Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The New Frontier E001: Bitcoin And The Middle East
Transcript
- 0:16Welcome to The New Frontier, a Bitcoin centric podcast that
- 0:19bridges the gap between the transformative world of Bitcoin
- 0:22and the unique financial landscape of the Middle East.
- 0:25This podcast is brought to you by Onrap Mino and is Co hosted
- 0:28by Ralph Debran, Managing Partner, Onrap Mino and Harris
- 0:31Irfan. CEO of Cordoba.
- 0:33Capital Markets and advisor to Onrap, Mino, Ralph and Harris
- 0:37have built their careers in traditional finance,
- 0:39accumulating extensive experience across capital
- 0:41markets, investment banking, and asset management.
- 0:44Each episode delves deep into how Bitcoin is reshaping
- 0:47finance, technology and investment within the region and
- 0:50beyond. From macroeconomic trends to
- 0:52real world applications, and from Islamic finance to
- 0:55sustainable energy practices, this show covers it all.
- 0:59In this launch episode, we'll cover Bitcoin on a global scale
- 1:02during the first half, and in the second-half, we'll discuss
- 1:05Bitcoin in the Middle East and its intersection with Islamic
- 1:08finance. So sit back, relax, and join us
- 1:12in the new Frontier. Hello, welcome to the New
- 1:18Frontier, a On Ramp MENA podcast.
- 1:21My name is Ralph Jabran, one of the Co hosts and managing
- 1:24partner at On Ramp MENA Harris. Why don't you introduce
- 1:28yourself? Thanks, Ralph.
- 1:30My name is Harris Irfan. I'm the CEO of a company called
- 1:33Cordoba Capital Markets or CCM, which is a company finance
- 1:39company that raises working capital in the form of listed
- 1:43profit sharing share a compliant notes.
- 1:45I'm also an advisor to On Ramp MENA and I'm the author of a
- 1:49book called Heaven's Bankers Inside the Hidden World of
- 1:52Islamic Finance. Right.
- 1:54So maybe as the first episode, we'll give our viewers a little
- 1:57bit of a background of this podcast, what it what they can
- 2:01expect out of it. So what we'll be doing is we'll
- 2:04be producing this podcast on a biweekly basis and we'll be
- 2:08covering a variety of topics such as macroeconomics, Islamic
- 2:12finance, how Bitcoin integrates within the region itself.
- 2:17We'll also be bringing in guests locally and from all over the
- 2:22world. So stay tuned.
- 2:24It's going to get interesting. And you know, there's a lot to
- 2:27learn from this. Thanks, Ralph.
- 2:29Why don't we kick off the podcast?
- 2:31This is obviously a bit of a strange one because you and I
- 2:34are speaking to each other. And I think one of the
- 2:36intentions we have from this podcast, the episode one is to
- 2:40get a feel for the series as it develops.
- 2:43And as you say, it's the intersection of, you know,
- 2:45Bitcoin, the MENA region, Islamic finance, which I think
- 2:49is a pretty unique sort of theme for our podcast, which hasn't
- 2:54hasn't been covered anywhere else before.
- 2:56And why don't we start that by, let me ask you the first
- 2:59question, which is an overview of Bitcoins role in the global
- 3:03financial landscape. Can you give us a bit of a sort
- 3:05of a high level view of it? What is its current role in that
- 3:09financial landscape? Yeah, of course.
- 3:12So, you know, really it depends who you ask because someone in
- 3:17the West might view Bitcoin differently than someone, for
- 3:22example, in the Middle East. Someone who is financially
- 3:26secure will view Bitcoin as, for example, a store of value versus
- 3:31someone, let's say, in Lebanon, for example, the country that's
- 3:35been severely hurt by hyperinflation might view
- 3:38Bitcoin as, you know, a way out, a lifeline.
- 3:42So it really does depend who you ask, their circumstances and
- 3:46where they're currently, you know, situated.
- 3:48So Bitcoin serves many roles. It could be a portfolio asset
- 3:54viewed simply as a commodity, similar to gold could be viewed
- 3:57as a medium of exchange in certain countries where the
- 4:01banking system there's no infrastructure to service the
- 4:04people. For example, in Africa, lots of
- 4:09people can't even get access to a basic bank account because
- 4:12there's a lack of government infrastructure to support the
- 4:16opening of the accounts. There's no ID IDs issued,
- 4:19etcetera. So really Bitcoin can be many
- 4:22things, but in general it is viewed as a store of value
- 4:26asset, something you hold on to to protect yourself from
- 4:30inflation, something that you own really once you own it the
- 4:35right way. Yeah.
- 4:37So let's expand a little bit on that.
- 4:39I mean, clearly Bitcoin is the market dominant cryptocurrency
- 4:44and Bitcoiners don't even like to associate it with
- 4:46cryptocurrency. So tell us a little bit more
- 4:48about its market dominance and and how that influences its
- 4:52position in the financial world. Yeah.
- 4:55So in our sphere we say Bitcoin, not crypto for a reason.
- 5:01So Bitcoin is the scarcest of all the digital assets.
- 5:06Some people might view it as being diluted because there's
- 5:09around 30,000 other crypto tokens, but Bitcoins really not
- 5:13competing with any of them. Bitcoin is hard money.
- 5:18I would view it more as competing with the likes of gold
- 5:22or current Fiat currencies. And if you really look at the
- 5:26dominance, you know, we have one chart, maybe we'll share it
- 5:30later with the viewers. But if you look at a 1012 year
- 5:33history since the creation of crypto assets, Bitcoin has been
- 5:40#1 consecutively every single year.
- 5:44If you look at all the other positions of the top ten by
- 5:47market cap, you'll notice that, you know, over two years,
- 5:51there's a new second in place, a new third in place.
- 5:54Some of them even never show up again.
- 5:57So really when you look at dominance Bitcoin both from a
- 6:01regulatory point of view and from a usage point of view and
- 6:05from an adoption point of view has really LED in the space.
- 6:10And the reason why personally I think is because it is based on
- 6:16sound money principles and it's not trying to be the next
- 6:20Google. It is not a tech stack.
- 6:22Some people like to view it as a technology, but in reality what
- 6:26it is is a hard form of money. Yeah.
- 6:30You talked about adoption there, and I think that's really,
- 6:33really interesting because, you know, Tranfi traditional
- 6:36finances is one of the means by which it gets adopted, at least
- 6:40in the short to medium term. So, you know, in what ways do
- 6:43you think Bitcoin is being integrated into Tranfi, you
- 6:47know, by major financial institutions?
- 6:49Yeah. So, you know, as a first step,
- 6:52we can pretty much see there is some coherence and some unity on
- 6:57how they view Bitcoin. Previously it was viewed as a
- 7:01speculative asset, so they wouldn't touch it.
- 7:04But as you know, people started to understand it, started to
- 7:08learn about it, It started to transition into this store of
- 7:12value, especially with the current political environment
- 7:17all around the world, there's been, you know, overreach in
- 7:22certain areas. So it's a way that these
- 7:26institutions have been somewhat marketing it.
- 7:28For example, BlackRock, BlackRock did a 180 switch on
- 7:33Bitcoin and then really those ETFs really were a stamp of
- 7:38approval from the institution of space.
- 7:41And for example, in Canada, Fidelity, what they did in their
- 7:45standard smart portfolios that you know as a retail person you
- 7:49would just buy and you get an allocation to diverse set of
- 7:54assets. They've included a 1% allocation
- 7:57to Bitcoin. So indirectly, without you
- 8:00knowing it, when you buy the portfolio, you're getting
- 8:02exposure to Bitcoin. And that can't be said of other
- 8:06cryptocurrencies because it's easy to categorize Bitcoin in
- 8:12multiple ways within a portfolio.
- 8:14So it can be viewed as a commodity.
- 8:16So it would be kind of in the commodity bucket alongside gold
- 8:21real estate, so as an alternative investment.
- 8:24But some view it also as a tech investment because on top of
- 8:30Bitcoin, you can build multiple layers of different
- 8:35technological infrastructure, for example of the Lightning
- 8:38Network, which is focused on payments.
- 8:41It can also be viewed as a venture investment, similar with
- 8:45similar risk return profile. So it gives portfolio managers
- 8:50and you know, traditional investors this, this, this
- 8:55choice on how to allocate it within their portfolio depending
- 8:59on their subjective views of the asset itself.
- 9:03So over the years, we see that what was once a speculative
- 9:08asset, some would call it rat poison, has turned into a, you
- 9:15know, get off 0 type of asset where, you know, you should
- 9:19allocate at least just a little. Yeah.
- 9:22Yeah, I mean, so that that's a nice overview of, of, of
- 9:25Bitcoin, it's relevance in the world.
- 9:27Let's let's these are all things that we're going to touch on as
- 9:30we go through the series and, and hopefully we'll do a deep
- 9:33dive on all of these issues. But maybe we can touch on
- 9:35briefly the transformative power of Bitcoin in finance.
- 9:40How do you think Bitcoin is transforming traditional
- 9:42finance? And you know, what are some
- 9:44examples of that transformation in action?
- 9:48Yeah. So what are the biggest
- 9:52transformation, and we've seen a few currently adopt it, is
- 9:57Bitcoin being considered as a treasury reserve asset?
- 10:01So, you know, typically they hold on to cash or cash
- 10:06equivalents like treasury bills. That has been the strategy for
- 10:10decades now. But you know, the the Cowboys
- 10:16would potentially invest in more traditional assets, but
- 10:20typically 90% would be in some form of fixed income, very low
- 10:24risk type of assets such as treasury bills.
- 10:29But companies such as MicroStrategy have
- 10:32revolutionized this space. And not only MicroStrategy,
- 10:37there's a company out of Japan as well who's been adding
- 10:40Bitcoin onto its balance sheet and it's done well for the stock
- 10:45in general over the last few years.
- 10:48So viewing Bitcoin as a asset that every company should hold
- 10:53to protect their purchasing power.
- 10:56You have companies like Apple who carry 150 billion in assets,
- 11:00in treasury assets just sitting there.
- 11:03And you know, when, when inflation kicks in, that's a
- 11:08melting ice cube basically. So some of them are using it
- 11:11strategically to, to compensate for that.
- 11:14The basement that's happening due to monetary printing and
- 11:17monetary easing. So I think that's the major
- 11:20component of the way finance is being transformed.
- 11:24The other component is the custody business because, you
- 11:29know, in traditional finance, no one really asks about the
- 11:34custodian. It's, it's an afterthought.
- 11:37Like when you buy a stock, you don't really ask who's, who's
- 11:42the custodian. Oh, I'm not comfortable with
- 11:44that custodian. It's not really a choice.
- 11:46You just buy the stock and it's custody.
- 11:49And I can understand why because at the end of the day, it's a,
- 11:52it's a digital record. And if something were to happen
- 11:56to the custodian, it's easy to spin out the same digital record
- 12:01saying that you own X amount of shares.
- 12:03But with Bitcoin it's different because there's only 21 million
- 12:08if the asset is lost at the custody level, it can't be
- 12:12created again. So custody is taking a very
- 12:17different form, right? Because and Bitcoin allows, you
- 12:20know, a variety of custody models, whether it's self
- 12:24custody where you take possession of the asset and
- 12:27you're responsible for it, whether you use multi
- 12:31collaborative custody where you hold the majority of the keys.
- 12:35But I think the future is more geared towards something called
- 12:40multi institution custody. And the reason why is because it
- 12:43decentralizes how Bitcoin is held.
- 12:46You have the ability to use its multi signature protocol to
- 12:49spread out risk across multiple counterparties.
- 12:52An asset that's so scarce and so valuable needs a more robust
- 12:58custody system that doesn't have single points of failure.
- 13:01And I think those two elements, the treasury strategy and the
- 13:06custody businesses in traditional finance, will be
- 13:10changed because of Bitcoin as an asset.
- 13:13They have to just, you know, figure it out.
- 13:15And we're seeing so many innovations within that space.
- 13:19And on top of that, even from a payment point of view, we don't
- 13:22want to forget about, you know, all the payment services that
- 13:26are being created on top of Bitcoin.
- 13:28For some people using the Lightning Network, for example,
- 13:31as a layer 2 protocol, sometimes they don't even know they're
- 13:34using it because you can move dollars from one location to
- 13:38another on top of Lightning, and the user only sees a movement of
- 13:43dollars from one end to the other.
- 13:44But what happens is it gets converted into Bitcoin, pushed
- 13:48on the Lightning and then transferred there.
- 13:50And it's facilitating remittances, it's lowering the
- 13:54cost of moving money across the world.
- 13:56So these are the primary transformative aspects of
- 14:00Bitcoin. And you know, one thing we want
- 14:02to mention to our viewers is there is actual regulation that
- 14:06will be facilitating the counting of Bitcoin on corporate
- 14:11balance sheet. So the fast be so that's going
- 14:13to be kicking in and we're likely to see a higher rate of
- 14:18adoption of the strategy. So Michael Saylor from
- 14:21Microstrategy's playbook, we view it as a potential, you
- 14:26know, a potential bet that some kind of companies will be doing
- 14:30moving. Forward, yeah, we, we're going
- 14:31to touch on regulation a little bit later in a little bit more
- 14:34detail, but there was a, a couple of characteristics of
- 14:37Bitcoin that you mentioned just just then and I thought it might
- 14:39be useful to compare it to traditional assets.
- 14:42You mentioned gold and real estate before.
- 14:45What makes Bitcoin a unique portfolio asset?
- 14:49Well, first one and the most important one is it's scarcity.
- 14:55So similar to how gold is scarce, Bitcoin becomes scarcer
- 15:00over time. So there's a cap on these total
- 15:03supply which is at 21 million gold is scarce, but there is
- 15:09also uncertainty around that scarcity because finding a
- 15:13deposit of gold somewhere we that was not known of will
- 15:18dilute that supply and dilute that scarcity.
- 15:21The difference is Bitcoin is absolutely scarce.
- 15:24It's pre programmed from day one.
- 15:26And what's amazing about that is that, you know, as adoption
- 15:32increases with a inelastic supply, you would expect the
- 15:36value to keep going up. So that that's kind of pre
- 15:39programmed into the code. So from portfolio point of view
- 15:43that's very different because that's kind of a extremely hard
- 15:46asset that you're holding on to that that that is likely to keep
- 15:50appreciating as more and more people want to own it.
- 15:53There's just not enough to go around.
- 15:56Compare that to real estate. Some people say real estate is
- 15:59scarce, but you know, real estate is scarce artificially
- 16:03because there's government regulation.
- 16:06There's a lot of bureaucracy there.
- 16:08The reality is there's a lot of land everywhere in the world
- 16:11that's uninhabited. It's just that, you know, it's
- 16:14not as easy to develop. So there's that inherent, you
- 16:17know, you know, like limited, scarce, constrained scarcity is
- 16:22what I would like to call it. And people fail to consider a
- 16:25lot of the costs that come with real estate because real estate
- 16:29as an investment within your portfolio, if you actually own
- 16:32the physical asset is, you know, costly between, you know, taxes
- 16:37on the property, between the maintenance cost of the property
- 16:40and it's very immobile. So Bitcoin has absolute
- 16:44scarcity. It's extremely mobile as an
- 16:47asset. So it's held the right way,
- 16:49whether through, you know, a multi institution setup, multi
- 16:53collaborative setup, or even through self custody, you know,
- 16:57you can move it and you can move it wherever you want to
- 17:01relatively quick. And you can't do that with gold
- 17:05and you can't do that with property.
- 17:07So as an asset itself, just the return and risk profile, yes, it
- 17:12is volatile, but if you look at it over a long enough period of
- 17:16time, which is what most institutional investors do, they
- 17:19look at 5:00 to 10:15 years. Most pension plans have such a
- 17:23long time horizon that when you take that into contact Bitcoin
- 17:27volatility is is really is really minimal.
- 17:30Like they're if they can allocate 1 to 5% to it, then it
- 17:35doesn't really matter because what it does and it increases
- 17:37risk adjusted returns so much. Bitcoins performance and returns
- 17:42are actually asymmetrical. They don't follow really a
- 17:45normal distribution. It's like skewed to the right.
- 17:49So it's one of those asymmetrical investments that
- 17:53you can take on that has very little cost to hold and to
- 17:57manage and gives you also the option for extreme mobility.
- 18:02So as an asset, that alone has value and it is anchored in
- 18:06reality. And it's decentralized in the
- 18:09sense that it's extremely difficult to influence and to
- 18:13manipulate, which is a hedge against not just, you know,
- 18:19inflation, but it's also a hedge against, you know, oppressive
- 18:23governments and governments that may overreach.
- 18:26So it's kind of like the people who buy physical gold and bury
- 18:30it in their backyard. It's like their Armageddon
- 18:32scenario, but the reality is, if there was an Armageddon and you
- 18:37had a bunch of gold and you wanted to leave with it, you're
- 18:41not going to get very far. You put a target on your back
- 18:43and at the airport, you're going to be, you know, beeping like
- 18:47like there's no tomorrow. So versus holding Bitcoin, you
- 18:51don't even have to move it across.
- 18:52You can have, you know, relative set up a family wallet somewhere
- 18:55else, transfer the Bitcoin and just happily move on with your
- 18:59life. So there's a lot of utility in
- 19:01it. That's that's a lot of people
- 19:03that that may have not spent the time studying it under
- 19:05appreciate. So that's great.
- 19:08We've introduced Bitcoin in the global financial landscape.
- 19:12We've touched on some of the characteristics of Bitcoin.
- 19:16How do you see it evolving in the global finance landscape
- 19:20over the next decade or so? Yeah.
- 19:23So there's going to be a lot of hurdles, of course.
- 19:26It's not going to be smooth sailing, but if you look at the
- 19:30overall trend and the overall developments that have been
- 19:32happening, I would say it's more aligned to the positive.
- 19:36So we're heading in the right direction.
- 19:38Of course, along the way there's going to be some hurdles that we
- 19:42will have to overcome from a regulatory point of view.
- 19:45And I think really it's more of an educational issue.
- 19:50People are afraid of what they don't understand, but those who
- 19:53do understand it seem to back it up.
- 19:57And we'll get to this a bit later in the podcast.
- 20:01And that's where you're you're going to come in Harris about
- 20:05the moral aspects of it as well. I'll leave that for next.
- 20:09But I see Bitcoin, you know, growing.
- 20:13It's it's maturing as an asset. And the FUD that we were
- 20:17constantly bombarded with seems to be diminishing, and at least
- 20:23its impact has been. Less impactful, like there's
- 20:26less panic just a few days ago we have the German government
- 20:31unload over 50,000 Bitcoin and you know we hit a negative 25%
- 20:37negative 20% whatever it was and look where we are today.
- 20:41Market has been unfazed yes, and and that would have been a huge
- 20:47event like four years ago that would have people would have
- 20:51freaked out. They would have panicked.
- 20:52They would have, you know, like off Bitcoin is dead, which we've
- 20:56heard like over 1000 times, but we didn't see that this time.
- 21:00Like I don't I don't think I saw any news outlet go out of their
- 21:05way to say Bitcoin crashed 25% in less than two days.
- 21:10So I'm actually very excited. You have political candidates at
- 21:16the elite level in the United States now taking a position on
- 21:21Bitcoin. You know, even in countries
- 21:25where regulation is more strict, Like as soon as the German
- 21:28government, for example, tried to sell their Bitcoin or began
- 21:32selling their Bitcoin, you had MPs actually telling them don't.
- 21:37And they did a present and they invited them to come to a
- 21:39presentation to learn why you shouldn't sell this as because
- 21:43we might have to buy it back later at a much higher price.
- 21:46So, you know, these things, you know, you don't want to be too
- 21:51overly optimistic. Of course, as an investor, you
- 21:53want to be a responsible investor and, you know, gauge
- 21:57how much exposure and volatility you can handle because it's not
- 21:59going to be a direct path to, you know, $1,000,000, but it's
- 22:07going to be volatile along the way.
- 22:09But we've seen that that volatility is diminishing.
- 22:11The panics are diminishing, which means it's maturing and we
- 22:16forget it's been 15 years. Like it's no longer that asset
- 22:21that's been around for five years. 15 years is a lot of
- 22:23time. It's pretty almost a generation
- 22:25and you have the new generation that's coming in that are
- 22:29Bitcoin native. You know, some of the younger
- 22:33folks I speak to, they've never seen an ounce of gold.
- 22:38Like it's of no interest to them, like, but they can talk to
- 22:43you about Bitcoin. So that's, that's kind of where
- 22:47my views are. And you know how I view it down
- 22:50the line. I'm excited.
- 22:52I'm sure you are too, Harris. Yeah.
- 22:55I mean, I think from a certainly from a meaner and Islamic
- 22:58markets perspective, I, I think that there is a huge amount to
- 23:02be achieved in the Middle East financial markets over the next
- 23:06decade or so. Yeah, I think let's there are
- 23:10first of all, there are some yeah, cultural alignments, if I
- 23:13can call it that, in the Middle East.
- 23:16I think that there is a a unique environment, a unique financial
- 23:20landscape in the Middle East, which is different from other
- 23:23regions. And, and that brings new
- 23:25opportunities for for Bitcoin adoption.
- 23:28You know, I think this uniqueness of Middle East
- 23:30markets is defined by, you know, a strong culture of family
- 23:35dominance, you know, merchant families, trading families, a
- 23:39spirit of entrepreneurship, you know, that exists in the Middle
- 23:43East. And I think it's also a
- 23:45commodity based culture, right? So obviously oil and gas is the
- 23:49obvious thing, but I think when you combine that on
- 23:51entrepreneurship, you know, people see it very much as a
- 23:54commodity type of, of of asset. So, you know, this is this is
- 24:00something very interesting because the Middle East has, as
- 24:02I say, unique financial landscape, energy as well, of
- 24:05course, energy sufficient, self-sufficient, you know, that
- 24:08has a huge impact as well. That's something that we'll be
- 24:10touching on as well in our podcast series.
- 24:13So I do think there are a whole host of things that we'll be
- 24:15looking at as a series develops that are specific to the Middle
- 24:19East and Islamic markets. Yeah.
- 24:22And let's let's kick it off. Let's give our viewers a little
- 24:26bit about that. So we've spoken about Bitcoin in
- 24:28general on a global scale, some of the developments there.
- 24:33But at the end of the day, this is a MENA region focused podcast
- 24:37and we want to make sure we tailor the conversation to that.
- 24:39So Harris, I'll flip it over to you.
- 24:42So you mentioned the financial landscape in the Middle East.
- 24:45You mentioned opportunities in the region.
- 24:48Maybe you can develop a little bit about that.
- 24:50What type of financial landscape?
- 24:52Why is it? How is it different than, you
- 24:54know, the West? Let's just say because that is a
- 24:58financial lesson that everyone's familiar to just because it's
- 25:01more prevalent on the news. And what are the opportunities
- 25:04you see in the region in the context of Bitcoin?
- 25:07Yeah. Well, I spent eleven years in
- 25:10the Middle East in the early 2000 between 2000 and one 2012.
- 25:15So that was there at the start of the DIFC, the Dubai
- 25:17International Financial Center. And something that struck me was
- 25:21that Dubai was a very is a very dynamic place.
- 25:25It's one where commercially it moves very, very quickly.
- 25:28And something I find very interesting is where I, where I
- 25:32sit now in the UK and also when I speak to my colleagues in the
- 25:36US, they sometimes bemoan the fact that when it comes to
- 25:39digital assets and crypto and the technology around this and
- 25:43especially Bitcoin, it seems that we're a little bit slow or
- 25:47at least slower in the UK, especially to pick up on the,
- 25:52the fast movement of this industry, the pace of this
- 25:54industry. Whereas when I visit, you know,
- 25:57DIFC or ADGM or, you know, Saudi or Bahrain and people are much
- 26:02more on to this. They're, they're very
- 26:04entrepreneurial to see the potential of this.
- 26:07There are government initiatives in place already Fintech highs,
- 26:10Bahrain Bay, that kind of initiative that's taking place,
- 26:14which is allowing, you know, early stage fintech companies,
- 26:18digital asset companies, crypto companies, Bitcoin related
- 26:21companies to set up and flourish in the Middle East.
- 26:25And the Middle East is a hub. Of course, it's potentially, you
- 26:29know, a billion, maybe even 2 billion within a short plane
- 26:31ride of the center of that region.
- 26:34So as an opportunity for developing Bitcoin related
- 26:39custody services, for example, I think it's a fantastic place to
- 26:43start those. I think the unique financial
- 26:47landscape of the Middle East. I think in terms of the role
- 26:50that, you know, high penetration rate would take place, would
- 26:55would achieve in the Arab world and it's a relationship with the
- 27:00adoption rate of Bitcoin. You know, I think there are some
- 27:03specific issues in the Middle East that that may encourage
- 27:06that adoption. The most obvious one I think is
- 27:09some of the troubles that we see in places like Lebanon and Gaza.
- 27:13So very high inflation, very troubled environments.
- 27:17You know, every now and then we hear some, you know, crazy
- 27:20stories like the person who held up a bank, couple of people held
- 27:23up a bank in Lebanon, you know, demanding their money at at the
- 27:27point of a gun from the bank. Now, normally you would say that
- 27:30that's, you know, that's sort of a criminal activity that should
- 27:33be outlawed. Of course it's a criminal
- 27:34activity. But in this case, it was a case
- 27:37of somebody who's got a family member who's seriously ill,
- 27:41needs a life saving operation, needs the money for that
- 27:44operation, has the money, their own money in the bank and is
- 27:47holding up the bank to get their own money back.
- 27:50So, you know, we have a situation where Fiat money is
- 27:53gate kept by financial institutions all around the
- 27:56world. But in high inflation and
- 27:58hyperinflation environments, in environments where you have
- 28:01trouble accessing a bank for whatever reason, Bitcoin can be
- 28:05a literal lifesaver. So I, I think there are some
- 28:08specific issues around that. There are other issues like it's
- 28:13anti inflation, it's a form of sound money.
- 28:15So culturally it's very attuned to a gold standard.
- 28:19People in the Middle East, Muslims in particular, talk
- 28:22about the Islamic age of the gold dinar for 700 years.
- 28:26And actually a commodity based currency that is scarce, that is
- 28:30finance, that is divisible, that is decentralized, all of these
- 28:33things that we already know is very compatible with that
- 28:36bimetallic currency standard. And then of course, there's a
- 28:39whole sort of Islamic finance aspect to it.
- 28:41So the Middle East is uniquely a, a region where Islamic
- 28:44finance has a big impact on the financial landscape.
- 28:47Now I happen to think that there's a huge intersection
- 28:50between the sort of Islamic Economic model as opposed to the
- 28:54practice of it today and the concept of sound money.
- 28:57So that's something that I want to be touching on as we go
- 28:59forward. Yeah, that's really interesting.
- 29:03I love the how you framed, you know, how the Middle East sits,
- 29:07you know, in the middle between the West and the East.
- 29:11So it is really hub and you know, I've been in Dubai for the
- 29:16last four months, so I'm relatively new here moving from
- 29:20the West in Canada and I can totally relate to what you
- 29:24described about people are so let's just say crypto educated
- 29:31and savvy. Yeah, there is this level of,
- 29:35you know, digitization and I totally agree because when you
- 29:40look at the regulation, the regulatory Moat that's been
- 29:43established here, they are here to promote innovation whether we
- 29:47agree with it or not in terms of the type of, you know, crypto
- 29:51assets that are coming out. But at the end of the day, they
- 29:54are facilitating fintech innovation and this fits right
- 29:58into that. So that was great.
- 30:00Let's take a moment to talk about On Ramp Mino.
- 30:02As a driving force behind the new frontier, On Ramp Mino
- 30:05offers best in class education and advisory services for
- 30:08Bitcoin accumulation strategy in custody.
- 30:11Our expert team specializes in crafting tailored Bitcoin
- 30:14strategies and providing recommendations that ensure your
- 30:17assets are both secure and accessible.
- 30:20Look at consultation with Arnamina today to take the first
- 30:23step towards securing your financial future with Bitcoin.
- 30:26Visit ourwebsite@arnamina.com to learn more and schedule your
- 30:30consultation. And now let's get back to the
- 30:33show. You walked us through the
- 30:35landscape, the opportunities that are there now.
- 30:39We both concur that, you know, the region from a regulatory
- 30:43point of view is supportive of innovation in the digital asset
- 30:48space. But what are your views on
- 30:52Bitcoin specifically it's adoption within the region
- 30:56versus, you know, the penetration rate that you've
- 30:59seen? Because I'm looking at it from
- 31:02a, you know, there is a lot of crypto stuff here, but how do
- 31:07you view bitcoins adoption within the Middle East?
- 31:10Even though we both agree once it clicks, it's going to click
- 31:14and it's going to align well with, like you said, the moral
- 31:18principles, Islamic finance. But currently, as things
- 31:22currently stand, what do you think of it?
- 31:25So I, I think this is something that we'll go on to in a lot
- 31:27more detail a little bit later, not just in this podcast, but in
- 31:29in the future future podcast. But I think very briefly there
- 31:35is a certainly there are a few initiatives, initiative sets up
- 31:40groups that have been set up to disseminate the idea that
- 31:43Bitcoin is the natural successor to a gold standard.
- 31:47And that appeals very much to the Muslim mindset who
- 31:52understands the the allure of sound money and money that is
- 31:56anti inflation and anti Ribbo by definition.
- 31:59So that's something I think that's very powerful argument
- 32:02within the Middle East region. So I can see Bitcoin as, so
- 32:06obviously there is, you know, a certain element of jumping on
- 32:11the crypto bandwagon and you know, every crypto is good and
- 32:15we should have all sorts of crypto and all sorts of digital
- 32:17asset stuff going on. And I, you know, to some extent
- 32:20that's good because it fosters an environment of
- 32:23entrepreneurship. But to some extent it's sort of
- 32:25there's a lot of white noise there.
- 32:27I think what will help Bitcoin stand head and shoulders above
- 32:31the rest of that noise is the fact that it's completely
- 32:35aligned with the concept of sound money.
- 32:37And if we compare it to a bimetallic currency standard,
- 32:41which was, you know, a cornerstone of the development
- 32:44of this and golden age of the Islamic empire, I think that
- 32:47appeals to people on an emotional level.
- 32:50That's why I think ultimately it'll be the one that wins out
- 32:52in the Middle East. Very interesting.
- 32:55Yeah, let. Me.
- 32:57Sorry. No, I totally agree.
- 32:59Go ahead, go ahead. Yeah, I was going to say let's
- 33:02talk about that potential impact and adoption of Bitcoin in the
- 33:05region. Maybe you would want to give us
- 33:07a quick overview of the potential impact on the
- 33:10economies of the Middle East of introducing Bitcoin and multi
- 33:13custody institutions, that kind of thing.
- 33:16Yeah. So I think one hurdle for, you
- 33:22know, getting solid impact, so the regulatory landscape, so
- 33:26right now, unlike for example, you know, the United States, the
- 33:30European Union, there's a bit of fragmentation when it comes to
- 33:35how crypto in general is regulated within the region.
- 33:40So this creates difficulties in terms of, you know, creating a
- 33:44product or a solution that can jump through borders.
- 33:48And you know, in the United States, if Bitcoin is labeled,
- 33:52you know, good thing in general you'll see it go over the entire
- 33:57United States and the European Union regulation is centralized.
- 34:01I mean, I'm not really a fan of centralization, but having a
- 34:06coherent united rule set will definitely affect how Bitcoin or
- 34:12impacts the region. So there are certain countries
- 34:18that are much more friendly to this regulatory approach to
- 34:23digital asset. However, one of the things that
- 34:26you know is slowing, I would say the right type of Bitcoin
- 34:31adoption, which is as a store of value asset as hard money is
- 34:35that currently it's being bucketed under crypto.
- 34:39So it's being regulated at the same level and the same way as
- 34:44other crypto assets versus, you know, in the United States, for
- 34:48example, we can comfortably say it's been labeled a commodity.
- 34:52Yeah. So step one I would say is to
- 34:56kind of push back on that, explain why it's different.
- 34:59It's not a tech stack. It's actually commodity asset.
- 35:02And then the way I view how it would impact and facilitate.
- 35:06So one thing that's common in the Middle East is there's a lot
- 35:10of expatriates, so our population in the Middle East,
- 35:14so I'm from Lebanon, there are more Lebanese outside of Lebanon
- 35:17than there are in Lebanon. And I think that's very common
- 35:21in all Middle Eastern countries where a lot of the local
- 35:25population leaves and you know, they work abroad and then they
- 35:29send money home. So I think Bitcoin using whether
- 35:33the primary layer or more likely the secondary layer, which is
- 35:37the lightning, the payment layer could facilitate remittances
- 35:41and, you know, allow for better capital accumulation because
- 35:46you're not spending such a huge percentage on sending money or
- 35:49receiving money from abroad. The second point is, as you
- 35:53touched on, it's kind of like a metallic asset.
- 35:57So we as Middle Eastern or people from the region, we we
- 36:01have an affinity for this type of asset.
- 36:03We like to own these type of assets.
- 36:06So we're huge on real estate, on commodities.
- 36:09It's just second nature to us. That's that's what we're taught
- 36:12as we are growing up like property and you know solid
- 36:17assets like gold, you should own that.
- 36:20So I think as a store of value asset, it would work out well.
- 36:24And I think how it could impact, it could impact how the the
- 36:30government's, you know, if they really, you know, decide to take
- 36:33a positive lens on Bitcoin, they can integrate it into their
- 36:37energy industry, which is huge, as you know, in the East, not
- 36:42just from an oil and gas point of view, but the level of solar
- 36:47irradiance that's available here is almost 365 days a year all
- 36:53the time. So if you can plug in Bitcoin
- 36:57miners, work with private Bitcoin miners or even, you
- 37:00know, have the government be involved, you can provide energy
- 37:04access to everyone within the region at a relatively cheap
- 37:09cost. So I think from a social point
- 37:10of view, it can also facilitate that and can subsidized the goal
- 37:15of the region to diversify their economy away from energy, oil,
- 37:21fossil fuel energy, oil and gas and to other industries.
- 37:25So not only will it, you know, help with, you know, the flow of
- 37:29money internally, externally, but it will also allow the
- 37:33economies here to leverage what they have, you know, some oil
- 37:39and gas to better their societies and to diversify their
- 37:44economies away from, you know, being so focused on one specific
- 37:48sector. And not only will it also open
- 37:52up the cultural side as well, because Bitcoiners, they love to
- 37:56visit places where they can use Bitcoin.
- 37:58Like you see it all over, like every Bitcoiner wants to go to
- 38:02El Salvador, for example, to Madeira just to spend his
- 38:06Bitcoin. Now, some people say don't spend
- 38:08your Bitcoin, but that is also a touristically appealing
- 38:13proposition. And in the region, you know,
- 38:16countries like Dubai for, well, the UAE is really big on
- 38:21tourism. Lebanon, almost half of its GDP
- 38:25relies on tourism. So, you know, you can really
- 38:28propel that by having, you know, individuals come in, spend
- 38:32money. So that's how I see, you know,
- 38:34Bitcoin impacting it. And also you look at the central
- 38:37banks here, they've been accumulating gold as reserve
- 38:41assets. And there are certain tensions
- 38:44between the Middle East and the West.
- 38:47And we've seen, you know, between also the the Russia
- 38:51Ukraine war, what's happening in Gaza, there is tension.
- 38:56And so you feel like they're accumulating gold potentially
- 38:59just, you know, as a hedge in case there's a weaponization of
- 39:05the US dollar, which we've seen can happen.
- 39:07So governments may view it as a hedge, may adopt it as a reserve
- 39:12asset and that way they have more security.
- 39:15So that that's how I view its impact.
- 39:19Fantastic. Yeah, I, I, I think there is a
- 39:23huge potential from an energy point of view, you know, from a
- 39:28financial institution point of view in a way we clearly there
- 39:31are great, there's great potential in the Middle East for
- 39:35adoption and the impact of Bitcoin.
- 39:38But I, I personally have an interest in the Islamic finance
- 39:42aspects of Bitcoin and you know, the importance of Bitcoin in
- 39:46that field, which I think is a, a huge unaddressed area and one
- 39:51that I, I'm personally, you know, very, very interested in.
- 39:55And I think that Bitcoin aligns with the principles of the
- 39:58Islamic Economic model. So, you know, it's sound money.
- 40:01Sound money is a fundamental principle of Islamic finance
- 40:05that is not followed today because Islamic finance is based
- 40:08on Fiat money. So it's it's on a fundamentally.
- 40:12Shaky basis the foundations of shaky for the current modern
- 40:16Islamic finance industry. Whereas, you know, we once had
- 40:19700 years of the Islamic gold dinar, which created a
- 40:24civilization that was, you know, scientifically advanced compared
- 40:28to other neighboring civilizations.
- 40:30You know, it was a time for development of, of mathematics
- 40:33and astronomy and science and culture and travel and business,
- 40:37the Silk Route, you know, imported ideas, not just
- 40:41commodities, not just goods and services, but ideas into
- 40:44Southern Europe. And you know, we talk about, you
- 40:48know, Venice perhaps being the start of the European, you know,
- 40:52banking model and entrepreneurship.
- 40:54But actually many of the ideas were imported into Southern
- 41:00Italy and beyond because of the that silk group trade.
- 41:03So the prophetic tradition of trade is something that is
- 41:10really, really interesting because it's real economy and
- 41:14it's low time preference. Now what if you had a a form of
- 41:17money that was anti riba? Riba, of course is interest.
- 41:21It's banned in Islam. You can't make money out of
- 41:23money. And Bitcoin has this unique
- 41:25property of proof of work. So it is something that cannot
- 41:30simply be magicked out of thin air.
- 41:32Whenever a bank lends money, it is creating money from nothing.
- 41:37Credit itself is an act of money creation.
- 41:39Every time the bank makes a loan, it's creating new money.
- 41:42And then of course, it's fundamentally effectively a type
- 41:46of river, a type of excess or surplus.
- 41:48So what I think is there's a, there is a unique and natural
- 41:53alignment between Islamic finance or the economic model
- 41:58and Bitcoin sound money. It's very similar to the gold
- 42:02standard and I think that leads to a low time preference.
- 42:06Yeah, please go ahead. Yeah, very interesting.
- 42:08So maybe let's take it back a notch and maybe you can walk us
- 42:12through for the viewers that may be watching that may not be
- 42:16familiar, maybe walk us through the key Sharia principles and
- 42:21then maybe show us or explain to us how Bitcoin aligns with those
- 42:26principles and what makes it attractive as an asset for
- 42:31Muslims all over the world. Yeah.
- 42:34Well, you know, a lot of people say, you know, what is Islamic
- 42:36finance? And then they say, well, it's a
- 42:39banking without interest. Riba is interest, and that's
- 42:43kind of correct. But also it's kind of reductive,
- 42:46actually. That's an outcome of the
- 42:47fundamental principles. The principles really are
- 42:50finance is just a tool. It's a servant to the real
- 42:54economy. It's there to lubricate the
- 42:56wheels of the real economy, not to be the master itself, which
- 43:00is what's happened in the modern economic system.
- 43:02So finance is there to finance the real economy.
- 43:05That's real goods and services and it needs to be risk sharing.
- 43:09Risk needs to be apportioned between the parties.
- 43:12So you don't have a borrower lender relationship.
- 43:15Actually what you have are two partners working together as Co
- 43:18finances of a business or a venture.
- 43:21So the prophetic tradition is the caravans leave the city
- 43:25gate. They carry tech, textiles and
- 43:27spices and other commodities. They trade them in another city,
- 43:31they return, and then the profits are shared between the
- 43:35financier, the rubble maul, the owner of the capital, and the
- 43:39mudare, the manager of the money.
- 43:41It's a pure venture capital model where profits and losses
- 43:44are shared between partners. And that's essentially the basis
- 43:47of the Islamic Economic model. What do we have today when we
- 43:50have a banking system that is fractional reserve where a bank
- 43:56takes in deposits but lends out more money than it has in
- 43:59deposits, so it's created new money in the process.
- 44:02Now, if you overlay on top of that halal contracts, Sharia
- 44:06compliant contracts, and you know, you can assign all sorts
- 44:09of, you know, similar sounding Arabic words, Musharraf and
- 44:12Mudaraba moralbaha. You know, at some point you have
- 44:16to take a step back and you say, well, wait a minute, these are
- 44:19halal contracts overlaid on top of a system, which is money
- 44:23creation. How can that be Sharia
- 44:25compliant? And in the past, I've I've
- 44:27described the phrase Islamic banking as an oxymoron.
- 44:31It doesn't make sense. You can't be Islamic and
- 44:33banking, you can't create money from nothing and just overlay
- 44:37Sharia compliant contracts on top of it.
- 44:39So actually the model of the Islamic Economic model is one
- 44:42that is real economy and it is profit sharing and money is just
- 44:46a medium of exchange. It's not something to be created
- 44:48and traded like a commodity. So I think that's that's the
- 44:51real thing, you know, traditional finance, traditional
- 44:54Islamic banks, what they've done is they've reversed engineered
- 44:58conventional Fiat based debt and that's a mistake in my opinion.
- 45:04I think what they should have done is looked at the subject
- 45:06from first principles. This is what I'm doing in my
- 45:08day-to-day life. The company that I run creates
- 45:12as I say listed profit sharing notes that finance trade in the
- 45:17real economy. That's the basis on which it
- 45:19works. I think the ideal marriage would
- 45:22be that type of financing with a sound money system, and that's
- 45:27what I think I want to be working towards.
- 45:30So interesting. So you're saying at the
- 45:33foundation the system needs to be reworked or readjusted to
- 45:39have at layer one as we speak in Bitcoin terms a hard asset on
- 45:45top of which all Islamic finance product are built on.
- 45:49So what are the potentials right now to have a Sharia compliance,
- 45:56you know, Bitcoin product like how do you perceive that?
- 45:59If you can share that would be great.
- 46:02Yeah, I, I this is a very tough question because the Islamic
- 46:07banking industry doesn't want to go down this route.
- 46:11It's happy where it is. It's happy reverse engineering
- 46:14conventional debt products with a halal overlay.
- 46:17And you know, in in some parts of the world it's successful in
- 46:21places like Malaysia and parts of the Middle East.
- 46:24In some parts of the world it's not so successful.
- 46:26So in the UK for example, there is only a 2% penetration rate of
- 46:30all Muslim households who have an Islamic bank account or an
- 46:34Islamic mortgage, which is amazing really when you think
- 46:38about it because there are only effectively 2 Islamic banks in
- 46:41the UK. So they effectively have a
- 46:42monopoly position. And Muslims know the heinousness
- 46:47of the sin of river of interest. It it ranks alongside the most,
- 46:53the the worst sins. And yet, you know, most Muslims
- 46:58in the UK will have a conventional bank account and
- 47:00conventional financing. And I think the reason for that
- 47:03is because the industry has not really attempted to look at this
- 47:07from first principles. It did about 60 years ago when
- 47:10the first experiments were taking place.
- 47:12So we had the the Mitt Rama experiment, which I've talked
- 47:14about in the past, which is effectively an economist in, in
- 47:18Egypt who set up a social Savings Bank that took in
- 47:22deposit money from investors, invested that in local
- 47:25industries and shared the profits with those depositors.
- 47:27So that's a pure Madonna, but that's a pure investment
- 47:29management agreement investment relationship.
- 47:32They're partners in that transaction, right?
- 47:34It's not an asymmetric relationship where you have a
- 47:36borrower and a lender. So this fundamental prophetic
- 47:40tradition of trade has not been implemented in a modern
- 47:43financial instrument. That is what I'm personally
- 47:46working towards. And and as I say, once you have
- 47:49these profit sharing structures based on pure Madaraba and pure
- 47:52Wakala and pure Musharraqa, these are risk sharing
- 47:55relationships. Once you attach a sound money
- 47:59basis to that, as I say, you've got the perfect define marriage.
- 48:03I think there are some challenges here.
- 48:06You know, I think the challenges are that we need to, we need to
- 48:10get scholars to buy into this, we need to get top down approval
- 48:15for some of these these initiatives and we need to get
- 48:17bottom up usage. So that's something that I think
- 48:20will happen in time. Those are steps to integrate
- 48:23within Tranfi. As far as the top down
- 48:27initiatives are concerned, you know, I think a lot of good work
- 48:29is being done. You know, I'm, I'm glad you guys
- 48:32are set up in Dubai. I think there are other places
- 48:35in the Middle East that have a great attitude to this.
- 48:37You know, there are government initiatives in place to to
- 48:40encourage the development of, you know, for example, a multi
- 48:44custody institution like yourself.
- 48:47In terms of a bottom up approach, there's a lot of
- 48:50awareness, there's a lot of education.
- 48:51People are literate about crypto and digital assets in the Middle
- 48:55East. You know, there is some
- 48:58essential life saving usage. I have made donations to Gaza
- 49:02for humanitarian aid that wouldn't have got in through the
- 49:05traditional banking channels. They've only been able to get in
- 49:09through Bitcoin channels. You know, that's, that's money
- 49:12that can literally be used to save lives in Lebanon.
- 49:16It is being used to combat hyperinflation.
- 49:19You know, these are real use cases, bottom up usage of, of
- 49:22adoption by the people. And then finally the scholars.
- 49:25I think that's a really interesting and important, you
- 49:29know, area to address. Traditionally, in the past,
- 49:34we've seen many scholars who have been misinformed not only
- 49:37on Bitcoin, but also on simple matters related to the global
- 49:41financial landscape, the monetary system.
- 49:44They simply don't understand how it works.
- 49:46So they delivered these opinions, these legal opinions,
- 49:49fatwas, let's say Bitcoin is Haram.
- 49:52It's impermissible on the basis of, frankly, ignorance of how
- 49:55things work. First of all, what is Bitcoin?
- 49:58How does it work? Why is it like gold?
- 50:01Gold is Islamic by metallic currency, is Islamic as a form
- 50:03of money. Why can gold not be?
- 50:05It has many characteristics and more.
- 50:08And you know, why do we think governments only have the right
- 50:12to issue money? They don't.
- 50:14That's never historically been the case in Islam.
- 50:17There's always been a separation between state and the judiciary
- 50:20and state and money. There's no reason why we can't
- 50:23do that again. So this is a really important
- 50:26point to get scholars on side. We're beginning to see the
- 50:28emergence of young, dynamic, very highly trained scholars who
- 50:33understand not only fickle MO amolot, which is the
- 50:36jurisprudence of transactions in Sharia law.
- 50:39So they're highly trained lawyers in that sense, but also
- 50:42well understand modern financial instruments and the modern
- 50:46economic system. So when you put the two
- 50:48together, they're able to take a look at Bitcoin and say, wait,
- 50:50this is the most Sharia compliant form of money ever
- 50:53invented. And that's what I believe as
- 50:55well. So.
- 50:57With regards to the scholars, if you were to take a snapshot on,
- 51:02you know, the average view towards Bitcoin, is that
- 51:06something that you can pinpoint right now as we currently, as
- 51:09things currently stand and what direction are we heading
- 51:13towards? Yeah, We have a diversity of
- 51:16opinion from one end of the spectrum to the other.
- 51:19So we've had those sort of traditional well known names who
- 51:23are not necessarily experts in economics or finance.
- 51:26Many of them are very active on social media.
- 51:29They have in the past, and I'm talking several years ago, made
- 51:32comments or delivered legal opinions saying Bitcoin is
- 51:35Haram. And then they've issued a series
- 51:37of FUD, fear, uncertainty and doubt.
- 51:39The propaganda that we see saying, oh, Bitcoin is gambling,
- 51:42Bitcoin is volatile, Bitcoin is this, Bitcoin is that, all of
- 51:46which can easily be rebutted. It is a very simple argument and
- 51:49we're going to do that in this series.
- 51:51We're going to say why each of these arguments is to be
- 51:53rebutted, right? But at the other end of the
- 51:56scale, as I say, we've got this young dynamic scholars who are
- 51:59at the cutting edge of the industry.
- 52:00They're deeply involved in digital asset companies,
- 52:03especially Bitcoin, and they well understand it.
- 52:06And they said, no, it's perfectly halal and it's usage
- 52:08determines whether it's harm or not, right?
- 52:11It's the usage which determines whether if you, if you use a gun
- 52:14or drive a car, you know, if you drive a car over the speed limit
- 52:17and break the red light, obviously it's that usage is
- 52:19Haram. It's a sin, right?
- 52:21But if you drive it within the law, then that's not a sin.
- 52:23That's a useful thing to use. I think what we're seeing is a
- 52:27move in that direction. We're starting to see scholars
- 52:30coming round and we're seeing some very big name scholars,
- 52:34some very well known brand name Sharia scholars well known
- 52:38around the world who are beginning to sit back and say,
- 52:41wait, I didn't know very much about Bitcoin before.
- 52:44But I'm starting to, you know, read articles and see things
- 52:47about this and I'm consulting people in the industry and I'm
- 52:51beginning to see that actually there's something very unique
- 52:54and interesting and potentially very Sharia compliant about this
- 52:57form of money. And they're starting to come
- 52:59round to it. And I'm pretty sure, inshallah,
- 53:01God willing, that they will come round to it because I'm a firm
- 53:04believer that, as I say, it's the most systemic form of money
- 53:07ever invented. So part of what I'd like to do
- 53:10is to sit with those guys and, and persuade them.
- 53:12I actually think, I think this is something you really ought to
- 53:14look at and you really ought to promote because it's good for
- 53:17society, it's good for humanity. Challa challa and inshallah
- 53:21we'll have them on this show sometime soon and we can have a,
- 53:25you know, productive conversation and get their live
- 53:29views on the matter. Anything else Harris we want to
- 53:32touch on? I mean, we're almost at the one
- 53:35hour mark and you know, this is episode one of our show.
- 53:38I think we've covered a variety of topics, you know, in general,
- 53:41Bitcoin on a global scale, and then we went deeper and more
- 53:45focused on the MENA region and then we touched on Islamic
- 53:49finance, you know, how things are going within that space,
- 53:53what we can expect in the future.
- 53:54Anything else we want to touch on before we wrap this up?
- 53:57No, I think we very deliberately kept it sort of light touch.
- 54:01I don't think we, we want to give viewers a chance to think
- 54:05about some of the themes that we've mentioned and fund is a
- 54:07very important theme, you know, fear, uncertainty and doubt.
- 54:10You know, there are a lot of issues that I think are, as I
- 54:13say, unique to the Middle East. Energy is one of those things,
- 54:15you know, what's the energy usage of Bitcoin and is that a,
- 54:18is that environmentally unsustainable?
- 54:20I hope what we're going to do is argue that it's very
- 54:22sustainable. Actually, there are very good
- 54:25reasons with strong empirical evidence as to why Bitcoin could
- 54:28be good for the environment, and that's something I hope that
- 54:31we're able to touch on a little bit later.
- 54:33There's many themes around Islamic finance, around the
- 54:36Middle East market, market in in particular, that I think we're
- 54:39going to spend much more time on over the coming weeks.
- 54:43Yeah. So we're not just going to talk
- 54:45about macroeconomics, we're also going to talk about Islamic
- 54:47finance, social aspect of Bitcoin, the game theory of
- 54:51Bitcoin. I'm going to talk about, you
- 54:53know, the variety of infrastructures is coming about.
- 54:56And, you know, on the topic of energy, actually a few weeks ago
- 55:00we released a paper regarding Bitcoin and the energy
- 55:04revolution, which has a, you know, tailor made approach
- 55:09specific to the Middle East within it.
- 55:10We'll be sure to put it in the description below.
- 55:13But yeah, really looking forward for the next episode.
- 55:16Harris, this was great and you know you and I will be meeting
- 55:22with a bunch of people hopefully in the near future, bringing
- 55:25high value content and high signal content to our viewers,
- 55:29just for the audience. Just make sure if you like this
- 55:32content, make sure to follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter, YouTube,
- 55:38Spotify, every possible podcast platform.
- 55:43Everything will be in the description below and we'll see
- 55:47you soon. Thank you so much.
- 55:50Cheers. Thanks for listening.
- 56:09If you found the content valuable, please make sure to
- 56:12share with a friend and subscribe on your favorite
- 56:14podcast platform. Before we finish, a quick
- 56:17reminder that the content provided is for informational
- 56:20and entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed
- 56:23as investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are.
- 56:27On your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 56:30Visit Onrap Mina com Schedule a consultation.