Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Alan Moon
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamers Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamers guild. Find out more at grand Gamers Guilds dot com. Out of
- 0:17the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:20waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:24at you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:29of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:32that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:36still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:39shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 0:53into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 0:57take five of their games with them. Which will they choose? My guess
- 1:02this week is one of the most recognizable names in board games. Designer of
- 1:06gargantuan Ticket to Ride. He has aludography longer than your arm. A former
- 1:10member of the Air Force. He has edited magazines and been the head of
- 1:12development for game companies, but it is with Ticket to Ride that he became
- 1:17a huge name, selling over eighteen million copies and becoming one of the Big
- 1:21Three with Carcassan and Catan. My guest this week is Alan Moon. Alan,
- 1:25Welcome to the Cabin. Hey, thanks Ben, thanks for having me.
- 1:29So my first question is is how difficult was it for you to pick
- 1:32the five games to take to the cabin. It's it's real hard, I
- 1:37think, you know. There's one of my favorite games ever was Descent Journeys
- 1:42in the Dark I would probably still be my all time favorite game, but
- 1:47there's no new scenarios for it, and I keep hoping that in you know,
- 1:51I'll be mildly forgetful enough to be able to play them all again.
- 1:57But the best ones had something really in them in the scenario, so I
- 2:01can't really go back and replay them, which is a shame. And I
- 2:06don't like Descent to It anywhere near as much as I loved the original,
- 2:09so I've only I've only played Descent to What And a few people have been
- 2:14saying to me recently the Descent one is by far the superior game way is
- 2:17that well, I mean mostly it's it's because of the way fatigue is used
- 2:23in the game, and that you can use the extra points to do extra
- 2:27actions and then you have to refresh your fatigue. It's a lot more complicated,
- 2:31and you know, to be honest, there were tons and tons of
- 2:35rules questions and we used to fight over them regularly, and you know,
- 2:38I always kept saying, Oh, I'm going to write them down, so
- 2:40we play this way the same way we played last you know, And there
- 2:44was tons of discussion, I mean, and those are things like rules questions
- 2:47and discussion during the game that like I normally wouldn't like, but I loved
- 2:53it in Descent. It was just part of the game. And I mean
- 2:55I also wouldn't really like a game that was very long, and we played
- 2:59twelve our scenarios and I just loved it. I don't know, I just
- 3:02had some sort of appeal with the I think part of the other The other
- 3:07part is that as a character, you've got to level up and you've got
- 3:09a lot of stuff in the games. Some games dungeon crawls are kind of
- 3:14too stingy, where you have to work too hard to get, you know,
- 3:16to get your level up and to get more stuff. Thiscent gave you
- 3:20lots of interesting options. So that was pretty cool and we were just talking
- 3:24before the mics were turned on. You've you've moved recently down to New Orleans,
- 3:30and you know you're a person who I'm sure owns a fair amount of
- 3:32games. How do you care for games in a swamp? It must be
- 3:36nightmares for the copy? Yeah, Luckily, you know, we have we
- 3:39have air conditioning in America. I think it's fairly recent development, but you
- 3:44know it's it's But I actually don't have tons of games. I used to
- 3:47my peak, I had five or six thousand games when I was really collecting
- 3:53and trading. I probably only have like, besides copies of my own games,
- 3:58which I keep for work reasons, I probably only have one hundred and
- 4:00fifty games. I'm guessing because now I'm into the mode where if I don't
- 4:04play them for a year or more, I just get rid of them.
- 4:08And I figure, you know, if I really get you know, turn
- 4:11out to like it again, I can just buy another copy. But I
- 4:14just tried not to keep games anymore. I think it's funny that the people
- 4:17who listen to this would go ooh, one hundred and fifty doesn't seem very
- 4:20many, and literally everyone else on the planet is going there are one hundred
- 4:26and fifty board games. That's a good point, exactly. Yeah, so
- 4:31let's go back to the beginning then. So you were born in Britain and
- 4:35I like to claim you as a British designer, but you move at a
- 4:40very young age to America. What is that story. Yeah, my father
- 4:45was a librarian. We lived in that I think we were living in Cricklewood
- 4:48at the time, and my father knew if he stayed in England his career
- 4:54would be, you know, the head of a library somewhere. So he
- 4:57had bigger dreams than that. So he was trying to move to America,
- 5:00but we couldn't because of the immigration quotas. It was just really hard.
- 5:03So he took a job as the head of the library in Saint John's,
- 5:08Newfoundland, and we were there for a couple of years, which was a
- 5:12really interesting experience as a kid. And then he got a job as the
- 5:15editor of Library Journal magazine in New York and we moved. We moved to
- 5:20America. So it was you know, I was I was either six or
- 5:25seven when we moved to Newfoundland, and then we moved to New York less
- 5:28than two years later. It was a big change, you know, but
- 5:31as a little kid, it was it was a cool adventure. So you
- 5:36know, I don't it's hard for me to think of myself as as English.
- 5:41I've I've only been back. I mean, in all of that time,
- 5:44I've only been back a few times. I don't have many relatives in
- 5:47England. They've either died or and we didn't have too many to start.
- 5:51So yeah, I think myself as American for sure. But it's okay for
- 5:58me to claim you as a British design sure, Yeah, I mean good,
- 6:01Yeah, I don't mind the English people. You know, they're okay.
- 6:05I know some that are fairly objectionable, but some are okay. And
- 6:09so you played a lot of classic games when you were young, But it
- 6:15is sometimes sometimes doing this job can be difficult to eat out a show,
- 6:17but with you it was wonderful because you've got a brilliant bio that you published
- 6:21on Board game Geek. And so you played a lot of classic games.
- 6:25But tell us about Uncle Brian. Yeah, my uncle Brian was. He
- 6:30was a real character. He he just he liked my father. He sort
- 6:34of lived the American dream. He worked at Vickers Viscount in England, and
- 6:39then from there went to be the vice president at the Lohi Airlines in Hawaii,
- 6:44and then a few years later became the vice president at Northwest Orient which
- 6:47is now Northwest. But his real what he really loved was being an artist.
- 6:54So after he retired from Northwest, he became really successful by drawing all
- 6:59this comic art of dogs and cats and you know, like peeting people professions,
- 7:04so like you'd have dogs and cats as doctors and everything else and and
- 7:09so. And I've never realized how big that was until I was standing at
- 7:14a department store one day and looked down and his art was on the rug
- 7:17I was standing. I felt like, oh my gosh. But his art
- 7:21was on greeting cards and and you know, hospital smocks and just everything you
- 7:27could imagine it was. It was amazing. So but he used to come
- 7:30visit us once in a while. When I was a kid. He would
- 7:33be traveling around, you know, because he worked at an airline company.
- 7:36He just he flew for free everywhere and he'd come, and whenever he came,
- 7:41it seemed like my father, my brother, and my uncle and me
- 7:45would play games and it was just you know, brother and brother type of
- 7:47really you know, competitive stuff, and it was just so fun. And
- 7:53that's a lot of my memories is, you know, playing games as a
- 7:56kid. Came from those games, particularly risk and but we'd play whatever,
- 8:01you know, people wanted to play. It was great. So he was
- 8:03he was a real character and he actually I mean just this is sort of
- 8:09off subject. But the thing. The other thing he did in his old
- 8:11age was he started up an organization called m I A Hunters and went to
- 8:16the South Pacific on numerous missions and found planes that had crashed during World War
- 8:22Two, in both Japanese and American planes, and they would they would basically
- 8:26contact the tribes in New Guinea and then the tribes would find the planes and
- 8:31take them out and they would retrieve the dog tags. They wouldn't try to
- 8:35bring their bodies back, but they retrieved the dog tags and give them to
- 8:37the government. He loved that. I mean, that was just his passion,
- 8:43even more than art. And you know, I really admire him for
- 8:46that. And so when I think of family games. I see a lot
- 8:52of modern family games, and I think they miss one central aspect of the
- 8:58family game, and that is for the children to have the ability to beat
- 9:01up the parents. And the Ticket to Ride certainly has that in abundance.
- 9:07Was it those games of risk with your family and your uncle Brian. Did
- 9:13that influence your attitude to a game like Ticket to Ride at all? It's
- 9:18hard to say. I mean, certainly, you know, every every Sunday
- 9:22when I was a kid was family day. So we would go out as
- 9:26a family and go bowling, or go to a museum or go to the
- 9:28movies, and then we come back, you know, sometime in the afternoon
- 9:31and play games as a family. That was just that was just every day,
- 9:35and you know, you weren't allowed not to take part of that.
- 9:37So my brother and I and I loved it. I mean, so we
- 9:41played, you know, every kind of common American game or English game you
- 9:46could think of, you know, facts and five and you know things like
- 9:50that, and so, I don't know, I'm pretty sure that had a
- 9:52huge influence on me. And because I just always loved games from the time
- 9:56I was a kid. Your first game then is quite a new one and
- 10:01this is Dice Minor. Why are you taking this one to the cabin?
- 10:05Oh? I love Dice Miner, and I think the interesting part about it
- 10:09for me is that the real serious games gamers probably hate it because it has
- 10:13so much luck in it. But to me, that's what you know luck.
- 10:18You know, you don't want to be a complete luck fest, but
- 10:20you know luck to me as excitement and really enjoyment. And so that the
- 10:24two games I remember most from the last few years were both Dice Minor games.
- 10:30One it came to the last reroll phase and I think I had ten
- 10:33rerolls and I needed one two, you know, to make it up straight,
- 10:37and I couldn't roll it in ten rolls, you know. So that
- 10:39was and then the other the other game. I actually have a picture of
- 10:43this on my phone because at the beginning of the third round when I rerolled
- 10:48my dice, I scored forty points with before we even started the round.
- 10:52It was just like the perfect role. I couldn't believe it. I was
- 10:56like, because usually I'm so unlucky, and I was like, this is
- 10:58amazing. But the game has very clever mechanics. The whole beer dye where
- 11:03you roll it. You basically roll it to another opponent and he gets whatever's
- 11:09rolled. But then you get to select two dice off the mountain instead of
- 11:13one, and you can take them out of different places. That's really clever,
- 11:18the way the different colors of the dice work come. And it's for
- 11:22me. It's interesting because I have the tendency to play games the same way
- 11:26each time, and it's hard for me to fight against that tendency. So
- 11:30in dice miner I'm always saying like, oh, I'm going to play differently
- 11:33this time, and yet I'm always taking the red and green dice no matter
- 11:35what. It's just I love that feeling, like I see that and I
- 11:39go, well, I could try the white dice this time. I go,
- 11:43I'm gonna go with the red and green. If you were to ask
- 11:46a non gamer what the dice do in a game, they would say,
- 11:48you roll them and you move. And Yet, and yet the development of
- 11:54dice over the last thirty forty years almost unrecognizable in their function. How astonishing
- 12:01is it the way dice have evolved in game design. Yeah, it's great.
- 12:05I mean it's it's sort of like cards too, right, I mean,
- 12:09Rich, my friend Richard Borgo always says that the greatest game ever is
- 12:13a deck of cards. He said, because you deal out, you deal
- 12:16out a hand, you think you're gonna have some chance of getting the perfect
- 12:20hand. It never is. And then ten minutes later you deal out the
- 12:24cards again and you're hoping for that greatest hand. So I think it's somewhat
- 12:28similar with dice. You know, every time you roll the dice, you're
- 12:31you're thinking you're going to get that perfect roll, and when you don't,
- 12:35no big deal. You get another right, you get another chance in a
- 12:39few minutes. So yeah, it's very very clever. And some games don't
- 12:43even roll the dice, you just use them to place down as markers or
- 12:48as I'm always thinking about dice games. I think they've been you know,
- 12:52that's pretty clever. I mean, I guess we're going to get to that.
- 12:56I mean, that's another brilliant use of dice. It's it's a me
- 13:01And so what does dice mind it? If someone doesn't know the game,
- 13:05how would you attract them to playing this one? Yeah, I mean I
- 13:11think it's just it's easy to teach, and I think it's quick and if
- 13:16you're miserable. You know, you're only going to be miserable for fifteen or
- 13:20twenty minutes. But it has so much excitement to it, and I feel
- 13:24like, you know, I've been on a real winning streak lately, and
- 13:26I try to convince myself that, oh man, I've really learned this game
- 13:31and I'm really good at it. But I think it's mostly luck, you
- 13:33know, which makes the difference betreame winning and losing. I don't know if
- 13:37that's true. I think there is strategy in it, and it's very clever,
- 13:41but yeah, I don't know. It's not a game that you know,
- 13:45if people who don't play games, it's so hard to get them involved.
- 13:48You're better off starting with something real. I think one of the best
- 13:52games for new people now is Just One, right, I don't know if
- 13:56you've got that is so simple to teach and just you know, everybody seems
- 14:01to enjoy it, and it's it's just a really good introductory game. I
- 14:05think it's even, you know, more of a gateway game than you know.
- 14:07People say Tickets Ride is a gateway game, but I think Just One
- 14:11is the step before that. So I'm want to talk now about your life
- 14:16before being a game designer. So you served in Vietnam, and you know,
- 14:22we have a picture through movies what being in Vietnam was like, I
- 14:28mean, how close was that experience to the films? Yeah, I mean
- 14:33I think there's a certain mash element to you know, war, where you
- 14:39know, when you're on the base, there's all sorts of you know,
- 14:41just amazingly silly things that go on, and but I think the reality part
- 14:46of it is I've read a couple of really great books. One was called
- 14:50Fields of Fire. There's there's a scene in that where the Marines are going
- 14:56through the elephant grass and just incredibly scene and also coming home, even though
- 15:03it was it was more Hollywood than anything, I thought that was a really
- 15:07interesting depiction of Vietnam. So I think, you know, I mean,
- 15:13saving Private Ryan, I would say that, you know, that's a pretty
- 15:16realistic version of war, depiction of war. So yeah, I mean it's
- 15:22it's it's not fun, that's for sure, and but there is you know,
- 15:26when you're when you're not in the battle or you're not in the heat
- 15:28of the action, there's there's a big mash element too. And what did
- 15:33you do out there? And did you did you experience the sort of horrors
- 15:37of war we you in battle. I mean, I wasn't really in battle.
- 15:41I was. I was in the Air Force. I was a radio
- 15:46operator and basically that meant that I coordinated air strikes. So I had a
- 15:50I would have a pilot up in the air who was an observer, and
- 15:54he would be covering the ground troops and if we needed if we needed air
- 16:00support, he would let me know and I would coordinate with the air support
- 16:03and him and the ground troops. And occasionally I was out in the field,
- 16:08but most of the time I was on a little base, fairly safe
- 16:11and you know, in a bunker somewhere. So it was it was a
- 16:17lot of responsibility for an eighteen nineteen year old who was pretty innocent, and
- 16:22yeah, it was. It was certainly a growing up experience for me.
- 16:26And you know, I don't know anyone who's been in war since you know,
- 16:32my grandparents died, and I don't have friends who are in the armed
- 16:36forces, and most of us don't have that experience. What what does it
- 16:41teach you about life being in a war. Yeah, it's I mean a
- 16:48lot of it's sad, you know, obviously, because I had. I
- 16:52did serve with some people who died in Vietnam, and you know, that's
- 16:56it's tough to think that, you know that, first of all, I
- 16:59could have been instead of them, so that's you know, they just happened
- 17:03to be selected for a mission and I wasn't. But yeah, you come
- 17:07back. I think I think I was troubled a lot for years, especially
- 17:11because when I went to college, I was part of a veterans group.
- 17:15You know, we would always be in the student cafeteria together, and and
- 17:18to hear some of those guys' stories was just, you know, amazing,
- 17:22just sort of horrifying too. But I don't know. For a long time,
- 17:26you know, I had, I had sort of I would say,
- 17:30bad dreams, but bad thoughts about it. But now it's hard to imagine
- 17:33sort of my life without having that experience. I would say, you'd like
- 17:38to think that, you know, it helped me mature and grow up.
- 17:41I'm not sure how true that is, but you know, it's just part
- 17:45of It's just part of my life, and I'm sort of proud of my
- 17:48service. I know lots of you know, lots of people you know,
- 17:52have no interest in going in the military. And I certainly wouldn't either,
- 17:56but you know, I'm proud of my service now. And so you you
- 18:02were clearly someone focused on making money, so you went to study English and
- 18:07drama. What drew you to these subjects? I mean, just I had
- 18:14no idea what I wanted to do. I think, like, you know,
- 18:18I've spent four years in the Air Force, and I came out and
- 18:21I didn't even really want to go to college, but I just didn't know
- 18:22what else to do. So I went on the GI bill. So I
- 18:26was really inexpensive to go, and I just I didn't know what I wanted
- 18:32to do. But you know, I thought briefly about going into library science,
- 18:34and I thought, oh god, that seems so boring, so,
- 18:40you know, and then I got interested in theater. And I think what
- 18:42turned me off about theater was, you know, the people. Most of
- 18:47the people in there, they wanted to be the star. And I'm just
- 18:49not interested in being a star, you know. I'm more interested in,
- 18:55you know, sort of doing something that makes me happy. And you know,
- 18:57and obviously I like money too, so but yeah, I mean,
- 19:03I guess I chose my profession is just as bad as being an actor.
- 19:06You know, your chances of being successful are so slim. But yeah,
- 19:11I just I really didn't know what I wanted to do in college. And
- 19:15so your first role in the world of games, it was a magazine.
- 19:18It was as a magazine editor and that sort of got derailed. What is
- 19:22that story? Yeah, I was hired to be the assistant editor of The
- 19:26General with the intention that I would take over as being the editor at Avalon
- 19:30Hill. When I got there, John Greenwood took me into this office,
- 19:36this huge office. He said, well, here's your office, you know.
- 19:38And that was basically it. I mean that was he just put me
- 19:41in the office and I was like, okay, what am I supposed to
- 19:44do now? And so and this is the way Avalon Hill was. It
- 19:48was just complete, you know, there was just no organization and no instruction.
- 19:52So I looked around this office and there were I mean more than a
- 19:56hundred prototypes just sort of stacked on this giant table. And I was like,
- 20:02well, what is this? And so I went in and asked Don
- 20:04Greamy, you know what is this? He said, oh, those are
- 20:07prototypes people have sent in. We don't have time to look at him.
- 20:10And I said, well, can I look at him. He says,
- 20:11sure, do whatever you want. I was like, okay. So I
- 20:15spent you know, a few days looking at them, and I went back
- 20:18to him. I said, well, I've looked at these. Some of
- 20:21these look pretty fun, you know, and he said, well, you
- 20:22know, do what you want. And I said, well, does that
- 20:25mean like I should send the ones back that aren't funny? He says,
- 20:27yeah, whatever. So I wound up sending most of them back to the
- 20:34to the people who sent them, and then I had maybe ten or twelve
- 20:37left and I and I played them. I got some people. I played
- 20:41the games, and some of them were really good. So I went back
- 20:45to Don again and said, you know, these are good and he said,
- 20:47well, just go around and ask if anybody wants to be the developer
- 20:51on him or he said, or if you want to be the developer on
- 20:52him, you do it. I was like okay, and so that's you
- 20:56know, a few of them got published, and basically I started working on
- 21:00games and that was just so much fun to be a developer at Avalon Hill.
- 21:04It was great that, you know, I didn't really want to be
- 21:07the editor. Being the editor of the magazine was hugely you know, hard
- 21:11work. I mean it was just especially back those days where you know,
- 21:15we didn't even have a computer. There was no computer, no word processor.
- 21:18We were doing everything on typewriters and you'd send it down to the copy
- 21:22centers and they'd send you back this this copy and you had to like glue
- 21:27or we used hot wax to put it on galleys. That was how we
- 21:30did the general back then. I mean, it was incredibly difficult process.
- 21:37So yeah, that didn't you know, working on games sounded like a heck
- 21:40of a lot more fun to me. And so for a few years you
- 21:44had your own publishing company. Can you tell us about White Wind? Yeah,
- 21:48I mean white Wind was I think I went through the same process as
- 21:52most designers. I think you start out saying, you know, oh,
- 21:56I'm owning design games for fun, you know, just to play with my
- 21:59friends. That's kind of the first step. And then the second step is
- 22:02you kind of think like, oh, well, maybe I should try to
- 22:03get it published, and you go around and show game companies your designs and
- 22:08you get a huge amount of rejection. And then the third step is thinking,
- 22:12well, I should just publish this myself because those guys don't know what
- 22:15they're talking about. So that was where I got to with White Wind.
- 22:18I had a lot of you know, a lot of I wanted to get
- 22:22some games published, and so I figured, you know, I'll just start
- 22:26White Wind. How hard can it be? And and I think I made
- 22:29just about every mistake you could possibly make. So it was a complete failure
- 22:36for I mean, the whole company was a complete failure until you know,
- 22:38I sold the rights to Elfin Rhads to Amigo and we remade it Intelfin Land.
- 22:45Up until that point, you know, there just nothing really had gone
- 22:48right. So your next game then is Carcasson Hunters and Gatherers. So firstly,
- 22:55how important a gain is Carcasson? I mean, I hold it in
- 23:02such high regard because here's the thing about it. You're the basic game is
- 23:07you have one tile in your hand and that's all you have to think about.
- 23:11And if you're confused, I mean, so this is a great starter
- 23:15game for people. You can just show the tile to everybody because it's your
- 23:18turn and you're going to have to play it anyway, So you can show
- 23:22it and they can give you suggestions. I mean, how great is that?
- 23:26But every time you play the game. Of course, it's different because
- 23:29of the order you get the tiles in, and the computer game is even
- 23:33in some ways even better because it shows you where you can't play on board,
- 23:37and it shows you if you do this, you know that you could
- 23:40block somebody else. It's just such an amazingly simple game. But I find
- 23:45it fascinating every time I play. I just really enjoy it. And I
- 23:49love tile games, and I've thought about tile games a lot, but it's
- 23:53sort of like Carcassone is just the perfect tile game for me. And so
- 23:59why are you taking the h doesn't Gatherer's version to the cabin? Yeah,
- 24:03I just think the hunting the animals in the instead of having the way you
- 24:07score the fields, which you know, I know, there's been various ways
- 24:11of doing that the farms, I guess, and over the years I found
- 24:17the hunting the animals to be much more straightforward with basically it's basically the same
- 24:22thing, just you know, twist it around a little bit to make it
- 24:25make it simpler. And that's that's the reason. I just like that.
- 24:29And I haven't I've tried some of the variants, you know, the expansions
- 24:33and stuff, but basic Hunters and Gatherers. I just think is great,
- 24:37especially the new version because it has a few more tiles, which I think
- 24:41makes it an even better game. So also, now about about you as
- 24:45a designer, So you won your first s field as Garrus with elfin Land.
- 24:49How important was it and this was this was in the nineties, So
- 24:53how important was the award back then? And how important was it to you
- 24:57was a designer. Yeah, I think elfin Land if it hadn't won the
- 25:03award, it probably would have sold, you know, fifteen twenty thousand copies.
- 25:07Winning the award meant that first year it sold almost four hundred thousand.
- 25:12That was just a huge deal. And for me, I was like totally
- 25:18in debt, you know, I was in credit card debt and I just
- 25:22didn't have, you know, anything going for me financially. So Elfinland,
- 25:25I always tell people, got me back to zero. So it sort of
- 25:29leveled out all the bad stuff and got me to a position where I could
- 25:33try to go forward. So it was huge, I mean, and just
- 25:37the award ceremony itself was amazing, and there were so many interesting things that
- 25:42was the last year that the jury picked the winner, like a few months
- 25:47in advance. They used to do that because they wanted to give the game
- 25:51company time to crank up the production. But of course the problem was trying
- 25:55to keep it secret. So people would call me and say, you know,
- 25:59we've heard you won the award, and they didn't know. They were
- 26:00just trying to pluck it out of me, so I had to lie,
- 26:03which I hate. And then the Stern magazine in Germany I think, talked
- 26:10to the printer and found out that Amigo was printing hundreds of thousands of copies
- 26:15of the game, so they knew that had won the award, and so
- 26:18they published their magazine like a few days before the actual award with my picture
- 26:23in it, and the jury were just, you just really mad about that
- 26:27that the magazine had stolen their thunder. So that was the last year they
- 26:33did it that way, and now they do it. They just decided the
- 26:34night before, so nobody can possibly know. So I knew. So they
- 26:40had called me a few months and I knew, and it was just amazing,
- 26:44And so when I got to Berlin, it was just an incredible experience.
- 26:48And the morning of the press conference, I think it was supposed to
- 26:52start at ten, I came down the elevator in the hotel and as the
- 26:56doors opened on the first floor, there was an AP reporter waiting for me,
- 27:00and he says, you have to come with me. And I said,
- 27:03I said, well, I'm supposed to be in this awards ceremony like
- 27:04right now. He says, no, you have to come with me.
- 27:07I have a deadline. I was like, okay. So I had a
- 27:11picture. He had a copy of the game, and I had a puppet
- 27:15that my partner had given me, the self puppet. So we went outside
- 27:21and he took a bunch of pictures of me holding the game a copy of
- 27:23elfin Land on the puppet. And so the next day I was. I
- 27:27came down the next day I was. I was just like just still amazingly
- 27:33high. And I walked into the gift shop in the hotel and I looked
- 27:37at the first paper and there was that picture in the paper, and I
- 27:41was like, oh my god. And the gift shop had twenty or thirty
- 27:45different papers from all over Germany. So I bought a copy of each one.
- 27:49Almost everyone had that picture in with and then just a little you know,
- 27:53blurb about like the elfin Land of one game of the year. I
- 27:56couldn't believe it. I was like, well, that would never happen in
- 27:59America. No, in Britain either. Yeah, I mean it was just
- 28:03a real story in Germany. So I you know, I cut out the
- 28:06article out of all the paper and I still have those somewhere. It was
- 28:08it was incredible. I stood in the coffee shop just like just beyond belief.
- 28:14It was amazing. And so you wrote in your biography that this was
- 28:21a re implementation of elfin Road and the Amigo asked you to simplify elfin Roads.
- 28:27What did that teach you about game design? That process of simplifying that
- 28:32game, I think that was I think that was a really important thing for
- 28:37me because because most of my games start out I wouldn't say complicated, but
- 28:40a little more involved, and as they go along, I try to take
- 28:44out the things that aren't necessary. My my design philosophy is really, you
- 28:48know, to only put in as much as I need to put in to
- 28:52make it really fun. And so if there's you know, when I worked
- 28:55at Avalon Hill, it was all about chrome. You know, you just
- 28:57want to add more and more chrome to the games, and the more the
- 29:00better. I have the exact opposite philosophy now, where I think the you
- 29:06know, you want the basic things that are fun and leave out all of
- 29:08the exceptions and the extra rules. And so that's what I did with with
- 29:15elfin Land. I really started with the map and made you know, a
- 29:18simpler map and just took out all the pieces that I felt didn't need to
- 29:22be in there. And you know, obviously that was you know, I
- 29:26made some good choices. I was really happy. Well, the first time
- 29:29I can remember the first time I've played the elphin Land version, I was
- 29:33like, oh, yeah, this is what I should have done originally,
- 29:37you know. But like I said, I think that's my design process.
- 29:41I often start with, you know, a prototype that's some sort of railroad
- 29:45game, and you know, it's it's complicated, and then I take things
- 29:48out as I go along, and the result is, you know, is
- 29:52the basic part of the game that was really necessary. So it's very rare
- 29:57that anyone could have something that they could call an Annus Mirabelis. But it
- 30:03seems that the Spielders yarras Are two thousand and one was pretty significant for you
- 30:08What happened and what effect did that have on you as a professional designer.
- 30:15Yeah, that was That's a good example of making the wrong decision. But
- 30:21it was just pure luck that it was either the wrong or the right decision,
- 30:25because I had gone to have gone to Germany and with a bunch of
- 30:29prototypes and traveled around to different game companies and trying to sell them, and
- 30:33I was able to sell quite a few that year. So and then all
- 30:37three of them, you know, Capital of Desamia and San Marco all got
- 30:41nominated for Game of the Year. And I was just super excited. I
- 30:44thought like, oh, that was so smart. But it was the year
- 30:47of Carcassel, right, so it wouldn't matter what game I had had nominated,
- 30:52Carcassel was going to win, and it was clearly the best choice.
- 30:55I mean, I totally understand that. But looking back, I think like,
- 31:00oh my god, why didn't I do those three games one per year?
- 31:03You know, it might have given me a chance to win in another
- 31:06year, but you know, hindsight being the wonderful thing that it is,
- 31:08you know, it didn't help me. So yeah, so that that was
- 31:12really I mean, that was really deflating to have those three games. I
- 31:17was so excited, and then you know, just everybody was talking like,
- 31:21oh, Carcasson's going to win. I was like, of course it is.
- 31:25I think it's fascinating. I had Klaus Judenflader on this show, and
- 31:30I got the distinct impression that he felt that Carcasson wasn't the best game he
- 31:33published that year, which fascinates me. Wow, I mean that is fast.
- 31:38I mean he was. He's somebody I look at like, I didn't
- 31:42never heard of him before, so I feel like, you know, his
- 31:45first game was he was like you know a band that comes out with that
- 31:51first album, that first song and has a huge hit. I kind of
- 31:53felt like he was one of those guys whereas you know, most people have
- 31:57to really work at it for quite a bit, but you know get that.
- 32:00And that's not a knock on him at all. I was it's just
- 32:04a great game. And I've heard like he was in Carcassone, and actually
- 32:08I was where he designed the game from just a visit in the city.
- 32:12I thought, wow, that's great and that it's not in the gift shop
- 32:15and Carcasson is mind blowing to me. A friend of mine visited and looked
- 32:20for it and couldn't find it. Oh my god, is that that's crazy?
- 32:24Yeah, that doesn't make any sense. This is sorry, I always
- 32:37get those two confused. Actually, I mean small. It's time to tell
- 32:42you about the newest title in the Holiday Hijix line number nine, The Easter
- 32:46Escapade. The Egg Hunt is in Disarray? Can you crack the case?
- 32:52The Easter Escapade features the interaction systems seen in The Birthday Burglary and The Groundhog
- 32:57Gambit, where players use objects in the style of a point and click computer
- 33:00game. Holiday Hijinks are aligned delightful eighteen card escape room adventures to play in
- 33:07about an hour. With over twenty six thousand units in print, now's your
- 33:10chance to hop into all the fun. You can get The East Escapade as
- 33:15a standalone game, in a bundle with a Turkey trial, or as a
- 33:17print and play all to now at Grand Gamesguild dot com, and I'd like
- 33:22to thank them for sponsoring this podcast. So your next game, then,
- 33:30is that's pretty clever? So of all the role and write games in the
- 33:34world, why is it this one? I would say this is probably the
- 33:38game I've played the most of in my life. I've probably played more than
- 33:44a thousand games of this online. It's so and I always look at like
- 33:51the high scores, and you know, say, the one I like best,
- 33:53I think is the third version. I think it's the third game.
- 33:58I think it's the second version online. I love this version, and I
- 34:01think the high score on there is five hundred and seventy or five hundred and
- 34:06eighty. So I spent weeks, maybe even months, trying to get a
- 34:08five hundred point score, and it took a long time, and then I
- 34:13finally got over. I maybe my high score was like five twenty, and
- 34:15I was like, how do you get the five seventy or eight? I
- 34:19just couldn't couldn't imagine. And I think the I could be wrong, but
- 34:23I think the only way you get there is by having the exact perfect roles
- 34:29in certain times. But it's just it's again, it's such a simple game,
- 34:34right, You're just you're rolling the dice and you're just picking what to
- 34:38do with them. Again, it's another brilliant, you know, brilliant use
- 34:42of the dice. But it's just and He's got I don't know how many
- 34:45versions there are now. I sort of stopped playing it for the most part
- 34:50after the first three. But it just it seems like it's endlessly you know,
- 34:53you can make endless expansions, and it's very very clever. And I
- 34:58think what I saw on the the last one was it was getting more complicated,
- 35:01and I'm not sure that's always a good thing. I think the basic
- 35:06game is pretty simple. You know, it has some you know, it
- 35:08has some yachtzi elements, it has elements from some other dice. So it's
- 35:14and I think this is important. I think it's familiar. I mean,
- 35:16think the dice, what I always think about dice and cards and trading things
- 35:21like that. It's very familiar to people because it even goes back to like
- 35:24settlers aton like when you trade in that. I think that's brilliant because I
- 35:29think it makes people think of monopoly, right and you know, I mean
- 35:34gamers hate the you know, the mention of monopoly. But I think it's
- 35:37good to have a familiar element like that, I would say, and tickets
- 35:40to ride. You know, the familiar element is the rummy, you know,
- 35:44the type of set collecting. But so that's pretty clever. It just
- 35:47takes all that sort of familiarity of the dice and just does amazingly clever.
- 35:52And the combos in the game are just wonderful. Volcanosh as a designer behind
- 36:00loads of different types of games, how good a designer do you think he
- 36:05is? Well, that's interesting because I haven't enjoyed a lot of the other
- 36:09I haven't enjoyed the others, Whereas I would say the same thing about Klaus
- 36:14toybro So, Klaus Torbert had Barbarossa a del Deftik, which I'm sure I'm
- 36:19mispronouncing, Drinterer and Drumer, which I love, and Settlers Ton there are
- 36:23four completely different games and they all won the award, And just I find
- 36:30that fascinating that he was able to produce these four games that have nothing in
- 36:35common, Whereas I tend to be, you know, I tend to think
- 36:37about the same types of things all the time. I mean, he obviously
- 36:42and maybe both gangvage too that they're able to I don't look at completely different
- 36:46things. I think that's a real talent. I wish, you know,
- 36:50I wish I had it. And so, you know, gamers can be
- 36:55a little snobby, and I think gamers might look at something like that's pretty
- 37:00clever and disregard it because you know, it's light and it's sort of mass
- 37:06marketing. Why why should they regard this game. I mean, I don't
- 37:12think they have to. I think, you know, I think there's there's
- 37:15several different types of gamers. I mean, obviously I consider myself a gamer,
- 37:19but I don't want to sit down and play eighteen xx anymore. I
- 37:22did, you know years ago. I did, and I enjoyed it.
- 37:25But I'm the competitive aspect and the sort of no fun aspect that you know,
- 37:30it's just a real serious I'm trying to win that That's not games for
- 37:36me anymore. What I want is to sit down and have a really good
- 37:38social experience. You know. I'm still going to try as hard as I
- 37:43can to win, and you know, and it matters. Winning matters for
- 37:45that moment, but once the game is over, I don't care anymore.
- 37:51So I think the gamers there's there's different types of ways of enjoying games.
- 37:54I mean, the gamers if they like that heavy, you know, hardcore
- 37:59like you know, I want to win. I want to play the best
- 38:00I can. I want to methodically, you know, think out the best
- 38:04strategy. That's great, but that's not that's not what I what I want
- 38:08to do, and I think the majority of people who play games, you
- 38:12know, are more like me than than those hardcore gamers. They want to
- 38:15just you know, an enjoyable evening with friends. So I want to talk
- 38:21now about what you're most well known for. And this is a course,
- 38:23Ticket to Ride. So what was the development process for Ticket to Ride?
- 38:28Yeah, the Tickets to Ride was kind of an amazing thing. It was.
- 38:30I had played another railroad prototype the night before, and so I used
- 38:37I lived in Beverly, Massachusetts at the time. I used to take a
- 38:39morning walk along the ocean, and so I played that game. So on
- 38:44my walk the next day, I was thinking about that prototype thingking like can
- 38:49I change it? You know, what can I do? Or should I
- 38:51just give up on that? Now? It hadn't been really fun, And
- 38:54all of a sudden, this Ticket to Ride was in my head. It
- 38:58was sort of like it started out with like but if you did this and
- 39:00this, And as I was walking along, I was sort of building the
- 39:04whole game in my head. And I got to a point where, you
- 39:07know, about halfway through my walk and I thought, I've got to go
- 39:09home. I need to I need to write this down. I need to
- 39:14make a prototype, and I literally almost ran home and just immediately went to
- 39:19my table and just started making the prototype. And I probably sat there for
- 39:22a good three hours making that prototype. And the most amazing thing about that
- 39:29was that that was ninety percent or more of the published game. I mean,
- 39:32it really was just one of those I know, people call it the
- 39:37Aha experience or whatever, when you just have an idea, and that was
- 39:40just there somehow that I don't know if it even had anything to do with
- 39:45the game I played the night before, but all of a sudden that was
- 39:47in my head, and I can tell you I've never had that experience since,
- 39:51and I probably didn't have it before, so you know, maybe that
- 39:54was I don't know, I don't know what you want to call it,
- 39:57but it was. It was really great. And so up until that point,
- 40:00you'd had your successes with German publishers. How did Days of Wonder get
- 40:05involved with Ticket to Ride? Yeah? I had met Eric Haltamont and Mark
- 40:09Kaufman. I think I'd only met them once or twice before at conventions and
- 40:15just very briefly, and that summer I just, I don't know why,
- 40:21I just decided I was going to go to the World Board Gaming Championship in
- 40:23Pennsylvania down in Baltimore, and I just I said, okay, I'm just
- 40:29going to go. I'll take some prototypes in case there's some companies to show
- 40:31them too. And I got there and I met Mark and Erica and they
- 40:36said, I said, you know, I have some prototypes. You want
- 40:38to look at them? And they said sure. And so I'm not sure
- 40:42if Ticket to Ride was the first game I showed them or not. But
- 40:45we were sitting in the lounge, like in a bar area in the hotel,
- 40:50and I had asked one of my friends, Pitt Crownomire, to join
- 40:52us. So we started playing the Ticket to Ride, and it was obvious
- 40:57that they liked it right from the start, and then about we were all
- 41:00I would say, we were like three corps of the way through the game,
- 41:04and Pitt said, oh, he had to go and play in a
- 41:06tournament. I said, okay, no problem, and so I just cleared
- 41:08the board at that point and Mark and Eric said, no, we wanted
- 41:12to. I was like, oh, I thought you guys had the you
- 41:15know, you got the gist of it, and they were just really bummed
- 41:17about it. But we sat there and Eric. Eric said he was going
- 41:22to France to you know, to talk to his colleagues, and he said,
- 41:25can he take the prototype? I said sure, And he called me
- 41:30maybe four or five days later and said they wanted to do it and he
- 41:32would give me a contract. I said, sure, let's do it.
- 41:36Because in those days, I mean, I don't know, people probably think
- 41:39there's more of a plan, But for game designers, I think you just
- 41:45generally show games to game companies and if somebody offers you your contract, you
- 41:47just take it. That's certainly is the way it was for me. So,
- 41:52you know, I had said. The funny thing is before that,
- 41:55like two weeks before, I had sent prototypes of Take to Ride to four
- 42:00other game companies, and so then I wrote to them all and said,
- 42:05oh, I've sold the game, send it back, and you know,
- 42:07months later, like several of them said, I'm so sorry we didn't play
- 42:10your game. It's because I don't think any of them had actually ever had
- 42:15played the pro type before they sent it back. I know one of them
- 42:19was Hans of Gluck, I know another was zuber Play. I'm not sure
- 42:22who the others were, but yeah, they had some regrets about it.
- 42:28It's kind of like the Deca turning down the Beatles audition. In moments,
- 42:32I guess, yeah, you know, But I mean you just never know.
- 42:37People always ask me, you know, did you know it was going
- 42:38to be hit, and I always say, well, if I known that,
- 42:42I would have done it years before. You just never know. You
- 42:45can't You can't know if something is and tickets ride, everything, absolutely everything
- 42:52had to go perfectly all along the way for that to be the success it's
- 42:54been, and most of that was almost all that was totally out of my
- 42:59hand. It's like Day's the one who had to do all the right things
- 43:02with the marketing and just talking to the jury and talking to retails. Plus
- 43:07the production had to be really good. I mean, there were so many
- 43:10things that were completely beyond my control, and so you I mean, no
- 43:17one can know what is going to be a hit, and when a hit
- 43:21happens, people generally tend to be surprised. I think the last sort of
- 43:24game that had that effect was Wingspan, and I was surprised that Wingspan was
- 43:29as big as it was. But did you when it comes to games you
- 43:31designed previously, did you think this is this is the best work I've done.
- 43:38I mean, for sure, like I love Capital. I think Capital
- 43:45is sort of one of the biggest disappointments in my career. I think it's
- 43:49just a great game, and I played it recently and thought like, wow,
- 43:52you know, why didn't this catch on? And it's been brought out
- 43:55twice and failed both times. So obviously there's something. There's something that I
- 44:00don't understand or you know, I don't know. But but yeah, I
- 44:04certainly have had other games that I thought were going to do really well,
- 44:07and sometimes, you know, in the early days, I mean I would
- 44:10have games published that would sell two or three thousand copies. I mean talk
- 44:15about like I think about the time I put in to design that game and
- 44:19the time the company put in, you know, to sell two or three
- 44:22thousand copies. It's it's heartbreaking. And so obviously Ticket to Ride one of
- 44:28the spielders Yaris and then went on to be Ticket to Ride. How does
- 44:34a game like this change your life? Oh, I mean in so many
- 44:38ways, I mean hard to believe. Like I mean, I certainly wouldn't
- 44:43be living in this beautiful condo in New Orleans without Ticket to Ride, and
- 44:47it's just allowed. It's allowed me to basically enjoy my life. I mean,
- 44:53it's so great. It's and I tell designers, I said, you
- 44:58know, if you want to look at it really realistically, since nineteen ninety
- 45:01five when Settlers of Katam won the award, I said, they've really only
- 45:06been four evergreens, and for me, it's Settlers Carcassone tickets, right,
- 45:09and now code Names you mentioned Wingspan. Wingspan maybe has a chance to be
- 45:15an Evergreen. I'll be amazed. I mean, not because I don't think
- 45:19it's a good game, but just it doesn't seem like a family game and
- 45:22it's a little more complicated than that. But it's doing great, and I'm
- 45:28just sort of like, are there really you know, I heard it sold
- 45:30six hundred thousand copies last year. I was like, well, who is
- 45:34this selling to the people, you know, to our families really reading the
- 45:37rules and or you know. I mean, it's great. I mean,
- 45:40and maybe that's a breakthrough. It could be like this is really a breakthrough
- 45:44game and that you know from Gateway people are now up to this next level
- 45:49of Wingspan. That'd be great. I think it's interesting, though, isn't
- 45:52it that actually when you go back and play Katan. It's not as light
- 45:55as you think. No, right, I agree, I agree, yeah,
- 46:00And you know that was when Settlers Time came out. I think year
- 46:05two, almost every college or university in Germany had a Settlers of Gauton club.
- 46:10I mean people just playing Settlers Town. They get together, you know,
- 46:15maybe multiple nights a week and just play Settlers. I mean it was
- 46:17incredible. I remember going to one of the universities in Berlin and I just
- 46:22couldn't believe. I mean, people were playing it. It was. It
- 46:23was incredible. So yeah, I agree with you, though I don't think
- 46:28it's that. I don't think it's a real family game. But again,
- 46:32I think it's those familiar elements, the rolling, the dice and the trading
- 46:37that help it along, that get people interested. And so you've gone on
- 46:42to design many expansions to get to rise in other things. And I was
- 46:45speaking to Donald X Facerino on this and he said something that was fascinating and
- 46:50I wonder if it applies to you. He told me that he designs games
- 46:52as a hobby and cashes dominion royalty checks as a job. How true is
- 46:59that you have a hit like Ticket to Ride? I would say, it's
- 47:02it's really fun to design tickets to write expansions because I know they're going to
- 47:07sell well and I'm going to make money on them, where if I do
- 47:10anything else, I work on other games, but I don't have that feeling.
- 47:15I like, I know that I'm going to design this other game and
- 47:19I could sell it to somebody and might sell a few thousand copies. But
- 47:22with tickets to write, I mean, I think New York. The first
- 47:25print run of New York was like three hundred thousand copies something crazy like that.
- 47:30I mean, that's fun and it's and it's really easy for me to
- 47:35do the expansions. I've been doing it for twenty years, and so it's
- 47:38fun. It's it's easy, and I know it's going to generate money.
- 47:43That's that's kind of the triple threat right there. And I know you shouldn't
- 47:47ask people to pick their favorite child, but which version of Tickets to Ride
- 47:52do you think is the best? You know? For years, I've I've
- 47:57always loved Switzerland, and I laugh when people say, oh, the country
- 48:00cards are so unbalanced, because that's what I love about Switzerland. I part
- 48:05of what I love. But and so that's been my favorite for a long
- 48:08time, but one of the games in the next map pack, which will
- 48:14be out this year, is my new favorite. It's a very simple change
- 48:20to the game, but really changes the way the game plays, and I
- 48:23just love it, and people have. I've seen some interesting reactions from the
- 48:29playtesters that you know, they at first they think sort of like, oh,
- 48:34is that really too much luck? And then I think if they understand
- 48:37what's really happening, they get it, and it just it really appeals to
- 48:43me. So I'm curious to see how that's received. And can you give
- 48:45us a scoop? I can't. Actually, it's funny because I designed both
- 48:52of these games like three years ago. I think, so they're they're not,
- 48:57you know, I it's just that we've laid this map back over and
- 49:00over. But it is going to come out this year, and I think
- 49:04both the maps are pretty fun, so I'm very curious to see the reaction
- 49:08since it's been so long since the last mapback. So your next game,
- 49:13then, is exquisite is the word I would use to describe it. And
- 49:19this is love letter. How brilliant to design is this? Oh my god?
- 49:22The first time I've played it, I just I think the best compliment
- 49:27you can give any other designers to say, I wish I had designed that.
- 49:30And here's the game was sixteen cards. I mean, that's the whole
- 49:34game, and you can just play over and over. It's just different every
- 49:38time. It's fun, it's quick, it's simple to explain, and you
- 49:43can I don't know about all the expansions, but like the Cthulu expansion is
- 49:51ads actually a really cool other element to it too, And the premium version
- 49:54that has the thirty two cards instead of the sixteen it's just great. It's
- 50:00just one of those games that I think about, like, how did you
- 50:02sit down and make this? It's so clever? And so this kicked off
- 50:08the brief micro game revolution where every publisher in the industry was publishing micro games.
- 50:15But is this the best one? Is this the one that stands out?
- 50:17Oh? I think so easily. It's not all. I think it's
- 50:22almost always the case where the first game of a genre is usually the best
- 50:29I can't think of. I mean maybe that's not true, but I just
- 50:32think when you because it's the basic idea like how did this person think of
- 50:37this game? It's so and maybe he had in a moment just like I
- 50:42had with Take a Drive where he's walking along and it's just in his head.
- 50:45I don't know, it's just so so clever. Yeah. I mean,
- 50:50what I love about love Letter so much is how the power is just
- 50:53interlock so beautifully. How difficult is that to get a game that he is
- 51:00so wonderfully balanced? Well, and you wonder did he start with a couple
- 51:04of cards and then add the others or did he have all the others,
- 51:07all the cards right from the start. Yeah, it's just and I know
- 51:10that people have tried, you know, to add other cards to it.
- 51:15I think that's the other real compliment you can give the game is that is
- 51:17there another card you can add in which improves the game? There's other cards
- 51:22you can put in that, you know, maybe add a new element.
- 51:25But is it really necessary to add another card? I don't know, although,
- 51:30like I said, the Cthulhu, I think he adds a little bit
- 51:32to the game, which I really like. I haven't There may be in
- 51:36one of the other expansions I haven't played that adds something, but I think
- 51:39that's I think there are games for me like Carcassone, Like there's been lots
- 51:45of expansions and stuff, and they're nice, but the basic core of the
- 51:49game, you don't need to add anything to it. It's so good.
- 51:52I played the base game a lot over the Christmas period and it have been
- 51:55years since I played it, really, and it is just unbelievable. I
- 52:00think, yeah, yeah, it's great. So let's all now by the
- 52:05future. So what can we expect from you in the future, I think,
- 52:10you know, I mean, obviously, I'm gonna work on tickets Ride
- 52:14as long as they'll let me, and you know, we'll do a few
- 52:15new products every year. I'm working on other stuff. I'm hoping to have
- 52:21a series of games from mister b Games, Sean Brown. He's a friend.
- 52:25And what I really want more than anything now in my career is to
- 52:30get some more recognition as a designer. And I don't mean fame, I
- 52:35mean sort of try to help game designers be more important. If you look
- 52:39at a book, and here's what I tell you. If you look at
- 52:42a book, it says Tom Clancy and some title, and who knows what
- 52:46the art is on the book? And who cares? And who knows what
- 52:50company does? And nobody cares they care about Tom clancy. But game manufacturers
- 52:54don't seem to get that, and they never have gotten it. So what
- 52:58I want to do is try to have a game that has Alan R.
- 53:00Moon on the cover. It's a title, you know, and some art
- 53:05behind it. It doesn't mean we can't have good art. Art's fine,
- 53:07but I want to have like the game designer to be more important because my
- 53:12belief is that personality. People care about personalities, they care about They don't
- 53:17care about corporations. They care about people. And so I think, let's
- 53:22let's and having my name bigger on a box. It's not going to hurt
- 53:27the sales. It might help, it may not, but it might help,
- 53:30but it certainly can't hurt anything. And game companies just don't seem to
- 53:34get this, and nobody's ever tried it. So I really want to try
- 53:37it and see if it makes a difference. And you know, maybe I'm
- 53:40not big enough. I think the person, you know, people you really
- 53:44should start with be somebody like Richard Garfield, Like I think he has a
- 53:46real following. But this is, you know, it's sort of a it's
- 53:51sort of a new quest for me, Like, Okay, can I make
- 53:53the game designer more important, I mean, And I'll give you the thing
- 53:58that was the most heartbreak for me was after Elfinland one Game of the Year.
- 54:02The next year, Union Pacific game out and I got my first copy
- 54:07of that in the mail and I looked down and I didn't think they'd even
- 54:09put my name on the box. I was like, what the heck?
- 54:13And so if you look at that original box, they've sort of hidden my
- 54:16name in the cars at the top. I was so mad when I saw
- 54:21that. I picked up the phone and called to me go and it's like,
- 54:24what are you guys doing? I said, is this really respectful?
- 54:28That you know? After I won Game of the Year for you in your
- 54:30company and really helped your company, this is what the respect I get to
- 54:35put my name like in these little letters. It was just horrible and so
- 54:39but that's the way it is. And when you talk to people. I
- 54:43talked to people at Parker Brothers years ago about this, I said, why
- 54:45don't you put game designers names on the box? And they gave every excuse
- 54:50you can imagine. But the real reason that I got to at the end
- 54:52was they'd always done it that way. They'd never put the names on the
- 54:57box. That was the real reason. I was like, it's crazy.
- 55:00And so sometimes you'll see, like a guy who publishes his own game,
- 55:06he publishes his own game and doesn't put his name on the box. I
- 55:08mean, if you wrote a book, would you leave your name off the
- 55:12book? I don't think so, But you're you're willing to do it on
- 55:15a game that drives me crazy. I mean, I just go. You
- 55:19could probably hear my contempt for that. It's just amazing. Ah. And
- 55:25so I mean, we can't really get into counterfactuals here because we'll never know.
- 55:31But does it ever sometimes feel frustrating that you're known as the Ticket to
- 55:40Ride guy and you would like to be known for other games you've published?
- 55:45I don't think so. I mean, I think you know, Tickets Ride
- 55:49has given me a great life, so I don't mind, But certainly I
- 55:52would. You know, I'm looking to have another game that would be a
- 55:55hit. You know, who knows whether I'll do that in my life,
- 55:59probably not. But I'm always looking at stuff like that, and I'm working
- 56:01on several prototypes that I love right now. But yeah, that doesn't bother
- 56:07me. I've heard people, you know, used to ask the like I'm
- 56:10trying to think of as a good example, the guy who did Sherlock Holmes.
- 56:15You know, yeah, they said, you know, were you sorry
- 56:17you did that? Because that just dominated your life? And I don't.
- 56:22I don't think it would be hard to imagine like being upset about having something
- 56:24as great as that. So yeah, that doesn't bother me. I just
- 56:29would like to I would like all game designers just to get a little more
- 56:34notoriety and have them become important. Because if if somebody isn't a known name,
- 56:39is a game is, I wouldn't that help the game company in the
- 56:43sales? I would I would like, you know, somebody publish one of
- 56:45my games that they should put a burst on the on the shrit wrap that
- 56:49says buy the designer of Ticket to Ride. Why wouldn't you do that?
- 56:52Hmm. And So sometimes I will go round to people's houses and then not
- 57:00gamers, and yet they will have a copy of Ticket to Ride on the
- 57:07shelf. And I think in many ways, I think in many ways,
- 57:10well, I live in Germany, so I think Germany is a unique case.
- 57:13But I think in many ways Ticket to Ride has kind of replaced Katan
- 57:19as the as the game you get to see what these board game things are
- 57:23about. How does that make you feel when you when you look back at
- 57:30the impact Ticket to Riders had. Yeah, it's a great thing. My
- 57:34favorite comment to see people say is that Ticket to Riders the new monopoly.
- 57:39I've seen that in any number of articles, and recently I saw I saw
- 57:45several advertisements that said this is a Ticket to Ride like game, and I
- 57:50thought, wow, that's that's awesome. So your last game then, is
- 57:57It's a wonderful world. What does this game do? Well? Oh,
- 58:00this is this is a real fun game. One of the things I love
- 58:05most about it is that my wife Janet is super good at it, and
- 58:08so whenever we play, she wins. And and this is this goes back
- 58:13to the tendency that I talked about in Dice Minor that my tendency in this
- 58:16game is to always play to get the white cards because I like the Initially
- 58:22you get lots of white cards, you generate lots of resources, but that
- 58:25is not a winning strategy. So so to try and win, I have
- 58:30to change that tendency and try not to collect the white cards, whereas meanwhile,
- 58:36Janet is obviously optimizing her play depending on what cards are available, and
- 58:42just doing really well. And she sees that, and I just I can't
- 58:45see that in the game that as well as she does. She's just really
- 58:50good at it. But the combinations in It's a Wonderful World are just great
- 58:55and and for me, it's it has a lot of the things I love.
- 58:59You get a lot of sources. I like getting a lot of stuff
- 59:01in games, and you you. I love card drafting. I think it's
- 59:06just a wonderful mechanic. I like to look at a bunch of cards and
- 59:10select one and then pass them. I think that's that's probably my favorite mechanic
- 59:15in games now. So there's a lot of things that I love and I
- 59:20don't and it's sort of I wouldn't say frustrating. It's sort of interesting to
- 59:23me that like, oh, we sit down to play and I go,
- 59:27oh, this is the time I'm going to play really great and beat her.
- 59:32It's just it's it's a terrific I would say. The one issue for
- 59:37me is that if you try to add things to it, the deck is
- 59:42already really big, and so it's dangerous to add more cards to it.
- 59:45I would actually I think, have you know like to see less cards.
- 59:52I don't know that that's interesting too, because because it seems like it's the
- 59:55right amount of cards. But I think when you add more cards to it
- 1:00:00becomes a little problematic. I played the two things, the little mini campaign
- 1:00:04games, and I really enjoyed those two I thought they were pretty clever.
- 1:00:09But again it does have the problem of the number of cards. The card
- 1:00:14mix is really important. And so going back to drafting, then why is
- 1:00:22drafting such a great and compelling mechanic, do you think? Yeah, I
- 1:00:28think for me, I always like, you know, some of the big
- 1:00:31games today, you know they have they give you so many choices and you
- 1:00:35can score points so many ways. I think for me, my design philosophy
- 1:00:39is I want to give people two or three choices every time they have to
- 1:00:44make a decision, and I want them a few minutes later to be able
- 1:00:49to realize whether they made the right or the wrong decision out of those two
- 1:00:52or three. I think as soon as you get to more than three,
- 1:00:55it's it becomes you know, there's the problem of analysis paralysis, of course,
- 1:01:00but there's also just the problems. It's overwhelming, and I think two
- 1:01:06or three decisions can be super interesting as long as you you know, you
- 1:01:09keep having to make them all the time. So I you know, I
- 1:01:14know that the gamers, you know that they're like a game like ark Nova.
- 1:01:17I mean, it seems to be doing very well. I played ark
- 1:01:22Nova and I just made my head spin. It was just and I think
- 1:01:27it's sort of the point salad games, you know, when those first started
- 1:01:31coming out, I was just like, oh my gosh, this is just
- 1:01:34so overwhelming. I would like something that's for me much, you know,
- 1:01:39much more straightforward. So one more question then, So you're you're heading out
- 1:01:45of New Orleans to the cabin, and you you head out into the bayou
- 1:01:49and you go around a corner and the back door of the car flies open.
- 1:01:52Four of the games fly out into the swamp and sync without trace.
- 1:01:59Which game do you hope is sitting on the back seat of the car.
- 1:02:01Wow, that's tough. That's tough. I don't know. I mean,
- 1:02:07I guess it has to be Dice Miner. But that's just today's answer,
- 1:02:12because I just every time I play it, it's just such a wonderful experience.
- 1:02:16So I hope that continues. But you know, sometimes things change over
- 1:02:21the years. But I hope that's the one that's left at the moment.
- 1:02:24So if people want to get hold of you, or people want to know
- 1:02:28what's coming out from you in the future, how can they go about doing
- 1:02:31that? Oh, I mean, I don't know. I'm not really I
- 1:02:36don't have a website that it's active. I don't know. I'm not.
- 1:02:42I'm sort of more private than that, you know. I think if you
- 1:02:45come to it, I'll be at gen Con probably every year. So if
- 1:02:49you want to come and say hi and talk, I'm happy to do that
- 1:02:52at gen Con. There's not too many other places you can really find me
- 1:02:57brilliant. Well, Alan, noon, Thank you very much. Oh thanks
- 1:03:00a lot, best. It's been real fun. You can support the show
- 1:03:02in many ways. You can tell it friends, you can talk about it
- 1:03:05on social media. You can talk about it in your own blog, podcast,
- 1:03:07or video. You can support it directly by going to pictureon dot com
- 1:03:10forward slash five GFD for a rolling donation, or for a one off donation,
- 1:03:14hitting the PayPal link at the bottom of the website five Games for Doomsday
- 1:03:16dot Com. It's these donations that keep the show going. Also, if
- 1:03:20you want to say something nice about the show. If you want to say
- 1:03:22something horrible about the show, can contact me on Twitter at five Games for
- 1:03:25Doomsday or send me an email at five Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com.
- 1:03:29And if I managed to leg it from the ambulatory cake pops and those
- 1:03:32people, you know the ones, I'll see you in two weeks for another
- 1:03:37Five Games for Doomsday