Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Space Disputes: Litigating in the New Space Economy
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Space Disputes, Litigating in the New Space Economy.
- 0:11I'm Ola Policastro, Director of Education and
- 0:13Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:15Association. And today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speaker, MC Sangaila. MC is a partner at
- 0:22the Complex Appellate Litigation Group, where
- 0:25she has briefed over or argued more than 170
- 0:28appeals spanning complex and cutting edge issues
- 0:31across a range of practice areas. She has handled
- 0:34matters before the U .S. Supreme Court, multiple
- 0:36state supreme courts, and numerous federal and
- 0:39state appellate courts, and the Inter -American
- 0:41Court of Human Rights. She teaches space law
- 0:44and policy at LMU Loyola Law School in Los Angeles
- 0:47and is a frequent author and speaker on topics
- 0:50related to space law. She also co -hosts the
- 0:53Cosmic Council podcast. She is an LLM candidate
- 0:56at the University of Mississippi Center for Air
- 0:59and Space Law, where she serves as consulting
- 1:02editor to the century -old Journal of Space Law
- 1:05and coaches the school's Manfred Lack Space Law
- 1:08Mood Court Team. We're so excited to hear what
- 1:11she has to share with us on this topic, so I'm
- 1:13now going to turn it over to her. Great. Thank
- 1:16you so much. Thanks for the introduction and
- 1:18thanks to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 1:21being repeatedly interested in sharing developments
- 1:25in space law with all of your members and those
- 1:29who join the webinars. So the last time I was
- 1:35presenting on space law and policy for Beverly
- 1:37Hills Bar. I was really focusing just on Space
- 1:40Law 101, sort of an overview of international
- 1:45and national laws relating to space and where
- 1:49some of the open and undecided issues are in
- 1:52that regard. And today I'm doing something a
- 1:55little bit different. Most of the work in space
- 1:59law has been revolving around policy and regulations
- 2:02and those who work in government and those who
- 2:07advise companies with regard to regulatory matters.
- 2:13But just like activities in space, space law
- 2:17itself is growing and going into areas where
- 2:22folks may not have thought they would have gone
- 2:23before. So. Space disputes and litigation and
- 2:29past questions that have gone to litigation,
- 2:32including arbitration, as well as potential future
- 2:35areas for dispute is the focus of the program
- 2:39today. So I'll do a little bit of an intro into
- 2:45international law so that there's a foundational
- 2:47understanding for those who did not participate
- 2:51in the Space Law 101 webinar. And then I'm going
- 2:54to get into sort of certain categories of disputes
- 2:57that have happened previously. I would say in
- 2:59the original space race era, and then moving
- 3:03into the new space economy era, what kinds of
- 3:06disputes we've had there and what kinds of disputes
- 3:08we can expect to continue to see or new ones
- 3:12that we might see as well. So next slide please.
- 3:20So previously, space activity was really Really
- 3:25limited to a few prime contractors doing work
- 3:29specifically for in the United States, at least
- 3:33the United States government, according to their
- 3:36specifications. And prior to that, even prior
- 3:41to that. It's really been on the international
- 3:45level really a state centric activity. It's very
- 3:48expensive to go to space, it's very expensive
- 3:50to build rockets, and even until recently expensive
- 3:55to build satellites. And so it really was a state
- 3:59-centric system, a state -centric governance
- 4:02system, a state -centric sort of power system
- 4:07within the building and use of space objects.
- 4:13But now we're evolving from purely Really significantly
- 4:17government run to a private sector driven ecosystem.
- 4:21That's as a result of various policies of the
- 4:24federal government to seek innovation through
- 4:28the private commercial system. And really encouraging
- 4:33that now most recently through US policy, both
- 4:38in the military Department of War, as well as
- 4:42in the civil space arena to some. concern and
- 4:47debate, but nonetheless, that's what's going
- 4:50on. So the commercial, the rise of the new commercial
- 4:52sector is beginning. And similarly, dispute resolution
- 5:00is evolving. So when you have states that are
- 5:04largely involved in activities, those states
- 5:06are going to want and be subject to different
- 5:10kinds of jurisdiction and different kinds of
- 5:12dispute mechanisms. really largely by treaty
- 5:16encouraged to be done through diplomatic methods.
- 5:20Although as I'll talk about, there's one claims
- 5:22commission that's set up under international
- 5:24space law, but largely trying to resolve disputes
- 5:29state to state and through diplomatic mediation
- 5:34or negotiation and then proceeding to arbitration
- 5:39or other claims within the treaty system. relatively
- 5:45slowly, trying not to escalate to the point of
- 5:47actual disputes. But as more and more actors
- 5:51have come into the realm, as more and more questions
- 5:55have come up domestically in terms of bid protests
- 5:59or other challenges by companies to government
- 6:04action, there's been really an increasing reliance
- 6:06on the judicial system. And then increasing reliance
- 6:10also on binding commercial arbitration set up
- 6:14by contract, both domestically and internationally.
- 6:19So these are sort of the larger trends and movements
- 6:23within space commerce generally, and then sort
- 6:27of how those will kind of frame the big picture
- 6:31of some of the things we'll be talking about.
- 6:34So next slide, please. So I mentioned foundational
- 6:39legal frameworks. These are the foundational
- 6:42frameworks of how the governments of the world
- 6:47have agreed we will operate in space for peaceful
- 6:51purposes, is largely the most famous term from
- 6:56the Outer Space Treaty. So these are still, these
- 7:00treaties remain relevant both for historically
- 7:03understanding you know, what the rules of the
- 7:08road were anticipated to be for space activities,
- 7:11what they remain because these treaties remain
- 7:13in effect, and then how they interact with domestic
- 7:16law because particularly for private actors,
- 7:21the Outer Space Treaty has Article 6, which specifically
- 7:26says that governments are responsible for the
- 7:31conduct of their private actors in space. And
- 7:35therefore those activities need to be authorized
- 7:39and supervised by the national government, either
- 7:42for the launching state or other licensing that
- 7:46the country might be doing. And so those countries
- 7:50are still on the hook, shall we say, for the
- 7:54activities of private companies. they cannot
- 7:57say, hey, it wasn't us, it was some company,
- 8:00and we have no responsibility or liability to
- 8:04others or to other governments. So these are
- 8:07important because this is the backdrop against
- 8:08which national law and regulations are built
- 8:12as a direct result of Article 6 of the Outer
- 8:15Space Treaty, but also it kind of tells you these
- 8:18are some of the norms and especially international
- 8:22norms because the Outer Space Treaty has a well
- 8:25over 100 Signatory countries, so it really is
- 8:29a widely accepted. So I want to talk about the
- 8:32outer space treaty first from 1967. It it arose
- 8:37from a concerns about the US and Russia escalating
- 8:44their conflict with each other. They were really
- 8:46the primary spacefaring states at that time.
- 8:49And there was a concern that perhaps they might
- 8:52put weapons of mass destruction or nuclear weapons
- 8:54into orbit. And there was a deep desire to prevent
- 8:59that from happening. And so that immediate concern
- 9:02of escalating disputes and geopolitical conflict
- 9:06between the US and Russia led to a very quick
- 9:09agreement for the outer space treaty, which does
- 9:13include a provision about nuclear weapons or
- 9:17weapons of mass destruction not being put in
- 9:21orbit or in space. But it also includes a lot
- 9:26of other really, we hope, aspirational principles,
- 9:31which we hope to achieve. So one is a freedom
- 9:35of exploration and use of outer space, including
- 9:38the moon and other celestial bodies. So the treaty
- 9:43says that those shall be freely explored and
- 9:45used, particularly for scientific purposes without
- 9:48discrimination. and with free access to all areas
- 9:52of celestial bodies. And also that exploration
- 9:56and use of space shall be carried out for peaceful
- 10:01uses for the benefit of all countries, and the
- 10:05use and exploration of space shall be the province
- 10:07of all mankind. So that's a very lovely, aspirational
- 10:11statement. There's certainly some questions between
- 10:15how that works now when there will be bases on
- 10:19the moon and there will be, you know, particular
- 10:23more areas will say than in the past that folks
- 10:27might not want people others to be able to just.
- 10:32Traverse, you know, very easily it also raises
- 10:36questions with regard to private privately built
- 10:39infrastructure on the moon. So also another important
- 10:43principle is that countries cannot claim ownership
- 10:46of outer space. There is no national appropriation
- 10:51by claim of sovereignty, use, or occupation.
- 10:55But this also means that activities in space
- 11:00are beyond the jurisdiction of national courts,
- 11:04with perhaps I would say the exception of space
- 11:06objects, which remain the property and obligation
- 11:13of the launching state to maintain. Other international
- 11:19laws also are incorporated into the Outer Space
- 11:21Treaty. Also, as I mentioned, no weapons of mass
- 11:25destruction and peaceful use of outer space.
- 11:28There's also an astronaut assistance provision
- 11:30that state parties are required to regard astronauts
- 11:34as envoys of mankind and provide them with all
- 11:37possible assistance if they come into distress.
- 11:40Also, From the US Russia. Heritage also if they
- 11:47land if they happen to inappropriately land in
- 11:50somebody else's country, it clearly says that
- 11:53they are required to be brought back to their
- 11:55country of origin and not taken away and harmed
- 12:00in any way. So there's that there's also state
- 12:04responsibility as I mentioned for national activities
- 12:07and for non governmental actors. There's also
- 12:10state liability. A launching state or one that
- 12:14procures the launching of an object into outer
- 12:16space also has liability. And also important
- 12:23principles have to do with due regard. So Article
- 12:269 of the Outer Space Treaty says, in the exploration
- 12:29and use of outer space, state parties shall be
- 12:32guided by the principle of cooperation and mutual
- 12:34assistance and shall conduct all their activities
- 12:37with due regard to the corresponding interests
- 12:40of all other state parties to the treaty, they
- 12:44must also avoid harmful contamination. So you
- 12:47can see all of this general principles of the
- 12:50treaty, really, the Magna Carta or Constitution
- 12:53of Space, setting these very broad aspirational
- 12:58humans at their best parameters for how folks
- 13:03should be expected to act in space. And then,
- 13:08There are other treaties like the rescue and
- 13:10return agreement, a registration convention,
- 13:13which calls for registering space objects. It's
- 13:17important for people to be able to know where
- 13:20a particular object, who it's tied to, because
- 13:24that country continues to have responsibility
- 13:26for it. But it also allows for transparency and
- 13:29communication as more and more objects go into
- 13:32space that you know exactly where and who to
- 13:34talk to to avoid a collision. And to make sure
- 13:37that everyone's working to prevent debris from
- 13:42clogging up lower orbit and also perhaps falling
- 13:47to earth, which is one area of claims. I think
- 13:50that are just inherently going to go up and increase
- 13:53as there's more space activity. And then the
- 13:56liability convention lays out more of the details
- 13:59of. of some of the ways that states can be viable
- 14:07for their conduct. So those are sort of the overviews.
- 14:11And as I said, they're really important into
- 14:13our domestic law through the licensing, essentially
- 14:18treated as licensing authorization and continuing
- 14:20supervision provision of Article 6 of the Outer
- 14:24Space Treaty that really allowed the growth of
- 14:28private space companies. Russia and China at
- 14:31the time of the negotiation of the outer space
- 14:33treaty really believed that space activities
- 14:38really are only the province of governments and
- 14:41should not be the province of private companies.
- 14:44And the United States foresaw a time, which we
- 14:47are in now, where private companies would have
- 14:49more and more of a role in space exploration.
- 14:53And so by negotiating this provision in Article
- 14:576, They made sure that the outer space treaty
- 15:01contemplated private actors, but had to kind
- 15:05of reach this middle ground with China and Russia
- 15:07in terms of saying, well, we'll still be on the
- 15:10hook for for their activities. We're not going
- 15:13to just release all of our responsibility to
- 15:16those private companies. All right. Next slide,
- 15:20please. So with that backdrop, I will say I have
- 15:24done a survey. of space disputes, litigation
- 15:28and arbitration, obviously a little harder to
- 15:30find, but from these reports, you can find those
- 15:34as well. From both the early space age era through
- 15:40to today, there are about 80 different disputes
- 15:46that my research has found, stemming from international
- 15:52arbitration, state to state disputes, private
- 15:57disputes, just a range of them. And really they
- 16:01fall into sort of these, I say, rough categories.
- 16:05So some of them are first, the landmark or first
- 16:08to interpret a treaty, sort of interpreting or
- 16:14applying foundational international space law
- 16:17and treaty obligations. The second category would
- 16:22really be liability and state claims. So issues
- 16:25involving state responsibility, cross -border
- 16:27damage claims for space -based activities. I'll
- 16:32be talking about one of those very early ones
- 16:36involving Canada and Russia very shortly. And
- 16:39then commercial and contract. A lot of the arrangements
- 16:44with the governments and with other space companies
- 16:48are through contract. So these might include
- 16:53launch services, satellite, other kinds of private
- 16:57sector operations. And to the extent they're
- 17:03tied to agency action, they could also include
- 17:06bid protests. And then regulatory and spectrum.
- 17:10So the most. Where most of the activity in space
- 17:14has been traditionally, and where, frankly, most
- 17:16of the money is, because really all of us rely
- 17:19on satellites, whether we know it or not, for
- 17:22transmitting our GPS locations, for our cellular
- 17:26service, for a number of different things. Satellites
- 17:32have been and will remain the core of space activities,
- 17:35particularly around Earth. And so the question
- 17:40of allocating spectrum for those activities.
- 17:43There's only so many communication lines that
- 17:47could be allocated and so duking it out over
- 17:51the allocation of spectrum and then, of course,
- 17:55regulatory questions also. All right, so next
- 17:59slide. So, as I mentioned, really, one of the
- 18:05original space disputes and original invocations
- 18:09of international treaties and international mechanisms
- 18:13is the cons this nine five four incident. So
- 18:17this involved in the nineteen seventies, so we
- 18:22had satellite entering the atmosphere over Canada
- 18:25and crashing and it's scattered radioactive debris
- 18:30around the beautiful. open wildlife part of Canada.
- 18:37And so Canada had to locate it, clean it up,
- 18:40and the U .S. helped Canada in cleaning it up
- 18:43also. But Canada invoked the liability convention
- 18:49and also the outer space treaty responsibility
- 18:53provisions saying, hey, Russia, your space object,
- 18:58which you remain responsible for, malfunctioned.
- 19:02and it injured and contaminated our beautiful
- 19:08land. And we are sending you first a little diplomatic
- 19:13letter about this, about that we are claiming
- 19:17our rights under the Liability Convention and
- 19:20the OST. And we estimate our damages to be six
- 19:25million Canadian dollars back in 1978. And we
- 19:28would like you to reimburse us for that, which
- 19:31reflects our the cost of our cleanup. And so
- 19:39Russia did not immediately respond to that. The
- 19:45Claims Commission then could be constituted to
- 19:49decide that claim. And so as the time for the
- 19:52Claims Commission to be constituted came to be,
- 19:56eventually the claim was settled for three million
- 20:01Canadian dollars. without supposedly admission
- 20:05of responsibility or liability under these different
- 20:09provisions. But nonetheless, from that became
- 20:12very clear that this is a real mechanism to be
- 20:16invoked, that the Claims Commission could be
- 20:20invoked for this kind of activity, and that claims
- 20:24by states could be brought. So again, this is
- 20:30reflects, though, that the Claims Commission
- 20:32procedure itself in the treaties clearly calls
- 20:36for this effort at diplomacy before the Claims
- 20:41Commission can be put into place. So there's
- 20:44a built -in delay mechanism in the timing for
- 20:48duking it out country to country. Because countries
- 20:52prefer to diplomatically resolve these things
- 20:55rather than go into court with each other or
- 20:58into arbitration or even a claims commission
- 21:00with each other. So there's a disincentive to
- 21:03do that. And that's kind of the slow down mechanism
- 21:06is built into the treaty. So. But, and it also
- 21:12highlights that this kind of claim is really
- 21:14a state -to -state kind of claim. I'll never
- 21:17forget when I had some of my first classes in
- 21:20space law. And of course, as a litigator, I'm
- 21:23thinking, well, how do we resolve issues? How
- 21:26do private companies have a role in resolving
- 21:28issues? And those who are involved largely in
- 21:32the international space realm said, well, you
- 21:36just get your country to make a claim for you.
- 21:39In this kind of claims commission, and that's
- 21:42how it's going to work out. And I kind of scratched
- 21:45my head about that and I thought, well, that.
- 21:47Is a problem because there are so many diplomatic
- 21:50reasons why a state might not pursue a claim
- 21:53for a private actor. And so this, this is a problem
- 21:56and where are the avenues that that private actors
- 22:00can use. So next slide please. So. Some of these,
- 22:10the early disputes along these lines related
- 22:14to really questions of liability limitations,
- 22:23of anti -trust challenges. ComSAT and INNLSAT
- 22:27were both treaty created organizations that ran
- 22:33satellites. And so these private companies would
- 22:37have contracts with them. And so in the Pan AmSAT
- 22:43versus ComSAT, that's really an antitrust challenge
- 22:52to satellite communications. And Pan AmSAT was
- 23:00allowed to bring and sort of revise its claims
- 23:03against ComSAT for that. And then Martin Marietta
- 23:09dealt with questions of, okay, if you have commercial
- 23:13space acts that require certain waivers of liability
- 23:19and things like that, then what kinds of claims
- 23:23can you bring if you have already essentially
- 23:26limited your claims by contract or by statute?
- 23:35and the Fourth Circuit held that no, in fact,
- 23:39there could be a breach of contract claim in
- 23:41this particular case because the contract was
- 23:42ambiguous, and that there was a sufficient allegation
- 23:45of gross negligence that even though regular
- 23:49negligence claims might not survive, certainly
- 23:52gross negligence claims could survive. So there's
- 23:56some testing of what it means. limits of liability
- 24:03are and what kinds of claims could be brought.
- 24:06Okay, next slide. The next dispute between Laurel
- 24:16and Q's technology transfer. So this was a series
- 24:21of disputes with regard to cooperation with China.
- 24:28So as a result of these circumstances, It led
- 24:32to very strict export controls being put in place
- 24:37in the space industry. So there are lawyers in
- 24:42space law whose focus is ITAR and other very
- 24:49specific statutes that need to be met in order
- 24:53to make sure that. We're not sharing any trade
- 24:57secrets with countries that shouldn't be having
- 25:00them and that we're not including in the chain
- 25:04of command any kind of information sharing as
- 25:11to which we have national security concerns.
- 25:15So, in this case, the Department of State had
- 25:18charged Morale with many violations of the international
- 25:22traffic and arms regulations. Act, and they eventually
- 25:28settled, required a huge civil fine to be paid,
- 25:34and of course no admission of liability. But
- 25:40it did lead to a reshaping of this kind of commercial
- 25:44space export control policy, which has led to
- 25:49a need for specialist lawyers, really for all
- 25:52space companies. and limitations on who can be
- 25:55hired and what can be shared with who. So it's
- 25:59somewhat shaping of the industry. All right,
- 26:04next slide, please. So then the really sort of
- 26:10the next category I would say is those that have
- 26:16challenged early on the authority and ownership
- 26:21of lunar materials. So in the one lewside ball
- 26:25case, It's an interim proceeding by the US to
- 26:32get back a small sample of lunar material that
- 26:36was encased in a lucite ball that was a diplomatic
- 26:39gift to Honduras. And then the Honduran colonel
- 26:44who had it, sold it to a Florida businessman.
- 26:48And then NASA Inspector General got involved
- 26:53and said, no, thank you very much. We believe
- 26:55that is ours. Hand that moon sample back to us.
- 27:02And Honduras had also requested the return of
- 27:04the sample saying it was a diplomatic gift to
- 27:06us, not for private sale by one of our colonels.
- 27:11So it was entitled to, the United States was
- 27:14entitled to gain forfeiture of this item because
- 27:17the items were stolen from the Republic of Honduras
- 27:19and then introduced into the United States. So
- 27:24it's frequently cited as an example of saying,
- 27:27hey, all moon samples and things that NASA has
- 27:30gathered are sort of US property, and that may
- 27:34actually practically be the case. But what was
- 27:41determined in this case was sort of the chain
- 27:43of ownership and command and ability to sell
- 27:47it. Similarly, Gregory Nimitz, a private citizen
- 27:52in Nevada, registered a claim to an asteroid
- 27:54with a private internet registry and then sought
- 27:58rental fees from NASA because it was his asteroid.
- 28:02NASA declined to pay and then he sued NASA and
- 28:05the State Department saying, no, you owe me this
- 28:07money. It's my asteroid. The district court dismissed
- 28:10the complaint for failure to state a claim and
- 28:12the Ninth Circuit affirmed. So it didn't quite
- 28:17address the fundamental issues, but it does,
- 28:22as anyone listening from the first part of the
- 28:24program can say, gosh, it really does implicate
- 28:28this appropriation question. And does the Outer
- 28:31Space Treaty really forbid individuals from doing
- 28:33this, or does it just forbid sovereigns? But
- 28:38also these cases show that There may be disputes
- 28:43that relate to space or originate in space activities,
- 28:47but many of them can land back on Earth. You
- 28:49know, this is where the people who are doing
- 28:51the activities are. And so federal courts and,
- 28:56as I mentioned, state courts are often, and increasingly
- 28:59so, a place for these disputes to be brought
- 29:02while technically not under the international
- 29:05laws, but under other domestic laws. All right,
- 29:09next slide, please. The other important trend
- 29:18is arbitration. So, private arbitration is preferred
- 29:27by a number of entities. Obviously, businesses
- 29:32like arbitration, business -to -business arbitration
- 29:36is common in the United States. It's also common
- 29:39internationally. Also international forums for
- 29:46specialized dispute resolution related to space
- 29:49law if they want to be invoked. One is the permanent
- 29:53court of arbitration has specialized space procedures
- 29:58for space disputes. No one has yet invoked them,
- 30:01but they exist. Also the ICC has some specialty.
- 30:11resolution of space disputes and has experiences
- 30:14with that, just like the American Arbitration
- 30:17Association's International Division also has
- 30:19that. There are also mechanisms where basically
- 30:26arbitration, international arbitration is really
- 30:28the best place where you can bring everyone to
- 30:31account, whether you're talking about the governments,
- 30:34the private actors, you're having jurisdiction
- 30:37over all of them in one forum. you're generally
- 30:41talking about arbitration being that place for
- 30:45that. Now, particularly with regard to foreign
- 30:47investment arbitration, there's specialty provisions
- 30:52for that as well. And of course, people like
- 30:56arbitration also for confidentiality, especially
- 31:00when there are technical matters that are proprietary
- 31:03that are at issue. Two of the claims that I've
- 31:12mentioned on this slide really involve companies
- 31:21that have, or in the case of KT, the Korean satellite
- 31:27company, that involve IP. So there's a lot of
- 31:31IP rates and protection of sensitive trade secrets.
- 31:35And these claims were first brought to arbitration
- 31:38and then confirmed the arbitration award is confirmed
- 31:42and turned into a collectible judgment in the
- 31:46United States in district courts. So under the
- 31:51New York Convention. So that is also another
- 31:54benefit obviously of arbitration is that the
- 31:58award can be domesticated, turned into an enforceable
- 32:02judgment. And in the case of a foreign country,
- 32:06you can then reach the assets of that country
- 32:10within the United States. Next slide, please.
- 32:17One of these examples of, I would say, one of
- 32:21the most complex and long -running disputes in
- 32:27space law has to do, and it continues to this
- 32:29day. Literally, they just sought re -hearing
- 32:33on bank at the Ninth Circuit, I think a couple
- 32:35of earlier this week, actually, on one of the
- 32:39arms of this challenge. So the Devis Antrix saga
- 32:46began in 2005. There was a lease by the Antrix
- 32:53Corporation of its spectrum. So as I mentioned,
- 32:56there's limited ranges of spectrum that are available
- 32:59to be allocated and shared. And so So they have,
- 33:09so India has this spectrum, Antrix is a India,
- 33:14essentially India company, and they say, okay,
- 33:17we're not gonna use this spectrum, we're going
- 33:19to allow you to lease it, Devis. And so they
- 33:25have this agreement, and then the Indian government,
- 33:31Antrix, decides no, actually. For national security
- 33:35and strategic needs, we're no longer going to
- 33:37do that. So we're going to renege on our deal
- 33:41and not allow you to do that. And this ended
- 33:47up with a $562 million arbitration award in favor
- 33:53of Debas. But it wasn't an arbitration that was
- 33:58just in one place. There were also foreign investors.
- 34:01And so there was a BIT arbitration. There was
- 34:05a separate commercial arbitration for breach
- 34:08of contract. And then there was also action in
- 34:13India itself, including the India Supreme Court
- 34:18and the Indian government becoming involved in
- 34:23assessing whether Deva should have been given
- 34:26the contract to begin with, whether it was fraudulent
- 34:29or tainted, or should therefore be assessed to
- 34:33have been void from the beginning, this entire
- 34:36contract. Obviously, by the time that was raised
- 34:40was obviously in an effort to avoid this very
- 34:43significant arbitration award. And then also
- 34:46enforcement challenges then in the US. So you
- 34:49have this impact of what is the impact of this
- 34:52later determination by the Indian Supreme Court
- 34:55of fraud. by the winning party in the arbitrations.
- 35:03And then second of all, the enforcement efforts
- 35:06by Davis to collect on its award and to confirm
- 35:12its award. And so what was just before the Ninth
- 35:16Circuit back and forth to the U .S. Supreme Court
- 35:19and back down to the Ninth Circuit was a question
- 35:21of foreign sovereign immunity and whether there
- 35:23was an exception to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities
- 35:25Act that allowed enforcement and recognition
- 35:31under the New York Convention of the Arbitration
- 35:34Award. And the Ninth Circuit first said no, because
- 35:39you need significant contacts to the U .S. to
- 35:43fit within this exception, and India doesn't
- 35:46have that. The United States Supreme Court said
- 35:48no, we don't think you need minimum contacts.
- 35:52You just need to satisfy the exceptions within
- 35:54the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, send it
- 35:57back to the Ninth Circuit. The Ninth Circuit
- 35:58said oh. Thank you very much, Supreme Court,
- 36:00for guiding us. And now we're going to analyze
- 36:03all of this. And now we've determined, yes, actually,
- 36:06it can be used and confirmed against India. And
- 36:12there's no foreign sovereign immunity problem.
- 36:15That, of course, as I mentioned just last week,
- 36:17now there's an unbanked petition to the Ninth
- 36:20Circuit. And probably there will be a cert petition
- 36:22as well, because that's just how this This roles
- 36:26so you've got a lot of money involved. Do you
- 36:28have a lot of different jurisdictions necessarily
- 36:31involved because it touches many different jurisdictions
- 36:35and many different. Venues and this is from again,
- 36:40it's 2026. This was from original activity or
- 36:44agreement in 2005 and the litigation in various
- 36:49for has been going on. for at least 16 years.
- 36:54So it's one of these never -ending things. So
- 36:58this is an example of all the places you could
- 37:00go potentially with claims and how you could
- 37:04be in many of them all at once. This is a very
- 37:07complex system for litigation. All right, next
- 37:13slide, please. So after having... shared sort
- 37:18of like the nightmare scenario with you of ongoing
- 37:22litigation from a contract that I think lasted
- 37:25a year. There's other areas that are ripe for
- 37:30dispute as well, which have been areas of dispute.
- 37:34So obviously, questions of regulatory oversight
- 37:40and licensing. Are you going to challenge a denial
- 37:46of a license? Are you also going to challenge
- 37:50a grant of a bid to another company that you
- 37:55were bidding for. There's a couple of those.
- 38:00There's actually one right now with Rocket Lab
- 38:02challenging sort of internally in the agency
- 38:06first a grant to another company of a bid. Blue
- 38:10Origin has also filed such claims in the past.
- 38:15These are valuable contracts, so it makes a lot
- 38:17of sense for for people to hold the government
- 38:21to their bidding statutes and requirements. There's
- 38:26also a growing challenge to the mega constellations.
- 38:33So originally there would just be sort of individual
- 38:37satellites that would be put up into orbit. Now
- 38:40we have SpaceX. even China has a company doing
- 38:43this, Blue Origin is starting to do it, setting
- 38:46up a constellation of smaller satellites to provide
- 38:51more widespread and significant service. So this
- 38:54is how Starlink is able to provide consistent
- 38:58internet service to very remote locations. And
- 39:02so there's challenges between those companies,
- 39:08right, who gets the The benefits of certain slots
- 39:12for mega constellation, so fighting whether those
- 39:14should be approved or not and how that impacts
- 39:17others activities, but also an increasing concern
- 39:22really environmentally and with a challenge to
- 39:26a principle in international space law that's
- 39:29known as dark and quiet skies that astronomers
- 39:32and those on on earth who are doing scientific
- 39:34investigation their efforts to. see far out into
- 39:40the universe or even relatively close in to Earth
- 39:44are compromised by these mega constellations,
- 39:49which emit a lot more light, because there are
- 39:51a lot of them all together in one spot. And is
- 39:55there something that should be done about that
- 39:58to balance the interests? So that's another area
- 40:06of tension and developing claims as well. Okay,
- 40:12next slide. Similarly, there's really been a
- 40:18big uptick in this question of environmental
- 40:21aspects and land use law, particularly around
- 40:26launch operations. So there's a number of these
- 40:30questions that are going on right now. Certainly,
- 40:36There's challenges to the current agency's assessment
- 40:43that NEPA does not apply to certain activities
- 40:46and that there are those who urge that, no, it
- 40:51does and it needs to be complied with. And then
- 40:56there are also many concerns about So, either
- 41:04the launch capacity is increasing and increases
- 41:07the noise for local residents, or there's allegations
- 41:13of environmental contamination from those launches,
- 41:18which have a lot of chemicals. So, a lot of these
- 41:21challenges have to do with SpaceX activities.
- 41:26SpaceX is the most frequent, frequently launching
- 41:29company. in the world right now, Rocket Lab is
- 41:33right after them, but they're the most frequent
- 41:36launchers. So those who are most frequently launching
- 41:38will have the most challenges. And I want to
- 41:44point to a couple of these examples. So one was
- 41:48right here in California that ended up being
- 41:52settled, and that is SpaceX's challenge to the
- 41:56California Coastal Commission. So in that case,
- 42:03SpaceX is launching from the Space Force base
- 42:07and which is federal land and the federal government
- 42:10says, yes, we want you to launch. We have done
- 42:12our own environmental review as required and
- 42:15we find that it's fine and increasing the range,
- 42:19the amount of lunches and frequency of lunches
- 42:21also does not have significant environmental
- 42:24impact. And so. we have done that assessment
- 42:29and we approve the increase in lunches. And the
- 42:33California Coastal Commission said, whoa, whoa,
- 42:34whoa, we have a say also, and we are concerned
- 42:39about the impact on California's environment.
- 42:42And in the course of doing that and saying that
- 42:44and wanting to stop SpaceX lunches as a result
- 42:48of that, they also said some unfortunate things
- 42:51that may have been a little bit biased. toward
- 42:55or against SpaceX and Elon Musk sort of politically
- 42:59and personally. And so SpaceX sued the California
- 43:03Coastal Commission saying, no, no, you cannot
- 43:06override the federal assessment of environmental
- 43:10impact. And moreover, you violated, you know,
- 43:16for the first amendment and in applying your
- 43:20agency regulation. And that is a separate problem.
- 43:23And in the course of filing this lawsuit, a central
- 43:27part of the allegations had to do with international
- 43:30and domestic policy favoring commercial space
- 43:33activities and launch and the national security
- 43:36interests that were implicated by the ability
- 43:38to continue to launch and increase launch frequency
- 43:41at the Space Force base. lawsuit was recently
- 43:46settled just before summary judgment. The commission
- 43:50apologized to Elon Musk and SpaceX and said they
- 43:52would never make such a blunt and blatant statements
- 43:58again adverse to a company in making a decision.
- 44:02And also said that, hey, unless anything new
- 44:06changes, we're not going to interfere with the
- 44:08federal government's assessment of environmental
- 44:10impact. This does not mean that challenges to
- 44:16the impact on the environment has stopped with
- 44:19regard to SpaceX though. One of their primary
- 44:22launch facilities is Bolsa Chica in Texas and
- 44:25there are recent lawsuits filed both by local
- 44:30governments but also local people and property
- 44:32owners in state courts actually claiming concerns
- 44:36from this. I anticipate this kind of environmental
- 44:41land use challenges to increase as the cadence
- 44:45of launch increases and for these things to end
- 44:48up both in state and or a federal court and in
- 44:53state court under really typical nuisance and
- 44:57state law kind of claims. So we've gone all the
- 44:59way from international law to domestic. All right,
- 45:04next slide, please. Another area where I think
- 45:08there will be continuing to be a lot of challenges
- 45:11is space debris. So, as I mentioned, there's
- 45:15more activity in space. We hope to maintain sustainability
- 45:19in those activities and to limit space debris
- 45:23because it is harmful both when it comes back
- 45:26to earth, but also harmful to space. orbit activities,
- 45:30a very small piece of space junk can create a
- 45:34huge, huge amount of damage to other space objects.
- 45:38And so in order to maintain the environment for
- 45:41everybody in space, you need to really minimize
- 45:44the kind of junk that's out there. So as I mentioned,
- 45:53there is a international liability framework
- 45:55for the state with regard to things Falling back
- 46:00to Earth. That is a very clear, absolute liability
- 46:08kind of framework. If something happens in space,
- 46:10there's a fault -based framework, a query, how
- 46:13easy it is to establish the fault in space. But
- 46:17at least when it's coming down to Earth, you
- 46:20say, OK, great. We identify whose object it is,
- 46:25and it should be really simple for us to go to
- 46:27that country and say, hey, Could you this crashed
- 46:31into some part of our country and we'd like you
- 46:34to clean it up or pay for the cleanup and haul
- 46:37this large piece of junk away. And but if, for
- 46:45example, a NASA or US space object falls to Earth
- 46:49in the United States, it is not clear either
- 46:55that private citizens could bring claims. They
- 46:59can't bring direct claims in international forms
- 47:01under the treaty. Those are really the states
- 47:06that have to pursue them. And second of all,
- 47:10there's that absolute liability provision under
- 47:12the treaties really relates, does not relate
- 47:15to stuff falling in your own country. So if you
- 47:17hit somebody else's, if your debris lands in
- 47:20another country. great, you're on the hook under
- 47:23international mechanisms, and your country can
- 47:26bring claims. But if you're a private citizen
- 47:28of the country in which that launched object
- 47:31came from, that absolute liability doesn't apply
- 47:35under the treaty. So what do you do? And there
- 47:41was one of the very first claims of this type
- 47:45involved some debris falling into a house in
- 47:49Florida. This was very recently, I want to say
- 47:52in the last couple of years. And so what did
- 47:57we, the family said, hey, you know, there's this
- 48:00big piece of junk that fell through our roof.
- 48:02What do we do? And they brought a claim, administrative
- 48:08claim against NASA saying, hey, could you please
- 48:12pay for this very expensive fixing up of our
- 48:17house. And they did end up settling that that
- 48:22claim and paying a certain amount of money to
- 48:24cover to cover that cleanup. But of course, again,
- 48:28without acknowledging that. Either that they
- 48:32were at fault or that they were sort of were
- 48:34appropriately sued under that under that claim,
- 48:37but it does indicate that that potentially, if
- 48:39you have debris falling into your house from
- 48:41your own countries, space activities, then. Maybe
- 48:48you can bring these agency claims against NASA,
- 48:55for example, to get some reimbursement for that.
- 48:59But again, like the diplomatic one claims, many
- 49:03of these things are resolved short of actually
- 49:06a judgment. Okay, next slide. So I wanted to
- 49:12be sure to address other areas where there haven't
- 49:15been claims yet and for good reason, but they're
- 49:18likely to be claims. So one of the more lucrative
- 49:22and immediate areas of activity in space, at
- 49:29least around Earth orbit, will be pharmaceutical
- 49:33production. So this has been going on on the
- 49:37ISS for several years, so we know that it works.
- 49:41Also, some of the private space companies like
- 49:44Virgin Galactic also have science missions and
- 49:47pharmaceutical missions on board their launch
- 49:53vehicles. And this is to do experiments and manufacturing
- 49:58of drugs in space. And there are certain things
- 50:03that can happen in space that cannot happen on
- 50:05Earth. So, for example, the cancer drug Keytruda
- 50:10when it's manufactured on Earth can be manufactured
- 50:15in a way that addresses certain types of cancer.
- 50:18But when work on the drug is done in microgravity,
- 50:24it's been allowed to be expanded to a number
- 50:27of different kinds of cancer. And so it's very
- 50:34exciting, the possibilities that could happen
- 50:36from microgravity manufacturing and research.
- 50:40and obviously quite lucrative for the pharmaceutical
- 50:42companies. So I expect that to really pick up
- 50:46in its cadence. And especially with the ISS going
- 50:52away and being decommissioned in a few years,
- 50:55really the only way to have this microgravity
- 50:57manufacturing will be on private vehicles. And
- 51:00so there's a whole. set of laws that apply to
- 51:06the ISS and understanding of jurisdiction and
- 51:09which module you're in and which laws apply and
- 51:11how patents work in that on the ISS. But there
- 51:16is no such provision for private space manufacturing
- 51:23vehicles like Varta and others. So I expected
- 51:28there will be not only regulatory oversight of
- 51:32this, but also needing to work out some important
- 51:37questions of patent and IP ownership. Likewise,
- 51:44you should be on the lookout for space tourism
- 51:46related claims. So right now, there is a learning
- 51:51period that's been allowed by our federal government
- 51:56saying, okay, we don't really know what the risks
- 51:59potentially could be with regard to human spaceflight
- 52:04and space tourism. And so we're going to allow
- 52:07a period where there are no codified standards
- 52:12so that we can kind of see what we might need.
- 52:16We don't want to create standards for things
- 52:18that just aren't going to happen or risks that
- 52:21really aren't going to present themselves. So
- 52:25there is a learning period until 2028 that Congress
- 52:29could extend it again. And certainly human passengers
- 52:33now are required to have waivers of claims against
- 52:39the space tourism companies. But those waivers
- 52:42do not extend, for example, to. questions of
- 52:46ground. So again, this question of debris. If
- 52:49some part of the tourist plane were to fall down
- 52:53to earth and hit someone, obviously that person
- 52:56has not engaged in a contractual relationship
- 53:00or waiver with Virgin Galactic or other companies
- 53:03or Blue Origin or any other company that might
- 53:06be engaged in this. And so there's a potential
- 53:08for claims from that despite the waivers. And
- 53:11then the question will be, will those How much
- 53:14will those waivers continue and how much will
- 53:16those waivers extend to? In the past, there have
- 53:21been claims of wrongful death and personal injury
- 53:24claims related to the Challenger disaster and
- 53:27other deaths of government astronauts in the
- 53:32Apollo program. all of the exclusions and limitations
- 53:38on liability, still the widows did manage to
- 53:41obtain some award and some settlement from the
- 53:45government. So if that's a past -as -prologue,
- 53:49it seems that there will continue to be a potential
- 53:54for those kinds of claims, either from third
- 53:56parties or those who were contractually tied
- 54:03to the space companies. All right, next slide,
- 54:06please. So I also want to mention a few other
- 54:11areas that I think will reach out into the 2030s
- 54:15a bit. Activities that we haven't even talked
- 54:18about that would be, you know, picking up speed
- 54:24and actually happening in the next few years.
- 54:27And then also what we can expect in terms of
- 54:29fora, where you might go for some of these claims,
- 54:32because as we get further out literally to things
- 54:35such as lunar resource extraction or even the
- 54:38building of lunar infrastructure, and what happens
- 54:42if there's an accident on a road in space kind
- 54:44of thing, or a nuclear power problem, or disputes
- 54:52even between private companies about who is allowed
- 54:56to extract where. and who has ownership of some
- 55:01very valuable potential mineral extractions,
- 55:05all of those things will be coming into fruition.
- 55:10And as we talked about, there's no clear jurisdiction
- 55:14in space. So whether people will have arbitration
- 55:18agreements in their provisions, in their contracts,
- 55:22or whether there will be other provisions for
- 55:25dispute mechanisms that remains to be seen. The
- 55:29other huge area of growth, as I said, is a collision.
- 55:34So as there's more activity in space, there's
- 55:36more space debris, there's more orbital debris
- 55:40impacts both in space and on Earth, there will
- 55:43likely be more claims and those will involve
- 55:46more private space companies because there just
- 55:48are more of them operating. IP and proprietary
- 55:52data in the pharmaceutical research context and
- 55:58other contexts, those will continue to be debated
- 56:02and very high value kind of claims. And then
- 56:05the question of like, where would you go, right?
- 56:07As I said, you could agree to arbitration. Some
- 56:11people could agree to just general arbitration.
- 56:14I know all of our commercial contracts are done
- 56:16at the AAA. And so we're going to send our space
- 56:19claims there too, or they could decide to go
- 56:23to a specialized space arbitration panel. There
- 56:27are some aerospace panels at American Arbitration
- 56:31Association. There is also, as I mentioned, a
- 56:35permanent court of arbitration with a space rules,
- 56:38specific rules. And there's also a growing private
- 56:42set, well. somewhat private set of courts in
- 56:46the UAE. The UAE is building a whole area of
- 56:51commercial courts, including space courts that
- 56:54are focused on new technology areas. And it's
- 56:58in a particular commercial zone that has its
- 57:01own commercial laws and generally judges and
- 57:06arbitrators who are from the UK. to judge these
- 57:12disputes and some companies find that helpful.
- 57:17So there might be even brand new fora that haven't
- 57:21even been in place yet where some of these disputes
- 57:24could be heard. And as I mentioned, multilateral
- 57:28frameworks and fora, obviously you hope you would
- 57:32never, if you're the space company, you hope
- 57:33you would never have such a long -winning dispute
- 57:35as Davis has had, but there could be, you could
- 57:38be litigating things in multiple fora at the
- 57:41same time. And then also potentially at the international
- 57:45level, there might be some development or clarification
- 57:50of private companies' roles in those dispute
- 57:53mechanisms as well, which could change where
- 57:56claims are brought. And also this sort of hybrid
- 58:02resolution of encouraging mediation first before
- 58:06actually going to arbitration is also something
- 58:11that some companies might want to have in place.
- 58:16so that hopefully there's an opportunity to resolve
- 58:19something early on, just as many of the different
- 58:22international countries have done with their
- 58:28claims procedures through the OST and the liability
- 58:31convention. So I hope I've given some context,
- 58:36like are there space disputes? Yes, there's been
- 58:39a fair amount of them historically, but I would
- 58:43say Now, with the new types of activities that
- 58:46are happening, and the new space actors commercially,
- 58:52and the variety of them, and the increased uptick
- 58:56in space launches and space activity in general,
- 58:59that we're going to see a significant acceleration.
- 59:03There are more and more claims being filed every
- 59:08month. than I would say have been in the past.
- 59:12And as also new regulations come into play and
- 59:15things are put out to bid by the federal government,
- 59:19that there will continue to be challenges in
- 59:21that regard as well. So there may be a lot of
- 59:25activities in space, but there's also a lot of
- 59:28opportunities for litigation on Earth. So many
- 59:35of you may have the opportunity to engage in
- 59:38in some of these claims and cutting -edge areas,
- 59:42and it should be a pretty exciting time for space
- 59:46lawyers and space litigators. I hope I've given
- 59:49a little preview of what to watch for and what
- 59:53you might be seeing as litigators in the aerospace
- 59:58industry. So I was going to check to see if there
- 1:00:04are any particular questions. We do have one
- 1:00:08question. Click on that Q &A. You might have
- 1:00:12to press more on the bottom of your. Yep, there
- 1:00:15it is. I see one. Yep, there it is. OK. OK, so
- 1:00:25it's a really good comment on the the Canadian
- 1:00:32claim against Russia about what you know, always
- 1:00:36asking for more than you think you might actually
- 1:00:38receive. So. So Stephen Wood, who is quite knowledgeable
- 1:00:46about this area of the law, welcome Stephen,
- 1:00:48thank you for your comment, is pointing out that
- 1:00:52the actual damages exceeded 14 million and they
- 1:00:55only sought partial compensation and then received
- 1:00:57obviously even less than that, the 3 million
- 1:00:59instead of the 6 million. And he's asking, why
- 1:01:03would Canada not seek full compensation? you
- 1:01:09know, that is a negotiation strategy. You know,
- 1:01:13other than the Canadians are really nice in general.
- 1:01:17Maybe they just asked for what they thought they
- 1:01:19wanted. There's also a little bit, I think, of
- 1:01:25that in that the US did also help them in identifying
- 1:01:30things and the cleanup. So I'm not sure how much
- 1:01:33also might have been incurred without seeking
- 1:01:38reimbursement by the US as opposed to Canada.
- 1:01:40Also, I think in that scenario, you're really
- 1:01:43testing things out, right? You're testing, it's
- 1:01:45the first time anyone's made a claim. It's the
- 1:01:48first time you're really testing the geopolitical
- 1:01:51commitment to the treaty and to the claims commission.
- 1:01:57And maybe you don't wanna press that hard. Maybe
- 1:02:01you just wanna kind of see what you can get.
- 1:02:04and not make it so significant monetarily that
- 1:02:10perhaps Russia might have balked at paying anything
- 1:02:14or wanted to take it all the way to the commission
- 1:02:19to an actual ruling. I think there's a lot of
- 1:02:23things about being first. You could either be
- 1:02:25bold and go for it, or you could say, We're just
- 1:02:29going to go for the principle and get a certain
- 1:02:32amount of money here. And who knows what, as
- 1:02:35I said, diplomatically or geopolitically was
- 1:02:39happening at the time that may have impacted
- 1:02:42a Canada -Russia dispute. So I think there's
- 1:02:49a lot of that. It's unlike, I think, other parts
- 1:02:51of litigation where there are so many other factors
- 1:02:54involved in these decisions. that really don't
- 1:02:58have to do with the specific belief in that particular
- 1:03:02claim. Just as we have with our clients in general
- 1:03:04as litigators, there are a lot of different things
- 1:03:08that the clients might be interested in or wanting
- 1:03:10to get out of a particular claim. And some of
- 1:03:13those are extra legal and extra litigation. So
- 1:03:17I would venture to say that a lot of those have
- 1:03:20to do with that. All right. So thanks for that
- 1:03:30question. It's a really good question because
- 1:03:32I think it's an important factor if you are litigating
- 1:03:34these claims. There are so many other things
- 1:03:38at play. Like even in the bid disputes, the government
- 1:03:42is still a major customer for all of the aerospace
- 1:03:45companies. So when you do a bid protest, you're
- 1:03:48not only making a statement as to your competitors,
- 1:03:53but you're also making a statement about where
- 1:03:54you're going to stand. you know, with a potential
- 1:03:58repeat and current customer of yours, the federal
- 1:04:01government. So there are a lot of different aspects
- 1:04:05of strategy that go into whether to make these
- 1:04:08claims and how far to proceed with them and how
- 1:04:11to make those claims. I mean, I think that I
- 1:04:15think that the SpaceX California Coastal Commission
- 1:04:17case is a good example of that. SpaceX had to
- 1:04:21kind of stand up on the First Amendment ground
- 1:04:25because if If people are just gonna not like
- 1:04:29you and not give your company permission to operate
- 1:04:33because they don't like you, that's a bad precedent.
- 1:04:37So you have to attack that and it seemed quite
- 1:04:40attackable. And then the second part is this
- 1:04:45interplay between state and federal regulators
- 1:04:47and how does the federal assessment of environmental
- 1:04:51regulation impact the California or state independent
- 1:04:54assessment. That obviously is an important question,
- 1:04:56not only for California, where there are a lot
- 1:04:58of lunches at the Space Force base, but also
- 1:05:01just an important precedent in general to try
- 1:05:04and move forward on. And so it's interesting
- 1:05:08in that settlement was reached in that case as
- 1:05:12well. It's probably true that SpaceX could have
- 1:05:14really done quite well, especially on the First
- 1:05:16Amendment claim, if you talk to a lot of constitutional
- 1:05:19law scholars. But they decided, you know, an
- 1:05:23apology is good enough. You know, there's been
- 1:05:26enough news about this. They're probably not
- 1:05:30going to make that mistake again, but at least
- 1:05:32getting the apology shows other state agencies
- 1:05:37as well that they might want to back off on refusing
- 1:05:42things on that ground, and then also establishing
- 1:05:44the importance and, at least in some ways, the
- 1:05:50superiority of the federal government's assessment
- 1:05:53of environmental impact on federal land. That's
- 1:05:56an important proposition as well. And if you
- 1:05:59can get that through a California Coastal Commission
- 1:06:02agreement through settlement, rather than taking
- 1:06:04it all the way through, I could see where SpaceX
- 1:06:08could have done that too. So I think that Stephen's
- 1:06:11question is a really good one because it actually
- 1:06:14highlights these larger questions. We can talk
- 1:06:16about these different kinds of cases and claims
- 1:06:18and he'll probably be litigating some of the
- 1:06:20major patent and IP questions. But also in representing
- 1:06:27clients in these kinds of cases, all of the various
- 1:06:32extra legal considerations. And I would say also
- 1:06:35the Davis case is an indication of how many different
- 1:06:39levels you have to fight at in some cases and
- 1:06:44be prepared to fight at and how long running
- 1:06:47some of these disputes can be. That's also a
- 1:06:50factor for companies that want to move forward
- 1:06:53and not live in the past. All right. So I didn't
- 1:07:00see any more questions. unless I missed one.
- 1:07:04But I really appreciate all of you joining us
- 1:07:07now and in the future in watching the recording,
- 1:07:12and appreciate your questions and engagement.
- 1:07:15And I look forward to seeing all of the interesting
- 1:07:19litigation that you all will be doing in the
- 1:07:21space arena. And thanks to Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:07:24for being continually on the cutting edge in
- 1:07:26their programs. Thank you so much, MC. It was
- 1:07:30such a great program. Everyone will get their
- 1:07:33certificates and the recording after the program
- 1:07:35is edited. Again, thank you. You guys have a
- 1:07:38good one. Thanks so much. Bye bye.