Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Attachment Deep Dive - Chapter 1 - John Bowlby (2019 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:06Hey, deserving listeners, I want to tell you something. Attachment theory is
- 0:11the most important theory in my life. I use attachment theory with my clients,
- 0:19I use it with my personal life. I use it to interpret other
- 0:24people's behavior. I use it to interpret my own behavior, my own emotions,
- 0:29my reactions to other people. Every regrettable thing I've ever done can be
- 0:36elegantly and thoroughly explained through attachment theory. It explains so many things that I've
- 0:42done when I've thought, geez, why did I do that? You know,
- 0:45why did I say that? Why did I hurt that person's feelings?
- 0:49Well, you know, why did they hurt my feelings? Why did I
- 0:51overreact in that moment? Attachment theory explains at all. It explains so many
- 0:58things about the human experiences. Childhood, development, psychopathology, personality disorders can
- 1:04be explained easily through attachment theory. Anxiety depression complex PTSD, and research has
- 1:11looked into the connections between these things, and I'll get into that in this
- 1:15deep dive. Eating disorders are explained through attachment theory. Divorce, you know,
- 1:23conflict in marriage, bad parenting, good parenting can be explained through attachment
- 1:27theory. Attachment theory explains why therapy works itself, why any relationship works to
- 1:34make us feel better. Attachment theory, it could be said, explains why
- 1:38this podcast helps people. You know, why listen to this podcast as opposed
- 1:44to one of the other thousands of other podcasts. Attachment theory explains why people
- 1:51fight with each other, why groups of people fight over random things on the
- 1:55internet, why nations fight with each other, why we like rom coms,
- 2:00why we like reality TV shows. Why we like this sort of TV shows
- 2:05where they will do an act on stage, like sing a song, but
- 2:08we need to hear the backstory. Attachment theory explains all that. Attachment theory
- 2:14explains why we feel bad when our spouse is distant from us, feels distant,
- 2:17you know, explains why we feel bad. Attachment theory explains why we
- 2:22get angry at our spouses, why our spouses getting angry at us. It
- 2:27explains why we grieve when we lose someone. And Attachment theory even explains why
- 2:32people think about or even attempt suicide and so on. It explains everything in
- 2:38my opinion, and every day because of this, I think about attachment theory
- 2:45because it helps me with almost everything I do. It helps me understand myself
- 2:49and other people. It helps me navigate relationships with other people. For example,
- 2:53last night, I was playing a show with my band and we're on
- 2:58stage and we're Strokes cover band. I'm in another band. I'll spread the
- 3:04details, but one of the bands I'm in is a Strokes cover band,
- 3:06and the Strokes are the Cold. They sound sort of simple, but they're
- 3:09actually hard, especially for the guitarists. We have two guitarists and each of
- 3:15them have solos that they play, and some of the solos are actually kind
- 3:17of hard, and so one of our guitarists was playing the solos and I
- 3:22knew it's always like he's always on the edge of screwing up, but most
- 3:25of the time he pulls it off really well. But last night, when
- 3:29we were playing one of the songs, he screwed up the solo pretty pretty
- 3:31horribly. I mean, I think he improvised well enough that I don't think
- 3:35anyone noticed, but everyone in the band was like, oh, he's he's
- 3:38losing it. And without attachment theory, I probably would have reacted to that
- 3:46in a destructive way, or I might, you know, like if I
- 3:52was just if I didn't think about attachment theory during because I did. Last
- 3:55night, after he made the mistake on the solo, I thought about attached
- 4:00theory and how it could help me understand what was happening. Because if I
- 4:02didn't have that, I probably would have tried to act like I didn't notice
- 4:06that he made a mistake on the solo, probably, if you know,
- 4:10if he came up to me afterwards, I'd be like, oh, I
- 4:12didn't notice, even though I totally did, which he might have interpreted as,
- 4:15oh, he's just saying that, because clearly there's no way he could
- 4:18not have noticed. Or without attachment theory, I might have tried to subtly
- 4:25tell him that he needs to practice more or something, because I would have
- 4:29been overly focused on the performance, if that makes any sense. But with
- 4:32attachment theory last night, I know that I have a part of my reaction
- 4:40is based on my feelings. You know, I'm observing this bad solo happening,
- 4:45and a lot of meanings are associated with that. I could interpret that
- 4:49as he's not putting in enough effort into this band, which made him,
- 4:55you know, which resulted in him making a mistake with a solo it,
- 5:00and that could mean that he's not really dedicated to his relationship with me.
- 5:05You know. That's that's where attachment theory really helps us. It's like a
- 5:09lot of things are interpreted on an attachment bond basis, and him making a
- 5:15mistake on a solo, particularly if I'm sensitive to attachment injury, I might
- 5:19have a securitiest rout route to interpreting him doing a bad solo to him basically
- 5:26rejecting me. And this wouldn't be conscious, of course, but it would
- 5:29be potentially happening, and this could make me feel hurt. It could make
- 5:32me feel angry, which could make me want to punish him somehow. So
- 5:40instead, with attachment theory in my mind, I put that aside, even
- 5:43though I had minor inklings along those lines, and I resolved to not see
- 5:47things that way, which helped me to relax and also to approach him better.
- 5:54I also knew through attachment theory that because he made a mistake with solo,
- 6:00he was probably panicking from attachment worries for fear of being rejected by me
- 6:05and the rest of the band because he missed up the solo, right,
- 6:09So he messes up the solo, and it makes him afraid of being abandoned
- 6:13by me and the band, because that's a you know, a viable thing
- 6:15that could happen if one of the band members is totally just not performing well,
- 6:20it's conceivable to someone that they'd be like, oh, maybe I'm on
- 6:24the chopping block now. Our band is so casual that would never happen.
- 6:30And the guys are amazing. I mean, I'm by far the least talented
- 6:34member of the band, so if anyone should be kicked out, it should
- 6:36be me. But anyway, but that's a real fear that people would have,
- 6:42and I suspected that he might have at least, you know, some
- 6:45inklings of that which could make him feel demoralized, and then maybe he would
- 6:49feel less happy about being the band, and then he would quit the band,
- 6:53which is not what any of us want. So and by the way,
- 6:58this happens with bands all the time. Attachment injuries happen within bands and
- 7:01leads to them breaking up, like the Beatles and so on. It explains
- 7:05things that even on that level. And when I look at the Beatles,
- 7:09because I'm such a huge Beatles fan and I'm watching Let It Be and the
- 7:12breakup of the Beatles. All I can think about is attachment theory about John
- 7:16Lennon and Paul McCartney and Ringo and George for that matter. And then Yoko
- 7:21comes in, and it just that the attachment movements within the band led to
- 7:29the inevitable breakup, and if I was to keep them together, I would
- 7:32have gone back and tried to actually help them with their attachment with each other
- 7:36and to help them understand what's happening and so that they can optimize their attachments
- 7:43and potentially stay together, because I really love the Beatles anyway, So anyway,
- 7:46in the end last night, as I'm thinking about this in the midst
- 7:53of doing all the other things last night, and instead of trying to gloss
- 7:58over it or punish him or give him a message like, hey, you
- 8:01know, you should probably practice more or something, in the end, I
- 8:05decided, well, what do I really want out of life? And I
- 8:07thought, well, the most important thing to me about being in the band
- 8:11is to have fun and to bond with these with my bandmates, and so
- 8:18because I know that that's the most important thing, and that being perfect is
- 8:20definitely not important to me, although being perfect would be great, to be
- 8:26awesome if people in the audience were just like, oh my god, that
- 8:28is a perfect band. Of course, that would never happen, but that
- 8:31seems intellectually like a great thing. But understanding through attachment theory tells me that
- 8:39that is meaningless compared to the meaning and well being that I get from strong
- 8:43attachment bonds cultivated over time with people that I trust, my bandmates and everyone
- 8:50else in my life. So in the end, after we were packing everything
- 8:56up and getting out the stage, he he turns to me and he apologizes.
- 9:01He turns it right away. He's like, I'm sorry, I screwed
- 9:03up. That that's solo. And I reached out with my I think I'm
- 9:09out of hugged him or you know, put my hand on his shoulder and
- 9:13said something like, oh man, I don't worry about it. It was
- 9:15cool, and and I said something to the effect which was true that he
- 9:20in his screw up, he tried to improvise his way out of it,
- 9:22and it actually probably went over well with the crowd. But anyway, so
- 9:28I said something along those lines. But my primary goal in that interaction was
- 9:31to soothe him and tell him that he's safe with me. That our bond
- 9:37is strong, and that I'm not going to reject him, and that I
- 9:43appreciate him and his apology or something. You know, It's it's about the
- 9:46bond. It's about that feeling of security between two people that really matters so
- 9:54much to us, and without that, bad things happen. Before example,
- 10:01the next time he's on stage and he's gearing up to play a difficult solo,
- 10:07if he feels secure in his relationship with me, he's less likely to
- 10:11be anxious and therefore more likely to nail the solo right. And the opposite
- 10:16is true. If he's about to play a solo on stage and he's really
- 10:22worried that he's going to get kicked out of the band or even just emotionally
- 10:26rejected by me. If he screws up, then that raises his anxiety and
- 10:28makes him more likely to screw up the solo. So, in the end,
- 10:33the attachment theory in the bond actually gives us a lot of what we
- 10:37want, not just in guitar solos, but in marriage, in relationships and
- 10:43parenting and co workers, in the meaning of life, in grief and death,
- 10:48in internet activity and podcast activity. Like everything comes together. I think
- 10:56when we look at things through attachment theory, it's just this wonderful guide to
- 11:01life I have found. So you know, with my wife, for example,
- 11:07it's just so important. Like every almost every interaction I have with my
- 11:13wife, I filter through the attachment lens when I'm when I'm when I need
- 11:18to think about it, do you know, particularly in times of conflict or
- 11:22tension, parenting issues, always through the attachment lens. With my students,
- 11:26with my co workers, with my clients. I'm almost always thinking about attachment
- 11:31theory when I'm working with my clients, with my supervisees. Not only when
- 11:35I'm teaching my supervisees how to do therapy. You know, I'm teaching the
- 11:41attachment theory lens, but I'm also wanting to cultivate an attachment with them,
- 11:46because when my supervisees feel safe with me, they're much less anxious, They're
- 11:50much more likely to share things with me. I actually write about this in
- 11:52my book Multi Role Clinical Supervision. I have a section on attachment and all
- 12:00the research that demonstrates that when the attachment is secure between supervisey and supervisor,
- 12:05a lot of good things happen, including better client outcomes and when attached.
- 12:11When supervisors don't focus on attachment, you could argue that it's unethical because they're
- 12:16actually there's actually research showing that if you don't pay attention to the attachment,
- 12:20it is more likely to lead to bad outcomes for clients. So by ignoring
- 12:26attachment and the supervisey relationship, you might be harming clients in the end on
- 12:30average, you know. So there's just a lot of things like that when
- 12:35I interact with listeners to the podcast. You know, I do this podcast
- 12:39for a lot of reasons, but one of the main reasons that I've always
- 12:43said this is the community that I that I feel, the community that it
- 12:48feels to me. That's a really bad syntax sentence, But and what does
- 12:54that mean at the base on what it means is basically the bonds that I
- 12:58have with all the listeners that I'm in contact with, some of them more
- 13:01so than others. If this was just a cold thing that I did,
- 13:07and it was you know, it was just like going to talk into a
- 13:09spcrophone and teach a few concepts and move on with my life, then it
- 13:13wouldn't really have the resonance in my life. For the meaning or the purpose
- 13:16or the motivation, and when I think about it through an attachment theory lens,
- 13:22then I think, Okay, well, what's what am I doing here
- 13:24on this podcast. Well, one of the things that I'm doing, among
- 13:26a number of things, is I am bonding with you, the listener,
- 13:31and that helps me to feel like I'm in the zone when I am embodying
- 13:39that mission, and it feels worth it to me, right, and I
- 13:45think that and for people who are into that style of podcast, you know,
- 13:48they get something out of it anyway. So attachment theory informs the podcast.
- 13:56It really just informs all my interactions with everyone I've interact with, and
- 14:01so it helps me to find happiness, It helps me to give happiness and
- 14:05will being to other people. It's just such a powerful thing. So that's
- 14:11what this series is going to be be about. This is part one in
- 14:13the attachment theory deep Dive. More parts will follow. I'm going to break
- 14:18it up. In the past, I would try to do deep dives in
- 14:22one fell swoop, one big episode, but this time I'm going to do
- 14:24different chapters essentially, and so I'm not sure how many chapters are going to
- 14:28be. But this is chapter one. In this chapter, I'm going to
- 14:33talk about or not. In this chapter, I'm going to talk about the
- 14:37history John bowlby Mary Ainsworth and others, because when we understand the history of
- 14:41attachment theory and where it emerged from, I think it helps to explain the
- 14:46theory itself, but also how it fits into our society and our profession.
- 14:52But in other parts I'm going to talk about attachment theory itself. Obviously,
- 14:56I'm going to have a whole chapter just to attachment theory, which is pretty
- 15:00complex. It's attachment theory is interesting because it's simple. It can be very
- 15:03simply explained. It's not like psychoanalytic theory, where it takes a while to
- 15:07even get the basics. Attachment theory lay people can understand it very easily with
- 15:13just reading a few sentences, honestly. But it is also extremely complex,
- 15:18so or deep, i should say so. And that's what makes a good
- 15:24theory, right, is when it's fairly easy to comprehend, particularly because it's
- 15:28so human and so real and so relatable to people that as soon as I
- 15:33talk about attachment theory with clients or students, they're just like, oh my
- 15:37god, yeah, I get it. And also you could study attachment theory
- 15:43for your entire career and never run out of things to look at because there's
- 15:45so many different things to unearth. So I'm going to talk about attachment theory
- 15:50itself, all the attachment styles, and through that you might list you listeners
- 15:56might be able to determine your attachment style and the attachment style of people around
- 16:02you, because I think that's a very use One of the most useful things
- 16:04you could ever learn is your own attachment style, the different signs of that
- 16:08attachment style, the development of that attachment style, and how to recover from
- 16:15that attachment style, and the attachment style of other people. I can't tell
- 16:18you how useful that is to understand for your spouse, your clients, your
- 16:23co workers. It's just mind blowingly helpful. I'm going to talk about lots
- 16:30of research. I have been working on the steep dive for months and it
- 16:34always you know, I thought I thought I would not take this long,
- 16:37but it has taken a long time, and I have read hundreds, maybe
- 16:44over a thousand studies. I've read several books on attachment theory, and so
- 16:48I'm going to review a lot of empirical research. I'm going to talk about
- 16:52social media and attachment Facebook. I'm going to talk about different measures of attachment
- 16:57theory. How do we measure your attachment style, how do we look at
- 17:03pornography? Pornography and attachment have been researched quite a bit. Couples therapy.
- 17:08Obviously, a massive important element of any qualified couples therapist is to understand and
- 17:17utilized attachment theory. Also using attachment theory in general with all clients. I'm
- 17:22going to talk about I'm gonna one chapter is just going to be about therapy
- 17:26using attachment theory. I'm going to talk about the brain and biology. I'm
- 17:30going to talk about mirror neurons and mentalization and development. Parenting. I'll probably
- 17:37do a whole chapter on parenting. How do you parent your children in a
- 17:41way that is optimal for attachment. Because attachment is related to so many things
- 17:48in life, it is critical that parents know how to properly attune to their
- 17:53children. You know, if you raise your child in a way that is
- 18:00focused on attachment, in a good way, in a competent way, you
- 18:07can lower the risk of so many things in your children, so many things,
- 18:11eating disorders, depression, personality disorders, divorce, problems with drugs and
- 18:18alcohol. So that's a whole other thing. Is attachment is related to drug
- 18:22and alcohol abuse, because of course it is. Once we get into the
- 18:26theory, it all this will make sense. You'd be like, well,
- 18:29of course attachment theory is related to these things because of the understanding that we
- 18:34get of our development in relation to attachment. I'm going to talk about personality
- 18:40development and psychopathology in general. Society and culture and our physical health is also
- 18:45related to attachment theory and many other things. So this episode and the series
- 18:52of episodes on attachment are for patrons only. I apologize if you're not a
- 18:56patron, but honestly, if you've ever thought about becoming a patron of the
- 19:02podcast and you've been waiting for that one thing, I think this is the
- 19:06time. This series might be the most important thing I've ever done on this
- 19:11podcast. Truly, I can't believe it's taking me this long to do it.
- 19:15I've been doing the podcast for over ten years and it's taking me this
- 19:18long to do an episode dedicated to attachment theory. I think the reason why
- 19:22was because I never wanted to do a half ass job. I wanted to
- 19:27make sure that I did it right, and it's taken me ten years to
- 19:30gear up to get to this point. And so if you've thought about being
- 19:37a patron, I encourage you. Of course, it's up to you.
- 19:41So if you're not a Patreon, you have to go to patreon dot com.
- 19:44That's patreon dot com and become a patron of the podcast there and then
- 19:48you'll be given instructions on how to access these episodes on attachment theory and this
- 19:55many other deep dives that we've done. So do so now, or or or