Latest / Deep Dive / How to Escape High Conflict: Find the Understory and Break the Binary
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to today's deep dive. We have an incredibly
- 0:03fascinating mission. Today we are exploring Amanda
- 0:07Ripley's book High Conflict. Right, which is subtitled Why We
- 0:11Get Trapped and How We Get Out. Exactly.
- 0:13We're going to map out the invisible like psychological
- 0:16forces that just drag us into toxic, all consuming feuds.
- 0:20Yeah, the kinds of conflicts that take over everything.
- 0:22Right. We're talking about those bitter
- 0:23fights with a spouse, endless turf wars with coworker, or even
- 0:27just political rivalries that seem to take over our entire
- 0:31lives and. More importantly, we're going to
- 0:33figure out how you actually escape once you're caught in.
- 0:35One, yes, absolutely. And to kick this off, I want to
- 0:38set a scene for you. Picture this.
- 0:40It's the dead of night in 1999, just outside Oxford, England.
- 0:45OK, very cinematic. It really is.
- 0:47So you're standing in a dark, muddy field and creeping through
- 0:51the stalks is this man named Mark Linus, and he's dressed
- 0:54entirely in black. Oh wow, like a burglar.
- 0:57Literally like a burglar, he is wielding A machete.
- 1:00He's just hacking down crop after crop, His heart is
- 1:03hammering in his chest, and eventually he finds himself face
- 1:06down in the dirt, hiding from police dogs that are sweeping
- 1:09the field. Is intense.
- 1:11Super intense. Now you might hear that and
- 1:14think Mark is, I don't know, a hardened criminal or an
- 1:17anarchist. But he's not.
- 1:19He's a guy who likes reading history books and playing
- 1:22ultimate Frisbee. Right, he's an environmentalist.
- 1:24Exactly. And in that moment, lying in the
- 1:27mud, hiding from the dogs, he fundamentally believed that with
- 1:30every swing of his machete against the genetically modified
- 1:33corn, he was literally saving the world from corporate poison.
- 1:38Which perfectly captures what happens when a rational,
- 1:41well-intentioned person gets sucked into this sort of
- 1:43ideological vortex. Yeah, it's wild.
- 1:46It really is. And to understand what happened
- 1:48to Mark, we first have to draw a hard line between what we call
- 1:51good conflict and high conflict. Because, you know, we often make
- 1:55the mistake of assuming all conflict is just inherently bad.
- 1:58Right, because nobody likes arguing.
- 2:00I mean, feels terrible, but we do need it, don't we?
- 2:03Absolutely, we need it. Good conflict is basically the
- 2:06friction that drives progress. It's how we negotiate things,
- 2:10how we set boundaries, and frankly, how democracies
- 2:13function. Right, You can't have a
- 2:14democracy without a little debate.
- 2:16Exactly. Good conflict can be intense.
- 2:19That can certainly be heated. But the key distinction is that
- 2:22your dignity remains intact and you maintain your cognitive
- 2:27flexibility. Meaning you can still change
- 2:29your mind. Right.
- 2:30You stay open to the idea that the other person might have a
- 2:33valid point, or you know that you might not have all the
- 2:36answers. High conflict, though, is an
- 2:38entirely different beast. It's.
- 2:40Like a totally different category.
- 2:41It is. It is an all consuming, US
- 2:43versus them spiral in high conflict.
- 2:47The conflict itself becomes the destination.
- 2:49There's literally nowhere else to go.
- 2:51The argument becomes the entire point of the relationship.
- 2:54Yes, and your brain physically behaves differently.
- 2:57You experience these recurring cortisol spikes that actually
- 3:00damage your immune system. Your peripheral vision literally
- 3:03narrows and you completely lose the ability to feel curiosity
- 3:07about the other side. Wow, your vision actually
- 3:09narrows. Yes, physically they cease to be
- 3:12human beings and just become like avatars of the enemy.
- 3:16OK, let's unpack this, because how does someone like Mark
- 3:20Lenas, a smart, reasonable guy, end up haunted by police dogs?
- 3:24I mean, how do any of us at work or at home get stuck in this
- 3:28kind of trap without even realizing it?
- 3:30Well, to understand the mechanics of the trap, think
- 3:33about the La Brea car pits in Los Angeles.
- 3:36Right, the asphalt pits. Yes, this place where natural
- 3:39sticky asphalt has been bubbling up from the ground since the Ice
- 3:42Age. So imagine you go back 10s of
- 3:45thousands of years. Okay, I'm picturing.
- 3:46It a large animal, like an ancient bison, lumbers into the
- 3:50pit looking for water, right? And it gets its Who's stuck in
- 3:53the muck Now? What does a trapped animal do?
- 3:55It panics, it probably flails wildly, and it cries out in
- 3:58distress. Exactly, and flailing in a tar
- 4:01pit is the worst thing you can possibly do.
- 4:03You just sink faster. Right.
- 4:05Plus, I imagine that crying out basically rings the dinner bell
- 4:08for all the predators in the area.
- 4:09Precisely. A pack of dire wolves.
- 4:13Here's the brain bison. They trot over thinking they've
- 4:16scored an incredibly easy meal. They pounce on the bison and
- 4:20suddenly they are stuck in the asphalt too.
- 4:22Oh man, so now the wolves are trapped.
- 4:24Right, so now the wolves are howling, which attracts larger
- 4:27predators like Saber, gooth, cats and eventually scavengers
- 4:30who also jump in and get stuck. It's just a chain reaction.
- 4:34It is. The La Brea Tar Pits is
- 4:36literally a living quagmire of escalation.
- 4:41Scientists have pulled the bones of 4000 dire wolves out of that
- 4:45one single spot. 4000 that is insane.
- 4:48It's wild, and this is the perfect metaphor for high
- 4:51conflict. It draws you in by appealing to
- 4:54perfectly normal noble desires. You know, justice, loyalty,
- 4:58protection of your family. But the more you flail, the
- 5:00worse it gets. Exactly.
- 5:02And the more you brave for help and demand that your friends
- 5:04take your side, the more people you pull into the muck with you.
- 5:07That is such a visceral image, but it makes perfect sense of
- 5:10how like workplace dramas or family feuds suddenly involved
- 5:1420 people who weren't even there at the start.
- 5:16Oh, totally. So how do we avoid walking into
- 5:19the asphalt in the 1st place? It seems like it comes down to
- 5:22something called the understory. Yes, the.
- 5:25Understory is crucial here. There is this incredible figure
- 5:29we need to talk about named Gary Friedman.
- 5:32He is a once renowned conflict mediator.
- 5:36The guy literally revolutionized divorce law in the 1970s by
- 5:40getting couples to mediate 8 instead of going to war in
- 5:43court. He's a legend in that field.
- 5:45And his entire strategy relies on finding the understory of a
- 5:49fight. Right, because when couples come
- 5:51to him, they're often fighting to the death over the most
- 5:54trivial things imaginable. Like what?
- 5:56Well, they will spend thousands of dollars in legal fees arguing
- 6:00over who gets a $20 crock pot or who gets a specific set of
- 6:03Legos. Which makes 0 financial sense.
- 6:06None. But Gary knows it's never
- 6:08actually about the crockpot. No, the crockpot is a decoy.
- 6:11Exactly. It's what we call a false flag.
- 6:14In one of Garry's famous cases, this couple was tearing each
- 6:17other apart over a crockpot, and they didn't even like to cook.
- 6:20That is so funny, they didn't even cook.
- 6:22Right. But Gary probes deeper.
- 6:25He goes down what he calls the Y trail.
- 6:27He just keeps asking questions until he uncovers the real
- 6:30issue. So what was it in this case?
- 6:32Well, the crockpot was on their wedding registry.
- 6:35For the wife, it represented a deep yearning she had for her
- 6:39own childhood home, where she'd smell a pot roast cooking on
- 6:42Sundays. Oh wow.
- 6:44Yeah, she was mourning the warm, stable family life she never
- 6:47managed to build with her husband.
- 6:49And what about the husband? Why did he want it?
- 6:51He just wanted the crockpot to inflict some of the pain he was
- 6:55feeling about the rejection of the divorce onto her.
- 6:58Wow, so once they understand the understory, that profound shared
- 7:04sadness over the failure of the marriage, they don't even care
- 7:07about the physical object anymore.
- 7:08Exactly. The conflict just dissolves
- 7:10because they're finally talking about the real issue.
- 7:11It's so relatable. It's exactly like when you're
- 7:14arguing with your partner over who forgot to run the
- 7:16dishwasher. You're yelling about plates, but
- 7:19the understory is actually that you're feeling completely
- 7:21unappreciated at work. Yes, precisely.
- 7:24And coming home to a messy kitchen just amplifies that
- 7:27feeling of not being supported by anyone.
- 7:30If you just talk about feeling overwhelmed, the dishwasher
- 7:32doesn't matter at all. Exactly, the plates are just the
- 7:35crock pot. Right.
- 7:36But I guess the thing I really struggle with if Gary Friedman
- 7:39is the absolute master of the understory.
- 7:42I mean, the guy who trains Harvard lawyers on how to
- 7:44navigate conflict, How could he possibly ever fall into the tar
- 7:49pits himself? That is the ultimate cautionary
- 7:52tale of this whole exploration, because no one is immune to the
- 7:56psychology of conflict, not even the experts.
- 7:59It's kind of terrifying. It is so Gary lived in this
- 8:02tiny, idyllic, practically utopian town in California
- 8:05called Muir Beach. Population 250.
- 8:08Very tight knit. Sounded peaceful.
- 8:10It was, and he decided to run for the local Community Services
- 8:13District board, genuinely wanting to help bring people
- 8:15together and modernize some of their system.
- 8:18Sounds like a noble goal. But the moment he entered the
- 8:20political arena, he succumbed to the first major trap, which is
- 8:24the power of the binary. He ran as an insurgent.
- 8:27Meaning he created two sides. Right.
- 8:30He grouped himself and his allies under the label of the
- 8:32new guard, and he cast the incumbents as the old guard.
- 8:36He immediately created an ascent of them in a town of 250 people.
- 8:40Precisely. And creating a binary is
- 8:44incredibly dangerous because it collapses all nuance.
- 8:47You see this dynamic throughout history.
- 8:49Look at John Adams and Thomas Jefferson.
- 8:51Oh, the founding Fathers. Yeah, these were brilliant
- 8:54Enlightenment era minds. They were close friends who
- 8:57drafted the Declaration of Independence together, right?
- 9:00But when the two party political system emerged in the early
- 9:02United States, it forced them into binary categories,
- 9:06Federalists versus Democratic Republicans.
- 9:08And the system demanded opposition.
- 9:10Exactly. They ended up running against
- 9:12each other in the ugliest, most vicious smear campaigns
- 9:15imaginable. They stopped speaking for 11
- 9:17years. That is wild.
- 9:19Two of the greatest minds in history completely broken by a
- 9:22simple binary. Because a binary plays right
- 9:24into our hardwired evolutionary bias to favor our own tribe and
- 9:28just demonize the other. Which we see all the time now.
- 9:31Oh, everywhere. We see this today with binary
- 9:34referendums like the Brexit vote in the UK or the peace deal vote
- 9:37in Colombia. You take intensely complex,
- 9:41deeply nuanced issues and force them into a simple yes or no,
- 9:46good or bad. It completely strips away all
- 9:48the Gray area where compromise lives.
- 9:50Exactly. And because Gary created this
- 9:52new guard versus old guard binary in Mir Beach, he primed
- 9:57everyone's brain for what is called the idiot driver reflex,
- 10:01which is such a brilliant term. It really is the perfect name
- 10:04for it. It's.
- 10:04Essentially the fundamental attribution error in psychology.
- 10:07Think about your morning commute.
- 10:09When you run a red light, you blame your circumstances.
- 10:12Right. You were running late.
- 10:13The sun was in your eyes. The kids were screaming.
- 10:15Exactly. You know you're a good person
- 10:17who just made a mistake, but when you see someone else run a
- 10:20red light, what's your immediate thought?
- 10:22Your immediate thought is that they are an arrogant, selfish,
- 10:26terrible human being who just doesn't care about anyone else's
- 10:29safety. Right.
- 10:30You attribute their actions to an intrinsic moral flaw rather
- 10:34than their circumstances. Exactly.
- 10:37We extend grace to ourselves and our tribe, but assume the
- 10:41absolute worst intentions of the out group.
- 10:43So Gary gets elected to the board in Mirby and almost
- 10:47immediately he pushes for a sudden 100% increase in the
- 10:51town's water rates. Which sounds drastic.
- 10:53It was an increase of about $300 a year, which he had looked at
- 10:57the books and knew was absolutely necessary to fix a
- 11:00severe budget shortfall and comply with state law.
- 11:03Right, he was just doing the math.
- 11:04But the old guard didn't see a public servant trying to fix a
- 11:07spreadsheet because of the idiot driver reflex.
- 11:10They immediately assumed Gary was arrogant, power hungry and
- 11:14trying to bankrupt the working class residents to favor the
- 11:17wealthy. Which brings us to a fascinating
- 11:19paradox. Yeah, because you're probably
- 11:21thinking, wait, Gary is a master mediator.
- 11:24Right. If people are misunderstanding
- 11:26his intentions about the water bill, why doesn't he just sit
- 11:28down, hold a town hall and communicate clearly?
- 11:32He wrote the book on communication.
- 11:34Why not just explain the budget? He genuinely thought he did, but
- 11:37he fell victim to the illusion of communication.
- 11:40The illusion of communication. Yeah, there is a famous
- 11:43psychology experiment from 1990 that perfectly illustrates this.
- 11:48A subject is asked to tap the rhythm of a well known song like
- 11:52Happy Birthday or the National Anthem on a table using their
- 11:56knuckles. Just tapping the beat right?
- 11:58The person tapping is asked to predict how many listeners will
- 12:01be able to guess the song. Usually, the tappers expect that
- 12:05about 50% of listeners will easily guess it.
- 12:07Which makes sense because it's so obvious to them.
- 12:09Exactly because as they tap, they can hear the melody, the
- 12:13trumpets and the lyrics playing crystal clear in their own head.
- 12:16But in reality, only about 3% of listeners ever guess it
- 12:19correctly. Because to the listener, there
- 12:21are no trumpets. It just sounds like a bunch of
- 12:23random dull taps on wood. Exactly.
- 12:26That is such a profound realization.
- 12:28Think about how many times you send a quick Slack message at
- 12:30work. Like, can we talk about this
- 12:32project in your head? You're singing a melody of
- 12:34collaboration. Right.
- 12:35You're just being helpful. But to your Co worker, that
- 12:38message reads like the dull taps of an impending firing.
- 12:41Yes. And Gary was tapping a song the
- 12:43town just couldn't hear. To make the board more
- 12:46efficient, Gary instituted a new three minute speaking limit at
- 12:50town meetings and he created 23 different subcommittees.
- 12:54That sounds like a lot of subcommittees for 250.
- 12:56People it was, but in his head the melody was beautiful.
- 13:00You know, he was creating democratic inclusion, preventing
- 13:04long winded people from monopolizing the meetings and
- 13:07getting more citizens involved. But his neighbors couldn't hear
- 13:09his melody. To them, it just sounded like
- 13:11the dull taps of bureaucracy, exclusion and a total power
- 13:15trip. They felt silenced and
- 13:17sidelined. Right.
- 13:18And feeling sidelined isn't just an emotional bummer.
- 13:20The pain of exclusion is a deeply physical reality.
- 13:23Yeah, have you ever wondered why being left out hurts so much?
- 13:27There is an experiment called Cyberball that explains.
- 13:29This Oh, the digital catch. Exactly.
- 13:32Researchers put people in an F MRI machine and had them play a
- 13:35simple digital game of catch on a screen with two other virtual
- 13:38avatars. OK, after a minute or so, the
- 13:40two avatars just stop throwing the ball to the human player.
- 13:43They exclude them entirely. What's fascinating here is what
- 13:46happens in the brain of the person being excluded.
- 13:50Keep in mind this is a cartoonish low resolution
- 13:53digital game with people they don't even know.
- 13:55Right, it's totally fake. Yet the exclusion triggered
- 13:59heightened activity in the anterior cingulate cortex, which
- 14:03is the exact same area of the brain that processes literal
- 14:07physical pain like a broken arm or a burn.
- 14:10That is crazy. A video game causes physical
- 14:13pain in the brain. Because from an evolutionary
- 14:15standpoint, if you are excluded from your ancestral tribe, you
- 14:18would die of starvation or exposure.
- 14:21We are social animals. Rejection literally threatens
- 14:24our fundamental survival. So when Gary's neighbors started
- 14:27rolling their eyes at him in the local cafe and his wife started
- 14:31losing her friends in town, Gary wasn't just annoyed, he was
- 14:34experiencing acute physiological social pain.
- 14:38Yes, and when we are in physical pain, our logic and our higher
- 14:41reasoning just basically go out the window.
- 14:43They completely shut down and social pain almost inevitably
- 14:46leads to aggression, which just breeds more social pain in this
- 14:49vicious feedback loop. It's a spiral.
- 14:51You can see how this spirals in the public sphere all the time.
- 14:55Take the 2018 Red Hen restaurant incident.
- 14:58Oh, I remember that. Right.
- 14:59A White House spokesperson was asked to leave a small
- 15:02restaurant in Virginia. That initial moment of exclusion
- 15:06led to a massive viral shaming spiral.
- 15:09It was everywhere on the news. People flooded the restaurant's
- 15:12Yelp page with one star reviews and the other side flooded it
- 15:16with five star reviews. It escalated to the point where
- 15:19the president was tweeting about it, protesters were screaming at
- 15:23each other on the sidewalk, and Ku Klux Klan Flyers started
- 15:26appearing in the neighborhood. It escalated so.
- 15:29Fast. Exactly.
- 15:29Public shaming doesn't make anyone pause and reflect on
- 15:32their actions. It just emboldens both sides,
- 15:35hardens the group identities and cements the division.
- 15:38It's the dire wolves jumping into the tar pits.
- 15:41The brain just brings more predators.
- 15:43That's exactly. It, and that social pain, is
- 15:45what finally broke Gary Friedman, the guy who
- 15:48revolutionized modern mediation, feeling physically pained by the
- 15:51rejection of his neighbors, sat down at his computer and wrote a
- 15:55highly aggressive, deeply lawyerly open letter.
- 15:58A huge mistake. Huge.
- 16:00He posted it on the town website, publicly attacking his
- 16:03neighbor's integrity and accusing them of mismanaging
- 16:06funds. He completely violated every
- 16:08single principle of mediation he had taught for 40 years.
- 16:12He was totally, hopelessly trapped.
- 16:15He was. And Gary's conflict, as intense
- 16:18as it was, was mostly contained to a small town board.
- 16:21But what happens when these same psychological traps, you know,
- 16:25the binary, the idiot driver reflex, the physical pain of
- 16:28social exclusion, are exposed to real?
- 16:30Accelerants. It explodes, right?
- 16:32Amanda Ripley calls these accelerants fire starters and
- 16:35she identifies 4 main ones, group identities, conflict,
- 16:39entrepreneurs, humiliation and corruption.
- 16:42Let's talk about the Hatfields and Mccoys because that is the
- 16:45ultimate historical example of a fire starter at work.
- 16:48I always assume these two families were just born hating
- 16:50each other. Those people do.
- 16:52But the feud actually started in 1878 / a single runaway pig.
- 16:56Randolph McCoy thought Floyd Hatfield stole his pig.
- 16:59They went to the local court to settle it.
- 17:00Now, if it had just ended with a standard ruling, it would have
- 17:03been a forgotten historical footnote.
- 17:04But it didn't end there. Because of how the trial was
- 17:07structured, the local judge, trying to be as fair as
- 17:10possible, created a jury composed of exactly 6 Hatfields
- 17:14and six Mccoys. Wait, why would a judge ever
- 17:17think that's a good idea? That sounds like a recipe for a
- 17:19hung jury or a riot. You're literally cementing the
- 17:23two sides into opposing blocks. Well, the judge thought he was
- 17:26ensuring balanced representation, but what he
- 17:28actually did was force a rigid binary group identity on a
- 17:33situation that was literally just about a pig.
- 17:35It makes everything so much worse it.
- 17:37Does. And then the unthinkable
- 17:40happened. One of Mccoy's own relatives
- 17:43voted against him, swinging the verdict to the Hatfields.
- 17:46Randolph McCoy. That wasn't just a legal loss.
- 17:48It was a profound public humiliation and a betrayal by
- 17:52his own blood that activated the Humiliation Firestarter.
- 17:55And that's when it got violent. A year and a half later, Mccoy's
- 17:58nephews murdered a witness from that trial, and the conflict
- 18:02exploded into a 12 year blood feud that dragged in 80
- 18:06different people. Because the group identity was
- 18:08so strong, every time someone was insulted or hurt, the entire
- 18:13group felt the pain vicariously. Which brings us to the second
- 18:16and maybe most dangerous fire starter.
- 18:20Yeah, conflict entrepreneurs. There is an incredible guy we
- 18:23learned about named Curtis Toller today.
- 18:26He works in Chicago, literally interrupting violence on the
- 18:29streets for a living. He does amazing work.
- 18:31But for 20 years he was the leader of a major gang, and he
- 18:34uses his hard won experience to dig into the story of gang
- 18:38feuds. He actually traced 1 multi
- 18:41generational, incredibly bloody feud back to its root cause.
- 18:44And you know what it was? Oh, was it a stolen watch left
- 18:47on the sidelines of a high school basketball game years
- 18:49ago? That watch was the crock pot.
- 18:52Wow. And if we connect this to the
- 18:53bigger picture, Curtis's story also perfectly illustrates the
- 18:57mechanism of conflict entrepreneurs.
- 18:58Right, the people fanning the flames.
- 19:00Exactly. These are individuals or
- 19:02organizations that intentionally exploit and inflamed high
- 19:06conflicts for their own ends, whether that's for political
- 19:09power, financial profit, or just social relevance.
- 19:13So how did Curtis get involved with one?
- 19:15When Curtis was a young teenager, he was lured into the
- 19:18Stones Gang by the immense charisma of a man named Jeff
- 19:21Fort. Fort understood the psychology
- 19:24of conflict masterfully well. He created a powerful group
- 19:28identity with specific handshakes, customized T-shirts,
- 19:32and sacred codes of honor. He gave vulnerable young men a
- 19:35profound sense of belonging, but he used that loyalty as a weapon
- 19:39to fuel an organization that profited immensely off of
- 19:41violence and drugs. And conflict entrepreneurs don't
- 19:44just exist in St. gangs, they exist at every level of society,
- 19:47right up to the heads of state. Absolutely.
- 19:49The geopolitical example that stands out is Bashar al-Assad in
- 19:53Syria. When the Arab Spring protests
- 19:55began in Syria, it wasn't initially A sectarian conflict.
- 19:58It was mostly middle class citizens and students protesting
- 20:01over teenagers who were tortured for painting anti government
- 20:04graffiti. Right, it was a civil rights
- 20:05issue. But Assad recognized that if the
- 20:08conflict remained the people versus a dictator, he would
- 20:11lose. He needed to reframe the
- 20:14narrative. So what did he do?
- 20:16He needed to frame his opposition not as citizens
- 20:19demanding democracy but is terrifying radical terrorists.
- 20:23If he could do that, the ruling class and the middle class would
- 20:27cling to him for protection. That's incredibly manipulative.
- 20:31So his regime intentionally released known religious
- 20:34extremists from their prisons. They deliberately engineered a
- 20:37terrifying binary to harden group identities and stoke fear.
- 20:41Because fear is the ultimate glue for an authoritarian.
- 20:44Exactly. They transformed a civil rights
- 20:46movement into a binary war of US versus the terrorists.
- 20:49So what does this all mean for us?
- 20:51I have to admit, sitting here I'm feeling a little
- 20:53overwhelmed. Between the tar pits, the
- 20:55literal brain pain of playing cyberball, the idiot driver
- 20:58reflex and conflict entrepreneurs actively pulling
- 21:01the strings, how does anyone ever get out?
- 21:03How do we actually escape the trap?
- 21:05It sounds impossible, but the escape route begins with a
- 21:08deeply counterintuitive technique that Gary Friedman
- 21:11calls looping for understanding loop.
- 21:14Yes, and we can see how powerful it is by looking at Gary's
- 21:17greatest triumph mediating the 1996 San Francisco Symphony
- 21:21strike. OK, set the scene for me.
- 21:23The musicians and the management were at each other's throats for
- 21:26months. They were trapped in the binary,
- 21:29bleeding money and just hurling insults in the press.
- 21:33Gary came in, but instead of letting them argue their
- 21:35financial positions, he forced them to loop.
- 21:38Walk me through exactly how looping works in practice.
- 21:41How does it lower defenses? Looping is essentially active
- 21:45listening on steroids. One person speaks and the
- 21:49listener is not allowed to argue or defend themselves at all.
- 21:51That sounds really hard. It is.
- 21:53The listener has to distill the core emotion and meaning of what
- 21:56they just heard and repeat it back to the speaker.
- 21:59But here's the critical mechanism.
- 22:01You keep refining your summary until the speaker genuinely
- 22:04says. Exactly.
- 22:05So you have to keep guessing until they feel heard.
- 22:08You cannot move on to your own point until the other person
- 22:10feels completely, fundamentally understood.
- 22:12That sounds simple on paper, but it is so rare in real life.
- 22:15There is a staggering statistic about doctors that blew my mind.
- 22:18Oh, the 11 second rule. Yes, when patients go into a
- 22:21clinic, they generally only need about 17 seconds to fully
- 22:25explain their ailments and concerns.
- 22:28But doctors on average interrupt them after just 11 seconds.
- 22:32Right. We are so eager to jump in to
- 22:35fix the problem or to argue our side that we don't even let
- 22:38people finish a 17 second thought.
- 22:41Looping forces you past that 11 second mark.
- 22:44It makes you actually listen. It forces you to actually hear
- 22:47the melody they are tapping on the table rather than just
- 22:50waiting for your turn to speak. And once the Symphony musicians
- 22:53and management started looping each other, the defenses finally
- 22:56dropped. They realized that beneath the
- 22:58rigid demands for money, the musicians wanted to ensure the
- 23:01Symphony remained prestigious enough to attract top global
- 23:04talent. Right?
- 23:05And management realized they wanted the exact same thing.
- 23:08Once they understood the shared understory, the tension just
- 23:11evaporated. They signed a six year contract
- 23:14and a musician literally kissed the board director on the cheek.
- 23:17Is incredible, but you don't always need a mediator.
- 23:20You can actually design entire institutions to prevent the
- 23:23binary from forming in the 1st place.
- 23:25A great example of this is the Bahai Fates election process,
- 23:29which is practiced by millions of people globally.
- 23:32Here's where it gets really interesting because their system
- 23:35is the complete opposite of Western democracy.
- 23:38There really is. In Baha'i elections.
- 23:40There are no political parties allowed.
- 23:43Campaigning is strictly forbidden.
- 23:44You can't even discuss who you think should win with your
- 23:47neighbor. Not at all.
- 23:48You just gather, pray, and write down the names of nine people in
- 23:51your community you believe have the moral character to lead.
- 23:54All ballots are completely secret.
- 23:56It is a fascinating structural alternative, but I know what
- 24:00you're thinking. Yeah, I have to push back on
- 24:02this. How do you even know who to vote
- 24:04for if no one is allowed to share a platform or debate
- 24:06policy? It sounds impossible to organize
- 24:09a large group that way. Well, it relies on deep local
- 24:13grassroots knowledge of a person's actual behavior in the
- 24:17community rather than their public relations skills.
- 24:19And the brilliance of it continues after the election.
- 24:23How so? When the 9 leaders are chosen,
- 24:25they govern using a process called consultation.
- 24:29If a leader brings a new idea or a proposal to the table, the
- 24:32moment they speak it out loud, the idea no longer belongs to
- 24:35them. It legally and spiritually
- 24:38belongs to the group. That completely strips away the
- 24:40ego. You don't have to defend an idea
- 24:42to the death just because you thought of it, and you don't
- 24:44feel humiliated if it gets voted down.
- 24:46Exactly. It scrambles the binary and
- 24:48prevents the idiot driver reflex from taking root.
- 24:51Because there is no my idea versus your idea.
- 24:54Exactly. It is a system specifically
- 24:57designed to exploit our human capacity for cooperation rather
- 25:01than our capacity for adversarialism, and you can
- 25:04apply that principle anywhere, in your workplace, in your
- 25:07family. By mixing things up.
- 25:08You scramble the binary by intentionally mixing up teams,
- 25:12avoiding strict yes or no votes when possible, and refusing to
- 25:15communicate sensitive, nuanced things over Slack or text where
- 25:18the illusion of communication guarantees you will be
- 25:20misunderstood. Which brings us full circle back
- 25:24to Mark Linus, our environmentalist, swinging the
- 25:27machete in the cornfield. How did he get out of the tar
- 25:31pits? Because he didn't have Gary
- 25:32Friedman there to loop with him. No, Mark escaped because he
- 25:36finally stepped out of his group's echo chamber and allowed
- 25:39himself to look at the data without his binary blinders on.
- 25:42What happened? Someone challenged his
- 25:44scientific knowledge in a comments section online.
- 25:47Normally that just triggers the idiot driver reflex and you lash
- 25:50out, right? But Mark actually went looking
- 25:52for the evidence to prove the wrong, and in doing so he found
- 25:56a massive scientific consensus he had been actively ignoring.
- 26:00Genetically modified crops were actually reducing pesticide use
- 26:04by 30%. To talk about cognitive
- 26:06dissonance, he realized that the crock pot hacking down the GM
- 26:09corn was actually destroying his understory, which was his
- 26:12genuine desire to save the environment.
- 26:14They were doing exactly what he wanted to do.
- 26:15Exactly. And the most incredible part is
- 26:18how he handled that realization. In 2013, he stood up in front of
- 26:22an international conference of farmers and publicly apologized.
- 26:26That takes a lot of guts. It does.
- 26:28He didn't give up his core values.
- 26:30He didn't stop being an environmentalist.
- 26:32He just abandoned the high conflict.
- 26:34And by doing that, he he became exponentially more effective at
- 26:37his actual. Goal So to synthesize this
- 26:40journey for everyone listening, if you want to stay out of the
- 26:44La Brea tar pits of high conflict, yeah, you have to look
- 26:47past the crock pot and find the real understory.
- 26:51Absolutely. You have to resist the
- 26:52intoxicating easy binary of US versus them.
- 26:57Keep an eye out for conflict entrepreneurs who are profiting
- 27:00off your outrage. And above all, practice looping.
- 27:03Force yourself to listen past that 11 second mark until the
- 27:07other person looks at you and says exactly.
- 27:10This raises an important question, and it's something I
- 27:11want to leave you with. We've talked about the illusion
- 27:14of communication, and we've explored the intense physical
- 27:16pain of social exclusion in cyberball, right?
- 27:19The next time you see someone melting down on social media or
- 27:22losing their mind in a PTA meeting, or getting overly
- 27:24defensive and snapping at you at work, ask yourself, are they
- 27:28just stuck in a game of cyberball that you can't see?
- 27:30That's a great question. Are they reacting to the
- 27:32invisible physical pain of feeling excluded or humiliated?
- 27:37And are you judging their entire character based on the silent
- 27:40taps of a song that only they can hear?
- 27:43That is such a powerful reframing.
- 27:45It changes everything about how you approach a disagreement.
- 27:48Challenge yourself to uncover that hidden understory the next
- 27:50time you find yourself digging in your heels over your own
- 27:53version of a crock pot. Thank you so much for joining us
- 27:56on this deep dive. Stay curious, keep looping, and
- 27:58keep learning. We'll catch you next time.