Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Anger and Rage
Transcript
- 0:00Heyes, our listeners. I received an interesting email from an anonymous upper tier
- 0:04patron about parentification rage, so I thought I would answer that email. Let's
- 0:10get to it. My name is doctor Kirk Khanda'm a therapist and a professor.
- 0:14Let's read this email. Anonymous middle tier patron wrote in she says,
- 0:19any tips on dealing with the rage of healing from prentifications? I don't know
- 0:26why I pluralized there, right, there any tips on dealing with the rage
- 0:30of healing from parentification. I guess rage is a good sign because it's a
- 0:36selfish feeling, but it's also really difficult as a relative newbie, just chiming
- 0:42in here, Yeah, anonymous middle tier patron, rage is a good sign
- 0:47because you say selfish, but it's taking care of yourself. You are paying
- 0:54attention to yourself. It is a need that you are noticing. So,
- 0:59yes, that is a very good sign. And you're saying it's difficult because
- 1:03you're new to it. Yeah, it's expected. Going on with your email
- 1:07during experience of rage, I've considered that. Obviously, the rage is informative
- 1:12and a motivator. Just chimming in, Yeah, that's the way that I
- 1:17see it is that it informs you about injustice and needs inside of you and
- 1:23issues that want to be expressed or something, and it is a motivator.
- 1:29Anger is all emotion is a motivator, but rage and anger in particular because
- 1:37it motivates us to right the wrong going on with your email. So obviously
- 1:44the rage is informative and a motivator. It tells me that I do actually
- 1:48need to honor my own needs because there is real harm if I don't.
- 1:53But what do you do when rage is a call to action that you can't
- 1:57actually take. Obviously, expressing parentification related rage can be dangerous because it feels
- 2:05unacceptable and it can be feutile. How do you deal with this call to
- 2:10action if the action you can take is really limited? Just shemming in here.
- 2:15Well, so I don't know exactly what you're experiencing, Patron, but
- 2:24the what I'll say, there's a lot that I could say. First off,
- 2:29I would say, you know, I would talk to a therapist about
- 2:30this because this is extremely nuanced and long term and very specific to you.
- 2:39There's no real formula to follow, and there's a wonderful opportunity to begin the
- 2:49process of healing through your anger, and it can be very confusing, and
- 2:54there can be fallout and nothing really dire, but there's just a lot to
- 3:00process and a lot of pitfalls. Mainly the main pitfall that you are exhibiting
- 3:07that I see universally, and I don't say that lightly. Universally, people
- 3:14who were prentified or who were mistreated growing up and treated in a way such
- 3:21that they could not express their anger, which is almost always the case.
- 3:23Kids that are mistreated are almost never allowed to express their anger appropriately at the
- 3:30very least. But when people enter therapy and they or for whatever reason,
- 3:38they discover that, hey, I deserve to recognize that I was mistreated,
- 3:44there was an injustice, and now I'm feeling that anger. The anger was
- 3:50always there, but I'm actually feeling it now. Universally, people will have
- 3:58some version of what you're saying, which is that but it's dangerous. So
- 4:02what do I do? Meaning that? And I don't know exactly what you're
- 4:06saying, Patroon, but what I hear a lot of clients say is so
- 4:12you know this anger that I have that you've helped me to identify with,
- 4:15then some clients might literally even blame me for pulling it out of them,
- 4:19which you know I'll take. But it's not my fault that they have the
- 4:24anger. I'm actually creating a space where they're able to feel their feelings and
- 4:30the angers down there. It's not my fault that the anger is down there.
- 4:32But what they will say is that, well, they'll have this dichota
- 4:40or this black and white way of looking at it where they either suppress it
- 4:45completely the way they used to, or the anger will destroy everything. They
- 4:51will have a narrative around that, like the anger will Some people will say,
- 4:59once I I feel the anger, I'll never not be angry. A
- 5:02similar thing will happen when people suppress their tears and their sadness and their their
- 5:10grief, is that they will believe that to open the door to grieving and
- 5:16to be sad and to cry. They will say, well, if I
- 5:19cry, I'll never stop crying. And this notion, of course, is
- 5:25a defense. It's a it's a like a fail safe. You know,
- 5:31it's like your ego has a you know, those those containers that those boxes
- 5:39that are in a hallway with a fire extinguisher, and I'll say, like
- 5:43in case of emergency break glass, well you have one of those in your
- 5:46ego that in case somehow your suppressed emotion finally starts knocking on the door,
- 5:56break this case, and when you do, you pull out, And it
- 6:00has this script that just says, convince yourself that if you open the door
- 6:06to this emotion it will destroy everything. So it's acknowledging that the emotion is
- 6:13down there, it's acknowledging that you're at least consciously that you're healthy to express
- 6:18it, but you're still completely convinced that the emotion will destroy you the same
- 6:25way that you did when you were young, because it was framed that way
- 6:30to you as you were being mistreated when you were young, and your ego
- 6:33framed it to you as well, And so it's not rational now, you
- 6:39know. There are nuances of this. Of course, if someone became rageful
- 6:42and decided to murder someone or something, then it is destructive. Or if
- 6:46someone became rageful and I don't know, I decided to drive drunk, So
- 6:51yeah, things can become destructive. But generally speaking, just the anger.
- 6:58You know, when I ask clients will say, well, what are you
- 7:00exactly worried? Will happen and they often won't either have a story and they
- 7:08just have a feeling that it will be a dangerous or they will tell me
- 7:11something that's ridiculous, like with the sadness thing. I'll have clients that will
- 7:15say things like, well, if I start crying, then I'll never stop.
- 7:20And I say, well, what do you do? You mean that
- 7:24literally? Or do you mean that figuratively? Like what do you mean And
- 7:27they'll say like, well, yeah, literally, I'm pretty sure that if
- 7:32I start crying, I'll be crying twenty four to seven. Maybe I'll stop
- 7:39crying when I sleep, but I'll wake up crying. I'll go to work
- 7:44crying. I'll watch you know, comedy movies with Will Ferrell. I'll be
- 7:47crying, and I'll just be sad and upset and demoralized twenty four to seven.
- 7:55And I will say, I can guarantee you that will not happen.
- 7:58There's not a lot I guarantee about emotion and your future, but I can
- 8:03guarantee you that that will not happen. It's just not ever happened. There
- 8:07there's not a single case of humans where that's ever had. I mean,
- 8:11the saddest person on the planet doesn't cry that often. So people will,
- 8:18like I said, either They'll just have an amorphous like, well, it's
- 8:22just dangerous. I just know something bad will happen. I'll be like,
- 8:24well, like what they're like, I don't know, just something bad.
- 8:26I'll be well, like, what, well, I don't know something bad.
- 8:28And so I get it. And it's not I'm not frustrated with it.
- 8:33I might sound frustrated. It's more just I'm frustrated at the abusers for
- 8:39creating this problem in the first place. But you know, I take my
- 8:43time, and it can take literally years to move past this phase, if
- 8:48you will, of identifying the emotions there, identifying that it's healthy to express
- 8:54it, but still you know, having doubts or being parent about what would
- 9:01happen if you actually did allow yourself to feel those feelings. So you're expressing
- 9:07that because you don't tell me anything, patron that you're you're actually worried about,
- 9:13you know, you say, but what do you do in the rage
- 9:18is a call to action that you can't actually take. Obviously, expressing parentification
- 9:24related rage can be dangerous because it feels unacceptable. Well that lasts a little
- 9:28bit, you know, Yeah, it feels unacceptable. It's not unacceptable.
- 9:31It is more than acceptable. It is not only acceptable, but it is
- 9:37fair. And I've had this conversation with many clients as well that there's just
- 9:43there's in the hallway during an emergency. There are many boxes that says,
- 9:48in case of emergency, break this class. There's the there's the catastrophization of
- 9:54the emotion, like well, this will destroy everything, you know, break
- 9:58that the glass, pull that defense out. If that doesn't work, then
- 10:03it's this notion that somehow it's just unseemly or impolite or unacceptable. It's you
- 10:13know, bad human behavior. It's childish, it's selfish. You know,
- 10:16there's all these labels that are put to it that are attempting to from within
- 10:24keep you suppressing your emotions. And a good way to look at it is
- 10:30all of these boxes of defenses in the hallway of emergency is an internalization from
- 10:39those that mistreated you because they told you this, They said, because you
- 10:46know, for those of you who have suppressed your anger, when you were
- 10:50very young, you did not suppress your anger because you didn't know yet.
- 10:54You hadn't learned that yet. So whether it's when you were four or even
- 11:01eighteen months old, you were expressing your anger for a time, whether you
- 11:05remembered or not, because it's just it's impossible not to. And during those
- 11:11times, you were probably disciplined and punished and abused with a variety of messages,
- 11:18either implicitly or explicitly. A lot of parents will explicitly tell you that
- 11:24you're being childish, or that you're being a baby, or that you're being
- 11:28unreasonable or something. And so not only are the defenses internalized literally, meaning
- 11:37that the abusive people will tell you these things are very much communicate, but
- 11:43also your experiences will tell you things as well, like if you express your
- 11:46anger and then that causes you to be abused for six hours or something,
- 11:52or causes you to be ignored for the next three days because parents will give
- 11:58a silent treems, you know, the holy grudge, then that experience will
- 12:03teach you something, will be telling you something that your anger is dangerous,
- 12:07that your anger is life or death, and because being rejected and ignored by
- 12:13one's parents, or being abused for that matter, is a life for death,
- 12:16literally a life for death matter to young children. So your ego was
- 12:22correct in drawing that conclusion. But you're no longer in those shoes, so
- 12:26you just have this general feeling like it's a life for death matter, but
- 12:30it isn't. Typically again, it depends, you know, there's there's no
- 12:33blanket statement regarding like all motivated behavior from rage is a good idea, but
- 12:39a lot of the motivated behavior from rage is in our society. We pathologize
- 12:46anger and rage, particularly for women, but anger and rage are wonderful,
- 12:54wonderful I love. I just today God angry about the fact that I wanted
- 13:03to see a movie and there's not a single movie in the theaters that I
- 13:05want to see right now. I've already seen the movies that There's a time
- 13:09when in Seattle, with all the various movie theaters, the indie movie theaters,
- 13:16and the big blockbuster movie theaters, at any given time, there was
- 13:22always a movie that I wanted to see, and I probably went to the
- 13:24movie theater twice a week, if not more. Late at night, I'd
- 13:30get done with work or something and I would just walk out the door when
- 13:35I live downtown and just walk to one of the many theaters that would be
- 13:39playing a late show at nine thirty or ten PM, and I, you
- 13:43know, the movies not necessarily like the best in the world, but they
- 13:50were absolutely watchable, entertaining movies that were worth the time and the money and
- 13:54the effort. I'm looking at the movies in the movie theater. You know,
- 14:00December is supposed to be when all the great movies are coming out,
- 14:03Oscar movies and stuff, And I'm just like, how come there's nothing?
- 14:09And I'm wondering, is it an old person thing? Is it because of
- 14:13Netflix? Is it because of the writer's strike. I'm guessing all these things
- 14:18or factors, but as upsetting, because you knew, if anyone knew me
- 14:26well enough, they would have said that I was a movie nut. I
- 14:28mean who goes to movie theaters two or three times a week. When I
- 14:33was poor in my twenties, and I mean poor meaning that there were times
- 14:39when I literally didn't have any money in my bank account and wondered how I
- 14:46was going to pay rent or something. And I was in one of those
- 14:50valleys of disposable cash, and yet I was like, nothing's going to stop
- 14:56me from going to a movie. And so I went in to my car
- 15:01and rifled through all the cushions to find enough quarters, dimes, and nickels
- 15:07to pay for a six dollars movie in Seattle back then, and and I
- 15:13went to a movie and it was well worth those coins from you know,
- 15:20under my seat. And so I'm a movie nut and so for me to
- 15:28not be able to enact my movie nuttness, if you will, is angry.
- 15:35For many people just be like who cares? But to me, it's
- 15:39a loss of a part of who I am. It's not the end of
- 15:43the world. It's not like being prentified by your parents. But because I'm
- 15:48because I wasn't prentified by my parents, I'm varying connection with my anger.
- 15:52And so I got angry, and so I started, so what did I
- 15:56do? Okay, So here's the thing, my anger. I didn't think
- 15:58of it as a dangerous thing. It went from straight from experiencing the anger
- 16:07to expressing it right and to be specific, you know, right now as
- 16:12I'm recording it, it's before my birthday and I Stacey asked me what I
- 16:18want to do for a birthday, and I hadn't really given it much thought,
- 16:22and I couldn't really come up with anything. So I thought, well,
- 16:26you know, we go to we got a date night, and we
- 16:30could go to a nice dinner and then go to a movie like we used
- 16:33to do before things, when things before the pandemic and back when movies were
- 16:38still okay. Because and it was kind of funny that I landed on that,
- 16:42because it's kind of a mundane evening really, but it sounded so soothing
- 16:48to me. It sounded so, I don't know, comforting and fun.
- 16:52I was really looking forward to it, So I started looking at restaurants,
- 16:53and I started looking at movie theaters and movies. So you know, it's
- 16:59not just that movie suck. It was like I wanted to return to a
- 17:06particular kind of date night that Stacy and I would have. Some of our
- 17:11best moments or funnest moments have been like there was this one moment when we
- 17:18saw one of their early MCU movies and somehow I handed her the popcorn tub
- 17:25of popcorn and she let go of it. We both thought the other person
- 17:30had it or something, and it spilled everywhere. I think it was conclude
- 17:37or I think we did. We ended up deciding collaboratively that it was mostly
- 17:42my fault, but I think I think I thought it was fifty percent my
- 17:45fault, but she thought it was ninety percent my fault, So I figured
- 17:48it must be at least seventy so so there was popcorn everywhere, and she
- 17:53starts laughing hysterically and can't stop laughing in the middle of this theater, like
- 18:03crying, laughing, and and and during she does she does this every now
- 18:07and then she's just start crying. There is this time when we were watching
- 18:10Netflix The Crown and one of the episodes from the previous season was called and
- 18:15as horrible horribilis. I think it's Latin for something like horrible year, and
- 18:23but it's it's you know, anus horribilis is essentially, and you know it's
- 18:33adolescent to laugh at such a thing, but we did, and she just
- 18:37couldn't. Both of us couldn't stop. When one of us starts laughing,
- 18:41the other one can't stop. And this is one of those moments in the
- 18:44theater. And when these moments happened her, her laughter goes on for so
- 18:48long and then I continue having and the laughter is so long that I will
- 18:53be I'll have enough time to pull out my phone, you know, unlock
- 18:57it, you know, switch to camera, switch from photo to movie,
- 19:03and start filming. So I have these I have a number of these videos
- 19:08of her cackling and crying, laughing, and she can't stop giggling and laughing
- 19:17the point where she can't breathe. And I'm only capturing maybe the last third
- 19:22of it, because the first two thirds of it happened where I'm laughing,
- 19:27and you know, so you get My point is that that was a fun
- 19:32moment. And that's just one of the moments that is within this context of
- 19:37dinner and a movie that we would go to. And so for me to
- 19:41be excited for my birthday, and I'm looking at the movie theaters and I'm
- 19:45trying to get excited, and I'm like, oh, okay, this movie
- 19:48and oh that one doesn't look so great. And not only not so great,
- 19:53but there's the of the movies I haven't seen, I don't think I
- 19:57would want to sit through. I mean, there's so many bad movies these
- 20:03days. Again, it's such an old person thing to say, but and
- 20:06I know there are a lot of great movies, probably like indie movies that
- 20:10are on like streaming somewhere, but you know, movie theaters there it's a
- 20:14whole experience. And I don't know, so I got angry, but and
- 20:19it's and I and I because I wasn't mistreated in this way as a kid,
- 20:23I instantly felt that anger and what did that anger motivate me to do?
- 20:29Well? Anger can motivate a variety of things, not just dangerous things,
- 20:33of course, but it can motivate a variety of things. Well,
- 20:37one way it's motivating me is ranting right now to you, which is actually,
- 20:44you know, if you heard me get angry, it's one of the
- 20:48way. It's it's a wonderful way for me to get something off my chest
- 20:52and get support or be told that I'm stupid or something. I don't know.
- 20:56Another way I express my anger is to talk with other people. And
- 21:00since I'mbardo is a good friend and he understands movies, I texted him this
- 21:07super long text, like several pages of me just ranting, and you know,
- 21:15and I went back to the beginning, I said, rant alert and
- 21:18you know, he'll have something to say. He hasn't texted me back yet.
- 21:21He's probably working or something, but I will also. Oh. The
- 21:26other thing I did was I decided to google why do movies suck? Today?
- 21:30And so I read a bunch of articles about that. It felt good
- 21:34to have some validation for that. And you know who knows. Maybe every
- 21:38every decade there's some group of people that think all movies suck today, So
- 21:45I don't know. But whether I'm right or I'm wrong, I felt rage
- 21:49and anger. And that was another way was that I watched a bunch of
- 21:52YouTube videos that were reviewing movies today, and some of them were positive,
- 22:02some of them were neutral, some of them were negative, and it just
- 22:03felt good to hear their opinions about moves. So that's my anger process.
- 22:10Now. Of course, the level of anger of that is, you know,
- 22:14point zero zero one percent of the anger that you have, patron regarding
- 22:18your pertification. But I'm telling you this because there's a lot of ways one
- 22:25can express anger. And when I talk with clients about their catastrophization of their
- 22:30anger response, they often will either, like I said, have nothing in
- 22:37their head as to Because that's the other thing, because throughout your life you
- 22:41were never allowed to express anger, you might not actually know the variety of
- 22:45ways to express one's anger. In fact, as I told y'all about my
- 22:52process of anger, you might actually think, well, that doesn't sound like
- 22:56anger and rage. That just sounds like processing feelings or something. You know,
- 23:00but you know, and we can debate the label, but to me,
- 23:04it's very much anger related. It certainly is. I mean there's some
- 23:08there's some emotion motivating me. Right. It's not sadness, it's not happiness,
- 23:15it's not jealousy, it's not discussed. It is anger. It's rage.
- 23:22It's and you know, and no joke. I Rage is a good
- 23:26word for I. You know, if there was a some sort of movie
- 23:30producer that I could I don't know, scream at and say, will you
- 23:37people stop fucking with script writing and let people write good scripts? Will you
- 23:47people stop trying to just make money and instead make money and a good story.
- 23:55Will you people stop getting in the way of our tours that know how
- 23:59to make good stuff, you know, stop ruining things with C G I
- 24:06and and the I don't know, bubble gummification of art like and you know
- 24:14it's always been that way. But anyway, you know, it's it's it's
- 24:18anger, it's rage because it's it's a big deal to me. It's not
- 24:22just this random activity. It's like I've been explained to you, it's you
- 24:26know, it goes back I in my family, my fa you know,
- 24:30there are some of my favorite family experiences were going to movie theaters. I
- 24:34remember seeing movies with my family when I was very young, like five years
- 24:40old. Christmas Eve. We had this tradition where we'd always go to see
- 24:45a movie. We still do. You know, it's infused in our family
- 24:48ceremonies to see him movie. So so you can, you can express your
- 24:57anger in a variety of ways, patroon that and especially in the interim especially
- 25:04uh, you know, maybe you're building up. What I'm guessing, Patron
- 25:07is that you are worried that you're just gonna scream and yell and insult your
- 25:14parents for prentifying you, and you're going to alien alienate them, You're going
- 25:21to burn a lot of bridges, and to be honest, that might be
- 25:23in your future. But if you don't want to do that, then don't
- 25:29express your anger that way. That's that's the key is your anger, isn't
- 25:34you say? The question is what do you do when rage is a call
- 25:40to action that you can't actually take the fact that I don't know what call
- 25:47to action you're even referring to. I'm guessing it's something like I said,
- 25:51where you're yelling and screaming the fact that you say my rage is calling me,
- 25:57you know, calling me to take that action. Your rage isn't calling
- 26:00you to take that action. Your rage is telling you, will you fucking
- 26:04do something about this, do something. You can't change the past, that
- 26:11that's gone, so your rage can't correct for that. And you really can't
- 26:17even go to your parents and say, can you make it up to me
- 26:19somehow? You know, there's nothing they could do to take away the damage.
- 26:26You know, like if someone were to crash into my car and I
- 26:33was angry, then they could make up for it by fixing it, right,
- 26:37But this is not like that. This is so you know, the
- 26:40anger is often a motivator to right the wrong, but there really isn't any
- 26:45way for them to right the wrong. So so anyway that the rage is
- 26:49just asking you to do something. It's not asking you to destroy, it's
- 26:55not asking you to yell. It's not even asking you to talk to your
- 26:57parents. It's just asking you to do something. In fact, there might
- 27:03be a lot of things that you're raging about, not only at those who
- 27:07printified you, but you might even be raging at yourself for suppressing it.
- 27:11You don't deserve to be to yell at yourself but you do deserve to have
- 27:15that feeling of I feel not only you know, mistreated by the outside world,
- 27:22but I've kind of been mistreating myself. The anger that you feel there
- 27:26isn't necessarily an anger of self harm or self you know, flagellation, but
- 27:33an anger of I deserve better and whatever kind of mechanisms I have in place
- 27:40in my mind, fuck you. And because I do that to myself when
- 27:45when I have certain voices in my head telling me things, I get angry
- 27:49at that part of me and I say, fuck you, shut up,
- 27:53like you don't run the show, you ridiculous voice. I do. So
- 27:59there's a lot of different angers potentially you can create, you can, you
- 28:04know, but tell you other things that I do. I write music and
- 28:07lyrics, and I listen to music that you know, helped me to feel
- 28:11and express emotions that I can't feel through through language. There are songs that
- 28:18express emotional experiences that I have no idea how to put into words. These
- 28:23mix, you know, songs that make me feel this mix of deep sadness
- 28:27and tremendous joy and you know, the the disgusting aspect of human life alongside
- 28:37the triumphant elevated nature of humanity. I'm feeling it all at the same time,
- 28:44weirdly, you know, how do you describe that? Really? I
- 28:48mean, I did just there, but it does that. It's not even
- 28:52near. I mean, it's close to the feeling, but not not really
- 28:56so because I say that because when I listen to music that make me feel
- 29:02at least the feeling I'm thinking right now, it's not both sadness and joy.
- 29:07It's like this other thing, you know. Anyway, Well, let's
- 29:10take a break. There are other ways to express one's rage. Like there's
- 29:18writing in a journal, there's going to therapy, there's yammering, there's you
- 29:21know, starting a podcast that I do. In fact, one of the
- 29:26reasons why I'm here today is because when I first started the podcast after a
- 29:33time because no one was really paying attention. I mean, that wasn't the
- 29:37reason, but that was a factor. I went back to school to get
- 29:41my doctorate and I didn't have time for the podcast, so I stopped making
- 29:45the podcast. And you know, there wasn't there wasn't a huge public outcry
- 29:52when I shut the thing down, and so it wasn't a big deal.
- 29:56But I did love the podcast. And I shut it down, but I
- 30:02didn't have time, and so I didn't know if i'd ever started up again.
- 30:07Well, what motivated me to dust off the microphone and make an episode
- 30:12after I don't know how long the break was. Maybe it was a year,
- 30:18it could have been longer, I don't know, but I decided to
- 30:22make an episode because I was angry about something. I had a lot of
- 30:26anger and I was I didn't know where to direct it. There were factors
- 30:32in my life making it so that I couldn't really talk about with other people,
- 30:37which sounds sounds kind of stupid, because why would I make a podcast
- 30:41about it? But long story short, anger and me wanting to process my
- 30:48emotions because I was being prevented to do that in a way motivated me to
- 30:56do something with my anger, and I decided to start the podcast again and
- 31:00then that kind of got the ball rolling to make more episodes. And here
- 31:03I am today, and I don't know. Maybe I never would have started
- 31:08the podcast up again. I mean I think I probably would have, but
- 31:11but not that early. Anyway, you can be an activist. You patron,
- 31:18for example, could go online and find other people who are being printified
- 31:22and help them or something that I'm not telling you to do this, but
- 31:26that can be another expression of your anger. Right when I help people,
- 31:33and you know, there's a variety of ways that I help people, and
- 31:37all those ways are at least partially motivated by anger. It's also motivated by
- 31:42compassion and altruism. But you know, like I have a lot of anger
- 31:48about the way I was treated as a supervisor, by the way I was
- 31:52treated as a student. There were a lot of wonderful supervisors, not a
- 31:56lot. There were a minority of professor and supervisors that were wonderful, but
- 32:04there were two other groups of professors with supervisors. One group was just a
- 32:08mediocre group, and then there was another group of supervisors and professors that were
- 32:13abusive to me. And I don't use that word lightly at all. And
- 32:16they didn't just abuse me, they abused many other people as well. I
- 32:20didn't know it necessarily the time, but and that makes me angry, because
- 32:24of course it makes me angry. And what do I do at that anger?
- 32:28Well, partially I set out to supervise and to teach in a way
- 32:35that counteracted all those things that happened to me, Like, for example,
- 32:39and there are many examples that I could yam aer about, but one example
- 32:44is that I, as a student, have always been fairly reserved. I
- 32:50don't raise my hand, I don't volunteer to speak in front of the class.
- 32:54I'm involved in the class, but I'm just not one of those people.
- 33:00I'm definitely at one end of the spectrum and in a class, if
- 33:04a teacher would let me get away with that, I would probably never say
- 33:07anything publicly to the group. I'm involved, I'm engaged, I'm just thinking
- 33:14in my head, and I'm also feeling like, well, there's really nothing
- 33:19I have to say that's that interesting. That's usually what I'm saying, which
- 33:22might be shocking to some of you, but not to me. And when
- 33:28I became a professor, so there were times as a student where I felt
- 33:31like professors were arbitrarily forcing me to talk in class just because they had this
- 33:38i don't know, religious dogmatic belief that if a student doesn't talk, then
- 33:43he's not learning, then they're not learning, which is so dumb. And
- 33:47so there were times when I would have professors that would actually keep track as
- 33:52to whether or not you spoke in a discussion or not. And I think
- 33:58this was during my bachelor's degree, but this definitely would happen sort of in
- 34:02my master's degree. But I think in my bachelor's degree there was a professor
- 34:06that as soon as you said something at a discussion, he would actually go
- 34:12to his book and he would make a little check mark in you know,
- 34:15next year name, indicating that you said something, and if you didn't say
- 34:19something that that class meeting, then you would be punished regard to your grade
- 34:23somehow. And I thought that was just so dumb because what it did to
- 34:30me and the other quiet people in class was one we would have to compete
- 34:36with the loud mouths. No offense to loud mouse. As a professor,
- 34:39I enjoy well, I mean extreme loudmouse, I'm not not a fan of.
- 34:44But the people who talk a lot, I as a professor, fully
- 34:49enjoy and they you know, they want to talk, so that's even a
- 34:52better thing. But one I would have to compete with the loud mouths because
- 34:58now I'm for and now I'm now all of us are trying to compete to
- 35:00say something. You know, we're all like, we're not We're no longer
- 35:04focusing on teaching, We're focusing on how to gain the system so we could
- 35:07possibly say something in class. And I just thought it was the dumbest thing.
- 35:13And so when I became a because that bothered me, and I would
- 35:16get angry about it. One of the ways I expressed my anger and got
- 35:21my anger out is that when I became a professor, I would tell all
- 35:24my students day one, you do not have to talk in this class.
- 35:29If you are one of those quiet people, proceed as you would normally.
- 35:35If you don't say a single thing in discussions for the entire term, you
- 35:38will not be punished. Because I hated it when professors did that to me.
- 35:44And not only will I do not do that to you, but you
- 35:46be you. If you want to say something, I encourage you. But
- 35:52what is it to me that you say something or not say something. What
- 35:57you're here to do is learn, And if you learn by staying quiet,
- 36:00then you learn by staying quiet, show me in your assignments that you learn
- 36:04something. So now there are other things that I might get a little more
- 36:13upset about if a student wasn't participating, Like if there was a group activity
- 36:16and a student was just you know, like where they talk amongst themselves.
- 36:21Maybe like one on one Like, you know, I tell everyone, you
- 36:23know, pair up with each other and talk about this topic. And one
- 36:28person says, I don't talk, you know, but I never had a
- 36:30student do that, and I wasn't like that, So it's not like that.
- 36:34It's just in large group conversations anyway. So and I could probably wear
- 36:39outle off another one hundred things that pissed me off about being a student and
- 36:44a supervisor that as a supervisor and as a professor, anger motivates me to
- 36:52not do those things. It's sort of like I'm getting back at those supervisors
- 37:00and those and those teachers, those professors by giving my students a completely different
- 37:07experience, and it satisfies that anger. You know, I can't go back
- 37:12to those professors and those supervisors and change what happened to me. And it
- 37:15wasn't you know, awful off. Well, some of the behavior, some
- 37:20of the stuff I went through with professor's supervisors was awful awful. It was
- 37:25you know, traumatizing where if I start to recall those experiences for me,
- 37:31my hands will start to sweat, my heart rate will start to go up,
- 37:35you know, a physical PTSD type response. So I mean a very
- 37:39mild PTSD response. But but you know, ten years ago I would have
- 37:45probably a diagnosable PTSD response anyway. So anger can do a lot of things.
- 37:52It's not just screened. You know, those those professors and supervisors that
- 37:55mistreated me when I was younger. I have expressed my anger in a variety
- 38:01of ways. I published a book on supervision, which is you could argue
- 38:05also about being a professor. The first chapter is just about how I was
- 38:08mistreated by my first supervisor. In my book on supervision, that was another
- 38:13expression of my anger. As I processed that and putting that out to the
- 38:16world and getting validation from other people, it feels like I am absolutely satisfying
- 38:24my urge to express my anger. And so there's a lot of ways in
- 38:31which one can, and people do express one's anger. You don't. So
- 38:37my point I was getting to is, at no point did I go back
- 38:39to those supervisors and those professors and yell in their face. At no point
- 38:44did I call him out by name and say that they're a horrible person.
- 38:49I have expressed my anger towards those few individuals that mistreated me in this field
- 38:53by doing a lot of things. On this podcast, I will ran and
- 38:58rave about them, and I'll rant about the way in which I believe things
- 39:07should be, and you know that often is a reflection of the way I
- 39:09was treated. So there's so many ways one can express runs anger that no
- 39:17one would say, we're dangerous, call to calls to action, patron.
- 39:24So I hope that I hope that makes sense to you. And then you
- 39:30also in your email say I'm really interested to hear if you have developed some
- 39:34sort of step by step way that you work through this type of rage with
- 39:37clients. My answer to that is no, I don't have a step by
- 39:43step model. I guess it would be nice if they're if humans were that
- 39:45simple, But there are so many roads to where you're at right now,
- 39:51and so many roads forward. Every client is different. Some some clients actually
- 39:55do yell at their at their parents. I've had clients who connect with their
- 40:00anger, and I'm thinking of one client where he connected with his anger through
- 40:07therapy and he said similar thing, and we worked on that, and then
- 40:14he said to me that he didn't actually want to yell at his parents.
- 40:17He didn't think that that would do any good. He didn't think it was
- 40:22fair necessarily, or he wasn't ready to think of it as being fair.
- 40:28And then he spent like a couple of weeks on vacation with his parents,
- 40:32and on day one he screamed at his parents something like that. I don't
- 40:37remember, I don't remember exactly how it went, but he yelled and screamed
- 40:42at his parents. And then he came to me for the next session and
- 40:47he told me that he screamed his parents, and I actually was like,
- 40:52oh, no, did I cause, you know, should I have done
- 40:55more to help him regulates or I don't know. Denny said that they it
- 41:01actually was a good thing, even though in the moment he, as an
- 41:06adult son, was being unreasonable and unfair. It opened a door, it
- 41:14opened a topic, and that was the beginning of many years of work that
- 41:20he did with his parents. Things weren't perfect in the end, but they
- 41:25progressed and he felt a lot better. The parents, you know, weren't
- 41:30super supportive, but they didn't reject him, and there was some understanding from
- 41:37the parents that would grow over time. So I'm not saying that's what you're
- 41:43supposed to do, patron is yell at your parents, but even raging and
- 41:47yelling at one's parents isn't necessarily a bad thing. It can be right,
- 41:53but it isn't necessarily And this is why therapy, and you know, working
- 41:58specifically was clients. I'll do long term family of origin work. There's a
- 42:01whole program that's been developed from you know, sixties, seventies, eighties called
- 42:07family of origin work, and I've done episodes on it, and it's a
- 42:12well understood format. There's variations. Framo has one, Donald Williamson has one,
- 42:21Murray Bowen has one. But generally speaking, the gist of it is,
- 42:25and you can listen to my deep dive, is that that I would
- 42:29work with clients is that they start to feel that anger, they start to
- 42:34feel the sadness, and they start to process the feelings. There's some emerging
- 42:37awareness. What we do is in therapy, mainly we talk about it and
- 42:44review it and go over a lot of details. We start developing a timeline.
- 42:47We might make a genogram, you know, a family tree if you
- 42:52will, that has a lot of detail about relationships and boundaries and different molds
- 43:00in time and the configuration, the alliances, the hierarchy and the family and
- 43:06really just looking at the family through a lot of different angles and then you
- 43:10know, understanding, anger, discovery, expression, validation, this is all
- 43:16happening, and then the client at a certain point feels like they want to
- 43:22stretch their wings, they want to start talking with their family about this.
- 43:29And the approach is very controlled, very calm, and the client might have
- 43:35a lot of anger and rage, but the path forward can be such that
- 43:42the client can be angry and rageful in therapy or with supportive people, but
- 43:47when they go home they try to hold they hold together such that they can
- 43:52actually interface with their family bit by bit such that they can like one model
- 43:59is that the client will ask the parents a lot of just curious questions about
- 44:06the parents' childhoods and by you know, like patron for yourself. If it
- 44:12was your parents, I'm assuming your parents were the ones that parentified you.
- 44:15If you were able to ask your parents questions that you've always wanted to know,
- 44:22like what were your parents? Like how did they cheat you? And
- 44:25you were able to get honest answers from your parents, then depending on the
- 44:32situation, there can be a lot of healing there. It's weird how healing
- 44:37just that can be. It doesn't make any logical sense, but a lot
- 44:42of people have done this, you know, before I was even a therapist,
- 44:47but as a therapist myself, I've been I've had this process with a
- 44:53lot of clients and a lot of students for that matter, because as family
- 44:57therapists we run our student it's through this process, an abbreviated version. But
- 45:02because their students, they're very gung ho about it, and so they go
- 45:06very rapidly through these steps. But there's a lot of transformation, a lot
- 45:09of healing. Even though you never actually your parents, your anger can be
- 45:15satisfied through a family of origin therapy processed, you know, over a couple
- 45:21of years. So well, let's think ray real quick. Don't give up
- 45:29on your anger. Don't believe the defense in your mind that says it's all
- 45:35or nothing. It's you know, it's black or white. Oh. Another
- 45:40way that some clients will deal with this anger is they will you know,
- 45:45what they call gray rock their parents. Gray rock meaning that they will become
- 45:52boring and not noticeable to their parents, meaning that they will just slowly and
- 46:01quietly back away from their parents. And that can be an expression of anger.
- 46:07Right because for a lot of preentified adults, you know, pratify kids
- 46:10who are now adults, they're often still un messed with their parents because their
- 46:15parents are continuing to depend on them in various ways. And so the adult
- 46:20client of mine, we might determine that for them what they want to do.
- 46:25They don't want to confront their parents. They don't see any point in
- 46:29that. They don't want to do family of origin work, they don't want
- 46:32to investigate their parents' lives, they don't want to get closer to their parents
- 46:37at all. You know, the best expression of their needs is to get
- 46:42their parents out of their life. But they know that if they just completely
- 46:45cut off their parents, that will cause a whole drama and it might even
- 46:51create more fusion between the adult child and the parents. So the adult child,
- 46:57my client will decide, I am going to very cool, quietly and
- 47:01very unannoyingly, I'm going to very slowly pull away, and they will react,
- 47:08and you know, and there's always a reaction because there's a change in
- 47:12the system. And in therapy we talk about, okay, what's the strategy.
- 47:17How do you It's kind of lying to everybody in a way, but
- 47:23sometimes you have to resort to that because there's no reasonable way forward such that
- 47:30you as a parentified child now an adult will be able to get your needs
- 47:36met and be treated fairly. You know, if you could, if you
- 47:38could deal with them in a fair way and just go to them and say,
- 47:43hey, I want to change how things have gone. I would like
- 47:45an apology, I would like things to be different, and there was at
- 47:50least some way forward, then sure, go to your family. But if
- 47:53there's no evidence, and often there is no evidence at the very least you
- 47:59don't have enough life times to go on a campaign to change these things,
- 48:02then sometimes it's best to just quietly pull away in gray rock. And the
- 48:07only way you can do that is by I guess you could frame it as
- 48:12you're being deceptive, you're not telling them the full truth, and it works.
- 48:17You know it can work. So that's another expression. And I say
- 48:22all this because I'm guessing a lot of the listeners have similar feelings, and
- 48:29I know a lot of you do, and in fact, I've interacted with
- 48:32some of you, and the feeling never ends. You know that parentified guilt
- 48:43is never really shed completely. And I've worked with people very where the clients
- 48:47have very successfully overcome a lot of the issues that I'm talking about, and
- 48:52yet after five ten years of therapy, there's still that voice in their head
- 48:57that says they're being selfish or feeling their anger, or even just looking at
- 49:01their needs at all. There's always that little voice of you're being immature,
- 49:07or you're being selfish, or you're being ridiculous, or you're being overly dramatic,
- 49:12or you're being mean to other people. That's another thing that will that
- 49:20another voice. It's like, how hurtful because for prentified kids, they are
- 49:28made to feel so extremely bad for having their own needs, such that when
- 49:34the adult starts to express their needs, you know, given their gauge that
- 49:39they acquired when they were young, it'll feel as though they're being very imposing
- 49:44on other people. You know, I can't tell you how many times I
- 49:46would have this conversation with a client. I'd be like, okay, so
- 49:52you know your gauge from zero to one hundred, with zero meaning that you
- 49:57are completely self sacrificial, and at one hundred meaning that you are a psychopathic,
- 50:04narcissistic, selfish individual and you're harming everyone around you who gets in your
- 50:09way regarding your needs. So the way I observe you today is you're at
- 50:16like a ten in terms of you're still ninety percent self sacrificial, but you're
- 50:24ten percent now starting to assert your needs with other people. But you think
- 50:30of yourself as being a ninety, meaning that you're very mean to everyone and
- 50:36you're stomping on everyone else's rights to assert yourself. But I guarantee you,
- 50:40based on unless you're completely lying to me about what's happening in your personal life,
- 50:47you weren't even at fifty percent yet. So it feels like you're a
- 50:52ninety and you're being unfair to others, and you're mean and selfish and immature,
- 50:59but you are. You're not even at fifty percent, which is what
- 51:01you deserved. Everyone deserves to be around fifty percent where they are assertive but
- 51:07not harmful to others most of the time. And so you're at ten percent,
- 51:13but you feel like you're at ninety and so that's another thing that has
- 51:16to be overcome. And yet after five or ten years of therapy, there
- 51:22will always be an echo or a remnant of that notion in your head that
- 51:27you're being harmful to others by even just looking at your own needs and feelings,
- 51:32which is, you know, the parentification curse. Well, that went
- 51:38on longer than I thought it would, but you know, so I got
- 51:45my anger out toward those internalized voices in your head, Patron and everyone else's
- 51:53by ranting about this for the past hour. This is something that I'm very
- 51:58passionate about and about because of the injustice that I have been, you know,
- 52:07very very close to you, with my clients and other people in my
- 52:09life for that matter. It's an injustice that I see and feel all the
- 52:15time and makes me very angry. I'm rageful at the parents for mistreating you,
- 52:22or I'm rageful at the great at the grandparents for mistreating your parents so
- 52:27that they would mistreat you, or something. I'm rageful at a at a
- 52:31lot of people and things and systems, And I'm angry at the government and
- 52:39our culture for not emphasizing parenting skills or guidance enough. I'm rageful that this
- 52:47isn't talked about, that you would have to wait until you're thirty five to
- 52:52randomly come across a podcast to talk about this before you could possibly know about
- 52:57this. I mean, why isn't this being talked about all the time?
- 53:00The things that I talk about on this podcast. You know, there's a
- 53:05lot of various things I talk about. There's not a single person on this
- 53:10planet that I'm not talking about, you know, including myself, regarding the
- 53:15various different ills of our society and the way people are treated and the defenses
- 53:22that we have. And so this is I'm not talking about some niche condition
- 53:28that only a small percentage of I'm talking about the things I talk about it
- 53:31when you pull them all together, I'm talking about things that are universal for
- 53:37humans across the planet and cross time and space, I think. And yet
- 53:43where is it being talked about in schools? Where is it being talked about
- 53:46on TV? And even physicians don't necessarily the people who actually are you know,
- 53:52talking to paces. Some therapists don't even talk about half the things they
- 53:58should be talking about with their clients. So that's an injustice and it's bullshit,
- 54:01and it makes me fucking angry. And so I have tremendous passion about
- 54:09this topic of parentification and many more, not because I'm just like interested in
- 54:15it. It's because I'm fucking rageful, and that rage motivates me to do
- 54:22all the things to set up this microphone and to get the email together and
- 54:28to start the software and to edit this thing and to post it. You
- 54:31know, anger is a part of the whole thing. Anger is not just
- 54:37a dangerous yelling at one's parents. Anger is is what gets me up in
- 54:43the morning. It's like, there's a lot of fucking bullshit in the world
- 54:46that I have to fight, that we all have to fight, and so
- 54:52let's fucking fight it. And everyone out there, please take care of yourself
- 54:55because he deserves it, because you goddamn deserve it. You really really do.
- 55:01Its paper in paper s