Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use Office Politics to Rebuild Trust After Conflict
Transcript
- Lucas: So you have a tense moment with a colleague. Maybe it's a raised voice in a meeting, maybe a passive-aggressive email chain, maybe you openly disagreed on a decision that ended badly. The question is, what do you do the next day? Luna: And not just the next day. The weeks after. Because trust doesn't come back from one apology. Lucas: Exactly. I want to use a real example that I think captures this well. A product manager at Salesforce, we'll call her Sarah, had a public blow-up with a peer over a failed Q2 launch back in 2025. It was tense. Other team members witnessed it. And she spent the next three months doing something very deliberate. Luna: I remember hearing about that. She didn't just go to HR or wait for it to blow over. Lucas: Right. She had a four-step playbook. And I think it's worth breaking down because it's not intuitive. The first step was owning her part specifically, not vaguely. She didn't say 'I'm sorry things got heated.' She said 'I interrupted you twice during the post-mortem, and that wasn't fair. I was frustrated about the timeline, but I should have managed that differently.' Luna: Specificity matters. A generic apology can feel like a performance. But when you name the exact behavior, it signals self-awareness. Lucas: Exactly. And that's step one. Step two was something she called 'resetting the relational contract.' She asked her peer: 'Going forward, how would you like me to flag concerns with you? Before meetings? In a direct message? Through a shared document?' She was basically co-designing a new communication protocol. Luna: So she's not just apologizing, she's proactively preventing the same conflict from recurring. That builds more trust than any apology alone. Lucas: Yeah. Step three is the one I find most clever. She made small, low-stakes promises and delivered on them consistently for a month. Things like 'I'll send you that data by 2pm' or 'I'll review your draft by end of day.' Small bets that prove reliability. Luna: Because trust isn't rebuilt in grand gestures. It's rebuilt in tiny, observable patterns. Like a stock price—it's not about one big trade, it's about consistent behavior over time. Lucas: That's exactly the analogy I was going to use. Trust is like a stock price. It fluctuates based on the cumulative evidence of reliability. One apology is a news headline, but the real recovery happens in the day-to-day trades. Luna: And step four? Lucas: Step four was leveraging third-party endorsements. Sarah asked a mutual colleague who worked with both of them to give her peer some positive feedback about her in a casual conversation. Not orchestrated to be obvious, but just a natural 'Hey, Sarah really helped me on that Q3 forecast.' It rebuilds your reputation through a credible source. Luna: That's subtle. But it works because the peer hears it from someone impartial, so it's not self-serving. Lucas: Right. And the key is it has to be genuine. If you're manufacturing praise, people can tell. But if you've actually been doing steps one through three, there should be real evidence for that colleague to reference. Luna: So this four-step framework—own specifics, reset the contract, prove with small bets, get a third-party nod—it's not just for big blow-ups. Could apply to smaller frictions too. Lucas: Absolutely. The same logic works for a tense email exchange or a disagreement in a meeting. The stakes are lower, but the mechanics are the same. Luna: One thing I'd add—timing matters. If you try to reset the contract too soon, emotions might still be high. But if you wait too long, the resentment solidifies. There's a window. Lucas: Yeah, Sarah waited about 48 hours. She didn't approach the person immediately. She let things cool, but not so long that it became awkward silence. That's a good rule of thumb—one to two business days. Luna: And she did it in person, not over email. That's brave, but it also signals commitment. Lucas: It does. And I think that's a big part of why it worked. Now, there's a counterpoint I want to address. Some people argue that you shouldn't have to 'manage' relationships this deliberately at work. That if you're authentic, trust should be natural. Luna: I hear that a lot. But the reality is that workplaces are high-stakes environments. If you've damaged trust, you can't just be 'yourself' and hope it recovers. You need to be intentional. Lucas: Exactly. Authenticity is great, but after a conflict, what's needed is reliability. And reliability is a choice, not a feeling. Luna: I want to bring up a related angle—the role of forgiveness in the workplace. Not everyone is willing to forgive, and you can't force it. Lucas: That's true. Sarah's peer could have held a grudge. But by following this playbook, she gave them reasons to let go of it. You can't control the other person's response, but you can control whether you've done everything reasonable to repair the relationship. Luna: And if they don't respond? If after three months of small bets and sincere apologies, the person still treats you coldly? Lucas: Then you've done your part. At that point, you might need to involve a manager or just accept that some relationships don't fully recover. But the goal is to make it possible, not guaranteed. Luna: That's a mature way to look at it. I think a lot of people get stuck because they feel like if they apologize, the other person owes them forgiveness. And that's just not how it works. Lucas: Right. And you know, this whole conversation reminds me of why we do this show without ads. We want to give you practical, specific advice without any fluff or sponsorship interruptions. Luna: Yeah, and if you find these episodes helpful, there's a simple way to support that choice. It's a small gesture, but it goes a long way in keeping us independent. Lucas: If we've helped you think through a career move or a tricky workplace situation, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's it. No perks, no tiers. Just knowing you value what we do. Luna: And we really appreciate it. It allows us to keep diving into these nuanced topics. Lucas: So back to rebuilding trust. I think one of the most underrated parts of Sarah's story is that she didn't just fix the relationship with that one peer. She also rebuilt trust with the wider team who witnessed the conflict. Luna: How did she handle that? Lucas: She did a small group post-mortem a few weeks later, not to re-litigate, but to share what she learned. She said something like 'I handled that poorly, and here's what I'm doing differently going forward.' It was vulnerable, but it signaled accountability to everyone. Luna: That's smart because it prevents the grapevine from filling in the gaps with worse versions of the story. Lucas: Exactly. And it also positions you as someone who can learn from mistakes. That's an invaluable reputation to have. Luna: So if a listener is in a situation right now where they're dreading going into work because of a recent conflict, what's the one thing they should do tomorrow? Lucas: Start with step one. Identify one specific behavior you own and apologize for it in person, without any 'but' or excuse. Just own it. Then ask the other person how they'd like to communicate going forward. That's enough for day one. Luna: And if they're not ready to talk? Lucas: Then give it another day or two, but don't let it drag out more than a week. And when you do approach them, keep it low-pressure. A simple 'I'd like to talk when you have a moment' works. Luna: One more thing—what about documenting the process? Is that helpful? Lucas: I'd say only if the conflict had serious consequences, like a formal complaint. Otherwise, documenting can feel too transactional. Focus on the human relationship, not the paper trail. Luna: Good point. At the end of the day, office politics is about relationships. And relationships require repair work. Lucas: They do. And the good news is that repair work is a skill you can learn. Sarah didn't have a natural gift for conflict resolution—she learned this playbook from a mentor. And now she uses it all the time. Luna: That's the takeaway. Trust can be rebuilt. It just takes intention, specificity, and a little patience. Lucas: And a willingness to be wrong. Which, honestly, is one of the most powerful things you can show at work.