table out of fear,
- 22:09but you carefully manage your exposure to a hand you cannot
- 22:12fully see. Man, pulling all of these
- 22:14threads together to view the entire landscape we've just
- 22:17covered. What does this all mean for you,
- 22:20the learner? Howard marks his entire
- 22:22worldview, whether he's analyzing the silent strategy of
- 22:24the Federal Reserve, the relentless optimist driving
- 22:27market valuations, or the unquantifiable societal threat
- 22:31of artificial intelligence, is fundamentally about embracing
- 22:34uncertainty without losing your analytical discipline.
- 22:38The goal of investing, and perhaps navigating the modern
- 22:40economy isn't to perfectly predict a future that is
- 22:43inherently unpredictable. The goal is to build a robust
- 22:46anti fragile system for yourself that can survive multiple
- 22:50different futures. And you can actively apply that
- 22:53small V value mindset to so much more than just a financial
- 22:57portfolio. You can apply it to how you
- 22:59consume Daily News or how you make long term career decisions
- 23:02in an increasingly AI heavy world.
- 23:05You calmly acknowledge the positive bias in the room.
- 23:08You accept that you cannot control macro forces like
- 23:11central bank policy or technological evolution.
- 23:14You don't waste energy bleeding before you're shot.
- 23:16Exactly. But you always build in your own
- 23:19margin of safety. And crucially, as Marx warns,
- 23:22you never let the algorithms do your critical thinking for you,
- 23:26because the moment you stop actively assessing context, you
- 23:29lose the only real advantage you have.
- 23:31If the AI models can eventually Marshall all the world's data
- 23:34and perform the basic fundamental analysis instantly,
- 23:37and Florida State, the only genuine edge left in the market
- 23:40and in the workplace is the human capacity to assess subtle
- 23:43context. To weigh the nuanced meaning of
- 23:46that data against the messy reality of human behavior.
- 23:48Which leaves us with something really fascinating to chew on as
- 23:51we wrap up. If the ultimate investing edge,
- 23:54and quite possibly the ultimate professional edge of the next
- 23:56decade is exceptional human critical thinking and artificial
- 24:01intelligence is rapidly automating all the basic
- 24:04analysis and data gathering. Is the most valuable asset of
- 24:07the future simply the human ability to ask the right
- 24:10unprompted questions? And if so, how are you actively
- 24:13training that muscle today? Are you practicing your swing on
- 24:16the real lane, or are you still relying on the bumpers?
- 24:19Thanks for joining us on this deep dive into the mind of
- 24:21Howard Marks. Keep exploring, keep
- 24:22questioning, and we'll catch you on the next deep dive.