Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage Up Without Selling Out
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this phrase that makes a lot of people cringe — 'managing up.' It sounds like political maneuvering, like you're buttering up the boss while your team rolls their eyes. Luna: Right, it has this reputation for being manipulative. But I think the reality is more nuanced. Lucas: Exactly. And I want to ground this in a real example. I was talking to a product manager at a large retailer — let's call her Sarah. She was leading a twelve million dollar initiative to overhaul their inventory forecasting system. Her VP was obsessed with AI — wanted to drop a machine learning model into every step of the process. Luna: And I'm guessing Sarah's team knew that wasn't the smartest path? Lucas: Exactly. They had data showing that the biggest gains came from cleaning up their data pipelines, not from a fancier model. But the VP had just read a book on AI transformation and was all-in. Sarah had a choice: nod along and watch the project go off the rails, or figure out how to redirect her boss without being dismissed as 'not visionary.' Luna: That's the classic managing-up challenge. How do you influence someone with more authority without seeming like you're challenging their competence? Lucas: Right. And Sarah's approach is the best I've seen. She didn't push back on the AI idea directly. Instead, she spent two weeks mapping her VP's actual incentives. Not the stated ones — the real ones. The VP was up for a promotion to SVP, and the board cared about two metrics: speed to market and cost reduction. AI was a means, not the goal. Luna: So she reframed the conversation around what the VP actually needed to deliver. Lucas: Exactly. She went to the VP and said, 'I love the AI vision. Here's the fastest path to show impact: we fix the data pipelines first, then layer in AI. That gets us a working prototype in four months instead of twelve, and we save three million dollars in rework.' She translated her team's technical reality into the VP's language of speed and cost. Luna: And the VP bought it? Lucas: Completely. Because Sarah never said 'you're wrong.' She said 'here's how to get what you want faster.' That's the core of managing up: aligning your expertise with your manager's priorities. Luna: But I think the reason people resist this is they feel like they're compromising their integrity. Like they're playing a game. Lucas: That's the trap. If you're just telling your boss what they want to hear, that's not managing up — that's sycophancy. Real managing up means you bring your professional judgment, but you package it in a way that your boss can actually hear. It's a translation skill, not a manipulation skill. Luna: So how do you draw that line? When does advocacy become self-serving? Lucas: I think there's a simple test: are you trying to make your boss look good, or are you trying to make the right decision happen? If it's the first one, you're politicking. If it's the second, you're leading. Luna: And that also protects you if the initiative fails. You can look back and say, 'I argued for the data-driven approach.' Lucas: Exactly. Sarah's approach also had a second step: she created a shared scorecard. She and the VP agreed on three leading indicators that would tell them within sixty days whether the ai first approach was working. That way, it wasn't her opinion against his — it was data against data. Luna: That's smart. It depersonalizes the disagreement. Lucas: Right. And that's actually a framework anyone can use. Step one: map your manager's real incentives — not what they say, but what their bonus depends on. Step two: translate your team's needs into those terms. Step three: build a measurement system that lets reality speak. Luna: And I think step three is where most people fail. They either don't measure anything, or they measure everything and create noise. Lucas: Yeah. Sarah picked exactly three metrics: data accuracy percentage, time to generate a forecast, and user adoption rate. She knew those would tell the story within two months. And when the data showed that data accuracy was the bottleneck, the VP himself suggested deprioritizing the AI rollout. Luna: So she never had to say 'I told you so.' The data did the work. Lucas: Which is the most sustainable form of influence. If you become known as the person who brings numbers that clarify decisions, your boss will start coming to you before making big calls. Luna: That's a good point. And that reminds me — I think a lot of first-time managers especially struggle with this. They go from being individual contributors who just execute to suddenly having to navigate their boss's priorities while also protecting their team. Lucas: Yeah, the team protection piece is huge. One thing Sarah did that I loved: she was transparent with her team about her strategy. She told them, 'I'm going to frame our work in terms the VP cares about, but I'm not going to overcommit or throw anyone under the bus.' That built trust. Luna: So managing up isn't just about the boss — it's also about keeping your team in the loop so they don't feel like you've gone over to the dark side. Lucas: Exactly. Your team needs to see that you're advocating for them, not just currying favor. If you only ever communicate top-down, they'll assume you're playing politics. Luna: And what about when your boss is genuinely unreasonable? Like, they're asking for something that's unethical or just impossible? Lucas: That's a different category. Managing up assumes good intent and reasonable competence. If your boss is asking you to misrepresent data or cut corners that hurt customers, that's not a managing-up problem — that's an integrity boundary. You need escalation or exit options. Luna: Fair. But I think for the vast majority of managers, the problem isn't an unethical boss — it's a boss who's stretched thin, pressured from above, and doesn't have time to understand the details. Lucas: Right. And that's exactly where managing up is most valuable. You're not just helping yourself — you're helping your boss be more effective. When you translate your team's work into their language, you reduce their cognitive load. That builds credibility. Luna: One thing I've seen work well is the 'pre-read' habit. Before a one-on-one with your boss, send a brief document — three bullet points — that says: here's what we accomplished, here's a decision I need from you, and here's a risk I want you to know about. Lucas: That's excellent. It shows you respect their time and it gives them a chance to process before they have to decide. It's a small habit but it signals that you're a strategic partner, not just someone reporting status. Luna: And that's really the end goal of managing up — to shift the relationship from 'boss and subordinate' to 'two people solving problems together.' Lucas: Yeah. And that's the frame I'd leave listeners with. Don't think of it as managing up. Think of it as building a partnership with the person who happens to sign your paycheck. Luna: Quick honest thing — and this ties back to what we just said about partnerships. We only do these episodes because listeners support the show through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No ads, no sponsors — just people who find value in what we do. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small group, but that support is what keeps us ad-free and focused on the real stuff. We don't have to chase clicks or sell you anything. We just get to dig into topics like this. Luna: Exactly. And if you've ever gotten a useful tip from an episode, that's the reason. So back to the framework — I think one more element is worth discussing: how to handle it when your boss says no. Lucas: Great point. Sarah actually faced that. Her VP initially said, 'Let's do AI first and fix data later.' She didn't push back in the moment. She said, 'Let me run a quick pilot to validate the timeline.' Luna: So she didn't fight the decision — she created a small experiment that would generate evidence. Lucas: Right. And after two weeks, the pilot showed that data quality issues were causing the AI model to fail. The VP saw it himself. So she didn't have to win an argument — she let reality win it for her. Luna: That's such a good lesson. Sometimes the best way to manage up is to stop trying to persuade and just create a situation where the truth becomes obvious. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what separates genuine influence from manipulation. You're not spinning — you're illuminating. So if you take one thing from this episode, let it be this: next time you disagree with your boss, don't argue. Ask, 'Can we run a two-week test to see what happens?' Luna: That's a great closing frame. Small tests, big trust.