Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, and its endorsement
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever found yourself agreeing to something, maybe a
- 0:03sales pitch, and then later you're thinking, hang on, why
- 0:05did I actually say yes to that? Oh, absolutely.
- 0:08It happens all the time, right? Yeah, it's such a common thing.
- 0:11And it turns out our decisions, while they're often way less
- 0:14logical than we think, they're shaped by these hidden forces.
- 0:18Exactly. Psychological triggers.
- 0:20So today we're doing a deep dive into exactly that.
- 0:23These subtle but, you know, incredibly powerful
- 0:26psychological triggers that guide what we choose, what we
- 0:29buy, even what we believe. And the goal here is really to
- 0:32shine a light on them. Right, so you can become a more
- 0:35discerning decision maker, spot these things in your own life.
- 0:39Our journey really starts with a giant in behavioral science,
- 0:43Robert Cialdini, and specifically his huge book
- 0:46Influence the Psychology of Persuasion.
- 0:49A classic. It's been around for decades.
- 0:50Sold millions. And it's not just some dusty
- 0:52academic text, right? It's like a foundational guide.
- 0:55It explains how we get nudged towards saying yes.
- 0:57And it's not just academics who value it.
- 0:59I mean, think about Charlie Munger.
- 1:01Warren Buffett, legendary partner.
- 1:02Exactly 1 of the sharpest minds in investing, he held influence
- 1:05in incredibly high regard. Famously, he even sent Sheldini,
- 1:09a Berkshire Hathaway, a stock. Which was worth what, like
- 1:12$75,000 back then? Something like that, yeah.
- 1:16And Munger openly said he and Buffett had made quote hundreds
- 1:19of millions of dollars by applying insights from
- 1:21Shieldini's work. Wow, hundreds of millions.
- 1:24He called the book a magnificent job and basically told everyone
- 1:28to read it. Said you will never make a
- 1:30better investment. High praise.
- 1:33That is some endorsement. You really can't ignore that.
- 1:35So OK, for this deep dive, we're going to unpack these
- 1:37principles. Look at.
- 1:38How they can be used ethically? And maybe even more importantly,
- 1:42how you can defend yourself when they're used dishonestly.
- 1:45It's really about equipping yourself to make sounder
- 1:48choices. It really is, because Cialdini's
- 1:51whole starting point, his core idea, it kind of challenges our
- 1:55view of ourselves as purely rational beings.
- 1:57Well, he argues that a lot of our behavior isn't driven by
- 2:00careful thought. It's more automatic, almost
- 2:03reflexive responses to specific triggers.
- 2:06You know that quote often attributed to him?
- 2:09All decision making is based in emotions, not logic, especially
- 2:13when things are uncertain. Right.
- 2:14So when you say automatic, almost reflexive, is that just
- 2:17our brains being lazy trying to be efficient or is it something
- 2:20deeper? It's mostly about efficiency.
- 2:22Our brains are trying to save energy.
- 2:24We use these cognitive shortcuts or heuristics as Kildina calls.
- 2:28Them mental shortcuts. They help us get through the day
- 2:31without analyzing every single thing.
- 2:34But, and this is the key part, these shortcuts create
- 2:37predictable vulnerability. OK, predictable.
- 2:40Yeah. Think about it, When you're
- 2:42overloaded with information or maybe feeling emotional,
- 2:45stressed or just tired, these shortcuts kick in.
- 2:49And people who are good at persuasion know this.
- 2:51Exactly. Compliance professionals,
- 2:53Giovini calls them. Salespeople, Marketers.
- 2:55Negotiators. They know how to trigger these
- 2:58automatic responses, often without you even realizing.
- 3:01It's happening below conscious awareness.
- 3:03That makes total sense. And Cialdini makes a big deal
- 3:05about the ethics of this, right? Huge deal.
- 3:08He draws this really sharp line. He talks about being a
- 3:11detective, someone who uses influence openly, responsibly,
- 3:15versus a smuggler who's deceptive, manipulative.
- 3:19The goal isn't just to learn how to persuade, though that's
- 3:23useful. It's just as much about quote
- 3:25how to defend yourself against dishonest influence attempts.
- 3:28So it's like a two sided coin for you listening.
- 3:30You can learn how to influence ethically, maybe in your job
- 3:34leading A-Team negotiate, even just some personal stuff.
- 3:37And at the same time, you learn how to spot manipulation and
- 3:39protect yourself, which is pretty critical today with
- 3:42persuasive messages coming at us from everywhere.
- 3:44It's like getting a user manual for the human mind.
- 3:46Yeah, for offense and defense. OK, let's get into the core
- 3:49principles then. Sheldini identified 6 universals
- 3:52based on decades of research. Teachable, learnable, and you
- 3:55see them everywhere. Ready for #1?
- 3:57Let's do it. The first one feels really deep
- 3:59seated. Reciprocity, the obligation to
- 4:02repay. Yeah, this isn't just, you know,
- 4:04you scratch my back, I'll scratch yours.
- 4:06It's more fundamental. It's almost like a reflex if
- 4:08someone gives you something, even something small you didn't
- 4:11ask for. You feel like you owe them.
- 4:13Instantly there's this subconscious feeling of debt,
- 4:17and that's powerful because, as Chaldini points out, the
- 4:20obligation to receive reduces our ability to choose whom we
- 4:25wish to be indebted to and puts that power in the hands of
- 4:28others. OK, I'm picturing examples like
- 4:32those Hare Krishna folks back in the day at airports pressing a
- 4:35flower into your hand. Classic example.
- 4:37That tiny, unsolicited gift made it so much harder to just walk
- 4:40away when they asked for a donation.
- 4:42Or, you know, free samples at Costco.
- 4:44Absolutely. You take the sample, you feel a
- 4:46little nudge to maybe buy the product.
- 4:48Right. Or even in a negotiation, if the
- 4:50other side makes a small concession first, you feel this
- 4:53pressure to give something back even if it wasn't part of your
- 4:56plan. And Munger saw this playing out
- 4:57at the highest levels in corporate boardrooms.
- 5:00He talked about director's fees. How so?
- 5:02He argued that if directors are financially dependent on those
- 5:05fees, they're not truly independent.
- 5:07It creates this sort of a reciprocation, like you keep
- 5:10raising my fees, I won't object when you want to raise the CEO's
- 5:13pay. A very club like environment as
- 5:16he put. It exactly, which he thought was
- 5:18really counterproductive to good company management because that
- 5:22unspoken obligation, that reciprocity, stopped directors
- 5:25from raising legitimate objections, especially about
- 5:28things like huge CEO compensation packages.
- 5:31That's a really striking example, yeah.
- 5:33Shows how even subtle things create these obligations.
- 5:35So, OK, how do you defend against this?
- 5:38How do you resist that poll? Gialdini's advice is pretty
- 5:41direct. First option, politely refuse
- 5:43the gift or favor if you can. Just say no thanks, yeah.
- 5:46Or, if you do accept it, make a conscious effort to assess its
- 5:49true value and, if appropriate, reciprocate with something of
- 5:52genuinely similar value later. Don't let a small, unsolicited
- 5:56gift trap you into a much larger, unwanted obligation.
- 5:59It's about maintaining your autonomy.
- 6:01OK, makes sense. So feeling indebted is 1
- 6:04trigger. What's next?
- 6:06It seems like we also have this deep need to well to appear
- 6:10consistent. That's number two, commitment
- 6:13and consistency, the drive to align.
- 6:16Tell me about that. Once we make a choice or take a
- 6:19public stand on something, these powerful internal and external
- 6:22pressures kick in. We feel this need to behave
- 6:25consistently with that earlier commitment.
- 6:27Why is it just about saving face?
- 6:30Partly, society generally values consistency.
- 6:33We see it as a sign of stability, rationality,
- 6:35integrity. But it's also internal.
- 6:37It reduces mental effort. Once we've decided, we don't
- 6:40have to keep thinking about it. OK, so this is where those foot
- 6:43on the door techniques come from.
- 6:45Get a small commitment first. Exactly, that's the salami
- 6:47slicing tactic. Get a small yes and it makes it
- 6:49much harder for the person to say no to the next slightly
- 6:52bigger request because it would feel inconsistent.
- 6:54Right. I've also seen those signs in
- 6:55hotel bathrooms. Oh yeah, Which ones?
- 6:57The ones that say something like 8 out of 10 guests in this room
- 7:00choose to reuse their towels. Perfect example.
- 7:03That's way more effective than just a generic environmental
- 7:06plea. It leverages your desire to be
- 7:09consistent with what other people like you, people who
- 7:12stayed in the same room, have done.
- 7:13And writing things down makes it stronger.
- 7:14Absolutely. Public written commitments are
- 7:17incredibly potent. Signing a petition, filling out
- 7:20a survey response, they engage our need to maintain a
- 7:24consistent self-image now. How does this connect to Munger?
- 7:28Did he see this in investing? Oh, massively.
- 7:30He talked a lot about what he called cognitive inertia.
- 7:34His view was the brain of man conserves programming spaces by
- 7:37being reluctant to change. Like our brains want to stick
- 7:40with the program once it's running.
- 7:41Pretty much he used this analogy of a human egg.
- 7:44Once one sperm gets in, the egg instantly changes to block all
- 7:47others. He said the human mind is
- 7:48similar. It grabs onto conclusions and
- 7:50attitudes and then becomes really reluctant to re examine
- 7:53them, even when new evidence comes along that contradicts
- 7:55them. And.
- 7:55That leads to. It leads straight to things like
- 7:58sunk cost bias. You keep pouring resources into
- 8:01a failing project or investment just because you've already put
- 8:04so much in. You want to remain consistent
- 8:06with your initial decision. Munger had a stark warning about
- 8:09this. Failure to handle psychological
- 8:11denial is a common way for people to go broke.
- 8:14Wow, that's sobering. We've all seen people do that,
- 8:17right? Cling to something long after
- 8:18it's clear it's not working. For sure.
- 8:20And Munger also said something really profound.
- 8:23What you do, it will change what you think, yes.
- 8:26That's crucial. It's not just that our beliefs,
- 8:28Dr. Our actions, our actions loop back and actually shape and
- 8:32reinforce our beliefs to maintain that consistency.
- 8:35So the challenge for you, the listener, is recognizing this
- 8:38inertia in yourself, how hard it is to change habits or deeply
- 8:42held beliefs. It really highlights the need
- 8:44for intellectual flexibility, for humility, right?
- 8:47Being willing to say OK, my initial thesis was wrong,
- 8:51especially as Monger warned against falling in love with
- 8:53investment ideas. You have to be willing to change
- 8:55your mind. OK principle #3 this one feels
- 8:59very intuitive in today's world. Social proof following the lead
- 9:04of similar others. Right.
- 9:06This is a fundamental shortcut we use, especially when we're
- 9:09uncertain. If you don't know what to do in
- 9:11a situation, what's the first thing you often do?
- 9:13Look around and see what everyone else is doing.
- 9:15Exactly. We look to the actions of
- 9:17others, especially people we see as similar to ourselves, to
- 9:20figure out the correct way to behave, and the more people
- 9:23doing something, the more right or valid we assume it is.
- 9:26So influence often works best sideways, peer-to-peer rather
- 9:30than top down. Often, yes.
- 9:31That's why those hotel signs referencing guests in the same
- 9:34room work so well. It's not just people, it's
- 9:36people like you. You see this everywhere.
- 9:39Restaurants seating the first customers near the window to
- 9:41look busy. The explosion of online reviews,
- 9:44testimonials, star ratings. All social proof.
- 9:46Claims like fastest growing, best selling, they imply quality
- 9:50simply because lots of other people chose it.
- 9:52But, and this is where Munger skepticism comes in, while
- 9:54social proof can be a useful heuristic, The wisdom of the
- 9:57crowd. It can also go wrong.
- 9:59It can go very wrong. It can quickly turn into the
- 10:02folly of the herd. Munger observed that even
- 10:05sophisticated people, big shot businessmen, get swept up in
- 10:09these waves of social proof. Did he give examples?
- 10:12He did. He talked about the oil
- 10:13industry. Back in the day.
- 10:14One major oil company bought a fertilizer company, and then
- 10:18almost every other major oil company rushed out and bought a
- 10:21fertilizer company too. Even if it made no strategic
- 10:24sense for them. Apparently not.
- 10:26There was no clear rationale just following the leader, and
- 10:29according to Munger, it ended up being a total disaster for most
- 10:33of them. They just followed the herd off
- 10:34a Cliff. That really makes you think.
- 10:36So for you listening, the big question is how do you tell the
- 10:39difference? When is the ground wise and when
- 10:42is it just a herd heading for trouble?
- 10:44When do you follow and when do you need to step back and think
- 10:47for yourself? No, it's easy.
- 10:49Definitely not. OK, let's move to authority
- 10:52deferring to experts. This one is about our tendency,
- 10:55often unconscious, to obey or defer to people we perceive as
- 10:59legitimate authorities. We're kind of conditioned from
- 11:02childhood to respect authority figures, parents, teachers,
- 11:05doctors, bosses. And it's not always about their
- 11:07actual knowledge, is it? Sometimes it's just the symbols.
- 11:10That's a key part of it, the mere symbols of authority like a
- 11:13title, a uniform, expensive clothes, or a car.
- 11:17Academic degrees can trigger this deference even if the
- 11:19person isn't truly an expert in the relevant area.
- 11:22Right, you see dentists in white lab coats endorsing toothpaste
- 11:26on TV. Airline pilot uniforms convey
- 11:28competence and trustworthiness. Even just seeing Doctor before
- 11:32someone's name can make us less likely to question them.
- 11:35And those famous or infamous psychology experiments, the
- 11:39Milgram shock experiments. Chilling.
- 11:41Weren't they showing how ordinary people could be induced
- 11:44by an authority figure in a lab coat to administer what they
- 11:46believe were painful, even dangerous, electric shocks to
- 11:49another person? It demonstrates the sheer power
- 11:52of perceived authority to override personal conscience.
- 11:55And Munger's take on this? He really hammered home the
- 11:58point that the symbol of authority can short circuit
- 12:00critical thinking, sometimes with disastrous results.
- 12:03He often cited these disturbing aviation studies.
- 12:06What? Did they find?
- 12:07They found cases where copilots knew the pilot, the authority
- 12:11figure, was making a critical error, one that would likely
- 12:14lead to a crash, but they still didn't intervene strongly
- 12:17enough. In some studies, this deference
- 12:19to the captain, even when fatally wrong, happened
- 12:22something like 25% of the time. 25% That's terrifying.
- 12:26It shows it's not just individual weakness, it can be a
- 12:29systemic issue baked into hierarchies.
- 12:31Exactly. The very structure meant to
- 12:33ensure order can become a huge vulnerability if people are
- 12:36afraid to question the person in charge.
- 12:38So the take away for you listening might be to think
- 12:41about the environments you're in.
- 12:43How can you help create a culture, whether it work or
- 12:45elsewhere, where it's is actually OK, even encouraged to
- 12:48respectfully question authority to see it as a safety mechanism,
- 12:51not insubordination? Critical thinking shouldn't stop
- 12:54just because someone has a title.
- 12:56Absolutely. OK, OK, 5th principle.
- 12:58This one feels very human, very relatable, liking agreeing with
- 13:03those we like. It's simple but powerful.
- 13:06We're just much more likely to be persuaded by people we know
- 13:08and like. What makes us like someone in
- 13:11this context? TL Dini highlights a few key
- 13:13factors. Perceived similarity.
- 13:16We like people who are like us. Genuine praise or compliments.
- 13:19Flattery works even when we suspect it might be flattery.
- 13:22Physical attractiveness. Like it or not, attractive
- 13:24people often have an easier time persuading others.
- 13:27Familiarity. Just repeated exposure can
- 13:29increase liking and cooperative efforts.
- 13:31Working together towards a common goal builds rapport.
- 13:33You see this everywhere in sales and marketing, don't you?
- 13:35Ads using likable celebrities or models?
- 13:38Salespeople trying to find common ground?
- 13:39Oh, you like golf too? Building that connection first.
- 13:42Even the classic good cop, bad cop routine and interrogations
- 13:45works partly on this. The good cop seems likable,
- 13:48understanding an ally and therefore gains influence.
- 13:51And companies trying to project a likable image on their About
- 13:54Us page sharing values. Building that connection, that
- 13:57feeling of they're like me. There was even that study about
- 14:00lost wallets. Right.
- 14:01People were more likely to return a lost wallet if the
- 14:04photo ID inside showed someone they perceived as similar to
- 14:07themselves. Amazing.
- 14:09And Munger talked about this, too.
- 14:10He called with the liking, hating tendency.
- 14:13He stressed how strong emotions, positive or negative, towards a
- 14:16person or entity can completely warp your judgement about them
- 14:20or their ideas. He had that funny but maybe true
- 14:23quote from Warren Buffett. Yeah, that a major difference
- 14:26between rich and poor people is that the rich people can spend
- 14:28more of their time suing their relatives, implying that even
- 14:32family ties, a strong form of liking, don't stop financial
- 14:36disputes, showing how potent these feelings are.
- 14:38But he also saw it used for good.
- 14:40Right. He noted how Alcoholics
- 14:42Anonymous uses similar principles.
- 14:43Community, shared struggle, mutual support, liking very
- 14:46effectively, but for a positive therapeutic outcome.
- 14:50So the principle itself is neutral.
- 14:51It's how it's used. That's a really important point.
- 14:54So the question for you, the listener, is how aware are you
- 14:57of how your own feelings, liking or disliking someone, affect
- 15:01your judgments? Can you step back and separate
- 15:04the person from the proposal, the message from the messenger,
- 15:08to make a more objective assessment?
- 15:09It's hard to do sometimes. Very OK, last of the big six
- 15:14scarcity, desiring what is less available, the fear of missing
- 15:18out principle. Exactly.
- 15:20FOMO is a big part of it. This principle states that
- 15:23opportunities seem more valuable to us when their availability is
- 15:26limited. If something is rare or
- 15:28perceived as rare, we automatically assign it more
- 15:30value and desire it more. This feels like the engine of
- 15:33modern online commerce sometime. It really does Think about
- 15:36travel websites. Only three seats left at this
- 15:38price. Creates instant urgency or
- 15:40limited edition products. Same effect makes you feel you
- 15:43have to act now or lose out. Cialdini even mentions a simple
- 15:46cookie experiment. People rated cookies as more
- 15:49desirable and better tasting when they were taken from a jar.
- 15:52Only two cookies left, compared to an identical cookie from a
- 15:55jar with 10. Just the perception of scarcity
- 15:57change the experience, yeah. Or think about selling a used
- 16:00car. If you arrange for multiple
- 16:02potential buyers to show up around the same time, the
- 16:05visible competition creates scarcity and often speeds up the
- 16:09sale at a higher price. And marketers use lost language
- 16:12too, right? Don't miss out focusing on what
- 16:15you stand to lose. Absolutely, because this
- 16:16principle taps into something deep psychological reactants.
- 16:20We hate losing freedoms or opportunities.
- 16:23When something becomes less available, we react against that
- 16:26restriction by wanting it more. Does this tie into behavioral
- 16:30economics? Very strongly.
- 16:31It connects directly to prospect theory developed by Kahneman and
- 16:34Kravarsky. The core idea there is that
- 16:36losses loom larger psychologically than equivalent
- 16:39gains. We feel the pain of a potential
- 16:41loss much more acutely than the pleasure of a potential game.
- 16:44So the fear of missing out on a scarce item is often a stronger
- 16:47motivator than the positive of appeal of the item itself.
- 16:50Often, yes, that potential loss feels more urgent, more
- 16:53powerful. OK, so the challenge for you is
- 16:56to recognize when scarcity is being manufactured to pressure
- 17:00you. When you feel that urge to grab
- 17:02something because it's limited, pause and ask, is this genuinely
- 17:07scarce and valuable, or is my aversion to loss being cleverly
- 17:11manipulated? A crucial question to ask.
- 17:13So those are the six principles. But Munger added another layer,
- 17:16didn't he, about how they combine.
- 17:18Yes, and this is absolutely critical.
- 17:20He called it the Lollapalooza effect.
- 17:22His point was that these psychological tendencies don't
- 17:24operate in neat little silos in the real world.
- 17:26They interact, they combine, they amplify each other.
- 17:29It's not just 1 + 1 = 2. No, it's more like 1 + 1 = 5 or
- 17:3310. Multiple biases pushing in the
- 17:36same direction can produce extreme, non linear, sometimes
- 17:39totally irrational or even pathological outcomes.
- 17:41The combined effect is way more powerful than just the sum of
- 17:44the individual parts. Can you give an example of this
- 17:46compounding? The Stanford prison experiment
- 17:48is often cited as a stark illustration.
- 17:51Where students assigned roles of prisoners and guards quickly
- 17:53descended into abusive behavior. Right, Munger would argue.
- 17:57That wasn't just one bias at work.
- 17:58It was a Lollapalooza. You had commitment and
- 18:01consistency, people stepping into their roles.
- 18:04You had authority, the guards wielding power.
- 18:07You had social proof. Guards observing other guards,
- 18:09prisoners observing prisoners. You had the power of the
- 18:12situation, the uniforms, all these forces compounded, as
- 18:16Munger put it, each person as he acted as a guard or a prisoner.
- 18:20The action itself was pounding in the idea, reinforcing the
- 18:23roles and the extreme behavior. So this isn't just about
- 18:26individual mistakes, it could explain bigger phenomena.
- 18:29Absolutely, Munger believed. This helps explain things like
- 18:31market bubbles and crashes where greed, scarcity, social proof
- 18:35and fear compound. It can explain the dynamics and
- 18:38cults where authority, liking, commitment and social proof all
- 18:41can converge to create intense loyalty and sometimes tragic
- 18:44outcomes. It shows how systemic failures
- 18:46can emerge from these converging psychological pressures.
- 18:49And this leads back to that really powerful monger inside we
- 18:52touched on earlier. The feedback loop.
- 18:54Yeah, what you think may change what you do, But perhaps even
- 18:57more important, what you do will change what you think.
- 19:01The Lollapanuse effect shows how actions driven by these combined
- 19:05biases can profoundly reshape beliefs and lock people into
- 19:08certain paths. It's a potent reminder of how
- 19:11our behavior shapes our cognition, not just the other
- 19:14way around. So quite a journey we've taken.
- 19:16Today we went from Cialdini score triggers of persuasion,
- 19:20reciprocity, commitment, social proof, authority, liking,
- 19:23scarcity. All the way to Munger's
- 19:25practical wisdom on spotting these biases in the real world,
- 19:29avoiding misjudgment, and understanding how they combine
- 19:31in that powerful Lollapalooza effect.
- 19:32What's the big take away here? Is it just about learning
- 19:35persuasion tricks? I really don't think so.
- 19:37I mean, yes, understanding these principles can make you more
- 19:40effective ethically, but the deeper value I think goes beyond
- 19:44just influencing others. It's more about self-awareness,
- 19:47cognitive self-defense. Exactly.
- 19:49It functions as a guide for cognitive self-defense and maybe
- 19:52even intellectual humility, recognizing how easily we can be
- 19:56swayed by these forces. Maybe the most critical use of
- 19:59this knowledge isn't becoming a master persuader, but becoming a
- 20:02master of discernment, being able to see what's really going
- 20:05on beneath the surface. That makes a lot of sense.
- 20:08Ultimately, the quest for more rational decision making.
- 20:11It really starts inside our own heads, doesn't it?
- 20:13Confronting these built in tendencies we all have.
- 20:16Couldn't agree more. So here's a final thought for
- 20:18you to Mull over. Thinking about your own daily
- 20:20life, your own decisions. Which of these biases,
- 20:23reciprocity, consistency, social proof, authority, liking
- 20:26scarcity do you see popping up most often?
- 20:30And how am I? Just being aware of them help
- 20:32you navigate things with a bit more prudence, maybe lead to
- 20:34better outcomes, something that you want.