Latest / Geoffrey Challen: Teaching and Technology / Tech v. Tech
Transcript
- 0:00Geoffrey Challen: Hey everyone, my name is Geoff Challen, and I teach computing at the University of Illinois.
- 0:04Geoffrey Challen: I write about teaching and technology at geoffreychallen.com,
- 0:08Geoffrey Challen: where you can find a written version of the essay you're about to hear.
- 0:11Geoffrey Challen: What follows is the essay being read aloud, but not by me, by a clone of my voice.
- 0:16Geoffrey Challen: I hope you enjoy it.
- 0:17Geoffrey Challen: If you have any feedback, please don't hesitate to reach out to me directly.
- 0:21Geoffrey Challen: I'd love to hear from you.
- 0:22Geoffrey Challen: Tech v.
- 0:23Geoffrey Challen: Tech, an essay by Geoffrey Challen, read aloud by Geoffrey Challen's voice clone.
- 0:29Geoffrey Challen: Computing educators frequently make reference to “industry”, by which we mean the technology industry.
- 0:36Geoffrey Challen: Industry demands that we teach C++.
- 0:39Geoffrey Challen: Industry requires that we teach ethics.
- 0:42Geoffrey Challen: Industry interviews for proficiency with coding agents.
- 0:46Geoffrey Challen: The technology industry has never been a monolith,
- 0:49Geoffrey Challen: but as long as I’ve been teaching “industry” has had expectations
- 0:52Geoffrey Challen: that are coherent enough for this shorthand to make sense.
- 0:56Geoffrey Challen: Our relationship with industry shows up both in what we teach and in the technology we use in our classrooms.
- 1:02Geoffrey Challen: But I think we’re about to see a split caused by coding agents, one with important implications for computing education.
- 1:09Geoffrey Challen: As an example of what’s happening relevant to educational technology, consider Canvas.
- 1:15Geoffrey Challen: Canvas is a learning management system (LMS), software that educators use to deliver courses.
- 1:21Geoffrey Challen: It allows instructors to publish materials, collect assessments,
- 1:24Geoffrey Challen: maintain a gradebook, and perform other common teaching tasks.
- 1:28Geoffrey Challen: Universities spend millions to access Canvas as software as a service (SaaS) from Instructure,
- 1:34Geoffrey Challen: the company that owns it and told the SEC its contract values
- 1:38Geoffrey Challen: run “from thousands of dollars to several million dollars”,
- 1:41Geoffrey Challen: and the North Carolina Community College System alone signed a five-year contract worth $12.5 million.
- 1:49Geoffrey Challen: Canvas is widely used by universities around the world.
- 1:52Geoffrey Challen: At the end of 2023 it ran 41% of higher education institutions in the United States and Canada,
- 1:58Geoffrey Challen: and by the end of 2024 it served half of all enrolled students.
- 2:03Geoffrey Challen: Canvas is remarkably poor software.
- 2:06Geoffrey Challen: I’ve never used it for my courses due to its many restrictions that hamper educational innovation.
- 2:12Geoffrey Challen: Recently I had occasion to use it as part of a faculty workshop.
- 2:15Geoffrey Challen: Even though I had low expectations, and was driving the API using Claude,
- 2:20Geoffrey Challen: rather than through the web interface, I was disappointed by its limitations.
- 2:24Geoffrey Challen: For example,
- 2:25Geoffrey Challen: I had wanted to create an assignment where students submitted
- 2:28Geoffrey Challen: structured data through a web form with several different fields.
- 2:31Geoffrey Challen: This is not possible; assignments can only accept unstructured submissions.
- 2:36Geoffrey Challen: You can use a survey for this, but there you run into other limitations,
- 2:40Geoffrey Challen: like limited form components with no validation.
- 2:43Geoffrey Challen: Google Forms is free and provides better functionality.
- 2:46Geoffrey Challen: And I’m clearly not the only faculty member struggling to use Canvas effectively.
- 2:51Geoffrey Challen: Having taken several courses at Illinois recently as a student, I can attest that,
- 2:56Geoffrey Challen: while it is possible to create a well-organized course using Canvas,
- 3:00Geoffrey Challen: it is also possible for instructors to make a mess,
- 3:03Geoffrey Challen: resulting in a course website that makes it difficult for students to find materials and complete assignments.
- 3:09Geoffrey Challen: None of that stopped Canvas from taking over.
- 3:11Geoffrey Challen: It spread not because it was good, but because it wasn’t Blackboard.
- 3:15Geoffrey Challen: Apparently Blackboard is worse, although I struggle to imagine how that could be possible.
- 3:20Geoffrey Challen: Whether the instructors forced to use it had much say in the purchase is an open question.
- 3:25Geoffrey Challen: Even if you don’t use Canvas, you might be wondering: Didn’t I hear about Canvas recently?
- 3:31Geoffrey Challen: You did.
- 3:32Geoffrey Challen: Because the site was hacked, resulting in a multi-day outage in May 2026 that caused chaos across higher education.
- 3:39Geoffrey Challen: At Illinois, the attack occurred right before finals,
- 3:42Geoffrey Challen: and the university took Canvas offline for two days while it assessed the risk.
- 3:47Geoffrey Challen: Instructors couldn’t prepare exams and students couldn’t prepare for them.
- 3:51Geoffrey Challen: Apparently this is what we pay millions of dollars for.
- 3:54Geoffrey Challen: And Canvas clearly has a captive market.
- 3:56Geoffrey Challen: In the wake of the May 2026 outage, I never heard the idea of moving away from Canvas even mentioned at Illinois.
- 4:04Geoffrey Challen: Canvas and other software-as-a-service tools exist for one simple reason: people can’t do better.
- 4:11Geoffrey Challen: I maintain my course’s online learning platform—but I’m a computing educator,
- 4:16Geoffrey Challen: and even among computing educators that makes me unusual.
- 4:20Geoffrey Challen: Most make do with the software the university provides and accept its limitations.
- 4:25Geoffrey Challen: But today’s coding agents are rapidly disrupting the relationship between software developers and software users.
- 4:32Geoffrey Challen: This is where the split starts:
- 4:34Geoffrey Challen: the same disruption that threatens the educational technology industry
- 4:38Geoffrey Challen: enables educators to create innovative educational technologies.
- 4:42Geoffrey Challen: This summer I participated in a faculty workshop on AI run by the University
- 4:47Geoffrey Challen: of Illinois’s Center for Innovation in Teaching and Learning (CITL).
- 4:52Geoffrey Challen: Watching what faculty can now create by working with coding agents was astonishing and inspiring.
- 4:58Geoffrey Challen: One of my colleagues, John Clark, entered the workshop with months of experience using AI to support his teaching.
- 5:05Geoffrey Challen: With little technical background he’s been building an entire suite of architectural design tools,
- 5:10Geoffrey Challen: including a whole set designed to support a vision-impaired student.
- 5:14Geoffrey Challen: I’ve spent hours watching in awe as he demoed all of the things he’s created.
- 5:19Geoffrey Challen: Another colleague, Ben Clegg, arrived never having used AI.
- 5:23Geoffrey Challen: Two weeks later he was using Claude to create Socratic tutors for his biology course and deploy them online.
- 5:30Geoffrey Challen: He kept asking me: How do I do this?
- 5:32Geoffrey Challen: I’d say: Claude will walk you through it.
- 5:34Geoffrey Challen: He’d show up the next day with it done.
- 5:37Geoffrey Challen: Out of the five faculty I worked with closely, all were able to create remarkable tools using AI coding agents.
- 5:44Geoffrey Challen: Why should faculty continue to use Canvas at all?
- 5:47Geoffrey Challen: We made do with an expensive and shoddy product because we couldn’t do better.
- 5:52Geoffrey Challen: But now we can.
- 5:53Geoffrey Challen: And we should!
- 5:54Geoffrey Challen: We’d need support from our university IT to provide access to internal university data (like enrollment)
- 6:01Geoffrey Challen: and secure interfaces for handling sensitive data (like grades).
- 6:04Geoffrey Challen: But this could be done at a fraction of the cost of what we pay for Canvas.
- 6:08Geoffrey Challen: The resulting platform would provide faculty with incredible
- 6:11Geoffrey Challen: opportunities to build effective and innovative courses and materials,
- 6:15Geoffrey Challen: rather than the limited mediocrity enforced by current LMS platforms.
- 6:20Geoffrey Challen: This is already possible,
- 6:21Geoffrey Challen: and will just get more and more tractable as coding agents and our ability to use them effectively continue to improve.
- 6:28Geoffrey Challen: This is just one example of a new opportunity available to every professional who uses computing technology.
- 6:35Geoffrey Challen: Today, domain experts use tools built by people who know a lot about computing but little about their domain.
- 6:41Geoffrey Challen: But by learning a little about computing technology,
- 6:44Geoffrey Challen: domain specialists can now create tools that better embody their domain knowledge.
- 6:49Geoffrey Challen: Instead of compromising with a few centralized tools doing a mediocre job at many different tasks,
- 6:54Geoffrey Challen: domain experts can maintain a smaller collection of personal tools
- 6:58Geoffrey Challen: that do an excellent job of accomplishing their most important tasks.
- 7:02Geoffrey Challen: And when they have a new idea they’d like to try, they can do so immediately,
- 7:06Geoffrey Challen: rather than hoping that some faraway application developer will notice, agree with, and implement their suggestion.
- 7:12Geoffrey Challen: Good ideas can be shared easily among colleagues and migrated smoothly between different educational contexts.
- 7:19Geoffrey Challen: One possible future is filled with useful and innovative technology built by users—
- 7:25Geoffrey Challen: the same people who have always been the experts at how the technology they use should work.
- 7:30Geoffrey Challen: That vision is made possible by coding agents, generative AI, and the technology companies developing these tools.
- 7:37Geoffrey Challen: But that same future is deeply threatening to the large part of the
- 7:40Geoffrey Challen: technology industry whose profits depend on users who can’t be builders.
- 7:45Geoffrey Challen: Danny Hillis has described this possible future as “tech without the tech companies”,
- 7:50Geoffrey Challen: but it’s probably more accurate to say that it represents tech without most of the tech companies.
- 7:56Geoffrey Challen: No longer a monolith, the industry is splitting in two.
- 7:59Geoffrey Challen: Some tech companies are positioning themselves for this future—
- 8:02Geoffrey Challen: certainly those creating and deploying the models that support agentic development,
- 8:07Geoffrey Challen: but also new ones that will emerge to create new tools and environments for the new generation of programmers.
- 8:12Geoffrey Challen: But others have no choice but to try to preserve the status quo as long as possible.
- 8:17Geoffrey Challen: They’ve counted the chairs and decided that the music must continue.
- 8:22Geoffrey Challen: Educators and other domain specialists can help bring about a future
- 8:26Geoffrey Challen: where technology is created and maintained by those who care about it.
- 8:30Geoffrey Challen: Educators are an intelligent and resourceful bunch.
- 8:33Geoffrey Challen: John, Ben, and many other teachers are already demonstrating what they can do with these new tools:
- 8:39Geoffrey Challen: motivated by their desire to support student learning, and guided by their domain expertise.
- 8:44Geoffrey Challen: There are certainly barriers ahead.
- 8:47Geoffrey Challen: Educational institutions are unprepared for educators who can build:
- 8:51Geoffrey Challen: lacking the required computation resources, budget lines, and institutional support.
- 8:56Geoffrey Challen: Educational technology companies will marshal ever more desperate arguments in support of their own survival,
- 9:02Geoffrey Challen: and may pursue regulations intended to make small educational tools less viable.
- 9:07Geoffrey Challen: Change isn’t inevitable—at least not on appropriate timelines.
- 9:11Geoffrey Challen: It’s going to require effort and advocacy.
- 9:14Geoffrey Challen: University educators can help lead the way.
- 9:18Geoffrey Challen: Compared with most K–12 educators, we have a great deal of pedagogical freedom.
- 9:23Geoffrey Challen: Few university faculty are actually forced to use poor educational tools.
- 9:28Geoffrey Challen: Institutions may encourage, and faculty may go along, but outright coercion is rare.
- 9:33Geoffrey Challen: Imagine firing an instructor for creating superior educational technology!
- 9:38Geoffrey Challen: The biggest barrier here is institutional support for faculty-created educational tools—
- 9:43Geoffrey Challen: particularly funding for AI inference,
- 9:46Geoffrey Challen: which is urgently needed.
- 9:48Geoffrey Challen: Computing educators may have the greatest opportunity of all.
- 9:52Geoffrey Challen: We can learn these tools ourselves and demonstrate to our colleagues how they are improving our courses.
- 9:57Geoffrey Challen: We can help colleagues from outside computing gain comfort and familiarity with the new computing—
- 10:02Geoffrey Challen: and then sit back and watch in awe as they transform education.
- 10:07Geoffrey Challen: And, most importantly, we can teach the new computing to a new generation of builders,
- 10:12Geoffrey Challen: abandoning the software priesthood in pursuit of tech without (most of) the tech companies.
- 10:19Geoffrey Challen: This is real Geoff again.
- 10:20Geoffrey Challen: Thanks for listening.
- 10:21Geoffrey Challen: You'll find more essays at geoffreychallen.com, and you can subscribe to the podcast wherever you're listening now.
- 10:27Geoffrey Challen: Until next time.
- 10:28Geoffrey Challen: Keep teaching with technology.