Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP295: How To Build Your Loyalty Strategy - Practical Tips For Delivering Results
Transcript
- 0:00It isn't just about getting people to spend more, it's about
- 0:02getting people to behave in positive ways that you want them
- 0:06to and rewarding them for that behavior.
- 0:07And that can be a myriad of thing depending on what your
- 0:09brand proposition is. You have sustainable LED brands
- 0:12who want people to buy into their sustainability ethic and
- 0:16they want them to understand that rewards aren't just get 10
- 0:19lbs off. It can be we're planting an
- 0:21extra tree for you or we're donating to this charity for you
- 0:24and there's a benefit to you shopping with us because we're
- 0:27helping you to do something positive.
- 0:29Whilst your shopping, you listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly
- 0:32ecom strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 0:35experienced digital consultants and re platform specialist James
- 0:38Gedacle Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:41leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:43leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:45improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 0:51Shopify. We are drilling into loyalty and
- 0:54e-commerce, but not from a very high level about why loyalty is
- 0:58good and what's good. Examples are we want to come in
- 1:00it from a a strategic lens of how you build out a loyalty
- 1:04proposition and what a loyalty actually means.
- 1:07To get into a bit more granular detail for those people who are
- 1:11either have a loyalty program but want to, you know, improve
- 1:14it or are in the journey of building out a loyalty strategy.
- 1:19So the the giving the context for this, we're going to do a
- 1:22little bit of a talking heads today, myself and Paul.
- 1:25The context of this is that basically loyalty strategy is
- 1:28more than a program. A loyalty strategy is a focus on
- 1:33overall customer engagement, customer experience, because
- 1:35loyalty is earned through great and consistently great customer
- 1:39experience. So actually loyalty isn't just
- 1:42about let's launch program, reward people with points,
- 1:45prizes, perks, whatever it is. It's about understanding the
- 1:48fundamental mechanics of customer engagement, what
- 1:52leavers encourage customers to feel more positive about your
- 1:54business and therefore more likely to be loyal shoppers and
- 1:58come back to you. And it starts when people first
- 2:00visit and come get used to your brand, not just when they're
- 2:04buying and in a repeat purchase cycle.
- 2:06So that's my that's my ramble. Paul, How let's let's talk about
- 2:10how, how businesses generally approach loyalty.
- 2:12Are you? Because we've seen we're joined
- 2:14us. Well, there's a shift for people
- 2:16seeing loyalty as a more strategic offering rather than
- 2:18just let's give some discounts. Let's start with that.
- 2:21Where What is loyalty and what? How should it be viewed?
- 2:25Yeah. So I think I think this is the
- 2:27interesting point because I think historically up until two
- 2:31or three years ago, maybe if you said the word loyalty of one
- 2:37would immediately looked at more traditional programs that are
- 2:41like points and tier and discount LED.
- 2:44And that's still definitely the case for the majority of
- 2:46programs. But I do think that now when
- 2:50particularly like kind of people that are like consultants in new
- 2:54gum industry are talking about loyalty, they're talking about
- 2:58like much broader things. So a lot of people would put
- 3:00client telling and the loyalty or kind of, but how was it
- 3:03within the same discussion or business case?
- 3:07They would also and I think the goals differ massively as well.
- 3:10So historically I think the programs were like based on
- 3:14models that were just specifically designed to
- 3:16increase customer lifetime value and purchase frequency.
- 3:21Whereas now actually like a lot of the discussions we've had
- 3:24recently have been more designed to get online customers into
- 3:28store or like collect more data early on from a customer or like
- 3:32increase frequency of engagement was an app for like.
- 3:37And I'm not saying that the primary goals are still pretty
- 3:40revenue and like trade LED, but I would say that loyalty to me
- 3:46now, I mean, and I said to you just for this, and I said it in
- 3:48my open post talk as well, this is like the first area I've ever
- 3:52seen that like needs a buzzword because it just feels like it's
- 3:56so much broader than like increasing customer loyalty.
- 3:59It's more just like, yeah, it's kind of customer strategy, isn't
- 4:02it? And if you've got a loyalty
- 4:04program nowadays, it's usually like the heart of your kind of
- 4:07customer strategy and you know, it kind of crosses over lots of
- 4:12just different departments beyond like CRM and E com.
- 4:16So yeah, I think it's, I think overall loyalty is just a lot
- 4:20broader than it used to be. And at the yeah, the Third
- 4:23Point, I brought it up. Yeah, 100%.
- 4:27And I also the the bits, the where I think people sometimes
- 4:31don't focus enough is the, is that loyalty isn't just about
- 4:35getting people to spend more. It's about getting people to
- 4:38behave in, in the positive ways that you want them to and
- 4:41rewarding them for that behaviour.
- 4:43And that that can be a myriad of thing depending on what your
- 4:45brand proposition is. So you, you have brands that
- 4:48like real sustainable LED brands who want to get people to buy
- 4:53into their sustainability ethic and they want them to understand
- 4:57that rewards aren't just get 10 lbs off.
- 4:59It can be we're planting an extra tree for you or we're
- 5:02donating to this charity for you.
- 5:04And there there's a benefit to you shopping with us because you
- 5:08know, we're helping you to do something positive whilst you're
- 5:11shopping, which always sounds a little bit contrite in when
- 5:14you're fundamentally telling people to, to buy and, and, and
- 5:17consume. But actually that's, that's
- 5:19important to some people. I know I support some brands
- 5:23because of the, the grassroots organisations they invest in.
- 5:26That's one of the reasons I like them, not just because I might
- 5:29get a discount sometime. And and then the other part is
- 5:33for D to C e-commerce where you own your own channel, but you're
- 5:37selling through retail and you can't control what the retail is
- 5:41doing with their pricing strategy, discount promotions,
- 5:43etcetera. You can't directly control it.
- 5:46You can influence it, but what's the differentiation point is
- 5:49strategically, how can we differentiate DTC and give value
- 5:52to customers in this channel that that gives them a greater
- 5:55reason to shop with us and trust with us rather than us having to
- 5:58compete on pricing continuously, just give them reductions, yeah.
- 6:03Yeah. I think the other thing that I
- 6:05think is hard in this area now because some of the programs
- 6:09that I think I would assume perform best amongst our client
- 6:16one aren't really measured. So they're more like closed
- 6:20groups and you've kind of got a small group of people that are
- 6:24maybe kind of, it's almost like an ambassador's program.
- 6:28And then it's kind of people that have been influential
- 6:31around brands. If one brand that we work with
- 6:33in particular that have got maybe like the 100 customers in
- 6:36a WhatsApp group, some of which are influencers, some of which
- 6:39are admins to their Facebook group where they've got 20,000
- 6:43customers talking about their product.
- 6:44And then some of which are just like VIP customers.
- 6:48And there's not really any tangible benefits beyond like
- 6:52input into new products, early access to new products, like
- 6:56early access to like their kind of like equivalent of outlets.
- 7:03Yeah. And it is.
- 7:04It's just, I just think now it's like it's so much broader than
- 7:07just kind of traditional programs.
- 7:09But I think it'll probably come on.
- 7:10Yeah, yeah. It's like this is about about
- 7:15thinking about what customers value is.
- 7:17I think this is the key theme in today's episode is, is you've
- 7:20got to really take the time to look at the data, speak to
- 7:23customers and understand what they value in order to be able
- 7:26to turn this into something coherent that's going to land
- 7:28rather than just saying, well, do you know what we're going to
- 7:30we're going to launch with some disk and that's fine.
- 7:32I'm not I'm not denigrating that.
- 7:33If you if you want to launch with just price and value,
- 7:36that's fine. But but it's even things, for
- 7:38example, a good, a good example, be a brand, I think like green
- 7:43people who do video customer testimonials with existing
- 7:46customers where they, they get them to record videos or talk a
- 7:50lot whether they like the product they get showcased on
- 7:52the homepage. Now that is a loyalty mechanism
- 7:57because you're engendering greater trust between you and
- 8:01the customer. You're giving them an
- 8:02opportunity to showcase themselves.
- 8:03You know who not everyone loves it, but some people love to be
- 8:07seen and to and for for what they're talking about to be
- 8:10taken seriously by other people to influence other customers.
- 8:12So there are all these techniques where you can,
- 8:15without being promotion LED, do things that will build a a kind
- 8:19of like a greater loyalty mechanism with your customers.
- 8:24What do Mattel, Victoria, Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 8:29all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 8:32Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 8:36and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 8:40It also happens to have the best converting checkout on the
- 8:43planet, Shopify, powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 8:49Find out more at shopify.com/enterprise.
- 8:53So let's, let's start. So the so I, I use the word
- 8:56framework, but it's pretty loose, to be honest.
- 8:59The the an important structure way of thinking about this.
- 9:02And it's about starting with goals and going to analysis,
- 9:04then doing your planning and then delivery.
- 9:06And, and I think often people look come to loyalty from a what
- 9:10loyalty tools are out there and there are lots, you know, pick
- 9:13your loyalty platform and there are lots of different tech out
- 9:16there that can help you. But I don't think that's right.
- 9:19You've got to start your strategy early and then come to
- 9:22the tech once you've got a clearer vision.
- 9:23But let's do the goal mapping and let's let's start with you
- 9:27and one of the primary goals that you're seeing customers
- 9:31putting down as like the key drivers for for doing something
- 9:34in the loyalty space. Yeah.
- 9:35So I think that's a really good question.
- 9:38So I was just making some notes then actually what I think in
- 9:42fact, we're going to come on to metrics, aren't we?
- 9:43So when you talk about goals, it's not really.
- 9:45Well, they're linked only, so we probably should just do them
- 9:48together. So I think overall, I think from
- 9:51a goals perspective, I think I'd touched on quite a lot of them.
- 9:54Like it'll either be like engagement frequency, like like
- 10:00types of interactions. So again, a lot of our clients
- 10:03believe that the value of getting someone in store is
- 10:06high. So they provide incentives
- 10:08designed to get people in store like ambassador level benefits.
- 10:13But I think the primary one would be revenue based.
- 10:17And then I just made some notes over here of some metrics that
- 10:21one of our clients has been using.
- 10:25So I think the main goal of this program was to get essentially
- 10:32day split customers based on number of purchases.
- 10:35And then within the first bracket, which would be a single
- 10:37time purchaser, they have sale and full price.
- 10:40But basically they were measuring time to move across
- 10:43brackets and percentage of customers that move between the
- 10:46brackets. So one of the girls with one to
- 10:48two, another girl was like 5-7, etcetera.
- 10:52You've then got movement between tiers.
- 10:55So if you've got a tier based programme, I think that's a good
- 10:59match for it to look at. And then also the speed.
- 11:02And we've had a client like re architect their programme
- 11:05recently and that was the main goals.
- 11:07They've essentially adapted the incentives based on how to get
- 11:11these to move up tiers. Bastard usage of incentives is a
- 11:16good one from a brand perspective.
- 11:18And again I think that's probably more designed to
- 11:21provide like you say the experience than a revenue based
- 11:24one. Overall, total spend by segment
- 11:29is a good one. And with like maybe some
- 11:31parameters that take out certain customers, full price reduction
- 11:38and key purchase rate, lifetime value by segment and then
- 11:43revenue per customer by segment are the ones that I've just put
- 11:46in. But I think yeah, yeah, you
- 11:48probably wouldn't have that many overall.
- 11:50I think it's it's basically revenue uplift based on how
- 11:55you're sucked during the programme.
- 11:58Yeah, I think so. The ones that I, I like to
- 12:00focus, I number one, there has to be a customer experience
- 12:03based goal and success measure in there.
- 12:06MPs is one example. It doesn't have to be, but I
- 12:10find that quite a nice one because actually if you're if
- 12:13you understand your customer, you know what makes them happy
- 12:16and you're giving them perks that align with that, you would
- 12:20expect their satisfaction with you to either stay high or
- 12:24increase over time. So having an MPs measure post
- 12:28after post purchase, but having it regularly checking up on your
- 12:31existing customer database when you survey them and contact them
- 12:34and tracking those and monitoring when you got falls
- 12:38and and increases. I think that's quite useful.
- 12:42There are some companies that do that that really well.
- 12:46Then it's yeah, the the margin 1 is really important because you
- 12:51could have a a particular second of customers who only ever buy
- 12:54discount. They maybe they only have buy
- 12:56when there's something's on sale or it's peak campaigns and
- 13:00wanting to try and encourage them to shop at higher margin
- 13:06items and more full price. Obviously, I've actually seen
- 13:09people in peak trading target these audiences specifically who
- 13:13are discount only shoppers with discounts on higher price point
- 13:17items to get them into buying higher price points.
- 13:20So that when they come out of the peak sales, they are they
- 13:24are buying like products in ranges or brands that are
- 13:27better, better price points. So I think there's lots of
- 13:29different goals you can go, but yeah, experience based, customer
- 13:34experience based plus a revenue based one for me having a mix of
- 13:37the two. Yeah.
- 13:38And I'll come back to MPs one, but one, we don't really talk
- 13:42about vendors that much, but one thing that I really like, plus a
- 13:46couple of vendors and one thing that one of our parents is known
- 13:49from one to another because it allows you, one, it's got much
- 13:54better reporting around that kind of discount and or like
- 13:58sale customer, full price customer.
- 14:00And then two, it gives you a lot more granularity around the
- 14:03promotions. And they also do things like you
- 14:06can do like specific campaigns where you get triple points on a
- 14:11specific product category and you can like refine that down to
- 14:15a group of customers. And obviously that's not
- 14:17something you might want for day one and a loyalty program.
- 14:19But obviously like a lot of the like department stores have done
- 14:23that in the past. And I think that I'm I've not
- 14:27done it with a client before, but I'm expecting that all for
- 14:31that. Yeah.
- 14:32That that, you know, that's a really important one actually,
- 14:34because if you if you're a multi category retailer, you might
- 14:40find that a lot of the customers only buy from certain categories
- 14:43from you. They're shopping elsewhere at
- 14:44the moment for maybe they don't buy homewares from you, they
- 14:48only buy sports and leisure, whatever it might be.
- 14:51And actually the incentive for you to get them shopping cross
- 14:53category to then put more of their wallet into your store on
- 14:56someone else. And having mechanisms to do that
- 14:59is really borne, which which comes back to the goal.
- 15:02I mean This is why we say don't look at tech until you've gone
- 15:04through this process because if you don't have these
- 15:06conversations, you don't have these discussions and you tease
- 15:09out what's important and therefore what's important in
- 15:11day one versus what you can add later.
- 15:14You might end up making a wrong decision on the platform and be
- 15:16stuck in with something that that doesn't work.
- 15:18Good example I'd recently when someone was asking me on
- 15:21LinkedIn about multi currency loyalty programs is that not all
- 15:26platforms that very few did up until recently allowed you in in
- 15:31a multi currency environment to have fixed levels in source.
- 15:35Say like 1-1. If 1 LB was one point then one
- 15:40euro was 1.1 dollar was one point.
- 15:42Rather than using currency conversion off of your base
- 15:45currency. So you get all these nuances
- 15:47that if you don't tease out and define your goals and how you
- 15:51want it to work properly, you end up being compromised at the
- 15:54implementation time. Yeah, yeah, I agree.
- 15:57I think I think you're absolutely right.
- 16:00You want to design the program first.
- 16:02I do think, I do think sometimes you can get really good
- 16:04inspiration from the vendors. So like there's a feature that
- 16:08one of our clients is doing where they've got quite a few
- 16:11retail stores and essentially they've got like local
- 16:14communities. So it's in the kind of sports
- 16:17world and the during you kind of pitch process, it was, I think
- 16:23it was on Tavo, they basically got I think it's called
- 16:27chapters. There's a feature called
- 16:29Chapters that is basically just location based and then you can
- 16:33adapt different elements and do that promotions by like
- 16:38geographic areas, which was quite cool.
- 16:42And that that driving some really good ideas of yeah.
- 16:46Oh yeah. I'm not saying don't, don't talk
- 16:51to vendors. My my point of this is you've
- 16:53got to you've got to know, you've got to have a baseline of
- 16:57what you want to achieve before you look at.
- 16:58Otherwise it becomes really disorientating because you'll
- 17:00get distracted. If that looks good, that looks
- 17:02good and you'll miss out on what the core critical deliverables
- 17:06that you need. I think they those conversations
- 17:08are brilliant with vendors instead of just being respond to
- 17:11this RFP. It is this is what we need and
- 17:14these are our goals. How would you how would your
- 17:17platform enable this? Do you have any advice?
- 17:19What, what are we missing? What, what are what are things
- 17:22that in your platform will be relevant that we don't even know
- 17:23about? That fundamentally should always
- 17:25be a conversation. Yeah.
- 17:27I actually, I completely agree with your point on.
- 17:30Yeah, basically that way of approaching it.
- 17:33It's I'm sure we could do like a whole episode on how to approach
- 17:36vendor selection. So.
- 17:38Yeah, Yeah. No.
- 17:39And also, there's no 100% right approach.
- 17:41It's just we've all been in for it plenty of times.
- 17:44You don't want a beauty parade where you're just you, you don't
- 17:47have any objective way of comparing things because you
- 17:49don't have any criteria. I, you know, I've got OCD, It's
- 17:52one of my great, but it's a strength and a weakness in equal
- 17:55measure. Yeah.
- 17:59So let's let's talk, let's come to the customer insight bit,
- 18:01because this is a fundamental pillar of any loyalty strategy
- 18:05is understanding what customers value.
- 18:07And I know that you don't quite love what have your clients as
- 18:09well about, you know, and they survey talk to customers.
- 18:12So do you want to, do you want to talk to you about how do
- 18:14people build up a pictures and what are some of the things
- 18:16you've seen that are quite interesting coming out of the
- 18:18customer analysis? Yeah, absolutely.
- 18:19Yeah. So this is quite timely because
- 18:23we've had a few clients recently.
- 18:24So one that's rebuilding existing programme, one that's
- 18:28suing a first loyalty programme. And for them like they're quite
- 18:32traditional brands, quite a big thing like lots of maybe older
- 18:36customers as well. And basically, so they both ran
- 18:40server is and basically the perks that people cared about
- 18:44were not particularly surprising to be perfectly honest.
- 18:48So early access was a big one. In fact, no actually discounts
- 18:54and exclusive products with the top 2 when you combined these
- 18:57two surveys, then it was early access and then it was like
- 19:01exclusive engagements. So things like in store events,
- 19:04all of that kind of stuff and anything else that's kind of
- 19:07exclusive to them. And one thing I would say is I
- 19:11think the brands that I've like something like I consider KIF to
- 19:16be one of the best loyalty programmes.
- 19:19And I think, I don't think they've maybe they haven't
- 19:21changed it loads since it launched, but it's, it's
- 19:24basically it's all native app based, which is actually
- 19:27something that another one of our clients is doing just so
- 19:30that they essentially get with many existing customers on for
- 19:33an app with possible. And then they've got the the
- 19:35engagement benefit and the push notification with everything out
- 19:38of it's alternate at that phase. But the big thing that KISS do
- 19:42really well is that they have some amazing, like really cool
- 19:45high profile products that people would want and they've
- 19:49intention or they bought low quantities and they
- 19:53intentionally only made some available to VIPs.
- 19:55And there were a couple of products that I really wanted,
- 19:58but I needed to spend like 1000 lbs to get them.
- 20:01And I'm definitely too cheap to do that.
- 20:04But I did consider it at one point.
- 20:07So yeah, I think that's a really nice one.
- 20:11And then yeah, the the only other bits of feedback that was
- 20:13interesting is basically across the two brands, 80% of customers
- 20:18that surveyed had. Used a loyalty program across
- 20:24another similar brand basically. Yeah.
- 20:27The, the exclusive products that you can only have access to
- 20:31after a certain threshold of spend or even when it's not even
- 20:34publicising it. And you only know about it if
- 20:37you are in that customer group that really just hits the
- 20:40premium and doesn't especially in fashion.
- 20:42You see the other brands like Balenciaga have done this where
- 20:45they, they create a load of buzz around it.
- 20:47It's a drop and they create the excitement of, you know, you
- 20:49could, you could get into our top level if you spend only 20
- 20:53million next year, which I'll never be part of that, that,
- 20:57that walk of life. But yeah, it's exclusivity comes
- 21:00up a lot actually when I, when I not in like mass market
- 21:05retailers, but people in the, in the kind of premium luxury space
- 21:09I got 1 of. I've worked with a few clients
- 21:11across different areas, whether it's beauty or fashion.
- 21:14And it's exclusivity means different things to different
- 21:17customer groups. It could be exclusive products,
- 21:19it could be events. There's all these different
- 21:23things that you can make available to customers.
- 21:26Some brands get out of the route of creating customer centric
- 21:28events where it's special invite only.
- 21:31You won't know about them unless you are part of that loyalty.
- 21:34But it's an extra perk on top of the other promotional elements
- 21:38where it, where you get something of value that will
- 21:41help keep, help you feel like, you know, you're, you're worthy
- 21:45and, and you're loved by the brand.
- 21:49I also like in the, I like how brands like Opoly do it in the,
- 21:52because they have tiers and you know, tiers is quite a
- 21:55standardised way of doing this to, to increase the rule.
- 21:57But you get the, it's not just, hey, now you get more products.
- 22:01They add service elements into it.
- 22:03And that I think is really smart.
- 22:04So I think in that their platinum tier, they've got AVIP
- 22:07phone line and that automatically sounds great.
- 22:09It's like, oh excellent, I'm going to get preferential
- 22:11treatment and faster service. Yeah, So what the client of
- 22:15ours, I won't mention them just in case, but so at the moment
- 22:21they've got all of that kind of stuff.
- 22:23So like priority customer service, like VIP in store
- 22:26service, private shopping, like free drinks in store, everything
- 22:30cows. But they're introducing some
- 22:32pretty cool stuff. So they're going to do receipt
- 22:34less returns across all channels.
- 22:38They're doing Uber to store in the top tier.
- 22:43I'm trying to, I think of some of the other ones, but there's
- 22:45some really cool like service based things and I think we're
- 22:48going to come on to the best programs or like some examples.
- 22:52But I think #1 for me and part of it's because of the type of
- 22:56brand they are and how big they are, but Hugo Boss is like
- 22:59exceptional with all this stuff. And I think the way that they've
- 23:02integrated it in store as well, I think is is amazing.
- 23:06So that's mineable and they've got loads of little service base
- 23:11things around like repairs and I think that's where we stole the
- 23:15receipt less return thing from. Yeah.
- 23:18And they've they've got loads of others.
- 23:19And I think it's it's pretty cool to see how invested they
- 23:24that program. Like they've got whole team on
- 23:26it, whole things like web freebase, like you go in store,
- 23:29they've got like the Soho House style check in, which gives you
- 23:32point. They've got like interactive
- 23:34mirrors. Like it's really cool how like
- 23:36all in they've gone on it. Yeah, no.
- 23:40Do any of your customers do do like face to face Custer and
- 23:44cheeks? I remember speaking to a a few
- 23:47fashion brands recently where one of them does phone
- 23:51interviews where they'll they'll directly get on the phone.
- 23:54Not just customer service team as well.
- 23:55It's like the people in the e-commerce team setting up calls
- 23:58with customers to ask some questions and have a proper
- 24:01chair. Others where they've, they've
- 24:03organised events, they've invited, yeah, a handful of
- 24:06customers along. They've, you know, give them
- 24:07refreshments and make it a nice relaxing, fun thing.
- 24:10And they just sat down and had a very open discussion in A room.
- 24:13Yeah, absolutely. So I think low Tel, so, yeah.
- 24:17And some of them haven't actually launched the program.
- 24:20Yes, typically that's some of the larger clients.
- 24:22But I think one of the clients, I think that I was talking
- 24:25earlier about it's more of a community than a loyalty
- 24:27program. And I didn't mind me mentioning
- 24:30them, but Fairfax and Favour was who I was referring to.
- 24:33And they they're so good with like personal customer
- 24:37interaction. I guess they're quite lucky
- 24:39because of the industry they're in.
- 24:41There's a lot of shows. So they have like that
- 24:43opportunity to the meet a lot of their like topped customers at
- 24:47the shows. But they're essentially like,
- 24:49yeah, meet them face to face and they do a really good job of
- 24:52like listening to customers and the customer feedback is like
- 24:56factored into a lot of like what they do at the shows, the
- 25:00products like everything else. Yeah.
- 25:03So they're they're quite intentional on that side.
- 25:05And I think it's been, it's been really good to that.
- 25:07Yeah. And I think this is where non
- 25:10membership E com can learn from membership E com because the
- 25:12membership business tends to be quite strong on this.
- 25:15They, I remember the projects to the wine society and we're
- 25:18trying to validate some of the strategic pillars of the
- 25:22improvements we're going to put forward across the site from
- 25:25the, the, the e-commerce functionality through to, you
- 25:29know, promotion strategy through to product, you name it.
- 25:32And there were all the data. We, we have a few things we're
- 25:35like, we're not quite sure if this is the right decision And
- 25:37we just, we ran various events and panels.
- 25:39It was right because there's a wine society.
- 25:40There was wine there. People love to come along and
- 25:42get pretty nice, good wine tasting, but it was great
- 25:45because instantly you get this straight feedback loop of of no,
- 25:50no interest in that. And you, you have this idea you
- 25:53think is really going to resonate and you're all right.
- 25:56So yeah, you can't, you can't underestimate the value of doing
- 25:59face to face. Sometimes I.
- 26:00Think one of the things that some of our clients have been
- 26:04getting feedback from fans been talking about recently, because
- 26:07I think this, for whatever reasons come up quite a lot, is
- 26:11the idea of your inclusion in a tier expiring.
- 26:15And like how you feel about that.
- 26:18Because I think that's like obviously a really powerful
- 26:21mechanism where it's like, you know, you if you don't spend
- 26:23another X, you're going to lose all the bad.
- 26:26But but obviously there's like the negative side to that as
- 26:31well. Like how do you feel if you're
- 26:32kind of going down to, Yeah, I think that's like, obviously I
- 26:36think it's quite mixed in terms of like how our clients feel
- 26:40about it. But a couple are going to do
- 26:41that. And I often refer to like BI as
- 26:45I think I've just seen like two or three people just obsessed
- 26:48with retaining their gold status for BI.
- 26:51So they get their like free upgrades or like discounted
- 26:55upgrades. Yeah.
- 26:56Yeah. And I think that's quite an
- 26:58interesting one that you probably need to be face to face
- 27:01to kind of get feedback on that a little bit as well.
- 27:03But do you know what I was going to raise the question about
- 27:06communication and communication strategy and loyalty because it,
- 27:09it's one of my big bug bears. And I've, I've seen really good
- 27:12programmes poorly managed because sort of a big one years
- 27:16ago, the M Brown group and one of the brands there where they
- 27:20had really good like programme and perks rewards, but it was
- 27:26predicated on annual spend. And if you were going to be
- 27:29under that spend for the next year, you would drop out of that
- 27:31tier. But there was no automated
- 27:32campaigns to alert people like 3 months before and say, hey, just
- 27:36to let you know, you know, you've got all these benefits
- 27:39for next year, but you need to spend another 120 lbs before the
- 27:41end of the year. You know, here's some ideas
- 27:45based on all this opportunity to make that really coordinated and
- 27:48also personalized based on the purchase history and knowledge
- 27:51You've got the customer. So you've got to get the comms
- 27:53absolutely spot on that. So I, I don't have a problem
- 27:57either, I guess from Nikon Bonivi or from a customer being
- 28:01a customer that if I'm not adding the value anymore, that I
- 28:05won't get those perks because you have a business to run.
- 28:07But you've got to give me clarity on it and you've got to
- 28:10help me be proactive because when you're forced into
- 28:15something that you you could have made a better decision if
- 28:18you had an alert that then can take the previous loyalty that
- 28:23feelings you've built up and the trust you've built on the
- 28:26company, that can erode it really quickly.
- 28:28Yeah, I completely agree. And I actually think your point
- 28:30at the start around cons, I've seen people build amazing
- 28:34loyalty program, but like the comms just haven't been strong
- 28:36enough or they've invested all their time in building the
- 28:40program, but they've not really got their resources to like
- 28:43actually build all the flows but play around it.
- 28:47But yeah, I think that's like I think that's probably the most
- 28:50important part of all of this is like actually like the the comms
- 28:54around the mechanisms. So yeah, I completely.
- 28:57Yeah, and especially when people are have a subscription that
- 29:02could expire or they benefit they previously had and say
- 29:06they've got a subscription and it's a discounted 1 and then
- 29:09it's going to go back up if they don't do X or Y.
- 29:12And I've had this with mobile phone providers and I just had
- 29:14one recently where I've just gone up to mental at the company
- 29:17for what they did where there was no alert to say the
- 29:21discounted period. You're going to be out of it
- 29:23next month and the cost is going up £25 a month.
- 29:26But hey, look, we can put you onto another package where you
- 29:30you won't So expecting. I know, I know we all should be
- 29:35responsible, but customers forget and it's so easy to
- 29:38automate alerts to tell people these things.
- 29:41So I would urge anyone listen, if if you're serious about
- 29:44loyalty, think about automation and communication, not just hey,
- 29:48we're announcing a great big feature to everyone as part of
- 29:50our brands comms, but what are those notifications and keep on
- 29:54top of them and check that they're working because that's
- 29:58the other thing is what happens if a flow is suddenly something
- 30:01balked it and the flow no longer works.
- 30:02Check, check your flows are working and check the numbers
- 30:05going through them like regularly.
- 30:07Yeah, agree. Let's talk about competitor data
- 30:13in this, because you, you should never just borrow from a
- 30:16competitor. You want to, you want to do, you
- 30:18want to do things your own way, but you can definitely be
- 30:20informed at the the obvious one for me is always, you know, what
- 30:26are they doing? What are their reward, public
- 30:27facing rewards. You, you can't see the hidden
- 30:30ones unless you are a customer and you go through that proper
- 30:33secret shopper thing yourself. But the one that I don't think
- 30:36people look enough at is if they're, if they do some mystery
- 30:40shopper and they get involved in the schemes is the communication
- 30:43and keep the track of those notifications, the e-mail
- 30:45campaigns, how proactive, the tonality, how they engage people
- 30:49and how they encourage people to come and redeem benefits.
- 30:53They're there. Yeah.
- 30:55I mean, that's really hard to audit, really, really hard to
- 30:57look at because you've got a, you know, be a pretty, you've
- 31:01got to spend a lot of money and engage in a further up to get to
- 31:06the point where you can see how they're managing the highest
- 31:09tier. But I think, I mean, to be
- 31:10honest, we're a lot of our cards.
- 31:11The most interesting thing is how you go from 1:00 to 2:00 or
- 31:15yeah, sale customer for a second purchase or even just like
- 31:19achieve profitability with a customer.
- 31:23Yeah. And I actually think that's
- 31:24really interesting as well. But yeah, I agree.
- 31:26I think the only one thing I'd say is quite a lot of our client
- 31:29can be quite tunnel visioned with this stuff or like they'll
- 31:33essentially just look at what's going on in their industry and
- 31:36they'll end up quite flat programme ones that I think so
- 31:40like another one that Connor always talks about from our
- 31:43team. I really like his panel mile or
- 31:45however you pronounce it, the Cyclin brand.
- 31:48But like it's super engaging. Like the, the onboarding to the
- 31:52program is like really strong and the data they collect is
- 31:54really cool. But I mean, they're not really
- 31:57relevant to a lot of our premium fashion clients, but like the
- 31:59experience. Yeah.
- 32:02And I and I think some of the early comms and it's like super
- 32:05strong. So I think it's just, yeah,
- 32:07making sure you're looking at, yeah, best in class as well as
- 32:10like the ones that are relevant to you.
- 32:13Yeah. I think that's that's a really
- 32:15important distinction actually because you don't want to forget
- 32:18myopic in it. And if you just look at your
- 32:21industry and the others aren't doing it very well, you're just
- 32:23you're just repeating the sense. Yeah, I think market, market
- 32:27leaders are good, but I think brands that that have got a good
- 32:32reputation that are currently trending where they're customer
- 32:35acquisition and retention, you know, they've got a good
- 32:37reputation for and you you see this in like fast go to DTC
- 32:40brands where they really, really hone in on the retention side as
- 32:43well. I think those are really
- 32:45interesting to watch. But I can I tell you a point
- 32:48about you can't easily audit all comms.
- 32:51You can't without doing shed loads of orders.
- 32:54But what you can do is is see the early days of how people
- 32:58engage. On 1st you could place a few
- 33:00simple orders. You can check the programs and
- 33:02see what drives points. So there are ways you can check
- 33:07how they, how well they do the basics.
- 33:09Because I definitely think that that's a competitive advantage.
- 33:11If your level of communication around your rewards is really,
- 33:14really hot and you're proactive and say, for example, there's a
- 33:17perk, I'm in segment A and I've got a perk where I get 10 LB
- 33:21vouch shopping voucher, but it expires at the end of next
- 33:23month. And I had this recently with
- 33:25vans where my, I, I had a voucher.
- 33:27I'd left it for ages because I don't buy that often.
- 33:30And it expired. And fair enough because the info
- 33:32was on there, but I didn't get any notification telling me that
- 33:37this was going to expire. And I went in, got upside, and I
- 33:39thought, oh, I need some new trainers.
- 33:41Yeah, that 15 LB voucher doesn't work anymore.
- 33:44Oh, that's good then. It just really annoyed me.
- 33:47That's, I think that's a really cool experience.
- 33:49Like back in the day, I used to work at bio gift experience.
- 33:54They come to that and like, they always gave people a grace
- 33:57period and like they do they, they were like really proactive
- 34:00and like notifying people when they were kind of getting close
- 34:03to that date. And I, yeah, that's a really
- 34:05tall experience, I think. And yeah, I, I really expect
- 34:09someone like Vans, especially if it's a 15 LB voucher to honour
- 34:13that person. I don't know how expired it was.
- 34:15If it was like 5 years, maybe not that.
- 34:19Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. It's that would be fair enough.
- 34:23Yeah. Not mean to name and shame,
- 34:25sometimes things slip full between the gaps, but hence the
- 34:29reason for having this conversation today about help,
- 34:32hopefully helping other people who are listening better plan
- 34:36for this. So in terms of competitor
- 34:42analysis, anything else that that you've seen people do
- 34:45that's interesting? Or is it mainly about looking
- 34:48wider than your close competitor set and spending time to to
- 34:53really like see what is happening, what they're
- 34:55promoting and how they're promoting it?
- 34:57Yeah, exactly. I think the other benefit of
- 34:58going broader as well is you can, or if you're not talking to
- 35:02a direct and that people are open their eyes, had
- 35:06conversations with quite a few different brands just like
- 35:08asking about like how different things have worked.
- 35:12Yeah. And there's there's a brand,
- 35:14another brand that I really like.
- 35:15And this is a topic that we could also do a whole episode
- 35:17on, but there's a brand called Bandit running based in New York
- 35:22and they have a membership. So essentially you buy into it
- 35:26and then and you pay. I can't believe it's not much,
- 35:29but you then get the equivalent map vouchers and then you get
- 35:32shed loads of part of his hands in low benefits within the
- 35:36program. And I think like that's one that
- 35:39quite a few of our clients have looked at and like they kind of
- 35:42they again, there's been quite a lot of discussion and
- 35:44potentially buying it to tears, potentially having like a for
- 35:48one client of the separate paid for tier, etcetera.
- 35:52And I guess if you're not in there vertical, you're in a
- 35:55better position for like reach out to them.
- 35:58Yeah. So I think from my perspective,
- 36:00I think it's just, I think if someone's really close to you
- 36:03and you want to see the comms, I think you've got a lot of best
- 36:05time into that really, but it is going to be hard to get the full
- 36:08experience. The other thing that I think a
- 36:12lot of brands do that we work with is have a, a closed tier.
- 36:18So there's actually so essentially if you go up to
- 36:20like, I don't know, platinum or gold or whatever else, there's
- 36:22then a hidden tier, which usually is some kind of closed
- 36:25group. And there's a lot more
- 36:27interaction. There's senior stakeholders
- 36:29hounder and there's a lot more rooms like input into like
- 36:33strategy almost, which I've I've always thought was pretty cool
- 36:40to be fair. And again, I think that probably
- 36:42works quite well. It's just how how you actually
- 36:46manage that because that's usually manual how you measure
- 36:50it, how you again like whether people stay in that or get
- 36:53removed etcetera. But yeah, I don't know what your
- 36:56views are on that. Yeah, yeah, definitely agree
- 37:01with that. Next question I want to talk
- 37:04about, because this is the thing about Lord, you can just sit and
- 37:08and talk for a long time on each of these points.
- 37:11But role of customer data, capturing direct customer data,
- 37:16the importance of doing that, how you do it and how that can
- 37:19that becomes a fundamental part of your loyalty strategy.
- 37:21So I know that you've done a lot of work in this and I know a lot
- 37:24of your clients do. So do you want to talk through
- 37:25some examples of of the type of customer data that you want to
- 37:29be doing that is useful and how it's useful?
- 37:31Yes. I think most of our clients
- 37:34apply the principle of essentially incentivizing you to
- 37:39build an account and as part of that build process, handover
- 37:42data that is useful for them to either personalize or you know,
- 37:48improve CRM effectiveness or generally just like give that
- 37:52more insight. And then probably 50% then have
- 37:57actual loyalty on top of that. But the type of data they're
- 38:02collecting varies. So I know you work at the pet
- 38:04food retail, I'm sure you'll talk about that in a second.
- 38:05So I think that's slightly pert mapped use case, but it's
- 38:08typically things like size profiling.
- 38:11It's things like category interest for customers that
- 38:15slightly bore the catalog, maybe some like Geo information.
- 38:21Yeah. And then essentially, especially
- 38:23size can then be used to personalise the on site
- 38:26experience. Same with interest or like
- 38:30category preference. I always like the Jay Limburg
- 38:33example where they're cross category sports and as part of
- 38:38the account field programme, you get free shipping and returns.
- 38:41They actually don't be euro to and then essentially you get
- 38:45they ask for details on the sport and size of and everything
- 38:48else. And then all of my cons.
- 38:51So then so in my case I put golf and medium and things like that
- 38:56and then all of the cons meal and that I don't even they do
- 38:58any on site personalisation yet. So that spokes, a really nice
- 39:02example that Eaton is a really nice example of that.
- 39:06Couple of our plants are starting to do it now where
- 39:08they're just highlighting size. But yeah, so that's kind of
- 39:13they're my examples. But again, we're quite niche in
- 39:15fashion. What about you?
- 39:17What examples do you have? Well, the great thing is this
- 39:20principle can be applied to any business.
- 39:22It's it's what data points will be useful for you for your
- 39:26merchandising, but also will enable you to add value and help
- 39:30customers. So yeah, the pet one's a good
- 39:32example like Lily's Kitchen working with have pet profiles.
- 39:35You can add a profile for up to, I think up to five or six of
- 39:37your pets. You could, it catches the pet
- 39:40birthday. And obviously then you can, you
- 39:43can come up with automated campaigns to give people special
- 39:46perks on the birthday of their pet, which is really, really
- 39:48nice. But one thing I love about that
- 39:50is they allow people to, to archive their pet profiles if a
- 39:54pet has passed on. And that's a really sensitive
- 39:56time for anyone who's got a pet, they are part of your family.
- 40:00So to not just like delete it, your pets no longer there to
- 40:04allow people to still have that, to still remember them.
- 40:07I think that's really nice as well, because that to me is
- 40:09about this is what what truth through like loyalty thinking
- 40:14is, is about what what is in the best interest of our customers,
- 40:16what helps our customers, what will make them feel more, you
- 40:19know, more, more. How can you speak?
- 40:21They happier about continuing to shop with us.
- 40:25Another example I had this, I saw this is years ago, so I
- 40:29don't know if they still do it, but I remember when as done on
- 40:33audit for somebody else like Netta Porte, Mr. Porter and how
- 40:36those sites work from a like product management and
- 40:38merchandising point of view. What they did quite nicely post
- 40:41sign up was capture specific brand interest.
- 40:43And this is great for like multi brand retailers is if you can
- 40:47straight away know what type of brand because you can quickly do
- 40:51some analysis behind the scenes of of that.
- 40:53Not only can you just do, OK, well, we'll only show those sort
- 40:57of only showing those products or were prioritized those
- 40:59products, but you could also look at the brand groupings.
- 41:02Is there any, is there anything you can learn from the type of
- 41:05brand that that person is shopping with, which then have
- 41:09affinities with other brands where you can then maybe add
- 41:11value by showcasing like, you know, content or lookbooks or
- 41:15whatever that are relevant to to that type of profile.
- 41:17So there's lots of different ways you can capture content.
- 41:20I think the most important thing is have a plan for it.
- 41:23Start simple, use the content and learn from it rather than
- 41:26capturing low because a lot one thing you don't want to do, and
- 41:29this annoys Castle is you capture always loads and loads
- 41:32of data and you do nothing with it because then people go, why
- 41:34did I give it to you? What's the value prop for the
- 41:36customer? The last point I want to talk
- 41:41about because I know that you've got, you've got a lot of
- 41:44insights and this is financial modelling and the importance of
- 41:46this. And you know, there are
- 41:48increasingly the gatekeepers for the, the investment loyalty is
- 41:53CFO and FD. And they, you know, we're in a
- 41:57period of trading now where it's tough margin pressures on cost,
- 42:01pressures on acquisition costs going up a lot.
- 42:04So suddenly saying we're going to spend loads of money by
- 42:07eroding margin and giving away perks and discounts doesn't land
- 42:10well unless you can do financial modelling to demonstrate what
- 42:13the potential uplift is. What is your advice on this and
- 42:16then and how do you go about doing it?
- 42:18Yeah, absolutely. So I think.
- 42:20I mean, you've just summed it up, I think so I think one of
- 42:22the drivers is often the rising customer acquisition costs and
- 42:27then essentially driving increased customer lifetime
- 42:29values. I think you basically got to
- 42:32take all the incentive, work out the costs based on the existing
- 42:35customers who are going to receive those benefits and
- 42:39incentives, and then the cost for new customers, and then
- 42:43essentially the increased purchase frequency and like net
- 42:47lifetime value. And then basically model out
- 42:51what profit looks like. But yeah, the one thing that I
- 42:55think that some people sometimes overlook is the cost to those
- 42:59existing customers a little bit. But yeah, I think that's exactly
- 43:03it. And like, you know, things like
- 43:04free shipping, free returns obviously cost a lot of money,
- 43:08particularly if you're offering them in a very early tier or
- 43:11even to people that just build an account.
- 43:14So yeah, I think, I mean, whenever our clients have done
- 43:17it, it's being quite financed LED.
- 43:20So essentially the econ team has designed the benefits by tier
- 43:24and then mapped out like spend threshold.
- 43:27And then the finance inputs are like, yeah, basically looking at
- 43:31all of the cost of the incentives versus the projected
- 43:36uplift. And then that's all kind of in
- 43:39the same. They're essentially thinking
- 43:42about the CAC as a starting point to actually try and
- 43:46increase or reduce cost per order.
- 43:49Yeah, nice. That's nice.
- 43:50That's. Succinct, I'm not going to add
- 43:52anything to that because that I've got nothing, nothing more
- 43:55meaningful to share on that because it's exactly how you do.
- 43:58I think the, the critical thing here is is you've got to go
- 44:02through this process. You've got to engage financial
- 44:03stakeholders early doors and you, you need to have a, a, a
- 44:08like business case of what the impact and have evidence behind
- 44:13it. Most important thing this
- 44:14process is to have incredible evidence because if you put in
- 44:17go, we're going to increase lifetime value by 50%.
- 44:20People are going to be quite cynical.
- 44:21So make sure that there's a realistic, make sure you've got
- 44:24case study evidence from somewhere else as well.
- 44:26And that's why sometimes speaking to the them when you're
- 44:29speaking to the technology companies, looking at the case
- 44:31study material they've got from other people who've done this.
- 44:34Yeah, absolutely. And some of the.
- 44:36Some of the things that the vendors will put in front of you
- 44:38is is often quite irrelevant as well.
- 44:40It's yeah, they're basically looking at the wrong metrics and
- 44:45just like global revenue and everything else.
- 44:48Cool. Well, we're going to.
- 44:50Stop there. I hope you found it useful.
- 44:51The aim was to help people get a more structured way of
- 44:55approaching, building out loyalty strategy or even
- 44:57extending the existing one they've got.
- 44:59Let us know what did you think? Was it useful?
- 45:01Any questions, anything else you would add, any advice?
- 45:04Would love to hear it. Thanks again for listening.
- 45:08You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 45:10experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 45:14Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 45:16featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 45:19industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 45:22explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 45:24and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 45:27really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 45:30to help fine tune your ecom strategy and tech stack.
- 45:33Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 45:36like to discuss an ecommerce project.
- 45:38We hope you enjoy the latest episode.