Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Demystifying AB 1058: Where Child Support and Family Courts Cross Over
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Demystifying AV1058, where child support
- 0:07and family courts cross over. I'm Katie Pandolfini,
- 0:10co -chair of the Beverly Hill Bars Association's
- 0:13Family Law Section. The Family Law Section is
- 0:16sponsored by White, Zuckerman, Warsowski, Luna,
- 0:19and Huntz, Lawyers Mutual Insurance Program,
- 0:21SoberLink, and our family wizard. White, Zuckerman,
- 0:25Warsowski, Luna, and Huntz provides a wide variety
- 0:27of resources to complete almost any project large
- 0:30or small. They also provide traditional accounting
- 0:32and tax practice services. We invite you to contact
- 0:35them to discuss your specific accounting needs.
- 0:39SoberLink provides objective real -time data
- 0:41that can be used to reduce disputes over alcohol
- 0:43consumption, leading to less conflict in custody
- 0:45cases. With an unprecedented combination of features,
- 0:49including advanced reporting, facial recognition,
- 0:52tamper resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 0:54testing, SoberLink has been the leader in remote
- 0:56alcohol monitoring since 2011. For five decades,
- 1:00Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company has been the
- 1:02only California -based company to continuously
- 1:04provide lawyers with professional liability insurance
- 1:06coverage. They offer special rates with competitive
- 1:09premiums for a wide range of areas of practice,
- 1:12including family law. Our Family Wizard is a
- 1:14co -parenting platform designed to help families
- 1:17communicate more effectively, reduce conflict,
- 1:19and create reliable court -admissible records.
- 1:22Features like tone meter, shared calendars, expense
- 1:24tracking, An in -app audio and video calling
- 1:27helps support compliance and better outcomes
- 1:29for families navigating custody matters. Now
- 1:32let me introduce our speakers. The Honorable
- 1:35Angela Davis joined the Los Angeles Superior
- 1:38Court bench in 2024 by appointment of Governor
- 1:40Gavin Newsom after serving as Commissioner of
- 1:43the Court since 2018. She sat by assignment on
- 1:46the California Court of Appeal, Second District,
- 1:48and previously served as a major fraud attorney
- 1:50with the U .S. Attorney's Office and a senior
- 1:52supervisory attorney with the U .S. Department
- 1:54of Justice. She practiced at Struck and Chuck,
- 1:58and Lavin and Coder Brothers, has taught as an
- 2:01adjunct professor of law at Southwestern Law
- 2:03School and holds a BA from Stanford University
- 2:05and a JD from UCLA School of Law. Judge Kaufman
- 2:09was appointed to the Los Angeles Superior Court
- 2:11by California Governor Jerry Brown in December
- 2:142013. She has been assigned to Family Law Department
- 2:1660 at Stanley Mosque since she was sworn in on
- 2:19January 17th, 2014. Managing a busy calendar
- 2:23is nothing unusual to Judge Kaufman. as she demanded
- 2:25a demanding and complex civil caseload before
- 2:27joining the bench. And now let's get started.
- 2:33Thank you. All right. We are beginning this title,
- 2:44Demystifying AB 1058, Understranding Crossover
- 2:49Issues Between the 1058 Courts and the Home Courts,
- 2:52which I will admit continue also to puzzle me
- 2:57on many occasions. Next. So we're going to be
- 3:05talking about everything you always wanted to
- 3:08know about 1058, but you were afraid to ask.
- 3:12This PowerPoint is an attempt to address questions
- 3:14we've been asked over the years at about AB 1058
- 3:18and to share with you some of our counterintuitive
- 3:21aspects of the practice and procedures in the
- 3:241058 courts. You're quite lucky to have Judge
- 3:30Angela J. Davis here. because I consider her
- 3:34one of our resident experts in the field of AB
- 3:381058. As you will learn, this is an assignment
- 3:42per statute that only commissioners may have.
- 3:46And she was, I believe, at least five years,
- 3:50if not six years as a commissioner in AB 1058.
- 3:54The minute she got appointed as judge and sworn
- 3:56in, she had to be taken out of the AB 1058. We
- 3:59took her out dragging except for the fact that
- 4:01she was happy about being a judge. Next slide.
- 4:08So Judge Davis, what exactly is AB 1058? And
- 4:15how did that become a shorthand for child support
- 4:17courts? And some people call them 4D courts,
- 4:21which is odd to self -represent a litigants even
- 4:24more than AB 1058. So how does that all fit in?
- 4:28Next slide. Next. So this is truly an intersection
- 4:36of state and federal law. The 4D comes from Title
- 4:404D of the Social Security Act, which requires
- 4:44all states to create child support programs.
- 4:48And it also provides accompanying federal funding,
- 4:52which is somewhat relevant to how the 1058 courts
- 4:57are structured throughout the state. In bigger
- 5:00counties, what you'll see such as in Los Angeles
- 5:03County, you have truly dedicated 1058 courts
- 5:06because there's a federal grant that is funding
- 5:08those courtrooms in part. In California, Assembly
- 5:13Bill 1058 resulted in the enactment of legislation
- 5:17that establishes California's compliance with
- 5:19Title IV -D. Next slide. Sometimes people actually
- 5:25just call them the child support courts too.
- 5:27That's another shorthand. We sent out earlier,
- 5:34and you'll have it with you to look at some highlighted,
- 5:38some printouts, some information, some highlighted
- 5:41portions regarding Family Code Section 4251,
- 5:44which is key. So I'm going to ask you, Judge
- 5:47Davis, aside from the yellow highlighting, which
- 5:50people might now run and look, but you could
- 5:52wait, how and why are the procedures different
- 5:56related to 1058 commissioners? And then I'll
- 6:00just do a compound question right here. But what
- 6:03should practitioners know about the operation
- 6:06of the objection to AB 1058 commissioners and
- 6:10a little, what I like to call it, is the sandwich
- 6:16objection. And she'll explain why in a second.
- 6:21Next slide. So family code 4251 is key here.
- 6:28And that provides, and it's a little bit counterintuitive.
- 6:33Normally parties have to affirmatively stipulate
- 6:35to a commissioner under 4251 of the family code
- 6:39matters where the local child support agency
- 6:43is providing enforcement services shall, the
- 6:46mandatory language shall be referred to a dedicated
- 6:501058 courtroom. If you don't want that commissioner
- 6:54to make a final ruling, what you can do is make
- 6:59a 4251C objection. C is in cat, and that's in
- 7:05the highlighted language of 4251 that we attach
- 7:09to these materials. If a party raises that objection,
- 7:14though, the commissioner still conducts the hearing.
- 7:17But instead of making a final ruling, we'll make
- 7:23recommendations and findings of fact. And within
- 7:2610 days, then either party, and this is a little
- 7:30tricky and this is also an amendment that came
- 7:32about in recent years. It's not just the objecting
- 7:35party. It's either party may object to those
- 7:40findings and recommendations that the commissioner
- 7:42will be making in lieu of an order. And if that
- 7:45objection to the findings and recommendations
- 7:48is made within that 10 -day period, then a judge
- 7:53conducts a de novo ruling. There's a little bit
- 7:57of a strategic issue here. If you raise a 4251c
- 8:02objection, in other words, you just think, why
- 8:04not? I automatically will get a second bite at
- 8:08the apple. Well, here's maybe why not. Once you
- 8:13raise that 4251c objection and say, I object
- 8:17to the commissioner making a final ruling, then
- 8:19the other side now has a right of de novo review.
- 8:23Because under the current incarnation of the
- 8:26statute, once that objection is made, either
- 8:30party can then request the de novo review of
- 8:32the commissioner's findings and recommendations.
- 8:36Can I want to add a couple things? So the reason
- 8:39I call it the sandwich objection is because there's
- 8:41an objection made before the hearing starts.
- 8:45And you're usually, if you're in court, you're
- 8:47provided a form or you say it orally on the record.
- 8:51So there's I object. And I think Judge Davis
- 8:54made an excellent point. The why not could be
- 8:57problematic because if everything went in your
- 8:59favor and now you've just provided an opportunity
- 9:02to the other side who might not have objected
- 9:06to be able to object. So I wouldn't always say,
- 9:09well, why not? And we'll see what happens. Think
- 9:13about it. Know what you're doing and why you're
- 9:15doing it. Now, after there's a finding and recommendation,
- 9:20that 10 -day period comes And the notice of objection
- 9:25is on a mandatory form. It's a judicial council
- 9:28form, not an LA County created form, and that's
- 9:30FL666. An objection that's just on pleading paper
- 9:36quite possibly will get rejected. Just to keep
- 9:39in mind, it's FL666. It's a judicial council
- 9:44form. We're ready for the next slide? Yes. Next
- 9:51slide. So the de novo hearing is de novo. Normally,
- 9:59especially those of you who've done some appellate
- 10:01work, you know that by and large, a lot of rulings
- 10:05by family law judges are reviewed for abuse of
- 10:08discretion. What's reviewed de novo is the judge's
- 10:12interpretation of the law, generally, in family
- 10:17law. However, if you're doing a de novo review
- 10:20of a commissioner's findings and recommendations,
- 10:22the whole thing is de novo. So just as an example,
- 10:25If the commissioner said, well, I think child
- 10:29support calculation is $800 a month, but all
- 10:33downwardly deviate to $600 a month, the judge
- 10:38who's doing the de novo, even if that commissioner
- 10:41did a well reasoned within the bounds of discretion,
- 10:45finding and recommendation, because it's de novo,
- 10:49the judge really does have the obligation to
- 10:52look at it without deference and make a ruling.
- 10:55Next slide. Before you go, there's actually a
- 10:58question I think could cause for some clarity
- 11:01here. And the question I'm a little unclear about,
- 11:05but it's dealing with how do you always have,
- 11:09unlike when you are not in AB 1058, you stipulate
- 11:14to the commissioner or you don't stipulate. And
- 11:16you don't have to, once you stipulate and there's
- 11:19some findings that are made on credibility, et
- 11:22cetera, that commissioner is on the case forever.
- 11:25You show up in court, you have an RFO in front
- 11:27of the commissioner. You say you submit your
- 11:34objection. Later, you have another RFO. It starts
- 11:38over again, right? It's you're not. Yeah. And
- 11:41you're back. Right. Or you don't object. Let's
- 11:43say you don't object. Right. Now you're back
- 11:45on some other RFO. You know, it's it's it's a
- 11:50new right. That's correct. And if and if you
- 11:55If you look at 4251, it's not analogous to a
- 12:05170 .6 or to a non -STEPA commissioner. You're
- 12:09objecting to the ability of the commissioner
- 12:14to make a final order. But if you're in the middle
- 12:18of a hearing, day one, and then a week later
- 12:21it was continued to finish it, you don't have
- 12:23to keep doing the same thing over again, right?
- 12:26I mean, this is a little bit of a best practices
- 12:29issue. I think it's probably a good idea, especially
- 12:34if the commissioner is going to continue it.
- 12:37The commissioner wants to see another calculation
- 12:40assuming different factors. I think it's probably
- 12:44best practices to make clear that the 4251C objection
- 12:50is preserved so that the commissioner can complete
- 12:54with the commissioner is doing and make the findings
- 12:58and recommendations that 4251 envisions the commissioner
- 13:02will be making even if there's a timely objection.
- 13:06Does that answer your question? Yes. Okay. Next
- 13:11slide. Okay. I can go first if you want. So I
- 13:18just, full transparency. I actually thought Judge
- 13:23Coffman and I both do de novo hearings and I
- 13:26thought we would just share some of our thoughts
- 13:29on de novo hearings. I love doing de novo hearings
- 13:32because it's a combination of family law and
- 13:35appellate work, so I love doing them. But I just
- 13:39want to emphasize, and sometimes I've actually
- 13:41said it out loud on the record, de novo means
- 13:43de novo. And sometimes when I reach a different
- 13:47conclusion, I will actually say on the record,
- 13:50because this is a de novo proceeding and not
- 13:52a review for abuse of discretion, I want to be
- 13:54clear Commissioner so -and -so is a respected
- 13:58colleague, but my de novo, fresh eyes look at
- 14:02this, is that the result should be X. Because
- 14:05that's really what de novo envisions. Go ahead,
- 14:09Judge Kaufman. I was going to say, it's not an
- 14:13appeal. And so it is awkward in some ways, because
- 14:18a very well -respected and thoughtful bench officer
- 14:23concluded one way. But I will tell you what I
- 14:27have found many times, I don't know if I'm going
- 14:30to say often, is it is a second bite at the apple.
- 14:34So what often happens or what may happen is one
- 14:38or both actually bring into the de novo hearing
- 14:43things that they didn't bring or bring up things
- 14:45that they didn't at the first hearing in front
- 14:49of the commissioner. And that always makes me
- 14:52feel better because then I don't find a different
- 14:54result because we are different judicial officers
- 14:56and we have different ways of viewing things.
- 14:58But then I know that there's different evidence
- 15:01that's been presented. And sometimes people show
- 15:05up for the first hearing, loosely say, just kind
- 15:10of not ready, just not understanding. And then
- 15:13when they see what's really happening, this is
- 15:16a lot with self -represented litigants and how
- 15:18it really works. Then when they come for the
- 15:20de novo hearing, they're super organized. They
- 15:22have their exhibits in a much better format.
- 15:26So a couple tips that I want to make is whatever
- 15:31happened before the commissioner, whatever was
- 15:35turned over to CSSD Child Support Services Department
- 15:40attorney, it's not in evidence. And especially
- 15:45if you have a self -representative that did the
- 15:47first part and then they come to you and they
- 15:49want you to do the de novo, you need to gather
- 15:53the evidence. We are now putting in our minute
- 15:56order, because I was finding it to be so difficult
- 15:58that they have to file an income and expense
- 16:03declarations. Because often, they don't file
- 16:06it. They send it to CSSD. Everybody looks at
- 16:09it. Everybody talks about it. That's what's used
- 16:12for guideline. but it never makes it to the file
- 16:16and then it comes in for de novo and the party
- 16:19says well what do you mean you didn't see the
- 16:21income and expense declaration nobody is handing
- 16:24the de novo judge anything so if it's not in
- 16:28the file it's not there so practice point is
- 16:31whether you see it in the minute order or not
- 16:33make sure either a valid ine is on file and if
- 16:38not make sure it's in the file any exhibits that
- 16:43you want the judge who's going to do the de novo
- 16:45hearing to do, make sure you have them to hand
- 16:49in to the judge, even though it was presented
- 16:51to the commissioner. It's not a file that gets
- 16:54transferred. It's a de novo, it's brand new,
- 16:58as if the other one never took place. You will
- 17:02hear me at least sometimes say, what is it you
- 17:05disagree with? on the guidelines support because
- 17:09that's just, it's just eliciting stipulations.
- 17:11It's not that I'm taking it as appeal, but if
- 17:14there's only three inputs that you have a concern
- 17:19about, then that's what we're gonna talk about
- 17:21and we're gonna use the old inputs. I think that
- 17:27those are my practice points. So one other thing
- 17:33that I would just add to it is sometimes depending
- 17:35upon what the issue is, there are, sometimes
- 17:39fairly granular issues of law that do come up
- 17:43in 1058 courts. An example would be incarceration
- 17:48credits, which are somewhat complicated because
- 17:51the law went through a series of changes. There
- 17:54are also parentage findings that get made in
- 17:57the 1058 courts. My practice is always to read
- 18:03what the commissioner's findings are. But I make
- 18:08clear that I am reading them without deference.
- 18:13In other words, it's not an abuse of discretion
- 18:16standard that we're all familiar with and that's
- 18:18often the standard of review for a family law
- 18:21decision when you get to the court of appeal.
- 18:24But I do read them and I would recommend that
- 18:27practitioners read them closely as well because
- 18:30it's certainly permissible for the reviewing
- 18:34judge to adopt the commissioner's findings and
- 18:39recommendations if the reviewing judge concludes
- 18:42on review with no deference on a de novo review
- 18:47that the judge sitting in that de novo review
- 18:52agrees with the commissioner's findings and conclusions.
- 18:59Okay, next slide. Okay, so before I ask Judge
- 19:07Davis a few questions here about myths and misconceptions,
- 19:13I'm going to just start out with one. The use
- 19:16of child support courts or AB 1058 or Title 4D,
- 19:23however we want to call them, any of those, is
- 19:27not just for indigent people. So let's start
- 19:31out with that. We're going to explain it in a
- 19:34minute. If the county is the one seeking essentially
- 19:40reimbursement because someone is on welfare,
- 19:43that is one type of case. But anyone can ask
- 19:48Child Support Services Department to assist them
- 19:52in seeking child support or enforcing child support.
- 19:57You don't have to be indigent or on welfare.
- 20:01So I know Judge Davis had quite a few cases like
- 20:04that. You will find high dollar, high volume,
- 20:07high earner cases. before in AB 1058 for a variety
- 20:13of reasons in terms of parties wanting it enforced
- 20:16or sought, which we'll explain in a minute. So
- 20:18I just want to let everybody know there who's
- 20:21watching, it isn't just for people on welfare
- 20:25or poor people. So I think I'm going to ask you
- 20:30this one, but well, I'll ask them all. And then
- 20:33so some of the myths that that we hear or people
- 20:37say that are can make it even more confusing
- 20:41is that CSSD, Child Support Services Department,
- 20:45is part of the court. I think I want to go one
- 20:47by one. Is that correct? It's absolutely not.
- 20:52And it's problematic to say that they are part
- 20:56of the court. It's almost like saying the district
- 20:59attorney is part of the court. They're not. They're
- 21:02a party. And there's other consequences, particularly
- 21:08consequences of perception that can flow when
- 21:13they're assumed to be part of the court. But
- 21:16there's other consequences too, which we'll get
- 21:18to momentarily. So I think the district attorney
- 21:22analogy is pretty good. And it's actually where
- 21:27the commissioner or the judge might rely on the
- 21:31attorney from CSSD is more, I'm going to use
- 21:34this word loosely, a ministerial function because
- 21:37they might do the calculation to help us out
- 21:42of the guideline, but not be as a finder of fact.
- 21:48Let me just refine that for a moment. If they
- 21:52are doing a guideline calculation, which they
- 21:54will do, and in the 1058 courts they have like
- 21:57a station with a laptop and a printer, They have
- 22:02to share that guideline calculation with the
- 22:04parties, just as any party would have to share
- 22:07information with the other parties before presenting
- 22:09it to the court. And the service that they're
- 22:11providing is as much for the parties as for the
- 22:15court, because sometimes the parties, especially
- 22:17if they're in pro -per, they're not. If we were
- 22:20to send hundreds of people a week down to the
- 22:23DSO to run guideline calculations, it would be
- 22:25overwhelming. So, okay, good point. And so in
- 22:30other words, the lawyer for CSSD or the CSSD
- 22:34receives the INE's from the parties ahead of
- 22:36time, whether they're filed or not. So they have
- 22:39what the parties claim is their income, and maybe
- 22:41they check math on the W -2s. That's what they
- 22:45would input. They're not making findings a fact.
- 22:48So it would be up to the parties to say, well,
- 22:49that's not accurate, or that's not accurate.
- 22:51And then if the judge says, I agree it should
- 22:53be this, then often the attorney will, if they're
- 22:57sitting in the... in the AB 1058 court and they
- 23:01have their computer right there, they'll just
- 23:04rerun the number. So it's quite helpful to the
- 23:07court in that regard, but it isn't because they're
- 23:09part of the court. All right, let me ask this
- 23:12question. This is, I think, one of your favorite
- 23:14ones. I'm gonna go to, both of them are your
- 23:16favorite. I'm gonna do the third one next. The
- 23:201058 cases, sometimes somebody will say, are
- 23:25under the jurisdiction of CSSD. I haven't really
- 23:29figured out why that happens, but we see it.
- 23:32What's the problem with that? The problem with
- 23:34that, again, CSSD historically was part of the
- 23:38district attorney's office. Child support enforcement
- 23:40was a division of the DA's office. The problem
- 23:43with that is it's like telling a criminal defendant,
- 23:46well, your sentence is under the jurisdiction
- 23:49of the DA's office. They're not, they're a party.
- 23:52They are often a financially interested party.
- 23:54We'll talk about that too. And frankly, like
- 23:59any other party in litigation, sometimes they
- 24:02overreach, right? And sometimes they will make
- 24:07an advocacy that the court Will not agree with
- 24:12and not adopt So they're they're not a part there.
- 24:17They are a party to the litigation. They are
- 24:20frequently a financially interested party Yes,
- 24:23they are a government agency and as such they
- 24:25have higher duties under professional responsibility
- 24:29codes But they're not part of the court and nothing
- 24:33is under their jurisdiction and they don't have
- 24:36a stronger word or influence than the self -represented
- 24:43litigant or the attorney representing the party.
- 24:46Right. And sometimes they need to, I mean, look,
- 24:52there's a dynamic in courts where sometimes experienced
- 24:56attorneys, whether they're government attorneys
- 24:58or private attorneys, will telegraph that they
- 25:05know things that the judicial officer doesn't
- 25:07know. And it's just something that everybody
- 25:12needs to be mindful of, that it does not do anyone
- 25:16any favors to not recognize that the decider
- 25:24is the court. And it's especially, I think, problematic
- 25:28for proper litigants, because if they perceive
- 25:31that CSSD, who is the entity that is going to
- 25:35be enforcing, is part of the court, it looks
- 25:41like a rigged system to them. And I've actually
- 25:44had proper litigants say as much in the courtroom.
- 25:48And it's important to, I think, conceptualize
- 25:54that they're a party, they have advocacy, but
- 26:00the individuals, the obligor and obligi parents
- 26:04are also parties and need to be heard. and the
- 26:08decision maker is the court, not so that if your
- 26:14client, especially if they've come to you after
- 26:16they either had a hearing with AB 1058 court
- 26:21or, and you're doing the de novo or even in the
- 26:24beginning, they come to you and say, they talk
- 26:26to somebody at CSSD or, you can help by also
- 26:32clarifying the myth that they are a party, they're
- 26:35an agency. they do their job, you do your job,
- 26:39the court does their job. All right, there's
- 26:42another myth and then we'll go into detail of
- 26:44all the myths. This is a tough one that sometimes
- 26:48your client will hear the words, CSSD is closing
- 26:54a case, is closing my case. I talked to so and
- 26:58so and they said they are closing my case so
- 27:02that I don't owe child support anymore. or they'll
- 27:05come to you and say, they told me they were closing
- 27:07the case so I didn't think I owed child support
- 27:09and now I just got garnished, my wages just got
- 27:12garnished. This is a big deal and we have a separate
- 27:16slide on it. Closing a case, again, this is one
- 27:20huge reason to keep in mind they're not part
- 27:22of the court. Closing a case with CSSD just means
- 27:26they're not providing enforcement services. they
- 27:30will not intercept a tax refund, which is one
- 27:34of the things that they will do. They will not
- 27:35freeze somebody's license, which is another thing
- 27:38that they will do. The garnishment order will
- 27:40be different. You can still get a wage assignment,
- 27:43but it will not go through the state disbursement
- 27:45unit. And we have a separate slide on that, because
- 27:50it's extremely consequential. Intuitively, people,
- 27:54including some attorneys, would assume, gee,
- 27:56if I closed my case, that means I don't The other
- 28:01party isn't owed anything. Or if the custodial
- 28:04parent closed her or his or their case, that
- 28:08means my client, who's the obligor, doesn't owe
- 28:10anything. That's not what it needs. And we have
- 28:13a separate slide on this. So maybe this is time
- 28:15to go to the next slide. Why are these less consequential?
- 28:18Let's go to the next slide. OK, it's actually
- 28:21one slide after this. Why it matters? First of
- 28:26all, you know, go back one slide. Okay. So first
- 28:32of all, this is just detail on the financially
- 28:40interested party. Under the Welfare and Institutions
- 28:43Code, if somebody is receiving public assistance,
- 28:47CSSD or we're saying CSSD interchangeably with
- 28:51local child support agency. Obviously, if you're
- 28:53in another county, it might be called something
- 28:55else. CSSD is our local child support agency
- 28:58in LA County. Under the Welfare and Institution
- 29:01Code, they are the assignee of child support
- 29:05up to the amount of the cash assistance grant.
- 29:07So somebody is receiving public assistance of
- 29:10$1 ,200 a month. child support is actually payable
- 29:14to CSSD. They're a financially interested party.
- 29:19Also, just another reminder that the agency is
- 29:22required to open up a case if requested. That's
- 29:25all you need to do. 17400A. All you have to do
- 29:29is ask, literally, and CSSD will open up an enforcement
- 29:33case, regardless of whether or not the person
- 29:36is receiving cash assistance. Let's go to the
- 29:38next slide, though. So I just want to make this
- 29:42this clear because when CSSD or the local child
- 29:48support agency is enforcing or is an assignee
- 29:52because the person is on public assistance they
- 29:55are trying to get the money back that was or
- 29:59a portion of that was paid out on behalf of the
- 30:03person on public assistance to support the child
- 30:05and the money goes back to them. So they have
- 30:08kind of a different interest in the case. I'm
- 30:10not saying they do their work any different,
- 30:13but I want to just be clear. I earn $10 ,000
- 30:18a month and my child's other parent earns $50
- 30:26,000 a month and the court is awarded. I don't
- 30:28know that I probably shouldn't have given examples,
- 30:30but the court is awarded. Let's just skip all
- 30:32that. The court is awarded that child support.
- 30:36This is before it even touches. the local child
- 30:39support agency. So I have a child support order
- 30:42that pays child support of $25 ,000 a month.
- 30:47Let's just go crazy here. And I don't know, whatever
- 30:51reason, somebody told me, I saw on the internet,
- 30:54whatever reason, I decide I want the local child
- 30:57support CSSD to enforce. So I go over to CSSD
- 31:00or I fill out a form and I say, can you enforce
- 31:03this order for me? Will they? Yeah. So they won't.
- 31:07They won't say, hey, you got plenty of money.
- 31:09Go hire a private attorney. No, not at all. Not
- 31:11at all. 17400 a they shall take action if requested
- 31:18on behalf of a child who is not receiving public
- 31:21assistance because it's considered in the interest
- 31:24of the state of California that people pay child
- 31:28support. So anyone can open a case. And I when
- 31:32I was in a 1050 court. I did see a lot of high
- 31:35net worth cases where, for whatever reason, somebody
- 31:39opened up an enforcement case. And we'll get
- 31:42to some considerations that you might weigh in
- 31:45deciding whether or not to do that. And it's
- 31:48also, just in case we forget, a myth that's not
- 31:51there, you can represent a party in AB 1058.
- 31:57Sure. And you can file motions. I've heard attorneys
- 32:01say, If they're in AB 1058, they're not supposed
- 32:04to have attorneys anymore. Not at all. To the
- 32:07contrary, you can file a motion for modification
- 32:10while CSSD is providing enforcement services.
- 32:15Either party can file a modification motion.
- 32:17They will weigh in. They will probably take a
- 32:21position. They might run the calculation for
- 32:24you. But you can actually make you can definitely
- 32:26make a motion and it'll be heard in 1050 a court
- 32:29if if Child Support Services Department is providing
- 32:33enforcement services. Next slide. Next slide.
- 32:41OK, this slide you see the red at the top and
- 32:46the light bulb. If you remember one thing from
- 32:50this presentation, you might want to make it
- 32:52this one. Let's just say. you are representing
- 32:59an obligor parent. And let's just say he's a
- 33:04police officer. So he has like affirmative obligations
- 33:07to comply with all laws, including child support
- 33:10laws. And let's say the obligi parent, and he
- 33:16reached some agreement, you know, they're they're
- 33:18being amicable, they're co parenting, they go
- 33:21parenting therapy, and she's going to close her
- 33:24case for enforcement. And they've had this nice,
- 33:28warm and fuzzy agreement. And they're just gonna
- 33:32work things out between the two of them. He's
- 33:34gonna pay for daycare or the babysitter or surfing
- 33:37lessons or whatever else. And then what you need
- 33:41to know, and she does the paperwork. She closes
- 33:44her case with the county. So the county case
- 33:47is closed. What you need to know. is that does
- 33:50not terminate the child support obligation, because
- 33:53remember, CSSD is not part of the court. All
- 33:57of that accomplishes is that CSSD will not intercept
- 34:02a tax refund, will not have payments go through
- 34:06the state disbursement unit, and will not enforce
- 34:09the obligation. But even if the parties reach
- 34:13this warm and fuzzy agreement, the meter on the
- 34:17existing child support order is like this invisible
- 34:20meter ticking in the background. And the example
- 34:24of the police officer is from a real case. Ten
- 34:27years later, after closing that enforcement case,
- 34:32the obligee parent, the custodial parent, came
- 34:34into court, said, I want, reopened the case,
- 34:39and said, I want a determination of arrears.
- 34:42Because even though I closed the enforcement
- 34:44case, he hasn't paid child support in all those
- 34:45years. So moral of the story is closing a case
- 34:51with CSSD does not mean that the child support
- 34:55obligation is modified to zero. You need to do
- 34:58that. If that's what your intention is, is to
- 35:02modify child support to zero, then you need to
- 35:05get a stiff on file to modify it to zero. And
- 35:08if this is part of the agreement to establish
- 35:12that the arrears are zero with prejudice. One
- 35:16of the things that the county is extremely well
- 35:18equipped to do is calculate arrears with accrued
- 35:21interest. They have the software and they can
- 35:24do that. So the practical takeaway is if you
- 35:30are reaching some kind of agreement where an
- 35:34obligee custodial parent is closing the case,
- 35:39that does not equal modification to zero. You
- 35:43need to dot that I, cross that T, get a zero
- 35:46modification step on file. Additionally, if it's
- 35:50part of what you're intending to do, stipulate
- 35:54that arrears are zero with prejudice. So short
- 35:58and simple, it's a stipulation and an order signed
- 36:01by the court. So if you take it out of AB 1058
- 36:05in your everyday practices, of modifying child
- 36:09support, which happens all the time between parties,
- 36:11that's what you're doing. You're modifying it
- 36:13by stipulation. The court's signing it. It's
- 36:15a new order. But if you don't do that, as Judge
- 36:18Davis was saying, it's just sitting there with
- 36:21the clock ticking. And the reason, one, you should
- 36:25know this and why it's so important is just for
- 36:27your own protection, your client's protection.
- 36:29This is a hard thing for a judicial officer,
- 36:32because even if we believed all of those things,
- 36:35Even if it's not fair, our hands are tied. Our
- 36:40hands are tied. We cannot say, this isn't fair.
- 36:44And then people will say, well, it's an equitable
- 36:46court. And even though we all agree this happened,
- 36:49our hands are tied by case law and statute. So
- 36:53if those words buzz in your head or your client's
- 36:57head and say, oh, they told me it was closed,
- 36:58so we're fine. either guide your client to do
- 37:02what they need to do if they don't want to hire
- 37:04you anymore, pay your services, or if they're
- 37:07still your client, then make sure you've taken
- 37:09care of it. And the record says that starting
- 37:12November 1, it is zero, child support is zero.
- 37:17Yes, and the arrears are zero with prejudice
- 37:22because what people can do is they can reopen
- 37:26a case after they've closed it. and they can
- 37:29file a motion for determination of arrears. And
- 37:32that policemen example that I just gave you is
- 37:35from a real case. And the Obligor parent was
- 37:41very worried about it impacting his job position
- 37:45and everything else. He credibly testified that
- 37:49he thought this was over and done with, and they
- 37:52had reached a zero agreement. But that wasn't
- 37:55documented. And the biggest, not the biggest,
- 37:59but the equally big pinch, if it's worse than
- 38:04a pinch, it's not only is the child support that
- 38:06was originally ordered owed, which maybe isn't
- 38:09that bad at the end of the day, it's with 10
- 38:12% interest. I mean, where do we get 10 % interest
- 38:15in life? And again, there's nothing the court
- 38:19can do on equity grounds to say, well, There
- 38:23was obviously a misunderstanding, so we'll just
- 38:25waive the interest. We don't have power to do
- 38:29that. Right. We can get you to a settlement officer.
- 38:34We can encourage the parties to explore a lump
- 38:38sum settlement. But that order is binding if
- 38:44it wasn't modified. Next slide. All right. So
- 38:50I have some more questions for you. Is it clear?
- 38:56Maybe we've covered this. Any party may open
- 38:58in case for enforcement regarding wealth and
- 39:01aid. I think we've made that pretty clear. Anybody
- 39:03can. But I guess more importantly right now is
- 39:08why would they? They have an attorney. They actually
- 39:11have money to pay for the attorney, are willing
- 39:15to pay for an attorney. Why would somebody or
- 39:18why is you as a lawyer, would you recommend to
- 39:22your client Let's open a case with child support
- 39:26services. And any considerations to the contrary?
- 39:32Okay, let's look at the next slide. Okay, so
- 39:37before, okay, so for starters, enforcement powers.
- 39:42CSS says D can do stuff that you cannot do. They
- 39:47can suspend a license that's under the family
- 39:50code, not just a driver's license, by the way,
- 39:53it might be a contractor's license. might be
- 39:58a law license, might be a medical license. They
- 40:01can suspend administratively a license for non
- 40:06-payment of child support. Let me ask you a question
- 40:11on that. So when somebody hasn't paid child support,
- 40:14sometimes we'll see contempt actions. I'm intending
- 40:17to have a lot of discussion about that. Often,
- 40:23the contempt action is literally because they
- 40:26just want the money. They're not really that
- 40:27excited about the other parent going to jail
- 40:30and not working and then not having money to
- 40:33pay for child support. The same would be with
- 40:37the suspension of a license. But how does the
- 40:40license suspension of the contractor's license
- 40:43or a truck driver's license, how does that get
- 40:46somebody's attention? So it gets their attention.
- 40:50If people are in progress on a construction project
- 40:56and they find out their license is suspended,
- 40:58it gets their attention. What usually will happen
- 41:00if there's some kind of a consequential license
- 41:04suspension is the person will go to court. The
- 41:09relief will sometimes be, I want release of this
- 41:12license freeze. the courts will typically construe
- 41:16it as a request for some kind of a payment plan.
- 41:20And depending upon the circumstances, the 1058
- 41:23commissioner might say, all right, I want a payment
- 41:26plan of X dollars a month. And sometimes if it's
- 41:32a high net worth person, it will be lump sum
- 41:35payment by X date, followed by a monthly payment.
- 41:40And only after that lump sum payment, will the
- 41:44license suspension be lifted? But that will get
- 41:49people's attention. They will get into court,
- 41:52usually, because the person will want that license
- 41:54suspension lifted. And the practice and procedure
- 41:59that usually follows is some kind of discussion
- 42:03about a payment plan. And if it's a high net
- 42:05worth person, possibly a lump sum payment. needs
- 42:10to be done first before the license release happens.
- 42:16So bank levies, they can do quadra orders and
- 42:20they do them all the time. They can also remember
- 42:23earlier, we talked about how there is this federal
- 42:26and state legislation intersection with 1058.
- 42:30Under Title 42, there is also a provision where
- 42:33they can refer somebody for a passport freeze
- 42:36or a passport denial. And the next one, interception
- 42:42of a federal tax refund. This can be significant
- 42:47depending upon what the person's financials are.
- 42:51A tax refund can be intercepted to pay child
- 42:56support. The other thing, it's not so much enforcement,
- 43:00but it's information. If you have somebody who
- 43:02is just not cooperating, I know... It's shocking
- 43:06that it happens, but sometimes it does. Somebody
- 43:08is just not doing an FL -150, not producing wage
- 43:13documents or employment documents, just kind
- 43:17of shining on the whole process. CSSD can get
- 43:21documentation from the Employment Development
- 43:24Department and can kind of figure out If the
- 43:27person is employed in the state of California,
- 43:30they can figure out wage information going back
- 43:32a couple of years, which can be helpful not only
- 43:35to calculation of current wages, but also in
- 43:38some instances to imputation assumptions. So
- 43:44kind of in summary, when I was looking at this
- 43:48and also now listening to it again, they're a
- 43:53collection vehicle. So that might be one of the
- 43:57reasons you would advise your client to open
- 44:01a case with CSSD, with the local county authorities,
- 44:08because they can help actually get the money,
- 44:11not just get orders that might be more effective
- 44:14and reliable than you filing a contempt action
- 44:19that might not get the money still. So that's
- 44:22one consideration or one thing. Definitely. Yeah.
- 44:26Next slide. Next slide. Okay. They will also
- 44:32do a computation of arrears. As I mentioned a
- 44:35moment ago, they have the software to crank out
- 44:40a calculation that includes the 10 % interest.
- 44:44They will often perform an informal audit on
- 44:49request. They will initiate a meet and confer.
- 44:56They will, I just mentioned this a moment ago,
- 45:00they will get income information, including unemployment
- 45:04benefits, if somebody is receiving unemployment
- 45:07benefits, disability and social security. And
- 45:10then this last one, I think is probably relevant
- 45:14in some instances where you have a client who
- 45:18can barely afford counsel. or can afford counsel
- 45:24for a couple of months and then is tapped out.
- 45:28Even if private counsel substitutes out, the
- 45:32CSSD obviously stays on the case. So if your
- 45:37client is not in a position to pay for counsel
- 45:41indefinitely, it might be a consideration. And
- 45:45then next slide. And here's a consideration.
- 45:50Yeah. So here are some contrary considerations.
- 45:54They will not do a Smith -Ossler. They're not
- 45:56in a position to enforce them. Depending upon
- 45:59what it is, they will sometimes annualize bonus
- 46:03or overtime pay just to create an average and
- 46:07work that into the calculation. The other, obviously,
- 46:11a big consideration is if you open up a 1058
- 46:15enforcement case, that means that everything
- 46:18pertaining to child support will go to your 1058
- 46:22courtroom. Depending upon the specific nature
- 46:25of your case, you may not want that. It may be
- 46:28better for your case and the efficiencies to
- 46:31keep everything in the same courtroom. And notwithstanding
- 46:37what Family Code 4251 says and the mandatory
- 46:40language of 4251, I have seen it happen on a
- 46:45case -by -case basis, sometimes the attorney
- 46:48assigned to a 1058 case from Child Support Services
- 46:53Department will say, you know, even though it's
- 46:56a child support motion, the county doesn't really
- 46:58have a dog in this fight and we think the home
- 47:00court should make the ruling. Frankly, I have
- 47:03attention with that because under Family Code
- 47:0640251, the word is shall. But on the other hand,
- 47:12I have seen it happen in a couple of cases. If
- 47:16it gets convoluted, there's a Smith -Ossler,
- 47:19there's a payment of private school, payment
- 47:23of certain activities or daycare that start coming
- 47:27into the mix of what the child support should
- 47:29be and the add -ons and the extras, and it gets
- 47:32bigger and bigger and blow up more and more.
- 47:35That's where it might get too convoluted to be
- 47:40not only in two courts or having some things
- 47:46that aren't really being enforced like the Smith
- 47:48-Ossler. And then keeping in mind that you get
- 47:53two bites at the apple, technically, that is
- 47:56also a factor. Would I encourage my client to
- 48:00open a case? Because every time we do a hearing,
- 48:04that means we might do it twice. It depends who's
- 48:07on the other side. So it isn't you know when
- 48:10I looked at well we just went over the other
- 48:12side it's like slam dunk just have child support
- 48:14do all the work and get all the collection but
- 48:17there are things to weigh and consider whether
- 48:22you're advising or your client to open up a child
- 48:25support case um yeah I was trying to answer this
- 48:30question. I think this is a valid question. I'm
- 48:32kind of reading it and say it, so I'll just say
- 48:33it out loud. If the other parent has evidence
- 48:35of hidden assets that were not disclosed by the
- 48:38payer or CSSD, homeownership trust, bank accounts,
- 48:41lump sum, should the other submit this to CSSD?
- 48:47So to me, this would fall, well, first of all,
- 48:50you can't stop a case from going if your client
- 48:53either does it or the other side asks to have
- 48:55it enforced through CSSD. when it gets really
- 49:01complicated and there's a lot of discovery involved,
- 49:05you're still gonna be doing the discovery no
- 49:07matter what court you're in. You're not, you
- 49:09know, CSSD is not going to all of a sudden become
- 49:11this discovery machine and trying to, you know,
- 49:14do depositions and things of that nature. And
- 49:17so if you've got a case that has lots of layers
- 49:20and hidden assets and this and that, and they
- 49:24get two bites at the apple, I'm not sure that's
- 49:27where you would encourage your client to go to
- 49:32have enforcement. It's very case -specific. Assuming
- 49:38you have a choice. Pardon me? No, assuming for
- 49:42the lawyer, you have a choice. And also, you
- 49:44could inherit a case where they asked for enforcement.
- 49:47They weren't getting what they want. And this
- 49:49would be where they would then close their case.
- 49:52And then you'd go back over to what we call the
- 49:55home courts. Yeah. I mean, I definitely think
- 50:00CSSD will often do a meet and confer prior to
- 50:03coming to court like any other meet and confer.
- 50:07You want to take that seriously. But that is
- 50:09an opportunity to tell them before you come to
- 50:15court that you're aware of additional income
- 50:20sources that you don't think were reported on
- 50:24the FL 150 of the other party and they may or
- 50:27may not consider it. And they also, again, because
- 50:30they have access to things like EDD filings,
- 50:33they also have access to tax transcripts. They
- 50:36will sometimes get industrious and look at things
- 50:40like automobile DMV records. If they get industrious,
- 50:45they might look into things even more deeply,
- 50:49but that's, it's really on a case by case basis.
- 50:53All right, next slide. Next, okay, here we go.
- 51:00So parallel proceedings. I'll start. This gets
- 51:08also, in my view, complicated and convoluted
- 51:11and confusing, so the CCNC. And we're going to
- 51:17explain it to you. I'm not sure that we can take
- 51:19any of those things away. So what we see happen,
- 51:22which I'm sure you've seen happen, is let's start
- 51:27out, you had a case in the home court and the
- 51:32court made child support orders and child custody
- 51:36orders. We're not even talking about trial yet,
- 51:38but either way. And then, I don't know, one of
- 51:43the parents who's receiving the money, the obligate
- 51:45parent said, you know, I don't want to be asking
- 51:49and the garnishment's not working or something
- 51:51happened. So they go and they open up the child
- 51:54support case. And now the other parent, says,
- 51:57well, I don't want to be calculated child support
- 52:00on 20 % timeshare. So they bring what would be
- 52:05normal, or you on their behalf brings an RFO
- 52:08to modified custody and modified child support.
- 52:10But now we have kind of a split case. I don't
- 52:15think I have a perfectly best practices for you.
- 52:19Judge Davis and I were talking about it. And
- 52:21I thought, well, the best practice is file your
- 52:23RFO for modification and custody in the home
- 52:26court. and the RFO for modification of child
- 52:29support directly in the AB 1058. Keep in mind
- 52:32there's only one case number in the scenario
- 52:34I've given you. It's not two case numbers. But
- 52:38I can see problems with that because they're
- 52:40not on track together. Maybe the custody case
- 52:43gets continued. In the child support case, they
- 52:45say, what's the change of circumstance? And you
- 52:48say, well, it's the anticipation of modifying
- 52:54custody and maybe the commissioner is going to
- 52:57say, well, let's continue or maybe we'll just
- 53:00deny it and come back and file when you're ready.
- 53:03So you're going, thanks, you know, that doesn't
- 53:06help me at all. If you're going to have to weigh
- 53:09in balance. But what what I want to tell you
- 53:13is if you file it as one motion and a courtroom
- 53:20says to you, Oh, no, we're going to dismiss your
- 53:23child support. You need to refile. You can kindly
- 53:27remind the court. Can you just tell me which
- 53:30can we just set a date in the child support?
- 53:34Your filing is to preserve retroactivity. And
- 53:37I know I will admit there are mistakes made.
- 53:41But if you have the information and you know
- 53:43that and can ask the questions, you can say,
- 53:46my understanding. is that the portion, once you
- 53:50determine custody, the portion on child support
- 53:53will just be set in a AB 1058 court. And that
- 53:58might trigger a recollection of the training
- 54:01we've provided to get you a date and not have
- 54:06you refile and potentially lose retroactivity.
- 54:11Child support issue can be transferred to the
- 54:141058 court. Sometimes it gets convoluted. And
- 54:19that's the opposite is somebody tries to file
- 54:23a modification of custody in the 1058 court.
- 54:26And then they say, you've got to go to the home
- 54:28court. They can set it on the home court calendar
- 54:32as well. I don't know if I helped or made it
- 54:35more confusing, but maybe Judge Day's. So if
- 54:39this comes up, here's my thinking. If you're
- 54:46in a home court because either your client or
- 54:50somebody else has filed one of those multi -faceted
- 54:56RFOs for child support, custody, spousal support
- 55:01attorneys. If the home court judicial officer
- 55:08says, well, I'm dismissing the child support
- 55:11because you have a 1058, you have child support
- 55:16enforcement, I do think it's appropriate to say,
- 55:21well, actually, under 4251, can you just transfer
- 55:26the child support hearing to the designated 1058
- 55:30court? And I also think it's appropriate to just
- 55:34request that the minute order reflect that retroactivity
- 55:37is reserved. Because it should be. Assuming that
- 55:42the i's are dotted and the t's are crossed for
- 55:44retroactivity to be reserved. The reverse problem
- 55:48also comes up. People will be in 1058 court on
- 55:53just a child support motion and somebody will
- 55:56come up and say, well, can we just get a continuance
- 56:00because my client has a custody hearing in two
- 56:04months. I mean, my own feeling about that is
- 56:10child support is a priority under the family
- 56:14code. If that child support hearing has been
- 56:16on calendar for a few months and there's not
- 56:19any child support order in place at all. I think
- 56:24there's a strong argument to be made that the
- 56:28child support proceeding should proceed and if
- 56:31a custody change in a month or two radically
- 56:34changes it, then you can come back or at a minimum
- 56:37there could be a temporary order in place and
- 56:39a continued hearing date. But I think If looking
- 56:43at the family code as a whole, I think the idea
- 56:46of not ordering any child support because there's
- 56:49a future hearing on custody is somewhat contrary
- 56:52to the family code. But the bottom line is that
- 56:58the child support aspect needs to be under family
- 57:04code section 4251, heard in a 1058 court, CSSD
- 57:08needs to get notice. You should request reservation
- 57:12of retroactivity where it's legally appropriate
- 57:14to do so. And everything else needs to go to
- 57:18the home court, right? And when in doubt, just
- 57:22serve everybody. Yeah, just serve everyone, right?
- 57:25OK, next slide. Yeah, in our last few minutes,
- 57:30Judge Davis is going to explain three noteworthy
- 57:35decisions. So yeah, I mean, there's a lot of
- 57:37unreported. As in family law generally, there
- 57:42are quite a few unreported decisions and not
- 57:46as many reported decisions as might be optimal,
- 57:49depending on your viewpoint, but just a few that
- 57:51I wanted to flag. So there is appellate authority,
- 57:56it's right here, Mendoza versus Ramos, that you
- 57:58don't impute income to a party receiving public
- 58:01assistance. That's actually consistent with the
- 58:04family code. that says in defining income that
- 58:07public assistance doesn't count. Let me just
- 58:10say something about that. Imputing no imputation
- 58:14of income means you don't impute income, right?
- 58:18You don't substitute earning capacity for actual
- 58:20earnings. However, if somebody is receiving public
- 58:24assistance, but there is evidence that that person
- 58:28also does something to earn money like works
- 58:32for a hair salon or whatever, or babysits or
- 58:37whatever it is, and you have evidence that that
- 58:41parent is earning money, there is no prohibition
- 58:45on proving actual income based upon evidence,
- 58:50including if the person just has $5 ,000 a month
- 58:53of expenses and testifies that nobody else is
- 58:55helping pay monthly expenses. The prohibition
- 59:00on imputation of income is not the same as prohibiting
- 59:04a finding of actual income. So just bear that
- 59:06in mind. But you cannot impute if somebody is
- 59:09receiving public assistance. County of San Diego
- 59:13versus PB. This is a case directly arising in
- 59:17the county enforcement context. where there was
- 59:23basically interference by the custodial parent
- 59:26in the other parent's custodial time. The commissioner
- 59:30was very sympathetic to the parent whose time
- 59:33was being interfered with and the commissioner
- 59:36essentially imputed a timeshare. The court of
- 59:40appeals said that's not okay. We don't do that
- 59:44because child support is sacrosanct and it's
- 59:46really for the benefit of the child. a parent
- 59:50who is interfering with the other parent's timeshare.
- 59:52There's other remedies for that, but you don't
- 59:54impute timeshare, and that's County of San Diego
- 59:57versus PB. The other one that is kind of a corollary
- 1:00:04to Mendoza versus Ramos is you don't order a
- 1:00:09job search on somebody who's already in a welfare
- 1:00:14to work program. That was considered an abuse
- 1:00:17of discretion in that case. So I just thought
- 1:00:21a few noteworthy rulings to bear in mind. Next
- 1:00:27slide. So we hit right on the button at 1 .15.
- 1:00:33So we thank you for joining us during your lunch
- 1:00:35hour and are always open if you're really stuck
- 1:00:39on questions to reach out in the procedural aspect,
- 1:00:43not so much the legal, but the procedural maneuvers
- 1:00:46that happen sometimes. So thank you very much.