Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / DOGE Days and Deep Cuts: NCUA in Flux with Bacino & McKechnie
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Kel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be here with former colleagues, friends, and credit union
- 0:07experts John Ney and Jeff Pacino.
- 0:09Guys, how you doing today?
- 0:11I.
- 0:11Very
- 0:12well,
- 0:12Treichel: thank
- 0:12you.
- 0:12Good.
- 0:13Been a little bit of a whips off the last couple days,
- 0:15Treichel: right?
- 0:15Yeah.
- 0:16It's been a, it's been a wild couple wild ride on the NCA Front Credit Union front.
- 0:21And guys, if you could give a little, I know who you are, my
- 0:25listeners, who've heard you on the show before, know who you are.
- 0:28But if you could give a little bit of your background before we
- 0:30start off and who wants to start?
- 0:32John or Jeff?
- 0:34Go ahead Matt.
- 0:35Bacion: Okay.
- 0:35I worked on Capitol Hill in the late eighties.
- 0:38Worked for CUNA for 18 plus years.
- 0:41First in the political affairs area and eventually to the job of senior lobbyist.
- 0:46Then in 2006, I was a appointed Joanne Johnson, who was chairman of
- 0:51NCUA at the time, brought me over as as the head of Congressional Public
- 0:56Affairs, and I happened to be there.
- 0:58I would like to say during the most the five most consequential years
- 1:01in the history of the agency when we had the the mortgage market crisis.
- 1:05And then since 2011, I have been fortunate enough to work, continue working with
- 1:09credit unions as a consultant, a go one of government affairs and advocacy.
- 1:14Treichel: Very good.
- 1:15And Jeff.
- 1:16Bacion: I
- 1:16guess my claim to fame is that I worked with John Ney at Kuna.
- 1:20I was actually the I was the first full-time hire at Callahan Associates.
- 1:24I went over to Kuna after that.
- 1:26Left Kuna went off on my own, was appointed to the
- 1:29NCA Board by Bill Clinton.
- 1:31Then left the board, I would say during the golden years of credit union.
- 1:35So I'll give John the most consequential, but we had the golden
- 1:38years was appointed by George W.
- 1:40Bush to be on the Federal Housing Finance Board.
- 1:42And after I left there, went back to running my own firm and we manage a
- 1:46handful of credit union trade associations and much like John, I still get to
- 1:49work with credit unions in that regard.
- 1:52Treichel: Very good guys.
- 1:53So if we've got consequential and we've got the golden
- 1:56years, what do we call today?
- 2:00On,
- 2:01Bacion: on cuss.
- 2:04Buckle up.
- 2:06Treichel: Buckle up the buckle up.
- 2:08Years.
- 2:10Here we go.
- 2:10So lot going on.
- 2:12I if you disappeared this week and you wonder what's going on in credit
- 2:16unions, president Trump, fired Todd Harper and Tanya Ska on Tuesday.
- 2:23And by the way, we're recording this on Friday.
- 2:25Good Friday.
- 2:26This will go live Monday.
- 2:28And NCAA's website still says they have three board members they've got a little,
- 2:31I noticed that little catching up to do, but yeah guys so what are you hearing?
- 2:36What's going on?
- 2:37What's in your head at, for these buckle up years and buckle up days?
- 2:41Bacion: Jeff, why don't you take that first?
- 2:43Because you're more you're, you have stronger opinions than I ever do.
- 2:48I
- 2:48Bacion: don't know if I have stronger opinions.
- 2:49I'm the one not smart enough to keep 'em to myself.
- 2:51The first thing I think you'd have to say out of it was that this is not, I.
- 2:56Unprecedented lately.
- 2:58Okay.
- 2:58It's unprecedented for credit unions.
- 3:00We've never had this happen where a board member has been fired in the past.
- 3:04The only time board members have been believed of their duty has
- 3:09been after their term expired.
- 3:10And the ones I think about is Bob Swan Yolanda Wheat.
- 3:13I think that's probably all I remember right now but basically
- 3:16your term was over and then.
- 3:19In the case of Swan, the White House wanted to, I think it was probably Norm de
- 3:23Moore wanted to get him outta there, and so he asked the White House to fire him.
- 3:28But until now, it's always been when a term has expired.
- 3:31Bacion: And j Jeff, by the way, I was gonna add, I'm glad you jogged or memory
- 3:36on that because I remember the Bob Swan I issue and I thought that he actually
- 3:41came to the office and was escorted out.
- 3:44Yes.
- 3:44He was, from what I remember, he was, his term was finished, but he still had
- 3:49the ability, legal ability to continue in office until the successor's appointed.
- 3:54That's what the act said.
- 3:55And if I remember the White House case, 'cause Bob did Sue and he lost
- 3:59because the White House's position was, at that time, Yolanda Wheat had been
- 4:03nominated and I believe had a hearing.
- 4:06I don't think she'd been confirmed by the full Senate.
- 4:08So in the White House legal opinion at that point.
- 4:12Her, his successor had been quote unquote qualified.
- 4:15Think that was the word they used back then.
- 4:17And again, you both know I'm not a lawyer, I don't play one on tv, but
- 4:20that's what I remember outta that.
- 4:21So yeah, Swan was that.
- 4:23But the thing now and basically since inauguration day, you've seen
- 4:27it, we've seen entire departments, U-S-A-I-D CFPB disappear.
- 4:32If you drive into DC from Virginia now, you would pass the old U-S-A-I-D.
- 4:37Office, which is in the Ronald Reagan building, which no longer
- 4:40even has the name on the wall as it used to until about two months ago.
- 4:46So these are, I said unprecedented, yet not unprecedented with what's going on.
- 4:51Trump, the Trump administration has done the same thing with FTC the
- 4:56National Labor Relations Board, the Merit Pay Systems Board basically
- 5:00taking out people that they didn't want.
- 5:03And to me, I.
- 5:05The reason this is consequential is obviously because as a board member,
- 5:10at least for me, in the past, it was always assumed you served out your term.
- 5:15Okay?
- 5:16So we can talk about the Harper Renomination, but for Abda it was,
- 5:22Tanya had a term that ran through 2029.
- 5:26And, basically was told on Tuesday night, you're fired.
- 5:30Yeah.
- 5:30And so again, unprecedented times in terms of our agency, but not unprecedented
- 5:37in terms of the last three months.
- 5:40Bacion: And John, I'm sorry, mark.
- 5:41Go ahead.
- 5:42No.
- 5:42John, you go ahead.
- 5:44The independent agency aspect of this is interesting.
- 5:46Although I will say, I know.
- 5:49The weeks the events of the last week have been very high wire act.
- 5:53It's been dramatic in some ways, melodramatic.
- 5:57But I would also point out that independent agencies, I'm not certain,
- 6:01and we can have a semantic debate about what independent agencies mean.
- 6:04They're part of the executive branch.
- 6:06Presidents have typically exercised the ability to fire, in 2021, president Biden.
- 6:12Fired the head of CFPB.
- 6:14Actually, she submitted a resignation an about an hour before she was
- 6:18told she was gonna be fired.
- 6:20That was the Trump appointed CFPB head, who was dismissed by Joe Biden.
- 6:24A couple weeks later, the head of the Federal Housing Finance
- 6:27Agency, mark Calabria, who was in office for a term, was fired.
- 6:32The republic did not end when that happened.
- 6:34I'm not trying to minimize or tell credit unions that they shouldn't be.
- 6:39Be on edge about some of the things that have happened at NCA this week,
- 6:42but, appointees get dismissed, and the courts have more recently said that,
- 6:47presidents have latitude to fire people.
- 6:51By the way, you mentioned CFPB.
- 6:52I want to interject something.
- 6:53It's nothing to do with NCA, but this morning I got a quick
- 6:57update from Capitol Hill.
- 6:59It sounds like CFPB is going to dismiss all but about 200 of their employees.
- 7:05Which I think brings them from about a thousand or plus down to 200.
- 7:09So that's an agency that's clearly re, re repositioning itself under the Trump
- 7:15administration, which you'd expect it to.
- 7:17Donald Trump and Joe Biden, or Donald Trump and Barack Obama are
- 7:21very different creatures when it comes to their views of government.
- 7:25And that's what we're seeing this play out is I think Trump, campaigned
- 7:29on it being a change agent.
- 7:31We're getting change.
- 7:33Treichel: We are getting change.
- 7:34And the thought on the thought of the CFPB, 'cause I've talked about,
- 7:37so I was the executive director when NCA shut two regions and, walked
- 7:42through the alternatives of what you could consider as an agency and
- 7:46a reduction in force is an option.
- 7:49It didn't it wasn't a kind way of doing things, but it's also not a really
- 7:53effective way of doing things, generally speaking, because what happens in a rif.
- 7:58The highest ranking person bumps into the next person, bumps into the next
- 8:01person, bumps into the next person, and you can get people save their pay.
- 8:05You don't save a lot of money, and at the bottom you end up
- 8:08getting rid of some of the newer people, the lower costing people.
- 8:12But I hadn't thought about Arif.
- 8:15So large of CFPB taking 1200 people doing it down to 200.
- 8:23That way you do save money when you get rid of five out of every
- 8:26six people, nobody's left a bump.
- 8:29And
- 8:29Bacion: on that point, mark and Jeff you and Mark May have a better perspective
- 8:33than I do, but I have heard various people who are currently at the agency
- 8:38who speculate that upwards of 200.
- 8:41To 250 people there are gonna take an early retirement by the end of
- 8:45the year, which will bring NCAA's head count down to about a thousand.
- 8:49If I'm not if I'm not mistaken.
- 8:51Treichel: Jeff, I have some thoughts on that, but why
- 8:53don't you, what have you heard?
- 8:54I've heard a couple things.
- 8:55Obviously, the Doge influence.
- 8:58Comes into play.
- 9:00I had heard that what they were gonna discuss at the board meeting that
- 9:02they didn't have yesterday because you don't have a quorum, was this I would
- 9:06say buyout plan, a retirement plan.
- 9:08I understood it had two major components.
- 9:11The first is if you were not if you were not eligible to retire, you
- 9:15could go on administrative leave through the end of the year with pay.
- 9:19But you would leave immediately unless you were wrapping up an
- 9:23exam or something like that.
- 9:24If you were eligible, retirement eligible, you could take a lump sum check.
- 9:29I understood it was five 50 grand and then you could leave, but you
- 9:34would not be on administrative leave.
- 9:35You were just gone.
- 9:37I do agree with both you, I think I've heard that it, they're trying
- 9:39to reduce the force by about 20%.
- 9:42And then what I heard was if they couldn't do it voluntarily,
- 9:45you would do it involuntarily.
- 9:47And and again, that, that takes you down in that in 1,012 hundred.
- 9:50People range
- 9:52Bacion: there.
- 9:52There was a Doge paid a visit to NCUA.
- 9:55I think everybody it was reported in the press.
- 9:57This is not a secret.
- 9:58I understand.
- 9:59Last Thursday at least some, somebody told me three Doge staff showed up.
- 10:04Somebody told me four doge staffs showed up, but whatever the number is, they
- 10:08were in the building last Thursday.
- 10:10I have not heard anything at all about their findings or
- 10:14conclusions or if they're reporting to anybody at the White House.
- 10:18What I did hear from an NCUA staff person who the three of us all know
- 10:22is that those, when they were in the building, made comments about how much
- 10:27empty space that they saw, and they thought was it that they they noted
- 10:32that and they apparently noted in a way that sounded like they were gonna
- 10:36make some recommendations off of that.
- 10:38With the disclaimer that predictions are hard to make, especially about the future.
- 10:42Thank you, Yogi.
- 10:43I'm, I wouldn't be completely surprised if some recommendations were made
- 10:47about the NCA building and use future use of that, but I don't know what
- 10:52those recommendations are gonna be.
- 10:54Treichel: I've heard some, a lot of what you just both
- 10:58said, similar versions of that.
- 11:01I will, I.
- 11:02Heard today that they are going to hit their 20% number that the
- 11:06returns keep coming in, right?
- 11:08And probably the firings of some board members had some people go, you know what?
- 11:11And John, like you said this happens, right?
- 11:13So it's it happens.
- 11:15But when it happens to you, it could make some people make that decision.
- 11:20I also, I heard something similar to Jeff on the two options.
- 11:23There was the one, there was Trump's fork in the road.
- 11:26NCA has their own version of fork in the road, and those folks are accepted.
- 11:32Something that gets them through September and they're on admin
- 11:35leave and they don't have computers.
- 11:38There's the second batch that had to commit to staying till December 31st.
- 11:45But leaving on December 31st, which then allows them to get that 50 K bonus.
- 11:51And then the way that I had the agency had set up, people who are at
- 11:57a capped pay get a lump sum for what they would've earned for the year.
- 12:01So they can double dip on that if they get if they sign up for
- 12:05this and stay through the 31st.
- 12:07But 20% change one out of every.
- 12:12Sick.
- 12:12One of every five people gone.
- 12:14And it's people who've been there a long time, people with
- 12:16a lot of corporate knowledge.
- 12:17What's the, when the dust settles, what is that going to look like?
- 12:21And you could have people, I was directed Reas.
- 12:24There were not a lot of directed Reas assignments at NCUA.
- 12:27I was direct reassigned by Damour.
- 12:30When I got a phone call from Bob Swan, it said, mark, do what?
- 12:33Do you know what's happening at the nsu, a board meeting and how it pertains to you?
- 12:37I had heard some rumblings and I was told you're gonna there's a vote to
- 12:41make you Deputy Executive Director.
- 12:42What will you do if you get a call that says you have to move?
- 12:46I call, I called my wife.
- 12:48We'd only been in, in Albany for a short time, but I wanted to be an RD and I
- 12:51was like, I was young and I did it.
- 12:53But, so now you have all these 20% of people leaving and people
- 12:57going, Hey, if this 20% leaves, that leaves me in the top.
- 13:01X percentage of experience.
- 13:03I'm in this location.
- 13:04I know they don't have enough people there.
- 13:06You could get not necessarily if they hit the goal and don't have a riff,
- 13:09you could get directed reassignments, which could then say, move somebody's
- 13:13cheese from Virginia to Phoenix.
- 13:19That and that, obviously, and you and I know this Mark, we,
- 13:22when I was on the board the.
- 13:24Rd spot in Albany opened up.
- 13:26And I think I came to you and said, look I knew that's where you were from.
- 13:29The ideal thing would be that they take into account people's wishes.
- 13:36And I said ideal, because I frankly don't think it, it always happens
- 13:39and sometimes it can't happen.
- 13:41At some point you need someone there.
- 13:43And so I think what you're gonna see over the next couple months
- 13:45is obviously a reshuffling.
- 13:47And you're right, you start to lose a lot of that top.
- 13:50Management.
- 13:50You lose that brain drain of people who have an institutional memory.
- 13:55That's, to be honest, what scares me the most, if you start losing
- 13:59people, I know John saying your praises earlier, I would do the same.
- 14:02But we've got a lot of people at the agency now that could leave and you
- 14:08tack that onto the people you know, like you that have left you've got a
- 14:12handful of folks who are just quality.
- 14:15People who knew the history of the agency and the history of decisions.
- 14:19And that's what I find scariest is that you're gonna have a lot
- 14:21of people who frankly may try to reinvent the wheel at the peril of
- 14:27basically credit unions and the agency.
- 14:29Treichel: Yeah.
- 14:29You just reminded me of a quote I use on occasion is if you don't
- 14:32know why offense was put up, you might not wanna take it down.
- 14:39Bacion: Yes.
- 14:41And we're gonna see that.
- 14:43I'm trying to, you guys are talking.
- 14:45I think it's fascinating to hear the specific specifics of this.
- 14:50I'm trying to keep my eyes on the bigger prize with NCA and I'm, I've been talking
- 14:54to my clients about this over the last couple days, which is, the actual.
- 14:58Regulation examination, supervision of credit unions, to me is still
- 15:02the most essential thing to talk about and to stay focused on.
- 15:06And whether we have a board that can function like it usually does, or
- 15:10whether the board is able to promulgate rules, which I don't think it will
- 15:13be able to with one person, but the.
- 15:17The real function that, that the public and the financial public as well as the
- 15:22industry, everybody needs to focus on the fact that NNC a's got to continue
- 15:27keeping us iron the ball when it comes to things like safety and soundness
- 15:30and the proper regulation of credit unions and the safety of the share
- 15:34insurance fund, all those things.
- 15:35I think, the disruptions that are have occurred this week at
- 15:38the board level are one thing.
- 15:40But let's I have a great deal of confidence that, that the cooler
- 15:45heads that prevail are gonna say, let's make sure that function
- 15:48is not disturbed in any way.
- 15:50And that's the hope.
- 15:51Let's hope that nothing happens with that.
- 15:53And I don't see any signs.
- 15:54It will, I think right now that the board is gonna be sorted out.
- 15:57If you want a look around the corner as to what may happen, my instinct
- 16:02tells me that we're gonna have two new board members appointed.
- 16:05And it may be unusual, it may be something that still rubs a lot of people the wrong
- 16:11way, and I get that, but ultimately life's gonna go on with it when it comes to
- 16:15NCA and its oversight of credit unions.
- 16:18Treichel: Jeff, thoughts on that?
- 16:20I think John, absolutely obviously, every board member's ever served,
- 16:23any board member that's gonna serve.
- 16:25Always loves those motherhood, apple pie and baseball words of safety and silence.
- 16:30Okay.
- 16:30We use that, as a mantra that says, okay, this is what you do.
- 16:33And so John's right, it, they've gotta keep up the blocking and tackling
- 16:37that there are supposed to do.
- 16:40Now until a couple probably a couple of hours ago, I probably would've
- 16:44disagreed and said, I think we may be.
- 16:46On a ride toward regulatory consolidation, which scares the hell outta me.
- 16:51But I think I've come to the grips after talking to a
- 16:53handful of people that I trust.
- 16:55Handful of people that are I believe in the know.
- 16:57But this may be more of a these firings may be more of kind of an overall
- 17:00plan to be able to put a target on the back of Fed Chairman Powell.
- 17:05And so I think it's, I think it's an and I'm gonna, I wrote
- 17:10about this in my scene report.
- 17:11You guys will be getting it a bit.
- 17:12I called it the canary in the coal mine.
- 17:14You fire all these people and in a minute I would wanna talk about
- 17:18the court case that decides this.
- 17:20You fire all these people if they all stick.
- 17:22In other words, if they don't get successfully challenged, then that tells
- 17:26the administration you can fire Powell.
- 17:28Even though he's got time left on his term, in other words, I think the
- 17:30argument would be, fired all these other people, nobody did anything.
- 17:34Courts decided we could do it.
- 17:35Now I can do this.
- 17:36So if that's the case, I believe John's 110% correct.
- 17:40I think we will get two new board members.
- 17:42To me this whole thing is gonna play out.
- 17:44Against the backdrop of, and again, you guys know I'm not a lawyer, but
- 17:49there was a Supreme Court case and.
- 17:51People have heard more about it in the last, probably three
- 17:53months than they ever have before.
- 17:55It's called Humphrey's Executor versus United States.
- 17:57It was a case from the Supreme Court in 1930s.
- 18:00Calvin Coolidge had appointed someone to the Federal Trade Commission,
- 18:03and when Roosevelt came in, he didn't feel that board member was
- 18:07sufficiently invested in his new deal.
- 18:09And so he twice asked him to quit.
- 18:11Both times.
- 18:11Humphrey told him no.
- 18:12So he finally fired him, took the Supreme Court, decided nine
- 18:15zero that he couldn't fire him.
- 18:17Now the interesting thing to me about that decision.
- 18:19Was Supreme Court made a bit of a change between that idea that
- 18:24they were executive branch only.
- 18:27Their reasoning was because they promulgated rules that made 'em
- 18:30similar to the legislative branch and because they enforced those rules that
- 18:33made 'em similar to Judicial branch.
- 18:35I had an argument with a lawyer the other day that said you can't have
- 18:37a quasi-government agency, which is what we've always called NC A.
- 18:41But the reality is I think they do duties that are beyond that now.
- 18:45Having said that, that case has been cited frequently, and it's the one that
- 18:50justice Roberts cited when he allowed the Trump administration to continue their
- 18:55firing of somebody from the National Labor Relations Board and the merit
- 18:59pay system, which again, from what I've read, signals that Roberts feels there's
- 19:05enough votes or there's enough votes on the court right now to overturn that.
- 19:10So similar to things like Roe v, Wade and some of these other things that
- 19:15the court has overturned recently.
- 19:16They may overturn it, and frankly, I think if they overturn it, it opens the
- 19:19floodgates to saying, you know what?
- 19:22I can't fire anybody you want if I'm the president of the United States.
- 19:24Bacion: Yeah I actually took the time, this may shock you to, to look at the
- 19:28Federal Credit Union Act on Wednesday afternoon, and what I saw was that
- 19:32there is really no, there's no for cause provision in the act like there is in
- 19:36some other federal agencies like CFPB.
- 19:40So I think that the, the president's probably gonna hang his hat,
- 19:43if you will, on that idea that.
- 19:46I can fire these people and don't have to give a reason, and
- 19:49that's a, that's just a guess.
- 19:51But Jeff, Jeff cites the case that apparently is gonna decide
- 19:56a lot of things over the next few months as to how much latitude this
- 19:59president has to dismiss people.
- 20:02Treichel: And I'm sorry, go ahead.
- 20:03Bacion: No I just think it's it is and I, in.
- 20:07I didn't want to interrupt you, mark, but I want to get back to something Jeff said
- 20:11about, the future and about what happens when if there are two new board members
- 20:16and the consolidation issue, which I have, I've been all over the map on that.
- 20:20So let's get to that in a minute.
- 20:22Treichel: Okay.
- 20:22Let's get to that.
- 20:23The one thing, that Supreme Court case, and I'm not a lawyer
- 20:27I read a little bit about it.
- 20:28I'm seeing some things that are said it looks like the quote I saw
- 20:35about that case said you can't fire him for political reasons if there
- 20:38were different reasons, the Supreme Court might decide differently.
- 20:42And I also, so that was percolating in my head and then I saw on LinkedIn.
- 20:47Inclusive made a comment about you shouldn't be firing
- 20:50people for political reasons.
- 20:51And then Todd Harper commented on that and highlighted that word, political reasons.
- 20:55And you can argue was it a political reason or wasn't it a political reason?
- 20:59A and but if you get, this is kinda like when you riff somebody, you're saying
- 21:04you're doing it for X, y, z reason.
- 21:06What did the letter say that Harper got and.
- 21:09And ska got, did it just say, I'm relieving you?
- 21:12Did it say, I'm sure it didn't say, I'm relieving you for political reasons.
- 21:15Did it say I'm removing you because you didn't get your plan into OPM on time.
- 21:20Were there things that, that you, that the agency is living by the
- 21:24contract to the union and not bringing back people to work there, there can
- 21:29be arguments that it was made for.
- 21:32Business decisions, but those business decisions could be
- 21:35interpreted into political reasons.
- 21:36I'm and then so the other piece of that then, so if this is positioning for
- 21:41Chair Powell and we're not attorneys, Harper and Ska Ken Sue Masu, probably
- 21:46will Sue pick one of those options.
- 21:48How does this get elevated to, in a fashion in the courts
- 21:52so that it does, it, it can.
- 21:55Serve as precedents for him to take action against Powell?
- 21:59Or is it just gonna be, we wait two months?
- 22:01Nothing.
- 22:02Nobody's sued nobody.
- 22:03Nobody got any, whether, okay.
- 22:04Now it's okay to get rid of Powell.
- 22:07All hypotheticals.
- 22:09Bacion: Those are great questions.
- 22:10I don't know if anybody has any real answers to 'em.
- 22:12I think the ball started to roll back when the president fired the
- 22:17FTC commissioners a couple weeks ago.
- 22:19That's when, and that honestly, I remember when that happened.
- 22:23I happened to be with with, at that day with somebody who was at, NCA
- 22:28senior staff person, and I think we both looked at each other and said,
- 22:31that could be the opening bell for what may happen eventually over here.
- 22:35I didn't know when, and I didn't know exactly what, but when the president
- 22:39reaches into an agency like that and dismiss democratic appointees I
- 22:43thought it was highly possible that the same thing could happen in NCUA.
- 22:46And here we are.
- 22:48Mark you, but
- 22:48you talked about where this goes.
- 22:50I think if the court, if the Supreme Court decides, okay, you can do it.
- 22:55I think that pretty much ends anything.
- 22:56Now, if I'm Todd or Tanya, the what?
- 22:59You have to wake up, yesterday morning, this morning thinking
- 23:02about is, do I wanna sue?
- 23:04I know that's where everybody goes.
- 23:06But I don't forget, that's expensive.
- 23:09Okay?
- 23:10When?
- 23:10When we were all at NNC A, if anybody sued nnc A, who defended
- 23:14US Department of Justice, okay?
- 23:16Last time I checked, department of Justice doesn't clock by the hour, okay?
- 23:19They don't really care.
- 23:21When you gotta go out and hire your own lawyer, you gotta pay.
- 23:24You gotta pay money, your money.
- 23:26And so the question I think they have to the ask themselves, is it worth it?
- 23:30Is it worth the time and trouble?
- 23:32What I think, again, if I were in that position, what I'd do is I'd
- 23:36watch these other ones play out and then determine what I wanted to do.
- 23:41In other words, if.
- 23:42FTC case or the National Labor Relations case is if those board members are
- 23:47successful, then I go back and look at it.
- 23:50But again, at this point, they may almost be throwing good money after bad.
- 23:54If they start spending money for lawyers that, that are working
- 23:58on a case that may never win.
- 24:00So again and the one thing I did hear, okay, and this is again
- 24:03rumor, but the three of us know that sometimes the rumors are the most fun.
- 24:07Is that one of the things that was that was cited in the letter was that
- 24:11they weren't coming to the office.
- 24:12I.
- 24:13Bacion: And I heard, and I heard that secondhand the Doge people again and I
- 24:18don't think this necessarily has a buried on the board members' dismissals, but
- 24:22again, the Doge commentary was lot of empty space here and that they question
- 24:30supposedly questioned how much the return to office directive has been followed.
- 24:35And if that's the case, again, I'm.
- 24:39I'm cutting the, splitting the baby here.
- 24:41We're talking about the board dismissals, but we're, I'm also talking
- 24:44about the future of the agency in terms of how it functions, where it's
- 24:47located, the building use, et cetera.
- 24:50That to me is also an equally fascinating topic and I think
- 24:54we're gonna get some more clarity on that over the next few weeks.
- 25:00Treichel: All great thoughts.
- 25:00I did hear recently.
- 25:05That NCUA agencies had to report at least weekly on how many
- 25:12people they'd gotten rid of.
- 25:14And under NCA's plan, it's been zero and still is zero until people started
- 25:20taking the plan that they approved late.
- 25:23Okay.
- 25:24You add to that, that, that.
- 25:29Helpmann went from wanting to propose Harper as Vice chair to pulling that off
- 25:34the agenda in violation of the Sunshine Act to correcting the Sunshine Act error.
- 25:41Th that may have gotten the B both of those things may have gotten nnc a's on
- 25:47the attention ladder, or they could have already been on the attention ladder.
- 25:50And none of that has to do with anything.
- 25:51But when you lay out a timeline of things that have happened or not
- 25:55happened at NCUA, I think it might have.
- 25:58Put the target on them potentially.
- 26:00Bacion: There's no such thing as a coincidence, especially in this business.
- 26:03And I think do, coming in last week, starting to, may, may have
- 26:07started the process that we saw come to a head on Wednesday.
- 26:10I wanted to ask you guys about your thoughts on the consolidation.
- 26:14'cause I've been like, Jeff, I've been all over the map on that.
- 26:17And I think when it first happened Wednesday I got a
- 26:20strong sense that the dismissal.
- 26:23Maybe a first step to getting N two A rolled into another super
- 26:27regulator, whatever that means.
- 26:28And that's been out in the press since February.
- 26:31People in Capitol Hill talked about a consolidation where the O-C-C-F-D-I-C
- 26:36would be moving into treasury.
- 26:38People in the hill said, don't think you're gonna be escaping that either.
- 26:41'cause your regulator's gonna be part of it.
- 26:43But now, as I, as this thing ca happened on Wednesday,
- 26:47I've gotten a stronger sense.
- 26:49From one person in the administration and one person on Capitol
- 26:53Hill who has knowledge, direct knowledge of consolidation plans.
- 26:57Sounds there's a realization that credit unions and NCUA are distinct
- 27:01enough that, that they shouldn't be part of the bank matrix.
- 27:05I think that's, that might be the best news I've heard in a long time.
- 27:09Treichel: That's fabulous.
- 27:10Yeah, I, yeah, if it's true.
- 27:11If it's true.
- 27:12Jeff,
- 27:13what things?
- 27:15Three things make me feel better.
- 27:17One is that the Treasury Secretary has no interest in wanting to
- 27:22regulate or be part of this, of a regulatory function where he's in
- 27:26charge of F-D-I-C-O-C-C-N-C-U-A-F-T-C, whatever's left to CFPB, maybe even the
- 27:33commodities Future Trading Commission.
- 27:35If you have somebody who wants to create a kingdom.
- 27:38That, that would appeal to 'em.
- 27:39Evidently, it doesn't appeal to the Treasury Secretary.
- 27:42Second thing is, and I've always thought this, the way that the one, the way that
- 27:46credit unions are funded by just credit Union money led me to believe that, you're
- 27:50gonna have to, Congress at some point is gonna have to, would've to approve
- 27:55merging the share insurance fund in with.
- 28:00And while it sounds easy, and I get a lot of people telling me, oh,
- 28:03come on Jeff, you can do something like that, with the stroke of a pen.
- 28:05The reality is that one of the reasons I think these discussions
- 28:09that I'll gonna be having now.
- 28:11Are so hel or skelter is because of the way this administration has basically
- 28:15just taken over and done things.
- 28:18And Congress really hasn't gotten involved in much of it.
- 28:21And you and the three of us know that once Congress gets
- 28:23involved, things slow way down.
- 28:25Okay.
- 28:26All of a sudden.
- 28:27We better have a hearing and we've got a hearing with 10 people who
- 28:30think it's a great idea and 10 people think it's a stupid idea.
- 28:32Now we gotta start horse trading.
- 28:33And this affects my and in essence, you get a commission that's gonna study it and
- 28:38they're gonna have to report back in 2028.
- 28:40So I, I will say this, I think regulatory consolidation is, if it happens,
- 28:46would be the most existential threat.
- 28:48To the credit union movement.
- 28:49Okay.
- 28:50I don't think we look and act like we do now if we're in a regulator
- 28:56with just with everybody else.
- 28:58And this is one of those cases where I can always tell people,
- 29:02look, I lived through it.
- 29:03Okay.
- 29:04I was at the Federal Housing Finance Board.
- 29:06They merged us in with eo, the Fanny and Freddie Regulator.
- 29:10And again, I remember everything.
- 29:12We were told, oh, we're gonna have silos.
- 29:13There's a federal, all known bank silo, there's a fanny silo, there's
- 29:16a Freddie Silo, and it all goes up through the director again.
- 29:19Sounds great.
- 29:20Everybody's equal.
- 29:21No, we're not.
- 29:22Okay.
- 29:23Fannie and Freddie are still 800 pound gorillas.
- 29:26And I like to joke that 1600 pound gorilla on your back if you're a
- 29:30federal home loan bank and frankly, I hate to say I was, I was right.
- 29:34But looking back, that's what's happened.
- 29:37The Federal Housing Finance Agency focuses on Fannie and Freddie, and we've got these
- 29:41banks, and I think if we were put into an agency with Chase Wells Fargo, Citi.
- 29:47In the end it's gonna be like, oh yeah, don't they have a credit
- 29:50union that's about that size?
- 29:52And again, frankly if there was no trade off for doing it, in other words, there's
- 29:55no open field of membership and there's no expanded business lending, why would
- 29:59a credit union stay at credit Union?
- 30:01If you're Navy and they tell you, oh, you're gonna be in this new
- 30:04super regulator, but you still gotta be the same way you were.
- 30:07I'm gonna say, you know what, I'm gonna be Navy Bank.
- 30:11Bacion: All good points, all.
- 30:13I worry about consolidation threat too.
- 30:15I, my, my thoughts of it have changed recently.
- 30:19'cause in February I got a, I got both barrels from somebody
- 30:22on Capitol Hill who said they're looking at NCUA as part of it.
- 30:27I'm actually surprised at how I'm now starting to.
- 30:32Think that maybe we're NCA is gonna be okay.
- 30:35And by the way, I heard the same thing Jeff did about the Secretary of Treasury
- 30:39saying he's not really that interested in in being part of this, being at
- 30:43the pinnacle of the super regulator.
- 30:45It remains to be seen obviously, but I think we can, I think we
- 30:49might be able to survive that.
- 30:51Treichel: That's consistent kind of with what I've been thinking.
- 30:54And the one thought.
- 30:56I thought could be possible.
- 31:00It is like a constructive conservatorship of a credit union where N two A
- 31:04wants to conserve a credit union might conserve a credit union, but
- 31:07the board is so cooperative and staff are so cooperative, you might
- 31:10as well let them run it themselves.
- 31:13In this scenario, Trump in, in some instances has said, okay, agency A,
- 31:18the head of agency A is going to be in charge of agency A and agency B.
- 31:23Let's say we get to August and Halman finds happiness elsewhere, or they
- 31:27say, you know what Kyle, your terms up.
- 31:30S let's have Rodney Hood, who's acting at OCC be in charge of OCC and NCUA.
- 31:37Us a a.
- 31:39Consolidation, that's not going to Congress.
- 31:41A consolidation that just has leadership for the short
- 31:44term, which would be chaotic.
- 31:46If someone would be, the good thing is Hood knows credit Union,
- 31:49so under that example, there's a.
- 31:53Maybe light at the end of the tunnel.
- 31:54Plus it has to always go to Congress and the commission will bog that down, Jeff,
- 31:58there, that, that reminds me of the, there's no monument anywhere on the planet
- 32:03to a committee and there's no monument anywhere on the planet to a commission.
- 32:06Because they just, they, that's where ideas go to die.
- 32:10And so it actually happening is different than maybe a, a
- 32:13consolidation of who's leading
- 32:16Bacion: that organization.
- 32:17Can I, let me just put a postscript on what I said about
- 32:20consolidation music to my ears.
- 32:23Yesterday when I heard from a senate, a senior senate banking committee
- 32:27staffer, who said he had been in contact with the White House, and this person
- 32:31essentially, without prompting, said.
- 32:34I think enough people around here on the hill and in the administration realize
- 32:38credit unions are different than banks.
- 32:40And boy, that's, again making my week, in the midst of all this other uncertainty,
- 32:44and there is a lot of uncertainty.
- 32:46I'm not trying to sound like I'm a Pollyanna about it but maybe this is
- 32:50this episode is forcing some clarity on how we are in fact distinct
- 32:56institutions that still deserve a distinct regulator, at least I hope so.
- 33:01Treichel: That's that is the best thing I've heard all week.
- 33:05No, I, again, I think it's another one of those cases where you
- 33:09have to be on the lookout for it.
- 33:11Yes.
- 33:12And we were talking earlier about, I.
- 33:15Kind of maybe what put the target on NCAA's back, maybe not having enough
- 33:19folks back to work and things like that.
- 33:20I think the other thing that may put the target on their back is you had two
- 33:23Democratic board members, a three person board when a Republican is president,
- 33:28this has happened a couple times.
- 33:29Again, I get to say I was part of it.
- 33:31If you're looking at it from a strictly partisan viewpoint, if
- 33:35you are the president, you may look at it and go, wait a minute.
- 33:37I won in November and I still got two Democrats and one Republican here.
- 33:42Something's wrong with this picture.
- 33:43And so I think that may have also been one of the things that kind of brought
- 33:47it to the attention of the White House.
- 33:49And I don't and look, I think the fact that Rodney Hood's been at our
- 33:53agency twice he obviously has very good ties with the administration.
- 33:56So you're gonna be running things I assume through, at least
- 34:00through the prism of understanding credit unions through Rodney,
- 34:03Treichel: good, good point.
- 34:04John or Jeff, one of one of you talked about, hey, eventually you anticipate
- 34:08two new board members coming in.
- 34:10Obviously one would be an R, one would be a d, you'd probably run 'em
- 34:12through together to get approval.
- 34:14But, and then we're talking about things going, will Tanya and
- 34:17Todd Sue, how does that play out?
- 34:18Does that get an audience with the Supreme Court?
- 34:21If you were to venture a window of a timeline, what's the soonest
- 34:25you, under all these scenarios you'd see and then where credit
- 34:29unions are in the pecking order.
- 34:30What's the soonest you'd see nominations go forward and what's the
- 34:34latest in your eyes on this Friday?
- 34:40Bacion: In Washington there are two timeframes now and not now.
- 34:43Okay.
- 34:44We can, we could I couldn't even venture.
- 34:47Guess I will say that a lot of the oxygen in the room on Capitol Hill is being taken
- 34:51up by this tax reform reconciliation, supposedly, that's gonna be.
- 34:58People on the hill are saying it'll be on the President's desk by Memorial Day.
- 35:01I'm not sure about that, but I think right now there's a very little attention.
- 35:05May, maybe the administration could name people, but I wouldn't see
- 35:08there any congressional action until sometime much later in the summer.
- 35:13Even then, I don't know.
- 35:16The
- 35:16only thing I could see that might make it a little different is I
- 35:20think almost anyone can agree that this administration doesn't really
- 35:23work like other administrations.
- 35:25I'll just put that out there and if I, not My House of Cards theory would be if
- 35:31you wanna try to lock out these lawsuits, you put people in those jobs as quickly
- 35:36as possible, no matter where they are.
- 35:39Which means, okay, you go through the court case again, one of the
- 35:42things I ask is, let's say you sue, let's say they're successful.
- 35:46What's the relief?
- 35:47What's the remedy?
- 35:48And again, let's say this thing takes six months or a year.
- 35:52Do you say to them, does the court say, okay, you can go back and oh, by the way,
- 35:56your terms now got two months left on it, or your term's up and you get back, pay.
- 36:01But I'm just saying, I, I think we all agree we're in uncharted territories.
- 36:06I think John's right.
- 36:07I think the pace in Washington is taken up by.
- 36:12Issues that are much bigger, not only tax reform, how about tariffs?
- 36:16How about immigration?
- 36:17There's a, you turn on the news and it, you can go cycle
- 36:19after things that are going on.
- 36:20But I, as I said, my, my thought would be if you wanted to try and head the
- 36:25courts off of the past, you fill these things with board members and all
- 36:29of them quickly to the point where.
- 36:32Even if the court decides, yeah, they can come back, now all of a sudden you're
- 36:34stuck with, wait a minute, you got, I ever get somebody confirmed to this post.
- 36:38What
- 36:39Treichel: do you do now?
- 36:40So the best defense is a good offense, and that's what the
- 36:43Trump administration seems to do.
- 36:44So that's a, that's an interesting interesting thought.
- 36:48Again,
- 36:48It's always amused me how people sometimes don't understand how
- 36:51this appointment process works.
- 36:54Trust me and John and I have been through it a lot and and
- 36:56I haven't gone through it.
- 36:57You hear people say, oh, they're gonna, they're gonna pair somebody,
- 36:59and you're like, okay, I understand that's conventional wisdom, but the
- 37:03reality is it's not always the case.
- 37:04Or, they won't get that done by now.
- 37:06And it, what I always tell people is it's an inexact science.
- 37:10Everyone's a little different.
- 37:12And the people that talk the most about it usually know the least, I
- 37:17remember after I'd been nominated, I heard at least eight other names of
- 37:20people who already were nominated.
- 37:22And again, I know I'm going through the background check.
- 37:24I know the minute that's done, the president's gonna send my name up, and
- 37:27yet you're still hearing people, oh no.
- 37:28You know he's gonna get it or he's already got it.
- 37:30But I do agree that I do agree with John that getting two new
- 37:33board members is paramount.
- 37:35And, but we do need to make sure that the agency.
- 37:39Keeps running
- 37:39Treichel: on a day to day basis.
- 37:40And on the agency keep running thing.
- 37:42I've got, we talk about losing the corporate brain losing 20% and that
- 37:50is a challenge under any scenario.
- 37:53But.
- 37:54I was a deep selection back when NCOA was under you can't hire because you violated
- 37:59fed federal rights and their hiring rights were taken, which is one of the reasons I
- 38:02came in to be a deputy executive director.
- 38:04'cause they viewed a bunch of people as not being able
- 38:07to be put into positions and.
- 38:10Would've I been that selection had that not happened?
- 38:12No.
- 38:12'cause I, I was new into the executive ranks and PE so they
- 38:17call that a deep selection.
- 38:18There's gonna be a lot of deep selections, there's a lot of talent
- 38:21at NCUA, the dust will settle.
- 38:23And as Henry Garcia once said to me, a former a RD.
- 38:27Nobody's ever ready for that next position you think you are,
- 38:30but you're gonna get punched in the face like Mike Tyson, right?
- 38:33And so there's talent, there's high iq, there's people that
- 38:36care about credit unions at NCUA left a and as long as they're not
- 38:40consolidated and can continue to do.
- 38:43What needs to be done for the mission.
- 38:45There, there will be a new version of NCA with really good, talented people
- 38:49that will help the industry and the agency move forward, in my opinion.
- 38:53Oh yeah.
- 38:54Look, Brock Purdy was the last player drafted.
- 38:56He's a pro baller.
- 38:57Mike Piazza was picked in the last round of the Major League
- 39:00baseball draft as a favor.
- 39:02That was did to Piazza's dad or grandfather.
- 39:04I agree there's talent all over.
- 39:06And the nice thing is that this might allow some of it.
- 39:08To rise to the top.
- 39:09You do get that kind of level where people aren't leaving Sure.
- 39:16And others can't move up behind them.
- 39:18Treichel: And Jeff, Caleb Williams was picked first, and
- 39:21Brock Purdy was picked last.
- 39:22What I irony.
- 39:23Oh, keep it up.
- 39:24Bacion: Speaking of irony I got a text, or I'm sorry, I got an email
- 39:27chain the other, I guess yesterday.
- 39:30Somebody.
- 39:31Was talking, talked about one of his colleagues at a league, and
- 39:35this other person had been lame.
- 39:38It was an email from.
- 39:40Yesterday's email re dug up some email from 2015 about how NCA needs to be
- 39:47cut in half in terms of staff and we need to cut the budgets and we need
- 39:50to get this agency under control.
- 39:52And the same person who wrote that in 2015 was now saying, my God, this
- 39:56is the end of the worlds we know.
- 39:57And how dare they cut the, it's, we're there, there's a tendency, I
- 40:02think, that people are just never happy no matter what happens.
- 40:05We've wanted, we, the industry collectively.
- 40:08Have wanted a leaner NCUA for years, regardless of your political posture.
- 40:14We're about to get it, I think.
- 40:17Treichel: Yeah and I think some of that narrative and I talk
- 40:20about it a lot here, NCA has a.
- 40:23Challenge getting exams done timely right now.
- 40:26Okay.
- 40:26And they just elongated their exam cycle a little bit to alleviate that.
- 40:30But then the aftermath of that is you cut staff 20%.
- 40:33So don't expect to get your exams any quicker in the short term, but the dust
- 40:37will settle, things will get better.
- 40:39And again the takeaway for me from this one is the.
- 40:42The positive things you guys are hearing about the independence of the agency
- 40:45and the independence of credit unions from another regulator, which, and that
- 40:49Bacion: could be out the window by five o'clock tonight.
- 40:51It could be,
- 40:51Treichel: yeah.
- 40:52Yeah.
- 40:52Maybe I should post this one today instead of wait until Monday.
- 40:56Bacion: This is fascinating.
- 40:57I just wish I had more clarity, but I don't,
- 41:01and to be honest with you though, I don't think anybody does, this isn't
- 41:03one of those things where you could say.
- 41:05Know we could do a little more work and figure it out.
- 41:08Reality is things are gonna change.
- 41:10If you had told me Tuesday morning that you were gonna have too fewer NCA Board
- 41:14members on, Wednesday morning I would've probably taken that bet against it,
- 41:19and, so we're in our unchartered waters.
- 41:22I get that.
- 41:22But unchartered waters don't necessarily mean that, something bad's gonna happen.
- 41:26And Mark, I do agree with you.
- 41:27I think that we are going to see other talent rise to the top.
- 41:32Because you get the chance.
- 41:33Look let's use John's Orioles as an example.
- 41:35They got a ton of talent.
- 41:36They got so much talent in the minor leagues.
- 41:38They can't get guys up to the major 'cause they're gonna be blocked, so
- 41:41if you look to trade some those guys, John, we'll take 'em at the Cubs.
- 41:44Bacion: I'm sure he would.
- 41:45We traded to my recently the Cubs a couple years ago.
- 41:47He won the s Young as soon as he got out of an oral uniform.
- 41:50So
- 41:53anyway,
- 41:54Treichel: let's just not talk, let's just not talk about the Minnesota Twins.
- 41:56What any final thoughts on on this week of.
- 42:02This week of what's happened.
- 42:04Bacion: Buckle up.
- 42:05Buckle up.
- 42:05I say again.
- 42:06That's all I can tell you.
- 42:07That's my best advice.
- 42:08And just try to stay calm and just realize that change is the watch
- 42:14word in Washington right now.
- 42:15And it's just, this is a very tumultuous period in a, in an
- 42:19administration promised that
- 42:20Treichel: very good.
- 42:21And last prediction, guys.
- 42:22I'm gonna say the Minnesota Vikings are gonna go nine and eight and
- 42:26we will split with the bears.
- 42:28John, how about the Ravens?
- 42:30Bacion: We'll choke in the playoffs again.
- 42:34And Jeff?
- 42:35Treichel: The Mighty Bears.
- 42:36The Mighty Bears, I think.
- 42:37I think the bears gonna make the playoffs.
- 42:38I will put it right there.
- 42:40Very good.
- 42:41Very good.
- 42:43Alright guys, this has been fun as always.
- 42:45I enjoy chatting with you.
- 42:46Good to see you.
- 42:47And if we have another week like this, we'll have another podcast like this.
- 42:52Thanks here, we're here for you if you need us.
- 42:54Treichel: I know where to find you.
- 42:55And listeners, I want to thank you for listening Watchers on YouTube.
- 42:58Want to thank you for watching.
- 43:00I hope you'll watch again soon.
- 43:01Mark Kel, signing off with flying colors.