Latest / Deep Dive / The Skills Gap Is a Myth: Why Good People Can't Get Hired
Transcript
- 0:00You know the feeling, right? You spend like hours tailoring
- 0:03your resume for this one specific role, you upload the
- 0:06PDF, and then you spend another 45 minutes manually typing that
- 0:10exact same information into into 30 tiny little text boxes on
- 0:17some company's career portal. Oh yeah, the dreaded automated
- 0:21portal. Exactly.
- 0:23And you finally hit submit and it's like dropping a coin down a
- 0:25deep well and just never hearing the splash.
- 0:28It's complete silence. Right goes into a total black
- 0:31hole. It really does.
- 0:32But then you open up any business news site and all you
- 0:35see are these screaming headlines featuring CEOs
- 0:38complaining that they simply cannot find good people to hire.
- 0:41It's a completely maddening paradox.
- 0:43I mean, you really have to wonder what's going on.
- 0:46Yeah, why does finding a job feel harder than ever, even when
- 0:49the labor market is supposedly, you know, desperate for talent?
- 0:52So if you've ever felt like your application is just vanishing
- 0:54into an unresponsive void, this deep dive is for you.
- 0:58The disconnect between those two realities is just massive, and
- 1:01to figure out what is really happening behind the closed
- 1:05doors of modern hour departments, we are looking at 2
- 1:08highly revealing sources today. Right, we've got some great
- 1:11material. Yeah, we do.
- 1:13First, there's this really detailed working paper on skills
- 1:16shortages. It's from the Monash University
- 1:18Acer Center for the Economics of Education and Training.
- 1:21Which is a mouthful, so we'll just refer to it as the CEET
- 1:25paper moving forward. Good call.
- 1:27And 2nd we have Peter Capelli's eye opening book.
- 1:30It's called Why Good People Can't Get Jobs.
- 1:33OK, let's unpack this. Our mission today is to
- 1:36basically decode this overarching skills gap
- 1:39narrative. We want to help you, the
- 1:42listener, understand the hidden, often contradictory, dynamics of
- 1:46today's job market. Because before we can point
- 1:48fingers or blame anyone for us, you know, a skills gap, we
- 1:51really need to understand what employers actually mean when
- 1:54they complain that they can't find workers.
- 1:56Right. And according to the CET paper,
- 1:58the language dominating the business world right now is just
- 2:01incredibly muddy. Oh, it's a mess.
- 2:03Employers are taking 3 completely distinct economic
- 2:07concepts and just throwing them all into the exact same bucket.
- 2:11Which is super confusing for everyone involved.
- 2:13Exactly. The blurring of those lines is
- 2:16where the confusion starts, because when a hiring manager
- 2:20goes to the press complaining about a talent shortage, they're
- 2:24usually confusing a true skill shortage with a skills gap or
- 2:28just a standard recruitment difficulty.
- 2:30Let's actually break those down, because they are fundamentally
- 2:33different problems. Right.
- 2:34They really are. So a true skills shortage is a
- 2:38very specific economic condition.
- 2:40It means the market lacks available willing workers at
- 2:43current market conditions and wages.
- 2:45So basically the people just do not exist in the labor pool at
- 2:49the price the market dictates. Right, they literally aren't
- 2:51there. But then you have the skills
- 2:52gap, which is a totally different scenario.
- 2:54Yeah, and a skills gap is when the OR even a company's existing
- 2:59workers, I guess have the baseline qualifications, like
- 3:02they have a college degree, but they lack specific desired
- 3:05skills. Exactly.
- 3:06A lot of times these are generic skills like baseline
- 3:10communication or maybe a specific type of Computer
- 3:14literacy. They are really close to what
- 3:16you need, but not quite there. OK.
- 3:18So that's a gap, but the third category is what the CE paper
- 3:22calls recruitment difficulties. Right.
- 3:24Yeah. And this is where the narrative
- 3:25really falls apart. A recruitment difficulty is when
- 3:29an employer cannot fill vacancies, but it has absolutely
- 3:33nothing to do with a lack of skilled people in the area.
- 3:36It's just bad offers. Right.
- 3:38It happens because the employers offering bad pay, poor working
- 3:42conditions, terrible hours, or maybe they are just running a
- 3:45completely ineffective recruiting campaign.
- 3:47So the skilled workers are sitting right there in the
- 3:49community. They just refuse to work for
- 3:51that specific company under those specific terms.
- 3:53Exactly. They exist, they just don't want
- 3:55your job. I love bringing this down to
- 3:57earth with a real estate analogy.
- 3:59Like think about trying to buy a house.
- 4:01A true skill shortage is like looking at a town and realizing
- 4:04there are literally 0 houses for sale.
- 4:07Right, total lack of inventory. Exactly.
- 4:10And then a skills gap is looking at the market and saying well
- 4:12there are houses for sale but none of them have a swimming
- 4:15pool, which is what I really want.
- 4:16It's close, but missing a future, yeah.
- 4:19But a recruitment difficulty? That's like walking into a
- 4:22neighborhood full of beautiful move in ready houses, offering
- 4:26the sellers half of their asking price, getting laughed off their
- 4:29porch, and then going to the local newspaper to complain that
- 4:32nobody in this town wants to sell you a house.
- 4:34That is a perfect way to look at it, and taking that analogy back
- 4:37to the job market, you start to see how widespread this
- 4:40confusion really is. It's everywhere.
- 4:42It really is. In Capelli's book, he highlights
- 4:45a manpower survey showing that 52% of US employers complain
- 4:49about talent shortages. Wow, 52%?
- 4:52That's more than half. Yeah, and that actually ranks
- 4:54the United States 7th globally for these kinds of employer
- 4:57complaints. That's worse than manufacturing
- 4:59powerhouses like Germany and China.
- 5:01But when you apply the CEA definitions to that 52%, you
- 5:05have to ask a serious question like is the US really
- 5:08experiencing A structural economy?
- 5:11Wide shortage of capable humans. Right.
- 5:14Or are we just looking at a massive wave of employers
- 5:17whining about their own recruitment difficulties?
- 5:20Honestly, it seems like the latter.
- 5:22And once you realize that a huge portion of employers are just
- 5:25confusing their own refusal to pay market rates with the
- 5:28structural skills shortage, you have to start looking at the
- 5:31psychology of the modern hiring manager.
- 5:33Oh, absolutely. And Capelli introduces a concept
- 5:37here that completely changes how you read job postings.
- 5:40He calls the Home Depot view of hiring the.
- 5:43Home Depot view. I love this concept.
- 5:45It's so accurate. The Home Depot syndrome is this
- 5:49profound shift in corporate behavior over the last few
- 5:52decades. In this mindset, employers
- 5:55approach hiring a human being exactly the same way they
- 5:58approach buying a replacement part for a broken washing
- 6:01machine. So you go to the hardware store,
- 6:03you find the exact piece with the exact serial number, you
- 6:05plug it into the machine, and it just functions perfectly the
- 6:08second you turn it on. Exactly.
- 6:10Modern companies expect a candidate to fit Florida State
- 6:13into the organization with zero ramp up time, 0 orientation and
- 6:170 training. They're basically hunting for
- 6:20unicorns at that point. They really are, and because
- 6:22they want this plug and play perfection, they pile ridiculous
- 6:26hyper specific requirements onto their job descriptions just to
- 6:31minimize any perceived risk. The examples detailed in the
- 6:35source material are just staggering.
- 6:37I mean, Capelli mentions a job posting for a cotton candy
- 6:40machine operator. Which is wild.
- 6:42Right, a job that doesn't exactly require an advanced
- 6:45degree in thermodynamics, but the posting explicitly required
- 6:49prior experience on that exact model of cotton candy machine.
- 6:54It just shows a complete breakdown in logical hiring
- 6:56practices. I mean they would rather leave a
- 6:58position open for months than spend 15 minutes showing a new
- 7:02hire. Which button turns on the sugar
- 7:05spinner? It's absurd.
- 7:06It gets worse. Another example from the sources
- 7:08featured a mechanical engineer who had a master's degree in 30
- 7:11years of industry experience. OK, sounds like a great
- 7:14candidate. You'd think, but the employer
- 7:16rejected him because the job description required the ability
- 7:19to type 65 words per minute. Wait.
- 7:21Really. Since when is administrative
- 7:23data entry the core competency of a senior mechanical
- 7:27engineering role? Exactly.
- 7:28It makes no sense. Yeah, but the most extreme
- 7:31example Capelli found was a company that received 25,000
- 7:35applications for a standard engineering position. 25,000.
- 7:39Yeah, 25,000 and the staffing department proudly claimed that
- 7:43absolutely zero of those candidates were qualified.
- 7:46See, let me push back on this a little bit though.
- 7:49Aren't employers just responding rationally to the environment
- 7:52they're in? What I mean, well, if we look at
- 7:54the macroeconomic math from the sources, productivity coming out
- 7:58of the recession was up 6.7%, but overall GDP was only up
- 8:021.2%. Right, those are the numbers so.
- 8:05That tells U.S. companies figured out how to get
- 8:07significantly more work done with fewer people.
- 8:11The math says they need about 5.5% fewer workers than they
- 8:15used to. That's true.
- 8:16So doesn't that just mean they have the luxury of being picky?
- 8:19If you have 25,000 applicants, why not hold out for the
- 8:21absolute perfect one? That's a fairpoint, and the
- 8:24macroeconomic data certainly explains their leverage.
- 8:28They do need fewer workers and they do have a larger pool to
- 8:30choose from, so they can afford to be highly selective.
- 8:33Right, it's a buyer's market for them.
- 8:35Exactly. And being selective isn't
- 8:37inherently wrong for a business trying to stay lean.
- 8:41The problem arises when the selectivity becomes so rigid
- 8:44that it creates an artificial shortage.
- 8:47I see. By demanding that candidates
- 8:49have already done the exact same job they're applying for, often
- 8:52using the exact same proprietary software, employers are creating
- 8:56a massive catch 22. Right, because you need exact
- 8:59experience for a job, which makes it impossible to get the
- 9:01experience in the 1st. Place Rice, Isley They are
- 9:04ignoring perfectly capable, highly educated people who could
- 9:08master the role with just a week of basic orientation.
- 9:11And isn't even just human hiring managers being stubborn, either.
- 9:15These unrealistic Home Depot expectations are hard coded into
- 9:18the applicant tracking software, the ATS, that filters your
- 9:22resume before a human ever gets a chance to see it.
- 9:24Oh. The ATS.
- 9:25This is where the tyranny of the algorithm really takes over the
- 9:28process. It's brutal.
- 9:30The algorithm is ruthless because it operates entirely
- 9:32without context. It just filters out exceptional
- 9:35candidates over mere semantics. Yeah, the sources describe a
- 9:38scenario where a highly qualified gets automatically
- 9:42rejected simply because their previous job title didn't
- 9:46perfectly match the unique, highly specific company internal
- 9:50title of the vacancy. Which is crazy because a human
- 9:53looking at the resume would instantly recognize the
- 9:55overlapping skills, but the software only looks for exact
- 9:59keyword matches. And the mathematical reality of
- 10:01these algorithms is daunting. Just think about how probability
- 10:05works. Let's say a piece of screening
- 10:07software has just 10 hurdle questions.
- 10:09These are things like, do you have this specific degree or
- 10:13have you used this specific software brand for exactly 3
- 10:16years? OK, so 10 hurdles.
- 10:18Let's assume a generally qualified candidate has a
- 10:20generous 50% chance of passing each specific narrow hurdle.
- 10:24By the time you multiply that 50% probability across 10
- 10:27consecutive questions, only about one in 1000 applicants
- 10:31actually makes it through the filter.
- 10:32Only one in 1000. That math explains exactly how
- 10:36an HR department ends up looking at 25,000 applications and
- 10:39concluding that nobody is qualified.
- 10:42Exactly, and the software also enforces what is essentially a
- 10:46blind wage auction. Oh right, the salary
- 10:48expectations box. Yes.
- 10:51Many of these automated systems require applicants to type in
- 10:54their lowest acceptable salary upfront, before they even know
- 10:57the full scope of the job. Which is such a trap because if
- 11:00you guess too high, the system automatically deletes your
- 11:03application. And if you guess too low, you
- 11:05make it through, but you are locked into a terrible salary.
- 11:09It creates A literal race to the bottom for compensation.
- 11:12Which brings us right back to the real estate analogy, right?
- 11:14Refusing to pay the asking price.
- 11:16Exactly. The sources highlight an
- 11:20airline, Emirates, trying to hire cabin crew in the US.
- 11:24They were offering a meager $2500 a month and the job
- 11:28required uprooting your life and moving to Dubai.
- 11:30It's laughable. Or look at Mechanical Devices, a
- 11:32parts company featured in the text.
- 11:34They were offering $13 an hour for skilled machinists when the
- 11:39local market average for that exact skill was over $19.00 an
- 11:42hour. And then they turn around and
- 11:44complain to the press about a skill shortage.
- 11:46Right, but here's where I get stuck.
- 11:49If the software is filtering out everyone and the human
- 11:53recruiters are just staring at empty desks, why don't they just
- 11:56go into the system, adjust the filters and look at the near
- 11:59miss candidates? What's fascinating here is how
- 12:01corporate compliance and legal fear completely paralyze the
- 12:05hiring process. Wait, legal fear?
- 12:07Yeah, HR departments operate under strict anti discrimination
- 12:10laws. There's this legal concept
- 12:12called adverse impact, which basically means a company's
- 12:15hiring practices, even if they seem neutral on the surface, are
- 12:19disproportionately screening out protected classes of people.
- 12:23Oh, I see. So if an employer sets up an
- 12:25automated system that applies A rigid set of rules to every
- 12:28applicant, they can defend it as objective.
- 12:30Right, the machine did it, so it's.
- 12:31Fair, exactly. But if a human recruiter
- 12:34manually bypasses those software rules to selectively look at
- 12:38near misses, or, you know, just give someone a chance, they
- 12:41invite massive legal liability. Because it implies the company
- 12:44knows their system is flawed. That, or worse, that they are
- 12:49selectively applying the rules based on personal bias.
- 12:52Legally speaking, corporate counsel often advises that it is
- 12:57safer to leave a job vacant than to selectively override their
- 13:00own software. So the.
- 13:02System is trapped in a cage of its own making.
- 13:04It's essentially yes. But since employers are looking
- 13:06at empty seats and their legally bulletproof software tells them
- 13:10nobody is qualified, they need someone to blame.
- 13:12Now, they certainly aren't going to blame their own algorithms or
- 13:15they're below market wages. No way.
- 13:16Instead, they point the finger at the education system.
- 13:20They blame the schools and the students, which is incredibly
- 13:22convenient because it shifts the responsibility and the cost of
- 13:26fixing the problem away from the corporation and onto the
- 13:29government and the taxpayer. It is the ultimate scapegoat
- 13:32tactic, and the narrative has been repeated so often by
- 13:35politicians and CEO's that society just accepts it as
- 13:39conventional wisdom. You hear it all the time.
- 13:41Public schools are failing. University students are studying
- 13:44the wrong things, and the American workforce is just
- 13:46falling behind. But the actual data from our
- 13:48sources completely contradicts that narrative, doesn't it?
- 13:52Completely. Let's look at the myth of the
- 13:53failing public school. According to the National
- 13:56Assessment of Educational Progress, the NAEP reading and
- 14:00math scores for 9 and 13 year olds have consistently improved
- 14:04since the 1970s. It's true, the scores are up.
- 14:07Furthermore, high school dropout rates for low income students
- 14:10were actually cut in half between 1972 and 2009.
- 14:14So the raw material, the academic baseline of the entry
- 14:17level workforce is objectively better than it was when these
- 14:20complaining CEO's were entering the workforce themselves.
- 14:23And. That narrative extends right up
- 14:25into higher education, particularly with the prevailing
- 14:27myth surrounding STEM and IT graduates.
- 14:30Oh yeah, everyone says we need more engineers.
- 14:32We. Are constantly bombarded with
- 14:34the idea that we don't produce enough science and technology
- 14:37graduates, yet there is no broad evidence of a science graduate
- 14:41shortage. Marlene.
- 14:41None. No.
- 14:43In reality, there's a massive glut of postdoctoral researchers
- 14:47struggling to find industry jobs right now, and the IT industry
- 14:50is notoriously cyclical. Rightlikethe.com era.
- 14:54Exactly. You can look back at the boom
- 14:56and bust ofthe.com era to see how this plays out.
- 15:00Students see high starting salaries and enroll in computer
- 15:03science programs, but by the time they graduate four years
- 15:06later, the technology has changed, the market has shifted,
- 15:09and companies claim those graduates no longer have the
- 15:12quote UN quote right skills. The tech sector basically treats
- 15:16the education system like a magical vending machine.
- 15:20They put a job posting in the slot and expect a perfectly
- 15:22packaged, fully formed candidate to just drop out ready to use a
- 15:27programming language that was only invented like 6 months ago.
- 15:30Which is impossible. Right.
- 15:31And they expect all of this without ever paying to maintain
- 15:34the machine or signaling to universities what inventory they
- 15:38will actually need three years from now.
- 15:40Which brings us to a huge core contradiction here.
- 15:43If employers aren't actually suffering from a lack of
- 15:45academic skills or technical degrees, what are they really
- 15:49complaining about? Well, the data from the sources
- 15:51is incredibly telling on this point.
- 15:53According to a 1994 census of employers and backed up by a
- 15:572009 Business Roundtable survey, when employers list their
- 16:00biggest frustrations with recent graduates, they rarely mention
- 16:04math, reading or technical prowess.
- 16:06Right, it's not about the hard skills.
- 16:08No, their primary complaints revolve around attitude,
- 16:12punctuality and work ethic. They are looking for perfect,
- 16:16polished workplace habits. Exactly.
- 16:18They want someone who already knows how to navigate office
- 16:21politics, manage professional pressure, and communicate in a
- 16:24corporate environment. But you don't learn those
- 16:26nuances by taking a multiple choice test in a high school
- 16:29classroom or sitting in a college lecture hall.
- 16:31You learn them by actually being in a workplace.
- 16:33You do. So what does this all mean?
- 16:36I have to imagine this brings us to the real root of the problem.
- 16:39If they demand these polished habits but refuse to hire anyone
- 16:42who doesn't already have them, the missing link has to be
- 16:45training, right? Because we used to bridge that
- 16:48gap with on the job training. Our companies just terrified
- 16:51that if they spend the time and money to train someone, a
- 16:54competitor will instantly poach them.
- 16:57You've hit on the most profound shift in the modern labor
- 16:59market. It isn't a skills gap, it is a
- 17:01training gap. A training.
- 17:03Gap and yes, the fear of poaching is the primary driver.
- 17:06The modern employer has almost completely abandoned the concept
- 17:10of bringing people in and training them up.
- 17:12The numbers in the sources outlining this decline are just
- 17:15stark. In 1979, young workers received
- 17:18an average of 2.5 weeks of training a year from their
- 17:21employers, which is a. Decent amount of time to get up
- 17:24to speed. Yeah, but Fast forward to a 2011
- 17:26survey by Accenture, and nearly 80% of the workforce reported
- 17:30receiving absolutely zero formal employer provided training in
- 17:34the past five years. None.
- 17:37We are witnessing the virtual extinction of the corporate
- 17:39apprenticeship and formal onboarding.
- 17:41Just look at the US manufacturing sector.
- 17:43It is a massive economic engine with a 12 million strong
- 17:46workforce, but today there are only about 18,000 registered
- 17:51apprenticeships left in that entire sector.
- 17:54Only 18,000 out of 12 million. Yeah, statistically speaking,
- 17:59the apprenticeship barely exists anymore.
- 18:01Wow. And returning to your point
- 18:03about the fear of poaching, I mean, it makes a twisted kind of
- 18:06financial sense for the individual company, even if it
- 18:09ruins the broader economy. It does make financial sense to
- 18:12them. According to the sources, 76% of
- 18:15employers explicitly state they don't train workers because they
- 18:19want to save costs. So they view it as a liability.
- 18:22Exactly. They view training not as an
- 18:24investment, but as a financial liability.
- 18:27They are terrified that if they spend thousands of dollars
- 18:30training an employee on a new software system, a competitor
- 18:33across the street will just swoop in, offer that newly
- 18:36trained worker an extra dollar an hour, and steal the
- 18:39investment. It's a massive economy wide game
- 18:42of corporate chicken, and nobody wants to be the one to pay for
- 18:45the gas. Every company wants to hire the
- 18:47fully trained, perfectly polished worker from the
- 18:50business across the street, but nobody is willing to do the
- 18:53training themselves. So we end up with this massive
- 18:56pool of educated, willing workers who are locked out of
- 19:00the market entirely simply because they haven't learned the
- 19:04highly specific software program that the hiring company refuses
- 19:08to teach them. When you pull all of these
- 19:10threads together, the overarching conclusion is clear.
- 19:13The much publicized skills gap is largely a self-inflicted
- 19:17wound by employers. They refuse to pay competitive
- 19:20market wages, they rely on deeply flawed, mathematically
- 19:24impossible algorithmic software to filter candidates.
- 19:27They demand perfect experience for entry level jobs and they
- 19:31have completely abandoned their historical necessary role in
- 19:34training the workforce. It really changes how you look
- 19:37at the entire system. So just to recap for you
- 19:39listening, the next time you see ACEO on financial news
- 19:42complaining about a quote UN quote skills shortage, remember
- 19:45to ask yourself the fundamental question.
- 19:47Is this a real shortage of human capability or is this a
- 19:50recruiter just refusing to pay a machinist $19.00 an hour?
- 19:54Remember the ridiculous demands placed on cotton candy machine
- 19:57operators, the impossible math of the 10 hurdle applicant
- 20:01tracking software, and the total devastating death of corporate
- 20:05training? I'll leave you with this final
- 20:07thought to Mull over. If the current system forces job
- 20:11seekers to spend years and thousands of dollars chasing
- 20:14exact hyper specific credentials just to beat an automated
- 20:18keyword algorithm, what happens to the broader creativity and
- 20:22adaptability of our workforce? Oh, that's a great question.
- 20:26If companies only ever hire people who have already done the
- 20:28exact same job somewhere else, are they inadvertently
- 20:31programming their own future stagnation?
- 20:34That is a brilliant point to end on.
- 20:35We might be filtering out our best innovators just because
- 20:38they didn't format their resume with the exact right keywords.
- 20:41Thank you for joining us on this deep dive.
- 20:43Hopefully, the next time you have to send your resume into
- 20:45the digital void, you'll understand a little bit more
- 20:48about the rigid, terrified machinery operating on the other
- 20:50side. Take a hard look at your own
- 20:52industry's hiring practices through this new lens.
- 20:55You might just spot the Unicorn they're endlessly chasing.