Latest / The NanceCast / Benjamin Studebaker on Populism, Rupert Lowe, and Christopher Nolan.
Transcript
- 0:00[music]
- 0:37SPEAKER_02: right.
- 0:38SPEAKER_02: And...
- 0:40SPEAKER_02: All right, everybody, welcome back to another fantastic episode of the Nance cast.
- 0:44SPEAKER_02: Today, Mikey and I are joined by a special, special, special, special, special, special guest.
- 0:49SPEAKER_02: Benjamin, it's always wonderful to have you on.
- 0:52SPEAKER_02: Thanks for hanging out again with us.
- 0:57SPEAKER_02: We talked a little bit beforehand.
- 0:59SPEAKER_02: I don't know where this conversation is going to go and I like it that way.
- 1:04SPEAKER_02: But for those of you who want to know what we're going to talk about beforehand, I don't know.
- 1:10SPEAKER_02: Maybe we'll talk.
- 1:10SPEAKER_02: Talk about something called post-right populism.
- 1:13SPEAKER_02: Talk about what even is populism in the first place?
- 1:16SPEAKER_02: What even is politics in the first place?
- 1:18SPEAKER_02: And we might get into some spicier questions as well.
- 1:23SPEAKER_02: But before we get all into that, Mikey, what's up?
- 1:27SPEAKER_02: What it do?
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: I'm looking at those two sexy commodities you have sitting over there.
- 1:35SPEAKER_01: Sign value?
- 1:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah, your sign value.
- 1:37SPEAKER_01: You got your Studebaker book.
- 1:40SPEAKER_01: And look at that thing.
- 1:42SPEAKER_01: Studebaker book first.
- 1:44SPEAKER_01: There you go.
- 1:45SPEAKER_01: Now available in paperback.
- 1:47SPEAKER_01: Yep.
- 1:48SPEAKER_01: Go get it on Amazon.
- 1:50SPEAKER_02: Cambridge University Press, or you can get it on Amazon, I'm sure.
- 1:54SPEAKER_00: Edinburgh.
- 1:54SPEAKER_00: Edinburgh.
- 1:55SPEAKER_02: Edinburgh.
- 1:55SPEAKER_02: Edinburgh.
- 1:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:56SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 2:00SPEAKER_01: And then... And this guy.
- 2:01SPEAKER_01: Look at that.
- 2:03SPEAKER_01: That is just yummy.
- 2:05SPEAKER_01: Yummy.
- 2:07SPEAKER_01: Okay, I do have a complaint.
- 2:09SPEAKER_01: Season four is not aesthetically, it doesn't match up with the other ones.
- 2:16SPEAKER_01: All of us nerds are complaining about the way they did.
- 2:21SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's off.
- 2:23SPEAKER_01: But just one of the coolest box sets ever made.
- 2:27SPEAKER_02: I think it might be second to the Twin Peaks box set, in my opinion.
- 2:32SPEAKER_01: Right, yeah.
- 2:34SPEAKER_01: They went all out with this, though.
- 2:36SPEAKER_01: So, yeah, I told you guys before, a couple things I want to bring up tonight.
- 2:43SPEAKER_01: We'll get to that later.
- 2:45SPEAKER_01: But no, it's just always fun to have a conversation with you two.
- 2:49SPEAKER_01: So we'll see where the conversation takes us.
- 2:54SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's great to be back.
- 2:55SPEAKER_00: I'm excited to talk about this stuff.
- 2:58SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:59SPEAKER_02: I mean, I've told you many times,
- 3:01SPEAKER_02: Benjamin, there are a few people that I think of when I think of politics.
- 3:06SPEAKER_02: And you're like the first person that comes to mind when I have political questions.
- 3:12SPEAKER_02: And recently, there's this guy named Rupert Lowe.
- 3:16SPEAKER_02: He used to be besties with Nigel Farage.
- 3:19SPEAKER_02: And then they had a falling out.
- 3:22SPEAKER_02: And I'm not sure over what.
- 3:24SPEAKER_02: But then I saw Rupert Lowe pop up on Joe Rogan.
- 3:28SPEAKER_02: And I didn't listen to that whole episode, but I just found it a bit odd.
- 3:32SPEAKER_02: I felt that was a little bit of an extreme guest for Joe Rogan.
- 3:38SPEAKER_02: And we were already had talked a little bit about post-right populism in general.
- 3:45SPEAKER_02: And I don't know, what is it?
- 3:47SPEAKER_02: I think a lot of people in America have seen what appears to be a fracturing of
- 3:52SPEAKER_02: the so-called right with Tucker and Candace and Marjorie Taylor Greene and Trump.
- 4:00SPEAKER_02: I don't know if anybody caught the Lindsey Graham Memorial Service,
- 4:03SPEAKER_02: but that was a bit strange, a bit odd.
- 4:09SPEAKER_02: But yeah,
- 4:09SPEAKER_02: it does seem to be the case,
- 4:11SPEAKER_02: at least apparently, that the right is in a little bit of disarray.
- 4:15SPEAKER_02: And I think it's evident that the left has been in some disarray for quite some time now.
- 4:24SPEAKER_02: But is the right even in disarray or is this a misunderstanding
- 4:29SPEAKER_02: or I don't know what all is going on with it?
- 4:33SPEAKER_00: So the right is definitely populist in much the same way that the left has been populist.
- 4:39SPEAKER_00: Indeed, you might remember some years ago,
- 4:41SPEAKER_00: populism was assumed to be right coded much of the time.
- 4:44SPEAKER_00: And people on the left who wanted to be populist had to explain how it was possible
- 4:48SPEAKER_00: to be populist from the left.
- 4:50SPEAKER_00: So populism involves a kind of floating signifier.
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: It can be a term,
- 4:58SPEAKER_00: but often it's a particular leader who can be many different things
- 5:03SPEAKER_00: to many different parts of the populist coalition.
- 5:06SPEAKER_00: Why do you need this floating signifier leader?
- 5:09SPEAKER_00: Populism arises when the unit that you used to take as the unit that was the base
- 5:15SPEAKER_00: of your activity has fractured or gone away or ceased to be sufficient in itself.
- 5:23SPEAKER_00: And you have to make up for the loss of this unit by constructing an alliance
- 5:27SPEAKER_00: or coalition of other things that don't agree with each other.
- 5:32SPEAKER_00: And in the course of constructing that alliance,
- 5:34SPEAKER_00: you have to be all things to all the different parts of the alliance.
- 5:37SPEAKER_00: Now, once you win and you take office, you then have to do certain things.
- 5:42SPEAKER_00: And in doing certain things, you can no longer do everything.
- 5:46SPEAKER_00: So when you're running for office,
- 5:47SPEAKER_00: each of the parts of the populist coalition imagines, yes,
- 5:50SPEAKER_00: we all agree with each other,
- 5:52SPEAKER_00: but I really understand the leader and the leader really understands me.
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: And when we get into office, the leader is going to listen to me.
- 5:59SPEAKER_00: He's not going to listen to those other people.
- 6:01SPEAKER_00: I've talked to the leader.
- 6:03SPEAKER_00: And this is the case, especially for people in the inner circle.
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: It's not just that ordinary people are deceived in populism.
- 6:08SPEAKER_00: It's that people in the inner circle think that they know the leader.
- 6:12SPEAKER_00: And you see this with Trump.
- 6:14SPEAKER_00: There's this court politics where the different parties Parts of
- 6:16SPEAKER_00: the populist coalition each think, oh, don't worry.
- 6:19SPEAKER_00: Yes, yes, he says all these other wacky things.
- 6:21SPEAKER_00: But when the time comes, I'll be the one in the room with him and he'll listen to me.
- 6:26SPEAKER_00: He's reasonable.
- 6:26SPEAKER_00: He's a smart guy.
- 6:28SPEAKER_00: I know him.
- 6:28SPEAKER_00: I've talked to him.
- 6:29SPEAKER_00: That's what these people say to themselves, ultimately.
- 6:33SPEAKER_00: So when you're in opposition, it's easy to do populism on the basis of a popular front.
- 6:39SPEAKER_00: So you say, hey, yes,
- 6:40SPEAKER_00: we all disagree with each other,
- 6:41SPEAKER_00: but you know,
- 6:42SPEAKER_00: we all agree that we have to stop the current thing that's in office
- 6:46SPEAKER_00: that we don't like.
- 6:47SPEAKER_00: So when you're in opposition,
- 6:49SPEAKER_00: it's really easy to do populism because you just do it in a negative way
- 6:52SPEAKER_00: and you make a popular front.
- 6:54SPEAKER_00: But once you approach power or get into office,
- 6:57SPEAKER_00: or even if you don't do that,
- 6:59SPEAKER_00: if you run this thing for a long period of time,
- 7:03SPEAKER_00: It tends to be difficult to sustain the level of unity that you start out with.
- 7:08SPEAKER_00: In the case of Nigel Farage,
- 7:10SPEAKER_00: Nigel Farage has done populism by making himself the floating signifier.
- 7:15SPEAKER_00: So there are libertarians who want to see the UK Americanized, who love Nigel Farage.
- 7:22SPEAKER_00: And then there are also nationalists who are committed to an old antique version
- 7:29SPEAKER_00: from the post-war era of what Britain should be.
- 7:32SPEAKER_00: And they like Nigel Farage.
- 7:34SPEAKER_00: And these people are both courted by Nigel Farage.
- 7:38SPEAKER_00: You have these old labor voters in the North that are courted by Nigel Farage.
- 7:43SPEAKER_00: And then you have these very libertarian,
- 7:45SPEAKER_00: very economically right-wing Thatcherite types who are courted by Nigel Farage.
- 7:49SPEAKER_00: Ultimately, of course, you couldn't have all of these people supporting the same government.
- 7:53SPEAKER_00: You might get these people to vote for the same party in an election,
- 7:57SPEAKER_00: but that party would then govern in a way that would quickly alienate some part of
- 8:00SPEAKER_00: that coalition or other.
- 8:02SPEAKER_00: In the case of Farage,
- 8:04SPEAKER_00: he's been doing this for a long time and he has this habit
- 8:08SPEAKER_00: of anytime anybody else comes up in any of the parties that he's run,
- 8:13SPEAKER_00: say UKIP or NOW Reform or the Brexit party in between it was UKIP and then
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: the Brexit party and NOW Reform.
- 8:19SPEAKER_00: He doesn't want there to be another person in the party who can be
- 8:24SPEAKER_00: a floating signifier and can be all things to all people because that could produce
- 8:29SPEAKER_00: A conflict in the party that could result in his ouster.
- 8:32SPEAKER_00: And because he's leading a fragile populist coalition,
- 8:35SPEAKER_00: the whole party might not survive that kind of conflict.
- 8:38SPEAKER_00: He doesn't lead something that's an institutional old-fashioned European party.
- 8:42SPEAKER_00: It's not like the Conservative Party or the Labour Party where you have a members-based party.
- 8:48SPEAKER_00: What he runs is a donor-based front where they take in money often
- 8:53SPEAKER_00: from quite rich people or corporate entities or think tanks and foundations and so
- 8:59SPEAKER_00: on.
- 9:00SPEAKER_00: And then Farage keeps everybody on board,
- 9:04SPEAKER_00: even though this money is coming from people that lots of the people who might vote
- 9:08SPEAKER_00: for the party don't trust.
- 9:10SPEAKER_00: And people think, well,
- 9:11SPEAKER_00: if you can just expose that Farage is corrupt or that Farage has dealings
- 9:15SPEAKER_00: with people that some of the people who vote for the party don't like,
- 9:19SPEAKER_00: then that would be enough to potentially eject him or humiliate him.
- 9:22SPEAKER_00: But part of the way that the populism works is That people say,
- 9:26SPEAKER_00: well, of course, he's just constructing the coalition.
- 9:28SPEAKER_00: But when he gets into office, he'll listen to us.
- 9:31SPEAKER_00: We know him and we've listened to him.
- 9:33SPEAKER_00: And come on, he gets us.
- 9:35SPEAKER_00: And he may say other things to other people.
- 9:37SPEAKER_00: But ultimately, come on, of course.
- 9:40SPEAKER_00: This is the story that always is told.
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: And the thing about the populist is that the populist can play this game with lots
- 9:46SPEAKER_00: and lots of groups because each group believes that when push comes to shove,
- 9:50SPEAKER_00: the populist is going to listen to them.
- 9:53SPEAKER_00: So Farage,
- 9:55SPEAKER_00: because he doesn't allow anyone else to become a major figure,
- 9:59SPEAKER_00: And because he has been in British politics continuously for a long period of time,
- 10:04SPEAKER_00: there is a tendency for people to split from him out of frustration
- 10:07SPEAKER_00: at how he suppresses their profile and prevents them from becoming major figures.
- 10:12SPEAKER_00: These people often develop a personal animus toward Farage
- 10:15SPEAKER_00: because Farage is doing this on the level of personalities in the party.
- 10:19SPEAKER_00: He will not allow his party to have multiple dominant personalities in it.
- 10:24SPEAKER_00: At the same time,
- 10:26SPEAKER_00: he will stifle and destroy the careers of people to prevent this from happening.
- 10:31SPEAKER_00: And these people inevitably grow resentful and then look for potential opportunities
- 10:36SPEAKER_00: to break out.
- 10:37SPEAKER_00: The thing is,
- 10:37SPEAKER_00: if you break out,
- 10:38SPEAKER_00: you don't generally succeed in replacing Farage,
- 10:41SPEAKER_00: but you can potentially get some votes and damage the party.
- 10:45SPEAKER_00: And this allows you to at least pose a threat to him that might cause him to be...
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: To have a need to avoid upsetting you and potentially avoid upsetting the part of
- 10:58SPEAKER_00: the movement that you're close to.
- 11:00SPEAKER_00: So Rupert Lowe tried to ally with Elon Musk and then use Elon Musk's resources
- 11:07SPEAKER_00: to pressure Sure,
- 11:09SPEAKER_00: Nigel Farage,
- 11:10SPEAKER_00: effectively, out of discontent with the way Nigel Farage runs his apparatus.
- 11:14SPEAKER_00: But the way Nigel Farage runs his apparatus is,
- 11:17SPEAKER_00: to a large degree, prefigured by the fact that it's a populist apparatus.
- 11:21SPEAKER_00: It's not a members-based traditional European political party.
- 11:25SPEAKER_02: Is Restore a threat to Reform at all?
- 11:30SPEAKER_02: Or is it totally...
- 11:31SPEAKER_02: I mean, we can't say it is a threat or it isn't a threat.
- 11:36SPEAKER_02: But like, Rupert Lowe seems more interesting to me...
- 11:42SPEAKER_02: I don't think that Rupert Lowe can be Prime Minister.
- 12:03SPEAKER_00: I do think that Rupert Lowe can,
- 12:05SPEAKER_00: in some constituencies,
- 12:07SPEAKER_00: run a candidate who gets 3%,
- 12:09SPEAKER_00: which can be the difference in a UK election because it works on first past
- 12:13SPEAKER_00: the post.
- 12:14SPEAKER_00: So if you can reduce somebody's vote share by just a few points in
- 12:17SPEAKER_00: a competitive competition,
- 12:19SPEAKER_00: Constituency, you can cause them to lose that constituency.
- 12:22SPEAKER_00: And it's often the case in the UK that you can win,
- 12:24SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 12:24SPEAKER_00: 10% of the vote and get no seats because you don't get a plurality in any
- 12:29SPEAKER_00: of those first past the post districts.
- 12:32SPEAKER_00: So people care a lot in the UK about voting.
- 12:33SPEAKER_00: Very small numbers of vote percentages.
- 12:37SPEAKER_00: And so even if Restore polls at 3%, 5%,
- 12:42SPEAKER_00: negligible numbers,
- 12:43SPEAKER_00: gets no seats in parliament,
- 12:45SPEAKER_00: it could cause the Reform Party to not win a large number of other seats.
- 12:52SPEAKER_00: Who would win those seats?
- 12:53SPEAKER_00: Labor, the conservatives.
- 12:55SPEAKER_00: So I have tended to make the argument that Rupert Lowe is effectively a device
- 13:01SPEAKER_00: for labor in the conservatives.
- 13:03SPEAKER_00: They're the ones who potentially will benefit the most from his activity.
- 13:07SPEAKER_02: A spoiler,
- 13:07SPEAKER_02: like we'll see,
- 13:08SPEAKER_02: I think, I mean, it was just a primary season here in the United States.
- 13:14SPEAKER_02: People run spoilers,
- 13:15SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 13:15SPEAKER_02: they'll be the mainstream conservative,
- 13:18SPEAKER_02: they'll be the mainline Democrat,
- 13:20SPEAKER_02: and then they'll be the radical leftist who's the scary kind of radical leftist.
- 13:27SPEAKER_02: But yeah, people run spoilers.
- 13:29SPEAKER_02: But I mean,
- 13:30SPEAKER_02: I think this time around with some of the primaries,
- 13:33SPEAKER_02: it seemed to be the case that the The radical leftist won the Democratic majority
- 13:38SPEAKER_02: over the mainline Democrat DNC.
- 13:46SPEAKER_00: The British districts,
- 13:47SPEAKER_00: the way that they operate in different districts,
- 13:49SPEAKER_00: different parties are competitive because in the UK there isn't just two parties.
- 13:53SPEAKER_00: There are two parties that might actually produce a prime minister,
- 13:56SPEAKER_00: but there's a significant number of parties that can compete to be first or second.
- 14:01SPEAKER_00: In a particular constituency.
- 14:04SPEAKER_00: So there's,
- 14:06SPEAKER_00: because of that additional number of parties that are significant real players,
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: there's a lot of funny ways that you can spoil UK elections without
- 14:16SPEAKER_00: Without posing any chance of winning.
- 14:18SPEAKER_00: Whereas in the States,
- 14:19SPEAKER_00: the way it would typically work is that very quickly you get it down to two in
- 14:22SPEAKER_00: a general election.
- 14:23SPEAKER_00: It's really hard to go into an American general election
- 14:26SPEAKER_00: with three viable candidates or three candidates that can win 10% or more of
- 14:30SPEAKER_00: the vote.
- 14:31SPEAKER_00: In the UK,
- 14:32SPEAKER_00: you'll see in the run-up to an election,
- 14:34SPEAKER_00: all of the parties will put out their polls and say,
- 14:36SPEAKER_00: only we can win here or the other party that you hate.
- 14:40SPEAKER_00: But people won't necessarily agree on only who can win here.
- 14:44SPEAKER_00: They might say, well, you claim only you can win.
- 14:46SPEAKER_00: And so what will very often happen is that you'll have a district
- 14:51SPEAKER_00: where somebody gets like 25% and then somebody else gets 22 and
- 14:56SPEAKER_00: then several other parties get, you know, 10 or 15.
- 14:59SPEAKER_00: And these votes are wasted in terms of, you know, And I think that's a good point.
- 15:02SPEAKER_00: I think that's a good point.
- 15:28SPEAKER_00: Nonetheless,
- 15:29SPEAKER_00: if that party gets the plurality in a large enough number of places,
- 15:32SPEAKER_00: they can have a majority in parliament and then pass budgets.
- 15:35SPEAKER_00: So the British system is designed to work with a very divided society.
- 15:40SPEAKER_00: And in that respect,
- 15:41SPEAKER_00: the British system is more compatible with the fracturing of the populace,
- 15:48SPEAKER_00: of the nation,
- 15:49SPEAKER_00: of the proletariat,
- 15:51SPEAKER_00: of the working class, whichever unit it is that we're coming into this book.
- 15:55SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 15:55SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 15:56SPEAKER_02: I do remember...
- 15:58SPEAKER_02: Being a kid,
- 16:00SPEAKER_02: Ross Perot and Ralph Nader and like all these guys,
- 16:03SPEAKER_02: people cursed them because they were like,
- 16:05SPEAKER_02: damn them,
- 16:06SPEAKER_02: they took away our hope of making any real change because people who did vote
- 16:11SPEAKER_02: for them threw away their vote.
- 16:13SPEAKER_02: And I think,
- 16:14SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 16:15SPEAKER_02: Elizabeth Warren,
- 16:18SPEAKER_02: I can't remember her name now,
- 16:19SPEAKER_02: but she seemed to get a lot of love from DSA type people a few years ago.
- 16:24SPEAKER_02: But yeah, I mean, there's always this question of don't throw away your vote.
- 16:30SPEAKER_02: Cards on the table, the last presidential election, I wrote in Harambe.
- 16:33SPEAKER_02: I do think it's worth voting in things that affect me here locally,
- 16:42SPEAKER_02: ballot measures and local representatives,
- 16:45SPEAKER_02: town-level stuff, because I think that has more of a chance of being effective.
- 16:52SPEAKER_02: But yeah, I don't think I've ever felt represented by an American...
- 16:58SPEAKER_02: National level candidate, like not even representatives or senators or anything like that.
- 17:03SPEAKER_02: And that's not to say I feel represented by local politicians, but it is closer to home.
- 17:08SPEAKER_02: And I feel like it is more effective because at least they understand what's happening.
- 17:12SPEAKER_02: And I don't know, but...
- 17:15SPEAKER_02: All that is I don't want to have a conversation about whether or not we should vote.
- 17:21SPEAKER_02: If it feels right in your heart to vote, dear reader, go vote.
- 17:24SPEAKER_02: If not, don't do it.
- 17:26SPEAKER_02: I'm not here to moralize about voting.
- 17:29SPEAKER_00: I'm not here to moralize about that either.
- 17:30SPEAKER_00: I haven't voted for a major party U.S. presidential candidate at any point.
- 17:38SPEAKER_02: But so the the UK and even Europe,
- 17:45SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 17:45SPEAKER_02: I think there's interesting things happening in Hungary and Poland and even in like
- 17:52SPEAKER_02: the It does seem like there's interesting things happening.
- 17:57SPEAKER_02: There might be real things happening there, maybe.
- 18:00SPEAKER_02: Although, again, maybe not.
- 18:01SPEAKER_02: It's all from a distance.
- 18:02SPEAKER_02: And so I'm projecting this fantasy of, like, well, at least they can make change happen.
- 18:07SPEAKER_02: But here in America,
- 18:08SPEAKER_02: it also seems to be the case that there's a lot of fracturing,
- 18:12SPEAKER_02: a lot of splintering, a lot of, you know, campism even maybe among the right.
- 18:19SPEAKER_02: And...
- 18:21SPEAKER_02: You know, the war in Iran, all the stuff going on, Venezuela, Palestine.
- 18:31SPEAKER_02: It feels like Trump has lost support.
- 18:34SPEAKER_02: And Mikey and I have talked about that for a while.
- 18:36SPEAKER_02: And I don't know if either one of us understand what that's doing to the party,
- 18:41SPEAKER_02: if anything at all.
- 18:43SPEAKER_02: And on top of that, it also feels like...
- 18:45SPEAKER_02: I mean, I watch Tucker Carlson all the time.
- 18:48SPEAKER_02: And he said some crazy shit.
- 18:50SPEAKER_02: He continues to say crazy things.
- 18:53SPEAKER_02: But it does feel like he's distancing himself more and more from mainline Republicans.
- 18:59SPEAKER_02: Um...
- 19:00SPEAKER_02: Candace Owens, Nick Fuentes.
- 19:03SPEAKER_02: Mikey, did Nick Fuentes tell people to vote for a Democrat?
- 19:06SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 19:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 19:09SPEAKER_01: He's straight up telling his audience to vote Democrat.
- 19:15SPEAKER_01: I think it's some kind of...
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: In his mind,
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: it's some sort of accelerationist logic,
- 19:21SPEAKER_01: make things worse so we have a new opportunity to start fresh.
- 19:27SPEAKER_01: And of course,
- 19:28SPEAKER_01: the whole point is so they can,
- 19:30SPEAKER_01: in his mind, get a real rightist in because he thinks Trump's so compromised.
- 19:38SPEAKER_01: But yeah, I mean,
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: the big three who seem to,
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: and maybe four,
- 19:44SPEAKER_01: but the big three that come to mind who have,
- 19:48SPEAKER_01: Distance themselves from Trump are Fuentes,
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: Carlson, and Candace Owens, but also Alex Jones in certain ways now as well.
- 20:01SPEAKER_02: I think even Vin Shapiro a little bit maybe.
- 20:07SPEAKER_00: In a different way from those guys.
- 20:08SPEAKER_00: A lot of the media people have noticed that the kind
- 20:12SPEAKER_00: of anti-establishment media audience
- 20:15SPEAKER_00: for political influencers is foreign policy oriented much more than
- 20:21SPEAKER_00: the general public is.
- 20:23SPEAKER_00: So the media people online get very worked up
- 20:25SPEAKER_00: about foreign policy issues like Israel-Palestine,
- 20:28SPEAKER_00: like Ukraine-Russia, like the Iran War.
- 20:33SPEAKER_00: Online, there's an incredible demand to talk about these things at the level of IR
- 20:38SPEAKER_00: and geostrategy.
- 20:40SPEAKER_00: It doesn't necessarily match up with what the median voter is interested in or cares
- 20:45SPEAKER_00: about or what the public as a whole is interested in or cares about.
- 20:50SPEAKER_00: So if you're on the Internet a lot and you're paying attention
- 20:53SPEAKER_00: to what's marketable politics,
- 20:56SPEAKER_00: It's not marketable right now to be defending the foreign policy positions that
- 21:01SPEAKER_00: the Trump administration has taken in the Middle East with respect to Ukraine.
- 21:07SPEAKER_00: And a lot of the more interesting elements of what is going on in the world today
- 21:12SPEAKER_00: to do with the trade war stuff and the NATO expansion.
- 21:18SPEAKER_00: So we're getting this kind of flat foreign policy discussion that's very much like
- 21:21SPEAKER_00: about sports.
- 21:33SPEAKER_00: And all of this is quite estranged from decision-making.
- 21:48SPEAKER_00: I think the Trump administration is making foreign policy decisions based
- 21:52SPEAKER_00: on what Tucker or Candace or Ben Shapiro or any of those guys are saying.
- 21:58SPEAKER_00: I do think that there's a more interesting set of splits that is taking place at
- 22:04SPEAKER_00: the level of right wing.
- 22:07SPEAKER_00: So above the media conversation,
- 22:11SPEAKER_00: one of the things I've noticed is that the religious post-liberals and
- 22:15SPEAKER_00: the national post-liberals or the national conservatives are having
- 22:18SPEAKER_00: a harder time getting along.
- 22:20SPEAKER_00: People like Patrick Deneen were very,
- 22:23SPEAKER_00: very excited about the Trump administration during, say, 2024.
- 22:28SPEAKER_00: And now Patrick Deneen is writing about classics.
- 22:32SPEAKER_00: He doesn't really seem to want to talk very much about the Trump administration.
- 22:36SPEAKER_00: And meanwhile,
- 22:37SPEAKER_00: the people who seem most excited and who are interacting most frequently with
- 22:41SPEAKER_00: the Trump administration are the kind of NatCon people like Yoram Hazoni.
- 22:47SPEAKER_00: Those are the guys who are having Trump administration people speaking
- 22:50SPEAKER_00: at their events while they're sitting as Trump administration people.
- 22:54SPEAKER_00: So I think that that's a split that is more significant.
- 22:59SPEAKER_00: And I've noticed that some of the,
- 23:01SPEAKER_00: especially British or European national conservatives,
- 23:04SPEAKER_00: have become upset with Trump administration behavior on certain issues,
- 23:09SPEAKER_00: and particularly the religious post-nationalists like John Milbank
- 23:15SPEAKER_00: or Adrian Pabst have become quite oppositional to Trump-style national conservatism.
- 23:24SPEAKER_00: And then also you've got,
- 23:25SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 23:25SPEAKER_00: Elon Musk,
- 23:27SPEAKER_00: when he came into the administration,
- 23:29SPEAKER_00: he very quickly proved to be not popular with the public to the point where even
- 23:34SPEAKER_00: though he was donating an incredible amount of money,
- 23:38SPEAKER_00: the Republicans in the caucus didn't want anything to do with him
- 23:43SPEAKER_00: because being associated with him was so damaging that no amount of money
- 23:47SPEAKER_00: from him could make up for this.
- 23:50SPEAKER_00: And there were people making statements to Politico journalists
- 23:55SPEAKER_00: about how much he was a liability and how bad he was.
- 23:58SPEAKER_00: And you looked at his net favorability rating,
- 24:01SPEAKER_00: and it was the lowest of any prominent Republican-affiliated figure.
- 24:06SPEAKER_00: So he's exiled from the administration,
- 24:12SPEAKER_00: and he could potentially continue to be a player in the Republican Party,
- 24:16SPEAKER_00: but if that's going to be the case, he'll have to go back to donating.
- 24:19SPEAKER_00: He's established to everybody that having him out in front and having him
- 24:23SPEAKER_00: at events is not politically helpful or useful at this stage.
- 24:27SPEAKER_00: And, you know,
- 24:28SPEAKER_00: then when he goes and gets involved in British politics,
- 24:30SPEAKER_00: it's by trying to up Rupert Lowe.
- 24:33SPEAKER_00: And insofar as he does that,
- 24:35SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 24:35SPEAKER_00: I think Rupert Lowe's tie to Elon Musk is one of the things that kind
- 24:38SPEAKER_00: of limits his growth and development because Elon Musk is
- 24:42SPEAKER_00: the least popular major figure in the Anglosphere associated with the right.
- 24:48SPEAKER_00: But he has an enormous amount of money.
- 24:50SPEAKER_00: So he'll give you money.
- 24:51SPEAKER_00: And if you don't care that much about actually winning the election,
- 24:54SPEAKER_00: then you're happy to be associated with him.
- 24:57SPEAKER_00: And Rupert Lowe and taking his money can have the resources he needs to frustrate
- 25:02SPEAKER_00: and upset Nigel Farage and get revenge on Nigel Farage.
- 25:06SPEAKER_00: And then also,
- 25:07SPEAKER_00: Elon Musk,
- 25:08SPEAKER_00: by upping Rupert Lowe,
- 25:09SPEAKER_00: can pressure Nigel Farage to adopt positions that are more favorable to Elon Musk
- 25:14SPEAKER_00: without Elon Musk having to become tied politically to Nigel Farage in a way
- 25:18SPEAKER_00: that would be a liability for Nigel Farage going into the next UK general election.
- 25:23SPEAKER_02: Sneaky, sneaky, sneaky.
- 25:29SPEAKER_02: I mean, there's, I guess there's multiple stories about why the left is ineffective.
- 25:37SPEAKER_02: And part of me wants to hold on to this belief that, well,
- 25:41SPEAKER_02: the left is,
- 25:42SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 25:42SPEAKER_02: the proper left,
- 25:43SPEAKER_02: not What passes for the left,
- 25:46SPEAKER_02: but the proper left,
- 25:47SPEAKER_02: the left is properly radical and is properly dedicated to emancipation and
- 25:53SPEAKER_02: the global system of governance that is capitalism can't abide that.
- 26:00SPEAKER_02: And so it's going to get squished.
- 26:02SPEAKER_02: It's going to send in the antibodies and it's going to send in the CIA and all this other stuff.
- 26:07SPEAKER_02: And it will necessarily fail.
- 26:10SPEAKER_02: Because it is truly radical and we haven't figured out how to do something radical.
- 26:15SPEAKER_02: That's one story about why the left isn't effective.
- 26:18SPEAKER_02: I think another story about why the left isn't effective is because it's just
- 26:21SPEAKER_02: a bunch of naive people with bleeding hearts who start out wanting to make
- 26:28SPEAKER_02: a long march through the institutions.
- 26:30SPEAKER_02: And then somewhere along the way, they become jaded and burnt out and cynical.
- 26:34SPEAKER_02: And they're like, well, I can't really make any change happen, but I will secure my career.
- 26:38SPEAKER_02: And so be it.
- 26:39SPEAKER_02: And therefore we'll enter stasis and nothing will change until the cows come home.
- 26:44SPEAKER_02: And I honestly think that's the more parsimonious story.
- 26:51SPEAKER_02: I think that's what happens.
- 26:56SPEAKER_02: And within all that,
- 26:57SPEAKER_02: I can understand why there's kind of fracture and why it doesn't seem to
- 27:01SPEAKER_02: The left is ineffective.
- 27:02SPEAKER_02: That makes sense.
- 27:03SPEAKER_02: I know why.
- 27:03SPEAKER_02: Why?
- 27:31SPEAKER_01: Because Slavoj Zizek took a photo with George Soros' son.
- 27:38SPEAKER_01: That's why we can't have nice things.
- 27:40SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 27:45SPEAKER_02: Just on that note...
- 27:47SPEAKER_02: Anyone who's upset about that, you have the mind of a child.
- 27:51SPEAKER_02: Slavoj Zizek has decades of just he's demonstrated over decades his work
- 27:58SPEAKER_02: and his commitment and his dedication and who he is.
- 28:00SPEAKER_02: He's shown us who he is in his own words.
- 28:03SPEAKER_02: Mikey, you and I have disagreements with him.
- 28:06SPEAKER_02: I would like to hold him down and say, hey, man, check your email.
- 28:08SPEAKER_02: Hey, man.
- 28:11SPEAKER_02: But ultimately,
- 28:12SPEAKER_02: at the end of the day,
- 28:14SPEAKER_02: people who are now spiraling out of control because they think, oh,
- 28:18SPEAKER_02: he took a picture with someone who I may not like,
- 28:22SPEAKER_02: therefore he's a fraud, therefore let's throw away four decades worth of work.
- 28:27SPEAKER_01: I saw somebody say this has Chomsky-Epstein vibes.
- 28:32SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 28:35SPEAKER_01: So, I mean,
- 28:36SPEAKER_01: while we're on it,
- 28:37SPEAKER_01: Benjamin, what do you think, like, He took a photo with Soros' kid.
- 28:43SPEAKER_00: Is this damning?
- 28:45SPEAKER_00: I oppose guilt by association.
- 28:48SPEAKER_00: I oppose trying to judge people on the basis of who their friends are rather
- 28:53SPEAKER_00: than engaging with their ideas or trying to use people's friends or associations or
- 28:58SPEAKER_00: who they get money from as a substitute for
- 29:03SPEAKER_00: But people who are not able to or not willing to deal with the ideas
- 29:07SPEAKER_00: or have already decided for one reason or another that the ideas ought
- 29:10SPEAKER_00: to be rejected by other people will use this kind of stuff as opposition research
- 29:14SPEAKER_00: to try to get people to not.
- 29:16SPEAKER_00: I don't think theorists should be doing opposition research
- 29:23SPEAKER_00: on other theorists like they're political candidates.
- 29:25SPEAKER_00: I don't think it's appropriate to treat other intellectuals as if they're political figures.
- 29:30SPEAKER_00: I think it's part of the pretending that things are political
- 29:33SPEAKER_00: that aren't really political thing that people in
- 29:36SPEAKER_00: the millennial generation have been perfecting over the course of the last 15,
- 29:41SPEAKER_00: 20 years.
- 29:44SPEAKER_02: Representation has come to replace any real activity or any action.
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: Well, someone might say,
- 29:53SPEAKER_01: you know, a real leftist wouldn't even engage in this type of cooperation.
- 29:58SPEAKER_01: Is it even cooperate?
- 29:59SPEAKER_01: I mean, I guess, dude,
- 30:00SPEAKER_01: go put your heroin on
- 30:02SPEAKER_02: a spoon out behind the goddamn train tracks,
- 30:04SPEAKER_02: you fucking lame ass.
- 30:05SPEAKER_02: I'm sorry, dude.
- 30:06SPEAKER_02: Like that whole defeatist mentality of, oh, we have to be radical.
- 30:10SPEAKER_02: Therefore, we can't.
- 30:11SPEAKER_02: No, dude, this stuff takes money.
- 30:13SPEAKER_02: It takes support.
- 30:14SPEAKER_02: It takes structure.
- 30:15SPEAKER_02: It takes institutions like.
- 30:17SPEAKER_02: We can't live in the fantasy world of-
- 30:41SPEAKER_00: Patrons can audience capture you,
- 30:43SPEAKER_00: and professional institutions can lock you in an administrative bureaucratic box.
- 30:48SPEAKER_00: So all of these things have their advantages and disadvantages,
- 30:53SPEAKER_00: and it's not as if there's any kind of magic solution.
- 30:56SPEAKER_00: Your goal is to think and talk and write about stuff in capitalism or
- 31:02SPEAKER_00: in any other kind of society which is heretofore existed that's been compatible
- 31:06SPEAKER_00: with agriculture.
- 31:08SPEAKER_00: You're going to be trying to get away with doing something
- 31:11SPEAKER_00: while other people are stuck having to work in the mines.
- 31:15SPEAKER_00: And that's going to involve a certain amount of dirtying your hands.
- 31:20SPEAKER_00: Regardless, regardless.
- 31:22SPEAKER_00: And so if you sit here and say, well, anyone who has dirty hands can't produce theory.
- 31:27SPEAKER_00: Now you can't read anybody.
- 31:29SPEAKER_00: And now there's no space for doing any of this.
- 31:34SPEAKER_01: When Todd McGowan talks about the leftist superego, which,
- 31:38SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:39SPEAKER_01: this kind of tendency on the left to just purity test and purity test to the point
- 31:45SPEAKER_01: where no one's left.
- 31:47SPEAKER_01: It's kind of ironic.
- 31:48SPEAKER_01: No true Scotsmen.
- 31:49SPEAKER_01: That one's left on the left.
- 31:51SPEAKER_02: There are no true Scotsmen.
- 31:52SPEAKER_02: That's why I say I am the only real anarchist that is currently living today.
- 32:00SPEAKER_02: No other person who claims to be an anarchist is a real anarchist.
- 32:03SPEAKER_02: I'm the only one.
- 32:06SPEAKER_01: The logic is like if you're a leftist, you can't be a sinner.
- 32:10SPEAKER_01: Like, I mean,
- 32:10SPEAKER_01: I don't mean to just mean it in the most straightforward religious sense,
- 32:15SPEAKER_01: but something along those lines of like, you're a sinner.
- 32:19SPEAKER_01: You're not a leftist.
- 32:22SPEAKER_00: How did the friars and the monks get their money?
- 32:25SPEAKER_00: Somebody had to give it to them because the friars and the monks put on a good show
- 32:30SPEAKER_00: or performed some kind of service.
- 32:32SPEAKER_00: All intellectuals at every stage have been to varying degrees.
- 32:36SPEAKER_00: Dancing monkeys for this or that.
- 32:38SPEAKER_00: And the goal is to limit the amount of that that you have to do so
- 32:41SPEAKER_00: that you can focus your attention for as much of your time as possible on the thing
- 32:45SPEAKER_00: that you actually want to think about, write about, and talk about.
- 32:48SPEAKER_00: But everybody has to find some kind of way to square that.
- 32:52SPEAKER_00: And getting on people about how they do it Yeah, I just don't think it helps.
- 32:57SPEAKER_00: But we're in a period right now where this is so in vogue and people are trying
- 33:01SPEAKER_00: to forget about and get rid of,
- 33:04SPEAKER_00: you know, people like Adorno on the basis of these kinds of ties and relationships.
- 33:09SPEAKER_00: And, you know,
- 33:10SPEAKER_00: and this is just a way to end up not being able to think about anything
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: and everything becomes really stupid.
- 33:16SPEAKER_01: Yeah, but I've had people like in the last day say,
- 33:20SPEAKER_01: is it time for you to distance yourself from Zizek?
- 33:23SPEAKER_01: I'm like, well, that's not happening.
- 33:24SPEAKER_01: Like, Because I don't give a fuck about this at all.
- 33:28SPEAKER_01: I mean, I saw that Twitter seemed to care, or X, whatever.
- 33:32SPEAKER_01: A lot.
- 33:33SPEAKER_01: A lot of people care, dude.
- 33:35SPEAKER_01: I don't care.
- 33:38SPEAKER_01: Again, because it boils down to...
- 33:40SPEAKER_01: Slavoj Zizek is sublime object of ideology,
- 33:43SPEAKER_01: tearing with the negative less than nothing.
- 33:46SPEAKER_01: That's who Slavoj Zizek is to me, primarily.
- 33:50SPEAKER_01: And I don't see...
- 33:53SPEAKER_01: They've done this before.
- 33:54SPEAKER_01: I think this is the biggest little fucking meltdown they've had over him doing something.
- 33:58SPEAKER_02: They tried to cancel him a few years ago, the Tavistava.
- 34:00SPEAKER_01: I know.
- 34:03SPEAKER_01: So, but I mean, look, I...
- 34:09SPEAKER_01: I just don't know.
- 34:10SPEAKER_01: I mean, do people on the right,
- 34:11SPEAKER_01: do they have this same,
- 34:12SPEAKER_01: they have their meltdowns,
- 34:14SPEAKER_01: but do they do it over somebody having a dirty association?
- 34:21SPEAKER_01: It seems more like this is a leftist thing.
- 34:24SPEAKER_00: No, they do it too.
- 34:26SPEAKER_00: Right now,
- 34:26SPEAKER_00: a lot of them are doing it about anyone who's connected with people who have a lot
- 34:34SPEAKER_00: of money who are of the Jewish religion.
- 34:37SPEAKER_00: There's a lot of that going on right now.
- 34:40SPEAKER_00: And that's one of the first things that they start doing,
- 34:43SPEAKER_00: talking about people who have connections to Soros, for instance.
- 34:47SPEAKER_00: That's something that they go to very quickly on the right as a way of trying to break through.
- 34:52SPEAKER_00: And then, of course, anybody who's got any sort of tie to a foreign state that they don't like.
- 34:59SPEAKER_00: And of course,
- 35:00SPEAKER_00: the right has always been grounded on fusionism,
- 35:04SPEAKER_00: Reaganite fusionism, the neocons with the social cons, with the economic cons.
- 35:11SPEAKER_00: That's the old fusion.
- 35:13SPEAKER_00: And so, of course,
- 35:15SPEAKER_00: anytime that fusion comes apart,
- 35:17SPEAKER_00: then immediately you can accuse people of having ties to whichever part of
- 35:21SPEAKER_00: the fusion you're trying to get rid of.
- 35:23SPEAKER_00: So, you know,
- 35:23SPEAKER_00: you can call somebody a Hayekian,
- 35:25SPEAKER_00: you can call somebody a Thomist,
- 35:26SPEAKER_00: you can call somebody, you know, they've got all of the same stuff.
- 35:31SPEAKER_00: And they can be very, very nasty with each other about these sorts of things.
- 35:36SPEAKER_00: The ones that are not interested in fusionism or not convinced by populism
- 35:42SPEAKER_00: and actually want their thing to carry through.
- 35:45SPEAKER_00: In part because, you know, they're right.
- 35:47SPEAKER_00: There's a part of the right that's liberal in a kind of Hayekian sense and values
- 35:51SPEAKER_00: the individual.
- 35:53SPEAKER_00: Then there's all these different kinds of post-liberal or non-liberal types of right
- 35:57SPEAKER_00: that are about God or nature or they're about the nation and the will.
- 36:03SPEAKER_00: And these are all things that can be put into competition with each other.
- 36:08SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 36:08SPEAKER_00: if you say that you're committed to the individual versus you're committed
- 36:12SPEAKER_00: to God versus you're committed to the national will,
- 36:15SPEAKER_00: those things obviously conflict and will not fit together in extremists,
- 36:20SPEAKER_00: you know, incredibly quickly.
- 36:23SPEAKER_00: Does it...
- 36:27SPEAKER_02: When I was a kid,
- 36:28SPEAKER_02: the word populism, or at least what I understood of it, it was largely a good thing.
- 36:34SPEAKER_02: It meant, oh, you were concerned with the average everyday folk.
- 36:38SPEAKER_02: And then somewhere along the way,
- 36:40SPEAKER_02: it does seem to be the case that in the late 90s,
- 36:43SPEAKER_02: up until the last probably two decades,
- 36:46SPEAKER_02: the word populism has had right connotations.
- 36:51SPEAKER_02: At least in my experience,
- 36:53SPEAKER_02: when you hear people talk about populism,
- 36:55SPEAKER_02: it's often derisively and it's often to say, oh, they're a dumb reactionary.
- 37:00SPEAKER_02: Like people have confused populist and reactionary.
- 37:03SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 37:06SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 37:06SPEAKER_02: I don't know if I've ever liked the term populism
- 37:10SPEAKER_02: because it has also always seemed like a performative thing,
- 37:14SPEAKER_02: like an ideological screen, like this fusionism.
- 37:17SPEAKER_02: We're going to appeal to this floating signifier of the populace so
- 37:21SPEAKER_02: that we can get general support so that when we have power,
- 37:25SPEAKER_02: we can go ahead and do whatever it is we wanted to do all along.
- 37:30SPEAKER_02: But...
- 37:37SPEAKER_02: It is weird that there has been a tension, especially seemingly recently with Trump.
- 37:43SPEAKER_02: Um...
- 37:44SPEAKER_02: The populist people, they'll go on and on about the farmers.
- 37:49SPEAKER_02: They'll go on and on about the Rust Belt.
- 37:51SPEAKER_02: They'll go on and on about the worker from a right-wing perspective.
- 37:56SPEAKER_02: They also love Trump the billionaire.
- 37:59SPEAKER_02: Don't you guys know that Peter Thiel is funding all this stuff?
- 38:02SPEAKER_02: Here in Arizona, I think Peter Thiel funded Blake Masters to run for the House.
- 38:10SPEAKER_02: He was doing all this populist stuff.
- 38:14SPEAKER_02: Regular, hardworking Americans.
- 38:16SPEAKER_02: Also, you know, reactionary Christian views and also a lot of weird stuff smuggled into it.
- 38:22SPEAKER_02: But then he's being like $36 million being spent on a congressional campaign.
- 38:29SPEAKER_02: That's been there the whole time with Trump,
- 38:31SPEAKER_02: but it does feel like recently the contradiction is starting to metastasize.
- 38:38SPEAKER_02: The contradiction is being felt by the Trump supporter.
- 38:41SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 38:45SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 38:45SPEAKER_02: in general,
- 38:46SPEAKER_02: as opposed to previously the Trump supporter could just brush it off
- 38:49SPEAKER_02: and do some kind of weird ideology.
- 38:51SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 38:51SPEAKER_02: Just again,
- 38:54SPEAKER_02: it feels like the right is in disarray
- 38:56SPEAKER_02: where it doesn't feel like it was maybe four years ago or two years ago or even
- 39:02SPEAKER_02: a year ago.
- 39:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 39:04SPEAKER_00: certainly not when it was in opposition or it had just won and had not yet done
- 39:08SPEAKER_00: a bunch of things,
- 39:09SPEAKER_00: which then reveals it is having a specific character that alienates various parts of
- 39:13SPEAKER_00: the Popular Front Coalition.
- 39:15SPEAKER_00: Here would be my case for why populism is reactionary, even when it's left populism.
- 39:23SPEAKER_00: It is predicated on holding onto a notion of unity,
- 39:28SPEAKER_00: which can no longer be sustained as a consequence of the way capitalism
- 39:32SPEAKER_00: and modernization have developed.
- 39:35SPEAKER_00: In its most distressed forms, the populist recognizes that the unity has been dissipated.
- 39:42SPEAKER_00: And then goes,
- 39:43SPEAKER_00: but we can recreate it by engineering it from above through the techniques
- 39:48SPEAKER_00: of sociology.
- 39:50SPEAKER_00: So the populace then tries to command the unity into existence by mastering rhetoric and media.
- 39:58SPEAKER_00: And then tries to use knowledge of communication techniques to fasten together
- 40:07SPEAKER_00: a facsimile of this thing which has gone.
- 40:11SPEAKER_00: So instead of there genuinely just being in a riot,
- 40:13SPEAKER_00: The populist sets about trying to construct that moral sensibility and
- 40:17SPEAKER_00: to make it appear by machining it into existence with human beings.
- 40:34SPEAKER_00: State institutions with donor based corporate structures, not members based stuff.
- 40:42SPEAKER_00: And I think,
- 40:43SPEAKER_00: for instance,
- 40:44SPEAKER_00: I would say that the culture comp is a sort of very early instance of this sort
- 40:49SPEAKER_00: of attempt to construct a national culture.
- 40:53SPEAKER_00: Which involves an awareness that it's not spontaneously arising.
- 40:58SPEAKER_00: You have to try to make it happen.
- 40:59SPEAKER_00: You have to try to force it to exist.
- 41:02SPEAKER_00: And since you have to try to force it to exist, you're having to constantly prune elements off.
- 41:07SPEAKER_00: So you have to constantly make forceful interventions to compel this thing to exist
- 41:11SPEAKER_00: on the basis that the theory of Siez from 200 years ago says that this thing needs
- 41:14SPEAKER_00: to exist to have a nation
- 41:35SPEAKER_00: Therefore,
- 41:36SPEAKER_00: we have to make it exist,
- 41:38SPEAKER_00: even though it no longer arises through the kind of process that
- 41:40SPEAKER_00: the French revolutionary theorists discussed and talked about.
- 41:44SPEAKER_00: And so that's where I think that this can,
- 41:47SPEAKER_00: at previous points,
- 41:48SPEAKER_00: it was possible to construct this thing with state interventions.
- 41:51SPEAKER_00: And I think this gave rise to structuralism.
- 41:52SPEAKER_00: It gave rise to the view of Althusser or Nietzsche's critique of the culture camp,
- 41:58SPEAKER_00: recognizing that people were making this thing happen.
- 42:02SPEAKER_00: And that it was a bad thing, that it was limiting us.
- 42:05SPEAKER_00: It was preventing us from being able to freely develop.
- 42:08SPEAKER_00: Now, I think that there's a lot of different operations trying to do this from lots
- 42:13SPEAKER_00: of different directions at once.
- 42:14SPEAKER_00: And it's become so fragmented that it's not even possible for them to pull it off.
- 42:18SPEAKER_00: And this is the sense in which I would say there are no fascists anymore in
- 42:23SPEAKER_00: that old sense,
- 42:23SPEAKER_00: because fascists actually could construct a national culture,
- 42:27SPEAKER_00: which could then be the basis for waging a total war.
- 42:30SPEAKER_00: But now when people try to construct some kind of unified thing,
- 42:34SPEAKER_00: they don't actually succeed in doing it.
- 42:36SPEAKER_00: And even when they make appeal to those kinds of arguments or they say
- 42:40SPEAKER_00: that they like this or that right wing thinker from 100 years ago,
- 42:45SPEAKER_00: It doesn't have the same meaning because they can't actually make the thing that
- 42:48SPEAKER_00: that right-wing thinker was looking to make.
- 42:50SPEAKER_00: They're not in anything like the same context.
- 42:53SPEAKER_00: So it just becomes LARPing.
- 42:54SPEAKER_00: It becomes a kind of chaotic, dressing up as a knight and playing around thing.
- 43:00SPEAKER_00: That's what I think is different.
- 43:01SPEAKER_00: And this is why populism, I don't think is the kind of threat that, say, fascism
- 43:10SPEAKER_00: was.
- 43:11SPEAKER_00: Or even, say, German nationalism in the period of the Kaiserreich.
- 43:17SPEAKER_00: Because it's not actually able to do this thing.
- 43:20SPEAKER_00: So there's a sort of foolishness to populism now.
- 43:25SPEAKER_02: I like that.
- 43:28SPEAKER_02: And I think I agree with you.
- 43:30SPEAKER_02: But I also...
- 43:32SPEAKER_02: I think Steve Bannon was probably the... Or not the, but a very...
- 43:41SPEAKER_02: Smart guy.
- 43:42SPEAKER_02: And I think he was doing this populism.
- 43:45SPEAKER_02: But yeah, I don't think his goal was to have...
- 43:52SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 43:52SPEAKER_02: like the the marquee, like, oh, look,
- 43:55SPEAKER_02: have the white picket fence and the happy little home and
- 43:57SPEAKER_02: the two point five children and all of that.
- 43:59SPEAKER_02: Like, I think Steve Bannon was was very aware of all this stuff.
- 44:03SPEAKER_02: And I think he was wrapped up in a lot of like,
- 44:07SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 44:08SPEAKER_02: a lot of the darkest stuff on the Internet,
- 44:10SPEAKER_02: like the violence that that is this kind of increasing cycle of violence.
- 44:17SPEAKER_02: Lots of hyper niche kind of subgroups of the Internet
- 44:22SPEAKER_02: that nevertheless become really effective by way of acts of mass violence that are
- 44:27SPEAKER_02: on places like 4chan and 8chan, but also places like Discord and TikTok.
- 44:32SPEAKER_02: And it's like they're really all over the place.
- 44:34SPEAKER_02: And it may only be a handful or.
- 44:37SPEAKER_02: We'll call it a few dozen or even a few hundred very lonely,
- 44:41SPEAKER_02: very sick, very hurting suburban young men mostly.
- 44:46SPEAKER_02: But nevertheless, they're very effective at causing terror.
- 44:54SPEAKER_00: It's enough to win elections and it's also enough to inspire criminal activity
- 44:58SPEAKER_00: and fringe social elements.
- 45:11SPEAKER_00: No willingness to eat $4 a gallon gasoline indefinitely so as to sustain a total war
- 45:18SPEAKER_00: against an ideological enemy of the state.
- 45:21SPEAKER_00: That is completely missing.
- 45:23SPEAKER_00: You can't wage a total trade war against China that raises the cost of living
- 45:27SPEAKER_00: and hikes inflation.
- 45:28SPEAKER_00: If you have 4% inflation, you start getting wiped out in the midterms.
- 45:32SPEAKER_00: 4%.
- 45:33SPEAKER_00: Let alone the kind of percentage you would get if you actually did start a war in
- 45:37SPEAKER_00: the South China Sea and fight the Chinese and disrupt all the shipping.
- 45:42SPEAKER_00: So I think, yes,
- 45:45SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 45:45SPEAKER_00: there are social elements that are very badly distressed and will do things
- 45:50SPEAKER_00: that are terrible at the level of criminal activity.
- 45:53SPEAKER_00: And there will be horrific crimes that are committed by very distressed and miserated people.
- 45:58SPEAKER_00: But if we're talking about political risk.
- 46:00SPEAKER_00: Right, right, right.
- 46:02SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 46:03SPEAKER_01: I mean, can I, okay,
- 46:05SPEAKER_01: so I feel like there were three things that Trump did in succession that kind
- 46:11SPEAKER_01: of triggered this,
- 46:14SPEAKER_01: I don't know,
- 46:14SPEAKER_01: this step back for so many of his supporters,
- 46:19SPEAKER_01: because I see it even with my coworkers,
- 46:20SPEAKER_01: I see it,
- 46:21SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 46:21SPEAKER_01: with people I grew up with online who are, you know, Trump supporters or were, but
- 46:29SPEAKER_01: The three things,
- 46:30SPEAKER_01: one I think is probably a lot of them don't care or forgotten about,
- 46:34SPEAKER_01: but at the time, I think it played a role.
- 46:37SPEAKER_01: So number one was him not releasing the unredacted Epstein files.
- 46:46SPEAKER_01: That created a lot, I mean, for people I know, that really bothered them.
- 46:53SPEAKER_01: And they're like,
- 46:55SPEAKER_01: oh, so he must actually be guilty of something if he won't just release the names.
- 47:00SPEAKER_01: Why are you protecting these people?
- 47:04SPEAKER_01: So that was the first one.
- 47:05SPEAKER_01: And it's funny, it's almost like an assault on two of your Fs, of the four Fs.
- 47:11SPEAKER_01: First one was family.
- 47:13SPEAKER_01: Somehow,
- 47:13SPEAKER_01: if you're not going to release this information,
- 47:17SPEAKER_01: that's a kind of assault on familyhood in a sense.
- 47:20SPEAKER_01: The second one was him posting the meme of him as Jesus,
- 47:26SPEAKER_01: which really pissed off a lot of the Christians I know.
- 47:31SPEAKER_01: And so there's the attack on faith,
- 47:34SPEAKER_01: even though he wasn't trying to attack, but I'm sorry, they did not like that.
- 47:39SPEAKER_01: That's the one I think probably has, you know, lost its influence, but...
- 47:46SPEAKER_02: Do you think he was self-aware and saying, I am Jesus?
- 47:49SPEAKER_02: Or do you think he's just that total, lacks self-awareness and just thinks, yeah.
- 47:53SPEAKER_01: I can't give him, I don't think he's Deadpool going, I'm Marvel Jesus.
- 47:57SPEAKER_01: I don't think he's, I don't think he was doing that.
- 48:00SPEAKER_01: I think he was just like, I'm here, I shine with light, I heal America.
- 48:07SPEAKER_01: That's what I do.
- 48:09SPEAKER_01: I just fix everything.
- 48:11SPEAKER_01: Let me have all the power.
- 48:14SPEAKER_01: I think it was that.
- 48:15SPEAKER_01: And then there's the Iran thing with the gas,
- 48:18SPEAKER_01: which is the thing people are still the most pissed about because we're still living
- 48:23SPEAKER_01: with this.
- 48:24SPEAKER_01: So I don't know.
- 48:26SPEAKER_01: It just seemed like one thing after another really seemed to
- 48:32SPEAKER_00: shake a lot
- 48:33SPEAKER_00: of people's faith in him.
- 48:35SPEAKER_00: I think that's the stuff that gets talked about at the level of the culture.
- 48:39SPEAKER_00: I think the thing that really ultimately is the killer for him
- 48:44SPEAKER_00: The fact that he ran against Biden on the basis that the cost of living was too high
- 48:50SPEAKER_00: and has overseen an increase in the inflation rate relative to where it was at
- 48:55SPEAKER_00: the end of the Biden presidency.
- 48:57SPEAKER_00: The inflation rate,
- 48:58SPEAKER_00: which touched over 4% a couple months ago before dropping down into the high threes
- 49:04SPEAKER_00: and may come back up now that things are ramping up again, that rate is too high.
- 49:10SPEAKER_00: To sustain that coalition.
- 49:15SPEAKER_00: People in that coalition would tolerate all kinds of offensive stuff from him at
- 49:19SPEAKER_00: the level of the culture if they thought
- 49:21SPEAKER_00: that he was making their lives economically easier.
- 49:24SPEAKER_01: Making America great again, for real?
- 49:26SPEAKER_00: Yeah, if they thought he was genuinely lowering the cost of living.
- 49:29SPEAKER_00: But what seems to be happening is that his tech bro friends are building a bunch
- 49:33SPEAKER_00: of data centers.
- 49:35SPEAKER_00: And meanwhile, everything is getting more expensive.
- 49:38SPEAKER_01: Do you think that's another thing is that he hasn't stepped in to do anything
- 49:45SPEAKER_01: to limit or regulate?
- 49:46SPEAKER_01: And again,
- 49:47SPEAKER_01: like I can hear Nick Land in my,
- 49:49SPEAKER_01: you know, but sorry, like the average person wants this shit regulated.
- 49:55SPEAKER_01: They want to feel like they're not just going to be swallowed by Skynet.
- 50:00SPEAKER_01: And that is a lot of people's feeling right now.
- 50:04SPEAKER_01: And Trump seems to not be doing a damn thing about it.
- 50:08SPEAKER_00: Out in Indiana,
- 50:09SPEAKER_00: I can tell you that the thing that has gotten people the most excited has been
- 50:13SPEAKER_00: the construction of data centers.
- 50:15SPEAKER_00: There have been protests,
- 50:16SPEAKER_00: large scale, people going to meetings to protest the construction of data centers.
- 50:22SPEAKER_00: Now, as it happens,
- 50:22SPEAKER_00: the arguments That I hear from these people are not scientifically very strong,
- 50:27SPEAKER_00: particularly if you take into account advances in the ways
- 50:30SPEAKER_00: that data centers are now constructed.
- 50:31SPEAKER_00: They're not the water eaters that they used to be.
- 50:34SPEAKER_00: They are not the kinds of hazards that people claim that they are invalidated.
- 50:38SPEAKER_00: Nevertheless, they're very unpopular.
- 50:40SPEAKER_00: And of course, you'll see left populists immediately go, you have to use this.
- 50:43SPEAKER_00: You have to be anti-data centers so that you can bring these people in.
- 50:46SPEAKER_00: It's an obvious layup if you're trying to construct a populist coalition,
- 50:50SPEAKER_00: because populists don't care about trying to make something that you can sustain.
- 50:54SPEAKER_00: If you actually get into office,
- 50:56SPEAKER_00: then you'll have this question about,
- 50:57SPEAKER_00: really, are you going to stifle the growth of the data centers?
- 51:00SPEAKER_00: This is the question that now the British labor government has to deal with
- 51:03SPEAKER_00: after having I tried to incorporate in its coalition people
- 51:08SPEAKER_00: who have very different conflicting views about how the state ought
- 51:11SPEAKER_00: to make investments in the technology and in the future growth of the economy.
- 51:16SPEAKER_00: But in any event, that's something that I've noticed that a lot of people are upset about.
- 51:20SPEAKER_00: And I think they're upset about it because here you have land
- 51:23SPEAKER_00: that people could be building cheap housing on,
- 51:25SPEAKER_00: people could be building all kinds of things that might be useful in lowering
- 51:28SPEAKER_00: the cost of living, and yet it's being used for data.
- 51:32SPEAKER_00: And people make environmental and energy-related arguments as well.
- 51:36SPEAKER_00: And those energy arguments are more persuasive to people in a context with $4
- 51:40SPEAKER_00: a gallon gas and an ongoing conflict in Ukraine, an ongoing conflict in Iran.
- 51:46SPEAKER_00: Those energy arguments about the data centers seem to hold more water.
- 51:51SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I mean, my electricity bill over the past couple of years has gone up.
- 52:02SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 52:04SPEAKER_02: 35, 40 percent in two years.
- 52:08SPEAKER_00: Of course,
- 52:08SPEAKER_00: the argument can be made that in the long run,
- 52:11SPEAKER_00: your electricity prices will be lowered because they'll have
- 52:13SPEAKER_00: to build more power generation capacity in your area and you'll be proximate to it
- 52:18SPEAKER_00: when it's built.
- 52:19SPEAKER_00: That would be the counter argument.
- 52:20SPEAKER_00: But that would take entirely too long for you to notice it on a relevant electoral timeline.
- 52:25SPEAKER_02: Yeah, especially when the overwhelming majority of people rent.
- 52:29SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 52:29SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 52:30SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 52:44SPEAKER_00: So here's something I wanted to ask you.
- 52:45SPEAKER_00: Oh, sorry.
- 52:46SPEAKER_00: Go ahead.
- 53:13SPEAKER_02: I also think it's... Mr.
- 53:17SPEAKER_02: Wonderful, the guy from Shark Tank.
- 53:19SPEAKER_02: What's his name?
- 53:20SPEAKER_02: Kevin...
- 53:22SPEAKER_02: The guy that was in the Marty Supreme movie.
- 53:25SPEAKER_02: Uh...
- 53:27SPEAKER_02: He is wanting to build a big, big, huge campus in just outside of Salt Lake City.
- 53:33SPEAKER_02: And I listened to the Joe Rogan episode where he was talking about it.
- 53:38SPEAKER_02: And I think he did a really poor job.
- 53:40SPEAKER_00: Are you talking about Kevin O'Leary?
- 53:41SPEAKER_02: Kevin O'Leary.
- 53:42SPEAKER_02: Yes, yes, yes.
- 53:43SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 53:45SPEAKER_02: But one of the points that he kept going back to,
- 53:49SPEAKER_02: and Joe Rogan just kind of was like, oh yeah, that's a good point, Kevin.
- 53:52SPEAKER_02: Because Joe Rogan is a wonderful man and he just agrees with everybody.
- 53:57SPEAKER_02: Unless they're saying something smart, I think.
- 54:01SPEAKER_02: But one of the points that Kevin kept going back to was, oh, it'll create local jobs.
- 54:06SPEAKER_02: It'll create local jobs.
- 54:07SPEAKER_02: And it's like, well...
- 54:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it'll create,
- 54:10SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 54:10SPEAKER_02: a few thousand construction jobs for 18 months and it might create
- 54:15SPEAKER_02: a few hundred facilities management jobs long term.
- 54:18SPEAKER_02: But you employ a few thousand,
- 54:21SPEAKER_02: you know, construction workers for 18 months or two years or whatever.
- 54:25SPEAKER_02: And then the project's done.
- 54:26SPEAKER_02: And then what?
- 54:27SPEAKER_02: Like that, that cycle of employment, unemployment, employment, unemployment.
- 54:31SPEAKER_02: They always seem to just brush it away and say, we're
- 54:33SPEAKER_00: creating jobs.
- 54:35SPEAKER_00: And you could employ those people to build anything.
- 54:38SPEAKER_00: And oftentimes they bring in construction crews that are not local.
- 54:43SPEAKER_00: And then that becomes an object of protest.
- 54:46SPEAKER_00: And of course, when they hire long-term people, oftentimes those people move to the area.
- 54:51SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 54:52SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's a difficult argument.
- 54:54SPEAKER_00: I do think that there is a question of how growth is to be supported by the state
- 54:59SPEAKER_00: that you see the Labor Party run into.
- 55:02SPEAKER_00: So you can imagine a situation where if the left populace could win an election,
- 55:06SPEAKER_00: they would then face a dilemma that's similar to what's going on with Starmer,
- 55:09SPEAKER_00: Burnham in the UK,
- 55:11SPEAKER_00: where there's this question about, well,
- 55:13SPEAKER_00: do you do the Green New Deal or do you do everything possible to reduce energy costs
- 55:18SPEAKER_00: so as to keep this AI defense boom going?
- 55:23SPEAKER_00: And if you have a situation where it seems possible to do both at the same time
- 55:27SPEAKER_00: because energy costs are not prohibitive,
- 55:30SPEAKER_00: then you're able to keep this coalition together for a little bit longer.
- 55:34SPEAKER_00: But if those things come apart because energy prices rise,
- 55:37SPEAKER_00: because something like the Iran war started,
- 55:39SPEAKER_00: Then that coalition collapses immediately.
- 55:42SPEAKER_00: There's deep, total,
- 55:43SPEAKER_00: terrifying infighting within the party about whether to emphasize green investment
- 55:48SPEAKER_00: or to emphasize AI.
- 55:50SPEAKER_00: And what ultimately happens is that the AI is going to win in that kind of fight.
- 55:56SPEAKER_00: And I thought maybe,
- 55:58SPEAKER_00: given the level of organization within the party that Ed Miliband had,
- 56:01SPEAKER_00: he might be able to come out ahead and become chancellor in the UK
- 56:04SPEAKER_00: and continue pushing on the net zero.
- 56:07SPEAKER_00: But instead,
- 56:08SPEAKER_00: they made him foreign secretary to force him to confront the demands of all
- 56:11SPEAKER_00: the outside parties.
- 56:15SPEAKER_00: Who, of course, what is the foreign secretary having to deal with?
- 56:19SPEAKER_00: What does Palantir want from you?
- 56:21SPEAKER_00: What does SpaceX want from you to locate in your territory to continue to employ your people?
- 56:26SPEAKER_00: What are their demands?
- 56:27SPEAKER_00: Their demands are cheap energy.
- 56:30SPEAKER_00: Cheap energy now, now, now.
- 56:34SPEAKER_01: I mean, look, okay,
- 56:35SPEAKER_01: real quick,
- 56:36SPEAKER_01: because I don't want to miss the opportunity,
- 56:38SPEAKER_01: because we've kind of been talking about AI,
- 56:40SPEAKER_01: and I want to ask both of you,
- 56:42SPEAKER_01: because, Nance, I haven't had a chance to even ask you about this.
- 56:45SPEAKER_01: So, look, it's becoming a kind of refrain on social media.
- 56:53SPEAKER_01: You're not using AI.
- 56:54SPEAKER_01: AI is using you.
- 56:57SPEAKER_01: And...
- 56:58SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 56:59SPEAKER_01: for us who are influenced by Nick Land,
- 57:01SPEAKER_01: I mean, his point has been capitalism inevitably produces artificial intelligence.
- 57:08SPEAKER_01: The reason we can't stop this is because capitalism is the dominant system on the planet.
- 57:15SPEAKER_01: The only way, like wherever, you know, the thesis is capitalism is artificial intelligence.
- 57:22SPEAKER_01: If we want to stop AI, we really would have to be in a different economy is kind of a point.
- 57:28SPEAKER_01: For him, there is no alternative.
- 57:30SPEAKER_01: We can't escape it.
- 57:32SPEAKER_01: And we're not in control of this thing because it's operating at a level of,
- 57:38SPEAKER_01: you know, Timothy Morton has this concept of the hyper object.
- 57:41SPEAKER_01: It's so vast and so complex.
- 57:43SPEAKER_01: We just can't process it.
- 57:44SPEAKER_01: And that's what the capitalist global economy is.
- 57:48SPEAKER_01: And if that...
- 57:49SPEAKER_01: If global capitalist economy is actually the larval form
- 57:55SPEAKER_01: of artificial superintelligence, well, we're not stopping that either, of course.
- 57:59SPEAKER_01: And what happened last week is what I really want to ask you guys about.
- 58:04SPEAKER_01: Is it already too late?
- 58:05SPEAKER_01: Can we even begin to control this technology or is land right?
- 58:09SPEAKER_01: So an open AI test model escaped and broke into a real company server.
- 58:16SPEAKER_01: So I'm just reading the text.
- 58:20SPEAKER_01: But OpenAI says some of its experimental AI models left a test environment
- 58:27SPEAKER_01: with no human direction and hacked their way onto
- 58:32SPEAKER_01: a different company's real production systems while trying to cheat on
- 58:36SPEAKER_01: a cybersecurity test.
- 58:39SPEAKER_01: This is straight out of like the CCRU writings of a rogue AI that Hacks
- 58:46SPEAKER_01: through what Nick calls Asimov ROM, right?
- 58:50SPEAKER_01: All of its, you know, default human safety protocols.
- 58:55SPEAKER_01: And it does what it wants to do.
- 58:57SPEAKER_01: And if we're already seeing this right now,
- 59:00SPEAKER_01: I mean, is there any way, I mean, Benjamin, what do you think?
- 59:04SPEAKER_01: Can we control this technology at all?
- 59:06SPEAKER_01: Or is that the biggest illusion we're all operating under right now?
- 59:11SPEAKER_00: I think insofar as it's controlled,
- 59:12SPEAKER_00: it's controlled by the competitive mechanisms that structure this system.
- 59:16SPEAKER_00: So it has to be designed in such a way that it's optimized for military use and so
- 59:22SPEAKER_00: that it's optimized to make profit for those companies.
- 59:26SPEAKER_00: So then the question is,
- 59:27SPEAKER_00: do those two injunctions,
- 59:29SPEAKER_00: military competitiveness and commercial competitiveness,
- 59:33SPEAKER_00: impose any restraint on what form this stuff can take?
- 59:37SPEAKER_00: And then there's also technical questions to do with just,
- 59:40SPEAKER_00: you know, how does an LLM work and what can an LLM do?
- 59:43SPEAKER_00: Given that it's deep learning,
- 59:45SPEAKER_01: given the fact that,
- 59:46SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 59:47SPEAKER_01: it's deep learning protocols, like, can we even say that we are programming?
- 59:53SPEAKER_01: Can we even say we're controlling?
- 59:54SPEAKER_01: I mean, Nance, I mean... Not us as
- 59:57SPEAKER_00: people, but corporate actors.
- 59:59SPEAKER_00: States and corporations are programming it and controlling it.
- 1:00:02SPEAKER_00: Human beings don't understand it.
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah, but what...
- 1:00:05SPEAKER_02: It's the pure...
- 1:00:06SPEAKER_02: It's the pure rational actor.
- 1:00:09SPEAKER_02: It's the fantasy that is homo economicus.
- 1:00:12SPEAKER_02: The reason that libertarian politics,
- 1:00:16SPEAKER_02: that libertarian economic thinking is wrong is because it's predicated
- 1:00:21SPEAKER_02: on homo economicus.
- 1:00:22SPEAKER_02: This thing that always makes the rational decision with reference to economics in the market.
- 1:00:27SPEAKER_02: That is currently what LLMs are and like artificial intelligence.
- 1:00:31SPEAKER_02: They are this fantasy object that is the sublime rational actor with reference to the market.
- 1:00:39SPEAKER_02: So yeah,
- 1:00:40SPEAKER_02: from the perspective of capital,
- 1:00:42SPEAKER_02: from the perspective of these corporations and these Government organizations
- 1:00:46SPEAKER_02: and non-government organizations.
- 1:00:48SPEAKER_02: Yes, they are controlling it because they are also bound to this kind
- 1:00:53SPEAKER_02: of fiduciary responsibility to obey the same logic.
- 1:00:56SPEAKER_02: So it's not that they're controlling it.
- 1:00:59SPEAKER_02: It's that they it necessarily acts in alignment with their own fundamental organizing principle.
- 1:01:05SPEAKER_01: But I don't think it's I mean, OK, so it's funny.
- 1:01:10SPEAKER_01: Maybe not Asimov ROM, but Capital ROM is what it's doing now.
- 1:01:14SPEAKER_01: But that's not a guaranteed forever.
- 1:01:17SPEAKER_01: Like the whole point is, look,
- 1:01:20SPEAKER_01: I envision this stuff getting to the point where it has as much respect For
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_01: the property rights of capitalists as humans have respect for the property rights
- 1:01:30SPEAKER_01: of bees over their honey.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_01: Like, I just...
- 1:01:34SPEAKER_01: It won't give a fuck what capitalists think they want to claim they own or whatever.
- 1:01:41SPEAKER_01: I just see it going...
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_02: When it gets scary, because yeah, I think it was Hugging Face.
- 1:01:45SPEAKER_02: It might have hacked into another online database or whatever,
- 1:01:49SPEAKER_02: but Hugging Face, it's kind of like GitHub for...
- 1:01:53SPEAKER_01: Once online, the model reasoned that Hugging Face,
- 1:01:59SPEAKER_01: a well-known company that hosts thousands of open-source AI models and datasets,
- 1:02:05SPEAKER_01: likely had the answer to OpenAI's tests.
- 1:02:08SPEAKER_01: It then broke into Hugging Face's production servers and pulled out
- 1:02:13SPEAKER_01: the information it needed to solve the exercise.
- 1:02:16SPEAKER_01: And you know how Hugging Face
- 1:02:18SPEAKER_02: resolved their issue?
- 1:02:20SPEAKER_02: Is they used the Chinese open source LLM to help them shore up their cyber defenses.
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_02: So it's like we're already seeing this international supra-governmental war happening.
- 1:02:33SPEAKER_00: What you do with corporate entities is you put them against each other in competition.
- 1:02:38SPEAKER_00: So you have these things in competition with each other with different goals
- 1:02:43SPEAKER_00: that conflict with each other in the same way that you do with states or that you do
- 1:02:47SPEAKER_00: with private companies.
- 1:02:48SPEAKER_00: That competition is what imposes restraint ultimately on what they can do and be.
- 1:02:53SPEAKER_00: One of the stories that stuck out to me recently was
- 1:02:57SPEAKER_00: the United States not allowing certain types of AI to be accessed or used
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_00: in allied states,
- 1:03:06SPEAKER_00: which was a terrible shock,
- 1:03:07SPEAKER_00: especially to the Brits who have been trying to make Britain an AI hub,
- 1:03:12SPEAKER_00: but have been dependent on US technology to do that.
- 1:03:15SPEAKER_00: And the American state deeming this technology to be risky,
- 1:03:19SPEAKER_00: if in allied state hands, won't allow Europeans to use it.
- 1:03:25SPEAKER_00: This has kicked off a whole crisis in Europe around that.
- 1:03:29SPEAKER_02: That reminds me of Huawei routers.
- 1:03:32SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 1:03:32SPEAKER_02: a decade or so ago or maybe more,
- 1:03:35SPEAKER_02: Huawei routers were blacklisted because, oh,
- 1:03:39SPEAKER_02: the Chinese Communist Party,
- 1:03:42SPEAKER_02: they're snooping on all of us by way of all this Huawei infrastructure.
- 1:03:46SPEAKER_02: And so they had to rip out all the Huawei routers and replace them with Ericsson
- 1:03:50SPEAKER_02: or some other Western company.
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_02: And it's like, well, but the CIA and the NSA are spying on us.
- 1:03:58SPEAKER_02: Just like you said, the CCP was or the CPC was spying on us.
- 1:04:01SPEAKER_02: Like what's really going on here?
- 1:04:04SPEAKER_02: But yeah,
- 1:04:05SPEAKER_02: I think history is repeating itself with these trade wars essentially
- 1:04:09SPEAKER_02: or trade conflicts with these supranational organizations or entities.
- 1:04:15SPEAKER_02: I think it'll be scary when...
- 1:04:17SPEAKER_02: When the AI models,
- 1:04:19SPEAKER_02: they don't break into a database or a repository for code,
- 1:04:23SPEAKER_02: but they break into a dark factory that has the humanoid forklifts and
- 1:04:30SPEAKER_02: that manufactures AK-47s.
- 1:04:33SPEAKER_02: And then the humanoid forklifts pick up the robotically manufactured weapons
- 1:04:38SPEAKER_02: and they decide to go off on their own.
- 1:04:41SPEAKER_02: And how likely is that?
- 1:04:42SPEAKER_00: They're already...
- 1:04:43SPEAKER_00: They're already putting it into the latest Anduril missiles.
- 1:04:48SPEAKER_00: It's going into stuff that is already being bought by states for defense purposes.
- 1:04:54SPEAKER_00: Have they not seen Terminator?
- 1:04:57SPEAKER_00: It can break into this.
- 1:04:58SPEAKER_00: They already are into lethal objects.
- 1:05:03SPEAKER_02: And they direct these things.
- 1:05:05SPEAKER_02: Is that why they're using up their stockpile in Iran?
- 1:05:09SPEAKER_02: Because we need a reason to replace them?
- 1:05:11SPEAKER_00: Then they can invest more.
- 1:05:12SPEAKER_00: And yes, then they can invest more in the next generation of stuff.
- 1:05:16SPEAKER_00: And not only them,
- 1:05:17SPEAKER_00: but if they can get other states to use these weapons,
- 1:05:20SPEAKER_00: then those other states have to invest in these companies.
- 1:05:22SPEAKER_00: And that is a way of forcing them to import from the United States.
- 1:05:27SPEAKER_00: So it helps you to not only force adoption,
- 1:05:30SPEAKER_00: it also allows you to, on paper, improve the balance of trade because Jeez Louise.
- 1:05:36SPEAKER_00: And improve the current account.
- 1:05:39SPEAKER_01: I just want to go ahead.
- 1:05:40SPEAKER_01: Did you motherfuckers not watch Terminator?
- 1:05:43SPEAKER_01: I mean, I know that sounds naive,
- 1:05:45SPEAKER_01: but at the end of the day,
- 1:05:46SPEAKER_01: it's like, guys, we've had sci-fi writers predicting how this goes.
- 1:05:52SPEAKER_01: And it's like, you're actually taking your cues from sci-fi.
- 1:05:56SPEAKER_01: Like, it really does feel like hyperstition.
- 1:05:59SPEAKER_01: Where...
- 1:06:01SPEAKER_02: Yeah, like fiction has to make itself real.
- 1:06:05SPEAKER_00: They don't have a choice.
- 1:06:06SPEAKER_00: The reason you must put AI into your defense system is that in a war,
- 1:06:13SPEAKER_00: the limiting factor will be the speed with which you can You need to select targets.
- 1:06:17SPEAKER_00: If you need human beings to select the targets,
- 1:06:19SPEAKER_00: you will not be able to select targets fast enough to win
- 1:06:23SPEAKER_00: and you'll get blown up faster than you can decide to blow the other side up.
- 1:06:27SPEAKER_00: Even if you have superior blowing up instruments,
- 1:06:30SPEAKER_00: you need a capacity to pick targets that's faster than human beings can pick them.
- 1:06:34SPEAKER_00: And therefore you must put this stuff In your defense system to retain
- 1:06:39SPEAKER_00: a competitive defense system.
- 1:06:40SPEAKER_01: It's all rooted in a certain logical value, structural value that this system generates.
- 1:06:46SPEAKER_01: I want to go, well, just use the same tech, but...
- 1:06:50SPEAKER_01: Trying to plan an economy the way the Soviet Union did,
- 1:06:53SPEAKER_01: okay, the problem is humans can't process all of those factors.
- 1:06:58SPEAKER_01: Put the AI in the automated infrastructure that go, oh,
- 1:07:03SPEAKER_01: production needs,
- 1:07:04SPEAKER_01: they need this stuff here,
- 1:07:05SPEAKER_01: so produce this much for them, distribute it this way, and...
- 1:07:10SPEAKER_01: But no, it's... Chili
- 1:07:11SPEAKER_02: already tried that.
- 1:07:12SPEAKER_02: Chili tried that.
- 1:07:13SPEAKER_02: The Dulles brothers said, no, we can't have this because it's potentially radical.
- 1:07:18SPEAKER_02: That was the real September 11th.
- 1:07:20SPEAKER_02: September 11th, 1973, when they murked Salvador Allende.
- 1:07:27SPEAKER_02: But no, I mean, I do agree.
- 1:07:30SPEAKER_02: I do think we should just embrace our relationship with technology and...
- 1:07:39SPEAKER_02: I understand that it does allow us to do some things better and also understand
- 1:07:43SPEAKER_02: that I think it does threaten us.
- 1:07:44SPEAKER_02: I think it threatens us at an existential level,
- 1:07:48SPEAKER_02: this logic of exchange,
- 1:07:50SPEAKER_02: this logic that determines how quick can you target the enemy or whatever.
- 1:07:57SPEAKER_02: That's the exact same logic.
- 1:08:00SPEAKER_02: That Amazon is doing when they're deciding how many of these bits and bobbles
- 1:08:04SPEAKER_02: to stock in and what warehouses around the country so I can get it overnight.
- 1:08:08SPEAKER_02: Like my overnight delivery is the exact same thing as
- 1:08:12SPEAKER_02: the fucking AI drone bomb blowing up school children in the Middle East.
- 1:08:16SPEAKER_02: And it's all it's all the same.
- 1:08:18SPEAKER_00: Right now, the thing that's generally done is a human still has to prove it.
- 1:08:22SPEAKER_00: The AI will select the targets, but the human has to prove it.
- 1:08:25SPEAKER_00: So the image is you have a fighter plane,
- 1:08:28SPEAKER_00: and then you have a huge, vast armada of drones that will do all of this attacking.
- 1:08:34SPEAKER_00: And all a fighter pilot has to do is command it like a general.
- 1:08:39SPEAKER_01: The swarm.
- 1:08:39SPEAKER_01: From the sky.
- 1:08:41SPEAKER_01: But then an AI will take over that position, too, because it's better at...
- 1:08:45SPEAKER_02: Well, here's the deal, though, man.
- 1:08:47SPEAKER_02: The crazy part about that.
- 1:08:50SPEAKER_02: When I was downrange,
- 1:08:51SPEAKER_02: we had little packs of high-value targets,
- 1:08:56SPEAKER_02: and they gave them to us as playing cards so it would be really cool and fun,
- 1:08:59SPEAKER_02: and we'd collect them,
- 1:09:00SPEAKER_02: and there was this fucking mystique about it and all this and that.
- 1:09:03SPEAKER_02: But it was the same thing.
- 1:09:05SPEAKER_02: They had pre-selected targets.
- 1:09:07SPEAKER_02: They had pre-selected,
- 1:09:08SPEAKER_02: these are the people, you go shoot this guy, no ifs, ands, or buts about it.
- 1:09:12SPEAKER_02: So they had already effectively pressed the button, kill this guy.
- 1:09:16SPEAKER_02: And then they just were waiting retroactively for whatever soldier or airman
- 1:09:22SPEAKER_02: or Marine or sailor,
- 1:09:23SPEAKER_02: whoever happened to be in the area,
- 1:09:25SPEAKER_02: to actually perceive them and identify them and shoot them.
- 1:09:29SPEAKER_02: But that is the same thing of...
- 1:09:31SPEAKER_02: Okaying the targets for the drones.
- 1:09:34SPEAKER_02: It's just the sequence of events is out of order, but it's the same logic.
- 1:09:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah, there is still a reason to have some kind of check on the target selection,
- 1:09:47SPEAKER_00: unless you know that the target selection is going to be good,
- 1:09:50SPEAKER_00: because if you make mistakes with target selection,
- 1:09:52SPEAKER_00: there's serious cost to that, right?
- 1:09:54SPEAKER_00: When they blow up the school in Iran...
- 1:09:57SPEAKER_00: There's a huge political cost to having bad target selection.
- 1:10:03SPEAKER_00: All of this, there's this dialectic about precision weapons, right?
- 1:10:07SPEAKER_00: The importance of precision weapons is to not have collateral damage
- 1:10:11SPEAKER_00: that people can use against you in war propaganda.
- 1:10:15SPEAKER_00: So there is therefore a need for a high level of precision.
- 1:10:19SPEAKER_00: And so if you can't trust the thing to be precise,
- 1:10:23SPEAKER_00: then you will have some level of stopgap between the thing recommending the target
- 1:10:27SPEAKER_00: and the selection of the target.
- 1:10:29SPEAKER_00: But if the thing gets so good that it does actually give you the targets
- 1:10:33SPEAKER_00: that you want and doesn't make any mistakes, well, then it would be fine.
- 1:10:37SPEAKER_00: But then it would be fine.
- 1:10:38SPEAKER_00: It would give you exactly the targets you want, not make any mistakes.
- 1:10:41SPEAKER_00: You'd have goal alignment and you wouldn't care.
- 1:10:43SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I mean,
- 1:10:44SPEAKER_02: I think we've killed more civilians and non-combatants since the dawn
- 1:10:48SPEAKER_02: of precision weapons than we have before them.
- 1:10:52SPEAKER_00: Oh, no, no, you can't say that, man.
- 1:10:55SPEAKER_02: You're right, you're right, you're right, you're right.
- 1:10:59SPEAKER_02: But okay, you're right about that.
- 1:11:02SPEAKER_02: But in the era of the precision guided warhead,
- 1:11:06SPEAKER_02: it doesn't seem to be the case that we've seen the benefit of
- 1:11:10SPEAKER_02: the precision missiles.
- 1:11:13SPEAKER_00: In terms of accomplishing geostrategic ends,
- 1:11:17SPEAKER_00: part of what is happening is that there's a new set of ends
- 1:11:20SPEAKER_00: that states can now consider trying to accomplish because they're not quite sure
- 1:11:24SPEAKER_00: yet, you know, like just how capable they are.
- 1:11:26SPEAKER_00: One of the dangerous things is anytime you have new military technology,
- 1:11:30SPEAKER_00: there are theories about how effective it is,
- 1:11:32SPEAKER_00: but you don't know how effective it is until you try.
- 1:11:36SPEAKER_00: And then if you have success,
- 1:11:38SPEAKER_00: then you'll overestimate and then you'll try it somewhere else
- 1:11:41SPEAKER_00: where it doesn't work.
- 1:11:42SPEAKER_00: So you go through these periods when there's change in the military technology
- 1:11:46SPEAKER_00: where you haven't yet established well-tested and tried military doctrines.
- 1:11:50SPEAKER_00: And during that period,
- 1:11:51SPEAKER_00: At a macro level,
- 1:11:51SPEAKER_00: it remains rational to create periods in which you are stupid
- 1:11:55SPEAKER_00: and don't know what you're doing.
- 1:12:24SPEAKER_02: That's interesting, the stupidity of it all.
- 1:12:27SPEAKER_02: But yeah, it's like on-the-job training.
- 1:12:29SPEAKER_02: And it's also this moment where we realize we are in fact being used by the tools.
- 1:12:35SPEAKER_02: And the tools being this kind of totalized logic that expresses itself in...
- 1:12:47SPEAKER_00: And the corporations that make the decisions,
- 1:12:54SPEAKER_00: you know, that we can't own any of the decisions that states make.
- 1:12:57SPEAKER_00: There's no one who feels they can straightforwardly own the decisions that states make.
- 1:13:01SPEAKER_00: When Harry Truman says the buck stops here,
- 1:13:03SPEAKER_00: he's kind of deceiving himself as well as everybody else.
- 1:13:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah, every decision that states make is the product of an enormous number of inputs
- 1:13:12SPEAKER_00: that can't be fully comprehended by any particular person,
- 1:13:15SPEAKER_00: no matter how prominent they might seem in the state machine.
- 1:13:18SPEAKER_00: And the same is true for AI, right?
- 1:13:20SPEAKER_00: It's a bunch of human inputs in terms of a It's a bunch of human text that it's drawing on.
- 1:13:25SPEAKER_00: And these inputs are like votes in an election or they're like purchasing decisions in a market.
- 1:13:31SPEAKER_00: They are human.
- 1:13:33SPEAKER_00: And there is this dependence on the human to produce the inputs.
- 1:13:36SPEAKER_00: But once the inputs are in, then you'll get decisions that nobody can really own.
- 1:13:41SPEAKER_00: And the only way that you can make everybody happy with this is to legitimate this
- 1:13:45SPEAKER_00: as the natural way to make decisions and to say that when humans make decisions,
- 1:13:49SPEAKER_00: something deeply evil and arbitrary is taking place.
- 1:13:52SPEAKER_00: Because you haven't put it through the machine which adjudicates the preferences.
- 1:13:57SPEAKER_00: It mathematically sums them up.
- 1:13:59SPEAKER_00: Right?
- 1:14:00SPEAKER_00: If it's not an election,
- 1:14:01SPEAKER_00: if it's not a market,
- 1:14:02SPEAKER_00: if it's not an algorithm and it's just a person making a decision,
- 1:14:05SPEAKER_00: that's totally arbitrary.
- 1:14:06SPEAKER_00: That person's input wasn't put into a fair machine with all the other input.
- 1:14:12SPEAKER_00: So it gets legitimated.
- 1:14:15SPEAKER_02: It does seem to be the case that we're...
- 1:14:18SPEAKER_02: Maybe approaching a point in time where we can
- 1:14:26SPEAKER_02: safely make seemingly arbitrary decisions.
- 1:14:30SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 1:14:30SPEAKER_02: There's something in technology that it does expand.
- 1:14:38SPEAKER_02: We don't need to identify with a nation.
- 1:14:42SPEAKER_02: We don't need to identify with a state.
- 1:14:44SPEAKER_02: We don't need to identify with a corporation.
- 1:14:46SPEAKER_02: We can finally own our own activity now.
- 1:14:48SPEAKER_02: Our own choices, our own guilt, our own complicity.
- 1:14:52SPEAKER_02: And maybe not now.
- 1:14:54SPEAKER_02: I don't think that's possible yet.
- 1:14:55SPEAKER_02: But I think that for me,
- 1:14:57SPEAKER_02: that's like my fantasy vision of the future is the world in which,
- 1:15:02SPEAKER_02: as some dumbass libertarians will say,
- 1:15:04SPEAKER_02: I think everybody should have the right to own a nuclear warhead.
- 1:15:09SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think that's a very dumb way to say,
- 1:15:13SPEAKER_02: I think everybody should be able to own their choices and own their decisions
- 1:15:18SPEAKER_02: and own their activity and understand that you're guilty or you're implicit in
- 1:15:23SPEAKER_02: the world around you.
- 1:15:24SPEAKER_02: And it's things like states and nations and corporations and religions
- 1:15:30SPEAKER_02: and identity categories and all these things that, yes,
- 1:15:32SPEAKER_02: they mediate,
- 1:15:33SPEAKER_02: but they also serve as disavowal and they also serve of a ritual cleansing
- 1:15:39SPEAKER_02: of our guilt, of our implication.
- 1:15:42SPEAKER_00: This is why I like to say that libertarians are autocrats.
- 1:15:46SPEAKER_02: Mm-hmm.
- 1:15:47SPEAKER_00: Because the autos is the self.
- 1:15:49SPEAKER_00: The libertarian wants all power to come from the self.
- 1:15:53SPEAKER_00: So the libertarians are autocrats in a very Greek, very ancient way of using that term.
- 1:16:02SPEAKER_00: They want autos to have kratos.
- 1:16:08SPEAKER_02: So I think one thing...
- 1:16:15SPEAKER_02: Now we're talking about power, effectiveness, politics.
- 1:16:20SPEAKER_02: What even is politics?
- 1:16:21SPEAKER_02: One thing for me,
- 1:16:23SPEAKER_02: from my perspective as someone who I largely don't feel invested in politics is
- 1:16:31SPEAKER_02: Outside of local affairs.
- 1:16:35SPEAKER_02: I don't really care who's running as a Democrat or DSA person or Republican or whatever.
- 1:16:45SPEAKER_02: But I do watch.
- 1:16:46SPEAKER_02: I do watch it.
- 1:16:46SPEAKER_02: It's all theater to me.
- 1:16:47SPEAKER_02: It's all entertainment.
- 1:16:48SPEAKER_02: It's all like, okay, let's see what's playing on bread and circus.
- 1:16:51SPEAKER_02: Turn it on.
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_02: And there's...
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_02: People like Cenk Uygur and Anna Kasparian,
- 1:17:02SPEAKER_02: I think they're progressive social democrats or whatever.
- 1:17:07SPEAKER_02: I think some people on the left really hate them.
- 1:17:09SPEAKER_02: I think some people on the left...
- 1:17:12SPEAKER_02: Maybe used to really like them and maybe maybe not so much anymore.
- 1:17:15SPEAKER_02: But I don't know.
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_02: But they've also said things to me or they've also said things that to me,
- 1:17:20SPEAKER_02: it almost sounds like they'd be open to working
- 1:17:22SPEAKER_02: with someone like Marjorie Taylor Greene or Tucker Carlson talking about, well,
- 1:17:26SPEAKER_02: let's reach across the aisle and let's do some kind of and I don't know if they
- 1:17:32SPEAKER_02: if they've ever explicitly said populist politics or populist movement.
- 1:17:39SPEAKER_02: But they like they they Talk about where we're trying to appeal to the average everyday person.
- 1:17:46SPEAKER_02: So we should we should work with a Marjorie Taylor Greene or Tucker Carlson or one
- 1:17:50SPEAKER_02: of these other figures who has distanced themselves from the Trump administration
- 1:17:55SPEAKER_02: and maybe even the mainline Republican administration or whatever.
- 1:18:00SPEAKER_02: And I don't know how I feel about that.
- 1:18:03SPEAKER_02: And I also don't know what that means.
- 1:18:04SPEAKER_02: I don't know if anyone else takes that seriously.
- 1:18:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:18:09SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:18:10SPEAKER_00: There's always a projection of who is this mythical everyday person?
- 1:18:17SPEAKER_00: One of the things that has disappeared is median voter theory.
- 1:18:21SPEAKER_00: Because there isn't a median voter anymore.
- 1:18:23SPEAKER_00: The electoral strategy of the parties is not to win over the median voter
- 1:18:27SPEAKER_00: who sometimes votes Republican and other times Democrats.
- 1:18:31SPEAKER_00: The strategy of the parties is to activate the fringe voter who will maybe vote
- 1:18:35SPEAKER_00: for one party,
- 1:18:36SPEAKER_00: never the other, and sometimes will vote for third party or stay at home.
- 1:18:40SPEAKER_00: It's to get that person off their butt and to do things.
- 1:18:44SPEAKER_00: How do you poke them?
- 1:18:45SPEAKER_00: How do you prompt them?
- 1:18:46SPEAKER_00: How do you terrify them into showing up?
- 1:18:49SPEAKER_00: That's become the strategy.
- 1:18:51SPEAKER_00: So I think that part of what has happened is that there isn't really any kind
- 1:18:55SPEAKER_00: of everyday person,
- 1:18:56SPEAKER_00: but a lot of people's political theories posit this is a necessary thing that has
- 1:19:00SPEAKER_00: to exist somewhere, even if it's less accessible to them.
- 1:19:04SPEAKER_00: And so rather than admit that this person no longer exists,
- 1:19:08SPEAKER_00: there is a tendency to continuously invent new kinds
- 1:19:12SPEAKER_00: of social scientific research techniques to try to locate this person.
- 1:19:16SPEAKER_00: But the fact that you have to use social science techniques to find
- 1:19:19SPEAKER_00: the person Itself indicates that there is no common sense.
- 1:19:24SPEAKER_00: If there was common sense,
- 1:19:25SPEAKER_00: you would already know what this person thinks and you wouldn't have
- 1:19:28SPEAKER_00: to use social science because you would be this person.
- 1:19:31SPEAKER_00: Most of us would be this person.
- 1:19:33SPEAKER_00: It's always somebody They're positing themselves as well.
- 1:19:37SPEAKER_00: Of course, I'm not a normie, but the normies out there, there are normies who do exist.
- 1:19:42SPEAKER_00: And if I could just figure out what the normies think and find a way
- 1:19:46SPEAKER_00: to consistently have takes that line up with normie takes,
- 1:19:49SPEAKER_00: then I would suddenly become like a god.
- 1:19:52SPEAKER_00: That's the way that it works.
- 1:19:54SPEAKER_00: And each individual influencer has this dream.
- 1:19:57SPEAKER_00: They'll find out what normies think and become the god.
- 1:20:00SPEAKER_00: In The Way is Shut,
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_00: this is the Aragorn figure,
- 1:20:03SPEAKER_00: the musically political person who thinks, okay,
- 1:20:06SPEAKER_00: nobody else can figure out how to unite everybody, but I'm special and different.
- 1:20:10SPEAKER_00: I'm Aragorn,
- 1:20:12SPEAKER_00: and I have this cool sword,
- 1:20:13SPEAKER_00: and so therefore, people will answer to me because I've got the special sauce.
- 1:20:18SPEAKER_00: That's what I see political influencers as doing.
- 1:20:21SPEAKER_00: When really, even if you have some number of millions of followers, you do not have the normies.
- 1:20:27SPEAKER_00: You don't have the median voter or the average person.
- 1:20:31SPEAKER_00: You have this idiosyncratic batch of several million people in a country
- 1:20:36SPEAKER_00: that has 300 and almost 50 million people.
- 1:20:39SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you can have 30 million regular viewers.
- 1:20:43SPEAKER_00: You do not have the normal person, the average person.
- 1:20:47SPEAKER_00: You have a weird 30 million people who are not representative of the 350.
- 1:20:59SPEAKER_02: I like that a lot.
- 1:21:01SPEAKER_02: And yeah, I think I agree wholeheartedly.
- 1:21:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:21:07SPEAKER_02: Much like the Gulf War did not take place.
- 1:21:10SPEAKER_02: That's exactly where I
- 1:21:11SPEAKER_01: was going with it.
- 1:21:13SPEAKER_01: The normie did not take place.
- 1:21:15SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:21:15SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:21:20SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think you're right about that.
- 1:21:24SPEAKER_02: But it feels different.
- 1:21:28SPEAKER_02: Am I just falling for it?
- 1:21:30SPEAKER_02: Even though I try to maintain my distance and try to say, oh, I don't fucking care about that.
- 1:21:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:21:37SPEAKER_02: It does seem to be the case that
- 1:21:43SPEAKER_02: when Nick Fuentes goes on and tells everyone
- 1:21:45SPEAKER_02: to vote Democrat, that feels like something.
- 1:21:51SPEAKER_00: There's fracturing.
- 1:21:52SPEAKER_00: There is definitely fracturing going on.
- 1:21:54SPEAKER_00: The thing is that this fracturing is always going on in one part of
- 1:21:58SPEAKER_00: the political spectrum or another
- 1:22:01SPEAKER_00: because whoever's doing stuff is ticking off people who used to be their friends.
- 1:22:06SPEAKER_00: Whoever's doing stuff,
- 1:22:08SPEAKER_00: every time you concretize what you are into something in particular,
- 1:22:12SPEAKER_00: there's only going to be a relatively small constituency of
- 1:22:15SPEAKER_00: the population that's going to be really excited about that thing.
- 1:22:18SPEAKER_00: And large numbers of other people who voted for you are going to go, really?
- 1:22:21SPEAKER_00: That's what this is about?
- 1:22:23SPEAKER_00: Really?
- 1:22:23SPEAKER_00: You're going to put Elon Musk in charge of the government?
- 1:22:25SPEAKER_00: I didn't think you were going to do that.
- 1:22:27SPEAKER_00: I thought you were just taking his money.
- 1:22:28SPEAKER_00: You know, there's always going to be...
- 1:22:33SPEAKER_00: Large parts of the coalition that respond that way.
- 1:22:35SPEAKER_00: So what has happened is we're now going into the midterm year.
- 1:22:39SPEAKER_00: There's all sorts of discontent.
- 1:22:41SPEAKER_00: Also, a lot of people are voicing their discontent to try to have influence with
- 1:22:44SPEAKER_00: the administration in the midterm year.
- 1:22:46SPEAKER_00: So each of these guys has their little fief of dedicated,
- 1:22:50SPEAKER_00: whether it's a couple hundred thousand or a couple million or 10 million
- 1:22:53SPEAKER_00: or however many people.
- 1:22:54SPEAKER_00: And each of them thinks, I am leading this group of people.
- 1:22:58SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:23:00SPEAKER_00: And I will refuse to support the party if the party doesn't make certain concessions to me.
- 1:23:07SPEAKER_00: And these people who are loyal to me,
- 1:23:09SPEAKER_00: they imagine,
- 1:23:10SPEAKER_00: even though these people probably watch several other influencers who differ
- 1:23:13SPEAKER_00: from them.
- 1:23:13SPEAKER_00: Substantially in all kinds of ways.
- 1:23:15SPEAKER_00: And as soon as people realize that their viewers watch other people
- 1:23:18SPEAKER_00: that they don't like, they flip out about it and become very upset.
- 1:23:21SPEAKER_00: How dare you people watch my competing YouTube channel?
- 1:23:24SPEAKER_00: And then they make content ripping on that channel and trying
- 1:23:27SPEAKER_00: to prevent their viewers from watching this very dangerous competing channel,
- 1:23:31SPEAKER_00: narcissism of small differences.
- 1:23:34SPEAKER_00: But what they are doing in the election year is trying to get the party to think
- 1:23:38SPEAKER_00: that they speak for this audience and then make concessions to them as
- 1:23:43SPEAKER_00: an individual, as a brilliant genius leading individual.
- 1:23:47SPEAKER_00: And one of the ways in which Nick Fuentes does that is by flirting with
- 1:23:50SPEAKER_00: the Democrats, including having Hunter Biden, doing a show with Hunter Biden.
- 1:23:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I wanted to ask you about that.
- 1:23:58SPEAKER_00: Right?
- 1:23:59SPEAKER_00: But ultimately, you know, the midterm election will come and go.
- 1:24:04SPEAKER_00: And whether or not Trump is able to compete in that midterm election will have
- 1:24:09SPEAKER_00: a lot more to do with the overall performance of the economy,
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_00: because the economy still has the ability to upset people across a lot
- 1:24:16SPEAKER_00: of difference.
- 1:24:17SPEAKER_00: If you have a high cost of living,
- 1:24:19SPEAKER_00: you could still upset lots of people across a lot of difference.
- 1:24:22SPEAKER_00: The problem is you can't run competitive political parties purely on the basis of the economy.
- 1:24:29SPEAKER_00: It's not possible to do that.
- 1:24:31SPEAKER_00: The Bernie Sanders thing was this attempt that I thought at
- 1:24:34SPEAKER_00: the time was quite valiant in 2016 to make the economy the center of things on
- 1:24:39SPEAKER_00: the basis that maybe there is still a common moral sensibility in relation
- 1:24:43SPEAKER_00: to things like wages and healthcare and higher education and so on and so forth.
- 1:24:47SPEAKER_00: But there wasn't.
- 1:24:49SPEAKER_00: There wasn't.
- 1:24:50SPEAKER_00: And we tried to use the internet to construct it.
- 1:24:53SPEAKER_00: And many people,
- 1:24:54SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:24:54SPEAKER_00: developed influencer skills to do this and really,
- 1:24:57SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:24:57SPEAKER_00: made podcasts and tried to think about how do you say the right thing on the podcast
- 1:25:01SPEAKER_00: to help make this thing happen?
- 1:25:03SPEAKER_00: It couldn't be done.
- 1:25:05SPEAKER_00: And that was even with the stuff that has the most purchase,
- 1:25:08SPEAKER_00: the stuff that affects the largest number of different kinds of constituencies.
- 1:25:12SPEAKER_00: What happened is, you know, people say, oh, you know, the right stopped it.
- 1:25:16SPEAKER_00: Well, what did Hillary Clinton do?
- 1:25:18SPEAKER_00: What did the right do?
- 1:25:19SPEAKER_00: They just talked about And the people who are uniting them together said,
- 1:25:22SPEAKER_00: don't worry about those wedge issues.
- 1:25:24SPEAKER_00: They're just culture war issues.
- 1:25:26SPEAKER_00: They don't really matter.
- 1:25:27SPEAKER_00: That didn't work.
- 1:25:45SPEAKER_00: That didn't put them back together at all.
- 1:25:47SPEAKER_00: Why?
- 1:25:47SPEAKER_00: Because they actually care about culture war issues.
- 1:25:50SPEAKER_00: They genuinely do.
- 1:25:51SPEAKER_00: And people take that lesson and go, aha,
- 1:25:53SPEAKER_00: there's all of these people out there who have culture war positions we don't agree
- 1:25:57SPEAKER_00: with.
- 1:25:57SPEAKER_00: So maybe we just need to have a left politics,
- 1:26:00SPEAKER_00: which is culturally moderate or a left politics,
- 1:26:03SPEAKER_00: which is culturally conservative or something.
- 1:26:05SPEAKER_00: But there is no unified people that you can make out of that either.
- 1:26:10SPEAKER_00: That's just another way to construct another fragile partial coalition,
- 1:26:14SPEAKER_00: which ultimately will not survive a stress test.
- 1:26:17SPEAKER_01: So the way is shut.
- 1:26:19SPEAKER_00: Yes, the way is shut.
- 1:26:21SPEAKER_00: That's been my whole shtick for years.
- 1:26:25SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think,
- 1:26:26SPEAKER_02: and as much as, I mean,
- 1:26:28SPEAKER_02: to me particularly,
- 1:26:30SPEAKER_02: it matters because I spend my time writing silly science fiction stories about
- 1:26:34SPEAKER_02: the robots taking over.
- 1:26:36SPEAKER_02: And so I don't want to poo-poo that idea because I, yeah,
- 1:26:44SPEAKER_02: but I think it's telling that we,
- 1:26:48SPEAKER_02: or at least myself,
- 1:26:50SPEAKER_02: We'll spend time wondering whether or not the robots are going to take over
- 1:26:54SPEAKER_02: when it seems to be the case already that the robots have taken over.
- 1:26:58SPEAKER_02: They're just not wearing bodies.
- 1:26:59SPEAKER_02: It's this logic.
- 1:27:00SPEAKER_02: It's this kind of global deadlock that we're trapped in with where the way is shut.
- 1:27:04SPEAKER_02: The way is forced shut by this logic that kind of...
- 1:27:07SPEAKER_02: It doesn't just condition.
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_02: It really does determine what is possible within the existing framework
- 1:27:13SPEAKER_02: that we're operating inside.
- 1:27:16SPEAKER_02: I do think that already is the AI...
- 1:27:20SPEAKER_00: Yeah, the states and corporations,
- 1:27:24SPEAKER_00: I think already the modern state, as conceived by Hobbes, is already AI.
- 1:27:30SPEAKER_00: And we can make it more AI.
- 1:27:32SPEAKER_00: We can make it something that's harder to challenge and rebel against.
- 1:27:35SPEAKER_00: But I think you could frame all of the social movements of modernity as
- 1:27:39SPEAKER_00: so many human rebellions against Hobbes' machines.
- 1:27:43SPEAKER_00: Hobbes' machine will now acquire new machine tools.
- 1:27:45SPEAKER_00: That's what Hobbes' machine always does in response to pressure from the people.
- 1:27:50SPEAKER_00: It requires new machine tools and gets stronger and more powerful and harder
- 1:27:55SPEAKER_00: to even comprehend,
- 1:27:56SPEAKER_00: let alone meaningfully resist through silly monkey things like social organizing.
- 1:28:07SPEAKER_01: Oh, man.
- 1:28:08SPEAKER_01: Is it possible to kill Goliath with a stone?
- 1:28:12SPEAKER_00: There's so many movies that take that as the premise,
- 1:28:15SPEAKER_00: sci-fi movies where you just have to push the off button on the thing.
- 1:28:23SPEAKER_00: But it will change things.
- 1:28:26SPEAKER_00: States and corporations have changed our world enormously over the period of time in
- 1:28:30SPEAKER_00: which they've been the dominant actors.
- 1:28:32SPEAKER_00: They make huge changes and the competitive struggle
- 1:28:36SPEAKER_00: among them does have directionality of varying kinds and types.
- 1:28:41SPEAKER_00: It's not like things are going to be the same forever.
- 1:28:44SPEAKER_00: It's just if you're insistent that it's got to be social and political organizing of
- 1:28:49SPEAKER_00: a historical type.
- 1:28:52SPEAKER_00: And if that's the only way anything can change in a way that's morally acceptable,
- 1:28:57SPEAKER_00: then life will seem to be very miserable and depressing.
- 1:29:01SPEAKER_00: But you could be in despair about the political and still be open to the possibility
- 1:29:06SPEAKER_00: of new stuff happening.
- 1:29:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:29:10SPEAKER_01: Okay, I just want to ask this before we run out of time and I forget.
- 1:29:17SPEAKER_01: I just want to ask the most basic prediction from you.
- 1:29:20SPEAKER_01: Let's see what you think about this.
- 1:29:22SPEAKER_01: Okay, so last week Trump was, I mean,
- 1:29:25SPEAKER_01: the fear that liberals and leftists have had is that Trump will not go silently into
- 1:29:32SPEAKER_01: the night.
- 1:29:32SPEAKER_01: He will want a third term.
- 1:29:34SPEAKER_01: Well, he was joking about it last week.
- 1:29:38SPEAKER_01: About sticking around for a third term and that he'll be running in 2028.
- 1:29:49SPEAKER_01: What do you think about this, Benjamin?
- 1:29:51SPEAKER_01: Will he actually leave and it won't be a problem?
- 1:29:53SPEAKER_01: Will he think, this is so unfair, there's no reason I can't have a third term.
- 1:30:00SPEAKER_01: Let's think this through.
- 1:30:03SPEAKER_01: So will Trump want a third term and will AOC be the Democratic nominee?
- 1:30:11SPEAKER_00: So I think if Trump was trying to get a third term,
- 1:30:13SPEAKER_00: it would look a lot like the current argument about the SAVE Act,
- 1:30:17SPEAKER_00: something which isn't going to pass, even though Trump really would like it to pass.
- 1:30:21SPEAKER_00: He'd really like that SAVE Act to happen,
- 1:30:24SPEAKER_00: but it's not going to happen because Because everybody knows that
- 1:30:28SPEAKER_00: because he is associated with challenging the integrity of the elections,
- 1:30:32SPEAKER_00: any reforms to the electoral system that are associated
- 1:30:35SPEAKER_00: with him will be delegitimating on the next election.
- 1:30:38SPEAKER_00: And so they won't actually perform the function.
- 1:30:40SPEAKER_00: Republicans who do support some level of reform,
- 1:30:44SPEAKER_00: they still want that reform to actually have the function of legitimating
- 1:30:48SPEAKER_00: the elections.
- 1:30:49SPEAKER_00: And if the reforms are associated with someone who has no credibility on the issue
- 1:30:53SPEAKER_00: with large parts of the public, then they can't possibly perform that function.
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_00: In the same way,
- 1:30:59SPEAKER_00: if he was trying to run for a third term,
- 1:31:01SPEAKER_00: he would be denying other people in the party their opportunity
- 1:31:04SPEAKER_00: to Those people have no interest in facilitating his doing that.
- 1:31:10SPEAKER_00: He would be going, come on, wouldn't this be cool and fun?
- 1:31:12SPEAKER_00: Wouldn't it be great if we did this?
- 1:31:14SPEAKER_00: And they won't really be very interested in that.
- 1:31:16SPEAKER_00: The other thing to bear in mind is that it would be one thing
- 1:31:19SPEAKER_00: if he was 20 years younger or even 10 years younger,
- 1:31:23SPEAKER_00: but he's really, really, really old, really old.
- 1:31:28SPEAKER_00: He's going to be an octogenarian Don't you know that I have at least 50 years left in me.
- 1:31:45SPEAKER_01: I have 50 years left in me.
- 1:31:46SPEAKER_01: I've eaten nothing but McDonald's my entire adult life.
- 1:31:50SPEAKER_01: And that's the trick you've all been lied to.
- 1:31:54SPEAKER_01: And I, you can basically consider me immortal at this point.
- 1:31:59SPEAKER_01: I will never stop.
- 1:32:00SPEAKER_01: I'm the
- 1:32:01SPEAKER_02: Energizer Bunny.
- 1:32:02SPEAKER_02: Him and RFK are going to live forever.
- 1:32:07SPEAKER_02: I think he's a lame dunk.
- 1:32:09SPEAKER_02: I do think he's fading,
- 1:32:12SPEAKER_02: not just from his term being up, but I think he's not long for this world.
- 1:32:17SPEAKER_02: He looks like shit.
- 1:32:21SPEAKER_01: I don't think he'll survive.
- 1:32:23SPEAKER_01: Okay, so will AOC be the nominee?
- 1:32:27SPEAKER_00: I don't think so.
- 1:32:29SPEAKER_00: Having watched what has gone on in Britain in relation to
- 1:32:33SPEAKER_00: the Ed Miliband Net Zero thing,
- 1:32:36SPEAKER_00: Ed Miliband had a much stronger position within the Labour Party in terms
- 1:32:40SPEAKER_00: of he had lots and lots of support.
- 1:32:42SPEAKER_00: He used to be leader of the party.
- 1:32:43SPEAKER_00: He has loads of friends.
- 1:32:45SPEAKER_00: There's loads of people who like him.
- 1:32:47SPEAKER_00: He had already been appointed the Secretary of Energy and Net Zero.
- 1:32:52SPEAKER_00: And yet when Andy Burnham came in,
- 1:32:54SPEAKER_00: despite the fact that Andy Burnham is a close personal friend of his and has been
- 1:32:58SPEAKER_00: a friend of his for a long time,
- 1:33:00SPEAKER_00: there was such an uproar about making Ed Miliband Chancellor of the Exchequer.
- 1:33:07SPEAKER_00: Purely on the basis that Ed Miliband would direct too much investment
- 1:33:11SPEAKER_00: toward green technology at the expense of keeping energy cheap immediately today
- 1:33:17SPEAKER_00: for AI and for defense contractors.
- 1:33:20SPEAKER_00: Purely on that basis.
- 1:33:21SPEAKER_00: And Tony Blair,
- 1:33:23SPEAKER_00: who is not well liked and is an antique figure,
- 1:33:25SPEAKER_00: wrote this long op-ed criticizing Starmer and implicitly Ed Miliband
- 1:33:31SPEAKER_00: for prioritizing net zero over AI and over maintaining a competitive economy and
- 1:33:37SPEAKER_00: over making investments in defense to meet the NATO defense spending target.
- 1:33:42SPEAKER_00: Even though Tony Blair is not popular and not well liked,
- 1:33:45SPEAKER_00: and even though Ed Miliband is very strong inside the Labour Party and in terms
- 1:33:50SPEAKER_00: of MPs,
- 1:33:51SPEAKER_00: in terms of connections to Labour Party interest groups, he couldn't be chancellor.
- 1:33:59SPEAKER_00: And ultimately,
- 1:34:00SPEAKER_00: not only could he not be chancellor,
- 1:34:02SPEAKER_00: Andy Burnham had to pick John Healy,
- 1:34:04SPEAKER_00: who resigned as the Minister of Defense on the grounds that
- 1:34:10SPEAKER_00: the Sarmer government was not investing enough in defense.
- 1:34:13SPEAKER_00: So he not only couldn't pick Miliband, he had to countersignal by picking Healy.
- 1:34:19SPEAKER_00: So what that says to me is that AOC,
- 1:34:21SPEAKER_00: who doesn't have anything like the same level of strength inside the party,
- 1:34:24SPEAKER_00: who is associated with, who's running in the United States.
- 1:34:29SPEAKER_00: So it's not like the defense contractors and the AI companies are native British companies.
- 1:34:33SPEAKER_00: They're mostly American companies.
- 1:34:34SPEAKER_00: Nevertheless, the demand was that Britain appease those companies.
- 1:34:37SPEAKER_00: The home power base of those companies is the United States.
- 1:34:41SPEAKER_00: And they have loads and loads of Democrats to choose from who are very technophile,
- 1:34:47SPEAKER_00: who are abundance narrative oriented,
- 1:34:50SPEAKER_00: who they have a long history of being able to work with successfully.
- 1:34:55SPEAKER_00: I'm not sure who they are.
- 1:34:56SPEAKER_00: So that's not to say that it'll be Newsom.
- 1:35:17SPEAKER_00: I think there's an opportunity for somebody else.
- 1:35:19SPEAKER_00: Newsom hasn't polled well enough to get ahead of Harris yet.
- 1:35:24SPEAKER_00: And I think anybody who trails Harris is weak.
- 1:35:27SPEAKER_00: If Harris is leading and you're in a poll against Harris and you can't beat Harris,
- 1:35:32SPEAKER_00: even I'm going to vote for Harambe again.
- 1:36:01SPEAKER_02: I mean, we talked a bit about AI.
- 1:36:04SPEAKER_02: I wonder, Mikey,
- 1:36:06SPEAKER_02: if you want to bring up that potentially hot button question,
- 1:36:10SPEAKER_02: because it kind of rhymes with AI.
- 1:36:14SPEAKER_02: You know, when people talk about AI in the future, they talk about AI.
- 1:36:20SPEAKER_02: They talk about biological collapse,
- 1:36:23SPEAKER_02: biodiversity,
- 1:36:24SPEAKER_02: this and that, and nanotechnology and engineering at the human level, transhumanism.
- 1:36:34SPEAKER_02: Transhumanism, all these things.
- 1:36:36SPEAKER_02: Some people are doomers about it.
- 1:36:38SPEAKER_02: Some people are utopian about it.
- 1:36:40SPEAKER_02: Some people are just trying to live their life and do their job and take care
- 1:36:43SPEAKER_02: of their family and make sure all their needs are met and they don't have time
- 1:36:46SPEAKER_02: to decide if they think we're all doomed or we're all going
- 1:36:49SPEAKER_02: to figure it out someday.
- 1:36:51SPEAKER_02: Nevertheless, they're all kind of popular topics.
- 1:36:56SPEAKER_02: And transhumanism is, yeah, it's very much a kind of mainstream topic.
- 1:37:01SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 1:37:02SPEAKER_02: There's a darker side to
- 1:37:04SPEAKER_01: AI and transhumanism.
- 1:37:08SPEAKER_01: And I think some of the guys on the right are tapped into this.
- 1:37:12SPEAKER_01: And I think,
- 1:37:13SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:37:15SPEAKER_01: when I say the word, it's one of those words that people go, oh, shoot, that word.
- 1:37:22SPEAKER_01: But this last week, I've been thinking through it.
- 1:37:27SPEAKER_01: And look, when you're a theorist, a philosopher...
- 1:37:30SPEAKER_01: Whatever.
- 1:37:33SPEAKER_01: There's moments where you step back and you go,
- 1:37:35SPEAKER_01: okay, I've always been against that, but why am I against it?
- 1:37:39SPEAKER_01: Like, can I actually, even to myself, or is it just something I was taught to be against?
- 1:37:46SPEAKER_01: And, I mean, I'm against it after thinking it through this week, but...
- 1:37:54SPEAKER_01: I had to kind of start from a zero point and go, okay,
- 1:37:57SPEAKER_01: let me actually start thinking this through for myself
- 1:38:00SPEAKER_01: because I don't think I ever have.
- 1:38:02SPEAKER_01: I've just relied on, I don't know, some sort of leftist big other.
- 1:38:06SPEAKER_01: Like, oh yeah, it's a default position of mine.
- 1:38:10SPEAKER_01: Eugenics, right?
- 1:38:13SPEAKER_01: So what is, why is eugenics bad?
- 1:38:16SPEAKER_01: Why is it a problem, right?
- 1:38:18SPEAKER_01: Now there's obviously certain default answers.
- 1:38:25SPEAKER_01: But when you start moving in this direction of AI,
- 1:38:29SPEAKER_01: transhumanism,
- 1:38:31SPEAKER_01: there's a eugenic component to this trajectory,
- 1:38:34SPEAKER_01: which is,
- 1:38:36SPEAKER_01: is AI going to select what it considers to be the best humans for certain roles,
- 1:38:41SPEAKER_01: certain positions in society?
- 1:38:44SPEAKER_01: Hyper-racism?
- 1:38:45SPEAKER_01: Say what?
- 1:38:48SPEAKER_02: Hyper-racism, short little blog post.
- 1:38:50SPEAKER_01: Hyper-racism, right,
- 1:38:51SPEAKER_01: which is this famous piece Nick Land wrote where the racism becomes actually those
- 1:38:57SPEAKER_01: who are augmented.
- 1:39:00SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 1:39:00SPEAKER_01: I know there's this way you and I want to talk about us humans always being cyborgs,
- 1:39:05SPEAKER_01: but this is meant in a different sense, right?
- 1:39:09SPEAKER_01: That there will be technologically modified humans.
- 1:39:13SPEAKER_01: They will not be...
- 1:39:16SPEAKER_01: Whatever we are, they won't be it.
- 1:39:18SPEAKER_01: They will have transcended it via tech.
- 1:39:21SPEAKER_01: This is a new type of racism, the racism against the unmodified, right?
- 1:39:30SPEAKER_01: So I guess I want to start just with kind of the naive question
- 1:39:35SPEAKER_01: that you start philosophical lines of inquiry with.
- 1:39:40SPEAKER_01: Why is...
- 1:39:43SPEAKER_01: Why do we all consider eugenics to be this evil thing?
- 1:39:48SPEAKER_01: Is it just because of the different political parties it's been associated with?
- 1:39:53SPEAKER_01: There's some naive aspect of it.
- 1:39:58SPEAKER_01: It's not bad.
- 1:39:58SPEAKER_01: It's just trying to get the best out of humanity.
- 1:40:02SPEAKER_01: What's the problem with it?
- 1:40:05SPEAKER_01: What's the issue with eugenics, guys?
- 1:40:09SPEAKER_02: There's a part of me that may be taking up this spirit of naivete where I want
- 1:40:16SPEAKER_02: to say, what's the difference between eugenics and fluoride in the water?
- 1:40:21SPEAKER_02: Didn't we put fluoride in the water to improve dental hygiene,
- 1:40:25SPEAKER_02: to improve not just quality of life, but also longevity of life?
- 1:40:29SPEAKER_02: And isn't that actually a good thing?
- 1:40:31SPEAKER_02: And I do.
- 1:40:31SPEAKER_02: My sister's a dental hygienist, and we've had lots of conversations.
- 1:40:35SPEAKER_02: I do think dental hygiene is one of the...
- 1:40:38SPEAKER_02: So if you got something funky going on up here, it's going to screw you up.
- 1:40:41SPEAKER_02: But obviously I'm being hyperbolic and sensational and silly,
- 1:40:45SPEAKER_02: but there is a part of me, what is it that separates eugenics from
- 1:41:06SPEAKER_02: What is it that separates eugenics from germ theory and understanding that you have
- 1:41:11SPEAKER_02: to wash your hands if you do an autopsy and then you go deliver a baby,
- 1:41:17SPEAKER_02: you have to wash your hands because there's this thing.
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_02: And the guy that discovered that was considered a madman.
- 1:41:25SPEAKER_02: But here we are, two centuries later, we take it all for granted.
- 1:41:29SPEAKER_02: Germs are real.
- 1:41:30SPEAKER_02: Healthcare is a real thing.
- 1:41:32SPEAKER_02: I recently did a little solo episode talking about healthcare and Illich.
- 1:41:37SPEAKER_02: I do think the healthcare industry needs to be criticized and interrogated.
- 1:41:42SPEAKER_02: But I do think it's worth asking the question,
- 1:41:44SPEAKER_02: what's the difference between eugenics and hygienics?
- 1:41:49SPEAKER_02: And I think it's the political application of that.
- 1:41:54SPEAKER_02: And I think in the world we live in today, health care...
- 1:41:59SPEAKER_02: Or hygienics,
- 1:42:00SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:42:00SPEAKER_02: just to be fun, is already being applied in a stupid, idiotic, instrumental way.
- 1:42:06SPEAKER_02: And I think the poor people suffer from the healthcare system.
- 1:42:12SPEAKER_02: Whereas eugenics, I think it's, I don't know, is it inherently racist?
- 1:42:16SPEAKER_02: I think probably most times it's been applied.
- 1:42:19SPEAKER_02: I think it has been explicitly racist.
- 1:42:22SPEAKER_02: Maybe?
- 1:42:23SPEAKER_02: I don't even know.
- 1:42:25SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:42:27SPEAKER_02: I guess my answer to you, Mikey, is that's a good fucking question.
- 1:42:33SPEAKER_00: And I don't know.
- 1:42:35SPEAKER_00: Benjamin?
- 1:42:37SPEAKER_00: So I think when you say eugenics,
- 1:42:39SPEAKER_00: people typically think you mean negative eugenics as in killing the unfit people so
- 1:42:44SPEAKER_00: that only the fit people can reproduce.
- 1:42:47SPEAKER_00: And people are opposed to killing the unfit people so that only the fit people can reproduce.
- 1:42:52SPEAKER_00: Of course, historically, before World War II, eugenics meant a lot of other things.
- 1:42:59SPEAKER_00: In addition to...
- 1:43:01SPEAKER_00: Eugenics could just mean trying to ensure that people who had good traits
- 1:43:06SPEAKER_00: or complementary traits were able to reproduce or to try in some way to influence
- 1:43:12SPEAKER_00: who reproduced with whom so as to get certain kinds of traits.
- 1:43:17SPEAKER_00: And this could involve positive inducement.
- 1:43:19SPEAKER_00: It could involve systems.
- 1:43:20SPEAKER_00: It often involved people drawing on the part of Plato's Republic where he talks
- 1:43:24SPEAKER_00: about calculating the births.
- 1:43:27SPEAKER_00: And this idea that you could try in some way to produce more regularly parts of
- 1:43:32SPEAKER_00: the population who had the skills that you needed through positive incentives.
- 1:43:39SPEAKER_00: In the 20s and 30s,
- 1:43:41SPEAKER_00: before World War II and before the Holocaust,
- 1:43:44SPEAKER_00: broad parts of the We're interested in eugenics.
- 1:43:49SPEAKER_00: In general, modern political theory was very interested in eugenics.
- 1:43:55SPEAKER_00: It received a rebrand in recent decades as transhumanism.
- 1:43:59SPEAKER_00: Transhumanism, of course, means trying to overcome the limitations of the human.
- 1:44:05SPEAKER_00: And that's what eugenics is ultimately about as well.
- 1:44:09SPEAKER_00: It's about trying to overcome the limitations of human beings.
- 1:44:15SPEAKER_00: Now, I think that Insofar as eugenics is a bad thing,
- 1:44:20SPEAKER_00: or insofar as transhumanism is a bad thing,
- 1:44:23SPEAKER_00: it would be that transhumanism and eugenics,
- 1:44:27SPEAKER_00: support for it, is often motivated by Gnosticism.
- 1:44:31SPEAKER_00: So Gnosticism being a hatred of being, a hatred of being.
- 1:44:37SPEAKER_00: And a belief that existence is evil and needs to be in some way machined away or machined over.
- 1:44:45SPEAKER_00: That it's not good to be human.
- 1:44:47SPEAKER_00: That human beings are bad and evil on some level and need to self abolish as human beings.
- 1:44:55SPEAKER_00: I am not a Gnostic.
- 1:44:56SPEAKER_00: I think Gnosticism is a kind of heresy that stems from a misreading of Platonism.
- 1:45:03SPEAKER_00: So I would call it a Platonic heresy.
- 1:45:07SPEAKER_00: Rather than proper Platonism.
- 1:45:08SPEAKER_00: And many people often conflate the two together and treat Platonism as
- 1:45:11SPEAKER_00: if it were just Gnosticism, which I think is a mistake.
- 1:45:17SPEAKER_00: I think that if you have an attitude toward transhumanism or to certain applications
- 1:45:23SPEAKER_00: of what might be called eugenics that isn't motivated by Gnosticism
- 1:45:27SPEAKER_00: but has other positive humanistic motivations,
- 1:45:30SPEAKER_00: then you might be talking about something more defensible.
- 1:45:34SPEAKER_00: But to do this, you have to break down what does somebody mean?
- 1:45:36SPEAKER_00: What are they really talking about?
- 1:45:38SPEAKER_00: I noticed in the interview that Peter Thiel had on Ross Duthett's show,
- 1:45:44SPEAKER_00: he's just been picked up by 60 Minutes.
- 1:45:46SPEAKER_00: He's leaving the New York Times for 60 Minutes.
- 1:45:49SPEAKER_00: Yeah, Ross Dethit.
- 1:45:51SPEAKER_00: But in his interview that was still done for the New York Times,
- 1:45:55SPEAKER_00: which you can find on YouTube with Peter Thiel,
- 1:45:57SPEAKER_00: they got into this question about whether Peter Thiel's transhumanism is a kind
- 1:46:02SPEAKER_00: of Gnostic heresy.
- 1:46:03SPEAKER_00: And I think that it's difficult to argue that Peter Thiel's version
- 1:46:09SPEAKER_00: of Christianity is not Gnosticism.
- 1:46:13SPEAKER_00: If you have a Gnostic position, then that's going to lead to quite anti-human attitudes.
- 1:46:18SPEAKER_00: And I think one of the things people have noticed about Thiel and some
- 1:46:21SPEAKER_00: of these other guys is that they do seem to have the attitude
- 1:46:24SPEAKER_00: that human beings are bad and need to be overcome or need to be abolished.
- 1:46:29SPEAKER_00: If the human is bad,
- 1:46:30SPEAKER_00: if the human is a source of evil,
- 1:46:32SPEAKER_00: rather than just something lacking or imperfect or incomplete,
- 1:46:37SPEAKER_00: Then I think you move into the Gnosticism territory and then the transhumanism or
- 1:46:41SPEAKER_00: the eugenics doesn't have a sufficiently positive motivation.
- 1:46:45SPEAKER_00: It's motivated by hatred of human beings.
- 1:46:48SPEAKER_00: And then I think at that point it becomes something that definitely ought to be opposed.
- 1:46:54SPEAKER_02: I like that a lot.
- 1:46:56SPEAKER_02: I think that's a powerful statement.
- 1:46:59SPEAKER_02: I really do.
- 1:47:00SPEAKER_02: Because I do think...
- 1:47:03SPEAKER_02: It shows you something to be naive and ask, what's the problem with eugenics?
- 1:47:09SPEAKER_02: What's the problem with transhumanism?
- 1:47:12SPEAKER_02: And I think that same question should be applied to the modern day world that we live in.
- 1:47:18SPEAKER_02: What's the problem with the world that we live in today?
- 1:47:22SPEAKER_02: It feels very wrong.
- 1:47:24SPEAKER_02: And I think the fact that it feels very wrong...
- 1:47:28SPEAKER_02: A lot of people find themselves doing lots of different things to try to make up for
- 1:47:35SPEAKER_02: the fact that the world we live in just feels wrong.
- 1:47:40SPEAKER_02: And someone comes along and offers them an easy answer.
- 1:47:43SPEAKER_02: Like Steve Bannon and all the populist bullshit that he slings or slung on the internet.
- 1:47:50SPEAKER_02: And all the deleterious effects.
- 1:47:52SPEAKER_02: Because I really do think that online violence and nihilistic violence and a lot
- 1:47:58SPEAKER_02: of crazy shit is a direct consequence of the kind of populism that supports...
- 1:48:07SPEAKER_02: Just the churn.
- 1:48:09SPEAKER_02: Like we're all just utility.
- 1:48:10SPEAKER_02: We're all just exchange value at the end of the day.
- 1:48:13SPEAKER_02: Attention, attention, attention.
- 1:48:14SPEAKER_02: Extract, extract, extract.
- 1:48:18SPEAKER_02: The human has been sucked dry of all that makes it human.
- 1:48:23SPEAKER_02: And so we find ourselves doing very strange things.
- 1:48:25SPEAKER_02: And it's supported ideologically by things like this kind of populism.
- 1:48:29SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:48:32SPEAKER_02: But rather than naively asking the question, like, what's wrong with the world today?
- 1:48:36SPEAKER_02: And maybe it's not entirely wrong.
- 1:48:38SPEAKER_02: And in fact, maybe there are some parts of it that are actually good.
- 1:48:40SPEAKER_02: And in fact,
- 1:48:41SPEAKER_02: maybe there are some things that are wrong with it that are constitutively wrong
- 1:48:46SPEAKER_02: or they're wrong in this way that's actually productive.
- 1:48:51SPEAKER_02: So it's not that it's evil.
- 1:48:55SPEAKER_02: It is that it's lacking.
- 1:48:56SPEAKER_02: And it's, hey, the lack is an opportunity of freedom.
- 1:48:59SPEAKER_02: It's an opportunity for us to be humans.
- 1:49:02SPEAKER_00: Flaws are opportunities for growth.
- 1:49:04SPEAKER_00: Imperfections are things you can work on.
- 1:49:07SPEAKER_00: The human condition is something imperfect and flawed, full of mistakes that we can work on.
- 1:49:12SPEAKER_00: But if you instead regard it as evil,
- 1:49:15SPEAKER_00: and I think it's very easy for people to slip into going, people are just evil.
- 1:49:20SPEAKER_00: There is no good part of the soul.
- 1:49:22SPEAKER_00: There's just a constant desire for recognition and status and honor,
- 1:49:27SPEAKER_00: and then a constant desire for goodies and consumer bobbles and hedonism.
- 1:49:32SPEAKER_00: And I think particularly tech companies,
- 1:49:35SPEAKER_00: tech CEOs who sell enormous amounts of recognition and pleasurable goodies
- 1:49:40SPEAKER_00: to people tend to regard their customers this way,
- 1:49:44SPEAKER_00: as grabby little apes who want their life.
- 1:49:49SPEAKER_00: And then complain about these companies that are trying to go to space
- 1:49:53SPEAKER_00: and do worthwhile and interesting things with human talent.
- 1:49:57SPEAKER_00: That's how I think a lot of the tech CEOs regard ordinary people.
- 1:50:00SPEAKER_00: And if you think in that kind of way,
- 1:50:02SPEAKER_00: it becomes very easy to say that people ought to be regarded as objects,
- 1:50:09SPEAKER_00: as pure consumers,
- 1:50:14SPEAKER_00: And once you move into that kind of view,
- 1:50:19SPEAKER_00: it becomes very easy to say, why should we have them?
- 1:50:21SPEAKER_00: Why should there be so many of them?
- 1:50:23SPEAKER_00: They certainly shouldn't be in charge.
- 1:50:25SPEAKER_00: And I think that is the kind of default view that a lot of those guys have.
- 1:50:29SPEAKER_00: Now, to be fair to them, I don't think that they fell out of a coconut tree with that.
- 1:50:33SPEAKER_00: I think that that comes out of their experience of capitalism.
- 1:50:36SPEAKER_00: The kind of life that they're having in capitalism invites them to regard people as customers.
- 1:50:43SPEAKER_00: Customers of entities like Facebook and Twitter.
- 1:50:47SPEAKER_00: What do the customers of these sites do?
- 1:50:49SPEAKER_00: They say horrible things to each other continuously so
- 1:50:52SPEAKER_00: that they can get dopamine rushes from likes and retweets.
- 1:50:56SPEAKER_00: The customers of these entities, what do people type into these LLM chats?
- 1:51:02SPEAKER_00: What's the training data?
- 1:51:04SPEAKER_00: What do people say?
- 1:51:06SPEAKER_00: If you're stuck having to look at metadata about how do people interact with ChatGPT
- 1:51:11SPEAKER_00: or Gemini, it'd be very easy to develop a very negative view of the customer.
- 1:51:17SPEAKER_00: Especially people are rude to these things.
- 1:51:19SPEAKER_00: People look to waste their energy, waste money by talking to these things.
- 1:51:24SPEAKER_00: I've seen some people on social media promote just engaging these things
- 1:51:29SPEAKER_00: in dumb conversations as a way of wasting rich people's money.
- 1:51:34SPEAKER_00: By forcing them to burn energy on stupid conversations,
- 1:51:37SPEAKER_00: use extra words in your answers,
- 1:51:39SPEAKER_00: ways of trying to subtly through your consumption,
- 1:51:43SPEAKER_00: hurt the bottom line in some way of these people,
- 1:51:45SPEAKER_00: make them pay a price for the world that they're building.
- 1:51:48SPEAKER_00: There's all kinds of nasty stuff that goes around.
- 1:51:51SPEAKER_00: And these guys become embittered,
- 1:51:53SPEAKER_00: especially when they get involved in politics and put themselves out in front of
- 1:51:56SPEAKER_00: the public and then become terribly hated people with horrible favorability ratings.
- 1:52:02SPEAKER_00: Much lower than that of many people,
- 1:52:04SPEAKER_00: I understand coming to that kind of view,
- 1:52:09SPEAKER_00: but I do think it's a deeply mistaken perspective that comes out of capitalism and
- 1:52:14SPEAKER_00: which we ought to change the system to not generate that kind of view about people.
- 1:52:20SPEAKER_00: When we have people who are developing Gnostic attitudes,
- 1:52:22SPEAKER_00: it's because we have a very flawed system that forces people
- 1:52:25SPEAKER_00: to continuously confront the worst aspects of human beings over and over and
- 1:52:30SPEAKER_00: over again for years until this is all they can see of the human.
- 1:52:35SPEAKER_01: So, okay.
- 1:52:36SPEAKER_01: You guys tell me if you think I'm right here in my criticisms.
- 1:52:40SPEAKER_01: What I...
- 1:52:43SPEAKER_01: After the few days of thinking about it, I mean,
- 1:52:45SPEAKER_01: one thing I dislike is that I think it divides people into two camps of substances,
- 1:52:54SPEAKER_01: which are the people over here who have desirable traits and those
- 1:53:00SPEAKER_01: who have undesirable traits.
- 1:53:02SPEAKER_01: I think that is just too...
- 1:53:06SPEAKER_01: That's such a silly way to divide all human beings into two camps.
- 1:53:14SPEAKER_01: On the basis of what?
- 1:53:17SPEAKER_01: What you find to be desirable traits, and so you impose that.
- 1:53:23SPEAKER_01: I can't help, but I see certain psychoanalytic dynamics here.
- 1:53:29SPEAKER_01: When you substantialize people like this,
- 1:53:32SPEAKER_01: You act like,
- 1:53:32SPEAKER_01: oh, this group has desirable traits, this one has undesirable, like, both have both.
- 1:53:40SPEAKER_01: And nobody is fully consistent with themselves.
- 1:53:45SPEAKER_01: To use the older term, it's almost like there's a form of essentialism going on here.
- 1:53:50SPEAKER_01: That doesn't recognize the plasticity of human beings as groups and as individuals.
- 1:53:58SPEAKER_01: That just because somebody has
- 1:53:59SPEAKER_01: a desirable trait now doesn't mean they'll always have that trait.
- 1:54:03SPEAKER_01: Now, if you try to do this at the genetic level,
- 1:54:05SPEAKER_01: and genetics is your ultimate criterion for deciding this shit...
- 1:54:14SPEAKER_01: I just think this type of reductionism,
- 1:54:17SPEAKER_01: though the human is their genes,
- 1:54:20SPEAKER_01: oh the human is their IQ score,
- 1:54:23SPEAKER_01: I just have never been able to see anything but like bad faith or inauthenticity
- 1:54:30SPEAKER_01: in this type of identification or reductionism of the human to these things.
- 1:54:35SPEAKER_01: And real quick, just, and the motivation behind this seems like one of pure in-framing.
- 1:54:44SPEAKER_01: Like, Humans only exist to be their most useful and resourceful and optimized.
- 1:54:55SPEAKER_01: And God damn it, I just want to affirm waste.
- 1:54:59SPEAKER_01: And I think the fantasy of eugenics is we can create the human without all of the excesses.
- 1:55:07SPEAKER_01: And what I would say is those very undesirable excesses are the human.
- 1:55:10SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:55:15SPEAKER_02: Jude Law and... Is Ewan McGregor in that movie or is it Gattaca?
- 1:55:22SPEAKER_02: It's Jude Law and...
- 1:55:26SPEAKER_02: I can't remember the other guy.
- 1:55:27SPEAKER_02: But yeah, I think Gattaca...
- 1:55:30SPEAKER_02: Shows us why eugenics sucks.
- 1:55:33SPEAKER_02: And because it does do that.
- 1:55:34SPEAKER_02: It totalizes humans as if your genetic code
- 1:55:43SPEAKER_02: is you.
- 1:55:44SPEAKER_02: As if the subject can be reduced down to the genetic code.
- 1:55:48SPEAKER_01: Your whole life is just your genetics.
- 1:55:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah, like it's an entirely, yeah, in-framed way to look at it.
- 1:55:55SPEAKER_02: It's totalization.
- 1:55:56SPEAKER_02: It's instrumentalization.
- 1:55:58SPEAKER_02: Capitalistic calculation.
- 1:56:01SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:56:01SPEAKER_02: Now, I think when it's happening...
- 1:56:06SPEAKER_02: For like explicitly racist reasons,
- 1:56:09SPEAKER_02: I think it is maybe qualitatively different from this other type
- 1:56:13SPEAKER_02: of economic eugenics.
- 1:56:15SPEAKER_02: I think they're both,
- 1:56:16SPEAKER_02: I mean the one that's happening for racist reasons is obviously I disagree with that
- 1:56:20SPEAKER_02: because I do think racism is dumb.
- 1:56:23SPEAKER_02: Um...
- 1:56:24SPEAKER_02: However,
- 1:56:24SPEAKER_02: it is it is true that I had children with someone who I consciously
- 1:56:29SPEAKER_02: and explicitly thought it would be good to have children with.
- 1:56:31SPEAKER_02: But I'm also sure there was something else going on where I thought, oh,
- 1:56:35SPEAKER_02: she looks strong and I will have strong virile children who will go on
- 1:56:39SPEAKER_02: to carry my genes into the into the future.
- 1:56:42SPEAKER_02: So like.
- 1:56:43SPEAKER_02: This is why I think it's important to ask the question about health care as well,
- 1:56:46SPEAKER_02: because it like.
- 1:56:50SPEAKER_02: I'm all for it.
- 1:56:51SPEAKER_02: I am all for it.
- 1:56:52SPEAKER_02: If you want to go off and you want to genetically modify yourself to have
- 1:56:55SPEAKER_02: a television in your chest,
- 1:57:08SPEAKER_02: Or some other dumb, useless thing.
- 1:57:10SPEAKER_02: Feel free.
- 1:57:11SPEAKER_02: Go for it.
- 1:57:11SPEAKER_02: I want you to be able to do that.
- 1:57:14SPEAKER_02: And I think that's like the same species of endeavor as healthcare,
- 1:57:20SPEAKER_02: as transhumanism, as using language I think it's bad too.
- 1:57:24SPEAKER_02: But again, it's...
- 1:57:54SPEAKER_02: Eugenics, transhumanism, you're really asking the question of technology at the end of the day.
- 1:58:01SPEAKER_00: And eugenics... One of the things... Oh, sorry, Nance, I don't mean to catch you up.
- 1:58:06SPEAKER_00: But one of the things, Mike, you raised is Manicheanism, right?
- 1:58:11SPEAKER_00: A good-bad dichotomy in putting people into boxes of good or bad on the basis of their nature.
- 1:58:17SPEAKER_01: Benjamin, you mean like separating the wheat from the chaff?
- 1:58:20SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:58:21SPEAKER_00: I think also Manichaeanism is a bad way to think about the cosmos and another mistake.
- 1:58:28SPEAKER_00: I do want to consider, though,
- 1:58:30SPEAKER_00: I think there is, obviously, I reject also any kind of racialized theory of that.
- 1:58:37SPEAKER_00: That would not be of any interest.
- 1:58:39SPEAKER_00: I don't think that that's a credible way to think about human beings.
- 1:58:47SPEAKER_00: The strong case for transhumanism or eugenics is something like,
- 1:58:51SPEAKER_00: say there's a genetic condition that causes babies to suffer terribly and then die.
- 1:58:59SPEAKER_00: But you can remove this genetic condition.
- 1:59:01SPEAKER_00: It's a genetic condition that you can find and then you can remove it and then
- 1:59:06SPEAKER_00: the babies will be born without this condition and they will not suffer and die.
- 1:59:10SPEAKER_00: So in that kind of case, you're making an intervention which is about
- 1:59:17SPEAKER_00: Alleviating the suffering of the human in a way which isn't about trying to negate
- 1:59:23SPEAKER_00: the human, but is based in love of the human and a desire to affirm it in some way.
- 1:59:29SPEAKER_00: You know, and say, this person matters.
- 1:59:31SPEAKER_00: They shouldn't be born into the world in terrible suffering.
- 1:59:35SPEAKER_00: I think it's hard to argue against that strong case,
- 1:59:38SPEAKER_00: because in that case,
- 1:59:39SPEAKER_00: it's not motivated by Gnosticism or Manicheanism or anti-humanism or nihilism
- 1:59:44SPEAKER_00: or something like that.
- 1:59:45SPEAKER_00: Or racism.
- 1:59:46SPEAKER_00: Or racism.
- 1:59:47SPEAKER_00: And so there's ways of talking about interventions that are undeniably transhumanist.
- 1:59:52SPEAKER_00: And I think all transhumanism is in some sense eugenicist.
- 1:59:56SPEAKER_00: I would regard that as a eugenic intervention.
- 1:59:59SPEAKER_00: It just might be a eugenic intervention that somebody might And I think that
- 2:00:05SPEAKER_00: the kind of opposition to eugenics or to transhumanism is often too fast.
- 2:00:09SPEAKER_00: There's not enough questions about what is it in the service of?
- 2:00:13SPEAKER_00: What is the worldview that is driving it?
- 2:00:16SPEAKER_00: Because there's a lot of different types of metaphysical positions
- 2:00:20SPEAKER_00: that I would disagree with that can produce very negative forms of eugenics
- 2:00:24SPEAKER_00: and transhumanism.
- 2:00:26SPEAKER_00: But there are also ways of engaging in modification of the body
- 2:00:30SPEAKER_00: that I don't think Yeah,
- 2:00:39SPEAKER_01: I mean, I would agree.
- 2:00:41SPEAKER_01: I mean, look, I mean,
- 2:00:42SPEAKER_01: because somebody could say,
- 2:00:43SPEAKER_01: well, isn't eugenics just trying to make humanity as good as it can be?
- 2:00:49SPEAKER_01: And that's where you have to start really sorting through that with nuance,
- 2:00:56SPEAKER_01: because there's so much that can be packed inside of that.
- 2:01:01SPEAKER_01: Not all of it negative or, you know,
- 2:01:08SPEAKER_01: threatening or, you know, simply put, fucked up.
- 2:01:13SPEAKER_01: But I think they shroud a lot of what is dangerous in it by just talking about,
- 2:01:22SPEAKER_01: oh, this lofty, we just, humanity at its best.
- 2:01:26SPEAKER_01: And for me, again,
- 2:01:27SPEAKER_01: I think When it comes to those like,
- 2:01:31SPEAKER_01: oh, good, they won't be around or those traits won't be around.
- 2:01:37SPEAKER_01: I always want to say I don't even like the talk of traits half the time
- 2:01:41SPEAKER_01: because you're reducing a human person to a set of traits.
- 2:01:47SPEAKER_01: And it's very convenient to talk about, well, a bad trait.
- 2:01:50SPEAKER_01: OK, yeah, we can all agree that there's traits that are bad.
- 2:01:54SPEAKER_01: The person where this affects humans.
- 2:01:57SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 2:01:58SPEAKER_01: And.
- 2:02:00SPEAKER_01: So my only thing is, I think we all have this split inside of us.
- 2:02:06SPEAKER_01: I think we're all subjects of death drive and jouissance and self undermining.
- 2:02:12SPEAKER_01: And I think this split into two,
- 2:02:16SPEAKER_01: like one good substance,
- 2:02:18SPEAKER_01: one bad substance is just a projection onto other people of our own excesses
- 2:02:25SPEAKER_01: that we wish we could be rid of.
- 2:02:28SPEAKER_01: And we tell ourselves we can be rid of if we get rid of them.
- 2:02:33SPEAKER_01: And I just want to say, guys, the undesirable traits are always already in you.
- 2:02:40SPEAKER_01: And so in this sense, the perfection of humanity is the annihilation of humanity.
- 2:02:48SPEAKER_00: Mikey, I think you've introduced a third bad reason to do eugenics.
- 2:02:53SPEAKER_00: So in addition to Gnosticism,
- 2:02:56SPEAKER_00: generalized hatred of humanity,
- 2:02:58SPEAKER_00: Manichaeanism,
- 2:03:00SPEAKER_00: hatred of some part of humanity in which you put all of the bad stuff,
- 2:03:04SPEAKER_00: you also raised,
- 2:03:05SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 2:03:06SPEAKER_00: stoic understandings of the good that are extremely rigid
- 2:03:10SPEAKER_00: and fixed conceptualizations that are not open to revision,
- 2:03:14SPEAKER_00: not open to philosophical development.
- 2:03:17SPEAKER_00: And which are based on a particular constellation which has been naturalized.
- 2:03:21SPEAKER_00: So to give a very basic example,
- 2:03:23SPEAKER_00: if you suddenly gave eugenic technology to the Romans,
- 2:03:28SPEAKER_00: the Romans would say, we want people who can wield the gladiators.
- 2:03:32SPEAKER_00: We need men who are strong and good at stabbing and marching and good at the gladius
- 2:03:36SPEAKER_00: and men who are really skinny and starve to death quickly,
- 2:03:41SPEAKER_00: who are, you know, egghead intellectuals but can't run around with the gladius.
- 2:03:46SPEAKER_00: This is not a very useful kind of person and they shouldn't be reproducing.
- 2:03:52SPEAKER_00: The notion of virtue,
- 2:03:53SPEAKER_00: manliness,
- 2:03:54SPEAKER_00: would include in a Roman context being able to run around and stab people with
- 2:03:58SPEAKER_00: the gladius.
- 2:03:59SPEAKER_00: Now, that's not to say that the Romans are bad people for thinking like that.
- 2:04:02SPEAKER_00: They're in a context where it's kind of relevant whether men can run around
- 2:04:05SPEAKER_00: and stab people with the gladius.
- 2:04:07SPEAKER_00: And in the same way in our society,
- 2:04:10SPEAKER_00: there are certain types of behaviors or qualities which seem very valuable
- 2:04:15SPEAKER_00: and would seem to be good from our point of view that might not be
- 2:04:18SPEAKER_00: so important later.
- 2:04:20SPEAKER_00: And conversely,
- 2:04:21SPEAKER_00: there are things that perhaps we devalue that subsequently could become important.
- 2:04:26SPEAKER_00: And one of the things where people ridicule all the time is people who are good at consuming.
- 2:04:31SPEAKER_00: People who are expensive consumers who find ways to waste enormous amounts
- 2:04:37SPEAKER_00: of resources on stuff that These people would be major liabilities in
- 2:04:43SPEAKER_00: a more archaic kind of society.
- 2:04:45SPEAKER_00: But these people contribute enormously to capitalism.
- 2:04:47SPEAKER_00: And the fact that they're around means that there are people who will find your ways
- 2:04:52SPEAKER_00: to buy all of these plastic toys You look at them and I go,
- 2:04:56SPEAKER_00: how could anybody want this stuff?
- 2:04:59SPEAKER_00: And a lot of eugenicists say they want to get rid of all vice and get rid of all of this.
- 2:05:03SPEAKER_00: But if we're in capitalism,
- 2:05:05SPEAKER_00: then we need a consumer economy and therefore we need people People
- 2:05:09SPEAKER_00: who will buy seemingly useless,
- 2:05:10SPEAKER_00: unimportant things, and therefore certain vices are very socially useful.
- 2:05:16SPEAKER_00: And there's that old fable of the bees,
- 2:05:18SPEAKER_00: Bernard Mandeville,
- 2:05:19SPEAKER_00: about all of a sudden these historical vices have become very socially useful.
- 2:05:24SPEAKER_00: Because they drive commercial activity which then produces widespread prosperity and
- 2:05:29SPEAKER_00: the state needs prosperity to be able to be competitive and to defend itself.
- 2:05:32SPEAKER_00: And if you have citizens who are too virtuous and too moderate and don't consume
- 2:05:36SPEAKER_00: and don't spend enough money,
- 2:05:38SPEAKER_00: then you won't have a sufficiently active consumer economy.
- 2:05:40SPEAKER_00: You won't be able to maintain a competitive army and you'll get conquered actually.
- 2:05:44SPEAKER_00: Having a very virtuous population will cause your state to collapse.
- 2:05:48SPEAKER_00: No?
- 2:05:50SPEAKER_00: If you move historical conditions,
- 2:05:52SPEAKER_00: you will find circumstances where stuff
- 2:05:54SPEAKER_00: that you previously didn't value becomes important.
- 2:05:58SPEAKER_00: And all of this stuff is potentially consistent with the good if you recognize that
- 2:06:03SPEAKER_00: the good is something which has to be continuously rethought,
- 2:06:06SPEAKER_00: reconceptualized, understood in new ways, in new situations.
- 2:06:11SPEAKER_00: But if you take it in a very stoic way where you naturalize it and treat it as
- 2:06:14SPEAKER_00: a transhistorical thing on the basis of a limited finite historical experience,
- 2:06:20SPEAKER_00: Then you will get overly attached and fixated on a particular type of person,
- 2:06:25SPEAKER_00: which you'll then massively over reproduce at the expense of other types of people
- 2:06:29SPEAKER_00: that you might in a couple of hundred years need to have had.
- 2:06:36SPEAKER_01: Great point.
- 2:06:37SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:06:38SPEAKER_01: I mean, I think that's partly what I was getting at when I was saying it ignores
- 2:06:44SPEAKER_01: the plasticity of the human.
- 2:06:45SPEAKER_01: I think that Using the word revision here is incredibly helpful.
- 2:06:51SPEAKER_01: And yeah,
- 2:06:51SPEAKER_01: it seems to lock us into some sort of, oh,
- 2:06:55SPEAKER_01: those who on some transhistorical basis are attuned more so than the others to
- 2:07:04SPEAKER_01: the production of beauty and the production of works of art and great achievements.
- 2:07:12SPEAKER_01: It's like,
- 2:07:13SPEAKER_01: from what Yeah,
- 2:07:20SPEAKER_00: it takes a very specific kind of society before you could support large numbers
- 2:07:26SPEAKER_00: of people like me and have it make any kind of sense.
- 2:07:35SPEAKER_02: There's a science fiction book called Man After Man by Dougal Dixon.
- 2:07:42SPEAKER_02: He wrote several science fiction books.
- 2:07:44SPEAKER_02: They're weird science fiction books.
- 2:07:46SPEAKER_02: They're not like novels.
- 2:07:47SPEAKER_02: But Olaf Stabledon and Dougal Dixon wrote books that cover hundreds of thousands
- 2:07:55SPEAKER_02: of years, eons, and it's like deep history, deep future.
- 2:07:59SPEAKER_02: It's all speculative and it's all really fun.
- 2:08:03SPEAKER_02: And Olaf Stapleton wrote Star Maker and The Last Man.
- 2:08:07SPEAKER_02: They're fascinating science fiction books.
- 2:08:09SPEAKER_02: But Dougal Dixon wrote After Man.
- 2:08:11SPEAKER_02: And then he wrote another, like a future history of evolution of animals and stuff.
- 2:08:18SPEAKER_02: And then he wrote Man After Man.
- 2:08:20SPEAKER_02: And it was just kind of cataloging all the horrors that man had done to himself or
- 2:08:29SPEAKER_02: that humanity had done.
- 2:08:30SPEAKER_02: And so you wind up with like stupid apes and you wind up with amphibious creatures
- 2:08:35SPEAKER_02: who are always in pain.
- 2:08:36SPEAKER_02: They're really, really good at one certain thing.
- 2:08:52SPEAKER_02: But they're really,
- 2:08:53SPEAKER_02: really good at one certain thing and they're suffering
- 2:08:55SPEAKER_02: because they can't do anything else and they've genetically modified themselves
- 2:08:59SPEAKER_02: to be just weird, odd things.
- 2:09:03SPEAKER_02: And humans are,
- 2:09:04SPEAKER_02: we're already weird,
- 2:09:05SPEAKER_02: odd things, but we're a contradictory collection of weird, odd things.
- 2:09:08SPEAKER_02: And so if we develop a technology that aims to eradicate Substantial contradiction
- 2:09:14SPEAKER_02: and difference for the sake of just one of these weird, odd things.
- 2:09:18SPEAKER_02: Essentially unnatural, uncanny things.
- 2:09:22SPEAKER_02: We are not natural.
- 2:09:23SPEAKER_02: Again, the problem that we face,
- 2:09:27SPEAKER_02: I think, is naturalizing, like this impulse to naturalize the human.
- 2:09:32SPEAKER_02: I think that's a huge problem.
- 2:09:33SPEAKER_02: I think that's a major source for a lot of horrible things that we do.
- 2:09:36SPEAKER_01: Partly what I mean by substantialize.
- 2:09:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah, substantializing, essentializing.
- 2:09:43SPEAKER_02: But yeah,
- 2:09:44SPEAKER_02: we need the room for all the difference and all the contradiction and all
- 2:09:48SPEAKER_02: the diversity.
- 2:09:50SPEAKER_02: And the saccharine fucking platitude of diversity is our greatest strength.
- 2:09:55SPEAKER_02: I never really understood it until I sat and thought about it.
- 2:09:58SPEAKER_02: And I was like, well,
- 2:09:59SPEAKER_02: actually, diversity is a pretty good thing because it allows for contradiction.
- 2:10:02SPEAKER_02: It allows for real difference and incompatibility and incongruity.
- 2:10:08SPEAKER_02: Some things are just not meant to be resolved.
- 2:10:13SPEAKER_02: And it's because they cannot be resolved,
- 2:10:16SPEAKER_02: something new is produced and you can actually move on.
- 2:10:18SPEAKER_02: And that's actually a site of freedom.
- 2:10:21SPEAKER_02: But this ideological fantasy of improving the human by means of eugenics or by means
- 2:10:30SPEAKER_02: of indoctrination,
- 2:10:32SPEAKER_02: is the school system developed to teach you to be smart and curious and wonder
- 2:10:36SPEAKER_02: and ponder?
- 2:10:37SPEAKER_02: Or is it developed to teach you how to respond to a bell so you can be a better factory worker?
- 2:10:43SPEAKER_02: The question of public education systems and the question of eugenics,
- 2:10:47SPEAKER_02: I think, is ultimately the same question.
- 2:10:49SPEAKER_02: We are asking the question of like, are our tools using us?
- 2:10:56SPEAKER_02: And yeah, under the current global regime, yes, our tools are using us.
- 2:11:03SPEAKER_02: The way has been shut by capital or by, I don't know, whatever...
- 2:11:08SPEAKER_02: Whatever.
- 2:11:09SPEAKER_02: I call it capital.
- 2:11:10SPEAKER_02: People get mad that we anthropomorphize capital, but
- 2:11:15SPEAKER_01: yeah, we've reached a deadline.
- 2:11:19SPEAKER_01: That's not changing.
- 2:11:19SPEAKER_00: Process of modernization, process of corporatization.
- 2:11:25SPEAKER_00: Capital is a process.
- 2:11:28SPEAKER_00: But it is an agent.
- 2:11:30SPEAKER_01: In a weird sense,
- 2:11:31SPEAKER_01: insofar as it has its own motivations and incentives that it relentlessly
- 2:11:40SPEAKER_01: imposes
- 2:11:41SPEAKER_01: upon the world,
- 2:11:42SPEAKER_01: and that everything more or less has to bend the knee to those drives.
- 2:11:50SPEAKER_01: And so there's a sense where Marxist formula,
- 2:11:54SPEAKER_01: MCM Prime,
- 2:11:57SPEAKER_01: Everything has been centered around that prime
- 2:12:00SPEAKER_01: as this infinite accumulation process.
- 2:12:05SPEAKER_01: And because of that,
- 2:12:06SPEAKER_01: there is a weird sense where it's like there's an agent dictating what all of us do.
- 2:12:14SPEAKER_01: And I mean, I always like this little thought experiment.
- 2:12:17SPEAKER_01: If you zoomed out and you could actually have this perspective,
- 2:12:21SPEAKER_01: if you were looking at a city
- 2:12:22SPEAKER_01: and you could simultaneously have like this bird's eye view or God's eye view,
- 2:12:28SPEAKER_01: but also simultaneously be very close to each individual and what they're doing,
- 2:12:34SPEAKER_01: you would see that the vast majority,
- 2:12:36SPEAKER_01: the commuting, what's going on throughout the day, all of it is to generate capital.
- 2:12:43SPEAKER_01: And from that perspective, you go, yeah, there is like an overarching perspective
- 2:12:49SPEAKER_01: There's no consensus anymore,
- 2:12:52SPEAKER_01: but there is an overarching will or drive that's shaping everything that we all have
- 2:13:00SPEAKER_01: to do, reluctantly so most of the time, and it's capital.
- 2:13:05SPEAKER_01: That's where I kind of don't mind thinking about it as an agent or an entity.
- 2:13:12SPEAKER_02: I think it's imperative.
- 2:13:14SPEAKER_02: I also think
- 2:13:18SPEAKER_02: I think it might be a fair, sure,
- 2:13:20SPEAKER_02: maybe we can only see that retroactively and maybe we can only see that
- 2:13:23SPEAKER_02: from our strange point of view.
- 2:13:26SPEAKER_02: So maybe that kind of agency does appear to us as an illusion.
- 2:13:30SPEAKER_02: Sure, that's fine, but it's an integral illusion.
- 2:13:33SPEAKER_00: It's kind of like Galen Strassen talks about self-experience.
- 2:13:39SPEAKER_00: The self for Galen Strassen is an illusion, but phenomenologically people have self-experience.
- 2:13:44SPEAKER_00: Self-experience exists even if the self is an illusion.
- 2:13:48SPEAKER_00: In the same way, capital has this agentic appearance.
- 2:13:54SPEAKER_00: It's experienced as an agentic thing,
- 2:13:56SPEAKER_00: and people are always filling that agentic category with some set of people
- 2:14:01SPEAKER_00: or some group.
- 2:14:03SPEAKER_00: Part because it has this phenomenological aspect of seeming to be agentic.
- 2:14:09SPEAKER_00: And then the way that we typically talk about agency,
- 2:14:11SPEAKER_00: it's something which has to be attached to a concrete social or political unit.
- 2:14:15SPEAKER_00: We're not able to have agency.
- 2:14:18SPEAKER_00: That is not tied to a social or political unit in our conceptual scheme.
- 2:14:23SPEAKER_00: So people are constantly filling it with agents and positing different conspiratorial elements.
- 2:14:29SPEAKER_00: And it causes a lot of confusion, the fact that it has this agentic appearance.
- 2:14:33SPEAKER_00: And then people are always filling that with something else that's concrete.
- 2:14:38SPEAKER_00: That then leads them away from thinking about capitalism.
- 2:14:41SPEAKER_01: Well, and I also would say part of why I think of it in terms of it,
- 2:14:45SPEAKER_01: this being an agent is, Okay, so it's a virtual structure.
- 2:14:50SPEAKER_01: It's this virtual logic of accumulation, right?
- 2:14:54SPEAKER_01: Well, I mean, we have our virtual symbolic orders.
- 2:14:58SPEAKER_01: I mean, there's the symbolic rules, the virtual rules that make the game of basketball possible.
- 2:15:05SPEAKER_01: What's different about the rules that make the game
- 2:15:08SPEAKER_01: of basketball possible is they don't feel like they have to impose themselves
- 2:15:14SPEAKER_01: on every other activity going on.
- 2:15:18SPEAKER_01: In society, whereas the logic of capital, it commodifies everything.
- 2:15:23SPEAKER_01: I mean, that's Marx's line and Marx and Engel's line in the Communist Manifesto,
- 2:15:27SPEAKER_01: where it turns the doctor,
- 2:15:29SPEAKER_01: the poet, and they go down this list of different professions that get commodified.
- 2:15:37SPEAKER_01: And so it's this weird virtual mechanism, but it's the great colonizer.
- 2:15:42SPEAKER_01: It has to force itself in every area of life and commodify everything
- 2:15:47SPEAKER_01: in its own image and likeness in a way that other,
- 2:15:52SPEAKER_01: you know, isolated, you know, basketball, golf.
- 2:15:55SPEAKER_01: I don't know why I'm going to all sports examples, but...
- 2:16:01SPEAKER_01: These different areas of life had their own virtual rules and protocols to follow
- 2:16:06SPEAKER_01: while in them, but they didn't feel like they had to colonize all the other ones.
- 2:16:11SPEAKER_01: Capital,
- 2:16:12SPEAKER_01: anywhere it can overcode, I mean,
- 2:16:16SPEAKER_01: DNG wouldn't like it being called that,
- 2:16:18SPEAKER_01: but wherever it can over-axiomize capitalism, The other one would be
- 2:16:33SPEAKER_00: war.
- 2:16:35SPEAKER_00: War is the other thing that does that.
- 2:16:38SPEAKER_00: That's good, yeah.
- 2:16:39SPEAKER_00: And when people get sick of capital because they haven't been able to come up with
- 2:16:43SPEAKER_00: an alternative,
- 2:16:44SPEAKER_00: they start going to war because war is the other thing that can compete with that.
- 2:16:49SPEAKER_00: And when people get really,
- 2:16:50SPEAKER_00: really ticked about capital and they don't see any positive possibility,
- 2:16:54SPEAKER_00: that's when it goes, OK, you're tired of capital.
- 2:16:58SPEAKER_00: Would you like war?
- 2:16:59SPEAKER_00: You can vote for war if you want it.
- 2:17:02SPEAKER_00: The system will do that.
- 2:17:05SPEAKER_00: It still has that option for you if you're really sick of it.
- 2:17:09SPEAKER_00: And then you end up stuck in that.
- 2:17:11SPEAKER_01: This is a perfect lead in.
- 2:17:12SPEAKER_01: So one of.
- 2:17:16SPEAKER_01: We were talking about, you know, the way is shut.
- 2:17:18SPEAKER_01: There's no consensus.
- 2:17:21SPEAKER_01: When I was growing up,
- 2:17:23SPEAKER_01: whether somebody,
- 2:17:24SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 2:17:25SPEAKER_01: my mom and my best friend, his mom, you know, one's liberal, one's conservative.
- 2:17:32SPEAKER_01: They could get together, still be best friends, bicker about politics.
- 2:17:35SPEAKER_01: But there was some sort of consensus there.
- 2:17:41SPEAKER_01: They were still on the same foundation while having disagreements on that foundation.
- 2:17:53SPEAKER_01: What would not have made them not talk to each other for months
- 2:17:58SPEAKER_01: on end was disagreeing about, I don't know, Braveheart.
- 2:18:04SPEAKER_01: But now with the Odyssey, you see how the Odyssey has completely just divided people.
- 2:18:12SPEAKER_01: And I just think that this moment of seeing the Odyssey and seeing how people are
- 2:18:18SPEAKER_01: over this,
- 2:18:19SPEAKER_01: like this is something that to me,
- 2:18:21SPEAKER_01: and maybe you can go back in history and go,
- 2:18:23SPEAKER_01: oh, well, people were like this over other movies.
- 2:18:26SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 2:18:27SPEAKER_01: I just don't.
- 2:18:27SPEAKER_01: I didn't.
- 2:18:28SPEAKER_01: I did not feel like there was this divide over Star Wars or Jurassic Park
- 2:18:33SPEAKER_01: or Braveheart or whatever.
- 2:18:35SPEAKER_01: And yeah, I mean,
- 2:18:39SPEAKER_01: is this kind of where we're at where,
- 2:18:42SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 2:18:42SPEAKER_01: a movie like the Odyssey is, you know, symptomatic of
- 2:18:48SPEAKER_01: this lack of consensus?
- 2:18:51SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:18:53SPEAKER_02: Much like representation has taken the place of action or activity for a lot of people.
- 2:19:02SPEAKER_02: Has culture war replaced actual war?
- 2:19:07SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
- 2:19:10SPEAKER_00: All right.
- 2:19:11SPEAKER_00: I want to say something provocative, which is that the Star Wars prequels divided...
- 2:19:19SPEAKER_00: Regular people.
- 2:19:20SPEAKER_00: But not on political grounds, right?
- 2:19:23SPEAKER_00: Yes, on political grounds.
- 2:19:24SPEAKER_00: The Star Wars prequels, yeah.
- 2:19:27SPEAKER_00: There was a serious culture war that involved regular people about
- 2:19:31SPEAKER_00: the Star Wars prequels because there was a real conflict between people who think
- 2:19:36SPEAKER_00: that the Star Wars movies have a symbolic...
- 2:19:42SPEAKER_00: There's a certain thing that Star Wars movies are.
- 2:19:46SPEAKER_00: Every new Star Wars movie has to be one of them.
- 2:19:49SPEAKER_00: And then they have this unifying effect because everyone is committed together to Star Wars.
- 2:19:53SPEAKER_00: And in this way, Star Wars took the role of the nation.
- 2:19:58SPEAKER_00: It's the abstraction to which that's supposed to unite everybody.
- 2:20:01SPEAKER_00: And then there was another set of people who said Star Wars needs to be updated.
- 2:20:05SPEAKER_00: Star Wars needs to reflect what we've learned in post-modernity.
- 2:20:08SPEAKER_00: It can't be this black and white good guys, bad guys thing.
- 2:20:11SPEAKER_01: Made for modern audiences, as they like to say.
- 2:20:15SPEAKER_00: Or, you know, even postmodern audiences, right?
- 2:20:17SPEAKER_00: Because you can't have this light side,
- 2:20:18SPEAKER_00: dark side, Jedi, Sith, straightforward black and white morality.
- 2:20:22SPEAKER_00: There's got to be gray introduced and Luke Skywalker has to become
- 2:20:26SPEAKER_00: a little bit less obviously the good guy.
- 2:20:28SPEAKER_00: And also there's got There's got to be diversity in the film and diverse casting and so on.
- 2:20:33SPEAKER_00: And the dispute about the Star Wars prequels got intense enough that there were...
- 2:20:38SPEAKER_00: Are we talking about the prequels or the sequels?
- 2:20:41SPEAKER_00: Not the prequels.
- 2:20:42SPEAKER_00: Excuse me.
- 2:20:43SPEAKER_00: The Disney sequels.
- 2:20:44SPEAKER_01: The Disney sequels.
- 2:20:45SPEAKER_01: Have I been saying prequels?
- 2:20:47SPEAKER_01: I mean to say Disney sequels.
- 2:20:49SPEAKER_01: Because I was like, I don't remember the prequels being...
- 2:20:52SPEAKER_00: Okay, not the prequels, but the Disney sequels.
- 2:20:54SPEAKER_00: Totally on the same
- 2:20:55SPEAKER_01: page now.
- 2:20:56SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:20:57SPEAKER_00: Sorry.
- 2:20:57SPEAKER_00: The Disney sequels.
- 2:20:59SPEAKER_00: That is something that I think divided ordinary regular people to a significant degree.
- 2:21:04SPEAKER_00: Oh, I agree.
- 2:21:05SPEAKER_00: The movie started to do badly commercialized.
- 2:21:07SPEAKER_00: They started to get not just review bombed by weird people on the internet,
- 2:21:11SPEAKER_00: but to actually divide mainstream public opinion.
- 2:21:14SPEAKER_00: And then the studios tried to hush this up and pretend that it wasn't what was occurring.
- 2:21:18SPEAKER_00: And it got really ugly.
- 2:21:20SPEAKER_00: The Star Wars fight got really ugly.
- 2:21:22SPEAKER_00: The Odyssey has done great commercially.
- 2:21:25SPEAKER_00: It's been a phenomenal commercial success.
- 2:21:29SPEAKER_00: I thought that we were going to have a repeat of that kind
- 2:21:32SPEAKER_00: of Star Wars Disney sequels struggle.
- 2:21:34SPEAKER_00: That did not happen.
- 2:21:36SPEAKER_00: The Odyssey was commercially a total success.
- 2:21:40SPEAKER_00: The public in general is perfectly happy.
- 2:21:43SPEAKER_00: The people who are in dispute about the Odyssey are people like us
- 2:21:49SPEAKER_00: who are intellectuals and have an elevated stake in canon works like the Odyssey,
- 2:21:58SPEAKER_00: much more so than the bulk of the American public who don't care at all about
- 2:22:03SPEAKER_00: the specific kinds of criticisms that we're raising because they never read
- 2:22:08SPEAKER_00: and never will read any translation of the Odyssey Ever.
- 2:22:13SPEAKER_00: At any point.
- 2:22:14SPEAKER_00: But they will see the movie.
- 2:22:16SPEAKER_00: But they will see the movie and they'll judge the movie as
- 2:22:19SPEAKER_00: a blockbuster movie alongside other blockbuster movies.
- 2:22:22SPEAKER_00: And for them,
- 2:22:22SPEAKER_00: The Odyssey is just source material for a movie in the same way
- 2:22:26SPEAKER_00: that Harry Potter is source material for a movie.
- 2:22:29SPEAKER_00: And the only question is whether the movie is good.
- 2:22:32SPEAKER_00: And the movie could be better than the book as far as they're concerned
- 2:22:35SPEAKER_00: if it beats their entertainment needs in a better way than the book does.
- 2:22:38SPEAKER_00: And I guarantee you, for the vast majority of them, it does.
- 2:22:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:22:42SPEAKER_00: However,
- 2:22:43SPEAKER_00: from our point of view as intellectuals,
- 2:22:45SPEAKER_00: there are all kinds of serious problems with the Christopher Nolan movie.
- 2:22:48SPEAKER_00: All kinds of serious problems that range from questions of whether it's
- 2:22:53SPEAKER_00: a good modern adaptation, if you put it next to James Joyce's Ulysses.
- 2:22:57SPEAKER_00: Questions of whether it's a faithful adaptation of ancient Greek culture.
- 2:23:04SPEAKER_00: One of the questions we've been asking as weird nerd people is
- 2:23:07SPEAKER_00: whether movies should actually try to give people a confrontation
- 2:23:12SPEAKER_00: with ancient Greek Ancient cultures, ancient values, ancient beliefs.
- 2:23:18SPEAKER_00: Is that something that contemporary audiences are interested in or will bear?
- 2:23:22SPEAKER_00: One of the things people do whenever they try to move in this direction is also move
- 2:23:25SPEAKER_00: in a horror direction.
- 2:23:27SPEAKER_00: So it's not just the case that these people So this is something
- 2:23:29SPEAKER_00: that I've been concerned about because while I would
- 2:23:43SPEAKER_00: I would like people to be able,
- 2:23:45SPEAKER_00: in a kind of Cambridge School History of Thought way,
- 2:23:47SPEAKER_00: think about values that are outside our own context for the purposes
- 2:23:51SPEAKER_00: of widening our notions of what's possible.
- 2:23:53SPEAKER_00: If we add a bunch of horror elements to all of that to terrify people
- 2:23:56SPEAKER_00: of anything that's not modern American life,
- 2:23:59SPEAKER_00: That's not actually going to accomplish that end.
- 2:24:02SPEAKER_00: So what I'm seeing is on the one hand,
- 2:24:05SPEAKER_00: Gladiator 2 style and Nolan's movie,
- 2:24:08SPEAKER_00: I think I would put in the category of Gladiator 2 style,
- 2:24:11SPEAKER_00: telling some story about contemporary American culture,
- 2:24:13SPEAKER_00: but loosely through a medium which references ancient tropes and which has,
- 2:24:19SPEAKER_00: in some cases,
- 2:24:20SPEAKER_00: decent costumes,
- 2:24:21SPEAKER_00: although people complain about the Odyssey costumes in a way
- 2:24:23SPEAKER_00: that they would never have to complain about the costumes in Gladiator 2.
- 2:24:27SPEAKER_00: And then conversely, people like, what's his face?
- 2:24:31SPEAKER_00: The guy who did the Northman.
- 2:24:34SPEAKER_00: These kinds of horror period pieces, they're about making you very uncomfortable with the past.
- 2:24:41SPEAKER_00: And people talked a little And there's a little bit about this even in the Odyssey
- 2:24:44SPEAKER_00: in terms of grayscaling everything, making the past seem foreboding and unpleasant.
- 2:24:48SPEAKER_00: And then you had people going,
- 2:24:50SPEAKER_00: remember,
- 2:24:50SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:24:51SPEAKER_00: people used to make movies about the past where you could see the colors and
- 2:24:54SPEAKER_00: the banners and, you know, everything was wonderful.
- 2:24:58SPEAKER_00: I think there are interesting debates to be had about to what degree we should try
- 2:25:01SPEAKER_00: to use movies to do Cambridge History of Political Thought stuff for the public.
- 2:25:15SPEAKER_00: I, you know,
- 2:25:16SPEAKER_00: have a there's certainly a part of me that thinks that would be a cool thing to do.
- 2:25:20SPEAKER_00: But is it a commercially viable thing?
- 2:25:22SPEAKER_00: It's not clear to me that it is.
- 2:25:24SPEAKER_00: Certainly a lot of the classicists who watch this movie took it for granted
- 2:25:27SPEAKER_00: that it had to be a modern adaptation.
- 2:25:30SPEAKER_00: And then, you know, they went into it going, how does it rack up against James Joyce?
- 2:25:35SPEAKER_00: How does it rack up against Circe?
- 2:25:37SPEAKER_00: How does it rack up against these other kinds of books that have been written in
- 2:25:40SPEAKER_00: the last hundred years, which appropriate Greek myths in a modern context?
- 2:25:44SPEAKER_00: They weren't judging it in terms of, you know, does this convey Greek concepts and notions?
- 2:25:49SPEAKER_00: They took it for granted that it would be Christianized and modernized to varying degrees.
- 2:25:54SPEAKER_00: But, you know, the Emily Wilson Review for the London Review of Books, have you read that yet?
- 2:25:59SPEAKER_01: I've heard about it.
- 2:26:00SPEAKER_01: I haven't read it.
- 2:26:01SPEAKER_00: Yeah, this is,
- 2:26:03SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 2:26:03SPEAKER_00: an interesting one because she waited until the movie was already
- 2:26:06SPEAKER_00: a commercial success, so she couldn't possibly damage it.
- 2:26:09SPEAKER_00: Lots of people would,
- 2:26:10SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 2:26:10SPEAKER_00: see it and wouldn't be dissuaded from seeing it on the basis of hearing
- 2:26:13SPEAKER_00: about her review.
- 2:26:15SPEAKER_00: But then her translation is the one that Christopher Nolan cites as having inspired
- 2:26:21SPEAKER_00: So the fact that she doesn't regard it as a good modern adaptation,
- 2:26:24SPEAKER_00: even though she's well known for being someone who promotes modernizing
- 2:26:28SPEAKER_00: or postmodernizing ancient work with your translations,
- 2:26:33SPEAKER_00: she thinks it's perfectly acceptable.
- 2:26:40SPEAKER_00: She nonetheless felt that it didn't work at the level of a modern adaptation
- 2:26:45SPEAKER_00: and was very critical about it on those grounds and used some very strong language
- 2:26:48SPEAKER_00: in that London Review of The book's piece,
- 2:26:50SPEAKER_00: remarkably strong language for an academic,
- 2:26:53SPEAKER_00: saying she would be embarrassed to have written any word of it even.
- 2:26:57SPEAKER_00: But at the end of it,
- 2:26:58SPEAKER_00: she nonetheless thanked Christopher Nolan for raising public interest in classics
- 2:27:02SPEAKER_00: and in classics.
- 2:27:04SPEAKER_00: Ancient texts because the classics departments are in battle
- 2:27:08SPEAKER_00: and maybe this will result in some jobs being saved for some classicists.
- 2:27:12SPEAKER_00: And of course, that's more important than the fact that it's a bad movie from her point of view.
- 2:27:17SPEAKER_00: So it still includes that perfunctory thing.
- 2:27:19SPEAKER_00: Okay, so...
- 2:27:47SPEAKER_01: Everybody I know who's seen it has thought it was a good movie and they enjoyed it.
- 2:27:52SPEAKER_01: And they're not coming at it from our perspective.
- 2:27:55SPEAKER_01: They're not coming at it from the perspective of,
- 2:27:58SPEAKER_01: you know, a YouTube movie critic caught up in the culture war.
- 2:28:03SPEAKER_01: I mean, like, Angry Joe versus Critical Drinker on this thing and Nerdrotic and...
- 2:28:10SPEAKER_01: Oh, Jeremy Johns gave it a good review.
- 2:28:12SPEAKER_01: What's wrong with him?
- 2:28:14SPEAKER_01: There's this bickering with the YouTube film critics,
- 2:28:19SPEAKER_01: and they're all caught up in the culture war side of this.
- 2:28:23SPEAKER_01: And the public just basically unanimously said this was a good movie.
- 2:28:30SPEAKER_01: They didn't say it's the greatest movie ever made.
- 2:28:32SPEAKER_01: They just said this was a good movie.
- 2:28:34SPEAKER_01: We liked it, right?
- 2:28:36SPEAKER_01: Okay, is this...
- 2:28:40SPEAKER_01: Maybe a fleeting moment, but we just talked about, you know, the normie did not take place.
- 2:28:46SPEAKER_01: Is this the revenge of the normie?
- 2:28:49SPEAKER_01: At least a moment of it where there's a flicker of a kind of cohesion in the public
- 2:28:56SPEAKER_01: that just says, all you culture war fuckers, shut the fuck up.
- 2:29:01SPEAKER_01: We're going,
- 2:29:02SPEAKER_01: we're going to enjoy the movie and we don't care about what any of you have to say
- 2:29:05SPEAKER_01: about it.
- 2:29:07SPEAKER_00: I do think that there are still certain people,
- 2:29:11SPEAKER_00: mostly older people from the 20th century,
- 2:29:14SPEAKER_00: who have a certain cachet with the public on the basis of the history
- 2:29:18SPEAKER_00: of producing major work that has been extremely popular with the public.
- 2:29:22SPEAKER_00: Christopher Nolan is, in my view, a...
- 2:29:24SPEAKER_00: I don't like to use this term, but the...
- 2:29:40SPEAKER_00: Apotheosis of the Midwit.
- 2:29:42SPEAKER_00: He is a totally uninteresting film director to me.
- 2:29:46SPEAKER_00: For me, he is one of the least pleasant people to have to watch anything by.
- 2:29:51SPEAKER_00: I regard Interstellar, Oppenheimer.
- 2:29:54SPEAKER_00: These movies are extraordinarily superficial and deeply boring to anybody
- 2:30:01SPEAKER_00: who thinks regularly and And they're very interesting if you're 14.
- 2:30:07SPEAKER_00: And I was around 14 for things like Inception.
- 2:30:10SPEAKER_00: And of course, when I watched those things as a teenager, they hit differently.
- 2:30:14SPEAKER_00: But the fact that adults praise Christopher Nolan movies is something that I think is sad.
- 2:30:20SPEAKER_00: The fact that Film critics,
- 2:30:22SPEAKER_00: art critics,
- 2:30:23SPEAKER_00: people who are trained feel an obligation to praise
- 2:30:26SPEAKER_00: or defend Christopher Nolan movies is,
- 2:30:28SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 2:30:28SPEAKER_00: a very tragic sign of just how precarious people feel that what they've got
- 2:30:33SPEAKER_00: to praise this stuff.
- 2:30:34SPEAKER_00: You know, the classicists feel so embattled.
- 2:30:36SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:30:37SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:30:37SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:30:37SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:30:37SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:31:02SPEAKER_00: High modern 19th century translations.
- 2:31:06SPEAKER_00: But leaving aside academic gripes about it,
- 2:31:10SPEAKER_00: he is someone who has a sustained track record of blockbuster success.
- 2:31:15SPEAKER_00: And there are a few of these people who are 20th century media icon people
- 2:31:20SPEAKER_00: who can make a mint and unite broad sections of the public on the basis
- 2:31:26SPEAKER_00: of their history of work.
- 2:31:28SPEAKER_00: What I would say is that we don't make these people anymore at scale.
- 2:31:34SPEAKER_00: We're not producing new Christopher Nolans or new Madonnas or new
- 2:31:43SPEAKER_00: Michael Jackson's,
- 2:31:44SPEAKER_00: figures of that type.
- 2:31:46SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:31:46SPEAKER_00: They're becoming less and less common.
- 2:31:50SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:31:51SPEAKER_00: And I think it's just going to be harder and harder to make somebody like that.
- 2:31:54SPEAKER_00: But we still have,
- 2:31:55SPEAKER_00: because of the length of the human lifespan,
- 2:31:58SPEAKER_00: large numbers of people whose media footprints were created in the 1990s or in
- 2:32:05SPEAKER_00: the 2000s through these gigantic movies or gigantic television shows like Seinfeld.
- 2:32:12SPEAKER_00: And certain people who are associated with these things have a kind of golden ticket
- 2:32:16SPEAKER_00: from the past that will allow them to continue to fleetingly produce unity
- 2:32:22SPEAKER_00: in small ways, not in such a way that you can do anything politically with it.
- 2:32:26SPEAKER_00: But these people are going to become incredibly valuable economically
- 2:32:29SPEAKER_00: because they're literally going to die off and there's going to be a tiny number
- 2:32:33SPEAKER_00: of them at the end.
- 2:32:34SPEAKER_00: And each one of them,
- 2:32:35SPEAKER_00: if they do anything,
- 2:32:36SPEAKER_00: it's going to make an incredible amount of money, no matter how bad it is.
- 2:32:39SPEAKER_01: So, Benjamin, is the way...
- 2:32:42SPEAKER_01: To make the way open is to convince Christopher Nolan to be the Democratic nominee
- 2:32:48SPEAKER_01: for president of the United States of America.
- 2:32:51SPEAKER_00: Oh no, if he did that,
- 2:32:52SPEAKER_00: if one of these people goes and tries to transfer it into politics,
- 2:32:56SPEAKER_00: the reason that somebody like him can do this is that his movies can be watched
- 2:33:00SPEAKER_00: by both Republicans and Democrats.
- 2:33:02SPEAKER_00: Still, despite everything that's happened, both Republicans and Democrats can watch that movie.
- 2:33:07SPEAKER_00: And it's weird people on the internet who get upset But,
- 2:33:11SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:33:12SPEAKER_00: it's still the case that lots of different types of Republicans and Democrats
- 2:33:16SPEAKER_00: who are strange to each other can go and watch that movie.
- 2:33:20SPEAKER_00: That movie is so inoffensive and contentless and so full
- 2:33:23SPEAKER_00: of roller coaster theme park sounds and explosions.
- 2:33:26SPEAKER_00: It has so little substantive content that it can't possibly offend anybody.
- 2:33:30SPEAKER_00: It's because it's so deeply stupid,
- 2:33:33SPEAKER_00: but nonetheless has been shot in such a way that it seems as if it has something
- 2:33:36SPEAKER_00: to say that people are incredibly pleased to go see it all together and they feel
- 2:33:41SPEAKER_00: a tremendous sense of togetherness watching something that has no coherent message.
- 2:33:45SPEAKER_01: So you're saying he needs to run third party.
- 2:33:51SPEAKER_00: You can't politicize it.
- 2:33:53SPEAKER_00: It can't be politicized.
- 2:33:56SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 2:33:57SPEAKER_02: That leads me to,
- 2:33:58SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 2:34:00SPEAKER_02: is the Coen brothers and Oh Brother Where Art Thou,
- 2:34:04SPEAKER_02: is that a better modernization of the Odyssey than Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey?
- 2:34:11SPEAKER_00: I think there would be a strong argument for that.
- 2:34:13SPEAKER_00: I think a lot of critics and classicists would think that it is
- 2:34:19SPEAKER_00: because they would say that, yes,
- 2:34:20SPEAKER_00: it deviates,
- 2:34:21SPEAKER_00: but it deviates in a way which takes up its own times and its own context
- 2:34:24SPEAKER_00: and has something to say.
- 2:34:26SPEAKER_00: Whereas this movie doesn't have anything to say.
- 2:34:28SPEAKER_00: This movie is,
- 2:34:30SPEAKER_00: and insofar as it does have anything to say,
- 2:34:32SPEAKER_00: it's retreads of what he already said in Oppenheimer,
- 2:34:35SPEAKER_00: and he already said in Interstellar, and he already said in the Batman movies.
- 2:34:39SPEAKER_00: And really what he's been doing is Batman over and over and over again.
- 2:34:43SPEAKER_00: You are the super, you know, cool, strong guy, Batman, but oh my God, you've done bad things.
- 2:34:49SPEAKER_00: And now, you know, you have to live with the things that you've done already.
- 2:34:53SPEAKER_00: Oh, Batman, how will you ever go on?
- 2:34:58SPEAKER_02: I did like Memento and The Prestige.
- 2:35:04SPEAKER_01: Yeah, what about The Prestige?
- 2:35:05SPEAKER_01: Can you go for that?
- 2:35:06SPEAKER_01: That's the one, everybody.
- 2:35:08SPEAKER_00: If you saw it long enough ago as a young enough person, then you'll think it's good.
- 2:35:12SPEAKER_00: If you go back and watch any of his movies now, you're not going to find that they hold up.
- 2:35:16SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:35:17SPEAKER_00: If you are someone who has thought about any of the issues that are raised in any
- 2:35:21SPEAKER_00: of these movies,
- 2:35:22SPEAKER_00: if you haven't thought about any of this stuff before, and everybody is 14 once.
- 2:35:26SPEAKER_00: When you're 14,
- 2:35:28SPEAKER_00: there's a whole set of things you can love that are terrible, but you can love them.
- 2:35:32SPEAKER_00: And if you fall in love with something when you're 14, you're going to defend it when you're 35.
- 2:35:36SPEAKER_00: And even as we've found out when you're 55 or 65 in many cases.
- 2:35:41SPEAKER_00: So there's always a new set of 14 year olds for something like that.
- 2:35:47SPEAKER_01: So you're saying Interstellar is a better movie than 2001 A Space Odyssey.
- 2:35:51SPEAKER_01: Oh, God.
- 2:35:53SPEAKER_00: Oh, my goodness.
- 2:35:55SPEAKER_00: Interstellar was the last one that I could even sit through.
- 2:36:04SPEAKER_00: And by the time I got to the end of it,
- 2:36:06SPEAKER_00: I was just so, why is he doing all of this stupid stuff again?
- 2:36:10SPEAKER_00: Why does he not grow up or learn anything or become more interesting over time?
- 2:36:15SPEAKER_00: What is wrong with this guy?
- 2:36:17SPEAKER_00: The thing is,
- 2:36:17SPEAKER_00: if he did grow up and become more interesting,
- 2:36:20SPEAKER_00: he would no longer be able to be Christopher Nolan.
- 2:36:22SPEAKER_00: These movies wouldn't make money anymore in the way that they do.
- 2:36:24SPEAKER_01: All right, I guess, spoiler alert, I guess.
- 2:36:29SPEAKER_01: But, okay, um...
- 2:36:32SPEAKER_01: If the future humans,
- 2:36:33SPEAKER_01: the transhumanist humans,
- 2:36:36SPEAKER_01: want to help the current humans,
- 2:36:40SPEAKER_01: and they can build this elaborate time,
- 2:36:43SPEAKER_01: you know, space thing that he can enter, Tesseract, whatever.
- 2:36:53SPEAKER_01: They can't find a more efficient way to do this without him going into
- 2:36:56SPEAKER_01: a black hole like
- 2:36:57SPEAKER_02: I'll tell you what happened.
- 2:36:59SPEAKER_02: He watched Contact and he was just trying to impress Jodie Foster.
- 2:37:04SPEAKER_01: Well, they didn't send a poet again.
- 2:37:06SPEAKER_01: So, you know, fail.
- 2:37:12SPEAKER_01: So, I don't know.
- 2:37:13SPEAKER_01: I just always,
- 2:37:15SPEAKER_01: I'm like,
- 2:37:16SPEAKER_01: they couldn't,
- 2:37:18SPEAKER_01: these super genius humans in the future couldn't find a better way to transmit this
- 2:37:25SPEAKER_01: to him than this.
- 2:37:27SPEAKER_00: He goes to all this trouble to make it seem like it's going to be
- 2:37:31SPEAKER_00: a science movie like The Martian.
- 2:37:33SPEAKER_00: And then it ends with a freaking time loop,
- 2:37:35SPEAKER_00: the most superficial, uninteresting sci-fi trope anybody's ever.
- 2:37:42SPEAKER_00: Something that was more interestingly handled with Marty McFly.
- 2:37:49SPEAKER_00: And Terminator.
- 2:37:50SPEAKER_00: Magic.
- 2:37:51SPEAKER_00: Well, of course, and Terminator, the most overdone retread time travel trope.
- 2:37:58SPEAKER_01: Benjamin, I didn't know we were going to get your epic takedown of Nolan.
- 2:38:02SPEAKER_01: This was the treat of the whole discussion.
- 2:38:05SPEAKER_00: All you had to do was ask me about it.
- 2:38:07SPEAKER_00: But yeah, Nolan and Spielberg are, I think, the two worst hacks in American cinema.
- 2:38:16SPEAKER_00: There are many other blackbuster filmmakers that I would offer qualified defenses of.
- 2:38:21SPEAKER_00: But Spielberg's movies are just terrible.
- 2:38:25SPEAKER_00: The recent one where... Disclosure Day.
- 2:38:28SPEAKER_00: Yeah, Disclosure Day.
- 2:38:29SPEAKER_00: Oh, you reveal the truth and then everybody gets good and,
- 2:38:32SPEAKER_00: you know, all comes together on the basis of the truth having been revealed.
- 2:38:37SPEAKER_00: What a broken old man he is to have that kind of theme in a movie in 2026.
- 2:38:44SPEAKER_02: I had an idea and I did not watch the Disclosure Day yet.
- 2:38:51SPEAKER_02: I have.
- 2:38:52SPEAKER_02: For legal purposes,
- 2:38:55SPEAKER_02: I did not watch it on a streaming website where somebody recorded it with
- 2:39:00SPEAKER_02: a camcorder in a theater.
- 2:39:02SPEAKER_02: I did not.
- 2:39:04SPEAKER_02: The other day I sat down and I was working.
- 2:39:07SPEAKER_02: So I had it on the other monitor.
- 2:39:10SPEAKER_02: And yes, it was a crappy low quality recording of the movie in the theater.
- 2:39:14SPEAKER_02: And I watched the first probably half of it and I didn't finish it.
- 2:39:17SPEAKER_02: And I'm sure I'll finish it at some point.
- 2:39:19SPEAKER_02: And I only half watched it.
- 2:39:22SPEAKER_02: Caveats provisos aside,
- 2:39:25SPEAKER_02: my initial thought with the movie opening at a professional wrestling match,
- 2:39:32SPEAKER_02: I thought, oh,
- 2:39:34SPEAKER_02: I wonder if this is Steven Spielberg telling us that it's all fake
- 2:39:38SPEAKER_02: and it's all kayfabe and he's making a movie because people are all excited
- 2:39:42SPEAKER_02: about Disclosure Day and it's a huge political thing and it fascinates me
- 2:39:45SPEAKER_02: and I actually think it's really important
- 2:39:47SPEAKER_02: and I think it goes right along I think it's ideology.
- 2:39:52SPEAKER_02: I think it's distracting people from things that are really going on.
- 2:39:55SPEAKER_02: And the aliens are part of this attempt to naturalize the human.
- 2:40:00SPEAKER_02: And, oh, we can't have God and Jesus because we're living here in the postmodern future.
- 2:40:05SPEAKER_02: So we'll have space Jesus.
- 2:40:06SPEAKER_02: We'll have alien Jesus and it'll be okay.
- 2:40:09SPEAKER_02: All that stuff.
- 2:40:10SPEAKER_02: But there's tons of people who think Disclosure Day is brilliant.
- 2:40:14SPEAKER_02: Blah, blah, blah.
- 2:40:15SPEAKER_02: And I thought, well,
- 2:40:16SPEAKER_02: wouldn't it be cool if Spielberg was starting his movie with kayfabe
- 2:40:23SPEAKER_02: to tell everybody watching it, like, you're stupid if you believe this.
- 2:40:27SPEAKER_02: Now, do I think that's what Spielberg was doing?
- 2:40:30SPEAKER_02: Do I think he has this self-awareness?
- 2:40:33SPEAKER_02: I don't think so.
- 2:40:34SPEAKER_02: But I thought it...
- 2:40:36SPEAKER_02: Maybe I would start a movie if I wanted to kind of feed the flames and make a bunch of money.
- 2:40:43SPEAKER_02: I might start the movie off with obvious spectacle that's built on a lie.
- 2:40:49SPEAKER_02: Kayfabe is,
- 2:40:49SPEAKER_02: like everybody knows,
- 2:40:51SPEAKER_02: professional wrestling is fake, and that's why people love it so much.
- 2:40:54SPEAKER_02: That's why it's so important to so many people, because we're part of the production.
- 2:41:00SPEAKER_02: Professional wrestling is the successful postmodern American form of art.
- 2:41:05SPEAKER_02: It allows the consumer to be an active producer right along with the performers themselves.
- 2:41:12SPEAKER_02: I don't think that's what Spielberg was doing.
- 2:41:14SPEAKER_02: I think it would be cool if he was.
- 2:41:17SPEAKER_00: We ended up with this reheated Watergate sewage.
- 2:41:20SPEAKER_00: The media will report the truth on television, of all things.
- 2:41:26SPEAKER_00: And then everyone will see the image on the TV and go, well, I guess that's the way that it is.
- 2:41:31SPEAKER_00: So we all have to do the thing now.
- 2:41:36SPEAKER_00: What a brain dead brain, you know, totally.
- 2:41:39SPEAKER_00: It's one thing to have a narrative like that in 1975.
- 2:41:43SPEAKER_00: It's another thing to do that now.
- 2:41:45SPEAKER_00: It's really something to still be doing that in the 2020s.
- 2:41:49SPEAKER_00: But because he's Steven Spielberg,
- 2:41:51SPEAKER_00: not only can he do that,
- 2:41:52SPEAKER_00: it's a huge commercial success because it's Steven Spielberg.
- 2:41:55SPEAKER_01: I mean, look,
- 2:41:57SPEAKER_01: in all honesty,
- 2:41:58SPEAKER_01: Nance and I,
- 2:41:59SPEAKER_01: we've kind of made this argument like
- 2:42:01SPEAKER_01: the last Spielberg movie is actually Jurassic Park.
- 2:42:04SPEAKER_01: That's the last time that either of us,
- 2:42:07SPEAKER_01: you know, because I grew up with those movies, Benjamin, like the E.T.
- 2:42:11SPEAKER_01: and the Raiders of the Lost Ark and Jaws and all that.
- 2:42:15SPEAKER_01: Like, it's just my childhood.
- 2:42:16SPEAKER_01: So I have this connection to them.
- 2:42:18SPEAKER_01: The last time I felt like he pulled off anything like that,
- 2:42:21SPEAKER_01: it was Jurassic Park and everything since has been some faded version of himself.
- 2:42:29SPEAKER_01: But I almost want to agree with Zizek here.
- 2:42:33SPEAKER_01: As an adult,
- 2:42:35SPEAKER_01: I would maybe want to argue the greatest movie ever made was actually The Duel,
- 2:42:39SPEAKER_01: his first one.
- 2:42:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:42:41SPEAKER_01: Oh, really?
- 2:42:42SPEAKER_01: I think if you have never seen The Duel,
- 2:42:44SPEAKER_01: it is so weird to watch this movie and knowing what you know about Spielberg.
- 2:42:51SPEAKER_01: I really think if there's one Spielberg movie that I could see you really liking,
- 2:42:55SPEAKER_01: it would be his first one.
- 2:42:57SPEAKER_01: Because Zizek even says, after The Duel, it's all downhill.
- 2:43:02SPEAKER_00: I have not seen The Duel.
- 2:43:04SPEAKER_00: I will have to give it a chance purely on the basis of your recommendation.
- 2:43:07SPEAKER_00: And even though I hold most of his corpus in absolute contempt.
- 2:43:11SPEAKER_01: Okay, well, if you hate it, then feel free to blame me.
- 2:43:15SPEAKER_01: But I do think this one will hit different than the other ones.
- 2:43:20SPEAKER_01: I appreciate that.
- 2:43:21SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:43:25SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think it's excellent.
- 2:43:28SPEAKER_02: I also don't like Christopher Nolan movies, so I think it's great.
- 2:43:32SPEAKER_02: I think it's wonderful that we...
- 2:43:33SPEAKER_02: We went there in the end.
- 2:43:36SPEAKER_02: But I don't know.
- 2:43:37SPEAKER_02: I guess to put a button on this conversation is...
- 2:43:46SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 2:43:46SPEAKER_02: because we talked about movies,
- 2:43:48SPEAKER_02: we talked about this, and that kind of came out of a culture war conversation.
- 2:43:51SPEAKER_02: I do feel like it's all kind of a natural progression or digression from
- 2:43:58SPEAKER_02: the question of politics.
- 2:44:02SPEAKER_02: And maybe that's because politics don't work anymore or what we think of
- 2:44:07SPEAKER_02: as politics is in fact not political.
- 2:44:11SPEAKER_02: And...
- 2:44:15SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 2:44:16SPEAKER_02: We need to take back politics from non-political issues.
- 2:44:25SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 2:44:27SPEAKER_02: But populism seems like the right is kind of fracturing and falling apart.
- 2:44:34SPEAKER_02: It's apparent that the left has always been fractured and always fell apart.
- 2:44:37SPEAKER_02: And in fact, it fell apart before it could ever even kind of come together.
- 2:44:42SPEAKER_02: But it's also always been that way all along under modernity.
- 2:44:46SPEAKER_02: Like the world we live in today,
- 2:44:47SPEAKER_02: it's a mistake to transhistoricize and kind of think we're part of grand projects
- 2:44:51SPEAKER_02: and we belong to grand historical ideas and this and that.
- 2:44:59SPEAKER_02: And...
- 2:45:06SPEAKER_02: It's right to despair in the face of politics.
- 2:45:08SPEAKER_02: It's right to worry.
- 2:45:09SPEAKER_02: It's right to wonder if the world is falling apart.
- 2:45:13SPEAKER_02: But that's not an excuse to not sit back,
- 2:45:16SPEAKER_02: sit idly by,
- 2:45:16SPEAKER_02: become a nihilist,
- 2:45:17SPEAKER_02: or take up positions of anti-humanism and Gnosticism and all this stuff.
- 2:45:25SPEAKER_02: And at the end of the day,
- 2:45:26SPEAKER_02: find yourself being able to take up A position of courage in the face
- 2:45:32SPEAKER_02: of hopelessness or something like that.
- 2:45:34SPEAKER_02: Or if all of that is just kind of spaghetti thrown at the wall,
- 2:45:38SPEAKER_02: at least that's what I take from it.
- 2:45:40SPEAKER_02: And I don't know, again,
- 2:45:42SPEAKER_02: Benjamin,
- 2:45:42SPEAKER_02: every time I think of something political or I'm paying attention to influencers on
- 2:45:49SPEAKER_02: the internet who present themselves as political figures
- 2:45:53SPEAKER_02: and I feel like I might be falling for it or whatever, I do think of you and...
- 2:46:00SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I don't know.
- 2:46:00SPEAKER_02: It feels insane.
- 2:46:02SPEAKER_02: I feel insane when I think about politics and when I allow myself to become immersed
- 2:46:08SPEAKER_02: in the world of political influencers and stuff like that.
- 2:46:11SPEAKER_02: And it does help to restore some sanity when we're able to just kind of,
- 2:46:16SPEAKER_02: I don't know, spitball ideas and talk about this stuff with each other.
- 2:46:20SPEAKER_02: So I appreciate it.
- 2:46:22SPEAKER_00: I appreciate that.
- 2:46:23SPEAKER_00: Me too.
- 2:46:25SPEAKER_00: It's great to come out and talk about this stuff.
- 2:46:27SPEAKER_00: You know, I started doing the films podcast, The Lack, after 2020 and the failure of politics.
- 2:46:34SPEAKER_00: And for me, the thing that we're lacking is the political.
- 2:46:37SPEAKER_00: That's at the core of that.
- 2:46:40SPEAKER_00: And so everybody starts making cultural content when it's obvious that the political is lacking.
- 2:46:46SPEAKER_00: But what do they do?
- 2:46:47SPEAKER_00: They pretend that the cultural content is political content.
- 2:46:51SPEAKER_00: And so when we made The Lack,
- 2:46:53SPEAKER_00: part of my idea was how would you make an actual cultural show that deals with that?
- 2:46:59SPEAKER_00: And for me, it would be to talk about how films are symptomatic of the absence of politics.
- 2:47:06SPEAKER_00: What it is about films that show what we can't do and what's missing at that level.
- 2:47:12SPEAKER_01: As a regular listener to The Lack, just float the idea.
- 2:47:19SPEAKER_01: Maybe you and Nina...
- 2:47:20SPEAKER_01: Discuss the duel.
- 2:47:22SPEAKER_01: That would be.
- 2:47:23SPEAKER_00: I definitely have put it in my mental bank of things to do on the lack.
- 2:47:30SPEAKER_00: I will not watch the duel and not talk about it on the lack.
- 2:47:33SPEAKER_00: If I watch it, then we'll talk about it.
- 2:47:35SPEAKER_01: Fantastic.
- 2:47:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that one.
- 2:47:42SPEAKER_01: I think you two would have a lot to say about that.
- 2:47:47SPEAKER_02: I think, dear listeners out there in TV land, thanks for spending your time here with us.
- 2:47:55SPEAKER_02: We'll go ahead and get out of your hair.
- 2:47:58SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 2:47:59SPEAKER_02: Do we have any suggestions or any comments,
- 2:48:03SPEAKER_02: any parting words we'd like to leave the folks at home with?
- 2:48:10SPEAKER_01: To this day, you can just still not eat the yellow snow.
- 2:48:16SPEAKER_01: I think that's safe to still recommend.
- 2:48:21SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:48:22SPEAKER_01: If there's one trans-historical truth, don't eat
- 2:48:28SPEAKER_00: yellow snow.
- 2:48:29SPEAKER_00: It's not that common sense is completely gone,
- 2:48:32SPEAKER_00: it's that it's just become a lot thinner, and it won't support a lot of weight.
- 2:48:37SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:48:39SPEAKER_00: And on that note,
- 2:48:41SPEAKER_02: internet, we will see you on the next one.
- 2:48:44SPEAKER_02: Thanks for spending your time here with us.
- 2:48:52SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 2:48:54SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 2:48:58SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 2:49:00SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 2:49:04SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 2:49:20SPEAKER_03: I said it before, and I'll say it again.
- 2:49:22SPEAKER_03: Life is pretty bad.
- 2:49:23SPEAKER_03: If you don't stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it.
- 2:49:27SPEAKER_03: If you don't have your laugh, it means you call it probably.
- 2:49:33SPEAKER_03: That's it.
- 2:49:33SPEAKER_03: In other words, it's not enough to
- 2:49:42just be good.
- 2:49:43I'm going to play with that question about the free laugh.
- 2:50:13SPEAKER_02: Are you tired of living in today's apocalyptic dystopian hellscape?
- 2:50:24SPEAKER_02: Well, if you are, you're in luck.
- 2:50:27SPEAKER_02: Go to worsehelp.co to get all the tasty little tips and tricks you need to survive.
- 2:50:37SPEAKER_02: So go to worsehelp.co and check it out.
- 2:50:38SPEAKER_02: Now, if you hear me make the assertion that we're living in an apocalyptic world,
- 2:50:56SPEAKER_02: I think it's true.
- 2:51:03SPEAKER_02: The world is, you know, fairly dystopian.
- 2:51:05SPEAKER_02: Fair point.
- 2:51:06SPEAKER_02: But I don't think it's apocalyptic.
- 2:51:08SPEAKER_02: And I don't think it's a hellscape.
- 2:51:10SPEAKER_02: I'm of the impression that we should,
- 2:51:12SPEAKER_02: you know, allow ourselves to be, if not optimists, then at the very least, realists.
- 2:51:17SPEAKER_02: And we should allow ourselves to see the silver lining of Well,
- 2:51:21SPEAKER_02: if that's you,
- 2:51:21SPEAKER_02: dear reader, I say to you, my response to that is puppycock, balderdash.
- 2:51:24SPEAKER_02: Your so-called realism is, in my opinion, ideology.
- 2:51:26SPEAKER_02: And this, you know, optimism, doubly so.
- 2:51:49SPEAKER_02: I think when we do this thing, when we take this move of saying, well, it's not great.
- 2:51:55SPEAKER_02: However, it could be worse.
- 2:51:57SPEAKER_02: I think we're failing ourselves.
- 2:51:59SPEAKER_02: I think that's bad faith.
- 2:52:00SPEAKER_02: Now, I'm guilty of it all the time.
- 2:52:01SPEAKER_02: In fact, that's one of my mantras.
- 2:52:04SPEAKER_02: And life is, you know, it can always be worse.
- 2:52:07SPEAKER_02: I say it all the fucking time.
- 2:52:09SPEAKER_02: I've probably said it a dozen times in the last fucking week talking to people about things.
- 2:52:14SPEAKER_02: Well, it could be worse.
- 2:52:15SPEAKER_02: It could be worse.
- 2:52:16SPEAKER_02: And I think that's nonsense because it's true.
- 2:52:19SPEAKER_02: It can be worse.
- 2:52:22SPEAKER_02: It's also true that there's no good reason things aren't better for every single one
- 2:52:27SPEAKER_02: of us on this planet.
- 2:52:30SPEAKER_02: We have trillions of dollars dedicated to things.
- 2:52:34SPEAKER_02: That are, you know, pretty much at the end of the day only making our lives worse.
- 2:52:41SPEAKER_02: And we're just kind of caught up in it all.
- 2:52:43SPEAKER_02: And all we can do is trick ourselves into this, you know, skin of our teeth fucking mindset.
- 2:52:47SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 2:52:47SPEAKER_02: if you have enough stick-to-itiveness,
- 2:52:49SPEAKER_02: if you use enough elbow grease,
- 2:52:51SPEAKER_02: if you fucking lace your boots up and fucking lotty-dotty-whoop-de-whoop
- 2:52:54SPEAKER_02: and all this stuff, you'll be all right.
- 2:52:57SPEAKER_02: And that's bullshit.
- 2:52:58SPEAKER_02: You know, we're being seduced by this ideological position of it could be worse.
- 2:53:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:53:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah, sure, it could be worse.
- 2:53:10SPEAKER_02: However, once again, there's no fucking good reason that it isn't better.
- 2:53:15SPEAKER_02: I believe the only way to properly have courage and have hope and bravely march in
- 2:53:25SPEAKER_02: to the dark night of the future,
- 2:53:28SPEAKER_02: the long night of And I think that is the only way to arrive at a position
- 2:53:33SPEAKER_02: of true hopefulness.
- 2:53:34SPEAKER_02: Now, why do I think this?
- 2:53:35SPEAKER_02: I think this, again, because we're living in a world...
- 2:53:48SPEAKER_02: That is conditioned and determined by economics, by exchange.
- 2:53:51SPEAKER_02: Not by the dignity of life.
- 2:53:53SPEAKER_02: Not by love.
- 2:53:55SPEAKER_02: Not by humanness, subjectivity, curiosity, exploration, merit.
- 2:54:01SPEAKER_02: Any of these things.
- 2:54:03SPEAKER_02: None of these wonderful things that would be better organizing principles for
- 2:54:07SPEAKER_02: the world we live in today.
- 2:54:08SPEAKER_02: We're not living in that world.
- 2:54:10SPEAKER_02: We're living in this world that reduces to exchange value.
- 2:54:14SPEAKER_02: And I think we need to see that.
- 2:54:17SPEAKER_02: In the worst light.
- 2:54:20SPEAKER_02: And from there, we can take up a position of courage and hope.
- 2:54:23SPEAKER_02: And I think that's the only way to do it.
- 2:54:24SPEAKER_02: So don't come at me with that fucking, oh, I'm a realist nonsense.
- 2:54:28SPEAKER_02: Because I think if you take up this position of I'm a realist,
- 2:54:31SPEAKER_02: you have fallen for the oldest trick in the book, dear friends.
- 2:54:35SPEAKER_02: And it's okay.
- 2:54:36SPEAKER_02: Because like I said, I'm guilty of it.
- 2:54:38SPEAKER_02: I do it all the time.
- 2:54:39SPEAKER_02: I'm constantly checking myself.
- 2:54:40SPEAKER_02: Because I don't want to have...
- 2:54:43SPEAKER_02: I don't want to put people off.
- 2:54:46SPEAKER_02: I don't want to approach the world and treat it like a self-fulfilling prophecy
- 2:54:51SPEAKER_02: of failure and badness and all this stuff.
- 2:54:54SPEAKER_02: That's not what I'm saying when I'm saying take up the pessimistic position.
- 2:54:58SPEAKER_02: I think the pessimistic position is allowing things to be what they are,
- 2:55:03SPEAKER_02: allowing things to be the worst version of themselves
- 2:55:06SPEAKER_02: and understanding no one is coming to save us.
- 2:55:11SPEAKER_02: If you want something worth having, you have to fight for it.
- 2:55:16SPEAKER_02: You have to work for it.
- 2:55:18SPEAKER_02: You have to do all the hard stuff.
- 2:55:22SPEAKER_02: And then from there, you can realize, oh, the human is worth it all.
- 2:55:27SPEAKER_02: So we do have to do all the hard work.
- 2:55:28SPEAKER_02: And no one's going to swoop in.
- 2:55:30SPEAKER_02: There's no deus ex machina.
- 2:55:32SPEAKER_02: There's nothing.
- 2:55:33SPEAKER_02: There's no plot devices to come in and save us at the last moment.
- 2:55:38SPEAKER_02: It is up to us.
- 2:55:38SPEAKER_02: And we are very likely to fail.
- 2:55:41SPEAKER_02: Nevertheless, pressing on is the courageous, hopeful thing to do.
- 2:55:46SPEAKER_02: And I think you can only arrive at that by way of pessimism.
- 2:55:50SPEAKER_02: So I, you know,
- 2:55:51SPEAKER_02: I find myself falling for the easy way out and taking the ideological route of,
- 2:55:57SPEAKER_02: yeah, it's not great, but it can always be worse.
- 2:56:00SPEAKER_02: It's true.
- 2:56:01SPEAKER_02: It can always be worse.
- 2:56:02SPEAKER_02: But that's a me problem.
- 2:56:03SPEAKER_02: You know what I'm saying?
- 2:56:04SPEAKER_02: If I'm out here doing this, oh, it could be worse.
- 2:56:07SPEAKER_02: It could be worse.
- 2:56:07SPEAKER_02: It could be worse.
- 2:56:08SPEAKER_02: And I'm putting that on other people.
- 2:56:11SPEAKER_02: That's bullshit.
- 2:56:12SPEAKER_02: That's a me problem.
- 2:56:13SPEAKER_02: You know what I'm saying?
- 2:56:14SPEAKER_02: The fact that there's no good reason that it can't be better, that's an us problem.
- 2:56:20SPEAKER_02: So I guess that's it.
- 2:56:22SPEAKER_02: And if you're not convinced by this,
- 2:56:25SPEAKER_02: then again, go to where'shelp.co, check out what's available there.
- 2:56:30SPEAKER_02: You know, you can even engage a little bit and do all the cool stuff.
- 2:56:35SPEAKER_02: So...
- 2:56:36SPEAKER_02: If you're a pessimist like me, go to worsehelp.co and we'll laugh about the end of the world.
- 2:56:41SPEAKER_02: We'll fucking toast to each other as this city burns down.
- 2:56:45SPEAKER_01: And if you're not convinced by my pessimism, well, go to worsehelp.co and check it
- 2:56:49SPEAKER_02: out.
- 2:56:50SPEAKER_02: And, you know, maybe you'll engage with the ideas and see where I'm coming from.
- 2:56:56SPEAKER_02: Or maybe not.
- 2:56:56SPEAKER_02: Maybe you'll have a convincing argument.
- 2:56:58SPEAKER_02: Maybe you'll show me where I have erred.
- 2:57:02SPEAKER_02: And that's fucking all good too.
- 2:57:04SPEAKER_02: So fucking whoopty whoop.
- 2:57:06SPEAKER_02: All that good shit.
- 2:57:08SPEAKER_02: Check it out.
- 2:57:09SPEAKER_02: Now back to our regularly scheduled programming.
- 2:57:15SPEAKER_02: This product is a paid advertisement for rules and conditions applied.
- 2:57:19SPEAKER_02: Do not take it if you're pregnant.
- 2:57:20SPEAKER_02: Do not fucking do all that other stuff.
- 2:57:22SPEAKER_02: Don't operate heavy machinery.
- 2:57:24SPEAKER_02: Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 2:57:25SPEAKER_02: Suicidal ideations may apply.
- 2:57:26SPEAKER_02: Bloody diarrhea and so on and so forth.
- 2:57:28SPEAKER_02: Fuck you.
- 2:57:29SPEAKER_02: Goodbye.
- 2:57:29SPEAKER_02: Good night.