Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Saylor's Sell Signal, Morgan Stanley, & Coinbase Just Cracked | Joe Consorti
Transcript
- 0:00We have a lot of debt. We have an increasing amount of
- 0:02debt. A larger and larger percentage
- 0:04of that is interest expense. Beyond a certain level, we
- 0:07cannot allow our interest expense to become the largest
- 0:09line item on our balance sheet as we're also raising the amount
- 0:12of debt that we're issuing. So as a mathematical function of
- 0:14that, we have to keep rates relatively low.
- 0:16What does that mean? More credit creation, more risk
- 0:18taking? And what is that?
- 0:20What serves as the greatest asset to absorb freshly printed
- 0:24money, IE credit that gets created out of thin air?
- 0:26It's Bitcoin, right? So this is a process.
- 0:28It's always expanding. Global money supply is always
- 0:31rising. Global credit is always being
- 0:33created. It's just a function of how
- 0:35quickly it's occurring, right? And if you extrapolate that out
- 0:37to the rest of the world, they're in a much more dire
- 0:39situation from a debt perspective than we are.
- 0:41So imagine the situation in the US cranked up to 10 or 11,
- 0:44particularly in places like China.
- 0:46So it's an it's an inevitability.
- 0:48A Bitcoin is is destined to rise.
- 0:51What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:55going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:59ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 1:08whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 1:11over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:14I say when we sell. I say when we sell.
- 1:23We are back. We're back.
- 1:25It's the last trade. We have our first guest on the
- 1:28show in quite some time, Joe Consorti.
- 1:31Joe, it's great to see you head of growth at Horizon.
- 1:34Thanks for joining us today and thank you in advance for not
- 1:37letting us down. I think you're going to do a
- 1:39great job on this podcast today. Excited to have you on.
- 1:42Absolutely, Jackson, Brian, Michael, absolute pleasure and
- 1:45very, very honored to be kicking it off as the first guest back
- 1:48in a while. I appreciate that.
- 1:49Our our audience got tired of hearing us offer for a full
- 1:53hour, so we decided, you know, might as well.
- 1:55Spice it up a little. Mainly Michael, there's only so
- 1:58much like even even working at the company, there's only so
- 2:00much Michael you can take and and I certainly feel for the
- 2:03audience. So it's good to have Joe back
- 2:05on, get some more, get some other opinions of the show, get
- 2:08some, some certified thought leaders in the Bitcoin space.
- 2:12So Joe, good to see you, man. Thanks for joining us again.
- 2:15Absolutely. You know, I haven't added
- 2:17Thought Leader to my LinkedIn yet, but I just might.
- 2:20Just might, just might after today.
- 2:22Cool man. Well, thank you.
- 2:24Let's get into it. We got AI think we'll have a
- 2:26tight RIP here today fortunately or unfortunately, depending on
- 2:29what that means for you. But I think a nice place to
- 2:32start would be we have some situation monitoring that needs
- 2:35to be done. So we're always back and forth
- 2:37on is there a war happening in Iran?
- 2:40Is there not a war happening? And I think what a lot of people
- 2:43tend to miss is the fact that you may notice a pattern with
- 2:48the rhetoric coming out from the Trump administration based on
- 2:51where bond yields are headed. And so I think TFTC has done a
- 2:55great job covering this. Luke Roman, of course, has been
- 2:57one of the best analysts out there.
- 2:58Joe, I know you cover this as well.
- 3:01And I bring this up in the context of just another another
- 3:04post on Truth Social about kind of it is, you know, we are going
- 3:08to have peace or we're not going to have peace.
- 3:10And you kind of see these peace talks coincide with a new spike
- 3:13up in the 10 year, the 30 year U.S.
- 3:16Treasuries. And then also across the board,
- 3:18you're seeing sovereign, sovereign credit move up or
- 3:22yields move up to the upside. And so I want to talk about just
- 3:25that context first, because it's really important.
- 3:27It it think often people miss the fact that we're not really
- 3:31calling the shots. The bond market is calling the
- 3:33shots. So Joe, what are your thoughts
- 3:35on that to kick us off here? For sure, it's a really great,
- 3:39great way to kick things off because it sort of tells you the
- 3:42entire game in a nutshell. And what you said last was very,
- 3:45very true. It's not the Fed that calls the
- 3:48shots. You know, the Fed what what the
- 3:50Fed's job is to do is to set policy rates in order to try to
- 3:54influence the direction of the US Treasury market.
- 3:56But ultimately, rates lead the Fed right where the bond markets
- 3:59go, where the bond vigilantes dictate.
- 4:01That's what the Fed invariably does.
- 4:04And So what you've seen and Lawrence, the part has pointed
- 4:06this out. Simon Dixon has pointed this
- 4:08out. You, you sent over a great tweet
- 4:09from Luke Roman. You know where he points out
- 4:13every time the 10 year yield over the last more than two
- 4:17months now that we've been in Iran has approached about 4 1/2
- 4:21percent, we have seen basically jawboning come out, jawboning,
- 4:27extreme jawboning occur where talk floats of the end of the
- 4:31war, right? And this is the latest example
- 4:33of it. Obviously the war in my mind,
- 4:35given what we're seeing right now, is nowhere near ending.
- 4:39You know, it's, it's really funny you look at the spike that
- 4:42occurred before this last one. I, I remember late last week
- 4:45people were saying, oh, the war is going to be overlook at
- 4:47Trump's latest truth social post.
- 4:49He was saying that, you know, they're hours away from a peace
- 4:52deal being inked. And then literally like 7 1/2
- 4:54hours later, 8 hours later, the a massive petroleum spot gets
- 5:01gets bombed in the UA. And so in my mind, you know,
- 5:06it's really interesting to see that the 10 year every single
- 5:09time it approaches this critical juncture, we see a lot of
- 5:12jawboning about the end of the war.
- 5:14It's no surprise to me. And and the recent the recent
- 5:17bid that we're seeing in 10's and really all across the curve.
- 5:20I would wager that that's going to sell off once again after
- 5:22it's revealed that the war is in fact not close to over.
- 5:25But it sort of reveals the entire game here, right?
- 5:27Like we can go to war in so far as we can afford it.
- 5:31War is not something that the US Treasury market particularly
- 5:34likes. There often times is a huge sell
- 5:37off, as you can see here, that strengthens the dollar.
- 5:39That's bad for funding. And as we know, not just funding
- 5:42the war, but also the funding, funding the government more
- 5:46broadly, right there is a level at which it becomes untenable or
- 5:49very uncomfortable for the US government to fund itself.
- 5:52And I suppose 4 1/2 percent on the 10 year is that level.
- 5:57And so this is just that the broader behavior to take away
- 5:59here is that, you know, that's what the US government is
- 6:02constrained by the reality of the interest rate situation, the
- 6:05fact that we have to roll over so much debt and we simply
- 6:08cannot do it at these rates. So I would say that's another
- 6:11constraint being thrown as into the war, as far as potentially
- 6:15ending the war is concerned. You know, if we have to roll all
- 6:19of the all of the the 10s we have outstanding at 4 1/2%, all
- 6:23of the bills, all the notes, all of the bonds, elevated rates, I
- 6:26would say that's probably drive the government to try to end the
- 6:28war sooner than later. Loyal listeners, the last trade.
- 6:31Before we get into this week's episode, I have a quick favor to
- 6:34ask of you. If you haven't already, please
- 6:36like and subscribe to the channel.
- 6:38And if you have a question or any feedback, please drop it in
- 6:41the comments section below and I will do my best to respond to
- 6:44every single one of them. Thank you for being here and
- 6:47enjoy this week's episode. Yeah, that's that's all.
- 6:51Well said. It makes me think of, you know,
- 6:53I guess we're more than two months into this thing now, this
- 6:56conflict, this war, whatever you want to call it.
- 6:58And in the first few weeks, it was a similar dynamic, but I
- 7:03guess less focused on where the 10 year was and more just like
- 7:06where the price of oil was. Like you saw any time price of
- 7:10oil started to spike up, Trump would go on true social and and
- 7:13tweet something to the effect of, you know, we've got a peace
- 7:15deal coming or this is we've already won.
- 7:18You know, we've heard that we've already won multiple times,
- 7:20Treasury. Secretary Scott Busan going on
- 7:22Fox News and saying that this will be over in a couple of
- 7:25weeks. Yeah.
- 7:26So that's the pattern, right? Is like you really can't take
- 7:29anything. I mean any administration, but
- 7:32particularly this one. I would say anything they say at
- 7:35face value, and there's sort of a ton of, I don't want to call
- 7:42it manipulation, but just attempts to temper markets,
- 7:44whether it's oil, the 10 year, because this conflict is ongoing
- 7:49and they basically don't want things to break even though,
- 7:53like you said, Joe, you know, I think early on the estimates
- 7:56were 6 to $8 billion a day that this would cost.
- 8:00And then there was the other sort of estimates that they
- 8:02wanted to actually quarter off like over a trillion dollars for
- 8:06the entire war effort, depending on how long it would go.
- 8:09And so, yeah, wars cost money. And so that challenges a lot of
- 8:12the already pretty strained fiscal and and monetary
- 8:16situations in this country. So they're doing anything and
- 8:20everything they can to quell markets at any point that things
- 8:23appear to potentially be breaking.
- 8:25And I guess I mean, it's an open question how long they can keep
- 8:28this going in terms of like just going out on true social and and
- 8:32attempting to keep these things in check.
- 8:33I'm not really sure. Well, for sure, I mean.
- 8:36One thing that I will say though to to interject is that like,
- 8:40and this can happen for a lot longer than we expect and
- 8:42markets can buy at hook, line and sinker a little longer than
- 8:45we expect. But the one flying the ointment
- 8:47is that like you can jawbone markets up, you can jawbone,
- 8:51jawbone rates down. You cannot jawbone the price of
- 8:54oil down, right? It's just reality.
- 8:56So like West TX intermediate, around 100 bucks right now, but
- 8:59if Brent keeps climbing to 14151617180 and the countries
- 9:04around the world keep having to drain their petroleum reserves
- 9:07in order to put some downward pressure on price, things can
- 9:09get hairy really quickly. I'm sure we'll talk about it,
- 9:12but like, we already have 70% of farmers in the United States say
- 9:15that they don't have fertilizer for the year and they can't
- 9:18afford it. That's not good, right?
- 9:19For the viewers at home who might not know, fertilizer is
- 9:21how we grow food. So that's really bad.
- 9:25And so like all of these downstream effects is a result
- 9:27of really high oil prices. You can't print your way out of
- 9:29that. You can't job on your way out of
- 9:31that. So we can we can sort of kick
- 9:33the can and do this song and dance for a while until it
- 9:36becomes impossible to do and the the reality of 150 dollar $200
- 9:40oil if we get there sets in. Yeah, yeah, I, I like the fact
- 9:44that you also clarified what fertilizer is used for, because
- 9:47if you're like me, you just get slapped delivered to your door
- 9:50every day after work and you'd actually don't know how to make
- 9:52any food. I'm just kidding.
- 9:53But it's important, Joe, because you make the point about oil,
- 9:57right? And so it's really forcing the
- 9:58hand of the bond market, as we're discussing.
- 10:00It's also forcing the hand of monetary policy.
- 10:03And what everyone expected going into this year was going to be
- 10:06lower rates, lower rates, more stimulus.
- 10:08And now you have one of the biggest inputs into just about
- 10:10everything climbing much higher because of this war.
- 10:13And so it's really challenging now with wars coming in and
- 10:16actually just over a week now stepping in the obviously of
- 10:19Trump wanting rates lower. He's very vocal about that.
- 10:22But then all the data is kind of the data that is manipulated is
- 10:26still showing that inflation is higher than their target.
- 10:29And so we talked about it last week, which is an interesting
- 10:31one. And then Michael, want to get
- 10:32your thoughts. But the trimmed mean, so looking
- 10:35into new ways to measure inflation that actually would
- 10:37justify rates cuts. So it's like probably being as
- 10:39it's all a mess. It's a shit show to to use a
- 10:41play term. And Joe, I thought you made some
- 10:44really good points to to start the show off, so I appreciate
- 10:46that. For sure.
- 10:48You know the oh, go ahead, Michael.
- 10:50No, I was just saying I, I, I don't have much outside of
- 10:53there's a component here that we're not talking about that I
- 10:56don't think the market really knows or understands in the
- 11:00sense of the debt was already in an unsustainable place.
- 11:04The government knew that and still took the actions it took
- 11:07with Iran. And then I think we forget like
- 11:10they're pretty sophisticated people in the government.
- 11:13They would know the 2nd order effects of the straighter Hormuz
- 11:15being an option to be closed down.
- 11:17And then oil is a byproduct. So I feel like there's just
- 11:20another layer into this and I don't necessarily know what it
- 11:23is. I don't think anybody does.
- 11:24But I think like a good example is for it seems like 3 months
- 11:28now, some of the smartest, most sophisticated people were
- 11:31talking about the fertilizer shortage, the oil shortage, the
- 11:33price going, the unsustainable nature of sovereigns having to
- 11:37sell bonds to service oil needs for their own countries.
- 11:41What does that mean for the US? That's that's effectively
- 11:44understood by the government, But we're still persisting going
- 11:46down this path. So like, what is the plan?
- 11:48There's, there's just something else.
- 11:49I don't think they they're unaware of it.
- 11:53So yeah, not a lot of answers I'm giving outside of like, I
- 11:56don't, I think they're aware of these things.
- 11:58It's just what is the plan? I don't know.
- 12:01Sounds like some fed speak man. Fed speak indeed.
- 12:05Yeah, no, it's, it's really interesting and I think with
- 12:08wars coming in, you mentioned the trimmed me and Jackson.
- 12:11It's funny because now he's given 2 justifications for
- 12:15cutting rates when the market is like screaming that we should
- 12:18not cut rates. 10s are soaring to 4 1/2% as we saw earlier.
- 12:22So growth and inflation expectations are super high.
- 12:25The front end of the yield curve threes, one year twos, all of
- 12:29them are are screaming that the Fed should hike rates.
- 12:34If anything, Kevin Worsch is out here talking about trimmed mean
- 12:38inflation, which is, you know, it's a completely ridiculous
- 12:41metric that that removes even more things from CPICIF PCE.
- 12:46And then you have trimmed mean PC, which is even more dumbed
- 12:49down. And basically what it does is
- 12:52like CP is are standard, like urban consumer, out of pocket
- 12:57expenses, whatever. PCE trims that fat and then
- 13:02trims it trimmed mean PCE removes what it calls the noise,
- 13:05which means like extreme outliers.
- 13:07But if you wanted to accurately measure inflation, you wouldn't
- 13:10remove any outliers, right? Because these are all of the
- 13:13things that we purchase. And so it's, it's manipulation
- 13:16on top of manipulation. And it's funny because while CPI
- 13:20is hovered around 3% for well over a year.
- 13:24And lo and behold, the metric that Kevin Wash chooses to say
- 13:27is the real inflation metric has fallen to like 2.3%.
- 13:32It's been falling for 12 months straight, you know, So it's,
- 13:35it's all one big scam. And I have a feeling, I have
- 13:38this really bad feeling in my gut, that Warsh is going to cut
- 13:42rates regardless of what the data illustrates because he is
- 13:45politically mandated to, which would be unfortunate.
- 13:48Yeah. It is an inevitability though,
- 13:50to tie back in Michael, some of the points that you made.
- 13:53I wanted to bring this up on the, So first of all, this is
- 13:57not what I wanted to bring out, but I wanted to show it here
- 13:59before I we talked about what I want, I actually want to talk
- 14:01about. But this is just the Federal
- 14:03Reserve is starting to expand balance sheet specifically on
- 14:05U.S. Treasury.
- 14:06So we don't need to go deep here, but it just is tying into
- 14:09the themes we have been discussing where it's like they
- 14:11say one thing but they do another.
- 14:13The bond yields are spiking. There needs to be some buyers in
- 14:15the market. the Fed is there to position themselves.
- 14:18But the more important thing to touch on here from our friend
- 14:22Marty Bent would just be imagine waiting for a catalyst once you
- 14:25understand the fundamental value prop of Bitcoin.
- 14:28Stay humble and sacks that's and this is so important, right,
- 14:31because we're trying to discern what's going on and it's
- 14:33important. It's good to it's good to have
- 14:35an informed take and be aware of what's happening in the world
- 14:38and how it's going to affect your investment positions.
- 14:41But it's also important to remember that a lot of what
- 14:43we're talking about is on the path of what we already know
- 14:46where this all ends up. And so sometimes I get trapped
- 14:50in this like, yeah, what's the next catalyst?
- 14:52What it is like? Thank you, Marty, just for
- 14:53reminding me the fact that we don't really need a catalyst.
- 14:56We know what Bitcoin is. We know that it's really
- 14:58positioned well for the time we find ourselves in.
- 15:00And it's only going to become more well positioned just given
- 15:03all the circumstances we find from the debt, the money, the
- 15:06geopolitical tensions, the political strife domestically as
- 15:10well. So it's like Bitcoin is really
- 15:12well positioned as a savings technology to protect you
- 15:15against that. Yeah.
- 15:16And it just step back from there like before getting to the
- 15:19Bitcoin aspect because I think a lot of people would read that
- 15:21and be like, well, how did you get to Bitcoin?
- 15:23It's the realization, and maybe this is an answer to what I said
- 15:25earlier, was that because the math isn't math anymore,
- 15:29especially we could post 2020 with the amount of debt and
- 15:31monetary units inserted, that inflation has to consistently
- 15:35pick up year over year and on the margins if it's 12 or 14%.
- 15:40But you get this huge catalyst from a narrative perspective,
- 15:43meaning Iran, war, fertilizer, oil, that gives you the overhang
- 15:48to do what you need to do from a monetary policy perspective.
- 15:51I'm not saying that's why this is happening, but do you think
- 15:54it's important from the normally lens of where we're going is
- 15:57inflationary no matter which way you slice it?
- 16:00And then that's how you end up in hard assets as the solution
- 16:04to protect your wealth. Yeah, the I like Marty's tweet
- 16:09because the catalyst is just ever present insanity in the
- 16:14Fiat monetary system. And you only get to that point
- 16:18once you start to understand bitcoins fundamentals and why it
- 16:21solves for a lot of those things that we've seen metastasize over
- 16:25the past 50 years of Fiat, right.
- 16:28And so he put it in very simple terms.
- 16:31And it's not to say it's easy for people to get there, because
- 16:33it's not. We know it's not.
- 16:35We see it with the institutions who are still coming up to
- 16:39speed. We see it with our friends and
- 16:40family who, you know, we've been talking about Bitcoin for years
- 16:43and they still don't understand it necessarily.
- 16:45So it's not to say it's an easy chasm to cross, but you're
- 16:50right, Jackson, and that like, you don't need a specific
- 16:53trigger necessarily. Like you just need to start
- 16:55understanding what's been going on for a long time.
- 16:59Right. And that was the context I
- 17:01interpreted it as well where I almost took it.
- 17:04For people who are already invested or already pay
- 17:06attention to space, sometimes it's easy to try to discern what
- 17:10the catalyst is going to be. But there's really not in this
- 17:12case, I don't think going to be a particular catalyst to point
- 17:16to. It's really just going to be the
- 17:18culmination of these events that are taking place that are
- 17:20ultimately supportive for Bitcoin as a neutral monetary
- 17:24asset one. 100% right. It's like you mentioned, Brian,
- 17:29I like the way you framed it. The catalysts are ever present.
- 17:32This is a, it's a process. There isn't, you know, we don't
- 17:35wait every five years for the money printed a fire and then
- 17:38Bitcoin has an explosion and then chops around for five years
- 17:42and then has an explosion. You know, the reality, the
- 17:45mathematical reality facing the United States is very simple.
- 17:48We have a lot of debt. We have an increasing amount of
- 17:51debt. A larger and larger percentage
- 17:52of that is interest expense. Beyond a certain level, we
- 17:56cannot allow our interest expense to become the largest
- 17:58line item on our balance sheet as we're also raising the amount
- 18:01of debt that we're issuing. So as a mathematical function of
- 18:03that, we have to keep rates relatively low.
- 18:05What does that mean? More credit creation, more risk
- 18:07taking? And what is that?
- 18:08What serves as the greatest asset to absorb freshly printed
- 18:12money, IE credit that gets created out of thin air?
- 18:15It's Bitcoin, right? So this is a process.
- 18:17It's always expanding. Global money supply is always
- 18:20rising. Global credit is always being
- 18:22created. It's just a function of how
- 18:24quickly it's occurring, right? So I really like how how this is
- 18:28being framed. And it's one of my biggest
- 18:30points of contention with a lot of the Bitcoin critics.
- 18:32They'll say, hey, well, you know, global M2 is actually
- 18:35going down. What do you think about that?
- 18:36It's like, well, you know, ultimately that can't persist.
- 18:39And if you extrapolate out that that, that out to the rest of
- 18:41the world, they're in a much more dire situation from a debt
- 18:44perspective than we are. So imagine the situation in the
- 18:47US cranked up to 10 or 11, particularly in places like
- 18:49China. So it isn't an it's an
- 18:51inevitability. A Bitcoin is is destined to
- 18:54rise, and some years it will rise exponentially faster than
- 18:59others. Yeah.
- 19:01And to your point, Joe, this is a global phenomenon we're we're
- 19:04talking about. We've been talking about the US
- 19:06for most of the debt conversation, but the UKI mean
- 19:09it's another great economy to point to where there's about 3
- 19:12trillion or so in national debt and interest payments on the
- 19:14debt are over $100 billion annually.
- 19:17And that already exceeds the defense budget of that country
- 19:19as well. And so you're getting to this
- 19:20point where higher interest rates are just a forcing
- 19:23function for the debt spiral. And obviously we need lower
- 19:26rates. To your point on ramp finance is
- 19:28live and the Genesis program just launched.
- 19:30Over half the spots are already gone and once they are claimed,
- 19:33they are gone for good. The 1st 210 signups get one year
- 19:36free of multi institution custody.
- 19:38Highest on ramp rewards to your earn up to 5 percent, 1 1/2%
- 19:43cash back on every swipe. A signed copy of Gradually then
- 19:47Suddenly by Parker Lewis, 21,000 cents deposited into your
- 19:51account upon activation. Sign up in 5 minutes on
- 19:54rampbitcoin.com. Use the code TLT and do not
- 19:57wait. Once the sponsor claimed the
- 19:59Genesis program closes for good. If I want to shift gear gears
- 20:03here, Chad, can we determine if this is a catalyst or not?
- 20:08We have to continue on the theme.
- 20:09Michael had a good take. I want to get to as well.
- 20:12On Morgan Stanley launching Bitcoin trading on their E*Trade
- 20:15platform, so it's about 9 million clients and how are they
- 20:19competing? Well, they're competing on
- 20:20cheaper fees. So we've touched on the fact
- 20:22that Charles Schwab is also planning to launch in the first
- 20:25half of this year to their 12 million client base, spot
- 20:29trading, custody of Bitcoin and I think the other few major
- 20:33digital assets, some may say, but now you have Morgan Stanley
- 20:36stepping in. They've also had an incredibly
- 20:38successful ETF launch. And it begs the question, well,
- 20:42why is this happening? And it's happening for a couple
- 20:44of different reasons. First is people want or these
- 20:47firms want people to stay on their platform.
- 20:49They want to generate revenue. They don't want people leaving
- 20:51and taking that activity away from the platform.
- 20:54And then the second piece is what they're doing it because
- 20:57they see that there is a clear trend in terms of demographics
- 21:01toward Bitcoin, toward the digital asset space.
- 21:04Younger people are allocating more meaningfully to the space.
- 21:06And so they want to get positioned for the $80 trillion
- 21:09of wealth that is being passed from the boomers to younger
- 21:11generations over the next couple decades.
- 21:13And then it begs the question, like, how do they actually
- 21:15compete here? And so it's really coming down
- 21:17to fees because everything's commoditized and there's very
- 21:20little different differentiation.
- 21:22And I just point this out because we saw the same thing
- 21:25with the Morgan Stanley ETF launch as well, where they were
- 21:28just under undercutting BlackRock by about half of the
- 21:30bips on their on the product there as well.
- 21:34And then you have Eric Balchunas, the one of the loyal
- 21:36listeners of the last trade. He says Morgan Stanley is
- 21:39rolling crypto trading on its E*Trade platform for 50 bits of
- 21:42trade, undercutting Schwab 75 bits.
- 21:45If we know, if I know Schwab, they likely won't let this
- 21:48stand. Others will probably undercut
- 21:50too. By the time the dust settles,
- 21:52it'll be pretty dirt cheap to create to trade crypto
- 21:55everywhere, just as we saw with the Bitcoin ETF expense ratios
- 21:58prior to the launch. This is why Triadfy is no joke
- 22:01and crypto exchanges should be scared.
- 22:04So that last point, Michael, I think you have some takes on
- 22:07because we're going to everything being commoditized.
- 22:09You're going to exchanges trying to keep their base, like let's
- 22:14say crypto, Bitcoin native exchanges trying to keep their
- 22:16base. And they're going to have to
- 22:17compete with these giants that are providing a very similar
- 22:20solution, but they're going to be able to drastically undercut
- 22:23them on call. So what are your thoughts there?
- 22:27Yeah, I think there's there's two before going directly to
- 22:31just like business strategy. I think this is something I
- 22:35stumbled on talking with Joe last week.
- 22:37I believe in Braun, there's there's a true like aspect of
- 22:41the machine. It's not popular to talk about,
- 22:43but it's something that I've been like dancing around in my
- 22:46mind around the notion of like bitcoins been stuck or pegged
- 22:51between this 80 to 120 K band and it'll move when the machines
- 22:54ready for it to move and not a second before.
- 22:56And there's precedent for this. We've seen gold sit around its
- 22:59price for a very long time. And part of it was stumbling on
- 23:03this notion of, well, why haven't sovereigns adopted
- 23:05Bitcoin? And there's real reasons why
- 23:07when you think about IMF and reliance on dollars and swap
- 23:10lines and you don't want to poke the bear.
- 23:13We saw El Salvador, what happened there?
- 23:14We've even seen other countries be super obscure or opaque with
- 23:19their stacking. Like, you know, Bhutan, UAE is
- 23:22using mining as their source versus swapping dollars.
- 23:25So point being is that I think there's been this strategy of
- 23:29going back to the ETF of this was going to get integrated into
- 23:32the financial system. And a lot of the incumbents, the
- 23:35Morgan Stanley's, the Fidelity of the Schwab needed to turn all
- 23:38these all this plumbing on. They went from the internal
- 23:41mechanism and stigma that this is rat poison square to now.
- 23:44Oh, we got to like go and compete against each other in
- 23:47the market to onboard. And so as these firms come into
- 23:50place for liquidity, we'll naturally see that narrative go.
- 23:55Inflation will run and that's when the price of Bitcoin will
- 23:57go. Why I'm bringing all of that up
- 23:59is because the 6040 is pervasive and I think that when you look
- 24:03at like traditional crossing the chasm as you go in you, you're
- 24:06going to pragmatist buyers. Pragmatist buyers want to buy
- 24:09out of their traditional brokerage or portfolio.
- 24:11They don't want to go somewhere else.
- 24:13So that is the version of Schwab, Morgan Stanley, Fidelity
- 24:16coming in now the thing that being in in having worked in a
- 24:20space and building a space for a while now started to dawn on me
- 24:23that the genius act and clarity post that you were really going
- 24:26to have to compete because free those acts being in place.
- 24:32None of these firms were offering any of these services.
- 24:34So it made complete sense if you were an early adopter, it wasn't
- 24:38a foreign, you know, foreign action to send the wire, figure
- 24:42out how to buy the Bitcoin, figure out how to take it into a
- 24:44cold storage. That's what an early adopter had
- 24:47to do. But ultimately a lot of that is
- 24:49going to be commoditized and obvious dated from the boomer,
- 24:53the retail market to go by here. And these firms have so much
- 24:57lock in when you think about your loans, your mortgage, your
- 24:59credit cards, your bank account, your equities, that it's the
- 25:02rational user behavior just to stay within that portfolio,
- 25:06especially if they're undercutting or doing comparable
- 25:08fees, even if they're 10 bits more expensive than pick your
- 25:11favorite stacking SAT's exchange.
- 25:13Most net new buyers are going to go there.
- 25:15And also probably existing buyers.
- 25:17If that experience ties in all your traditional life.
- 25:20Think about cross collateralization for a
- 25:21mortgage, like if you can keep those Bitcoin and then also
- 25:24cross collateralize. So I think this was easily
- 25:27forecasted and it was part of like the big reason for us to
- 25:29start to look more like a traditional brokerage and offer
- 25:32in dollar accounts, earn rewards and then really have that
- 25:35differentiation with multi institution.
- 25:37Because I think the thing that the market's going to get lulled
- 25:39to sleep at is if the products free, you are the product in the
- 25:43sense that if custody is free, they're telling you it's not
- 25:46really worth much. This was a big thing from the
- 25:50market, investors, others. It's like custody shouldn't cost
- 25:53anything in Bitcoin. And all that told me was they're
- 25:55very unsophisticated because ultimately the delta between you
- 25:59holding any Bitcoin or no Bitcoin is literally how you
- 26:02custody it. So if you have this room to go
- 26:05from zero to 10,000 or 10,000 to $100,000 asset or 100,000 to
- 26:091,000,000 and the difference in you having it or not having is
- 26:12literally how you custody it. That's what we've seen from FTX,
- 26:14Celsius, Block 5 hardware devices.
- 26:16Then the market will pay for that on a long enough time
- 26:19horizon if they feel confident in the underlying custody.
- 26:22And so it's going to be an interesting to see how this
- 26:26plays out because I think the existing incumbents are going to
- 26:28take a lot of market share because their custody looks
- 26:30exactly the same as everyone else's.
- 26:32And that's going to be the net differentiator on a long enough
- 26:34time horizon. Because unless everyone thinks
- 26:36that North Korea is going to stop state sanction hacking
- 26:40attempts and physical bad actors, and there's not going to
- 26:42be any third party, you know, hacks with AI, then there's
- 26:45going to be a realization that you need to change on the
- 26:47custody side. Very, very well said, right?
- 26:52It's, we're, we're entering into an era where you know, when,
- 26:57when you start to see these shops competing on fees, that's
- 27:02how, when you know, that's how you know, Bitcoin is sort of one
- 27:04out. And it's, it's sort of moved
- 27:06into the mainstream at long last.
- 27:08And this was an announcement that I was not expecting to be
- 27:10very clear. Like I thought Morgan Stanley
- 27:13with their ETF, they would stop there and then maybe they would
- 27:17launch spot Bitcoin trading a year from now after seeing how
- 27:20successful it was. But the fact that this was and,
- 27:23and again, this is sort of skewed data because they only
- 27:25have 9 ETF launches ever or 11, but the fact that it was their
- 27:30best ETF launch in history drove them to do this much, much
- 27:33sooner than later. So it's for me, you know, it's
- 27:35another feather in the cap of Bitcoin.
- 27:37It's another piece of the pipe that has been laid for
- 27:40invariably when the next Bitcoin bull market comes, the
- 27:42infrastructure will be down for people of all stripes, whatever
- 27:46types of Bitcoin they want to buy, whether they want to buy
- 27:48the ETF, spot Bitcoin, etcetera. Yeah.
- 27:50One thing just to add is it wasn't necessarily surprising
- 27:54from market forces, but also at least in my perspective, if you
- 27:59looked, I think right when the ETF launched, Morgan Stanley had
- 28:02real interesting research or like marketing that was
- 28:04explaining the difference between a spot allocation and
- 28:07then an ETF. And the way I perceive that was
- 28:10that they along with other private wealth firms understand
- 28:15that they have sophisticated clients and they understand they
- 28:17want Smas and they want other assurances with the underlying
- 28:20when they go get significant exposure.
- 28:23So it was the rational behavior. If they're really in this, which
- 28:26I think Morgan Stanley, Fidelity in my view are the most
- 28:28sophisticated in that they're building out their own custody.
- 28:31Fidelity has their own Morgan Stanley is signaled that they're
- 28:33building out custody for themselves and then that you
- 28:36would offer different kinds of products and exposures for
- 28:39people that just want to buy a security type exposure in an ETF
- 28:42or if you want spot. And so they kind of signaled
- 28:46that they understand where the market's going to go.
- 28:48And I think the opposite is kind of like Schwab because Schwab
- 28:51really flipped on a dime and also they kind of outsourced
- 28:54everything to Paxos. And so it'll be interesting to
- 28:58see how that plays long term because I think Morgan Stanley
- 29:00looks at this is there's a lot of room for the price to
- 29:02appreciate. And not that it's a loss leader,
- 29:05but if they can get their brand associated with Bitcoin and get
- 29:08more of that Bitcoin within their like domain, they can
- 29:11monetize that as the price appreciates in the future versus
- 29:14somebody like Schwab offering transactional like exposure.
- 29:18If they don't get known for doing best in class, those
- 29:20assets are going to lead to somebody like Fidelity or Morgan
- 29:23Stanley. Yeah, I agree with all that.
- 29:26I think the a couple things to just like pull out from there is
- 29:30like the order of operations show to your point and the speed
- 29:33at which a Morgan Stanley is going about.
- 29:35This is I think an important signal in terms of OK, let's do
- 29:40the ETF, let's compete head to head with BlackRock.
- 29:42But at the same time we know people are going to want spot
- 29:45and let's also build out custody in the background or at least
- 29:47signal that we're going to do that.
- 29:48And that's all come together like relatively quickly.
- 29:51Like this is we are beyond sort of the stage of the institutions
- 29:57dipping their toe like this is playing to win, playing for
- 30:00keeps, playing across different verticals and different vectors
- 30:03of the asset class in in pretty short order.
- 30:07So I think that that's super important.
- 30:09Then Mike to your point on sort of the the longer term signal
- 30:14and why they would be OK with undercutting fees potentially
- 30:18having these products or services being loss leaders at
- 30:22least in the interim figure? Exactly right.
- 30:25It's because it actually tells you they're bullish on the
- 30:27asset, not just making fees from it.
- 30:29It tells you that they think Bitcoin goes up over time and
- 30:32you want to get closest to the asset.
- 30:33You want to have clients that have material exposure this
- 30:36thing so that as it monetizes, as it grows, you can continue to
- 30:41monetize your clients assets as as the Bitcoin appreciates.
- 30:45So I think that is also a significant tell in that they're
- 30:47just bullish on the asset. It's not that they're just
- 30:50because I think early on with the ETFs, it was like, you know,
- 30:52I think there was some narrative of like, well, Blackrock's just
- 30:55doing this because they can make fees.
- 30:56It's like this is a little bit different.
- 30:58Like if they're going to just undercut on fees, then they're
- 31:01not just doing it for fees. They're doing it to be close to
- 31:03the asset and watch this thing monetize and, and, and you know,
- 31:07earn revenue from it over time, over the long term.
- 31:11Yeah, I think those are great points that the main thing that
- 31:13sticks out to me is sometimes you hear people in the comments
- 31:16section or just generally online, you hear people say,
- 31:19well, of course these firms are going to launch products.
- 31:22They just want to make money from it.
- 31:23They don't really have any dog in the fight.
- 31:25But I think Brian and Michael, you guys made some great points
- 31:27just on the fact that these, yes, that's true.
- 31:31They want to make money from it. Of course, I mean, that's good
- 31:33business. But there's also, if you look
- 31:35more into the details on how they're positioning themselves,
- 31:38they really do expect Bitcoin to succeed long term.
- 31:41Now, if we can shift gears here, because again, we have to move
- 31:44through a number of topics fairly quickly, I want to touch
- 31:49on what happened with Coinbase this week.
- 31:52Coinbase is relevant, of course, because they're the largest
- 31:54custodian. They custody, I think over 2
- 31:57million Bitcoin. So over 10% of the terminal, 21
- 32:01million supply, over 10% if you account for Bitcoin that's been
- 32:04permanently lost like 3 to 4:00-ish million.
- 32:07And look, when we talk about commoditization in this
- 32:11industry, we're pretty much talking about who can win on
- 32:14fees and we're talking about who has the best Coinbase rapper.
- 32:18Outside of a few major players, virtually everyone is using
- 32:21Coinbase. And this is problematic for a
- 32:23number of reasons we don't need to get into today.
- 32:25But the tweet I have up in front of me is Brian Armstrong
- 32:28followed suit from a few other notable CE OS in recent months
- 32:34and shared the e-mail that he sent to his team where he laid
- 32:37off 14% of the workforce. Now this actually one against
- 32:41the kind of the thesis that I have where I think longer term
- 32:44that AI cited layoffs are actually the new form of
- 32:48financial engineering and stock buybacks because Coinbase went
- 32:52down yesterday. But I think it had partly couple
- 32:55things to point out here, partly the first part about where he
- 32:57says why now is he didn't really have confidence in this message
- 33:01about just the the direction of the industry.
- 33:04So he's talking about, oh, well, poor me, we're in a bear market
- 33:08and you know, we're still doing well.
- 33:09We've weathered these storms before, but the market's not
- 33:12great essentially is the first is the first point he makes.
- 33:15He also we could talk about some of the things he mentions
- 33:18cryptos on the next wave of adoption with stablecoins.
- 33:21OK. And that that's all right.
- 33:22Prediction markets, OK, I don't know about that one.
- 33:25Tokenization, yeah, but I think there's some merit there in
- 33:28terms of at least making money in terms of providing rails.
- 33:31So this is a note that he shared.
- 33:33You can check it out online if you'd like.
- 33:35And then he also sites, of course, AI.
- 33:37Just a few notable things here. AI is changing work, getting rid
- 33:41of kind of like the managerial class.
- 33:42Everyone needs to be using this stuff.
- 33:45AI native pods like building out teams kind of around agent
- 33:48swarms where people can manage all these different areas of the
- 33:50business. And then I think one thing that
- 33:53was kind of humorous, if I can find it was essentially some
- 33:57people are making comments about how Coinbase largest custodian
- 33:59managers, security, etcetera, etcetera.
- 34:01And you have non-technical teams who are now shipping production
- 34:04code and many of their work flows are being automated.
- 34:06I mean, I thought that was funny jab some people made online.
- 34:10But gentlemen, what do you guys think of this news coming out of
- 34:12Coinbase this week? I think, right, I think the most
- 34:17ironic thing, right? Do we all remember a couple of
- 34:20months ago when for whatever reason, Coinbase bought like a
- 34:24$100 million NFT from Kobe on crypto Twitter to start his
- 34:29podcast again? So I mean, how many salaries is
- 34:32that for Coinbase's employees? Like they could have easily
- 34:34redo, they, they could have, you know, not reduced headcount by
- 34:37an additional 5 or 6% with that alone.
- 34:39So I mean, I think it's it's to me, in my mind, it's it's sort
- 34:44of scapegoating, right? Like we know broadly crypto,
- 34:48quote UN quote, non Bitcoin, you know, assets apart from stable
- 34:52coins are dying. They're largely dying on the
- 34:54fund. Now that people can gamble the
- 34:56old fashioned way by downloading polymarket on their phone and
- 34:59betting on the weather, what's the point of trying to 100 X
- 35:02your money on meme coins, right? So Coinbase is having a really
- 35:07difficult time finding its identity and value proposition
- 35:09in a world where you can just gamble anywhere.
- 35:12You don't need to do it with crypto.
- 35:13And so that's why you're seeing them introduce other things like
- 35:15stock trading, prediction markets, etcetera.
- 35:19It's sort of, you know, this platforms attempt at gasping for
- 35:25air and becoming relevant in a world where non Bitcoin crypto
- 35:28is is sort of dying. So I think here it's a scapegoat
- 35:31with block a couple of weeks ago, I think it was more
- 35:33legitimate. But I think either way, both of
- 35:35these companies are probably going to find that this isn't
- 35:39the most optimal way of leveraging AI within your
- 35:43company. And I'm curious to hear
- 35:44Michael's thoughts. In my mind, you know, you can
- 35:46make the individual workers more productive, but ultimately
- 35:51bringing on new hires is still something that you need to do.
- 35:54I think after an initial culling, you know, admit it, the
- 35:57initial culling may make some sense.
- 35:59But rather than a loss to head count, I think if anything,
- 36:02because it's such a productivity boon, you would want to hire
- 36:05more people, particularly more people who are capable with AI.
- 36:08But yeah, Lee, I'll, I'll pass it to you, Michael, because I'm
- 36:10curious to hear your take as someone who actually runs a
- 36:12company. Yeah, I think aside from like
- 36:16work changing, it's funny because he was at Airbnb and
- 36:19there was actually a fantastic pod that came out two days ago
- 36:21from Brian Chesky talking about the nature of work changing and
- 36:25inefficiencies. I think we all know that's there
- 36:27and this is probably a scapegoat.
- 36:29I think what's more alarming that doesn't get discussed
- 36:32enough is he's not really that impressive of a guy.
- 36:36Like, I didn't read that, but that doesn't surprise me that he
- 36:40said, you know, just from an optics perspective, people that
- 36:43are non-technical shipping code. Because I saw some clips a few
- 36:46months ago where he was referencing, you know, very like
- 36:50in an aloof way, like somebody brought up stable coins.
- 36:53He's like, that's a dumb idea. And he's like, lucky for me they
- 36:56didn't listen to me and like their stable coin exposure.
- 36:59Like even if that's true, it's probably not like the smarter
- 37:01you can like tactfully say it better.
- 37:03But why I'm bringing this up is because to what you and Jackson
- 37:06talked about, I think like the thing that the market really
- 37:10misses and what we're sticking our neck out and I think firms
- 37:13that will win long term. Rivers, another example is
- 37:16Bitcoin is just money. It's the best form of money
- 37:18we've ever seen. And it's a form of money we
- 37:20think that a large percentage of the market will adopt.
- 37:23And if you come at it from that lens, then you fundamentally
- 37:27treat it from every level in a different way from a business
- 37:30perspective. And that's the thing I think
- 37:32crypto forgets and sometimes on the Bitcoin side, that if it's
- 37:36money, money requires financial services and financial services
- 37:39are relationship driven. So you have to be there and
- 37:41present and then they're somewhat localized.
- 37:43And so the notion to be an everything company and service
- 37:46everything is just a recipe for not only, I don't want to say
- 37:50recipe for not being successful, but potentially disaster because
- 37:53your attack surface is so broad. And you see this kind of in the
- 37:56market being it should, it should scare people when it
- 37:59comes to these large institutions that are leaving
- 38:01their assets with Coinbase. Because if you think about it,
- 38:04Coinbase has this like large position in Bitcoin from
- 38:08custody, but it's nobody with their own material welfare.
- 38:11It's my understanding anecdotally.
- 38:13And and also you can see this where it's not somebody with
- 38:161000 Bitcoin that goes to Coinbase.
- 38:17It's institutions that are sitting on thousands, hundreds
- 38:22of thousands of millions of people's Bitcoin and very small
- 38:24immaterial sizes. And they're all being put at
- 38:27Coinbase because that's what the administration, that's what the
- 38:30regulatory apparatus, that's what the SEC has deemed as like
- 38:32the place to go. So it's this really counter like
- 38:36paradox where you have this firm that's not solely focused on
- 38:40Bitcoin. And you can see this empirically
- 38:41from like their balance sheet and how much Bitcoin had been
- 38:44stacking like their products and services, what they offer around
- 38:47it, how much they talk about it. I think there's a lot of memes
- 38:49on Twitter talking about like I got laid off from I don't know
- 38:51how true or I think somebody was actually true and then everyone
- 38:54else but memes off, which was they were working on Bitcoin and
- 38:58then they came out to say I was the guy that was supposed to be
- 38:59working on Bitcoin and we never got any burn or whatever.
- 39:02Or like, I was the guy that worked at TSAI just got fired.
- 39:04I was the guy responsible for making everyone take their shoes
- 39:06off. Or something.
- 39:08And so it's just this notion. There's a lot of anecdotes out
- 39:10there. There's no fat focus on Bitcoin.
- 39:12You see this via the product services and marketing.
- 39:14And then you have them holding all this bitcoins, which should
- 39:17just give a lot of people a pause because everyone comes out
- 39:20and says, well, it's Coinbase. Like of course, like what do
- 39:22you, what do you mean? Their permissions are the best
- 39:24and all of it. And I just don't.
- 39:26I just think that's the most like interesting part and also
- 39:29potentially scary part. Yeah, you guys both hit on on
- 39:34something there, which I think is very true.
- 39:37And it's, it's like kind of a microcosm for the entire crypto
- 39:40space over the past decade. And, and Coinbase is like the
- 39:42poster child for it of like if you're everything to everyone,
- 39:46like you're kind of nothing. And I think there's a few areas
- 39:50that you can look at within Coinbase's business over the
- 39:52years that would point exactly to that.
- 39:54Like if you look at Coinbase Ventures, so their venture arm,
- 39:57they've basically invested in every single crypto project
- 40:00that's ever existed, more or less.
- 40:03And so like that sort of like spray and pray, we need to be
- 40:07involved in everything just shows you really don't have like
- 40:10a grasp on where the value is going to accrue over the long
- 40:13term. Like obviously they should have
- 40:15been more focused on Bitcoin over the past decade.
- 40:19They were focused on stable coins, but I think that was kind
- 40:21of like luck as as a result of being focused outside Bitcoin
- 40:25and seeing stable coins proliferate around around
- 40:29Bitcoin. And then the other thing I was,
- 40:32I was going to note was like Jackson, like you're, you know,
- 40:35the AI layoffs being the new stock buyback, like I still
- 40:38think that that will work. But I, I, I do think it's going
- 40:41to be case by case. And I think the market is
- 40:44naturally getting better at discerning like who's doing it
- 40:48in a legit way or not. And I think one of the reasons
- 40:51that you could point to why the market perceived this is not
- 40:54legit in terms of like that narrative and that story was
- 40:58that Coinbase fired 20% of their staff in 2022.
- 41:01So like they've done this before where they fire a ton of people
- 41:05and then they just over hire again and then they fire a ton
- 41:07of people. So like, who's to say they're
- 41:09not just going to over hire again?
- 41:11Or at least like, you know, you can just look at the AI sort of
- 41:15excuse as the scapegoat because like you guys have done this
- 41:19before where you just are clearly you don't have a, a real
- 41:23intentional focus around sort of the, the ethos or the vision of
- 41:26the business. You say you, you're
- 41:29democratizing finance, but now you're focused on prediction
- 41:31markets and adding stocks. It's like, you know, it's just
- 41:36it, there's a lot of incongruencies with their
- 41:38message, their story. And I think so.
- 41:39I think that's kind of why the, you know, the market's not
- 41:41buying it in terms of this explanation.
- 41:44And just one thing to add to that, we truly are in uncharted
- 41:46territory. When you think about there's
- 41:48like a confluence of things happening.
- 41:49One is you have this asset that is monetizing in real time.
- 41:52We've never seen it at these prices for a persist like a long
- 41:55enough time. And we're, if we're all bullish
- 41:57here, we think we're going into six figures and beyond.
- 42:00You have the notion of I believe it's 5% of GDP for North Korea
- 42:05and state sanctioned hackers. That's only going to increase.
- 42:07That's going to increase across other sovereigns, meaning that
- 42:10where most of the hacking from sovereigns, specifically North
- 42:14Korea's like embedding themselves into organizations
- 42:17via social engineering because as the honeypot grows, the ROI,
- 42:20you could take longer. We saw this with Bibet and
- 42:22others. And then the biggest one that
- 42:24nobody's talking about is with the proliferation of AI and all
- 42:26these tools that it gets a lot easier to effectively manipulate
- 42:30and potentially hack anything. So you have all those things
- 42:35happening. You have this native digital
- 42:37asset that's six figures and beyond.
- 42:39And then you have the central honey pot that's increasingly
- 42:42non focus. It just doesn't feel good for
- 42:46like, whether it's them or somebody else that everyone just
- 42:48assumes that this whole notion of custody is figured out and
- 42:52we're just going to get slapped, you know, in the face with it.
- 42:54And like, this is that example because Brian hit on a perfect
- 42:57point. It's like everyone in this space
- 42:59knows that the market gets real frothy.
- 43:01And then you start to hire a bunch of people and you're it's
- 43:03OK. Like fool me once, but fool me
- 43:04twice is a different story. Because those layoffs in 2022,
- 43:08almost everyone did and because of the market took off.
- 43:11But then you're starting to see that in the Bitcoin space and in
- 43:14the crypto space again, because the market took off, went into
- 43:16six figures, and it did this retrace.
- 43:18And now you just sit there with all this headcount, your
- 43:21revenues decreased and you're wondering what the hell to do,
- 43:24which I think this is what this was mostly about.
- 43:27Yeah. The, the only other thing I'll
- 43:28mention which relates to our previous topic was like the, the
- 43:32reaction to the stock this week could have just been that Morgan
- 43:34Stanley is, is, is undercutting fees on trading Like that could
- 43:37have been related to it as well as like there's real competition
- 43:40now in, in sort of the exchange and and trade arena.
- 43:46Yeah, well, no one will have to wonder if On Ramp does layoffs
- 43:50because if you just don't see me on the podcast, at some point
- 43:52you'll know I'm the first to go. So there's no.
- 43:55Or that's when a GIAGI we have Methos or whatever, because
- 43:58we'll just have you still showing up for the pod, but you
- 44:02won't. I don't consent to that.
- 44:04Let's just don't. Buy you as intellectual
- 44:06property, and then your avatar costs one half of what you do.
- 44:09Jackson, we're so sorry. Yeah, I know, Joe.
- 44:13I'm expecting it. So.
- 44:14That's the real, that's the real sorry.
- 44:16It's the real 3D version of having Jackson every week is so
- 44:18we get enough data to train the BOD so we can we can
- 44:22effectively. We're close.
- 44:24I think we're close. We're close.
- 44:26How many more episodes? Just so I'm aware.
- 44:30All right, so we'll get, let's, let's roll through a couple of
- 44:32things here. Whether you've been in Bitcoin
- 44:34for 10 months or 10 years, managing your Bitcoin wealth has
- 44:37been a fragmented experience. One place to buy, another to
- 44:41custody. A patchwork of providers for
- 44:43your IRA, your loans, your estate plan, and everything in
- 44:47between. Every additional platform is
- 44:49another point of failure, and that is why we built on Ramp
- 44:52Finance, a unified platform for your entire Bitcoin life.
- 44:57Enhanced brokerage. Cash bearing accounts with earn
- 44:59rates up to 5%. A card that earns cash back that
- 45:03you can use to stack more Bitcoin.
- 45:05Multi institution custody, Iras and built in inheritance
- 45:08planning all under one roof. The genesis program is live and
- 45:13spots are filling up fast. You can sign up in 5 minutes at
- 45:16on rampbitcoin.com and use the code TLT to lock in one year
- 45:21free of multi institution custody and our highest earn
- 45:24rate. I'm just going to throw some
- 45:26shit at the wall and then you guys can tell me what you want
- 45:29to talk about. So here's one I Brian, you
- 45:32mentioned layoffs, right, with a Coinbase and or are they going
- 45:36to do a next cycle? Maybe there's no next cycle for
- 45:38Coinbase because all of their crypto casino traffic is going
- 45:42to Polymarket where you have 67% of polymarket profits going to
- 45:47just .1% of accounts. While most traders are in the
- 45:50red, most Kaushi users are also losing money.
- 45:53So yeah, I mean, this is something we've talked quite a
- 45:56bit about. Gambling is one of the fastest
- 45:59growing financial sectors there are, and a lot of people, one of
- 46:03the prescribed different reasons as to why that is, I would
- 46:05generally just say it's because there's a lot of societal
- 46:08despair. Younger people don't feel like
- 46:10they can get ahead, and this is kind of the new and exciting
- 46:14shiny way to gamble on whatever you want.
- 46:17So I'm very bullish on Bitcoin in the context of being very
- 46:21bearish on crypto because a lot of what you saw in 20/20/21,
- 46:25even as far back as 2017, was just essentially gambling on
- 46:30shit coins. And a lot of people are down 99%
- 46:33on those bags and they're utterly devastated.
- 46:36But the behavior hasn't changed. And so a lot of that behaviors
- 46:38ended up on these prediction market platforms.
- 46:41And probably it's going to get worse.
- 46:43I mean, I don't see why these prediction markets don't
- 46:45continue to explode to the upside in terms of popularity,
- 46:48unless for some reason it's regulation related.
- 46:51But this is one thing that caught my attention and then a
- 46:54few other things. We could go tie this back into
- 46:57AI as well. There's a good amount of
- 47:00information here, but this is from TFTC.
- 47:02They're just sharing a, a chart here with some context just
- 47:06about Goldman, Goldman Sachs saying 95% of enterprises are
- 47:10getting 0 return on 30 to $40 billion in generative AI
- 47:13spending. And so I think this ties back to
- 47:17the last topic on Coinbase, because AI is a great scapegoat
- 47:21for layoffs. I do think that there is a lot
- 47:23of legitimacy there as well. We feel this here at On Ramp for
- 47:25people who are using AI on a daily basis as like, you know,
- 47:29as part of a consumer, let's say the consumer agents, it's
- 47:32providing a ton of value. But I think you cannot just as a
- 47:35company, like a large company, Goldman and the companies that
- 47:38they're referencing are spending all this money on AI, but it
- 47:41doesn't mean they actually know how to use any of these tools.
- 47:43And so there's a lot of inefficiency that's still being
- 47:45worked out here. And then this chart is
- 47:46interesting as well where you can just kind of see real
- 47:50tokenomics, right? Remember tokenomics from
- 47:52shitcoins? Real tokenomics is when we're
- 47:53talking about token usage for these different platforms.
- 47:57And so you can get a sense here where consumer agent workloads
- 48:01could dramatically increase token consumption, leading to
- 48:0410X token consumption by 20-30. I mean, we're all using this
- 48:07everyday, Joe, I imagine you are as well.
- 48:09And man, I can't get enough tokens.
- 48:11I'm trying to find a token dealer who can hook me up there.
- 48:14And the last piece here, I just, I thought this is kind of a
- 48:17funny way to put it. Jamie Dimon reveals that he had
- 48:20his first experience with Claude this past weekend.
- 48:23I mean without context that could mean a couple of
- 48:26different. I don't know why, but calling it
- 48:27an experience sounds dirty. It certainly does.
- 48:31So gentlemen, I'm going to throw a couple things out there.
- 48:33What do you guys want to riff on?
- 48:35Well, I also found this funny. I will shout out Polly Market.
- 48:39They've got a pretty good Twitter account.
- 48:41They they put out some good tweets here and there.
- 48:43I guess back to the prediction market deal, like that data,
- 48:46that data has been consistent ever ever since these things
- 48:52really started to crop up years ago in that they're basically
- 48:58worse than like walking into a casino in terms of your expected
- 49:02value as someone participating in it.
- 49:06And so I think that's why it's particularly pervasive and and
- 49:12somewhat nefarious in the sense that like people, people know
- 49:16going into a casino, like walking on the casino floor,
- 49:19like, you know, you're gambling, you know, you probably aren't
- 49:21going to win, but it's fun. There's an element to it that
- 49:24people enjoy with prediction markets like you are, you're
- 49:28tapping into and taking advantage of someone's like
- 49:31perceived knowledge on something.
- 49:35And like the reality is most people have no idea what's going
- 49:38to happen. And so, yeah, most people lose
- 49:41on these things. Side note, like I did see some
- 49:45other data that was related to this that basically like,
- 49:48because people are, you know, people have all these like
- 49:51trading bots that they build with AI to trade on polymarket.
- 49:54And some of those actually, you know, can do well.
- 49:58And I think that's probably where some of the actual
- 50:01winnings are, are sort of coalescing around.
- 50:04But one of the, the data points, I forget the exact numbers, but
- 50:07it was like, if you just bet no on on anything, like across the
- 50:11board, like you're better, you're better off because like
- 50:14have the natural incentive to think something's going to
- 50:16happen. They think they know something
- 50:18and like, Oh yeah, that's going to happen by X state or
- 50:20whatever. And like if you just Orient to
- 50:21like nothing ever happens, you end up doing better than most.
- 50:25Yeah, there was another stat from like I think it was
- 50:29political, politically related bets that were marked at 25%
- 50:34likelihood 50% of the time it won, right.
- 50:39So theoretically should be 25% of the time and 50% of those.
- 50:42But just to spice it up before jokes, I'm sure he has a couple
- 50:44thoughts on all that is over under what you guys think on
- 50:47that 65% in people in the the red on DATS.
- 50:52Goodness gracious. Probably well over, I'd say,
- 50:55because. You all do it.
- 50:56Yeah, you also have to lump in the gosh, you also have to lump
- 50:59in all the crypto ones. We forget about that, right?
- 51:02Which is the Bitcoin ones? Which is It's a Bitcoin show
- 51:04the. Bitcoin ones easily, yeah.
- 51:06Easy over, right? So that's as bad as what we just
- 51:09talked about. The dat has people and the
- 51:11insiders at .1%. But either way, I digress.
- 51:14No, you're right, and I mean like with polymarket
- 51:16specifically, it's so nefarious and I don't hate many things
- 51:21right? As a Christian, we're not called
- 51:22to hate, but I absolutely hate gambling.
- 51:23I despise gambling and the fact that it's packaged in the way
- 51:27that it is is so disgusting and nefarious.
- 51:29Like, you have it, it's just the latest in a long line of exit
- 51:33liquidity schemes, right? The crypto people are all
- 51:36jumping over to prediction markets, and for very good
- 51:38reason, because everybody knows that crypto is a scam.
- 51:42You look at the reactions to Coinbase's Super Bowl
- 51:46commercial. Everyone was screaming at their
- 51:48television when the Coinbase logo came up.
- 51:50For good reason. You either know someone or you
- 51:53yourself lost a ton of money on something that you bought on
- 51:56their platform. With Polymarket, with Calci,
- 51:58what have you, what began as a really great idea and in some
- 52:01sense is a very cool idea because you can have real time
- 52:05pricing for anything, is unfortunately being utilized to
- 52:08gamble on sports, right? It's literally just another
- 52:11version of a sports book. And like you said, Brian, I
- 52:14think you bring up a really good point.
- 52:15When you're in the casino, you know you're gambling, you know
- 52:17you're going to lose money. When you're in polymarket, you
- 52:20think you're smart, you think you have an edge, you think
- 52:22you're going to make a ton of money in that addictive feedback
- 52:25loop is going to send so many people into extreme despair.
- 52:29And it's just devastating to see the the, the odds don't surprise
- 52:32me, honestly, I thought it would be higher than that.
- 52:35I thought it would be 7075 or 80% of people.
- 52:37But it's no wonder it's a casino.
- 52:39Yeah, the, the, the speculative markets, the Poly markets are,
- 52:44are interesting because like even before Bitcoin, I was
- 52:47always interested in, in technology.
- 52:49And so I'm always fascinated. That's where the stable coin and
- 52:51like crypto, when you see the D5 stuff, you're like, oh, I can
- 52:53see how this could eventually end up on Bitcoin.
- 52:55To your point, Joe, like the polymarket stuff, it's never
- 52:58been interesting to see the NYSE the the valuations because you
- 53:04just know that a, the house is always going to win, but B, like
- 53:07I personally to your points, like I hate losing money more
- 53:09than I like winning it. And so I've just never been
- 53:11interested in gambling because you don't feel like you're in
- 53:14control. And yeah, it's just it's, it's a
- 53:18masked within a smartphone with a click of a button for anybody
- 53:22to participate and feel like they're a genius under the guise
- 53:25of, well, this is a free market or it's providing education for
- 53:29the market. Going back to the earlier part
- 53:31of the conversation, there's another angle which I saw and we
- 53:33talked a little bit with Matt Odell about it's like, I don't
- 53:35know, there's an angle here of the, the, the inertia or the
- 53:40momentum with it. Because these could have always
- 53:42existed. And they like really picked up
- 53:44steam the past 12 to 24 months. And now there's a lot of
- 53:46political kind of infighting with like the gambling, the like
- 53:50sports books and the states that allowed for it.
- 53:52And now they're, it's like a roundabout way to get into these
- 53:55different platforms. I don't know what the end game
- 53:57for it is, but you can just feel that there's something else at
- 54:00play because there's an insane, I mean, you feel like every
- 54:02three to nine months there's another large capital raise
- 54:05amount of capital going into these firms.
- 54:07And a lot of that is for marketing expenses.
- 54:09When you think about Uber, Lyft, those wars were around
- 54:12subsidizing the cost to bring it.
- 54:13So when you marketing, you put this on every application, every
- 54:16arena, every commercial, you're going to pull as much of the
- 54:21addressable market as you can into that.
- 54:23You know, it's devastating to say, except, you know, with Uber
- 54:26and Lyft, they were competing for customers in such a way
- 54:29where the marketing tactics were guerrilla marketing and they
- 54:32were trying to undercut one another, but it was to provide a
- 54:34net value to the consumer. Whereas this time you're seeing
- 54:37that exact same tactic but played out in a value extraction
- 54:39game. Yeah, it's very true.
- 54:43I am certainly on board and agree with you guys sentiment
- 54:46about it. We only have a few more minutes.
- 54:51We didn't talk about Michael Seller.
- 54:55Apparently there's something going on there.
- 54:58Brian, I'm going to I'm going to let you decide.
- 55:02Are we talking about that or are we not?
- 55:03Because. I actually am curious.
- 55:05I want to get Joe's thoughts on it.
- 55:09The earnings call for MSTR last night and and I think there was
- 55:13some signalling of this perhaps in the last earnings call as
- 55:15well, like basically priming people for the notion that at
- 55:19some point seller may sell some Bitcoin.
- 55:23Now I think the way it's being posited or framed is like these
- 55:27are non-emergency reasons. So it could make sense in some
- 55:31way, shape or form. I guess what I kind of take
- 55:34issue with is like this is a guy who said like sell your kidney
- 55:37before you sell your Bitcoin and it does cut against the
- 55:40narrative that he has built the entire business on.
- 55:43And so whether it's non-emergency or not, and he
- 55:45ends up buying more Bitcoin a week later, like it's kind of
- 55:48beside the point to me in the sense that like the only reason
- 55:52he's doing this is because now he has these Fiat dividend
- 55:55obligations. And so a few months ago, six
- 55:59months ago, he didn't think he needed to do this.
- 56:01So he wasn't saying that he would sell Bitcoin.
- 56:03He was saying never, never sell you Bitcoin.
- 56:05So the fact that he's now saying this tells me that like it's not
- 56:09all going as he thought it would six months ago.
- 56:11Is there any, I guess curious your thoughts on any of that?
- 56:15For sure. Yeah, I think people are taking
- 56:18it a little bit out of context. Michael and I have different
- 56:20opinions as far as stretch is concerned and and strategies,
- 56:23strategy if you will. We'll see how this plays out
- 56:26over the next several years, right.
- 56:28I think the quote itself was taken out of context because the
- 56:32the first half of the quote was I just pulled it up.
- 56:36We'll probably sell some Bitcoin to fund the dividend just to
- 56:38inoculate the market, just to send the message that we did it.
- 56:42So in my mind, basically he's saying, just to your point,
- 56:44Brian, that like they're not forced to sell their Bitcoin,
- 56:47but they would do it just to prove that they could do it
- 56:49without, one, tanking the Bitcoin price and two,
- 56:52showcasing to the market that, hey, you know, in the event that
- 56:56we reach a point where we decide to begin selling Bitcoin, it
- 56:59won't be the first time. So in my mind, it's a way to
- 57:02reduce future panic in the event they do begin selling their
- 57:05Bitcoin because in my mind, the one of the more efficient ways
- 57:10to fund the stretch dividend is to incrementally sell Bitcoin
- 57:15over time, right. If you think about it this way,
- 57:18you know, if Bitcoin is doing twenty 2530% CAGR and STRC
- 57:23remains around 11%, you don't need to sell all of your
- 57:26Bitcoin, just a chunk of it. And in my mind, that would do so
- 57:29much to remove all of the Ponzi accusations.
- 57:32And so, you know, the summary for me is that I think a lot of
- 57:35folks are taken out of the context and it's, it's basically
- 57:38him getting out ahead and trying to dispel one of the biggest
- 57:42attractions against STRC in the strategy complex more broadly,
- 57:46which is that the only way they can fund the dividend is through
- 57:49issuing new shares. It's like a form of forward
- 57:52guidance. In a way, I suppose for the
- 57:55Bitcoin central bank that people are calling it.
- 57:57Yeah, yeah, very few I guess. Yeah, I mean, I hear your
- 57:59points. I guess it just, I don't
- 58:02understand why he needs to put like we he can sell the Bitcoin.
- 58:05Like we know he can sell Bitcoin, he can buy Bitcoin, he
- 58:07can sell Bitcoin. Like, I don't think he needs to
- 58:08prove it's in the market. I think maybe he's the take away
- 58:12to me is like he's priming investors for like he might do
- 58:14it in the future and he's couching it in like this, this
- 58:19terminology that like, oh, it's it's like Elon saying he needed
- 58:22to test liquidity. It's like, well, OK, like we
- 58:26know Bitcoin's pretty damn liquid.
- 58:30I think it's more so from the perspective of proving to the
- 58:32mark that he can do it without like tanking strategy stock or
- 58:35like like you said, Michael sort of setting the expectation for
- 58:37the future. If he does, we'll see.
- 58:40It'll certainly be interesting to see how the market reacts if
- 58:42that happens. Love it.
- 58:46Man, we, we didn't even get to some of the things I wanted to.
- 58:49But that's all right, Joe, it was a pleasure.
- 58:52I know we got to be respectful of your time.
- 58:54We also have a hard stop as well.
- 58:56Where do you want people to get in touch with you if there's
- 58:58anything they want to follow up on?
- 59:00For sure. Well, again, thanks you guys so
- 59:02much for having me. This is one of my favorite pods
- 59:04in the Bitcoin space. Lots of signals, so keep it up
- 59:06and there are plenty of Wednesdays for the rest of the
- 59:08year. So happy to always come back on
- 59:09if it's relevant. If you're watching this on
- 59:11YouTube, guys, just go to the top bar up there, search up Joe
- 59:14Consorti and subscribe to the channel for more of these
- 59:18thoughts and analysis. If you found it valuable, if
- 59:20you're watching an extra search Joe Consorti, follow that
- 59:22account. And if you want to convert some
- 59:23of your idle home equity to Bitcoin, you can go to
- 59:25joinhorizon.com and schedule a consultation with yours truly.
- 59:30We'll take you on the. Offer.
- 59:32We'll definitely have you back before the end of the year.
- 59:34Awesome, sounds like a playing guys.
- 59:36Thanks. Thanks for listening to this
- 59:38week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 59:41valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 59:43rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 59:45All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 59:47notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 59:50reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 59:53entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 59:56investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 59:59your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:00:01Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:00:05one of our private Client Advisors.