Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Mark Ritter of MBFS MBL CUSO & the Credit Union Conversations Podcast
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Treichel with another episode of with flying colors.
- 0:04I'm excited today to have the CEO of member business financial services.
- 0:09QSO Mark Ritter with me today.
- 0:11Mark, how are you doing?
- 0:13Mark Ritter: I'm doing great.
- 0:14Thanks for having me looking forward to the conversation and you can just call it
- 0:18MBFS so I don't tongue tie you the whole
- 0:21Mark Treichel: MBFS QSO.
- 0:25And you're also a podcast host of the credit of credit union conversations,
- 0:30and I was fortunate enough to chat with you a couple of weeks back.
- 0:33And we have a mutual friend Vin, Vin Vieten who helps me with my
- 0:38clients and Vin and I were chatting about some of your war stories from
- 0:41back in the day, the other day.
- 0:43But Mark, I want to, I've got your bio here and just my, my audience
- 0:47knows your extensive background.
- 0:49I'm gonna, I'm gonna read through it here.
- 0:50Mark is the CEO of MBFS and New Directional Lending and an expert in
- 0:55credit unions and business lending.
- 0:58His primary role at MBFS is overseeing the strategy of helping credit unions assist
- 1:04members with business needs and consulting with credit unions on planning the
- 1:09delivery of services to their membership.
- 1:11In 2002, Mark started a large Central Pennsylvania Credit Union's business
- 1:16lending program as one person and a desk with no policies, products,
- 1:22staff, systems, or business members.
- 1:25That program grew to be one of the top ten in the nation.
- 1:29In 2012, he took on the challenge of being the CEO of a business lending CUSO.
- 1:34Mark was the fifth CEO in five years for the organization.
- 1:38That's a lot of turnover.
- 1:39That's more turnover than the NCOA board.
- 1:41At times, which lost many, which lost money every month of its existence.
- 1:47Since joining MBFS, Mark increased the number of credit unions, the QS
- 1:51in the QSO and revenue by over 10 X.
- 1:55and ensured positive cash flow every full year he's been at the CUSO.
- 1:59More importantly, MBFS has helped countless credit union members
- 2:04gain the financing they need for business and investment needs.
- 2:08Mark's a native of Berwick, Pennsylvania in Northeast Pennsylvania,
- 2:12where he was a member of his high school's nationally ranked and
- 2:15state championship football team.
- 2:18After high school, Mark hung up his cleats to work for the Penn State Nittany Lions
- 2:22full time as a student assistant while attending Penn State as an undergrad.
- 2:27During this time, Penn State transitioned to the Big Ten and culminated in Penn
- 2:32State's first Big Ten championship and a trip to the Rose Bowl.
- 2:36Mark remains an avid Penn State supporter.
- 2:38Today, Mark lives in Bucks County, PA, outside of Doylestown with
- 2:42his wife and two teenagers.
- 2:43Mark, I didn't realize that you were a part of the Big Ten family.
- 2:47I'm a golden gopher.
- 2:49Most sports, probably everything but hockey, you're probably
- 2:51better than us right now.
- 2:52Anyway welcome to the show, Mark.
- 2:55Thank you.
- 2:56Mark Ritter: And thanks for the audience for putting up with my long bio makes
- 2:59me think I have to shorten it up.
- 3:00Minnesota is getting a
- 3:02Mark Treichel: lot of good information there.
- 3:03Mark Ritter: Minnesota is getting a little better every year.
- 3:05And they got a couple sports that they clip us on, but not too many.
- 3:09Not
- 3:09Mark Treichel: too many.
- 3:10No, not too many.
- 3:11Not too many.
- 3:12Yeah.
- 3:132002.
- 3:14You're at a credit union, they didn't even have member business loans, and now you're
- 3:17helping members all across the country, and so Mark one of the things in our pre,
- 3:23pre chat, we talked about how things have changed in credit unions, in commercial
- 3:28lending, et cetera, et cetera and, exams back then versus exams today, why don't
- 3:33you take me through a little bit of the, of a timeline of the journey of different
- 3:37things you've seen In commercial loans at the QSO and as it relates to NCOA.
- 3:43I, there's a lot loaded into that question, but but let me know
- 3:46Mark Ritter: your thoughts on all that.
- 3:47Yeah and I'll give you the point of comparison.
- 3:51The industry has grown so much, but I remember looking back.
- 3:56Early in my career.
- 3:57And when I started in Pennsylvania, there was a total of 13 million
- 4:05in business loans among every credit union in Pennsylvania.
- 4:11And most of those and funny as it sounds, most of those were at the
- 4:16Amish credit union who was doing Amish business loans at the time.
- 4:22Today there's credit unions that just do deals bigger than that on a regular basis.
- 4:27Sure.
- 4:27So the industry was virtually nothing and I knew enough at the time.
- 4:34And I, okay.
- 4:36I was your typical, at a community bank, I knew, Oh, go out and talk and shake
- 4:41hands, handshakes and everything, but.
- 4:44But it was an incredible opportunity because I had to learn
- 4:52everything and everything systems.
- 4:55I never wrote a policy.
- 4:57I never wrote a policy.
- 5:02And there were, there were virtually no CUSOs at the time to help people.
- 5:08And when you called a system person and said you were from a credit
- 5:12union, they looked at you like you had three heads, you were literally,
- 5:16this was Lewis and Clark in the Wild West during that generation.
- 5:21Sure.
- 5:22And, but the one thing that I found is the credit unions had an awful lot of
- 5:29members who were small business owners.
- 5:33And needed and they like their credit union, but they just
- 5:36didn't do it at the time.
- 5:38So it was such a fascinating experience because you had this such strong
- 5:44affinity of, people who love our credit unions and, but they couldn't
- 5:49go to the credit union at the time.
- 5:52Sure, and really what I found from N.
- 5:56C.
- 5:56U.
- 5:57A.
- 5:57At the time, and you could probably back me up on this is they didn't
- 6:05know what they didn't know, even at the time, and I always say when we
- 6:10talk to each other, it was like an 8th grade dance because we were both
- 6:15staring at each other with nothing.
- 6:16Nobody knew what to do.
- 6:18Mark Treichel: And you think about that, it's they're self employed.
- 6:21So you need to have the tax return in the file.
- 6:22So thinking, putting my, my, my time back when I was an examiner at the time and
- 6:27then then you'd go through the phase of, okay you got the tax return, whether it's
- 6:31a self employed or it's the business now.
- 6:34Now we need to understand what that means and adding back
- 6:37depreciation and what does that mean?
- 6:39And, an NCUA when I was in, let's see, I started in 86 somewhere between 86
- 6:44and 89, maybe 90, I went down to LSU for two training classes because NCUA
- 6:50was starting to see commercial loans.
- 6:52There was a big credit union in Texas that had caused some
- 6:55problems for the insurance fund.
- 6:57Which then turns into, Hey, we did need to step up our training.
- 7:00So they sent us down to the LSU school of banking of the South.
- 7:05I remember a teacher there, Willie Stotts looked a little bit like
- 7:09Groucho Marx, fabulous teacher.
- 7:11And, he's giving an example about when he worked at a bank and they had,
- 7:16he took over some troubled credits.
- 7:18And they had made loans to a chicken farm and he started talking about,
- 7:23you got to keep the chickens alive and you got to get the feed and all these
- 7:26different things that, that his bank didn't understand when they made these
- 7:30loans that you might end up with the collateral, and NCUA raised the bar
- 7:34collectively or individually of different.
- 7:38People and it might have been when I was a problem case officer that I went
- 7:40to that training, but I learned enough there maybe to be dangerous, but I
- 7:45learned enough there to raise the bar, raise that conversation from an 8th
- 7:48grade conversation to maybe 11th grade in the summer between 11th and 12th grade,
- 7:53perhaps where we were able to, I was able to ask some questions, which led
- 7:58the credit union to ask more questions of their members, et cetera, et cetera.
- 8:02So that ring any bells the thoughts of, the transition to.
- 8:06To tax returns.
- 8:07And then now we're in the world of global cash flows.
- 8:10Mark Ritter: The funniest piece from those days is, we were at a large
- 8:16credit union and we were about an hour and a half from Alexandria.
- 8:21And I noticed all of us, like I was just getting NCUA exams and people reviewing
- 8:29my files, like more than any other time that I've ever had in my life.
- 8:34And finally I sat down and I asked them, I said, let me ask you this.
- 8:41Are you just sending people here to re to train them?
- 8:45And they said, yes, that's exactly what we're doing.
- 8:47I go, cause we're the only ones doing business loans in any volume at this time.
- 8:52They're like, yeah, there's nowhere else we can go in this region.
- 8:56So I said, Oh, okay let's sit down and work together and I'll guide you
- 9:01through a file and talk about what we do rather than me just slapping a file
- 9:06on you and coming back with a bunch of comments that don't make sense.
- 9:11So really my, my outlook on that is much more of a partnership and conversation
- 9:17versus combativeness because, the commercial lending side and even the
- 9:22small business lending piece, it's much more of an art form and subjectiveness.
- 9:30As compared to a mortgage loan where these are the 20 things that need to go into it.
- 9:36Here's the compliance.
- 9:37This mortgage loan looks exactly like the next mortgage loan, and I think
- 9:41that's probably the piece that examiners struggle with more than anything else
- 9:47as a well as the credit union and.
- 9:50Credit unions, what we really figured out at that time is you really have
- 9:53to make it a story for somebody to open up with who can understand
- 9:58it and have a conversation with.
- 10:01Mark Treichel: Yeah, here's the narrative.
- 10:02Here's the write up on that loan with why it makes sense.
- 10:05And I asked these questions and I had these follow ups and I, we, I mentioned
- 10:08Vin Vieten and Vin has talked a lot about.
- 10:11It's like he viewed his role when he was, before he came to NCA and he
- 10:16worked as a lender, he viewed it as a, really an opportunity to help the
- 10:20small business understand how they could see succeed because of the interview.
- 10:25It was like a free consultation, if you will, that, have you thought
- 10:29of this and you have thought of this, cause if I'm going to.
- 10:31Look, if you're going to get money from me, I need to understand
- 10:35that I'm going to get it back.
- 10:36So if I'm thinking this is how I might get it back and I pass these things on to
- 10:39you, you can improve their thought process on how to make their business succeed.
- 10:46Mark Ritter: That's exactly right.
- 10:47And really, and at this point too, the piece that we were lifting up is you have
- 10:53the lender And the business, but we're also educating the regulators, the board,
- 10:59the senior management on how we can help everybody succeed, improve the local
- 11:05economy and bring everything together.
- 11:08And I think that's the one piece that credit unions as the industry
- 11:11matures is that, never forget at the end of this food chain.
- 11:18There's a small business who has hopes and dreams and a mission of
- 11:24really improving their life, having improved employees and don't forget
- 11:29that piece of it, which is why we're
- 11:31Mark Treichel: here.
- 11:32Sure.
- 11:32Sure.
- 11:32And that business is contributing to the community, whether it's two employees
- 11:37or 25 employees that need to get paid every Friday or every other Friday.
- 11:42Which, which keep the economic engine of this great country
- 11:45that we that we live in going.
- 11:47Absolutely.
- 11:50I, can you think of any specific examples of a, an aha moment of on a type of loan?
- 11:59Like right now you can read in the wall street journal, you can read
- 12:02in, in Bloomberg, there's this anxiety about office space, which
- 12:07is a certain type of business loan.
- 12:09And then there's, there's.
- 12:11Collateral based lending, which might have a crop loan.
- 12:14When I was an examiner, one way I learned some things was I had some farm credit
- 12:18unions because I was from Minnesota and the whole board was farmers.
- 12:23The credit committee was farmers.
- 12:24And if they were given a tractor loan, they understood it.
- 12:28And I learned from them.
- 12:29And if they had a crop loan.
- 12:31I remember the first concept.
- 12:33Guess what?
- 12:33The crop loan it should be paid off every at the end of every crop.
- 12:37And so these different nuances can you think of any examples or aha moments
- 12:42of certain types of loans where where you were able to move the ball forward
- 12:46relative to something along those lines?
- 12:49Mark Ritter: Yeah, a absolutely and I can think of the great recession and.
- 12:56I never did as high quality of loans as I did during as any time,
- 13:03except during the great recession.
- 13:05Those are the best loans that I have ever done.
- 13:09And really, I can think of 1 RV dealership that we helped restructure at during the
- 13:15great recession and roll back in time.
- 13:20Not unlike today.
- 13:22Where people just weren't lending and there was a, there was, there was a
- 13:28demand issue and then there, and people weren't lending and we had a very well run
- 13:35business, very well run business that was struggling with the manufacturers because
- 13:44of the because of the great recession and, you What we were able to do was go
- 13:51in and look at his business on a micro level micro level, understanding him,
- 13:58his customers and put together a package.
- 14:02And for years after that, as I talked with him, he always, every time I talked to
- 14:06him, he said, mark, you saved my business.
- 14:11You saved my business.
- 14:12And that's where.
- 14:13I tell people, credit unions have the advantage.
- 14:17If you're a national bank, if you're a super regional bank, you're
- 14:24lending into these large buckets.
- 14:29And delinquency in certain areas is increasing.
- 14:33It was, things like office space.
- 14:35But that doesn't mean delinquency is 100%.
- 14:41And in your you have the advantage of getting into your members in your
- 14:48towns, in your neighborhoods and making decisions based off of individual
- 14:53fact versus saying, and I'll give you I'll give you my peeve example.
- 15:00People always say, I don't lend to gas stations.
- 15:03Why?
- 15:04Too much risk.
- 15:06If the only thing I did was lend to Sheetz and Wawa gas stations
- 15:11on the leases, my life would be very boring and very profitable.
- 15:15There's gas stations that don't make sense.
- 15:19There's aging gas stations, but it's not 100%.
- 15:22And really during that great recession is that's when I really learned that
- 15:27you need to dig in on a micro level and be a credit union for your members
- 15:33and not just say, we're turning our back on this segment of the community.
- 15:40There's very few, unless you're a video rental company, that was dying
- 15:44and going away, there's very few industries where just 100 percent
- 15:48of the people are going to go bad.
- 15:50Sure,
- 15:50Mark Treichel: sure.
- 15:51There are no absolutes, right?
- 15:52And if you're gonna, if you're gonna write off every business it's like the the
- 15:55thing in Congress where bond owners were having difficult getting bank accounts.
- 15:59And I, there was a congressional hearing on it.
- 16:01It's no, we don't say that they can't have business.
- 16:03But the, but when the government came out with some guidance, all the big
- 16:06banks were just like, you know what?
- 16:08We're not going to deal with them.
- 16:09We're not going to look.
- 16:10We're not going to look at them individually.
- 16:12We're going to look at them collectively and say the juice isn't worth the squeeze.
- 16:17In credit unions it's about serving everybody.
- 16:20And so taking the time to understand them, that RV story is It's a great a
- 16:25great example of how credit unions can help, my internet cut out right there
- 16:29for some reason, Mark, could you repeat what, could you repeat what you just
- 16:32Mark Ritter: Yeah.
- 16:33So that's what I really enjoy with credit unions and why I love what I do is just
- 16:37because of that, we can talk to people and make, yeah, you always have to have
- 16:43the financials always have to make sense.
- 16:46That's a given.
- 16:47But to me, it's more about the story and understanding the business.
- 16:52And the relationship and how it can fit into your strategy.
- 16:56And sometimes I think we lose that as the industry matures because we
- 17:02have, people just want to say, okay, let me just look at the financials.
- 17:06Or maybe we have some newer people that I you know, I reminisce about these days
- 17:10where the industry's gotten so large.
- 17:13Maybe we're just lending in that box of, I just want to do these deals,
- 17:17but I just think we're missing.
- 17:19The opportunity and who we are as a credit union, because, way back when, the N.
- 17:25C.
- 17:25U.
- 17:25A.
- 17:26put us in a box and we had very little flexibility about what
- 17:31we do and today I always say.
- 17:35The last thing in your way of a successfully serving business members
- 17:39is the NCUA because they have never been more flexible and given people more
- 17:45freedom to do what they want to do today.
- 17:47Now with that comes great responsibility.
- 17:51You cannot blame the, there's always that straw man, the NCUA.
- 17:56Why we can't do that.
- 17:57That does not exist today when serving businesses.
- 18:00Mark Treichel: Yeah, that's a great point.
- 18:01And there was the old rule, for example, that said your LTV had
- 18:04to be 80 percent and you could get a waiver if it was over that.
- 18:07And then they shifted to a more principled based approach to what
- 18:12your policies have to include it.
- 18:14And, what your staff skill sets have to be as opposed to you, it
- 18:18having to be spelled out the way the regulation said it used to be.
- 18:20Yeah, I agree that the regulation has come a long way and NCWA has come a long way.
- 18:24Relative to giving credit unions the opportunity to best serve their members.
- 18:29But like you said, a lot of responsibility that, that comes with that.
- 18:32The QSO, a lot of different credit unions own it.
- 18:35And how does that structure all work?
- 18:37Is it to gain access to participate it, you have to be an owner
- 18:43or how does that structure all
- 18:45Mark Ritter: work, Mark?
- 18:47So mbfs is owned by 13 credit unions, but we work with more
- 18:51than 100 credit unions nationwide.
- 18:54So we try to make it very easy for people to work with us.
- 19:00And what I always say is, accused.
- 19:02So like us.
- 19:04It can be a few different people should really use a QSO or the gain
- 19:11efficiencies and I think that's one of the main pieces of, these systems
- 19:15that we have are expensive and to gain to get to big to gain access to scale.
- 19:23We help with participations.
- 19:25We help with originations.
- 19:26We can make your program grow much bigger.
- 19:31It used to be.
- 19:33That you went to a QSO for expertise, and I would say people should go to their
- 19:40business lending QSO for niche expertise.
- 19:44You can't be an expert on everything, but a lot of times people encounter
- 19:52a situation or they're running into some difficulty, you could call
- 19:55us up and say, what do you think?
- 19:58You shouldn't be going to a QSO for what I'll call base expertise.
- 20:03Like you used to 20 years ago, 20 years ago, you could say who's the expert
- 20:08and you would point at the QSO and said these guys tell us what to do.
- 20:11It's not like that anymore.
- 20:12You have to understand what you do on the basic level and stay within that
- 20:19box, but we really can help grow.
- 20:23And do it much more efficiently than maybe doing everything
- 20:28Mark Treichel: internally.
- 20:30Very good.
- 20:30Very good.
- 20:31And if Looking forward.
- 20:34So there's what it used to be, back at the beginning, there's
- 20:37the progress everybody's made.
- 20:38What do you see 2024, 2025 and beyond for the QSO and or for
- 20:44commercial lending and credit unions?
- 20:47Mark Ritter: You made a good point where there was always this rule of 80 percent
- 20:52LTV and what that jammed the industry into was being a real estate lender.
- 21:01We would do any loan as long as it had a piece of real estate.
- 21:06And I think the sh and the shift is going to be, or I think it
- 21:12should be, and it's, and it'll help people to shift to much more of
- 21:16relationships over commercial lending.
- 21:21You want relationships where they're bringing you the deposits.
- 21:26You want relationships.
- 21:28SBA lending is the best program out there that our federal government has, and
- 21:34it's the most underutilized by credit unions, other than a couple niche players.
- 21:40You can help people grow their business with a properly managed line of credit.
- 21:46And they probably have a building that they need to refinance too.
- 21:5110 percent of the businesses out there own their building.
- 21:55We can help people a lot more by focusing on relationships, focusing on deposits,
- 22:02focusing on loans to small businesses, and not just saying it's a better loan because
- 22:09I have a piece of real estate behind it.
- 22:11Excellent.
- 22:12Mark Treichel: Excellent point.
- 22:13And deposits are becoming, we're in an environment right now where deposits
- 22:17growth is as tight as it's ever been.
- 22:19So that relationship and the ability to bring over all the business is
- 22:23a real opportune time right now for credit unions as it relates to that.
- 22:28Mark are there any questions today that I haven't yet asked you that perhaps
- 22:35Mark Ritter: I should have?
- 22:37Yeah I think I really liked talking about the future and I could rem,
- 22:42we could both reminisce the war stories of commercial lending exams
- 22:46from 30 years ago, but I think we'd bore people after a couple hours.
- 22:50I really just think people, like I said, just reiterate that focus on the
- 22:55business focus on relationships, but also today, keeping in mind is that.
- 23:04Your loans, your it's in, it's all about a portfolio strategy and not
- 23:10individual loans and you're, you can't just make the same loan a hundred times
- 23:16over and say, I have a good portfolio.
- 23:19You need a balanced portfolio with a nice diversified mix whether that's
- 23:25participations, business loans, different industries, different geographies, if you
- 23:31just make the same loan a hundred times over to a hundred different borrowers,
- 23:35that's not a diversified portfolio.
- 23:37That's a
- 23:38Mark Treichel: great point.
- 23:39Yeah.
- 23:39And I've had conversations recently with clients relative to pointing out
- 23:44to NCUA that they do have a diverse commercial loan portfolio because they
- 23:48do, 10 different varieties of loans and then building, and looking at that
- 23:52as it relates to concentration risk and looking at that as it relates to
- 23:56net worth and all sorts of things.
- 23:57And 101 type alone is not diversity.
- 24:02Mark Ritter: And so many people, our industry has grown so much and the
- 24:06expertise level, but sometimes when we bring in the new outsiders, many of them,
- 24:12if they came from a commercial bank.
- 24:15They tend to have that sort of mentality where it's not as cooperative and sharing.
- 24:22So if you're listening to this from a commercial bank, it's
- 24:25okay to share with people.
- 24:26It's okay to learn from people.
- 24:28It's okay to cooperate with people.
- 24:30And you're, and you don't have to.
- 24:33Hide everything and it's okay to work together where you maybe didn't
- 24:37do that in some of your past life.
- 24:39But other than that, I had a great time.
- 24:41Thank you for
- 24:42Mark Treichel: having me.
- 24:43Mark, I want to thank you for being on the show and providing your insights.
- 24:46Now, if someone, one of my listeners wants to reach out and talk to you
- 24:50about the QSO or your podcast what's the best way for someone to reach you?
- 24:55Mark Ritter: Sure please subscribe to Credit Union Conversations on
- 24:58your favorite audio platform just and you can do that the second after
- 25:02you hit subscribe for this podcast.
- 25:05Please yeah, that's the easiest way to make sure we come up on your feed to work.
- 25:10But we would love to talk to you about your portfolio and program
- 25:15to see if it's a fit at mbfs.
- 25:17org.
- 25:18You can also check out my personal website of markritter.
- 25:22com.
- 25:23But a lot of people message me.
- 25:24I'm very active on LinkedIn as well.
- 25:27Just search Mark Ritter on LinkedIn and you'll find me that's great, Mark.
- 25:31Mark Treichel: And I'll put those contact points in the show notes for this episode.
- 25:34And I want to thank you again for your time today.
- 25:37Thank you.
- 25:38Very good.
- 25:39And listeners, I want to thank you as always for listening.
- 25:42I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 25:43This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.