Latest / Kentuckiana's Morning News Early Edition w/Scott Fitzgerald / Executive Director of the Kentucky Waterways Alliance Michael Washburn on Senate Bill 89
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Good morning. I'm Tony Cruz. Michael Washburn is the executive
- 0:03director of the Kentucky Waterways Alliance and he joins us
- 0:05this morning. Mister Washburn, good morning.
- 0:08Speaker 2: Good morning.
- 0:09Speaker 1: I'm doing just great. You're not doing so great because
- 0:12Centerbill eighty nine passed overwhelmingly in the Senate and is
- 0:17now a bill. Governor Bisher tried to veto it but
- 0:21was al maneuvered there. So what do you think about
- 0:24this bill? What is first of all, define it for us?
- 0:29And then what are your concerns?
- 0:32Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, it is. It's bad news for all of us,
- 0:35I think so. Senate Bill eighty nine was a bit
- 0:39of a legislation now law that was going to redefine
- 0:42what is known as waters of the Commonwealth to be
- 0:45in alignment with what is known as waters of the US.
- 0:48Those are two rules that governs what lake, streams, ponds,
- 0:52rivers are deserving a protection. Water is the US is
- 0:55a federal rule, what is the Commonwealth of the state rule?
- 0:57That sounds kind of jargoning, belong and sort of it is.
- 1:00SB eighty nine effectively pulls all of the ground water
- 1:04in the state out of environmental permitting and protections, which
- 1:08puts at risk the drinking water supplies of well over
- 1:12a million Kentuckians.
- 1:13Speaker 1: So why doesn't the why don't the federal laws pertain here?
- 1:19And what's what did they not have or do that
- 1:23now has been taken away or not been t away,
- 1:26but the state law made it a little tighter.
- 1:29Speaker 2: I guess, yeah, yeah, it's uh, well it actually it's
- 1:33a good question. The federal waters, the US Rule and
- 1:36the Clean Water Act are there to protect what are
- 1:39known as navigable waters. And in the context of that law,
- 1:42what navigable waters means are interstate waters waters that are
- 1:46considered federally navigable. We're talking to Ohio River, the Salt River,
- 1:50the Green River, the Big Waterways. Everything else was left
- 1:54for the states to protect. So what spaighty nine effectively
- 1:57does is by saying that, oh, the waters of the
- 2:00are now the same as waters of the US. It
- 2:03has the effect of saying, well, our police can only
- 2:06affect the only enforce the laws on our interstates, leaving
- 2:10the back roads, the two lane roads. The surface treats
- 2:13all out of protection. That's the difference. It doesn't frinkson
- 2:17or narrow state protection so much as entirely seed jurisdictions.
- 2:22The state has actually now become the only state in
- 2:24the country to offer up the control over its own
- 2:27waters for an overall controlling federal rule. It is disempowered
- 2:32the state from controlling.
- 2:34Speaker 1: So with that, this was Senator Scott mad and Madam
- 2:39who from Pineville, who brought this out. He says, this
- 2:43law ensures that Kentucky maintains authority over how we regulate
- 2:46and protect our water while aligning our statues with long
- 2:49standing federal standards. It does not diminish safeguards for drinking water,
- 2:53ground water, or floodplains, which will remain fully protected under
- 2:56state and federal law. So what's the beg.
- 2:59Speaker 2: It's that it's categorically untrue the senator's misunderstanding the plain
- 3:04language of his own bill. There, you cannot have the
- 3:10protection on groundwater, for instance, in the state by adhering
- 3:14solely to the Waters of the US, because the Waters
- 3:17of the US rule, which is now the law throughout
- 3:19all of Kentucky, does not protect groundwater. I mean, it's
- 3:25you can't even I don't need to elaborate on anymore.
- 3:27That's just an incorrect statement. It isn't tightening regulation. It's
- 3:31entirely letting regulation goal is what it's doing in effect,
- 3:34And this is going to sound like a theoretical argument,
- 3:36but what it's it's very real and very very dangerous
- 3:39for folks. It has defined groundwater of thermal streams, intermitten
- 3:44strings outside of what it can even be considered the
- 3:48environment in the state. So now there can be I
- 3:51know that sounds like a legal but that's what the
- 3:52law is. The law of defining things. SB eighty nine
- 3:55does not include groundwater or affrimal strains under the state's
- 3:58definition of the environment. Okay, for those don't, there can
- 4:02be no pollution there. So therefore the crazy thing to.
- 4:05Speaker 1: Say, well, so groundwater. Let's face it, I had no idea,
- 4:09but apparently over a million people that still drink water
- 4:14that they have to purify themselves and or have wells
- 4:18or something of that nature, and you're concerned about what
- 4:20poisoning these waters.
- 4:23Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah, there's absolutely no protection for private wells. I
- 4:26believe there are four hundred and sixteen thousand families in
- 4:28the Commonwealth that rely on private wells which pull from
- 4:32groundwater for their drinking water supplies. There are no protections
- 4:37for what happens for the headwaters of streams or for
- 4:39the groundwater. Now, the Senator and his allies have said, well,
- 4:43there are other protections, such as the Safe Drinking Water Act.
- 4:45What that really regulates is the water as it comes
- 4:47out of your tap and into your glass. If you're
- 4:50pulling from a well, there are no protection. Or a
- 4:52stream which a lot of rural water utilities rely on,
- 4:56is groundwater from streams. The Safe Drinking Water Act has
- 5:02control over effectively what comes from the tap and end
- 5:04of your glass. It has no jurisdiction over what happens
- 5:07before it gets into the pipes of the water utility.
- 5:09And so if you're dealing with something like headwater, streams
- 5:12and groundwater in a place like eastern Kentucky or in
- 5:14the western coal fields places like that, if there is
- 5:18runoff or the byproduct of certain sort of industrial production
- 5:24that ends up fouling the groundwaters in the headwaters, then yeah,
- 5:28you can use the jurisdiction of the Safe Drinking Water
- 5:31Act to fix it. But it's going to be astronomically
- 5:33more expensive and never entirely complete to clean the water
- 5:37after its fouled.
- 5:39Speaker 1: I'm going to ask you, why would anybody want to
- 5:42endanger that kind of water. I mean, if what you're
- 5:46saying is accurate here, I mean, I understand water runoff
- 5:50we see down in Florida, for example, the algaie blooms.
- 5:52It's part heat from the golf and all that kind
- 5:55of thing. But now it's expanded. They've talked about agricultural
- 5:57things that are making these plumes, the red tide and
- 6:00all that kind of thing happened. Is this kind of
- 6:03an effective way of kind of looking at it from
- 6:05you know, if you went down to Florida for example.
- 6:09Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean it's all connected. So what happens with
- 6:11the algebra, the agricultural impact on algae blooms, the sort
- 6:14of nitrogen and phosphorus pollutions running off off the ground
- 6:17into the water. Yeah, it's some ways. It's basically it's
- 6:20a very basic principle. Everyone is downstream from something, and
- 6:23hydrologically speaking, everything is all connected. The main emphasis behind
- 6:27the bill was to loosen whatater known as buffer zone,
- 6:31which is how much you can effectively do a bunch
- 6:33of coal mining near headwater streams and epheral streams. So
- 6:37they were wanting to reduce the size of buffer zones.
- 6:39That was the impulse behind it. It isn't to poison people.
- 6:41But the implication of the bill as it was written
- 6:44and as it was passed, is that we are imperiling
- 6:46the drinking water supplies of millions of Kentuckians.
- 6:49Speaker 1: So have you had this becomes a political hot potato,
- 6:52as you know, and I'm getting tired of just yeling
- 6:54the political I mean, is that what's behind here? You think,
- 6:59you know, are the coal miners behind it?
- 7:01Speaker 2: For anyone?
- 7:02Speaker 1: But that are the coal miners behind it?
- 7:05Speaker 2: The coal companies are behind it. You know, Kentucky Waterways
- 7:08Alliance is a member organization. You know, the only our
- 7:11mission is to protect, for store and celebrate. So when
- 7:14we were making a bunch of noise about SB eight nine,
- 7:17we're really doing that response to people who live in
- 7:19eastern and throughout the state. You know, we have members
- 7:21throughout the entirety of the commonwealth, and a lot of
- 7:25our folks who are members and support our organization, they
- 7:28are coal families. They were not behind the bill. You know,
- 7:32coal companies in some industry is behind the bill because
- 7:34you know, deregulation and loosening rules is always is often
- 7:37better for the bottom line, and perhaps some cynical, but
- 7:39it seems to me that there's been very few times
- 7:41in history where an industry or a polluter has been
- 7:44given the right to pollute something and haven't exercised that
- 7:47right when it's going to help their bottom line or
- 7:48make things more convenient.
- 7:50Speaker 1: Well, I've done family in Somerset that they are very
- 7:54much Republican, but they've complained about it and concerned. They're
- 8:00concerned about this as well, just so you know. So
- 8:03there's conservatives that are that are very concerned about this,
- 8:06you know, because it becomes you know, a progressive thing
- 8:08and conservative and yeah, it's it's interesting how this happened. Michael,
- 8:13I gotta go, Thanks for your time this morning. Appreciate it.
- 8:17Speaker 2: Thank you. Talk to you all right.
- 8:18Speaker 1: Michael Washburn, executive director of the Kentucky Waterways Alliance. Gotta
- 8:21get to a break. We're coming back. Scott Fitzgerald has
- 8:23sports coming up.