Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🚨 Market Time Bomb: Historic Bubble Warnings!
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive, where we try to make sense of
- 0:03the market's biggest puzzles. We dig into the sources, try to
- 0:05find the real story. And today we are looking at a
- 0:09really stark contrast, wouldn't you say?
- 0:11A massive dichotomy. We really are.
- 0:13It's it's a strange place for the market to be this October
- 0:162025. You could call it an unstable
- 0:19equilibrium. It's like on one hand you've got
- 0:21these big picture long term signals.
- 0:23Fundamental value kind of stuff. Exactly.
- 0:25Strategic indicators and they are just flashing bright red,
- 0:29screaming extreme caution, really loud alarm bells.
- 0:32OK. But then you look at the
- 0:34day-to-day stuff, the short term picture.
- 0:37Totally different story. The tactical indicators, the
- 0:40ones measuring, you know, immediate fear or risk
- 0:42perception, they're signaling this deep, almost eerie calm.
- 0:46How is that even possible? How can both things be true?
- 0:49That's the big question. Right, That is absolutely the
- 0:51core question for this deep dive.
- 0:52What the sources seem to suggest is that the market is priced
- 0:56well. It's priced for near perfect
- 0:58execution going forward. Meaning everything has to go
- 1:01exactly right. Like earnings inflation,
- 1:04geopolitics A whole lot. Pretty much.
- 1:06Which leaves, as you can imagine, a razor thin margin for
- 1:09any kind of error, any mistake. So it's like.
- 1:13Like a Jenga tower that's way too high.
- 1:14Perfectly balanced for now, but super unstable.
- 1:18That's a great analogy. As long as there's no wind,
- 1:21maybe it stays standing. But the second something
- 1:23unexpected happens, well, the fall could be really fast and
- 1:28messy. OK, let's break this down.
- 1:30We should start with the scary part first, right?
- 1:32The strategic risk, the long term valuation problem.
- 1:36Where do we begin? I think we have to start with
- 1:38the the most talked about maybe the most extreme one right now,
- 1:42the Buffett indicator. Yes, the big one.
- 1:44Simple concept, right? Beautifully simple.
- 1:46That's its power. You just take the total value of
- 1:49all U.S. stocks, the total market cap, and you divide it by
- 1:52the countries annual economic output, the GDP.
- 1:54It's like a price tag for the whole U.S. stock market relative
- 1:57to the size of the actual economy.
- 1:59And it's harder to fudge with accounting tricks than, say, PE
- 2:03ratios. Much harder, less susceptible to
- 2:06corporate engineering like buybacks influencing earnings
- 2:09per share. It gives you a cleaner sort of
- 2:11macro view. So what's the reading?
- 2:13OK, brace yourself. What is it?
- 2:15Right now, the Buffett indicator is sitting at a truly mind
- 2:18boggling 221.6%. Whoa.
- 2:22OK, 221.6%. Let that sink in.
- 2:27The stock market is valued at more than double the entire US
- 2:30annual economic output. And we know how dangerous that
- 2:33zone is, historically speaking. Warren Buffett himself, the
- 2:36indicator's namesake, famously warned that when this ratio gets
- 2:39near 200%. Well, his words were you are
- 2:41playing with fire and. We're not near 200%, we're way
- 2:44past it, 221.6%. Decisively passed it.
- 2:47Now here's where it gets really kind of shocking when you look
- 2:51back. Put it in context for us
- 2:52compared to other bubble. Okthinkaboutthe.com Peak year
- 2:552000. Massive bubble, right?
- 2:57That indicator topped out somewhere between, say, 140% and
- 3:00160%. OK, so significantly lower than
- 3:02now. What about before the O seven, O
- 3:048 crisis? Even lower.
- 3:05Around 110% was the peak then. Wow, so we are currently right
- 3:09now October 2025 in territorythatmakesthe.com bubble
- 3:15and the pre GFC peak look almost modest.
- 3:19Statistically speaking, yes, it's far more stretched.
- 3:21This isn't just a bit pricey. We're talking about historically
- 3:24rare air. It points to extreme optimism,
- 3:27maybe even, you know, euphoria baked into prices.
- 3:30So from a long term investors perspective, someone planning
- 3:33for the next say decade, what does a number like 221.6% imply
- 3:39based on the historical data? Well, it implies a very very
- 3:42high chance of really poor returns, like below average
- 3:45returns, possibly even negative returns after inflation over the
- 3:48next 7 to 10 years. So the gains we've seen, they
- 3:51weren't just companies earning more.
- 3:53Not primarily, no. A huge chunk of the returns over
- 3:56the last decade came from what we call multiple expansion.
- 3:58People just got willing to pay more and more for each dollar of
- 4:01earnings or assets. Essentially borrowing returns
- 4:04from the future. That's exactly the implication.
- 4:06And eventually that bill has to be paid, the multiple has to
- 4:08contract, or earnings have to explode upwards in a way that's
- 4:12frankly hard to imagine. OK, let's.
- 4:14Bring in the other big valuation gauge to see if it tells a
- 4:16similar story. The Shiller KP ratio cyclically
- 4:20adjusted PE. I like this one because it tries
- 4:22to smooth things out right the. Key is smoothing earnings over
- 4:2510 years. It irons out the wrinkles of the
- 4:28business cycle. You know, the temporary booms
- 4:30and busts. Gives a more stable picture of
- 4:32underlying profitability. And the current reading on the
- 4:35TV. It's hovering around 39.5. 39.5
- 4:39OK. And the long term historical
- 4:40average is somewhere around 1718.
- 4:42Roughly 17.6 over the very long term.
- 4:45So yeah, 39.5 is, well, it's way up there.
- 4:49How? Far up there.
- 4:49Where does that rank historically?
- 4:51It's basically the second highest reading ever.
- 4:53The only time it was higher was at the absolute peak
- 4:56frenzyofthe.com bubble when it briefly touched 44.2.
- 5:01So adjust for inflation, smooth out the earnings cycle, and
- 5:04we're basically as expensive today as stocks have ever been,
- 5:07except for that one specific moment of insanity 25 years ago.
- 5:10That's what the data suggests, yes.
- 5:12Now you've looked at the numbers quantitatively, what happens
- 5:15next? When valuations get this high
- 5:18and the CPE is up in this top tier, say above 26 or So, what
- 5:23were the actual subsequent returns?
- 5:24This is the really sobering part that you know you need to
- 5:27internalize if you're thinking long term.
- 5:29In that highest valuation group. Historically, the average real
- 5:33return that's after inflation over the following ten years was
- 5:36just .9% per year. Less than 1% annually for 10
- 5:40years after inflation. Think about that.
- 5:42You take all the risk of owning stocks for a decade.
- 5:45Ride the ups and downs and your purchasing power barely grows.
- 5:49It's effectively a lost decade for wealth accumulation from
- 5:52broad market exposure. And that's the average outcome
- 5:54in that expensive group. What was the worst case?
- 5:56The worst historical outcome from that high KP starting point
- 5:59was an actual loss in real terms, losing medics 6.1% per
- 6:03year every year for ten years after inflation.
- 6:07Ouch. OK, that's the strategic reality
- 6:09check heavy stuff. Now to be fair, there are
- 6:12counter arguments, right? People push back on these
- 6:13historical comparisons. Oh, absolutely.
- 6:16And we should mention, you hear things like, well, U.S.
- 6:18companies earn more globally now, so GDP isn't the right
- 6:21comparison for the Buffett indicator.
- 6:23Right. Or that the economy has changed,
- 6:25more tech companies, less capital intensive, higher
- 6:28margins. So maybe higher valuations are
- 6:31justified now compared to say, the 1950s.
- 6:34And those points have some merit.
- 6:36The structure of the economy has shifted.
- 6:38Global profits do matter. They might help explain why the
- 6:41average valuation, maybe the fair KP ratio isn't 17 anymore.
- 6:45Maybe it's, I don't know, 20, 425 now, but those arguments
- 6:49really struggle to explain the extremity we see today.
- 6:52They don't get you from a justified 25 CPE to almost 40.
- 6:56They don't justify A Buffett indicator over 220%.
- 6:59The current levels seem way beyond what those structural
- 7:02shifts can rationally account for.
- 7:03OK, so if the long term picture looks that risky based on
- 7:07history, why is nobody apparently worried right now?
- 7:10Why does the short term picture look so com?
- 7:13That takes us to the other side of this contradiction.
- 7:15Exactly the tactical tranquility.
- 7:17And the 1st place you look for that is the market's so-called
- 7:20fear gauge, the VIX index. The CBOE Volatility Index.
- 7:25It measures expected choppiness over the next 30 days derived
- 7:28from options prices. Right, that's right.
- 7:31It's basically the price of portfolio insurance.
- 7:34When people are scared, they buy protection and the VIX goes up.
- 7:37When they're confident, they don't bother and the VIX falls.
- 7:40And the current reading is. It's very subdued around 16.6.
- 7:4316.6 and the historical average is more like 20.
- 7:47Closer to 20, yeah. So being in the mid teens like
- 7:50this signals a lot of confidence, very little demand
- 7:53for hedges. Options are relatively cheap.
- 7:55Which leads to that dangerous feedback loop.
- 7:57The volatility paradox. Precisely when volatility stays
- 8:01low for a long time, people get used to it.
- 8:03They get complacent. They might take on more leverage
- 8:06thinking things are safe. They sell volatility assuming
- 8:09it'll stay low. Setting the stage for a bigger
- 8:11shock when something finally does break the calm.
- 8:13Exactly. The sustained low Vol itself
- 8:16becomes a source of instability down the road, makes the system
- 8:19more fragile. And this lack of fear isn't just
- 8:22in the stock options market, is it?
- 8:24What about the credit markets? Sometimes they're seen as
- 8:27smarter, the Canary in the coal mine.
- 8:29Good point. We need to look at credit
- 8:31spreads, specifically the high yield option adjusted spread, or
- 8:35OAS. OK, breakdown Oas for us.
- 8:38What is it measuring? It's basically the extra
- 8:40interest, the extra yield that investors demand to hold riskier
- 8:44corporate bonds, junk bonds, compared to holding super safe
- 8:48U.S. Treasury bonds.
- 8:50It's the market's price on the risk of companies defaulting.
- 8:53So if investors get nervous about defaults, that spread
- 8:55widens out, they demand more compensation for the risk.
- 8:58Exactly. And when they feel confident
- 9:00that companies will pay their debts, the spread tightens.
- 9:04And right now? Right now it's very tight.
- 9:06The OAS is only 2.95%. That's 2.95%.
- 9:10And what's considered a normal or stressed level?
- 9:13Historically, a level below, say 3.5% is considered tight,
- 9:17indicating low perceived risk. Stress usually starts to show up
- 9:21when it gets above 4%, so 2.95%. The credit market is basically
- 9:25saying we're not worried about defaults even among the riskiest
- 9:28borrowers anytime soon. It's endorsing that calm near
- 9:32term outlook. So let me recap the
- 9:34contradiction. We have valuation metrics like
- 9:36the Buffett indicator and KP ratio at levels only seen maybe
- 9:40once or twice before screaming long term danger.
- 9:43Historically extreme valuation. But at the same time we have the
- 9:46VIX near historic lows and credit spreads incredibly tight,
- 9:51signaling almost your own near term fear or perceived risk.
- 9:54That's the unstable equilibrium. That's the tightrope.
- 9:56And this combination, it feels familiar, doesn't it?
- 9:59Haven't we seen this movie before?
- 10:00High valuations plus low volatility.
- 10:02We absolutely have. History really provides some
- 10:04pretty stark warnings here. Think about the mid to late
- 10:071990s dot com mania. Valuation soaring, VIX generally
- 10:11low until it wasn't, and then 2000, 2002 happened.
- 10:15Or look at 2005 to 2007. Housing bubble inflating, stock
- 10:19valuations climbing. Credit spreads tightening to
- 10:22incredibly low levels. Right before the global
- 10:25financial. Crisis exactly.
- 10:27In both cases, that specific combination, sky high Optimism
- 10:31reflected in valuations, coupled with suppressed risk perception
- 10:34and volatility and credit, ended very, very badly, abruptly and
- 10:39violently. OK, let's try to tie this market
- 10:41tension to the actual economy. What's happening on the macro
- 10:44front? Because the yield curve did
- 10:46something interesting recently. It was inverted for ages,
- 10:49signaling recession. Right.
- 10:51The 10 year Treasury yield minus the two year yield was negative
- 10:54for a long time. Classic recession warning.
- 10:56But now it's uninverted. It's steepened again, yes.
- 10:58It has re steepened. The 10 year is now yielding plus
- 11:0154 basis points more in the two year.
- 11:03So a positive spread again. And a lot of people might look
- 11:06at that and breathe a sigh of relief, thinking, okay,
- 11:08recession averted, all clear. But it's not that simple, is it?
- 11:11The way it rest deepens matters. It matters hugely and
- 11:15historically the rest. Deepening after a deep inversion
- 11:18often isn't an all clear signal at all.
- 11:21It's frequently associated with late cycle dynamics or even the
- 11:24start of a recession. Oh.
- 11:26Does that work? It's often what's called a bull
- 11:28steepener. That means the short end yields,
- 11:30like the two year, are falling faster than long end yields like
- 11:34the 10 year. And why do short end yields fall
- 11:36fast? Because the market expects the
- 11:38Fed to cut rates aggressively. And why would the Fed cut rates
- 11:41aggressively? Because the economy is weakening
- 11:43significantly or is already in recession.
- 11:46So the steepening isn't necessarily signaling future
- 11:49growth. It's reflecting the market
- 11:51pricing and Fed rate cuts in response to economic trouble.
- 11:55OK, so the steepening itself could actually be confirming the
- 11:57slow down the inversion predicted.
- 11:59Are we seeing that slow down in the actual data?
- 12:02We are starting to see signs. Yes, manufacturing has been a
- 12:05week for a while. The ISM manufacturing PMI is
- 12:08still below 50 at 49.1 which means contraction.
- 12:12But manufacturing is a smaller part of the economy.
- 12:15What about services? That's been the engine holding
- 12:17things up. And that's where the recent data
- 12:19is more concerning. The ISM services PMI, which have
- 12:22been quite strong, has cooled right off.
- 12:24The latest reading was exactly 50.0.
- 12:27Bang on neutral. Not contracting but not growing
- 12:30either. Stagnation.
- 12:31Exactly. The engine seems to have
- 12:33stalled, and if services roll over, that's a much bigger deal
- 12:36for the overall economy. And this economic softening,
- 12:39this stalling, it creates a huge vulnerability for the market,
- 12:42doesn't it? Because those high valuations we
- 12:44talked about, they're leaning heavily on some very optimistic
- 12:47profit forecasts. That's the critical link.
- 12:50The whole valuation structure relies on expectations of really
- 12:53strong corporate earnings growth.
- 12:54Continuing FactSet consensus estimates, for instance, are
- 12:57projecting what almost 11% earnings growth for the S&P 500
- 13:00this year, 2025. Yeah, 10.8% for 2025 and then
- 13:04another 13.8% for 2026. Those are big numbers.
- 13:07Huge numbers, especially if the economy is actually slowing down
- 13:11like the ISM and the yield curve re steepening, might suggest if
- 13:14that economic weakness forces companies and analysts to slash
- 13:18those earnings forecasts. Then the E in the PE ratio drops
- 13:22and to maintain the same PE the P the price has to drop too or
- 13:26the multiple has to compress dramatically.
- 13:28Precisely that's how the valuation pillar gets kicked
- 13:30out. If the earnings don't
- 13:32materialize as hoped, today's CPE of 39.5 becomes completely
- 13:36unsustainable very quickly. And this all loops back to the
- 13:40Federal Reserve, doesn't it? They just cut rates.
- 13:42Yes, In September 2025, they did a 25 basis point cut, brought
- 13:47the target range down to 4.00 percent, 4.25% and they
- 13:51explicitly said it was partly to support the labor market, which
- 13:54was showing signs of softening. So the Fed sees the weakness
- 13:57too. But here's the rub.
- 13:59They're cutting rates even though inflation isn't back to
- 14:01their 2% target yet, but it's still kind of sticky.
- 14:04That's the really tricky part. Inflation is proving stubborn,
- 14:07staying above target. So the Fed is easing policy into
- 14:10persistent inflation because they're worried about growth.
- 14:12Which sounds like stagflation, slow growth, high inflation.
- 14:16That is the nightmare scenario risk here.
- 14:18Even mild stagflation is incredibly difficult for
- 14:21financial assets, especially for assets priced for the kind of
- 14:24perfect non inflationary growth embedded in current valuations.
- 14:28OK, let's. Pull it all altogether.
- 14:30The synthesis seems to be we're stuck in this unstable
- 14:34equilibrium. Valuations are stretched like a
- 14:37rubber band about to snap. Yeah, stretched by historical
- 14:39standards. But for now, factors like maybe
- 14:43decent liquidity, market momentum and that profound lack
- 14:47of fear measured by the VIX and credit spreads there holding the
- 14:51band taught. For now, it's priced for a
- 14:54Goldilocks outcome. Not too hot, not too cold.
- 14:56That looks increasingly like a low probability scenario given
- 14:59the data. So the crucial question for you,
- 15:01the listener, is what breaks this tension?
- 15:03What are the warning signs, the trip wires that signal the calm
- 15:06is ending and the strategic risks are taking over?
- 15:08We need to watch a few key indicators very closely.
- 15:11These would signal a real regime shift away from tactical calm
- 15:15towards, well, turmoil. Give us the levels.
- 15:18What should we be watching for? OK, first the VIX.
- 15:21Forget little spikes. We need to see it move
- 15:23decisively higher and stay there.
- 15:25A sustained move above 25 on the VIX would signal a structural
- 15:29shift. Fear is back.
- 15:31Complacency is dead. Insurance costs are soaring.
- 15:34Got it. VIX sustained above 25.
- 15:37What's #2. Credit markets need to confirm
- 15:39the fear. Watch that high yield OAS.
- 15:41If it widens out beyond 4%, that's your signal.
- 15:45It means bond investors, the supposedly smart money, are
- 15:48seriously pricing in a higher risk of companies defaulting.
- 15:51That would shatter the current benign narrative.
- 15:53OK, VIX 25 OAS 4%. What about the real economy data
- 15:58the macro triggers? A couple of things there.
- 16:00If we start seeing consecutive months of negative non farm
- 16:03payroll reports, that's a very strong recession signal the Fed
- 16:07can't ignore. Or if inflation does the
- 16:08opposite of what the Fed wants. Exactly.
- 16:10If core inflation starts to reaccelerate significantly, that
- 16:13takes Fed rate cuts off the table.
- 16:14It kills the Fed put that everyone relies on.
- 16:16That would be a major shock. And also keep an eye on that
- 16:19services PMI. If it drops sharply, say below
- 16:2247, that indicates A broader, deeper economic contraction is
- 16:26likely underway. So VIX, OAS, payrolls, inflation
- 16:30and services, PMI, those are the key dashboards to watch given
- 16:34this setup. High long term risk, temporary
- 16:38short term calm. What does this mean for you, the
- 16:41listener? How should you position
- 16:43yourself? Well, given that the outlook for
- 16:46just passively owning the broad market, what we call beta, those
- 16:50look pretty poor over the next decade.
- 16:51Based on these valuations, you probably need to shift your
- 16:54focus. Shift towards what?
- 16:56Towards quality, look for companies with really strong
- 16:59balance sheets, low debt, lots of cash, companies with
- 17:02consistently high profit margins, maybe some pricing
- 17:04power, lesser reliance on debt in the economic cycle.
- 17:08And use the current calm. Absolutely.
- 17:10This period of low VIX, tight spreads, it means protection
- 17:14like options is relatively cheap.
- 17:16Now is the time potentially to think about building hedges,
- 17:19adding downside protection, improving the overall resilience
- 17:21of your portfolio. Don't wait until the VIX is at
- 17:2430 or 40. Because by then it's too late,
- 17:26or at least too expensive. Exactly, the insurance is
- 17:28cheapest before the storm hits. So the key take away is that
- 17:31this weird divergent, this high risk versus low fear, it
- 17:36actually gives investors something valuable time.
- 17:39It does. It's a window.
- 17:40Time to potentially reposition to enhance quality, to add
- 17:44hedges without having to do it in a panic.
- 17:46But the biggest challenge might just be psychological right?
- 17:49Accepting that this period of calm might actually be the most
- 17:52dangerous time to be complacent. That's perfectly put.
- 17:55It feels safe, but the underlying conditions suggest it
- 17:58might be anything but. The final question maybe for you
- 18:01to ponder is this. Is the market's resilience right
- 18:04now a sign of genuine strength? Maybe a new paradigm that
- 18:08justifies these valuations? Or is it simply a reflection of
- 18:11how much risk and therefore how much future return has already
- 18:14been pulled forward and consumed?
- 18:16Is the market running on fumes borrowed from the future?
- 18:19Think about that, especially when you look at the handful of
- 18:21mega cap names driving so much of the index valuation.
- 18:25Are they truly priced for reality or for a perfection that
- 18:28can't last?