Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Brad Edwards And His Affidavit In Support Of Epstein Related Transparency By The DOJ (Part 2)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:05where we left off with the Brad Edwards affid David
- 0:09in regards to CVRA and documents not being produced by
- 0:13the government in light of the court's order. On October third,
- 0:16twenty eleven, the victims file a request for production with
- 0:20the government. The requests included twenty five specific requests, each
- 0:24of which linked very directly to the facts that the
- 0:27victims were attempting to prove in the case. On November seventh,
- 0:31twenty eleven, the day when the government's responses were due,
- 0:35rather than produce even a single page of discovery, the
- 0:38government filed emotion to dismiss the victim's petitions. On that
- 0:42same day, the government filed a motion to stay discovery.
- 0:45The victims filed a response arguing that the government's motion
- 0:49was a stall tactic. The victims also filed emotion to
- 0:52compel production of all their discovery requests. The government filed
- 0:57a reply arguing that it was not stalling. Indeed, the
- 1:00government told the court that the United States has agreed
- 1:03to provide some information to the victims even during the
- 1:07pendency of the stay of discovery and is undertaking a
- 1:10search for that information. Contrary to that representation. However, over
- 1:15the next seventeen months, the government did not produce any
- 1:19information to the victims, despite the victims reminding the government
- 1:23of that statement made to the court. Ultimately, after some
- 1:26additional motions and rulings, on June nineteenth, twenty thirteen, the
- 1:30Court denied the government's motion to dismiss and lifted any
- 1:34stay of discovery. That same day, the Court entered an
- 1:37order granting the victim's motion to compel and directing the
- 1:40government to produce all correspondence between it and Epstein, all
- 1:45the communications between the government and outside entities, and every
- 1:49other document requested by the victims with respect to the
- 1:53third item. The court allowed the government to assert privilege
- 1:56by producing the items in question for in camera inspection
- 2:00and filing a contemporaneous privileged log. The Court required that
- 2:04the privileged log must clearly identify each document by the author, address,
- 2:08recipient date, and general subject matter. On July nineteenth and
- 2:13July twenty seventh, twenty thirteen, the government made its production
- 2:18with regard to Item number one correspondence with Epstein. The
- 2:21government withheld the correspondence pending the ruling from the Eleventh
- 2:25Circuit on Epstein's motion to stay production of these materials.
- 2:29With regard to the other items, the government produced fourteen thousand,
- 2:33eight hundred and twenty five pages of documents to the
- 2:35court for in camera inspection, but turned over only one
- 2:39three hundred and fifty seven pages to the victims. Thus,
- 2:43the government asserted privilege to more than ninety percent of
- 2:46the documents in question. The documents that the government produced
- 2:50were almost worthless to the victims, as they included such
- 2:53things as the victim's own letters to the government, court
- 2:57pleadings filed by the victims themselves or others victims by
- 3:01Epstein or by news media organizations, public court rulings on
- 3:05Epstein related matters, public newspaper articles, and similar materials already
- 3:11available to the victims. It also included roughly four hundred
- 3:15pages of notices sent to the various other victims in
- 3:18the case, notices that were substantially indistinguishable from the notices
- 3:23the victims themselves in this case had already received. Almost
- 3:27without exception, the documents the government produced do not go
- 3:31to the disputed issues in the case. The government made
- 3:35one last production of material in the case on August six,
- 3:39twenty thirteen. This involved roughly fifteen hundred pages of documents
- 3:43that were largely meaningless in the context of the contested
- 3:46issues in the case. They included public documents in the case,
- 3:51such as the crime victim's own pleadings, copy of the
- 3:54victims redacted some rejudgment motion. Curiously, while the government has
- 3:58produced these documents that would likely fall into a relevant
- 4:02category of documents, they have simultaneously refused production of hundreds
- 4:06of other documents that are responsive to our requests on
- 4:10the basis of relevance. The victims have tried to obtain
- 4:15information on all relevant subjects through requests for admission. The government, however,
- 4:20has refused to admit many of the victim's central allegations
- 4:23in the case. A copy of the victim's requests for
- 4:26admissions and the government's response is attached to this affidavid,
- 4:30so the court can see that the victims have diligently
- 4:33tried to pursue this avenue for developing the facts in
- 4:36the case. The victims have also tried to obtain information
- 4:41on subjects related to their suit by voluntary requests for
- 4:45interview with persons who are no longer employed by the
- 4:48Justice Department. For example, I've sent letters to both Bruce
- 4:52Reinhardt and Alex Acosta, who both have information about the
- 4:56Epstein case, requesting an opportunity to discuss the case with them.
- 5:01Both of them have ignored my letters. The need for
- 5:04materials requested by the victims. The documents that the victims
- 5:08requested that the government produced to them on October third,
- 5:12twenty eleven, are all highly relevant to their CVRA enforcement action.
- 5:17We would not have requested them otherwise. The victims also
- 5:21have no other means of obtaining the requested material. This
- 5:24section of the affid David explains why the materials are
- 5:27needed by the victims for the convenience of the court.
- 5:30The affid David will proceed on a section by section
- 5:33basis concerning the need for material also for the convenience
- 5:37of the court. A copy of the October third, twenty
- 5:40eleven request for production is attached to the affid David
- 5:44also attaches the victim's supplemental discovery request of June twenty fourth,
- 5:49twenty thirteen. As the Court will note from reviewing the
- 5:52requests for production, most of the requests specifically recount the
- 5:56allegations that the requested documents would support in an effort
- 6:01to eliminate any dispute from the government that the documents
- 6:04were not relevant to the case. Many of the requests
- 6:07for production linked directly to specific paragraphs in the victim's
- 6:11previously filed summary judgment motion. Accordingly, the victims have a
- 6:16very specific need for these documents to support the allegations
- 6:20in the summary judgment motion found that De forty eight
- 6:23at three twenty three. The Court has previously concluded that
- 6:28the victim's proof of their claims is at this point
- 6:31in the case inadequate. Instead, the Court is ruled whether
- 6:34the evidentiary proofs will entitle the victims to that relief
- 6:38of setting aside the non prosecution agreement is a question
- 6:41properly reserved for the determination upon a fully developed evidentiary record.
- 6:47The Court is further indicated that it'll be considering estoppel
- 6:50argument raised by the government as a defense in the case.
- 6:54The Court is noted that this argument implicates the fact
- 6:57sensitive equitable defense, which must be considered in the historical
- 7:01factual context of the entire interface between Epstein, the relevant
- 7:06prosecutorial authorities and the federal offense victims, including an assessment
- 7:11of the allegation of a deliberate conspiracy between Epstein and
- 7:15federal prosecutors to keep the victims in the dark on
- 7:18the pendency of negotiations between Epstein and the federal authorities
- 7:23until well after the fact and presentation of the non
- 7:26prosecution agreement to them. The victims have a compelling need
- 7:31for information about the government's action, to show what the
- 7:34entire interface was and to respond to the government's estoppel
- 7:38arguments as well as other defenses that it appears to
- 7:41be preparing to raise requests for production. Number one requests
- 7:47information recording the Epstein investigation. These documents are needed to
- 7:51support the victim's allegation that the government had a viable
- 7:55criminal case for many federal sex offenses that it could
- 7:58have pursued against Epstein. RFP Number two requests information regarding
- 8:04crime victim notification In the case, these documents are needed
- 8:08to support victims allegations that their rights under CVRA their
- 8:12right to notice and to confer with the government, were
- 8:15violated in the case. In particular, these documents are needed
- 8:19to demonstrate that the victims were not properly notified about
- 8:22the non prosecution agreement entered into by the government and
- 8:26Jeffrey Epstein, and that the government did not confer with
- 8:29the victims about the agreement. RFP Number three requests information
- 8:34about the NPA, including in particular it's confidentiality provision. These
- 8:39documents are needed to demonstrate that the confidentiality provision precluded
- 8:44disclosing the agreement to Jane No. Number One and Jane No.
- 8:47Number Two, as well as to other victims. These documents
- 8:51are further needed to demonstrate that Jeffrey Epstein specifically orchestrated
- 8:55the secrecy of the agreement, thereby deliberately causing the governments
- 8:59see violation in the case. RFP number four request documents
- 9:05relating to negotiation between the government and Jeffrey Epstein concerning
- 9:09the court and or location in which Jeffrey Epstein would
- 9:13enter any guilty plea, including in particular any negotiation concerning
- 9:18concluding the plea in Miami or other location outside of
- 9:22West Palm Beach. These documents are relevant to the victim's
- 9:25allegations that the government was interested in finding a place
- 9:29to conclude any plea agreement that would effectively keep Epstein's victims,
- 9:33most of whom resided in or about Palm Beach, from
- 9:36learning what was happening through the press. RFP Number five
- 9:40requests documents pertaining to negotiation between the government and Jeffrey
- 9:44Epstein regarding any legal representation of the victims in civil
- 9:48cases by Epstein. These documents are needed to prove the
- 9:52victim's allegation that part of the plea negotiation with Epstein
- 9:55involved Epstein's efforts to make sure that victims would be
- 9:58represented in cases against Epstein by someone who was not
- 10:03experienced personal injury lawyer or by someone familiar to Epstein
- 10:07and his legal team. Number six request documents concerning the
- 10:12government and or Epstein's awareness of discussions of possible public
- 10:15criticism and the victim objections to the non prosecution agreement
- 10:19that they negotiated. The documents are needed to prove the
- 10:23victim's allegation that the government wanted the non prosecution agreement
- 10:27with Epstein concealed from public view because of the intense
- 10:30public criticism that would have resulted had the agreement been disclosed,
- 10:35and or the possibility that victims would have objected in
- 10:38court and convinced the judge not to accept the agreement.
- 10:42They are also relevant to bias and motive by the
- 10:45authors or subjects of other documents in the case. RFP
- 10:49Number seven request documents regarding the government's awareness of its
- 10:53potential CVRA obligation in the case and regarding any discussion
- 10:58between government and Epstein can discerning these CVR obligations in
- 11:02the case. The documents are needed to approve the victim's
- 11:05allegation that the government was aware that have potentially had
- 11:08obligations under the CVRA to notify the victims about the
- 11:13non prosecution agreement and any related state court plea agreement.
- 11:17RFP Number eight requests documents regarding Epstein's lobbying efforts to
- 11:22persuade the government to give him a more favorable plea
- 11:25arrangement and or non prosecution agreement, including efforts on his
- 11:29behalf by former President Bill Clinton, Prince Andrew and Harvard
- 11:33law professor Alan Dershowitz. These materials are needed to prove
- 11:38the victim's allegation that after Epstein signed the non prosecution agreement,
- 11:42his performance was delayed while he used his significant social
- 11:46and political connections to lobby the Justice Department to obtain
- 11:50a more favorable plea deal. These materials are also needed
- 11:54to establish the course of proceedings in the case, which
- 11:57is necessary in light of the government's letters to the
- 12:00victims concerning the status of the case. All Right, folks,
- 12:04we're gonna wrap up right here, and in the next
- 12:06episode dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where
- 12:08we left off. All of the information that goes with
- 12:11this episode can be found in the description box.