Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / How Canada’s New Justice Bill Could Reshape Courts, Sentencing, And Digital Harms
Transcript
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: Oh my goodness, there is a lot here, that's for sure.
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: This uh piece of legislation introduced by the government, so likely to pass um in some form or other, is 76 pages long.
- 0:40Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh only half jokingly I suggested uh, you know, rather than uh the current name of it, you might call this the uh criminal lawyers make work project.
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: But uh boy, there's a lot happening here.
- 0:51Michael Mulligan: And I genuinely hope if they pass all of pass this or something like it, one of the other uh requirements uh is going to be to increase capacity of the justice system, which is already completely stretched uh in terms of judges and courtrooms and crown and legal aid and all the things that are already lacking, is that this is just going to add to it.
- 1:12Michael Mulligan: Uh but a whole bunch here.
- 1:14Michael Mulligan: So some of the things which are uh interesting in it, one of the interesting things that is being proposed here is a introduction of a new type of murder referred to as femicide, uh, which is uh intended to refer to murders of female persons.
- 1:31Michael Mulligan: Um and what it amounts to is uh various different ways in which murder could become first degree murder, right?
- 1:39Michael Mulligan: The there are various ways that could occur now.
- 1:42Michael Mulligan: The most common way that murder becomes first degree as opposed to second degree, right, would be planning and deliberation.
- 1:48Michael Mulligan: Uh there are other ways currently that uh a murder could become a first degree murder, which mandates mandates the uh no prol eligibility for at least twenty five years.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: It's a life sentence either way, but longer prol and eligibility.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: We currently have things like uh if it's a murder of a police officer or a jail guard, uh things of that sort.
- 2:08Michael Mulligan: So what this does is it says that irrespective of whether a murder is planned and deliberate, a murder would become first degree murder in the form of femicide if a number of other things were also established.
- 2:22Michael Mulligan: Um so for example, um if the murder occurred while engaging in or ha having engaged in a pattern of coercive or controlling conduct, first part of it, with the intent to cause the victim to believe that's the next part of it, remembering the victim is necessarily dead, that's the part of litigation, that the victim's or psychological safety is threatened in the case where the victim is the person's intimate partner.
- 2:50Michael Mulligan: Okay, so think about all the elements of that, what that's gonna mean.
- 2:53Michael Mulligan: Uh it can you can also get to femicide in other ways, uh while exercising control, direction, or influence over the movements of the victim with the intent to exploit the victim within the meaning of a section.
- 3:06Michael Mulligan: Also, you could get to femicide uh if uh the murder was motivated by hate based on color, race, religion, national or ethnic origin, age, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or mental or physical disability.
- 3:22Michael Mulligan: Why that last part would be under this category of femicide, I'm not sure, but that's what they've done uh under that heading.
- 3:29Michael Mulligan: So uh this is uh an interesting thing.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: I guess a number of things there for sort of public uh consideration about whether that uh is an appropriate way to handle that.
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: Uh and it should also be apparent looking at that, uh, that it's going to create some uh additional complexity uh in murder trials going forward where the victim is female, um trying to sort out uh things like uh, you know, was there a pattern of coercive or controlling conduct which was intended to cause the person who's deceased to believe that their psychological safety was threatened, for example.
- 4:05Michael Mulligan: Just imagine what that's going to look like in court or trying to explain that to a jury.
- 4:10Michael Mulligan: But uh so that's femicide.
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: That's one of the things that this would add.
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: Um another uh whole series of things are have been introduced here, or if this passes, which would deal with um images online, and interestingly, uh many of them are concerned with now what AI is doing, right?
- 4:30Michael Mulligan: Um so for example, uh this would make it a criminal offense uh for a person to publish, distribute, transmit, sell, make available, or advertise any visual representation that is likely to be mistaken for a photographic, film, video, or other visual recording of a person committing bestiality.
- 4:52Michael Mulligan: So sexual activity with an animal.
- 4:54Michael Mulligan: What that appears to be contemplating is AI generated photorealistic images.
- 4:59Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 5:00Michael Mulligan: Uh you know, only you gotta shake your head at what uh humans do with amazing technology, but uh apparently this is part of it.
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and so it would create this offense if somebody, if it's a visual representation that is likely to be mistaken, so I guess not a cartoon.
- 5:18Michael Mulligan: It would have to be photorealistic, maybe without a uh uh uh a messenger warning on it.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: That's an interesting thing.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: What do you have if you have an AI-generated image that looks very realistic but has printed on it, this is AI.
- 5:30Michael Mulligan: Is that likely to be mistaken for those things?
- 5:32Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure.
- 5:33Michael Mulligan: I'm sure we'll be litigating it.
- 5:35Michael Mulligan: Um also an interesting concept, I must say is an exception to that, that the bestial AI bestiality provision has an exception that is not an offense if the conduct uh was uh to serve the public good.
- 5:50Michael Mulligan: So I guess they're contemplating some version of people circulating AI-generated bestiality images for the public good.
- 5:56Michael Mulligan: Uh you can't imagine quite what all that might involve.
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: Maybe that's the uh uh crown transmitting it or the police transmitting it or something.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: Anyways, that's what they've done, so that will be uh interesting.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: They've also uh created uh definitions dealing with the uh criminalizing the distribution of intimate images, which are obviously also intended to deal with what's become of AI.
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: Um and you know, there's been a little bit of reporting on this that I've read about.
- 6:24Michael Mulligan: I haven't seen it in any criminal cases that I've been involved with, but uh AI generated or modified images.
- 6:31Michael Mulligan: Like apparently there are apps uh that uh you know high school students are getting that are like nudify apps, so they can like take a picture of a person and AI would modify the picture to make it look like the person is naked.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: Uh and so once again you shake your head at humanity, but there it's what we've done.
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: Uh and so this would make it an offense to uh distribute, um, like posting online or saying it to somebody, a visual representation that is made by any electronic or mechanical means.
- 7:03Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure how you're mechanically doing this, but electronically certainly, uh, that shows an identifiable person who is depicted as nude exposing their sexual organs or engaged in explicit sexual activity if the depiction is likely to be mistaken for a visual recording of that person.
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: Just there are a lot of things going on in that sentence, right?
- 7:26Michael Mulligan: Um and so uh, you know, if you had an AI generated image that's likely to be mistaken for a recording of the person, again, doesn't see what what happens if it's like labeled as this is not real, right?
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: Or generated by Nutify app.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: But I guess if the visual recording is likely to be mistaken for a visual recording of the person, it would create offenses prohibiting those things from being um like posted or distributed.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Um other things that are in included in this proposal or this bill, not a proposal, um uh would be to make it an offense to threaten to distribute um child uh images of child sexual abuse.
- 8:09Michael Mulligan: So I think this would contemplate you know somebody who might be online threatening a child with you, you better do something or take more pictures or send me money or do something or I'm gonna publish this, right?
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: Um so that's uh uh I think obviously a serious matter.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: That's that's been added here.
- 8:24Michael Mulligan: They this would uh create uh another uh defense of uh for a person who's in a position of trust or authority or power over somebody.
- 8:32Michael Mulligan: So that would be a first legal question, you know, parent or guardian or teacher probably, uh employer maybe, um, who is trying to uh uh recruit somebody under the age of 18 to become uh party to um a crime.
- 8:49Michael Mulligan: Now it's already an offense to uh uh try, you know, if you're doing something to like encourage or abet somebody to commit a crime, that's already an offense, but this would create a new offense with those elements of under 18 and trust and authority and so on.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: Uh I'm not quite sure what's motivated that is uh coming out as a separate matter.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: They've also uh in this they've uh uh amended a section dealing with a concept of coercive control.
- 9:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and that is being defined in here as repeated instances of controlling conduct, and then there are a whole bunch of things listed here, um, including things like a threat to use violence against a long list of people, including things like an animal owned by a person.
- 9:32Michael Mulligan: So I guess if you're somebody who was repeatedly threatening an animal, that could amount to that.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: Um the other things that are in there, this is interesting, in terms of sort of who might be caught up in this, there are uh the engaging in other conducts, a broad category under this heading of coercive conduct, uh, can include things like um uh a person who is controlling or attempting to control or monitor an intimate partner's location.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: You think cell phone things like that, right?
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: Uh, or uh social interactions or movements.
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: Also, uh, if there was controlling or attempting to control an intimate partner's uh or other partners' finances or monitoring their finances, if that if that uh sort of thing uh might cause the person to feel threatened for their safety.
- 10:19Michael Mulligan: So again, it's not to say that any of these are good conduct, but you can just imagine when I just describe it in that degree of detail, what that is going to look like uh in terms of litigating uh those things and the beliefs and purposes and what is that ca uh what does that uh amount to.
- 10:36Michael Mulligan: Um one of the other things, this is obvious, this large package of amendments uh is intended to try to deal with are some of the uh delay problems which we are already uh dealing with in a virtually crushing manner in the criminal justice system.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: Um a few years ago, the Supreme Court of Canada uh set out sort of presumptive upper limits for how long a criminal case can go before it's considered uh not in a reasonable time.
- 11:02Michael Mulligan: Um and it's important to know that uh none of that includes conduct like the calculation of delay caused by an accused person, obviously, maybe not obviously, but that is not included in that.
- 11:11Michael Mulligan: If somebody's like, you know, unnecessarily delaying something, that does not count in terms of the uh that presumptive uh time limit.
- 11:19Michael Mulligan: But one of the things which has genuinely caused a problem is that in the prosecution of sexual offenses in Canada, uh, and some of this came out of the Gian Gomeshi case, uh Parliament has created a bunch of circumstances where prior judicial approval has to be obtained in order to, for example, ask a complainant in a uh sexual assault case about uh particular records, sometimes text messages, sometimes uh things that might involve other sexual activity that's not the part of the specific charge in the case.
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: And the screening mechanism for those things involves like notice being provided and then uh uh the person getting their own lawyer potentially and a judge reviewing it and having often two different hearings.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: Um and as you can probably tell even from that description, uh that can be time consuming, right, when you're the introducing another lawyer and multiple hearings, and those things occur now in most sexual assault cases because some of those things are so common uh these days, right?
- 12:20Michael Mulligan: Uh the sort of uh material that might be an issue there.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: And so this legislation, if if passed, uh would do things like trying to uh have a longer notice period, like a 60 days notice before that kind of a hearing, presumptively.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: I guess with the idea that might allow more time for the other lawyer to be engaged, that sort of thing.
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then trying not to count time when there wasn't 60 days notice provided, but um and then not to count the actual days that the hearing is occurring, although that seems not particularly significant in most cases.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: Um adding some things to that, trying to ameliorate the delays being caused by all of those screening provisions and hearings that are now required, um, and then also requiring a judge where there is uh potentially going to be a stay of proceedings as a result of a case just being delayed too long, uh, to require the judge to consider whether there's any other just remedy.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: Usually there would not be, right?
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: Uh, you know, but um requiring that to be considered.
- 13:19Michael Mulligan: Um another thing in here, which is also going to add significantly to uh timing in criminal cases is that they've introduced, and this is interesting, a provision providing that mandatory minimum sentences for somebody will not be applicable to the person, uh, if it would result in a cruel and unusual punishment, like a uh or grossly excessive punishment for that particular person.
- 13:43Michael Mulligan: Now, here's really the import of that.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: The way the law is now is if there's an issue about whether a sentence is um uh going to be uh constitutionally impermissible because it's excessive, right, um the court would consider whether it would be that for this particular person or whether that could occur in a sort of a reasonable hypothetical circumstance.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: And if a sentence would be grossly disproportionate, the minimum, then the court would find it to be the minimum to be unconstitutional, and that wouldn't get relitigated in every case, right?
- 14:14Michael Mulligan: This would contemplate uh at least potentially here, a court being required in every single case where that's an issue to be litigating the issue of whether the sentence would be the mandatory minimum would be a grossly disproportionate for this person.
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: And so what that will mean is that in cases where that is so, you will be repeating that litigation process case by case to determine whether that is so.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: Uh, and that is going to add significantly to the burden in uh criminal courts.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: Uh other interesting miscellaneous things, just going through all of this, we have had uh for some time now uh provisions that allow, for example, like young witnesses to testify outside a courtroom, like by closed circuit television or behind a screen to make it more comfortable for them.
- 15:02Michael Mulligan: I find that's generally a positive uh thing, at least from my perspective.
- 15:07Michael Mulligan: Uh but it the idea would be to expand that to other categories of witnesses potentially.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: And also interestingly, at the moment, it permits a person to be uh have a support worker sit with them when they're testifying, like on the video connection.
- 15:20Michael Mulligan: Uh but this legislation would uh allow a support animal.
- 15:24Michael Mulligan: So I guess we may have circumstances where witnesses are testifying with a dog or cat or something in another room hooked up by uh video uh as a matter of accommodation.
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: Um, anyways, none of this is a there's a you know, all of these things have to be, of course, considered on their, you know, on their own merits, whether these things will be helpful or to assist or not.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: But it's very clear from this, without a shadow of a doubt, that if this is passed, there is going to be a increased demand on court time and requirements.
- 15:56Michael Mulligan: Simply more judges, courtrooms, sheriffs, clerks, crown, legal aid, and all of that is going to be required to make this work.
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: Um so a very interesting package of things.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: There's a whole bunch packed up in that, um, you know, that uh should be carefully considered.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: Uh, but uh at least what I've indicated there in terms of resourcing, there's no doubt about it that if you add 76 pages of additional requirements and offenses and considerations and hearings and so on, you need the capacity to actually decide those things.
- 16:28Michael Mulligan: And so it's not free, you can't just do it and make everything go away.
- 16:32Michael Mulligan: Um, you need to be able to have the capacity to do it.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: So that's Bill C 16, introduced uh first reading on December the 9th, so just introduced this week.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: We'll have to watch and see how that makes its way through the just through the uh legislative process, but uh boy, there's a lot uh a lot going on uh in Bill C sixteen.
- 16:50Adam Stirling: All right, let's take our first break.
- 16:51Adam Stirling: We'll be back right after this.
- 17:26Adam Stirling: We've got about four minutes left.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Sure.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Uh so just in your last point, I must say in addition to the uh being able to make sort of democratic judgments about things, the other thing I think we need to bear in mind with just how complex some elements of the criminal law have become is you need to ask yourself, is this going to be effective as a means of deterrence when I'm probably the only one who uh at least maybe live is anyone else listening to this taking the time to read bill C16, all 76 pages of it?
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: How do you expect it to have a general deterrence effect if uh almost no one is going to understand what's going on there?
- 18:02Michael Mulligan: But anyway, that's just an aside.
- 18:04Michael Mulligan: So in the last couple the last just few minutes here, uh there's another case I just wanted to touch on because it has some important uh issues in it.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: And it's another case dealing with this concept under the BC Family Law Act of who is a spouse.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: Um and we've talked about a few of these cases before.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: They are coming up frequently.
- 18:22Michael Mulligan: I'm seeing them just in the reported decisions.
- 18:25Michael Mulligan: Um and the ish particular issue that's getting repeatedly litigated is the fact that under the Family Law Act, even if you don't marry somebody, you're effectively married to them if you live in a marriage-like relationship for a continuous period of at least two years.
- 18:41Michael Mulligan: So that produces a lot of litigation.
- 18:44Michael Mulligan: Uh, and this is another example of that.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: Um it's a uh couple who had uh a complicated and tumultuous relationship that went on for a period of time.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: They were romantic partners, business partners, they lived together, they didn't have children together, but each of them had children from a prior relationship, uh, and eventually the relationship broke down, and the woman in the relationship was suing for things including child support and spousal support, division of property.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: And for I should pause there just for a moment so people uh appreciate this.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: If you wind up uh being in what amounts to a marriage-like relationship, which is continuous for a period of two years, uh, and you stood in the position of a parent in that context, you can be responsible for the child support for the children even if they are not biologically your children.
- 19:31Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that was the a part of the basis of this claim.
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: And because of that definition, it involves, as many of these things do, days of trial, many days, and then a judge in this case writing a twenty nine page judgment, having to pick out all of the various times when who moved in together and who moved out, and were you planning to get back together, and were you fighting, or were you trying to reconcile?
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: Uh, and did this amount to uh you know, marriage like relationship, and was it continuous?
- 19:56Michael Mulligan: Did it end?
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: Did it restart?
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: Um there's a lot of Effort going into trying to sort those issues out.
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: Here, ultimately, given all that complexity, uh the judge concluded no.
- 20:07Michael Mulligan: Certainly during extended periods of time, uh they were living together, but it wasn't continuous for that period of time in a marriage-like relationship.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: And certainly at times when they had sort of broken up, they still sort of had, you know, chats and went on a vacation from time to time and then kind of got back together and then broke up again.
- 20:23Michael Mulligan: But it never amounted to a continuous period of two years, and so that part of the that claim was found not to be marriage-like and continuous uh cohabitation for that period of time, and so the claim didn't succeed.
- 20:35Michael Mulligan: The other thought, the other part of it, which I at least found amusing, was part of the litigation involved a Range Rover, really nice vehicle, not known to be reliable.
- 20:43Michael Mulligan: And there's an issue about whether the Range Rover that the woman had been using, that the fellow had paid for and but she'd been using continuously during a relationship was a gift, or whether he was just allowing her to use it while they were together.
- 20:55Michael Mulligan: Uh and some of the details, including that the vehicle was purchased in 2020 for a little over$101,000.
- 21:01Michael Mulligan: The other amusing element of it was that at the time of the trial, the Range Rover was not working or insured as it was parked to the driveway.
- 21:08Michael Mulligan: So not exactly a great review of the$101,000 Range Rover.
- 21:12Michael Mulligan: The ultimate decision was it wasn't a gift, but maybe the uh bigger takeaway there is the judicial commentary on the status of the$101,000 Range Rover.
- 21:21Michael Mulligan: You might want to take that into account when you're doing your uh car shopping.
- 21:24Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the BC Supreme Court on uh who's a uh who's a spouse for the purpose of the Family Law Act.
- 21:30Adam Stirling: All out of time for this week, but we look forward to the next one.
- 21:32Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers Legally Speaking on T FAX.
- 21:35Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 21:36Adam Stirling: Thanks a butt.
- 21:37Adam Stirling: It's always great to be here.
- 21:38Adam Stirling: All right, quick break.
- 21:39Adam Stirling: News is next.