Latest / Film And Whiskey / Rogue One: A Star Wars Story / Jim Beam Devil's Cut Bourbon Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 2016, director Gareth Edwards and star Felicity Jones gave the
- 0:05world an emotional and expansive back story to a single line from
- 0:10a much more famous film. In 2024, we drink a whiskey
- 0:14fitting of Darth Vader. The film is Rogue One, a Star
- 0:19Wars story? The whiskey is Jim Beam Devil's
- 0:22Cut. And we'll review them both.
- 0:24This is the. Film and Whiskey Podcast
- 0:48Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:50review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:53I'm Bob Book. I'm.
- 0:57Brad Chi and we have a video component going on tonight.
- 1:00Brad, as we chat with each other and I subtly give you the finger
- 1:03for making fun of the way I talk.
- 1:07It's good to see you man. It's been a couple weeks since
- 1:09we've recorded. We got a little bit ahead
- 1:11because we both had work stuff going on.
- 1:13I literally just got back from a work trip today.
- 1:16So your boy is tired and a little bit slap happy.
- 1:20So we'll see where this episode goes, man.
- 1:22Dude, I celebrated with a buddy of mine last night.
- 1:26He is about to break ground on a house that they're building in
- 1:30Delaware. And we drank some Lafroig 10
- 1:35cask strength straight from the motherland.
- 1:38And then we drank some Lagavalin 16.
- 1:41And then we drank some barrel rye cask string.
- 1:44And I woke up at 4:00 AM and have not gone back to sleep.
- 1:49I should have called you, man. I was.
- 1:51I was in North Carolina for work.
- 1:53I rolled over because I couldn't sleep at 4:00 in the morning.
- 1:56And I said, well, I guess I'll just start driving home.
- 1:59And I could have just been talking to you.
- 2:00We could have recorded this episode while I was on the road,
- 2:02man. We sure could have.
- 2:04I don't know if our illustrious guest was up at 4:00 in the
- 2:09morning today, though. Bob no.
- 2:10And Brad, it's been a while since A we've had a guest on the
- 2:13show, but B since we've talked with our good friend Zach
- 2:16Johnston, who has been patiently waiting to say hello.
- 2:19Zach, how are you today, man? I'm doing well because I slept
- 2:23in till about seven. OK, cool.
- 2:27Well, it's been nice catching up, Zach.
- 2:28We'll talk to you in a couple weeks.
- 2:30Yeah, so whiskey movies, good times.
- 2:34Normally I introduce Zach as the spirits writer and editor for Up
- 2:38Rocks, but that is not his title anymore.
- 2:41Zach, I don't want to, I don't want to step all over your
- 2:44announcement, but let's catch Film and Whiskey Nation up a
- 2:47little bit. What's going on in your life,
- 2:48man? So I transitioned into the
- 2:53industrial side of the spirits world after eight years in media
- 2:57and about, you know, 3-4 years before that in high end
- 3:00bartending, I am now officially working for a distillery,
- 3:05Blackwood Distilling Company, which is at the moment based in
- 3:09Versailles, KY. They do Blackwood toasted Rye
- 3:12and toasted bourbon. They brought me on to help
- 3:16expand the brands and help expand into the European and
- 3:20U.S. market further because for the last few years we've been
- 3:23Kentucky only and they're gearing up for a big $200
- 3:25million distillery just South of Lexington.
- 3:28And they, you know, it's time to expand and grow into that sort
- 3:31of size of company and distillery in the spirits of the
- 3:34sphere. So I was one of the first two
- 3:37people hired on from the outside.
- 3:39And we've spent the last three months, you know, getting things
- 3:45set up in, in the EU, getting things set up in Florida, Texas,
- 3:50Wyoming and Kentucky, expanding Kentucky, you know, fixing
- 3:56little things here and there, you know, expanding our social
- 3:58media presence, having a really good time, kind of working with
- 4:03fun people, traveling in Florida way more than I thought I'd ever
- 4:07in my life, which is fun. And you know, I have time to
- 4:12watch movies like Rogue One again, which is nice.
- 4:15Yeah, you do. Perfect segue.
- 4:17Man. Well, Zach, it's so good to have
- 4:20you back and you've been very kind in sending us a bottle of
- 4:23the batch three of the toasted bourbon from Blackwood.
- 4:27So we'll be kind of sipping that all day as we talk.
- 4:29Brad, we can give some some tasting notes as we go, but I
- 4:32think it's time we dive into talking about the movie itself.
- 4:36And in order to do that, we have to get into our first segment of
- 4:39the day, which we call, Brad explains.
- 4:42Brad's gonna give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 4:45ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and hear your take with
- 4:49this little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 4:52Brad Explains is the part of the podcast where Brad breaks down
- 4:55the plot of the movie that he has just seen, often for the
- 4:59first time. Brad we are on week two in a row
- 5:02of Star Wars and I am over this already but because we I am over
- 5:08it. We have not talked at all about
- 5:10like prep for this episode. We are coming in extra blind
- 5:13today when it comes to each other's preferences here yes.
- 5:17Have you seen this movie before? I.
- 5:19Have Yeah, I saw this in theaters and I believe I watched
- 5:24it one more time with some friends.
- 5:26So this is viewing #3. I'm on viewing #2 I saw this in
- 5:31the theater and absolutely loved it.
- 5:34I bought it on Blu-ray. It has been sitting on my shelf
- 5:37for what, like seven years now and I have not returned to it at
- 5:41all. So I, I am actually less
- 5:44informed than you are on this movie, Brad.
- 5:46And because of your deep and encyclopedic knowledge of the
- 5:48Star Wars universe, you should be able to give us a great
- 5:51breakdown of the film. Now, folks, I do want to say we
- 5:55are getting into spoiler territory from the get go here.
- 5:57And this is a movie that, I mean, you kind of know the
- 6:01contours of it if you've seen A New Hope, but you don't know the
- 6:05details. And I, I do not want this movie
- 6:07to get spoiled for you. If you have any intention of
- 6:09watching Rogue One, I would say hit pause here.
- 6:13Go watch the movie and then rejoin us because Brad is about
- 6:16to drop some bombs, literally and figuratively in describing
- 6:19this film. Brad.
- 6:22I just want everybody to know that there was no one harmed in
- 6:26the dropping of bombs for this episode.
- 6:28Brad 60 seconds on the clock and go.
- 6:31Rogue One, A Star Wars Story is a film about the construction of
- 6:37the Death Star in the Star Wars universe.
- 6:40It follows a group of ragtag heroes that are unlikely to band
- 6:46together, but they do. It's so wild how they they all
- 6:51come together even though they have different goals and
- 6:53objectives. Jen Urso is our main character.
- 6:57She is trying to find her father, Galen Urso, who's a
- 7:01scientist that helped to build the Death Star.
- 7:05She finds out that he actually programmed in a fail safe.
- 7:11You can blow this up if you really want to in the Death Star
- 7:14because he doesn't want it to get built.
- 7:17And man, other things happen. The Death Star kind of blows
- 7:21things up. Jen They, they go to this this
- 7:24beach planet that's really pretty and they get the data up
- 7:29to the Alliance and Darth Vader is just incredible.
- 7:34OK, and and the spoiler is that quite literally everyone dies at
- 7:39the end of this movie. It it is a film where the actual
- 7:43fake spoiler that we give sometimes when people are like,
- 7:46oh, what happens at the end? You say everyone dies.
- 7:48Everyone No like like honestly they all.
- 7:51Die. Every single living creature in
- 7:53the universe is wiped out by the.
- 7:55It was a great like on ramp to end game an Infinity War, you
- 8:00know, all right, guys, let's dive into talking about the
- 8:05movie itself. Now.
- 8:06This was the first kind of one off.
- 8:09They called them Star Wars anthology films, which were
- 8:11meant to be separate from the Star Wars saga and and the new
- 8:15trilogy of sequels. And because of that, they wanted
- 8:18to give it some stylistic flourishes that were different
- 8:21from your regular Star Wars movie.
- 8:23It doesn't have the sort of Akira Kurosawa wipes and
- 8:26transitions. It also doesn't have an opening
- 8:29crawl. And I remember being in the
- 8:31movie theater and seeing a long time ago in the Galaxy far, far
- 8:35away. And then there's just this
- 8:37musical sting from the orchestra.
- 8:39It's just put it on and it was jarring.
- 8:43And I was immediately like, I am on board for this.
- 8:46This is really, really cool. They also are missing the
- 8:50Wilhelm screen for the first time ever.
- 8:52Really. I thought I heard it a couple
- 8:54times. Very disappointed.
- 8:57Now, do you know that for a fact, or did you just not hear
- 8:59it with your own ears? No, I know it for a fact.
- 9:02It's sorry. It's either this one or The Last
- 9:06Jedi, 'cause they both came out like back-to-back years, but one
- 9:10of them omitted the Wilhelm scream for the first time in
- 9:13Star Wars history, and I was quite disappointed with that.
- 9:17They also omitted John Williams. They sure did.
- 9:21And here's the thing about the soundtrack to this movie.
- 9:23It is not good. It's not super memorable.
- 9:26It's a cheap knock off of John Williams.
- 9:28It is 100% a cheap knock off and I can't remember exactly what
- 9:33the famous Star Wars leap is if I don't think it's a full
- 9:36octave, but the they mimic that in the sort of heroic fanfare of
- 9:44this movie's theme. There's that, there's that jump
- 9:47that sort of whatever it is, 1/5 or 1/7, I don't know what it is,
- 9:50but they mimic that exact same thing and it does not land.
- 9:54And I think even people who are not familiar with music theory,
- 9:59you can hear that they're, they're hinting at the things
- 10:02like the Imperial March will, they'll give you 4 notes of the
- 10:05imperial March and then kind of twisted into something
- 10:08different. They're doing variations on
- 10:10themes. And the thing about doing
- 10:13variations on a John Williams theme is that John Williams has
- 10:16already found the optimal way for that to be a theme that you
- 10:19remember for the rest of your life.
- 10:20And so you're automatically making music that is less
- 10:23memorable when you do that. And it's the.
- 10:26Scene. Go ahead.
- 10:27It's the scene from Amadeus, but in reverse.
- 10:30Like like Mozart has created the piece and then Salieri writes
- 10:35his worst version of it. Like, that's literally what's
- 10:38going on here. Was this Michael Giacchino who
- 10:42did the music for this one? Michael.
- 10:45Yeah, that's correct. Michael Giacchino.
- 10:46OK, I'll I'll give him a pass because he is the go to young
- 10:50composer now and he's created some of the best music of the
- 10:5321st century. Also, he he was brought on late
- 10:57to redo the whole school, so he didn't have time really to dive
- 11:00in. So I think that why a lot of
- 11:02there's a lot of illusions to John Williams as opposed to
- 11:07something fresh. On another note, can I dive into
- 11:12something that's crazy about this movie?
- 11:14Oh, please. This is probably the best cast
- 11:18of any Star Wars film that we've ever had and may ever have.
- 11:22The cast on this film is insane. Let me just let me just name a
- 11:26few names here. Donnie yen legend, Jiang Wen,
- 11:30legend. Ben Mendelsohn, basically a
- 11:33legend. Matt Mickelson, basically a
- 11:35legend. You know, Alan Taylor, Forest
- 11:37Whitaker legend, obviously, Carrie Fisher, Diego Luna,
- 11:40amazing. Felicity Jones, amazing.
- 11:43Like just that core cast alone of our core characters.
- 11:48Insane that they came together in any film, much less a star.
- 11:55I think that's, I mean, I don't, I don't even know how to compare
- 11:58it to another Star Wars film where you have a cast of just
- 12:04absolute knockouts. Every single one of them.
- 12:06Like top of their game actors. Yeah, I don't think you can
- 12:11compare it to any other Star Wars film.
- 12:12I think you're you're probably right.
- 12:13This is the best assembly of people for a movie.
- 12:17And if I could start getting into Brad like some some
- 12:20critique of the film, a film that I loved on 1st watch.
- 12:23I'm a little bit cooler on this movie this time around.
- 12:26And the cast is somewhere that I'm going to have some spicy
- 12:29takes, I think. But I am not so much a fan of
- 12:34the Force Awakens as you folks heard last week.
- 12:36But one thing that I really loved about what Abrams and
- 12:40company did with that script is they gave, they did a really
- 12:44great job with close-ups in that movie and giving people their
- 12:47sort of John Wayne in Stagecoach, like push in
- 12:51introduction to like you're a movie star now.
- 12:53John Boyega like sees this moment.
- 12:55You're a movie star. Daisy Ridley, Gareth Edwards
- 12:58doesn't do that. He's he's not concerned with
- 13:00making his actors into stars, but he also doesn't seem to be
- 13:04super concerned with giving them any chance to really like sink
- 13:08their teeth into the material. It's very exposition heavy.
- 13:12And when they're not talking, then there's long pauses of
- 13:16silence. And, and I feel like, if I'm
- 13:19being frank, if you're going to get this sort of murderer's row
- 13:22for a cast, they need something juicy and meaty to really sink
- 13:27their teeth into. And I'd, I'd kind of rather
- 13:30watch this cast in The Force Awakens than I would in this
- 13:32movie, Brad, because I just don't think that I, I think they
- 13:35painted really broad strokes in this movie.
- 13:37And I was a little bit let down by how I'm not amateurish, but
- 13:42kind of like remedial. The script was here.
- 13:45Yeah, I mean, I think that the best character development you
- 13:48have in the film is probably Alan Tudyk as K2.
- 13:54SO the robot, because he has that kind of joking relationship
- 13:59throughout, which in comparison to The Force Awakens from last
- 14:04week, the humor of the robot weirdly worked for me in this
- 14:07film. Even though it's like borderline
- 14:10Marvel humor. I, I think it works for me
- 14:14because it's coming from a non human character and like he
- 14:17doesn't have to convey facial expressions or try to be serious
- 14:21as he's delivering this comedic line.
- 14:24It works much better coming from a robot.
- 14:26I think that's why C3PO is so funny in in the original films.
- 14:32But man, you get to the end and everybody's dying and I don't
- 14:35give a rip about any of the characters dying except for the
- 14:39the freaking robot for some reason.
- 14:42Like, that's the death that I was like tearing up a little bit
- 14:45over. Right.
- 14:47And it's the sort of thing where like, I think also, you know,
- 14:50let's very quickly, what is Star Wars?
- 14:52Like an actual Star Wars? Star Wars is great because they
- 14:55have that one cinematic moment that makes you jump out of your
- 14:58seat in the cinema. It's when Luke uses the force in
- 15:01the trench to blow up the Death Star.
- 15:03It's when Vader says, I know I'm your father.
- 15:05An Empire return to Genet doesn't have one.
- 15:08That's why it kind of sucks, you know?
- 15:11Come on man, Vader picking up, picking up the Emperor and the
- 15:15electricity. You knew that was coming.
- 15:17Like it wasn't that like, Oh my God moment.
- 15:19Whereas in like I, I remember I saw Phantom Menace in the
- 15:22theater like opening day 1999. I was 20 years old.
- 15:26The moment that Maul comes out, those doors open and he they
- 15:29throw off their robes and like, we'll take we can handle this.
- 15:33People lost their shit in the theater like they did.
- 15:35Then when Vader revealed he was his father, the same thing
- 15:38attacked the clones. That movie has a lot of
- 15:40detractors, but when the Jedi show up in Geonesus and all turn
- 15:44on their lightsabers, I know people who have a tattoo of that
- 15:48scene on them because it's another one of those holy shit
- 15:50moments. Again, Revenge of the Sith,
- 15:52Anakin and Obi Wan. That battle is an oh shit
- 15:55moment. Force Awakens doesn't have one.
- 15:58It was supposed to be when Rey catches the lightsaber in the
- 16:00forest. I was there and nobody gave a
- 16:03shit. I can tell you though, in Last
- 16:06Jedi when Luke showed up, I watched an entire row of 10 year
- 16:10olds jump out of their seat and scream and joy seeing Luke show
- 16:13up to fight Kylo Ren. It had that ocean moment.
- 16:16Rise of Skywalker obviously didn't have it at all.
- 16:19This movie has that moment. It has a pure Star Wars moment,
- 16:23which is Vader shows up in that hallway in the mist and that
- 16:27lightsaber turns on and we get to finally see Vader fighting
- 16:31non force people and just going to town.
- 16:34Like I'm a huge fan of the Vader comics and sort of that whole
- 16:39mythos of what he actually did and how he became Vader after,
- 16:44after the fight on Mustafar and seeing him.
- 16:47Like people jumped out of their seat the same way they did when
- 16:51Ball shows up and Naboo, the same way that my dad saw people
- 16:54jump out of their seat when Vader revealed he's Luke's
- 16:57father. And that's what Star Wars is
- 16:59Like. Yes, there's all the other
- 17:00stuff, but Star Wars succeeds as a film on moments like that,
- 17:06that you walk out and you're like, holy, did you see the
- 17:09double edged lightsaber? And that's all you talk about,
- 17:11right? Or it's like, I, I remember
- 17:14like, and this is me. You know, I, like I said, I just
- 17:17as the quick preface, when I was five, I had the full Return of
- 17:21the Jedi like bed set, like the comforter, the pillows, the
- 17:24curtains, the whole Ewok playset, everything.
- 17:29But my dad had Empire, right? And that was like the moment he
- 17:33said people jumped out of their seats, they couldn't believe it.
- 17:35And I never really got that until that moment in Phantom
- 17:38Menace where I was like, holy. And then I got that again.
- 17:41I got to have that again with this movie where Vader shows up
- 17:45and just slaughters fools. And it's like, I got it twice.
- 17:48We're like, wow, this is amazing.
- 17:51And so for me, this film works perfectly as a Star Wars film
- 17:55because Gareth Edwards and Tony Gilroy understood that.
- 17:58They understood like we need this to be a Star Wars film.
- 18:01And where JJ sort of falls down is he didn't understand that
- 18:05because neither of his films have that like he has.
- 18:08He has people riding horses on a * destroyer, which is so stupid.
- 18:12But also the whole the whole fight between Rey and Kylo in
- 18:18the forest, it's like it's not that moment because it's just,
- 18:22it's, it's, I understand it's yes, her using the force just
- 18:25like Luke did and blah, blah, blah.
- 18:27And New Hope. I get the, the whole parallel
- 18:29there, don't get me wrong, But it's not the same thing because
- 18:32it, it, it's not a triumphant moment.
- 18:35The the Death Star in Force Awakens has already been blown
- 18:37up. That's already over.
- 18:38She had nothing to do with that. And so, you know, it's this
- 18:42weird thing where I feel like with Gareth Edwards and then, of
- 18:45course, Tony Gilroy taking over in the end there and working
- 18:47with Gareth to sort of reshoot a lot of this film.
- 18:51They understood was like, hey, this is this is what Star Wars
- 18:55is as core, where you walk out and you're like, holy shit, that
- 18:59was amazing. Yeah.
- 19:01And like you said, I think it's like you walked out actually,
- 19:03and you were like hiked on it, right?
- 19:04Oh, 100% right. Yeah.
- 19:07Like you, you walk out of Rogue One.
- 19:10I'll give just kind of my initial take from, you know, a
- 19:13decade ago almost, I remember watching walking out of this
- 19:17film and thinking the first half of this movie was like flaming
- 19:22hot garbage. I don't give a rip about any of
- 19:25these characters cause none of them are interesting.
- 19:28They all just kind of have A and then mentality of.
- 19:33Like way too much till not show like.
- 19:36Yeah, yeah, there's there's so much of that.
- 19:39And then the second-half of this film, I was like, that felt like
- 19:43a Star Wars movie. Like the battle scenes, the
- 19:46connection between Jin and what's his name, Cassian, right?
- 19:52This like the connection between them in the midst of battle.
- 19:55Like that's something you get in good Star Wars films, capped off
- 19:59with maybe a top three scene in All Star Wars films of Vader
- 20:06just being awesome. And like the when he walks in,
- 20:11the shadows almost look like they have like tendrils.
- 20:14Like they're like they are. A demonic embodiment of evil
- 20:19that you couldn't quite do in 1977.
- 20:22And so I, I walked out of the film going, man, if I could just
- 20:26get rid of the first half and just watch like, you know, maybe
- 20:30add a little bit, but like an hour and 15 minutes.
- 20:33Oh my gosh, the ending was incredible.
- 20:36So maybe this would be a good time for me to give a little bit
- 20:38of my personal history with the movie too, Brad, because as you
- 20:41know, I am not a Star Wars fan and I wouldn't call myself a
- 20:46Star Wars hater. But they've just never worked
- 20:49for me. And so even in moments where I
- 20:54am like supportive of Star Wars and the people in my life who
- 20:58love it, I find myself having to work really hard to, to feel
- 21:02excitement. You know, like I went on
- 21:05Christmas, Christmas night in 2015 to go see Force Awakens.
- 21:11I took like, we took like eight people.
- 21:13I got a gift card for Christmas. I bought everyone's tickets.
- 21:16And then like, my gift card was gone.
- 21:18But we went, went to see Force Awakens.
- 21:20And I could see how excited everybody was to see that
- 21:22opening crawl come up again. And I'm like, I want to be as
- 21:26excited as you guys are. Rogue One is the first time.
- 21:30And I think it was because it it was it didn't have the burden of
- 21:34being a Star Wars movie. It was just a movie that existed
- 21:37within the wars of the stars. That was just like, it was a
- 21:42completely separate thing. And it was the first time that I
- 21:45had the ocean moment when Vader comes in at the end.
- 21:48I like in the theater, I was like, oh, shit, like it's it's
- 21:53happening now. And that sent me out on such a
- 21:56high. But if I'm being honest, this is
- 22:00this is my problem with Gareth Edwards movies, whether it's his
- 22:03Godzilla movie or he made a movie last year called the
- 22:06creator. He creates the most brilliant
- 22:11cinematic images. Like there's such a sense of
- 22:14scale. I don't know if he's doing if
- 22:16anyone does scale like him, except for maybe Denis
- 22:19Villeneuve. Like when you can literally see
- 22:21the height the way that like Star Destroyers are filmed in
- 22:25this movie. It's the coolest the ships have
- 22:27ever looked in a Star Wars movie.
- 22:30And yet I think it says a lot about the flimsiness of the
- 22:34script and Edward's inability to really make you ever care about
- 22:38characters that we have just watched our lead characters die
- 22:44a horrific death in what is essentially a nuclear explosion.
- 22:48And then we immediately forget about them because he tacks on
- 22:52this ending of like, but Vader do cool thing now.
- 22:55And you're just like, yeah. And so I think that that's like
- 22:59that's the the dichotomy here is like the the stuff that we
- 23:03should be caring about falls away so quickly because he knows
- 23:07that we just want that immediate heroine hit of Vader killing
- 23:12guys. And here's my here's my spicy
- 23:14take on Star Wars in general. And and Brad, I know you're a
- 23:17fan as well. And I think true fans understand
- 23:20flaws as much as they understand the shine, right?
- 23:23And Star Wars has always been deeply flawed.
- 23:27Like you go back and look at the script of that first film.
- 23:29The dialogue's terrible, like it's literally terrible.
- 23:33And the. They've talked about that in so
- 23:36many interviews where Harrison Ford is like, George, you go out
- 23:40there and say this fucking shit. Yeah, and also there's a lot of,
- 23:44there's a lot of fat on that film too.
- 23:46Like that film is way too long. Empire, that whole it's, it's 30
- 23:51minutes. A Hoth where you're just like
- 23:53couldn't have been in the scrawl.
- 23:54Like I don't really need to see this.
- 23:56Like there I've been through phases of my life where I've
- 23:58just skipped over Hoth entirely and gone straight into the movie
- 24:03when, you know, the movie starts.
- 24:05So it's the sort of thing where I always feel like with Star
- 24:10Wars, people try to find reasons to gloss over the problems with
- 24:16the scripts, the problems with the filmmaking, the problems
- 24:19with the ACT. Well, I don't really want to
- 24:20blame actors because it's the director's choice.
- 24:22It's the editor's choice. Like the actors are doing their
- 24:24job. I don't want to be like, oh, Riz
- 24:26Ahmed, you know, didn't do his, didn't act right.
- 24:28It's like, well, no, he was being told what to do by Carrot
- 24:31Edwards and Tony Gilroy. And like, he's doing his best in
- 24:34like, Rogue One, for instance. But it's for me, it's like Star
- 24:37Wars is campy fun, you know what I mean?
- 24:41And then it's also really fucking boring.
- 24:44And sometimes you got to skip over the boring parts.
- 24:45Like I said, I often skip over Hoth.
- 24:47And for some people that's probably blasphemy.
- 24:49But also like, I don't, I can't remember the last time I watched
- 24:52Return of the Jedi. Like it would probably was when
- 24:55I was a little kid or it was on in the background at a party or
- 24:59something, you know what I mean? Because like, I don't need to
- 25:01watch it. I watched Rise of Skywalk
- 25:02Skywalker once in the theater. Never need to see that again,
- 25:06you know what I mean? And it's the and it's the story.
- 25:09You don't like the film. What I like about Rogue One and
- 25:14why I rewatch that pretty much every year.
- 25:15And like I said, I rewatch it twice for this is that film
- 25:18technically, which is this is really where you're just
- 25:20supposed to say, but bear with me.
- 25:21This film kind of stands alone, which is crazy because it's a
- 25:25prequel so tied to something so specific and has such beautiful
- 25:30detailed work. Like when you rewatch New Hope,
- 25:33you notice when they're that first scene in the Death Star
- 25:36with Peter Cushing and Vader and all the generals, there's one
- 25:39empty seat that's Chronic's seat because Chronic was, you know,
- 25:44down on down on the beach, you know?
- 25:46So there's all these wonderful little details and illusions
- 25:49that you can draw the two together and they connect, you
- 25:51know, like 2 octopuses coming together to Make Love or
- 25:54something. But it's the sort of thing where
- 25:57you can really let this movie stand alone and watch it and
- 26:00have a great experience and it doesn't matter.
- 26:03Like, yeah, they got the Death Star plans for the rebels.
- 26:05They're going to blow it up. It doesn't matter.
- 26:07Like, it almost makes me hope kind of like, unnecessary in
- 26:11that sense. The story's over.
- 26:14And for me, as a cinephile and someone who loves story, I'm a
- 26:19huge sucker for the tragic ending.
- 26:23You know, the the heroes sacrifice themselves for the
- 26:26greater good. I mean, that's for me why like
- 26:28Pixar cars is so great because, you know, like including
- 26:32sacrifices his win for the greater good to help someone
- 26:35else out. He doesn't take this trophy.
- 26:37He, you know, he chooses to help win or, you know, there's, you
- 26:42know, you know, Godfather's so great because Michael Corleone
- 26:45becomes, you know, he loses everything by becoming the
- 26:48godfather, you know, and even his wife and his children, which
- 26:52he, you know, and it's, it's that tragedy of like, you know,
- 26:55the American dream, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 26:57And I so for me, like seeing them die on the beach, it's
- 27:00like, yeah, they're that's the sacrifice you have to make for
- 27:03good, right? And that sort of.
- 27:06I mean, Zach, I've always said, and I'm glad you you brought
- 27:10this up. I've always said to Brad, Cassie
- 27:12and Andor is the Lightning McQueen of the Star Wars
- 27:16universe. And he always said that there's
- 27:18no way but but I'm glad you really backed me.
- 27:21Up on It's been a common back and forth in our texting, yes.
- 27:24Now, you brought up something, though, Zach, that I think is
- 27:26really important, and it is. It's that this movie really does
- 27:29stand alone, both thematically and in terms of like, how dour
- 27:32it is. But unfortunately, I think that
- 27:36the endless Star Wars machine churning over the last eight
- 27:40years by Disney has really reduced the power of this movie.
- 27:45It's not the movie's fault, but I have been so inundated with
- 27:48advertisements for freaking and the and or TV show and the Obi
- 27:52Wan Kenobi show and the Mandalorian and now the Acolyte
- 27:55that it's like we had never seen a boots on the ground Star Wars
- 28:00movie like this before. And it was the coolest, most
- 28:03revolutionary thing to hit this series in a long, long time.
- 28:07But now watching it, it's like, oh, this is, this is really
- 28:10similar to watching any of those Star Wars TV shows.
- 28:13It's it's better than them, but I think that it's diluted the
- 28:17effect that the movie had at the time.
- 28:20I will say though if and OR is worth watching that is a
- 28:23phenomenal series because they keep with the same theme and
- 28:28look of the film or one it's all actually shot on location
- 28:32instead of that stupid 3D screen shows so it feels real.
- 28:36It's got the same vibe to it and it is it is dour.
- 28:39I mean, it is hardcore, like, you know, politics of like what
- 28:44it's actually like to live under a fascistic empire and, you
- 28:48know, you know, people are literally tortured to madness
- 28:50and things like that. And so again, I'm kind of a
- 28:56sucker for that because it kind of fits into where I am now as a
- 29:01Star Wars fan. Like if I was in my mid 20s when
- 29:05all this stuff was coming out, I'd probably think it's like
- 29:07ridiculous, you know what I mean?
- 29:09But just it's, it's, it's all where it hits you, right?
- 29:12Like I think we're like about 10 years apart age wise.
- 29:15And so like, you know, I totally, you know, me kind of
- 29:18menacing me when I was 20 was, you know, it was sort of like,
- 29:24you know, I took a date, you know what I mean?
- 29:25Like it was a date night for me. And so, you know, it was that
- 29:28sort of thing where there is a different expectation there as a
- 29:33young adult as opposed to if I was 10.
- 29:36I mean, that movie, I would probably still think that was
- 29:38the best Star Wars movie of all time, you know what I mean?
- 29:40Because it was because that that's what it was made for.
- 29:42And that's what I think what's so interesting about Rogue One
- 29:46is Rogue One was made for a wider audience where, and George
- 29:49Lucas says this over and over and over again.
- 29:52His Star Wars films are made for children.
- 29:55One was not made for children and, and, or is not made for
- 29:59children. And I think where Star Wars
- 30:03really starts to fall down is like in The Acolyte and Boba
- 30:06Fett and all those where it's like, yeah, these are just shows
- 30:08made for kids that should be animated but aren't because they
- 30:10want to do a live action. And it's like, you know,
- 30:13Lucasfilm understood this, and that's the way they made Rebels
- 30:15and Clone Wars and all those things animated because they're
- 30:17for kids. When you bring those people into
- 30:19the real world, and especially in what was the the latest one,
- 30:24Ahsoka, whereas like there's brilliant moments in there, but
- 30:27the overall it's like, these are cartoon characters and I hate
- 30:30them because they're acting like cartoon characters and quote UN
- 30:34quote real life because it doesn't transfer, right?
- 30:37And that's the feeling of Disney's, like you said, churn
- 30:40of just like pushing the stuff and pushing and pushing.
- 30:43And you know my only response is hey, just watch the good stuff
- 30:46and ignore the rest, right? Yeah, yeah, I'm, I'm with you on
- 30:50that man. They, they have put out so much
- 30:53stuff that it, it, it loses its value.
- 30:57Like there's a, there's a huge reason why Episode one did so
- 31:02well and why The Force Awakens did so well because there was
- 31:06what, 9/10/10 years between Revenge of the Sith and The
- 31:13Force Awakens and 15 years, 16 years between Return of the Jedi
- 31:19and Phantom Menace, right. And so it's like you kind of
- 31:24need a little bit of time for the films to walk off into the
- 31:29sunset and just remain in your memory and for them to come back
- 31:33and have the impact. And I'm sorry, I don't mean to
- 31:36be so monopolizing here, but I think also the one smart thing
- 31:40Disney knew, or at least Kathleen Kennedy knew going into
- 31:44the reboot when it became Disney.
- 31:46It's like, OK, we're going to do Force Awakens for the reboot,
- 31:50for the fans, for the kids, but let's also do one for the
- 31:53grown-ups who were alive when the first ones came out.
- 31:57And so that's why those two films came out so close to each
- 32:00other, right? So that's sort of yin and Yang
- 32:02where it's like, yeah, but we also have fans who are 40 now
- 32:06who who have, you know, more complex thought processes and
- 32:10understand, like, hey, this is actually a kind of amazing world
- 32:14that Lucas created here. We can dig in a little bit more.
- 32:18But then like you said, you can go off and I mean, I don't know
- 32:21how much you guys read like the books or like I said, I'm really
- 32:23into the major comic books and like, I know the animated shows
- 32:27from the early 2000s decently. I didn't watch them religiously
- 32:31or anything. I know like the Canon and things
- 32:34like that. And I I collected, you know, the
- 32:36cards in the 80s and 90s and blah, blah, blah.
- 32:40But it's the sort of thing where, you know, this film,
- 32:44Rogue One, I believe, does fan service and, and this is so
- 32:48rarely done, but right where it's like, yes, it is 100%
- 32:51there. There's so much fan service on
- 32:53this, but it's never flashing in your face.
- 32:56It's been with Vader at the end being the most ridiculous thing
- 33:01ever. But it's amazing because it's,
- 33:03it's, it's what it's that scene is only like 30 seconds long
- 33:07too. It's not him fighting for 5
- 33:09minutes at the end of the film. It's like, no, this is instant
- 33:12because he's a God, said Lord. He's a magical space wizard and
- 33:16this, this is how it would be. There's no contest here.
- 33:19And that's the thing I hate about like especially in the
- 33:21Acolyte where they forget their Jedi, where it's like, how about
- 33:25you just read their mind? You're a Jedi, you know, like,
- 33:27you know what I mean or whatever.
- 33:28It's like you read that guy's mind like last scene.
- 33:30Why aren't you reading it now? You know, Sorry, I had a
- 33:32digression there. But it's like they don't forget
- 33:34what everyone is like. Jen Erso is just a rebel.
- 33:39Cassian is just a person. He's a rebel.
- 33:42You know, Galen, Yeah, he's a he's an engineer.
- 33:44You know, I, I love the new take where he's ethical Oppenheimer.
- 33:49But he's still, he's still just a person, right?
- 33:52And he's, he's trying to exist in this world.
- 33:54And even Krennick is just a bureaucrat.
- 33:57And so, you know, yes, Krennick is sort of, you know, very
- 34:00lightly associated with with Vader as his kind of overlord
- 34:05boss, but not really like his day-to-day is bureaucracy.
- 34:08And you see it. I, I sent you the the jiff of
- 34:11him when he first gets to Galen and on the Iceland planet,
- 34:15whatever it's called. And it's like farming really
- 34:18like, you know, it's almost an insult to him.
- 34:20And just I love the whole scene because he like it's Ben
- 34:23Mendelsohn and Matt Mickelson. So they're phenomenal.
- 34:26But just like, oh, your wife died.
- 34:28That's really a shame. And just his way of like
- 34:30conveying like, I know you're bullshitting me.
- 34:33Can we just, you know, jump? Can we cut to the chase here?
- 34:36Cut to the chase. Like, come on, you, you don't
- 34:39insult my intelligence. I know you're a genius engineer,
- 34:41but it's not insulting my intelligence.
- 34:43We're old friends. And, you know, it's this like
- 34:45nice subtlety between those two actors, which they can pull off
- 34:49because they're phenomenal actors, right?
- 34:52Where you don't get that with a lot of people cast in these
- 34:55movies. Yeah, I was going to say that
- 34:57the opening scene is incredible. It is so sharp.
- 35:02And for me, Bob, like you talked about the impact of not having
- 35:05the fanfare of jumping right into a scene.
- 35:08I felt the same way the first time I watched this.
- 35:11I like I was like, hey, if we're going to do a spin off Star Wars
- 35:17movie, like sure, let's change a few things up.
- 35:20And there's not a lot of sacred cows for me in the Star Wars
- 35:24universe. As long as I feel like the
- 35:27director respects the Star Wars universe.
- 35:30And I think that's which, yeah, Gareth, Gareth Edwards 100% does
- 35:35in the way he makes this film. I mean, even the little tiny fan
- 35:38service things, like whenever they fly into Yavin 4 and you
- 35:41see the random guy in the tower, like, tracking them in, you
- 35:45know, like, yeah, like it's a tiny, little fan service thing
- 35:48that that doesn't detract or out of the plot.
- 35:51It just gives you a beautiful panorama to look at for a few
- 35:55seconds. And it kind of scratches the
- 35:57Star Wars itch. So yeah, that I think there's a
- 35:59lot of things to like here in Rogue One.
- 36:03All right, guys, I think we're at a good spot to hit pause here
- 36:06when we come back from break it. You know, in addition to two
- 36:09facts and a falsehood. Let's talk about the cast a
- 36:12little bit because I still have to get my spicy takes about the
- 36:14cast out of the way. But I think it's all tied in
- 36:16with this Gareth Edwards soup where I can't tell if it's the
- 36:20way he directs his actors or if there's just not a lot for some
- 36:23of them to do. But but there are definitely
- 36:26peaks and valleys to the cast list here.
- 36:28So we'll hit on that when we get back from break.
- 36:31Brad, it's time for us to go drink some Jim Beam Devil's Cut.
- 36:35What do you say? Get the devil in me, Bob.
- 36:44All right, so today we are checking out Jim Beam Devil's
- 36:47Cut Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey.
- 36:50This is the second in the Jim Beam sort of mini series that
- 36:54we're doing to round out the season here, Brad.
- 36:56And I have to be honest with you, I'm I'm very familiar with
- 36:59this product. I don't know if I've ever tried
- 37:01it before. Yeah, I've seen it many times on
- 37:04the shelves. It's it's a somewhat distinct
- 37:07bottle on the lower shelves of the whiskey aisle.
- 37:13I have never drank it. I remember very distinctly when
- 37:16it came out, 'cause I was working at a grocery store at
- 37:18the time and they were running a whole bunch of ads.
- 37:22That was really playing up the bad ass Ness of this bottle.
- 37:25And do you know who their spokesperson was at the time?
- 37:27Brad, I don't know if you remember these ads.
- 37:29Ozzy Osbourne. It was Kid Rock.
- 37:32Hey, the baddest of asses. And man, I feel like the bourbon
- 37:36industry has come a long way from that.
- 37:39Was like the biggest name attached to bourbon at the time.
- 37:41It was like, whoa, Kid Rock. Yeah, the the whiskey industry
- 37:45has indeed come a long, long way to the point where now they can
- 37:50charge, you know, hundreds if not thousands of dollars for
- 37:53whiskeys that probably don't deserve that that type of a
- 37:56hype, Bob. But not, crucially, for Jim Beam
- 38:00Devil's Cut 'cause this is still a bargain whiskey if ever I've
- 38:04seen one. Now what I understand of the
- 38:06process, Brad and I'm I'm going to go ahead and read the copy on
- 38:09the side of the bottle here to lay lay some groundwork for
- 38:13those who are not familiar with Devil's Cut.
- 38:15They say while bourbon ages and the angels share evaporates,
- 38:19some also remains trapped inside the barrel.
- 38:22This is the devil's cut. We extract this dark and intense
- 38:27liquid from our charred white oak barrel walls and blend it
- 38:31with extra aged bourbon. So that is the process folks.
- 38:34They found a way to extract the devil's cut out of the wood and
- 38:38then kind of infuse it back into their regular bourbon.
- 38:41I have it on good authority from people in the industry that
- 38:44there really is some sort of proprietary way that they do
- 38:46this. I don't know what it is, but
- 38:48it's not complete BS. It is a gimmick, but it is a
- 38:51gimmick that has reality attached to it.
- 38:53So, you know, I'm OK with a gimmick as long as it's not a
- 38:56made-up gimmick. Yeah, 100%.
- 39:00The best that I can tell from reading more about it online,
- 39:03everybody seems to be in agreement that what they do is
- 39:06they add a little bit of water to the empty barrel, set it out
- 39:10in the sun and let it heat up and evaporate the liquid out of
- 39:15the wood and back into. That's the proprietary thing is
- 39:18like hey go rinse the barrel. Yep, it's just the barrel back
- 39:22washing. Yeah, supposedly there's some
- 39:25sort of like agitation that also happens.
- 39:29So I, I like to think that they just hire like an Andre the
- 39:32Giant look alike to like shake the barrel, like he's just
- 39:35walking around. Squeezing the Steve the staves
- 39:38like he's ringing out a rag. Yeah, yes.
- 39:41All right. So this is 90 proof.
- 39:43It is not age stated, but we know that it is at least four
- 39:46years old because of that. So Brad, let's go ahead and dive
- 39:49into Jim Beam. Devil's cut.
- 39:51What are you picking up on the nose here?
- 39:53Oak, Bob there, there's some oak and then there's some oak.
- 39:58There's a little bit of burnt caramel.
- 40:00It gets a little bit peanutty. There's a bit of like a sour
- 40:05young apple peel vibe going on. I'm not a huge fan here.
- 40:14It's not bad. 5 1/2. I don't know if I've ever really
- 40:18experienced a bourbon smelling thin on on the nose.
- 40:22It doesn't smell like not potent.
- 40:24It just smells like it's going to be a really thin whiskey.
- 40:26And that's OK. You know, it has that classic
- 40:29beam nuttiness that we've talked about last week and, and in many
- 40:32prior reviews. There's a lot of peanut butter
- 40:35here underneath the oak. It's not super complex, but the
- 40:38oak gives it a spice. The peanut butter gives it that
- 40:40nice kind of round sweetness. I do get a really weird note,
- 40:44Brad, and it I am, I am cataloging this for my future
- 40:48fat guy tasting notes here. You know how when you get
- 40:51Chinese takeout, everything kind of smells like MSG a little bit
- 40:58Like it just kind of hangs on the paper bag.
- 41:00And it reminds me of like when I'm going to eat the fortune
- 41:03cookie at the end of the Chinese meal, but there's still the the
- 41:07smell of like fried rice hanging around.
- 41:09I don't know how to explain it. It's like cookie with MSG.
- 41:13And that is a note I don't think I've ever had on a bourbon
- 41:16before, man. Yeah.
- 41:18I, I mean, it's a proprietary process, Bob.
- 41:20So you're gonna get some proprietary nosings here.
- 41:24All that said, I don't. I don't hate this.
- 41:26I'm gonna give it a 7 out of 10. Man, that, that's a lot higher
- 41:29than me, Bob. I was not quite as impressed
- 41:32taste wise. I'll come up a little bit from
- 41:35my nosing score. I'll give it a six out of 10 on
- 41:38the pallet. The apple peel comes through a
- 41:40little stronger. The oak turns into like a
- 41:43charred oak. There's a little bit of cinnamon
- 41:46here. It's watery Bob I I don't know
- 41:50how else to explain it, but it it does not taste as viscous as
- 41:54it ought to at 90 proof like it. To me this feels like an 80
- 41:58proof whiskey. I don't like this, Brad.
- 42:03Yeah, I'm going to be honest here.
- 42:05And you know what? We have had the master distiller
- 42:07of Jim Beam on our show before. Wonderful guy.
- 42:10They make a myriad of products that I thoroughly enjoy.
- 42:15This is not one of them. It is really, really thin in
- 42:18terms of mouthfeel, but the bitterness from that oak
- 42:22extraction, it doesn't even taste like oak to me.
- 42:25It tips into almost chemically like it's just a really bitter,
- 42:30you could call it herbal, but it almost tastes artificial.
- 42:33And that's like, it's a, it's a type of bitter that I only
- 42:36really associate with very low grade cheap whiskey.
- 42:41And that's what I'm getting here, man.
- 42:43And it, and I think because of that oakiness, it's kind of
- 42:46compounding that bitterness and that chemically flavor for me.
- 42:49I'm only going to give this a 5 out of 10 on the palate.
- 42:52And I think that's being generous for me.
- 42:54Yeah, 100%, dude. I think the finish just kind of
- 42:57disappears on me. There's a little bit of oak and
- 43:00black pepper, but there is nothing happening on the finish.
- 43:054 1/2 for me here. I, I really don't have a ton to
- 43:08say, Bob. Yeah, the finish is not quite as
- 43:10bad for me. I do get a little bit of that
- 43:12apple peel that you were mentioning.
- 43:14It comes out at the end and some of those cinnamon notes.
- 43:16So it is a slight rebound, but even then it's it's just wisps
- 43:20of flavor because it's such a thin whiskey.
- 43:24I think I'll give it a 5 1/2 on the finish.
- 43:29Yeah, balance wise, there's nothing to write home about
- 43:34here. I'll give it a 5 out of 10.
- 43:38I don't know, we might as well get into value pretty soon here.
- 43:42Yeah, I'll, I'll give it a six out of 10 on balance because
- 43:45again, this is a very inexpensive whiskey.
- 43:47I don't expect a lot from inexpensive whiskeys, especially
- 43:50in today's market. That has nothing to do with what
- 43:52I'm going to say on value, but it is a, it is a perfectly fine,
- 43:58very cheap whiskey. So I'll give it a six there.
- 44:01Now Brad, to my knowledge, this is still going for somewhere in
- 44:04the 20s, right? $19.99 in the.
- 44:08State of there you go baby. Now again, when we talk value,
- 44:13Brad and I often operate from different points of view.
- 44:15I usually look at it from, is this overpriced given the
- 44:19market? Brad usually looks at it from
- 44:22one of two perspective, which is would I just pay that much for
- 44:26this whiskey or is there another whiskey out there at this price
- 44:30that I think is way better? And so I think we give a a nice
- 44:33picture of overall value here for the market.
- 44:37This is not a bad value because you really can't get whiskey for
- 44:39much cheaper than this unless you're going to knock all the
- 44:41way down to Benchmark. Here's the thing though, Brad, I
- 44:45think Benchmark's probably a better whiskey than this.
- 44:47It's certainly, Yep, it certainly doesn't have those
- 44:50bitter notes that are off putting to me the way that this
- 44:53one does. So I think on every metric that
- 44:56we can judge value, this one is probably not going to fare very
- 45:00well. I'm just going to give this a 5
- 45:03out of 10 on value. Yeah, I, I'm 100% with you, man.
- 45:075 out of 10 on value. I I liked the double oaked Bob
- 45:11and I, I think if you're going for an oakier version of Jim
- 45:15Beam, go spend 20 bucks on that. Don't spend it on the Devil's
- 45:19Cut. I'm coming to a 26 out of 50.
- 45:23I'm just a little bit higher than you.
- 45:24I'm at a 28.5 which puts us at a 54 1/2 out of 100 or just a
- 45:3027.25 out of 50 on average. This is really close to, if not
- 45:37the lowest rated whiskey of the season for us.
- 45:39Brad and I. I would say like just in plain
- 45:43honesty here, this is a misfire from Jim Beam.
- 45:46I'm really surprised that this thing has lasted as long as it
- 45:49has on the market. I imagine people are using this
- 45:52as a mixer and I think it probably might make a good
- 45:56whiskey and Coke just because there is so much oak and
- 45:58bitterness to it, it it would really stand out versus a Coke.
- 46:03Unfortunately we don't sample our whiskeys with Coke when
- 46:06we're deciding if it's a good whiskey or not, so I I can't
- 46:09really speak to that. Did did you just say,
- 46:11Unfortunately we don't do that? I mean, I would like to every
- 46:15now and then. That sounds nice.
- 46:17I'm not a cola guy. Oh my gosh dude, every now and
- 46:21then you like truly dig your heels in on just the weirdest
- 46:24stuff. Like everyone likes a Coca-Cola.
- 46:28What do you mean you're not a cola guy?
- 46:30I I don't like any colas Bubba RC.
- 46:35Oh man, maybe you did grow up poor after all.
- 46:38Brad, I, I know that brand very well.
- 46:43Oh man. All right.
- 46:45Do we recommend this product? I'm going to say no.
- 46:47No. Yeah, OK, let's get back into
- 46:50talking about this movie with our friend Zach Johnston.
- 46:53What do you say? Let's get to it, man.
- 47:00All right, everybody, That was Jim Beam.
- 47:04Devil's poop. No, that wasn't that bad.
- 47:06Come on, man. Hey, by the way, did you did you
- 47:09like my my comparison to Darth Vader talking about devil's cut?
- 47:13Do you get it 'cause he's kind of like the devil Also also his
- 47:17lightsaber, it cuts. Yeah, it does cut.
- 47:21And it's red. This is this operates on so many
- 47:24levels. Brad, you are.
- 47:28That's why they called me the master of metaphor.
- 47:32That's my basketball 1970s basketball player nickname.
- 47:35The. Master of metaphor.
- 47:39I feel like if you were a coach in the 70s, that would be your
- 47:42nickname. Me and Red Auerbach just smoking
- 47:45cigars and coming up with convoluted nicknames.
- 47:49Turning off the hot water to the opposing locker room.
- 47:51I love it. All right, dude, let's get into
- 47:54two facts and a falsehood. Brad is gonna try to stump your
- 47:58ball. 2 All right and what is wrong?
- 48:042 Facts and a falsehood. Two Facts and a Falsehood is the
- 48:08part of the show where Brad presents me with three items as
- 48:11fact about the making of this movie, one of which is a
- 48:15complete lie. Brad, I have been on just an
- 48:17absolute horrible streak lately for myself.
- 48:21Luckily, I have a ringer here today to help me out.
- 48:24So the way this usually works, folks, is that if we have a
- 48:27guest and I choose to enlist his or her help, I can get one win
- 48:33in the win column if we guess correctly.
- 48:35But if we lose, I can get two losses in the loss column.
- 48:39So it kind of throws off the tallying a little bit, but it
- 48:43raises the stakes quite a bit. I can already tell you that I am
- 48:46going to enlist Zach today because I don't know anything
- 48:51about the Star Wars universe. Frankly, I also do not care that
- 48:55much so. So.
- 48:58So this is basically all made-up. 100%.
- 49:01Man, so Anakin Skywalker became Darth, and I'm kidding.
- 49:07Spoilers. All right man, hit me with your
- 49:10two facts and a falsehood. Fact #1 Alan Tudyk, voice of K2
- 49:16SO also voiced fan favorite character HK47 in the critically
- 49:21acclaimed video game series Star Wars Knights of the Old
- 49:25Republic. Fact #2 Anthony Daniels was
- 49:29jokingly disgruntled that Alan Tudyk was allowed to pay play K2
- 49:33SO in the relative comfort of a motion capture suit, whereas
- 49:37Daniels had to endure years of discomfort and injuries in the
- 49:40C3PO costume. Fact #3 This is, I know you're
- 49:46getting sick of him. This is Alan Tudic's second time
- 49:50portraying a robot in a film, the first being in 2004's I,
- 49:54Robot. Let me frankly make a confession
- 50:00to you here, Brad. You got another confession to
- 50:03make. Alan Tudic is a guy that I
- 50:07recognize his face, like when I see him in the cast list and I
- 50:10know that he's done things that have like large fan bases, like
- 50:14I don't know if he was involved in Doctor Who or like what what
- 50:17else he's from. I don't know a lot about the
- 50:20guy. And like, even as I went down
- 50:21the cast list, I was like, oh, Alan Tudyk, people know him.
- 50:25You could not have picked a worse person for me to make
- 50:29three statements about because as far as I know, they are all
- 50:32false. I don't know a thing about this
- 50:34man. Good thing you got to phone a
- 50:37friend 'cause I know exactly what you're rich.
- 50:40OK, well then let let me let me say my guesses first before Zach
- 50:43just shuts this down. I feel like Zach's going to be
- 50:46like in the third Lord of the Rings movie when Aragorn shows
- 50:49up with all the ghost pirates and then the battle's just over.
- 50:52Like we need to at least prolong it a little bit.
- 50:54The Ghost Pirates. Whatever they're called, they
- 50:57they're on a ship. The Army of the Dead Robert the.
- 51:01Army of dead robot pirates, whatever they're called.
- 51:06OK, so Alan Tudyk, I'm going to say sure.
- 51:11He was a voice in a video game. I assume this was a mocap
- 51:16performance because he's so tall that it kind of would have to be
- 51:19some sort of mocap performance. And then the third one was, what
- 51:25was the third one, Brad? This is his second time
- 51:28portraying a robot, the first being 2004's I, Robot.
- 51:32I remember loving the film I, Robot and I just saw a clip come
- 51:36up on YouTube shorts last week and boy howdy does that not look
- 51:41very good anymore 20 years later.
- 51:44I One of the few things I remember from my robot is when
- 51:47the the main female protagonist objects to Will Smith using a
- 51:52motorcycle because it has gasoline in it and gasoline
- 51:56explodes. All right.
- 52:00So Zach, I really don't know. If I had to venture a guess, I
- 52:03would say it's got to be either one or two.
- 52:09Brad is a gamer, so he could just make up a game that I don't
- 52:11know and one could be false. He also knows a lot about and
- 52:15has a fondness for C3PO. So maybe it's two.
- 52:19I would say 2, but that's just, I'm just taking a stab here.
- 52:22What is the actual answer here, Zach?
- 52:25So I'm going to lead you away from those.
- 52:29Oh, OK. No, HK47 was voiced by
- 52:33Christophe Tabori, famously so. Famously is is famously in
- 52:38quotes. Feel like famously is things
- 52:40that people know dude. So I, I played all the games
- 52:44like, you know, the sort of thing where it's like, no.
- 52:46And he was sort of 'cause he's kind of like that 70s
- 52:50avant-garde, like John Cassavetes guy level filmmaker.
- 52:55So like, having him voice a robot was a big deal at the
- 52:59time. But yeah, it definitely wasn't
- 53:01Alan Tuda to voice that role. Unless.
- 53:04Unless they did a remake or something that I'm not aware of,
- 53:07but it was definitely Christopher Tobieri.
- 53:09So #1 then according to Zach is the falsehood and I again just
- 53:16for the record do not know or care.
- 53:18So this is solely to save my own pride and record at 2 facts and
- 53:23a falsehood. I'm going to push on all my
- 53:26chips and put my lot in with Zach and say that one is the
- 53:29falsehood, Brad. Bob, I'm not even upset that I
- 53:33lost this week. Yeah, like the the fact that not
- 53:38only did Zach, has he played those games?
- 53:42And Zach, would you agree with me that HK47 is one of the
- 53:46greatest characters? Yeah, of all.
- 53:48Time any Star Wars iteration Bob he is a robot assassin who joins
- 53:56your party in First off. I can't believe you've never
- 53:59heard of Knightsville Republic, one of the greatest game series
- 54:02of all time. He is a robot assassin that he
- 54:07speaks by like he always prefaces what he's about to say
- 54:12with the type of sentence. So he'll be like query, what
- 54:18does this meat bag think he is doing in front of me?
- 54:21And he always refers to humans as meat bags.
- 54:24And it's just it's an incredible character.
- 54:27The fact that Zach knew the voice actor.
- 54:30I I'm stunned and happy and will happily give you a victory here,
- 54:35Bob. Thank you so much, I really put
- 54:37in the work to earn this one this week too so.
- 54:40I'll take that victory. Yeah, that's right, Zach.
- 54:43I hope you'll appreciate that. I was actually like really proud
- 54:46of this one. I was like, Oh yeah, I'm gonna,
- 54:48I'm gonna put a little Knights, the Old Republic mentioned in
- 54:50here. Exactly, Yeah, 'cause that's
- 54:52great. That's a great call back as well
- 54:54because it's sort of, in my opinion, they've been chasing
- 54:57that Android character this whole time and they've never
- 55:00nailed it again. And honestly, I I thought of it
- 55:02because I think K2, SO like they had to have used HK as like very
- 55:10heavy inspiration for the, the Rogue One character.
- 55:14Yeah, especially the way he talks to Jin, like all, you
- 55:17know, slap the taste out of your mouth sort of thing.
- 55:19Like that's so him. No, it's it's so him, am I right
- 55:23guys? So HK.
- 55:27Bob. Classic HK.
- 55:29Move. All right, let's get back.
- 55:31Into talking and I fall in order.
- 55:34Let's get back into talking about Rogue One here, guys.
- 55:36And Brad, as we do it, As you know, we've said that we're
- 55:39sipping on this Blackwood here. I don't want to go too deep into
- 55:42our tasting notes on the Blackwood, especially since I
- 55:44I'd really like to give this a full review in an upcoming
- 55:47episode, but especially coming off of the Jim Beam.
- 55:50Brad, I am picking up on this toasted bourbon just like it's a
- 55:55vanilla bomb on the nose. And then when you get to the
- 55:58palate, it's got like, it almost has that sort of slightly tannic
- 56:04black tea and mint from the toasted oak.
- 56:07I get a ton of black cherry on this.
- 56:10Like there's just there's a depth of flavor here.
- 56:12And you know, Brad, that I don't typically go in for toasted
- 56:17barrel bourbons, but this has a really nice, I wouldn't call it
- 56:20black tea, more like a Roy Bus tea.
- 56:22Like it's really, really, really good, man.
- 56:24And Zach, I think you guys are hitting it out of the park with
- 56:27this Batch 3. Yeah, there there's a, oh, it's
- 56:32like a BlackBerry citrus tea that my wife gets that I'm a big
- 56:35fan of that. Like I literally drank this and
- 56:39was like, Oh my God, it's a better version of that because
- 56:43it's whiskey. There is so much incredible
- 56:46flavour here. And it's the, for me, the thing
- 56:49that really stood out was the viscosity.
- 56:52Like this thing has an ability to coat your palate, your tongue
- 56:56to, to give you the flavours and sit there for a while.
- 57:00Dude, this is some good. This is some daggone good
- 57:04whiskey. Yeah, it's absolutely, you know,
- 57:07intentional and I agree, like toasted finishes can get really
- 57:11chewy and woody, like your firewood kindling sort of not to
- 57:15name many names, but the it's sort of they think toasted means
- 57:18it's got to be like the kindling that's just been lit on fire or
- 57:21whatever. That's not really what the point
- 57:23of toast it is. Like when you're talking about a
- 57:24toasted barrel, it's about activating the sugars that are
- 57:28in that barrel to make them more accessible to the distillate,
- 57:30right. And so if you're doing that, you
- 57:34want to have that creaminess, you want to bring balance.
- 57:36So like with with this the balance.
- 57:39To the force. Yeah, balance, right?
- 57:41Both are toasted dry and toasted bourbon.
- 57:43It's part of it is a sort of sort of throwback to the heyday
- 57:47of the 50s and 60s in American whiskey when you had those Old
- 57:50Fitz 64 and the Old Granddad won fourteen in the 70s and the Old
- 57:54Wellers antiques in the 60s as well, where you had those like
- 57:58bold, creamy, balanced, spicy, like dark stewed fruit, sort of
- 58:03bourbons that everyone's been chasing ever since.
- 58:06But can I can act to because, you know, the the world's a
- 58:08different place than it was in the 50s and 60s.
- 58:10And So what we've sort of done here is found a way to get back
- 58:15to those super balanced, super creamy, bold whiskeys with those
- 58:21flavor knows you guys so aptly mentioned without having to, you
- 58:25know, recreate it in the mash bill of that.
- 58:28We you simply don't have the grains from back then.
- 58:31You don't have to whip from back then.
- 58:32And so putting it in that toasted barrel allows you to
- 58:36pull those fresh caramelized sugars out into an already good
- 58:39distillate because it's a 7 to 9 year old Kentucky bourbon into a
- 58:43good distillate and then a lower char so that you're not
- 58:47filtering, you're not losing that through the filtration of
- 58:49the charcoal, right. And and for me, it's the sort of
- 58:52thing where I can tell you, you know, the story Blackwood farms
- 58:56and country house and our our origin story and you know, it's
- 58:59all has complete veracity to it and it's fun, fascinating story,
- 59:04but I'd rather just pour you one of these and be like tasteless.
- 59:08But I gotta say, folks, the bourbon is really, really good
- 59:10and it has given me the courage to move forward with my spicy
- 59:14takes on this cast list. The spicy take of all spicy
- 59:18takes. I'm gonna start right at the top
- 59:20here, guys. I love love me some Felicity
- 59:25Jones. Like she made a movie called
- 59:29like crazy back in the day. That was AI took Carrie to see
- 59:34it Brad, and it was like the tiniest little indie movie,
- 59:37insanely good movie. And then she she goes on to star
- 59:41in the theory of everything and I think she's even better than
- 59:44Eddie Redmayne is in that movie. She's like just fantastic in
- 59:48that movie. Bob Eddie Redmayne won the
- 59:50Oscar. There, I think she's actively
- 59:54bad in this movie, Brad, and I think that it it's a combination
- 59:59of the way Gareth Edwards directs her.
- 1:00:01It's also just like, if I can be frank here, there's just
- 1:00:05something about her sort of like her make up as a person and and
- 1:00:08her like constitution. She is like a very she plays
- 1:00:11very fragile and kind of delicate people in movies and I
- 1:00:15think she she taps into that really, really well.
- 1:00:19Kind of similar to what you got with.
- 1:00:22Natalie Portman. But then you see how George
- 1:00:24Lucas directs Natalie Portman in like the second and third
- 1:00:28installments of the prequel trilogy and she's a freaking
- 1:00:30badass. And there really wasn't any
- 1:00:33point in this film where I didn't feel like Felicity Jones
- 1:00:36was just pretending when she gives her rousing speech to the
- 1:00:40whole group of rebels. It does not work at all.
- 1:00:43And it really, honestly makes me appreciate Daisy Ridley even
- 1:00:46more as Rey, because I think Rey can shoulder a lot of both the
- 1:00:51emotional weight of her character and the badassery in a
- 1:00:55way that Felicity Jones just does not pull off here.
- 1:00:58So you know the bipolarness of that, right?
- 1:01:02Like you guys remember the there was the first trailer, which
- 1:01:06there's exactly 0 footage from the film in that trailer.
- 1:01:10So the first kind of the film where she's like I rebel.
- 1:01:12Like she's a hardcore rebel. Oh yeah, I do remember that one
- 1:01:16now, yeah. Basically that's what Tony
- 1:01:18Gilroy was brought on and they completely re shot her entire
- 1:01:21character and so there is there is a reason why she's not all
- 1:01:28there. Interesting.
- 1:01:30Yeah, which is it's no, it's no excuse.
- 1:01:33That's that's a fault. This film 100%.
- 1:01:37So are you guys with me on this take then?
- 1:01:38It's not as spicy as it seems. Yeah, I the first time through,
- 1:01:43I gave 0 rips about her. I thought she was a terrible
- 1:01:46character. This time through, I think that
- 1:01:49there's places where you're, you see her acting chops come
- 1:01:54through. I'm thinking of when she goes
- 1:01:56and picks up the child in the middle of the battle.
- 1:01:59I'm thinking when she tears up and is like losing it,
- 1:02:02overseeing her father for the first time in like 20 years.
- 1:02:07It's those more emotional moments where I think she
- 1:02:10shines. So I yeah, I'm kind of with you,
- 1:02:12Bob. Like when she has a chance, the
- 1:02:15camera can just sit on her and she can have an emotional
- 1:02:18moment. I like her the rest of the film,
- 1:02:22though. She's not an action hero.
- 1:02:26She doesn't really have an arc. Like, let's face it, like she
- 1:02:30starts off as like, OK, the rebels pick me up, I'm going to
- 1:02:33go do this and she does it and that's it.
- 1:02:36Whereas you look at like Cassian, a lot of the heavy
- 1:02:39lifting of the ark and the emotional thrust of the story is
- 1:02:42put on him because he goes from like a rebel willing to kill his
- 1:02:46sources to being able to die for the wanting to die for the
- 1:02:49'cause, you know, and sort of that's another fault of the
- 1:02:53script. Like you can have both of them
- 1:02:55have an ark, you know, you can have her be like, you know, I'm
- 1:02:58a rebel, I rebel. What do you want me to do?
- 1:03:00Be, you know, nice. Because again, it's hard because
- 1:03:04I keep going into like, Canon here, but she was raised by Saw
- 1:03:06Guerrero, right, who was a terrorist rebel.
- 1:03:09And, you know, they very clearly say, you know, Moth was says
- 1:03:11like, yeah, he was too extreme for us, so we got rid of him.
- 1:03:15And that's how her original character supposedly was in the
- 1:03:18script where she was kind of an extremist.
- 1:03:22And then she had to learn to play ball, which is an arc,
- 1:03:24right? And they completely took that
- 1:03:26out, which is 100% hard to ignore in this film.
- 1:03:31Cool. Well, that, man, that that did
- 1:03:34not elicit the spicy reactions I thought it was gonna get.
- 1:03:37It sounds like we all. Really.
- 1:03:39Go back to my point, that's not her fault, that's that's Gareth
- 1:03:43Edwards and Tony Kilroy's fault. Yeah.
- 1:03:45Actors like she's an amazing actress.
- 1:03:46I just wanted to make that clear.
- 1:03:47Like she was doing her job the best of her ability and she kind
- 1:03:51of got a shit sandwich of a script when they started
- 1:03:53reshooting. 100% man, I do think Diego Luna is just being Diego
- 1:03:58Luna and that's really, really great for what this movie needs.
- 1:04:01He is just, he has such an air of I don't know, chill about
- 1:04:08him. Like everything just seems to
- 1:04:09kind of roll off his back even when he's in high pressure
- 1:04:11situations. He kind of reminds me of like
- 1:04:14pre Marvel Mark Ruffalo that way.
- 1:04:16He has that sort of like shaggy chill guy quality Brad.
- 1:04:20This is at least the 2nd movie we've talked about with him in
- 1:04:23it after his smaller role in The Terminal, but he was even really
- 1:04:27good in that movie and I, I just think he's really welcome here.
- 1:04:30I'm glad they continued to develop this character with the
- 1:04:32Andor TV show. If there's a spicy take
- 1:04:36remaining in my cast list, I don't know, like I was kind of
- 1:04:39excited to see Forest Whitaker show up and then I was like, oh,
- 1:04:43that's what we're doing here. Oh, OK.
- 1:04:46That my guy was not just chewing scenery, but he like he was in a
- 1:04:50different movie if I'm being honest.
- 1:04:52Yeah, I mean, let's go back to what Zach talked about earlier
- 1:04:55with cartoon characters in a live action setting.
- 1:04:59Saw Guerrero was originally a cartoon character and they
- 1:05:03brought him into a live action setting and man, oh man, I I
- 1:05:08think he was like the main turn off for me the first time I saw
- 1:05:13this. This time around I had a little
- 1:05:16more grace for him, but man, I do not like Forest Whitaker in
- 1:05:21this movie. Guys, it is not my favorite.
- 1:05:24Yeah, luckily it's short, like if they're smart enough at least
- 1:05:27not to make him an integral part of the.
- 1:05:31But again, watch like I, I hate to say this again, broken
- 1:05:35record. Go back and watch that original
- 1:05:37trailer for this film. Its character was completely
- 1:05:39different. Like all those things were
- 1:05:41reshot. And so, you know, not in any way
- 1:05:47being like Snyder Cutter or anything like that, but it's
- 1:05:50it's curious like the like the bipolarness of this film
- 1:05:54sometimes where you're just like saws this, you know, insane
- 1:05:57terrorist rebel who, you know, obviously has been through so
- 1:06:00much. And they do.
- 1:06:01So they do a wonderful job of showing visually showing, not
- 1:06:04telling that he's, you know, a hardcore veteran.
- 1:06:08But then it's just sort of like there's no purpose there.
- 1:06:13Like there's no like they could have.
- 1:06:16They could have accomplished that in such a more fastidious
- 1:06:19way. I kept expecting him to show up
- 1:06:22later in the movie and like be a surprise bad guy or something.
- 1:06:26Because the way that they send his character off, he's, I don't
- 1:06:30remember exactly what he says, but he basically just goes go be
- 1:06:34free. Like he's releasing her into an
- 1:06:37open pasture. And then they just cut away from
- 1:06:40him. And I'm like, what?
- 1:06:41What's that? That surely that can't be the
- 1:06:44end of his character, But it was.
- 1:06:48Did did you want a 10 minute back story on him, Bob?
- 1:06:51No, I just like he says something that is so
- 1:06:55outlandishly cheesy. It's something like be free.
- 1:06:59He's like, you know, continue to play the game or something and
- 1:07:04she she runs off and he gets buried alive.
- 1:07:06And I guess that's that's how he wanted to go out.
- 1:07:09Yeah, I mean, it's, it's, it's again, it's Star Wars, right?
- 1:07:12It's it's got a lot of fat and cheese that are you.
- 1:07:15Sometimes you got to kind of like this is my perfect, my
- 1:07:19perfect 44 year old father of two Star Wars synopsis.
- 1:07:26Perfect for a Sunday afternoon where you fall asleep two or
- 1:07:28three times during each movie. Yep.
- 1:07:30And usually fall asleep during the dumb parts like that and
- 1:07:33wake up for the fun parts. Yeah, as long as you wake up
- 1:07:35later at the end. Yeah.
- 1:07:37You know, then you really didn't miss much, you know?
- 1:07:40Yeah. And honestly like to talk about
- 1:07:42things that I like in this movie.
- 1:07:44I think that they nail the Star Wars visual style of what it
- 1:07:50looks like to have a space battle, what it looks like to
- 1:07:53have a ground battle, and what it looks like to be up close
- 1:07:55with your main hero. Like, like we see this in so
- 1:07:58many of the movies where it's like, let's have a bunch of
- 1:08:01spaceships fight each other and it's going to look awesome.
- 1:08:03We're going to have a bunch of people on the ground explode and
- 1:08:06shoot each other and it's going to look awesome.
- 1:08:08And then we're also going to follow our heroes.
- 1:08:10And I think that they really nailed that aspect of the movie
- 1:08:14at the end. And you're right, Bob, they make
- 1:08:16the Star Destroyers look so freaking cool in this movie.
- 1:08:22And when they're like knocking into each other and destroying
- 1:08:26the the planetary shield, that there's just so much of that
- 1:08:29that feels awesome in the proper Star Wars way.
- 1:08:36So, Brad, we're in a really unique position here this week
- 1:08:39because we are in the middle of a run of three Star Wars films.
- 1:08:43And so next week is going to be even more interesting for a
- 1:08:47number of reasons, but because we won't just be comparing it to
- 1:08:50one other film, we'll be comparing it to its predecessor
- 1:08:53in the trilogy, but also to this movie.
- 1:08:55But for now, I, I really want to pick your brain because I've,
- 1:08:59I've been struggling to compare this to The Force Awakens.
- 1:09:03And I think that where I'm landing on this, Brad, is this
- 1:09:07is the, the kind of Star Wars movie I'd rather see for.
- 1:09:10If you're going to make a movie for grown-ups like this is the
- 1:09:13direction you need to go with it.
- 1:09:15But between the two movies, there is a perfect Star Wars
- 1:09:19film buried in there somewhere. If you could just kind of
- 1:09:21Frankenstein together some elements of each.
- 1:09:25Because for all of his faults, JJ Abrams has always been
- 1:09:29really, really good at getting you to care about characters.
- 1:09:33Whether you agree with those characters arcs or not, He makes
- 1:09:37you feel the weight of their decisions and their emotional
- 1:09:41arcs. Like I think about the TV show
- 1:09:44Lost, which ultimately I think suffers from the same thing as
- 1:09:47his sequels, which is just like, I'm never going to actually
- 1:09:51reveal what's going on. I'm going to continue playing
- 1:09:53this mystery box thing until you figure out that that that I'm
- 1:09:57just stalling for time. But in the interim, I'm going to
- 1:09:59get you really invested in where this might be going by writing
- 1:10:04these characters backstories in in a really profound way.
- 1:10:07And that's. Why Mission Impossible Three is
- 1:10:09one of my favorites. I freaking love Mission
- 1:10:11Impossible three man like, and I think that if this movie had
- 1:10:15more of Abraham's ability to make you care about characters,
- 1:10:19this might end up being my favorite Star Wars movie because
- 1:10:22it's got the visuals, It's got the ultimate tragic arc, but the
- 1:10:27tragic arc doesn't land as hard as it should.
- 1:10:31And so I guess I'm, I'm wondering, Brad, like let's draw
- 1:10:34comparisons, but also like, am I way off base and thinking that
- 1:10:38there's a almost perfect Star Wars movie somewhere between
- 1:10:41these two? No, I I think you're, you're
- 1:10:43right in line, Bob. The problem with there's so many
- 1:10:48problems with Force Awakens. The problem for me is that The
- 1:10:54Force Awakens feels so much shinier than this one and has,
- 1:11:04in my opinion, just so much bad dialogue.
- 1:11:08There are elements of I care more about the characters in The
- 1:11:12Force Awakens, but the Rogue One just looks like a Star Wars
- 1:11:18movie. It plays like a Star Wars movie.
- 1:11:20It sounds like a Star Wars movie.
- 1:11:21And it, and you're right, Zach, I honestly, I'd never thought of
- 1:11:24it before in that terms of like, what is the big punch that this
- 1:11:28movie delivers like and that being an important element of
- 1:11:31the Star Wars universe. But I'm with you.
- 1:11:34Like, I think that Abrams tries to do that not just with I think
- 1:11:38he does try to do it with the the lightsaber moment.
- 1:11:41I think he tries to do it with Han Solo and Kylo right when
- 1:11:46they meet on the bridge and and Kylo kills him.
- 1:11:48I think he's trying to deliver that big punch there, but we all
- 1:11:52know that Kylo is going to kill him.
- 1:11:54So it kind of takes away from that.
- 1:11:57I, I think Rogue One succeeds in those areas, but I'm with you
- 1:12:01100%. My I, I think my take away the
- 1:12:04first time I watch this is still my take away the second time.
- 1:12:07I don't care about these characters.
- 1:12:10Like the only reason I care about the faux Jedi, the the
- 1:12:14blind faux blind Jedi and his guardian companion is because a,
- 1:12:21they mimic more characters from Knights of the Old Republic,
- 1:12:26which I don't know, Zach, if you kind of caught that, but but
- 1:12:31they have great chemistry with each other.
- 1:12:33And like, that's the only reason I care about them.
- 1:12:36They don't have a great arc. They're not actually that
- 1:12:39interesting of characters. The actors have great chemistry
- 1:12:42together and that makes me a little sad when they die.
- 1:12:45And I think that's why Felicity Jones and Diego Luna don't work
- 1:12:50great. I don't think that they have
- 1:12:51really good chemistry with each other.
- 1:12:53Yeah, especially like Jianwen and Donnie yen, like you can
- 1:12:56tell they're brothers to the death, right?
- 1:12:59But I also think like sort of going back to Bob's point, like
- 1:13:03the the problem with Force Awakens is the rebels don't look
- 1:13:06like rebels. They look like a very well
- 1:13:09funded private army from like Baxter or whatever.
- 1:13:14Whereas in Rogue One, they look like the rebels who are a Ray
- 1:13:18Tang group. I mean, look, we George Lucas
- 1:13:21has said like he was thinking of the Vietcong and and the
- 1:13:23American Empire when he was writing New Hope, right?
- 1:13:26Which is like, yeah, that's an obvious illusion, right?
- 1:13:28That's an obvious parallel where how can these like Ray take
- 1:13:31group of, you know, guerrillas take on an empire and win?
- 1:13:37You know, it was 74 was the fall of Saigon 7576.
- 1:13:40He's right. And it's obviously that's the
- 1:13:41big thing you would be thinking about in your mind, not that the
- 1:13:44rebels are the Vietcong. That's, you know, it's not
- 1:13:47literal, right. And I felt for the first time
- 1:13:51ever, and I think George Lucas told Gareth Edwards and Tony
- 1:13:53Gilroy, this Rogue One's his favorite film in the series of
- 1:13:57the new ones because it felt like that.
- 1:14:00It felt like these were actual rebels who were, who weren't all
- 1:14:03united and there were different factions, but they were ragtag
- 1:14:07and they were, you know, they were, you know, emaciated and
- 1:14:09they, they had morals that were all over the place.
- 1:14:12And, you know, it wasn't this like, oh, in Force Awakens, we
- 1:14:16are the perfect good guys who look perfect and are perfectly
- 1:14:20coiffed and shaved and uniformed.
- 1:14:22It's like, well, that's not rebels.
- 1:14:25That's, you know, army for hire. And that's what they literally
- 1:14:29say in Last Jedi, which people got kind of pissed off about.
- 1:14:32But you know, I, I do like Gareth Edward said when George
- 1:14:38Lucas told him Rogue One was his favorite Star Wars movie that he
- 1:14:41didn't make. He says I can die happy now, but
- 1:14:44I can see it. I can see that being that could
- 1:14:47have been new or sorry, that could have been Force awakens.
- 1:14:50Force Awakens could have looked like that.
- 1:14:51It could have felt like that. And so Bob, I agree with you.
- 1:14:54Like the aesthetic of Rogue One. Put that on to Force Awakens,
- 1:15:00and I think Force Awakens becomes marginally, but not
- 1:15:03marginally. It becomes exponentially better
- 1:15:05just from that care alone. Obviously there are other
- 1:15:08problems with the script and blah blah blah, but that doesn't
- 1:15:10matter. The look was wrong in Force
- 1:15:12Awakens, right? Yeah, which we we touched on
- 1:15:16last week too, Brad. And, and I think that this might
- 1:15:19be a good natural segue into getting into our last segment of
- 1:15:21the day, 'cause now we're we're pairing this up with Force
- 1:15:24Awakens. So let's see what other movies
- 1:15:26we want to pair this up with with our last segment.
- 1:15:28Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:15:31episodes of Things, listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 1:15:35Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:15:37struggling. It's a final segment of the day.
- 1:15:39Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 1:15:42part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 1:15:45to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:15:47Zach, you are on A roll today. Man, I I did not know that you
- 1:15:51felt this strongly about this film and or the Star Wars saga
- 1:15:54in general. So I'm going to ask you what
- 1:15:57would make the best double feature for this film?
- 1:16:00So I'm going to, I'm going to go back to the the 70s well, which
- 1:16:03you guys probably know well by now from me, but I'm going with
- 1:16:08Kelly's heroes. Oh nice.
- 1:16:11It's a World War Two heist film and at the core, Rogue One is a
- 1:16:14heist film. Like Brad, like you said, the
- 1:16:16second-half of the film where the heist starts, that's when
- 1:16:18the film kind of starts. Like it, like in a good Star
- 1:16:20Wars movie, it starts 40 minutes in.
- 1:16:23But the Kelly's heroes, you know, it's a sort of, you know,
- 1:16:26the, you know, these, these rebels in the American American
- 1:16:31GIS who are rebels who go AWOL to go get some gold from the
- 1:16:35Nazis and have to, you know, fight their way back through
- 1:16:37ridiculous odds. Just like the battle Scara for
- 1:16:40the, you know, they're fighting, you know, ATATS and like trying
- 1:16:43to blow them up and they just, you know, turn back and look at
- 1:16:45them. You know, they're fighting
- 1:16:47Panzer tanks and Tiger tanks in the end of that film.
- 1:16:49And it's a very similar vibe where, you know, it's it's
- 1:16:53insurmountable odds for, you know, oddball and Claremont and
- 1:16:55the whole team to like get through out of France, back
- 1:17:00through the German lines and back into home territory.
- 1:17:04And it just feels like also it's more light hearted.
- 1:17:05I mean, it's as comedy. It's a 70s comedy, so the
- 1:17:08comedies are very dry and kind of weird sometimes.
- 1:17:11But it's a nice little throwback and it's a lot lighter and it's
- 1:17:14a little more fun. Everybody doesn't die in the
- 1:17:16end. You know what, I'm I'm glad you
- 1:17:18said that one because I was thinking at first this reminds
- 1:17:21me of like The Dirty Dozen or not, not the guns of Navarone.
- 1:17:26What's the other one? Force 10 from Navarone, like all
- 1:17:28of these kind of almost exploitative.
- 1:17:31We're gonna send dudes into World War Two and just, you
- 1:17:35know, everything that influenced Inglourious Basterds
- 1:17:37essentially. I think you could definitely
- 1:17:39pair this movie up with. But also a killer cast, right?
- 1:17:42He's 100%. Don Rickles, Carol O'Connor
- 1:17:45Donald Sutherland who just passed Henry.
- 1:17:47All right, P man. You know, like a real like, you
- 1:17:51know, of the time heavy hitter cast again, just like Rogue One
- 1:17:55heavy hitter cast of the time. And so, you know, I think, and
- 1:17:58it's also, like I said, it's a comedy heist or it's not.
- 1:18:03You're not going to watch at the enemy.
- 1:18:04Like, Oh well, they all died, OK.
- 1:18:09I think ultimately the reason I didn't decide to go with Dirty
- 1:18:12Dozen here is that tragic arc. And so I wanted to think of
- 1:18:15something a little bit that follows that path a little bit
- 1:18:18more. And I think I'm ultimately going
- 1:18:20to go with a movie, Brad, that is a war film that takes a
- 1:18:24ragtag group of soldiers who have come from oppressed
- 1:18:28backgrounds, just like in this movie that culminates in a a
- 1:18:33doomed raid on a Fort on a sandy beach.
- 1:18:37That is the 1989 Civil War film Glory by Edward Zwick with
- 1:18:43Denzel Washington, Matthew Broderick.
- 1:18:46That movie's freaking slaps. It's a film we have never talked
- 1:18:48about on this podcast before. I don't know if you've ever seen
- 1:18:51Glory. No, I, I I have never seen
- 1:18:54glory. Oh man, oh so good dude.
- 1:18:59Tearjerker, but like a true dad movie, like a really good It's
- 1:19:04on AMC at at 2:30 in the afternoon on a Saturday.
- 1:19:07Yeah. But so it's phenomenal that
- 1:19:10alone. Yeah, 100%.
- 1:19:13Denzel wins his first Oscar for this movie, and it's it's really
- 1:19:16well deserved. I can't recommend it highly
- 1:19:18enough. So I'm going with glory.
- 1:19:20Brad, that means you get to round us out here.
- 1:19:23Bob, I think I'm going to pick a two film arc.
- 1:19:30Are we OK with that? Sure.
- 1:19:32I am going to lean into the two elements we've kind of talked
- 1:19:36about. I think that the first, I think
- 1:19:39both movies do this really well. They establish a fight for
- 1:19:44humanity against all odds and there's no feasible chance that
- 1:19:50they ought to win this battle. And I think it nails the tragic
- 1:19:55arc. I'm talking Terminator and
- 1:19:59Terminator two baby. I'm so happy that I have,
- 1:20:05whether you acknowledge it or not, that I have made a Jim
- 1:20:08Cameron fan out of you over the course of this podcast.
- 1:20:12The only thing, the only thing better is if you could have just
- 1:20:14said that you're pairing it up with True Lies.
- 1:20:17Oh dude, that's not a bad one either.
- 1:20:21I just I really wish that we can get a cut.
- 1:20:24Where Cassian and as he and Felicity Jones are like holding
- 1:20:29each other as the the nuclear bomb explodes around them.
- 1:20:33If he just like threw a thumbs up.
- 1:20:36Yeah, or it could just be a a complete mimic of that scene in
- 1:20:40True Lies where Jamie Lee Curtis and Arnold Schwarzenegger are
- 1:20:42making out with the bomb going off behind them.
- 1:20:45That's what we needed here. Very nice.
- 1:20:48All right, so I've picked Glory, Zach has picked Kelly's heroes,
- 1:20:53Brad has picked Terminators one and two guys, let's give this
- 1:20:57movie some final scores. I'm really struggling with this
- 1:21:00because like I said, I drove 7 hours to get home today, sat
- 1:21:05down on my couch and finished watching this movie that I had
- 1:21:08only been able to get through 20 minutes of in like 3 attempts
- 1:21:12over the last couple days. I'm tired.
- 1:21:15I was a little bit distracted, but I think this movie just it,
- 1:21:19it just didn't hook me the way that it did the first time.
- 1:21:22And I think part of that is the theatrical images of Gareth
- 1:21:26Edwards, like, overwhelm you in a movie theater.
- 1:21:30And then once they've sunk it, like sunk in and you get to go
- 1:21:33home and watch them on a smaller screen.
- 1:21:36I think the flaws and the seams of this movie show a lot more.
- 1:21:41If you'd asked me walking out of that theater what I'd give it, I
- 1:21:43would say like an 8 1/2 probably.
- 1:21:45If you asked me today, I'd say like a six.
- 1:21:48So I think I'm going to split the difference and I'm going to
- 1:21:50give it a little bit of the benefit of the doubt because I
- 1:21:52do think that there are just quite a few moments that still
- 1:21:55absolutely rule. And I'm going to say a 7 1/2,
- 1:21:59but I don't really know if I can go higher than that, Brad.
- 1:22:02Yeah, I mean, I still have my IMDb score for this.
- 1:22:05From when I first rated it, it was a 5 out of 10.
- 1:22:10I was really very unimpressed with this movie.
- 1:22:13This time around, I think I was sitting at A7 and then Darth
- 1:22:19Vader happened and I was like, that's a half point right there
- 1:22:23for sure. So I'm going to give it a 7 1/2
- 1:22:26as well. Bob, I'm kind of right there
- 1:22:27with you. Watch Zach be like this is a 10
- 1:22:30out of 10. What's wrong with you?
- 1:22:32I mean, that's definitely not, you know, like I said, I'm very,
- 1:22:35very aware of the faults, the flaws.
- 1:22:38You guys are right on though. Like the IMDb is right around
- 1:22:41here talking. I always like to say a solid B
- 1:22:43plus, but that would be an 85 or 8 1/2, wouldn't it?
- 1:22:47So the Vader scene, that's an 11 out of 10.
- 1:22:52He definitely turned it up to 11 at the very least.
- 1:22:55I would say the actual film is, yeah, I hate to, I have to agree
- 1:23:01with you guys. It's a 7 1/2 out of 10.
- 1:23:02Like it's it's it's like most Star Wars movies that are great.
- 1:23:06They're 7 1/2 out of 10s. There's No 10 out of 10 Star
- 1:23:09Wars movie. Because this dude gets it.
- 1:23:12Thank you. If we could all just
- 1:23:15collectively agree that Star Wars movies are fun trifles for
- 1:23:19the most part then like the world would be a better place.
- 1:23:22It's this entire cult that has that has emerged around them
- 1:23:26that insists that they are like on par with the Godfather that I
- 1:23:30don't understand about Star Wars.
- 1:23:31Like, let's just be happy that we have these fun little movies
- 1:23:35that, you know, with a giant dog man that growls at Han Solo and
- 1:23:40we get to shoot lasers and say pee pee.
- 1:23:42Like it's like, yeah. And also, The Godfather's not
- 1:23:46perfect. We'll go watch that film again.
- 1:23:48I mean, doesn't make sense. Let's let's just cool it on the
- 1:23:52spicy takes here, man. You've hit your quota for the
- 1:23:56day. All right, so it's a 7 1/2 for
- 1:23:59me and Brad and Zach. So we've got the weight of all
- 1:24:02three of us behind this one. But folks, if you disagree, let
- 1:24:06us know. You can find us on all of our
- 1:24:08social media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok, and
- 1:24:13YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or you can jump into the
- 1:24:16conversation. We are on Discord every single
- 1:24:19day talking to you guys, fans of the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 1:24:23If you'd like to join that conversation, you can find a
- 1:24:25link at the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:24:29Zach, open invitation for you to come back anytime you want.
- 1:24:32And I say that because. We probably do need a moderator
- 1:24:36for next week's episode. I was going to say I I've been
- 1:24:39listening, been listening along and I feel I can just hear Bob
- 1:24:42sort of like getting more and more broken as he talks about
- 1:24:48these movies and Brad sort of like Glee kind of rising and
- 1:24:53rising. So I I feel like there needs to
- 1:24:55be somebody in between to be like but Bob, no movies are
- 1:24:59perfect. It's OK And and I.
- 1:25:02Listen man, I'm in a very fragile place now and like I can
- 1:25:06feel Brad like circling for the kill.
- 1:25:08The Hammer's ready, man. I don't think the hammer needs
- 1:25:11to come, man, because The Last Jedi is a really good movie.
- 1:25:14And to Zack's point, it doesn't have to be perfect to be really
- 1:25:17good. Yeah, but we will get into that
- 1:25:19next week, hopefully with Zack in tow to to back me up here
- 1:25:24when we talk about Rian Johnson's 2016 film The Last
- 1:25:28Jedi. So join us for that as we
- 1:25:30finally shake Star Wars off our back for the season.
- 1:25:34But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:25:38And we'll see you next time.