Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Back To ICE, Used Car Market Dip, Costco's Tech Timing
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] It's Thursday, the th- a Thursday that kinda feels like a Friday in a way. Yeah. I don't know why it does, but we have a fun show today.
- 0:06We're gonna be talking about consumers going back to ICE after EVs, the used car market dip, and Costco's tech timing. Can they pull it off? Where I go. The people really wanna know. I feel like- Who I is and who I be...
- 0:16uh, the last couple of days, I feel like there's stories I wanna talk about that aren't stories in the show. Talk on me, walk your talk to your needs. Right?
- 0:22Because it's, like, one of those rare times where, like, there's a lot of context, but, you know, we gotta- There's a ton of context out there, like the, you know, I don't know what it is about the middle of June, but everybody kind of woke up and started s- saying stuff again.
- 0:34I know. It was like- It was wild... it was like dead out there.
- 0:36But, you know, we wanna make room for the stories that are retail-focused in the show and not just automotive-focused 'cause we, you know, believe deeply that that's a big part of being successful in automotive, is paying attention to retail.
- 0:47So we'll get to that. Uh, first we have a really fun way to start the show today because, uh, we have a podcast called Auto Collabs, A-U-T-O C-O-L-L-A-B-S. Um, we have a lot of fun with Michael Cirillo.
- 0:59There was a really special episode. You should subscribe because it's great audio experience. We had a 13-year-old on the show, Kaylee Jewett. Wowee. Uh, she spoke at the Women on Automotive Conference.
- 1:11Our friends out there at Women in Automotive put her on the stage. That's how we got turned on to her, got connected with her father, um, and had her on the show.
- 1:18So we're gonna play a little clip of having her because it was, it was just such a fantastic experience- Yeah... and we want you to listen to the whole thing. This is good. But let's, let's check out this clip.
- 1:29Off the idea, like, well, there's not a lot of automotive, like, being shown to people in your school, right?
- 1:36Like, you've had people come into your school and talk to you about the high school that you wanna go to, and then this is where you're figuring out who you wanna be.
- 1:44So why don't you also have people who work in automotive go and talk to you and be like, "There's more than just working on cars. There's coding." Love that. "There's, like, data analysis. There's all this"
- 1:56But there was no one talking about that to us 'cause- Right... I mean, if I wouldn't have been around my dad, I wouldn't have known that automotive has anything to do with a computer- Right...
- 2:06other than coding whatever goes on in a car. What is it that you want people to take away? Like, why do you want people to pay attention to you?
- 2:15What, what are the traits that you think you want people to gather around when they see and hear from you? That even though I'm younger, I still have, like, important things to say.
- 2:26Like, there is important things that you can get from the younger generation. Mm.
- 2:30It's not just, oh yeah, the adults know everything, 'cause the kids who have the creativity are the ones who will think of, like, the next thing to put in the car.
- 2:39Like, oh hey, for the family, why don't you put a little net that comes in every car, in like the family-style ones, so that the kids can put their backpacks in them and they don't, like, move around?
- 2:50Like- That's a good idea... just thinking- That's a great idea. [laughs] We, yeah, and if you- you're just listening to the show, she kinda looks like Taylor Swift. She does. A 13-year-old version. Without a doubt.
- 3:00So it was a lot of fun. It's a 13-year-old Taylor Swift, yes. Well, and, and this is what I, I love about, like, her saying there are career fairs.
- 3:09There's people in different industries sharing with why we should come into their industry, and we're starting to see more and more automotive companies, specifically on the dealership side, participating in career fairs, younger into the, the, the next generation.
- 3:25But- Mostly on the fixed op side, though, right? Like, come be a mechanic- Awareness... come be a technician. Man, awareness is such a big deal right now. It's just like, yeah, we're here. We're available.
- 3:34That's, that's what I'm waiting for now. I'm waiting for the dealer group that goes into high schools with, like, tech opportunities, marketing, customer experience, hospitality, sales, right? Like, it's there.
- 3:45She had a great point. She's like, "I had no idea you could get into coding or tech or anything like that-" Psh "... in the auto industry." For sure. So go check it out, Auto Collab, C-O-L-L-A-B-S.
- 3:54You can also find it from our homepage, asoto.com. Just click on podcasts and it'll be right in there. Uh, let's talk about some news, shall we? Let's do it.
- 4:02A McKinsey & Company survey has revealed that over, get this, 40% of current EV owners are likely to switch back to combustion engine vehicles due to charging concerns mostly.
- 4:15But basically, the study asked 200 questions to more than 30,000 consumers in 15 countries. These are the places that, uh, really make up 80% of current EV sales volume, so very relevant audience.
- 4:27Uh, 46% of US EV owners, so 29% globally, but 46% in the US said they are likely to revert to combustion engines after they're done with this. What? Yeah, record scratch that one twice. What?
- 4:40[laughs] Surprised the crap out of me. Inadequate public charging infrastructure, high ownership and maintenance costs, and impacts on long distance travel because of lack of charging are the top concerns that came out.
- 4:52Um, Philipp Kampshoff, the leader of McKinsey's Future Mobility division, said, quote, "I didn't expect that. I thought once an EV buyer, always an EV buyer."
- 5:01Um, basically 21% of global respondents do not wanna switch to an EV from combustion. 33% citing charging concerns, exacerbated by rising range expectations. So people now expect a range at minimum of 270 miles.
- 5:18In 2022, that was already, all, that was, um... I'm sorry. In 2022, it was 270 miles. Now they expect a range of over 290 miles. So people are expecting more.
- 5:30EV chargers, not, not as plentiful, definitely not as visible. They said, you know, they're behind gas stations a lot of the time, behind retail stores.
- 5:38And, uh, Philipp, uh, Kampshoff from McKinsey said the next generation of EV buyers will rely on public charging more, much more than the current one. But boy, that feels like a step back. It's totally a step back.
- 5:49Well, I love the last quote, and we've been talking about this a lot, that the next, like, the next swath of EV buyers does not have EV charging access- Up front... at their home. Yeah. Right? Out front of- Younger...
- 6:02the place where they want, right? Less established, yeahThe, the, the other piece of this that I think is, is really interesting, and I hadn't even thought of this, is the gas- the, is the mileage range expectation.
- 6:13When you put in hybrids into the market, and you go from having- 500 [laughs]... you know, a car that has 300 miles of range to my van, a van, has 570 miles of range- Ooh...
- 6:28if I'm going on a long trip, right" That's a long trip. [laughs] That thing, you can go, I mean, we basically make it to Ohio and back on- Dude, I could go to Atlantic City, New Jersey and back.
- 6:37[laughs] You're done, right? So you, you look at that as, like, a new metric that, that EV has to scale to. Mm-hmm. It's just, it's different than maybe what was expected seven, eight years ago when
- 6:51gas engines were not getting that type level of, you know, miles per gallon, and even just miles per tank. Dude, I, I mean- Right...
- 6:58so we have, we have a, n- family wagon's a Navigator, and I just filled it up the other day, um, and I, I'd thought about this, 'cause I had rented an EV a few weeks ago, and the mileage at its highest was, like, at 260.
- 7:09Something, it was a Polestar 2. Yeah. And so it was constantly, like, I just, eh, you get to under, get to, like, 150 and I just, you just feel anxious. But that's, like, still 60%, [laughs] right? No, weird. Yeah.
- 7:18And, and but I filled it up and it was, like, 474 was the mileage. Wow. And it's just, like, I just feel like I could go forever on that thing. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. It's got the six cylinder turbo charge.
- 7:28And so yeah, the miles expectation is a big deal. I definitely didn't, I mean, I love the driving experience of an EV, but obviously, like, people are gonna say it's gonna be so much cheaper to maintain. Not so much.
- 7:38M- tires are so expensive, right? So expensive. And when you're burning through them that way, um, so yeah, I mean, that is a, that is a- What a study... significant...
- 7:45I'm wait to see what Steve Greenfield thinks about that one, um, 'cause he's gonna have- I know... that global perspective on it. But even the global numbers, right? More than a third.
- 7:52The fact that this came from 15 countries kind of blows my mind, you know? Absolutely. 30,000 respondents. It was not like a, a thousand people.
- 7:58It's like- This is one of those, like, hit you in the face moments you, n- I don't think anybody in the industry, well, maybe some people expected or maybe- I, I didn't expect it...
- 8:06they were hoping for, but I didn't expect it based on- Uh, speaking of things, maybe we expected. Stop. Segway. Dang. This is not nearly as shocking as the first story. No. Yeah.
- 8:15[laughs] Cox Automotive's reporting a slight decline in used vehicle wholesale prices in May, and significant yearly drops, uh, varying impacts across different segments of the used car market.
- 8:24Manheim Used Vehicle Index fell to 197.3 in May, down, uh,.6% from April, but down 12% from May of 2023, so we're getting back down there. Yeah, back in there.
- 8:35On a non-adjust- a non-adjusted basis, prices dropped, uh, 1.2% from May to April, and 11%, but the adjusted number is really what we pay attention to seasonally, right? Right. Things happen. Um, uh, let's see.
- 8:46Let's see.
- 8:47Seasonally adjusted wholesale prices for luxury vehicles, SUVs, crossovers, compact vehicles, mid-size vehicles, and pickups were down 11 to 17%, so the luxury vehicles were super expensive last year, I remember.
- 8:59They're coming back down to earth. Yeah. Um, let's see. The survey, so that's the Used Car Price Index. Cox has their Dealer Sentiment Survey that just went out, too.
- 9:08Included 550 franchise dealers and 476 independent dealers.
- 9:13Basically, uh, dealers scored the used vehicle inventory levels at 48, so that's down from 53, which they scored at last, so it feels like the sentiment's coming down on inventory availability, but, um, it's, it's up from- Still up from last year...
- 9:26it was just 44 two years ago. Yep. So there you go. Yep.
- 9:30Yeah, I mean, I think that, at least my perspective on just getting the feedback individually on the used car market right now is, like, it's a, it's a fair buyer's and seller's market.
- 9:41Like, it's, it's kind of- It's a fair market... right in the middle. I like that. Right? Yeah. Like, there, there's nothing that is, you know, too hard to get, right? It, it, there's...
- 9:50It's a little tough to get inventory, but not too hard. And then from a sales perspective, it's not brutalizing the customer because of costs, and so you get this good balance.
- 10:00I think there's still an affordability issue when it comes to interest rates, but I think dealers are feeling a little bit more balance in the used car market. That's for sure.
- 10:07Um, the, the imbalance is definitely on the new car market still. We're starting to see just higher day supply. We were talking about that yesterday. Mm-hmm.
- 10:14Uh, and then just, you know, overall consumer demand and, and whether or not, uh, y- you're able to capitalize on that, I think is, is the biggest concern right now.
- 10:24We're hearing, I'm, I mean, literally I'll hear a dealer talk about May as, like, it was raging, we had a all-time high, or it was terrible, we had an all-time low. It is.
- 10:35It does feel like- And so I think there's a massive difference in the market right now. I think that Jonathan Smoke's favorite word there, we know what it is, it's bifurcated. Bifurcated.
- 10:42[laughs] Ah, speaking of a bifurcated opinion. Stop. Segway. Oh, we got one coming in hot here. I have one coming in hot.
- 10:50[laughs] So Costco's set to undergo significant changes as new leadership aims to enhance its technological infrastructure and e-commerce capability.
- 10:59So the new CEO, Ron Vachris, and CFO g- uh, Gary Millichap, are focused on expanding Costco's digital presence and fulfillment offerings, so mainly in their e-commerce strategies.
- 11:09Uh, historically, they've been conservative with technology. I got a note on that.
- 11:13[laughs] Uh, Costco plans to improve its, uh, buy online pickup in store model, starting with electronics, naturally, um, and enhancing member engagement through technology with over 90% membership renewal rates globally.
- 11:26Um, so, uh, despite the advancements, Costco reassures that, yes, the $1.50 hotdog- [laughs]... and soda combo will, price will remain unchanged- It's really the only question... and monthly sales reports will continue.
- 11:39So don't worry, don't worry, fam, you still get your buck 50 hotdog. Um- All right, you- Uh, last- Go get it. Okay. I think, I think we need to get into this. You, you wanna, you wanna hear the story?
- 11:48I wanna hear the story. Okay. 'Cause usually I would give, I have some thoughts on this story, but I feel like they might be colored by your story. Yeah, I didn't hear the story yet. They're gonna be colored.
- 11:55Look-Costco is amazing. We've been, I've been to Costco. Costco pizza, Costco hotdog, it's great. There's a lot of great products, you know, ease of, ease of buying in bulk, all of those type of things.
- 12:05But yesterday my family, wife, three kids, went to our brand new Costco, which we've, um, we've always had Sam's Club close, so we haven't been able to do Costco. Well- I'm sure it wasn't crowded...
- 12:16we got a brand new Costco 15 minutes away. They go yesterday. They're like, "We're gonna get registered for our membership." First of all, it's r- it's, I think, impossible to buy a full membership online. I see.
- 12:30So my wife goes, and it took her 30 minutes. 'Cause of the line, right? Nope. Nope. She had to fill out handwritten paperwork. [laughs] Oh, no.
- 12:46Not once, but with two different people. What?
- 12:50Said she met three separate people that engaged her in upsell activities, both in the initial table, during her standing in line with the three kids, and at the checkout terminal. Oh, my. The, uh...
- 13:08She said that all of the people in there were- You mean the workers?... clearly and obviously older than her. So there was no one in a millennial or Gen X or Gen Z, or, sorry, Gen Z, um, uh, age range. Demo, yep. Demo.
- 13:25She, uh, the way she likened it was it felt like she was getting sold a timeshare. [laughs] That's unbelievable. Were you there? She s- no, sh- I wasn't. Oh.
- 13:36And she was like, it was the worst experience ever, and it completely tainted the rest of the trip because she had to spend 30 minutes just getting- Oh... the initial thing...
- 13:44and the kids, like, that, that timer starts ticking the moment you take them out of the car. Oh, the timer's done, yeah. Right? By 30 minutes in, they're all like, "Nope."
- 13:51So like obviously that's probably not gonna be the, that's not gonna be the experience the next time she goes. Wow. She's just gonna engage in, like, the retail experience. What an opportunity. But- Fix that...
- 13:58what an opportunity. All right, Ron. No digital, no digital screens whatsoever, no- That makes sense 'cause, like, I mean- It was wild... I registered a long time ago, right? So I haven't had- Yeah...
- 14:09that experience in a long time, but that makes total sense that they would do it old school. 'Cause even when you look at, when you look at the registration desk, it still feels old school, right? Oh, yeah.
- 14:18If you wanna return an item, dude, they got that down. It's so easy, right? Right. Get in line, give it to them. It could be half-eaten. They're like, "All right, we'll take it back. See ya." Right?
- 14:26[laughs] Money's back on the card. They got that down.
- 14:28But the registration, right, the camera's all, like, they're still like, "All right, stand there," and you can tell, like, this picture's gonna suck, and it does, right? [laughs] Yep. That... Man.
- 14:36Well, the CEO, Ron Vart- uh, Vaitris, Vaitris, and, uh, CFO, Kelly Millership, we're looking at you saying fix the registration process. Look, the good news is- That's right... it's only up from here.
- 14:48I think, uh, my take on the story before I heard the registration thing, that makes a ton of sense, um, is that you don't need cutting edge tech to have an amazing business. And I think this just- You're right...
- 15:00proves that. It is, like, I have to say, like, I've tried to buy s- stuff online. I've just accepted, like, I can't shop Costco online. It just is not something that I wanna do. Wow. So, so I don't. That's wild.
- 15:10So I don't. Yeah. Now they just, you know, they do the Ins- I don't really do the Instacart thing, but they have that now.
- 15:14But I think, like, buy online, pick up in store, or even, like, they said they're gonna lean into things like next day shipping, two day shipping. Another reason I don't buy from Costco online.
- 15:23Also, the price is different for online and in store. That's something our industry could, [clears throat] right, is paying a little attention to. [clears throat] Yep.
- 15:29Um, but, but I think they didn't need the great tech to build a great system and a great process that people love. The fan base is fanatical. They buy everything in the store.
- 15:38Before you know it, Kyle, your wife's gonna buy everything she doesn't need because they put it in the first two aisles. I know. It's gonna be brutal. It's over, man. It's over.
- 15:42[laughs] But, but again, I think this is, we've said this before, right? Tech should serve great process. Tech doesn't replace good process. And so- That's right. Yep...
- 15:50I think this is an example of that, and wow, interesting story about the check-in. I'm hopeful for them, you know? I, [laughs] I hope for, I hope for your wife's sake they figure it out. [laughs] That they at least...
- 16:00They probably didn't get the hot dog either on the way out. They got, they... Oh, I will say- Okay... four people, $9, fully fed. All right. Amazing. There you go. [laughs] That feels a little bit more like it.
- 16:11All right. Well, whatever you're doing today, uh, it's Thursday, right? We got today, we got tomorrow before the weekend even hits and the selling part, you know, the big selling part hits.
- 16:19Until then, pay attention to what your consumers are doing. Care about some people. We'll see you here tomorrow. [upbeat music]