Latest / Ego and Other Things / Vlogesque 1 - The Value of Philosophy
Transcript
- William: Okay, I don't know how long this recording's gonna go. Today we kinda got off to a a rough start. Well not a rough start, but just things keep kinda getting in the way. Like I woke up late and then I was trying to print out something earlier and I had to reset the Wi Fi and then I also had to fix the printing. I had to clean like the printing and whatnot. And I still gotta do my bike ride as it's almost eleven. And I'm really that's fine 'cause I think it was gonna supposed to rain at around ten. Or so now it's saying it's gonna rain at eleven, so I have no idea actually. so we might have to wait later. Maybe at twelve to go bike riding. Which, you know, isn't rain possible around eleven forty five. Yeah, we might have to wait until twelve. So I guess in the meantime I could do some of this the stuff here, but I've kinda had a slow start and ⁓ I'd like to do a longer recording. I just don't ⁓ really know. Like I don't have much motivation right now to do ⁓ like a sermon based one. So I don't really know what to do it about. I'm kind of just getting on here. I thought about talking about my book or at least going through what's written here. How do put it? I don't know, I don't have a lot of motivation right now. Or at least I don't have anything to talk about. I've been in this sort of strange space with philosophy in general where ⁓ it's hard to like estimate the value of it, though I still feel compelled by it and it it's hard to feel it's hard to know the the value of it because You have this idea of everything ultimately being solved in Jesus. All right, like knowing fundamentally that you can't solve The problems of the world yourself. And You don't even have the I guess background hopelessness that you had before when you didn't have Jesus, where you're like, Well, I don't know how to solve the problems of the world, but you know, there's no it makes no sense to go backwards or it makes no sense to abandon it because there might be a chance in in furthering it, right? Now it's like, okay, there is actually no hope. There is no ultimate hope in philosophy. for the goodness of the world and the problems of the world will never be solved by something that I do. They will be solved through Jesus Christ and Him alone. like He will come back and fix everything that's wrong with the world. And so the question becomes like what is the point of philosophy? What is the point of Talking about it, what is the point of talking about things like economics or psychology or or anything like that, right? is it just intellectual masturbation at this point? And that's not a great answer to that. I mean the book that I'm writing, the value of that gets solved in the sense that okay, I I'm you know, I put my greatest effort on display. in showing my philosophy so that I can reveal it to be useless at the end. I can reveal it to be it's not useless, insufficient for who Christ is. And So like the philosophy gets value in showing its impetus impotence and showing its insufficiency for solving the problems of life and really for getting us out of just pure nihilism and power and pleasure. much of the value is in that. So you have that on the one hand and on the other hand you kinda have this there's there's also the problem of ⁓ let's go with the medical analogy. ⁓ also another way of looking at it where you can say ⁓ no, philosophy is like medicine. ⁓ the sense that ⁓ strives ⁓ ⁓ sickness and disease and extend lifespans, ⁓ no matter ⁓ what medicine does or how advanced it gets or how much effort or time you put into it, people get sick and die. And people get sick, they degrade, they degenerate, and they die. And there's absolutely nothing you can do about it. You can only you can only kind of extend the The timeline on it, and you can make people somewhat more comfortable and get more out of the life that they have already. But you can't solve the problem of sickness or disease or death. And it's the same thing with philosophy, where philosophy doesn't solve the problem of evil. Philosophy doesn't solve the problem of emptiness. Philosophy doesn't solve the problem of nihilism or power or or death. It doesn't solve the problem of meaninglessness. it can you can only get more out of life through it than you would have otherwise. You can only kind of somewhat improve the quality of the conditions. You can only somewhat put people back on the right track. You can only somewhat reshape the world if the philosophy is is potent enough towards a marginally better world without actually solving the problem of evil. And so you know philosophy gets this kind of marginal utility. Such that it's not absolute nonvalue, meaning something like you'd rather have it than not have it. But compared to what Christ does, it's it's it's like nothing, you know. A human being would rather have access to medicine and advanced medicine, right? But the most advanced medical care in the world cannot give you eternal life. and you know, y you'd rather have access to philosophy and to a philosophy of life. But the the greatest philosophy of life will never give you will never free you from sin or evil or a degrading world. So you you you sort of ask yourself, is it enough? Is it enough? Is it worth it enough to pursue it? And That's a question which is entire too abstract to answer. Like you have to you have to answer it from this personal perspective. Meaning something like the pursuit of philosophy and of writing is so costly with such a marginal benefit to it that for yourself and for other people, that you only can pursue it if you really enjoy it, something like that. You know, at least with a doctor, if you're in the medical field, at least with a doctor, something like that, you know, you have the you get the I guess the prestige, the you at least get paid, right? You at least get paid well to be a doctor. But it's not the case with a philosopher. You know y ⁓ can get stable university positions if you have connections and ⁓ you ⁓ along with the institutional prejudices ⁓ ⁓ colleagues respect you. ⁓ but it's very much a ⁓ Not not pay to win, but it's very much Kind of a club, you know, a ph ⁓ university of philosophers are a sort of club that stick together. And If you value the independence of thought, if you or if you hold philosophical pre positions that are radically against whatever institutional philosophy is going with, whatever is trendy in institutional philosophy, the likelihood of getting something that's stable with in the university context is minimal. And th the the point of all this is to say is that like genuine a genuine philosophical pursuit is inherently unstable from a social perspective, from a money perspective, from a your status in the community. it's unstable financially because like nobody pays people to be philosophers unless they're already within the university standard. which is sort of an echo chamber, where positions depend very much on your thought content. And socially unstable, because if you're a philosopher who ha who who has any sort of radical ideas, right? If you if you're a person who is thinking outside of the mainstream, you could say, then the likelihood that you're gonna get significant social pushback is significant so it's socially costly, it's financially costly, ⁓ it's costly in terms of time because you you spend years and years and years thinking and writing and reading to come up with marginally beneficial ideas that most people are not gonna even be interested in seriously engaging with. You think of the most think of the most you know, influential and think about the most important and influential books, philosophical books in the world, and the vast majority of people have not read them. Some of them haven't even heard of them. I mean the degree of people who haven't heard of like Immanuel K Kant never mind ne never mind read, you know, something like the Critique of Pure Reason or or even just engaged with the ideas in general. I mean it's it's staggering. Most of philosophy's influence is this, it's a second order dispersed influence. Like the ideas of John Locke, for example, influence our society today. But that's not because the individuals in our society have invested their time and energy and money into reading and understanding John Locke, but because the founders of the country, a certain select group of people more influence and invested in John Locke's ideas and they went on to sort of create the institutions that we all inhabit. that most people inhabit in sort of a a blind way, which is to say that most people are not interested in pioneering ideas. You know, they're they're interested in in successfully operating within the rules of the game that are set up already. And So you can see the the the influence of that. You know, even if you get into political circles like the left and especially the extreme left is influenced by ideas from Hegel and Marx and the Frankfurt School and Foucault and these kinds of stuff, but the actual amount of people in that movement who who have directly engaged with those thinkers in a substantial way, never mind directly engaged with the the counter arguments, something like the Austrian school or or Ayn Rand or libertarian thinkers or something like that. is is Minuschool. It's the leaders of the movement who engage with these things and sort of proliferate the ideas down to I guess you for lack of a better word, the f the the intellectual foot soldiers who go out and actually have this commentary in the public space. So your your actual even as a philosopher, your direct influence is ⁓ it's dispersed and it's not necessarily in your hands and it's often ⁓ ⁓ and misapplied, ⁓ if you're careful about how you're going about ⁓ it, right? ⁓ ⁓ know, all this is to say is that ⁓ From a Christian perspective, ultimately philosophy fails completely in its ability to solve the problem it's trying to solve. And then the philosophical life is sort of uniquely costly financially and socially and I guess in the in the the normal ways that we would measure success, whether we explicitly agree to it or not, the philosophical life is costly. And I guess I often wonder to myself, I wonder I wonder to myself what is what keeps driving me on? Because it's it's more than just like idolatry in a sense. Because that's the first criticism that comes to my mind. You know, is this just an idolatry? Is this just the thing that I worship instead of Jesus, right? Is this the thing that is this a sunk cost fallacy because I've invested so much time into it? But the innate interest in it doesn't go away. And the excitement I feel about talking about it with people doesn't go away. It gets reshaped, it gets ⁓ reconfigured, it has different applications, it have just different focuses, it has different foundations, but it doesn't really go away. And it's a similar thing with with writing. I mean these really the two are just sort of com conjoined or combined there. It's like to me, even if Jesus solves the problem of evil, philosophy doesn't end up losing its value to me. I mean, I spent ten years I spent ten years as an atheist pursuing philosophy. And I was greatly helped by it. I was greatly influenced by it. I was greatly changed by it. I came from a circumstance that where you know I should have ended up in in an incredibly worse situation. But I had philosophy. I had writing. Not that about it, you know, I had and I still have a talent for it and I've always kind of wanted that lifestyle of leading people into it. Leading people into it. But in the right way. Because I've seen thinkers philosophical thinkers go down the right the wrong path. Like the egoistic path. The and I mean egoistic in the sense of, you know, here's my philosophical system and it is the truth. And if you think outside of the system then you're evil or you're stupid. Essentially is the argument always goes down. And of course the just the whole atheistic side of it, where they think that their salvation lies in philosophy. And the truth is that your salvation does not lie in philosophy, it lies in in Jesus. But Philosophy can be such an an indispensable tool for understanding our world and making good out of it. And, you know, maybe that says more about Jesus than it says about philosophy, because Jesus is so astronomically more valuable to our ultimate salvation and to our ultimate eternity that the power of philosophy pales in comparison to it. But the the but philosophy is not unimportant. Philosophy is not Therefore unpowerful. Philosophy can rescue a child out of the abuse that they've suffered and give them a sense of understanding about themselves and the world that helps transform themselves and the world. I've always wanted to engage directly with people in these conversations and you know, someone with with a person like Stefan Molyneux where I mean he's got his own problems, right? But I mean, as somebody who goes and shares their thoughts as best as they can, to the world around them, without trying to have all the definitive answers and having th the emphasis really be much more on I guess thinking for yourself. ⁓ yeah, really thinking for yourself, right? But Growing with other people by deliberately talking about these things, by deliberately thinking about these things, and by trying to live them out, trying to develop the praxis underneath to to really live them out. So that's why I feel like I have a Where I feel like that's what I was meant to do. or that's such a significant part of what I'm meant to do. And it's not to ⁓ get rid of the evangelistic part, but it's also to I don't know how to put it, stay true to the things that I have already. Stay true to the to the Mm-hmm how do I put it? Stay to that part of myself that is so significant. And so central. And of course, yes, like adopting it for Christ's sake. And But I mean how do I put it? embrace this as the thing that I do with my life, right? Despite the costs or the potential costs of it. I think maybe that's the best way of putting it. And yesterday I felt very calm about this. I felt very much like I had come to accept it. Because I've been thinking along the lines of well, why don't I go, you know, thirties thirties still young enough to go into something like nursing, right? Like, ⁓ I should go into nursing because ⁓ go to school and get the degree for nursing because principally because it makes money. Principally because it would Principally because I would make more money. And I think, well, I need to make more money. Why? You know, because I feel I don't know, some sort of obligation to make more money, or I have some sort of vague idea that if I had more money, then somehow that's gonna make me feel more ⁓ Secure or meaningful, right? Or purposeful, I don't know. And you think, like at least nursing would be valuable, right? ⁓ is this philosophy thing even valuable? ⁓ It's not valuable to many other people but me. But does that mean it's not valuable? And it was also the question again of like I have invested so much into this and I have gotten so much out of it. And the more time I invested in the more consistent I am, which is the big problem I've been dealing with my my life is in my life, is just that like daily consistency, which is beginning to be solved. Because I'm getting on here and and and doing things on a consistent basis and engaging with this stuff on a consistent basis. ⁓ What's the point of deviating? What's the point of significantly deviating? You know, even I have to I have to go back to the to where I was before where I working f mm full time and doing this. I mean it's fine. Like like I'd rather go back to that slow and grow kind of idea where at least I have a con it's consistent. Like maybe I only have a half an hour a day to to like put myself into this. But you know, and I don't know exactly how it it's gonna pay off, except that I think the philosophy I've created could actually really help people's lives. And then you tie it in to Christ Himself and then you've got You know, you how I put it, you've got the best of both worlds, right? You've got You've got the ultimate telos in heaven through Christ, and you also have a life that is authentic here on earth. And not only that, but just being able to to set people on the right course, especially younger people who, you know, are beginning out in life and they have those questions of of meaning, and maybe they have a background that they're struggling to deal with. And my philosophy has just so much to say to people's lives, so much that is valuable to say to people's lives. And even if people don't agree with me, those conversations in and of themselves are so powerful. The the difference between somebody who is actively thinking about life and its meaning Who is actively thinking about right and wrong, who is actively thinking about the kind of world that they live in, who's actively thinking about who they are and what they want, who is actively thinking about, you know, how do I develop my relationships and what is love and what is authenticity and what is power and what kind of world do we live in? Those kinds of conversations, those kinds of thoughts, those kinds of self-confrontations, relational confrontations are so crucial to life and They often don't happen unless somebody challenges you, right? The people don't tend to t tend to seek these things out. They have to be sought. They have to be challenged within. That's part of that's one of the greatest. That's one of the most important things that a philosopher can do. Is go out and even just get people to be thinking about these questions, even if they don't come to the same conclusions as you, because inevitably, and this is again what Christianity helps me to do, you have to have humility when it comes to your own philosophy, you have to have humility when it comes to your own ideas of the world, because inevitably, inevitably, what you have thought out is mistaken. There are holes that you don't understand. There are connections which are broken. There is incompleteness. There is brokenness within any philosophical system. Just like this brokenness in the medical field, and this broken and and and gaps in knowledge and etc. etc. It's it's the same edit everywhere because we live in a broken world. It's not like you go out and you have this perfect philosophical system that you know, solves every kind of problem because the only thing that solves every problem is Jesus Christ. But it doesn't mean that philosophy in and of itself is not crucially important. And I have this talent and I have this interest and I have this drive. And it's been with me, you know, since I was fifteen. And regardless of whether it's it it has never ever brought me ⁓ fame or money or prestige or any of these kinds of things. And yet I'm I'm still here doing it doing it. Because why? Because it's it is of such importance. to myself and it's of such importance to the world, whether or not they recognize it, that I am compelled to return to it again and again, especially because I have some sort of capacity with it. So I can't just leave it aside. I can't I I could never just turn away from it. It has to be the thing which I do. Or at least a significant part of that. You know, and if that means I have to work full time at, you know, a crappy job, but I still get time to do this, then I wanna do that rather than, you know, invest my time in a job just to get more money. Especially when I work at a job that's that's quite convenient for being able to think and is flexible with scheduling and things like that. And You know, again, maybe eventually something comes out of this. I don't know. Again, I've I'm overcoming the biggest hurdle I've had so far, which is the consistency, where it's like every single day I am building upon something, you know, I'm rebuilding that identity, which is so crucial. But And so I think solving that that that foundational weakness is going to pay great dividends over the long run. But I think the last thing we need to do is turn from the path that we we've been going down. I think the last thing we need to do is, you know is fundamentally turn away from this. We can't fund we shouldn't be fundamentally we shouldn't turn away from this at all. We need to to press forward. But press forward more intelligently, for sure, and It's I don't know how to put it, it is simply impossible for me to let go of this part of myself for no compelling reason. You know, I mean it'd be one thing if like Christ himself came down to earth and said, William, I don't want you to do philosophy anymore. I don't want you to do this any this kind of writing anymore. I want you to completely devote yourself to, you know, this thing over here, which you find you have no You don't find value at all because hey, it's God talking to you, and God is gonna end up knowing better than you what is actually going to bring you fulfillment and happiness. But Christ is not doing this. If anything, he's allowing me to lean into it. the only thing that has really come up to compete with this is evangelism, which It's not really a competition and they blend well very well together. But I mean there's a little bit of balancing between like the time you spent learning to do evangelism essentially, though it's becoming less and less time having to invest in that because it becomes easier and easier to kind of talk about the message and it's mostly hands-on work anyway, but there's this, you know, balance that you can have between the or a mixture of the evangelism and the philosophy together. And you know, I just I wrote a I just wrote a a little piece called Christian Egoism where I talked about how the self is, you know, something that is not something that is annihilated by Christ. And it's actually ⁓ fulfilled in Christ and the ego is fulfilled in Christ. And This was a blend of theology and philosophy, which was partially evangelistic in the sense that, you know, there are definitely those secular types out there who believe that if you come to Christ, that who you are, your individuality, is going to be suffocated and destroyed by Christ, right? It's a it's a form of slavery that just annihilates your sense of meaning and purpose and individuality and uniqueness, and you get absorbed into this Blob of a body that is just only directed by Christ. When of course the reality is that Christ created you, Christ created your uniqueness, your individuality, He created who you are, and He He is not only the key to that true individuality, but He is the key to like what you really were meant to be, what would really fulfill you, what would really restore you. He is the path to that. And so there's plenty of atheists out there, or plenty of secular types out there, who fear Christianity because they have a misunderstanding of the concepts involved. And part of the evangelistic task is to sort of be able to philosophically lay out what is what is Christ even talking about? What is he teaching? What does it actually mean? What are words like sin and redemption and salvation and dying to the self? What does that actually mean? So there's not necessarily a contradiction between evangelism on the one hand and philosophy on the other hand. And if anything, I think that Christ is encouraging in me a public version of this. Because for a long time for there was a few years for sure. I mean there were there were years in my early twenties where I wasn't going public with anything because I knew what I had to share wasn't competent enough. And then there was a few years in between where I wasn't sharing with the public because I was incredibly pessimistic about the response. I was incredibly pessimistic about the how would how would people treat it and whether what kind of impact it would actually have on people and whether or not it was even possible for people to understand or grasp what I was talking about. And I there was a there was a sort of an aspect where I thought The world, I don't owe the world a philosophy. I don't owe the world engagement. I don't owe the world, etc., etc. Because I was afraid of the reaction. And now Christ, and so I would write and I would study philosophy and whatnot, but it was all self-absorbed, it was all self-de-focused. selfish in the true words, is being like cut off from other people and concerned for other people. And now Christ is freeing me from that, and he's certainly pushing me to engage with other people. I mean, the street evangelism is one particular example of that where he has very much been pushing me into engaging with people in the public. And it's the same thing with these recordings, it's the same thing with writing on Substack, etc. etc. But anyway, we're in close to forty minutes here, so I I don't know how much more we have to talk about, but anyway, we'll end it here.