Latest / Following Leads / How the Lindsay Clancy Trial Could Redefine Postpartum Mental Health
Transcript
- 00:00:00 Laura Hettiger: There are three names we all need to remember Cora Dawson and Callan Clancy. Three young siblings were all killed by their mother, Lindsay Clancy. Three deaths that shocked a community and brought on national attention. Three deaths that also forced a really difficult conversation about motherhood, mental illness, and the very real mental health crises that can occur after childbirth. This podcast, Following Leads, is not here to try the case. There are plenty of other shows doing just that. We want to understand what happens beyond the courtroom. We want to know what it has been like for the people of Massachusetts to live with this story since it broke in January of twenty twenty three, and also how it has changed the conversation around postpartum mental health. For that perspective, we turn to Chris Pisano, the evening anchor at Western Mass News, a gray television station. And Chris, thank you for being here. 00:01:05 Chris Pisano: It's absolutely my pleasure. I wish it were under different circumstances, but it is what it is. Yeah. 00:01:10 Laura Hettiger: Chris, if you would please take me back to January twenty fourth, twenty twenty three. What do you remember about that day? 00:01:20 Chris Pisano: Well, it was a normal day, honestly, a normal news day. I can't remember any stories that were happening up until we were done with the six p m newscast. Um, we get done at six thirty and there were some rumblings, nothing confirmed, but we, we received word that there was a large presence in Duxbury at a house with the possibility of serious injuries and fatalities, and that played out throughout the night until by about ten o'clock, uh, it was confirmed that there was indeed a scene there, uh, with reports of three children, two potentially fatal, one in the hospital and an adult woman who had, from what they believe, attempted to commit suicide. It wasn't until the next day, which was a Wednesday, that the D.A. held a press conference, that unfortunately, the worst, the absolute worst, the most darkest details came out. But that was the next day, that Tuesday. Clearly a dramatic crime scene, some type of violence. But the officials were reticent to really give out exactly what was going on. And they may not, frankly, have known until all the reports came in. And the D.A. kind of sorted through it and figured out what exactly had happened. 00:02:49 Laura Hettiger: During that day's news conference. As you are learning more, your reporters are learning more. When was there a turning point in the newsroom where you all realized this is not just a horrific, tragic local story that this is going to be a story of national news. 00:03:14 Chris Pisano: And again, I'm not pausing because I don't remember. I'm just I'm trying to put the right word. Again, this is a very, very dark case, and it's exceptionally upsetting. When the D.A. announced the adult woman's name, Lindsay Clancy identified her as the mother and said he was bringing charges against her murder charges for two children. Uh, the youngest child, the eight month old, was still in the hospital at that time. And we were all hoping that, um, he would pull through. That did not happen, I believe about two days later he passed as well. But, um, you could have heard a shoe drop when it came out that the mother, Lindsay Clancy, had killed her own children. And, um, I can think I actually, I can't think of any crime worse than that. Uh, you could come up with a list, I suppose, of heinous crimes that might rival that. But for a parent to be charged with killing their children and young children. Not that it's okay at an older age. That's not my implication. But the fact that they were so young all under six. I myself at the time had, um, geez, my son was six years old and then I had a three year old. So I had two children that were about the same age as the Clancy children. And, um, it certainly floored everyone when these details came out, but, uh, we were talking about it prior to this. I think as a parent, you internalize these stories more so than perhaps someone who isn't a parent yet. Um, because I always the first thing I came to was, oh my gosh, these were my children's age. It was, um, absolutely horrible, horrible, horrible, horrible. And it was when the Da had his first press conference was, was less than twenty four hours after this had occurred. And he laid out, um, that Lindsey was going to be charged for the deaths of her for the murder of her children. 00:05:31 Laura Hettiger: And you put such a human perspective by bringing in the fact your boys were around Cora and Dawson's ages and then Baby Callen, for me personally, when this happened, I had a one month old at home. My first. And even when reading in the days and weeks later about what might have happened, I started learning so much more about postpartum mental health. I want to bring this conversation to that point. When did postpartum mental health become a really significant conversation surrounding this case? 00:06:11 Chris Pisano: It was it was fairly it was quickly after the details of the case came out. Obviously, you're looking for a motive. Mhm. Um, I think I think right off the bat, many people were thinking this was some type of a domestic issue. Um, a traditional domestic issue. Um, because there hadn't been a lot of talk about Patrick the husband. And rumors were flying. Exactly what was going on in this house for something like this to occur. Um, and I think that's a natural reaction for many people. There has to be an explanation. Um, things like this just don't happen. And to backtrack a little bit, um, for your audience to put it into perspective, this happened in, um, a small town called Duxbury, which is south of Boston, probably about thirty, thirty five miles south, considered a suburb of Boston and its exceptionally wealthy. This is a wealthy community. It's right on the South Shore. So it's on the harbor beaches and boats and yachts and clubs. And, um, this is a community where crime of any sort rarely happens. And certainly something to this level never happens. I mean, of all places, Duxbury would not be a place where you would think this type of crime would happen. So just at the outset, it was so jaw dropping on many, many levels. But to get back to your point again, trying to figure out a motive, I think we've all heard of postpartum depression. Um, and, and I'm not a doctor. I don't pretend to be. I don't know how common it is, but it's common enough to be part of the vernacular. I think of, of just mental health. Postpartum depression is not so uncommon that people haven't heard of it. We all know sometimes when women have children, there is. It's a tough time. It's a tough place to be. Lack of sleep. This child is is very demanding on the mother and the father as well, but more so the mother takes the brunt of it. You're not getting any sleep. You feel like a zombie. Days turned into weeks. You don't know what time it is. This child is dependent on you for everything. But I had never heard of postpartum psychosis before, which is exponentially more serious than postpartum depression. And if you are to believe the defense in the Lindsay Clancy case, it is so extreme, so serious, that you can invoke the insanity defense such that we are to believe that Lindsay did not know at the time the difference between right and wrong. She wasn't morally culpable for this because she didn't know or she was in such throes of postpartum psychosis that killing the children wouldn't be considered murder. And again, I don't want to go down that rabbit hole because I'm not a psychologist or a doctor. But that's essentially what the defense is saying. She's not criminally responsible because of her state of mind. 00:09:25 Laura Hettiger: I think it's been uniquely hard for mothers, as you mentioned, to watch and follow this trial. Many mothers have just said, I can't. Anytime I see even the last name Clancy, I turn it off, I exit out, I get off Facebook. It's just too much. But then there are other mothers who have dealt with postpartum depression, postpartum OCD, maybe getting close to that psychosis line. I'm sure in your coverage you have started hearing from those mothers. What types of stories have you heard of moms coming out and saying something similar. I was having these intrusive thoughts too. 00:10:13 Chris Pisano: Um, I think it's more common than many people realize, and it's a shame that something like this had to happen for the spotlight to be shown onto that aspect of mental health, but I think you bring up a good point there. There are a lot of women who have certainly not to this extent, but have experienced some sort of postpartum depression. Um, and I would be lying and I'd be lying to say that even I and I don't pretend to understand as a man, I don't want to go there, but I have six children. I've been through the infancy stage and the toddler stage and the potty training stage and the complete dependence stage many times and for a long time. And I understand when your nerves are frayed, um, it takes supreme control To keep your things together. To keep yourself together. And not only that, to be there for your child. Because again, they are completely dependent on you, especially at very young ages. Now, couple that with some type of mental disorder, postpartum depression, or God forbid, psychosis. And I would think we would be deceiving ourselves. Not to say that you couldn't understand how someone could snap. Now, to that level, I think that's where understanding begins to break down. Because again, for a mother to kill their own children is such a leap beyond what we would consider a response to stress. Mhm. Um, it's, I mean, I'm struggling for I'm in the business to put together coherent sentences and even I'm struggling to right now understand it. Um, it's it's incomprehensible. It really is. Other than I think we all can put ourselves in a position where we have lost it in front of and because of our children. It's just a part of humanity. Mhm. Um, and if you're not mentally enough healthy, uh, you could see how someone could break not to that extent per se, but you could see how someone could break. 00:12:32 Laura Hettiger: You are there in Massachusetts, your entire news team has been covering the trial each day, and you've been covering this case for three and a half years. What is something you think that national news and national consumers removed from Massachusetts are missing about this story? 00:12:55 Chris Pisano: Well, I think anytime you have a story, especially that goes national, it becomes impersonal. Um, you don't understand perhaps the people involved or the community at large. It's easy to place people in two buckets, us and them. And so when you have national stories, it's usually, oh, this is happening to them. This isn't happening to me. When it happens, figuratively speaking, in your own backyard, um, it brings it to a whole new level. Um, it's not something you can necessarily shut off because people are talking about it everywhere you go. And some people may even know the players involved or be two or three degrees separated from, oh, I knew such and such. Who knew such and such. So it becomes a much deeper conversation, um, than if you were to just be living, you know, a thousand miles away. And you can just, you know, click off your TV or turn off your phone. Like you said, it's, it's a heavy, dark, dark, dark case and subject. And I think we would all like to just somehow put it in the corner. But when it's happening in your neighborhood, in your town, in your part of the country or state, it's much more difficult to do it. This is a haunting case that will I'm I'm certain it will. It will not fade away for many, many people. It just will not fade away. You and I don't mean to sound callous either, but you have to learn to live with it, I suppose. Um, and just just go on. 00:14:43 Laura Hettiger: And we also hope the memories of Cora, Callen, and Dawson don't go away, either. In the three and a half years that you've covered this case. I'm sure there have been anecdotal stories, maybe from Patrick or their grandparents, about what these three kiddos like to do. What do you hope people remember about these precious, innocent victims in this case. 00:15:10 Chris Pisano: I think you hit the nail on the head. I just hope that they are remembered. Um, we've got become so entranced with the trial. Um, and perhaps rightly so. It is. Um. It is one of those trials that don't happen all the time, thank God. Um, and many people follow it and you kind of get lost in the details and forget that we are talking about three innocent lives, three children who didn't really have a chance to live. Um. And the amount of betrayal, fear, just the horror. I again, I don't want to get too dark. Um, it it's, it's almost incomprehensible what they may have been experiencing that night. Um, there are large crowds that stand outside to support Lindsay Clancy. Uh, right or wrong? I'm not the one to decide, but I think at the end of the day, we also have to remember, as you said, the three children. Mhm. Um, and I just hope that it brings Patrick, uh, the grandparents, the aunts and uncles some solace to know that there were happy moments, that there were aspects of their lives that, um, should be remembered. And maybe at some point years down the road, they can smile when they remember those children. Um, one thing that always struck me the day of the murders. Patrick Clancy had said Lindsay was having a good day. I don't remember the exact quote, but said something to the effect of, this is one of the best days she's had. Um, little did he know that hours later, this horrible thing would happen when he was out running errands to get some takeout food and a prescription at CVS and came home to an unimaginable. Unimaginable scene. 00:17:18 Laura Hettiger: In that response, I noticed you used the word hope. As the trial wraps up and whatever the verdict is, whatever happens to Lindsay, I think personally and from other moms I have spoken to, we do have the hope that maybe this is going to not only start a larger conversation about postpartum mental health issues, but move past the conversation and put more checks in place. Do you think Massachusetts, the people there who have been impacted by this most directly will start doing that? Have those conversations and programs already been put in place? 00:18:06 Chris Pisano: I have little doubt. Um, it's horrible that it has to come to something so extreme for this to take the spotlight. But I would not be surprised if there's even legislatively some type of action to prevent or try to prevent a tragedy like this from happening. In what form? I don't I don't exactly know. I would hope at the very least, that next time a new mother comes in and says, I'm having thoughts or, you know, whatever she might be presenting with for symptoms, it is taken serious, deadly serious, and not something that is just shunted to the side and, well, try this pill and come back in a week and let us know how it works. Um, I've gone over this many, many times how how to prevent something like this from happening in the future. And I, I come down to, you know, mental health is, is such a difficult thing to pinpoint. And I'm talking in generalities, but like, if you if you were to break your leg, you could get an X-ray and they could confirm, yes, you definitely broke your bone. Um, if you have heart palpitations, they can check your arteries. They. Yes. One of your arteries is ninety percent black, you know, or diabetes, whatever it might be. You know, there are physical aspects and tests that can be taken to determine exactly what the issue is physically going on. But how does that work with mental health? And beyond that, if something is diagnosed, what type of treatments are available? Um, it's it is a very tough subject, and I can only hope that there is wider awareness to an issue like this and not something that is just pushed aside, you know, like, well, mom, toughen up. It's, it's, we know having a baby is going to be tough and you're just going to have to soldier on, but rather some type of larger understanding that there may be. A bigger issue happening, and God forbid, it might end in tragedy. So at some point there is an intervention. What that might be, I don't know, but at least be more cognizant that there may need to be some type of intervention before things spiral out of control. 00:20:42 Laura Hettiger: Chris, we so appreciate your sensitivity, the time you have given us to explain the impact of this in Massachusetts. And as you mentioned earlier, I am I'm so sorry that we are connecting on a story like this, but may we all remember Cora Dawson and Cal and Clancy. Thank you for being here, Chris. 00:21:04 Chris Pisano: Amen to that. 00:21:05 Laura Hettiger: And thank you for listening. This has been following leads where real life meets true crime.